﻿

   Table of Contents
About This Book
DIET & NUTRITION
Science-Based Nutrition. Steven Novella 
An Apple a Day | S Novella
Let food be thy medicine and medicine be thy food? The obsessive worship of “medicinal foods” | Science-Based Medicine
The Food Is Medicine (FIM) Movement | S Novella
Food for Thought | H Hall
Food Fears | S Novella
Ultraprocessed Foods | S Novella
The War Over Ultraprocessed Foods | S Novella
RFK Turns Food Pyramid On Its Head | S Novella
Should you be “Eating Clean”? | S Gavura
The Clean Eating Delusion | S Novella
No Health Benefits from Organic Food | S Novella
A closer look at Dr. Oz’s 15 Superfoods | S Gavura
Vani Hari (a.k.a. The Food Babe): The Jenny McCarthy of food | D Gorski
Vani Hari, a.k.a. “The Food Babe,” finally responds to critics | D Gorski
The Food Babe’s war on “chemicals” heats up again | D Gorski
Making One’s Own Reality – Food Babe Edition | S Novella
Nutrigenomics – Not Ready for Prime Time | S Novella
“DNA-based” personalized nutrition advice: Not ready for prime time | S Garvura
Steven Fowkes (Part 2 of 2): Nutrients for Better Mental Performance | H Hall
Diet Recommendations Based on DNA | H Hall
Dietary Associations with Cardiovascular and Diabetic Mortality: “Bacon, soda, and too few nuts”? | H Hall
The NORI protocol: An unproven fruit-based nutritional treatment for cancer sold by a self-proclaimed “expert” | D Gorski
Death as a Foodborne Illness Curable by Veganism | H Hall
Everything we eat causes cancer…sort of | D Gorski
Peddling Misinformation About Diet and Cancer | S Novella
Ketogenic diet does not “beat chemo for almost all cancers” | D Gorski
Diet and exercise versus cancer: A science-based view | D Gorski
A New Medication to Combat Obesity | H Hall
Can “optimizing your metabolism” through diet prevent or cure COVID-19? | D Gorski
I Used To Be a Holistic Nutritionist | D Royal
Guess who pioneered chemoprevention through diet? | J Bellamy
Five Fatal Foods | H Halls
Pesticides: Just How Bad Are They? | H Hall
Microwaves and Nutrition | S Novella
New Cholesterol Guidelines | H Hall
What Whole Foods Markets Doesn’t Tell You | J Bellamy
Antivaccine versus anti-GMO: Different goals, same methods | D Gorski
More bad science in the service of anti-GMO activism | D Gorski
The Seralini GMO Study – Retraction and Response to Critics | S Novella
Another Anti-GMO Paper Retracted | S Novella 
National Academy of Sciences Report on GMOs | S Novella
We still Need Better Communication on GMOs | S Novella
Can GMOs cause gastrointestinal sensitivity and inflammation? | S Gavura
Gene Edited vs Genetically Modified | S Novella
Update on GMOs and Health | S Novella
Philippines Approves Golden Rice | S Novella
Save the Whales, Blind the Children | M Crislip
Seneff Claims GMOs Cause Concussions | S Novella
The Science Fiction of Nutritional Genomics. Ben Kavoussi
Organic vs Conventional Meat and Milk | S Novella
Is Organic Food More Healthful? Steven Novella.
Treating Mental Illness with Nutrition: The Walsh Protocol | H Hall
Processed Foods and Autism | S Novella
GLUTEN
Is gluten the new Candida? | S Gavura
A balanced look at gluten sensitivity | L Laforest
Risks of a Gluten-Free Diet | S Novella
Gluten Update | S Novella
Gluten-free skin and beauty products: Extracting cash from the gullible | D Gorski
Ancient Origins of Modern Dietary Demons | C Jones
Re-thinking Antioxidant Supplementation for Macular Degeneration | H Hall
Everything you always wanted to know about fermented foods | L Shewell
Antioxidant Hype and Reality. Steven Novella
Antioxidant Supplements for Macular Degeneration. Harriet Hall.
Resveratrol: Of Mice and Men. Harriet Hall
Protandim: Another Kind of Antioxidant. Harriet Hall.
Protandim Update: New Studies and an FDA Warning Letter | H Hall
The Plant Paradox: Steven Gundry’s War on Lectins | H Hall
WATER
Eight Glasses of Water Myth | S Novella
Rehydrating with an appeal to nature | S Gavura
Scaremongering to Sell Water Filters | S Novella
Monochloramines in Tap Water | S Novella
Down the Virtual Rabbit Hole: Kangan water® | M Crislip
Alkaline Water Surges Despite Lack of Evidence | S Novella
Deadly Alkaline Water Case Highlights Problems with Bottled Water Regulations | C Jones
Hydrogen Water Is Not “the New Nutrient;” Health Claims Are Hype, Not Science. | H Hall
Gold Water, Silver Water, Copper Water | H Hall
“Raw water”: The latest dangerous “natural health” fad | D Gorski
Oxygen water? You can’t breathe through your stomach | S Gavura
You can’t breathe through your stomach | S Gavura
Living Water | Science-Based Medicine
It’s Still Not Safe to Go Back in the Water, and Other Tales of Woo | C Jones
Science-based medicine versus the Flint water crisis | D Gorski
Deconstructing the Conspiracy of Deliberate Poisoning of US Municipal Water | C Pearcey
Juice Plus+: Good Marketing, Not Good Science | H Hall
Super Fruit Juices – The New Snake Oil. Steven Novella
Energy Drinks are Risky, Especially for Kids | C Jones
Energy Drinks. Scott Gavura 
The World’s First Productivity Drink | H Hall
Cranberry Juice. Mark Crislip.
Cranberries to prevent urinary tract infections: Another alternative medicine zombie that’s impervious to evidence | S Gavura
I No Longer Love a Parade. Mark Crislip
Probiotics. Mark Crislip
The Cholesterol Controversy | C Labos
Red Yeast Rice to Lower Cholesterol. Harriet Hall
Statins beat supplements | S Gavura
Study – For Lowering Cholesterol, Statins Work, Supplements Don’t | H Hall
The Movie “Cholesterol: The Great Bluff” Is an Exercise in Denialism | H Hall
Fake News About Margarine | H Hall
Most Patients Get No Benefit from Most Drugs | H Hall
MEAT
Skeptical of the Carnivore Diet | S Novella
Meat and Weight Control. Steven Novella.
Red Meat: Is It Hazardous to Health? Harriet Hall.
Is Meat Poison? Is Fat the Antidote? | H Hall
Study Correlates Red Meat Consumption and Type II Diabetes | S. Novella
Cell-cultured meat: Earth’s savior or just a $600 burger? | J Bellamy
The Red Meat Controversy | S Novella
Raw Meat and Bone Diets for Dogs: It’s Enough to Make You BARF. Brennen McKenzie 
Cannibalism? | M Crislip
Eating Placentas: Cannibalism, Recycling, or Health Food? Harriet Hall .
Placentophagy and the Risk of Invasive Neonatal GBS Disease | C Jones
Eggs and Atherosclerosis | S Gavura
The Skinny on Saturated Fat | S Novella
Of Mice and Men…and Coconut Oil | G Rictchey & S Tornberg-Belanger
Coconut Oil | H Hall
Coconut Oil Warning | S Novella
What the Health: A Movie with an Agenda | H Hall
The China Study Revisited: New Analysis of Raw Data Doesn’t Support Vegetarian Ideology. Harriet Hall.
H.O.P.E.: A Movie Promoting Veganism | H Hall
Simply Raw: Making overcooked claims about raw food diets. David Gorski.
MILK
Evaluating milk and its substitutes | S Gavura
Milk and Health: The Evidence | H Hall
Should We Avoid Dairy Out of Fear of Cancer? | H Hall
Raw Milk in Modern Times. Mark Crislip.
Spring Update on Prior Posts | M Crislip
Raw deal: Got diarrhea? John Snyder
More Evidence Raw Milk is Bad | S Novella
More On Raw Milk | S Novella
PETA Embraces Autism Pseudoscience | S Novella
One Hump or Two? Camel’s Milk as a New Alternative Medicine. Harriet Hall.
Oil of Oregano. Scott Gavura.
Turmeric for osteoarthritis: Promising but modest effects | S Gavura
Reeling In Misrepresentation: Fish Oil Supplements Found Lacking | S Gavura
Is Olive Oil Good Medicine? | H Hall
Seed Oils Are Not Bad For You | S Novella
A review of Benecol, a plant-stanol margarine | K Pett
Pass the Salt (But Not That Pink Himalayan Stuff) | H Hall
SWEETNERS
Sugar Industry Research | S Novella
Does the Movie Fed Up Make Sense? | H Hall
Gary Taubes and the Cause of Obesity | Science-Based Medicine
Gary Taubes and the Case Against Sugar | H Hall
High Fructose Corn Syrup: Tasty Toxin or Slandered Sweetener? Jim Laidler 
The Sweetener Wars – HFCS Strikes Back | H Hall
Artificial Sweeteners – A Free Lunch, or an Obesogenic Carcinogen? What 80+ Studies Say (part 1 of 2). | J Solokas
Artificial Sweeteners – A Free Lunch, or an Obesogenic Carcinogen? What 80+ Studies Say (part 2 of 2) | J Solokas
Update on Low Calorie Sweeteners | S Novella
New Review of Artificial Sweeteners | S Novella
Low Energy Sweeteners and Weight Control | S Novella
Aspartame – Truth vs Fiction. Steven Novella
Aspartame and Cancer | S Novella
Pepsi Removing Aspartame | S Novella
Are dietary sugar alcohol sweeteners safe? | S Gavura
Sweetened Drinks and Risk of A-Fib | S Novella
Soft Drinks and Death Risk | S Novella
Coca-Cola Science | S Novella
Do you need to drink electrolytes? | S Gavura
Implausible Apple Cider Vinegar Weight Loss Study Retracted | S Gavura
The Health Benefits of Moderate Drinking | H Hall
Failed Flaxseed and Bad News Brownies. David J Kroll.
Swedish Blueberries Are Bluer, But Are They Better? | H Hall
Garlic, the fragrant panacea | S Gavura
Pesticide in Oat Products – Should You Worry? | S. Novella
A good journal breaks bad: AAP spreads misinformation about glyphosate | N. Keller
Panera Markets Food Fear | S Novella
Phthalates and BPA: Of Mice and Men | H Hall
Killer Tomatoes and Poisonous Potatoes? | H Hall
IgG Food Intolerance Tests: What does the science say? | S Gavura
IgG food intolerance tests continue to mislead consumers into unnecessary dietary restrictions | S Gavura
IgG Food Sensitivity Tests Not Valid | S. Novella
The Obesity Paradox | H Hall
BMI and the Obesity Epidemic | S Novella
Update on the Obesity Epidemic | S Novella
RFK Jr On Obesity | S Novella
Fat Shaming Is Counterproductive | S Novella
Okinawan Flat Belly Tonic | H Hall
Garcinia Probably Works But Is Far From a Weight Loss Miracle | H Hall
Forskolin: Here We Go Again | H Hall
Weight Loss Customers Are Being Hoodia-Winked | H Hall
It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo dream | D Gorski
Keto Diet for Neurological Disorders | S Novella
Diet Cults vs. Science-Based Healthy Eating | H Hall
What Can We Learn from the Kitavans? | H Hall
Does Intermittent Fasting Work? | S Novella
Shred360: The Weight Loss Product with the Stupidest Hype Ever | H Hall
The HCG Diet: Yet another ineffective quick fix diet plan and supplement | Science-Based Medicine
GOLO for Weight Loss | H Hall
Plenity – A New Weight Loss Pill | H Hall
Big Success for Anti-obesity Drug | H Hall
Eat To Save Your Life: Another Half-True Diet Book | V Jones
The Shred Diet: A Minimally Kooky Way To Lose Weight | V Jones
Eat Fat, Get Thin? | H Hall
The Diet Fix | S Gavura
Blue Zones Diet: Speculation Based on Misinformation | H Hall
Intermittent Fasting | H Hall
The McDougall Diet | H Hall
GAPS Diet | H Hall
The Hallelujah Diet | H Hall
The Rosedale Diet: Here We Go Again | H Hall
Vegan Betrayal: The Myths vs. the Realities of a Plants-Only Diet | H Hall
Betraying the Science on Vegan Nutrition | G Messina
Mosconi’s Brain Food Diet | H Hall
Eat for Life: Joel Fuhrman’s Nutritarian Diet | H Hall
Lose Weight without Diet or Exercise? Where’s the Proof? | H Hall
#Oatzempic – The viral oat-based alternative to Ozempic? | S Gavura
GLP-1 Patch Scams: The Science Doesn’t Support the Hype | S Gavura
Generic GLP-1s are coming, but Americans don’t want to wait | S Gavura
A British Teenager is Blind, But Not Because of Junk Food or “Fussy Eating” | C Jones
Natural Medicine, Starvation, and Murder: The Story of Linda Hazzard | H Hall
Pet Food Mislabeling: Let Food Be Thy Dogma | G Bishop
The Top Ten Pet Supplements: Do They Work? Brennen McKenzie.
Science-Based Satire: Portland Compounding Pharmacy Introduces Line of Bespoke Artisinal Parenteral Nutrition | C Jones
Science-Based Satire: A New Fad Diet Has Farmers and Doctors Baffled | C Jones
Science-Based Satire: Experts are Warning Parents About a New and Highly Potent Synthetic Sugar | C Jones
LAW AND REGULATION
Can Medical Schools Really Teach 71 Nutrition ‘Competencies’? Should They? | H Miller
Why Did the FDA Ban Red Dye #3 | S Novella
Food fights in the courtroom | J Bellamy
Nigeria Court Ruling on Benzene in Soft Drinks | S Novella
As of 2025, there are over 5000 essays on the Science Based Medicine website. I do no know about you, but I find it difficult to find any post I wrote, much less one written by another contributor. 

So I have updated the books and include almost all the articles through 2025. The volumes are

CAM Concepts
Chiropractic
COVID 
Critical Thinking
Diet and Nutrition
Ethics and CAM
Herbs, Supplements, and Diet
Homeopathy
Infections and Immunity
Law and CAM
Media and Internet
Medicine, Public Health, Dentistry and Pediatrics
Miscellaneous CAM
Naturopathy
Neurology and Psychiatry
Placebo
Quackademic Medicine
Regulation. FDA and FTC
SBM or EBM
Stem Cells, Genetics, AI and Gender
Supplements, Vitamins and Herbs
Vaccine & Anivax
Vaccines and Autism
Vaccines and Preventable Infections

The articles are roughly organized by publication date and topic. Many articles will be in multiple volumes as an essay of, for example, chiropractic and law will be found in both the chiropractic volume and the law volume.

You may find the organization a bit odd. I do. But 4700 plus articles are difficult to organize and I have more to do in my retirement than work of these volumes.

Still, if you find I have missed a nentry or some glaring error, drop me a note and I will fix it for the next edition.

About the authors
Steven P. Novella, MD – Founder and Executive Editor Science Based Medicine.
Founder and currently Executive Editor of Science-Based Medicine Steven Novella, MD.
David H. Gorski, MD, PhD – Managing Editor. Science Based Medicine.
Mark A. Crislip, MD. Editor, Science Based Medicine Guides. 
He did he editing of all the volumes so is to blame for any mistakes.
As to all the other contributors, if you are interested click on the ‘Link’ at top of each essay to go the SBM site, where further information about each author can be found.
A Note On References

The chapters in this book were originally blog entries at ScienceBasedMedicine.org.
Blog and web pages lend themselves to hyperlinks to sources and references that are tedious to translate into footnotes for this ebook.
Under the title of each essay is a hyperlink, cleverly titled ‘Link’, to the original blog entry with all the hyperlinks and references, as well as the comments to the blogs, which often have interesting and thoughtful insights by our readers, as well as some curious comments by the not so thoughtful.
Graphs, tables and links to videos are not in included these essays due to issues of copyright and permission. However, thanks to the ‘Link’, the graphics are a click away.
Thanks for reading the site.
Mark Crislip 



   Diet & Nutrition

   Science-Based Nutrition
Steven Novella 
Link
One of the most successful propaganda campaigns within health care in the last few decades has been the re-branding of nutrition as “alternative” or out of the mainstream of scientific medicine. I have marveled at how successful this campaign has been, despite all the historical evidence to the contrary. I suppose this is partly a manifestation of the public’s short-term memory, but it also seems to reflect basic psychology.
Some History
There is evidence that most ancient cultures recognized the importance of diet in health. The Greeks recognized both the benefits of a varied diet and the negative health consequences of obesity, for example. But knowledge of nutrition was limited to these broad observations and was mixed with superstition and cultural beliefs.
The science of nutrition probably dates back to 1614 when scurvy (the disease that results from vitamin C deficiency) was first recognized as a dietary deficiency, one that could be cured by eating fresh fruits and vegetables. In 1747 Lind conducted what might be the first clinical trial – systematically comparing various diets for the treatment of scurvy and finding that citrus fruits were the key to treatment.
From 1928 to 1933, two research teams independently isolated ascorbic acid (the chemical name for Vitamin C): a Hungarian research team of Joseph L Svirbely and Albert Szent-Györgyi and the American researcher Charles Glen King. Albert Szent-Györgyi was awarded the 1937 Nobel Prize in Medicine for his part in the discovery.
Prior to that, in 1912, Casimir Funk developed the concept of vitamins (so named because he thought that chemically they were all amines – therefore “vital amines” or vitamins). Vitamins are not, it turns out, all amines, but are defined as micronutrients that are essential for biological function but cannot be sufficiently synthesized by an organism and therefore must be obtained in the diet.
Other components of a healthful diet include other micronutrients, such as minerals and trace elements, and the macronutrients – those that give us our calories and major building blocks. The macronutrients include carbohydrates, fats, and proteins.
Nutrition in Medicine
There have been three major conceptual trends (not mutually exclusive) in the thinking about nutrition in medicine and health. The first was the concept of deficiency – that an insufficient amount of a critical nutrient can cause disease. Nutrition science and intervention in the 19th and earth 20th centuries focussed on malnutrition, identifying specific nutrients and the diseases caused by their dearth, and on the role of supplementation in public health. This approach resulted in iodine in salt, vitamin D in milk, and on the recommended dietary allowances (which are basically the minimum necessary to avoid deficiency).
As an extension of the malnutrition model was the recognition that certain disease states or situations come with increased nutritional requirements. For example, when battling cancer individuals typically have significantly increased nutritional and caloric demands. Increased nutrition may therefore stave off weight loss as a result of the cancer, and help fight off the disease and weather the stress of chemotherapy. It is also recognized that wound healing after injury or surgery requires vitamin C in particular and increased nutrition in general.
In the latter half of the 20th century and continuing into the 21 century science-based nutrition has added two new conceptual frameworks. The first is thinking about excess nutrition – meaning getting too much of something in our diets as a risk factor for disease. Here the focus has been on the macronutrients – too much of the wrong kind of fat as a risk factor for vascular disease and too many carbohydrates as a risk of Type II diabetes are prominent examples. But also too much salt as a risk for hypertension, and even the possibility of too much iron in the diet of men and non-menstruating women.
The other concept that has been added to the scientific approach to nutrition is the recognition that specific nutrients may decreased the risk of developing certain diseases and may even treat an existing disease. To give some examples from my own specialty – vitamin B2 and Coenzyme Q10 have been shown to reduce migraines, vitamin B6 may be helpful in nerve healing (for example from carpal tunnel syndrome), and folate is essential for pregnant women to reduce the risk of spina bifida.
Therefore, to summarize, science-based nutrition includes the recognition of nutritional deficiencies, the increased need for nutrition in situations of physiological stress, the risks of dietary excess, and the role of specific nutrients in mitigating specific diseases and conditions. This is all part of standard medical training, ongoing medical research, and everyday practice. The examples I gave above are meant to be representative, and not exhaustive. Also, specific conclusions are tentative and will change as new data is gathered.
Nutritional Pseudoscience
Nutritional claims are prominent among health products and services that lie outside of science-based medicine. Part of the reason for this is regulatory – supplements are often regulated as food, rather than as drugs, and therefore subject to less regulation and oversight. Nutritional supplementation is also highly marketable, because it seems less invasive and less risky than other modalities.
There are many legitimate health benefits for specific nutrients. However, the claims for nutritional therapy often go far beyond the evidence or scientific plausibility. Some promoters go as far as to claim that poor nutrition is the cause of most or even all disease and illness, and therefore all human disease can be treated with supplementation.
Because such claims are not supported by current science, it seems that the industry has decided to make a pre-emptive strike against scientific criticism. Therefore they have created, as part of their marketing strategy, the notion that the medical community does not understand, value, or study the role of nutrition in health. Some even go as far as to claim that there is a conspiracy to conceal real scientific information about nutrition.
Conclusion
Nutrition is an essential part of health and medicine, and nutritional science is a vibrant and successful research program. However, nutrition is also a common target of dubious marketing and harmful medical pseudoscience. Readers are encouraged to have healthy skepticism toward nutritional claims that seem to good to be true, take a hostile approach toward mainstream science and medicine, and especially those that claim there is a conspiracy to silence the truth about nutrition.

An Apple a Day
Steven Novella on December 18, 2013
Link
We (the authors and editors) at SBM get accused of many nefarious things. Because we deliberately engage with the public over controversial medical questions, we expect nothing less. It goes with the territory. In fact, if there were a lack of critical pushback we would worry that we were not doing our job.
Still, it is disconcerting to see the frequently-repeated ideological accusations in response to simply evaluating and reporting the evidence. That is what we do here – follow the science and evidence. When that trail leads to a conclusion that some people do not like (usually for ideological reasons) a common response is to accuse us of ideology, malfeasance, being part of a conspiracy, or having conflicts of interest or ulterior motives. That is easier, I suppose, than engaging with us on the science.
One common accusation is that we are shills for the pharmaceutical industry, and downplay or ignore the benefits of diet and “natural” treatments. A search through the SBM archives demonstrates that this accusation is false – we criticize bad science and poor-quality control, regardless of who is committing it. Sometimes pseudoscience is used to promote a drug, sometimes a nutritional supplement, and sometimes pure magic.
We have been consistently critical of the marketing of routine vitamin and mineral supplementation because there is simply a lack of evidence to support it. Scott Gavura will be writing tomorrow on three new studies published recently in the Annals of Internal Medicine, all of which provide further evidence for the lack of a health benefit from routine multivitamin use.
I have found this to be a topic full of irony, because whenever I have taken the position that the evidence does not support routine supplementation, I am commonly accused of being a pharma shill. This is ironic because supplements are largely sold by large corporations, including pharmaceutical companies. Further, what I do recommend is a well-rounded diet instead – eat your five portions of fruits and vegetables a day and have a generally well-rounded diet with appropriate calorie control. I still fail to see how recommending a healthful diet over a product of the pharmaceutical industry makes me a pharma shill – but the ideologues only have so many arrows in their quiver, and they are going to use them.
Specifically the evidence shows that taking a multivitamin is not a substitute for a healthy diet.
A recent paper in the BMJ further makes the point that promoting a healthy diet can have a significant impact on reducing vascular risk. This is not a study, but rather a statistical model that uses existing evidence and asks two questions:
– What would happen if everyone over 50 were offered a statin, and 70% complied?
– What would happen if everyone over 50 were told to eat an apple a day (or one extra portion of some fruit) and 70% complied (and assuming no overall increase in calorie consumption)?
This is what the numbers showed:
The estimated annual reduction in deaths from vascular disease of a statin a day, assuming 70% compliance and a reduction in vascular mortality of 12% (95% confidence interval 9% to 16%) per 1.0 mmol/L reduction in low density lipoprotein cholesterol, is 9400 (7000 to 12 500). The equivalent reduction from an apple a day, modelled using the PRIME model (assuming an apple weighs 100 g and that overall calorie consumption remains constant) is 8500 (95% credible interval 6200 to 10 800).
That statin would save 9,400 lives, while eating an apple would save 8,500 lives per year. Not only is an apple a day just about as effective as taking a statin, it has fewer side effects. The increased statin use would also cause over a thousand cases of muscle disease and 10,000 new diagnoses of diabetes.
The authors did not recommend replacing statin use with eating more fruit. Using statins still has a net benefit to overall mortality. But it does show that a simple nutritional intervention has the potential for a similar benefit, at lower cost and without side effects.
Conclusion
Star Trek’s Dr. McCoy famously said, “I can do more for you if you just eat right and exercise regularly.” This just shows that over 40 years ago (or 250 years from now, depending on how you look at it) the bottom-line best medical advice has not changed.
This is a very strong and consistent signal in the clinical literature. Eat a well-rounded diet with plenty of fruits and vegetables (five portions a day), and exercise regularly, and this will have a significant positive impact on your health and longevity. This simple statement is what all the research boils down to, but this won’t sell many books or supplements.
The evidence also shows that taking vitamins does not substitute for a good diet. In fact one of our criticisms of pushing vitamins is that it may lead to a false sense of security and give people psychological “permission” to persist with a suboptimal diet.
I think it’s important, in fact, to keep our message as simple as possible. I am concerned that getting overwhelmed with all the minute details of specific nutrients and nuanced diets has an overall negative effect on public health, because the more basic messages are getting lost in the noise. There is an entire industry, in fact, based upon that noise (including statistical noise in the research).
If you want to live longer, here is what the evidence clearly shows in terms of lifestyle:
– Eat a well-rounded healthy diet– Exercise regularly– Get enough sleep– Don’t smoke– Use alcohol in moderation
I would add – get appropriate medical care and screening where appropriate (get your mammograms and colonoscopies). Beyond those basic lifestyle recommendations, there are diminishing returns, with greater and greater complexity and difficulty for smaller and smaller benefit (if any).
The latest publication shows that simple messaging can potentially have a huge impact.
Eat an apple a day (or your fruit of choice, I personally like bananas).

Let food be thy medicine and medicine be thy food? The obsessive worship of “medicinal foods”
David Gorski on June 1, 2015
Link

Let food be thy medicine and medicine be thy food.
– attributed to Hippocrates
Who said anything about medicine? Let’s eat!
– attributed to one of Hippocrates forgotten (and skeptical) students
Who hasn’t seen or heard Hippocrates’ famous quote about letting food be your medicine and your medicine your food? If you have Facebook friends who are the least bit into “natural” medicine or living, you’ve almost certainly come across it in your feed, and if you’re a skeptic who pays the least bit of attention to what’s going on in the quackosphere you will almost certainly have seen it plastered on a picture as a meme, either using a picture of Hippocrates or pictures of plates of green, leafy vegetables, or both. I like to view the fetishization of “food as medicine,” to cite Hippocrates, as one of the best examples out there of the logical fallacy known as the appeal to antiquity; in other words, the claim that if something is ancient and still around it must be correct (or at least there must be something to it worth considering).
Of course, just because an idea is old doesn’t mean it’s good, any more than just because Hippocrates said it means it must be true. Hippocrates was an important figure in the history of medicine because he was among the earliest to assert that diseases were caused by natural processes rather than the gods and because of his emphasis on the careful observation and documentation of patient history and physical findings, which led to the discovery of physical signs associated with diseases of specific organs. However, let’s not also forget that Hippocrates and his followers also believed in humoral theory, the idea that all disease results from an imbalance of the “four humors.” It’s also amusing to note that this quote by Hippocrates is thought to be a misquote, as it is nowhere to be found in the more than 60 texts known as The Hippocratic Corpus (Corpus Hippocraticum).
As Diana Cardenes argues:
But Hippocratic doctors clearly saw a difference between food and medicines. In fact, food was considered as a material that could be assimilated after digestion (e.g. the air was also food) and converted into the substance of the body. For example, food was converted into the different parts of the body such as muscles, nerves, etc. By contrast, the concept of medicines at the time was a product which was able to change the body’s own nature (in terms of humor quality or quantity) but not be converted into the body’s own substance. Thus a food wasn’t considered a medicine. A possible root of the food-medicine confusion is the following cryptic phrase found in the work On Aliment: “In food excellent medication, in food bad medication, bad and good relatively”.3 This text is nowadays attributed to the Hellenistic period, but was considered to be Hippocratic in Antiquity by Galenus in particular.
Now, it is certainly true that Hippocrates and his followers used diet to treat many illnesses, it’s not really clear what sort of success they had. However, this ancient idea that virtually all disease could be treated with diet, however much or little it was embraced by Hippocrates, has become an idée fixe in alternative medicine, so much so that it leads its proponents twist new science (like epigenetics) to try to fit it into a framework where diet rules all, often coupled with the idea that doctors don’t understand or care about nutrition and it’s big pharma that’s preventing the acceptance of dietary interventions. That thinking also permeates popular culture, fitting in very nicely with an equally ancient phenomenon, the moralization of food choices (discussed ably by Dr. Jones a month ago).
Let food be thy medicine and medicine be thy food?
This idée fixe that diet can fix everything even leads respectable doctors to write stories that are in some ways balanced but in other ways maddeningly credulous, like this story published last week in The New Republic by Dr. Sushrut Jangi, an Instructor in Medicine at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, entitled “The Nutrition Gap.” You can tell right away that there are going to be…problems…with the article by its summary:
In America, where the pharmaceutical industry is king, many doctors dismiss nutritional therapies as quack medicine. But many patients disagree, and they’re taking matters into their own hands—sometimes to the detriment of their health. Can food cure disease? And are doctors ready to think outside the pillbox?
Yes, the trope is there, that pharma rules all and nutritional therapies are dismissed as quackery. Of course, one has to distinguish between different nutritional therapies because many nutritional “therapies” promoted by alternative medicine are quackery. Unfortunately, Dr. Jangi can’t quite bring himself to do that properly. Before I get to the most egregious examples of that failing, first I must in all fairness acknowledge one thing that he gets right, and that’s his pointing out that there is a “nutrition gap in America, a disconnect between how patients and clinicians perceive diet,” a gap that has “been largely filled by opportunists like Gwyneth Paltrow and Dr. Mehmet Oz, obscuring many meaningful advances in understanding how nutrition influence health.” Right on! There are so many quack nutritional therapies out there, so many diets, so many claims, and so little science to back them up that it’s no wonder that it’s hard for a nutritional therapy to break through.
As is usually the case with articles like this, Jangi begins with a human interest anecdote, about a woman who is identified only as Helen who unexpectedly developed multiple myeloma at an age far younger than the disease usually strikes. Multiple myeloma is a cancer of plasma cells, immune cells that make antibodies. Because of this, as the disease progresses, multiple myeloma can cause kidney failure due to it secretion of excess antibodies and components of antibodies, proteins that can damage the kidney at high concentrations. It can also cause bone pain and fractures due to its secretion of a factor that activates cells that break down bone. Life expectancy can vary considerably, depending on age and how aggressive the tumor is. Survival rates have been increasing steadily, however, over the last 15 years, particularly in younger patients like Helen. Indeed, given improvements in treatment, after the initial treatment with chemotherapy, it is possible that one day in the not too distant future multiple myeloma could be treated as a chronic disease, as Dr. Jangi himself points out.
If you’ve been reading this blog and stories like this long enough, you’ll know what’s coming next:
…Helen began to wonder if this was her fault—if she had done something wrong. Still a young woman, married, employed, with two children at home, she exercised regularly, never smoked, rarely drank, and hardly ever got a cold. What in my life, she wondered, was to blame?
Helen’s doctors encouraged her to look forward. Her hematologist, at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston, explained that her bone marrow had become overgrown by cancerous immune cells, and that the treatment required high doses of chemotherapy. The doctor described the litany of consequences from the powerful medications: hair loss, infections, and a probable bone marrow transplantation. Helen sat in the clinic of the busy Boston hospital, surrounded by expert oncologists with their novel clinical trials in dismay. She faced either the threat of a serious, potentially life-limiting disease or a heavy-duty regimen of drugs that she felt would similarly poison her body. “There had to be another way,” she said. “I didn’t want chemotherapy.”
Helen did choose another way, based on her suspicion about why she had fallen sick in the first place. “It had to be my diet,” she told me. So, against all professional medical advice, she started an experiment on herself.
Humans crave explanation, as I have pointed out so many times before. When someone as young as Helen is diagnosed with a life-threatening disease that’s pretty uncommon to begin with but very uncommon in patients her age, the natural thing for her to do is to look for possible explanations, just as, for example, the mother of Tiffany Frantz did when Tiffany was diagnosed at age 21 with breast cancer. She ended up incorrectly blaming her daughter’s keeping her cell phone in her bra. Also, as I’ve said so many times before about so many other patients, I don’t blame Helen for being afraid. High dose chemotherapy followed by stem cell rescue (i.e., a bone marrow transplantation) is a brutal, brutal regimen that requires prolonged hospitalization and guarantees some nasty side effects. I understand, at least as much as anyone who hasn’t himself been faced with such a choice. However, there is little good evidence connecting diet with elevated risk for multiple myeloma, other than one study in which risk correlates with obesity and negatively correlates with cruciferous vegetables and fish. In such an uncommon disease, rare in her age group, the likelihood that the small absolute risk reduction from a dietary change would have made any difference is exceedingly small. In any case, before too long we learn that Helen headed for the Mexican border and went to Baja to begin “nutritional therapy for her cancer.” That therapy? You guessed it: Gerson.
Here’s where Jangi goes off the rails. For one thing, I hate it when Gerson therapy is just described as “nutritional” therapy or “dietary therapy.” So vague. So bland. It doesn’t tell you just exactly what the Gerson protocol involves. It’s something I discussed in detail less than three months ago; so I don’t feel a need to go into great detail, but let’s just briefly recap what the Gerson protocol involves:
    • Thirteen glasses of fresh, raw carrot/apple and green-leaf juices prepared hourly from fresh, organic fruits and vegetables.
    • Three full plant-based meals, freshly prepared from organically grown fruits, vegetables and whole grains. A typical meal will include salad, cooked vegetables, baked potatoes, Hippocrates soup and juice.
    • Fresh fruit and vegetables available at all hours for snacking, in addition to the regular diet.
The Gerson therapy requires enormous amounts of these fruits and vegetables to make these juices and meals, up to 20 lbs. per day or even more, as well as these supplements:
    • Potassium compound
    • Lugol’s solution
    • Vitamin B-12
    • Thyroid hormone
    • Pancreatic enzymes
To top all this off (I know, old joke), the Gerson therapy involves coffee enemas, lots and lots and lots of coffee enemas, usually five a day. To be fair, Jangi does describe some of this and how it took three weeks at the Gerson Clinic to learn the protocol, which she followed for two years. She even quoted Helen as saying, “I was actually pretty exhausted that whole time.” However, instead of making the Gerson protocol sound quacky (which it is), he makes it sound downright rational (which it isn’t). For instance, he portrays poor Max Gerson as persecuted, having come up with his idea as the “pharmaceutical industry entered its golden era”:
While in Germany, Gerson had created a regimen devoid of processed foods and had published several cases of patients forever cured of migraines, arthritis, and even forms of tuberculosis. He surprised himself most when, in 1928, a patient with cancer of the bile ducts asked for his diet. Initially, he refused, but caved to her persistence. Six months later, he announced her cure. Two more cancer cures followed.
Dr. Jangi desperately needs to read Peter Moran’s excellent deconstruction of Max Gerson’s “50 cases” that he used as evidence that his protocol could cure cancer. Seriously. There is no excuse to portray Gerson’s nonsense this way, no excuse at all, much less to go on to write:
But Gerson ran into resistance when he began applying his dietary regimen at Gotham Hospital in New York City in the 1940s. Suspicious of his methods, the Journal of the American Medical Association asked for copies of Gerson’s data. When he failed to provide the reputed medical journal the requested information, the editors responded. In a widely read 1946 JAMA article, editor Dr. Morris Fishbein (who actually made much of his reputation busting medical flimflammery) denounced the Gerson diet as lacking significant evidence in the treatment of cancer. In a follow-up editorial in 1949, Fishbein published a criticism of Gerson’s approach in a review entitled “Frauds and Fables,” labeling Gerson a charlatan.
Gee, Jangi writes this as though what Dr. Fishbein did were a bad thing! Or that it were a bad thing that the American Medical Association and the American Cancer Society blacklisted the Gerson regimen and insurance companies stopped providing compensation for the therapy! It wasn’t. None of it was. In fact, the whole tone of Dr. Jangi’s article is irritating to the extreme to anyone who knows the actual history of Max Gerson and his “alternative cancer cure,” painting Gerson as an unfairly persecuted visionary who was driven unjustly from his country. Heck, Jangi even uses the word “persecution” when he observes that after Gerson’s death his daughter Charlotte “founded a place to administer his therapies at a hospital near Tijuana, free from the persecution of American medical societies.” She’s still there, decades later. None of this stops Jangi from making Gerson sound like the brave maverick doctor persecuted by the medical establishment who just didn’t see his genius. Oh, sure, ten patients were admitted to hospitals in Southern California with Campylobacter fetus sepsis, believed to be a side effect of the liver injections that accompany the older versions of the therapy, none of them cured of cancer. And there were a bunch of other complications and fatalities, too, as documented in this article.
Of course, that doesn’t seem to bother Jangi as much as this:
In 1992, JAMA published a “special communication” again denouncing the therapy. “The poisons in processed foods that proponents of the Gerson therapy say cause cancer have never been identified,” they wrote, disputing the idea that a diet of fruits and vegetables could prevent the process of cancer development. “This makes the Gerson therapy impossible to accept,” they wrote.
I can’t get an article from JAMA that old through my institutional subscription, so I can’t evaluate it for myself in context. However, the many criticisms of the Gerson protocol from that era and before that I have read generally emphasize its extreme biological implausibility given how it is based on an idea of how cancer forms from the early 1900s that had long since been shown to be incorrect; the lack of evidence, basic science or clinical trial, that it works; and the harm caused to patients. It’s well-accepted that diet can decrease the risk of certain cancers; what’s not well-accepted, mainly because there is little or no good evidence, is that dietary interventions can impact the progression and course of cancer. Remember, that is what Gerson claimed, that a radical diet, a boatload of supplements per day, and coffee enemas could cure cancer. Indeed, a deceased proponent of the Gerson protocol, Jess Ainscough, reported that over the two years she did the Gerson protocol she had consumed 8,760 glasses of juice, 1,460 baked potatoes, 1,460 bowls of Hippocrates soup, 33,580 supplements, and 174 shots of castor oil, while giving herself 2,920 coffee enemas. Two years include 730 days; so you can do the math yourself.
In other words, the reason the Gerson protocol is viewed as quackery (at least by physicians who even know what it is in the first place) is quite simple. It is quackery. Max Gerson was not some poor, misunderstood, persecuted visionary. He was a dangerous quack, and his daughter continues to carry on that quackery. Yet the average reader only gets a very minimal inkling of this possibility, if any at all, from Dr. Jangi’s article.
Food versus medicine
As much as the whole Gerson business irked me, what really frustrated me about this article is that there are some insights in there. This could have been a good article explaining to the lay public what is known and what isn’t known about nutrition and disease and why it’s difficult to evaluate such treatments. He takes a stab at that when he points out how difficult it is to do randomized controlled studies of dietary interventions because it’s almost impossible to blind them and they require one group to make a major change to their lifestyle that could take years before an effect is observed. Still, such studies have been done, such as the study of the Mediterranean diet published in the NEJM in 2013 that showed a Mediterranean diet supplemented with extra-virgin olive oil or nuts reduced the incidence of major cardiovascular events by 30% in high risk patients.
Jangi also mentions work by Gary Wu, the associate chief of research in the Division of Gastroenterology at the University of Pennsylvania, who has studied elemental diets—a regimen composed of components of food in its simplest form—as a treatment for inflammatory bowel disease. His results suggest that the therapy works almost as well as TNF inhibitors, although Jangi didn’t make a couple of important things clear. First, as far as I can tell, there has as yet not been a randomized controlled trial. The most recent clinical study by Dr. Wu I could find was a prospective observational study. He also neglects to note that these “elemental diets” are liquid diets that sometimes have to be administered through a feeding tube. They’re not exactly great as far as lifestyle goes. They’re not “normal” in the sense that they don’t allow the patient to eat what most would refer to as “real” food. They’re also nothing new. These sorts of diets have been studied in inflammatory bowel disease and other gut disorders on and off for a long time. I remember endless debates in my ICU rotations in the 1990s over whether using elemental diets, parenteral nutrition, diets with medium chain triglycerides, or various other tube feeding formulas best prevented and/or healed gut dysfunction in critically ill patients.
Oh, and Dr. Jangi falls a bit for the magical thinking so many are layering on the emerging field of epigenetics. Ugh. (Click the links if you want to see why his brief discussion of epigenetics is a misfire.) He also greatly exaggerates the promise of substances like curcumin, whose reality (in my not so humble opinion) hasn’t really lived up to the hype of several years ago, citing a seven year old article.
One area that could also have used a bit more explanation is the recent FDA guidelines about whether a human study can be conducted without an investigational new drug application (IND). It’s a topic that I might have to take the time to do an entire post about after reading the entire draft guidelines and looking up some analyses. Basically, he has a germ of a point when he writes:
But recent guidance from the FDA similarly requires that foods being tested for the management of illness also mandate submission of an IND if those foods are to be studied in humans, a significant hurdle for academics and researchers who cannot invest in such a potentially expensive gamble. Consequently, nutritional therapies have a hard time reaching the stage of serious clinical trials. They never receive the FDA’s blessings and stagnate in the dark corner of the local vitamin shop, lost to the mainstream.
On the one hand, I can understand the FDA’s rationale if the intent of the food use is to treat a disease; in that case, it is arguably being used as medicine. On the other hand, what about diets that don’t necessarily involve what the FDA refers to as “medicinal foods” (e.g., curcumin for cancer prevention or treatment), such as exclusion diets for inflammatory bowel disease, or, for that matter, the Mediterranean diet, which doesn’t include any specific single “medicinal food” but rather broad types of foods in certain proportions? One also can’t help but wonder whether this confusing morass has a lot to do with how dietary supplements were handled 20 years ago by the DSHEA of 1994? For instance, I have seen supplement manufacturers complain that these guidelines make it possible for the same supplement to be considered simultaneously a drug if it’s in a clinical trial after an IND is obtained and a supplement. Of course, I rather suspect that they doth protest a bit too much because they don’t want to do clinical trials anyway when the DSHEA lets them sell their supplements with minimal regulation. Why would they want to dive into this morass, when it could only hurt their profits? Be that as it may, requiring an IND makes sense when it’s a defined supplement or manufactured diet (such as the aforementioned elemental diet) but makes a lot less sense for diets like the Mediterranean diet.
In the end, Dr. Jangi sweeps around again to his human interest element, Helen. Happily, she is still alive and doing well six years later:
Yet her appearance, however glowing, belied her five-year struggle—her trip to Baja, to various clinics, hospitals, and rehabilitation centers; her inner conflicts between her own philosophies and those offered by conventional doctors and alternative practitioners; blood-test results that made her question her decision to forgo chemotherapy. Yet nutrition continued to be a centerpiece of her life. A volunteer at her children’s elementary school, she saw what other children were eating and worried about her own kids’ health. At home, her family followed her lead in dietary change. “Now my husband and children eat real food,” she said, citing almond-flour pancakes, oatmeal, honey, whole grain breads, bananas, berries, kale, spinach, red carrots, and grass-fed meats.
I really wish that Dr. Jangi had read a bit about these alternative cancer cure testimonials before featuring Helen so prominently. I found what is almost certainly her blog, given her timeline. It wasn’t hard, but since Dr. Jangi didn’t want to reveal who she is I will honor that. What I did learn is that she was into alternative therapy from the beginning, given that she went to her naturopath to evaluate her initial complaints that ultimately led to her being diagnosed. Thankfully for her, her naturopath was one of the more reasonable ones and noticed that a lot more was going on than he could handle. After she finished Gerson therapy (which she described as the “two hardest years of my life”), her disease was merely “stable,” as she described it, and she was clearly disappointed. In the process she had had to have all her amalgam fillings removed, which left her with extreme sensitivity to hot and cold.
So she moved on to the Gonzalez protocol, where she takes 160 supplements per day, fewer coffee enemas than the Gerson protocol, and a lot of the same other woo, given the considerable overlap between Gerson’s protocol and Dr. Gonzelez’s protocol. There’s also the usual stuff on there about how big pharma has no interest in “natural, safe, effective healing” as there is no way for them to “patent a nutritional product and reap large profits.” She also doesn’t vaccinate her children (a decision that Nicholas Gonzalez fully supported, telling her that childhood diseases “served a purpose”). Her disease has waxed and waned, and at one point it must have alarmed Gonzalez enough that he sent her to an oncologist who wanted to begin chemotherapy but was going to start her on Revlimid, a drug related to thalidomide, which has been found to be effective treating multiple myeloma. Overall, though, there are lots of posts about her IgA (she has IgA myeloma) going up and down and various dubious markers drawn by Gonzalez similarly going up and down. She keeps saying she’s getting better, but somehow the tumor never seems to go away and there’s always a story about her numbers “going in the wrong direction.” Her IgA level seems to bounce between 6,000 and 7,000. (Normal is 70-400.) The most parsimonious explanation is that Helen is fortunate enough to have an indolent tumor that is not really progressing much, despite her having a higher-risk subtype. It is, after all, known that there is a “clear heterogeneity amongst patients with myeloma as some individuals have a slow disease pace and can live decades and others have rapid disease progression, unresponsiveness to multiple therapies and short survival.”
Dr. Jangi clearly hasn’t dealt with alternative medicine cancer cure testimonials, as I have. All you have to do is to look at the comment section, where alt-med believers have descended to castigate big pharma and tout their alternative cures.
In the end, I can’t help but reiterate my disappointment. There is so much to discuss with respect to diet and cancer, but Dr. Jangi decided to structure his story around a run-of-the-mill alternative medicine cancer cure testimonial that didn’t tell anywhere near the whole story, much less enough to judge whether Helen is doing better than she should be expected to do. She is then represented as an example of a “nutrition gap” in which doctors and patients believe very different things about nutrition when in fact, all you have to do is to read her blog to see that she is an alt-med True Believer, hardly typical of the average person interested in nutrition and health. Then, the whole story is bolstered with alt med tropes that border on conspiracy mongering, in which pharmaceutical companies rule and doctors’ organizations ruthlessly suppress research into diet and health. There is promise in using dietary manipulations as medicine (“let food be your medicine”) for a variety of conditions; doctors have been doing it since Hippocrates. It does no one any favors to use a sympathetic portrait of an unfortunate alt-med true believer to stand in for the disconnect between what people think about food and health and what doctors think about it.
ADDENDUM: A nice article: The new religion: How the emphasis on ‘clean eating’ has created a moral hierarchy for food.

The Food Is Medicine (FIM) Movement
Optimal nutrition can be a highly cost-effective, even net positive, government program.
Steven Novella on September 27, 2023
Link

I have to admit, I have a knee-jerk negative reaction to phrases like “food is medicine” because of how much this concept has been abused within the alternative medicine sphere. The concept, for example, of “neutraceuticals” – using vitamins and supplements as if they were drugs – is misleading. Alternative practitioners also often behave as if every medical problem is nutritional, and directly lobby to blur the lines between nutrition and medicine. The Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA) of 1994 did this explicitly, regulating herbal products, which are drugs, as if they were food.
But the “Food Is Medicine” (FIM) movement is not this. “Medicine” in this term does not refer to concepts like “neutraceuticals” but rather to the health effects of nutrition. “Medicine” is sort-of a metaphor – meaning that nutrition can be a proper medical intervention, not that it should be thought of like a drug. And they are clear – they are talking about the health effects of good and bad nutrition.
A recent report (two US-based case studies) produced by the FIM group at Tufts University is a good example of the kinds of interventions they are talking about, and what they mean by “medicine”. They studied the potential impact of programs that fall into two basic groups – medically tailored meals (MTMs) and nutritional support. The ultimate point of the data is that public spending on these types of programs is cost effective. They will save more money than the programs cost. They note:
The economic costs of suboptimal diets due to health care spending and lost productivity are estimated at $1.1 trillion each year.
This is partly due to lack of nutrition, but also due to poor diets in general. This counts obesity and diabetes, for example, as chronic conditions impacted by diet. What kinds of interventions are they talking about? Three types of programs address tailoring food to specific chronic illnesses – medically tailored meals, medically tailored groceries, and produce prescription programs. One intervention addresses poor nutrition – nutrition security programs. And then they include population-level interventions dealing with food policies and programs.
Addressing nutrition as part of dealing with a chronic illness is nothing new. What is new about such programs is taking such interventions to the next level – treating it as a prescribed medical intervention (a literal prescription), one that would be covered by insurance and supported by specific programs.
This concept is not entirely new either. It is possible, for example, for physicians to document that a patient has a medical condition that warrants something, like air conditioning, that might otherwise be deemed a luxury. For certain diseases, air conditioning is not a luxury, it is a medical necessity. Often there are state programs or even regulations that force companies to provide services to customers if they are medically necessary. The FIM movement essentially wants to formalize a similar approach to nutrition.
It is pointless to consider whether the government “should” be paying for such things. The government is already paying for health care, which is the largest part of most government’s spending (even the US), and rising. The real question is – are such programs cost effective? These two case studies show that they potentially are.
The first study looks at a national medically tailored meal program. They estimate this will save $38.7 billion in direct healthcare costs, with a net savings of $13.6 billion. Even when just considering direct healthcare costs, such a program would more than pay for itself. This does not even consider the secondary savings from avoiding lost productivity and other government support programs that come along with that. For a net savings, this would also improve the health and quality of life for millions of people.
The second study looked at produce prescription programs. They estimated the total cost of the program at $44.3 billion with direct healthcare savings of $39.6 billion and productivity savings of $4.8 billion. Even though this does not produce a net positive in direct healthcare costs, it is essentially neutral when adding lost productivity. Without adding in lost productivity, it is still a highly cost-effective program, when considering the health outcomes per dollar spent.
Of course, these are estimates. For the first study:
For this case study, a population-level, cohort policy simulation model was created based on nationally representative samples from the 2019 Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (MEPS).
These are standard methods and are validated, but they are still estimates based on models. The next step is to actually implement such programs and measure outcomes. In the US the healthcare system is setup to easily allow for 50 experimental regions – the states. Such programs are implemented at the state level in any case, even if they receive federal funding. This allows for easy experimentation, to see which programs work best and then to replicate them on a national level. At the very least these studies show the potential of such programs – if implemented well, they are likely to be highly cost effective, and even net positive.
The broader concept here, that I think is legitimate, is that there are many potential interventions that have a huge impact on health that are not traditional medical interventions. Many of these we already take for granted, like poison control, public safety, and sanitation (the latter being arguably the greatest health intervention in human history). We should add to this list things like optimal nutrition, gun safety, and addressing health misinformation. And as always, such interventions need to be as evidence and science-based as possible.

Food for Thought
Harriet Hall on February 4, 2014
Link
I am excited to tell you about a wonderful new endeavor that is helping to promote critical thinking about science and medicine. It’s a free online course on “Food for Thought” that offers a scientific framework for understanding food and its impact on health and society from past to present.
The “Food for Thought” course is a product of EdX, which offers online college courses from Harvard, MIT, and other prestigious universities. They provide videos with interactive features and access to online student communities. Students can audit a course and get full access to all the materials including tests, assignments, and discussion forums with no commitment, and can choose what and how much they want to do.
The course is presented by 3 chemistry professors from McGill University’s Office for Science and Society, “a unique venture dedicated to the promotion of critical thinking and the presentation of scientific information to the public, educators and students in an accurate and responsible fashion.” Joe Schwarcz (also known as “Dr. Joe” from his long-running radio show), Ariel Fenster, and David Harpp are world-class science communicators who tirelessly promote science in various ways, including books, media appearances, and a “Chemistry for the Public” lecture series with 60 offerings in two languages and intriguing titles like “Hey! There are Cockroaches in my Chocolate Ice Cream!” They are definitely on the same wavelength as the writers on SBM; in fact, the “suggested sites” listed at the bottom of the OSS page include SBM, Quackwatch, and Respectful Insolence (that blog written by Dr. Gorski’s not-so-mysterious friend). They have been co-teaching the “Food for Thought” course as a “World of Chemistry” course to McGill students for 30 years, and they have developed it into a polished act.
Week 1 is an introduction that includes material on scientific principles, methods, research, and publishing. There is an excellent discussion of the different types of study (cohort, case control, RCT, etc.). They cover many other topics that we have addressed on SBM. In subsequent weeks they will cover vitamins, minerals, nutrient groups, agricultural science, food additives, sweeteners, adverse food reactions, weight control, diet and cancer, diet and the heart, health food, wine and cheese, and even a cooking demonstration! Throughout, they present the most up-to-date research and examine it with a critical eye.
Each lesson consists of several short videos interspersed with polls (followed by a breakdown of how many students chose each answer), self-assessment questions to see how well the student has understood the material just presented (with immediate feedback), other activities, and at the end, a list of references. Then there are discussion groups organized by topic, where you can ask questions and interact with other students all over the world. If you do the tests and assignments, there is a tab where you can see your overall progress at a glance. There is even a wiki, and a map showing where students are located. You can go back and review any lesson at any time. A feature I really like is the simultaneous transcript that runs to the right of the videos to reinforce what you hear with what you see, and also to facilitate scrolling to a specific part of the video. There is even a speed control so you can save time by running the videos at 1.5x or 2x normal speed. 2x is too fast for me, but I found 1.5x to be handy.
They illustrate common errors in thinking with memorable funny examples and stories. For example, Dr. Schwarcz illustrates the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy by pointing out that breast cancer is correlated with wearing skirts, but that doesn’t mean skirts cause breast cancer. In a discussion of meat in the diet, he tells us he grew up in meat-loving Hungary, “where salami is a vegetable and tofu is illegal.”
If I had my druthers, I would like to see a way to educate the public that:
    • Attracts students by relating science to subjects that are important to them every day, like deciding what to eat
    • Explains why science is important
    • Explains how science works
    • Explains how the scientific publishing system works
    • Explains why we shouldn’t automatically believe the results of every RCT
    • Explains how people can be misled and reach false conclusions
    • Debunks common health myths
    • Provides accurate evidence-based answers to health questions
    • Says “we don’t know” when the evidence is insufficient
    • Is widely available to everyone
    • Is free
    • Has short segments that don’t exceed the typical short modern attention span
    • Can be accessed at the reader’s own pace
    • Can be viewed on iPads and other devices
    • Has lots of effective visuals
    • Has dynamic, engaging teachers
    • Is funny and entertaining
    • Is interactive
    • Has a way to ask questions and communicate with other students
    • Can be audited with no commitment
“Food for Thought” fulfills every item on my wish list. It’s just what the doctor ordered. And the quality is superb.
The course started on January 22, 2014 and will be released in weekly segments for 14 weeks. You can register at any time during the course with no penalty except that you will not be able to submit any assignment that is past due.
By January 24th, only two days after the course officially started, 22,000 people had already registered in more than 150 countries. This is huge, more than the total number of students who took the course at McGill over a period of 3 decades.
I am really enthusiastic about “Food for Thought.” I registered, and I can hardly wait for the next weekly segment to be released. I urge you to register too, and to tell your friends (and enemies).

Food Fears
Steven Novella on June 25, 2014
Link
A new Cornell University study examines the origins of food fears, and possible remedies. It’s a survey of 1,008 mothers asking about foods they avoid and why.
Food fears are a common topic on SBM, likely for several reasons. Humans have an inherent emotion of disgust, which is likely an adaptation to help avoid contaminated or spoiled food. In our modern society this reflex can be tricky, because we do not always have control over the chain of events that leads to food on our plates. Other people grow the food, transport it, process it, and perhaps even cook it.
Modern food technology can also involve many scary sounding substances and unusual processes. As the saying goes, you may not want to know how the sausage is made, as long as the end result is wholesome.
This leads to a second reason for modern food fears – we are living in an age of increasing transparency, partly brought about by the dramatic increase in access to information on the internet. I think ultimately this is a good thing – people are seeing how the sausage is made, which makes it more difficult to hide shady practices. This introduces a new problem, however. If you’re going to inspect the process of making sausage, then you need to know something about sausage-making.
In other words – people are obtaining a great deal of information about food, food ingredients, and manufacturing processes, which is a good thing. However, much of this information is coming from dubious sources – non-professional or academic sources that have not been peer reviewed in any meaningful way and may have ulterior agendas or ideological biases.
Further, it is not easy to understand any complex science, including chemistry and food science, which includes medical studies on ingredient safety. The Food Babe has essentially made a career out of provoking irrational fear of ingredients with unsavory sources and with scary-sounding, long chemical names. Neither of these factors have anything to do with actual food safety, but they make it easy to scare the non-expert.
Specifically this includes so-called “chemophobia” – which is the fear of chemicals. The problem with this “Food Babe”, chemophobic approach is that everything is chemicals. As the banana graphic above demonstrates, the formal chemical names even for everyday food molecules are long and unfamiliar to non-chemists.
The end result is that many people use shortcuts or heuristics to determine what food they trust and what food to avoid. One heuristic is the “natural” false dichotomy – if something seems natural it is healthful, and if it seems synthetic it should be avoided. This heuristic rapidly breaks down on two main counts. The first is that there is no good operational definition of “natural.” All food is altered by humans or processed in some way. Where do you draw the line? The second is that something occurring in nature is no guarantee of safety. Most things in nature will harm or even kill you. Many plants and animals have evolved toxins specifically to harm anything that tries to eat it.
Another food heuristic (one explicitly endorsed by the Food Babe) is the chemophobia heuristic – if it has a long chemical name that is difficult to pronounce, then it’s scary.
Yet another heuristic is to avoid anything about which anyone expresses fear or concern. This tactic is to essentially err on the side of caution in response to any expression of risk regarding a food. This strategy obviously occurs along a spectrum, but even a moderate degree of the precautionary principle can put a great deal of power in the hands of internet fearmongerers.
The fearmongering heuristic is also related to another one, which is to separate foods into “good” foods and “bad” foods. Bad foods are to be avoided all the time, in any amounts. This derives partly for a desire for simplicity and control – boiling all the complexity of diet and nutrition down to a simple list of naughty and nice. The reality is that the health effects of eating most food are all about proportions. Most things are fine in moderation.
Let’s get back to the recent survey – they found that food fears were associated with wanting others to know about your food choices and deriving food information from the internet rather than TV or other sources. One might conclude from this that the internet drives food fears, which would seem to be a reasonable conclusion. However, there are too many potential confounding factors to make any statements about cause and effect.
The survey also found that mothers with food fears were not more willing to pay more for food without the scary ingredient than mothers with less food fears. This again is difficult to interpret.
One potentially encouraging result of the survey is that the effects of food fears were mitigated by providing information about the food. This would suggest that attempts to educate the public about the real nature and scientific evidence regarding a demonized food could reduce irrational fears. The limitation of the survey was that the results were only assessed immediately, so it’s difficult to tell if there was any real long-term effect.
Conclusion
Irrational and faddish food fears now seem to be part of the culture, worsened by the immense flow of information over the internet, most of which is unvetted. This results in some people avoiding perfectly harmless ingredients based on unfounded fearmongering. As we have seen, this can also lead to pressure being placed on food manufacturers to eliminate the harmless ingredients (and their benefits) just to avoid the effects of a fearmongering campaign.
Further, irrational fearmongering about food provides unintentional cover for ingredients that should be limited or avoided. This results from two factors. The first is simply burying the useful information under piles of misinformation. The second is replacing a science-based assessment of reliable information about the real risks vs benefits of food ingredients, with sloppy heuristics that will tend to lead astray.
Internet food warriors are promoting an unscientific approach to food safety, based upon the naturalistic fallacy, chemophobia, the demonization of foods and ingredients, and a misapplication of the precautionary principle.

Ultraprocessed Foods
Steven Novella on June 12, 2024
Link

What are “ultraprocessed foods” and are they a health risk? One would think there is reason for concern, given all the hyped headlines, but as is often the case the data is somewhat complicated.
The complexity begins with the fact that there is no agreed-upon operational definition of “ultraprocessed food” (UPF). Processed food generally refers to food products that are already prepared and packaged, as opposed to raw ingredients that need to be prepared and cooked. This could include a can of soup or a baked good. There is no clear dividing line between processed and ultraprocessed, and no specific features that are considered key.
One of the common features of processed foods is that they have additives which serve a variety of purposes. These include preservatives to prolong shelf life and enhance food safety, stabilizers, emulsifiers, anti-oxidants, flavoring, and coloring agents. Each ingredient, of course, is studied and approved separately by the FDA or similar agencies in other countries.
Processed foods also tend to be higher in fat, sugar, and salt, and lower in fiber and micronutrients than foods prepared from raw ingredients. Diets with such a profile are already known to carry health risks.
There have now been numerous studies, all observational, looking to see if there is any correlation between the consumption of processed or ultraprocessed foods and adverse health outcomes, including all-cause mortality. Most prominently is data from the French online health survey NutriNet-Santé which has spawned multiple studies. One study published in JAMA found:
A total of 602 deaths (1.4%) occurred during follow-up. After adjustment for a range of confounding factors, an increase in the proportion of ultraprocessed foods consumed was associated with a higher risk of all-cause mortality (HR per 10% increment, 1.14; 95% CI, 1.04-1.27; P = .008).
So it looks like consumption of upf was association with a 10% increase in all cause mortality. But many experts have found this data unconvincing, mostly for the usual reasons that limit the interpretation of observational studies. In this data set consumption of upf was associated with lower income, lower educational level, living alone, higher BMI and lower physical activity. These are all features that increase the risk of all-cause mortality. When you account for preexisting conditions the statistical significance of the effect is reduced, and if you eliminate those who die in the first year of the study, it goes away.
One way to look at this data is that, when we study each individual ingredient that may be present in processed food they appear to be safe. When you look at processed food consumption itself (rather than specific ingredients) you observationally see a correlation with negative health outcomes, but this data is massively confounded by a host of lifestyle factors.
Overall it seems highly likely that increased consumption of processed food is simply a marker for people who need the convenience of preprepared food because they live alone and are low SES (socioeconomic status). People in this category tend to be more overweight and exercise less, in addition to a host of other health factors.
But perhaps the biggest weakness of this data is the way it chooses to define processed and ultraprocessed foods, by the number of ingredients they have that are typically used in processed food. The nutritional quality of the food is generally not considered, nor are the ingredients themselves or their purpose.
The result is a focus on the wrong thing – where and how food is prepared rather than its nutritional content. Processed foods may also be high in fat, sugar, and salt, but so can non-processed or minimally processed foods. Also, telling people not to eat cheap, tasty, convenient food seems unlikely to be a successful public health measure. The people who currently rely on cheap convenient food likely don’t have many other options.
A better approach, one that is generally already used, is to investigate individual ingredients for their safety. Second, focus on public education regarding how to have a healthful diet. Eat a varied diet with plenty of foods that are high in nutrients, such as fruits and vegetables. Keep an eye on your overall salt and sugar intake. Keep it simple and focus on the data that is highly reliable.
There can also be a positive impact from focusing on the manufacturing end – make food labeling informative and easy to read and understand. Don’t allow deceptive or manipulative labeling. Other public health measures that may be effective include addressing so-called food deserts, where fresh foods are simply not locally available.
Demonizing processed foods based upon weak observational data that focuses on the wrong thing, however, is unlikely to be helpful.

The War Over Ultraprocessed Foods
Steven Novella on December 3, 2025
Link

Recently the city of San Francisco sued several food giants (Kraft Heinz, Mondelez and Coca-Cola) for deceptively marketing “ultraprocessed foods” and then externalizing the resulting health care costs onto the public. They cite a recent Lancet review which concludes:
“The totality of the evidence supports the thesis that displacement of long-established dietary patterns by ultra-processed foods is a key driver of the escalating global burden of multiple diet-related chronic diseases.”
What are ultraprocessed foods, and what is the evidence base for their health effects? I don’t think this story is as clear as the Lancet authors claim. There is likely some real signal here in the data, but the details are fuzzy.
The first problem is that there is no operational definition of “ultraprocessed”. The basic idea is these are foods that are highly processed and ready-to-eat, as opposed to “whole” foods that are minimally processed, such as raw vegetables. But the processing of good into a ready-to-eat form is not itself a health risk. Processed is being used as a marker for specific features that are common but not universal in processed foods. As the Lancet authors summarize:
“…overeating driven by high energy density, hyper-palatability, soft texture, and disrupted food matrices; reduced intake of health-protective phytochemicals; and increased intake of toxic compounds, endocrine disruptors, and potentially harmful classes and mixtures of food additives.”
But of course not all processed foods have all of these features. It is also not clear if each of these features represents a genuine health risk by themselves. For example, a lot of attention has been focused on food dyes, with RFK and the FDA planning to phase out 8 “artificial” food dyes by 2026. The evidence, however, does not support a specific health risk from any of the dyes, they are just being targeted for being “artificial”. Prior to the MAHA takeover, the FDA approved food dyes based on adequate safety data. Any small potential for adverse effects would only come from consuming unrealistically large amounts of such dyes. But they are easy to demonize.
Given that there are multiple regulatory agencies reviewing and updating the evidence, existing food additives are unlikely to present any significant health risk. If there is evidence for a specific risk from a specific additive, the regulations can easily be updated. Essentially the Lancet authors are criticizing processed foods for containing ingredients that have already been reviewed and approved.
Also, demonizing specific ingredients is also not science-based or rational. It results in measures that are unlikely to have any health benefit, and in fact may be counterproductive. For example, Coke has promised to replace corn syrup with cane sugar in their American products. This is essentially complete nonsense – sugar is sugar, but making people believe that cane sugar is somehow more healthful because it’s natural is deceptive.
Where there is some legitimacy, I think, is in the fact that processed foods can often be calorie dense. People can end up consuming far more calories than they think, and this can contribute to obesity. The evidence for this is mostly observational, and this make it difficult to form firm conclusions. Also, may foods in the processed category are obviously high calorie – no one should be shocked that Twinkies are calorie-dense. But even if we assume this connection is real, and not just due to confounding factors, there are solutions other than banning processed food. Processed food is cheap and convenient, that is why they are so popular, and banning them so that people are forced to buy fresh ingredients and cook is unlikely to go over well.
There are other less radical solutions. The first, which is already partly in place, is transparency – food labels should clearly indicate how many calories are in the food. Often this can be a bit deceptive, with counterintuitive serving sizes, but easily remedied with regulation. Labeling of other ingredients, such as salt, fat, and sugar content, is also helpful.
Perhaps we need to take this transparency issue further, however. Calorie dense foods could be easily indicated with a prominent warning label. This would motivate companies to stay below the threshold for being considered calorie dense. Further, lower calorie foods could also be indicated on the label, which food companies could chase by reformulating their products.
There may be other measures as well, to help people make healthier decisions easier and to avoid competition leading to the most calorie-dense foods possible.
What I fear from the current war on ultraprocessed foods is that they are focused on the wrong things and/or are making unrealistic policy recommendations. Banning food dyes and promoting the use of cane sugar are perfect examples of how these efforts can go wrong. Food companies will also happily makes these essentially cosmetic changes without altering the essence of their products. Telling people to buy more fresh produce and spend more time cooking (while these are things I personally endorse) is unlikely to achieve the hoped-for results. Cheap and easy are hard to give up. 


RFK Turns Food Pyramid On Its Head
Steven Novella on January 14, 2026
Link

Last week I wrote about the new vaccine schedule under RFK, which reveals his process. He doesn’t appear to have one. Our HHS secretary is shooting from the hip, ignoring expert advice, and trusting only his own conspiracy-addled instinct. He quickly followed with his take on the food pyramid, echoing unscientific nonsense he has been spouting for years. This also reflects another aspect of his lack of process – he does not respond to criticism. There does not appear to be any self-correcting mechanism in place, so he persists in error.
Like most dubious or alternative medicine-derived nutrition advice, it’s a mixed bag. There is often some common-sense advice mixed in, and some parts are reasonable, but the details and emphasis are often framed unscientifically. So let’s take a look.
RFK’s emphasis is on eating “real food” and avoiding processed food. I have written about the processed food gambit previously. The problem with this framing is that there is no operational definition of which foods are “real” or how much and what kind of processing poses a health risk. Yes – too much salt, fat, and sugar are a health risk, and processed foods often contain too much of these ingredients. But using “processed” as a short-cut is highly problematic.
First, not all processed foods are bad, and many are fine (like most things) in moderation. Also, this is a highly elitist recommendation. Not everyone has access to adequate produce, or the time to cook every meal. Many people rely on ready-made food for cost and convenience. RFK probably does not understand the intention-to-treat paradigm. What matters more than whether advice is precisely optimal is how people respond to that advice. Telling people to do something highly inconvenient or too expensive may be counterproductive.
A far better approach would be to regulate the processed food industry more effectively, so that the options people have are more healthful. Much of this could likely be accomplished with thoughtfully regulated labeling, requiring accessible transparency. Clearly visible warning labels about being high in salt or sugar would motivate manufacturers to avoid them, for example.
RFK also goes after non-nutritive sweeteners. This is a complex area of research, but there is no clear evidence that the net health effect of these sweeteners is negative. In fact, it is highly likely that they are superior to consuming sugar (yes, even “natural” cane sugar).
Perhaps the most controversial aspect of the new pyramid is that RFK puts meat and dairy near the top, recommending diets with higher levels of protein than the previous recommendation – up from 0.36 grams per pound of body weight to between 0.54 and 0.73 grams per pound of body weight. As a general recommendation, this is also likely counterproductive. Older adults and people on a weight-loss diet may benefit from a higher protein diet, but most people would not. In fact, most Americans already eat too much protein if anything, and further pushing high protein foods would likely come at the expense of fiber and other important constituents. He also underemphasized plant-based proteins like beans an legumes.
He also suggests full-fat dairy products. Again, this is highly likely to be counterproductive. The evidence suggests that people already consume too much dairy if anything, and increasing amounts are likely to result in consuming excess fat and sodium.
Nutrition experts are not impressed. Dalia Perelman, a research dietitian at Stanford University, pointed out internal contradictions in the recommendations:
“The guidelines contain internal contradictions,” she said. “They retain a numeric recommendation to limit saturated fat to 10% of calories, while simultaneously emphasizing meat and full-fat dairy and allowing portion sizes that make it very difficult to stay within that limit in real-world diets.”
He also recommends cooking with olive oil, which is fine, but also butter or beef tallow. This reflects his pseudoscientific fears of seed oils, not science or evidence.
In short – the recommendations are a mess. They are not evidence-based, not well-thought out from a public health perspective, and not even internally consistent. They are unlikely to make Americans more healthy, and in fact are likely to do the opposite. Given this is how RFK operates, we should expert more of this.
.

Should you be “Eating Clean”?
Scott Gavura on January 31, 2013
Link
Like many of you I’m interested in the science of good nutrition. In general, I’ve come to be pretty skeptical of the nutritional literature, as so many studies seem to follow the same trajectory that we see with drug studies: Trivial changes in non-relevant outcomes, a failure to consider the results in the context of the accumulated scientific evidence and often, significant conflicts of interest. What’s worse, “real world” nutritional studies aren’t blinded and they’re rarely prospective. So we’re left to dig through observational studies and try to sort out correlation from causation. It’s little wonder that so many consumers are confused about the basics of healthy eating. Many believe that vitamins supplements are both beneficial and routinely necessary (they are not) and that the latest “superfood” is all that’s standing between themselves and immortality. But nutritional science is important, and I’m always pleased when patients initiate discussions about weight loss, or just improving their dietary habits. After all, obesity is a significant risk factor for an array of chronic illnesses. Improving our dietary patterns should pay off with improved health. A regular challenge I face is that my patient that has already decided to use a highly restrictive weight loss plan in order to achieve a specific weight loss goal. I always caution them to take a long-term view. Weight loss is easy. Maintaining that loss is the challenge. Most “diets” fail. So I’m critical of useless interventions (like food intolerance blood tests) or faddy diets (like going gluten-free) with the hope of easy weight loss. At its core, weight loss and weight maintenance comes down to caloric balance. Permanent weight loss requires permanent dietary changes, and how we “spend” our calories matters.
Over the past few months I’ve seen a few friends and colleagues announce that they’ve decided to transform their diet, lose weight, and “eat clean”. When I asked what “clean” food was, no-one seems to have a consistent answer. The most common response was that “eating clean” meant cutting out processed foods. But to others, eating clean meant avoiding meat, anything with GMOs, wheat, and sometimes milk. It seemed to mean something different to everyone. It reminds me a bit of Humpty Dumpty in Through the Looking Glass:
When I use a word,’ Humpty Dumpty said, in rather a scornful tone, ‘it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.’
Is “eating clean” just a faddish buzzword? There are a number of personalities competing in the “eating clean” dietary space. The pioneer seems to be Tosca Reno, who has the Eat-Clean Diet and about a dozen related books based on the same idea. But she’s not alone, as there are several other books with related names, including Terry Walters with her “Clean Food” books. Success breeds competition, it seems. Given Reno’s book appears to be the most popular, I’ll take her plan as the template. She outlines the principles of how she defines eating clean in her 2007 book. I’ve added my comments after each principle.
Eat 5 or 6 small meals every day. There’s nothing inherently wrong with this approach, but there’s no good evidence to say that it’s necessary. Obesity specialist Yoni Freedhoff notes that while smaller, spaced meals may reduce cravings and hunger, meal spacing is often individualized and shouldn’t be forced into any specific schedule. The best schedule is what works for you.
Eat every 2 to 3 hours. This is somewhat redundant with the above. Eating regularly may reduce the risk of snacking.
Combine lean protein and complex carbs at every meal. Protein promotes satiety, and the requirement to combine it with complex carbohydrates is presumably based on the idea that it will result in more stable blood sugar levels. There’s nothing unorthodox about this advice, but neither has it been shown to be always necessary.
Consume adequate healthy fats each day. This is a reasonable recommendation, and one that’s supported by good evidence. Substituting refined carbohydrates for saturated or trans fats with has either no effect, or a negative effect, on your health. Substituting monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats for saturated and trans fats helps lower the risk of heart disease, a positive effect. So the advice to consume adequate healthy fats would be better phrased as guidance to substitute healthy fats (mono- and poly-unsaturated) for unhealthy fats (saturated and trans).
Drink at least 2 liters, or 8 cups, of water each day. This is unfounded advice. There’s no persuasive evidence to demonstrate that we need to consume that much water each day. It’s such a pervasive urban myth that there’s even a Snopes page on the statement. Water may be supplied in beverages but also in food. Thirst is an acceptable guide – there’s no reason to force fluid consumption.
Never miss a meal, especially breakfast. Again, this is somewhat redundant with the advice above. While there is some evidence to suggest that regular eating, including breakfast, can help manage hunger, it’s not an absolute rule. Some people don’t like to eat breakfast, and it’s often an individual decision.
Carry a cooler loaded with Eat-Clean foods to get through the day. This is reasonable advice if accessing foods is difficult or expensive. But not always necessary.
Avoid all over-processed, refined foods, especially white flour and sugar. Here’s where we finally get into some specific dietary advice. This is largely reasonable, as heavily processed foods tend to be higher in salt and calories, and may also be less nutritious. There is very little scientific debate that whole grain products are superior to those that contain mainly white flour, which is missing the most nutritious parts of the grain. There’s also good evidence to suggest many people obtain an excessive number of calories from sugar, and from refined carbohydrates in general. However, advising that all white flour and sugar be avoided is very difficult, and there’s no reason they cannot be consumed in moderation. What matters is the overall caloric balance.
Avoid chemicals, preservatives, and artificial sugar. This simply the fallacy of appeal to nature. It’s not possible to avoid “chemicals” in your diet; chemicals ARE your diet. The same can be said for preservatives. Salt is a preservative. Added ingredients need to be evaluated on their own merits, not avoided wholesale. The same can be said for artificial sweeteners. Reno demonizes sugar substitutes claiming they “work against you just as much as white sugar does.” Yet there is no persuasive evidence to demonstrate that artificial sweeteners are harmful, or will compromise dietary goals. The same cannot be said for sugar.
Avoid saturated and trans fats. There is no good evidence to suggest that a high fat intake is inherently harmful so long as overall calorie intake is reasonable, or that total amount of fat in one’s diet must be limited. However, as noted above, the types of fats matter. Avoiding saturated fats completely is difficult and probably inadvisable as many sources of healthy fats will usually contain some saturated fat (e.g., fish, nuts). Trans fats from prepared foods, however, should be avoided, as there’s good evidence to suggest that their consumption is associated with negative health outcomes.
Avoid sugar-loaded colas and juices. Reno’s advice here is consistent with most dietary advice that identified colas and juices as low-nutritive, high-calorie beverages. Beverages can be a significant source of calories. In these circumstances, minimizing their consumption is probably warranted. While most liquid calories are treated the same as colas and juices, these two categories are commonly consumed and represent easily modifiable changes in one’s diet. However, Reno also says products like honey and maple syrup are acceptable substitutes for sugar when used in moderation, ignoring the fact that calories are calories, and these substitutes differ little from sucrose from a nutritional perspective.
Consume adequate healthy fats (EFAs) each day. This advice is largely sound. Essential fatty acids (EFAs) are “essential” because they cannot be synthesized by the body. Polyunsaturated fatty acids like eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) are healthy fats are associated in prospective and observational studies with a number of cardiovascular (and other) benefits. Fatty fish consumption (e.g., salmon) at least twice per week is the usual recommendation for those without known disease, with supplements only when justified in those that don’t eat fish. Daily consumption, however, hasn’t been established as necessary.
Avoid alcohol-another form of sugar. While alcohol can be a source of calories, and contains no nutritional benefits, the health effects of alcohol are mixed. Alcohol may reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease, while raising cancer risks slightly. For many, alcohol can be consumed in moderation without any expected significant health effects.
Avoid all calorie-dense foods that contain little or no nutritional value. This is a general statement that speaks to caloric and nutrient density. On balance we want to maximize the nutrition within a given amount of food consumed. But while intuitively appealing, studies don’t show a strong relationship between caloric density and weight. It may be that we increase overall consumption in response to deliberately cutting calorie density. Whether these types of foods need to be avoided completely hasn’t been established – it’s a restrictive rule, and it’s probably better to consider the consumption of these products in the context of the overall diet. Forbidding “treat” foods entirely may be more difficult to manage than accommodating them within daily or weekly eating plans.
Depend on fresh fruits and vegetables for fiber, vitamins, and enzymes. Fruits and vegetables are good sources of nutrients, fiber and vitamins, but so are other foods, such as grains. Insisting on “fresh” produce is unnecessarily restrictive, as frozen or canned versions can offer the same nutritional benefits. Enzymes are large proteins that act as catalysts for biochemical reactions throughout the body – but our body produces what we need, and digests the ones we consume.
Stick to proper portion sizes-give up the super sizing! This is also reasonable advice. Portions sizes, particularly in restaurants, have grown over time. While Reno doesn’t mention calories, they’re the fundamental energy unit of diet.
The good
Reno’s plan emphasizes whole grains, lean cuts of meat, healthy fats and lots of fruits and vegetables. No classes of foods are completely banned, and the plan promotes an overall balanced diet of grains, fruits, vegetables, fats, and protein. Consequently, I can see the program being easier to maintain for some people than diets that advocate dramatic shifts in habits (e.g., Atkins and paleo). The recipes she promotes look nutritious and some look quite tasty. Depending on your current diet, following the principles may significantly improve your dietary habits, and help you break established bad habits. Like most diet plans, exercise is encouraged, particularly weights, which is a good recommendation.
The bad
Reno is a certified Nutritional Therapy Practitioner (NTP), an accreditation offered by the Nutritional Therapy Association. The NTP certificate program’s required reading include books on detoxing and adrenal fatigue (a non-existent condition). This non-science-based background is evident in Reno’s recommendations. Much of her advice is based on anecdotes, not science:
She says that calories don’t matter. She’s wrong.
We now realize that different foods react in different ways in our body. Whereas we may lose weight on 2000 calories per day of Clean food we may gain weight on 1600 calories per day of junk. Many, many people have messed up their metabolisms by worrying too much about calories and not enough about just getting good nutrition regularly throughout the day.
Tell that to Mark Haub, who lost 27 pounds eating only Twinkies. Calories matter, no matter how you spin it. If you eat excessive amounts of the foods she recommends, you will gain weight, just as sure as a consistent calorie deficit will cause weight loss. While some of the recommended approaches (small, spaced meals, each with protein) may help with satiety, they are no guarantee that you’ll lose weight by eating clean (if that is your goal).
Even more questionable is the advice to take supplements and even drug treatments, with recommendations (depending on the book) ranging from human growth hormone, to bee pollen, wheat germ, L-carnitine, vitamin K, turmeric, green tea extract, and raw apple cider vinegar. No references are provided to substantiate claims of benefit that range from burning fat to improving abdominal definition. She recommends “natural” hormones such as pregnenolone for “memory”, and states that bioidentical hormones are a safe natural alternative for hormone replacement. They’re not.
Reno advocates “detoxing” and believes it has an effect on your body’s pH, reducing acidity which she attributes to be a cause of disease.
Eliminating all processed foods is something that Reno emphasizes repeatedly. This may be very difficult to do, and the incremental benefits are unclear. Eliminating frozen meals is one matter, making your own condiments and crackers is something entirely different. It’s not necessary to eliminate all processed foods to benefit from the best elements of the eating plan.
Other “eat clean” advice
Several other authors and personalities that advocate some form of “eat clean” use the same formula as Reno: Combine some reasonable dietary advice and recipes using unprocessed foods with bizarre statements and suggestions that reflect a strong appeal to nature fallacy and a lack of basic science knowledge. Terry Walters has some nice recipes in her Clean Food cookbook, but also suggests you chew your food well “to avoid putting stress on your digestive organs.” She calls aluminum “a known carcinogen” and says to avoid it, as well as plastic and Teflon. She believes that some foods make the body acidic and recommends cooking them with minerals (e.g., sea salt) to “neutralize this effect”. She also attributes specific effects to specific foods (“Dark leafy greens lift our mood, heal our organs, and counteract the damage resulting from out stressful lives.” Root vegetables “help us feel longer and ‘rooted'”. Squash is “blood -alkalinizing”. And so on.) She argues organic food is “cleaner” and believes that organic foods are grown without the use of pesticides or herbicides (wrong).
Conclusion: Clean eating is marketing, not science
    • Categorizing foods as or diets as “clean” is clearly a successful marketing strategy, but is less useful when it comes to daily decision-making about good nutrition. Some of the concepts that underlie “eating clean” are supported by good scientific evidence. But the “eating clean” philosophy is imbued with a considerable amount of pseudoscience and a large amount of the naturalistic fallacy. Calories matter, and supplements probably don’t. For that reason, I would not recommend any of the “Eat Clean” and related books. There are too many inaccuracies to compensate for the good advice buried within. Dietary design needs to be based on good evidence, not anecdotes and logical fallacies.

The Clean Eating Delusion
Steven Novella on January 20, 2016
Link

While some parts of the world are concerned with eating, because of food insecurity, the “worried and well-fed well” are increasingly obsessed with so-called “clean eating.”
This is nothing new, but like every cultural phenomenon, it seems, has increased partly due to the easy spread of misinformation over the internet. If you are anxious about your health, and who isn’t to some degree, your anxiety is fed by a steady diet of pseudo-experts, con-artists, and internet personalities telling you about all the things you eat that adversely affect your health.
This phenomenon is increasingly being recognized as a health issue among experts. In 1996 Dr. Steven Bratman proposed a formal disorder he calls orthorexia nervosa. He writes:
For people with orthorexia, eating healthily has become an extreme, obsessive, psychologically limiting and sometimes physically dangerous disorder, related to but quite distinct from anorexia.
Essentially orthorexia is an unhealthy obsession with eating healthy. There are a lot of parallels with anorexia, which is an unhealthy obsession with weight control. As Bratman himself points out, and I want to emphasize – there is a spectrum from a healthy concern with eating a healthful diet at one end to a harmful or even delusional obsession with a restrictive diet at the other. This is also not an attack on veganism or vegetarianism, which are a combination of health and ethical considerations.
There is also the belief that both orthorexia and anorexia are partly driven by the media, which means that there is a large cultural element to these disorders. There is a lot of overlap between orthorexia and anorexia, and in some cases anorexics follow “clean eating” as a socially acceptable means to achieving weight loss.
What is clean eating?
In practice “clean eating” tends to be avoiding whatever food is the latest boogeyman in the pseudoscientific diet-advice industry. Today this often includes eating organic, avoiding GMOs, avoiding gluten, avoiding perceived “chemicals,” eating “natural” which can mean many things but often means avoiding processed foods and food additives, and sometimes eating raw foods.
It is important to emphasize that none of these food beliefs are science based. After 50 years of research there is no evidence for any health benefit to eating organic. After 20 years of research there is no evidence of any health risk to any currently available GMO foods.
About one percent of the population has true gluten sensitivity, called celiac disease. For everyone else there is no current consensus that gluten causes any problems. This story is more complicated, though, as there are also wheat allergies, and some people with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) are sensitive to FODMAPs, which are in many of the same foods as gluten.
Avoiding “toxins” includes a large category of claims, but essentially misses the point that the dose makes the toxin. Sure, there are toxins everywhere – substances that in high enough dose will cause adverse health effects. Water is a toxin if drunk in sufficient quantities. The important question is, what is the dose? It is easy to scare people, however, with the notion that there are toxins in their food or water, without putting that information into its proper context.
Closely related to this is the avoidance of “chemicals.” This is a particularly naive position, as everything is a chemical. Water is a chemical (H2O). You can give even common substance a long technical chemical name and make it sound scary, giving rise to popular memes in which the contents of a banana or blueberry are listed in scary chemical names.
In order to avoid “Food Babe” level ignorance on this issue (“if you can’t pronounce it, you shouldn’t eat it”), some have made the distinction between natural and synthetic chemicals. This is a false dichotomy, however. How much processing or change to a naturally occurring chemical makes it synthetic? Also, there is no reason to suspect that chemicals which happen to occur in nature have any greater tendency to be healthful than synthetic chemicals. This is just another manifestation of the appeal to nature fallacy.
There are legitimate reasons to be concerned about eating too much processed food, as it tends to contain lots of sugar, fat, and/or salt. This has to do more with trends in the food industry, rather than anything inherent to processing foods rather than eating foods prepared from scratch. This is where reading labels can be helpful, and there also needs to be pressure on the food industry to provide more transparency and healthful options. But avoiding processed foods is no guarantee of healthy eating either, as there are many unprocessed sources of excess fat, sugar, and salt.
Eating raw is nothing but pure nonsense. Cooking changes food, mostly for the better, making certain nutrients more accessible and digestion easier. Some types of cooking, or overcooking, (such as boiling vegetables) can remove nutrients from certain foods, but it is not necessary to eat raw in order to get adequate nutrition (and of course, microwaves are no better or worse than any other source of heat).
Raw eating often involves pure pseudoscience, such as the claim that it is better to eat food that is alive, and cooking kills food. Stomach acids also kill food, by the way. Raw claims vary from the pseudoscientific to the mystical, with claims about the essence of food.
The psychology of clean eating
If clean eating is not based on scientific evidence, on what is it based? I am not going to discuss the alleged mental illness end of the spectrum as that notion is still evolving and has not yet reached consensus. Rather I am going to make observations about the broader cultural trends, partly from the perspective of a physician.
Clean eating, it seems, is partly an obsession with purity. This is closely tied to the emotion of disgust, which evolved to motivate us to avoid potentially dangerous food or water and to avoid infectious disease and actual toxins. This protective emotion can become unhinged, however.
The desire for purity combines with two other psychological phenomenon, especially in industrialized nations. Some experts believe we are also overly obsessed with hygiene, even to the point that it may be impairing our immune systems which are not getting the regular workout they need for optimal function.
We live in a sanitary, even sterilized environment. Obviously there are situations where this is necessary, such as in hospitals. As a result, however, we tend to feel (ironically) separated from nature, in that we feel disgust at the notion that we are fully part of messy nature.
We are literally surrounded by a cloud of bacteria. There are (roughly) as many bacterial cells as human cells in your body, not counting fungi and viruses. There are parasites living on our skin.
We are messy biology. We are just meat that thinks. We live with the persistent delusion, however, that we are somehow more than meat.
Additionally there is a tendency to believe that existing in the natural state of every person would mean their body functions perfectly. In reality the human body is a kluge, a series of evolutionary compromises that functions well enough to breed, and exists in a constant state of decay, barely staving off entropy for seven or eight decades until finally succumbing to the inevitable.
Don’t get me wrong, the human body is also a marvel of evolutionary complexity. Biology is subtle and powerful. But it is also messy and imperfect. Everything that can go wrong, does (in someone). I think most people intellectually know this, but just don’t want it to be true.
When we do develop some symptom or dysfunction, there is a tendency to assume that the problem is being caused by something outside of our bodies, rather than a defect in our body itself. We are being infected or poisoned, and if we can just identify and remove the foreign threat, our body will return to its natural state of perfection.
In fact, this is the overt philosophy of many alternative medicine practices. Straight chiropractors, for example, preach the belief that our bodies will be perfectly healthy, as long as the life-force is allowed to flow.
Clean eating goes along with this psychology – all you have to do to be healthy is avoid “bad” food. Of course “bad” is a moving target, one that follows trends more like the fashion industry than anything scientific.
Conclusion: Clean eating is about feelings, not reality
I again want to emphasize that I am not being judgmental here, just describing a psychological tendency that can lead to behavior that accomplishes the opposite of what it intends – health. The emotions I describe are normal and ubiquitous. It is also perfectly reasonable to be concerned with what you eat, to read labels, and to strive to have a healthful diet.
What I feel is mostly happening is that self-made gurus are exploiting these normal and healthy emotions essentially for self-promotion. They turn reasonable concerns into fears and obsessions. They spread misinformation authoritatively, or create echochambers in which fears of toxins and chemicals become unhinged.
There is an industry of clean eating that is not science-based or healthy, but it is highly marketable.

No Health Benefits from Organic Food
Steven Novella on September 5, 2012
Link
A recent review of 240 studies has concluded that:
The published literature lacks strong evidence that organic foods are significantly more nutritious than conventional foods. Consumption of organic foods may reduce exposure to pesticide residues and antibiotic-resistant bacteria.
Organic produce has become increasingly popular in recent years. There are several reasons that consumers might prefer organic produce, including the belief that organic farming is better for the environment and more sustainable. I am going to focus in this article about the health effects of organic produce. Environmental claims for organic farming are complex and controversial – I will just say that such claims largely fall prey to the naturalistic and false dichotomy fallacies. In my opinion, farming practices should be evaluated on their own merits individually, based on evidence rather than philosophy. Sustainable and environmentally friendly farming are certainly laudable goals and I support farming practices promote them, however they are labeled.
The alleged superiority of organically grown produce is a separate question. In a 2003 survey 68.9% of people who purchase organic food said they did so because they believed it to be healthier (more than any other reason given). However, fifty years of research has so far not produced convincing evidence that there is any health benefit to consuming organic food. Likewise, systematic reviews of nutritional quality of organic produce also reveals no difference from conventional produce.
The recent review is therefore in agreement with previous reviews – organic produce is not more nutritious or healthful, but it is more expensive.
Some studies that find small differences in the content of specific nutrients may be due to confounding factors. For example, organic produce is generally smaller than conventional produce, so if nutrient content is measured by mass (as opposed to the total for an individual vegetable or piece of fruit) organic produce may have a slightly higher concentration. This does not necessarily translate to more overall nutrients for the consumer. Further, many studies measure multiple endpoints (nutrients) and find some differences, but may not be properly accounting for multiple analyses. The researchers in the recent study found that results were “heterogeneous” – meaning that there were significant differences in outcome among the studies. This could indicate a lack of replicability of specific outcomes, indicating that differences were more artifacts of method rather than genuine.
One type of study that I have not seen is essentially the equivalent of an “intention to treat” analysis – what is the impact of buying organic food in the real world. Even if there are tiny nutritional advantages to organic food (although to be clear this conclusion is not supported by the evidence), is there an overall nutritional advantage to eating organic? Does the higher price mean that for many consumers fewer overall fresh produce will be consumed?
The recent review did find that organic produce had fewer pesticide residues than conventional farming. However, there is no evidence that these low levels of pesticides present any health risk. The review found:
The risk for contamination with detectable pesticide residues was lower among organic than conventional produce (risk difference, 30% [CI, −37% to −23%]), but differences in risk for exceeding maximum allowed limits were small.
So while there was a difference, this did not result in a significant difference in terms of exceeding safe limits. Further, studies looking at health outcomes did not find any significant difference between consuming organic vs conventional produce. These studies are limited in number and duration, however. Further, there may be a bias in how these studies are performed. Organic farming does use pesticides, but only “natural” pesticides are allowed. There is little to no evidence that these organic pesticides are less harmful for consumers or the environment. It is just assumed that they are based upon the naturalistic fallacy.
Even if we take the most pro-organic assumption – that there are more pesticides on conventional produce and that those pesticides have greater negative health effects than organic pesticides, it must still be recognized that simply washing fruits and vegetables effectively reduces pesticide residue. If minimized exposure to pesticide residue is your goal, thoroughly washing your produce is probably the easiest and cheapest way to achieve that end.
Differences in bacterial contamination were similar. There were no differences seen in E. coli contamination. There was a 33% greater chance of isolated a multi-antibiotic resistance bacteria on conventional produce, but no evidence this translates into a health risk. Again – even if we assume a difference in health risk (something not demonstrated by the data) this can be remedied by thorough washing.
Conclusion
The recent review of organic vs conventional produce agrees with previous systematic reviews that there is insufficient evidence to conclude that organic produce is healthier or more nutritious that conventional produce. Despite the scientific evidence, the alleged health benefits of organic produce is the number one reason given by consumers for buying organic. This likely represents the triumph of marketing over scientific reality.

A closer look at Dr. Oz’s 15 Superfoods
Scott Gavura on September 26, 2013
Link
I’m sure I’m not the only health professional that bites their tongue whenever a patient starts a question with “I heard on Dr. Oz that…” More often than not, I have expectations to realign, and some assumptions to correct. I could easily devote all my posts to simply correcting information presented on the Dr. Oz show. But given I’m blogging here biweekly, and Dr. Oz has a daily television show, I’ll never be able to catch up. So while my first choice in topics isn’t to add a post to our extensive Dr. Oz archives, I often end up, like many other health professionals, needing to respond to his shows shortly after they air.
Should you happen to be someone that has never seen the Dr. Oz show, Dr. Mehmet Oz is an Oprah protégé who has gone on to build a health media empire that is possibly the biggest vehicle for health pseudoscience and medical quackery on television. Whether it’s promoting homeopathy, recommending unproven supplements, or advocating ridiculous diet plans, there seems to be no health subject too dubious to endorse. Oz has established an impressive track record of providing highly questionable health advice. A few months ago I examined his absurd endorsement of green coffee beans, followed by his dubious “clinical trial” of green coffee beans that likely didn’t meet minimal research ethics standards. Then there was the weight loss “miracle” (his words), red palm oil, which followed the same episodic formula of breathless hyperbole backed by questionable evidence. One of the meta-trends of the Dr. Oz show are weight loss secrets – typically gimmicky interventions, supplements and therapies that he promotes as panaceas for obesity.
What frustrates me the most about Dr. Oz is that he should know better. He’s a heart surgeon, (who continues to treat patients), an academic, and a research scientist, with literally hundreds of publications to his name. He has gone through the peer review process more times than most health professionals. There is little reason to expect, based on his pre-television history, that he’d be willing to build a platform to offer demonstrably bad health advice. And that’s a shame, because with a show in 118 countries that reaches over 3 million viewers in the USA alone, it could be a powerful tool for providing good health information to those seeking it. And more often than not, that opportunity is squandered.
Another meta-trend on The Dr. Oz Show is the list. (Actually that’s not just Dr. Oz, it’s more of an internet trend, with websites like Cracked solely devoted to lists.) Sure it’s linkbait, but it works, and these lists of health-related topics are shared via social media. So if this list didn’t already appear on you Facebook wall, you may see it soon, titled Eat Yourself Skinny!
It may seem too good to be true, but the key to weight loss is right in your grocery store. These 15 superfoods can rev your metabolism, whittle your waist and leave you looking and feeling better than ever.
– Dr. Oz
Superfoods. I both love and hate the term. I’ll put my business degree hat on first. It’s genius. Who has time for perfectly adequate foods, or even good food? Superfoods are what you need to be consuming. Can’t you just picture yourself fitter, happier and more virtuous? The pseudoscientific bookends to vitamins and supplements, superfoods are touted as the simple dietary cure. The real genius of the term is that it has no established definition. Here, superfoods are products that “rev” your metabolism and “whittle” your waist. The implication is clear – consuming them will have magical effects – you eat, you still lose weight, and you look and feel wonderful. What could be wrong with foods like that?
So now I’ll put my pharmacist hat on. Superfoods are pure marketing speak, meaningless nutrition woo like “detox”, “clease”, “immune boost” and pretty much every other word you’ll see in the advertising from a naturopath or nutritionist. Claims are usually based on anecdotal information, or information extrapolated far beyond the scientific evidence. Rather than help dietary decisions, designing what you eat based on “superfoods” can make meal planning more complex, with consumers focusing on single ingredients rather than overall dietary choices. There’s a fad component too. Pomegranates and acai berries were superfoods, but now they’re out. We can only eat so much food in one day, and superfoods are a compelling term used to shape our food purchasing decisions.
So with this in mind, let’s take a look at Dr. Oz’s list of superfoods, and his claim that they are the “key to weight loss”:
#1. Beans
Dr. Oz claims: “Ignites your fat-burning furnace”, 50% of calories are not absorbed, reduce blood sugar, “may burn fat faster”
Reality check: There’s no clear evidence that establishes bean consumption will cause you to preferentially “burn fat”, though they may help with controlling blood sugar. Oz is partially correct with respect to his calorie counts, as the usual 4 calories/gram of sugar rule isn’t accurate when it comes to fiber. But it’s only these calories that are overestimated, not the entire calorie count for the food. Still it’s hard to argue with increasing your consumption of beans which are nutrient-packed, high in protein, and low in fat. Whether they promote weight loss, however, hasn’t been established.
#2: Pine nuts
Dr. Oz claims: “Help suppress hunger”; contain pinolenic acid, which in a clinical trial “was associated with a reduction in food intake by 36%”.
Reality check: Pine nuts (which are actually seeds) are delicious, but they’re also calorie-rich, owing to their fat content. (A tablespoonful of pine nuts provides 60 calories). I could locate no published clinical trials that have studied pine nuts directly. The “36% reduction in food consumption” claim seems to come from an paper presented at the American Chemical Society National Meeting that used daily doses of 3 grams of pinolenic acid (supplied as the oil) in 18 overweight volunteers. It does not appear to have been published, peer reviewed, or duplicated. Given pine nuts are usually consumed as part of a meal, and not as a pre-meal supplement of the oil alone, it’s difficult to see how relevant this research is to everyday weight management.
#3. Fennel tea
Dr. Oz claims: “Cleansing”, “boosts digestion”, “resets taste buds”, reduces fat storage, “squash morning hunger pangs”
Reality check: There is no credible evidence demonstrating that fennel can do any of these things. Like many herbal remedies, side effects have not been systematically studied, but it’s generally considered safe when consumed as a food. While it’s most popular for promoting lactation, its effects have not been established, and is also considered potentially unsafe for that use.
#4. Crimini mushrooms
Dr. Oz claims: Meaty flavour cuts the fat when mixed in meat-based dishes.
Reality check: I can’t argue with Dr. Oz here. Crimini mushrooms are tiny portobellos. If you like mushrooms and want a meat substitute, mushrooms are a reasonable alternative. Nothing super about them, but they are low-calorie and nutritious.
#5. Apples
Dr. Oz claims: When eaten pre-meal, the pectin reduces the subsequent sugar and calories that are absorbed into the bloodstream.
Reality check: Apples are delicious and most varieties are reasonably low in calories. Pectin is a soluble fibre that gives a gelatinous consistency to products like jams and jellies. I could find no published information that demonstrates that apple or pectin consumption reduces subsequent calorie absorption, though there is some evidence suggesting pectin supplements can have beneficial effects on cholesterol levels.
#6. Avocados
Dr. Oz claims: The monounsaturated fats are “are healthy sources of energy to keep you going all day long.”
Reality check: Avocados are a great source of monounsaturated fats and that seems to have positive cholesterol effects. They are a source of energy – quite a bit of it, with about 300-400 calories each. As a source of nutrition they’re an excellent part of your diet, as long as you keep in mind the total calories.
#7. Raspberry ketone
Dr. Oz claims: This product regulates adiponectin, a protein that causes “the fat within your cells to get broken up more effectively, helping your body burn fat faster.”
Reality check: Come on Mehmet. You were doing reasonably well, only to veer off into rank pseudoscience with your favorite “miracle fat-burner in a bottle”. Setting aside the fact that raspberry ketone isn’t really a “food” at all (it’s formulated synthetically), the scientific evidence doesn’t back up these claims. There are no human studies that substantiate these statements. It’s supplement snake oil.
#8. Chili peppers
Dr. Oz claims: Capsaicin “curbs your appetite while you eat” and “raises your body temperature, which may boost your metabolism.”
Reality check: Oz is suggesting that chili peppers will independently change the heat production of your body, confusing capsaicin’s effects on pain receptors on tongues, for actual thermal energy. There is the hypothesis that capsaicin supplements may have some effects on calorie burn, but it’s not clear that the modest increase is the same as eating chili peppers as part of a typical diet. Chili peppers are delicious though, so if you like them, go ahead and eat them – just don’t expect that hot sensation to mean you’re burning away calories.
#9. Vinegar
Dr. Oz claims: “Slow the absorption of carbohydrates” and “slows the passage of food through your stomach, keeping you fuller for longer.”
Reality check: Vinegar is an old folk remedy, its main ingredient is acetic acid (the usual home supply version is 4-8% acetic acid in water). The best evidence I could find to substantiate Oz’s claim of satiety was a study in 12 people given white bread and vinegar. As an unblinded study, not much can be concluded. There’s also a small study suggesting vinegar may enhance insulin sensitivity. So while there’s no evidence to suggest it will “rev up” your metabolism or aid in weight loss, if you like the taste of vinegar or pickled foods, enjoy. Just don’t expect you’re losing weight doing so.
#10. Cinnamon
Dr. Oz claims: “Slows the passage of food through your stomach” and “lowers your blood sugar levels by stimulating glucose metabolism.”
Reality check: Cinnamon supplements have been studied in diabetics and beneficial effects have not been established. There is no evidence to demonstrate that cinnamon has any beneficial effects on weight in people with or without diabetes. If you like it, eat it. But cinnamon won’t negate the calories you’re eating it with.
#11: Chia seeds
Dr. Oz claims: The soluble fiber has “cholesterol-lowering properties and prevents the absorption of fat”
Reality check: Chia is an herb, eaten for its seeds, which are a good source of fiber and the omega-3 fatty acid, alpha-linolenic acid. A single-blind study showed chia had no effect on weight loss, though it may improve some risk factors, like cholesterol, in those with diabetes. Given alpha-linolenic acid is poorly converted to docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), if you’re looking for cardiovascular benefits you’re better off getting DHA directly via cold water fatty fish. So while chia is a reasonable addition to your diet, there is no evidence it has any special ability to support weight loss.
#12: Green tea
Dr. Oz claims: Contains EGCG (epigallocatechin gallate) that “increases the hormone responsible for making you feel satiated”; “can help prevent storage of excess fat”, “improve your appetite-regulating hormones” and will change how your body handles cravings and metabolizes food.
Reality check: Green tea is brewed from the non-fermented leaves of the Camellia sinensis plant. It contains a number of biologically active ingredients which are believed (though not established) to be a panacea for nearly everything. With respect to weight loss, a systematic review of green tea for obesity concluded that green tea has no meaningful effects, and a Cochrane review concluded that any effects are “not likely to be clinically important”.
#13. Pepitas (pumpkin/squash seeds)
Dr. Oz claims: “Seeds have been shown to decrease the body’s ability to store fat”; the protein and magnesium “helps curb cravings and strengthen muscles”; “Eat 1 cup of seeds a few times a week.”
Reality check: Pumpkin seeds, like other seeds, are nutrient and energy dense. One cup of pumpkin seeds has about 700 calories, which is about the same as a Double Big Mac (albeit with less fat and more fiber). Three cups of seeds a week could easily exceed an entire days’ worth of calories. There is no published evidence to suggest that seeds block fat production or retention in any meaningful way that could assist with weight loss or weight maintenance.
#14. Red lentils
Dr. Oz claims: “these legumes will help you stay fuller for longer.”
Reality check: Hard to find fault with lentils which are both nutritious and high in fiber which might contribute to satiety. While no “superfood”, they are a staple in many diets – I prefer mine as daal.
#15. Watermelon
Dr. Oz claims: “Women who ate water-rich foods lost 33% more weight in the first 6 months than women on a low-fat diet”; contains vitamins A, C, “as well as the ‘mother of all antioxidants,’ glutathione, which is known to help strengthen the immune system.”
Reality check: For a fruit that’s so delicious and is mainly water, watermelon has a lot of nutrients too. The study referred to is this paper which compared a low-fat diet to a low-fat diet with more fruits and vegetables. The group randomized to fruits and vegetables lost about 5lbs more than the other, an increase of 33% at the six month mark (the difference narrowed by one year). So while the study is reported accurately, it is not a trial that studied watermelon, or that studied the effect of fruits and vegetables alone.
Conclusion
Oz’s latest list is a mix of both reasonable and silly dietary advice that repeatedly overstates the evidence, while ignoring the biggest determinant for obesity: calorie consumption. The list reinforces the rule that information presented on the Dr. Oz show cannot be taken at face value.

Vani Hari (a.k.a. The Food Babe): The Jenny McCarthy of food
David Gorski on June 16, 2014
Link

NOTE ADDENDUM – Ed.
I’ll admit it: I’m a bit of a beer snob. I make no bones about it, I like my beer, but I also like it to be good beer, and, let’s face it, beer brewed by large industrial breweries seldom fits the bill. To me, most of the beer out being sold in the U.S., particularly beer made by Anheuser-Busch and MillerCoors can easily be likened to cold piss from horses with kidney disease (you need protein to get beer foam, you know), only without the taste. I have to be mighty desperate and thirsty before I will partake of such swill. I will admit that there is one exception, namely Blue Moon, which is manufactured by a division of MillerCoors, but that’s the only exception I can think of. Ever since I discovered Bell’s Oberon, a nice local (well, statewide, anyway) wheat ale, I can do without Blue Moon. Sadly, Oberon is only brewed during the spring and summer months; so when I want a similar bit of brew during the winter months sometimes I’m tempted by Blue Moon. Otherwise, I’m generally happy with one of the many craft and microbrews made by local brewers such as Short’s Brewing Company (whose brewpub I had the pleasure of visiting about a month ago) and Bells Brewery.
Despite my general hostility to Anheuser-Busch and MillerCoors products as examples of everything that is wrong with American beer, I have to say that I almost feel sorry for the people running those corporations right now. Unfortunately, they’ve fallen victim to the latest quack making a name for herself on the Internet by peddling pseudoscience. As is my wont, I’ll go into my usual excruciating detail shortly. But first, to whom am I referring?
Enter the font of misinformation that is The Food Babe
Like Mark Crislip, who recently wrote about her about her mind-numbingly stupid antivaccine post, until recently I had no idea who she was, but unfortunately, I do now. She’s photogenic and also has a talent and penchant for making her utter ignorance of chemistry and science work for her as a powerful P.R. tool that has catapulted her from an obscure food blogger to a guest on television shows such as The Doctors and that repository of all medical crankery and quackery, The Dr. Oz Show, where The Great and Powerful Oz himself praised her activities as part of the “Oz effect.” Her name is Vani Hari, but she is much better known by her blog name, The Food Babe. She’s been featured on this blog before, not surprisingly, both by Mark Crislip and Steve Novella, who dismantled her claims that microwaving food somehow destroys its nutritional value and renders it full of “toxins” and her attack on Subway for using azodicarbonamide, which she dubbed the “yoga mat chemical.”
Unfortunately, in that latter case, when faced with a young, telegenic, clever but scientifically ignorant blogger who used her popular website and blog to gather a bunch of signatures rooted in the same ignorance she promotes, Subway caved, even though there is no good evidence that azodicarbonamide is harmful and lots of good evidence that it’s useful as a maturing agent. Basically, when it’s added to flour, it makes bread dough rise better. It also improves the handling properties of dough, making it drier, more cohesive and more pliable, allowing it to hold together better during kneading. No wonder uber-quack Mike Adams is so impressed with her. The two are kindred spirits, given how Mike Adams has been doing, in essence, the same sort of thing with a mass spectrometer, using it to measure heavy metals in various foods and supplements as fodder for fear mongering campaigns to demonize the food industry, not to mention to undercut competitors in the supplement business.
Last week, The Food Babe turned her ever-scientifically-ignorant sights on one of my favorite beverages of all, beer. As befits her growing skill at using PR combined with rants against genetically modified organisms (GMOs) and scary sounding chemicals (i.e., all of them), she targeted large breweries like MillerCoors and Anheuser-Busch, charging that they had all sorts of nefariously toxic “chemicals” and GMO-derived products in their beers and challenging them to publish their complete ingredient list. As typically happens when The Food Babe takes aim at a corporation, these beer behemoths hemmed and hawed for a couple of days as they figured out a response—and that response was, ultimately, to cave just like Subway:
Anheuser-Busch and MillerCoors, two of the world’s biggest beer makers, are posting online what’s inside bottles of Budweiser and Miller Lite after pressure from a food blogger.
The two companies on Thursday posted the ingredients of some of their most popular brands, and promised to be more transparent in the future. The announcements come a day after blogger Vani Hari posted a petition on FoodBabe.com to get major brewers to list what’s in their beverages.
Anheuser-Busch posted the ingredients for its two top-selling brands on its website, tapintoyourbeer.com. It lists the same ingredients for Budweiser and Bud Light: Water, barley malt, rice, yeast and hops. The company, which also makes Beck’s, Busch and Michelob beers, said it will list the ingredients for all of its other brands online “in the coming days.” It’s the first time Anheuser-Busch has detailed the ingredients of its beers.
Here’s the problem. All you have to do to see that this won’t satisfy Hari is to go back to her original charges and petitions. Of course the main ingredients of beer are water, barley malt, rice, yeast, and hops! That’s how beer is made. The original petition paints the issue as a comparison of Coca Cola and Windex having to reveal their ingredients but beer not having to do so. Then there’s a video featuring Hari starting out gushing about how her husband “loves beer” and that’s why she wanted so badly to find out what’s “really” in beer. There’s then a list that scrolls down the screen to her right of—you guessed it!—a whole lot of chemicals with scary-sounding names plus—of course!—the dreaded GMOs:
I was tempted to leave the deconstruction of Hari’s claims to the reader as an exercise, to see how much you grok science-based medicine, but then this would turn into the all-time shortest Gorski post in the history of SBM, and we can’t have that, now, can we?
Scary chemical names and origins as a propaganda weapon
I must confess. I didn’t know that there was caffeine in beer until I perused the list that flew by in Hari’s video above. It seems rather counterproductive. On the other hand, I do like the occasional Irish coffee, which also combines alcohol and caffeine. Never mind. In any case, her strategy is very transparent, but unfortunately it’s also very effective: Name a bunch of chemicals and count on the chemical illiteracy of your audience to result in fear at hearing their very names. However, if you have any background in chemistry, much of what Hani is doing is almost painfully transparent, a veritable insult to one’s intelligence and training. Here are some examples.
Particularly hilarious are some of the “evil” chemicals listed, which include
    • Calcium phosphate, dibasic
    • Calcium phosphate, monobasic
    • Calcium phosphate, tribasic
What’s the difference between these three forms of calcium phosphate? I know the answer because my undergraduate degree is in chemistry. To make it very simple, these are all different forms of calcium phosphate that differ in the ratio of calcium ion to phosphate ion that depends upon the charge on the phosphate ion. Calcium ion holds a +2 charge, and the ratio of calcium to phosphate in the salt must be neutral. That’s it. Monobasic calcium phosphate contains a one-to-two ratio of calcium to phosphate, because the phosphate in this form holds a -1 charge. It’s acidic; so when it reacts with alkali it produces carbon dioxide and a salt, which is why it is often used as a leavening agent to make baked goods rise. Dibasic calcium phosphate has a one-to-one ratio of calcium to phosphate, because the phosphate in it has a -2 charge, having lost one hydrogen ion. It’s sometimes used as a dietary supplement and a tableting agent. It’s also more neutral, and a lot less soluble in water. Tribasic calcium phosphate has three calcium ions to two phosphate ions, because the phosphate ions have a -3 charge. Now here’s the thing. In aqueous solution, there is always going to be a mixture of these three forms, because at a pH of around 4 (the pH of most ales and lagers) different proportions of the phosphate ions will have differing numbers of hydrogen ions associated with them, from one to three. I could go into a lot more detail, and almost certainly chemists reading this might take issue with my simplification, but in reality what we’re talking about is a combination of calcium ion and phosphate ion in aqueous solution at a pH of around 4-4.5. Listing them as three different chemicals is deceptive. Sure, in solid (i.e., crystal) form they have different properties, this means little in dilute aqueous solution.
She pulls exactly the same deceptive trick with sodium phosphate, the three forms of which are basically sodium salts of phosphoric acid as formed at different pHs. At low pH, more of the phosphate will be monobasic; at high pH more will be tribasic. Again, it’s an equilibrium where the proportion of mono-, di-, and tri-basic forms of phosphate depends on the pH. In fact, that’s how you can make phosphate buffers of any pH you want: Vary the proportions of di- and monobasic forms of phosphate, like so. In chemistry, according to the Bronsted-Lowry acid-base theory, an acid is a proton donor and a base is a proton acceptor. Boiled down to a very simple explanation, that’s where the “basic” in mono-, di-, and tribasic comes from, the number of protons the phosphate group can accept.
In her petition, Hari complains:
When I called and emailed these companies, they gave me the runaround about their ingredients — providing basic information but not the full story.
Who can blame them? Surely MillerCoors and Anheuser-Busch were aware of the deceptive “yoga mat chemical” gambit used by Hari to such effect earlier this year. I wouldn’t give Hari the time of day, either. Unfortunately, companies live and die by public perception. It’s far easier to give a blackmailer like Hari what she wants than to try to resist or to counter her propaganda by educating the public. And, make no mistake, blackmail is exactly what Vani Hari is about. (NOTE ADDED AFTER PUBLICATION: Forbes blogger Trevor Butterworth calls this sort of strategy “quackmail.” Damn. Another term, like “quackademic medicine,” that I wish I’d thought of. Meanwhile Jay Brooks calls it “yellow journalism,” which to me is being far to kind to the Food Babe, who has demonstrated her intolerance of dissent and outright intellectual dishonest time and time again. That’s why I think Tom Cizauskas is more accurate to refer to what the Food Babe does as “calumny.”)
Oh, no, there’s antifreeze in my beer! Or is there?
I’ve frequently deconstructed and, at times, mocked what I like to call the “toxins” gambit as applied to vaccines by antivaccinationists. Basically, the toxins gambit is a fallacious trope in which antivaccinationists list the scary sounding chemicals in vaccines and use that list to portray vaccines as full of “toxins.” Of course, they don’t take into account the simple fact that the dose makes the poison and these chemicals are present in vaccines in such a small quantity that they are not dangerous. Another tactic often used as part of the toxins gambit is to pick scary-sounding chemicals in vaccines that sound dangerous but aren’t, at least not in the concentrations in vaccines. A great example is formaldehyde. There are, indeed, trace amounts of formaldehyde in vaccines from the manufacturing process, in which formaldehyde is used to kill the viruses used and/or to denature the proteins from the viruses. However, formaldehyde is a normal product of metabolism, and the amount of formaldehyde in vaccines is minor compared to the amount in the body and the amount to which we’re exposed every day.
And that’s part of what you need to know before you read the Food Babe “expose” that started this whole thing. It’s nearly a year old and called “The Shocking Ingredients In Beer“. This rather lengthy article is a rather long example of just that, the toxins gambit. Her entire list consists of various ingredients with no context given other than the scariest—deceptively so—spin. No concentrations are provided, ignoring the principle of dose-response and the dose making the poison. She lists propylene glycol, of course, as being in “antifreeze.” Of course, propylene glycol is also in vaccines, and, ironically enough, it’s the carrier used in most e-cigarettes. In any case, as has been pointed out to me multiple times, propylene glycol is an ingredient that has been generally recognized as safe (GRAS). Indeed, here’s what the FDA website says about it:
Propylene glycol is metabolized by animals and can be used as a carbohydrate source. Propylene glycol can be ingested over long periods of time and in substantial quantities (up to 5 percent of the total food intake) without causing frank toxic effects. Propylene glycol monostearate is readily hydrolysed in vivo and the propylene glycol and fatty acid moieties enter their respective metabolic pathways. At lethal or near lethal doses (6 g per kg or more), however, it has been reported to cause kidney damage in several species and toe deformities in chicks. These doses contrast with the few mg per kg per day estimated in Section III of this report to be the human daily dietary intake of propylene glycol. The Select Committee has weighed the available information and concludes that: There is no evidence in the available information on propylene glycol and propylene glycol monostearate that demonstrates, or suggests reason to suspect, a hazard to the public when they are used at levels that are now current or that might reasonably be expected in future.
The CDC has more information.
Because it falls under the category of GRAS, propylene glycol has been widely used as a moistening agent in cosmetics and for various purposes in food. None of this stops a staff writer over at that wretched hive of scum and quackery, NaturalNews.com, to crank up the fear mongering even more, complaining that it’s derived from petroleum and natural gas fossil fuels. I like to call this, for purposes of medical and food uses, the fallacy of origin. In other words, the claim is that, because a substance originated from a source that sounds toxic (or just plain disgusting), it must be bad for you.
And, if you listen to brewer Mitch Steele, it’s not even in beer! It’s used as a food-grade substance in external chilling systems, but he’s never heard of it being added to beer, concluding, “The only way propylene glycol could get into beer is by a leak in the cooling system,” and saying that when he worked at Anheuser-Busch they used to test the beers regularly to make sure they were glycol-free. Another brewer, Steve Parkes, points out that the main reason such substances are listed is because every production process aid has to be listed, regardless of whether it’s in the final product or not. Steele also points out that food dyes are not commonly used in beer.
Hari pulls the same gambit over isinglass (dried fish bladder), gelatin, and casein (milk protein). In particular, isinglass bothers her:
But, Guinness beer also contains isinglass, a gelatin-like substance produced from the swim bladder of a fish. This ingredient helps remove any “haziness,” solids, or yeast byproducts from the beer. Mmmmm… fish bladder sounds delicious, doesn’t? The sneaky thing this beer company does like many of the companies mentioned here today is create an illusion of using the best ingredients when in actuality what they tell you publicly on their websites is a complete farce.
The funny thing is, this is nothing new. Guinness has been using finings (substances to clear the beer) containing isinglass since the mid- to late 19th century and is generally considered natural. It’s used to help any remaining yeast and solid particles settle out of the final product, because as the isinglass passes through the beer it attracts particles from the fermented beer that create an unwanted haziness. It forms a jelly-like mass that settles to the bottom of the cask, where it’s easily separated from the beer. Beer will clear on its own, but isinglass speeds up the process and doesn’t affect the final flavor of the beer. It’s also been noted that isinglass is rarely used today in the beer brewing process. In other words, isinglass is nothing more than a form of gelatin derived from fish swim bladders rather than from the bones and/or connective tissue of cattle and other domestic animals.
There is a question among some vegans whether mere contact of one’s food or beverage with animal matter and the possibility that trace amounts of animal matter might remain in it are enough to make such foods or beverages off-limits, but if that’s the case then vegans shouldn’t drink most beers, many of which use gelatin instead of isinglass as a clearing agent. There are also a huge number of foods in whose manufacture gelatins from various sources are used. What’s not so funny is that the emphasis on isinglass as having been derived from fish bladders is deceptive, given how few beers are manufactured using it. It’s there for no other purpose than to scream, “Oooh! Fish bladders are used to make beer! Yucky! We must stop this yuckiness!” Of course, isinglass resembles fish bladder about as much as gelatin resembles a cow, but that doesn’t stop our intrepid Food Babe for making in essence, an argument against yuckiness about isinglass and substances like castoreum, an exudate from the castor sacs of the North American Beaver that is used in some perfumes and as food additives, of which she asks, “Do you eat beaver butt?” In other words, if the source is yucky to the Food Babe, it must be unhealthy. Yes, her “reasoning,” such as it is, is just that vacuous.
Indeed, the Food Babe has postulated her very own rule:
When you look at the ingredients [in food], if you can’t spell it or pronounce it, you probably shouldn’t eat it.
As everyone’s favorite chemist Joe Schwarcz said, Hari should then stay as far away from cyanocobalamine as possible. Not only is it hard to pronounce but it has cyanide! Oh, wait. That’s vitamin B12. Josh Bloom helpfully provides a whole list of difficult-to-pronounce chemical names for some very common substances, some of which are necessary and quite healthy.
Oh, noes! GMOs!
Perhaps the most horrific thing of all about beer to the Food Babe is that MillerCoors and Anheuser-Busch apparently use GMO-derived products to make their beer:
Most beers brewed commercially are made with more GMO corn than barley. Many of the companies I contacted dodged the GMO question – however Miller Coors had a very forthcoming and honest response. They stated “Corn syrup gives beer a milder and lighter-bodied flavor” and “Corn syrups may be derived from a mixture of corn (conventional and biotech.)”, admitting their use of GMOs.
And:
Dextrose and maltose can come from a variety of substances that are sweet, but likely are derived from GMO corn because it is super cheap for a company to use corn instead of fruit or other non-GMO sources. With cheap beer – you are not just getting a cheap buzz, you are getting the worst of the worst. Just like with cheap fast food – if you don’t invest in your beer – you will be drinking a lower quality product like Pabst Blue Ribbon that is made from GMO Corn and Corn Syrup.
Hey, Vani, don’t diss my PBR! I lived in Chicago, and that’s blasphemy! (Actually, PBR is one of the only beers manufactured by “big beer” that I can stomach, at least when it’s on tap, but it’s not one of my favorites.)
In any case, this is pure silliness, nothing more than tying GMO fear mongering to scary chemical name fear mongering. They’re too crappy tastes that test crappy together. I don’t feel the need to discuss the lack of validity of the anti-GMO nonsense that’s being peddled, other than to point out that the most “damning” studies presented by anti-GMO activists to convince people that GMOs are pure evil have been thoroughly discredited by multiple sources. In any case, it’s the naturalistic fallacy all over again. The basic fact is that the wheat, barley, and other grains used to make beer have been constantly genetically modified over many centuries through selective breeding, as has nearly every plant commonly farmed by humans for consumption. Ditto the very yeast used to ferment the grain products into beer. Indeed, there are many different strains of yeast maintained by many different laboratories, often with the help of scientists. Indeed, yeast are quite adept at swapping genes quite promiscuously; so in the wild yeast is constantly being “genetically engineered.”
In the end, Hari recommends German beers, because the Germans have stricter beer purity laws, organic beers (because, organic, of course), and craft beers and microbrews, because they use higher quality ingredients and are apparently less likely to contain GMOs. Ironically, this is good advice but not for the reason Hari thinks. It’s good advice because such beers tend to be much, much better than the mass-produced, tasteless brews concocted by massive companies like Anheuser-Busch and MillerCoors.
As for whether beer is healthy or not, that is an entirely different matter. There are many reasons to recommend not drinking a lot of beer. Beer is an alcoholic beverage, and too much alcohol contributes to a number of diseases, such as cirrhosis and various cancers. It also has a lot of calories, which can contribute to weight gain when consumed in excess—or even not in excess if the extra calories are enough to put one “over the top.” None of these reasons include any of the reasons Hari lists, such as use of GMO-derived grains and sugars and the various scary-sounding chemicals that are in beers. Whatever grain of a possibly reasonable point (such as whether various food colorings are necessary) is completely drained by her tsunami of pseudoscientific nonsensical fear mongering about chemicals, because chemicals she can’t pronounce are to her inherently bad.
Who is this “Food Babe,” anyway?
It’s a marker of just what a double-edged sword the Internet is. While the Internet is the most fantastic piece of technology ever devised for spreading knowledge and empowering anyone to speak up, there’s a dark side. That dark side consists of people like Vani Hari. No Internet, no Food Babe, no chemically illiterate, scientifically ignorant rabble rousing. How did she get her start? What are her qualifications?
The second question is easy to answer. She has no relevant qualifications. She isn’t a scientist. She isn’t a doctor. She isn’t a dietician. She has no training in nutrition. It’s not for nothing that she’s been referred to as the Mike Adams of food activism, which is not a compliment. In any case, according to her Wikipedia entry she has a B.S. in Computer Science and began her career as a banking consultant. In a story about how she got her start, Hari said:
I suffered from a lot of health problems early on in my career. I got a really cool job that demanded a lot of hours and traveling, so I was away from home eating whatever people in the office brought in. I got so sick and so overweight that I gained about 30 pounds within a few months, that I had appendicitis. A lot of people think that appendicitis has nothing to do with the way you eat, it’s a random occurrence, a lot of doctors think that it is just random, but I have no doubt that the reason why I had appendicitis was because of the way I was eating. It was kind of that life changing moment that brought me to bring health as my number one priority,” said Hari.
Hari, after learning and reading book upon book about living clean, taught herself how to eat and live a healthy lifestyle despite a busy schedule. From reading and learning, she decided to she wanted to spread her knowledge, so she began blogging.
“I said, ‘OK, yeah I will start a blog.’ So I started it last year in April, and I write about things I do on a daily basis,” said Hari.
Yes, it would appear that the Food Babe got her education from popular books and Google University and somehow got the messianic bug to save the world! Maybe a better way to describe her is the Jenny McCarthy of the food industry. Of course, I don’t mean that as a compliment. Just as Jenny McCarthy has been a prime force spreading fear and ignorance about vaccines, Vani Hari has been a malignant force promoting ignorance about food. Sure, mixed in with all the pseudoscience, antivaccine beliefs, and admiration of cranks like Russell Blaylock, is the occasional bit of good advice about eating more vegetables, avoiding too much processed food, and recipes that, for all I know, might actually be tasty. But the price is too high, buried as the occasional trivial bit of good advice is under the tsunami of nonsense.
She sure does have a talent for self-promotion, though. Come to think of it, that’s a lot like Jenny McCarthy, too.
ADDENDUM: Apparently the Food Babe noticed some of the blog posts quite rightly criticizing her for her disingenuous fear mongering and grandstanding and responded. It’s all the same blather about the evils of GMOs and corn syrup and such, but one paragraph does deserve a response:
There are a few blog posts circulating that indicate propylene glycol is used in the external chilling system at breweries and that it’s never is added to beer. They go as far to say that the only way it could be in beer is if there is a tank leak. Well, I’m not talking about leaking tanks here. The chemical Propylene Glycol Alginate (PGA) is added to some beers as a stabilizer for foam control and it is sold as an additive under various commercial names such as Stabilfoam. Another potential source of PGA is as a carrier for some “natural flavors” in fruit-flavored and cider beers. Propylene Glycol is added to many foods and drinks, it’s a very common food additive and I see it on ingredient lists everywhere at the grocery store. I know this because ingredient lists are on those items – but rarely on beer. In Germany, Propylene Glycol Alginate is listed as an ingredient on this bottle of Corona as “E405 Alginat” (the European food additive number for Propylene Glycol is E405), and you will also find it on this ingredient list on Sinebrychoff’s website in Finland. So, I’m really curious to know if and what other beers Anheuser-Busch and MillerCoors may add this ingredient to.
Whoopie. So she found one beer that uses Propylene Glycol Alginate to stabilize foam. Sounds damning, right? Wrong. The chemical ignorance in her claim is silly. Propylene Glycol Alginate is not the same thing as propylene glycol, as a quick visit to something as easy as Wikipedia would reveal, if the Food Babe had even a modicum of chemical knowledge to realize it. Here’s the Wikipedia entry:
Chemically, propylene glycol alginate is an ester of alginic acid, which is derived from kelp. Some of the carboxyl groups are esterified with propylene glycol, some are neutralized with an appropriate alkali, and some remain free.
What this means is that propylene glycol alginate is alginic acid (derived from kelp) with propylene glycol groups attached to some of the carboxyl groups. It is not the same chemical as propylene glycol, not even close. It is not antifreeze. And the Food Babe is still an idiot.

Vani Hari, a.k.a. “The Food Babe,” finally responds to critics
David Gorski on December 8, 2014
Link

It’s no secret that we here at Science-Based Medicine (and many scientists and skeptics with a knowledge of basic chemistry and biology) have been very critical of Vani Hari, better known to her fans as The Food Babe. The reasons for our criticisms of her are legion. Basically, she is a seemingly-never-ending font of misinformation and fear mongering about food ingredients, particularly any ingredient with a scary, “chemically”-sounding name.
Not surprisingly, as the Food Babe has gained prominence her antics have attracted more and more criticism for her toxic combination of ignorance of chemistry coupled with fear mongering. The criticism started with science and medical bloggers and leaked into the mainstream press, most recently in the form of a recent NPR blog entry entitled “Is The Food Babe A Fearmonger? Scientists Are Speaking Out” that liberally quotes from yours truly and our fearless founder Steve Novella, as well the professor and chair of the Horticultural Sciences Department at the University of Florida, Kevin Folta, who in October complained about the Hari being invited to speak at his university, where she didn’t take questions after spewing her usual disinformation. Indeed, her most recent foray into fear mongering, an attempt to attack Starbucks for its pumpkin spice latte because it not only contains “no real pumpkin” but also contains a “toxic dose of sugar,” and—brace yourself—uses dairy from “Monsanto milk cows fed GMO,” failed.
With a book and media tour scheduled for early 2015, apparently the Food Babe is feeling the heat and has finally responded to criticism on Saturday in a rather long post entitled “Food Babe Scam: My Response To The Attacks On Me and Our Movement“. Utterly predictably, she started with a quote commonly attributed to Mahatma Gandhi, “First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.” Never mind that Gandhi almost certainly never actually said it. Rather, Nicholas Klein of the Amalgamated Clothing Workers of America did. It’s also a misquote of what Klein did say. What Klein actually said was, “First they ignore you. Then they ridicule you. And then they attack you and want to burn you. And then they build monuments to you.”
Yes, they did build monuments to Gandhi, but I highly doubt anyone will be building monuments to The Food Babe, either now or many years from now. Her response to criticism is worth examining, however, because her defense itself reveals the many flaws in science and reasoning that led to the criticisms in the first place.
The Food Babe, redux
To be honest, I only became aware of Ms. Hari relatively recently, as in just this year, although apparently she’s been at it around three years now. Basically, her technique is simply and pithily described by a word that appears to have been coined by Trevor Butterworth but is one that I wish I’d thought of first, namely quackmail. Her M.O. is always the same, with minor variations. First, she identifies a scary sounding chemical in a food item. Then she publicizes it to her generally scientifically-ignorant readership and urges them to bombard the food manufacturer or restaurant with complaints and requests to remove said chemical from their product. Up until recently, she has tended to be very successful at this.
One prominent example of The Food Babe’s quackmail (and the one that first brought the Food Babe phenomenon to my attention, thanks to Steve Novella) was her campaign to get Subway to stop using the benign ingredient azodicarbonamide in its bread, a chemical that she characterized as the “yoga mat chemical,” the implication being that, by eating sandwiches made with the bread Subway makes, you’re somehow eating plastic, with the no doubt intentionally-planted mental image of sweaty bodies leaving their residue all over it. Steven Novella discussed the utter ridiculousness of this claim not once but twice, not to mention myself and a certain friend of the blog. It turns out that azodicarbonamide is what’s known as a maturing agent. Basically, when it’s added to flour, it makes bread dough rise better. It also improves the handling properties of dough, yielding drier, more cohesive dough that is more pliable, holds together better during kneading, and machine better. Moreover, azodicarbonamide is barely even in the final product. Once flour is wetted with water, the reaction of azodicarbonamide with the constituents of flour is rapid. By 45 minutes, there are only trace amounts left.
A second prominent example is one that I discussed extensively, namely Hari’s assault on beer, an assault that led me to dub her the “Jenny McCarthy of food.” You can read the details in the link, but basically her “reasoning” if you can call it that, was to borrow a page from the antivaccine manual and engage in some fear mongering about propylene glycol as “antifreeze,” even though according to brewmasters it isn’t even in the final product. Then, when called on this, Hari conflated propylene glycol alginate, which is used in beer as a stabilizer for foam control, and propylene glycol, even though the two are not the same chemical—or even close to the same chemical—structurally. But hey, the shared words “propylene glycol” must mean they’re the same chemical, right? Only if you have no knowledge of organic chemistry and didn’t bother to look up the chemical structures of the two. Amusingly, propylene glycol alginate is derived from seaweed; in other words, it’s pretty “natural” by Food Babe standards.
The Food Babe doesn’t limit her scientific ignorance just to food ingredients, however. For instance, she has promoted the unsupported claim that microwave cooking is evil and robs foods of their nutrients, even using vitalistic language about food being “alive” and microwaves “killing” it, as well as promoted misinformation about the flu vaccine cribbed straight from the antivaccine movement. Most recently, science bloggers have dug up an old post from The Food Babe in which she expresses her view about healthy traveling. As Steve Novella put it, her advice contains some major howlers. Perhaps the one that made me laugh the most was this:
The air you are breathing on an airplane is recycled from directly outside of your window. That means you are breathing everything that the airplanes gives off and is flying through. The air that is pumped in isn’t pure oxygen either, it’s mixed with nitrogen, sometimes almost at 50%. To pump a greater amount of oxygen in costs money in terms of fuel and the airlines know this! The nitrogen may affect the times and dosages of medications, make you feel bloated and cause your ankles and joints swell.
Apparently Hari doesn’t realize that normal air contains close to 78% nitrogen, 21% oxygen, with the rest made up of carbon dioxide and other trace gases. Thus, even if Hari’s claim that airplane air contains 50% nitrogen were true, airplane air contains nearly 30% less nitrogen than she normally breathes every day. Yet she seems to think that the airlines are “diluting” their oxygen with 50% nitrogen in order to save money. Personally, I think it’s a good thing that the airlines don’t use 100% oxygen for obvious reasons, not just because of the potential for fire and explosions, but because 100% oxygen is toxic to the lungs. Also, airplane air is recirculated every 3 minutes or so and is highly filtered.
The scientific ignorance on display in that article was so epic that, not long after science bloggers started deconstructing it (Folta amusingly parodied it in a post entitled Deadly Aviation Pretzel Gas: Foodbabeliness in Action), Hari removed it from her website and changed her robots.txt file so that Archive.org no longer archives her site. Indeed, it’s been reported on various Facebook pages that she appears to be engaging in quite a bit of sending embarrassing articles like her travel article down the old memory hole. Perhaps this is in anticipation of her higher media profile in 2015 after her book is released, which looks to be more of the same, given the Amazon.com blurb that starts out with, “Did you know that your fast food fries contain a chemical used in Silly Putty?”
No, but if The Food Babe is all worked up about it, somehow I doubt it’s an issue.
The Food Babe responds to critics. Unfortunately, misogyny, too.
When I first saw Hari’s response to her critics over the weekend, I had to wonder: Why now? After all, she’s remained largely silent in the face of scientific criticism, which in retrospect was probably the smartest thing she’s done over the last year. After all, look at how much more ignorant she looked after responding to criticism about “antifreeze in beer” when it was clear that she didn’t know that propylene glycol alginate was nowhere near the same chemical as propylene glycol. I had to wonder whether it had anything to do with the NPR article about her, although the article reported that Hari’s publicist said Hari wasn’t speaking to the media until her new book is released. I can’t help but wonder whether that was the final straw after she had an op-ed published in The New York Times that provoked considerable criticism and the backlash that resulted from her being featured on the cover of Experience Life magazine, which published a puff piece about her and her “activism.” The backlash was epic, and rightfully so.
And, in her response, she admits as much:
Part of the reason I am responding now is because their messages have started to infiltrate the mainstream media. Seemingly reputable news organizations like NPR (in a blog post titled “Is The Food Babe A Fearmonger? Scientists Are Speaking Out”) even linked to the hate groups – quoting one of their spokespeople and repeated their ridiculous and biased messages as if they have any merit.
Just as Hari is complaining about ad hominem attacks on her, she’s using ad hominem attacks and poisoning the well to fire back. Clearly, self-awareness, thy name is not Food Babe. Also, apparently Science-Based Medicine is a “hate group.” Clearly, when Hari asserts that it’s about the movement and it’s “not about me,” it really is all about her.
In any case, it’s clear that Hari is feeling harried, a sentiment that is obvious early in her response:
With this much game-changing activism and success in a short period of time, it comes as no surprise that some powerful corporate executives and some “independent” voices they help to finance, disagree with our work. An intelligent debate is welcomed, but not all the discussion has been civil.
There’s a group of aggressive scientists, biased doctors, skeptics, agribusiness publicists, lobbyists (and their anonymous webpages and social media sites), along with in some cases, well intended but misinformed people (influenced by propaganda) attacking our work, other consumer advocacy groups, my partners, my friends and me, personally.
Did you think the powerful chemical companies and food giants of the world were going to let us waltz right into their world and turn it upside down?No – they won’t and, as I expected, the people who wish to keep the status quo are attacking me personally while simultaneously trying to discredit the entire Good Food Movement.
This is, of course, simply a variation of the pharma shill gambit, in which the food industry replaces big pharma as the shadowy evil corporate cabal that is obviously behind all criticism of The Food Babe, because, obviously, no one who isn’t being paid by the food industry could ever find reason to criticize Hari. Or so Hari apparently seems to think. It’s a very arrogant position to take; Hari is so sure of her righteousness that if you oppose her, you’re either part of the evil food industry cabal or a sheeple who’s been deceived by that cabal. It’s also a convenient excuse not to engage seriously.
There is one aspect of this that must be acknowledged, however, and that’s misogyny. It’s one thing to attack Hari’s ideas and claims. That’s such a “target rich” environment that one could write about it over and over and over and there would still be copious material to refute with science. It’s fair game to call her scientifically ignorant, because she provides copious evidence that she is, in fact, scientifically ignorant with virtually everything she writes. It’s even fair game to create pro-science parodies of her, like Chow Babe, Science Babe, and Food Hunk. What is not fair game are some of the Facebook comments that she includes. They are misogynistic and vile in the extreme, which is something that women who go online face all too frequently. One refers to her as a “stupid female” who should “kill herself.” Another wishes death upon her from something she ate. Yet another makes a not-so-subtle reference to raping Hari’s dead body. None of these misogynistic comments and threats of death is acceptable in any way, shape or form, and I condemn them completely.
Indeed, my likening The Food Babe to Jenny McCarthy is even more appropriate than I had thought at the time I did it. McCarthy, after all, has also been the subject of misogynistic attacks based on her looks and her history as a Playboy Playmate of the Year. In retrospect, long ago I even fell into that trap in that I sometimes mentioned her ditzy blonde image and that she was an ex-Playmate as an introduction to dismantling her claims. I now realize that McCarthy’s history with Playboy has nothing to do with her promotion of antivaccine pseudoscience, and it was neither necessary nor appropriate to reference it. McCarthy provided more than enough fodder that needed refuting without mentioning it. The same is true of Vani Hari. Even though she has chosen “The Food Babe” as her “brand,” that does not excuse misogynistic attacks on her and implied rape threats. Any skeptic who has made misogynistic or threatening comments online about Hari is not my friend or ally. To them, I have just one thing to say: Knock it off.
On the other hand, it is necessary to point out that, as inappropriate and vile as these examples provided by Hari are, Hari also appears to be using them to her advantage. I can (and do) condemn such attacks, and will continue to do so. However, I also can’t help but notice that she appears to be conflating the vile comments she’s received on her Facebook page with the reasoned, science-based criticism that she’s been receiving from many bloggers, including us at SBM, all in order to tar reasonable criticism of her fear mongering with the brush of the sorts of misogynistic slurs featured in her response. All of this (or Hari not-so-subtly implies) is supposedly orchestrated by her enemies in the food industry. It’s fallacy of poisoning the well/guilt by association, plain and simple.
The Food Babe responds “substantively” to criticism. Hilarity ensues.
After having condemned criticism that is not science-based but is threatening and misogynistic, I next wondered: What about the substance of her point-by-point responses to criticism? Let’s just say that the same flaws in thinking that led to all the criticism are on full display here. I’ll pick some examples. Perhaps my favorite example is how she responds to the criticism of her chemical ignorance embodied in her “antifreeze in beer” nonsense:
What they say: I exaggerated claims about the ingredients in beer – from Propylene Glycol and it’s derivatives to Isinglass (fish swim bladders).
The truth: The beer campaign was all about transparency and we have the right to know what we are drinking.
For decades the multi-billion dollar beer industry (along with the entire alcohol industry) has gotten away with not disclosing their ingredients and I find this appalling. That’s why I started a petition to ask the 2 largest beer companies to disclose their ingredients. I pointed out several of the ingredients beer manufacturers are allowed to use in our beer according to the Treasury Department, where beer is regulated. I listed these ingredients in the video I created for my petition that received over 40,000 signatures in 24 hours and that ultimately forced Anheuser-Busch and Miller Coors to start disclosing their ingredients for the first time in history. Propylene glycol (which is found in airplane deicing liquid, aka “anti-freeze”) and propylene glycol alginate that is derived from kelp are both allowed to be used in alcohol. In fact, Fireball Whisky recently had to remove it’s [sic] products from shelves in Europe because it contained too much propylene glycol (the antifreeze variety). Corona beer uses propylene glycol alginate. Regardless of which propylene glycol ingredient is used in an alcohol product, I believe we have the right to know what ingredients we are consuming. The same goes for “Isinglass” – which is made from fish swim bladders. I know this ingredient has been used for centuries and not harmful, but this is a real issue for vegans & vegetarians. They deserve to know if an animal product was used in its production. Along with these ingredients, I have exposed several other very controversial chemicals in beer my detractors fail to mention, like caramel coloring level IV, carrageenan and high fructose corn syrup. Who will hold the alcohol industry accountable for transparency, if we don’t?
Notice that she’s still confusing propylene glycol and propylene glycol alginate (“regardless of which propylene glycol ingredient is used in an alcohol product”) without acknowledging that they are two very different chemicals and is still mentioning that propylene glycol is in airplane de-icing fluid. Funny, but shouldn’t she also mention that propylene glycol is also of a class of ingredients that the FDA calls “generally recognized as safe” and that large quantities of it can be consumed without causing toxic effects? That’s what I call selective reporting of information, coupled with ignorance of chemistry, given that propylene glycol alginate isn’t even the same chemical. As for isinglass, as I’ve described before, that’s basically what I like to call an “appeal to yuckiness.” Because fish bladders sound yucky, they must be harmful. That bit about vegans is a nice touch, but that wasn’t part of her original argument. She only thought that up after it was pointed out to her that isinglass has been used in beer production since the 19th century. She also neglects to mention that isinglass is removed from the beer before it is sold. While it is true that there is a question among some vegans whether mere contact of one’s food or beverage with animal matter and the possibility that trace amounts of animal matter might remain in it are enough to make such foods or beverages off-limits, if that’s the case then vegans shouldn’t drink most beers because many use gelatin instead of isinglass as a clearing agent. There are also a huge number of foods in whose manufacture gelatins from various sources are used.
Basically, here The Food Babe’s response boils down to: Ignore my chemical illiteracy. It’s all about “transparency.” Of course, she doesn’t seem to realize that her case for transparency was very much undermined by her chemical illiteracy.
Another here’s a hilarious one:
What they say: The phrase “If you can’t pronounce it, you shouldn’t eat it” is not scientific.
The truth: I didn’t come up with this clever phrase, but think it’s great advice.
This idea actually originated with Michael Pollan in his prominent book “In the Defense of Food” and later on in “Food Rules” where in rule #7 he stated “Avoid food products containing ingredients that a third-grader cannot pronounce.”
I love this advice and I think it works well in the majority of cases when reading the ingredient label on food products in the grocery store. Not everyone has the time to tirelessly review all the ingredients allowed in our food system. This simple rule makes it easy for the average person to avoid processed food, which I think everyone can benefit from!
If you can’t pronounce it that probably means the material has been part of the human diet for a minute period of time in terms of the human evolutionary or developmental process. Using many of these substances is a grand experiment that many people would prefer not subjecting themselves or their children to.
In other words, Hari is doubling down on what can only be described as one of the dumbest things I’ve ever heard from an activist. The only appropriate response to this is along the lines of a meme that’s been going around Facebook and elsewhere (as always, click to embiggen):
Clearly, Hari should never, ever eat a banana.
The list of “responses” in which Hari just goes on and on and on, with Hari listing criticisms of her and then trying to “refute” those criticisms by, in essence, doubling down on the same misinformation that was being criticized in the first place. For instance, she claims she’s “not antivaccine,” contrary to the evidence in her post on the flu vaccine that argues that she is. Basically, she says she isn’t against all vaccines (while declining to say which vaccines she would recommend) then uses the antivaccine ploy of argumentum ad package insert and cites antivaccine sources, such as Mark Hyman (who recently co-authored a book with—yikes!—antivaccine activist Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and appeared with him on The Dr. Oz Show) and Joe Mercola, a purveyor of “alternative” medicine and antivaccine activist who has supported the antivaccine group National Vaccine Information Center with considerable cash and co-sponsored with her “Vaccine Awareness Week,” which is designed to make people aware of the fictitious links between vaccines and autism and various other diseases. Elsewhere, Hari claims that she isn’t afraid of answering questions after her talks, when Kevin Folta has clearly described otherwise. Hari even argues:
What They Say: Our findings are based on pseudoscience or we hate science and we are “fear mongering”.
The Truth: If our findings didn’t have any concerns, do not have a solid basis in fact, why are companies willing to drop these controversial chemicals?
As I’ve pointed out before, it has nothing to do with science or pseudoscience. Companies can live and die by public perception of their products. To them, even if their position is rooted in solid science (and we know that The Food Babe’s position almost never is), sometimes it’s far easier and less expensive for them just to give in to a quackmailer like Hari than to try to resist or to go to the considerable effort and expense necessary to counter her propaganda by educating the public. And, make no mistake, quackmail is exactly what Vani Hari is about. I was only surprised and gratified that Starbucks didn’t cave. Maybe that’s a sign that companies are finally getting wise to Hari’s tactics.
Building the brand
Hari is about nothing if not about building The Food Babe brand. Clearly, she was finally goaded to responding (poorly) to legitimate criticism because that criticism has finally crossed over from the realm of science and medical bloggers and skeptics into the mainstream media. Now it’s hurting that brand. With the release of her book a mere two months away, she probably had little choice but to respond somehow, and that’s consistent with her scrubbing her site of the most egregiously-embarrassing posts and setting it so that it is no longer archived and deleted posts can no longer be so easily recovered. I have no doubt that she started out sincere. Misguided and scientifically wrong, but sincere. She’s probably still sincere. Certainly she sees herself that way:
What They Say: I’m in it only for the money or I’m a snake oil salesman.
The Truth: I left a secure career without any guarantee or safety net that this new role as a full time food activist would ever support me.
The people who use this attack don’t know me or my story. When I quit my secure corporate job, in December of 2012, I wasn’t making any money blogging. Everyone needs to find a way to make a living and I feel very lucky that I’ve figured out how to do that without compromising my values. I have now dedicated my life to create a better food system and I feel good knowing my work contributes to the knowledge of others and their quality of life.
I work harder now, than I ever have in my life. I spend my days investigating, writing, meeting with experts and consumer organizations, traveling to conferences, speaking, and attending food trade shows.
Note that her being in it for the money and selling snake oil are not incompatible with her having started out sincere and still viewing herself as a shining white knight battling the evil food industry. Clearly, that’s how Hari views herself, and humans consistently underestimate how much their behavior is affected by money. There’s plenty of evidence in her response that she views this as a Manichean struggle of good (her and her “Food Babe Army”) versus evil (the food industry and its minions). The difference is that, unlike two years ago when she got started, now she makes considerable cash at it. She’s become quite the entrepreneur:
In less than two years, Hari, 35, has gotten a book contract with Little, Brown (“The Food Babe Way,” due out in February, on her organic lifestyle), a William Morris Endeavor agent to handle her TV appearances and a website packed with advertising and product endorsements. You can even buy an eating-plan subscription for $17.99 a month.
Like other well-trafficked sites, the Food Babe is an affiliate of Amazon.com: If you click on a product and it takes you to the shopping site, Hari gets a percentage from your purchase as well as a percentage from anything else you buy during the same visit.
Google Analytics shared by Hari show an average of 5.3 million page views and 2.4 million unique visitors a month since mid-March. She logs 600,000 “likes” on Facebook, mostly from women between 25 and 34 years old. Her Twitter page shows 64,000 followers.
And:
Being a consumer advocate, which is what Hari calls herself, appears to be lucrative. While Hari declined to disclose what she makes from the website, she and her husband, Finley Clarke, both left what she says were “six-figure incomes” as technology consultants to work full time for foodbabe.com.
In other words, the Food Babe brand has become lucrative. Viewed through this prism, Hari’s antics are more understandable. She needs media attention, and she needs to fire up her fans. More importantly, she needs to prove that she’s “somebody,” even better, somebody her enemies and the enemies of her followers fear. If she can’t keep demonstrating that the food industry fears her by trumping up false controversy and activism against them, she loses her influence and thus her power and, even worse, her earning potential. Again, I’m not saying that she’s in it only for the money. Clearly that’s not the case. She’s an ideologue with no understanding of science or chemistry. Worse, she’s a telegenic and charming ideologue. Through a perfect storm forged in the confluence of her ideology, ignorance, and budding media savviness, she’s used misinformation and pseudoscience to become an Internet star and a media sensation. She could even be on the cusp of becoming a real star, given her book deal. It’s quite possible she could use her talent for food quackery in the same way Dr. Oz has used his talent for medical quackery to become a daytime TV star.
Sincerity aside, The Food Babe’s business model is described in this article, “Activist or Capitalist? How the ‘Food Babe’ Makes Money“. In it, E. J. Schultz and Maureen Morrison are more explicit about how Hari monetizes her activities:
Ms. Hari declined to answer a question about why she incorporated in Delaware. She also declined to reveal her annual revenue from the site, including how many food guides she has sold or how many brands with which she has business relationships. “This is information that is not important to my activism and my work,” she said, noting that she discloses partner brands when she mentions them in posts. “In order to be an activist you do need funds to do your work, and this is the most honest way that I think I can do that,” she said.
Part of her business model appears to be rooted in her affiliate-marketing partnerships. One of the companies she has recently plugged on her site is called Green Polka Dot Box, which sells home-delivered natural, organic and non-GMO foods. The company’s affiliate partners can earn 30% of the company’s annual $49.95 per-person membership fee for each person referred, plus $2 for every food purchase that person makes as long as they are a member, according to terms of the program listed on the company’s website.
Obviously, Hari incorporated in Delaware for a very good reason, the same reason many corporations choose Delaware to incorporate in: It’s a corporate tax haven, where corporations are “minimizing taxes, skirting regulations, plying friendly courts or, when needed, covering their tracks.” Delaware regularly tops the list of domestic and foreign tax havens because it allows companies to lower their taxes in the state in which they actually do business by shifting royalties and similar revenues to holding companies in Delaware, where they are not taxed.
Another interesting example is Hari’s relationship with a company called The Maca Team, which sells organic raw maca powder. On her site, Hari wrote that the plant can reduces stress, “improve mental clarity,” and “treat PMS.” It turns out that The Maca Team’s affiliate program lets partners earn 20% on each sale they refer. The Federal Trade Commission requires that bloggers disclose paid endorsements “clearly and conspicuously” on their blogs and websites. Although Hari does generally disclose such relationships, Schulz and Morrison questioned whether she met the “clear and conspicuous” standard.
In any case, whenever I’m accused of being a “pharma shill” by someone like Hari or accused of being “in it only for the money” by her supporters or supporters of, say, Mike Adams, I take great pleasure in pointing out that, in contrast to me, Hari makes quite a healthy living selling products and, above all, her brand. She’s not alone, either—unfortunately. I have no doubt that Hari didn’t start out being in it for the money, and I’m guessing she still probably isn’t. That doesn’t mean that money isn’t an important consideration in determining her behavior. It’s a consideration that can be very easily rationalized as necessary for her to continue to wage her war against what she sees as nasty unpronounceable ingredients in food. (After all, more money equals more fame and power, which would allow her to be a more effective advocate.) Hari might not be in it only for the money, but she’s definitely in it for the money far more than most of her critics, which is why I view her extravagant use of the pharma shill gambit in her response to skeptical bloggers who criticize her pseudoscience and ignorance of chemistry as likely a rather obvious case of projection.

The Food Babe’s war on “chemicals” heats up again
David Gorski on February 15, 2015
Link

[Note: This is an extra bonus post. Because The Food Babe has been in the news and I couldn’t wait until today, I discussed it at a certain not-so-super-secret blog. If you’ve read it before, it’s only somewhat modified and updated. If you haven’t, it’s new to you. Either way, feel free to comment. Completely new material by me will appear here in a scant few hours.]
It’s been a while since I’ve taken notice of Vani Hari, a.k.a. The Food Babe, the misguided “food safety” activist who sees chemicals, chemicals, chemicals everywhere and raises fears about them all, especially the ones that she can’t pronounce. The first time I took any significant notice of her was about a year ago, when she was making news for lobbying Subway to remove the “yoga mat chemical” azodicarbonamide from its bread, although I didn’t write about her here for a few months after that. As I explained at the time, azodicarbonamide is a chemical used in small amounts to mature bread dough, improve its handling properties, and produce a drier, more cohesive, and more pliable dough that holds together better during kneading by hand or machine. It is safe, breaks down during baking into small amounts of safe substances, and is only a hazard if you inhale it in powder form, where it can be a pulmonary irritant. Then, she made some astonishingly ignorant statements about beer, where she pulled the same routine, to the point where I labeled her tactics as the “appeal to yuckiness.” Basically, if something sounds yucky to her (such as isinglass, which is derived from the swim bladders of fish and is used in some beers to remove haziness and yeast byproducts), then it must be bad, either for you or just bad because it’s gross. It also turns out that The Food Babe makes quite a pretty penny spreading her ignorance and has become sought after to feature in various media appearances, such as magazine covers.
For the last few months I’ve been somewhat dreading February, because I knew Hari was poised to release her first book. As I described before, she has more than a fair amount of social media savvy and business acumen, which have allowed her to build the Food Babe brand rapidly and explains (to me at least) why she seemed to come out of nowhere on a trajectory to become as influential as Dr. Mehmet Oz. Her book, released this week, is called The Food Babe Way: Break Free from the Hidden Toxins in Your Food and Lose Weight, Look Years Younger, and Get Healthy in Just 21 Days! (Talk about ridiculously long subtitles!) You see, I knew that when it came time for Hari’s book to come out we’d be seeing a lot more of her, and unfortunately that’s what happened. As part of that publicity, Hari was featured in a fairly long feature article in The Atlantic by James Hamblin, The Food Babe: Enemy of Chemicals. It’s a relatively amusing title, to be sure, and there’s a lot that’s good about the article. Unfortunately, there’s also a lot that’s downright infuriating about it as well, the more so given that Hamblin is a physician and really should know better, but unfortunately in this piece he shows himself far more respectful of pseudoscience of the sort promoted by The Food Babe than a physician should be.
What’s infuriating is that this article is one of the most egregious examples I’ve seen in a long time of “false balance.” In this case, the false balance comes in the form of a “point-counterpoint” style of telling the Food Babe’s story, whereby she makes a claim, which is then refuted or contested by a scientist. You might think: Great! The article is debunking Hari’s nonsense, and, to a reasonable extent it does, but it does so in such a way as to give the illusion that there is actually a scientific controversy about the topics Hari gloms onto. With few exceptions, there isn’t, and for the exceptions she inevitably takes the most fear-mongering approach. I suppose I shouldn’t be too surprised. Hamblin has revealed himself to be insufficiently skeptical about dubious medical claims before, specifically about chelation therapy.
On the other hand, I will give Hamblin credit for quoting part of Hari’s book that perfectly encompasses her complete ignorance of chemistry, physiology, and pharmacology:
Her stance on food additives is an absolute one: “There is just no acceptable level of any chemical to ingest, ever.”
So may I assume that Hari doesn’t ingest water? That’s a chemical. What about salt or sugar? Those are chemicals too. What about food? Our food, even part of a perfect raw vegan diet, is chock full of chemicals because organisms, be they plants or animals, are made up of chemicals with structures ranging from very simple to highly complex, such as proteins, nucleic acids, carbohydrates, lipids, and many others.
Yes, yes, I know that when someone like Hari says “chemical,” she isn’t using the scientific definition of the word, which basically describes the constituents of all matter cooler than nuclear plasma. After all, everything in our everyday lives is made up of chemicals. Rather, when someone like Hari says “chemicals,” she means synthetic, manmade chemicals. Of course, that’s—if you’ll excuse the term—an artificial distinction. What’s “natural” and what’s not? Is it “unnatural” to modify a natural product and use it? What about mixtures? Yes, Hari’s fear of chemicals is completely over-the-top, and Hamblin notes the criticism that she has received:
Most of the scientists who have spoken on Hari’s work, though, are less than supportive of that sweeping message. Rather, her work has drawn ardent criticism, primarily from a vocal contingent of academic researchers and doctors, who accuse her, in no uncertain terms, of fear-mongering and profiteering. They say that she invokes science when it is convenient, as in the passage above, but demonizes it when it is not—as in her blanket case against any and all genetically modified food. Last month, NPR ran a critique of Hari’s work, quoting several of her outspoken detractors. Science writer Kavin Senapathy, for one, captured the concerns of many in saying that Hari “exploits the scientific ignorance of her followers.” Others, including neurologist Steven Novella, have said that she is to food what Jenny McCarthy is to vaccines.
Yep. The Food Babe is, as I’ve put it, the Jenny McCarthy of food.
Of interest to me, at least, was the part of the profile where Hamblin goes into a bit more detail than I had known before about the Food Babe’s origins:
One cold winter night, when she was in her early 20s, Vani Hari developed some pain in her lower abdomen. She went to a nearby hospital in Charlotte, North Carolina, where she was born and had returned to live after college. In the emergency department, she remembers being told to relax, that her ovaries were “moving,” and she’d be fine. The next morning she went in for a second opinion, and she was diagnosed with appendicitis. Within an hour she was having her appendix laparoscopically excised. Recovering in the hospital that night, she remembers someone took a picture of her, and she ripped it up thinking she looked “so, so bad.” And she definitely felt horrible.
Since graduating from college, Hari had been working as a consultant at Accenture. She kept long, exhausting hours. She recalls being afraid to leave to use the bathroom during meetings because the environment was so intense. She ate decadent catered meals from exorbitant expense accounts. “A bunch of stuff that really doesn’t serve the body,” she recalls. “But I wanted to fit in, I wanted to be a partner. I was ambitious.” But the health issues she’d had as a child—allergies, eczema, asthma—flared up. Over the first year of the job, she gained between 30 and 40 pounds. She felt bad and “didn’t look that great.”
When the appendicitis hit, that was a breaking point. Lying in her hospital bed, Hari said, “I just had this light bulb awakening moment, you know? This isn’t how I want to live.”
It’s not that uncommon a story among cranks. Mike Adams, for example, cites the origin of his crank activism (although he wouldn’t describe his activism that way, of course) as being due to a deterioration in his health at a young age where he was, if you believe his story (and, given Adams’ history of embellishing his own history, I’m not sure I do), diagnosed with type II diabetes at age 30. Ditto Chris Wark of Chris Beat Cancer, who became an activist after suffering from colon cancer in his 20s, an unusually young age to be stricken with the disease, and has since been promoting cancer quackery. The “wake up call” of a serious health problem suffered at a young age is a common story among cranks and quacks. After all, young people tend to believe that they are relatively indestructible and can expect good health for several more decades before old age and its attendant problems finally catches up with them. When poor health strikes at such a young age, people can feel cheated.
Of course, it’s great that Hari cleaned up her act, lost a bunch of weight, and (apparently) saw her health problems go away. However, as all too often happens, she also attributed her health problems to more than just a poor diet and lifestyle. She blamed the evil chemicalz! She blamed processed foods, various food additives, and basically any synthetic chemical. Over time, as I’ve observed, this belief has morphed into a seeming concept that anything with a long chemical name that she can’t pronounce must be bad. Indeed, it’s evolved, as Hamblin notes, to include even things that are perfectly “natural,” such as isinglass derived from fish swim bladders. Hamblin just doesn’t seem to note that the reason isinglass is bad to The Food Babe is nothing more complex than her revulsion that a product of fish swim bladder is used to make some beers. Ditto the product of beaver anal glands and others:
At times, even, Hari’s suspicions lead her to contradict the basic tenet that natural is good. “Readers of my blog know,” she writes in the book, “that the next time you lick vanilla ice cream from a cone, there’s a good chance you’ll be swirling secretions from a beaver’s anal glands around in your mouth.” Indeed. “Called castoreum, this secretion is used as a ‘natural flavor’ not only in vanilla ice cream but also in strawberry oatmeal and raspberry-flavored products.” And, similarly, “If you chew gum, you may also be chewing lanolin, an oily secretion found in sheep’s wool that is used to soften some gums. What nutritional value do you think these disgusting additives have for your body? None! They exist just to get you to buy something fake or that shouldn’t be food, rather than a real alternative.”
Appeal to yuckiness, indeed. And to “chemically-sounding” names. Or whatever else Hari can’t understand or finds gross.
Another thing that drives Hari is an intense competitiveness, which she attributes to her talent as a high school debater. Of course, as I’ve mentioned before, the goal of a debater is not to find out what is accurate from a scientific standpoint (or any other standpoint, for that matter). It is to defend her position. It is to attack her opponents’ position. It is to win the debate based on rhetoric and carefully-selected evidence (not to mention carefully-constructed attacks on your opponents’ evidence). Winning a debate involves marshaling evidence to support a given position, not following the evidence to where it leads. Actually, Hari’s love of high school debate and her competitive nature, when coupled with her scientific ignorance, provide a pretty darned good explanation why she is so impervious to correction. So does this:
“There’s disconnect between the language of science and the language of common communication,” Folta said, explaining why, while many people are upset over the GRAS system, it doesn’t bother him. “You can never demonstrate that something is ‘safe.’ Whether it’s water or sugar; there’s no way. Because you can’t test every aspect. All we can say is, of all the things we’ve looked at, there’s no evidence of harm. If you said, can you prove to me beyond a shadow of a doubt that something is safe, I’d say, no way. With vaccines, sure, you can’t account for some extremely rare effect that might be seen in someone with a particular metabolic disorder, but that’s not to say they’re not a tremendous benefit to society as a whole.”
I guess the only good thing about my having encountered Vani Hari is that I became aware of Kevin Folta, an outspoken scientist whose work involves GMOs. He’s an impressive guy, although I must disagree with him when he says, “I don’t want to throw her under the bus; I want her to get on the bus.” The reason is that I don’t think Hari is educable. I suppose that there’s some slim chance that I’m wrong about this, but I doubt it, given how rare it is for someone who’s gone so far down the rabbit hole of pseudoscience to reverse course. I suppose we can always hope.
In any case, GRAS stands for “generally recognized as safe,” a designation used by the FDA to describe substances that have been in long use and are, well, generally recognized as safe. There might be an issue, as noted by Hamblin, that more substances have gained the GRAS designation than rate it, but the Food Babe goes far beyond science-based calls for reform of the GRAS designation every time she goes off the deep end with respect to science. For instance:
“The scientists who argue with me about this minute data, who keep saying ‘The dose makes the poison,’ Hari says, shaking her head. “Why aren’t we more cautious about the ingredients we allow in our food supply? Why are we allowing all these additives? And what’s the cumulative effect of all these additives together? That’s something people are just starting to study.”
And why are we giving so many vaccines so early? It’s “too many too soon.” What are all those chemicals in vaccines? They’re “toxins.” Truly, it must be emphasized once again that Vani Hari is the Jenny McCarthy of food.
Like Jenny McCarthy, Hari thrives on the opposition her crusade provokes. She thrives on victimhood. It’s how she rallies her troops. It’s what she did a couple of months ago in response to the NPR article mentioned above. She spent a lot more verbiage claiming that her critics were all in the pay of pharmaceutical companies and agribusiness than she did actually trying to refute anything. Yes, there were some despicably misogynic comments directed at her, as, unfortunately, many women suffer online. (It always pisses me off to see such behavior from anyone on “our side.”) Unfortunately she wielded them like a shield and tried to use them to paint “our side” as nothing more than a bunch of misogynistic trolls, almost certainly in the pay of the evil Monsanto, of course.
Then there’s the issue of how she deals with reasonable criticism. Hamblin notes that Hari admits that her post about microwaving food and how it supposedly harms the food’s nutritional value (complete with a credulous reference to her post with the Masaro Emoto’s water woo in it). In response to some criticism, she has said:
Hari recently implemented an editorial policy on the site wherein any change or correction will be noted (“I make mistakes, I’m human.”). And she will be announcing an advisory board that will help to review her claims. She will continue to be, as she has already proven, relentless and purposeful and clearly effective. It may be too optimistic to think that both sides of these debates can grow together and learn from one another’s concerns and perspectives, but the opportunity is certainly there. Until then, the battle for moral high ground marches on.
Anyone want to guess who will be on this “advisory board”? Joel Kahn, perhaps, the woo-friendly cardiologist who gave Hari a publicity blurb for her book? Mark Hyman, the “functional medicine” guru who provided the foreword to her book? Dr. Oz? The possibilities are endless, unfortunately.
The passage by Hamblin above is another example of false equivalency. Hari’s just another party battling scientists for the moral high ground. Never mind that she peddles nothing but pseudoscience and food fear mongering and her scientist critics do their best to promote information well-grounded in science. Meanwhile, contrary to her promise, in November Hari actually began to use search engine optimization tricks to actively thwart her critics by making old posts that she now finds embarrassing disappear down the Internet memory hole by changing the robots.txt file of her website and using other tricks to prevent archiving by Archive.org. Hamblin never mentions this, nor does he mention that there’s also no evidence that she’s ever made a substantive correction to something she’s said that was shown unequivocally to be wrong. Add that to the discovery that she sells products with some of the dreaded chemicals she demonizes in them (something Hamblin also fails to note), and I see no evidence that the Food Babe is ever likely to reform her pseudoscientific ways.
I have little doubt that Hari started out sincere and probably still is sincere, at least mostly. Hers is a classic American “rags-to-riches” story, at least in the Internet era. Not so long ago, no one, including myself, had ever heard of Vani Hari. Now everyone knows who The Food Babe is. Unfortunately, the Internet and today’s media often don’t distinguish that much between science and pseudoscience when it comes to fame and influence.

Making One’s Own Reality – Food Babe Edition
Steven Novella on March 18, 2015
Link


The default mode of human activity is to construct our own internal model of reality based upon our desires, biases, flawed perceptions, memories, and reasoning, and received narratives from the culture in which we live. That model of reality is then reinforced by confirmation bias and jealously defended.
But we also have the capacity to transcend this pathway of least resistance. Philosophy is the discipline of thinking carefully and systematically about ideas to see if they at least are internally consistent. Science is the discipline of systematically and carefully comparing our internal models of reality against objective reality, and then changing those models to suit the evidence.
Everyone engages in a combination of bias, superstition, logic, and evidence-based reason to varying degrees – the question is, to what degree? The goal of science-based medicine is to increase the proportion of science and reason in the mix with respect to the practice of medicine and public health.
There are many forces at work in society, however, that explicitly oppose the role of science because, in my opinion, they find it inconvenient to their internal model of reality or whatever narrative they are selling.
At its core, we are engaged in a cultural battle over reality. We advocate a transparent, fair, and rigorous science-based approach to determining what is reality. Others, however, are trying to break or replace the rules of science so that they can advocate for a version of reality that is consistent with their narrative.
This has probably always been part of the human condition, but seems to be more acute recently, likely because of the power of the internet and social media. It is quite easy these days to create an alternative infrastructure dedicated to promoting a particular version of reality.
If you are, for example, an anti-vaccine ideologue, you can have your own experts, studies, journals, websites, and networks, creating an echochamber dedicated to your version of reality.
Sometimes these echochambers arise spontaneously as part of a grass-roots movement. Sometimes they are manufactured deliberately as part of a campaign to erect a pocket of alternative reality in our society, or to defend a vested interest.
We address many examples of manufactured alternative realities on SBM, and I am going to focus on one today for the purpose of illustration – Vani Hari (aka the Food Babe).
Hari is an up-and-coming food activist (although she is getting to be old news rather quickly). We have discussed her here and on other science-based blogs because she appears to be an utterly scientifically illiterate ideologue.
Her narrative is that all chemicals are bad, anything synthetic is bad, and anything that superficially seems yucky to her must also be bad. She has literally stated that there should be no amount of any chemicals in food. She has also famously stated that any substance whose name she cannot pronounce should not be in food.
She is, unfortunately, media savvy and has been very effective at self-promotion. Her routine is to identify something she finds yucky in food, completely misrepresent the science, then fearmonger about the safe ingredient in order to bully companies into doing PR damage control. Recently, however, the scientific community is noticing how dangerously scientifically illiterate she is.
Last week The New York Times published an unflattering article about Hari. Here is a typical passage:
Kevin M. Folta, the chairman of the horticultural sciences department at the University of Florida, described Ms. Hari’s lecture at the university last October as a “corrupt message of bogus science and abject food terrorism.” (Her fee was $6,000.) Dr. Folta added, “She found that a popular social media site was more powerful than science itself, more powerful than reason, more powerful than actually knowing what you’re talking about.”
The article also quoted our own David Gorski:
David H. Gorski, a surgical oncologist who also has a degree in chemistry, wrote on Science-Based Medicine that the beer ingredient is propylene glycol alginate, which, despite its name, is not even close to propylene glycol, is not antifreeze and is derived from kelp.)
Hari recently responded to the NYT article, which is more interesting than the article itself because it demonstrates, in my opinion, her utter intellectual dishonesty – something which is necessary to maintain a bubble of alternative reality.
In her response she blatantly plays the shill card. She tries to dismiss her critics:
as manufactured by “the processed food lobby” and “industry-funded science.”
In her reply she states about Kevin Folta:
Ms. Rubin quotes Kevin Folta, chair of the Horticultural Sciences Department at the University of Florida. He does not specialize in health or nutrition; rather he is a crop scientist specializing in GMOs who seeks industry funding and support for this research (3).
This, of course, answers none of Kevin’s criticisms of Hari. He is a publicly funded geneticist without any conflicts of interest. He would like to see some of the genetically modified plants he has studied make it to market (like disease resistant strawberries) – how does that in any way affect his criticisms of Hari’s unscientific statements?
She also goes after David, stating:
The piece mentions Dr. David Gorski, who also has received pharmaceutical industry funding (6). He likes to vilify “quackery”, and has even attacked the venerable Cleveland Clinic for using some alternative medicine (7). He is simply wrong that there is no propylene glycol, the antifreeze kind, in some beers and alcohol. We know Fireball Whiskey contains it (8) and it’s listed as an approved ingredient in alcohol on the government website ttb.gov (9). This is easy to prove if you aren’t looking to discredit someone. I answered this previously in a response to my critics back in December 2014 (10), but this was ignored and has been re-hashed time and time again.
These statements are, how we say, “factually challenged.” David has responded on his own blog, but to reiterate a couple of points here: David received a small amount of pharmaceutical company funding years ago. This hardly amounts to a conflict of interest in pointing out Hari’s bad science. This is not even part of the food industry. It is easy to see how Hari uses any sliver of an appearance of a conflict as a witch hunt to discredit her critics.
Hari also tries to pull one over on her readers with the propylene glycol issue. She clearly mistook propylene glycol alginate in beer for propylene glycol, because she doesn’t understand that these are different chemicals. The fact that there is a small amount of propylene glycol in Fireball Whisky is completely irrelevant.
Conclusion
The culture war continues. The Food Babe and others are attempting to distort the process of science in order to promote their alternative world view. Part of the strategy is to dismiss and discredit scientists who know enough to level devastating criticism at their particular brand of nonsense.
We are seeing this from antivaxxers, anti-GMO activists, and others as well. Unfortunately, this controversy can have a chilling effect and make it difficult or unappealing for scientists to engage with the public.
However, we need to engage all the more because of popular nonsense like that peddled by self-proclaimed but entirely incompetent “experts.”

Nutrigenomics – Not Ready for Prime Time
Steven Novella on January 2, 2013
Link
Quackery in medicine takes many forms – use of bad science (pseudoscience), fraud, and reliance on mysticism are a few examples. Perhaps the most insidious form of dubious practice, however, is to use genuine and promising medical science to promote treatments that are simply not at the point of clinical application. New treatments, and especially new approaches to treatment, in medicine often take years or decades of research before we get to the point that we have sufficient clinical evidence of safety and effectiveness to apply the treatment in clinical practice.
One example of the premature promotion of an otherwise legitimate scientific medical treatment are the many dubious stem cell clinics promising cures for serious diseases. Stem cell science is real, but we are still in the long period of build up when we are mostly doing basic and animal research. Human clinical trials are just beginning.
Another treatment approach that is being prematurely promoted by some is nutrigenomics. The claim is that by analyzing one’s genes a personalized regimen of specific nutrients can be developed to help their genes function at optimal efficiency. One website that promises, “Genetics Based Integrative Medicine” contains this statement:
Nutrigenomics seeks to unravel these medical mysteries by providing personalized genetics-based treatment. Even so, it will take decades to confirm what we already understand; that replacing specific nutrients and/or chemicals in existing pathways allows more efficient gene expression, particularly with genetic vulnerabilities and mutations.
The money-quote is the phrase, “it will take decades to confirm what we already understand.” This is the essence of pseudoscience – using science to confirm what one already “knows.” This has it backwards, of course. Science is not used to “confirm” but to determine if a hypothesis is true or not.
As with the stem-cell quackery, this idea (of studying one’s genes in order to personalize therapy) is not itself pseudoscience. It is, in fact, an area of legitimate research. We already use genetic analysis to diagnose certain diseases, and to target chemotherapy. We are beginning to identify specific genes that affect how different individuals metabolize and respond to specific drugs. While genes are not necessarily destiny, our genes do exert a powerful influence over our health. They are already an important part of science-based medicine.
Further, as genetic analysis becomes more rapid and cost effective, there is the increasing potential that it can be used as part of a routine screening health evaluation in order to identify susceptibilities, target preventive treatments, adjust behaviors to target risks, and guide therapy. However, similar to stem cell treatments, our current knowledge base with respect to genetic predispositions is still in its infancy. What is well established is already incorporated into mainstream medical practice. The rest is a matter for research, not current practice.
This creates an opportunity for exploitation, however – using current cutting edge research to make clinical claims that are years or decades premature by pretending to have knowledge that simply does not exist. This type of medical pseudoscience is also a manifestation of one common tactic among dubious practitioners – basing clinical claims on pre-clinical scientific research. This is especially insidious and difficult for the non-expert to properly evaluate (which makes for effective pseudoscientific marketing).
A November 2012 review of the field of nutrigenomics states:
It has, however, proven very challenging to define an individual’s responsiveness to complex diets based on common genetic variations. In addition, there is a limited understanding of what constitutes an optimal response because we lack key health biomarkers and signatures.
In other words – the relationship between nutrition and personal health is complex and we do not yet have the scientific knowledge to apply to practice. The article concludes that, while promising, the field is not yet ready for the marketplace.
One way to look at the issue of nutrigenomics is moving from population-based nutrition data to individual, or personalized, data (specifically, genetic profile). Health promotion advice is now based largely on population-based data – what is statistically likely to happen with respect to risk factors and disease outcomes. Nutrigenomics research focuses on tweaking this advice (not replacing it) with an additional level of detail targeted to an individual’s genetics. The application would go something like this: you have a blood test to test for specific gene variants. If you have one specific variant then that might predict a need for a higher level of one specific vitamin, or it may predict whether or not there will be a benefit from a specific intervention, like lowering triglycerides. This way you can focus your efforts on those factors that will actually help.
This is an interesting approach – we just don’t know yet if this type of data will produce useful results.
A 2010 review by the Evaluation of Genomic Applications in Practice and Prevention (EGAPP) Working Group, specifically with relation to preventing heart disease, concluded:
The Evaluation of Genomic Applications in Practice and Prevention Working Group (EWG) found insufficient evidence to recommend testing for the 9p21 genetic variant or 57 other variants in 28 genes (listed in ) to assess risk for cardiovascular disease (CVD) in the general population, specifically heart disease and stroke. The EWG found that the magnitude of net health benefit from use of any of these tests alone or in combination is negligible. The EWG discourages clinical use unless further evidence supports improved clinical outcomes. Based on the available evidence, the overall certainty of net health benefit is deemed “Low.”
There is a great deal of basic science research going on (test tube and petri dish type research), which asks questions about how the body works and how it is affected by all conceivable factors. There is also translational or clinical research which seeks to apply this knowledge to specific medical interventions. Biology is horrifically complex, however, and so it is extremely difficult to extrapolate from basic science knowledge to net clinical effects. Most guesses that derive from basic science research turn out to be wrong. Sometimes our guesses are even the opposite of what we predicted – interventions cause harm rather than improvement. The only way to know is to conduct careful rigorous clinical research to measure the actual effects (good and bad) of a specific intervention in a specific population.
What the EWG is saying is that researchers have identified specific genetic types that do indeed affect metabolism and nutritional factors can influence gene expression, but the existing clinical data does not show a significant clinical effect. This is often what dooms very promising medical research – all of the science is correct and points in the direction that a specific intervention should have a specific benefit, but in the end the magnitude of the net clinical effect is tiny – too small to be worth all the trouble.
Further, because of the vast reservoir of published basic-science research it is possible to find studies that seem to support almost any conceivable intervention you wish. To the public this can make any intervention seem as if it is science-based and legitimate, even when the treatment is nothing but deception.
The nutrigenomics website, for example, claims to treat the following conditions:
Welcome to Genetics Based Integrative Medicine (GBIM), a telemedicine practice dedicated to the education, treatment, and recovery of those with autism spectrum disorders, ADD/ADHD, and PANDAS as well as highly complex & disabling disorders affecting adults such as CFS/ME/FM, Multiple Sclerosis, ALS, Parkinson’s and mitochondrial dysfunction.
There is no compelling evidence for any nutritional treatment for the above diseases, let alone for personalized nutritional treatment based on specific genetic types. How the practitioners of GBIM came by the knowledge they are claiming to have is a mystery. As with the prematurely promoted stem cell treatments, such clinical claims, if legitimate, would have a paper trail of hundreds of published studies in the literature. Further, if such studies existed such practice would be standard of care, not isolated to one or a few special clinics.
I would add “nutrigenomics” to the list of red flags for dangerous quackery. It is a shame because, like stem cells, it is a legitimate field of research, and the current quackery is likely to taint the reputation of what in the future might be a promising approach.

“DNA-based” personalized nutrition advice: Not ready for prime time
There are countless vendors offering “personalized” nutrition recommendations, some based on DNA- or microbiome-testing. What does the evidence actually say?
Scott Gavura on February 20, 2020
Link

DNA testing is a recurrent topic on this blog, driven mainly by the significant technology advances that makes getting your DNA sequenced and analyzed both simple (usually a mouth swab) and inexpensive. Very quickly, this science has moved from the bench, to the bedside, and now to online test kits sold directly to consumers. What’s been missing in this weakly-regulated space is evidence that the information and advice derived from these tests is both reliable (i.e., you consistently get the same results) and valid (i.e., that the actions recommended are backed by robust evidence). An area that seems to have exploded in popularity is “DNA-based” diet advice, where your DNA is used to infer recommendations about your diet and to even recommend specific supplements. The idea of “personalized nutrition” sounds enticing (aren’t we all special snowflakes?), but as in many areas of science that are evolving quickly, the hype evolves even faster, outpacing the evidence. I was recently asked about a few products that have all appeared on the market over the past few years, each with impressive websites and lots of sciencey terms.
3D-printed vitamins?
Population-level evidence is convincing that there is no clear rationale to supplement with vitamins in the absence of a deficiency or demonstrated medical need. But is possible that benefits could be realized based on customized formulations defined by perceived need? The company Nourished promotes customized “3D-printed” “stacks” of vitamins that, while not strictly based on your DNA, are based on questions you answer. For context, I’m healthy, I exercise regularly, and I eat a well-balanced diet. I enter some demographic information, answered a few questions (How often do you eat vegetables? How often do you travel internationally?) and it suggested I need the following in my daily supplement – which Nourished will custom manufacture and ship to me monthly.
Each product has its own rationale included, none of which included citations or evidence to demonstrate that supplementation was necessary or beneficial, given my circumstances. The strangest one to me was the suggestion I need 1600mg of Vitamin A per day, presumably because I reported that I wear glasses. Not only is there no rationale to take vitamin supplements if you have myopia, like me, there’s pretty much no need for anyone in a resource-rich country (like me, in Canada) to take vitamin A – deficiencies are that rare.
Another company (Pure Genomics) goes a step further, using your results from 23andMe or Ancestry.com testing to offer up specific vitamin supplement recommendations. There is no published evidence to show that specific vitamin supplements are warranted based on this type of testing, but this doesn’t prevent an array of recommendations based on your results. And when a company offers supplements that claim to help “detoxification” then it’s a big red flag for the scientific rigor of the information and advice presented. Unless you have known organ failure, your kidney and liver are “detoxing” you just fine, and you don’t need any supplements to help them.
There was also a company that makes wine recommendations based on your DNA. That may have tested the limits of consumer credulity, and it looks like they’re no longer in operation. (Besides, I don’t need your DNA results to suggest that you’ll probably like Beaujolais).
What about eating aligned with your microbiome?
I admit that this one surprised me when I saw it, but there is apparently a market for “personalized nutrition” using “artificial intelligence” based on a stool sample. Viome claims that with an examination of your microbiome this information can be used to identify your “superfoods”, your foods to minimize, or enjoy, and what supplements you should take. Dr. Mark Crislip doesn’t blog here anymore but his posts on the microbiome are all in the archive and I strongly recommend them as background on this topic. My take on the topic is that the scientific understanding of the microbiome is progressing but still preliminary, particularly nutritional recommendations based on stool analyses. While Viome has raised a significant amount of funding, I couldn’t locate any published information to demonstrate that the Viome test is validated or that the recommendations that it produces result in meaningful, measurable benefits. The website Gut UK says the following:
If the types of bacteria shown in your test are similar to what is commonly seen in thousands of other people’s poo, then congratulations: your poo is just like other people’s poo. Some companies will send you a report showing how your poo compares to thousands of other people’s poo, and also showing the levels of different types of bacteria associated with some diseases. These results are interesting, but do not indicate a particular risk of developing that disease. We have not yet made strong links between the presence or absence of any types of bacteria with many of the “big” diseases such as cancer, heart disease or dementia. So, DON’T PANIC, for instance, if your report says you have low levels of a bacterium associated with preventing Type 2 diabetes. We are not at a stage where we can confidently say that we need to increase levels of that bacterium to reduce your risk of getting Type 2 diabetes. At the moment, we just do not have enough knowledge to safely and accurately recommend any specific interventions (such as particular changes in diet, and/or particular probiotics) to cause beneficial long-term changes to the composition of the bacteria in the gut.
There is also the question of how much value there is in doing a single test taken at a single time point. Many doctors measure markers of disease more than once, just in case the one reading they took was an odd one. Some of these poo tests only become useful when you look at the profile or fingerprint of the bacteria at different times.
Additionally, we do not really know what a ‘healthy’ level of some of these bacteria and chemicals should be in poo, and are only beginning to understand to what degree levels of microbes naturally fluctuate in the gut in a healthy person over time. Until we have done more research, the information given by these tests can be confusing, and often does not help doctors or nurses in guiding their advice to make you healthier or in treating any conditions that you may have. We do know that if you have a well-balanced diet with a good variety of different foods, this usually leads to a wide variety of different bacteria in your large bowel and poo. Many experts feel that this is probably a good thing.
Another good review, in Nature, notes the following:
Basing dietary advice on microbiome studies also assumes that it is possible to predict the health effects of different microbial communities — a goal that is far from being realized. Even well-studied mechanisms have unclear consequences for human health. Take, for example, the production of short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) from the bacterial digestion of fibre. SCFAs act on multiple tissues and targets of interest in both bacterial and host cells. Furthermore, not all SCFAs are the same, and they have not been considered in the context of products of carbohydrate and amino-acid fermentation — let alone the diversity of other microbial metabolites that could enhance or counteract the effects of these specific compounds. Therefore, although it is tempting to recommend diets that boost SCFAs to prevent metabolic and other diseases, the broader effects on the microbiome and its complex interactions with the host are hard to predict.
There are significant gaps in our knowledge and it’s premature to think that we understand the relationship between the consumption of specific foods, the composition of our microbiome, and health outcomes. But that hasn’t stopped testing vendors from making that leap. Given the state of the evidence, the results can’t be considered reliable or reproducible. Perhaps not surprisingly, one individual tried Viome and a competitor, DayTwo, and found the results and recommendations largely contradictory:
Perusing my list of foods with “Excellent” scores, I noticed some troubling conflicts with the other app. Lentils, which had been a no-no according to Viome, received high marks from DayTwo. Ditto for Kombucha. My purported superfood of cranberry received low marks. Almonds got an almost perfect score (9.7) while Viome told me to minimize them. I found similarly contradictory advice for foods I regularly eat, including navel oranges, peanuts, pork, and beets.
It seems a bit premature for a company to state “Imagine living in a world where illness is optional” when all it has are lots of testimonials yet no convincing scientific evidence that their “DNA-based” recommendations actually deliver meaningful health benefits.
Marketing outpaces the science
Our ability to collect DNA data is progressing quickly, and in time we may have more evidence to inform decisions about nutrition and possibly even supplements. At this time, however, there is a big gap between what we know, and what, if anything, to do with that information. You don’t need a DNA test or a stool sample to know that eating a varied, healthy diet, minimizing highly processed foods, eliminating trans fats, and keeping alcohol consumption moderate are reasonable approaches to designing your diet. It’s worth noting again, as we have blogged about many times before, that the evidence for taking supplementary vitamins, in general, is neutral to negative. In the absence of a specific medical need (e.g., pregnancy) there a few circumstances where routine supplementation is necessary or warranted. There is no robust evidence to date to show that personalized, “DNA-based” or “microbiome-based” nutritional recommendations give useful, actionable nutrition advice that actually improve health outcomes.

Steven Fowkes (Part 2 of 2): Nutrients for Better Mental Performance
Harriet Hall on November 1, 2011
Link
Last week, in part 1, I covered Steven Fowkes’ “cures” for Alzheimer’s and herpes. In part 2, I will cover a video where he goes further afield. It is titled “Nutrients for Better Mental Performance,” but he also discusses sleep, depression, hangovers, and a lot of other topics.
Some of what he says are simple truisms: mental performance is affected by everything related to health such as sleep, food, vitamins, minerals, detoxification, nutrients, amino acids, hormone replacement, pharmaceuticals and herbs. Metabolism is the key to brain function: 3% of the body uses 20% of the energy. Macronutrients, micronutrients, exercise, water, and breathing are important too.
We knew that.
Which nutrients promote optimal brain function? All of them: any deficiency will affect the brain. Fowkes goes beyond the evidence to claim that some nutrients are needed at super-physiological levels; Mother Nature is not optimal. Some supplements appear to work but the effects are not sustainable. It’s not about parts, but about how things work together.
Energy production is essential. Anaerobic metabolism only produces 2 ATP molecules from a glucose molecule compared to up to 38 ATP from aerobic metabolism.  He says this is inadequate. He says it’s enough to support unicellular life but not multicellular life (this is not true: there are multicellular organisms that are obligate anaerobes).  He says it’s not enough to give you robust life, consciousness and a working brain.  So aerobic metabolism is essential to preventing and treating Alzheimer’s.
He shows how a complex cascade of effects from an imbalance between mercury and glutathione affects a series of other processes and leads to Alzheimer’s, and he recapitulates some of the material from his Alzheimer’s video, but this presentation is not about Alzheimer’s: it’s about mental performance in everyone. What nutrients are commonly deficient enough to impair mental performance? The elderly are deficient in melatonin, B12, and pregnenolone. Teenage boys are deficient in zinc. Everyone is deficient in Vitamin D and magnesium. 30% of teenagers have a 10-point IQ increase just from RDA level supplements.
He says some hormones are neuroprotective, but estrogens have an anti-metabolic effect and impair energy production, which explains why women have more stamina than men. This is also why when men get inflammation they produce estrogen and start gaining weight and have more health problems. These statements are taken out of context from research that has little or no clinical significance. In contradiction to numerous published studies, he says estrogen has a profound adverse effect on the brain.
How to Get a Better Night’s Sleep
He has lots of advice for better sleep, from truisms to highly questionable recommendations:
    • Pay attention.
    • Use consistent background sound.
    • Sleep with regularity.
    • Sleep in the dark (melatonin).
    • Wake up with red light to mimic sunrise and sunset.
    • Try tryptophan for serotonin.
    • Eliminate inflammation (from allergy, infection, gut).
        ◦ Balance A and D.
        ◦ Digestive enzymes.
        ◦ Zinc with every meal to tighten up your gut and prevent undigested food particles from passing in and producing inflammation.
    • If a drug is needed, use Xyrem, which is a nutrient and enhances stages 3 and 4, which are decreased or absent in old age. This means you are not really asleep at night. Note: Xyrem is a brand name version of the date rape drug GHB and it has only been approved for the treatment of cataplexy associated with narcolepsy. It can have serious side effects. Ironically, one listed side effect is difficulty falling asleep or staying asleep. It is absurd and dangerous to recommend it as a sleeping pill.
    • Do-it-yourself sleep studies with camcorder — wakenings, breathing, etc. Note: No home studies can replace sleep lab studies, which should be done on anyone suspected of sleep apnea because it can lead to life-threatening complications.
Depression
Alternatives to SSRIs (which he calls SRI’s): B vitamins, correcting mineral deficiencies, discovering unrecognized toxicities like lead toxicity. Most laboratories measure statistical norms, others look at functional needs. Rather than measuring the amount of a mineral, he recommends measuring the function of enzymes that use the mineral. Treat hypothyroidism. He’s had hundreds of clients come to him with thyroid test results and only one was done right. Patient with low normal tests take thyroid and their energy goes up, their depression resolves, they start sleeping better, and they lose weight. Load with neurotransmitter precursors: 5-htp, DLPA. Shift estrogen dominance with iodine therapy to increase estriol which improves infections, etc. Measure estrogen levels in men. Add 5htp or tryptophan to SSRIs to prevent habituation. Note: This is all non-standard advice not supported by evidence. Depression is a potentially life-threatening condition (suicide), and unproven “alternatives” to effective treatment could be dangerous.
Milk is Bad
Raw milk has good fat structure that is destroyed by homogenization; homogenized milk causes irritation of the vascular system. Raw milk is “way better,” but in terms of allergy it may not be better at all. (He doesn’t mention that in terms of infection risk, it is much worse!) Casein, whey, galactose are the problems with milk. Low fat doesn’t help because milk solids are added and they cause cataracts. Milk causes osteoporosis and it causes an inflammatory response in 95% of blacks and 50% of whites. Milk is not a good source of calcium; grain is better. (But he tells us to avoid grain too!)
He recommends a test for milk allergy that is positively bizarre: go off all dairy (including eggs!?) for 2 weeks and then re-challenge with one drop of milk under the tongue. If a metronome synchronized to your body slows down, or if you freak out, or if your pulse rate goes up dramatically, you’re allergic to milk.
Or gullible. The test doesn’t discriminate.
Bread is Bad
Gluten is extremely difficult to digest and undigested gluten protein has an inflammatory effect that causes all kinds of degenerative problems and stress to your gut, and leads to heart disease and probably cancer as well. Corn and red meat are also difficult to digest. And yeast, because we don’t have good enzymes to digest the cell wall.
Avoid grain. Eat a Paleolithic diet (what we are best adapted to): unlimited greens, fruit, nuts, meat when you can kill it. If you have to eat gluten or dairy at Aunt Mildred’s house at Thanksgiving, take digestive enzymes with you to ease the burden.
Questionable Statements
    • Vaccines cause autism (false!)
    • There is a conspiracy to cover up information about natural treatments.
    • Doctors are ignorant.
    • Monitoring urinary pH is a reliable way to monitor acid/base balance and health (Not!)
    • “Subclinical hypothyroidism” is a common problem. (Here he doesn’t even get the terminology right. He attributes a variety of symptoms to a low level of hormone that doesn’t register on blood tests, whereas subclinical means abnormally low on blood tests without any symptoms.)
    • Estrogen/testosterone ratio is a risk.
    • Ketosis treats end-stage organ failure. (No, but ketosis is a result of end-stage kidney failure).
    • If you’re insulin resistant, depending on glucose for energy, your energy is sabotaged: your brain is living on 90 or 70 volts instead of 100 volts. Ketosis puts you back up to 100 volts.
    • Alcohol causes addiction through glucose addiction, serotonin addiction, and NADH addiction.
    • Hangovers can be reliably prevented or cured with vitamin C and cysteine.
    • Nutrasweet (aspartame) is an excitotoxin, an irritant to the brain, and can aggravate calcium toxicity in the brain.
    • He blames epigenetic effects of generations of poor nutrition as the reason that “There’s a lot of falling apart going on around us: autism is way up, brain cancer is way up.” (They aren’t way up; and besides, he already blamed autism on vaccines.)
    • Wheat has estrogens that make male animals infertile, for the buffalo.  (!? I’m guessing he meant that plants produce toxins to try to defend themselves against herbivores. I’m pretty sure the male buffalos didn’t go infertile from eating estrogens in wheat. And I think he meant bison.)
    • Mustards have mutagens (Did he confuse Grey Poupon with nitrogen mustard?)
    • Alfalfa sprouts have an ingredient that produces autoimmune disease in humans and chimpanzees. (In fact, alfalfa sprouts have been used to treat autoimmune disease.)
    • Plant toxins are not different from manmade ones, but we are adapted to eating phytotoxins. (If they’re not different, shouldn’t we be equally adapted to both?)
    • If you have residual effects from anesthesia, tell your doctor you need T3 monotherapy.
Some of these are clearly false, some need qualifying, some are speculations mixed with a grain of truth that I didn’t have the time or inclination to untangle.
“Myths to Live By”
He calls his dietary advice “myths to live by” and prefaces it by saying:
I’m not going to say this is all quite scientific, because on some level it’s based on prejudice, philosophy…
    • Low carb vegetables.
    • Eat meat (insects OK) to supply B12 (tiny to moderate amounts, maybe just the bugs in your grain as in India).
    • Cultivate ketosis (go in and out of ketosis weekly or monthly to exercise your metabolism).
    • Consume tropical oils.
    • Eat less carbs and calories than your peers.
    • Assume industry ads are lies.
    • Assume the food pyramid is upside down.
    • Assume your doctor is profoundly ignorant (doctors will never say “I don’t know” – they’ll just make it up).
    • Assume all experts are biased.
He recommends Gary Taubes’ book Good Calories, Bad Calories. He favors low-carb and Paleolithic diets.
Tests?
He recommends nonstandard and unreliable lab tests and do-it-yourself home trials.
    • Ask your doctor for RBC trace mineral profile (30-40 nutrients), normative blood vitamin levels, Spectrocell functional medicine test for nutrients, urine chelation challenge for heavy metals.
    • Try a nutrient and see if you notice a difference. (We all know how reliable “try-it-for-yourself” is!)
    • Cultivate computer games (Tetris, etc.) to measure small differences that you might not notice otherwise.
    • 1 week should be enough to see an effect of supplementing things like B12. (Not!)
He tells an anecdote about a patient who was supposedly almost killed by doctor who gave him potassium based on low blood levels even after the patient and his wife told him the patient was a potassium over-accumulator. The excess potassium needed to normalize his blood potassium test drove him into heart failure and even when he was on digoxin, the doctor wouldn’t admit that he was wrong. The patient had to leave AMA to save his life. Really? “Potassium over-accumulator” is not in my medical dictionary, and Googling for the phrase got only one hit: Fowkes’ video itself.
Bottom Line
I’ll be polite and simply say I do not consider Steven Fowkes to be a reliable source of health information. Some of his facts are wrong, his speculations have not been tested with clinical studies, and some of his advice is frankly dangerous.

Diet Recommendations Based on DNA
Diet recommendations based on DNA are not based on good science.
Harriet Hall on June 21, 2022
Links

When the human genome was first sequenced, some people optimistically assumed that we now knew (or soon would know) everything about human genetics and would be able to predict who would develop a disease and prescribe what each individual should do to ensure the best possible health. Those expectations did not pan out. Science is complicated.
Recently several companies have been offering to examine your genome and figure out what you should eat based on your DNA. GenoPalate is a typical one. It promises to tell you:
    • Your optimal macronutrient mix to set the foundation for a healthy diet
    • What amount of each micronutrient your body may benefit from the most
    • Which 100+ foods are the best match for your nutritional needs
    • how your body reacts to substances including alcohol, gluten, caffeine, lactose
    • How to make decisions at the grocery store, for instance whether to buy Brussels sprouts or broccoli
Under the “Our Science” tab they list 10 studies as examples of those they relied on to make their recommendations. That may look “sciency” and impressive at first glance, but most of the studies were inconclusive, preliminary, or not pertinent to the company’s claims. One thing glaringly missing is any study testing whether people who follow the company’s DNA-based diet recommendations are healthier in any way than people who follow standard evidence-based guidelines for a healthy diet.
When one woman’s DNA-based diet and exercise recommendations arrived, she was underwhelmed.
Even though they were ‘personalized’ based on her DNA, they seemed vague and not very actionable. For example, the assessment indicated a ‘high sensitivity’ to carbohydrates. ‘The genes in this panel impact the way you metabolize and assimilate refined carbohydrates, and the combined effect of your variants puts you with a slightly increased effect, meaning you are less well placed to deal with excess carbohydrate intake than most,’ her report read.According to researchers, there’s a reason why the ‘personalized’ DNA diet plans touted by these wellness companies are filled with generalized scientific jargon and loose recommendations that come with no promises: There’s just not enough evidence yet for truly personalized gene-based diet plans.
Some things to keep in mind:
    • The foods we eat are complex mixtures of ingredients.
    • Genetics is even more complicated.
    • Genes are influenced by other genes.
    • Genes can be turned on or off by other genes and environmental factors.
    • An association between a genetic variant and a disease in a population doesn’t mean an individual with that variant will get that disease.
    • DNA can be wrong; it may predict that a person with brown eyes should have blue eyes.
    • Different companies often provide different DNA-based diet recommendations.
    • Identical twins may have different responses to the same foods.
These companies are mixing half-baked insights from genetic research with standard nutrition and lifestyle guidelines that are available elsewhere for free. The companies charge anywhere from hundreds to thousands of dollars.
Conclusion: Not based on good science
Are you sick and tired of people who tell you what to do and what to eat? I know I am! They all disagree with each other and they don’t offer credible scientific evidence. As for me, I’ll continue to eat a variety of foods that taste good, and to follow the general advice of nutrition experts who agree with each other about the existing science.One of the first things I looked into, working with Stephen Barrett on Quackwatch, was dubious genetic testing. We quoted an expert whose words are just as true today as they were back in 2008:
For most people, tailoring your diet to your genetic make-up is about as scientific as tailoring your diet to your star sign.

Dietary Associations with Cardiovascular and Diabetic Mortality: “Bacon, soda, and too few nuts”?
A recent study attempted to quantify the association of ten dietary factors with deaths from cardiovascular disease and diabetes. Headlines about the study were misleading.
Harriet Hall on March 21, 2017
Link


I’ve been seeing differing headlines about a recent study:
    • MDLinx said, “Bacon, soda and too few nuts tied to big portion of US deaths.”
    • USNews said, “Poor Diet Tied to Half of U.S. Deaths from Heart Disease, Diabetes.”
    • Reuters said, “Poor diet tied to nearly half of U.S. deaths from heart disease, stroke, diabetes.”
Since they said different things, I had to wonder which headline was the most accurate, and the whole thing just didn’t sound quite right to me. It fits too neatly with the alternative medicine myth that if you just eat right, you won’t get sick. I could just see people reading those headlines and concluding “If I just stop the bacon and soda and eat more nuts, I’ll be half as likely to die.” I don’t question that diet plays an important role in health, but that role is frequently exaggerated by people with a “natural medicine” bias. The CDC has estimated that nearly half of US deaths could be prevented with lifestyle changes; but that includes not only healthy diet but also exercise, avoiding overweight, and avoiding tobacco and alcohol.
The study
I went to the source and read the study itself: “Association Between Dietary Factors and Mortality from Heart Disease, Stroke, and Type 2 Diabetes in the United States,” by Micha et al., published in JAMA on March 7, 2017. As it turned out, the Reuters headline was the most accurate.
Objective: To estimate associations of intake of 10 specific dietary factors with mortality due to heart disease, stroke, and type 2 diabetes (cardiometabolic mortality).
Methods: They used a comparative risk assessment model to evaluate previously published data. Data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) was based on 24-hour dietary recalls. Data on disease–specific mortality was taken from the National Center for Health Statistics, which covers the entire US population. They developed models that tried to compensate for potential confounders.
They studied fruits, vegetables, nuts/seeds, whole grains, unprocessed red meats, processed meats, sugar-sweetened beverages, polyunsaturated fats, seafood omega-3 fats, and sodium. They chose not to study several other dietary factors (monounsaturated fats, vitamin D, magnesium, calcium, antioxidant vitamins, dairy products, cocoa, coffee, and tea) because of insufficient evidence for a causal relationship. They looked only at cardiometabolic conditions, not at other conditions like cancer, osteoporosis, gallstones, inflammatory diseases, depression, cognitive function, or micronutrient deficiencies.
Findings:
    • High sodium intake (> 2000 mg/d) was linked to 9.5% of cardiometabolic deaths
    • Low nuts/seeds (<20.2 g/d) to 8.5%
    • High processed meats (>0 g/d) to 8.2%
    • Low seafood omega-3 fats (<250 mg/d) to 7.8%
    • Low vegetables (<400 g/d) to 7.6%
    • Low fruits (<300 g/d) to 7.5%
    • High sugar-sweetened beverages (>0 g/d) to 7.4%
    • Low whole grains (<125 g/d) to around 6% (not specified in text; I estimated from graph)
    • Low polyunsaturated fats (<11% energy/d) to 2.3%
    • High unprocessed red meats (>14.3 g/d) to 0.4%
    • Taken together, non-optimal intakes of these 10 dietary factors were associated with 45.4% of all cardiometabolic deaths.
They did some subgroup analyses for individual diseases, age, sex, education, and race/ethnicity; and they looked for trends between 2002 and 2012. They found a larger diet-related proportional mortality for men than for women, for younger than older ages, for blacks and Hispanics than whites, and for those with low and medium education than for those with high education. Between 2002 and 2012 they found several improvements but these were not uniform.
In the Discussion section, they pointed out some of the strengths and weaknesses of their study and stressed that their model does not prove that changes in these dietary habits reduce disease risk and that model estimates do not make assumptions about the feasibility of society-wide interventions to improve diet.
Editorial comment
In an accompanying editorial, Noel T. Mueller, PhD, MPH, and Lawrence J. Appel, MD, MPH pointed out that in attributing death to diet, precision counts. They say:
It is generally accepted that a sub- optimal diet is causally related to CMD, but scientists debate which factors are responsible and the relative importance of each factor given the challenges of isolating and estimating the potential effects of individual nutrients and foods, especially in observational studies.
They have three caveats:
     1.  Evidence from observational studies is subject to pitfalls and confounders.
     2.  We don’t know whether the 10 selected factors comprise the right set.
     3.  Dietary factors are interrelated and modified by each other.
They say: “Despite these limitations and concerns, the study by Micha et al is quite relevant to public health nutrition policy, a critically important issue both in the United States and around the world.” Whatever the actual numbers, they undeniably showed that better diet quality (with reference to the 10 items studied) is associated with fewer cardiometabolic deaths. What they did not show was that you could take people with poor diet quality and reduce their death rate by improving the quality of their diet. It might seem intuitively obvious that that would work, but even the most compelling assumptions can be wrong. The history of science has taught us not to assume but to test. Hypotheses about interventions remain to be tested, and will require further studies.
Conclusion: nothing really new
The study’s findings are interesting and contribute to our understanding of relative risks, but there are really no big surprises here. We already knew a healthy diet was beneficial, not just for cardiometabolic disease but for cancer and other conditions; and we have a pretty good idea what constitutes a healthy diet. Evidence from various sources is converging on the consensus that fruits, vegetables, whole grains, nuts/seeds, and omega-3s from seafood are good for us and that sugar-sweetened beverages, processed meats, and salt are not.
Opinion: everything in moderation
I found it interesting that the weakest association was with unprocessed red meats. That confirms my opinion that small amounts of red meat (for instance, the occasional steak or hamburger) can be part of a healthy diet. For that matter, if you eat a lot of fruits, vegetables, nuts, whole grains and salmon, you can probably feel free to indulge in bacon on occasion without worrying that it will kill you. We have enough to worry about without denying ourselves the pleasures of the foods we love. The goal of living longer should be put into context with the goal of enjoying life.

The NORI protocol: An unproven fruit-based nutritional treatment for cancer sold by a self-proclaimed “expert”
Mark Simon is the founder of the Nutritional Oncology Research Institute. He doesn’t have an MD, DO, nor PhD. (He doesn’t even have an ND!) Yet he claims to have discovered a dietary protocol that can cure cancer. Can it? (I think you know the answer to this question.)
David Gorski on May 13, 2019
Link

I’ve been blogging for Science-Based Medicine for over eleven years now, and, before that, I had my personal blog, affectionately and sarcastically known here as my not-so-super-secret other blog (NSSSOB), which has been around more than fourteen years. So you’d think (or at least I do much of the time) that over all those years I’ve covered pretty much every form of dubious cancer treatment there is, either here on SBM or on my NSSSOB. Sadly, every so often reality disabuses me of this notion. Over the weekend, I was perusing what I like to call my Folder of Woo, basically a folder of links to potential blogging topics, when I noticed something called the NORI Protocol. I forgot when I had come across it the first time, but obviously I had meant to write about it sometime or another. After all, it was in my Folder of Woo! Given how much I write, though, I couldn’t remember if I had ever covered it. A quick search of both my blogs disabused me of this notion. There was one hit on my NSSSOB, but only because someone mentioned the NORI Protocol in the comments. Damn, I thought. How could I have failed to write about this one, given that it shows up all over the place?
So it’s time to take a more in-depth look at the NORI Protocol.
NORI Protocol: Red flags for quackery galore
So what is the NORI Protocol? Basically, it’s a high-fruit diet coupled with selenium supplementation. It helps to know what “NORI” stands for: the Nutritional Oncology Research Institute, home of the NORI Protocol. If you visit the website, the main page of NORI regales visitors with this description of the “institute”:
NORI is an independent research organization that has developed non-conventional methods for cancer treatment that do not rely on toxic drugs, surgery, or radiation. Cancer patients who choose to avoid conventional therapies or who have exhausted all other options may wish to explore this revolutionary and unique approach to cancer treatment and management offered exclusively by NORI. The NORI program is designed to be the most cost-effective alternative cancer treatment available. NORI represents the future in treating cancer in a safely and holistically, in the most health-promoting, effective, and scientifically sound manner possible.
So. Many. Red. Flags. And all of them right on the entry page. There’s the quack trope about cancer treatment that “does not rely on toxid drugs, surgery, or radiation.” There’s the statement about using this treatment instead of conventional therapies. There’s the claim that NORI is the “future of treating cancer in a safely and holistically, in the most health-promoting, effective, and scientifically sound manner possible,” whatever that means.
Then there’s this:
NORI is an organization focused on research and development of nutritionally based, nontoxic, drug-free cancer treatment methods. NORI has created a unique treatment protocol that may be utilized along with conventional therapies, or utilized alone for the treatment of nearly any form and stage of cancer. The NORI protocol is based on a specialized plant-based diet as a foundation while administering safe and effective natural compounds that selectively kill cancer cells. The NORI protocol has been proven effective for a wide array of cancers at all stages.
I love it when alternative medicine sellers claim that their treatment has been “proven effective for a wide array of cancers at all stages”. Whenever I see that, I ask: Where’s the beef? Where’s the science? Where are the randomized controlled clinical trials? As you will soon see, there is, to put it kindly, a paucity of these things supporting the NORI Protocol, although if you look at NORI’s page on its protocol, you’ll see lots of cherry picked studies, most in vitro, with only a phase I and phase II trial, the latter of which was not randomized. (Phase I trials by definition are not randomized.) You’ll also see lots of testimonials. I’ll discuss these later, with one exception – this testimonial from Amy H. in Los Angeles:
I was diagnosed with DCIS, stage 0, breast cancer in January of 2014. A surgeon wanted to give me a mastectomy and flap, and felt no other way would ensure my survival, or an attractive appearance. Shell shocked, I chose to treat it with a Naturopath, who guided me to healthier living on all levels. While I felt the results of that, I had developed a growth. I was told that it was a biopsy scar, but in late 2016 it grew significantly. I suspected it was not scar but tumor and started researching more about cancer, which made me doubt the effectiveness of what I was doing to heal. Sure enough, I went for an ultrasound and was told I had stage 4 breast cancer. Through a series of events I was told about the NORI Protocol and put into contact with Mark Simon. He presented what sounded to me like a very clear understanding of cancer and how to treat it. I had been facing unavailable doctors and practitioners, and he was available and supportive, and put me on a path that honored my instincts, calmed my fears, and made me feel like an active participant in my healing. While new to the protocol, I feel hopeful and aptly guided.
This testimonial is horrifying on so many levels, and I can’t believe that any hawker of an alternative dietary cure for cancer would include a testimonial like this. Those of you who’ve read SBM for a long time know that I’ve often questioned whether we overdiagnose and overtreat DCIS. However, that doesn’t mean that DCIS is benign, only that, because we don’t know which DCIS lesions will go on to turn into invasive cancer, we feel obligated to treat them all. However, as a breast surgeon, I can read between the lines here. If the surgeon seeing Amy H. recommended a mastectomy, that means that the DCIS took up so much of the breast that breast-conserving surgery was not possible. That’s high-risk DCIS. It’s therefore not surprising that Amy’s DCIS progressed to invasive cancer. As for having stage 4 cancer, it’s not clear to me how that could be diagnosed with just an ultrasound, unless maybe she had metastases in her liver that could be evaluated by ultrasound. Be that as it may, this testimonial shows a woman with high risk DCIS refusing standard-of-care treatment, seeing her cancer progress under the care of a naturopathic quack (even watching a mass grow and attributing it to scar tissue from her previous biopsy!), and then choosing another dubious treatment, with no outcome other than “hope” and being “aptly” guided being listed.
Time to discuss the NORI approach in more detail. First, let’s look at its creator, Mark Simon. Then we’ll look at the protocol itself, which involves a high fruit diet to “starve” cancer cells of the amino acid methionine, which, it is claims, sensitizes cells to selenium. Of course, it can’t be just any selenium. It has to be a special form of selenium. Nothing else will work.
Mark Simon: Developer of the NORI Protocol
Perhaps the best introduction I could find to Mark Simon is this 2015 interview with Chris Wark of Chris Beat Cancer fame. As I’ve described, Mr. Wark has the typical anecdote in which he misattributes his cure to the wrong treatment. Basically, he had stage 3 colon cancer, underwent surgery, but refused the recommended standard-of-care chemotherapy afterward. As is all too often the case, he sought out all manner of quackery, and when he did well he attributed his good outcome to the quackery, not to the surgery that removed his cancer. Now he runs a website and an alternative cancer cure Internet business in which he sells books and “coaching”, and uses all manner of dubious testimonials to hawk his wares. It’s a perfect match.
We learn from this interview that Mark Simon that he had been interested in alternative medicine for a long time, but details on his actual professional background are maddeningly vague. We’re told that he has a background in neuroscience and biomedical engineering, which is nice, but finding out what that background actually is wasn’t too easy. It took a fair amount of Googling to lead me to pages like this one, where I learned that Simon’s credentials include being a “health coach” and having a Clinical Nutrition Certificate from Natural Healing Institute. His LinkedIn profile only shows his positions at NORI dating back to 2011, when he founded NORI. Elsewhere, on Facebook Gene Fuss posted on The Truth About Cancer page that Simon “is trained in Neuroscience and Biomedical Engineering and nutrition, and has been a vegan for 32 years,” while attributing to him “DEEP knowledge about the biology of cancer tumors, more so than anybody I have encountered to date.”
If the claims made in the video above, and this video below about the NORI Protocol are any indication, I would be willing to contest the claim that Mark Simon has anything resembling “deep knowledge” about anything having to do with cancer or nutrition.
It doesn’t take too much knowledge to realize that the scientific claims in both videos and the NORI Protocol website are, at best, rather fishy and, at worst, downright quacky. As for Simon’s background, if he’s such an expert in neuroscience and biomedical engineering, why doesn’t he trumpet that background by including his degrees and what he did? He clearly doesn’t have an MD, PhD, or even an ND (the naturopath’s degree that I like to call “Not-a-Doctor”), and you know that if he had any of those degrees he’d include them, in his bio. Instead, he’s maddeningly vague. My guess is that he got an undergraduate or master’s degree in some science-related field and/or worked as a technician in a neuroscience and/or biomedical engineering lab somewhere. Simon can, of course, prove me wrong by listing his degrees and his pre-2011 employment history somewhere prominent.
On to Simon’s protocol!
NORI Protocol: Methionine deprivation and selenium cure cancer!
In both videos above, we learn that Mark Simon was inspired by the work of someone named Dr. Daniel Epner, a faculty member at Baylor College of Medicine, who published an article on methionine deprivation in 2001. It was this article that inspired Mark Simon to look into methionine restriction as a treatment for cancer. A PubMed search reveals 36 articles from Daniel E. Epner, 41 if you leave out his middle initial. The last article Dr. Epner wrote about methionine and cancer dates back to 2003. It’s a study that found that methionine restriction targets synthesis of thymidylate synthase, an enzyme that plays a crucial role in the early stages of DNA biosynthesis. His article is interesting, because it summarizes the studies in cell culture and animals showing that methionine restriction can have antitumor effects in a number of cancer cell lines and animal models. Of course, we all know how hard it is to translate such findings to humans, and Dr. Epner notes that a phase I trial had been carried out to show that methionine restriction plus chemotherapy was achievable and safe.
Interestingly, Dr. Epner does not practice medical oncology any more. He’s moved from Baylor to M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, whose website states:
Dr. Epner is a palliative care physician at MD Anderson Cancer Center who practiced medical oncology for several years before moving to the Department of Palliative Care in 2012. He began his faculty career at Baylor College of Medicine as principal investigator of a basic science lab, but he now focuses on psychosocial aspects of oncology. His primary academic interest is communication skills training for medical oncology fellows, palliative care fellows, and a variety of other providers.
Interesting career trajectory.
So, basically, with Mark Simon, we appear to have an overenthusiastic evangelist glomming on to one interesting finding with respect to cancer cells and running straight off the cliff with it, as you can see by the claims made by Simon for his NORI Protocol. Basically, these claims involve massive oversimplifications of the science and as yet unproven (and therefore unjustified) extrapolation from cell culture and animal studies to humans, with none of the valid research being done by Simon himself, just cherry-picked from the literature and based on nonsense like this:
There are two types of DNA in human cells, nuclear and mitochondrial. Cancer appears to be the result of damage to mitochondrial DNA while nuclear DNA damage is “after the fact”. Mitochondrial damage prevents the normal process called apoptosis or natural programmed cell death which shuts down the cell so that it does not continue to divide without end. Cancer is the same condition regardless of the site or organ of origin. Cancer is not 200 different diseases. It is a process defined by common metabolic abnormalities within malignant cells that can be effectively exploited without toxic drugs. It is generally the side effects of conventional therapies that take a cancer patient’s life, not cancer itself.
Whenever you see someone say that it is the toxicities of conventional therapies that kill most cancer patients, it’s 99.99% likely (at least) that you’re dealing with a quack. Also, yes, there is a metabolic component to cancer. Cancer cells, in addition to having their genomes messed up badly, also have messed up metabolic pathways. (I do so love using scientific terms.) That does not mean that cancer is all one disease, nor does it mean that the mutations driving cancer are unimportant.
Then the NORI website claims:
The key difference between the NORI approach and other nutritionally based cancer treatments is that NORI attempts to limit the availability of essential nutrients necessary to cancer cell survival while supplying adequate nutrients to healthy cells. The NORI approach to cancer nutrition is not designed to build or enhance the immune system. Cancer cells, like normal cells, have built-in means of defense against immune system attack, what separates conventional from most alternative cancer therapies is selectivity, meaning that conventional treatments destroy healthy cells while alternative therapies attempt to spare them.
Well, that’s a new one, an alternative therapy that doesn’t claim to “boost the immune system”!
The idea behind the NORI Protocol is this. Because many cancer cells are sensitive to methionine restriction, first you restrict methionine using a fruit-heavy diet. (Fruit doesn’t contain much methionine.) The length of time for this diet is “individualized”, of course. Also of course, he declines to discuss what criteria are used to determine the length of time recommended for each patient, just this:
Methionine restriction is individualized for each patient according to weight, nutritional status, disease progression and past dietary preferences. A methionine restricted diet may be continuous or cycled on and off depending on individual circumstances. Methionine restriction involves the elimination of many foods and a focus on mostly fruits. The natural sugars in fruits will not feed cancer cells or cause tumors to grow. It is a common misconception that fruit equals sugar and that fruits raise blood sugar. Fruit can be a problem if there is a high fat intake (greater than 10% of total caloric intake) which will cause insulin resistance.
That’s nice. Give me the protocol and the evidence base behind its specifics.
I’m particularly amused at how Simon gets past the “sugar feeds cancer” woo by claiming that the “natural” sugars in fruits don’t feed cancer unless you also eat a lot of fat and develop insulin resistance; so, yes, his NORI Protocol involves low fat diets as well. It’s also rather interesting that Simon focuses on fruits so much, given that vegetables are also low in methionine. Also problematic is the observation that normal cells need methionine too, as it’s an essential amino acid that the body can’t synthesize, which means that methionine can’t be eliminated from the diet entirely.
The next step after the methionine restriction, the patient can then eat a high methionine diet. The idea is that the methionine restriction will cause the cancer cells to stop growing, to arrest their cell cycle, and then adding methionine back, which supposedly causes them, to grow again and undergo apoptosis (programmed cell death). Layered on to this core idea is the claim that methionine restriction sensitizes the cancer cells to selenium, as well as the claim that the digestive enzymes in fruits also combat cancer.
If you look at the full NORI Protocol list of “chemotherapeutic agents,” you’ll find sodium selenite, selenomethionine, vitamin K3, shikonin (derived from the bark of the Gromwell root), vitamin E succinate, pine bark and grape seed extract, green tea extract, and a number of others. Basically, if you listen to Simon in his video above and read all the scientific claims on the NORI protocol website, what you’ll hear and see is what I like to refer to as “woo babble,” which is basically like Star Trek technobabble, only with woo.
But is there any evidence that methionine restriction combats cancer in actual humans? The answer is: Not a lot. If you look at recent review articles (e.g., this one, this one, and this one) about methionine restriction and cancer, you’ll find that, 18 years later, scientists are still working on it, and there is a huge paucity of clinical data supporting methionine restriction as a treatment for cancer. You’ll also learn that there’s evidence that methionine restriction could extend lifespan. You’ll also see authors recommending clinical trials, which appear not to have been done yet. You’ll also learn that there is a compound, methioninase, which breaks down methionine and can be used to restrict methionine. There’s evidence from patient-derived xenografts (tumors from humans clinical specimens grown in mice), but again little in the way of clinical evidence.
To Simon, however, the reason is obvious:
Why are alternative treatments like the NORI protocol not practiced by oncologists and researched through clinical trials? The answer is simple economics and excessive control by the pharmaceutical industry. Money and profits has become the primary driver in medical science in general. Medical science must serve all of us rather than the bottom line of multi-national corporations. NORI is a grassroots alternative cancer research institute that is carving out a path towards medical sanity within oncology.
It couldn’t possibly be because doing dietary studies of this sort of treatment is very difficult, could it? Oh, no! It has to be the big pharma conspiracy. So that’s why NORI sells a line of nutraceuticals, including—of course!—CBD oil. Not surprisingly, the protocol itself contains a disclaimer:
All statements regarding NORI nutraceuticals have not been evaluated by the United States Food and Drug Administration. NORI nutraceuticals are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. NORI nutraceuticals are provided as a component of a nutritional support program and are not intended as a substitute for conventional medical care.
Yep, it’s a quack Miranda warning! As is the case with so much cancer quackery, Simon has taken interesting scientific observations that aren’t ready for prime time yet and extrapolated mightily with them.
Testimonials galore!
So if all the science Mark Simon has is cherry picked science, does he have anything else? Like all good alternative cancer treatment advocates, he has testimonials! The most famous NORI protocol testimonial comes from Candice-Marie Fox, who claims to have cured her thyroid cancer using the NORI protocol:
We learn that Ms. Fox was diagnosed with thyroid cancer a few days before her 28th birthday in 2011. She claims it was stage III. Doing a bit of Googling reveals several things. First, she had papillary thyroid cancer, which is the most common and most treatable form of thyroid cancer. Indeed, there is controversy over whether papillary thyroid cancer always requires treatment given how much of it is overdiagnosed by ultrasound. (I doubt that applies here, because Ms. Fox states that she had a lump in her neck.) Also, there is no such thing as stage III papillary thyroid cancer in a 28 year old. If you look at the staging for this cancer, the highest stage a 28 year old can be is stage II, even with distant metastases. The survival rates are very high as well, with near 100% 5-year survival for localized and regional disease and 78% for even distant disease.
Also, Ms. Fox underwent standard-of-care surgery, a total thyroidectomy and what sounds like a central neck lymph node dissection, for the tumor. So at around the two minute mark, when she claimed that the cancer came back and had metastasized to her lungs, lymph nodes of the neck, and elsewhere. According to her, the doctors told her to come back in 6-9 months for more radiation and, if that doesn’t work, chemotherapy. That, too, caused my skeptical antennae to start twitching, because although radioactive iodine is used for metastatic papillary thyroid cancer, chemotherapy is not.
I’m not the only one who noticed holes in Ms. Fox’s story. Auma, a self-described “evil troll, Big Pharma employee and government spy,” noticed a lot of issues. Based on these articles and her own writing on Facebook, there are several impossible or misleading claims about her diagnosis and “natural cure”.
     1.  Having cancer spread to liver. After those pesky cancer surviving trolls started asking her questions on Facebook, she admitted liver tumors referenced in Daily Mail were benign.
     2.  Being stage IV. A few days back she claimed on FB that she had never called herself stage IV. How did the journalists get the idea of stage IV (in one article – grade IV) cancer then? Also, papillary thyroid cancer in people younger than 45 can only be stage I or II and 5 year survival is almost 100%.
     3.  Mark Simon being an oncologist instead of a quack nutritionist without a medical degree. This she also later admitted on FB and Daily Mail actually made a correction.
     4.  Rejecting chemo – in different sources Candice mentions having rejected radioactive therapy or chemotherapy. This sounds strange, because chemotherapy usually is not the first line of treatment for papillary thyroid cancer, but she makes it sound like she was certainly offered to do chemo and absolutely rejected it.
     5.  The biggest claim of them all is her terminal diagnosis and being given 5 years to live. I am not sure if she actually believes that herself or exaggerated her claims to get attention and embellish her money-earning cancer story. This is what I want to explore the most. Please keep in mind that I am not a doctor, just a patient myself who remembers the process of treatment well. If a medical specialist reads this, please add your perspective. Also, because I am not from an English speaking country, I constantly call thyroglobulin TGB, because that is how we abbreviate it. In English documentation it is usually abbreviated as Tg.
Auma also took a bunch of screenshots of Ms. Fox’s Facebook page contemporaneous with her actual treatments that show she left out a lot of stuff. It’s worth reading both posts, as long as they are, because of the level of detail. The bottom line is that Ms. Fox was cured by conventional therapy, not the NORI Protocol, but attributes her “cure” to her dietary intervention.
But what about the other testimonials? Most of them are similar in that it’s clear that the conventional treatment was what cured the cancer. There are patients with colorectal cancer who underwent surgery but turned down chemotherapy (like Chris Wark). There’s someone with recurrent Hodgkin’s lymphoma who underwent chemotherapy and the NORI protocol but attributes the good outcome to NORI. There are a couple of prostate cancer testimonials that aren’t particularly convincing because of the highly variable and often indolent courses that prostate cancer can take. There was another one of metastatic pancreatic cancer that regressed with the NORI protocol—and, of course, chemotherapy. Particularly distressing is that the man and his wife totally attribute the man’s good outcome to the NORI protocol. I wonder if they’ll blame it when the pancreatic cancer recurs, which it almost certainly will if it truly is pancreatic adenocarcinoma.
NORI Protocol: An idea oversold
If there’s one common theme in cancer quackery, it’s the co-optation of preclinical science (i.e., science that hasn’t been tested in clinical trials yet) or inadequately tested clinical science, and running with it. In other words, this sort of quackery involves taking the gray areas of science and unjustifiably eliminating the gray in order to sell a treatment. Will the NORI protocol hurt cancer patients? Probably not, but it’s hard to tell. Nutritional manipulations are not without risk. Will it treat their cancer? Based on my reading of the literature, who knows? It’s unproven, and the track record of translating cell culture and rodent studies into treatments is littered with the wreckage of promising-sounding ideas.
In this case, the gray area is methionine restriction as a treatment for cancer. It’s a dietary intervention that shows promise based on preclinical studies in cell culture and in rodent models but as yet has not been convincingly demonstrated to work in humans. Might methionine restriction have a role in treating human cancer? Possibly. One thing I can say for sure, though, is that, if methionine restriction is ever validated in randomized controlled clinical trials as an approach to improving the efficacy of chemotherapy, the science-derived protocol will almost certainly look little like what Mark Simon’s quackery-derived NORI protocol. Simon has both oversimplified the science (e.g., his claim that cancer is a single metabolic disease) while adding unnecessary complexity to the protocol (e.g., selenium and all the additional supplements, the mystical “individualization” of methionine restriction) to produce a protocol that is being massively oversold to desperate patients with cancer.
No wonder naturopaths love it so much.

Death as a Foodborne Illness Curable by Veganism
Can you cure death through a vegan diet? Of course not. But some people claim you can.
Harriet Hall on February 12, 2013
Link

Most reputable sources of nutrition information recommend a diet high in fruits and vegetables and low in red meat. Vegans go much further. Strict vegans reject all animal products including fish, eggs, and milk. Some vegans come across like religious zealots. Here are some comments recently posted by vegans on Facebook:
    • Right now the biggest social issue facing the world is the violence and suffering of animals.
    • The dairy industry is the number one feminist issue facing our modern society.
    • I expect within a generation that milk will be viewed as the most unhealthy habit after cigarettes. I bet it is responsible for more disease than anything else in the US. Dairy products promote all stages of cancer. [In fact, low fat dairy can be protective against some types of cancer]
    • Milk contains blood and puss[sic]
    • Humans are not omnivores; they are herbivores. [Most biologists would disagree.]
I was even told that that anyone who really cares about the welfare of others must promote veganism. It seems I am an evil, uncaring person if I waste my time writing about any other subject.
Vegans offer some good arguments based on ethics, environmental protection, cruelty to animals, and sustainability. I won’t get into those issues here. I’ll only address the scientific evidence behind the health claims. How does this description of a video strike you?:
Death in America is largely a foodborne illness. Focusing on studies published just over the last year in peer-reviewed scientific medical journals, [Hardly any of the studies he cites were published over the last year.] Michael Greger, M.D., offers practical advice on how best to feed ourselves and our families to prevent, treat, and even reverse many of the top 15 killers in the United States.[emphasis added]
That video was recommended to me by a vegan activist. I dipped into it randomly and noticed statements that I knew were not true, at least not as stated without any qualifications. I prefer to get my information from the medical literature rather than from videos. But I was eventually browbeaten into watching the whole thing when the activist impugned my objectivity and my ethics.
“If only you would watch this video”
I hear that all the time from people who have been overwhelmed by the information presented in a video that supports their beliefs. They assume that the evidence presented is incontrovertible, and that anyone who agreed to watch it would necessarily be converted to their beliefs. These videos tend to fall into an easily recognizable pattern. They feature a charismatic scientist with an agenda who makes sweeping statements that go beyond the evidence, makes unwarranted assumptions about the meaning of studies, and omits any reference to contradictory evidence. I recognized this pattern by briefly sampling the video, and my initial opinion was only confirmed by watching it in toto.
The leading causes of death
He starts with a table showing the leading causes of death and goes through them one by one, presenting his evidence that a diet devoid of animal-based foods can prevent and cure each of them.
To evaluate the accuracy of his information, let’s ask:
    • What exactly is he claiming?
    • What references does he supply in support of that claim?
    • Do those reference really say what he says they say?
    • Have those studies been replicated?
    • How good was the methodology of those studies?
    • Are there other studies that came to different conclusions?
    • Is there any good evidence comparing total avoidance of animal-based foods and a diet that is mainly plant-based but includes small amounts of animal products?
Cardiovascular disease (CVD)
He cites a reference showing that “a plant-based diet of primarily whole grains, fruits, vegetables, and legumes can completely prevent heart attacks.” This is a quotation from an article in the Food and Drug Law Journal, and the footnotes there only send us to Caldwell Esselstyn’s flawed research. Esselstyn studied only a small number of patients who already had heart disease, and he treated them with statin drugs in addition to diet, and their diet included skim milk and low-fat yogurt. You can read my criticism of his research here. It is ludicrous to interpret that research as showing that a plant-based diet can completely prevent heart attacks. A more accurate interpretation is that patients (only a few patients in one study) who had already had a heart attack did not have a second heart attack while being treated with cholesterol-lowering medications and a diet that was largely plant-based but also included foods derived from animals.
Cancer
That same article claims that up to 75% of cancers can be prevented, but the supporting reference indicate smoking accounts for 30% of cancers and diet alone might prevent somewhere between 20-42% of all cancers, and as little as 10% of certain individual types of cancer. It points out that “making quantitative estimates at this time is treacherous, as the available evidence can only be interpreted roughly,” because of confounders like exercise, methodological difficulties, and the need to rely on unreliable memory for recall of intake. They conclude that “one can sensibly recommend an abundant consumption of fruits and vegetables and low intake of red meat.” This supports mainstream nutrition advice, not veganism.
Inflammation
He cites a study showing that a single meal high in animal fat can paralyze our arteries and “cripple” them. This was a small study of 10 volunteers with no control group. It measured flow-dependent vasoactivity. It’s not clear what that means, but surely it’s an exaggeration to say that the arteries were paralyzed or crippled. It would be interesting to compare the results to those of vegans who ate a meal with an equal number of calories. And what we really want to know is whether the observed changes have any practical clinical significance.
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD)
COPD “can be prevented and even treated with a plant-based diet.” He relies on a study that measured exhaled NO as a marker for inflammation, showing that it increases after a high fat meal. He describes it as causing internal damage. The study’s conclusion was “This suggests that a high fat diet may contribute to chronic inflammatory disease of the airway and lungs.” But this study showed no association between airway inflammation as measured by exhaled nitric oxide and systemic inflammation as measured either by CRP or fibrinogen. And it said nothing specifically about COPD or about the effect of removing animal foods from the diet.
Alzheimers
“We’ve known for 20 years that those who eat meat are 2-3 times as likely to become demented as vegetarians.” This claim is based on an old Adventist health study that has not been replicated. It studied two groups: matched and unmatched subjects. The data he cites are from the matched group. There was no difference in incidence of dementia between meat eaters and vegetarians in the unmatched study. Adventists are lacto-ovo-vegetarians who eat milk and eggs. And they are also a rather unique group with other healthy lifestyle practices. So it is disingenuous to claim this study as definitive evidence for veganism.
He neglects to tell us about studies that got different results, like the one showing that fish consumption reduces the risk of Alzheimer’s.
What is his evidence that Alzheimer’s can be treated with a plant-based diet? He offers a phase II study from Iran that compared saffron extract to a low dose of a drug that has only a small clinical benefit. The authors only claim it provides “preliminary evidence of a possible therapeutic effect of saffron.” Not very convincing, and certainly not evidence that a plant-based diet can treat Alzheimer’s. Saffron extract was being studied here as an herbal medicine, not as a food.
Kidney failure
Can kidney failure be prevented and treated with a plant-based diet? He points to a study showing that diets lower in red meat and animal fat may decrease the risk of microalbuminuria. It also showed a reduced risk with low fat dairy!
Other claims
He cites a study concluding “Our results suggest that a decrease in meat consumption may improve weight management.” Suggest, may, decrease. Not veganism.
He compares raw meat to hand grenades, because of bacterial contamination. If you don’t handle them safely, it’s like pulling the pin. Are we selling hand grenades in grocery stores? This is a ridiculous comparison, and it ignores the fact that plant-based foods can be a source of contamination too.
Flu: kale stimulates the immune system.
Eating just a few fruits and veg can improve the body’s ability to fight off pneumonia.
Suicide prevention? Restriction of meat fish and poultry improves mood.
I’m bored, and I’m sure you are too. There is more, much more. But I have made my point.
What Do Other Studies Show about the Benefits and Risks of Veganism?
This study showed mortality from ischemic heart disease was 26% lower in vegans and 34% lower in lacto-ovo-vegetarians (in other words, it’s better not to eliminate milk and eggs). “There were no significant differences between vegetarians and nonvegetarians in mortality from cerebrovascular disease, stomach cancer, colorectal cancer, lung cancer, breast cancer, prostate cancer, or all other causes combined.”
Another study showed that the healthiest people in Europe, the inhabitants of Iceland, Switzerland, and Scandinavia, consume large amounts of animal foods.
This study found no significant differences in mortality between vegetarians and nonvegetarians.
There are risks. A vegan diet can lead to deficiencies in various nutrients: vitamin B12, vitamin D, calcium, iodine, iron and omega-3 fatty acids. Careful planning can help avoid that; but anecdotally, the vegan who recommended the video to me recently found out he was deficient in B12 despite supplementation.
Confounders
The elephant in the room is weight loss. Vegans weigh less than meat eaters, and many of the benefts claimed could be consequences of weight loss, particularly in diabetes. And they could be a consequence of eating more fruits and vegetables, rather than avoiding meat and milk.
The data he finds most convincing are from the 7th Day Adventist study. One of his tables shows reduction in blood pressure and diabetes that are right in line with decrease in body mass index (BMI). This contradicts other data that supposedly removed BMI as a confounder. Adventists are a select group with other healthy lifestyle behaviors. Until we have confirmatory data from other studies in a general population, I don’t think it is wise to hang our hat on these decades-old Adventist studies.
Can diabetes be cured?
He says it can be cured by a plant-based diet, but the general consensus of medical experts is that diabetes can’t be “cured.” Diabetes can be treated and controlled with diet, weight loss, medication, obesity surgery, and even islet cell transplants. The symptoms subside, the blood sugar normalizes, and some patients no longer need their medication after they lose weight and make other lifestyle changes. But we don’t consider it “cured.” If you’re going to say diet “cures” diabetes, it would only be fair to say medication also “cures” it. It’s better to think of it not as cured but as controlled and requiring continuing attention.
Other diet beliefs
Surprise, surprise! Not everyone agrees that the vegan diet is best. Gary Taubes has written a book (with far more references than this video) advocating a low-carb diet. William Davis, the “Wheat Belly” doctor, tells us we must avoid a whole category of plant-based foods. He says meat is OK but wheat is addictive. The pH balance contingent tells us it is the acid in the food that is important, not whether the food comes from a plant or animal. The lacto-ovo-vegetarians don’t eat meat, but have no objection to eggs and milk. The paleo diet accepts meat, as does the Bible diet. Fruitarians reject animal products and also all vegetables and grains; they can be considered an even more restrictive form of vegans. Some of these diet beliefs are based mainly on ideology, but most of them claim to be based on solid science. There is only one science. If the evidence were really so clear-cut in favor of veganism, we wouldn’t have all these differing approaches.
What about the Eskimos?
Some people eat meat almost exclusively and seem to thrive on it. All the nutrients the human body requires are found in meat, even vitamin C when the meat is eaten raw.
Vegans tell us the Inuit, who lived almost exclusively on food of animal origin, had a short life span. That’s not true. Statistics on the Inuit between 1822 and 1836 showed that their average life expectancy was about the same as that of European peasants of the time who ate a diet overwhelmingly based on bread. 25% of Inuit lived past 60, and some lived into their 80s and 90s.
The Inuit ate meat out of necessity. It was all they could get for most of the year. Their diet was very high in fat. If it had not been, they could not have survived in one of the coldest, most barren, most hostile environments anywhere on Earth. Even today, it would not be wise for people living in the Arctic to try to follow a vegan diet.
Blubber is a staple of the Inuit diet, and it contains large amounts of antioxidants. Atherosclerosis is practically unknown in Greenland. In Uummannaq, Greenland, a population of 3000 residents had no deaths due to CVD in the 1970s. And the average 70 year old Inuit with a traditional diet of whale and seal has arteries as elastic as that of a 20-year old Danish resident. Why didn’t Dr. Greger mention that research? I think I can guess why.
Veganism prevents harm to animals
That sounds like a slam-dunk, but it’s more complicated. Some people think veganism is not really the lifestyle of least harm to animals.
Conclusion
The video confirmed what I already knew from evaluating the published evidence: it is healthier to eat more plant-based foods and less red meat. It didn’t convince me that we should categorically eliminate all animal products. The vegan diet can be a healthy one, and I wouldn’t discourage anyone from following it; but the evidence for health benefits is nowhere near as impressive or definitive as the true believers think. Death is not “a foodborne illness” and eliminating all animal products is not a cure-all.
As Ben Goldacre said in Bad Science:
The most important take-home message with diet and health is that anyone who ever expresses anything with certainty is basically wrong, because the evidence for cause and effect in this area is almost always weak and circumstantial…

Everything we eat causes cancer…sort of
David Gorski on January 7, 2013
Link
Red meat causes cancer. No, processed meat causes cancer. OK, it’s both red meat and processed meat. Wait, genetically modified grain causes cancer (well, not really). No, aspartame causes cancer. No, this food coloring or that one causes cancer.
Clearly, everything you eat causes cancer!
That means you can avoid cancer by avoiding processed meats, red meat, GMO-associated food (no, probably not), aspartame, food colorings, or anything “unnatural.” Or so it would seem from reading the popular literature and sometimes even the scientific literature. As I like to say to my medical students, life is a sexually transmitted fatal disease that gets us all eventually, but most of us would like to delay the inevitable as long as possible and remain as healthy as possible for as long as possible. One of the most obvious ways to do accomplish these twin aims is through diet. While the parameters of what constitutes a reasonably healthy diet have been known for decades, diet still ranks high on the risk of concerns regarding actions we take on a daily basis that can increase our risk of various diseases. Since cancer is disease (or, I should say, cancers are diseases) that many, if not most, people consider to be the scariest, naturally we worry about whether certain foods or food ingredients increase our risk of cancer.
Thus was born the field of nutritional epidemiology, a prolific field with thousands of publications annually. Seemingly, each and every one of these thousands of publications gets a news story associated with it, because the media love a good “food X causes cancer” or “food Y causes heart disease” story, particularly before the holidays. As a consequence, consumers are bombarded with what I like to call the latest health risk of the week, in which, in turn, various foods, food ingredients, or environmental “toxins” are blamed and exonerated for a panoply of health problems, ranging from the minor to the big three, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and cancer. It’s no wonder that consumers are confused, reacting either with serial alarm at each new “revelatory” study or with a shrug of the shoulders as each new alarm joins other alarms to produce a tinnitus-like background drone. Unfortunately, this cacophony of alarm also provides lots of ammunition to quacks, cranks, and crackpots to tout their many and varied diets that, they promise, will cut your risk of diseases like cancer and heart disease to near zero—but only if adhered to with monk-like determination and self-denial. (Yes, I’m talking about you, Dean Ornish, among others.)
All of this is why I really wanted to write about an article I saw popping up in the queue of articles published online ahead of print about a month ago. Somehow, other topics intervened, as did my vacation and then the holidays, and somehow I missed it last week, even though a link to the study sits in my folder named “Blog fodder.” Fortunately, it just saw print this week in its final version, giving me an excuse to make up for my oversight. It’s a study by one of our heroes (despite his occasional misstep) here on the SBM blog, John Ioannidis. It comes in the form of a study by Jonathan D. Schoenfeld and John Ioannidis in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition entitled, brilliantly, Is everything we eat associated with cancer? A systematic cookbook review.
Now, when John Ioannidis says a “systematic cookbook review,” he really means “a systematic cookbook review.” Basically, he and Schoenfeld went through The Boston Cooking School Cookbook and tested whether various ingredients described and used in the recipes in the cookbook had been tested for an association with cancer and what was found. What I love about John Ioannidis is embodied in the methodology of this study:
We selected ingredients from random recipes included in The Boston Cooking-School Cook Book (28), available online at http://archive.org/details/bostoncookingsch00farmrich. A copy of the book was obtained in portable document format and viewed by using Skim version 1.3.17 (http://skim-app.sourceforge. net). The recipes (see Supplementary Table 1 under “Supplemental data” in the online issue) were selected at random by generating random numbers corresponding to cookbook page numbers using Microsoft Excel (Microsoft Corporation). The first recipe on each page selected was used; the page was passed over if there was no recipe. All unique ingredients within selected recipes were chosen for analysis. This process was repeated until 50 unique ingredients were selected.
We performed literature searches using PubMed (http://www. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/) for studies investigating the relation of the selected ingredients to cancer risk using the following search terms: “risk factors”[MeSH Terms] AND “cancer”[sb] AND the singular and/or plural forms of the selected ingredient restricted to the title or abstract. Titles and abstracts of retrieved articles were then reviewed to select the 10 most recently published cohort or case-control studies investigating the relation between the ingredients and cancer risk. Ingredient derivatives and components (eg, orange juice) and ingredients analyzed as part of a broader diet specifically mentioned as a component of that diet were considered. Whenever ,10 studies were retrieved for a given article, an attempt was made to obtain additional studies by searching for ingredient synonyms (eg, mutton for lamb, thymol for thyme), using articles explicitly referred to by the previously retrieved material, and broadening the original searches (searching simply by ingredient name AND “cancer”).
How can you not love this guy?
His results were also not that surprising. First, he noted that for 80% of the ingredients his methodology identified there was at least one study examining its cancer risk. That’s forty ingredients, which he helpfully lists: veal, salt, pepper spice, flour, egg, bread, pork, butter, tomato, lemon, duck, onion, celery, carrot, parsley, mace, sherry, olive, mushroom, tripe, milk, cheese, coffee, bacon, sugar, lobster, potato, beef, lamb, mustard, nuts, wine, peas, corn, cinnamon, cayenne, orange, tea, rum, and raisin. He also notes that these ingredients represent many of the most common sources of vitamins and nutrients in a typical US diet. In contrast, the ten ingredients for which no study was identified tended to be less common: bay leaf, cloves, thyme, vanilla, hickory, molasses, almonds, baking soda, ginger, and terrapin. One wonders how almonds aren’t considered under nuts, but that’s just me being pedantic.
One also wonders whether “Dr.” Robert O. Young, alkalinization quack extraordinaire, who claims that cancer is due to too much acid and that alkalinization is the answer, has heard about no studies for baking soda, which to him, along with a vegan-based diet that is allegedly “alkalinizing,” is part of the “alkaline cure” for everything from cancer to sepsis to heart disease. Now, if you type “baking soda cancer” into the PubMed search box, you’ll actually pull of over 350 articles. However, none of them appear to be epidemiological studies. This reminds me. I need to look into that literature and do a post about it again. But I digress.
Let’s get back to the meat of the study itself. (Sorry, I couldn’t resist.)
Having identified the studies and meta-analyses, Schoenfeld and Ioannidis next extracted the data from the studies, looked at the quality of the studies, the size and significance of the effects reported, how specific they were, and whether there were indications of bias in any of them. The results they found were all over the map, with about the same number of studies finding increased compared to decreased risks of malignancy, and, as before, Schoenfeld and Ioannidis provide a helpful list:
Author conclusions reported in the abstract and manuscript text and relevant effect estimates are summarized in Table 1. Thirty-nine percent of studies concluded that the studied ingredient conferred an increased risk of malignancy; 33% concluded that there was a decreased risk, 5% concluded that there was a borderline statistically significant effect, and 23% concluded that there was no evidence of a clearly increased or decreased risk. Thirty-six of the 40 ingredients for which at least one study was identified had at least one study concluding increased or decreased risk of malignancy: veal, salt, pepper spice, egg, bread, pork, butter, tomato, lemon, duck, onion, celery, carrot, parsley, mace, olive, mushroom, tripe, milk, cheese, coffee, bacon, sugar, lobster, potato, beef, lamb, mustard, nuts, wine, peas, corn, cayenne, orange, tea, and rum.
The statistical support of the effects was weak (0.001 # P , 0.05) or even nonnominally significant (P . 0.05) in 80% of the studies. It was also weak or nonnominally significant, even in 75% of the studies that claimed an increased risk and in 76% of the studies that claimed a decreased risk (Table 1).
To boil it all down, what we have here are a bunch of studies that report an association between a food or food ingredient and either increased or decreased risk of various cancers, but the vast majority of them have very weak effect sizes and/or nominal statistical significance. Next, Schoenfeld and Ioannidis looked at ingredients for which meta-analyses existed and found 36 relevant effect size estimates based on meta-analyses. Many of these meta-analyses combined studies using different exposure contrasts, such as highest quartile/lowest quartile versus another measure, such as the highest versus lowest consumption. Only 13 meta-analyses were done by combining data on the same exact contrast across all studies. As one would expect when one pools diverse studies, meta-analyses tended to find smaller effects than individual studies, as shown in the following table from the paper (click to embiggen):
As I said, these findings are all over the map. Now, if you really want to see how chaotic the literature examined by Schoenfeld and Ioannidis is, take a look at the effect sizes found for ingredients for which there have been more than ten studies:
As you can see, it’s quite complex and all over the map, although there are a few ingredients for which the studies do appear to be fairly consistent, such as bacon being associated consistently with a higher risk of cancer. Bummer. Or is it? Let’s continue with Schoenfeld and Ioannidis’ analysis. What they found is rather disturbing. First, they report that although 80% of the studies they examined reported positive findings (i.e., a positive association between the food or ingredient studied and some form of cancer):
…the vast majority of these claims were based on weak statistical evidence. Many statistically insignificant “negative” and weak results were relegated to the full text rather than to the study abstract. Individual studies reported larger effect sizes than did the meta-analyses. There was no standardized, consistent selection of exposure contrasts for the reported risks. A minority of associations had more than weak support in meta-analyses, and summary effects in meta-analyses were consistent with a null average and relatively limited variance.
In other words, there are lots of studies out there that claim to find a link, either for increased risk or a protective effect, between this food or that ingredient and cancer, but very few of them actually provide convincing support for their hypothesis. Worse, there appear to be a lot of manuscript-writing shenanigans going on, with the abstract (which usually means, I note, the press release) touting a strong association while the true weakness of the association is buried in the fine print in the results or discussion sections of the paper. Given that most scientists tend not to read each and every word of a paper unless they’re very interested in it or it’s highly relevant to their research, this deceptive practice can leave a false impression that the reported association is stronger than it really is. Yes, I realize that we as scientists should probably be more careful, but a combination of time pressures and the enormous volume of literature out there make it difficult to do so. Moreover, as Schoenfeld and Ioannidis note in their discussion, although they didn’t cover the entire nutritional epidemiology literature for all these ingredients (which would be virtually impossible), their search strategy was “representative of the studies that might be encountered by a researcher, physician, patient, or consumer embarking on a review of this literature.” In other words, they tried to search the literature in a way that would bring up the most commonly cited recent studies.
The effect is likely to be even worse for the lay public, who get information filtered through press releases that tend to amplify the same problem (lack of proper caveats and discussion of how nominal or marginal the association actually is when examined critically). After all, university press offices are not generally known for their nuance, and reporters tend to want to cover stories they deem interesting. Marginal studies are less interesting than a study with a strong, robust result. So studies all too often tend to be presented as though they have a strong, robust result, even when they don’t. This is facilitated by another problem observed by Ioannidis, namely the wide variety and inconsistency in definitions and exposure contrasts. This, argue Schoenfeld and Ioannidis, make it easier for reporting biases to creep into the literature.
There’s also the issue of reporting bias, which could easily be more acute in nutritional epidemiology. The reason is that there is, understandably, a huge public interest in what sorts of foods might either be protective against or cause cancer. In an accompanying editorial, Michelle M. Bohan Brown, Andrew W Brown, and David B Allison, while noting that Schoenfeld and Ioannidis’ work does indeed suggest that everything we eat is associated with cancer in some way, also note that their study reports evidence of publication bias:
They [Schoenfeld and Ioannidis] found that almost three-fourths of the articles they reviewed concluded that there was an increased or decreased risk of cancer attributed to various foods, with most evidence being at least nominally significant. It appears, then, that according to the published literature almost everything we eat is, in fact, associated with cancer. However, Schoenfeld and Ioannidis proceeded to show that biases exist in the nutrient-cancer literature. The fidelity of research findings between nutrients and cancer may have been compromised in several ways. They identified an overstating of weak results (most associations were only weakly supported), a lack of consistent comparisons (inconsistent definitions of exposure and outcomes), and possible suppression of null findings (a bimodal distribution of outcomes, with a noticeable lack of null findings).
Brown et al note that the sources of these sorts of biases have been well known for a long time and can lead to self-deception. The types of bias most responsible for positive findings appear to include what is known as “white hat bias” (“bias leading to distortion of research-based information in the service of what may be perceived as ‘righteous ends’”), confirmation bias (in which overstated results match preconceived views, so that the authors overstating the results don’t adequately consider the weaknesses of their work), and, of course, publication bias. These biased results are then disseminated to the public through the lay media. As Brown et al note:
The implications of Schoenfeld and Ioannidis’ analysis may be important for nutritional epidemiology even more broadly. Numerous food ingredients are thought to have medicinal properties that are not sufficiently supported by current knowledge—for example, coffee “curing” diabetes (11). These distortions can also be used to demonize foods, as shown by the longstanding presumption that dietary cholesterol in eggs contributes to heart disease (12). Causative relations between various foods and diseases likely do exist, but the evidence for many relations is weak, although conclusions about these relations are stated with the certainty one would expect only from the most strongly supported evidence.
Indeed. Another implication, not noted by either Schoenfeld and Ioannidis or Brown et al, is that weak research findings suggesting a link between this food or that food and cancer, not only lead to the inappropriate demonization of some foods but to quackery. Anyone who has been a regular reader of this blog or one of the other blogs of the contributors to SBM, or who has followed the “alternative medicine” online underground will immediately note that quacks frequently tout various “superfoods” or supplements chock full of various food ingredients believed to have protective effects against various diseases as the cure for what ails you, be it cancer, heart disease, diabetes, or whatever. Publishing studies with weak associations tarted up to look stronger than they really are only provides fuel for these quacks. Indeed, there is one site run by a Sayer Ji that devotes much of its news section to publishing stories and abstracts describing such studies. I’m referring to GreenMedInfo, which routinely publishes posts with titles like Avocado: The Fat So Good It Makes Hamburger Less Bad; Black Seed – ‘The Remedy For Everything But Death’; and 5 Food-Medicines That Could Quite Possibly Save Your Life. And that’s just one example. Mike Adams, for instance, does the same sort of thing, just yesterday posting articles claiming that various foods can “lower blood pressure fast” and that the “Paleo diet” combined with vitamin D and avoiding food additives can reverse multiple sclerosis. Not surprisingly, the same sorts of hyperbole can regularly be found on The Huffington Post, and touted by supplement sellers. Even mainstream media outlets like MSNBC get into the act.
Of course, in all fairness, in science, most studies should just be published and let the chips fall where they may. It’s unfair to blame the authors of nutritional epidemiology studies for how their studies are used and abused. It is not unfair to blame them if they use poor methodology or the strength and significance of their findings in the abstract and hide their weakness by burying it deep in the verbiage of the results or discussion sections. If Schoenfeld and Ioannidis are correct, this happens all too often. Obviously, their sample is a fairly small slice of the nutritional epidemiological literature and as such might not be representative, but given the methods used to choose the studies examined I doubt that if Schoenfeld and Ioannidis had gone up to 100 foods they would have found anything much different.
Unfortunately, in almost the mirror image to the nutrition alarmists, one also sees a disturbing temptation on the part of those who represent themselves as scientific to go too far in the other direction and point to Schoenfeld and Ioannidis’ study as a convenient excuse to summarily dismiss nutritional epidemiological findings linking various foods or types of foods with cancer or other disease. For example, the American Council on Science and Health (ACSH) did just that in response to this study, gloating that it proves that its dismissal of food health scares are insignificant. Well, actually, many scares are insignificant, but surely not all of them are. The ACSH also almost goes into conspiracy theories when it further claims that the mainstream media except for a couple of UK newspapers, such as The Guardian, ignored the study. Although arguably this particular study didn’t get huge coverage, it’s going a bit far to claim that the mainstream media ignored it. It didn’t; the study was featured on Boing-Boing, The Washington Post, Reason, Cancer Research UK, and others. Of course, one can’t help but note that the ACSH is the same organization that has referred to advocating organic foods as “elitist”, likes to disparagingly refer to questions about links between environment and cancer as “chemophobia,” and been very quick to dismiss the possibilities that various chemicals might be linked to cancer, as so famously parodied on The Daily Show. a few years ago. We must resist the temptation to go too far in the opposite direction and reflexively dismiss even the possibility of such risks as the ACSH is wont to do, most famously with pesticides and other chemicals.
Indeed, as was pointed out at Cancer Research UK, the real issue is that individual studies taken in isolation can be profoundly misleading. There’s so much noise and so many confounders to account for that any single study can easily miss the mark, either overestimating or underestimating associations. Given publication bias and the tendency to believe that some foods or environmental factors must cause cancer, it’s not too surprising that studies tend to overestimate effect sizes more often then they underestimate them. Looking through all the noise and trying to find the true signals, there are at least a few foods that are reliably linked to cancer. For instance, alcohol consumption is positively linked with several cancers, including pancreatic, esophageal, and head and neck cancers, among others. There’s evidence that eating lots of fruit and vegetables compared to meat can have protective effects against colorectal cancer and others, although the links are not strong, and processed meats like bacon have been linked to various cancers, although, again, the elevated risk is not huge. When you boil it all down, it’s probably far less important what individual foods one eats than that one eats a varied diet that is relatively low in red meat and high in vegetables and fruits and that one is not obese.
So what can be done? It would be a good thing indeed if the sorts of observations that Ioannidis has made lead to reform. Between Schoenfeld and Ioannidis’ study and the accompanying editorial several remedies have been proposed that are not unlike steps that have been imposed on clinical trials of therapies and drugs: increased use and improvement of clinical trial and observational study registries; making raw data publicly available; making supporting documentation such as protocols, consent forms, and analytic plans publicly available; and mandating the publication of results from human (or animal) research supported by taxpayer funds. I must admit that the last of these is already a requirement, as is registration of all taxpayer-supported clinical trials at ClinicalTrials.gov, but the other proposals could also help.
Finally, I’ll finish with a quote from the editorial by Brown et al:
As Schoenfeld and Ioannidis (6) highlighted, comprehensive approaches to improve reporting of nutrient-disease outcomes could go a long way toward decreasing repeated sensational reports of the effects of foods on health. However, none of these debiasing solutions address the fundamental human need to perceive control over feared events. Although scientists may have ulterior motives for looking for nutrient-disease associations, the public is always the final audience. It is therefore imperative that we spend less time repeating weak correlations and invest the resources to vigorously investigate nutrient-cancer and other disease associations with stronger methodology, so that we give the public lightning rods instead of sending them up the bell tower.
That last remark refers to Ben Franklin’s lightning rod and how churches used to think that ringing bells would protect against lightning strikes when in fact ringing bells only put the bell ringers in danger from lightning, which often struck bell towers because bell towers were usually the highest buildings in most towns. It’s a metaphor that fits, because the superstition about lightning before the lightning rod could divert devastating lightning strikes from bell towers is not unlike the irrational beliefs about food-cancer links that all too often predominate even today. The answer is more rigorous science and less publicizing of weak science.

Peddling Misinformation About Diet and Cancer
Selling dubious nutrition products often involve attacking, and suing, your critics.
Steven Novella on March 22, 2023
Link

Many people in the SBM community have expressed concern about a lawsuit currently happening in Australia. Dr. Adam Smith, a Melbourne GP, is being sued for defamation by naturopathy, Farrah Agustin-Bunch. It my opinion this looks like a classic case of using legal thuggery to silence and intimidate legitimate commentary. Smith says he was concerned by the extreme claims being made by Agustin-Bunch and wanted to “do a good deed” by providing some scientific response. Looking at Agustin-Bunch’s website it looks like she has a history of responding to such criticism by going on the attack, trying to turn the tables on her critics and, at least in this case, suing them.
Unfortunately for Smith, the laws in Australia are are defamation friendly. Sydney has been called the defamation capital of the world. He is reportedly already out of pocket $600,000 dollars in legal fees, and will likely spend two million before things are done. But to his credit he is not backing down.
To get the flavor of Agustin-Bunch’s strategy, I found a 2018 Quackwatch article about her, and her response. Quackwatch is a consumer protection website focuses on bogus medical claims and treatments, founded by Stephen Barrett and now run by CFI. Smith and Barrett take exception to the fact that Agustin-Bunch is promoting the typical range of dietary solutions to all problems, selling her “pixie dust” magnesium supplement and Boston-C supplements for many things, including cancer. On the package the Boston-C supplement claims it “supports immune system function” and “natural detoxification and cleansing”. We have heard these claims before. The Philippines FDA, where her clinic is, has shut down her clinic and cited her for selling products that are not approved.
To fight back against Barrett she quotes the following criticism:
“The Quackbusters, founded by the disgraced, unlicensed psychiatrist, Stephen Barrett, are a ubiquitous shadow network in the world of health and medicine with a unique talent.
Now that is defamation. Stephen Barrett is only “unlicensed” because he is retired. He was fully licensed when practicing. He is not “disgraced” by any objective measure, and she cites no cause or justification for this claim. (He had no complaints against his license, which was in good standing when he retired.) She tries to diminish Dr. Barrett by saying he has no “reported medical training since 1961”. That was the year he completed his residency. He was in practice until 1993, which means he had to keep up with his continuing medical education requirements, so her statement is false.
There is more, but actually that is likely the point – keep her critics defending themselves from her own baseless accusations rather than discussing the dubious nature of her medical advice. She is setting up a battle of authority (rather than evidence) and then relentless attacks her critics. I want to focus, rather, on one claim she makes as part of her push back against Quackwatch. She quotes Barrett as writing:
“I recommend steering clear of: Anyone who suggests that most diseases are caused by faulty nutrition. Although some diseases are diet-related, most are not.”
She takes this out of context then takes a number of other quotes from medical sources out of context to create a false impression. She writes:
“Increasing cancer rates also cannot be attributed to genetic factors, which are directly implicated in, at most, 5 – 10 percent of all cancers. I firmly believe that upwards of 90 – 95 percent of cancer incidence originates from lifestyle and environmental factors, with diet being far and away the primary causal component in cancer incidence today.”
For support she does not have definitive references in the medical literature, but misleading quotes. Here is just one representative example:
The National Academy of Sciences contradicts Stephen Barrett.
“In most Western countries, including the United States, diet-related chronic diseases represent the single largest cause of morbidity and mortality.”
She is conflating diet and nutrition. In the West, in developed nations, the contribution of diet to disease is largely not from malnutrition – not something that can be fixed with supplements – but from obesity and consuming too much of certain things, like meat, sugar, and fat. She uses conclusions that are really about obesity to justify prescribing supplements for cancer.
Let’s look at the actual evidence. A 2019 study looking at 80,000 new cancer cases in the US found that only 5.2% were attributable to diet. That is what Dr. Barrett is talking about, and directly contradicts Agustin-Bunch’s narrative. A 2020 review of diet and cancer published in BMJ made very direct conclusions from the data.
“High dose vitamin or mineral supplements have not reduced cancer risk in well nourished populations and might increase risk; for example, high dose β carotene might increase the risk of lung cancer. Vitamin and mineral supplements should not be used for cancer prevention, although they can be important for other aspects of health, such as folic acid supplements for women before conception.
What about eating fruits and vegetables, rather than supplements?
“In the 2018 World Cancer Research Fund report neither fruits nor vegetables were considered to be convincingly or probably associated with the risk of any cancer.”
They leave the door open for a small effect for some cancers, most notable colon cancer, which makes sense. About 10% of cancers likely result from genetics. This does not mean the rest is environmental and lifestyle factors, as Agustin-Bunch false concludes. The evidence, in fact, suggests that as much as 65% of cancers are just due to bad luck. The rest are due to known significant causes, like smoking and obesity. There is some controversy over how exactly to interpret the data on “bad luck” as a cause for cancer, but either way it is still a major cause.
But that doesn’t sell supplements. Supplement sellers need to create the narrative that most health issues are cause by poor nutrition and that their special products are the best way to treat that – but the evidence is just not on their side. When called out on their misleading claims, it is common for them to go on the attack. They claim there is a conspiracy, scientists don’t actually know what they are talking about, they attack specific critics, they claim that they have some special knowledge, and when they can, they use legal thuggery.
What they can’t use is legitimate science, because it does not support their marketing narrative.

Ketogenic diet does not “beat chemo for almost all cancers”
David Gorski on June 23, 2014
Link
One of the difficult things about science-based medicine is determining what is and isn’t quackery. While it is quite obvious that modalities such as homeopathy, acupuncture, reflexology, craniosacral therapy, Hulda Clark’s “zapper,” the Gerson therapy and Gonzalez protocol for cancer, and reiki (not to mention every other “energy healing” therapy) are the rankest quackery, there are lots of treatments that are harder to classify. Much of the time, these treatments that seemingly fall into a “gray area” are treatments that have shown promise in animals but have never been tested rigorously in humans or are based on scientific principles that sound reasonable but, again, have never been tested rigorously in humans. (Are you sensing a pattern here yet?) Often these therapies are promoted by true believers whose enthusiasm greatly outstrips the evidence base for their preferred treatment. Lately, I’ve been seeing just such a therapy being promoted around the usual social media sources, such as Facebook, Twitter, and the like. I’ve been meaning to write about it for a bit, but, as is so often the case with my Dug the Dog nature—squirrel!—other topics caught my attention.
I’m referring to a diet called the ketogenic diet, and an article that’s been making the rounds since last week entitled “Ketogenic diet beats chemo for almost all cancers, says Dr. Thomas Seyfried.” Of course, when I see a claim such as that, my first reaction is, “Show me the evidence.” My second reaction is, “Who is this guy?” Well, Dr. Seyfried is a professor of biology at Boston College, who’s pretty well published. He’s also working in a field that has gained new respectability over the last five to ten years, namely cancer metabolism, mainly thanks to a rediscovery of what Otto Warburg discovered over 80 years ago. What Warburg discovered was that many tumors rely on glycolysis for their energy even in environments with adequate oxygen for oxidative phosphorylation, which generates the bulk of the chemical energy used by cells. I described this phenomenon in more detail in a post I did four years ago about a drug that looks as though its anticancer properties come from its ability to reverse the Warburg effect.
What not to do if you want your hypothesis to be taken seriously
So on the surface, Dr. Seyfried’s argument that cancer is primarily a metabolic disease (an argument I’ll look at in more depth shortly) is well within the bounds of current oncologic science. Indeed, a few years ago it was all the rage, and I remember attending several sessions and lectures on the Warburg effect and cancer at the AACR meetings three or four years ago, although, oddly enough, I don’t recall as many the last couple of years. In any event, if that’s all I looked at, I probably would have shrugged my shoulders and moved on, as in, “Nothing to see here.” But there are quite a few red flags. The first red flag is a claim that a ketogenic diet can treat cancer better than chemotherapy. The second, even bigger, red flag is on Dr. Seyfried’s Boston College web page:
In addition, Dr. Seyfried has worked with noted alternative health advocate Dr. Mercola to provide a thought-provoking discussion on the benefits of a ketogenic diet. Dr. Mercola provides a thorough synopsis of the talk on his website, and also includes the original audio recording of their conversation.
Über-quack Dr. Mercola? Oh, dear. His evident pride at having been interviewed by Dr. Mercola does not reflect well on Dr. Seyfried’s critical thinking skills and knowledge of medicine. Dr. Mercola sells quackery. He has promoted antivaccine views, breast cancer pseudoscience, and the rankest cancer quackery, such as that of Tullio Simoncini, who believes that all cancer is a fungus and that baking soda is the way to treat it, and the Gerson therapy, which involves massive doses of supplements and, of course, twice-a-day coffee enemas. Seriously, this is not the sort of person a legitimate scientist wants to associate himself with—ever—if he wants to be taken seriously. I can see a naive researcher making a mistake and, not realizing who Dr. Mercola is, agreeing to an interview, but that’s the sort of thing that a reputable scientist would do his best to disavow and distance himself from.
Neither is the American College for Advancement in Medicine (ACAM), which bills itself as the “voice of integrative medicine,” where he’s given a major talk, the sort of organization a legitimate scientist wants to associate himself with if he wants to be taken seriously. Don’t believe me? Just peruse the ACAM website, where you will find lots of chelation therapy, including a program to “certify” in chelation therapy and detoxification, as well as other quackery. There’s a good reason that ACAM has appeared in many SBM posts throughout the years, and not in a favorable light. I emphasize again, this is not an organization with which a scientist who wishes to be taken seriously by oncologists associates himself.
Also, if a scientist wishes to be taken seriously, he shouldn’t say things like this:
The low-carb, high-fat ketogenic diet can replace chemotherapy and radiation for even the deadliest of cancers, said Dr. Thomas Seyfried, a leading cancer researcher and professor at Boston College.
In an exclusive interview, Dr. Seyfried discussed why the ketogenic diet has not been embraced by the medical community to treat cancer despite its proven track record both clinically and anecdotally.
“The reason why the ketogenic diet is not being prescribed to treat cancer is purely economical,” said Dr. Seyfried, author of Cancer as a Metabolic Disease. “Cancer is big business. There are more people making a living off cancer than there are dying of it.”
And don’t associate yourself with Ralph Moss, the number one promoter of laetrile quackery and make easily refuted claims such as the claim that “chemo and radiation do not cure cancer or extend life, although cancer physicians often make this claim” and that radiation “often does more harm than good to the patient.” Given that all Dr. Seyfried has is a couple of case studies as clinical support for his treatment (see below) and I can produce reams of studies over nearly 50 years demonstrating that chemotherapy can cure specific cancers and prolong life when used appropriately, the “2% gambit” notwithstanding, it’s not a winning proposition, and it sure doesn’t help your credibility to use the language of cancer quacks to promote your idea.
So, what, exactly is Dr. Seyfried’s hypothesis?
Cancer as a metabolic disease
Red flags or no red flags, it is, of course, possible that Dr. Seyfried is on to something and has let his enthusiasm overwhelm his judgment with respect to whom he associates with and the sorts of statements he makes, many of which sound as though they could have come from Stanislaw Burzynski, Ralph Moss, or Joe Mercola. In actuality, he isn’t totally wrong, but he isn’t totally right, either. As is typical of someone without a medical background, in particular an oncology background, he is, basically, putting the cart before the horse, as you will see.
In his talk, Dr. Seyfried begins with what he refers to as a “provocative question”: Is cancer a genetic or metabolic disease? Actually, whether he realizes it or not, his question is not quite as provocative as he thinks it is, nor is the answer anywhere near as clear-cut as he thinks it is or as he characterizes oncologists and cancer researchers as thinking it is. I’ll tell you what I think the answer to the question is after I’ve discussed Dr. Seyfried’s hypothesis. In the meantime, not surprisingly, his answer is that cancer is a metabolic disease, while everyone else’s answer—according to him, at least—is that it is a genetic disease, making him the brave maverick doctor, who says things like:
The current view now, without any question, is that cancer is a genetic disease. If you go on the National Cancer Institute website or you read any of the major articles published in Nature and Science, often the articles will start with, “Cancer is a genetic disease.” I think that this has become dogma.
Except that it really isn’t, at least not anymore. If you do a Pubmed search on “targeting cancer metabolism,” which is what Dr. Seyfried is talking about, you’ll find over 22,000 articles, with over 3,000 in 2013 alone, with a sharply increasing curve since 2000 that only now appears to be leveling off. A search on “cancer metabolism” brings up 369,000 references, with 28,000 in 2013 alone. Cancer metabolism is an incredibly important topic in cancer research and has been for several years now, and finding means of targeting the common metabolic abnormalities exhibited by cancer cells is currently a hot area of research. From my perspective, Dr. Seyfried is exaggerating how hostile the cancer research community is towards metabolism as an important, possibly critical, driver of cancer, although, to be fair, one prominent cancer researcher, Robert Weinberg, has been very skeptical. To me, Seyfried just appears unhappy that genetics is currently thought—for good reasons, I might add—to be the primary driver of most cancers. Note that I intentionally used such phrasing, because Dr. Seyfried, in my readings, appears all too often to speak of “cancer” as if it were a monolithic single disease. As I’ve pointed out many times before, it’s not. Indeed, only approximately 60-90% of cancers demonstrate the Warburg effect.
There are three components to glucose metabolism: glycolysis, which feeds the Krebs citric acid cycle, which in turn feeds oxidative phosphorylation. I show them below in simplified illustrations:
The issue with the Warburg effect is that it leads to a shift in metabolism that favors glycolysis. As a result of this shift, tumor cells tend to use a lot more glucose than normal cells because glycolysis is much less efficient at converting glucose into ATP molecules used for cellular energy than oxidative phosphorylation. One reason that this is thought to provide a growth advantage to cancer cells is because oxidative phosphorylation requires oxygen while glycolysis does not and cancers frequently outgrow their blood supply such that they often live and grow in tissue spaces where there is not much oxygen. In any case, the avidity of cancer cells for glucose has been known a long time and is the basis for positron emission tomography (PET) scanning, where a radiolabeled derivative of glucose is the most commonly used tracer for exactly that reason: Tumor cells take it up much more avidly than do normal cells, leading to ugly black blobs (old-fashioned PET scans alone) or pretty bright blobs (PET-CT) where there are tumor masses in the scans.
The idea behind ketogenic diets is very simple. If glucose is the primary fuel for cancer, then lower carbohydrate intake and replace carbohydrates with other sources of fuel, such as fats, in order to push the body’s metabolism into ketosis. It actually turns out that ketogenic diets are probably useful in the treatment of intractable epileptic seizures in children. Unfortunately, their mechanism of action in preventing seizures is unclear, although four potential mechanisms, including carbohydrate reduction, activation of ATP-sensitive potassium channels by mitochondrial metabolism, inhibition of the mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) pathway, or inhibition of glutamatergic synaptic transmission (glutamate as a neurotransmitter), have been proposed. Interestingly, the mTOR pathway is an important signaling pathway in many cancers that couples energy and nutrient abundance to the execution of cell growth and division, owing to the ability of TOR protein kinase to simultaneously sense energy, nutrients and stress and growth factors. It’s a commonly overactive signaling pathway in cancer.
It’s also interesting that the cancers used to produce the basic science cited by Dr. Seyfried are virtually all brain cancers and that virtually all the evidence comes from rodent tumor models. For one thing, if there is a tumor type that exhibits the Warburg effect and a high degree of metabolic derangement, it’s brain tumors. It’s no coincidence that dichloroacetate was first tested in brain tumors. In this study, VM/Dk mice were used, and a mouse histiocytoma cell line resembling human glioblastoma multiforme with macrophage/microglial properties derived from that same mouse strain (VM-M3) was implanted subcutaneously. This cell line has the property of metastasizing quickly and widely when implanted under the skin and allowed to grow, which actually makes it not very much like brain tumors, which seldom metastasize and usually kill through local invasion and taking up increasing volume in the closed space of the skull, something the brain most definitely does not like. The results showed that a ketogenic diet increased mean survival time by over 56%, while a combination of a ketogenic diet and hyperbaric oxygen therapy (HBOT) increased survival time 78%. The result is interesting, but it is a mouse tumor model, not a human tumor model, and that makes its applicability to humans tenuous, particularly given the nature of the murine tumor, but probably worth investigating further.
Another mouse study cited by Seyfried is one in which dietary restriction was reported to promote vessel maturation in a mouse astrocytoma model. Given that tumor angiogenesis is one of my scientific interests and I have a fair number of publications on the topic, I was interested. Unfortunately, I ended up being disappointed. This was another syngeneic model (i.e., a mouse tumor implanted in mice of the same strain from which the tumor was isolated as a cell line, like the one discussed above). Although it showed increased tumor vessel maturation (which is one mechanism by which inhibitors of angiogenesis work), I wasn’t quite convinced, because there was a distinct lack of quantification of the phenomenon, and the microscopy appears not to have been blinded, something that’s critical to avoid unconscious bias in the results. It’s not surprising that this result, which, if more convincing evidence had been obtained, could easily have appeared in Cancer Research, was published in a low tier journal. It’s an OK study, but not fantastic. Certainly it didn’t lead me to smacking myself in forehead and saying, “Of course!”
Throughout his talks, both here and elsewhere, Dr. Seyfried presents mouse studies that are interesting and suggestive that there might be something to this whole ketogenic diet thing, at least in brain tumors, such as this one. However, this is what we in the oncology biz would call pretty preliminary data, worthy of further investigation but not supporting the grandiose claims that Dr. Seyfried makes.
We need more beef. We need clinical studies. Unfortunately, they’re in short supply.
Clinical evidence for ketogenic diets as a cancer treatment
It’s not as though Dr. Seyfried doesn’t cite clinical evidence. It’s just that the evidence is so darned thin and unconvincing thus far. For instance, in this talk, the first study he presents is a very small case series (two patients, actually) performed in 1995 in which two girls with inoperable astrocytomas were placed on a ketogenic diet in order to “determine if a ketogenic state would decrease glucose availability to certain tumors, thereby potentially impairing tumor metabolism without adversely affecting the patient’s overall nutritional status.” Interestingly (to me, at least) these case reports came from University Hospitals of Cleveland, where I did my general surgery residency. In fact, I was still there in 1995. Unfortunately, I don’t have access to the journal back to 1995; so I’m stuck with just the abstract. However, the abstract is pretty clear:
Within 7 days of initiating the ketogenic diet, blood glucose levels declined to low-normal levels and blood ketones were elevated twenty to thirty fold. Results of PET scans indicated a 21.8% average decrease in glucose uptake at the tumor site in both subjects. One patient exhibited significant clinical improvements in mood and new skill development during the study. She continued the ketogenic diet for an additional twelve months, remaining free of disease progression.
One notes that the patient who didn’t survive 12 months wasn’t much mentioned; so I assume she didn’t demonstrate any clinical improvement. In any case, this study doesn’t really show anything, other than that a ketogenic diet might decrease glucose uptake in some brain tumors. It’s like a Burzynski case report, in which we have no idea whether the patient did better than expected because of the intervention or because she had less aggressive disease.
The next case report is from 2010. It describes the case of a 65-year-old woman who presented with progressive memory loss, chronic headaches, nausea, and a right hemisphere multi-centric tumor seen with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Following incomplete surgical resection, the patient was diagnosed with glioblastoma multiforme (GBM). Now here’s the kicker: The patient underwent standard therapy plus the ketogenic diet. A day after her surgery, she underwent a two-day fast, followed by a three day fast beginning a week after surgery, followed by a restricted ketogenic diet (only 600 Cal/day). Three weeks after her surgery (and two weeks after starting the ketogenic diet) she began standard of care treatment, concomitant radiation plus chemotherapy (temozolomide), “according to standard procedures,” which lasted six weeks. The patient also had a gene mutation in her tumor that produces increased sensitivity to temozolomide. The conclusion? Fortunately for the patient, she had what appears to have been a complete response, after which she went on a less restrictive ketogenic diet. Unfortunately, the patient recurred eight months later. By that point, the patient was off of the ketogenic diet. The authors’ conclusion? Because it was “unlikely” that the tumor would have responded this well on standard therapy alone, it must have been adding the ketogenic diet that done it. Worse, in the talk, Dr. Seyfried strongly implies that the tumor recurred because she had gone off the ketogenic diet two and a half months before her recurrence.
Irritatingly, during the same talk, Dr. Seyfried refers to having done a “biopsy” on the GBM when the case report clearly says that the patient underwent a partial excision of the temporal pole with incomplete debulking of the tumor, which is a different thing. When a surgeon tries to debulk a tumor, he is trying to remove as much of it as possible. When a surgeon biopsies a tumor, he is trying only to get enough tissue to make a diagnosis. He also heaps scorn on the hospital for insisting that the patient undergo standard of care therapy, clearly demonstrating that he has no understanding of clinical trial ethics. What most likely happened with this patient is that the debulking was significant, and the remaining tumor was small enough to be eliminated by the combined chemotherapy and radiation therapy—at least to the point of no longer being detectable on PET scan. Also, just because the diet appears to have decreased glucose uptake by the tumor doesn’t mean that the tumor was dying. In fact, it might have even made the PET scan less sensitive to whatever remaining viable tumor cells might still have been around, a possibility that I don’t see Dr. Seyfried as having considered.
There are other studies, but little or nothing in the way of randomized clinical trials. For instance, a recent retrospective study of 53 patients, of whom only six followed a ketogenic diet while being treated for GBM, concluded that the diet was safe, but no suggestion of efficacy was noted. More recently, a German group examined the effect of a ketogenic diet on 16 patients with advanced cancer of various types who had exhausted all therapeutic options. The treatment didn’t result in any serious side effects, although subjects found it very difficult to maintain the diet, particularly in the context of family life. Only five were able to complete the three month treatment period, and it was reported that these five didn’t have progression while on the diet. Of the remaining 11, two died early, one was unable to tolerate the diet and dropped out very quickly, two dropped out for personal reasons, one couldn’t continue the diet for more than a month and three had disease progression within less than 2 months of starting the diet and one dropped out to resume chemotherapy. As a whole, this study was well-nigh uninterpretable due to the different kinds of cancer, other than to conclude that less than 50% of patients with advanced cancer could adhere to the diet, and that those who could generally had no significant side effects. Of course, it’s unclear whether the diet helped the five who could adhere to it or whether those who adhered to it could do so because they had more indolent, less aggressive disease.
None of this stops Dr. Seyfried from concluding:
     1.  Preclinical and case report studies indicated that the restricted ketogenic diet (R-KD) can be an effective “metabolic therapy” for managing malignant brain cancer in children and adults.
     2.  The therapeutic effects of the R-KD against brain cancer can be enhanced when combined with drugs or HBOT that also target energy metabolism.
Uh, no. Not exactly. Preclinical experiments are intriguing but fairly limited in applicability, and the case reports demonstrate nothing of the sort. There’s more to Dr. Seyfried’s hypothesis, for example, his idea that metastatic cancer comes about because of alterations in glutamine metabolism, but unfortunately he appears to misunderstand the genetics of metastasis when he bases part of his conclusion on observations that metastatic cancers often have the same genetic derangements as the primary tumor. It’s been a longstanding question whether clones of tumor cells possess the ability to metastasize as an intrinsic part of the process of becoming cancer cells or whether they acquire it later. Given that evolution is a major force driving cancer cells to become more invasive and that tumors are very heterogeneous, full of lots of different clones with different sets of genetic mutations, Dr. Seyfried’s hypothesis is at best simplistic. Also disappointingly, the evidence for any diet as a treatment for cancer is weak at best.
Putting the cart before the horse
Clearly, ketogenic diets are not ready for prime time as a treatment for cancer, either alone or in combination with conventional therapy. Unfortunately, that hasn’t stopped it from being touted by all manner of alternative cancer practitioners (i.e., quacks) and others as a cancer cure that “they” don’t want you to know about or saying things like, “…it’s nothing short of medical malpractice and negligence to fail to integrate this type of dietary strategy into a patient’s cancer treatment plan,” as Joe Mercola did. Dr. Seyfried himself has contributed to the hyperbole quite a bit as well. For example:
These studies are all in combination with either radiation or chemotherapy. My preference is to start metabolic therapy with GBM (glioblastoma multiforme). This is a devastating type of brain cancer. Metabolic therapy with a restricted KD could be done with a few tumors where you know the conventional standard of care doesn’t work at all. You would choose those kinds of patients and do a clinical trial based on historical controls and see what the outcome would be and see if you could get some level of survival that would match or be better than the conventional standard of care.
Regular readers of SBM should know the problem with this sort of approach. No IRB worth its salt would approve such a trial because it would be ethically dubious, but, even worse, it would be ethically dubious and it wouldn’t really tell us anything unless those few patients either had near-miraculous responses or died very quickly. Anything else would simply tell us that the diet is probably doing no harm. More numbers would be needed, particularly if the comparison is to historical controls, to get even an inkling of whether there might be benefit. In that case, you might as well do a proper phase I/II clinical trial, which is what is happening. For instance:
    • Calorie-restricted, Ketogenic Diet and Transient Fasting During Reirradiation for Patients With Recurrent Glioblastoma (ERGO2), a randomized clinical trial designed to evaluate whether a calorie-restricted, ketogenic diet and transient fasting can enhance the efficacy of reirradiation in patients with recurrent glioblastoma.
    • Pilot Study of a Metabolic Nutritional Therapy for the Management of Primary Brain Tumors (Ketones), a phase I pilot study in my neck of the woods (at least in my state) looking at the same sort of diet.
    • Ketogenic Diet as Adjunctive Treatment in Refractory/End-stage Glioblastoma Multiforme: a Pilot Study, a small pilot study designed to examine the effect of a ketogenic diet in refractory GBM being treated with Avastin.
    • Ketogenic Diet With Radiation and Chemotherapy for Newly Diagnosed Glioblastoma, a phase I/II trial designed to test whether a ketogenic diet enhances the efficacy of radiation and chemotherapy.
In other words, clinical data should be rolling in fairly soon, and that’s a good thing. In the meantime Dr. Seyfried and other advocates who so passionately believe that ketogenic diets will greatly help patients with brain cancer do no one any favors by claiming unequivocally that cancer is a metabolic disease and saying that ketogenic diets are more beneficial than chemotherapy for patients with brain tumors.
This brings me back to the question of whether cancer is a metabolic disease or a genetic disease, the answer to which I promised early on. The likely answer? It’s both! Indeed, a “chicken or the egg” argument continues about whether it is the metabolic abnormalities that cause the mutations observed in cancer cells or whether it is the mutations that produce the metabolic abnormalities. Most likely, it’s a little of both, the exact proportion of which depending upon the tumor cell, that combine in an unholy synergistic circle to drive cancer cells to be more and more abnormal and aggressive. Moreover, cancer is about far more than just the genomics or the metabolism of cancer cells. It’s also the immune system and the tumor microenvironment (the cells and connective tissue in which tumors arise and grow). As I’ve said time and time and time again, cancer is complicated, real complicated. The relative contributions of genetic mutations, metabolic derangements, immune cell dysfunction, and influences of the microenvironment are likely to vary depending upon the type of tumor and, as a consequence, require different treatments. In the end, as with many hyped cancer cures, the ketogenic diet might be helpful for some tumors and almost certainly won’t be helpful for others. Dr. Seyfried might be on to something, but he’s gone a bit off the deep end in apparently thinking that he’s found out something about cancer that no one else takes seriously—or has even thought of before.

Diet and exercise versus cancer: A science-based view
Yes, diet and exercise can be useful to prevent some cancers. Unfortunately, they don’t prevent all cancers, and the effect size is more modest than often represented. That’s not to say that eating right and exercise aren’t good. They are, for so many other reasons than cancer. Just don’t view them as a panacea for preventing cancer.
David Gorski on September 19, 2016
Link

One of the most effective spin techniques used by advocates of “integrative medicine” (also sometimes called “complementary and alternative medicine,” or CAM for short) to legitimize quackery has been to claim basically all non-pharmacologic, non-surgical interventions as “integrative,” “complementary,” or “alternative.” Thus, science-based interventions such as diet changes to treat and/or prevent disease, exercise, and other lifestyle alterations are portrayed as somehow so special that they need their own specialty, “integrative medicine,” even though they are simply part of medicine. I pointed this out a mere two weeks ago when I discussed the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) review of non-pharmacological treatments for pain. It was a systematic review that was essentially negative but spun as positive for some interventions and lacked some key analyses that a good systematic review includes, such as assessment of the quality of the studies included and evaluating them for bias.
Such were my thoughts over the weekend as I got into a Twitter exchange with an advocate of integrative medicine who was touting the benefits of diet as a cancer preventative and how a course in nutrition “opened her eyes.” That in and of itself wasn’t particularly annoying, although I strongly suspect that the nutrition course she took was not given by actual registered dietitians or other experts in science-based nutrition (she wouldn’t say when questioned). What was annoying is that she trotted out some tropes beloved by integrative medicine proponents, such as the claim that most doctors don’t do prevention because they get paid to treat. She was called out for it:
.@DrKristieLeong "Not all docs emphasize prevention because they get paid to treat it." How else to interpret that? pic.twitter.com/5mMmpxGDKC
— Doc Bastard (@DocBastard) September 17, 2016
Oddly enough, on the same day a post from the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) came up in e-mail lists that discussed the actual evidence for the utility of diet and exercise for cancer prevention. It’s almost as though Twitter were telling me it was time for me to discuss this issue from a science-based perspective. So I will attempt to do so.
Diet and exercise versus cancer: The evidence
As I was in the middle of this Twitter exchange, which was much longer than most that I indulge in mainly because my wife was away for the day, I saw in my e-mail in box this article, Impact of Adherence to Cancer Prevention Guidelines on Diet, Physical Activity on Cancer Risk and Mortality (PDF). My first thought when reading this summary was that this is cool, something I need to read. My second thought was, given my recent Twitter exchange now would be a good time to blog about it. My third thought, which came as I went searching for the actual study, is why it took ASCO two months to feature the story, given that the actual study by Lindsay N. Kohler, MPH and co-authors had been published in July in Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention. I also noted that it came from the University of Arizona, which did raise red flags for me given that that is the home of the godfather of “integrative medicine,” Andrew Weil, but fortunately the systematic review came out of the Department of Nutritional Sciences and the Mel and Enid Zuckerman College of Public Health. That’s not to say that I wasn’t concerned somewhat, given that the Zuckerman College of Public Health made a deal last year with Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine to offer a dual-degree program for a naturopathic medical degree (ND) and a master’s degree in public health (MPH), slated to begin this term.
Still, I decided to take a look at the review on its merits. It begins with a discussion of existing dietary and exercise guidelines for health and cancer prevention developed by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services along with health organizations such as the American Cancer Society and the World Cancer Research Fund/American Institute for Cancer Research (WCRF/AICR). These cancer prevention and health promotion guidelines focus on specific lifestyle recommendations to
    • Achieve and maintain a healthy weight throughout life
    • Adopt a physically active lifestyle
    • Consume a healthy diet with an emphasis on plant-based foods
    • Limit alcohol consumption
Looking at the detailed ACS guidelines (lay version here) originally published in 2012 and the WCRF/AICR guidelines, I realize that I’m probably not doing so great. Granted, I recently started a concerted effort to alter my diet and lose about 20-25 lbs, which would bring me back to a pretty healthy weight, and to exercise by bicycling several miles five or more times a week, taking more brisk walks, and taking the stairs instead of the elevator more often, but I still am sedentary a lot and really have a hard time sticking to the more plant-based diet. In this, I rather suspect that I’m not unlike a lot of middle-aged guys whose jobs don’t involve physical labor.
My own personal difficulties grappling with trying to adopt a healthier lifestyle aside, Kohler et al sought to determine whether adherence to the ACS guidelines is associated with a decreased risk of cancer. In other words, do the guidelines work? To this end, they undertook a systematic review of the epidemiology literature, focusing only on prospective cohort studies. That means that the investigators followed the subjects in their cohorts only after they were enrolled in the study. Prospective studies are generally considered a higher level of evidence than retrospective studies (studies that look at patients in the past) because recall bias can be decreased, objective measurements can be taken in a standardized fashion, and the effect of confounders can be decreased. Here’s how the studies were chosen:
Only prospective cohort studies were eligible for inclusion, as the focus was to ascertain cancer incidence and cancer mortality. Minimally, studies must have collected data for physical activity and diet, generated an adherence score on the basis of either ACS or WCRF/AICR cancer prevention guidelines (2, 12), and reported cancer outcomes of incidence and/or mortality to be deemed eligible for this review. Overall cancer incidence and cancer mortality were the primary outcomes of interest. However, site-specific cancer risks were also considered when data were available from at least two studies meeting the eligibility criteria. Commentaries and summary documents were excluded unless they presented additional data.
Resulting in the following studies being chosen from the database databases the current recommendations of Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analysis Approach (PRISMA):
A total of 2,033 potentially relevant studies were reviewed; after removal of duplicates and exclusion on the basis of title or abstract, 25 full articles on nutrition and physical activity cancer prevention guideline adherence were retained for in-depth consideration. The selection process for the articles is shown in Fig. 1. We identified 12 articles that met the a priori criteria for inclusion (Table 1). These studies represented analyses of data from 10 cohorts including the Cancer Prevention Study-II (CPS-II) nutrition cohort (13), the Women’s Health Initiative (WHI) cohort (14), the NIH-American Association of Retired Persons (NIH-AARP) Diet and Health Study cohort (15), the Framingham Offspring (FOS) cohort (16), the Vitamins and Lifestyle (VITAL) Study cohort (17), the Canadian National Breast Screening Study (CNBSS; ref. 18), the Swedish Mammography Cohort (SMC; ref. 19), the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition (EPIC) cohort (20, 21), the Southern Community Cohort Study (SCCS; ref. 22), and the Iowa Women’s Health Study (IWHS) cohort (23).
Reviewing the 12 studies, Kohler et al found that high adherence to established nutrition and exercise guidelines was associated with decreases of 10% to 61% overall cancer incidence and mortality. The study finding the greatest reduction in risk was the analysis of the VITAL study by Hastert and colleagues, which found that meeting at least five recommendations from the WCRF/AICR guidelines compared with meeting none demonstrated a 61% reduction in cancer-specific mortality over 7.7 years of follow-up (HR, 0.39; 95% CI, 0.24–0.62). The study that showed the lowest decrease was a study utilizing the ACS guidelines including nearly a half a million men and women aged 50-71 years in the NIH-AARP Diet and Health Study. Basically, Kabat and colleagues reported a statistically significant decrease in cancer incidence over the 10.5 years of follow-up for both highly adherent men (HR, 0.90; 95% CI, 0.87–0.93) and women (HR, 0.81; 95% CI, 0.77–0.84). A statistically significant reduction in cancer mortality was also reported during the 12.6 years of follow-up for both highly adherent men (HR, 0.75; 95% CI, 0.70–0.80) and women (HR, 0.76; 95% CI, 0.70–0.83; ref. 27). In fact, here’s a table summarizing the studies (click to embiggen, if necessary):

Yes, the figures are all over the place, but there is a consistent association with adherence to the ACS or WCRF/AICR dietary guidelines with decreased overall incidence of and mortality from cancer. The variability can likely be explained by the differences in the cohorts (for instance, the NIH-AARP cohort consisted only of people over 50, an age when people enter the most cancer-prone period in their lives), how adherence scores were defined, and the like. But what about the effect of diet and exercise on individual cancers?
Diet and exercise versus individual cancers
The authors also looked at the effect of adherence to these diet and exercise recommendations on the incidence and risk of mortality from individual cancers, primarily breast, colorectal, lung, and endometrial cancer, because these are the cancers for which the most studies were available.
For breast cancer, there were eight studies reporting results for breast cancer. Kohler et al note that there were consistent reductions in breast cancer incidence reported in the WHI, NIH-AARP, and EPIC cohorts for high adherence to nutrition and physical activity cancer prevention guidelines versus low adherence, for a reduction in risk. Also, meeting at least five WCRF/AICR recommendations compared with meeting none was associated with a 60% reduction in breast cancer incidence. Overall, the reduction in risk associated with high adherence to guidelines compared to low adherence ranged from 19%–60%, although one of the studies did not reach statistical significance.
Results were similar, although there were fewer studies, for colorectal cancer and endometrial cancer. Basically four of these studies reported results for colorectal cancer specifically, with decreased risk of this disease found in the WHI cohort and the NIH-AARP cohort, as well as the EPIC cohort. The FOS cohort showed a trend towards decreased risk of colorectal cancer that did not reach statistical significance. Taken together, the four studies suggested a reduction in risk associated with adherence to diet and exercise guidelines ranging from 27%–52%. In the case of endometrial cancer, there were three studies that examined this cancer as an endpoint. Both the NIH-AARP and EPIC cohorts both found decreased risk associated with higher adherence to guidelines, and, again, there was one cohort (WHI) with a finding of decreased risk that did not reach statistical significance; the overall decrease in risk reported was 23%–60%.
Finally, the authors examined lung cancer. Of course, lung cancer is unique in that it is a cancer for which the main lifestyle cause is unequivocally known: smoking tobacco products. Although Kohler et al characterize the effect of adherence to diet and exercise guidelines on lung cancer risk as “equivocal,” my reading of the studies they report leads me to believe that adherence to the diet and exercise probably has little or no effect on the risk of lung cancer. This is not particularly surprising given how powerful the effect of smoking is on lung cancer risk and how uncommon lung cancer not associated with smoking is.
What did surprise me is that there was no association with prostate cancer incidence noted utilizing the ACS guidelines in the NIH-AARP cohort or the WCRF/AICR guidelines in the EPIC or FOS cohorts given that prostate cancer is one cancer commonly invoked as being preventable by diet. On the other hand, the diets touted for preventing prostate cancer are more extreme than those encompassed by the ACS and WCRF/AICR guidelines because they are usually vegan. The authors also found no reduction in risk associated with high adherence to diet and exercise guidelines versus low adherence for ovarian cancer.
Diet and exercise versus cancer: Putting it all together
Physicians have sought to identify modifiable risk factors for cancer for a very long time now, possibly as far back as Hippocrates. Of course, two such factors that rapidly rise to the top of any list for just about any disease must be diet and exercise, and, contrary to the frequent criticism of “conventional” medicine by those advocating “integrative” approaches, a great deal of research has been done examining the effects of various diets, exercise, and the like on the risk of cancer in general and of specific cancers. Unlike the case of drug therapies and other discrete treatments, it’s a lot harder to tease out the effects of diet and exercise on cancer risk because such studies take a lot of subjects (one of those cohorts has half a million subjects) and, because the most common cancers are generally diseases of aging, a long period of time. Moreover, while it’s possible to do a randomized controlled trial for many interventions, the complexities of diet make studying the effects of nutrition in such a manner very difficult. That’s not to say that it can’t be done. Indeed, it is being done, but the same problem exists: Lots of patients and lots of time are still required, which has led some to question whether RCTs are superior to prospective cohort studies for such interventions. The point, of course, is that physicians and scientists, contrary to the stereotype, have not been “ignoring” the role of diet in diseases like cancer. Quite the contrary.
This particular systematic review is touted as the first to examine dietary and physical activity cancer prevention guidelines and aggregate the effects on cancer outcomes reported by the existing scientific literature. As such, the authors note its strengths and weaknesses, which are worth quoting at length:
Strengths of this systematic review include strict inclusion criteria to include only prospective studies that constructed adherence scores to the established cancer prevention guidelines by ACS or WCRF/AICR. All of the studies contained sizeable cohorts with multiple years of follow-up leading to sufficient sample sizes, ample power to detect associations, and sufficient number of outcomes, enabling them to evaluate associations for some site-specific cancers. However, there are also some limitations that must be considered. First, all studies generated their own adherence scores on the basis of recommendations from either the ACS or WCRF/AICR. Most studies assigned points for meeting or partially meeting recommendations, whereas others categorized adherence as “met” or “did not meet” recommendations. Including multiple levels of exposure may better capture the degree of adherence to the guidelines. Although ACS and WCRF/AICR guidelines are very similar, interpretations of how to measure the recommendations varied. Notably, physical activity was assessed several ways including in metabolic equivalents, times per week, and even a physical activity index. Furthermore, studies utilized frequency questionnaires to capture diet and physical activity data. These self-reported measures are well-known sources of measurement error, which may bias findings toward the null, lending to conservative findings in this review. Components of the adherence score were measured singularly at baseline and used to assess cancer risk over time. Repeated measurements of diet and physical activity may have provided an improved exposure assessment of long-term behavior and risk over time. Follow-up times ranged from 7.7 to 14 years, which may not be sufficient for assessing the protective role of adherence to nutrition and physical activity cancer prevention guidelines. In addition, although the studies evaluated large cohorts, there was limited population heterogeneity with regard to race or ethnicity, with the exception of the WHI and SCCS studies. Furthermore, analyses varied somewhat among the studies. All studies evaluating associations with ACS guideline adherence made comparisons of high versus low adherence. One study used WCRF/AICR guidelines to compare “met” versus “did not meet” recommendations (29), whereas a single study evaluated adherence to WCRF/AICR guidelines on the basis of point increments of the overall score (36). Finally, the potential for publication bias is always of concern. Studies with significant findings are more likely to be published than those with null or unimportant findings. Grey literature was included in the search via Google Scholar in an attempt to capture any work that hasn’t been formally published (abstracts, conference proceedings, etc.). Even though the studies differed in some measurements of individual score components, construction of the adherence score, specifics of the set of guidelines used, and analytic methods, it is important to note that studies generally demonstrated agreement in their findings even across countries with varying diet and physical activity patterns.
You get the idea. The studies chosen were generally of high quality, but their methodologies for assessing adherence to the ACS and WCRF/AICR guidelines varied considerably. In actuality, to me the very fact that studies of such disparate groups using differing methods of assessment are all finding more or less the same thing tells me that the assessment by Kohler et al is likely pretty robust.
Another thing that has to be considered. This is a systematic review of a very specific question: Does adherence to the ACS and/or WCRF/AICR guidelines for diet and exercise (which, when you come down to it, are strongly similar) decrease the risk of being diagnosed with cancer and ultimately dying of cancer? The answer is yes, and we know at least some of the cancers affected: breast, colorectal, and endometrial cancers. We also know cancers for which adherence to these guidelines probably has little effect: lung, prostate, and ovarian cancers. Of course, this is a very limited number of the cancers that afflict human beings. It’s quite likely that diet and exercise impact the risk of many other cancers. However, this review doesn’t really address the effects of specific dietary and exercise interventions. It doesn’t, for instance, tell us if this food or that food, this nutrient or that nutrient, is associated with increased or decreased cancer risk. Those are different questions, and they are actually questions better suited to RCTs than the question that Kohler et al examined.
The reason proponents of integrative medicine claim so many non-surgical, non-pharmacological interventions is because, although inflated claims are often made for them, they can actually work, in contrast to the pseudoscientific treatments also “integrated” into medicine, such as acupuncture, traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), and the like. There’s a reason why we at SBM have at various times referred to diet, exercise, and other science-based lifestyle interventions co-opted by integrative medicine as a “Trojan horse,” particularly in academia. Once academia brings the nice, shiny “horse” of “non-pharmacological interventions” into its citadel, out jump the Greeks of quackery.None of this, however, means that diet and exercise aren’t powerful tools to promote health. Rather, it’s that they are and should remain part of science-based medicine, rather than being tainted by association with the quackery of integrative medicine. And there is a lot of science out there to support the important role of diet as a modulator of cancer risk.
Unfortunately, taking all the evidence together for individual foods, nutrients, exercise, and diet becomes devilishly complicated and contradictory, too. For example, do you remember John Ioannidis’ systematic review of existing scientific evidence associating specific foods with cancer? I do, as Steve Novella and I both blogged about it. Basically, Ioannidis examined 50 common ingredients at random out of cookbooks. He then scoured the literature looking for studies showing an association (positive or negative) with cancer and found that 80% of the ingredients had such studies, often with studies linking them to cancer and others showing a protective effect. As I said at the time, that’s why it’s important to aggregate data. Whenever it comes to studies of diet and virtually any health outcome, there is always a lot of noise.
There is a lot of noise in Kohler’s study, too, but the results are consistent. You can reduce your risk of cancer by staying active and exercising, eating a healthy diet with a lot of plant-based foods and minimizing intake of processed meats, limiting alcohol consumption (although I think the WCRF/AICR guidelines go a bit too far in saying that you shouldn’t drink at all if possible), and maintaining a healthy weight. (Of course, if you stay active and eat a healthy diet, maintaining a healthy weight will probably not be a problem.) Conceptually, it’s easy to do. In practice, as I’m discovering, it’s anything but easy.

A New Medication to Combat Obesity
New study in The New England Journal of Medicine finds impressive evidence that weekly semaglutide injections produce clinically significant weight loss as well as many other benefits, approaching the improvements seen with weight loss surgery. Not a definitive answer to obesity, but a very encouraging step in the right direction. Science works.
Harriet Hall on April 6, 2021
Link

Science works. The rapid development of COVID-19 vaccines is a case in point. Wouldn’t it be great if science found a safe and effective way for obese people to lose weight? We can hope, and we will have to wait for good evidence; but meanwhile, a new study in The New England Journal of Medicine is an encouraging sign that science is working on the problem and may eventually find a solution. “Once-Weekly Semaglutide in Adults with Overweight or Obesity” by Wilding et al. was published on March 18, 2021.
Previously available treatments
Obesity is a recognized health risk, but efforts to reverse obesity have been problematic. Diets and exercise work in the short term, but long-lasting weight loss is seldom achieved. Weight-loss surgery works but is drastic, risky, and requires lifelong nutritional supplementation.
There are various medications on the market. They are mostly prescription only, but sometimes available at a lower dose as over-the-counter meds (e.g. Alli). The use of medications has been limited by modest efficacy, safety concerns, and cost. A convenient table can be found here. Some highlights: orlistat (sold over-the-counter as Alli) causes diarrhea, gas, stomach pain, and leakage of oily stools, and rare cases of severe liver injury have been reported. Lorcaserin was withdrawn from the market in 2020 because of evidence that it increased the occurrence of cancers. Phentermine-topiramate (Osymia) has multiple side effects and may cause birth defects; there are many contraindications such as glaucoma or hyperthyroidism. Naltrexone-bupropion (Contrave) has a long list of side effects and contraindications and may increase the risk of suicide. Liraglutide (Saxenda) may increase the chance of developing pancreatitis.
The fen-phen disaster was a cautionary tale. It was a very popular weight loss drug until it was found to cause heart valve disease and pulmonary hypertension and was withdrawn from the market. There were over $13 billion in legal damages.
Innumerable dietary supplements are advertised to help people lose weight, but they are mostly untested or inadequately tested. When they do work, it’s usually because they contain unapproved stimulants like amphetamine analogues or ephedra.
The new study
Semaglutide is a treatment for diabetes. It comes in two forms: an oral 3mg tablet (Rybelsus) taken daily and a 0.25 mg subcutaneous injection (Ozempic) given once a week. Serendipity struck when clinicians discovered that people taking semaglutide lost weight, and they thought of repurposing it as a weight loss drug. After a phase 2 trial confirmed that it caused weight loss in type 2 diabetics and overweight adults, this new trial was designed to test the safety and efficacy of injecting 2.4mg once weekly.
It was a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial carried out at 129 sites in 16 countries in Asia, Europe, North America, and South America. Participants were 18 years of age or older who had one or more unsuccessful dietary efforts to lose weight and either a BMI of 30 or greater or a BMI of 27 or greater with one or more treated or untreated weight-related coexisting conditions. Diabetics were not eligible, nor were those who had had weight loss surgery or pancreatitis or had recently taken antiobesity medications.
Semaglutide was administered by prefilled pen injectors starting with 0.25 mg and gradually increasing to 2.4 mg. There were a total of 1,961 participants, 1,306 randomly assigned to receive semaglutide and 655 assigned to receive placebo. Most participants were female (74.1%) and white (75.1%). Mean age 46, mean body weight 105.3, mean BMI 37.9. 43.7% had prediabetes. In addition to the injections, all participants received individual counselling sessions every four weeks to help them adhere to a reduced-calorie diet and increased physical activity. The study lasted 68 weeks.
The results were dramatic. Body weight dropped by 14.9% with semaglutide compared to 2.4% with placebo. 86.4% of participants lost 5% or more of body weight with semaglutide compared to 31.5% with placebo. 69.1% of the semaglutide group lost 10% or more, compared to 12.0% of the placebo group. Semaglutide clearly produced clinically significant weight loss.
Concerns
Adverse events were more common in the semaglutide group (74.2% vs. 47.9%). Nausea, diarrhea, vomiting, and constipation were reported, but these were typically mild-to-moderate, transient, and resolved without discontinuing the regimen. Serious adverse events were reported in 9.8% of the semaglutide group and 6.4% of the placebo group. 7.0% of the semaglutide group and 3.1% of the placebo group discontinued treatment due to gastrointestinal events. Gallbladder-related disorders were reported in 2.6% of the semaglutide group vs. 3.1% of the placebo group.
Other benefits
In addition to weight loss, patients taking semaglutide had greater reductions in waist circumference, blood pressure, fasting plasma glucose, C-reactive protein, and fasting lipid levels. 84.1% of participants who had prediabetes reverted to normoglycemia with semaglutide, compared to 47.8% with placebo. Physical functioning also improved. There was a reduction in calorie intake due to decreased appetite. The benefits of semaglutide for weight and prediabetes approached the benefits seen in weight loss surgery.
Conclusion: a promising first step
This study is encouraging but far from definitive. An accompanying editorial characterized it as “a good beginning” but called for further studies, to include a comparison with weight loss surgery. There are no easy answers, but it’s good to know that scientists are working on the problem and making progress. I urge you to look at the detailed, careful evidence provided here and compare that to the lack of evidence or poor excuse for evidence for a typical CAM weight loss product. There’s no comparison.

Can “optimizing your metabolism” through diet prevent or cure COVID-19?
A favorite claim by those favoring “holistic” therapies is that using diet to “optimize metabolism” can prevent or treat COVID-19. These claims are of a piece with similar claims for many other diseases and are just as exaggerated.
David Gorski on August 31, 2020
Link

Since COVID-19 was officially declared a pandemic on March 11, unsurprisingly much of the material written for this blog has focused on the science and pseudoscience of COVID-19. In particular, we have covered medical misinformation, urban legends, astroturf disinformation campaigns, and conspiracy theories being spread in what is sometimes called a COVID-19 “infodemic”, as well as the regulatory and public health issues regarding proposed COVID-19 therapeutics and vaccines. However, there is one disturbing false (or at least highly distorted) narrative that we haven’t really addressed, at least not directly. I’m referring to a narrative that started very early on in the pandemic that nutrition and lifestyle can protect you against the coronavirus, or at least make it much less likely that you will develop life-threatening illness if you do “catch this cold“, as Del Bigtree so disturbingly and deceptively put it as he vastly understated the dangers posed by the virus and basically proposed leaving those at high risk for serious disease on their own during this pandemic. (I will be quoting him again later, near the end of this post.)
Of course, those inclined to distrust “Western medicine” and believe in so-called “alternative medicine”, or, as it’s increasingly called as it’s been infiltrating conventional medicine, “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine”, have long overemphasized the potential benefits of nutrition and lifestyle in preventing infectious diseases (or at least drastically ameliorating their symptoms to the point where they go from being potentially life-threatening to minor inconveniences that serve only to “strengthen the immune system”). Just as a reminder, I’ll cite an example over a decade ago during the H1N1 influenza pandemic. Then, HBO’s “politically incorrect” pundit Bill Maher, whom I had noticed spreading antivaccine talking points years before (and who’s still doing it), touted the benefits of nutrition and lifestyle and bragged that, because of it, he’d never catch the flu, even on an airplane. Indeed, Maher said, “I would never get the flu on an airplane”, presumably because his immune system is so healthy and, thanks to his lifestyle, there is no “swamp” there for the virus to breed in, leading his guest Bob Costas to retort in an exasperated voice, “Oh, come on, Superman!” (This was the best retort ever to Maher’s antivaccine nonsense, with the possible exception of Bill Frist basically calling him the “crazy person” when it comes to vaccine pseudoscience.)
Maher is just one of the more amusing examples of antivaxxers and quacks implying (or outright claiming) that nutrition can do a better job of preventing infectious disease than vaccines. I could quote many others, given that I’ve been following the antivaccine movement since the early 2000s. One particular favorite is a common antivaccine claim that, because children in Third World countries are much more likely to die when they contract measles than children in First World countries, nutrition and sanitation are far more important in preventing measles than vaccines, the idea being that better nutrition makes for a “stronger immune system”. Basically, it’s a good example of how antivaxxers take a pebble of truth (certainly poor nutrition does impact the immune system) and try to turn it into a boulder of an unsupported claim or outright lie (e.g., that nutrition can do as well or better, in “strengthening the immune system” to prevent infectious diseases, than vaccines).
It’s not just infectious diseases, either. This fetishization of nutrition and food above all permeates not just the antivaccine movement but all of alternative medicine. Indeed, when alternative practitioner Toni Bark developed a deadly cancer, the cognitive dissonance was such that her son had to admit that she developed her cancer even though she had lived what he considered to be an incredibly healthy lifestyle and consumed a vegan diet. (Yes, there is considerable victim blaming among the “nutrition cures everything” crowd.) A corollary of the “food as medicine” mindset is a persecution complex, in which advocates like to claim that any suggestion that food can cure or prevent disease is dismissed by nasty scientists and skeptics as “quackery”. (It’s not; only overblown claims for the medical benefits of foods, nutrients, diet, and lifestyle are so dismissed.)
So it should be no surprise that similar claims are being made regarding COVID-19 and have been since very early in the pandemic, including claims that vitamin C (of course!) or an “alkaline diet” (double of course!) can treat or cure COVID-19.
Which brings me to an article reviewing a book by Dr. Asseem Malhotra, The 21 Day Immunity Plan:
Winter is coming and the current spate of Coronavirus-related news is not encouraging: the pandemic is ravaging Europe, efficient cures are still just over the horizon, and many are prophesizing that the second wave will hit us even harder than the first one. But amidst this doom and gloom, Dr. Aseem Malhotra’s book, The 21 Day Immunity Plan (1), is a much needed breath of fresh air.
Malhotra is a familiar name for European Scientist readers – in one of our most read articles of the year, Covid-19 and the elephant in the room, Dr. Malhotra excoriated the mainstream media for their failure to notice the role nutrition has in the outcome of Covid-19 cases. Obesity, diabetes, and other metabolic diseases led to increased hospitalization rates, overwhelming the NHS:
The government public health message enhanced by the media to stay at home, protect the NHS and save lives has been powerful and effective. Given the speed at which health markers for metabolic disease improve from dietary interventions, an equally strong if not more significant population health message should now be to “eat real food, protect the NHS and save lives.”
Driving that point home, Malhotra has now followed up on this story with a solid 21-day program on how to optimise the immune fonction [sic].
To see where this is going, let’s first look at what we know about the factors that predispose to death or serious illness from COVID-19.
COVID-19 risk factors
Since the earliest major outbreak of COVID-19 in Wuhan, China, doctors have recognized certain risk factors that portended a higher likelihood of life-threatening illness and death from SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. Many of these risk factors have been confirmed over and over again in multiple studies in multiple countries.
Unmodifiable risk factors for death from COVID-19
The first—and by far the strongest—risk factor for serious disease and death due to coronavirus is unchangeable. Specifically, it is age. It has been known since very early on in the pandemic that, the older you are, the more likely you are to die if you contract COVID-19—and not by a little. The CDC has published a handy-dandy guide that tells you how much higher or lower your risk of death due to the virus is compared to the reference group (18-29 year olds). There is a dramatic increase in the risk of hospitalization and death with rising age, going from a 2x higher risk of hospitalization and 4x higher risk of death for 30-39 year olds to a 13x higher risk of hospitalization and 630x higher risk of death in those 85 years of age or older:

In terms of absolute numbers, the reported case fatality rates (CFRs, or the risk of dying if you develop symptomatic COVID-19) range from 13%-20% for those over 80.
A recent study from PNAS shows this age effect most starkly:
In terms of infection fatality rate (IFR), which includes all infections, including the asymptomatic, we know this
For every 1,000 people infected with the coronavirus who are under the age of 50, almost none will die. For people in their fifties and early sixties, about five will die — more men than women. The risk then climbs steeply as the years accrue. For every 1,000 people in their mid-seventies or older who are infected, around 116 will die. These are the stark statistics obtained by some of the first detailed studies into the mortality risk for COVID-19.
And:
“COVID-19 is not just hazardous for elderly people, it is extremely dangerous for people in their mid-fifties, sixties and seventies,” says Andrew Levin, an economist at Dartmouth College in Hanover, New Hampshire, who has estimated that getting COVID-19 is more than 50 times more likely to be fatal for a 60-year-old than is driving a car.
This preprint quantifies the risk. (Note that preprints are not yet peer reviewed.)
Another major risk factor for death is also unchangeable in that sex also matters. Men have a significantly higher risk of dying from COVID-19 than do women, as also shown in the preprint:
A recent correspondence in The Lancet suggests, though, that the relationship is not straightforward:
The overall male to female mortality sex ratio per 100,000 population was 1·4 (crude ratio 1·3). This ratio was not equal at all ages. For example, for people aged 0–9 years the ratio was 0·81. The ratio was 1·9 in the 40–49 years age group, 2·3 in the 50–59 year age group, 2·6 in the 60–69 years age group, and 1·65 in people older than 80 years (appendix p 1).
There was some variation across countries, although broadly the pattern was similar, and the numbers became too small for clear-cut interpretation (appendix p 3).
These data alter our understanding of male–female differences; the relationship is not straightforward, and efforts should now be made to understand risk based on the interaction of sex and age, along with other factors.
Unsurprisingly, ethnicity also plays a role. Of course, it can be difficult to separate socioeconomic factors from ethnicity, but we do know that there is a considerable racial and ethnic gap in terms of COVID-19 mortality, with Black people suffering death rates twice as high as white people, and Hispanic/Latino people somewhere in between. There is also evidence that Native American and Alaska Native people are at higher risk of death and severe disease as well.
Of course, we’re still early in our experience with COVID-19, and it will take considerably more research to tease out the reasons for elevated risk of severe disease and death in various populations. My point here is that there are at least two major risk factors that are not modifiable (sex and age) and at least one that might not be modifiable (race, if the increased risk is truly due to race and not more due to comorbidities and social forces that disproportionately affect Black populations and other minorities). No matter whether risk of death from COVID-19 can be decreased by “metabolic optimization” or not, if you’re 80 years old you’ll still be many, many times more likely to die of COVID-19 than if you’re 20 years old.
Modifiable risk factors for COVID-19
Another observation that was made early in the pandemic is that a number of chronic comorbid conditions correlate strongly with the risk of severe disease and death from COVID-19. Currently, these conditions include:
    • Cancer
    • Chronic kidney disease
    • COPD (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease)
    • Immunocompromised state (weakened immune system) from solid organ transplant
    • Obesity (body mass index [BMI] of 30 or higher)
    • Serious heart conditions, such as heart failure, coronary artery disease, or cardiomyopathies
    • Sickle cell disease
    • Type 2 diabetes mellitus
It’s also suspected that these conditions also predispose to severe disease from COVID-19:
    • Asthma (moderate-to-severe)
    • Cerebrovascular disease (affects blood vessels and blood supply to the brain)
    • Cystic fibrosis
    • Hypertension or high blood pressure
    • Immunocompromised state (weakened immune system) from blood or bone marrow transplant, immune deficiencies, HIV, use of corticosteroids, or use of other immune weakening medicines
    • Neurologic conditions, such as dementia
    • Liver disease
    • Pregnancy
    • Pulmonary fibrosis (having damaged or scarred lung tissues)
    • Smoking
    • Thalassemia (a type of blood disorder)
    • Type 1 diabetes mellitus
As you can see, these are a mixture of unmodifiable and potentially modifiable diseases and conditions. For instance, if you have cancer, chronic kidney disease, sickle cell disease, thalassemia, type 1 diabetes, or dementia, medical control can be optimized, but these can’t be reversed. The interesting question arises for conditions and diseases that can be impacted by lifestyle and nutrition, such as hypertension, obesity, and type 2 diabetes, the focus of the claims made by Dr. Malhotra.
Who is Dr. Aseem Malhotra?
Upon looking into his claims, I realized that I didn’t recall having ever heard of Dr. Malhotra before. It turns out that he appears (to me, at least) to be the UK equivalent to Dr. Mehmet Oz, a celebrity doctor known for promoting all sorts of dubious medicine, particularly diet advice. A quick search of this blog revealed that I had mentioned him before, as I had quoted him trying to explain away negative data on hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19. At the time, I had no idea of his reputation; so mea culpa.
In any event, Dr. Malhotra is a British consultant cardiologist best known for promoting a low-carb, high-fat fad diet known as the Pioppi diet, a diet that earned the “honor” of being named one of “Top 5 worst celeb diets to avoid in 2018” by the British Dietetic Association, along with the ketogenic diet, nutritional supplements, and a number of other fad diets, which characterized it as, in essence, a tarted up version of the Mediterranean diet that “recommends a higher fat diet than the traditional Mediterranean one” and notes that “adherents are encouraged to eat lots of vegetables, nuts, legumes, and fish and discouraged from eating red meat, starchy carbs, and sweetened treats.” It also encourages 24-hour fasting. Dr. Malhotra is also very much in the anti-processed sugar camp, having characterized sugar as “enemy number one in the Western diet.” To give you an idea of how anti-sugar he is, he recently made headlines by attacking Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust for accepting a gift of 1,500 Krispy Kreme doughnuts sent to the staff as a gift for their work in dealing with the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK in March and April:
Absolutely disgraceful. Feeding junk food to already overweight and obese #NHS staff? I will forward this to CEO of @NHSEngland Simon Stevens personally and I can assure you he won’t be impressed especially as THESE foods a root cause of increased death rates from #COVID19 https://t.co/zAkIsyMJL4
— Dr Aseem Malhotra (@DrAseemMalhotra) April 22, 2020
And I’m going to tell your mother! Amusingly, Dr. Malhotra was dragged hard for his remark (and deservedly so!), as you will see if you click on the Tweet above and look at the responses, although there were also people who bought into this demonization of doughnuts.
Dr. Malhotra also seems to argue that modern medicine does more harm than good treating chronic conditions with medications, channeling Peter Gøtzsche in claiming that “too much medicine can kill you.” Of course, it is not in itself unreasonable to criticize too much medical intervention, but to me a brief perusal of Dr. Malhotra’s oeuvre gave off a seriously disturbing vibe that medicine doesn’t do any good for chronic illness. Unsurprisingly, he is a statin denialist, even having gone so far as to suggest that stopping statins might save more lives and that statins might not benefit anyone.
You get the idea.
So what is Dr. Malhotra arguing? I haven’t read his book, although the review makes plain that it’s basically a repackaging of his promotion of the Pioppi diet. Of course, any book called The 21 Day Immunity Plan that implies that you can basically “fix” your immune system with diet in 21 days is going to draw a lot of skepticism, and rightly so. For instance, how does he justify 21 days? Why not 30 days? Why not 14 days? Why not 60 days? According to the credulous review:
Of course, one will question the arbitrary choice of 21 days. Why would three weeks be enough? Well, as it happens, the number 21 is explained at length by the author, who refers to numerous studies (4) as well as his first-hand experience with the program. In the context of the book, this is justified by good pragmatic reasons such as:
    • For most people it takes three weeks to break any habit, or for many what is a form of addiction to sugar and ultra-processed food. »
    • Most people with adverse metabolic health will start to see marked improvements to their health and/or shape albeit to different degrees within three weeks, without having to count calories. »
    • It is the need to change the narrative around the impact of lifestyle changes and show that their effect on health can be rapid and substantial. We should use this to motivate ourselves to continue to reap the benefits of improved health for life.
What’s Reference 4? Jean-Paul Oury, the reviewer, cites two studies without links or references to them:
A previous diet and exercise study carried out by researchers at the University of California involving 31 participants also revealed reversal of metabolic syndrome in 50 per cent of those that followed a low-fat, high-fibre diet combined with 45–60 mins of moderate intensity exercise per day. Markers of insulin resistance improved but again there was no correlation with weight loss suggesting an independent benefit on metabolic health. Similar rapid improvements in markers of metabolic health with reversal of metabolic syndrome in all participants were observed in a trial involving 7 obese children from a diet and exercise program within 21 days.
31 participants? Seven obese children? These are not particularly large studies. As for Dr. Malhotra’s “first hand experience with the program”, you know what they say about anecdotes…
Still, one has to consider the possibility that, history of overblown claims for the dangers of processed sugar and pharmaceutical medicine and the benefits of a specific fad diet aside, it’s possible Dr. Malhotra could have a point. In fact, he probably does have a germ of a good point. It’s clearly just massively exaggerated.
Can “metabolic optimization” prevent or treat coronavirus?
The first thing to realize here is that, if you’re obese (particularly if you’re morbidly obese), losing weight is a good thing for your health. Even if it doesn’t do a thing to decrease your risk of life-threatening COVID-19, reaching a healthier weight can decrease your risk of any of a number of complicating conditions, including hypertension, heart disease, type 2 diabetes, certain cancers, stroke, fatty liver disease, and more. There is no doubt that losing weight to come closer to a healthy weight range is associated with improvements in many of these conditions, especially type 2 diabetes and hypertension, which can sometimes be reversed by weight loss to the point where medication is no longer necessary.
At the risk of “going anecdotal”, I know that this can be true. Over about a two to three year period, I changed my diet and started exercising regularly, ultimately losing 50 lbs. As a result, the dose of blood pressure medicine that I need to keep my blood pressure under control has declined markedly, and I might even be able to get off of blood pressure medicines altogether. (We’ll see. Given that I’m now at my target weight, with a BMI in the “normal”—whatever that means—range, I might well have maximized my benefit on that score, and my family history doesn’t bode well for my ever getting completely off of blood pressure medication.) Similarly, I might well be able to get off of statins, as my total, LDL, and HDL cholesterol levels are quite acceptable now. (As an aside, I look at studies suggesting that ACE inhibitors might decrease the risk of life-threatening COVID-19, and I wonder if I want to be off my ACE inhibitor altogether or not while the pandemic is still raging.)
The bottom line is that we have no strong evidence yet that “metabolic optimization” will decrease the risk of severe COVID-19, although it is certainly scientifically plausible that weight loss to bring oneself out of the obese range could well help. It’s also undeniable that weight loss and exercise are good things for one’s general health if one is obese, and that a healthier diet can impact type 2 diabetes, hypertension, and other chronic “lifestyle diseases”. On the other hand, it is possible that it might be that treating the “root causes” of metabolic syndrome might not lead to a decreased risk of severe COVID-19, a scenario that could happen if the “root cause” of metabolic syndrome leads to metabolic syndrome through a different mechanism from the one by which it increases the risk of severe COVID-19. Basically, we just don’t know yet. Moreover, where Dr. Malhotra goes wrong is in touting a fad diet as The One True Diet to fix one’s immunity in three weeks, a claim for which there is no good evidence. For example, how do we know his diet is a more effective, healthier way to “metabolic optimization” compared to all the other “healthy diets” out there? We don’t.
It’s particularly irritating to see these sorts of statements:
Dr. Aseem Malhotra : The best vaccine against Coronavirus is optimising metabolic health https://t.co/mWbew8aaER
— Dr. Jason Fung (@drjasonfung) August 28, 2020
In particular, there’s a distinct possibility of this:
More importantly, “optimizing metabolic health” takes time. It’s highly unlikely that 21 days would make a significant difference in decreasing your risk of severe COVID-19, and it’s unhealthy to lose weight too quickly. (We don’t know, but it’s not at all implausible that rapid weight loss could potentially actually be another factor for severe COVID-19.) It’s generally advised that you shouldn’t lose more than a pound or two per week. If you’re 25 lbs. overweight, that’s 12-25 weeks to get down to your target weight. Obviously, if you’re more overweight than that, it will be longer. Losing weight and changing your diet is also very, very hard. Many people can’t do it, or at least they have a lot of difficulty doing it. The reason I could do it is that I had several advantages, including:
    • I have money.
    • I don’t live in a food desert, where calorie-rich fast food is a main food source and it’s difficult to find vegetables, fruits, and other healthier choices for food.
    • I can arrange my schedule so that I have time for exercise.
    • I have a supportive wife.
    • And many others.
Not everyone has these advantages.
There’s another pernicious aspect to this narrative. Even if nutrition could prevent coronavirus, Dr. Malhotra’s is a very privileged position that basically excludes those unable to “optimize metabolic health”. These “nutrition cures and prevents #COVID19” people labor under a delusion of privilege in that they have the time, resources, and luxury to “optimize their metabolism”. There’s also a subtext of victim blaming where it’s your fault if you get sick because you didn’t “optimize your nutrition”. And, make no mistake, victim blaming is rampant among these “nutrition prevents/cures COVID-19” propagandists. Indeed, Del Bigtree did just that when he urged his presumably “healthy” listeners to “catch this cold“. That’s why I’m going to quote him again extensively:
What is the group that is really at risk? Let’s be honest about this and say something that might get me some trouble here, but let’s be honest. That group is very well known. It’s people over the age of 65—not just because you’re over the age of 65, but you’re sick with other diseases. You have heart disease. You have COPD. You have diabetes. You have issues, many of those issues coming from the fact that you didn’t treat your body very well while you were on this planet. And I want to talk about this for one minute as we close this down. That 0.26% are the most sick among us, and I have nothing against you. Go ahead and bubble wrap your house. Lock yourself in your basement. Go and do what’s necessary.
But here’s the problem. When you were my age, you were most likely eating food and fast food and Doritos and drinking Coca-Cola, which you’ll never find in my home. You were eating that all the time. You probably were drinking a lot of alcoholic beverages and really liked to party and enjoyed your cigarettes and said to yourself, “You know what? It’s more about the quality of my life right now. I don’t care if I live to be 100 years old. I want to enjoy my life right now. I like the finer things in life. I like good rich food. I like smoking a cigarette once in a while. I like to drink my drinks.” And you know what? Good on you! That’s the United States of America. No problem, that, some of my best friends think like that. It’s great, and they’re fun to hang out with. That’s perfectly OK.
But here’s what’s not OK. When you reach that point in your life where now your arteries are starting to clog up, your body is shutting down, and the alcohol is eating up your liver, and you have diabetes, or you have COPD, you have asthma, you can’t breathe, all the cigarette smoking has finally caught up with you, you have heart disease because of the way you decided to live your life in the moment, here’s what you are now. You are pharmaceutical-dependent. You did that to yourself, not me. You decided that the moment mattered, and now you find yourself pharmaceutical-dependent, which is really what that 0.26% is, and that’s OK too. Thank God there’s drugs out there! There’s drugs that allow you to eat the Philly cheesesteak even though your body knows it hates it, but, go ahead, take the Prilosec. What difference does it make? Drug yourself! Drug yourself! Get through the day! Don’t exercise! Maybe just attach an electrode and see if a little electricity to the stomach will give you the abs you want.
Come on! Grow up! You made choices! And now that you’re pharmaceutically dependent, here’s what you don’t get to do. You don’t get to say I have to take a drug to protect you. That’s what this is. You don’t get to say I have to wear a mask and suck in my own CO2 to protect you. You don’t get to say I have to lock myself in a basement and destroy my career and take away my own ability to feed children because you are pharmaceutical dependent. You lived your life. You made your choice. And thank God we live in the United States of America so you don’t have to worry about grocery police standing outside a grocery store saying, “Really? You really need four liters of Coca-Cola? You really need four bags of Doritos or Chitos or Fritos or whatever the heck it is, little cupcakes with synthetic icing on them? You really need all that?” Because we could go there. We could go there. If we’re really going to get into each other’s schiznit, that’s what we could do.
Or could we live and let live? Eat all the Twinkies you want! Drink all the bourbon you want, and smoke as many cigarettes as you want, and when you find yourself pharmaceutical-dependent I will go ahead and say thank God the drug companies are there for you, but you do not get to make me pharmaceutical-dependent. You do not get to put me in the way of Heidi Larson, who wants to eradicate natural health and natural immunity and make us all pharmaceutical dependent.
Again, make no mistake. Dr. Malhotra’s message is simply a more genteel, less obviously judgmental version of the message that Del Bigtree is promoting. As I mentioned when I first dealt with Bigtree’s message, I once coined a term, the central dogma of alternative medicine, to describe the belief that we have near-total control over our health through lifestyle, such as diet, activity, exercise, and a Secret-like belief that wishing makes it so. It never seems to occur to them that age is a major risk factor for death from COVID-19 and that people can’t do anything about how old they were when the pandemic hit, nor can older men like myself do anything about the fact that we were older men when the pandemic hit.
Certainly, a healthy weight, exercising, eating a healthy diet are all good things for your health. Who knows? They might even lower your risk of severe COVID-19. However, don’t be fooled by overblown claims for what they’ll do for your risk of COVID-19, and don’t forget the judgmental implications behind advice like that promoted by Dr. Malhotra. He’ll deny it to high heaven, of course, and maybe he personally doesn’t intend to be judgmental, but judgment is there nonetheless.

I Used To Be a Holistic Nutritionist
Up until a year ago, I was a practicing holistic nutritionist. As someone who has left that world behind, I have a moral obligation to do what is right – and what is right is to denounce my former beliefs in an industry rife with deception.
Denby Royal on April 27, 2018
Link

[Editor’s note: SBM welcomes a guest contribution from Denby Royal, a former holistic nutritionist who has since left woo behind. Her story appears here as an updated and expanded version of a blog post from her website. Welcome Denby!]

As someone who has spent the better part of the last decade in the wellness realm, I have a moral obligation to do what is right. And what is right is to denounce my former beliefs, condemning an industry rife with deception.
The thing that led me to become a holistic nutritionist in the first place was my innate ability to doubt and criticize absolutely everything around me – a trait I believed I had well sharpened. Turns out, the honed sword of scrutiny I was wielding had morphed into a balloon sword. Squeaky, probably pink, and 100% imaginary. But here I was, nature-timing, walking barefoot, preaching organic, and not wearing deodorant, all the while brandishing my balloon sword in the face of all those who would listen.
Coconut oil! Squeak, squeak!Pesticides! Squeak!Toxins! SQUEAK! SQUEAK!
Then one day, my beloved balloon sword popped in my face.
How did this turn of events come to pass? It’s a bit of a convoluted story that I am still trying to understand. I can’t quite pin it down to one specific moment but can credit it to a series of events that dominoed my ideals. One of the first few dominos was likely laid by a ridiculous and nonsensical magazine in my local community; one of those publications full of snake oil, faith healers, Flat Earthers, and conspiracies about pretty much everything you can imagine (did you know mountains are actually just giant tree stumps?!). I was even asked to contribute my own brand of nonsense. I managed one interview before I couldn’t visualize myself being dragged any further under the hippy bus.
How the rest of the dominos fell
Another step in my development in critical thinking was a brief stint at a health food store. It was while working there I became gravely aware of the breadth and dark depths of the supplement industry. An insight, all too familiar to the readership of SBM, into a world of quackery and woo where a multi-billion-dollar supplement industry hides its lack of science and evidence from the world. An unregulated industry that definitely fooled me into believing that they have the tools to save us, peddling the sales pitch of “natural”, “holistism”, and “well-being” that portrays itself as more honest than what’s offered through mainstream medicine but is, in fact, full of dishonest products that either lack evidence or are straight-up scams. There, I was an active participant to a whole host of alternative tomfoolery and supplement-pushing to a clientele of the “Worried Well” who mistook me and my fellow employees for experts. But in reality we were just regurgitating, with the best of intent, the rubbish spewed by quacks like Joe Mercola and Silicon Valley scamsters like Dave Asprey. Beyond the pamphlets preaching the ketogenic diet and shelves of flashy boxes of cleanses and overpriced bottles of unverifiable mushroom tinctures lay the final domino to topple the queue: homeopathic remedies. In an effort to expand my product knowledge I did research on the different remedies available. I used all the best bias-confirming websites and got to work. Quickly, I found that I had fallen for the greatest weapon that homeopathy has, which is the fact that no one really has any clue what it is. But once I landed on a video by James Randi, my world crumbled like a dry piece of raw gluten-free paleo cake. Without question, I had fallen for the false language of pseudoscience where a morsel of real medicine is blended with enough nonsense and conviction to fool so many people.
Another domino was definitely placed by social media (we are all already familiar with the bubble-world of selective representation). Sometimes we find ourselves morphing into a strange amalgamation of social media influencers; people who seem to embody the exact ideals we visualize our own avatars becoming. A weird thing that happened to me, and I am sure has happened to others, was a transformation in real life, into the person the internet wanted me to be. Not necessarily the person I wanted to become, but an identity that was shaped by likes and demanded by the comment section. A world full of beautifully curated Instagram accounts of skinny yogis gathering wild herbs or making raw quiche. It’s extremely surreal to look back at photos of myself during this time. Come on, Royal, what were you thinking? Well, you weren’t necessarily thinking for yourself, that’s for sure.
I graduated from the Dunning-Kruger School of Natural Nutrition*
I will not wait until the men in white coats with their white hats tell me what I can see every day to be truth.– Dr. Richard Mackarness, as quoted from the school’s website
*Not its real name.
During the brief education I received to become a holistic nutritionist, I was provided with a few valuable stepping stones to initiate a general understanding of how the body works – an understanding that wholeheartedly fell short of anything close to authority on the subject of health. We spent 27 in-class hours on the pathology of disease, and 30 combined hours on anatomy and physiology. And let’s not forget the whopping 12 hours dedicated to cellular biology! Consider these courses in relation to the 27 hours spent studying the mind, body, and spirit connection (yep, you guessed it, it involved chakras, human energy fields, and intuition), touted as being an evidence-based domain. During the 33 hours devoted to symptomatology, we learned the basic guidelines for detoxing—an updated course description now mentions the guidelines for fasting —with a heavy emphasis on recommending foods that are natural, alive, and organic. And of course, there was plenty of demonization of GMOs and pesticides, and underlying, yet not necessarily mentioned, opposition to vaccination (not officially instructed in the course, but the subject was addressed as a group discussion where personal options and anecdotes were given more weight than any science).
The most valuable course offered at the Dunning-Kruger School of Natural Nutrition was the incredibly compact six-hour course of Nutritional Literature Research. This course looked at methods for assessing nutritional literature for credibility, accuracy, and biases. I don’t know about you, but I’ve likely spent more time inadvertently watching ZDoggMD videos on Youtube. That being said, the information I did get out of the literature research course stuck with me and helped pull me out of the pile of organic manure I was buried in for so long. But I can’t say this for many others who share my miseducation. A quick internet search can draw several examples of holistic practitioners preaching far beyond their scope of practice. In my country, many holistic nutritionists define their role as a practitioner with the ability to help clients in a wider role than that of a registered dietitian because they are self-regulated and thus unbound by science or evidence. This definition is in itself a demonstration of the lack of credibility and the cognitive bias rampant in an industry of delusional superiority. A generally accepted creed within the wellness world is that holistic nutritionists, being independent from evidence-based science, are akin to crusaders of ancient teachings that the evil scientists have deemed invalid or unworthy of attention. It’s their destiny to dismantle Big Pharma with love and light while bypassing the role of the scientific method with manifestations and coffee enemas – all with a clear cognitive disconnect from how the supplement industry actually functions.
What did I ultimately learn?
There is a reason why holistic nutritionists are legally prohibited from saying words like “treat”, “heal”, “prevent”, or “cure”, and that is because they are light-years away from being capable of even understanding what that truly entails. With what I do have from my quasi-education I can pick apart a lifestyle that needs some fine-tuning and provide guidance on how to structure a solid meal plan. That’s it. I can neither diagnose the metaphysical blockage on your thyroid nor can I detox your liver (spoiler alert: no one can). Within the limited duration of my education I developed a knowledge base that qualifies me to be only marginally closer to being a medical professional than I am to becoming a professional cricket player.
The cardinal (and rather simple) rules for nurturing a healthy human were not omitted from the curriculum: addressing sleep, recommending a variety of foods, stress management, and regular exercise. As Britt Hermes has said about her education as a naturopath: there is just enough actual science to make all the woo seems credible. By peppering a bit of pathology into the hearty dose of New Age nonsense like chakras and reiki, we thought we were gaining the tools to change lives for the better. We believed that it was the holistic world alone that possesses vital knowledge of diet and exercise, which was (allegedly) dismissed by impersonal doctors.
In total, my entire education as a holistic nutritionist took a mere ten months. Following this, I was permitted to start taking clients immediately. No residency or clinical hours were required to prepare us for the real world and interactions with real patients. Unlike registered dieticians here in Canada, who must obtain a bachelor’s degree in Nutritional Sciences and qualify to complete a 40-week internship or get a Master’s degree, my entire education as a holistic nutritionist took only 10 months. We received a certificate, and that was that. A piece of paper showcasing our ten months of nutritional know-how.
After years of self-diagnosis and preaching all my fad-diet escapades (for this, I greatly apologize to everyone I have alienated with my self-righteousness) I cannot express how deep of an appreciation I have for those on the front lines in the fight against pseudoscience, who attempt to mitigate the damage it does to real medicine. The influence of pseudoscience is not harmless and I have seen firsthand how it lures people away from evidence-based help in their times of need. I am fortunate enough that within my practice I had enough foresight to turn away individuals who required more assistance than I was capable of giving. But along the way I made many embarrassing and conjectural recommendations that cost myself, and others, far too much money and time.
The woo delusion
When I could no longer accept the world I had dedicated my career and identity to, I made the difficult decision to leave the Church of Woo. It was an ego-crushing experience to burst my own self-righteous bubble and to let go of the person I had become through a mix ignorance, misinformation, and a misguided desire to be different. I wouldn’t wish the moments of isolation I endured on anyone. I was already on a long journey of self-doubt and insecurity when I finally came across this website, along with others; a corner of the internet outside of my presiding algorithms where I found a vast world of skeptics who have been wielding swords of scrutiny for decades in the defence of science. It was similar to first reading Richard Dawkins fresh out of years of a Catholic high school education. I realized then that I wasn’t crazy and that I could find validation for the doubts that plagued my self-confidence.
Initially, and after a lot of hesitation, I wrote about my decision to leave the wellness world on my personal blog. Many of the comments included the tired accusation that I am just a ‘corporate shill’ for Big Pharma —though I would gladly accept a cheque from Pfizer, just saying— or a series of straw man arguments that I might as well start smoking cigarettes. What greatly outweighed all of this nonsense were the many comments I received from fellow holistic nutritionists, many of whom have experienced the same sense of contempt toward their limited education or have witnessed the lack of respect and understanding for real science that runs rampant in the industry. Above all else, it was the overwhelming support that I found from friends and strangers in the wellness community, who I greatly feared I would alienate, which was a far more purgative experience than any quacky cleanse on the market.

Guess who pioneered chemoprevention through diet?
Jann Bellamy on December 24, 2015
Link


This is an expansion of a post I did over on the Society for Science-Based Medicine blog about this time last year. The original post, which got far more traffic than is usual for the SFSBM, is a good example of how science works and the good that it can do. The hard work of real science illustrated here serves as a striking counterpoint to the slap-dash system of pseudoscience, which churns out fake diseases, causes, and cures by the dozen based on a fuzzy understanding of real science fueled by a healthy dose of imagination.
Naturopaths and “functional medicine” practitioners would have the public believe that they are the true experts on nutrition and health. Even though their nutritional advice contains a large serving of hooey and a big helping of dietary supplements, which they are happy to sell to patients.
So it was with great interest that I read the obituary of Dr. Lee Wattenberg in the New York Times.
Dr. Wattenberg published a landmark paper in the journal Cancer Research that reviewed 36 years of animal studies on the effects that certain compounds had on the development of cancer. The paper laid the framework for understanding how these compounds work. . . .
He showed that cabbage, brussel sprouts, cauliflower and broccoli inhibit the development of carcinogens. He isolated a compound in garlic that decreased “by a factor of three” the chances that animals injected with cancer agents would develop that cancer. He found two chemicals in coffee that neutralize free radicals, which are harmful chemicals commonly implicated in the onset of cancer.
Who was Lee Wattenberg?
Was he a naturopath? A functional medicine practitioner? No, Wattenberg was a medical doctor and his pioneering paper was published in 1966, almost 50 years ago. Long before functional medicine appeared on the scene, Wattenberg was researching the effect of diet on cancer prevention.
So was Wattenberg assailed by his colleagues as an apostate, a renegade who might destroy the medical profession’s alleged lucrative devotion to treating cancer with the tools of Big Pharma and surgery? Not at all. He was, according to the American Association for Cancer Research, “revered by his colleagues in the cancer field as a self-effacing leader.”
Wattenberg served on the Board and as president of that organization, where he was elected a Fellow. He received a number of awards from organizations devoted to fighting cancer and cancer research. For 60 years, Wattenberg was a faculty member at the University of Minnesota medical school and published many papers in the medical literature.
According to the obituary,
His interest was in helping to prevent cancer, and in a statement after his death, the American Association for Cancer Research called him the “father of chemoprevention.” . . .
“About two-thirds of all cancers are preventable,” Margaret Foti, the association’s current chief executive, said in the statement. “Because of Lee Wattenberg’s dedication to and belief in the promise of cancer prevention, the field has taken its rightful place as one of the most important areas of cancer research.”
Isn’t that something? The CEO of a respected medical research organization is talking about prevention, right there in the Times. Prevention through diet, no less. And saying it is an important area of cancer research! Doesn’t look like the stereotypical picture of medicine the pseudoscientific diet wizards try to sell. Doesn’t appear that medicine is solely interested in treating the disease rather than the “whole person,” as integrative medicine proponents would have us believe. Frankly, it appears to be – dare I say it? – positively “holistic” to me.
However, as is always true in scientific inquiry, not all of his hypotheses panned out.
Dr. Wattenberg and others once hoped that beta carotene, a substance found in carrots, squash and other vegetables, would help prevent cancer. But in clinical trials, beta carotene was found to increase the risk of lung cancer. Similarly, vitamin E, a substance once thought to lower the risk of prostate cancer, may actually raise the risk.
According to his daughter, these setbacks never discouraged her dad. He was “always eager to try the next thing.” Of course, when the next thing didn’t work, he didn’t keep advocating for its inclusion in clinical practice in spite of the evidence. He moved on.
Let’s briefly compare this approach to that of naturopaths, who wield their claimed expertise in nutrition like a truncheon, and Mark Hyman, MD, functional medicine guru.
Diet as disease prevention and treatment: naturopathic version
Guided by a “food is medicine” philosophy that relies heavily on the philosophy part, evidence be damned, the naturopath’s approach seems to dictate an endless trial-and-error elimination of this, adding that, until some positive result is achieved. This result is then attributed to the naturopath’s expertise in dietary advice, whether actual causation was involved or not.
Britt Hermes, herself a former naturopath and guest blogger on SBM, describes her own experience with naturopathic dietary advice on her own blog, Naturopathic Diaries. While anecdotal, it is a fair exemplar of standard naturopathic practice, as her “treatment” took place in a clinic run by Bastyr, where she received her naturopathic education and training. She later incorporated this dietary philosophy into her own naturopathic practice. As she describes it:
When my naturopath suggested severe dietary restrictions [for psoriasis and acne], I embraced them wholeheartedly and cultivated them into my own nutritional monster.
She was told to avoid all dairy, eat more protein, and eliminate refined sugars. Her naturopath explained the fictional gut-skin connection, reinforced when she learned about the “leaky gut” syndrome at Bastyr. For this, she was prescribed dietary supplements and herbs. She got IV “detoxification” treatments at Bastyr. Unnecessary weight loss was encouraged. She was given bogus IgG food intolerance tests. She was told not to eat any food that was the “root cause” of her acne and that she was “addicted to sugar.”
At her naturopath’s prompting, she detailed every bowel movement and her symptoms of bloating, pain and constipation. Instead of properly diagnosing these as a result of her pseudoscientific treatments, they were chalked up to “food reactions,” as were her irritability and depression, which were actually caused by hunger and malnutrition. Hermes instituted her own regimen of unproven dietary measures prompted by her faith in naturopathy and vetted in discussions with other Bastyr students and her naturopath.
As she notes:
Even by critics, naturopaths are often acknowledged for having training in nutrition . . . However, the nutritional training is wrapped up in pseudoscience, which makes it difficult to tease apart what is real and what is fake. For example, naturopaths often make dietary recommendations based on applied kinesiology tests, unvalidated blood tests, or far-fetched medical explanations. A commonly prescribed, but unproven, naturopathic diet theory is the elimination of nightshades to reduce the symptoms of inflammatory diseases, especially arthritis.
This is but one example of how naturopaths’ claim of special expertise in health and disease prevention through diet crumbles under closer examination, a subject we’ve examined on SBM a number of times in posts addressing dubious naturopathic dietary advice and diabetes, autism, infertility, allergies, and hypertension.
Diet as disease prevention and treatment: functional medicine version
The medical profession has its own “food as medicine” gurus, characterized by their splashy diet books and money-making diet schemes. Notable among these is Mark Hyman, MD, a family practice doctor and the main public face of “functional medicine.”
What is functional medicine? Good question. Here’s David Gorski’s take:
Functional medicine is pure pseudoscience, as Wally Sampson has explained. It postulates “imbalances” in hormones and neurotransmitters, oxidation-reduction, detoxification and biotransformation, immune function, inflammation, and cell structure. It’s all so vague that these “imbalances” could mean almost anything, and when practitioners of “functional medicine” refer to them, they usually do.
And that of the late, great Wally Sampson, who wrote a classic series on functional medicine (Functional Medicine (FM): What Is It?; Functional Medicine II; Functional Medicine III; Functional Medicine IV):
After extensive searching and examination, my answer is still – only the originators of “FM” know. Or, at least one must assume they know, because so far as I can see, I certainly see nothing that distinguishes “FM” from other descriptions of sectarian and “Complementary/Alternative Medicine” practices. A difference may lie in the advocates’ assumptions to have found some “imbalance” of body chemistry or physiology before applying one or more unproved methods or substances. From what I could determine, the “imbalance” or dysfunction is usually either imaginary or at least presumptive. And the general principles are so poorly defined as to allow practioners vast leeway to apply a host of unproven methods.
Hyman has adopted the naturopathic mantra that “conventional” medicine treats only symptoms by reaching for the prescription pad, while “functional medicine” gets at the “root cause” of disease. In fact, Hyman’s articles on the treatment of psoriasis and acne sound remarkably like the naturopathic regimens prescribed for Britt Hermes.
Hyman’s outfit sells proprietary programs online, including dietary supplements prescribed by these programs. According to his website, he has authored journal articles on the subject, but, according to PubMed, all of them have appeared in one journal of dubious scientific rigor, Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine.
Unfortunately, the “Institute for Functional Medicine,” where Hyman serves as board chair, is an approved provider of continuing medical education credit, where its courses are chock full of quackery, aided by lectures from not only the supposedly science-based professions, like medicine and dentistry, but a fair helping of naturopaths and chiropractors.
Hyman’s poor understanding of the diseases about which he pontificates have been the subject of several take downs in the science blogosphere: autism, dementia, and, relevant to our subject here, cancer. He regularly holds forth on the Huffington Post, free from the restraints of science and evidence.
As Steve Novella opined, practitioners like Hyman:
seem to search for any tenuous evidence to support their philosophy or marketing strategy and then make huge hand-waving extrapolations from the evidence to their practice.
Jerome Groopman, MD, chronicled Hyman’s extrapolations versus actual evidence more recently in a New Yorker article, where several experts disagreed with Hyman’s conclusions. Even in the face of this, according to Groopman:
Mark Hyman holds fast to his view. “Inflammation is the final common pathway for pretty much all chronic diseases,” he told me. His recommended solution is an “anti-inflammatory diet”—omitting sugar, caffeine, beans, dairy, gluten, and processed foods, as well as taking a variety of supplements, including probiotics, fish oil, Vitamins C and D, and curcumin, a key molecule in turmeric.
Although, Groopman added, Hyman, “at times, acknowledges the possible limits of his paradigm” and that it is hard to “connect the dots.” This reads more like another act of hubris on Hyman’s part rather than an actual admission that he might be wrong. “Possible” limits?
Note the contrast here between Dr. Wattenberg’s work and that of functional medicine practitioners and naturopaths. Dr. Wattenberg reviewed the research before developing his theories. He published his work in well-regarded peer-reviewed journals. And he was willing to move on when the evidence wasn’t there. No clinging to a “philosophy” or pet ideas despite the evidence. Just a lot of hard work and devotion to the scientific method. Dr. Wattenberg was “revered” by other scientists. No one would ever say that about Hyman or naturopaths.

Five Fatal Foods
Dr. Nina Koduru identifies 5 fatal foods that endanger your life and offers a solution: an untested remedy with unsubstantiated claims.
Harriet Hall on January 9, 2018
Link
I get a lot of emails offering dubious health advice and dubious products. I recently got one with the alarming title “Five Fatal Foods” and a link to a video. It had a warning in big red capitals: WARNING: YOUR LIFE IS IN DANGER! DON’T EAT THESE FIVE FOODS BEFORE YOU WATCH THIS VIDEO. “A shocking presentation the mainstream medical establishment does not want you to see.” You can watch the video here but I don’t recommend it. So you might interpret my lack of recommendation as supporting their claim: at least this one member of the mainstream medical establishment doesn’t particularly want you to see it. (Although I trust that most of our SBM readers are savvy enough that if you did waste your time watching the video, you wouldn’t just gullibly believe everything it says.)
I didn’t expect to get reliable scientific information from the video, but I was intrigued. In the first place, how could I not eat those five foods before I watched the video to find out what foods they were? And I was curious to know what foods were putting my life in danger. I presumed they were not talking about foods that were really fatal, like misidentified foraged mushrooms or improperly-prepared fugu. I tried to guess what the five foods were. People are always trying to tell us what to eat and what not to eat. What not to eat usually involves denying ourselves some of the yummiest foods we love. I thought of bacon, ice cream, pizza…
A challenge: before you scroll down, try to guess what the five fatal foods are. I would bet good money that you will guess wrong.
Who is making these claims?
The video is by Dr. Nina Koduru, an Internal Medicine Doctor at The Mount Sinai Hospital in New York. She has been practicing medicine for nearly a decade and she “uses groundbreaking research and provides cutting-edge solutions that restore your body to its peak level of performance.” So she says. But there is a disclaimer that the information presented on the website is not intended as specific medical advice. Hmmm…
She says tens of millions of Americans over the age of 30 experience chronic fatigue, weight gain, low energy, and digestive problems. She says these symptoms can be fatal, and they are warning you about much worse health problems like heart disease, diabetes, obesity, and more. She promises to reveal the one thing that finally gave her and her patients results after everything else had failed. It takes just 60 seconds a day, and is the most crucial thing you can do for your health, even if you don’t have any of those symptoms.
Dr. Koduru says millions of people have watched this presentation, and she is getting thousands of thank yous from people who have followed her advice with great results. Even celebrities. I wonder if Gwyneth Paltrow and the Food Babe know about the Five Fatal Foods.
She says the facts she presents come from years of experience. No, facts don’t come from experience. Testimonials come from experience. Facts come from scientific testing.
She warns that the video could be taken down at any moment due to the influence of big corporations that profit from the fatal foods. A soupçon of conspiracy theory always adds spice.
These five fatal foods are destroying our health
     1.  Diet soda. She cites research showing that diet soda intake is linked to obesity, heart disease and stroke. Our own Steven Novella recently reviewed the research and came to a different conclusion: that artificial sweeteners are not a health risk and may even offer a health benefit. Koduru says diet sodas contain “less than zero calories.” Negative calories? How is that possible? She tries to explain how diet sodas cause harm, but her explanation is incoherent. She talks about gut bacteria. She says Candida is the main bad bacteria, (but of course Candida is not bacteria, it’s yeast/fungus). She says you want to have no more than 20% Candida and at least 80% good bacteria. She doesn’t say how she knows this, or how you could measure the percentage (by weight? number of organisms?). I found the same 20%/80% claim on the unreliable site Natural News, but their link to the original source no longer works. She says sweets and preservatives feed the Candida. If they predominate, they will absorb [sic] the good bacteria. What she doesn’t say: Candida colonizes 90% of normal people without causing any harm, and chronic candidiasis is a fake disease. And she never explains how diet sodas could affect Candida.
     2.  Salad. Because salad dressings contain sugar or high fructose corn syrup. They will make you fat and sabotage any health benefits from the salad vegetables.
     3.  Juice. Because 60% of juices on supermarket shelves contain high fructose corn syrup. She says when you eat fructose, your brain doesn’t understand it, your hormones get out of balance, and it’s impossible to tell when you’ve had enough to eat. She says sugar is more addictive than heroin or cocaine, and over 75% of Americans are currently addicted. “The human body naturally converts any foreign substances into body fat.” (That is demonstrably not true!) She says choosing HFCS is equivalent to gluing fat all over your body. All this is highly misleading. What she doesn’t tell us is that HFCS has been unfairly demonized, as Jim Laidler explained here.
     4.  Coffee. She says it causes constipation due to its dehydrating nature (Not true. The water in coffee compensates for the diuretic effect and regular coffee drinkers do not become dehydrated). She says it causes inflammation and heartburn by stimulating stomach acid production. But “the real problem is the absurd amounts of sweeteners and sugar that most Americans use in their coffee!” She says a venti latte from Starbucks has as much sugar as over 3 Twinkies. (Not accurate.)
     5.  Yogurt. The milk in yogurt already contains sugar, and many brands have added sugar or (gasp!) HFCS. Claims of probiotic benefits are questionable because most of the good bacteria is destroyed when they pasteurize the yogurt.
The solution
So the problem seems to boil down to sugar and other sweeteners. But you don’t have to cut them out entirely. The solution is probiotics. She says, “There are many doctors that now believe probiotics are more essential than taking any other supplements or vitamins.” (How many doctors? Who are they? Where is the supporting evidence?) She says, “…probiotics may be one of the greatest health breakthroughs of the century.” I’m guessing there are very few people who would agree with that statement. She says having bad bacteria in your gut is like having poison in your body, and probiotics are the antidote.
But beware! You have to get your probiotics from the right sources. Yogurt is no good because the sugar in it counteracts the probiotics. There are two good sources:
     1.  Eating fermented vegetables such as pickles, miso, and kombucha. But this requires a whopping 5-6 servings a day.
     2.  High grade probiotic formulations (1) that contain at least 8 strains of probiotics, (2) that can pass through bile and stomach acids to reach the intestines, (3) that contain a very large amount of good bacteria (at least 10 billion colony forming units), and (4) that include Bifidobacterium and L. acidophilus.
No worries! She has teamed up with one of the most innovative and trusted probiotic companies in the world, Digest MD.
[Update: Digest MD states as of December 5, 2019 that it no longer works with Dr. Koduru]
Together they “created a breakthrough Probiotic Blend that is currently one of the most potent and effective probiotic formulas ever created.” It contains 20 strains with 25 billion CFUs, and they added two revolutionary prebiotics to feed the probiotics. She claims this proprietary formula will destroy all of the bad bacteria in your gut no matter how much there is in your system. It’s called Elite Biotics. She claims that it has all kinds of health benefits including more energy, weight loss, improved mood, clear skin, reduced digestive symptoms, improved metabolism, reduced cravings, higher sex drive, and improved sleep. She has lots of testimonials from customers, but testimonials are not evidence, and the product has not been scientifically tested. The retail price for a one-month supply is $67, but if you order through the video, you will get a reduced price of only $39, or a 3-bottle package for $99. A family pack is even less expensive. Limited time offer; stock up now! They even offer a 90 day 100% total money back guarantee.
Other opinions
A review article in Scientific American found that while there are demonstrated benefits for a few specific conditions, probiotics do not offer anything of substance to individuals who are already healthy, and “most of the health claims for probiotics are pure hype.”
Our own Mark Crislip wrote about probiotics. He explained the rationale and the evidence for probiotics and pointed out some interesting facts about the bacteria. From the perspective of an infectious disease specialist, he made these two predictions:
     1.  Population studies will show an increased risk of heart attacks, strokes, and pulmonary emboli as a consequence of the mild increase in the inflammatory state induced by chronic probiotics.
     2.  Infections will increase in the month or two after stopping chronic probiotics.
Conclusion: No evidence
The video about “Five Fatal Foods” is misleading propaganda designed to sell a product. There is no evidence that those foods kill people or that avoiding them would result in better health. There is little published evidence for most of the many benefits claimed for probiotics. This specific product has not been tested for effectiveness or safety, nor has it been compared to other products on the market.
You might think this is a trivial issue not worth writing about, but if Dr. Koduru is telling the truth, millions of people have watched her video and thousands have used the product and been impressed enough to write to her with testimonials. They may be risking their health: if Mark Crislip’s predictions are correct, some of those users may develop heart attacks, strokes, and pulmonary emboli. By posting this article on the Internet, I can at least give prospective customers a chance to learn that Dr. Koduru’s claims have been questioned by another MD, so they can make a more informed choice.

Pesticides: Just How Bad Are They?
Harriet Hall on December 9, 2014
Link


I think everyone would agree that it would not be a good idea to put pesticides in a saltshaker and add them to our food at the table. But there is little agreement when it comes to their use in agriculture. How much gets into our food? What are the effects on our health? On the environment? Is there a safer alternative?
Where should we look to find science-based answers to those questions? One place we should not look is books written by biased non-scientists to advance their personal agendas. A friend recently sent me a prime example of such a book: Myths of Safe Pesticides, by André Leu, an organic farmer whose opinions preceded his research and whose bias is revealed in the very title.
The foreword and introduction: A bad first impression
The Foreword is by Dr. Vandana Shiva, an environmentalist who blames Monsanto’s GMO seeds and pesticides for causing 284,000 Indian farmers to commit suicide since 1995, a claim that is almost certainly false. She says pesticides don’t even work in the first place: Roundup is failing to control weeds and is creating superweeds, and “pesticides create pests.” She is an alarmist who cites the Bhopal tragedy and Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring. She says Leu’s book synthesizes the scientific evidence of pesticides’ harm to public health and provides evidence that pesticide-free alternatives are more productive. He does collect a lot of evidence for the harms of pesticides, but he doesn’t balance it with other evidence of benefits and safety. And his evidence for pesticide-free alternatives is far from convincing.
His introduction begins with his personal observation of “so much illness in our communities, especially cancers, behavioral disorders, and degenerative diseases” and with his personal testimonial of getting sick every spraying season even though no sprays are used on his farm. He set out to find evidence to validate his belief that pesticides were responsible. Predictably, confirmation bias kicked right in and had a field day.
His bias even interferes with his reading comprehension. He says the US President’s Cancer Panel report of 2010 “clearly states that environmental toxins, including chemicals used in farming, are the main cause of cancers.”[emphasis added] It states no such thing! It says “the true burden of environmentally induced cancer has been grossly underestimated [at 6%],” and even that statement has been challenged by the American Cancer Society, whose representative said the panel restated hypotheses as facts and its conclusion does not represent scientific consensus. Tobacco causes 30% of all US cancer deaths and another 30% are attributed to diet, obesity, and lack of physical activity; and there are many other causes of cancer including alcohol, sun exposure, radon, medical radiation, infections, and occupational exposures. Pesticides are low on the list.
The five “myths”
After finding such obvious errors in the Foreword and Introduction I was tempted to drop the book in the wastepaper basket, but I persevered. Leu proceeds to address five “myths” in five chapters:
     1.  All agricultural poisons are scientifically tested to ensure safe use.
     2.  The residues are too low to cause any problems.
     3.  Modern pesticides rapidly degrade.
     4.  Regulatory authorities are reliable and trustworthy.
     5.  Pesticides are essential to farming.
Myth 1: All agricultural poisons are scientifically tested to ensure safe use.Note the inflammatory choice of words: “poisons” rather than pesticides. It is true that many chemicals in use in the US have not been adequately tested for safety, but even he himself admits that pesticides have been studied more than most. He cites several of those studies. For instance, one study found 232 chemicals in the cord blood of newborns; some of those chemicals can harm brain development and the nervous system, but they have never been found to do so in the amounts detected. He criticizes current scientific testing methods as unsound, and he points out that the developing fetus may have special needs. Pesticide exposure has been linked to a number of health problems in children, including lower IQs, autism, ADHD, lack of physical coordination, loss of temper, bipolar illness, schizophrenia, and depression. These are reported correlations, not proven causations. He cites birth defects and gene alterations in mice exposed to pesticides, but there is no comparable evidence for humans. I agree that these studies are cause for concern and further research, but I think it is premature to draw firm conclusions or use that evidence to guide public policy.
Myth 2: The residues are too low to cause any problems.He says the lowest doses of some chemicals can be more toxic because they begin to act as hormones at those low levels. Several of us have written about endocrine disruptors on SBM here, here, here, and here. Leu reproduces graphs showing increasing rates of diabetes, obesity, and thyroid cancer, and implies that endocrine disruptors are a major cause. He has a whole section on cell receptors that doesn’t make sense; he tries to tell us that “key” molecules can only fit into the “lock” receptors when they are present in small numbers (!?) Yes, there are legitimate concerns about hormone disruption, but so far it’s all hypotheses and no reliable conclusions; and if there is any effect, it is small in magnitude.
Myth 3: Modern pesticides rapidly degrade.Dioxins are very persistent in the environment, and they can contaminate food. Pesticides can degrade into other chemical compounds that are harmful. Testing is not done on every possible pesticide and metabolite. Washing and peeling produce can reduce pesticide residues, but can’t eliminate them. He says the bulk of pesticides are inside the food, but that is only true for systemic pesticides; other pesticides only affect the surface and can be washed off. For that matter, 99.99% of all the pesticides in our diet are natural components of the food, pesticides that plants produce naturally to protect themselves and that can’t be eliminated. Any synthetic pesticide residue is a drop in the bucket compared to the much larger concentrations of natural plant pesticides.
Myth 4: Regulatory authorities are reliable and trustworthyHe doesn’t trust authorities. He says, “History shows that regulatory authorities have consistently failed to prevent the contamination of the environment and human health by products previously designated safe, such as asbestos, lead, mercury, dioxins, PCBs, DDT, dieldrin, and other persistent organic pollutants.”
That’s horribly one-sided and unfair. He could have cited some of the many, many successes of government regulation in protecting public health and the environment; some of those successes involve the very contaminants he lists. He faults the government for continuing to allow mercury in fillings and vaccines, not acknowledging that mercury is no longer used in any vaccine but the multidose injectable flu vaccine, and that there has never been any evidence of danger from the use of mercury in vaccines or fillings. He points out variations in regulations between different countries, and his simplistic explanation is “politics.” I think it is more complicated than that.
He particularly targets glyphosate (Roundup). He shows nine graphs with correlations between glyphosate, GMOs, and everything from diabetes to intestinal infection. He omits that now-famous graph showing an almost perfect correlation between autism and organic food.
Myth 5: Pesticides are essential to farmingHe cites a number of studies where organic farming practices produced greater yields than conventional methods. He shows evidence that organic crops are more resilient in adverse conditions like droughts, and that good-practice organic systems produce higher yields in traditional smallholder farm settings.
Recent advances in organic farming techniques are very encouraging, and anything that reduces the need for pesticides sounds like a good idea. But it remains to be seen whether the techniques can be implemented everywhere, whether “industrialized” large-scale organic farming can adopt them, and whether they are really the most practical way to increase yields and improve safety. It may be possible for farmers to eschew pesticides; but is it feasible on a large scale, and is it really preferable to judicious use of pesticides following best practices and evidence-based guidelines? Those are questions that science will be able to answer, but the necessary studies have not been done yet.
Some facts and balances
How much pesticide residue is actually present on our foods? The Pesticide Data Program of the USDA has been asking that question for 22 years now. In 2012 they sampled nearly 12,000 foods, and found that residues were below EPA tolerance levels in over 99%. You can read the details here. They concluded that “residues found in agricultural products sampled are at levels that do not pose risk to consumers’ health (i.e., are safe according to EPA).” The World Health Organization and other organizations around the world are also monitoring pesticide residues and establishing tolerance levels, and there are international databases.
The obvious next question is how are safe levels determined. Here’s how. The details are here. They don’t just make stuff up, they go by evidence and expert reasoning. Levels change as new evidence warrants. The system isn’t perfect, but it’s reasonably good. A perfect system would be prohibitively expensive if not impossible to carry out to Leu’s satisfaction.
One activist organization reports that 86 pesticides were found on cucumbers. That might sound scary, but what does it really mean? Modern analysis can find tiny trace amounts of lots of things, but remember the old adage “The poison is in the dose.” We know, for instance, that organophosphate pesticides are toxic and workers must take precautions; but we also know that ingesting one single molecule of even the most deadly poison will not result in any detectable harm. There is a legitimate concern that ingesting multiple chemicals at safe levels might add up to unsafe cumulative effects, and that infants and pregnant women might be at higher risk. This doesn’t mean we should reject all pesticides on the precautionary principle; it only means more studies should be done.
It’s important to put the harms of artificial pesticides into context. As Bruce Ames has pointed out:
Carrots, celery, parsley, parsnips, mushrooms, cabbage, Brussels sprouts, mustard, basil, fennel, orange and grapefruit juices, pepper, cauliflower, broccoli, raspberry, and pineapple contain natural pesticides that cause cancer in rats or mice and that are present at levels ranging from 70ppb (parts per billion) to 4 million ppb–levels that are enormously higher than the amounts of man-made pesticide residues in plant foods.
Any discussion of harms from pesticides should weigh the harms against the benefits. There certainly are benefits: pesticides have increased crop yields and helped humans in other ways:
    • Pesticides are the only effective means of controlling disease organisms, weeds, or insect pests in many circumstances.
    • Consumers receive direct benefits from pesticides through wider selections and lower prices for food and clothing.
    • Pesticides protect private, public, and commercial dwellings from structural damage associated with termite infestations.
    • Pesticides contribute to enhanced human health by preventing disease outbreaks through the control of rodent and insect populations.
    • Pesticides are used to sanitize our drinking and recreational water.
    • Pesticides are used to disinfect indoor areas (e.g., kitchens, operating rooms, nursing homes) as well as dental and surgical instruments.
    • The pesticide industry also provides benefits to society. For instance, local communities and state governments may be partially dependent upon the jobs and tax bases that pesticide manufacturers, distributors, dealers, commercial applicators, and farmers provide.
Incidentally, when plants are not exposed to artificial pesticides, they tend to increase their production of natural pesticides. This phenomenon has not been well studied. And the “natural” pesticides allowed in organic farming have not been studied anywhere near as thoroughly as the artificial ones. It is a fallacy to assume they are safer because they are natural.
The news about health effects of pesticides is not all bad. This study concluded:
When compared to the general population total mortality has been found to be consistently lower among pesticide manufacturers as well as among other groups of workers. This observation has been mostly attributed to the ‘healthy worker effect’ or, in the case of agricultural workers, to the healthier lifestyle of farm families. With the exception of deaths by accidental causes, non- cancer causes of death (mainly represented by cardiovascular diseases), were generally found to be less frequent than expected among manufacturers or users of pesticides, in particular among farmers. No consistent evidence of global cancer mortality different from that of the general population has been reported among pesticide manufacturers or applicators. On the other hand, the papers examined have been strikingly consistent in reporting a low overall cancer risk among agricultural workers; life-style, clean air, low prevalence of smoking have been hypothesized so as to explain this observation.
Conclusion
Pesticides are meant to harm weeds and insects, but are they also harming us? Leu demonizes pesticides as “poisons” and argues that the precautionary principle should make us eliminate their use entirely. I think he exaggerates the dangers, especially considering that evolution has equipped the human body to thrive while eating foods with levels of natural pesticides several orders of magnitude greater than the levels of artificial pesticides in today’s foods. I certainly agree with him that there is a need for more research. He says safe pesticides are a myth, but I have to wonder if any evidence of safety would ever satisfy him; he seems to be demanding “perfect” safety like some anti-vaccine activists do. There is a danger to invoking the precautionary principle before ensuring that the alternatives are not worse.
This is what typically happens when a layman with an ax to grind ventures into the scientific arena looking for evidence to support his prior beliefs. A good scientist would look just as carefully for any evidence that might prove his hypothesis wrong. Leu’s book stands in stark contrast to another book by a layman, Matt Fitzgerald. Unusually for a layman, Fitzgerald approached his subject without bias and got it right. I reviewed that book here.
Leu’s book is useful, but only as a handy compilation of things we ought to be thinking about. Things that scientists are already addressing.
Addendum: This article originally called Carson’s Silent Spring “a book that has been discredited for raising fears based on ‘gross misrepresentations and atrocious scholarship’.” It has been pointed out to me that the discrediting has itself been discredited, so I have removed that reference, since it was not important for the point I was trying to make.

Microwaves and Nutrition
Steven Novella on April 30, 2014
Link
Science-based medicine is a concept that is larger than the analysis of any specific topic. It is, essentially, an approach to answering health and medical questions, one that involves careful and thorough analysis of scientific evidence within a framework of understanding of critical thinking, mechanisms of self-deception, and the process of science itself. We feel this creates the best opportunity to arrive at tentative conclusions that are most likely to be reliable.
We often address claims that are the result of a very different process. In fact there seems to be a thriving subculture on the internet that emphasizes the naturalistic fallacy, fear of anything technological (including irrational chemophobia), paranoia about the government, corporations, and mainstream medicine, and embracing anything perceived as being contrarian, exotic, or radical. To this subculture science is either the enemy, or it is used (as Andrew Lang famously quipped) like a drunk uses a lamppost, for support rather than illumination. This approach is simultaneously gullible and cynical.
It is no surprise that those who follow this fatally flawed approach consistently arrive at the wrong conclusion, especially on any controversial scientific topic. The two most prominent netizens following this approach, in my opinion, are Joseph Mercola and Mike Adams. I do believe, however, that there is another hoping to join their ranks – Vani Hari, who blogs under the name Food Babe. (Mark Crislip also blogged about her here.)
She first came to my attention as a result of her campaign to pressure Subway to remove the benign ingredient azodicarbonamide from their bread, dubbing it the “yoga mat” chemical. Looking into her writings, however, was like peeling back a small crack in a wall and finding, just under the surface, a vast infestation of termites. Unsurprisingly, for example, she is anti-vaccine. In her blog post attacking the flu vaccine she summarizes the naturalistic-antiscience approach, described above, quite well.
One of the goals I made in starting this blog back in April, was to uncover and unveil information that isn’t readily available for public consumption on true health, nutrition and wellbeing. I want this blog to help you break free from the “conventional” wisdom that the food industry, government agencies, pharmaceutical and medical community try to push because of greed or corruption that is ultimately harmful to you and your family.
Vaccines are not my topic for today, however, but rather the effects on nutritional content from microwaving food. There have been anti-microwave activists as long as there have been microwaves, it seems simply because it is a new-fangled technology that uses radiation to cook food. It is a perfect villain for the naturalistic-antiscience crowd.
Hari warns her readers to throw out their microwaves, writing:
Live, healthy, and nutritious foods can become dead in a matter of seconds when you use a microwave. We are the only species on the planet that destroys the nutrient content of our food before eating it. A study published in the November 2003 issue of the Journal of Science of Food and Agriculture found that broccoli cooked in the microwave lost up to 97 percent of its antioxidant content.
The first claim above is that food is supposed to be alive, and that cooking it “kills” the food. This is pure naturalistic nonsense. By the time certain foods, like meat, hit your table, even if it is raw, any cells in the food are dead. The cells in fruits and vegetables start dying after they are picked. Anything frozen will also be dead. Some things alive in the food, you probably don’t want there, such as bacteria that cause spoilage.The more important point, however, is that having living cells is irrelevant to nutrient content.
The core claim she is making is also that when we cook food, especially with a microwave, we “destroy” the nutrient content. Hari is one who will quickly cite a scientific study if she thinks it supports her side, but she often completely misinterprets the studies she cites. She is looking for support, not insight, and gives no evidence of making an effort to truly understand the science she references.
Before I take a look at specific studies, including the broccoli study Hari references, a little background is in order. Cooking actually has a complex effect on the nutrient content of food. In general heating food, by any method, can break down vitamins and other nutrients. The variables that are relevant to this process are the intensity of the heat, the duration of heating, and contact with water. The latter seems to be the most important variable.
Boiling vegetables, therefore, has the most dramatic effect on their nutrient content, especially on water-soluble vitamins. The water leeches out the nutrients, which then evaporate with the water. An extensive study of various cooking methods on the antioxidant nutrient content of 20 vegetables found:
According to the method of analysis chosen, griddling, microwave cooking, and baking alternately produce the lowest losses, while pressure-cooking and boiling lead to the greatest losses; frying occupies an intermediate position. In short, water is not the cook’s best friend when it comes to preparing vegetables.
That’s right – microwaving is among the best methods of cooking in terms of preserving nutrients. Hari’s conclusion, therefore, is the exact opposite of what the science says.
What about the study she references? That study, “Phenolic compound contents in edible parts of broccoli inflorescences after domestic cooking“, added water to the vegetables during microwaving. In essence, they were boiled using the microwave, so the results were more similar to boiling vegetables. Other studies looking at microwaving without added water demonstrate minimal nutrient loss. The advantage of microwaving is shorter cooking time – just don’t add water to your vegetables before putting them in the microwave.
Cooking, in fact, can increase the amount of certain nutrients in certain vegetables, such as lycopene in tomatoes and carotenoid levels in carrots.
Also, Hari fails to consider bioavailability. The nutrient content of food is only half the equation, we also need to know how much we can extract from the food through digestion. This is the main advantage of cooking, it weakens cell walls and breaks down proteins so they are easier to digest, enabling us to extract more nutrition. In fact, studies show that cooking broccoli increase the bioavailability of certain nutrients.
The bottom line is that cooking has complex but net positive effects on how much nutrition we get from our food, and that microwaving is one of the best methods for cooking (in terms of nutrient content). Hari’s advice to readers is therefore exactly wrong, as is her interpretation of the scientific literature.
Her other claims about microwaves are equally misleading, and venture into the truly bizarre. She claims that microwaving food releases carcinogens into the food. She repeats the dioxin claim, which is nothing but an urban legend.
The kernel of truth is that you should not heat food, by any method, in plastics that are not specifically designated as safe for the microwave or cooking. To be safe, place food into inert containers like glass or ceramics for microwaving.
She also warns about the risk of radiation from microwaves. She quote the dubious book, Cancer is Not a Disease, as saying:
And apparently, the same can happen to the human body when it is exposed to this type of radiation on a regular basis. After all, human cells are made of molecules and molecular bonds are broken and destroyed when exposed to radiation.
This is simply wrong. Microwave radiation is not energetic enough to break molecular bonds. It is considered non-ionizing radiation. Microwaves can heat water, including water in your body, and this can have biological effects. That’s why microwave ovens are shielded. The best advice is not to use a really old microwave that may not be functioning well. Also, don’t stand directly in front of the microwave when it is operating. Radiation falls off quickly with distance, so stand a few feet away and any minimal radiation leakage will be harmless.
Finally, Hari cites the work of Dr. Masaru Emoto, who claims that being mean to water will make it form ugly crystals when it freezes, while being nice to it will make it form beautiful crystals. This, of course, is pure pseudoscience. That doesn’t stop Hari from citing it as if it were real scientific evidence, because Emoto also claims that microwaving water makes it unhappy and ugly. This is provided as evidence that microwaving food will cause a host of health problems.
Conclusion
Microwave cooking is a safe technology. It’s not my favorite method of actually cooking, but it is a great tool for heating food. It is fast and convenient, and, it turns out, has a favorable profile in terms of the net effects on food nutrition.
Vani Hari’s conclusions about microwaves are all demonstrably incorrect and at odds with the scientific evidence. This seems to stem from a fatally flawed process of starting with an extreme naturalistic ideology, combined with misunderstanding and misinterpreting scientific evidence, which is used not to truly investigate or discover the truth but to back-fill her existing biases and opinions.

New Cholesterol Guidelines
Harriet Hall on November 26, 2013
Link
On November 15, the American College of Cardiology and the American Heart Association released an updated guideline for the use of statins to prevent and treat atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease (ASCVD). The full report is available online. It has already generated a lot of controversy. The news media have characterized it as a “huge departure” from previous practice and have trumpeted that it will lead doctors to prescribe statins to millions more people. As usual, the truth is much more nuanced. There are some problems with the guidelines, but on the whole they represent an improved, more rational approach to prescribing statins.
Statins have always been a source of controversy: people seem to either love them or hate them, and discussions about them generate a lot of emotion. The International Network of Cholesterol Skeptics denies that cholesterol has anything to do with cardiovascular disease. An article on HuffPo calls statins “an unsafe, unnecessary product that will now be recommended to healthy people to make them sicker.” Mercola says they can actually make heart disease worse and cause premature aging, and no one should take them unless they have the genetic defect of familial hypercholesterolemia. A website collects patient self-reports of adverse effects; but like the vaccine reports on VAERS, these are only anecdotal reports of correlation, not evidence for causation.
At one time the evidence only supported using statins for secondary prevention and for men. We now have better evidence showing that they are effective for both primary and secondary prevention in patients of both sexes and all ages, and that they are more effective for those with higher risk factors. 
What are the new guidelines?
Under the previous guidelines, doctors aimed to keep LDL cholesterol below 160 mg/dL for low-risk patients, below 130mg/dL for people at moderate risk (10 year risk of cardiovascular event between 10 and 20%) and to reduce it to 100mg/dL for those with a history of cardiovascular disease or diabetes, or with a 10-year risk of greater than 20%. For high-risk patients, doctors often aimed for less than 70mg/dL.
An expert panel evaluated all the available published evidence. They found that there was no good evidence to support the current target levels for LDL cholesterol, so they recommended an approach that disregards target levels and is based only on risk level and intensity of statin therapy. In essence, they switched from treating lab tests to treating patients. They identified 4 groups of individuals for which an extensive body of RCT evidence demonstrated a reduction in ASCVD events with a good margin of safety from moderate- or high-intensity statin therapy:
     1.  Individuals with clinical ASCVD
     2.  Individuals with primary elevations of LDL–C ≥190 mg/dL.
     3.  Individuals 40 to 75 years of age with diabetes and LDL–C 70 to 189 mg/dL without clinical ASCVD
     4.  Individuals without clinical ASCVD or diabetes who are 40 to 75 years of age with LDL–C 70 to 189 mg/dL and have an estimated 10-year ASCVD risk of 7.5% or higher.
The guidelines are the same for women as for men.
They found no evidence to support adjusting treatment to achieve specific target levels of LDL-C. They found no evidence that using non-statin therapies for prevention would provide acceptable risk reduction compared to their potential for adverse events.
They provided a risk calculator to identify those with a risk of 7.5% or higher for having a cardiovascular event in the next 10 years. It quantifies risk based on age, sex, race, cholesterol, blood pressure, diabetes, and smoking. They pointed out that the data are inadequate to quantify risk for some racial, sex, and age groups, for instance those over the age of 75. The guidelines are not intended to be a cookbook, one-size-fits-all approach. Clinicians are expected to rule out secondary causes of hyperlipidemia, to take other individual patient factors into consideration, and to discuss risks/benefits and patient preferences before starting therapy. They stress that lifestyle modification (adhering to a heart healthy diet, regular exercise habits, avoidance of tobacco products, and maintenance of a healthy weight) is critically important for everyone, both before and during treatment.
For both primary (patients with clinical ASCVD) and secondary prevention, they recommend high-intensity statin treatment below age 75, and moderate intensity statin treatment for those over age 75. Table 5 in the report defines high, moderate, and low intensity statin dosages. High intensity includes atorvastatin (Lipitor) 40-80 mg and rosuvastatin (Crestor) 20 mg daily; these have been shown to lower LDL-C by 50% or more.
They provide guidelines for monitoring patients on statins:
    • Regular assessment of adherence to medication and lifestyle
    • Re-testing lipid levels at intervals as long as 12 months
    • Other safety measures as clinically indicated
They no longer recommend routine monitoring of liver function tests unless there are symptoms suggesting liver toxicity.
They provide safety recommendations, listing patient characteristics that might increase the risk of side effects and advising how to manage patients who report symptoms that might be side effects of the drugs.
For patients not in the 4 groups, other factors may be considered to inform decision-making: primary LDL–C ≥160 mg/dL or other evidence of genetic hyperlipidemias, family history of premature ASCVD with onset <55 years of age in a first degree male relative or <65 years of age in a first degree female relative, high-sensitivity C-reactive protein >2 mg/L, CAC score ≥300 Agatston units or ≥75 percentile for age, sex, and ethnicity, ankle-brachial index <0.9, or elevated lifetime risk of ASCVD. Additional factors may be identified in the future.
Criticism of the new guidelines
     1.  The risk calculator was based on old data and it overestimates risk.
     2.  Out of 46 recommendations, 20 were based only on expert opinion.
     3.  Too many people will be put on statins.
     4.  The American Academy of Family Physicians is not willing to endorse the new guidelines.
     5.  Conflict of interest: six out of the 15 authors reported having recent or current ties to manufacturers of statin drugs.
These objections can be answered:
     1.  Those who say the risk calculator overestimates risk are relying on studies that underestimate risk because they used research subjects who were much healthier than the average American (the Nurses’ Health Study, the Women’s Health Initiative, and the Physicians’ Health study). And the risk calculator is only a starting point; clinicians are expected to take other factors into account, and a risk over 7.5% doesn’t automatically engender a prescription.
     2.  The major recommendations were based on high-quality evidence from RCTs; the ones based on expert opinion were about minor details.
     3.  The new guidelines may put more patients on statins, but it will put more appropriate patients on statins and will make sure that those who are not appropriate will not be given statins. There are a lot more people at risk today because of changes in the population: the population is older, and there is more obesity, hypertension, and metabolic syndrome.
     4.  The AAFP is only exercising its usual rigorous scientific caution. It tries to make independent decisions based on its own assessment of the evidence rather than slavishly following the recommendations of other groups. It has said it will not endorse the new recommendations until it has had time to thoroughly review the hundreds of pages of supporting evidence as well as evidence from other sources.
     5.  There is no evidence that those with ties to drug companies influenced the findings of the panel. The majority of the panel had no conflicts of interest, and the panel leaders said no one with industry connections could vote on the recommendations.
Even those who criticize the new guidelines say they support the majority of the recommendations.
How Safe Are Statins?
Mercola cites an article that says 17% of patients stopped taking them because of side effects. But that study concluded “most patients who are rechallenged can tolerate statins long-term. This suggests that many of the statin-related events may have other causes, are tolerable, or may be specific to individual statins rather than the entire drug class.” It’s easy to find horror stories on the Internet from patients who are convinced statins have harmed them, but they don’t necessarily mean that the drugs were at fault in those cases. The way to find out, of course, is to do controlled studies. The evidence is mixed. The JUPITER study, with 17,802 subjects, reported a greater number of serious side effects in the placebo group than in the statin group (!), as well as fewer deaths from cancer; but only one difference was statistically significant: an increase in newly diagnosed diabetes in the statin group. The most common side effect is muscle pain, which is often mild and manageable. The most serious reported side effect is rhabdomyolysis, but it is rare: in the JUPITER trial there was only one nonfatal case reported in a 90-year-old patient after the study, and he also had febrile influenza, pneumonia, and trauma-induced myopathy. Increases in liver enzymes, digestive problems, rashes, and neurological side effects have also been reported, often in patients who are susceptible to those problems for other reasons. The neurological effects are memory loss and confusion, which can be reversed by stopping the medication; but on the other hand there is evidence that statins may actually improve brain function in patients with dementia or Alzheimer’s disease. There is a slight risk of increased blood glucose levels that prompted the FDA to include a warning on package labels. The risk of side effects is greater for women, those on multiple cholesterol-lowering meds, with a smaller body frame, aged 65 or older, diabetics, and people who overuse of alcohol.
All drugs with effects have side effects, and most cardiologists consider statins one of the best drugs we have ever had and consider them remarkably safe compared to most other drugs. The new guidelines include a section that objectively evaluates the evidence for risks. Those who object to Big Pharma and prefer natural alternatives may be reassured to learn that the first statin (lovastatin) was isolated from a fungus and can still be obtained from red yeast rice, although products sold in the US no longer contain the active ingredient since the FDA mandated its removal.
Conclusion
It is the overall management of risk factors, regardless of blood cholesterol levels attained, that is important for heart disease and associated mortality. The new guidelines are based on the best evidence we have today from RCTs; they simplify treatment by basing it on risk rather than chasing target levels, and they require fewer blood tests for monitoring. They are meant to be taken as recommendations, not as inflexible requirements; and they will undoubtedly evolve as more evidence comes in. Cardiologist Harlan Krumholz summarized the changes nicely: “The new message is don’t chase targets, know your risk, and — if you need drug therapy — use statins.”

What Whole Foods Markets Doesn’t Tell You
Jann Bellamy on April 17, 2014
Link
Whole Foods Market is a relentlessly hip American supermarket chain which prides itself on organic fruits and vegetables, gluten-free just-about-everything, and high-end touches like wine bars and exotic take out items (roasted yucca, anyone?). The health products aisle is stocked with Bach Flower and homeopathic remedies. For example, in-house brand Flu Ease: “an established homeopathic formula that should be taken at the first sign of flu for temporary relief of symptoms including fever chills and body aches.”
Selling Flu Ease and like products certainly exhibits a lack of appreciation for scientific evidence, not to mention basic science. But I recently saw a product in the checkout line that was so filled with over-the-top quackery and so shocking in its disregard for the public’s health that I haven’t been back to Whole Foods since. And I won’t be going back.
The product? A glossy, slickly-produced magazine with the conspiracy-minded title What Doctors Don’t Tell You. The April 2014 issue promises, in banner-headline font size, a “New Light on Cancer.” It features the well-known symbol of fighting breast cancer, a loop of pink ribbon, but with a tear in the middle of the loop. We’ll look into this “new light” in a bit.
WDDTY is a British export. The magazine launched there a couple of years ago as a companion to the website of the same name, which has been around since 1989. Both are the creation of Lynne McTaggert and Bryan Hubbard. She claimed, in 2012, that the magazine has a circulation of 40,000. I am not sure when it made its American debut, but this is the first I’ve seen of it.
McTaggert and Hubbard are no strangers to pseudoscience. I’ll let the UK blog Tessera introduce them.
Who are McTaggart and Hubbard? She has form as an anti-vaccination campaigner. In one of her books, The Intention Experiment, she says that the universe is connected by a vast quantum energy field and can be influenced by thought. He recommends vitamin C as a treatment for cancer and they complain about the Cancer Act which prevents them promoting their ‘cures’. So I think we know what we’re dealing with.
Yes, we certainly do.
The magazine’s appearance was not well-received in the UK’s scientific and skeptical community, and for good reason. Simon Singh led the charge: he and others called for its removal from newsagents’ (as the British call them) shelves, a campaign that enjoyed some success. This, in turn, was not well-received by McTaggert, whose representative threatened to sue Singh, a libel litigation veteran. Although McTaggert later denied the threat, she left an internet trail that contradicted her claim. (Moral of that story: don’t deny something you said on the internet. Someone will find it somewhere.)
UK skeptics, science supporters, and their blogs rained well-deserved criticism on WDDTY, especially after McTaggert’s threat to take legal action. Josephine Jones has an extensive list of links to posts and tweets, as well as newspaper articles and a BBC interview with Margaret McCartney, M.D., who also wrote an article about WDDTY in the BMJ. As you might imagine, in addition to the nonsense within the covers, the magazine’s name proved fertile ground for sport. Even the staid BMJ got into the act with “What a new consumer health magazine doesn’t tell you.” Here’s a personal favorite from The Quackometer, a re-do of a WDDTY cover:
(Be sure to look at all of Andy Lewis’s hilarious cover re-dos.)
More criticism heaped on, British-style
What were Singh and the scientific and skeptical community so put off by? Here’s a sample of articles discussed by Dr. Margaret McCartney, in the BMJ. (We should note that Dr. McCartney is no defender of “conventional” medicine.)
In the October issue’s news section the article “Thyme is better for acne than creams” starts, “Thyme is more effective than prescription creams for treating acne. . .The herb outperformed pharmaceuticals in a series of laboratory tests, killing the actual bacteria that cause acne . . . Not only is thyme more effective, but it’s kinder on the skin too, say the researchers. Most pharmaceuticals cause a burning sensation and irritation to the skin, whereas thyme and other herbal preparations have none of these side effects.”
What did the magazine cite in support of this claim? Dr. McCartney found that it was an in-vitro study reported in a press release that (obviously) didn’t compare side effects. (This is a recurring theme in WDDTY: in-vitro or small studies cited with the same degree of confidence as if they were large, randomized, controlled clinical trials.)
Another article Dr. McCartney criticized:
“Army personnel with noise deafness and tinnitus are commonly deficient in B12, but enjoy an improvement in symptoms after taking B12 vitamins.” The study referred to contained 12 patients receiving vitamin B12 and was not a randomised controlled trial.
But that was small potatoes in comparison:
The editorial on Gardasil, headed “Lock up your daughters,” warned that “your doctor and your daughter’s school nurse are not likely to tell you about the 100-plus American girls who suddenly died after receiving an HPV [human papillomavirus] vaccine.”
Tessera jumped on this too:
[An] article, by McTaggart, says that cervical cancer is a third world problem, a ‘disease of poverty and unhealthy living’. She talks about the huge number of side-effects but lists only the serious, scary ones. The article bombards the reader with statistics and ‘facts’ and ends by claiming that the vaccination will ‘at best’ save 40 lives in the UK while harming huge numbers.
She accuses drug companies of using extreme scare tactics to promote the vaccines and make money — which is a bit rich when the magazine is shot through with scare stories to promote supplements and alt med.
An article in the same issue, “How I avoided a hysterectomy through diet,” tells of a woman who claims to have healed herself of severe dysplasia and HPV after turning down a biopsy and D&C. A chiropractor/nutritionist friend suggested she be tested for “hidden food allergies.” A naturopath recommended vitamins and supplements and she went on a “special diet.” The article ends with a list of “helpful supplements.”
WDDTY’s extensive advertising for dietary supplements and other alt med products didn’t escape notice either. The Nightingale Collaboration reviewed the September 2012 issue and submitted 26 complaints to the British Advertising Standards Authority, perhaps the “greatest number of complaints submitted to the ASA for a single publication.” Skeptical Letter Writer listed questionable ads in one issue, including these doozies:
Although doctors tell you that a hearing aid is the only recourse for age-related hearing loss, a wide range of herbs and supplements may be able to restore your hearing… Try the herb Gingko biloba, which helps to improve circulation to the ears.
And this ad from Brandon Bayes, “one of those feel-good-about-yourself speakers from the US” (apparently Americans have a reputation for this sort of talk):
Research by the American Center for Disease Control states that 85% of all illness is emotionally based.
As Skeptical Letter Writer noted, Bayes couldn’t seem to find room in her full-page ad for a citation in support of this statement. Or, I might add, get the name of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention right.
Included in the list was an ad for a subscription to WDDTY, with these enticing claims:
Discover treatments that are safer and more effective… Reverse bone loss for good — The secret your doctor doesn’t know… Asthma exclusive — End your child’s wheezing without drugs… Sunbathe your diabetes away… Natural botox — Safer ways to beat wrinkles… ‘How I avoided a hysteroctomy through diet’… Rock’n’roll dads — You can regain your hearing… Unsteady gran? It’s drugs that cause the falls, not old age…
Meanwhile, back in the checkout line
I was intrigued, but knew none of this controversy, when I bought (@ $7.99) WDDTY’s April issue at Whole Foods. In fact, my first thought was: “Kevin Trudeau has a magazine now?”
A glance at the Editorial Panel, on page six, hinted at the contents. We have here several members of the American Academy of Environmental Medicine, a specialist in “multiple chemical sensitivity,” the Medical Director of the Alliance for Natural Health, a water birth advocate, and one gentleman who is an osteopath, homeopath, acupuncturist, naturopath and medical herbalist, all rolled into one, as well as a member of the Prince of Wales’ Foundation for Integrative Health.
The uproar over her magazine has apparently made Lynne McTaggert a bit testy. She jumps right into the fray on page seven with her Editor’s note, entitled “Natural medicine is a human rights issue.” It seems all these bad thoughts about WDDTY have negatively affected her universal quantum energy field and she aims to set things straight. She declares that “there is nothing remotely scientific about conventional medicine,” a conclusion buttressed, she says, by three points: (1) Most of the science behind standard treatments is fiction (a conclusion based solely on reports that some drug companies have manipulated the data on some drugs); (2) most conventional treatments haven’t been proven to work (a myth kept alive by people like McTaggert), and (3) they cause more harm that health (the “Death by Medicine” fallacy).
After chewing on that for a while, she decides that “this is not a fair debate.” It is “a blatant attempt to deny you one of your basic human rights: the gift of effective health care.” By this point, McTaggert has worked up a real lather, triumphantly concluding:
In fact it is essentially a form of persecution — no less than it was to deny an African-American a seat on the bus before the Civil Rights movement.
So, in sum, calling McTaggert on her magazine’s pseudoscientific articles, advertisements shilling for quack products, and potentially dangerous health advice has turned her into no less than a modern-day Rosa Parks.
WDDTY’s April issue has the same eye-popping cover as the UK’s November, 2013, version, along with its claim that a “new light” would be thrown on cancer. Let’s take a closer look and see if it lives up to its billing.
But first, a few words from an advertiser in the magazine. A two-page spread advertises the “Chikey,” a quack device that “provides biophoton treatments to restore energy, rejuvenate the mind and body, and tackle specific health complaints at their root cause.” The Chikey is based on the work of:
Dutch health care pioneer Johan Boswinkel who discovered that the cause of each disease and ailment can be found by measuring the light — biophotons — emitted by the body’s cells.
Yes, the one true cause of all disease is discovered, yet again. So clever is the Chikey that it can be used not only on people and animals, but also on plants and food. It can even “take the chlorine out of water.” Apparently it accomplishes these things by restoring the light of the cells and of food. (Whatever that means.) And then there is the article by Boswinkel coincidentally appearing in the same issue. Boswinkel dramatically revels how his biophoton therapy saved a woman’s life, after (and isn’t it always the case?) she had been told by her doctor nothing was wrong. Not only will WDDTY’s editors allow the sale of bogus devices through their magazine, they actually believe them newsworthy.
But let’s get back to putting cancer under WDDTY’s “new light” and see what we can see.
In “107 degrees Farenheit, When cancer just goes away,” by Bryan Hubbard, WDDTY’s founder and co-editor, Hubbard offers the tantalizing possibility that a high fever could cause cancer to go into remission, although I don’t know if this is still (or ever was) a viable hypothesis. But credence is also given to the “mind over cancer” research from the Institute of Noetic Sciences (IONS), a new-agey California group. (Or, as I like to call it, the “your cancer is your fault” theory). IONS identified “eight changes that may play an important role” in cancer regression. Example: “believing in a positive outcome.” To give you the flavor of its agenda, IONS is also researching “both the accuracy and the mental activity of mediums as they were tasked with communication with the deceased.” I do hope “communication with the deceased” is not something you are ever “tasked with” at your job. And, by the way, what mediums do is known at IONS as “mediumship.” Funny, I thought it was called “fleecing the bereaved.”
Unfortunately, according to Hubbard, spontaneous regression isn’t being given enough attention by researchers because of that eternal alt med villain, drug companies, who are the only ones with research funds and aren’t interested. Apparently, in Hubbard’s world, the NCI, NIH and a slew of universities and other cancer research institutions don’t exist.
Another article shedding “new light” is “Pet Corner: When your pet has cancer.” Written by a veterinarian who (while not discouraging conventional cancer treatments) recommends a “natural” approach that includes dietary supplements, Apocaps, an algae-based “alkaline superfood that helps alkalinize the body,” and “giving them positive energy via Reiki.”
But the most execrable bit of this nonsense-laden publication is “Like Water for Chemo” by Bryan Hubbard and its companion piece “How might homeopathy work?” by Lynne McTaggert. (Note to McTaggert: you can find the answer here. And that is all I need to say on the topic.) Hubbard’s article has already been eviscerated by those who read it in the November UK issue, but I’ll add my two cents.
Hubbard’s piece touts India as a mecca of cutting-edge research on using homeopathy as a cancer treatment. It cites a couple of questionable “research” facilities, one of which has done no actual clinical trials but rather relies on “14 million cases dealt with through past generations of [the owner’s] family.” Hubbard cites three of these “case studies,” finding them “impressive.” Data from the other clinic suggests, according to Hubbard, that homeopathic remedies match the best results for conventional medicines “without the debilitating results of chemo and radiation.” He even trots out that reliable homeopathic warhorse, the Frankel study, skewered by Orac and others (here and here).
Hubbard claims that the National Cancer Institute is so “impressed” by these results it wants to see more research carried out. But the NCI, he says, can’t find funding because “most research is paid for by drug companies” who “have nothing to gain from these studies — other than perhaps a loss of revenue for their chemotherapy drugs.” (Them again!) This is an extraordinary statement because the NCI is funded by Congress, not the drug companies. I imagine the reason the NCI isn’t funding research on homeopathic remedies for cancer is because the scientists there think it’s a stupid waste of taxpayer money.
Finally, there is an article by Laura Bond, who says her mom, Gemma, refused chemo “and instead made extensive changes to her life, from dietary changes to changes in attitude” which cured her of uterine and ovarian cancer. This led me to wonder whether Gemma actually had surgery and refused adjuvant chemotherapy, an important distinction David Gorski covered, but the article doesn’t say. Gemma’s treatment included ozone therapy, about which there is a separate, credulous article.
While Bond’s article is ostensibly about “six characteristics that cancer patients commonly share” (e.g., “embrace change”) it is actually a thinly veiled homage to choosing dubious remedies instead of conventional treatment. Examples: coffee enemas, vitamin C injections (IV, 3 times a day, for 12 days, in one case), infrared saunas, pop psychology, addressing the “root cause” (e.g., a “horrible job”), ozone therapy, hydrogen-peroxide infusions, and giving up gluten, salt, dairy and sugar.
The “new light” WDDTY promised to shed on cancer is in fact darkness itself, the darkness of a prescientific age, when medicine could be practiced by all comers, including snake oil salesmen.
As Andy Lewis rightly said on The Quackometer blog:
There is a very good reason that doctors do not tell you the things in this magazine — because it is nonsense, quackery, conspiratorial rubbish designed to sell vitamin pills and other useless treatments.
But I’m sure Whole Foods Markets doesn’t want me to tell you that.

oals, same methods
David Gorski on October 1, 2012
Link
Countering ideologically motivated bad science, pseudoscience, misinformation, and lies is one of the main purposes of this blog. Specifically, we try to combat such misinformation in medicine; elsewhere Steve and I, as well as some of our other “partners in crime” combat other forms of pseudoscience. During the nearly five year existence of this blog, we’ve covered a lot of topics in medicine that tend to be prone to pseudoscience and quackery. Oddly enough, there’s one topic that we haven’t really written much about at all, and that’s genetically modified organisms (GMOs). GMOs, as you know, are proliferating, and it’s quite worth discussing the potential and risks of this new technology, just as it is worthwhile to discuss the potential benefits versus the risks of any new technology that can impact our health, not to mention the health of the planet. Unfortunately, GMOs have become a huge political issue, and, I would argue, they have become just as prone to pseudoscience, misinformation, and bad science as vaccines, with a radical group of anti-GMO activists who are as anti-science as any antivaccinationist or quack.
Leave it to that quackery promoter to rule all quackery promoters, Mike Adams, to give me just the opportunity to show you what I mean. Over the last couple of weeks, Mike has been in a fine lather about GMOs, with multiple posts with titles such as The GMO debate is over; GM crops must be immediately outlawed; Monsanto halted from threatening humanity and The evil of Monsanto and GMOs explained: Bad technology, endless greed and the destruction of humanity. In other words, it’s a series of post with Adams’ typical hyperbole. If you were to believe him, GMOs are the product of a plot by Satan, Monsanto, big pharma, and the government, and he’s not sure which one of these is the most evil of the bunch.
Not to be outdone, that other quackery supporter vying with Mike Adams to be the quackery supporter to rule all quackery supporters, Joe Mercola, also weighed in with a post entitled First-Ever Lifetime Feeding Study Finds Genetically Engineered Corn Causes Massive Tumors, Organ Damage, and Early Death. It also turns out that Mike Adams had pontificated about this very same study a couple of days before Mercola with a title equally ominous, Shock findings in new GMO study: Rats fed lifetime of GM corn grow horrifying tumors, 70% of females die early. Whenever I see the cranks pile on a study like this, my curiosity is piqued. I also noticed that Steve Novella had already discussed the study that had this not-so-dynamic duo in such a frothy lather. Of course, as you know, that a blogger as awesome as our fearless leader had covered a topic never stopped me from pontificating about the very same study before (well, actually, it has, but in this case it wasn’t enough to stop me). Besides, these sorts of studies are right up my alley, given that I’m a cancer researcher, and the study being touted as “smoking gun” evidence that GMOs are pure evil is such a an incompetently designed and performed study that it actually irritated me more than the usual bit of bad science that I discuss on occasion.
There’s a lot in common between anti-GMO activists and antivaccine activists. Perhaps the most prominent similarity is philosophical. Both groups fetishize the naturalistic fallacy, otherwise known as the belief that if it’s “natural” it must be good (or at least better than anything man-made or “artificial”). In the case of antivaccine activists, the immune response caused by vaccines is somehow “unnatural” and therefore harmful and evil, even though the mechanisms by which the immune system responds to vaccines are the same or similar to how it responds to “natural” antigens. That’s the whole idea, to stimulate the immune system to think that you’ve had the disease without actually giving you the disease, thus stimulating long term immunity to the actual disease! In the case of anti-GMO activists, the same idea appears to prevail, namely that, because GMOS are somehow “unnatural,” they must be harmful and evil. That’s not to say that they might not have problems and issues that need to be dealt with, but the apocalyptic language used by many of the anti-GMO activists like Mike Adams and Joe Mercola is so far over-the-top that it is very much like the language of the antivaccine movement. In fact, not surprisingly, antivaccinationists are often anti-GMO as well, and vice-versa, an example of crank magnetism in action. Indeed, Joe Mercola himself is one of the biggest backers of California Proposition 37, which would require the labeling of GMO-based food, having donated $1.1 million so far.
The particular study that has been reverberating through out the anti-GMO community over the last couple of weeks was done by a group in France led by Gilles-Eric Séralini at the University of Caen with a history of opposition to GMOs. Also, as Steve pointed out, Séralini et al did not allow reporters to seek outside comment on their paper before its publication. If there’s a bigger red flag that a study is ideologically motivated crap and that the authors know it’s ideologically motivated crap, I can’t think of one. Even if Séralini et al didn’t know their study was weak and were somehow afraid that the nefarious Monsanto scientists would plant negative sound bites into news stories about the study, I’m sorry, but trying to control initial news reports like this is just not how scientific results should be announced, period. It’s cowardice and an unseemly attempt at spin:
“For the first time ever, a GM organism and a herbicide have been evaluated for their long-term impact on health, and more thoroughly than by governments or the industry,” Séralini told AFP. “The results are alarming.”
Meanwhile, Mike Adams writes:
As a shocking new study has graphically shown, GMOs are the new thalidomide. When rats eat GM maize, they develop horrifying tumors. Seventy percent of females die prematurely, and virtually all of them suffer severe organ damage from consuming GMO. These are the scientific conclusions of the first truly “long-term” study ever conducted on GMO consumption in animals, and the findings are absolutely horrifying. (See pictures of rats with tumors, below.)
What this reveals is that genetic engineering turns FOOD into POISON.
I do so love all caps for emphasis. So very antivaccinationist-like.
Meanwhile, Mercola writes:
The research was considered so “hot” that the work was done under strict secrecy. According to a French article in Le Nouvel Observateur,2 the researchers used encrypted emails, phone conversations were banned, and they even launched a decoy study to prevent sabotage!
One wonders if they mixed up the “decoy” study with the real study, if the quality of the final published study is any indication. Let’s take a look. This study, by Séralini et al, was entitled Long term toxicity of a Roundup herbicide and a Roundup-tolerant genetically modified maize. Here’s the abstract:
The health effects of a Roundup-tolerant genetically modified maize (from 11% in the diet), cultivated with or without Roundup, and Roundup alone (from 0.1 ppb in water), were studied 2 years in rats. In females, all treated groups died 2–3 times more than controls, and more rapidly. This difference was visible in 3 male groups fed GMOs. All results were hormone and sex dependent, and the pathological profiles were comparable. Females developed large mammary tumors almost always more often than and before controls, the pituitary was the second most disabled organ; the sex hormonal balance was modified by GMO and Roundup treatments. In treated males, liver congestions and necrosis were 2.5–5.5 times higher. This pathology was confirmed by optic and transmission electron microscopy. Marked and severe kidney nephropathies were also generally 1.3–2.3 greater. Males presented 4 times more large palpable tumors than controls which occurred up to 600 days earlier. Biochemistry data confirmed very significant kidney chronic deficiencies; for all treatments and both sexes, 76% of the altered parameters were kidney related. These results can be explained by the non linear endocrine-disrupting effects of Roundup, but also by the overexpression of the transgene in the GMO and its metabolic consequences.
Wow. Sounds really disturbing, doesn’t it? Certainly, at first glance it did to me, but something seemed fishy. Although some have pointed out that the rat strain used (albino Sprague-Dawley rats from Harlan Labs) have a high propensity for tumors to develop as it is, initially I didn’t really consider that as big a problem as some do. You want a certain baseline of tumor development, and it’s not entirely unreasonable to pick a strain that develops tumors at a rate that is frequent enough that it’s likely that the strain will be sensitive to carcinogens. On the other hand, if the baseline rate of developing tumors is high enough, there’s not much room to go up further, and it’s harder to detect effects that result in an increased incidence of tumors. The problem with this particular rat strain is that the rate might well reach that point, which is why the control group size is a really big problem.
Indeed, what seemed fishier to me were two things. First, there were only 20 rats in the control group. In actuality, in practice it was less than that, because the authors looked at both males and females; so there were 10 male controls and 10 female controls, which struck me as a rather small number for a study of this type. Then there were nine other groups, with twenty mice in each group, 10 males and ten females each, making for a very complicated experimental design. Indeed, I agree with Marion Nestle, the Paulette Goddard professor in the Department of Nutrition, Food Studies and Public Health at New York University who supports labeling of genetically modified foods on a national scale, when she said, “It’s weirdly complicated and unclear on key issues: what the controls were fed, relative rates of tumors, why no dose relationship, what the mechanism might be. I can’t think of a biological reason why GMO corn should do this.”
“Weirdly complicated” doesn’t even begin to describe it. I found the experimental design unnecessarily complicated to a ridiculous degree, with too few mice in each group, especially the controls. In fact, these were the groups (the number of animals in the group is in parentheses):
     1.  Controls (20)
     2.  11% GMO (20)
     3.  22% GMO (20)
     4.  33% GMO (20)
     5.  11% GMO + R (20)
     6.  22% GMO + R (20)
     7.  33% GMO + R (20)
     8.  R(A) (20)
     9.  R(B) (20)
     10.  R(C) (20)
The percentage means the percentage of GMO corn in the rat chow, specifically the Roundup resistant strain NK603, and “R” means that Roundup had been applied to the corn. R(A) through R(C) are different concentrations of Roundup in the rats’ drinking water. This is way too many groups to have a high likelihood of producing interpretable data, particularly with only 10 females and ten males in each group. In essence, there were 20 experimental groups with ten rats in each group. Most problematic is the small number in the control group. There’s an old study on this line of rats published in 1979 that looked at the spontaneous development of endocrine tumors. After two years, 86% of male and 72% of female rats had developed tumors of the sort described by Séralini et al. Note that the time period of this 1979 study was the same as that of Séralini et al, two years. In other words, the “treated” rats developed as many tumors as expected for this particular strain of rats allowed to live to their natural lifespanand in fact the control groups arguably had an unusually low incidence of tumors.
Elsewhere, biologist Andrew Kniss ran a simulation (for which he provides the code) based on this study and found:
Let’s assume that the Suzuki et al (1979) paper is correct, and 72% of female Sprague-Dawley rats develop tumors after 2 years, even if no treatments are applied. If we randomly choose 10,000 rats with a 72% chance that they will have a tumor after 2 years, we can be pretty certain that approximately 72% of the rats we selected will develop a tumor by the end of 2 years.
In our very large sample of 10,000 simulated rats, we found that 71.4% of them will develop tumors by the end of a 2 year study. That’s pretty close to 72%. But here is where sample size becomes so critically important. If we only select 10 female rats, the chances of finding exactly 72% of them with tumors is much less. In fact, there is a pretty good chance the percentage of 10 rats developing tumors could be MUCH different than the population mean of 72%. This is because there is a greater chance that our small sample of 10 will not be representative of the larger population.
In other words, large numbers matter. In a group of 10 mice, each with a 72% chance of developing tumors after two years, there’s a much higher chance that the number of rats in the control group that develop tumors will be a number other than 7 (72%). Also curious is that the rate of mortality didn’t appear to be related to the dose of GMO corn. The authors attribute this to the GMO corn being so nasty that it was a “threshold” effect, where the observed effect maxed out before the lowest percentage of GMO corn was even hit, which, if true, would imply that a followup study was warranted looking at, for instance, 0% GMO corn to 11% GMO corn. However, more modeling of the study revealed:
But here’s the important part: Simply by chance, if we draw 10 rats from a population in which 72% get tumors after 2 years, we have anywhere from 5 (“t2″) to 10 (“t1″) rats in a treatment group that will develop tumors. Simply due to chance; not due to treatments. If I did not know about this predisposition for developing tumors in Sprague-Dawley rats, and I were comparing these treatment groups, I might be inclined to say that there is indeed a difference between treatment 1 and treatment 2. Only 5 animals developed tumors in treatment 1, and all 10 animals developed tumors treatment 2; that seems pretty convincing. But again, in this case, it was purely due to chance.
It’s even worse than Dr. Kniss demonstrates.
What do I mean? The investigators measured numerous parameters in each group, some of them at multiple different time points. An experiment with this many groups and this many parameters measured this many times is virtually guaranteed to generate multiple “positive” results. How did they control for all these multiple comparisons? I’ve read the study a few times now, and I still can’t figure it out. An experiment with this many groups in which this many parameters are measured is guaranteed to produce “statistically significant” differences in a number of variables by random chance alone. Heck, in Figure 5, I counted 47 different parameters measured, and in some tables thirteen different parameters recorded curiously as percentage changes. Even worse, for the mortality data (arguably the most critical data), no confidence intervals are reported, and there appears to be no discussion of how the mortality data were analyzed, as Michael Grayer points out in an excellent takedown of the statistical analysis (or, more appropriately, lack of statistical analysis) in this paper. I would only add to this a couple of questions. First, why was there no power analysis reported to justify the number of mice per experimental group and the number of experimental groups chosen? What was the statistical power of this design to detect significant differences? This is some very basic stuff here. Second, who the heck was the statistician on this? He or she should be fired for gross incompetence.
And don’t even get me on the lack of blinding of observers to the identities of the experimental groups. That’s just single blinding, which is the absolute minimum that could be acceptable in an animal experiment. Double blinding would have been better. Apparently, the researchers used neither.
There’s another fishy thing about how the results are reported. Steve Novella noted this, too, but it’s more pervasive than he pointed out. In fact, never before in a scientific paper have I seen a line like, “”All data cannot be shown in one report and the most relevant are described here”—that is, until this paper. Steve wondered whether the authors were cherry picking the results they were presenting. I more than wonder. I strongly suspect. After all, in these days of online publication, that’s what supplemental data sections are for, to publish all the supporting data necessary to convince reviewers and readers, but prioritizing the important data to be shown in the paper. What this paper represents, in fact, is a massive failure of peer review.
Then there are the graphs. I was half-tempted to reproduce the graphs here, but in reality I found Figure 1 (which contains them) so confusing. It consists of six graphs, three for males, three for females, each graph consisting of four curves for different percentages of GMO corn in the rat chow. Not only that, each graph had a shaded area stated to represent the mean lifespan and beyond. But not only that, each graph had an inset graph representing “cause of death” for mice who died before the lifespan of the gray area. That’s basically a total of twelve different graphs, in which it’s hideously difficult to directly compare the experimental groups that I would want to compare to each other. It’s almost as though the authors were trying to make it hard to interpret the results of this study. However, considering that, in essence, this was a study of 20 different groups (two controls and eighteen experimental groups), the results are well nigh uninterpretable to the point of meaninglessness. Besides, Emily Willingham went to the trouble (and it was a lot of trouble, I bet) of graphing the data in a much more standard way that makes it easier to interpret. Guess what? The differences mostly disappear. She also speculates whether BPA was a confounding factor, although I’m not particularly convinced by her arguments for that. She is correct, however, in pointing out how crappy the statistical analyses were and deceiving the graphs were. In fact, if you want an idea of why Figure 1 is so deceptive, you can find it in, of all places, this Tweet. When someone can demolish graphs in a Tweet like this, you know they’re bad.
Finally, there is a question of whether the control groups were exposed to GMO corn. Tim Worstall, a blogger at Forbes.com, looked into the issue of whether there is GMO corn in normal rat chow sold for use in feeding laboratory rats. He contacted Harlan, the company that supplied the rats for this study, and asked about GMO products used in rat chow. The company told him that “we do not exclude GM materials from rodent diets.” He also points out that, if the findings of this paper were accurate, because there is a difference in the use of GMO corn in the U.S. and Europe, we’d expect to see a massive change in the incidence of tumors in this mouse strain in the U.S. but less so in Europe. He has a point, but I think he overstates his argument. If the incidence of tumors in these mice is really 72-86% by two years, it could very well be difficult to detect a significant increase in a number that is already so high. On the other hand, his point that the control mice might well have been exposed to GMO corn is valid. Certainly, there is nothing in the paper that demonstrated that the control group’s feed was free of GMO corn.
The bottom line is that this study is about as bad as studies get. The editors of Food and Chemical Toxicology, the journal in which this pitiful excuse for a study was published, ought to hang their heads in shame. As it was so aptly put:
But it could more simply mean the GM maize and the herbicide had no measured effect, and that is why the dose made no difference. “They show that old rats get tumours and die,” says Mark Tester of the University of Adelaide, Australia. “That is all that can be concluded.”
Indeed. That is about all one can say about the study. Certainly we can’t say whether the GMO maize increased the propensity for tumors. It’s also interesting how the authors included so many photos of the rats and their tumors, photos that quacks like Mike Adams and Joe Mercola eagerly post on their websites, but failed to include photos of the control rats. They got tumors too. Were they qualitatively different in histology or organ distribution or different in size than the tumors in the mice eating the GMO maize? No, including all those photos of rats with tumors served no purpose other than to be sensationalistic and provide shocking pictures for anti-GMO activists to use to scare people.
So why should we care? As I said before, I detest ideologically-motivated pseudoscience and bad science. It’s the same reason I come down so hard on antivaccine “researchers” like Andrew Wakefield, Mark and David Geier, and various other “researchers” who pump out bad studies that support the long-discredited hypothesis that vaccines cause autism or that vaccines cause a whole host of problems. This bad science has real implications, both politically and in policy. Already, Séralini’s risibly bad study has motivated the French government to order a probe into the results of the study, which could result in the suspension of this strain of genetically modified corn. Moreover, one can’t help but wonder a little bit about the timing of the release of this study, given that Proposal 37, which would require the labeling of GMO-based food, is a big issue in California right now, and a study like this might just influence the election.
When it comes to GMO, I don’t really have a dog in the hunt, so to speak, but brain dead studies like this one certainly prod me towards the view that much of the “science” behind anti-GMO activism just doesn’t hold water, and the easy acceptance of such nonsensical results as valid by those who should know better but apparently don’t is just plain depressing. There might be valid reasons to be wary of the proliferation of GMO-based foods, such as concern over the control that large multinational corporations like Monsanto might exercise over the food supply, but the studies purporting to find horrific dangers of GMO-based food strike me as having the methodological rigor of a typical Andrew Wakefield or Mark Geier study—or an acupuncture study. Perhaps that’s why I wasn’t too surprised when one of my readers pointed out that one of the authors of the study is also a homeopath and acupuncturist; so maybe the better comparison to make to this paper would be papers by homeopaths trying to show that homeopathy works. Either way, this is bad, bad science, and it’s sad to see how many people who should know better (but apparently do not) lap it up so credulously while applying much greater skepticism to science that doesn’t damn GMOs as pure poison.
Next up, I anticipate that someone, instead of calling me a “pharma shill,” will call me a “Monsanto shill.” It’s coming. You know it is. Just wait. It’s inevitable. On the other hand, maybe I should look on the bright side. Perhaps I can generate a new revenue stream by adding all that filthy food industry lucre to all the filthy pharma lucre that antivaccinationists and quacks think I’m getting.
Heck, maybe Monsanto will want to hire me.*
*I kid. I kid.

More bad science in the service of anti-GMO activism
David Gorski on June 17, 2013
Link
I never used to write much about genetically modified organisms (GMOs) before. I still don’t do it that often. For whatever reason, it just hasn’t been on my radar very much. That seems to be changing, however. It’s not because I went seeking this issue out (although I must admit that I first became interested in genetic engineering when I was in junior high and read a TIME Magazine cover article about it back in the 1970s), but rather because in my reading I keep seeing it more and more in the context of anti-GMO activists using bad science and bad reasoning to justify a campaign to demonize GMOs. Now, I don’t have a dog in this hunt, (Forgive me, I have no idea why I like that expression, given that I don’t hunt.) I really don’t. I was, not too long ago, fairly agnostic on the issue of GMOs and their safety, although, truth be told, because I have PhD in a biomedical science and because my lab work has involved molecular biology and genetics since I was a graduate student in the early 1990s, I found the claims of horrific harm attributable to GMOs not particularly convincing, but hadn’t bothered to take that deep a look into them. It was not unlike my attitude towards the the claims that cell phones cause cancer a few years ago, before I looked into them and noted the utter lack of a remotely-plausible mechanism and uniformly negative studies except for a group in Sweden with a definite ax to grind on the issue. Back then, I realized that there wasn’t really a plausible mechanism by which radio waves from cell phones could cause cancer in that the classic mechanisms by which ionizing radiation can break DNA molecular bonds and cause mutations don’t apply, but I didn’t rule out a tiny possibility that there might be an as-yet unappreciated mechanism by which long term exposure to radio waves might contribute to cancer. I still don’t, by the way, which has gotten me into the odd kerfuffle with some skeptics and one physicist, but I still view the likelihood that cell phone radiation can cause cancer as being just a bit more plausible than homeopathy.
As was the case for the nonexistent cell phone-cancer link, there has now been a steady drip-drip-drip of bad studies touted by anti-GMO activists as “evidence” that GMOs are the work of Satan that will corrupt or kill us all (and make us fat, to boot). Not too long ago, I came across one such study, a truly execrable excuse for science by Gilles-Eric Séralini at the University of Caen purporting to demonstrate that Roundup-resistant genetically modified maize can cause horrific tumors in rats. I looked at the methods and conclusions and what I found was some of the worst science I had ever seen, every bit as bad as the quack “science” used by the antivaccine movement. It wasn’t for nothing that I made the comparison, because the anti-GMO movement is very much like the antivaccine movement and the cranks who claim that cell phone radiation causes cancer. As if to demonstrate that very point, last week I came across an article by the all-purpose crank to rule all cranks, Mike Adams, at NaturalNews.com entitled GMO feed turns pig stomachs to mush! Shocking photos reveal severe damage caused by GM soy and corn:
If you have stomach problems or gastrointestinal problems, a new study led by Dr. Judy Carman may help explain why: pigs fed a diet of genetically engineered soy and corn showed a 267% increase in severe stomach inflammation compared to those fed non-GMO diets. In males, the difference was even more pronounced: a 400% increase. (For the record, most autistic children are males, and nearly all of them have severe intestinal inflammation.)
The study was conducted on 168 young pigs on an authentic farm environment and was carried out over a 23-week period by eight researchers across Australia and the USA. The lead researcher, Dr. Judy Carman, is from the Institute of Health and Environmental Research in Kensington Park, Australia. The study has now been published in the Journal of Organic Systems, a peer-reviewed science journal.
It sounds pretty damning, doesn’t it? It sounds truly horrific, just as the Séralini study did. Adams is useful in that he takes the messages of anti-GMO activists (well, actually, he takes the messages of just about all cranks and quacks) and, as they said in This Is Spinal Tap, turns them up to 11. On the surface, it does, anyway. But what about the actual study. There was really only one thing for me to do, and that’s the same thing I did with the Séralini study: Go and see for myself. So I did.
What hath Judy Carman wrought?
Judy Carman’s study was, fortunately, published in an open access journal, and there was a direct link to the study itself. The first thing I did was to look at the journal. I had never heard of it before. The journal seems to cater to the organic crowd, being sponsored by groups like the Organic Federation of Australia and CSAFE, while the guidelines for authors state that “topics are to be consistent with current principles of organic farming and its associated industries, especially those in Australia, New Zealand, Asia, and the Pacific Islands.” The journal itself appears not to be indexed on PubMed, which tends to indicate either that it’s a new journal or not a very good journal. On the other hand, to be fair, there are plenty of CAM journals indexed in PubMed, and many of them are pure pseudoscience; so I can no longer conclude that lack of indexing in PubMed automatically means a journal is dodgy. It is, however, often an indication that it is. Moreover, if you wander over to Judy Carman’s website, gmojudycarman.org, you’ll see that it’s chock full of anti-GMO activism.
After having seen this study, I think that the editors of this open access journal have made a massive mistake and have, either wittingly or unwittingly, allowed their journal to become a tool of anti-GMO activist groups, a couple of which which gleefully announced the results of the study with press releases (for example here and here) calling the study “groundbreaking,” asserting that it was evidence of “adverse effects” due to GMO feed, and claiming that the results show “…clear evidence that regulators need to safety assess GM crops containing mixtures of GM genes, regardless of whether those genes occur in the one GM plant or in a mixture of GM plants eaten in the same meal, even if regulators have already assessed GM plants containing single GM genes in the mixture.”
Here’s a hint: It’s none of the above.
As I read the study itself, the first thing that became apparent to me is that it’s a massive fishing expedition. What do I mean by that? I mean that there’s no clear hypothesis. Basically, the only seeming hypothesis was “GMOs bad,” and the study was designed to find bad things associated with GMOs. At first glance, the design seems simple enough. The investigators used 168 just-weaned pigs at a commercial piggery in the US. The pigs were fed a standard diet, but half the pigs were fed widely used varieties of GM soy and GM corn, while the control group fed an equivalent non-GM diet. Basically, one protein made the plant resistant to a herbicide and two proteins were insecticides. The specific GM varieties used were as follows:
The corn used in this study contained 90% DK 42-88 RR YG PL (a triple stack of NK603, MON863 and MON810 genes) with the remainder being equal quantities of Pannar 5E-900RR (containing NK603), Pannar 4E-705RR/Bt (a double stack of NK603 and MON810) and Producers 5152 RR (containing NK603). Therefore, the GM corn that was used was genetically modified to produce three new proteins. Two were Bt proteins that protected the plant against insect attack, while the third protein provided the plant with tolerance to the herbicide glyphosate (Testbiotech, 2012; Monsanto, 2012). Because Roundup ReadyTM (RR) soy is predominant in the GM soy market, this was used. This crop contains a gene that provides tolerance to the herbicide glyphosate. GM DNA analysis (Genetic ID, Fairfield, Iowa, US) confirmed that the GM corn contained a combination of NK603, MON863 and MON810 genes (expressing the CP4 EPSPS, Cry 3Bb1 and Cry 1Ab proteins respectively), that the RR soy was 100% RR soy (expressing the CP4 EPSPS protein), that the non-GM feed contained a median of 0.4% GM corn and that the non-GM soy contained a median of 1.6% GM soy. Such GM contamination of apparent non-GM material is common in the US.
So the investigators fed piglets a diet of GMO grain versus non-GMO grain, let the pigs mature according to the normal methodology, and then after slaughter looked at a variety of outcomes. Worse, the authors measured these variables without any sort of control for multiple comparisons. Of course they found differences! Actually, what surprised me is how few differences they found between the groups, not how many. I’m going to hone in on the main finding of the paper first. It’s the finding that seemed the most dramatic and was the most highly publicized, the one mentioned by Mike Adams in his breathless description of he results, as though it was slam-dunk evidence that GMOs are evil. I’m referring, of course, to the claim that more stomach inflammation was observed in the pigs fed a GMO diet, specifically a 267% increase in severe stomach inflammation in the GMO group, with a whopping 400% increase in male pigs. It’s the result that produced pictures like this one in the paper (and, not surprisingly the same picture posted to many an anti-GMO website):
These images certainly look striking, but what do they mean? Well, not much. First of all, as many have pointed out, the photos chosen are deceptive in that not enough of the groups are shown, nor can we be sure that these are representative. Also, as Mark Hoofnagle points out, the assay for inflammation in the gastric mucosa of the piglets was only based on gross pathology. Basically, there was no histological study and pathological examination of the tissue to detect and quantify actual inflammation. Basically, the assay was based just on a gross visual inspection of the the tissue by a veterinarian (not even a veterinary pathologist even, as far as I can tell). Unfortunately, such inspections can be highly misleading, particularly after animals have been slaughtered in an abattoir, as described by Professor Robert Friendship, University of Guelph:
Dr. Robert Friendship, a professor in the Department of Population Medicine at the Ontario Veterinary College, University of Guelph and a swine health management specialist, reviewed the paper [see reference below]. He concluded that ‘it was incorrect for the researchers to conclude that one group had more stomach inflammation than the other group because the researchers did not examine stomach inflammation. They did a visual scoring of the colour of the lining of the stomach of pigs at the abattoir and misinterpreted redness to indicate evidence of inflammation. It does not. They would have had to take a tissue sample and prepare histological slides and examine these samples for evidence of inflammatory response such as white blood cell infiltration and other changes to determine if there was inflammation. There is no relationship between the colour of the stomach in the dead, bled-out pig at a slaughter plant and inflammation. The researchers should have included a veterinary pathologist on their team and this mistake would not have happened. They found no difference between the two experimental groups in pathology that can be determined by gross inspection.’
What I found particularly suspicious was Table 3. Notice how the level of inflammation is divided into no inflammation, mild inflammation, moderate inflammation, severe inflammation, erosions, pin-point ulcers, frank ulcers, and bleeding ulcers. This is not really a standard way of scoring inflammation. I don’t know about pigs, but in humans there are a variety of scoring systems for the endoscopic assessment of inflammation (for example, this one), particularly chronic gastritis (which is what we’re talking about, although such redness as described would, if associated with gastritis, be more associated with acute gastritis). Worse, gross visual assessment of gastric mucosa is subject to high inter-observer variability, and, although the personnel caring for the pigs and doing the autopsies were blinded to the experimental group (which is good), I don’t see any attempt to control for inter-observer variability, and, again, no control for multiple comparisons.
I also note that the difference between pin-point ulcers, frank ulcers, and bleeding ulcers is rather arbitrarily defined and not entirely clear. Also notice how twice as many pigs had no inflammation in the non-GMO group and that there was actually a lower risk of mild and moderate inflammation, as well as erosions and pin-point ulcers. Of course, the p-values are all non-significant, except for one: that for severe inflammation. In fact, on the entire table, the only “statistically significant” result is for “severe inflammation.” In fact, as Mark Lynas points out, many more pigs fed non-GMO feed had stomach inflammation than those with GMO feed.
Lynas also points out that the data are all over the place with respect to reported levels of inflammation, asking the very apt question, “If GMO feed is causing the severe inflammation, why is the non-GMO feed causing far more mild to moderate inflammation?” One also can’t help but notice that for “moderate” inflammation, there was a difference favoring the non-GMO feed, and I echo the question, “Do Carman et al perform a test for statistical significance to see if GMO feed has a protective effect on pigs stomachs? Of course not – that’s not the result they are after.” Exactly. Even worse, they used the wrong statistical analysis to analyze categorical data. When the data are analyzed more appropriately, there appears to be no statistically significant difference between the groups, just as there was no real statistically significant difference in the tumor burden of the rats in the Séralini study. Come to think of it, Carman’s study resembles the Seralini study in that it basically looks at a whole lot of outcomes in a fairly arbitrary fashion and cherry picks the inevitable “positive” result. In fact, if you take all the groups together, there actually appears to be a non-statistically significant trend towards less stomach inflammation in the GMO group. Yes, less. As Karl Haro von Mogel put it, the authors appeared to be “trying to shoe-horn individual categories that aren’t binary data into a statistical test designed for binary data is the wrong approach.” Basically, however you look at it, there’s just no “there” there. Analyzed correctly, there is no statistically significant (or, no doubt, biologically significant) difference in stomach inflammation in this study. As for the reported increase in uterus weights, as Professor David Spiegelhalter, Winton Professor of the Public Understanding of Risk at the University of Cambridge points out, “There are also 19 other reported statistical tests, which means we would expect one significant association just by chance: and so the apparent difference in uterus weight is likely to be a false positive.”
There’s another aspect of this paper that’s very troubling, and it is that these animals were all very sick. Indeed, I have to wonder how they were being cared for. Over half the animals are reported in Table 3 to have pneumonia, defined as “consolidating bronchopneumonia of the cranial ventral lung lobe(s) and/or caudal lobes.” That is just not normal, and it doesn’t sound like a minor pneumonia. True, this pneumonia wasn’t histologically verified either, as far as I can tell, although pneumonia can be viewed grossly if it’s bad enough. It is, after all, basically puss mixed with mucous in the alveolae and bronchial passages. As has been pointed out in multiple discussions of this study, such a high percentage of animals with pneumonia is an indicator of very bad animal husbandry, indeed. The bottom line is that there are many, many problems with this study, the totality of which are more than enough to render its results meaningless. There is no dose-dependent mechanism for the effects reported, no rhyme or reason consistent with a mechanism that would explain why GMOs would affect just the stomach (and then only to cause severe inflammation) and uterus size. The study was a fishing expedition and not hypothesis-driven. It’s not surprising that it found something. I’d be shocked if it hadn’t. In the end, this study abused a fairly large number of innocent pigs to produce no useful data. She might try to defend it against criticism, but she basically fails. In particular, one notes that she can’t seem to defend against the charge of a lack of hypothesis and that she didn’t even try to defend the criticism that she didn’t bother to look at stomach histology to verify that there really was inflammation in the gastric mucosa, despite Carman’s touting that the “authors have over 60 years of combined experience and expertise in medicine, animal husbandry, animal nutrition, animal health, veterinary science, biochemistry, toxicology, medical research, histology, risk assessment, epidemiology and statistics.” Sad that they didn’t use all that experience to produce a paper whose results are believable and useful.
This isn’t Judy Carman’s first time…
In reading this study, I couldn’t help but notice the corresponding author: Judy Carman. I had heard that name before. But where? Oh, yes. I remembered. I had encountered her making some truly ridiculous claims about GMOs, so ridiculous that I think it’s worth bringing up now. She didn’t write the commentary I’m about to describe, but she voiced support for its findings, providing tactical air support to its author, Jack Heineman. I had wanted to write about it at the time I came across it, but, for whatever reason, didn’t manage it. So now’s as good a time as any. In brief, Carman appears to be an anti-GMO activist who, along with another anti-GMO activist, Professor Jack Heinemann at the University of Canterbury’s Centre for Integrated Research in Biosafety, made some truly nonsensical claims about GMOs. I first encountered these nonsensical claims in the blog of a homeopath named Heidi Stevenson, who claimed that genetically modified wheat may damage human genetics permanently.
Stevenson prefaces her article with this scary paragraph:
The Australian government, in the form of its science research arm, is joining Agribusiness profiteering by designing a GM wheat that could kill people who eat it & be inherited by their children.
Scared yet? Does Stevenson have your attention? Who are these nefarious scientists, and why would they want to make genetically modified wheat that would do these things? They wouldn’t, of course, but, like the Frankenstein that anti-GMO activists think scientists are, it’s a matter of messing with nature resulting in unintended consequences. In fact, the hilarity is such that I think it’s worth quoting a decent sized chunk of the first part of Stevenson’s article:
We have not yet seen the worst damage that genetic engineering may do. Australia’s governmental agency, Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO), is developing a wheat species that is engineered to turn off genes permanently.
Professor Jack Heinemann at the University of Canterbury’s Centre for Integrated Research in Biosafety has studied the wheat’s potential. Digital Journal reports that he says1:
What we found is that the molecules created in this wheat, intended to silence wheat genes, can match human genes, and through ingestion, these molecules can enter human beings and potentially silence our genes. The findings are absolutely assured. There is no doubt that these matches exist.
The implications are clarified by Professor Judy Carman of Flinders University:
If this silences the same gene in us that it silences in the wheat—well, children who are born with this enzyme not working tend to die by the age of about five.
Silencing the equivalent gene in humans that is silenced in this genetically modified wheat holds the potential of killing people. But it gets worse. Silenced genes are permanently silenced and can be passed down the generations.
Yes, that’s the very same Judy Carman who published this awful “stomach inflammation” study that I just discussed.
Basically, Carman’s claim here is that a variety of genetically modified wheat under development by the CSIRO will kill your children. I kid you not. And Judy Carman has not only promoted this idea but amplified it by emphasizing that she thinks children could die. Of course, Stevenson apparently doesn’t see the contradiction between saying that this GM wheat will kill your children but that its gene-silencing effects will also be passed down the generations. Neither does Carman, who continued:
As a result, there is a chain of evidence to show that there is a risk that the dsRNA from this GM wheat may survive digestion, enter the tissues of people that eat it and silence a gene or genes in those people. There is also evidence that any genetic changes so produced may be stable and become established in many cells of an organ. Furthermore, there a possibility that these changes may be passed-on to future generations.
In any case, I could recognize some amazing speculation and fear mongering right off the bat; so it’s time to explain.
Gene “silencing” means what the name implies: Shutting down the activity of a gene so that it stops making its gene product. Of course, gene silencing is not an all-or-nothing phenomenon. Like other forms of gene regulation, silencing happens on a continuum from zero to complete silencing, depending on the level and activity of the silencing agent. In this case, the silencing agent that is being turned into the bogeyman du jour is RNA. Specifically, it’s a type of RNA-mediated gene silencing called RNA interference (or RNAi), also known as post transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS). The idea is that the CSIRO is apparently engineering a strain of wheat that produces a short RNA molecule designed to silence specific genes in the wheat. Most of the time, when we talk about RNA, we talk about messenger RNA (mRNA), the RNA that is the intermediary between DNA and protein. However, back in the late 1990s, it was discovered that there are other RNA molecules that actually regulate gene expression by binding to complementary sequences on mRNAs. These molecules include classes of RNAs called microRNAs, as well as double-stranded RNA molecules known as short interfering RNA (siRNA), that can participate in cellular pathways that contribute to gene silencing, most commonly through binding to complementary sequences and inducing the degradation of different mRNAs in a sequence-specific manner. In fact, siRNAs were first discovered in plant genetics and only later was it discovered that short RNAs serve as a gene regulatory mechanism in mammalian cells as well.
An excellent video explanation of RNAi can be found, courtesy of Nature:
So what’s the problem? Heinemann and Carman are apparently worried that the siRNA that will be used to silence two genes in wheat called SEI and SEII. Heinemann apparently did an analysis based on the sequence of the SEI and SEII genes, comparing them against the human genome and looking for matches. He found them in the gene for the enzyme mentioned by Judy Carman. In humans, the equivalent gene is known as glucan (1,4‐alpha‐), branching enzyme 1, abbreviated GBE. Based on some similarities he found between SEI and GBE, Heinemann sounded an alarm through an anti-GMO activist group known as the Safe Food Foundation & Institute. Humans store carbohydrates as glycogen, and GBE makes branches in glycogen. There is a consequence to not being able to branch one’s glycogen, although not branching it in wheat could be useful for decreasing its glycemic index. There is a disease known as glycogen storage disease IV, which leads to damage to the liver over time. That’s the disease that Judy Carman was referring to.
Of course, the problem with Dr. Heinemann’s highly speculative analysis is that he didn’t know the actual siRNA sequences that were going to be used. Without that information his analysis was pretty pointless. At the very best, it was highly speculative. At the worst, it was ideologically and politically motivated.
So how could this possibly matter? After all, it’s RNA. It’s really unstable, isn’t it? Well, not exactly. Single stranded RNA is very unstable. It can’t survive long outside of the cell. However, dsRNA can be quite stable, even outside of a cell. But that still leaves the question of whether dsRNA from a plant that is eaten can have any effect. To do that, the siRNA would have to survive digestion, be absorbed into the bloodstream, enter other cells, and act on gene expression. Heinemann notes that such a phenomenon can be observed in insects and worms.
But can it happen in humans? Well, there is one paper that Heinemann latched on to because he thinks it demonstrates that the same phenomenon can happen in humans. It’s a paper by Zhang et al. published in Cell Research that showed that showed that a plant-derived microRNA (miR-168a) from rice can be found in human serum after ingesting rice and that it can actually bind to the mRNA for low-density lipoprotein receptor adapter protein 1, thus inhibiting the expression of this protein. It’s an interesting observation, but there are a number of questions. For one thing, although the microRNAs are detectable in serum they circulate at a really low concentration, namely the femtomolar range (10-15 mole/Liter). News stories describing the study at the time were quite credulous, but a better discussion can be found at Sandwalk. In any case, the exceedingly low concentration of microRNA observed in the bloodstream leaves a huge question in that there is no known mechanism by which such a low concentration could have such an effect. When I first read the study, I thought it plausible, but the more I think about it the more I agree with the Sandwalk commenter who says it screams “artifact” to him. Or this commenter:
There is probably 10 fM of everything in the blood. Sheesh, that’s less than 4×10^9 molecules per whole body consisting of about 7×10^12 cells and containing no more than 7×10^10 hepatocytes. That’s less than 0.1 miRNA per liver cell in the best possible scenario. What are these RNAs, totally magic?
Maybe they’re homeopathic, although admittedly fM concentrations are far and away greater than the concentrations of most homeopathic remedies (i.e., zero). In any case, stoichiometry is your friend when figuring these things out. Personally, I’ll wait for some confirmation that this happens from other groups before I buy it. True, another group has reported finding miR-168a, but it also reported a huge variety of microRNAs in the serum from a variety of sources, including bacteria and fungi as well as from other species, such as various insects. Basically, we’re awash in microRNAs from other species that we come into contact with. So far, the only evidence that they have any effect whatsoever is that one study suggesting that miR-168a might regulate one gene, even though it’s hard to figure out by what mechanism it could possibly accomplish this. Add to that the utter lack of evidence that any circulating microRNA can not only silence a gene in human cells but actually induce epigenetic changes, and Professor Heinemann’s speculation becomes ever more…speculative. This is true particularly in light of the fact that we regularly eat plants that make many siRNAs and microRNAs. Why would GM wheat siRNAs be any different or more dangerous, particularly given the very low concentrations involved?
Let’s put it this way. For Heinemann and Carman’s fear mongering to be a real concern, any siRNA or microRNA from genetically modified wheat would not only have to be made in sufficient quantity at least to equal the normal concentration of miR-168a in rice, but also be stable enough to pass through stomach acid and the gut lining undigested, and get into the bloodstream at a high enough level to affect gene expression. That’s leaving aside the question of whether there is even enough sequence match that the siRNA could even target the human GBE mRNA in the first place, which is impossible to say because we don’t know the actual sequence of the siRNA being used. It’s true that Heinemann has updated his “report.” However, that update doesn’t really show anything new or contribute to the plausibility of Heinemann’s concerns. In fact, it trashes the plausibility even more because the homology (in laymen’s terms, match) to the glycogen enzyme that Heinemann was promoting pretty much disappears in this reanalysis. (In fact, if you look at it in depth, it wasn’t even there to begin with, and it’s questionable whether he even used the right wheat sequence in his BLAST analyses.) Even in the reanalysis, the only areas of match appeared in introns, which, as Biofortified put it:
However, all of the matches he highlights are either to introns – which would not matter for the mechanism of action that is the issue here. Or they are in the genome desert areas, thousands of bases away from anything that appears to be a gene.
Result: Take a deep breath. The GMO wheat that forms the basis of this claim will not kill your children or permanently alter your genome.
More interestingly, I decided to check back and see if the human GBE gene is still sticking with this sequence switcheroo. The main fear-based claim was that the GBE gene would be suppressed and children with a disorder of this can die by the age of 5. So let’s see–let’s do an analysis of this new sequence and compare it to GBE. If you perform a BLASTn at NCBI with these two sequences and default settings as Jack says he does, what do we get?
The result? No significant similarity found.
That’s right. The entire foundation of the fear–the match to GBE–is gone. Evaporated. Vanished. Nada. Zip.
No wonder Australian and New Zealand regulators have rejected the concerns.
Add to that the enormous lack of likelihood that, even if the siRNAs and microRNAs in GM wheat could actually make it into the bloodstream in concentrations sufficient to alter gene expression, it’s incredibly unlikely that such RNAs could actually induce “permanent” epigenetic changes to justify the fear mongering.
There might be questions about GMOs, but by and large they are not issues of safety. Rather, they are issues of intellectual property; i.e., how large companies developing GMOs behave. Hysteria of the like generated by the likes of Jack Heinemann and Judy Carman and parroted by useful idiots like Heidi Stevenson generate heat, but no light. Nor does the latest round of attempts to generate hysterical fear mongering based on Carman’s latest study. Both Heinemann’s speculations and Carman’s most recent bit of data mining are of a piece. They are not designed to provide a dispassionate analysis of the true potential risks and benefits of GMOs. They are designed to be propaganda to produce fear, uncertainty, and doubt about GMOs, just like Andrew Wakefield’s studies about the MMR vaccine, just like Mark and David Geier’s studies of thimerosal in vaccines, just like the studies of any variety of antivaccine cranks. It is the equivalent of shouting “fire!” in a crowded theater.
Unfortunately, the pseudoscience is metastasizing. GMO Pundit points out the next frontier of anti-GMO fear mongering.:
Yes, because a new flu vaccine Flublok is made in “insect cells” (specifically, the baculovirus system, a very common system of expressing mammalian proteins for use in genetically engineered products), it is now a “GMO product” and to be feared as much as GMO-derived foods. In actuality, Flublok should end up being safer than the old flu vaccine because it doesn’t include all those extraneous proteins, such as egg protein, just the three hemagglutinin, or HA proteins, of the most common flu strains circulating in any given year.
What’s next? Telling diabetics that they shouldn’t take insulin derived from genetic engineering because the protein is made in—gasp!—bacteria or yeast?

The Seralini GMO Study – Retraction and Response to Critics
Steven Novella on December 4, 2013
Link

Elsevier has announced that they are retracting the infamous Seralini study which claimed to show that GMO corn causes cancer in laboratory rats. The retraction comes one year after the paper was published, and seems to be a response to the avalanche of criticism the study has faced. This retraction is to the anti-GMO world what the retraction of the infamous Wakefield Lancet paper was to the anti-vaccine world.
The Seralini paper was published in November 2012 in Food and Chemical Toxicology. It was immediately embraced by anti-GMO activists, and continues to be often cited as evidence that GMO foods are unhealthy. It was also immediately skewered by skeptics and more objective scientists as a fatally flawed study.
The study looked at male and female rats of the Sprague-Dawley strain of rat – a strain with a known high baseline incidence of tumors. These rats were fed regular corn mixed with various percentages of GMO corn: zero (the control groups), 11, 22, and 33%. Another group was fed GMO corn plus glyphosate (Round-Up) in their water, and a third was given just glyphosate. The authors concluded: 
The results of the study presented here clearly demonstrate that lower levels of complete agricultural glyphosate herbicide formulations, at concentrations well below officially set safety limits, induce severe hormone-dependent mammary, hepatic and kidney disturbances. Similarly, disruption of biosynthetic pathways that may result from overexpression of the EPSPS transgene in the GM NK603 maize can give rise to comparable pathologies that may be linked to abnormal or unbalanced phenolic acids metabolites, or related compounds. Other mutagenic and metabolic effects of the edible GMO cannot be excluded.
Sounds pretty scary. Now let’s look at the multiple criticisms:
The biggest criticism of the study is the combination of two features – the small sample size and lack of statistical analysis. The entire study is premised on comparing various dose groups with control groups that were not exposed to GMO or glyphosate. And yet, the authors provide no statistical analysis of this comparison. Given the small number of rats in each group, it is likely that this lack of statistical analysis is due to the fact that statistical significance could not be reached.
In other words – the results of the study are uninterpretable. In the retraction statement Elsevier wrote:
Ultimately, the results presented (while not incorrect) are inconclusive, and therefore do not reach the threshold of publication for Food and Chemical Toxicology.
The retraction reads like a long excuse for the editorial failure of the journal, and is disappointing. But at least they ultimately reached the correct conclusion – this paper should never have been published. It slipped through the cracks of peer review.
If you look at the survival curves for the various groups, I think you will see that the results are all over the place. This is a typical scatter of data with no clear pattern. In the male groups, the GMO and glyphosate groups tended to do better, if anything. In the female groups they did worse, but there is no clear dose-response effect evident, and the overall results are a wash. Inconclusive is being polite – the data do not show anything, especially absent any statistical analysis.
The study has also been criticized for their choice and treatment of animals. Choosing a strain with a very high background rate of tumor is asking for lots of noise in the data. In fact, a study of the strain found:
The total tumor incidences were 70 to 76.7% and 87 to 95.8% in males and females, respectively.
Further, many scientists charged that the rats were not treated ethically. It is standard practice in such studies to establish an endpoint, such as tumor number and size, at which point the animal with be euthanized. In this study the rats were allow to die of their tumors. The more cynical critics of the study speculate that this was done to generate graphic images in order to have the intended effect on public opinion.
Seralini responds
Despite the fact the the article has been withdrawn, Seralini is not backing off his support of the results. In a detailed response to critics, Seralini and his coauthors write in the introduction:
This may explain why 75% of our first criticisms arising within a week, among publishing authors, come from plant biologists, some developing patents on GMOs, even if it was a toxicological paper on mammals, and from Monsanto Company who owns both the NK603 GM maize and R herbicide.
They are immediately trying to frame the discussion as that between vested corporate interests and scientists. This is a diversion, however, and is irrelevant to the substance of the scientific criticism of their paper. Further, much substantive criticism came from the scientific community, not Monsanto. The most recently published, for example, concludes:
We and many others have criticized the study, and in particular the manner in which the experiments were planned, implemented, analyzed, interpreted and communicated. The study appeared to sweep aside all known benchmarks of scientific good practice and, more importantly, to ignore the minimal standards of scientific and ethical conduct in particular concerning the humane treatment of experimental animals.
They also call for Monsanto to release the raw data for the 2004 Hammond study, which was a 13-week trial of Roundup Ready corn. This is a reasonable request in itself – I think all such studies should disclose the raw data for independent review. But the placement of this request in the Seralini response still serves as another diversion from criticism and a way of calling into question the results of the 2004 study, which showed no health effects from the GM corn.
Much of their defense of their protocol consists of pointing out deficiencies in other similar research. While this does address the standards typical in this type of research, it does not address the main criticism, that the cumulative deficiencies in the Seralini study make interpreting the results impossible.
They even defend the lack of statistical analysis of the survival curves, which were the main outcome. They stated that they wanted to be “simply factual” and then again criticize the statistics used in other studies.
Conclusion: Seralini’s study was unethical, poorly-done, and ideologically motivated
The Seralini study suffers from small sample size, lack of statistical analysis, ambiguous results, a questionable selection of rat strain which maximizes noise in the data, and dubious ethical treatment of the animals for possible dramatic effect. At this point anyone referencing this study as support for their position that GMO has health risks sacrifices their credibility.
It helps that the study has now officially been withdrawn, but references to the study in the anti-GMO literature are spread across the internet. The damage is done.
The study is similar in quality to the Carman pig stomach study – which was also worthless but was presented as evidence that GMO is bad. This study also took a random scatter of data and then hunted for any possible illusion of a signal in the noise.
Meanwhile, systematic reviews of the research show no evidence for any health risks from GMO foods.
Seralini et al.’s response to their critics is not convincing, and mostly consists if the tu quoque logical fallacy. They also call for more rigor and transparency in further GMO research. This is hard to disagree with – we can always use more rigor and transparency. This does not, however, answer the deficiencies in the Seralini study.
Calls for more rigorous research also echo what we hear from the anti-vaccine movement. Safety data consists of not finding a health risk, and negative findings are difficult to prove. They are only ever as good as the amount and rigor of our current data. We can always benefit from more and more rigorous safety data, and this makes for an easy criticism for anti-GMO activists or anti-vaccinationists (or anti-fluoridation, or whatever) to make.
At some point we have to set reasonable thresholds for safety data. To the critics, it will never be enough. Vested interests, of course, want the bar to be very low (they would probably be happy with the bar being eliminated, as with the supplement industry). The scientific community, in collaboration with regulators, need to set reasonable, science-based thresholds for safety data, which will never be perfect or guarantee zero risk.
For current GMO foods the evidence seems to be above a reasonable threshold for safety. More data is always welcome, but that does not mean holding an industry hostage to endless calls for more data.

Another Anti-GMO Paper Retracted
Steven Novella on March 16, 2016
Link


Retraction Watch is a great website. As the name implies, it focuses on a key aspect of quality control in science, the retraction of scientific papers that have already passed peer-review and were published when serious concerns about those papers come to light.
Retracting published papers is similar to phase IV clinical trials – tracking side effects of drugs that have already been approved and are on the market so regulatory agencies can monitor for post-marketing concerns and recall the drug if necessary.
Infascelli’s woes
Recently the journal animal retracted a paper by Italian researcher, Federico Infascelli. Here is there announcement:
From late September 2015, we received several expressions of concern from third parties that the electrophoresis gels presented might have been subject to unwarranted digital manipulations (added and hidden bands or zones, including in the control samples and the DNA ladder). A detailed independent investigation was carried out by animal in accordance with the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidelines. This investigation included an analysis of the claims using the figures as submitted, and reassessment of the article by one of the original peer-reviewers in light of the results of the analysis. The authors were notified of our concerns and asked to account for the observed irregularities. In the absence of a satisfactory explanation, the institution was asked to investigate further. The University of Naples concluded that multiple heterogeneities were likely attributable to digital manipulation, raising serious doubts on the reliability of the findings.
Based on the results of all investigations, we have decided to retract the article.
It looks to me like the authors of retraction statement are trying very hard not to use the words, “scientific fraud.” The “observed irregularities” essentially were due to alleged digital manipulation of images of electrophresis gels. Retraction Watch recounts a Nature report which stated:
…sections of images of electrophoresis gels appeared to have been obliterated, and some of the images in different papers appeared to be identical but with captions describing different experiments.
The included picture is taken from the now-retracted article, showing images of electrophoresis gels. Let’s be clear – these images are the data. Those bands represent identified pieces of DNA. When you add or delete bands from the images, you are manipulating the data. Data manipulation is scientific fraud.
This is the second paper by Infascelli retracted due to concerns over data manipulation (the first was retracted in January). A third is under investigation but has not yet been retracted. All of these papers were used to raise concerns about the safety of genetically modified crops and have been used for anti-GMO lobbying.
Given this revelation, I don’t see how any research by Infascelli or his team can ever be trusted. He now joins Seralini as a researcher who publishes dubious articles which seem motivated by an anti-GMO ideology. In Seralini’s case he was not accused of fraud, just egregiously poor scientific rigor.
A deeper problem
This one paper is not an isolated event. Nor is the problem unique to Infascelli, or even anti-GMO papers. There are two aspects to this phenomenon I want to consider – scientific fraud in general, and the emergence of an ideologically-motivated scientific fringe or subculture.
Scientific fraud is increasingly being recognized as a serious problem. I don’t want to overstate the issue – most scientific studies are perfectly legitimate, and the system tends to work itself out over the long haul. Fraud is the exception within the scientific literature, but it happens often enough to be a serious problem.
Estimating the prevalence of fraud (or more generally, “misconduct”) is difficult, because first you have to agree on an operational definition. Then there is the problem of finding and reporting all cases of misconduct. A recent paper estimates that there have been hundreds of recent cases of exposed misconduct in the US, and about 50 cases per year in the UK alone.
An anonymous survey sent to researchers found that 2% admitted to outright fabrication of data. However, 33% admitted to some dodgy research practices. These practices include throwing out data that contradicts their hypothesis, deliberately fudging the design of studies in order to get a desired result, and altering a study design at the request of the sponsor.
Fudging the study design has a powerful effect on the outcome. Simmons et al showed that such design manipulation can generate a false positive result to a 0.05 significance from dead-negative data 60% of the time.
All of this is why independent replication is so important. This is part of the reason we set the threshold for being convinced by scientific evidence as high as we do – it has to rise above the noise of false positives. That noise is a lot louder than many people realize. Small studies, one-offs, or outcomes that only seem to come from one researcher, are just not convincing.
In addition to the background noise of varying degrees of scientific misconduct, there appear to be dedicated scientific subcultures that always seem to produce results that are against the scientific mainstream but consistent support a particular ideological position.
There are a few researchers who consistently produce results which call into question the safety of GMOs, for example, despite the fact that the rest of the scientific world finds that genetically modified foods are safe for human consumption.
There are a few researchers who consistently produce results which call into question the safety of vaccines, despite the fact that the rest of the scientific world finds that approved vaccines are generally safe and effective.
The same can be said about anthropogenic global warming and the safety of cell phones. Unfortunately, these outlier researchers produce the impression that there is more of a controversy than there really is. They create “two sides,” and the press often misses the fact that those sides are decidedly asymmetrical.
They also produce scientific studies that can be cited by those with a particular political or ideological opinion, giving their position the false appearance of being science-based. Work by Seralini and Infascelli has become the centerpiece for anti-GMO lobbying, for example.
Solutions to scientific misconduct?
Fortunately, I think we are already heading in the direction of addressing the issue of scientific misconduct. Efforts like Retraction Watch are helping. Journal editors need to have more of a process in place to sniff out fraud and misconduct during the peer-review process. Failing that, any concerns about misconduct raised post-publication need to be taken seriously, investigated, and then transparently corrected when necessary.
Obviously when a researcher is found to have committed brazen fraud, their career must be over. Their research can never be trusted again.
However, there is a vast gray zone of scientific misconduct that can be addressed through education. Researchers need to be explicitly trained about the nature of scientific misconduct, how to avoid it, and put on notice that such misconduct will not be tolerated.
The institution of science depends upon both transparency and trust. That trust is a product of the culture of the institution. Scientific culture cannot tolerate cutting corners, looking the other way, compromising rigor to get a desired outcome, fudging protocols, or yielding to pressure.
To a large extent the culture of science does promote honesty and transparency, but it seems we need to make a push even further in that direction.

National Academy of Sciences Report on GMOs
Steven Novella on May 18, 2016
Link

Despite the fact that numerous scientific and health organizations around the world have examined the evidence regarding the safety of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) and found them to be completely safe, there remains a public controversy on this topic. In fact a Pew Poll found that while 88% of AAAS scientists believe that GMOs are safe for human consumption, only 37% of the public do – a 51% gap, the largest in the survey.
This gap is largely due to an aggressive anti-GMO propaganda campaign by certain environmental groups and the organic food industry, a competitor which stands to profit from anti-GMO sentiments. There is also a certain amount of generic discomfort with a new and complex technology involving our food.
Because of all this, the National Academy of Sciences put together an expert committee to systematically review all the evidence regarding this new technology. Their thorough 407 page report is now available.
They pulled together experts with diverse backgrounds, and also took public comment and solicited input from a wide range of interests. They decided specifically not to rely on any previous review, but to conduct their own review of the primary literature.
The NAS report’s findings
Health and safety of GMOs
The report gives this summary of its findings regarding the health risks of GMOs (for which the report uses the synonym “genetically engineered/GE”):
The design and analysis of many animal-feeding studies were not optimal, but the large number of experimental studies provided reasonable evidence that animals were not harmed by eating food derived from GE crops. Additionally, long-term data on livestock health before and after the introduction of GE crops showed no adverse effects associated with GE crops. The committee also examined epidemiological data on incidence of cancers and other human-health problems over time and found no substantiated evidence that foods from GE crops were less safe than foods from non-GE crops.
This coincides with every other major review of the evidence. The bottom line is that there is no particular reason to believe that currently available GM crops pose any health risk or that they are different with regard to their safety and nutrition from their conventional analogues. There is also nothing about the current processes used to generate GMOs that would theoretically pose a unique health risk.
It is especially compelling that over the last two decades, animals and humans exposed to GMOs have not experienced any relative increase in any major disease.
Economic and environmental issues
Introduction of available GMOs has generally had a positive effect on farmers and the environment. They write:
The available evidence indicates that GE soybean, cotton, and maize have generally had favorable economic outcomes for producers who have adopted these crops, but outcomes have been heterogeneous depending on pest abundance, farming practices, and agricultural infrastructure.
Essentially what their analysis is saying is that GMOs have been a useful tool to increase profits for farmers and can be very beneficial to the environment, but they have to be used correctly and are not a panacea. This makes GMOs, therefore, like any other technology.
Obviously farmers face complex economic challenges, especially in some parts of the world. The availability of GM crops has been a positive factor, but does not address all the complex issues faced by farmers. I do not consider this a criticism, but rather an obvious truism.
The same is true for the environmental effects. The NAS committee found that the introduction of Bt varieties (which incorporate a natural pesticide) reduced overall pesticide use, reduced pest populations (and therefore benefited even non-GMO crops), and increased insect diversity.
Likewise, the use of herbicide-resistant crops has resulted in a small increase in yield without any decrease in plant diversity.
In both cases, however, the report also notes that if these technologies are overused then pesticide and herbicide resistance will become a problem. They recommend, as have many previous experts and reviews, that Bt and herbicide-resistant crops be used as part of integrated pest management.
To summarize the summary – when used properly, GMOs are good for farmers and good for the environment. GM foods are safe for animals and humans.
Testing and regulation
Another interesting area of the report is their comment on testing and regulation. They essentially argue that current regulations are based upon a false dichotomy, between conventional and genetically modified organisms. They point out that emerging technologies are increasingly blurring the lines. Gene editing is not quite genetic engineering, and genetic technologies are being used to guide crop breeding, for example.
They argue, and I agree, that it is not rational to base requirements for testing on the process but rather on the outcome. They write:
Emerging genetic technologies have blurred the distinction between genetic engineering and conventional plant breeding to the point where regulatory systems based on process are technically difficult to defend. The committee recommends that new varieties—whether genetically engineered or conventionally bred—be subjected to safety testing if they have novel intended or unintended characteristics with potential hazards.
This makes a great deal of sense. Conventional breeding, use of forced hybridization, or mutation farming, is not inherently safer than using any of the increasing number of technologies for more directly altering the genetic makeup of a crop. What matters is if there are novel traits of unknown safety, in which case they should be tested.
This blurring of the lines should also frustrate labeling efforts, since the entire notion behind labeling is based on the false dichotomy that the NAS report just demolished.
Responses
As one might predict, responses to the report have coincided with previous ideological leanings. The report is so large and covers so much territory that it provides a Rorschach test – people see in it what they want.
For example:
Michael Hansen, PhD, senior scientist with Consumers Union, said, “When it comes to GMO labels, the NAS report points out that there are value choices that consumers want to make when they shop for food. We’re pleased to see that the report cites the wealth of polling data showing consumers want GMO labelling.”
They say the report provides reasons for GMO labelling, when actually it doesn’t. It just refers to public opinion, but from a scientific point of view it entirely removes the rationale for labelling.
This NPR headline is typical of another dubious negative response: “GMOs Are Safe, But Don’t Always Deliver On Promises, Top Scientists Say.”
The promise that GMOs have not delivered on, according to NPR, is that they have not substantially increased yields. This is a common criticism of the GMO industry. However, the currently available GMOs are not intended to increase yield. They do reduce loss and make yields more predictable, which is very useful to farmers, making this a highly misleading criticism and a cherry-picked point to feature in a headline.
This says nothing, also, about the technology, only its current applications. There are researchers working on traits that could substantially increase yield. Some scientists argue we will need GM technology to keep up with growing demand for crops, especially with a changing climate.
Finally, it is no surprise that some are already lazily dismissing the NAS report as biased:
“The makeup of the panel is pretty clear. People are coming in with a perspective that is pro-genetically engineered crop,” says Patty Lovera, assistant director of Food & Water Watch.
Meanwhile the reality is that the committee is almost entirely made up of independent academics from major universities with not significant ties to industry. At worst some committee members may have done some consulting for industry, but that is a common and insignificant connection without any conflict of interest.
Conclusion: Another refutation of GMO fearmongering
The NAS report adds to the growing list of comprehensive scientific reviews of GM technology finding that they are safe, good for farmers, and good for the environment when used as part of integrated pest management.
The dire warnings of anti-GMO groups are not backed by evidence; in fact they are directly contradicted by the evidence. It is ironic that environmental groups oppose GM technology when the result of their opposition is to harm the environment.
The clearest evidence relates to the health effects of GM technology and currently available GMOs. GMOs are safe for humans and animals. Hopefully the NAS report will help move the needle on public opinion, which is currently highly divergent from reality.

We still Need Better Communication on GMOs
A new PEW survey has been carried out regarding public attitudes toward genetically modified organisms (GMOs), organic food, and scientific consensus. While the numbers are better than I expected for science, they still indicate a large disconnect between scientific and public opinion on food matters. Scientists need to do better.
Steven Novella on December 7, 2016
Link

A new PEW survey does a deep exploration of public attitudes toward genetically modified organisms (GMOs), organic food, and scientific consensus. While the numbers are better than I thought they would be, perhaps indicating some progress, they still indicate a large disconnect between scientific and public opinion on food matters.
GMOs are safe
It is reasonable to take as a premise for understanding this survey that there is a strong scientific consensus that GMOs are safe for human and animal consumption. Every major scientific and medical organization that has systematically reviewed the published data (most of which, by the way, is independent from industry) have come to the same conclusion, that current GMOs on the market are safe and that there are no inherent risks to current technologies used to create GMOs. The latest such report, a 2016 review conducted by the National Academy of Sciences and discussed here on SBM in May, also concluded GMOs are safe.
In a 2015 Pew survey, 88% of scientists surveyed reported they felt GMOs were safe. That was higher than the 87% who reported they believed in man-made global warming. So arguably there is a stronger scientific consensus that GMOs are safe than there is for anthropogenic global warming.
At the same time there is no convincing evidence, after 50 years of research, that organic food is more healthful than conventional produce.
In that same 2015 Pew survey only 37% of US adults agreed with the statement that GMOs are safe to eat. That was a 51% difference in opinion between scientists and the general public, the largest gap of any issue covered in the survey.
As an aside, when discussing GMO safety and the healthfulness of organic vs conventional food many advocates will argue that many people choose organic or to avoid GMOs for reasons other than health, either environmental or reasons of social justice. However, this survey also found that 76% of people who choose organic do so for perceived health benefits. It’s also irrelevant to this discussion, which is about the public perception of the scientific consensus on health.
The New Survey
The new Pew survey goes into more detail about public attitudes toward GMOs, food in general, and scientists.
Of those surveyed, 39% reported that they felt GMOs were worse for health than conventionally grown produce, while 55% felt that organic produce was better for health. This is asking the question the other way around from the 2015 survey which found that only 37% of adults feel that GMOs are safe.
We cannot conclude that this means attitudes have changed from 2015 to 2016. It’s possible, for example, that in the current survey many people felt that conventional food was also unhealthy.
In any case, there remains a profound disconnect between public and scientific opinion on the issue of organic and GMO produce. This is likely the result of activist and marketing campaigns to both promote the more expensive and more profitable organic produce and to vilify anything GMO.
Interestingly, negative attitudes toward GMOs do not vary by any predictable demographic. Numbers were roughly equal across the political spectrum, and for gender, age, and income.
For the public GMOs are not a partisan issue (which is in stark contrast to other scientific issues, such are global warming, which are dominantly partisan). The same is not true, however, of the main political parties. The Republican Party has been consistently opposed to mandatory GMO labeling, while the Democratic Party has been largely for it.
If GMOs are not a partisan issue for the public, what factors do align with the false belief GMOs are not safe? Not surprisingly, of those who said that they follow the issue of GMOs closely and care about the issue, those who believe GMOs to be worse for health jumped from 39% to 75% and that organic food is better for health from 55% to 81%.
The survey does not capture the arrow of causation, however. It is possible that being misinformed about GMOs and organics raises the level of concern about these issues.
Distrust of science
One strong predictor of negative attitudes toward GMOs is negative attitudes toward scientists and a misunderstanding of the scientific consensus.
Of those surveyed, 53% stated they felt that half or fewer of scientists believed GMOs are safe, and 35% said they do not feel scientists understand the health effects of GM foods.
Only 35% said they trusted scientists “a lot” to provide full and accurate information on GMOs, while 43% said they trusted scientists “some” and 21% “not too much/not at all”.
Also, 30% of those surveyed said that scientists were influenced by industry concerns most of the time, and another 50% some of the time.
This is disappointing but not surprising. People distrust science for a variety of reasons, but the research shows that if people come to distrust science because of a political view they hold that is at odds with the scientific consensus, their trust in science in general also suffers.
We should therefore be very concerned about campaigns of misinformation about organic produce and GMOs. They not only confuse the public about the science, and the nature of the current scientific consensus, but they also weaken overall trust in science itself.
Such misinformation campaigns are arguably contributing to what is being called our “post-truth” society. In this world there is no consensus, only propaganda. There are no scientific facts, only opinions. You can accept any science that supports your position, and breezily dismiss any science that contradicts your position.
There are ready-made conspiracy theories to suit any purpose. Just play the “shill card” whenever evidence contradicts your position.
Science communication
Science communicators, including our own humble contributions, are trying to improve the situation, but clearly we need to be doing a better job.
On issues where there is a strong scientific consensus, we need to clearly and forcefully communicate that consensus and the underlying science. We additionally need to expose the tactics and illogic of the anti-science position.
Both factual knowledge and critical thinking skills are required to combat the many anti-scientific campaigns out there. We can have an impact, but it seems to require tireless vigilance over years or decades. We may be turning the corner on issues like homeopathy. We are just getting started correcting years of misinformation on GMOs.

Can GMOs cause gastrointestinal sensitivity and inflammation?
A closer look at the widespread claim that GMOs cause bowel irritation and inflammation.
Scott Gavura on May 27, 2021
Link

If you think it’s difficult to find credible information on COVID-19, try searching for science-based information on genetic modified organisms (GMOs.) I recently received an email pitch for a protein supplement, and it made a very specific statement about GMOs that I was not familiar with:
The statement that GMOs can cause bowel hypersensitivity and inflammation seems testable, so I asked the manufacturer for evidence. The customer service representative that replied suggested that I do a Google search for “GMOs can create bowel hypersensitivity” to find out more. (Yes, that was their actual response). That choice of keywords gave disappointing results, so I undertook my own search to try to answer that question. It took me long enough that I felt it was worth documenting.
Attitudes about genetic engineering
GMOs have been a recurring topic at this blog since its inception, given the anti-science arguments that underpin much of the anti-GMO movement. Over the past year, however, most of the discussion on genetic engineering at this blog has been in studying their application in the development of COVID-19 vaccines and refuting some of the concerns about this technology. It has been fascinating to see the evolving public dialogue on the genetically engineered COVID-19 vaccines (Moderna and Pfizer) move from initial apprehension into being (at least where there is a choice) the most sought-after vaccines. Given the efficacy and safety profile of these vaccines, their use in hundreds of millions of people, and their role in ending the COVID-19 pandemic, it will be interesting to see what this does to general attitudes about genetic engineering and especially the anti-GMO movement, where there has been a persistent gap between public perceptions and the actual evidence.
What foods are GMO?
Protein supplements are among the most popular dietary supplements, taken by athletes and non-athletes alike. By far the most popular source of protein in these products is whey protein, which is a by-product of cheese manufacturing. Whey is cheap and most people can tolerate it well. Some people prefer non-whey-sources, and there are several other vegetable-based protein products that are used in supplements.
Not many individual foods are GMOs, but GMOs do end up in a lot of commercially-prepared food. The FDA has a helpful page that on GMO crops that notes that GMOs may be ingredients in many of the foods we eat, such as corn starch, corn syrup, canola oil, granulated sugar, and soybean oil. There are a small number of fruits and vegetables that can be purchased that are GMO, such as potatoes, summer squash, apples and papayas. Despite the relatively small number of GMO foods, many products are labelled “non-GMO”, even when there has never been a GMO version available (e.g., rolled oats).
So let’s take a look at the supplement above to first see if GMOs are even relevant, considering the ingredients:
    • Soy protein isolate – most soy grown is GMO
    • Pea protein concentrate – there are no GMO peas
    • Cricket powder – crickets are not genetically modified
    • Cocoa powder – there is no GMO cocoa
    • Natural flavours – a vaguely-worded statement; presumably non-GMO
    • Stevia – non-GMO
    • Sea salt – there is no G to M in salt.
Given the ingredients, we can now look for evidence that GMOs, particularly soy, causes gastrointestinal hypersensitivity and inflammation.
GMOs and allergies
The original advertisement claims that GMOs can create bowel hypersensitivity and intestinal inflammation. This would be presumably be caused by some sort of immune response to a GMO protein (food allergens are usually proteins) that doesn’t occur with its non-GMO counterpart. These concerns go back over two decades, to research that found that a Brazil nut protein that was transferred into soybeans by genetic engineering caused skin test reactions to those with Brazil nut allergies. The product was never commercialized. Evaluating GMO products for allergic potential is a requirement for new GMO crops: The European Food Safety Authority has 2017 document titled “Guidance on allergenicity assessment of genetically modified plants” that provides a detailed explanation on how allergenicity is to be assessed.
I started my search by reviewing clinical practice guidelines and other references on the impact of diet on inflammatory bowel disease. I looked for guidance from major gastroenterology associations (USA, Canada, UK, Australia) and could find no reference at all to GMOs. Up-to-Date, a commonly used medical reference, doesn’t make any recommendation against GMO foods in the management of inflammatory bowel disease. Given there was no advice against GMOs, I was not optimistic that there was much to substantiate these claims.
My next step was to turn to the primary literature, where I searched pubmed.gov: first for papers on diet and inflammatory bowel disease, and then on GMOs and gastrointestinal effects. I looked for both systematic reviews, review articles, and clinical trials. A few papers stood out:
A 2008 paper from Nature Biotechnology, titled “Allergenicity assessment of genetically modified crops – what makes sense?” makes the following statement:
Furthermore, to date there is no documented proof that any approved, commercially grown GM crop has caused allergic reactions owing to a transgenically introduced allergenic protein, or that generation of a GM crop has caused a biologically significant increase in endogenous allergenicity of a crop.
This seemed like a pretty definitive statement, albeit from a review paper. A 2017 systematic review published in the Annals of Allergy, Asthma, & Immunology was the most comprehensive summary of the evidence. It concluded (bolding is mine):
Based on the data to date identified in this systematic review, we conclude that, in reference to the first query, GM products do not appear more allergenic than their conventional counterparts as determined by IgE binding studies in well-characterized sera from humans with allergy and animal models, case series of direct provocation and ingestion, and simulated digestion studies. These are methods approved by the World Health Organization for determining allergenicity of GM products. We did identify limited evidence that genetic modification, in some instances, resulted in the product having decreased IgE binding capacity in subjects with allergy compared with its conventional counterpart, which could indicate hypo-allergenicity, although this concept requires more robust study. It is important to emphasize that known allergens to an individual, be it in a GM form or conventional form, will still be allergenic in that individual and it should be avoided. This review also highlights that there is no evidence that eating GM products in individuals who are not allergic to conventional forms of those items would result in allergy or increase the risk of developing an allergy to that item.
For the second query, there were no animal or human studies identified that evaluated the effect of the consumption of GM products and the overall risk of developing a food allergy or other allergic disease. Thus, given no controlled studies and no proven medical evidence to support or refute an association between use of GM products and the development or risk of developing food allergies, no data outside the NAS report conclusion are available to evaluate this hypothesis. This would represent a knowledge gap where future study could be highly informative. In conclusion, although individuals with allergy should avoid conventional and GM forms of that particular food, GM foods do not appear to be more allergenic than their conventional counterparts, and no data exist that consumption of GM proteins causes allergy to develop to that particular food in individuals who are not allergic at baseline.
No evidence to suggest GMOs are more allergenic
Despite statements made by manufacturers of GMO-free products, there is no credible evidence to substantiate claims that GMO foods increase the risk of bowel hypersensitivity and inflammation of the intestines. Over 1,300 regulatory assessments of GMO crops from around the world have concluded that GMO crops are as safe as their conventional counterparts. Consumers may have different reasons for not wanting to purchase GMO-free foods, but fears about the potential for negative effects of GMOs on the gastrointestinal tract are unfounded.

Gene Edited vs Genetically Modified
Why regulations should, and some are, distinguishing gene edited crops from GMOs.
Steven Novella on September 29, 2021
Link

The public debate about genetically modified organisms (GMOs) seems to have quieted down a bit, but I suspect that is an artifact of the pandemic (all news is COVID news these days). Still, public concern about the health effects and overall safety of GMOs remains high, and is the single issue in which there is the greatest disconnect between public opinion and scientific consensus.
In a 2020 Pew Research survey 38% of Americans felt GMOs were unsafe, 27% felt they were safe, and 33% did not know. These numbers varied significantly by country, with the mean being 48/13/37 respectively. Australia was the only country to reach parity, with 31% saying they are safe and 31% unsafe, and no country had a plurality of the public believing GMOs are safe.
Meanwhile, there is a strong scientific consensus that GMO crops are indeed safe for human or animal consumption. According to a 2016 study by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine:
…while recognizing the inherent difficulty of detecting subtle or long-term effects on health or the environment, the study committee found no substantiated evidence of a difference in risks to human health between current commercially available genetically engineered (GE) crops and conventionally bred crops, nor did it find conclusive cause-and-effect evidence of environmental problems from the GE crops.Specifically regarding human health:
The committee carefully searched all available research studies for persuasive evidence of adverse health effects directly attributable to consumption of foods derived from GE crops but found none.
Those who wish to fearmonger about GMOs (as they do about vaccines, cell phones, or other alleged hazards) can always demand more evidence, or claim risks that have eluded existing evidence. This is always possible because it is impossible to prove zero risk for anything. And of course we legitimately need to be on the look out for evidence of subtle harm missed by prior research. But at some point the evidence showing a lack of risk is robust enough that we can be relatively confident any remaining possible risk is small enough to safely ignore.
We can also follow basic scientific principles – there is no scientific reason to suspect that GMOs should be unsafe for consumption. There is no plausible mechanism, and public fears are mostly based on gross misunderstandings of the basic science, such as the false notions that only GMOs have DNA or that they can alter the genes of those who consume them. Often fears are based upon an overapplication of the precautionary principle, while ignoring a more proper risk vs benefit analysis, and further ignoring comparisons to the alternatives. It is reasonable to argue that not using genetic technology to improve agriculture is a greater risk than using it. Further, techniques for developing new cultivars that are not categorized as genetic modification may pose a higher risk of introducing harmful substances into the food chain.
There is also the point that “GMO” is a somewhat arbitrary category, targeting certain technologies but not others, based, it appears, on nothing but a vague “ick” factor. For example, mutation farming, in which radiation or chemicals are used to increase the rate of mutation in the hopes that a rare mutation will prove useful, is not considered GMO. Another example is forced hybridization, in which species that would not normally cross fertilize are forced to do so. There is also greater fear for transgenic GMOs (where a gene is inserted from a distant species) vs cisgenic (where the inserted gene is from a closely related species). Again, there is no scientific basis for this distinction, only an “ick” factors that derives from the idea that a “fish” gene is being inserted into a tomato. Such distinctions are not genetically important, however (apart from some technical aspects that don’t affect the final product), as evidenced by the fact that humans and bananas share about 60% of their genes. In short there is no such thing as a “fish gene”.
The lines between different techniques for developing crops is getting further blurred over time, making the GMO category increasingly arbitrary and scientifically dubious. But this can have a good effect from a regulatory perspective, in that it can allow certain techniques to escape from the unnecessarily harsh regulatory environment imposed on GMOs. One such emerging category is “gene-edited”.
Gene-edited crops are those that are created by altering existing genes already present within the genome, rather than inserting an entirely new gene. This is an increasingly important category because of innovations like CRISPR, that makes gene editing relatively quick, cheap, and easy. In fact gene editing is becoming so powerful it may, to some extent, render the GMO category obsolete.
The political fight over how to regulate gene-edited crops is now underway. There has been partial success in some countries and regulatory zones, and failures in others. The landscape is complex, however. In the US, for example, regulating crops falls under the FDA, EPA, and USDA, and these agencies can have conflicting categories and regulations. Currently:
The three agencies regulate the characteristics of the products themselves and not the process to develop it. Gene edited crops lacking foreign genes (which trigger regulation as GMOs) and that do not pose a risk to other plants, and gene-edited food showing no food safety attributes different from those of traditionally bred crops, are not subject to pre-market regulatory evaluation. It remains the responsibility of the developer to assure that products placed on the market are safe for use and consumption.
Currently the EU and New Zealand are the only legislatures that regulate gene edited crops as if they were GMOs. Just recently the UK moved to relax regulations on gene edited crops, essentially allowing their development and use in the UK (thanks to Brexit). Canada, Japan, Brazil, Argentina, Colombia, Chile, Paraguay, and Uruguay also have relaxed regulations for gene edited crops. The rest of the world has not made a determination.
This is an important public debate to have. This is especially true because anti-GMO attitudes are one of the few topics where the knowledge deficit model of science communication is actually effective. In other words – people who are anti-GMO are largely open to changing their minds if they are given more scientifically accurate information, because being anti-GMO is largely based on misinformation (rather than something harder to change like tribal affiliation or ideology). The stakes here are also very high. The experience of golden rice is a good example – this is a GMO that can potentially save millions of poor children from blindness or death, and its deployment is being slowed by unscientific opposition and unreasonably burdensome regulations.
        ◦ The fight for gene edited crops may be politically easier to win, and increasingly more important as technology shifts in this direction anyway.

Update on GMOs and Health
Thirty years on, there is even more evidence that GMO food are safe.
Steven Novella on June 21, 2023
Link

There is a lot of competition for our attention, and many issues that seem urgent and controversial. Sometimes important issues just fall off the radar because of this competition. Part of our goal at SBM is to keep tabs on relevant issues – antivaccine efforts, promotion of pseudoscience in medicine, weakening consumer protection laws, and many others. That is when a lot of harm occurs, when the public is not paying attention, and fanatics are tirelessly working in the background to subvert science and public health. So when an important issue has not been in the news recently, I like to take a look and see what’s going on.
GMOs (genetically modified organisms) is one of the topics I try to track carefully, even when it’s not making headlines. The first GMO food was approved in 1994 (a GMO tomato that is no longer on the market), so we are getting close to 30 years of GMOs. Opponents of GMOs falsely claim that they have not been studied enough (there is more evidence for their safety than other food products) and that there may be long term unknown risks. They were wrong 30 years ago, but it was at least true that GMO introduction into the food market and animal feed was new. But the “new” argument, by necessity, doesn’t age well. By now, if there were any actual risk to GMO foods, we would likely be seeing the result – and we are not.
The labeling of GMOs have been updated in the US, and while there is no evidence that this is useful information to consumers, there has been a reasonable improvement. The USDA now uses the term “bioengineered” to refer to any food product that has detectable levels of altered genetic material – genes that could not have results from usual breeding techniques. The term “GMO” now is restricted to those organisms with foreign DNA introduced, usually transgenic, from distant organisms, not possible with breeding. Bioengineered can also refer to a host of processes, such as using CRISPR to alter existing genes without introducing new genes.
As an aside, I find it ironic that a large number of available crops were produced over the last century through mutation breeding. This technique uses chemical or radiation to dramatically increase the rate of mutation (a thousand to a million fold) to increase the number of varieties to select from. But mutation breeding is not considered GMO or bioengineered. Many other crops are hybrids, even forced hybrids that would not occur in nature. But labeling such crops would be pointless, and banning them impossible, and they constitute virtually our entire agricultural industry.
Safety of bioengineered crops
Each bioengineered crop is studied for safety, to ensure that they do not introduce any new allergens or toxins. They are more studied than non-bioengineered crops, even those produced through mutation breeding. The claim that bioengineered crops are not adequately studied is simply wrong and hypocritical.
But we also have a lot of ecological evidence about GMOs in general. Because of the agricultural advantages of many GMO crops, animal feed transitioned from entirely non-GMO to mostly GMO very quickly. A 2017 review of studies, essentially two decades after this switch, found:
Based on this literature review, we conclude that there is no clear evidence that feed composed of first generation GM crops has adverse effects on animal health.
Literally trillions of animals have been fed with GMO feed without any detectable negative health effect. However, switching to non-GMO feed can have negative effects. According to research conducted by Iowa State University, such a change would increase greenhouse gas emissions by 7%, increase land use, and increase the price of food.
To date there have been over 3,000 studies looking at the health and environmental safety of GMO crops, without any evidence of harm or a legitimate safety issue. Based on this evidence, 280 scientific organizations around the world have declared that GMOs are just as safe as non-GMO foods and present no special risk. There is, in fact, an overwhelming scientific consensus that GMOs currently on the market are safe and pose no threat to the environment.
On the contrary, GMO technology has been critical to the agricultural industry, increasing efficiency, food safety, and reducing spoilage. Banning GMOs would have a net negative effect on the environment and worsen food security. This effect will only get greater in the future, as GMO technology progresses and the human population grows.
This disconnect between public fears, caused by a fearmongering campaign of misinformation, and a strong scientific consensus based on decades of research is stark and very dangerous. One particularly poignant example is the fate of golden rice – a bioengineered variety of rice with enhanced beta carotene meant to reduce the burden of vitamin A deficiency, especially in developing parts of the world. There are no legitimate concerns about golden rice – the patent rights are freely licensed, there is no issue with pesticide use, and there are no safety issues. The best opponents can do is to request even more research – and endless game of shifting the goalpost, or to claim that golden rice is not that effective. It seems what they are really afraid of is that golden rice will be successful, shifting public opinion away from their propaganda.
The Philippines has approved golden rice, and so far farmers have produced over 100 tons of golden rice grain. However, activists have managed to convince the Philippines Supreme Court to keep this grain away from malnourished children by claiming that it is a risk to nature. There is a temporary stay on releasing the grain, pending arguments about the safety and environmental impact of golden rice. They are trying a desperate last minute plea to relitigate the scientific evidence that has already been reviewed. This is a tragedy in the making, based entirely on pseudoscience.
The GMO saga is still playing itself out. On one hand, time is on the side of science here. The longer we go without the fears of anti-GMO activists being realized, the stronger a case we build for the safety of bioengineering technologies and specific crops. Further, the technology continues to improve, and new applications are being developed. The need for bioengineered crops is also growing, and issues like climate change, food security, and land use, are increasingly eclipsing the false concerns of activists. But at the same time it is easy to exert a sort-of heckler’s veto on the technology, making it too controversial and too costly to be commercially viable. That is exactly what we are seeing play out in the Philippines over golden rice.
This gets back to the core problems – activists are tireless, while the defenders of science and common sense have countless battles on their hands and a lot of competition for their attention. We should not take our collective eyes off the issue of golden rice and the broader issue of the benefits of bioengineering. The stakes are just getting higher.

Philippines Approves Golden Rice
Golden rice passes the final regulatory hurdle in the Philippines. Farming can now start planting.
Steven Novella on August 18, 2021
Link

The golden rice saga began in 1999 when researchers developed a genetically modified version of rice that produces beta-carotene (hence the yellow or “golden” color), which is a precursor to vitamin A. Finally, last month the Philippines approved golden rice, which is now cleared to be planted by farmers. The reason for the two-decade delay was mostly regulatory, and caused by ideological opposition to genetically modified organisms (GMOs), not based in science or evidence. The story reflects some important basic principles in public health.
Golden rice was developed to fight vitamin A deficiency, which remains a serious problem in many parts of the world. The prevalence of vitamin A deficiency (VAD) is about 140 million worldwide, with 250,000-500,000 children going blind every year from VAD, half of whom will die within a year. These numbers are despite existing programs to distribute vitamin A supplementation to poor children in developing nations, and programs to introduce vitamin A rich fruits and vegetables into their diet.
The concept of golden rice is simple. Rice is a staple crop in many parts of the world, often being responsible for a majority of calories consumed, but those calories come largely without micronutrients. This is not an ideal diet, which should contain a larger portion of fruits and vegetables. But if the rice itself could be fortified with vital micronutrients, such as vitamin A, then this would create a self-sustaining automatic supplement system.
Golden rice was developed by a humanitarian organization, who obtained the necessary licenses from the companies who own them. They sublicense the technology to anyone who wants to create local varieties through conventional breeding with the golden rice strain. This sublicense requires that the rice seed is freely available to farmers. Therefore, despite the common anti-GMO narrative, there are no corporate profits involved here. This is a purely humanitarian project.
The current strain of golden rice is also effective, with a single cup providing 50% of the RDA of vitamin A. It has gained symbolic approval by the FDA in the US and also by Canada and New Zealand – symbolic because these countries do not grow and have no need for golden rice, but the approval was meant to support countries that do.
Despite what sounds like a potential home run for public health in developing nations, many environmental groups oppose golden rice on purely ideological grounds. Greenpeace has infamously opposed golden rice, writing about the recent approval:
The GM rice variety was approved despite longtime opposition from Filipino farmers, scientists, consumers, health advocates, and environmental groups who have clamored for stricter regulatory systems for GM crops on the basis of the precautionary principle.
There are a few general points brought up by the opposition from Greenpeace and other groups. First, this is an abuse of the precautionary principle. Medicine and public health correctly adhere to the principle of first do no harm, and to err on the side of caution. But this sensible position can easily be twisted to oppose any new technology or intervention. We never have 100% perfect knowledge, and risks can never be guaranteed to be zero. There is always a risk vs benefit assessment with the knowledge we have. Anti-vaxxers use this technique as well, and it is not surprise that there is a large overlap between the anti-vaccine and anti-GMO groups.
Further, the position of Greenpeace and many opponents to golden rice is both a false choice and the Nirvana fallacy. Golden rice is not a perfect solution to a complex socioeconomic and health problem. It will not fix poverty, make the distribution of resources equitable, nor perfect the farming infrastructure. Nor can we afford to wait around for these problems which have plagued humanity for literally thousands of years to be fixed before we take action to prevent blindness and death in poor children. We can take actions to improve all of these deep-seated issues, while mitigating some of the negative effects in the meantime.
Greenpeace falsely asserts that by freely giving farmers access to fortified rice, this will somehow hamper efforts to improve farming infrastructure or address poverty. This is an absurd and evidence-free assertion. In fact, reducing VAD, blindness and death in children, this will improve the situation for poor farmers and other impoverished populations. This will reduce one more burden that conspires to keep them down.
Those opposed to golden rice also argue that it is too expensive, but this argument is now irrelevant. The cost of development was largely donated, and is already spent. Now we have golden rice, and the only question is – should we freely give it to farmers?
It is clear that opposition to golden rice, and GMOs more generally, is not based on any legitimate argument or evidence. It is an ideological position, and also a commercial one. Anti-GMO activism is largely pushed by the organic food lobby, which stands to benefit from demonizing what they have turned into a competing brand. They have positioned organic produce as the GMO-free alternative, then fear-monger about GMOs with misinformation.
The real fear of Greenpeace and other anti-GMO activists is that golden rice will succeed. If it works, destroying all their anti-GMO talking points and saving the lives of poor children, it will be a disaster for their propaganda.
They are also being threatened by a technological development, gene-edited crops. This involves altering existing genes in cultivars, without inserting new genes. In the US and many other parts of the world, gene-edited crops are not considered GMOs, and are therefore not subject to GMO regulations. Europe is the current exception, which does consider gene-edited crops GMOs. Some other nations are still undecided. This does reveal how ultimately arbitrary the GMO category is, but also we now have a powerful gene editing tool that can speed the development of crops with enhanced traits while avoiding the overly burdensome regulations and propaganda against GMOs.
Hopefully, progress will continue in the background, with benefits that the world cannot afford to ignore, rendering anti-GMO ideology irrelevant.

Save the Whales, Blind the Children
The Ancient Egyptian Book of the Dead depicts a scene in which a bowl of golden rice is weighed against the feather of truth.
Mark Crislip on June 18, 2024
Link

Yo VIP, let’s kick it
Rice, Rice, babyRice, Rice, baby
Alright stop, collaborate and listenRice is back with my brand new inventionVitamin A grabs me tightlyLetting me see daily and nightly“Will it ever stop?” Yo, I don’t knowTurn off the lights, and I’ll see the glowTo the extreme, genes in rice like a vandalLight up a cones and rods like a candleCornea clear, no necrosis, boomNot killing your eyes like a poisonous mushroomDeadly, with no vegetable melodyChildren going blind should be a felonyLove it or leave it, you better gangwayYou better hit bullseye, the kid don’t playIf there was a problem, yo, I’ll solve itCheck out the rice while my gene revolves it
Rice Rice Baby
Vanilla Ice. That brings back memories.
A couple of years ago, pre-COVID, I was enjoying a beautiful summer day on the frontporch. Probably writing one of these beloved and insightful essays.
A pair of young women walked up the path to the porch. Female and no matching white shirts. Not Mormon, likely Jehovah’s’ Witnesses. They seem to come around every year or two. I grimaced internally and prepared to blow them off.
Nope. They were Greenpeace acolytes, looking for money to fight climate change.
I was a sucker for climate change pleas, back before I concluded that it was all futile. But before I gave them any money, I asked if Greenpeace had made any amends for their irrational opposition to golden rice and all the harm it had caused. I was uncertain at the time as it had been a while since I had seen anything on the topic
They hadn’t heard of golden rice. Well, I said, look it up and get back to me if they have done their penance.
They never returned.
When I was starting out in medicine, oh so many years ago, insulin was isolated from the pancreases of slaughterhouse cows and pigs. The problem was that these insulins are immunologically different than human insulin and a fair number of patients would develop antibodies against their insulin, making the diabetes harder and harder to control. It often did not end well.
And then.
Someone figured out how to put human insulin genes into E coli and suddenly we had insulin that was not immunogenic. Well, not so suddenly. It was expensive and, then as now, diabetics were often priced out of life-saving insulin.
As an aside, what kind of society allows life-saving insulin to be cost prohibitive?
Anyway. The principle, if not the execution, is simple. Cells are little machines that turn DNA into RNA and RNA can then produce pretty much any biologic product you need or want. Like insulin. The Wikipedia has a list of biologic products available as a result of this recombinant technology. Including golden rice.
What, you may ask, is golden rice and who cares?
Humans are unable to synthesize a number of micronutrients aka vitamins. Vitamins are curious. They are critical for some physiologic processes but many species never acquired, or lost, the ability to make their own vitamins. Like vitamin C:
Vitamin C (ascorbic acid) plays important roles as an anti-oxidant and in collagen synthesis. These important roles, and the relatively large amounts of vitamin C required daily, likely explain why most vertebrate species are able to synthesize this compound. Surprisingly, many species, such as teleost fishes, anthropoid primates, guinea pigs, as well as some bat and Passeriformes bird species, have lost the capacity to synthesize it.
Which I find fascinating, that once we could make vitamin C, but no longer.
Humans cannot synthesize vitamins A, B1 (thiamine), B2 (riboflavin), B5 (pantothenic acid), B6 (pyridoxine), B7 (biotin), B9 (folate), B12 cobalamin), E and K but are able to synthesize some vitamin B3 (niacin) and D.
Let’s talk about vitamin A. It has two main forms in food. Retinol in meat and carotenoids in vegetables. Humans need to eat one or the other to stay replete in their vitamin A.
Much of the world does not have access to the jaw-dropping selection of foods found in the local Safeway needed to avoid vitamin deficiency As such, vitamin A deficiency is common in SE Asia and sub-Saharan Africa, affecting children and pregnant females.
About 250,000 to 500,000 malnourished children in the developing world go blind each year from a deficiency of vitamin A, around half of whom die within a year of becoming blind.
That is awful. No one with a shred of conscience would support policies that result in thousands of children going blind and dying? Right?
The simplest intervention would be to give children at risk just 2 doses a year of vitamin A. That decreases blindness and all-cause mortality by 12 to 24%. Easy peasy. Would that the world worked so smoothly — only 59 percent of targeted children were reached in 2022, with East Asia and the Pacific achieving the lowest coverage at 20 percent, followed by Eastern and Southern Africa at 57 percent.
More ways to get vitamin A into people are needed. Human ingenuity being what it is, very clever people discovered how to put the genes beta-carotene, a vitamin A precursor, into rice. Viola. Golden rice, a potential partial solution to vitamin A deficiency, especially where rice is a diet staple.
Golden Rice looked good to go in the Philippines until April of this year when the Court of Appeals in the Philippines issued a cease-and-desist order on the commercial propagation of two genetically modified crops, golden rice and Bt eggplant, citing a lack of “full scientific certainty” regarding their health and environmental impact.
And who filed a petition to halt the Golden Rice? Greenpeace.
Greenpeace! Heros from my youth. Eco-warriors who put their lives on the line, steering their Zodiac boats into the paths of whaling ships to save the whales. An organization with cred. Lots of cred. Unfortunately, since misleading claims from credible sources can be more damaging than blatant falsehoods.
Greenpeace has a long history of opposing GMOs and has been fighting the introduction of golden rice, and other GM foods. Actions do have consequences, and the consequences of opposing golden rice is that more Filipinos are going to go blind and die, given that around 17% of children in the country are vitamin A deficient and they rely on rice as their main source of nutrition. Greenpeace says in response to the ruling
“Significantly, the decision firmly upholds the Precautionary Principle and puts the burden of proof for safety on the respondents. Greenpeace has constantly noted that GM crops have been approved in the Philippines despite the lack of robust data on safety assessments submitted by proponents. GM crops have never been proven safe, and have hindered necessary progress on climate resilient ecological agriculture that keeps the control of seeds on our farmers.
“We reiterate our stance: the involved companies and agencies have yet to show concrete evidence that these crops would be in the best interest of Filipinos, our environment, and our agricultural sector.
Greenpeace does not address the blindness and death that will occur as a result of this decision. As best I can tell, there is but one mention of blindness and death in all the Greenpeace golden rice blog posts, preferring to focus on other issues. Wonder why that is. However, as is so often the case for the poor and powerless, those who make the rules do not play the game.
The Precautionary Principle, huh?
From basic biology, I can’t see why Golden Rice would present a problem. We eat the genes and their products that make Vitamin A every day to our benefit. As one review noted
There are no cases where post-market surveillance has uncovered harm to consumers or the environment including potential transfer of DNA from the GMO to non-target organisms.
I suspect Greenpeace doesn’t realize when we say that someone is now, tragically, in a vegetative state, we are speaking metaphorically. Vegetable genes have not jumped into the patient.
I can’t find where there have been any worrisome effects from transgenic foods, specifically golden rice. As another review noted
Transgenic crops are subjected to a rigorous pre-market safety assessment. The safety of novel proteins and other products is established, and through compositional analysis and animal studies, the safety of any observed changes is evaluated. These studies provide evidence that the new product is as safe as, or safer than, comparable varieties. It must be asked, however, if this rigorous analysis is necessary, because unregulated crops produced by other breeding methods also undergo genetic changes and contain unintended effects. Golden Rice poses infinitesimally small, if any, risk to consumers whilst it has the potential to spare millions of lives each year. However, because it is a transgenic crop, it cannot be deployed without years of expensive pre-market safety review. Paradoxically, if Golden Rice had been produced by less precise conventional methods of breeding, it would already be in the hands of poor farmers.
Try as you might, you can’t cross-breed a carrot with rice. A shame, really. Although I look forward to eating a tomato-fish. Hope they use San Marzanos.
As far as I can tell, there is no a priori reason golden rice would be dangerous and there is no data to suggest it is a danger.
It looks like the US has approved at least 10 GMO crops while places like the the Philippines get nothing.
When it comes to GMO food crops, anti-GMO campaigners have thus won a remarkable yet dubious victory. They have not prevented rich countries from using GMO animal feed or GMO cotton, yet farmers and consumers in poor countries need increased productivity for food crops, not animal feed or industrial crops. Today’s de facto global ban on GMO food crops therefore looks suspiciously like an outcome designed by the rich and for the rich, with little regard for the interests of the poor.
Same as it ever was.
If you like the Nobel Prize gambit, and I am not so sure I do, but a decade ago 107 Nobel laureates signed a letter calling for Greenpeace to stop it, noting
Scientific and regulatory agencies around the world have repeatedly and consistently found crops and foods improved through biotechnology to be as safe as, if not safer than those derived from any other method of production. There has never been a single confirmed case of a negative health outcome for humans or animals from their consumption. Their environmental impacts have been shown repeatedly to be less damaging to the environment, and a boon to global biodiversity
Greenpeace didn’t stop it.
Greenpeace’s anti-GMO stance has been called a crime against humanity, and their actions do fit the definition, although history and current events suggest it is rare that anyone really cares about crimes against humanity. Kind of sucks that Greenpeace prefers to support laws that result in people going blind and dying despite all the negative studies.
In medicine, there are never any good solutions to medical problems. There are bad solutions and worse solutions. Interventions are about risks and benefits, trying to determine the least bad solution.
The risks of vitamin A deficiency are well known and common. The benefits of vitamin A are well established. The risks of golden rice appear to be as close to zero as one would like. Seems a simple and safe enough partial solution to a very real problem. If I were given a choice, I would prefer the benefit of my children being able to see and to live to the ripe old age of 71 rather than dying young and blind weighed against the vanishingly small chance of a risk from golden rice.
But the courts of the Philippines ruled otherwise. Hm. Justice is blind, perhaps from vitamin A deficiency. A shame she did not have golden rice as a child so she could read the literature and see the mistake being made.
The nice thing about working in health care is I could look in the mirror at the end of the day and know that my actions improved someone’s life, at least a little. I always wonder how those whose actions lead to suffering and death look at themselves in the mirror at the end of the day and know they have made the world a little, or a lot, worse. They probably do not consider it; no one is evil in their own story. Much the pity. It would be so much simpler if people and organizations acted like Snidely Whiplash, twirling the ends of their moustashe as they tied golden rice to the train tracks. But we lack a Dudley Do-Right in this metaphor. I guess ole Nell is doomed.
        ◦ As another aside, as best I can determine, whales have a diet high in vitamin A and are themselves an excellent source of the vitamin for Eskimos. Imagine what would have happened if whales needed golden rice to survive or the only solution to vitamin A deficiency in humans had been to eat the whales. Golden rice seems so much more civilized.

Seneff Claims GMOs Cause Concussions
Steven Novella on September 16, 2015
Link

You read that headline correctly.
Stephanie Seneff first came to skeptical attention when she published a study claiming that vaccines were linked to autism. She trolled through the VAERS database and, as David Gorski noted, “tortured the data until it confessed.” Last year she published a paper in which she claimed glyphosate caused autism, claims which I addressed almost a year ago. Gorski also deconstructed this paper, noting, “In fact, if you look at the slides for Seneff’s talks (e.g., this one, available at her MIT web page), you’ll find a tour de force of confusing correlation with causation…”
Seneff is a computer scientist who apparently is anti-vaccine and anti-GMO. In a stunning example of the Dunning-Kruger effect, she feels she can take her computer expertise and export it to biology. She nicely demonstrates that expertise is not so easily transferable.
From autism to concussions
Last year she also published a paper, which escaped my attention until it was recently pointed out to me, claiming that glyphosate, GMOs, and other modern lifestyle factors are responsible for the recent increase in concussions. Her co-author on the paper is Wendy Morely, who is a “Registered Holistic Nutritionist” specializing in the nutrition of concussion. Neither author has any neuroscience background.
In order to make this claim the authors have to take the reader on a wild ride of speculation, over-interpretation of the literature, tenuous links, cherry picked data, and confusing correlation with causation, all guided by motivated reasoning to arrive at a pre-determined destination.
The authors propose the existence of, “Diminished brain resilience syndrome.” In fact, they propose many entirely new concepts in the paper, all without doing any actual research or presenting any actual data. It is a long and tortured argument, but let’s see if I can briefly summarize.
Essentially they argue that concussions are on the increase because the general population had poor nutrition, disordered gut microbiota, and increased exposure to toxins (specifically glyphosate and GMOs) which render the brain less resilient to injury and less able to repair itself after injury.
They tie their new syndrome to various metabolic factors, including decreased availability of sulphur, magnesium deficiency, decreased function of the pineal gland, and altered omega 3:6 fatty acid ratio. It would take a novel to deconstruct every aspect of their elaborate web of speculation. Suffice it to say that hundreds of studies would be required to verify the many steps in their chain of argument.
Their theory is based partly on the idea that sulphate is required to help the cerebrospinal fluid organize into a gell-like substance that cushions the brain from impact. They write:
Thus, while encephalopathy is associated with a high risk of collateral damage to neurons through excitotoxicity, it serves an essential role in boosting sulfate levels in the extracellular matrix, which is required in order to replace damaged neurons with newly differentiated progenitor cells, regain the ability to metabolize glucose as a fuel, promote the breakdown and recycling of cellular debris, and, more generally, to support the maintenance of structured (gelled) water that will protect neurons from damage due to mechanical stress.
Poor referencing
They do have many references, but none of them establish their central thesis. I followed many of the links to see what they show, and they often do not establish the fact they are referencing. Here are a couple examples – they write:
The level of demand and utilization of magnesium has significant implications for athletes, as it is estimated that 90% of athletes are deficient in magnesium compared with the general American population at 68%.
Those numbers struck me as very high, so I followed the citation, and I could find nowhere in the referenced paper a mention of those percentages. I looked for the incidence of magnesium deficiency and found that the rate is not even close to the numbers cited. For example, in one reference it was found that that an in-patient population (i.e. a sick population) had a prevalence of magnesium deficiency of 10%.
If you are a “holistic nutritionist” then of course it’s good for business for everyone to have a nutritional deficiency.
Glyphosate and gut bacteria
Another linchpin of the author’s claims is that glyphosate has a negative effect on the beneficial bacteria in our guts. They link to one paper, which is an in vitro study of chicken microbiota. So it is not a study in living organisms, and not in people. I searched the database for glyphosate and microbiota and came up with – that one study. That’s why they referenced it, it’s the only study.
We can keep going through the dozens and dozens of claims that they make. Each one is wild speculation, proposing entirely new mechanisms or biological phenomena, or taking preliminary evidence as if it is a solid conclusion.
Conclusion: A proposal is not proof
Sometimes scientists will publish a paper, which is essentially a commentary, in which they propose a new phenomenon. This is a perfectly legitimate part of science. Such papers should be taken as nothing more than that – a proposal. It is a suggestion for possible future areas of research.
Generally, however, you don’t propose more than one entirely new phenomenon in a single paper. Each new proposal is statistically unlikely to be true, and if you present two new proposals you end up with unlikely squared.
Morely and Seneff make dozens of new claims and proposals in one paper. They are trying to get to a specific destination by leaping from one slippery rock to the other. They slip and fall on the very first stone, however, as they begin by claiming that:
While the number of reported sports-related concussions (SRCs) has been steadily rising over the past decade, prompting increased media and medical attention, the number of children participating in the top five organized team sports (OTS), over the same time period, has actually been declining. This surprising juxtaposition is not limited to the world of sports.
This is not a surprising juxtaposition. As they themselves point out (although it seems only to dismiss) – there is increased recognition that concussion, especially in sports and especially multiple mild concussions, is a serious neurological issue. Increased awareness and a markedly reduced threshold is most likely driving the increased presentation of concussion to medical attention.
There is absolutely no data to suggest that the population is more susceptible to neurological injury – there is no evidence for the alleged “diminished brain resilience syndrome.”
At present this proposal is nothing but speculation and utter nonsense apparently designed to drive business to holistic nutritionists and scaremonger about glyphosate and GMOs.

   The Science Fiction of Nutritional Genomics
Ben Kavoussi
Link
A centipede was happy quite,
Until a frog in fun
Said, “Pray, which leg comes after which?”
This raised her mind to such a pitch,
She lay distracted in the ditch
Considering how to run.
Anonymous
Just like complementary and alternative medicine (CAM), nutritionism — meaning the unexamined assumption that food is only a conveyor of the substances it contains 1,2 — has evolved independently of science and medicine since the 1970s, and has caused so much wondering and confusion about food and diet that many Americans have become unable to eat properly. Today, there isn’t a popular magazine that doesn’t have a “health and nutrition” section that — often with the backing of very little science — promises many health benefits of a nutrient or warns against the harms of another; and then provides a list of foods that contain it. The same publication might time and again write the exact opposite, further adding to the already-prevalent nutritional confusion. Nutritionism is thus an ideology sourced by popular beliefs, academic reveries, and the food and dietary supplements industry, where food is simply seen as a mean to achieve a specific health goal. In its latest form, however, coupled with genomics and biomedical informatics, and called “nutrigenomics” or “nutritional genomics,” nutritionism takes academic reveries to such an extent that it could be accurately described as “science fiction.” The Center of Excellence for Nutritional Genomics at UC Davis writes indeed (in bold) on its website that:
“The promise of nutritional genomics is personalized medicine and health based upon an understanding of our nutritional needs, nutritional and health status, and our genotype. Nutrigenomics will also have impacts on society — from medicine to agricultural and dietary practices to social and public policies — and its applications are likely to exceed that of even the human genome project. Chronic diseases (and some types of cancer) may be preventable, or at least delayed, by balanced, sensible diets. Knowledge gained from comparing diet/gene interactions in different populations may provide information needed to address the larger problem of global malnutrition and disease.”
Nutritional genomics is one of the “omics” that have come out of the human genome project — meaning the mapping of the 3 billion base pairs that make up the 20,000-25,000 genes in the human genome — and claims that it can develop means to optimize nutrition by exploring “personalized” or “genome-based” nutrition, in which foods are optimized for each individual’s unique genetic makeup. This goal is presumably achieved by correlating gene expression or single-nucleotide polymorphisms in health and disease with the consumption of a food or a combination of foods. The website of the UC Davis Center also states that its goal is to “devise genome-based nutritional interventions to prevent, delay, and treat diseases such asthma, obesity, Type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and prostate cancer.” The Center also adds (again in bold) that its goal is also to “reduce and ultimately eliminate racial and ethnic health disparities resulting from environment and gene interactions, particularly those involving dietary, economic, and cultural factors.”
The fundamental clinical medicine and public health assumptions that underlie this narrative are (1) the supposition that our lack of understanding of the precise mechanisms of environment/gene interactions is at the origin of our failure to prevent or to delay these diseases; and (2) that the futuristic cognitive tools of nutrigenomics can convert the large, complex, high-dimensional and nonlinear data on the complex interactions between the genetic makeup of a susceptible population and multiple environmental variables into useful knowledge. Identifying the positive and negative connections between the common constituents of their diet with genetic determinants of health and disease, will presumably uncover the insufficient intake or overconsumption of certain nutrients, and a population’s inability to absorb, metabolize or excrete them. To encounter that, nutritional genomics claims to be able to recommend specific, “personalized” and “genome-based” nutritional adjustments. According to the Center of Excellence’s Director, Raymond Rodriguez, nutritional genomics has been identified “as an emerging research focus of critical importance to global health and a vital link between agriculture, food and human health.”
To illustrate the nutritionism in these assumptions, and the “sciencefictional” nature of the promised solutions to the current epidemic of obesity, Type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease in the US, let us first consider the last time nutritionists undertook such grandiose public health and clinical ambitions. I am referring to the fat-free diet craze of the late 1980s, which Gary Taubes and Michael Pollan independently deconstruct as politically-motivated nutritionism. As Taubes writes in The Soft Science of Dietary Fat:
Since the early 1970s, for instance, Americans’ average fat intake has dropped from over 40% of total calories to 34%; average serum cholesterol levels have dropped as well. But no compelling evidence suggests that these decreases have improved health. Although heart disease death rates have dropped–and public health officials insist low-fat diets are partly responsible–the incidence of heart disease does not seem to be declining, as would be expected if lower fat diets made a difference. Meanwhile, obesity in America, which remained constant from the early 1960s through 1980, has surged upward since then–from 14% of the population to over 22%. Diabetes has increased apace. Both obesity and diabetes increase heart disease risk, which could explain why heart disease incidence is not decreasing. That this obesity epidemic occurred just as the government began bombarding Americans with the low-fat message suggests the possibility, however distant, that low-fat diets might have unintended consequences–among them, weight gain.3
To that Michael Pollan, the author of The Omnivore’s Dilemma, adds in a New York Times article called Unhappy Meals:
Last winter came the news that a low-fat diet, long believed to protect against breast cancer, may do no such thing — this from the monumental, federally financed Women’s Health Initiative, which has also found no link between a low-fat diet and rates of coronary disease. The year before we learned that dietary fiber might not, as we had been confidently told, help prevent colon cancer.2
In other words, it appears that nutrition-based clinical medicine and public health in the last decades not only have been unable to prevent, delay, and treat diseases, but have actually contributed to the current rise of metabolic syndrome, obesity, Type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and a host of other conditions arising from glucose intolerance and metabolic syndrome. According to Gary Taubes, the rampaging epidemic of obesity in America is partially due to the disastrous ambitions of Senator George McGovern’s Select Committee on Nutrition and Human Needs that changed the nutritional and public health policy in this country in the late 1970s. McGovern’s Committee had a mandate to eradicate malnutrition and disease, but in the mid-1970s the original mandate was replaced by an overzealous fight against “overnutrition,” and the health concerns associated with the dietary excesses of Americans. The Committee held hearings in July 1976, at the end of which McGovern — who was heavily influence by the diet-guru Nathan Pritikin’s very low fat diet and exercise program — with the aid of a handful of his staff members created the basis for the disastrous fat-fear-mongering of the next three decades.
In the wake of the panel’s recommendations, to which a 1982 National Academy report added the association of dietary fat with cancer,4 Americans did change their diets; and their average fat intake dropped significantly. But instead of fruits, vegetables and legumes, the average person replaced the missing fat with refined carbohydrates and high-fructose corn syrup, ostensibly as a way to avoid the evils of fat. Gary Taubes adds that the food industry which had little incentive in advertising non-proprietary items such as vegetables has been a major contributor to this public health blunder, for it spends the great bulk of the $30-billion-plus spent yearly on food advertising on selling carbohydrates in the guise of fast food, sodas, snacks, and candy bars. Michael Pollan writes that paradoxically Americans got really fat on this new low-fat, high-carbohydrates diet.
Now that two of the top leading causes of death in the US, meaning heart disease (1st) and diabetes (6th),5 are predominantly arising from decades of nutritional confusion and fear-mongering, nutritional genomics, armed with Artificial Intelligence, data mining and pattern-recognition technology is poised to “sniff” through the 3 billion-byte-long code of the human genome, and uncover genetic patterns that would explain why and how the low-fat and high-carbohydrates diet recommendations of George McGovern’s Select Committee are causing glucose intolerance, obesity, Type 2 diabetes, and cardiovascular disease in susceptible individuals and populations! But all we need for this purpose is some common sense, a little knowledge of American public health history, and the initiative to look through the grocery bills, the refrigerators, the restaurant menus or the trash cans of susceptible individuals and populations, and we can easily find out how super-sized refined carbohydrates and high-fructose corn syrup have made their way to their diet. For this, there is no need to analyze their genome with the aid of computational biology and pattern recognition technology, unless we have a taste for science fiction and Digital Age divination — none of which merits to promise medicine and health!
Nutritionism about prostate cancer has a connection to the dietary supplement industry that deserves to be mentioned here. A diet rich on animal fats and poor in grains, fruits and vegetables has been blamed for not providing enough of the presumably needed lycopenes, selenium, vitamins C and E, green tea, sulforaphane (found in broccoli, cabbage and cauliflower) and soy, and thus supplements, as David Heber, the Founding Director of UCLA Center for Human Nutrition, and coincidentally the Chairman of Herbalife’s Nutrition Advisory Board claims, could be used to prevent the occurrence of prostate cancer.6 According to a 2004 Forbes article, Heber joined the Board at roughly the same time the multilevel marketer of supplements and weight-loss products made a $3 million donation to establish the Mark Hughes Cellular & Molecular Nutrition Laboratory at the Center for Human Nutrition, leading to the criticism of Heber’s nutrition-based preventive claims as unfounded and pro-supplements, for obvious reasons.7 As for the value of any type of nutritional intervention to prevent, delay, and treat prostate cancer, Bill Nelson, a pioneer in the study of diet as preventive medicine at Johns Hopkins Brady Urological Institute tells us:
I’d have almost no reservations about advising someone to make sure his selenium levels are not too low, says Nelson. Beyond that, eat plenty of fruits and vegetables, and less red meat. And beyond that, take every story about a new dietary “wonder drug” with — pardon the food imagery — the proverbial grain of salt.8
The nutritional management of asthma is even less in need of avant-garde nutritionism. Merck Manual briefly mentions that “diets low in vitamins C and E and in ω–3 fatty acids have been linked to asthma, as has obesity,” and nothing beyond that.9 But if the deficiency of these nutrients and obesity are truly linked do asthma, then all we need is to “eat food, not too much, mostly plants,” as Michael Pollan recommends, and get them local, organic, seasonal and diverse, as others have suggested. And if you think that the link between obesity and asthma is a new discovery; and that the knowledge of how dietary chemicals alter gene expression or structure is required to address the problem, then read Galen of Pergamum’s (ca. 130-ca. 200) humbling treatise on the Thinning Diet:
The thinning diet is indicated for the majority of chronic diseases, which can, indeed, frequently be treated by such means alone, and without recourse to drugs. It is therefore important to form a clear idea of this diet; for wherever a result can be achieved purely by regimen, it is preferable to refrain from pharmaceutical prescriptions. Even with complaints of the kidneys and joints (provided the patient is not yet presenting joints full of ‘stones’), I have known many cases where the thinning diet lead either to complete remission or at least to a lessening of the pain. I have also known quite a few sufferers from chronic breathing difficulties derive such benefits from it that they returned completely to normal, or else suffered very few attacks over a long period.10
REFERENCES:
Scrinis G. Functional foods or functionally marketed foods? A critique of, and alternatives to, the category of ‘functional foods’. Public Health Nutr. 2008
Pollan M. Unhappy Meals, The New York Times, January 28, 2007
Taubes G The Soft Science of Dietary Fat. Science. 30 March 2001. Vol. 291. no. 5513, pp. 2536 – 2545.
Campbell TC, Campbell TM. The China Study: The Most Comprehensive Study of Nutrition Ever Conducted and the Startling Implications for Diet, Weight Loss and Long-Term Health. Benbella Books; 1 edition. 2004.
Heron MP, Hoyert DL, Murphy SL, Xu JQ, Kochanek KD, Tejada-Vera B. Deaths: Final data for 2006. National vital statistics reports; vol 57 no 14. Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health Statistics. 2009.
Yip I, Heber D, Aronson W. Nutrition and prostate cancer. Urol Clin N America 1999;26:403-11.
Pomerantz D. Supplemental Income. Forbes. November 04, 2004
Nelson B. Prostate Cancer and Diet. Prostate Cancer Update. Volume V, Winter 2000.
Beers MH, Porter RS, Jones TV. The Merck Manual. Merck. 18th Editions. 2006.
Galen C, Singer PN. Selected Works, Oxford University Press. 1997.

Organic vs Conventional Meat and Milk
Steven Novella on February 17, 2016
Link

Two recently published meta-analyses, one on meat and another on milk, conclude that levels of polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA) and omega-3 fatty acids are higher in the organic versions of both. This is being widely reported as evidence that organic meat and milk is healthier, but a closer look at these two studies shows a different picture.
The organic false dichotomy
I am going to start with what I consider to be the biggest problem with how both studies are being presented and reported. This relates to a deeper issue – the false dichotomy of organic vs conventional. In my opinion, we should use whatever farming techniques prove to be best (for the quality of the food, sustainability, cost-effectiveness, and environmental impact) regardless of whether or not they are considered organic.
While proponents of organic farming claim that for them food quality and sustainability are the real issue, they aren’t. Organic techniques are based on the appeal to nature, not an evidence-based approach to best practices. 
The conclusions of the meta-analysis addressing milk are:
Redundancy analysis of data from a large cross-European milk quality survey indicates that the higher grazing/conserved forage intakes in organic systems were the main reason for milk composition differences.
And for meat:
Evidence from controlled experimental studies indicates that the high grazing/forage-based diets prescribed under organic farming standards may be the main reason for differences in FA profiles.
In other words, the differences found can be entirely due to the difference between grass feeding and grain feeding – that’s it. That is the real variable here, not organic vs conventional. Grass fed conventional meat and milk has the same profile as grass-fed organic. It is therefore deceptive, in my opinion, to frame this difference as organic vs conventional when it is clearly grass-fed vs grain-fed.
The differences are really insignificant
For milk, the study found that PUFA was 7% higher in organic (meaning grass-fed) while omega-3 PUFA were 56% higher. For meat these numbers were 23% and 47% respectively.
These sound like impressive numbers, and most reporting simplifies this to around 50% for both. Regular readers of SBM by now should recognize that relative percentages can seem impressive but be misleading.
Neither milk nor red meat are significant sources of omega-3 fatty acids, and therefore even a 50% relative increase in this small amount likely has few health implications.
For example, if you drank a half liter of whole milk every day, consuming grain-fed milk would provide 11% of the recommended daily intake of omega-3, while drinking grass-fed would provide 16%. If you drink 2% or 1% milk the effect is even smaller. Simply put, you are not going to reach your targets of omega-3 by consuming milk.
The numbers are even worse for meat. Red meat is high in saturated fat. The net effect of eating grass-fed beef on your fatty acid profile is going to be negative. You are better off substituting fish or poultry for red meat. Another way to look at this is – because of the low amounts of omega-3 in red meat, in order for the grass-fed vs grain-fed difference to be significant in your diet, you would have to be eating way too much red meat.
In summary, while the relative percentages of omega-3 in grass-fed vs grain-fed meat and milk sound impressive, in absolute terms the differences are insignificant.
Problems with the meta-analyses
To further dilute the implications of these two studies, we need to consider the challenges of doing a proper meta-analysis. Meta-analyses in general are no substitute for single large rigorous trials. They are a method for combining the data from many studies to gain more statistical power.
That is the advantage of a meta-analysis, the statistical power. However, there are also some drawbacks. They suffer from the GIGO problem – garbage in, garbage out. If you take a lot of small and less rigorous studies and combine them, you don’t get one large rigorous trial. You get a mess – but a mess that can seem statistically impressive.
A meta-analysis is also an opportunity to introduce a host of new biases. You have to decide which studies to include, how to weight them, and how to combine different outcomes and different techniques. There are many “researcher degrees of freedom” which potentially lead to biased outcomes.
In the milk meta-analysis the authors did not weight the studies, which means they gave equal weight to small uncontrolled studies as they did to large controlled experiments.
The meat meta-analysis was more problematic. They could not find enough studies of any one type of meat, so they combined them into one analysis. Further, 21 of the 63 studies they included were not even controlled. They report a high degree of heterogeneity among the studies they looked at, which means the results were all over the place and any conclusions are highly suspect.
Conclusion: Organic is still not any better
The three main points that are important to understanding the relevance of these two meta-analyses, and which have not been consistently reported, include:
     1.  The differences observed are not between organic and conventional farming, but between grass-fed and grain-fed animals. It is misleading to focus on an arbitrary category (organic) rather than the actual variable having the observed effect.
     2.  The absolute differences are insignificant in practical terms. For the amount of red meat and milk that most people consume (or should consume) the differences are small and the chance of any net health effect is slight.
     3.  These two studies were meta-analyses, which have generic limitations, but these particular meta-analyses have serious problems. Their results are therefore not very reliable.

   vIs Organic Food More Healthful?
Steven Novella
Link
In 1952 Martin Gardner, who just passed away this week at the age of 95, wrote about organic farming in his book Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science. He characterized it as a food fad without scientific justification. Now, 58 years later, the science has not changed much at all.
A recent review of the literature of the last 50 years shows that there is no evidence for health benefits from eating an organic diet. The only exception to this was evidence for a lower risk of eczema in children eating organic dairy products. But with so many potential correlations to look for, this can just be noise in the data.
Another important conclusion of this systematic review is the paucity of good research into organic food – they identified only 12 relevant trials. So while there is a lack of evidence for health benefits from eating an organic diet, we do not have enough high-quality studies to say this question has been definitively answered. It is surprising, given the fact that organic food was controversial in the 1950s, that so little good research has been done over the last half-century.
It should be noted that we only recently had any rules in the US regarding the label “organic”. According to the USDA:
The Organic Foods Production Act (OFPA), enacted under Title 21 of the 1990 Farm Bill, served to establish uniform national standards for the production and handling of foods labeled as “organic.”
The definition of organic entirely relates to the method of production, not the final product. It involves three principles. One is sustainable farming that is optimal for the environment. That question is beyond the scope of this medical blog. Many people do advocate organic farming for this reason alone, and many of the principles of sustainable farming are being incorporated more generally into agriculture and animal husbandry.
The second principle is the establishment of an ecosystem, using cover crops, crop rotation, and other methods. Again – I want to set aside the environmental questions and focus on the nutritional claims: Does organic farming result in produce that is more nutritious? There are different ways we can approach this question. One is addressed by the systematic review above: Can we measure a health advantage to eating an organic diet? The answer to that question at the present time is “no.” This could be due to the fact that there is no health benefit, or that any benefit is smaller than the studies currently available could detect. Long term modest health benefits are very difficult to detect with clinical trials, and it is therefore difficult to rule out such benefits, but at present there is no evidence of health benefits from an organic diet.
The second way to approach this question is to evaluate the food products themselves: Are they more nutritious? The most recent systematic review of the evidence concluded:
On the basis of a systematic review of studies of satisfactory quality, there is no evidence of a difference in nutrient quality between organically and conventionally produced foodstuffs. The small differences in nutrient content detected are biologically plausible and mostly relate to differences in production methods.
There is also a recent study concluding that birds prefer seed that is conventionally produced over seed that is organically produced – likely because conventional production methods result in a 10% higher protein content.
The third issue with organic food is what is not in, or on them – pesticides, hormones and antibiotics. Here, again, we can take the same two approaches as with nutrition: Is there any evidence of a difference between organic and conventional produce, and is there evidence for a health benefit? There seems to be a consensus on the first question. There are lower levels of synthetic pesticides in organic produce and lower levels of hormones and antibiotics in organic meat than in conventionally grown equivalents. But is this safer for health? The review cited above is also relevant to this question, and essentially there is no evidence for greater safety of organic food over conventional food.
With regard to pesticides, it must also be noted that organic farming, while using methods to minimize pests and the need for pesticides, still uses organic, rather than synthetic, pesticides. For example a rotenone-pyrethrin mixture is commonly used. Such pesticides are not as well studied as synthetic pesticides, often require more applications, and may persist longer in the soil. In fact the use of “natural” pesticides is nothing more than an appeal to the naturalistic fallacy – there really is no evidence for superior safety, and they have not been adequately studied.
There is a recent study which has garnered a great deal of press linking organophosphates – a type of synthetic pesticide – to higher prevalence of ADHD. However, this is a preliminary observational study. While interesting, it really can only be used to justify further research, not any conclusions regarding the effects of organophosphates. (I discuss this article in more detail here.)
It does seem reasonable to minimize human exposure to pesticides. This can be accomplished, at least in part, however, by simply washing all produce thoroughly. I could not find any direct comparisons of organic produce to thoroughly washed conventional produce, but what evidence we do have suggests that residue levels are below safety limits and can be lowered further by washing. This is an area that does require continued monitoring and research, however.
Conclusion
Overall there does not appear to be any advantage for health to organic farming (sustainability and environmental effects being a separate issue). However, despite the fact that organic farming has been around for over 50 years, there is a surprisingly small amount of quality research available. The organic farming industry and popularity of organic products is growing. Organic products are more expensive, and questions remain about whether or not such methods would be adequate to supply our food needs. There may also be hidden health risks or unintended consequences to relying upon organic farming. There may also be benefits that have not been adequately documented. Therefore, this is one area where I think it is reasonable to conclude more research is genuinely needed.

Treating Mental Illness with Nutrition: The Walsh Protocol
The Walsh Institute offers the Walsh protocol for the nutritional treatment of mental illness. This “orthomolecular psychiatry” is not supported by any clinical studies.
Harriet Hall on May 28, 2019
Link

The Walsh Institute, founded by William J. Walsh, is “dedicated to unraveling the biochemistry of mental disorders and development of improved clinical treatments through scientific research and medical practitioner education”. It aims to bring advanced biochemical therapy to patients with ADHD, schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, anxiety, clinical depression, behavior disorders, autism, and neurodegenerative disorders. These goals sound very worthy, but they have produced no credible clinical studies to evaluate the efficacy of their recommendations. The Walsh protocol is basically just an updated version of a decades-old questionable approach called orthomolecular psychiatry. It is gussied up with recent science, with references to epigenetics, heavy metal overloads, and methylation. It might impress some readers as cutting-edge science but is really little more than lipstick on a pig.
In the world of alternative medicine there is a widespread belief that all disease can be prevented or cured by simply eating the right diet. That simply is not true. There is a grain of truth: the risk of developing some diseases can be reduced (not totally prevented) by eating a healthy diet (cardiovascular disease, diabetes, etc.). The risk of developing some cancers can be reduced through diet; but once the cancer has developed, diet won’t make it go away.
The Walsh Institute’s claims
The Walsh Institute website cites Pfeiffer’s Law: “For every drug that benefits a patient, there is a natural substance that can achieve the same effect.” That’s not a law, that’s just wishful thinking. They advise treatment by a licensed practitioner experienced in the therapeutic use of vitamins, minerals, amino acids, and essential oils. (Yes, essential oils!)They disparage drugs because drugs cause side effects. They say “nutrient therapy may gradually replace psychiatric drugs as the treatment of choice for mental illness.” That’s also just wishful thinking, and to my mind is so unrealistic that it borders on the delusional.
In his book Nutrient Power, William Walsh says:
most humans have nutrient imbalances due to genetic and environmental factors, and these imbalances can cause mischief in various ways: (1) serotonin, dopamine, and other key neurotransmitters (NT’s) are continuously produced in the brain from nutrient raw materials that may be at improper concentrations; (2) nutrient imbalances can alter epigenetic processes that govern NT activity at synapses; (3) deficiency in antioxidant nutrients can cripple the brain’s protection against toxic metals …
You may have noticed some alternative medicine buzzwords in that statement, and I question everything in it. How could he know that most humans have nutrient imbalances? How could he know that neurotransmitter synthesis is impaired by “improper concentrations” of nutrients? How could he know what the proper concentrations are? Where’s his evidence?
Where’s the evidence?
The Walsh Institute claims to understand and be guided by the biochemical individualities of each patient and to benefit them by:
    • Normalizing the concentration of nutrients needed for neurotransmitter synthesis
    • Epigenetic regulation of neurotransmitter activity
    • Reducing free-radical oxidative stress
Can they do what they claim? The limited available evidence suggests not. For instance, a randomized double blind controlled trial in 1999 found that vitamin therapy improved serum levels in schizophrenic patients but had no effect on symptoms or behaviors. There are some suggestive studies, but they are small and poor quality. The references listed in the “Research” section of the Institute’s website include unpublished speculations, PowerPoint presentations, a few published studies authored by Walsh (impossible to interpret because they had no control group), basic science information, irrelevant information, but no controlled clinical studies.
Wikipedia’s article is instructive. It defines orthomolecular psychiatry as the use of orthomolecular medicine for mental illness and says:
The approach uses unorthodox forms of individualized testing and diagnosis to attempt to establish an etiology for each patient’s specific symptoms, and claims to tailor the treatment accordingly, using a combination of nutrients, dietary changes and medications that are claimed to enhance quality of life and functionality as well as to reduce or eliminate symptoms and the use of xenobiotic drugs. Orthomolecular psychiatry has been rejected by the mainstream medical community.
Orthomolecular medicine
Orthomolecular medicine is critiqued on Quackwatch. It originated in the 1950s when psychiatrists started adding vitamin B3 and other nutritional therapies to their treatments of severe mental problems. Dr. Stephen Barrett, the owner and driving force of Quackwatch, cites a special American Psychiatric Association task force which produced what he calls “probably the most strongly worded statement ever published by a scientific review body.” It said:
This review and critique has carefully examined the literature produced by megavitamin proponents and by those who have attempted to replicate their basic and clinical work. It concludes in this regard that the credibility of the megavitamin proponents is low. Their credibility is further diminished by a consistent refusal over the past decade to perform controlled experiments and to report their new results in a scientifically acceptable fashion. Under these circumstances this Task Force considers the massive publicity which they promulgate via radio, the lay press and popular books, using catch phrases which are really misnomers like “megavitamin therapy” and “orthomolecular treatment,” to be deplorable.
Hypothetical conditions
Orthomolecular psychiatrists claim to treat several hypothetical conditions that are not recognized by the mainstream scientific community.
Pyroluria is said to be a form of schizophrenic porphyria, with excessive levels of pyrroles caused by improper hemoglobin synthesis and deficiencies of zinc and vitamin B6. Several studies have failed to find pyroluria in schizophrenics or have found no correlation of pyrrole levels with mental illness. Nevertheless, the Walsh Institute calls urine pyrrole levels “the decisive test” and claims pyrrole disorder is a common feature of many behavior and emotional disorders. “Common symptoms include explosive temper, emotional mood swings, poor short-term memory, and frequent infections. These patients are easily identified by their inability to tan, poor dream recall, abnormal fat distribution, and sensitivity to light and sound.”
Histadelia is hypothesized to involved increased levels of histamine and basophils, to cause depression, and to be treatable with megadoses of methionine and vitamin B6. There are no published clinical trials.
Histapenia is high copper and low histamine. Apparently both high and low levels of histamine are problematic? Others have noticed that this doesn’t make sense.
Conclusion: The Walsh protocol is not credible
The Walsh protocol claims to treat behavior disorders, ADHD, autism, anxiety, depression, bipolar disorders, schizophrenia and Alzheimer’s disease. The Institute has trained more than 600 practitioners in specialized (but unvalidated) lab testing, diagnosis of chemical imbalances, and individualized treatments, and they claim to have thousands of reports of recovery. Anyone can make claims and offer testimonials, and innumerable charlatans and self-deluded practitioners do just that. The Walsh protocol might be on to something; but unless they start publishing meaningful controlled clinical trials, I see no reason to take them seriously.

Processed Foods and Autism
Reports of a “link” between processed food and autism highly misrepresent the actual findings of an in-vitro study.
Steven Novella on July 3, 2019
Link
A new study is making the rounds in the media, with unfortunate but typical misrepresentation. This is partly due to media hype, but I think some of the responsibility goes back to the study authors. The title is: “Propionic Acid Induces Gliosis and Neuro-inflammation through Modulation of PTEN/AKT Pathway in Autism Spectrum Disorder”. I cannot figure out, from reading the study, why those last four words are in the title. Sure, that is the speculation that derives from the data, but the data has nothing directly to do with autism, as we will see. The effect, however, was dramatic. Here are some headlines:
Forbes: “Spike In Autism May Be Linked To Preservative In Processed Foods, Study Suggests”
Medical News Today: “Could processed foods explain why autism is on the rise?”
UPI: “Processed foods may lead to autism, study says”
Business Standard: “Researchers draw link between processed foods and rise in autism”
None of those headlines are fair or accurate. After reading those headlines you may be surprised to learn that the study did not involve children with autism, the risk of autism, or really anything to do with autism. The study, rather, looked at the effects of propionic acid (PPA) on neurons (brain cells) cultured in a dish:
We investigated the effect of Propionic acid (PPA), a short-chain fatty acid (SCFA) and a product of dys-biotic ASD gut, on human neural stem cells (hNSCs) proliferation, differentiation and inflammation.
They found that when the cells were exposed to high levels of PPA this promoted neural stem cell growth, increased the ratio of glial cells to neurons, decreased neurite outgrowth, and increased neural inflammation. These are also features seen in the brains of children with autism. Of course, this is one study and it needs to be replicated to see if this effect is robust, but let’s assume for now that the methods and results are valid. The real question is – how to interpret the results.
As we often point out as SBM, it is a long way from an in-vitro study to a clinical implication, and this applies for either treatment effects or risks. A dish of cultured cells is not an organism. Organisms are complex dynamic homeostatic living things. You cannot extrapolate directly from the petri dish to the animal. At best these in-vitro studies suggest a possibility that would then need to be confirmed in animals. The authors do acknowledge this, and the need for follow up animal study to show if the possible effect they are seeing is relevant in a whole live animal.
But even then we are not done, because rats and mice are not people. We would then need to do epidemiological studies in people, for example studying whether the diet of pregnant women, specifically relating to the amount of PPA, affect the risk of autism in their children. We cannot expose pregnant women to PPA for ethical reasons, but you can also do an experimental study in which you randomize pregnant women, or women who are trying to become pregnant, to a diet low in PPA. Only then, really, will we know if there is a “link” between PPA in the diet and risk of autism. That won’t end the scientific questioning either, as we need to answer many subquestions about dose, other confounding factors, vulnerable populations, and mechanism of action. At best the current study shows a potential mechanism of action IF an actual link is discovered – but it does not establish a link.
There are many ways in which these in-vitro finding will not translate to actual risk in humans. First, PPA is normally found in the gut of humans. So, does the amount of extra PPA consumed in processed foods significantly affect the amount of PPA in the GI system? Does this translate into changes in blood levels, and the levels that cross the placenta, and therefore concentrations in the developing fetus? Are those differences, if any, sufficient to cause biological changes? If any link in this chain is broken, the effects seen in-vitro will not translate to people. Most of the time, the vast majority, effects seen in-vitro do not directly translate to people.
Of course, most people will read the headlines, and not the study, and would not appreciate the distinctions made above in any case.
As an aside, the reporting accepts without challenge the premise that autism rates are increasing. As we have discussed many times, the rise in autism diagnoses is at least partly due to increased surveillance and recognition. We are diagnosing it more, but that does not mean the true incidence is increasing. It’s hard to know exactly, but if we look at all the evidence it seems likely that true rates are stable. There is definitely an increase in surveillance, diagnostic substitution, and a broadening of the definition. If we compare different age cohorts, however, using the same diagnostic criteria, the rates seem stable. But I will grant this is still a bit of an open question, but at the very least much of the apparent rise is an artifact and not real.
Another aspect of the question addressed in this study is the broader question of the apparent link between the GI system and autism. In the last two decades there has been increased evidence for an actual link. For example, there does seem to be a subset of children with ASD who have gastrointestinal symptoms that are sensitive to diet. Some of these children have been found to have specific species of bacteria in their gut microbiome not seen in people without ASD. This does not establish the arrow of cause and effect, but it is intriguing and deserves further research.
That is basically where we are with the current study as well. This is interesting, it deserves further research, and it may fit in with the broader picture of a gut-brain connection in autism, which is also preliminary and deserves further research. In fact the broader issue of a gut-brain connection in general is interesting but needs further research. I am hopeful that in 20-30 years we will actually have interventions based on altering the gut microbiome for certain neurological diseases, but that is likely the time frame we are dealing with.
But for now we are in the preliminary scientific stage, where hype and misleading headlines rule, while firm scientific conclusions, and even less so, interventions, are not yet here.

GLUTEN

Is gluten the new Candida?
Celiac disease and non-celiac gluten sensitivity are very different things. The former has a large, visible, well-understood scientific foundation that is lacking in the latter.
Scott Gavura on March 1, 2012
Link

Much of the therapeutics I was taught as part of my pharmacy degree is now of historical interest only. New evidence emerges, and clinical practice change. New treatments replace old ones – sometimes because they’re demonstrably better, and sometimes because marketing trumps evidence. The same changes occurs in the over-the-counter section of the pharmacy, but it’s here marketing seems to completely dominate. There continues to be no lack of interest in vitamin supplements, despite a growing body of evidence that suggests either no benefit, or possible harm, with many products. Yet it’s the perception that these products are beneficial seem to be seem to continue to drive sales. Nowhere is this more apparent than in areas where it’s felt medical needs are not being met. I covered one aspect a few weeks ago in a post on IgG food intolerance blood tests which are clinically useless but sold widely. The diagnosis of celiac disease came up in the comments, which merits a more thorough discussion: particularly, the growing fears over gluten consumption. It reminds me of another dietary fad that seems to have peaked and faded: the fear of Candida.
It wasn’t until I left pharmacy school and started speaking with real patients that I learned we are all filled with Candida – yeast. Most chronic diseases could be traced back to Candida, I was told. And it wasn’t just the customers who believed it. One particular pharmacy sold several different kits that purported to eliminate yeast in the body. But these didn’t contain antifungal drugs – most were combinations of laxative and purgatives, combined with psyllium and bentonite clay, all promising to sponge up toxins and Candida and restore you to an Enhanced State of Wellness™. There was a strict diet to be followed, too: No sugar, no bread – anything it was thought the yeast would consume. While you can still find these kits for sale, the enthusiasm for them seems to have waned. Whether consumers have caught on that these kits are useless, or have abandoned them because they don’t actually treat any underlying medical issues, isn’t clear.
The trend (which admittedly is hard to quantify) seems to have shifted, now that there’s a new dietary orthodoxy to question. Yeast is out. The real enemy is gluten: consume it at your own risk. There’s a growing demand for gluten labeling, and food producers are bringing out an expanding array of gluten-free (GF) foods. This is fantastic news for those with celiac disease, an immune reaction to gluten, where total gluten avoidance is essential. Only in the past decade or so has the true prevalence of celiac disease has become clear: about 1 in 100 have the disease. With the more frequent diagnosis of celiac disease, the awareness of gluten, and the harm it can cause to some, has soared. But going gluten free isn’t just for those with celiac disease. Tennis star Novak Djokovic doesn’t have celiac disease, but went on a GF diet. Headlines like “Djokovic switched to gluten-free diet, now he’s unstoppable on court” followed. Among children, there’s the pervasive but unfounded linkage of gluten consumption with autism, popularized by Jenny McCarthy and others. Even in the absence of any undesirable symptoms, gluten is being perceived as something to be avoided.
What’s been lost in an enthusiasm for gluten avoidance, is the fact that there are some people who do experience undesirable symptoms from gluten consumption, but don’t have celiac disease. It’s this group that was the focus of a recent paper in the Annals of Internal Medicine: “Nonceliac Gluten Sensitivity: Sense or Sensibility?” It’s behind a paywall, but I’ll try to summarize the paper in the context of what we know, and what we don’t know, about celiac disease and possible non-celiac gluten sensitivity.
Celiac disease
Celiac disease (CD) is an autoimmune disease, not an allergy or intolerance. The disease manifests with inflammation and injury to the bowel lining when gluten is consumed. It can cause gastrointestinal scarring and villous atrophy – resulting in permanent damage. While it normally presents with gastrointestinal symptoms, symptoms can also manifest as conditions like skin rash.The disease has been described as protean, which is appropriate. A 2001 survey of patients with confirmed celiac disease indicated patients reported symptomatic disease an average of 11 years before a diagnosis was reached. A similar survey of pediatric patients suggested a similar trend: Multiple physicians and other diagnoses. By manifesting in so many different ways, it cannot be diagnosed based on symptoms alone. So why is it so difficult to identify? It isn’t – but you need to look for it.
The immunologic response in celiac disease is a reaction to gliadin, a protein found in wheat, barley and rye. A highly effective test is now widely available. Blood is tested for IgA antibody human recombinant tissue transglutaminase (IgA-tTGA) or endomysium (IgA-EMA). These tests are both highly sensitive (90%–96%) and specific (>95%) for celiac disease. Positive results are followed by biopsy, necessary to establish a diagnosis. That diagnosis is confirmed by evaluating the effectiveness of a gluten-free diet on reported symptoms. (The full diagnostic workup is nicely summarized in the AGA Institute Medical Position Statement on the Diagnosis and Management of Celiac Disease.) Given the availability of a sensitive and specific test for celiac disease, there has been some discussion on whether widespread and routine screening for celiac disease should occur. The evidence and risk/benefit currently suggests screening in the absence of any symptoms is still unwarranted.
Non-celiac gluten sensitivity
We have a sensitive and specific test for celiac disease, so diagnosis should be straightforward, right? If you have celiac disease, you must avoid gluten for life. But what about those that test negative for celiac disease, but have symptoms from eating gluten-containing foods? There are at least five possible scenarios:
    • You could be IgA deficient, in which case there’s a false negative. Other laboratory tests may be done, and compared with the biopsy.
    • You may already be on a gluten-free diet, which will cause a false negative result.
    • It could simply be a false negative laboratory test result (no laboratory test is 100% sensitive and specific).
    • There may be some form of subclinical CD present (not yet established as fact, but plausible).
    • It may not be celiac disease, and other causes need to be evaluated.
It’s this last category, deemed non-celiac gluten sensitivity (NCGS) which is the subject of the recent Annals paper. Despite the identification of NCGS over 30 years ago, it’s only recently that interest seems to have exploded – I count about 336,000 Google results, but only 10 results in PubMed. Remarkably, the Annals paper points out that the public awareness of NCGS exceeds that of celiac disease [PDF].
So how do we distinguish between the CD and NCGS, objectively? Here the Annals paper includes a nice table which summarizes the challenge:

It is the protean nature of CD that makes NCGS seem so prevalent. As there’s a myriad of non-specific symptoms that could signal true CD, any any of these symptoms can also be attributed to NCGS. So what high-quality evidence exists to establish NCGS is real? Not a lot, yet. The Annals paper identifies only a single placeb0-controlled rechallenge trial, which concluded that NCGS “may exist”. There is a lack of systematic research, but lots of opinions. A recent essay [PDF] from Sapone et al in Biomed Central used a consensus-based approach to evaluate NCGS and other gluten-related disorders. It concludes by labeling gluten “toxic”, declaring celiac disease an “epidemic”, and suggesting that the prevalence of gluten sensitivity will continue to increase, supposedly because of a lack of adaptive response to deliberate changes bred into wheat strains.
But is that accurate? There are no accurate prevalence estimate for NCGS – because there are no objective signs or symptoms that can be evaluated. Given the magnification of fears of gluten among the general population, I suspect prevalence will increase simply because of perceived health concerns and rank fearmongering over gluten: nocebo effects, where an inert substances causes negative symptoms. From a scientific perspective a few possible mechanisms that have been postulated for NCGS, none of which have been established yet:
    • a stress response, rather than an immune response, which is unlikely given the varied manifestations of NCGS
    • an IgE-mediated reaction to wheat flour, possibly to another chemical compound it contains
    • starch malabsorption
    • opioid-like effects of gluten on the colon (opioid receptors in the gastrointestinal tract are the reason narcotics cause constipation)
    • some degree of low-grade inflammation, possibly signalling some sort of subclinical CD, presenting in a way that cannot be diagnosed with the current tests
Conclusion: Gluten sensitivity is not well-supported
The idea that gluten sensitivity is real and widespread goes far beyond the current scientific evidence, and the well-established facts of celiac disease. Time will tell if gluten avoidance follows the path of Candida, and other dietary fears and fads that preceded it. But it doesn’t need to. Given the protean nature of CD, symptoms cannot be dismissed as nocebo effects: A CD diagnosis needs to be ruled out before NCGS is even contemplated. Going gluten-free in the absence of a proper medical evaluation may not be directly harmful, but it complicates a diagnosis. Moreover, it can be expensive, and difficult to maintain 100% avoidance – essential with CD, but not established as necessary with NCGS. Besides, who really wants to cut out all gluten-containing products if they don’t need to? Until better diagnostic criteria are established, the N of 1 trial is probably the most science-based (if impractical) approach: single-blind challenges to measure for subjective or objective symptoms. Our challenge in dealing with dietary fads as health professionals is to recognize that some of our patients are suffering, and evaluate them in a science based way: without dismissing the symptoms, and without advocating dietary transformations that may be unnecessary.
Reference
Di Sabatino A, & Corazza GR (2012). Nonceliac gluten sensitivity: sense or sensibility? Annals of internal medicine, 156 (4), 309-11 PMID: 22351716

A balanced look at gluten sensitivity
Laurie Laforest on August 16, 2014
Link
Even though it doesn’t appear on any calendar, May 2014 will go down in history as “gluten sensitivity month.” After RealClearScience picked up on a 2013 paper that brought into question the existence of non-celiac gluten sensitivity (NCGS), news sites were obliged to post their own analysis of the article, and the blogosphere was alight with pro- and anti-gluten posts. One of the authors of the paper in question, Dr. Peter Gibson of Monash University, was even mentioned on the People magazine website, which gives him the distinction of being the only researcher to be published alongside the Kardashians.

The Monash paper,1 which was previously discussed on SBM, suggested that it might be the fructans in wheat and not gluten that is responsible for symptoms in IBS sufferers who feel better on a gluten-free diet. Fructans belong to a group of short-chain carbohydrates known as FODMAPs that are readily fermented by bacteria in the intestine. If fructans were really to blame for wheat-induced gastrointestinal symptoms, this would be good news for IBS sufferers currently on a gluten-free diet — for some, a diet low in FODMAPs would be less restrictive than one without gluten, making it less prone to nutritional deficiencies.
As it stands, the existence of NCGS has neither been proven nor disproven by anyone. But gluten sensitivity sits at the intersection of several dilemmas in medicine today and, unlike how it’s portrayed in the media, is hardly an all-or-nothing affair. Proving it wrong will not instantly heal the people who have prescribed themselves a gluten-free diet. Proving it wrong will not produce a cure for IBS, a shorter time to a celiac diagnosis, or the correct way to handle potential celiac disease. Neither will proving it right. In the eyes of one gluten avoider, “Modern medicine is really good at crisis intervention…[but] they don’t do well with chronic issues”.2
With these issues in mind, it’s time to move past the media debates and fad dieters and take a balanced look at NCGS. This overview will use four recent articles by the Monash group1, 3, 4, 5 as a framework to uncover some of the factors contributing to the gluten sensitivity phenomenon. Even though it has been gone over many times, a discussion of the FODMAPs study is still in order — in fact, essential — to appreciate the central importance of the elimination diet in diagnosing a food sensitivity. Along the way, we’ll get an idea of who the gluten sensitive might be, how successful gluten-free diets really are, and how challenging it is to pursue a celiac diagnosis.
Some definitions
To refresh, here are some of the key ideas discussed:
    • Gluten: A protein found in relatively large amounts in wheat, but also found in other grains.
    • Celiac disease: A genetically-linked autoimmune disorder caused by the small intestine reacting to gluten. Causes pain, altered bowel movements and malnutrition.
    • Irritable bowel syndrome: A diagnosis made purely on the basis of symptoms (bloating, pain and either diarrhea, constipation, or both), with no known current cause.
    • Elimination diet: A diet which removes specific foods or classes of foods from the diet in an effort to identify the trigger to an allergic reaction or symptom(s).
A food sensitivity is born
In 2011, an international panel of experts defined NCGS as “a non-allergic and non-autoimmune condition in which the consumption of gluten can lead to symptoms similar to those seen in celiac disease”.6 Non-intestinal symptoms can include behavioral changes, bone or joint pain, muscle cramps, leg numbness, weight loss, and chronic fatigue.7 But this is only a working definition, and there is still a lot of uncertainty as to what NCGS actually represents, even for its proponents.
So far, NCGS appears to be a heterogeneous phenomenon, with at least three different and potentially-overlapping subtypes6, 8:
    • A type reminiscent of celiac disease — a family history of celiac disease or the celiac HLA genes but no increase in intestinal permeability and no auto-immune response.
    • A type reminiscent of irritable bowel syndrome — intestinal motility issues but a greater frequency non-intestinal symptoms.
    • A type reminiscent of food allergies — prior history of allergy or concurrent food sensitivities and some immunological markers for celiac disease, but no activation of mucosal basophils by gliadin.
Multiple subtypes imply multiple mechanisms, and this too needs to be ironed out for NCGS. Sapone et al.9 described NCGS as “an inflammatory condition mostly supported by innate immune mechanisms,” which differentiates it from celiac disease and wheat allergy, and in vitro evidence suggests that other poorly-digested wheat proteins known as amylase-trypsin inhibitors might trigger the innate immune response.6 Changes in intestinal microbiota may also play a role in NCGS.10 And, of course, the fructans have their own special magic.
The backstory
When NCGS was officially created by consensus, things weren’t proceeding according to the normal order. Celiac researchers, mainly centered at the University of Maryland, were pretty convinced that they had seen non-celiac patients whose symptoms had improved on a gluten-free diet. They searched for a set of biomarkers that would shed light on these cases, but found nothing consistent except for the absence of two celiac hallmarks — an autoimmune response and increased intestinal permeability.6, 8
From a food sensitivity perspective, however, searching for biomarkers is putting the cart before the horse. Food sensitivities, like cow’s milk protein intolerance or certain food additive intolerances, are only recognized after they have been demonstrated in studies using a double-blind, placebo-controlled food challenge (DBPCFC). The DBPCFC works regardless of the mechanism behind the reaction, so it can be used before any biomarkers have been identified.
Back in 2011, only one study had been completed on gluten sensitivity using a DBPCFC,3 and this first bit of positive evidence came from the Monash group. The study looked at a small group of IBS sufferers who identified themselves as gluten sensitive and who tested negative for celiac disease. They could only enter the study if their symptoms — abdominal pain, bloating, gas, constipation, diarrhea, or tiredness — were currently well controlled by a gluten-free diet.
Most DBPCFC studies use a crossover design, but the first Monash study randomly divided the participants into test and control groups. All participants continued on their usual gluten-free diet during the course of the study and were challenged with either gluten-free or gluten-containing low-FODMAP bread and muffins. The gluten group experienced greater gastrointestinal symptoms and tiredness compared to the control group, so it looked like gluten could induce GI symptoms on its own.
Shortly thereafter, a group at the University of Palermo11 used a DBPCFC to see whether any of their IBS patients were affected by wheat. In the end, they reclassified 30% of the 920 patients as suffering from wheat sensitivity. Notice I said wheat sensitivity — this study used capsules of wheat flour as the challenge instead of gluten. It also differed from the Monash study in that it included a stricter elimination diet before and during the challenges, not just relying on participants to maintain their own gluten-free diets.
The elimination diet — or the baseline diet — just may be the most important part of a DBPCFC. It puts everyone on a level playing field, stabilizing symptoms and doing away with any effects that might carry over from the participants’ normal diets. An elimination diet excludes the food under investigation and, if the study is thorough, all other foods or food additives that might produce a reaction. If symptoms don’t improve by the end of the elimination diet, then the study is on the wrong track.
The Palermo researchers were looking at a broader set of food sensitivities than just wheat. Gluten-free participants were asked to resume a normal diet for 2-4 weeks before beginning the elimination diet, which excluded wheat plus cow’s milk, eggs, tomato, and chocolate — foods known to aggravate IBS — and any other triggers identified by the participants. A challenge was considered positive if symptoms returned after having disappeared during the elimination diet. Of those testing positive for wheat sensitivity, the majority were also positive for cow’s milk protein intolerance when challenged separately; half were also sensitive to eggs and tomato.
Since many different foods are commonly, although not universally, reported to trigger or worsen IBS symptoms, the Palermo study didn’t go far enough to determine whether NCGS (or wheat sensitivity) is really its own entity outside of IBS or to explain the possible overlap between the two conditions. On the other hand, the Monash results were significant because gluten alone seemed to have caused an adverse reaction in IBS sufferers. But this result needed to be replicated under stricter conditions, so 2013 brought a new paper from the Monash group1 on a second gluten trial.
FODMAPs-gate
In IBS, the enteric (intestinal) nervous system is easily overstimulated, leading to abnormal contractions and an exaggerated perception of pain. Food triggers IBS symptoms by stimulating the enteric nervous system directly through various chemical receptors or indirectly by pressure.12 FODMAPs — which include fructans, galactans, polyols, fructose, and lactose — lead to more pressure in the intestine than other foods because they are poorly absorbed, rapidly fermented, and osmotically active.13 In other words, they cause gas and loose stools. The low-FODMAP diet, developed in 2008 by the same group at Monash University that we have been discussing, is the first comprehensive diet plan shown to reduce symptoms in the majority of IBS sufferers.14
Before the low-FODMAP diet, avoiding single foods like wheat or milk wasn’t always effective in treating IBS14; eliminating more than one carbohydrate type, like fructans and fructose, seems to have an additive effect that controls IBS symptoms better.15 That said, not everyone with IBS is sensitive to all of the FODMAPs, and the diet is highly customizable. The effectiveness of the low-FODMAP diet means that any diet study involving IBS sufferers must control for the effects of high-FODMAP foods.
The second DBCPFC study from the Monash group — the one that has received all the media attention — was a randomized crossover trial using stricter diets and stricter testing to make sure that participants did not have latent celiac disease. In this trial, meals were provided and additional snacks were logged. Here they ran two experiments — one where the elimination diet excluded high-FODMAP foods and the other where the elimination diet excluded high-FODMAP foods, dairy, and known triggers of pharmacological food intolerance reactions.
In the first arm of the study, participants were given challenge foods containing gluten, gluten plus whey, and pure whey, each separated by a washout period. Overall, symptoms improved during the low-FODMAP elimination diet but worsened for each of the challenges. Individually, though, only 3 out of 37 showed a significant response attributable to gluten when all challenges were considered.
In the second arm, 22 people from the first group were rechallenged with foods that contained gluten, whey, or no additional protein. This phase, which was meant to verify the results of the first using an even stricter elimination diet, could not reproduce any of the previous reactions. For example, only 2 out of 22 responded to gluten in the second arm, and these were not the same people who responded to gluten in the first.
One blogger took issue with the fact that many of the participants reacted to whey: “If some of the ‘placebo’ and low-gluten patients were, in fact, sensitive to whey, then that would invalidate the results of the study.” But that’s not true. The point to remember is that most people did not react to the same challenge food twice, and only one person consistently reacted to whey. Furthermore, it isn’t a catastrophe in a study like this if someone reacts to the placebo — this can happen for many reasons, including just having a bad day. What matters is how the reaction to the real challenge compares to the placebo reaction; if it is significantly greater, then the challenge is positive.
What did the researchers conclude? Considering both arms of the study and the immunological testing that also took place, no evidence of gluten-specific effects were found in patients on a low-FODMAP diet. They did not conclude that gluten sensitivity does not exist, only that “gluten may not be a specific trigger of functional gut symptoms once dietary FODMAPs are reduced.” That, however, does not settle the debate over gluten sensitivity. What the two Monash trials have shown us is the correct elimination diet to be used when looking for NCGS.
Gluten free with symptoms
The story doesn’t end there, though. From the Monash work we also learned that a good number of gluten-free dieters continue with the diet even though their symptoms do not completely resolve. This came out in two ways. To be included in the two Monash studies, participants needed to have well-controlled symptoms on a gluten-free diet. For the second study, for example, 147 volunteers were screened using several questions, one being, “Do you currently feel in control of your symptoms?”4 To this, 22% answered “no,” 3% answered “sometimes,” 16% answered “mostly,” and 59% answered “yes.” Then, when participants rated their symptoms at the beginning of the study, 11 of 37 were under significant distress, and 22% of the group significantly improved while on the low-FODMAP elimination diet.1
It is tempting to think that the people who did not see complete improvement on their own gluten-free diet were not really sensitive to gluten in the first place, but we don’t have the data to support this — only 58% of the larger group believed that they were strictly gluten free, and it is not clear how many of the gluten ‘cheaters’ still had symptoms. As the researchers pointed out, we also do not know how the symptomatic group felt before they began avoiding gluten — perhaps they had actually improved quite a bit on a gluten-free diet, but just not completely. Another explanation is that FODMAPs were really to blame for their symptoms, and avoiding only wheat wasn’t enough to provide complete relief.
It isn’t surprising that a person could be mistaken about having gluten sensitivity. According to someone like Dr. Oz, gluten sensitivity can be diagnosed by avoiding gluten for a while — say two weeks or a month — and then trying some to see what happens. But avoiding a staple food like wheat amounts to a major change of eating habits, and it is likely that wheat will not be the only food that is eliminated. For those who aren’t accustomed to performing experiments on themselves, these diet instructions don’t explain that any and all foods excluded during an elimination diet must be excluded for the entire diet and then used as a challenge later on. On top of this, placebo challenges really are necessary, and one round of challenges may not be enough — when symptoms are subjective or when a strong nocebo effect is expected, the active and placebo challenges should be randomized and repeated three times.6, 7
Oddly, many participants from the second Monash study opted to continue their gluten-free diet after the study ended because the diet made them “feel” better.5 This intrigued the researchers, so they invited the participants back for a third study to find out whether gluten was affecting their mental state.5 This trial proceeded along the same lines as the second, and mental state was assessed using the Spielberger State Trait Personality Inventory. Gluten still had no impact on gastrointestinal symptoms, but it did induce feelings of depression. This is a very interesting result because it could explain the lure of the gluten-free diet; however, researchers are still a long way off from uncovering a definite link between gluten and depression, transient or otherwise.
The missing celiacs and other sufferers
The final bit of information from the Monash researchers comes from the 147 people who applied to participate in their gluten studies.4 Of these, 44% had initiated their gluten-free diet themselves; the rest were following the advice of an alternative health professional (21%), dietitian (19%), or general practitioner (16%). In the surveys that followed, the researchers determined that two-thirds had not adequately excluded celiac disease, meaning that 15% had not been tested at all for celiac disease and that 29% of those who had undergone duodenal biopsies did not consume enough gluten beforehand for the results to be valid [see 18]. This includes half of the tests initiated by general practitioners.
Considering that one in 56 people with symptoms will have celiac disease,19 it is important to know why people feel confident diagnosing themselves with gluten sensitivity without first ruling out the more serious problem. Even if they do maintain a strict gluten-free diet for their entire lives, without a formal diagnosis, these people with possible celiac miss out on follow-up care, accommodations by schools and employers, and tax breaks or food subsidies in many countries. The truth is, many have pursued a celiac diagnosis or wish that they could have pursued one. The decision to go it alone is not taken lightly — consider these situations pulled from stories posted online:
     1.  They met the serologic for celiac disease but had a negative biopsy.
     2.  Their doctor won’t test them even though they have asked.
     3.  Their doctor says that they cannot have celiac disease because they are overweight.
     4.  Their doctor told them that they are too old to have celiac disease.
     5.  They were not told to or told not to do a gluten challenge before the endoscopy.
     6.  Their doctor ordered a colonoscopy to check for celiac disease.
     7.  They already believe that they have celiac disease because of their symptoms and family history.
     8.  An alternative practitioner told them that they have celiac disease because their reaction to gluten is severe.
     9.  They are already gluten free and don’t want to “get glutened” again in order to be tested.
     10.  Having a celiac diagnosis won’t affect their commitment to a gluten-free diet.
     11.  They believe that the Cyrex test is more thorough than conventional celiac testing from a doctor.
     12.  They believe that celiac disease is only a minor part of the spectrum of gluten-related disorders.
     13.  They are worried that their health and life insurance premiums will increase.
     14.  They don’t want a preexisting condition on their the health insurance records.
     15.  They do not have enough money for an endoscopy.
     16.  Their health insurance wouldn’t pay for an endoscopy.
Regardless of what we might think about these reasons, they paint the picture of a larger problem. Roughly 80% of celiac cases go undiagnosed,20 a situation that The Lancet has described as a “public health farce”21 in light of the millions of healthy people who choose to be gluten free. Undiagnosed celiac disease can lead to osteoporosis, anemia, infertility, certain intestinal cancers, other autoimmune disorders, and an increased risk of mortality, although the latter is still under debate.22, 23 Still, the average time to receive a celiac diagnosis has been around 11 years.24
Right now we don’t know how many people with self-diagnosed gluten sensitivity actually have celiac disease, but the Monash data tells us that this is a significant concern. Efforts are being made to cut down the time it takes for a celiac diagnosis, but progress is slow.24 Increasing celiac awareness among physicians is part myth busting and part reeducation, and in the absence of mass screening, doctors must be able to spot non-GI or “atypical” symptoms and associated conditions that suggest the presence of the disease.25 At the same time, the protocol for diagnosing celiac disease is being reexamined26 — in Europe, the duodenal biopsy, currently regarded as the gold standard for celiac diagnosis, can be omitted in certain circumstances.27
We also don’t know how often potential celiac disease is actually mislabeled as gluten sensitivity. Potential celiac disease describes cases where serologic and genetic markers for celiac disease are positive but the biopsy is negative.24 There is no consensus on whether to treat potential celiac disease, nor, for that matter, whether it is a real problem or just a false-positive result.24, 28 Some evidence suggests that a gluten-free diet is beneficial,28 while another report describes patients whose symptoms spontaneously improved even though they continued to eat gluten.29 Until the issues surrounding celiac and potential celiac disease have been resolved, non-celiac gluten sensitivity — or at least one of its subtypes — cannot be clearly defined.
Where do we go from here?
In a large Australian survey from 2013, roughly 7% of respondents had diagnosed themselves with gluten sensitivity.30 The gluten free fad is just as popular in Australia as it is in the US,30, 31 so this figure might also estimate the prevalence of gluten sensitivity here, even though a 2009 estimate was much lower at 0.55%.32
Who might be in the 7%? Some with IBS, some with a botched celiac diagnosis, some with potential celiac disease, some who are intolerant to foods that they inadvertently eliminated because of their new diet, some who get only a psychological benefit from avoiding gluten, some whose symptoms continue despite their best efforts, some who really are hypochondriacs, and perhaps some with NCGS as its own entity. It doesn’t even matter whether non-celiac gluten sensitivity exists — these people will remain.
But it’s going to be a while until gluten sensitivity is understood. According to Dr. Alessio Fasano, director of the Center for Celiac Research at the Massachusetts General Hospital, NCGS stands where celiac disease stood 40 years ago.8 Even so, all we need are a few good DBPCFC trials to answer the basic question as to whether gluten sensitivity exists. This may be easier said than done, however, as the Monash group found such a strong nocebo effect in their trials that they now believe that future research should involve IBS sufferers who have not tried a gluten-free diet before.33
In the meantime, more people will suspect that they are sensitive to gluten, and if they are not to be lost to self-diagnosis or alternative medicine, the medical community must be able to lead them through the process of sorting out their suspicions. The Monash researchers have suggested an interim pathway for diagnosing gluten sensitivity, which includes:4
     1.  The adequate exclusion of celiac disease.
     2.  The exclusion of other dietary triggers, like FODMAPs or other foods suspected by the individual.
     3.  A gluten-free diet, if symptoms did not resolve or improve in Step 2.
     4.  Blinded gluten challenges, if symptoms did improve in Step 3.
     5.  Rechallenges with gluten to establish their gluten threshold.
As a clinical approach, this moves us away from thinking about gluten sensitivity in all or nothing terms and addresses the issues one person at a time.

References
     1.  Biesiekierski JR, Peters SL, Newnham ED, Rosella O, Muir JG, Gibson PR. No Effects of Gluten in Patients With Self-Reported Non-Celiac Gluten Sensitivity After Dietary Reduction of Fermentable, Poorly Absorbed, Short-Chain Carbohydrates. Gastroenterology. 2013 Aug;145(2):320–328.e3. PMID 23648697
     2.  Moore LR. “But we’re not hypochondriacs”: The changing shape of gluten-free dieting and the contested illness experience. Social Science & Medicine. 2014 Mar;105:76–83. PMID 24509047
     3.  Biesiekierski JR, Newnham ED, Irving PM, Barrett JS, Haines M, Doecke JD, et al. Gluten causes gastrointestinal symptoms in subjects without celiac disease: a double-blind randomized placebo-controlled trial. Am J Gastroenterol. 2011 Mar;106(3):508–514. PMID 21224837
     4.  Biesiekierski JR, Newnham ED, Shepherd SJ, Muir JG, Gibson PR. Characterization of Adults With a Self-Diagnosis of Nonceliac Gluten Sensitivity. Nutrition in Clinical Practice [Internet]. 2014 Apr 16 [cited 2014 Apr 26]; Available from: http://ncp.sagepub.com/cgi/doi/10.1177/0884533614529163. PMID 24740495
     5.  Peters SL, Biesiekierski JR, Yelland GW, Muir JG, Gibson PR. Randomised clinical trial: gluten may cause depression in subjects with non-coeliac gluten sensitivity – an exploratory clinical study. Alimentary Pharmacology & Therapeutics. 2014 May;39(10):1104–12. PMID 24689456
     6.  Mansueto P, Seidita A, D’Alcamo A, Carroccio A. Non-Celiac Gluten Sensitivity: Literature Review. Journal of the American College of Nutrition. 2014 Feb;33(1):39–54. PMID 24533607
     7.  Sapone A, Bai JC, Ciacci C, Dolinsek J, Green PH, Hadjivassiliou M, et al. Spectrum of gluten-related disorders: consensus on new nomenclature and classification. BMC medicine. 2012;10(1):13. PMID 22313950
     8.  Catassi C, Bai J, Bonaz B, Bouma G, Calabrò A, Carroccio A, et al. Non-Celiac Gluten Sensitivity: The New Frontier of Gluten Related Disorders. Nutrients. 2013 Sep 26;5(10):3839–53. PMID 24077239
     9.  Sapone A, Lammers KM, Casolaro V, Cammarota M, Giuliano MT, De Rosa M, et al. Divergence of gut permeability and mucosal immune gene expression in two gluten-associated conditions: celiac disease and gluten sensitivity. BMC Med. 2011 Mar 9;9:23. PMID 21392369
     10.  Carroccio A, Mansueto P, D’Alcamo A, Iacono G. Non-Celiac Wheat Sensitivity as an Allergic Condition: Personal Experience and Narrative Review. The American Journal of Gastroenterology. 2013;108(12):1845–52. PMID 24169272
     11.  Carroccio A, Mansueto P, Iacono G, Soresi M, D’Alcamo A, Cavataio F, et al. Non-celiac wheat sensitivity diagnosed by double-blind placebo-controlled challenge: exploring a new clinical entity. The American Journal of Gastroenterology. 2012 Dec;107(12):1898–1906; quiz 1907. PMID 22825366
     12.  Gibson PR, Shepherd SJ. Food choice as a key management strategy for functional gastrointestinal symptoms. The American Journal of Gastroenterology. 2012 May;107(5):657–666; quiz 667. PMID 22488077
     13.  Gibson PR, Shepherd SJ. Evidence-based dietary management of functional gastrointestinal symptoms: The FODMAP approach. J Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2010 Feb;25(2):252–8. PMID 20136989
     14.  Halmos EP, Power VA, Shepherd SJ, Gibson PR, Muir JG. A Diet Low in FODMAPs Reduces Symptoms of Irritable Bowel Syndrome. Gastroenterology. 2014 Jan;146(1):67–75.e5. PMID 24076059
     15.  Shepherd S, Gibson P. The Complete Low-FODMAP Diet: A Revolutionary Plan for Managing IBS and Other Digestive Disorders. Workman Publishing; 2013. 290 p. ISBN 9781615190805
     16.  Gellerstedt M, Bengtsson U, Niggemann B. Methodological issues in the diagnostic work-up of food allergy: a real challenge. Journal of Investigational Allergology and Clinical Immunology. 2007;17(6):350. PMID 18088015
     17.  Bindslev-Jensen C. Standardization of double-blind, placebo-controlled food challenges. Allergy. 2001;56(s67):75–7. PMID 11298015
     18.  The number of those improperly tested for celiac disease could actually be a little lower than 29% since the researchers judged the adequacy of the prerequisite gluten challenge against the current Australian guidelines (at least four weeks of 16 g of gluten per day), and this duration and amount may be higher than necessary:Leffler D, Schuppan D, Pallav K, Najarian R, Goldsmith JD, Hansen J, et al. Kinetics of the histological, serological and symptomatic responses to gluten challenge in adults with coeliac disease. Gut. 2013 Jul 1;62(7):996–1004. PMID 22619366
     19.  Fasano A, Berti I, Gerarduzzi T, Not T, Colletti RB, Drago S, et al. Prevalence of celiac disease in at-risk and not-at-risk groups in the United States: a large multicenter study. Arch Intern Med. 2003 Feb 10;163(3):286–92. PMID 12578508
     20.  Rubio-Tapia A, Ludvigsson JF, Brantner TL, Murray JA, Everhart JE. The prevalence of celiac disease in the United States. The American Journal of Gastroenterology. 2012 Oct;107(10):1538–1544; quiz 1537, 1545. PMID 22850429
     21.  Gluten-free diets: vital or vogue? The Lancet. 2012;380(9843):704. PMID 22920739
     22.  Haines ML, Anderson RP, Gibson PR. Systematic review: the evidence base for long-term management of coeliac disease. Alimentary Pharmacology & Therapeutics. 2008 Nov;28(9):1042–66. PMID 18671779
     23.  Godfrey JD, Brantner TL, Brinjikji W, Christensen KN, Brogan DL, Van Dyke CT, et al. Morbidity and Mortality among Older Individuals with Undiagnosed Celiac Disease. Gastroenterology. 2010 Sep;139(3):763–9. PMID 20685275
     24.  Catassi C, Fasano A. Is this really celiac disease? Pitfalls in diagnosis. Current Gastroenterology Reports. 2008;10(5):466–72. PMID 18799121
     25.  Collin P. Should adults be screened for celiac disease? What are the benefits and harms of screening? Gastroenterology. 2005 Apr;128(4):S104–S108. PMID 15825117
     26.  Caio G, Volta U. Coeliac disease: changing diagnostic criteria? Gastroenterology and Hepatology from bed to bench [Internet]. 2012 [cited 2014 Jun 4];5(3). Available from: http://journals.sbmu.ac.ir/ghfbb/index.php/ghfbb/article/viewFile/274/227. PMID 24834212
     27.  Husby S, Koletzko S, Korponay-Szabo IR, Mearin ML, Phillips A, Shamir R, et al. European Society for Pediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology, and Nutrition guidelines for the diagnosis of coeliac disease. Journal of Pediatric Gastroenterology and Nutrition. 2012;54(1):136–60. PMID 22197856
     28.  Kurppa K, Collin P, Viljamaa M, Haimila K, Saavalainen P, Partanen J, et al. Diagnosing Mild Enteropathy Celiac Disease: A Randomized, Controlled Clinical Study. Gastroenterology. 2009 Mar;136(3):816–23. PMID 19111551
     29.  Biagi F, Trotta L, Alfano C, Balduzzi D, Staffieri V, Bianchi PI, et al. Prevalence and natural history of potential celiac disease in adult patients. Scandinavian Journal of Gastroenterology. 2013 May;48(5):537–42. PMID 23506211
     30.  Golley S, Corsini N, Topping D, Morell M, Mohr P. Motivations for avoiding wheat consumption in Australia: results from a population survey. Public Health Nutrition. 2014 Apr 17;1–10. PMID 24739252
     31.  NPD Group. Percentage of U.S. Adults Trying to Cut Down or Avoid Gluten in Their Diets Reaches New High in 2013 [Internet]. 2013 Mar. Available from: https://www.npd.com/wps/portal/npd/us/news/press-releases/percentage-of-us-adults-trying-to-cut-down-or-avoid-gluten-in-their-diets-reaches-new-high-in-2013-reports-npd/
     32.  DiGiacomo DV, Tennyson CA, Green PH, Demmer RT. Prevalence of gluten-free diet adherence among individuals without celiac disease in the USA: results from the Continuous National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 2009–2010. Scandinavian Journal of Gastroenterology. 2013 Aug;48(8):921–5. PMID 23834276
     33.  Biesiekierski JR, Muir JG, Gibson PR. Is Gluten a Cause of Gastrointestinal Symptoms in People Without Celiac Disease? Current Allergy and Asthma Reports. 2013 Dec;13(6):631–8. PMID 24026574

Risks of a Gluten-Free Diet
Non-Celiac Gluten Sensitivity does not seem to be a real entity according the current evidence, but this has not stopped the gluten-free fad, which may be causing real harm.
Steven Novella on November 8, 2017
Link

There is a simple reason we strongly promote science-based medicine – it results in the best outcomes for individuals. That is true by definition, since the SBM approach is to use the best evidence and science available in order to determine which interventions result in the best outcomes.
There are numerous ways in which relying upon poor-quality evidence or invalid methods for making health decisions cause potential harm. Often the list is unimaginatively limited to direct physical harm, but that is only the tip of the iceberg. There is financial harm, loss of opportunity to pursue more effective interventions, psychological harm from false hope and being deceived, and sacrifice of quality of life, time, and effort.
Even without direct physical harm, with inert treatments like homeopathy, there is tremendous potential harm from relying upon fake medicine and bad science. But often there is potential physical harm, and even if slight it is not justified if there is no real benefit. Medicine is a game of risk vs benefit – when the benefit is essentially zero, any risk is unacceptable. 
The gluten-free fad
Even a small potential harm can be significantly magnified if it is marketed to the general public. The “clean eating” movement, in my opinion, clearly represents such a case. The best overall advice we can give the public regarding healthy eating is to eat a variety of food with plenty of fruits and vegetables and watch overall caloric intake. Unless you have special medical considerations, simply eating a good variety of different kinds of food will take care of most nutritional concerns. It will result in you getting enough of what you need and not too much of anything that can increase your risk.
Having a restricted or narrow diet is always tricky, and runs the risk that you will be getting too little of some key nutrients and may be getting exposed to too much of others. This is the key risk of so-called “fad” diets, because they are often premised on a simplistic notion that specific foods or categories of foods are inherently bad and should be avoided. Therefore any diet which essentially consists of avoiding certain foods or heavily relying on others is likely to take you away from an optimal diet, and therefore be a net negative for your health.
The recent gluten-free fad is no exception.
As I discuss in detail here, gluten is a composite of two proteins found in wheat, rye, barley, spelt, and related grains. About 1% of the population has an autoimmune reaction to one of the components of gluten (usually gliadin) and eating gluten can cause serious illness (a condition known as celiac disease). For those with celiac disease, avoiding gluten is essential and even a small amount of gluten can cause serious symptoms.
There is a controversy, however, surrounding the alleged existence of so-called non-celiac gluten sensitivity (NCGS). This is a hypothetical condition in which people may have a sensitivity to gluten without forming antibodies to gliadin or meeting the diagnostic criteria for celiac disease. Discovering a new disease is always complex, and requires the identification of something definitive and discrete. We either need to identify a clear clinical syndrome, or some new specific pathology.
For NCGS there is no clear pathology. The entity’s legitimacy currently relies on the alleged existence of individuals who do not have celiac disease but have a negative reaction to eating gluten. If, however, we are going to base a new disease purely on clinical history, we need to make sure that the history is accurate and that we are not simply overinterpreting non-specific symptoms or falling victim to confirmation bias.
For example, there are people who feel they have a specific syndrome of sensitivity to electromagnetic waves, despite the absence of any identifiable pathology. However, properly blinded studies show that self-identified sufferers of EM sensitivity cannot tell when they are being exposed to EM waves in a blinded condition.
For alleged NCGS the most salient evidence of its existence as a clinical entity are rechallenge studies. In these studies subjects are challenged with either gluten or placebo, then the gluten is removed, and then they are later rechallenged. If NCGS is a real entity then their symptoms should resolve when gluten is removed and then return when rechallenged, at a higher frequency when the same is done with a placebo.
A recent systematic review of gluten rechallenge studies did not find significant evidence for NCGS. They conclude:
The prevalence of NCGS after gluten re-challenge is low, and the percentage of relapse after a gluten or a placebo challenge is similar.
This is a pattern of evidence that is consistent with the null hypothesis, that NCGS does not exist – results are all over the place, with better-controlled studies tending not to show an effect, and on average there is only a tiny signal that does not reach statistical significance. The most parsimonious interpretation of available evidence, therefore, is that NCGS does not exist. Despite this fact, roughly one third of the population report that they are trying to avoid gluten.
What’s the harm
What, then, is the potential harm from restricting gluten from the diet in the millions of people who do not have gluten sensitivity? Potentially, all of the things I listed above may contribute to harm.
For many people they have settled on gluten sensitivity to explain real symptoms they may be having. In this case they may be missing the real cause of their symptoms. There is therefore an opportunity cost of making a false diagnosis.
Perhaps most significantly, a gluten-free diet is very difficult. You have to eliminate all wheat and similar grains from the diet. This has become somewhat easier recently as industry is cashing in on the gluten-free fad, but it is still a significant inconvenience and expense and therefore drain on quality of life.
Further – a gluten free diet eliminates a major category of food from the diet. People on a low or gluten-free diet tend to also be low in whole grains. They risk being deficient in iron and folic acid. A recent study linked low-gluten diets to a higher risk of type-II diabetes.
Avoidance of gluten may also result in a heavy reliance on rice as a staple grain, and this might increase the risk of heavy metal exposure. Again – having a varied diet spreads out exposure to contaminants and toxins as well as maximizing exposure to needed nutrients.
Science over marketing
If we take a scientific approach to the question of NCGS we find that there is no clear evidence that non-celiac gluten sensitivity is a real thing, and that gluten-free diets not only have no benefit for the general public they present health risks. Clearly, however, we need to do a better job of communicating this to the public.
Part of the challenge, however, is that nutritional gurus (who always seem to have something to sell) have a simple and appealing narrative to market. They tell the public that their problems are due to one bad food or type of food they just need to avoid. Or, they market of lifestyle of “clean eating” that is based on the appeal to nature and irrational fear of toxins and chemicals, rather than an even basic understanding of science and evidence.
The science-based position, however, takes time to emerge. It may take a decade or more to do the kinds of studies necessary to effective answer the question about whether or not a new hypothesized clinical entity exists. There are many types of evidence to be considered, and many sub-questions to be addressed. Over time a clear picture will tend to emerge, but in the meantime the health gurus can establish a market for their nonsense. Once their simplistic and marketable narrative gets into the public consciousness it is hard to correct.

Gluten Update
Non-celiac gluten sensitivity remains controversial, but the research continues.
Steven Novella on August 28, 2019
Link

The gluten-free craze continues, despite a lack of evidence that anyone other than the 1% of the population who have true Celiac disease, are harmed by gluten or benefit from removing it from their diet.
The controversy remains over the questionable existence of non-celiac gluten sensitivity (NCGS). These are people who do not have Celiac disease, which is an autoimmune reaction to gluten and is diagnosed primarily through the presence of anti-gliadin antibodies in the blood. Gluten is a protein in wheat and similar grains, and gliadin is one of the protein components of gluten. Some patients with gastrointestinal symptoms who test negative for Celiac disease still feel their symptoms are worsened by gluten.
This, in turn, has led to a gluten-free fad as part of the overall clean-eating movement, with gluten being demonized as a “bad” food ingredient that everyone should avoid.
A 2017 systematic review, however, found that studies looking at subjects with possible NCGS being challenged with gluten in a blinded fashion did not show any reliable symptoms. More recent studies have focused on the Salerno Experts’ Criteria – this is a procedure to remove wheat and gluten from the diet of those suspected with NCGS, then rechallenge them to see if symptoms return. There are some positive preliminary results with this protocol, but this the evidence is insufficient to conclude that NCGS is a distinct entity. A 2019 review gave this summary:
There are limited studies estimating the prevalence of NCGS using this study design. The existing studies have variable results likely due to the lack of a uniform diagnostic criterion, a great deal of dependence on the patient’s perception of symptoms and a large nocebo effect in existing studies. In clinical practice, a single blind placebo-controlled rechallenge trial has been recommended for diagnosis. The pathogenesis of NCGS is unclear and there is no known biomarker or diagnostic histologic lesion for this condition.
This situation warrants clinical and scientific caution. It is also a good example of why an SBM approach to such questions is so important. The clinical data is mixed and often subjective. In order to know that a clinical phenomenon is actually real, we would like to see multiple independent lines of evidence. When they are consistent lacking, that should raise skepticism.
In this case, when we look at the gastrointestinal lining of those with presumed NCGS we do not see any consistent pathological changes. We have found not markers in the blood. And challenge experiments show preliminary and mixed results.
This does not mean that NCGS does not exist, and certainly does not mean that patients with possible NCGS do not have real symptoms. What it means is that we do not know if NCGS exists, and we do not know why those patients have the GI symptoms they do. At present NCGS is a hypothesis, and it is a particularly shaky one given the current state of evidence. This means we need to remain humble and open-minded. There is a risk to prematurely settling on a hypothesis before it has been clearly demonstrated.
The risk of premature acceptance is particularly great in medicine. The very belief in a disease can easily take on a life of its own. The putative disease becomes a reality filter, a lens through which vague, heterogeneous, and poorly understood symptoms are viewed. Treatments, practitioners, and markets catering to the alleged disease emerge. Patients with their own support groups and organizations also take root. The entire enterprise is driven by placebo effects and questionable research nibbling around the edges of the core question but never answering it – is this entity real? And of course, those with questionable ethics exploit the situation, and do their best to portray the completely appropriate and even necessary lingering skepticism among experts as a conspiracy.
But keeping that skepticism alive is vital. It is the only way ultimately to the truth. We also have to keep in mind that if we are on the wrong track with NCGS then we are missing the real underlying cause of the symptoms of those who believe they have NCGS. There are already other hypotheses, such as sensitivity to some other component of wheat, or perhaps FODMAPs (fermentable, oligo-, di-, monosaccharides, and polyols). There is probably a reason the ducks are not all lining up. We need to discover what that reason is.
It is still also possible that NCGS is real, but that we simply have no idea what the true mechanism is. Finding that mechanism will be immensely helpful in confirming that NCGS is a distinct clinical entity, understanding it, and ultimately treating it.
To be clear, we don’t need a known mechanism to know that a disease is real. What we do need is a critical mass of evidence, but the balance of different types of evidence can take many forms for different diseases. We could, for example, have an iron-clad clinical syndrome – clear objective signs and symptoms that are fairly homogeneous with a predictable demographic and natural history. We could also have objective pathological markers, in the blood, on biopsy, on imaging, with genetic testing, or some physiological test. Some combination of clinical and pathological factors should lead to a reliable way to make a diagnosis, with good intra- and inter-rater reliability (something which is considered necessary for external validity – meaning that the diagnosis is real).
Finally, if all of this leads to an objectively effective treatment, that closes the loop on our understanding and also helps confirm we are on the right track.
For NCGS we have none of this. We have a vague and heterogeneous clinical syndrome without any objective markers and no clear response to any intervention. Again – none of this proves a negative. It means we don’t know, and we should continue to research other options.
It’s also possible that NCGS is a “garbage pail diagnosis”. This means it is a label applied to many different conditions that we currently don’t understand. If you have GI symptoms and we don’t have a diagnosis, then we throw it in the pail with everything else and call it NCGS. Such diagnoses, however, are better defined as clinical syndromes (like fever of unknown origin or chronic fatigue syndrome) rather than a presumed and unproven cause. The premature label biases our thinking, and the public’s perception.
In any case, this seems like a nut we will eventually crack. It remains an area of active research, and there is significant skepticism regarding NCGS among experts. That skepticism is good, and will serve well in guiding further research.

Gluten-free skin and beauty products: Extracting cash from the gullible
Gluten-free doesn’t make sense for a lot of diets. Except for lip balm and toothpaste, it makes an order of magnitude less sense for beauty products.
David Gorski on April 21, 2014
Link

Even though yesterday was Easter, and, as unreligious as I am, I was still thinking of taking it easy, there was one target that popped up that I just couldn’t resist. My wife and I were sitting around yesterday reading the Sunday papers and perusing the Internet (as is frequently our wont on Sunday mornings), when I heard a contemptuous harrumph coming from her direction. She then pointed me to an article in our local newspaper entitled Gluten-free beauty products in demand among some customers. Now, I must admit that I haven’t been keeping up with the gluten-free trend, other than how easily it fits within the niche of “autism biomed” quackery, where, apparently, nearly every “biomed” protocol for autistic children demands that gluten be stripped completely from their diets, lest the evil molecule continue to infect them with the dreaded autism. I’ve kept an eye the literature, but haven’t really written about gluten. That’s why I could immediately tell why my wife had called my attention to the article:
Amy Soergel’s lip gloss was making her sick. The problem, she realized, was gluten — hydrologized wheat protein, to be exact. Then she went to the hairdresser who used a shampoo that made her neck burn. Again, it contained gluten.
“There’s hidden gluten in many places you may not consider,” including stamp and envelope glues, toothpaste and lip balms, said Soergel, who has a store, Naturally Soergel’s, near Pittsburgh that caters to people with allergies. Indeed, for people with celiac disease, a bit of gluten that might get swallowed from a lipstick or a stream of shampoo in the shower can be enough to cause illness.
A slew of gluten-free skin care products have come on the market, including items from well-known companies such as Murad, Dr. Hauschka, EO, MyChelle, Suntegrity, Acure and derma-e. Many are sold in Whole Foods and other health food stores. If they’ve been certified by a third-party agency, an icon usually appears on the packaging.
Whole Foods. Of course, it had to be Whole Foods (among others). Let’s take a look at the whole gluten-free movement and then at the end I’ll revisit the question of gluten-free cosmetics and skin products.
Gluten, of course, is nothing more than proteins found in wheat endosperm (a type of tissue produced in seeds and that is ground to produce flour) and can also be found in barley and rye. It consists of two proteins, gliadin (a prolamin protein) and glutenin (a glutelin protein). Gluten cannot be consumed by sufferers of celiac disease (CD), whose main manifestation is inflammation of the bowel lining when gluten is eaten. The end result of this chronic inflammatory process can be gastrointestinal scarring and atrophy of the villi (the finger-like protrusions of the lining of the bowel responsible for nutrient absorption, among other things). The most common symptoms are, of course, gastrointestinal, including diarrhea, nausea, abdominal pain, and bloating, but CD can also manifest itself in a number of other symptoms, including skin rashes, weight loss and fatigue, oral ulcers, joint pain, anemia, and depression. CD (or gluten-sensitive enteropathy) is not caused by gluten, but rather a genetic predisposition. If you’re unlucky enough to have this predisposition, gluten can do bad things to you.
There is no doubt that CD can cause real problems in the people who have true gluten sensitivity. Indeed, as this New York Times article describes, in the 1990s the general medical consensus was that in the US the prevalence of CD was around 1 in 10,000. More recent studies, such as this one from 2012, report a prevalence of around 1 in 100. Worse, the majority of CD goes undiagnosed. In actuality, what is happening appears to be a combination of more intensive screening due to better awareness of celiac disease as a potential cause of puzzling symptom constellations, plus what is arguably a real increase in prevalence since 1950, estimated by Mayo Clinic researchers to be approximately four-fold and continuing to increase over the last decade.
The definitive diagnosis of CD is made by:
    • Detection of anti-gluten antibodies in the blood (specifically, as Scott Gavura described, IgA antiendomysial antibody (EMA) and the IgA tTGA), a test that is 90-95% sensitive and 95% specific. This is suggestive of gluten-sensitive enteropathy but not fully diagnostic.
    • The gold standard test: Distal duodenal biopsy specimens demonstrating characteristic histologic changes in the small intestinal mucosa, changes that include: a spectrum from total to partial villous atrophy and crypt lengthening with an increase in lamina propria and intraepithelial lymphocytes. It is also important to take at least six biopsies, because changes can be patchy.
It’s also noted in multiple sources that these tests should in general be done before the patient is placed on a gluten-free diet, because otherwise the tests often produce a false-negative result. There is also a controversial condition known as “non-celiac gluten sensitivity” (NCGS). As both Steve Novella and Scott Gavura note, these are patients without definitive diagnostic criteria for CD who believe that gluten causes symptoms of bloating, fatigue, and irritable bowel syndrome, but do not have antibodies to gliadin. Indeed, Scott quite correctly speculated over whether non-celiac gluten sensitivity is becoming the new Candida; i.e., an all-purpose bogeyman responsible for all sorts of vague, chronic health complaints and thus a nice foundation upon which quacks can base all sorts of dubious therapies related to removing gluten from the diets of anyone with vague complaints but no evidence of CD on testing.
Scott also noted the dearth of good studies on NCGS, and a review of PubMed just yesterday found that, although there are about 27 more articles out there in PubMed than there were when Scott last wrote about NCGS, the quality of evidence supporting the existence of the entity of NCGS remains poor. For example, in 2013, Biesiekierski et al. reported a placebo-controlled, cross-over rechallenge study of 37 subjects, in which they found no evidence of specific or dose-dependent effects of gluten in patients with NCGS placed on diets low in fermentable, oligo-, di-, monosaccharides, and polyols (FODMAPs) in order to control other potential triggers of gut symptoms. No markers of intestinal injury were noted in any of the groups, although a high nocebo response was noted. It’s not surprising that a recent review article characterized NCGS as “an entity awaiting validation, better diagnostic criteria, and, if it does exist, pathogenic mechanisms.” It was also noted that the “reluctance to acknowledge other components of wheat, such as fructans, non-gluten proteins and WGA, as potential pathogenic factors has often hampered good interpretation of clinical observations.” In other words, people are so fixated on gluten that they ignore other potential components of wheat and grains that might be the real cause of symptoms noted. The authors of the review article even go so far as to propose reasonable rules for future rigorous clinical trials on the subject:
Essential rules for future studies should include the following. First, celiac disease has to be seriously excluded by HLA studies and/or strict histological and immunological criteria. The inclusion of patients with intraepithelial lymphocytosis will always raise the issue of whether they really have celiac disease with a milder intestinal lesion. Secondly, the use of blinded placebo-controlled food re-challenge methodology to prove gluten sensitivity is present is not reliable, especially in patients who believe they have NCGS. Perhaps the selection of patients for study should be those with IBS naïve to a GFD. Thirdly, the trap of assuming that response to a GFD or exacerbation of symptoms due to a gluten-containing diet reflects specific effects of gluten should be outlawed and credence be given to the other wheat-related food constituents that can also cause gastrointestinal symptoms. Perhaps if these rules were followed, we would now be a lot closer to defining mechanisms by which gluten might act, might have developed biomarkers to identify patients who truly do have NCGS and perhaps, most importantly, answered the question of whether NCGS does really exist. On current evidence the existence of the entity of NCGS remains unsubstantiated.
So, in other words, CD is a real entity that is more common that diagnosed, but it is not even clear whether NCGS is a distinct clinical entity, despite the number of people who believe themselves to have it, the number of companies that cater to the belief that this entity exists, and the number of practitioners, particularly “integrative” practitioners and alternative practitioners, who have come up with all sorts of exclusionary diets and “biomedical” interventions to treat it. As yet, we do not have convincing, reproducible clinical evidence that the condition exists, which makes it premature to be speculating about mechanisms, no matter how much advocates of gluten-free diets as a cure-all for everything might “draw a line in the sand” and try to dismiss skeptics who don’t cite the biomarker studies they like as they promote dubious “paleo” diets. Does any of this mean that NCGS doesn’t exist or is bogus? No, not necessarily. What it means is that evidence is inconclusive and contradictory. Worse, because of relentless messaging in popular culture that gluten is bad for you, that many—who knows how many?—people have undiagnosed gluten sensitivities, and that most people would be better off without gluten in their diets, there’s a substantial nocebo effect. Meanwhile, confirmation bias, nocebo and placebo effects, regression to the mean, and the usual confounders that make individual experience so unreliable when determining if an intervention is effective in an individual explain the vast majority of glowing “testimonials” of people who “go gluten-free” and believe it made them so much healthier. Here’s a perfect example of An Open Letter to Gluten-Free Skeptics:
I gave up gluten in 2010. At the time I had no symptoms of gluten sensitivity – no digestive issues, no overt symptoms of problems. No diagnosis of celiac. I was, however, obese (and have been for most of my life), and prone to uncontrollable binge eating. I gave it up as an experiment – not sure that it would help me, just hoping.
And it did.
I’ve been leaner, and generally healthier, during the past 3 years than at any prior time in my life. And this hasn’t been an easy 3 years – it’s been very stressful (for reasons having nothing to do with food), yet despite lots of travel and lots of serious life changes, I’ve been able to lose most of my excess fat and keep it off, without very much effort.
This was not my first attempt at leaning out – I’ve tried many different eating strategies, from low fat to low carb to vegetarianism to intermittent fasting – over the years. None of them “stuck” until I went gluten free.
He continues:
Even if I DON”T have dozens of double blind studies published in peer reviewed journals showing that a GF intervention reduces inflammation, improves digestion, and leads to weight loss, I DO have evidence that it vastly improved MY life and health.
And:
But as much as YOUR argument that I don’t have science proving gluten is bad for everybody – nobody has any science showing that NOBODY benefits from a GF diet.
Let me reiterate: NOBODY has ever done even a single study that shows in any sense that NOBODY benefits from eliminating gluten from their diet.
None of which demonstrates that a gluten-free diet did anything for this man. These are, in fact, the same sorts of arguments, confusing correlation with causation riddled with confirmation bias that antivaccinationists use to “prove” that vaccines cause autism, that “autism biomed” can “recover” autistic children, and even that Stanislaw Burzynski or Robert O. Young cured their cancers. They prove little or nothing. Unfortunately, given the panoply of vague symptoms attributed to NCGS, it’s a condition, if it exists, that’s seemingly custom-made for all the confounders that make demonstrating the efficacy of a treatment so difficult. That’s why the rules suggested in the review article I cited above are so critical to future studies. Unfortunately, it’s also why gluten is likely to continue to be demonized beyond its health effects on people who have true CD.
Which brings us back to why on earth anyone thinks gluten-free cosmetics and beauty products are of any value. The answer is: They aren’t, with possibly one exception. The reason, of course, is that the gluten protein is too large to be absorbed through the skin. Now, it is known that it only takes a relatively small amount of gluten ingestion to result in gastrointestinal problems, as little as 50 mg (present in 1/80th of a slice of wheat bread) can cause damage to the intestinal villi. Consequently, there is a rationale for “going gluten-free” for any product that goes on the lips or in the mouth, such as lip balm, toothpaste, or lipstick, at least for people with severe CD. For people who think they have NCGS, where it hasn’t even been convincingly demonstrated that gluten is actually the component in wheat that causes symptoms, gluten-free cosmetics is nothing but marketing hype feeding into the same marketing hype behind the gluten-free products that are only really needed by people who have true CD and only debatably helpful to others. Remember, as I’ve seen pointed out, 93% of consumers purchasing gluten-free products are not diagnosed with CD, but rather do so because of an interest in “health and wellness,” ascetic-based practices of self-improvement, or the “flavor of the month” diet trend.
But what about gluten-free skin products? In general, these are an even bigger waste of money, again because gluten isn’t absorbed through the skin. Most of the reports, like this one, in which people attribute skin issues to gluten, do not constitute decent evidence that topical gluten causes their symptoms. The reason is simple. Those with CD not-infrequently suffer from dermatitis herpetiformis, a type of skin rash, as part of their symptoms, that is not caused by contact with gluten (indeed, a gluten skin patch test is notoriously poor in sensitivity for diagnosing CD) but by ingesting gluten. When they remove gluten from their diet, their dermatitis herpetiformis resolves with the rest of their symptoms. Such people, once they are made aware that they have CD, start wondering if gluten in skin products can be the cause. Not surprisingly, they switch to gluten-free skin products at the same time they are removing gluten from their diet, and, as usually happens, their skin symptoms recede along with their gastrointestinal symptoms.
But what about the rest, who do not have CD but buy gluten-free skin products in order to avoid rashes? In my estimation, they’re wasting their money if they’re paying a premium for such products. If they’re not paying a premium, than it’s how well the product works for them that matters, not whether it has gluten in it or not. Again, there are many compounds and substances in skin products that can cause allergic reactions or simply contact dermatitis in some people, particularly fragrances. Because of all the publicity about gluten, it’s not surprising that so many people, whether they have CD or not, are quick to assume that a rash after using a skin product is due to gluten in the product. Without careful patch testing, assuming a reaction is due to gluten in a skin product is a leap.
It’s become clear that, up until the last decade or so, CD was severely underdiagnosed in the US. To some extent, it still is, although increased awareness and better-defined diagnostic criteria have alleviated that problem. Unfortunately, it is also a condition that appears to be increasing in prevalence, both due to an apparent increase due to greater awareness and, thus, diagnosis and, likely, to an increase in the actual frequency, as evidenced by studies suggesting that the prevalence of seropositivity for the appropriate IgA antibody in the population. In general, increased awareness is a good thing, as it allows for the appropriate diagnosis and treatment of a greater fraction of people with CD. So is the increased availability of gluten-free options for the approximately 1% of the population with CD, which allows them to alter their diet without suffering as grievous a hit to their quality of life.
Unfortunately, the known deleterious health effects of gluten in people with CD have been extrapolated into a much vaguer, as-yet scientifically unvalidated, clinical entity that supposedly a much larger percentage of the population suffers from. This has led to the unjustified demonization of gluten (which is really only harmful in a small minority of the population), overblown claims for “going gluten-free,” and ridiculous products such as gluten-free skin care products, deodorants, and shampoos.

Ancient Origins of Modern Dietary Demons
Clay Jones on April 24, 2015
Link

There are few aspects of daily existence, particularly in modern society, that are more pervasive than advice on what we should eat. Everyone, including friends, family, strangers on Twitter and self-proclaimed experts in nutrition and health, seems to have an opinion on how to eat in order to improve and prolong our lives. Even legitimate organizations dedicated to the health and well-being of the population add to the cacophony of recommendations on diet.
Readers of Science-Based Medicine should be well aware of the current popularity of avoiding gluten, even absent the diagnosis of celiac disease or thoughtful evaluation for another related condition. Gluten, we are told by gurus and authors of books like Wheat Belly and Grain Brain, is the one true cause of a host of medical complaints, even autism. Avoid gluten at all costs, they say, and watch the pounds melt away or experience the clearing of your “brain fog.”
The resulting glut of glutenless products on the market may benefit the 1% of the population with celiac disease, or help to ease symptoms of the small percentage of people that may be intolerant, but it also helps to further solidify the beliefs of the millions of fad dieters. In the process, pocketbooks are emptied and unhealthy dietary restrictions are encouraged. And rogue gluten-free dieting may actually delay the diagnosis in actual celiac disease sufferers.
Other dietary concerns predate the current gluten-free trend, sometimes by many centuries, and have come to incorporate the language of science, the better to fool us with. Too much fat will kill us with cardiovascular disease. Excess salt will raise our blood pressure and lead to strokes. Added sugar is toxic and the root of our obesity and diabetes epidemics. These are the recommendations that are handed down, often with absolute certainty. They are the mantras that many of us live by without really knowing why.
In his book, The Gluten Lie: And Other Myths About What You Eat, Alan Levinovitz attempts to point out the elephant in the room. What if, as Levinovitz claims, there is a great deal more uncertainty than we are lead to believe? As a scholar of philosophy and religion, an expert in discovering and understanding the common threads that connect seemingly disparate beliefs, Levinovitz argues that many claims about the right way to eat are more religious in nature than scientific, even if the language used to promote a particular claim has evolved.
History is a wheel
Levinovitz first illustrates his overarching theme, that the history of demonizing certain foods is a wheel, with the story of MSG. Beginning in the late 1960s, the common flavoring agent quickly became targeted as a cause of migraine headaches as well as a number of additional symptoms, even severe neurological disease, based on a simple letter to the editor of the New England Journal of Medicine. Widespread public acceptance based on flimsy evidence led to public outrage and MSG became demonized to the point that “No MSG” was soon emblazoned on restaurant signs and menus all over the country. Public pressure even led to the removal of MSG from baby foods, further cementing its toxic status in the lay mind.
In the medical community, we now know that so-called “Chinese-Restaurant Syndrome” is a fiction. Unfortunately belief in the toxic effects of the chemical remain fairly widespread, even if they are dwarfed by the current gluten-free fad. And, as Levinovitz discusses in his book, the psychological pitfalls that resulted in MSG fears are the same.
Although the book is focused on dietary demons, it is the discussion of how our thinking goes wrong where Levinovitz truly shines. As I read the book, and the information revealed by numerous leading experts in the nutrition science, I certainly learned a great deal about the reality behind the science of food fears. But I learned even more about their history and scientific skepticism in general. Although not marketed as such, I found this book to be an excellent primer on critical thinking.
Why did people come to believe that MSG or gluten were the cause of their complaints? Levinovitz, with wit and the occasional laugh out loud snark, discusses the common pitfalls that readers of SBM should be familiar with. As humans, we are terrible at evaluating causal relationships. We are prey to a variety of placebo and nocebo affects. Our memories are highly unreliable. Confirmation bias and the avoidance of cognitive dissonance are powerful forces in all of our lives.
And once a self-diagnosis is made, we are amazingly resistant to questioning it, likely because of the societal stigma against a psychological origin for symptoms. Levinovitz convincingly argues that these same pitfalls are behind a great deal of the current gluten-free trend. He also discusses a variety of powerful archetypal myths that influence our individual food choices and likely bias our attempts at studying them in populations. The ability to deceive ourselves appears to know no limits as even well-meaning scientists without an apparent agenda are at risk.
Nutrition myths
To an author like Levinovitz, who has spent countless hours working to understand the meaning and significance behind the religious narratives passed down over time, dietary claims demonstrate an uncanny similarity. He even compares them to how flood myths have recurred in a variety of cultures. He attempts to understand them in a historical context, ultimately raising serious concerns about their veracity. He wonders if our acceptance of many of them are akin to reading flood myths like a weather report rather than as a metaphor for cleansing and divine punishment.
Think that “going paleo” represents a new approach to choosing what to eat? Think again. Probably the most important archetypal myth that influences our beliefs about food is that of the paradise past. Levinovitz traces the rejection of modern culture and technology back to a group of Daoist monks who rejected grains, believing them to be the one true cause of disease and death two thousand years ago. As Chinese culture changed, and grains became less of a symbol of their civilization, so did the focus of those rejecting modernity. In later generations, the Daoist monks turned their ire on meat and blood, serving as an example of how the rejection of the status quo in favor of the good old days, rather than a specific food, is truly at the core of many of our food fears.
Another archetypal food myth involves the assigning of moral and religious qualifiers to our food. We think of foods as “good” or “bad,” “sinful” or “natural.” These designations don’t actually mean anything however. Rather than science, their origins are often found in religion or in the random notion that if it tastes good it must be bad for you. And once established they perpetuate, becoming part of the underlying fabric of a culture. People come to express dogmatic acceptance without knowing exactly why. Processed food is evil…just because it is. Natural is better…because Adam and Eve didn’t have MS?
Sugar is the most blatant victim of the moralization of food. In addition to concerns regarding weight gain and associated medical problems, historically sugar has been blamed for everything from scurvy and “weak nerves” to ill-behaved children and even insatiable sexual desire. And despite all evidence and understanding of addiction, some anti-sugar proponents have even likened it to nicotine and cocaine, claiming that there is no safe level of consumption.
In the chapter on sugar, Levinovitz introduces two important concepts that have contributed to the belief that sugar is toxic. Monotonic thinking is common in the public. This occurs when we have a hard time accepting that something that is unsafe or unhealthy in large amounts can be fine, perhaps even healthy, in small amounts. A classic example would be red wine. Although the jury is still out on the benefits of moderate alcohol consumption, it is clearly the case that a glass a day is not equivalent in any way to being an alcoholic. The poison, after all, is in the dose.
The second concept is that of “white-hat bias.” This can occur when we investigate and interpret data involving claims that are seen as righteous. It serves to bias us against things we perceive as bad and for things seen as good or virtuous, exaggerating findings that fit into that world view.
In his chapter on the demonization of dietary fat, Levinovitz discusses the concept of “sympathetic magic.” One of the most primitive and widespread examples of magical thinking, sympathetic magic is the force behind, among numerous examples still prevalent today, the belief that ingesting tiger penis can impart virility in a man. Or that drinking beet juice might restore the blood. It also informs the archetypal food myth that you are what you eat.
If you eat animal fat, you will become fat. If you eat lean, you will be lean. At least that was the medical advice given by the Greek physician Galen to his patients almost two millennia ago. Not much seems to have changed since. We are still extremely biased against the consumption of fat such that we think a 47-calorie candy bar will cause more weight gain than an almost 600-calorie binge at an all-you-can-eat buffet of veggies and low-fat cheese. The low-fat label on products, for another example, gives them a so-called “health halo” that isn’t explained by the very unclear science on the subject.
Conclusion: A compelling destruction of food myths
This is a good book and I highly recommend it. In keeping with the tenets of science-based medicine, where prior plausibility and basic science are considered in the evaluation of causal claims, Levinovitz lays a compelling deconstruction of a variety of food myths. The fact that the beliefs at the root of why we fear gluten, fat, salt and sugar are centuries old does not disprove the current popular trends in their consumption. It doesn’t mean that all proponents of their proscription to varying degrees are hopelessly biased and making inappropriate recommendation. But the bar for acceptance must be set higher because of it.
Currently, as detailed in The Gluten Lie, the evidence regarding our diets is almost always less clear than we are led to believe. The study of nutrition is extremely challenging and the difficulty in designing and carrying out research that might more definitively answer these questions is understandable. But, as Levinovitz states, the problem isn’t really with the science. We know that science is a process that can take time to hone in on the right answer. The problem is with the overstatement of our understanding based on what we currently do know. An exaggeration, a half-truth, is still a lie.

Re-thinking Antioxidant Supplementation for Macular Degeneration
After the AREDS trial, people with moderate to severe age-related macular degeneration were advised to take dietary supplements to slow the progression of the disease. But some experts say the trial actually showed supplements don’t work, and might even make some patients worse.
Harriet Hall on February 7, 2017
Link

Age-related macular degeneration (AMD) is a leading cause of blindness. Known risk factors include smoking, obesity, hypertension, high intake of vegetable fat, and low dietary intake of antioxidants and zinc. The AREDS (Age-Related Eye Disease Study) trial was designed to test whether supplementation with an antioxidant formula could slow the progression of the disease. In 2001 the results of the trial were published in the Archives of Ophthalmology. They found that a mixture of vitamin C, vitamin E, beta-carotene, zinc, and copper significantly slowed the progression of disease in patients with moderate to severe age-related macular degeneration. It was a large multicenter double-blind study.
There was concern about possible harm from certain ingredients in the original formulation (beta-carotene was associated with lung cancer in smokers, and zinc in high doses was known to cause adverse effects), so a subsequent study, AREDS2, was done. It tested the effects of various changes in the formulation: removing beta-carotene, reducing the amount of zinc, and adding lutein/zeaxanthin or omega-3 fatty acids. The results, published in 2013, found that there was no additional benefit from the changes.
I wrote about AREDS in 2010, with an update on AREDS2 in 2014. I was skeptical then, and I am even more skeptical now that more information has come to light about the trials.
The response
Most clinicians accepted the results of AREDS and recommended that patients with moderate to advanced AMD take a supplement mixture. There was no evidence that patients with mild AMD would benefit, and there was no suggestion that supplements could prevent the disease from developing in the first place. Not everyone followed the actual evidence. Eye vitamin preparations were taken by people who had no evidence-based justification for taking them. And many of the eye vitamins on the market were different from the AREDS mixtures.
A Cochrane review considered the strength of the evidence to be “moderate,” concluding:
People with AMD may experience delay in progression of the disease with antioxidant vitamin and mineral supplementation. This finding is drawn from one large trial conducted in a relatively well-nourished American population. The generalisability of these findings to other populations is not known. Although generally regarded as safe, vitamin supplements may have harmful effects.
Was the AREDS trial actually negative?
Dr. Daniel Seigel accused the AREDS investigators of distorting their findings. He said they promoted a nonsignificant result into a conclusive recommendation. The original study design called for 4 tests, none of which was statistically significant. “One, testing the effect of zinc on progression to advanced AMD, achieved a level of significance defined by the investigators as suggestive.” Essentially, the results were negative. They then restricted their analysis to a sub-group and “featured a combined treatment group which in secondary analysis broke the boundary of statistical significance, thereby disregarding the primary analysis in which neither treatment was significant.” They then made a conclusive recommendation based on these inconclusive findings. Dr. Seigel points out that a negative result would have been more in line with the majority of other studies in which antioxidant supplements have failed to prevent diseases.
In a letter to the editor in the Archives of Ophthalmology, Ambati and Ambati cautioned against “misplaced enthusiasm.” They said the benefit of these supplements is questionable, some of the ingredients may be harmful, and the study’s methodology is flawed. The researchers failed to correct for post hoc analysis. When the proper corrections are made, “The effect of the combination treatment on loss of visual acuity, the only endpoint that truly matters to patients…is even less compelling at a similarly corrected P=.24.”
Another professor of ophthalmology, Cynthia J. Mackay, published a devastating critique on her website She claims that the study results were actually negative, that the researchers went back and changed the research design after the study was completed, that they arbitrarily threw out all patients with mild AMD from the study, and the definition of “success” was changed from “preventing vision loss and progression” to “preventing AMD events.” She said:
The only people who supposedly “benefitted” from this drug are people who have intermediate AMD in one eye, and advanced AMD in the other. No other type of patients had any benefit. Even if a doctor accepts the results of this study, he should only recommend this drug to this small subgroup of patients.
She also pointed out that there were conflicts of interest, that there was no rationale for choosing the particular ingredients in AREDS, that all the ingredients were known to cause serious problems, and that the doses are far above recommended amounts.
The manipulation of the data amounts to what Norbert Kerr, writing in Personality and Social Psychology Review, called “HARKing: Hypothesizing After the Results are Known.”
Conflicts of interest
The AREDS study was funded in part by Bausch + Lomb, and many of the investigators had ties to the company. One of the AREDS study authors, Dr. Ferris, holds a patent for the AREDS formulation with Bausch + Lomb and earns royalties, and he did disclose this conflict of interest in a few published papers; yet in many of the papers he co-authored reporting AREDS data, he neglected to report it. Out of 48 AREDS reports, only 8 include any mention of conflicts of interest. While this doesn’t necessarily mean the studies are biased, a conflict of interest statement is standard practice, and one can only wonder why it was selectively omitted from most of these reports. One article explains that Dr. Ferris invented the patent, but it is owned by Bausch + Lomb, and he has assigned his interest in the patent to the United States Government and received government compensation. A Freedom of Information request disclosed that Dr. Ferris has personally earned $1.8 million from the Bausch + Lomb patent. Such payments to federal employees are allowed under a U.S. law designed to encourage transfer of technology from government to industry. Isn’t $1.8 million worth mentioning in a financial disclosure? An article on Medscape criticized this and similar conflicts of interest.
Do genotypes matter?
Emerging evidence suggests that the response to antioxidants varies with the patient’s genotype.
In the original AREDS study, only patients who had category 2 through 4 disease (minimal, intermediate, and advanced) were enrolled in the trial. Category 1 patients who were thought to be at low risk of AMD were enrolled in a separate study to evaluate the effect of antioxidant supplements on cataract progression. In a Jan 26, 2017 article in the Journal of Vitreoretinal Diseases, 3 doctors (Awh, Zanke, and Kustra) re-analyzed data from that trial and genotyped the subjects.
Here’s what they concluded:
On average, antioxidant treatment has no impact on the development of intermediate AMD in patients without AMD. However, antioxidant treatment may increase the risk of developing intermediate AMD in patients with low genetic risk and may reduce the risk of developing intermediate AMD in patients with high genetic risk.
This would seem to support the idea of selectively prescribing eye vitamins for patients without AMD based on genetic testing, but the authors cautioned:
Pending validation studies, physicians, and patients should be mindful of the unproven benefit, and the potential risk, of antioxidant supplementation for most patients without AMD.
It should be noted that two of the authors disclosed a conflict of interest: they both own shares in a company that markets genetic tests for AMD.
Should prescription be guided by genotype?
It’s probably too early to say. The American Academy of Ophthalmology does not support the routine use of genetic testing, citing bias in the data analysis. The validity of the genotype studies was questioned in an editorial in Ophthalmology .
Deceptive marketing
A 2015 study examined 11 of the top-selling ocular nutritional supplements in the US and found that the majority of products were not identical to the formulations tested in the AREDS or AREDS2 trials. Only 4 out of the 11 contained equivalent dosages. They found evidence of misleading marketing. All the individual supplements claimed to “support,” “protect,” “help,” or “promote” vision and eye health, but none specified that there is no proven benefit in using nutritional supplements for primary prevention of eye disease.
Inappropriate use
In an abstract presented at the ARVO Annual Meeting in September 2016, Ellingson and Ambati reported that 73.5% of patients taking eye vitamins did not meet AREDS criteria, and only 29.6% of those taking eye vitamins were taking a preparation identical to the AREDS formulation. They calculated an adjusted NNT (number needed to treat) of 220, and they calculated the direct cost of inappropriate vitamin use as between $218,000 and $657,000 per quality adjusted life year. They also noted that 86% of patients who were active smokers were unaware that beta-carotene might increase their risk of lung cancer.
Standard of care?
Many ophthalmologists, and the manufacturers of eye vitamins, would have us believe the standard of care is to recommend AREDS formulas for patients with moderate to severe AMD. In my opinion, there is good reason to question that recommendation. The evidence is from a single flawed study.
The AAO Preferred Practice Pattern Guidelines say supplements “should be considered,” rather than employed routinely. They rate it as “discretionary,” a category they use when there is low-quality evidence or when the evidence suggests that desirable and undesirable effects are closely balanced. The Veterans Administration noted the poor-quality analysis, pointing out that the 6% absolute risk reduction comes from a post-hoc analysis.
Conclusion: Questions remain
With all the questions that have been raised about the evidence, and the fact that it hinges on a single study, I don’t think we can strongly recommend AREDS-type supplements for anyone. Patients who meet the AREDS study criteria can be offered the supplements with acknowledgement of the uncertainty, and they can work with their ophthalmologists to arrive at a shared informed decision. Patients who do not meet the AREDS criteria should not take the supplements, and there is no justification for taking supplements that do not match the AREDS formulations. There is an intriguing possibility that genetic analysis might identify some patients without AMD who could prevent or delay the development of the disease by taking an AREDS-type formula, but it’s too early to base clinical recommendations on that yet.

Everything you always wanted to know about fermented foods
Are fermented foods the best thing since…bread?
Lucy Shewell on October 30, 2015
Link


Fermented foods, such as sauerkraut and kombucha, have become popular for health reasons. I have made my own sauerkraut in the past and have recently made the tasty, fermented Korean side dish, kimchi. I did it not only for the taste but also for the hope that the bacteria responsible for the fermentation of the cabbage — lactic acid bacteria (LAB) — would contribute to the diversity of my gut microbiota.
As a research scientist in the field of bacterial pathogenesis, this made sense to me. Now that I have started blogging about health and fitness and have been writing more in depth articles about health related topics, I started wondering what research has been done on the health benefits of fermented foods. Can the bacteria in fermented foods even survive the harsh conditions of the human gastrointestinal (GI) tract, particularly the stomach?
I was amazed to learn that the fermentation of food has been used by humans for thousands of years as a way to preserve foods, and that the health benefits go beyond their microorganisms (don’t worry, citations are provided below). The fermentation process enhances the nutritional quality of food by contributing beneficial compounds such as vitamins, and by increasing the bioavailability of minerals. Probiotics, including those found in kimchi, have a range of positive effects on health, including the improvement of various intestinal inflammatory conditions, positive impacts on the immune system and even weight loss, and can alter the composition of the gut microbiome.
However, these effects mostly depend on whether the bacteria actually make it in sufficient numbers to the colon. And let me tell you, the journey to the colon is one harsh and dangerous ride!
What are fermented foods?
Fermentation is a mostly anaerobic process, meaning without oxygen, carried out by microorganisms or cells. These microorganisms convert sugars, such as glucose, into other compounds, such as alcohol, to produce energy to fuel their metabolism. Bacteria and yeasts — which undergo lactic acid fermentation and ethanol fermentation, respectively — are used in the fermentation of foods. The unique flavours and textures of fermented foods are due to the different species of bacteria and yeast used.
Humans have fermented foods for thousands of years throughout the world, and many dishes are unique to specific ethnic groups.1 Not only does the fermentation of foods add flavour and texture, but fermentation can also improve its shelf-life and may have been initially used to preserve fruits and vegetables during times of scarcity.2 The fermentation of food can occur spontaneously by the natural LAB surface microflora or by the use of a starter culture.3
Types of fermented foods
Fermented dairy
Lactic acid bacteria are the main bacteria in the production of fermented dairy products, such as yoghurt, cheese and kefir milk. They make lactic acid from lactose, the main sugar in milk. This increases acidity and makes life difficult for other microorganisms. The most common LAB involved in the fermentation of dairy are members of the genera Lactobacillus, Streptococcus, Leuonostoc, Enterococcus, and Lactococcus. Bifidobacteria are also included in fermented milk products.4 Most yoghurt, the fermented dairy product people know best, is produced with a culture of L. delbrueckii subp. bulgaricus and S. thermophiles.5
During the fermentation of dairy, many beneficial compounds are produced or increased by the metabolic activity of LAB, propionibacteria, yeast and mould, such as vitamin B-12, folic acid and biotin.6 Conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), a fatty acid with reported health benefits including fat loss, is also increased in fermented milk7 (I have previously blogged about CLA and found the mechanism by which it causes fat loss somewhat concerning, as it may damage surrounding cells, increase fatty deposits in the liver, and make blood lipids more prone to atherosclerosis aka hardening of the arteries.) Bioactive peptides with reported antihypertensive, antimicrobial, antioxidative, and immune-modulatory activities are also released by the activity of LAB in fermented milk products.8
Another potentially beneficial compound in fermented dairy is the non-digestible carbohydrate galacto-oligosaccharide, which is synthesized by LAB from lactose. Galacto-oligosaccharide has a prebiotic effect on intestinal microbiota, meaning it probably promotes the growth of beneficial bacteria in the gut.9
In addition, yoghurt in particular is a rich source of dietary minerals, including calcium, magnesium, potassium, phosphorus, and zinc.10 The concentration of these minerals is nearly 50% higher in yoghurt than in milk,11 and they are easier to digest and absorb: the acidic environment created by fermentation with LAB can enhance the bioavailability of these minerals.
And there’s more: yoghurt is also an excellent source of essential amino acids. The amount of free amino acids is increased due to the pre-digestion of milk proteins by the activity of bacterial cultures, allowing for better protein digestibility.12
Large cohort studies conducted in the Netherlands, Sweden, and Denmark found that fermented milk products were significantly associated with decreased disease states. These disease states include bladder cancer, cardiovascular disease, and periondontitis.13-15 Based on these findings, I am going to enjoy my Greek yoghurt for breakfast even more now!
Although harmful compounds, including mycotoxins and biogenic amines, can contaminate fermented dairy products, strict regulatory standards are set by international agencies for the monitoring of these substances. Fortunately, reliable methods to detect these compounds have been developed.16-19
Fermented vegetables
The fermentation by LAB is recognized as a simple and valuable method to maintain and enhance the safety, nutritional quality, and the shelf life of vegetables, particularly when access to fresh vegetables is limited. The most commercially significant fermented vegetables are:
    • Cabbage, in the form of sauerkraut and kimchi
    • Cucumbers, in the form of pickles
    • Olives
If you’d like to try making your own fermented veggies, here are some good recipies for kimchi and sauerkraut.
Typically the fermentation of vegetables occurs spontaneously just from the bacteria already present on the surface, but starter cultures can also be used. Starter cultures speed up the fermentation process, ensure reliability of the final product, prevent the risk of fermentation failure, and assist with the inhibition of spoilage and pathogenic microorganisms.20
Lactic fermentation has been shown to enhance the nutritional value of vegetables. When used with maize, soybeans, and sorghum (a grain), it reduces phytate content, a well-known inhibitor of iron and zinc absorption.21 It has also been shown that fermentation of maize enhances the bioavailability of iron.22 A 2015 study published in the European Journal of Nutrition found that the reason for the increased bioavailability of iron in lactic-fermented vegetables compared to fresh vegetables is due to an increase in the concentration of hydrated ferric iron (Fe3+) which may be more favourable for iron absorption.23
It is clear to me that the fermentation process boosts the nutritional quality of foods. Now, what about the impact of the actual bacteria carrying out the fermentation?
The impact of fermented foods and probiotics on the microbiome
Understanding of the importance of the human gut microbiota and microbiome to health and disease has expanded rapidly with the advances in DNA sequencing technology. (The gut microbiota is the microorganisms that inhabit the gut, while the gut microbiome is the total genome content of the gut microbiota.) Research in this field has focused on what role this complex bacterial community plays in human health and disease, and how it can be altered.
Diet is one of the main influences on the human gut microbiota.24, 25 Many food-ingested bacteria can temporarily join the gut microbiota, possibly affecting the behaviour of the resident gut microbial community. These food-ingested bacteria can be found in great numbers in fermented foods and as probiotics. Probiotics are defined as live microorganisms in food that confer a health benefit on the host.26 Here on SBM, Scott Gavura concluded, “There’s reasonably good evidence that probiotics, when taken with antibiotics, will reduce the risk of antibiotic-associated diarrhea.” In her review of Martin Blaser’s Missing Microbes, Dr. Harriet Hall wrote, “This is exciting stuff! I wish I could be alive 100 years from now to see how research into the microbiome will change the practice of medicine.”
The bacteria in fermented foods are considered probiotics.
Recent research suggests that the human gut microbiome is made up of a core population of bacteria and a variable commensal community, and it seems that bacteria ingested via food contribute to this “variable microbiome”.27 As I have already mentioned, LAB are the most widely-used strains to ferment foods. While some LAB species are thought to be permanent inhabitants of the gastrointestinal (GI) tract, other species, such as L. plantarum, L. rhamonosus, and L. paracasei appear to be temporary colonizers.28 Some species of bifidobacteria, which are found in fermented dairy, are also typical members of the transient microbiota.29
A recent study in Scientific Reports directly compared the impact of fermented and non-fermented milk products on the gut microbiome of subjects with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS). The fermented milk product altered the species of the gut microbiota more than the non-fermented milk product. Additionally, consumption of the fermented milk product decreased the “pathobionts” Bilophila wadsworthia and Clostridium sp. HGF2.30 Pathobionts is a new term describing members of the resident microbiota that have disease-causing potential.31
Bacteria derived from food appear to be members of the variable human microbiome with the ability to alter the gut microbiome. But do the bacteria we ingest in common fermented foods, such as yoghurt (and my new favourite fermented food, kimchi) actually survive once we eat them? In other words, are common fermented foods a direct source of bacteria that contribute to our microbiome?
Can bacteria from fermented foods survive the human GI tract?
Before ingested bacteria can have a beneficial impact in the human intestinal system, they must first be able to survive within the food matrix, the nutrient and non-nutrient components of food plus their interactions at a molecular level. Many factors can affect probiotic viability in the food matrix, such as the acidity, oxygen availability, concentration of sugars, moisture content, and the storage temperature.32
Immediately after swallowing, these poor little microbes must be able to withstand the hostile environment of the human upper GI tract, which includes the mouth, esophagus, stomach, and duodenum (the first part of the small intestine). After being chewed and mixed with enzymes from saliva in the mouth, the bacteria from fermented foods then pass down the throat and esophagus and into the stomach. The stomach is an extremely acidic environment (pH <3) and contains destructive digestive enzymes, such as pepsin, which break down proteins into smaller amino acid building blocks. Most ingested bacteria will not survive this first part of the journey.
Those bacteria that do survive then enter the remainder of the small intestine, where the pH rises to over 6, but they are exposed to bile and many more digestive enzymes, including amylase (which breaks starches into simple sugars), lipase (which breaks down fats), and protease (which further breaks down proteins). Some bacterial strains can recover, and even grow in the small intestine, and these cells must then continue their journey on to the colon.33 Not only must these ingested bacteria be able to survive the human GI tract, they must also be able to adhere to the gut epithelial cells in order to have any beneficial effects.34, 35
Variation in the ability of probiotic strains to survive the human GI tract has been demonstrated. Studies subjecting various strains to conditions simulating the environment of the human GI tract found that strains of B. animalis, L. casei, L. rhamnosus and L. plantarum have the greatest resilience.33, 36-38
Since many of us are familiar with yoghurt as a fermented food, I wanted to know if the bacteria within commercial yoghurts actually survive this treacherous journey. A study of 15 healthy adult volunteers looked at the effect on the fecal bacterial community of probiotic LAB in commercial yoghurt.39 The subjects were divided into three groups: one group consuming 110 grams of yoghurt A, one group consuming 180ml of yoghurt B, and the third group consuming 90 grams of yoghurt C. Everyone ate one serving per day for 20 days. The labels of yoghurt A and B stated that these products contain a probiotic Lactobacillus strain, while yoghurt C did not state this on the label.
The probiotic strains were detected in the feces of subjects consuming yoghurt A and B for up to 28 days after the first day of consumption. This showed that probiotic strains in yoghurt survive the human GI tract. The study also detected changes in the populations of bacterial groups in the fecal microbiota in all three groups.
Another similar study of 36 subjects looked at the persistence of four probiotic strains from capsules, yoghurts, or cheese at a dose of 1.9–5.0 × 109 colony-forming units (CFUs). They found that all four probiotic strains survived the GI tract and could be detected in fecal samples following consumption in all subjects. Two strains endured better, with the highest quantities recovered in the fecal samples from the yoghurt group,40 so it does seem that probiotics present in yoghurt can survive the human GI tract provided that the bacteria are present in high enough numbers in the yoghurt to begin with.
How about the LAB in kimchi? One study found that L. plantarum KC21 isolated from kimchi showed acid and bile tolerance and the ability to adhere to human intestinal cells.41 Another found that subjects who consumed 300g/day of kimchi had significantly higher counts of fecal Lactobacillus species and Leuconostoc species during the kimchi intake period.42 As with the yoghurt, these results suggest that LAB will survive in your gut if it’s present in sufficient numbers in your kimchi in the first place.
Now let’s look at the clinical studies investigating the health benefits.
Clinical studies on the health benefits of probiotics and fermented foods
Many clinical studies have investigated the effect of probiotics on human health. The reported beneficial effects of probiotic consumption include improvement of constipation, diarrhea, and intestinal inflammatory conditions (such as Crohn’s disease, ulcerative colitis, irritable bowel syndrome, and necrotizing enterocolitis),43 and the prevention of allergic disease in infants.44, 45 Furthermore, supplementation with probiotics has been shown to positively enhance immune system function,46-48 improve the symptoms of lactose intolerance, and can prevent infection with pathogenic or disease causing microorganisms.49 One promising study recently published in The Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology showed possible alleviation of peanut allergy in children by coadministering probiotics with a peanut oral immunotherapy. Previous studies found that administration of probiotics or peanut oral immunotherapy alone did not have this effect.80
The mechanisms by which probiotics exert these influences are not yet clear. The cells lining the intestine, the intestinal epithelial cells, are an important part of the innate or non-specific immune system and act as a link to the adaptive or specific immune system. The intestinal epithelial cells are able to recognize many bacterial components and are the first point of contact for ingested microbes.50, 51 The latest research suggests several mechanisms by which probiotic microbiota may produce health effects:
    • outcompeting bacterial pathogens
    • preventing attachment of pathogens to host cells52-54
    • strengthening the mucosal barrier55
    • release of immune-cell-stimulating and anti-inflammatory molecules (cytokines)56, 57
    • the production of antimicrobial substances, including organic acids, hydrogen peroxide, and bacteriocins (small strings of amino acids that inhibit the growth of other bacteria)58, 59
Probiotics can be in food or supplements, such as pills and capsules. In 2009 the global probiotic supplement market was worth about $1.5 billion USD60 and predicted to rise to $32.6 billion by 2014.61 The probiotic industry holds about a 10% share of the global functional food market.62
How many microorganisms do you have to eat to get a benefit?
Dosages of probiotics are measured in CFUs per serving: the number of cells able to grow from a single serving (food or capsule) in a petri dish. There seems to be agreement in the literature that, for health benefits to be achieved, a dosage of 108–109 CFUs is needed.63-65 That’s one hundred million to one billion per serving. Bacteria are small!
A 2013 study published in the Journal of Applied Microbiology found between 107 and 108 CFU/ml of Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus within a commercial brand of yoghurt (Activia® from Danone) — and most people probably eat more than a fifth of a teaspoon of yoghurt at a time.66 Other studies have also found that commercial yoghurts do contain enough Lactobacillus to confer potential health benefits.67
Does kimchi have health benefits too?
Let’s zoom in on kimchi. I am a big fan of this tasty fermented side dish, and have started getting into making it at home. After looking at the studies, I am even more enthusiastic!
Kimchi has been eaten in Korea for about 2,000 years. The most popular kimchi is baechu or Chinese cabbage kimchi, which is generally made by LAB fermentation of baechu cabbage, radish, green onion, red pepper powder, garlic, ginger and fermented seafoods.68 Most kimchi contains 107 – 109 CFUs/gram of LAB. The profile of LAB species in kimchi changes with the pH throughout the fermentation process. Leuconostoc mesenteroides is present during the early stages (pH 5.64–4.27) while Lactobacillus sakei dominates in the later stages of (pH 4.15).69 Other LAB contributing to kimchi fermentation include Leu. citreum, Leu. gasicomitatum, L. brevis, L. curvatus, L. plantarum, Lactococcus lactis, Pediociccus pentosaceus, Weissella confusa and W. koreensis.70, 71
Studies investigating the potential beneficial effects of the bacteria isolated from kimchi have found the following:
    • One of the LAB strains isolated from kimchi was found to have potent antioxidative activity in vitro.72
    • L. plantarum from kimchi has shown various immune-modulatory activities, such as the activation and stimulation of cytokine production in mouse macrophages,73, 74 and a variety of other immune-modulating activities.75, 76
    • LAB from kimchi was found to have antiobesity effects in rats77, 78 and mice.78
    • LAB isolated from kimchi has shown antimicrobial activities against a range of pathogenic bacteria.41, 79
So it appears that kimchi is more than just a delicious addition to my bibimbap.
Conclusion: Fermented foods probably deserve their healthful reputation
The bacteria in fermented dairy and vegetables can survive their perilous journey through the digestive tract. Once they are there, it’s clear that they have at least some positive effects on human health, ranging from the enhanced nutritional contents of the foods themselves, to alleviation of inflammatory bowel conditions, to restoring normal gut microbiota after antibiotics, to enhancement of the immune system, and possibly even weight loss. It would be nice to know more about the mechanisms of these effects — and maybe we will know soon, because it is currently a hot area of research. I will continue to enjoy fermented foods not only for their delicious tastes and textures, but also for the health benefits. Have some fun and have a go at making your own kimchi. It is absolutely worth the effort.
References
     1.  Farnworth ER (2008). Handbook of Fermented Functional Foods (CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, USA). ISBN 9781420053265
     2.  Rolle R & Satin M (2002). Basic requirements for the transfer of fermentation technologies to developing countries. International Journal of Food Microbiology 75(3):181-187. PMID 12036141
     3.  J. Karovičová, Milan Drdák, Gabriel Greif, & Hybenová E (1999). The choice of strains of Lactobacillus species for the lactic acid fermentation of vegetable juices. European Food Research and Technology 210(1):53-56. DOI: 10.1007/s002170050532
     4.  Quigley L, et al. (2011). Molecular approaches to analysing the microbial composition of raw milk and raw milk cheese. International Journal of Food Microbiology 150(2-3):81-94. PMID 21868118
     5.  Donovan SM & Shamir R (2014). Introduction to the yogurt in nutrition initiative and the First Global Summit on the health effects of yogurt. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 99(5 Suppl):1209S-1211S. PMID 24646825
     6.  Beermann C & Hartung J (2013). Physiological properties of milk ingredients released by fermentation. Food & Function 4(2):185-199. PMID 23111492
     7.  Hennessy AA, et al. (2012). The production of conjugated alpha-linolenic, gamma-linolenic and stearidonic acids by strains of bifidobacteria and propionibacteria. Lipids 47(3):313-327. PMID 22160449
     8.  Parvez S, Malik KA, Ah Kang S, & Kim HY (2006). Probiotics and their fermented food products are beneficial for health. Journal of Applied Microbiology 100(6):1171-1185. PMID 16696665
     9.  Padilla B, et al. (2012). Evaluation of oligosaccharide synthesis from lactose and lactulose using beta-galactosidases from Kluyveromyces isolated from artisanal cheeses. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 60(20):5134-5141. PMID 22559148
     10.  USDA ARS (2013). USDA national nutrient database for standard reference, release 26. Nutrient Data Laboratory homepage.
     11.  Wang H, Livingston KA, Fox CS, Meigs JB, & Jacques PF (2013). Yogurt consumption is associated with better diet quality and metabolic profile in American men and women. Nutrition Research 33(1):18-26. PMID 23351406
     12.  Adolfsson O, Meydani SN, & Russel RM (2004). Yogurt and gut function. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 80:245-256. PMID 15277142
     13.  Keszei AP, Schouten LJ, Goldbohm RA, & van den Brandt PA (2010). Dairy intake and the risk of bladder cancer in the Netherlands Cohort Study on Diet and Cancer. American Journal of Epidemiology 171(4):436-446. PMID 20042437
     14.  Sonestedt E, et al. (2011). Dairy products and its association with incidence of cardiovascular disease: the Malmo diet and cancer cohort. European journal of epidemiology 26(8):609-618. PMID 21660519
     15.  Adegboye AR, et al. (2012). Intake of dairy products in relation to periodontitis in older Danish adults. Nutrients 4(9):1219-1229. PMID 23112910
     16.  Siddappa V, Nanjegowda DK, & Viswanath P (2012). Occurrence of aflatoxin M(1) in some samples of UHT, raw & pasteurized milk from Indian states of Karnataka and Tamilnadu. Food and Chemical Toxicology 50(11):4158-4162. PMID 22939935
     17.  Prandini A, et al. (2009). On the occurrence of aflatoxin M1 in milk and dairy products. Food and Chemical Toxicology 47(5):984-991. PMID 18037552
     18.  Linares DM, Martin MC, Ladero V, Alvarez MA, & Fernandez M (2011). Biogenic amines in dairy products. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition 51(7):691-703. PMID 21793728
     19.  Redruello B, et al. (2013). A fast, reliable, ultra high performance liquid chromatography method for the simultaneous determination of amino acids, biogenic amines and ammonium ions in cheese, using diethyl ethoxymethylenemalonate as a derivatising agent. Food Chemistry 139(1-4):1029-1035. PMID 23561206
     20.  Buckenhuskes HJ (1997). Fermented vegetables. Food Microbiology: Fundamentals and Frontiers, eds Doyle PD, Beuchat LR, & Montville TJ (ASM Press, Washington, DC), 2nd Ed, pp 595-609. ISBN 9781555811174
     21.  Bering S, et al. (2006). A lactic acid-fermented oat gruel increases non-haem iron absorption from a phytate-rich meal in healthy women of childbearing age. The British Journal of Nutrition 96(1):80-85. PMID 16869994
     22.  Proulx AK & Reddy MB (2007). Fermentation and lactic acid addition enhance iron bioavailability of maize. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 55(7):2749-2754. PMID 17355139
     23.  Scheers N, Rossander-Hulthen L, Torsdottir I, & Sandberg AS (2015). Increased iron bioavailability from lactic-fermented vegetables is likely an effect of promoting the formation of ferric iron (Fe). European Journal of Nutrition. PMID 25672527
     24.  Flint HJ (2012). The impact of nutrition on the human microbiome. Nutrition Reviews 70 Suppl 1:S10-13. PMID 22861801
     25.  Scott KP, Gratz SW, Sheridan PO, Flint HJ, & Duncan SH (2013). The influence of diet on the gut microbiota. Pharmacological Research: The Official Journal of the Italian Pharmacological Society 69(1):52-60. PMID 23147033
     26.  FAO/WHO (2001). Report on Joint FAO/WHO Expert Consultation on Evaluation of Health and Nutritional Properties of Probiotics in Food Including Powder Milk with Live Lactic Acid Bacteria.
     27.  Jalanka-Tuovinen J, et al. (2011). Intestinal microbiota in healthy adults: temporal analysis reveals individual and common core and relation to intestinal symptoms. PloS One 6(7):e23035. PMID 21829582
     28.  Reuter G (2001). The Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium microflora of the human intestine: composition and succession. Current Issues in Intestinal Microbiology 2(2):43-53. PMID 11721280
     29.  Turroni F, et al. (2014). Molecular dialogue between the human gut microbiota and the host: a Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium perspective. Cellular and Molecular Life Sciences: CMLS 71(2):183-203. PMID 23516017
     30.  Veiga P, et al. (2014). Changes of the human gut microbiome induced by a fermented milk product. Scientific Reports 4:6328. PMID 25209713
     31.  Round JL & Mazmanian SK (2009). The gut microbiota shapes intestinal immune responses during health and disease. Nature Reviews. Immunology 9(5):313-323. PMID 19343057
     32.  Champagne CP, Ross RP, Saarela M, Hansen KF, & Charalampopoulos D (2011). Recommendations for the viability assessment of probiotics as concentrated cultures and in food matrices. International Journal of Food Microbiology 149(3):185-193. PMID 21803436
     33.  Derrien M & van Hylckama Vlieg JE (2015). Fate, activity, and impact of ingested bacteria within the human gut microbiota. Trends in Microbiology 23(6):354-366. PMID 25840765
     34.  Lee YK, et al. (2000). Quantitative approach in the study of adhesion of lactic acid bacteria to intestinal cells and their competition with enterobacteria. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 66(9):3692-3697. PMID 10966378
     35.  Ouwehand AC, Tuomola EM, Lee YK, & Salminen S (2001). Microbial interactions to intestinal mucosal models. Methods in Enzymology 337:200-212. PMID 11398429
     36.  van Bokhorst-van de Veen H, et al. (2012). Modulation of Lactobacillus plantarum gastrointestinal robustness by fermentation conditions enables identification of bacterial robustness markers. PloS One 7(7):e39053. PMID 22802934
     37.  Marteau P, Minekus M, Havenaar R, & Huis in’t Veld JH (1997). Survival of lactic acid bacteria in a dynamic model of the stomach and small intestine: validation and the effects of bile. Journal of Dairy Science 80(6):1031-1037. PMID 9201571
     38.  van Bokhorst-van de Veen H, van Swam I, Wels M, Bron PA, & Kleerebezem M (2012). Congruent strain specific intestinal persistence of Lactobacillus plantarum in an intestine-mimicking in vitro system and in human volunteers. PloS One 7(9):e44588. PMID 22970257
     39.  Uyeno Y, Sekiguchi Y, & Kamagata Y (2008). Impact of consumption of probiotic lactobacilli-containing yogurt on microbial composition in human feces. International Journal of Food Microbiology 122(1-2):16-22. PMID 18077045
     40.  Saxelin M, et al. (2010). Persistence of probiotic strains in the gastrointestinal tract when administered as capsules, yoghurt, or cheese. International Journal of Food Microbiology 144(2):293-300. PMID 21074284
     41.  Lim SM & Im DS (2009). Screening and characterization of probiotic lactic acid bacteria isolated from Korean fermented foods. Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology 19(2):178-186. PMID 19307768
     42.  Lee KE, Choi UH, & Ji GE (1996). Effect of kimchi in intake on the composition of human large intestinal bacteria. Korean J Food Sci Technol 28:981-986. Abstract
     43.  Vitetta L, Briskey D, Alford H, Hall S, & Coulson S (2014). Probiotics, prebiotics and the gastrointestinal tract in health and disease. Inflammopharmacology 22(3):135-154. PMID 24633989
     44.  Kirjavainen PV, Arvola T, Salminen SJ, & Isolauri E (2002). Aberrant composition of gut microbiota of allergic infants: a target of bifidobacterial therapy at weaning? Gut 51(1):51-55. PMID 12077091
     45.  Hattori K, et al. (2003). [Effects of administration of bifidobacteria on fecal microflora and clinical symptoms in infants with atopic dermatitis]. Arerugi = [Allergy] 52(1):20-30. PMID 12598719
     46.  Isolauri E, Arvola T, Sutas Y, Moilanen E, & Salminen S (2000). Probiotics in the management of atopic eczema. Clinical and Experimental Allergy: Journal of the British Society for Allergy and Clinical Immunology 30(11):1604-1610. PMID 11069570
     47.  Neish AS, et al. (2000). Prokaryotic regulation of epithelial responses by inhibition of IkappaB-alpha ubiquitination. Science 289(5484):1560-1563. PMID 10968793
     48.  Schiffrin EJ, Brassart D, Servin AL, Rochat F, & Donnet-Hughes A (1997). Immune modulation of blood leukocytes in humans by lactic acid bacteria: criteria for strain selection. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 66(2):515S-520S. PMID 9250141
     49.  Lee YK & Puong KY (2002). Competition for adhesion between probiotics and human gastrointestinal pathogens in the presence of carbohydrate. The British Journal of Nutrition 88 Suppl 1:S101-108. PMID 12215184
     50.  Creagh EM & O’Neill LA (2006). TLRs, NLRs and RLRs: a trinity of pathogen sensors that co-operate in innate immunity. Trends in Immunology 27(8):352-357. PMID 16807108
     51.  Hughes DT & Sperandio V (2008). Inter-kingdom signalling: communication between bacteria and their hosts. Nature Reviews. Microbiology 6(2):111-120. PMID 18197168
     52.  Botic T, Klingberg TD, Weingartl H, & Cencic A (2007). A novel eukaryotic cell culture model to study antiviral activity of potential probiotic bacteria. International Journal of Food Microbiology 115(2):227-234. PMID 17261339
     53.  Juntunen M, Kirjavainen PV, Ouwehand AC, Salminen SJ, & Isolauri E (2001). Adherence of probiotic bacteria to human intestinal mucus in healthy infants and during rotavirus infection. Clinical and Diagnostic Laboratory Immunology 8(2):293-296. PMID 11238211
     54.  Resta-Lenert S & Barrett KE (2003). Live probiotics protect intestinal epithelial cells from the effects of infection with enteroinvasive Escherichia coli (EIEC). Gut 52(7):988-997. PMID 12801956
     55.  Banasaz M, Norin E, Holma R, & Midtvedt T (2002). Increased enterocyte production in gnotobiotic rats mono-associated with Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 68(6):3031-3034. PMID 12039764
     56.  Deplancke B & Gaskins HR (2001). Microbial modulation of innate defense: goblet cells and the intestinal mucus layer. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 73(6):1131S-1141S. PMID 11393191
     57.  Otte JM & Podolsky DK (2004). Functional modulation of enterocytes by gram-positive and gram-negative microorganisms. American Journal of Physiology. Gastrointestinal and Liver Physiology 286(4):G613-626. PMID 15010363
     58.  O’Shea EF, et al. (2009). Characterization of enterocin- and salivaricin-producing lactic acid bacteria from the mammalian gastrointestinal tract. FEMS Microbiology Letters 291(1):24-34. PMID 19076236
     59.  Pridmore RD, Pittet AC, Praplan F, & Cavadini C (2008). Hydrogen peroxide production by Lactobacillus johnsonii NCC 533 and its role in anti-Salmonella activity. FEMS Microbiology Letters 283(2):210-215. PMID 18435747
     60.  Heller L (2009). Danisco breaks down probiotics market. (Nutra Ingredients, USA).
     61.  Cook MT, Tzortzis G, Charalampopoulos D, & Khutoryanskiy VV (2012). Microencapsulation of probiotics for gastrointestinal delivery. Journal of Controlled Release: Official Journal of the Controlled Release Society 162(1):56-67. PMID 22698940
     62.  Starling S (2009). Probiotics must meet Europe’s new health claim laws head on.
     63.  Oliveira RP, et al. (2009). Effect of different prebiotics on the fermentation kinetics, probiotic survival and fatty acids profiles in nonfat symbiotic fermented milk. International Journal of Food Microbiology 128(3):467-472. PMID 19000641
     64.  Reid G (2008). How science will help shape future clinical applications of probiotics. Clinical Infectious Diseases: An Official Publication of the Infectious Diseases Society of America 46 Suppl 2:S62-66; discussion S144-151. PMID 18181725
     65.  Govender M, et al. (2014). A review of the advancements in probiotic delivery: Conventional vs. non-conventional formulations for intestinal flora supplementation. AAPS PharmSciTech 15(1):29-43. PMID 24222267
     66.  Herbel SR, et al. (2013). Species-specific quantification of probiotic lactobacilli in yoghurt by quantitative real-time PCR. Journal of Applied Microbiology 115(6):1402-1410. PMID 24024971
     67.  Dunlap BS, Yu H, & Elitsur Y (2009). The probiotic content of commercial yogurts in West Virginia. Clinical Pediatrics 48(5):522-527. PMID 19246412
     68.  Park KY, Jeong JK, Lee YE, & Daily JW, 3rd (2014). Health benefits of kimchi (Korean fermented vegetables) as a probiotic food. Journal of Medicinal Food 17(1):6-20. PMID 24456350
     69.  Lee D, Kim S, Cho J, & Kim J (2008). Microbial population dynamics and temperature changes during fermentation of kimjang kimchi. Journal of Microbiology 46(5):590-593. PMID 18974963
     70.  Lee JS, et al. (2005). Analysis of kimchi microflora using denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis. International Journal of Food Microbiology 102(2):143-150. PMID 15992614
     71.  Kim M & Chun J (2005). Bacterial community structure in kimchi, a Korean fermented vegetable food, as revealed by 16S rRNA gene analysis. International Journal of Food Microbiology 103(1):91-96. PMID 16084269
     72.  Lee J, Hwang KT, Heo MS, Lee JH, & Park KY (2005). Resistance of Lactobacillus plantarum KCTC 3099 from Kimchi to oxidative stress. Journal of Medicinal Food 8(3):299-304. PMID 16176138
     73.  Lee JH, Kweon DH, & Lee SC (2006). Isolation and characterization of an immunopotentiating factor from Lactobacillus plantarum in kimchi: assessment of immunostimulatory activities. . Food Sci Biotechnol 15:877-883. Abstract
     74.  Hur HJ, Lee KW, & Lee HJ (2004). Production of nitric oxide, tumor necrosis factor-alpha and interleukin-6 by RAW264.7 macrophage cells treated with lactic acid bacteria isolated from kimchi. BioFactors 21(1-4):123-125. PMID 15630182
     75.  Jang SE, et al. (2013). Lactobacillus plantarum HY7712 ameliorates cyclophosphamide-induced immunosuppression in mice. Journal of microbiology and biotechnology 23(3):414-421. PMID 23462016
     76.  Chae OW, Shin KS, Chung H, & Choe TB (1998). Immunostimulation effects of mice fed with cell lysate of Lactobacillus plantarum isolated from kimchi. Korean J Biotech Bioeng 13:424-430. Article
     77.  Kim NH, et al. (2008). Lipid profile lowering effect of Soypro fermented with lactic acid bacteria isolated from Kimchi in high-fat diet-induced obese rats. BioFactors 33(1):49-60. PMID 19276536
     78.  Kwon JY, Cheigh HS, & Song YO (2004). Weight reduction and lipid lowering effects of kimchi lactic acid powder in rats fed high fat diets. Korean J Food Sci Technol 36:1014-1019. Article
     79.  Ahn DK, Han TW, Shin HY, Jin IN, & Ghim SY (2003). Diversity and antibacterial activity of lactic acid bacteria isolated from kimchi. Korean J Microbiol Biotechnol 31:191-196. Abstract
     80.  Tang, M., Ponsonby, A-L., Orsini, F., Tey, D., Robinson, M., Su, E. L., Licciardi, P., Burks, W., and Donath, S., (2015). Administration of a probiotic with peanut oral immunotherapy: A randomized trial. The Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology. 135 (3): 737-44.PMID 25592987

   Antioxidant Hype and Reality
Steven Novella
Link
A new study by lead author Shelly Gray and published in the latest issue of the Journal for the American Geriatric Society, found no effect from taking Vitamin C or E, either alone or in combination, on the risk of dementia or Alzheimer’s disease after 5.5 years. Vitamins C and E were chosen because they both have significant antioxidant activity, and so this study was partly to test the hypothesis that oxidative stress causes or contributes to dementia.
The science behind the role of oxidative stress in aging and neurodegenerative disorders and the modulation of oxidative stress by nutritional antioxidants is complex and has not yielded many confident therapeutic recommendations. And yet, by contrast, antioxidants are sold to the public with dramatic health claims as if they were well established. It is common for marketing hype to out pace scientific reality, especially when the science is complex and preliminary so that there is as yet no firm scientific consensus.
For background, oxidative stress refers to the production in the cells of the body of certain oxygen-based compounds, collectively called reactive oxygen species (ROS), that are highly reactive. Some of these compounds are simply waste products of cell metabolism. Others serve a useful purpose, such as nitric oxide that is used in neurotransmission. What these ROS compounds have in common is that they react with proteins, DNA, and other cell components and cause damage.
The body has evolved a natural defense against the onslaught of ROS. These compounds are called free radical scavengers or antioxidants (such as the protein superoxide dismutase) and their job is to gobble up ROS before they can damage cells.
In the last two decades our increasing knowledge of oxidative stress and natural antioxidants has led to a great deal of legitimate scientific speculation about the role of ROS in degenerative disorders and even natural aging. Even conservative and responsible scientists dared dream that antioxidants might cure everything from Alzheimer’s disease to old age.
Before scientists could even write their research grants, however, there emerged from this “irrational exuberance” a cottage industry of antioxidant products marketed as if they were the very elixir of life. But two decades later a complex picture has emerged – and continues to emerge. At this point what does the evidence say about oxidative stress and antioxidants?
Of course this is many separate questions that must be addressed individually. First let us consider the basic science. We have learned a great deal about the various kinds of cellular damage caused by ROS. This includes damage to mitochondrial function (mitochondria are the energy factories of cells) and also to DNA, which is likely at least partly responsible for cellular aging. We have also found the products of oxidative damage in virtually all neurodegenerative diseases, like ALS and Parkinson’s disease.
So, if anything, the basic science plausibility of antioxidants has increased over time. There is no question that oxidative damage is occurring as part of neurodegenerative diseases. But biological symptoms are frustratingly complex and often mock our simplistic explanations. It is possible, for example, that oxidative damage may be more of a consequence of the cellular damage that occurs than a cause of it. Therefore antioxidants may not necessary stop the cellular damage.
Medicine also seems to follow the law of unintended consequences. For example, it is also possible that antioxidants may decrease the beneficial actions of some oxidative agents. Heat shock proteins, which are proteins that function, in part, by activating protective cell functions, are themselves activated by oxidative stress. It is possible that therefore, that exogenous antioxidants might decrease some protective function activated by heat shock proteins.
In other words – the regulation of ROS and oxidative stress in the body may be more of a balancing act than any simplistic notion of oxidative stress being all bad and antioxidants being all good. So nutritional antioxidants may have some benefits but at the same time disrupt certain metabolic balances. And yet, in disease states this balance may already be broken, and therefore antioxidants may have the potential to correct excessive oxidative stress.
Ultimately we need clinical evidence to make any conclusions about the health benefits, if any, of nutritional antioxidants. We simply need to see what the net effects of these substances are in actual people. On this score the scientific evidence is highly mixed and has yet to yield a clear benefit for any antioxidant, but this has not been ruled out either.
A recent review of clinical studies of antioxidants in Alzheimer’s disease (AD) concluded that the evidence is “ambiguous”, while still recommending them largely because they are low risk. More definitive trials were recommended, like the study I referred to above which shows no benefit for prevention of AD.
The evidence for antioxidants in ALS is largely negative. In Parkinson’s disease (PD) the picture is a bit more complex. There is some evidence that eating Vitamin E rich foods may help prevent PD but not Vitamin E supplements. So perhaps it is something other than the Vitamin E in these foods that is of benefit, or perhaps eating healthy foods is simply a marker for some other variable that protect against PD. In other words, the evidence is ambiguous.
In general research into antioxidants as treatment for the various neurodegenerative diseases has been disappointingly negative. But hope is not gone. There are enough preliminary positive results, as well as positive animal and preclinical data, to fuel antioxidant enthusiasm for years. Some argue that we simply have not found the right antioxidant or the proper dosing. Vitamin E, for example, does not cross over into the brain significantly so perhaps an antioxidant with more brain penetration would work better.
These are all very legitimate points, and I think it is reasonable to continue to conduct clinical research with antioxidants, although the lackluster clinical evidence has reduced my optimism. It may even be reasonable for patients with neurodegenerative disorders to take antioxidants in the hopes there will be some modest benefit – as long as they understand that they should still be considered experimental, and that while they are generally low risk, at high doses there may be (and probably are) unknown risks. Some trials, for example, have shown a possible adverse effect from Vitamin E in treating heart disease.
The use of antioxidant supplements and the consuming of foods high in natural antioxidants for routine health maintenance needs to be considered completely separately from the use of antioxidants in treating specific diseases. But here the evidence is also ambiguous. The difficulty here is that most studies are epidemiological and don’t control for many variables, such as the effects having a generally healthful diet. A danish meta analysis published one year ago in JAMA even showed that the use of certain antioxidants was associated with a higher mortality rate. All of this evidence, good and bad, is preliminary. Long term, prospective, definitive trials are simply lacking.
Conclusion
Oxidative stress and the effects of antioxidants are an important and interesting aspect of human physiology. We have already learned a great deal, but it seems like just enough to understand that we still have a great deal more to learn. It is clearly playing some role in aging and many diseases, but likely a more complex one than we initially assumed. Antioxidants may one day play an important role in the treatment of certain diseases or in routine health maintenance, but so far there is insufficient evidence to make any confident predictions or to make specific recommendations.
However, when it comes to the marketing hype for antioxidant products I can make a clear recommendation – healthy skepticism.

   Antioxidant Supplements for Macular Degeneration
Harriet Hall
Link
Age-related macular degeneration (AMD) is one of the major causes of visual impairment in the elderly: it affects central vision, impairing the ability to read and recognize faces while preserving some peripheral vision. It comes in two forms: wet and dry. Dry macular degeneration is by far more common, but wet macular degeneration, involving the proliferation of blood vessels, is more severe. 
There is evidence that antioxidant vitamin supplementation may slow the progression of the dry type when it is already established and moderately severe, but the published evidence does not support the use of these supplements for prevention or for patients with early stages of the disease. Some people are using it for prevention, but there is concern that the risks might exceed any benefit. Of more concern, it appears that a manufacturer’s (Bausch & Lomb’s) advertising has gone way beyond the available evidence. 
This review by the American Academy of Ophthalmology covers the subject well. 
A Cochrane review found that the evidence for effectiveness of antioxidant vitamin supplements comes mainly from one large trial, the AREDS trial, that was funded by the manufacturer Bausch & Lomb. The AREDS study used vitamin C, 500 mg; vitamin E, 400 IU; beta-carotene, 15 mg (approximately 25,000 IU vitamin A); zinc 80 mg as zinc oxide; and copper, 2 mg, as cupric oxide. (The copper was added to prevent copper-deficiency anemia, an adverse effect of high-dose zinc.) 
The effect was statistically significant but modest. Patients taking the antioxidant and zinc supplement had a 23% chance of developing vision loss from advanced AMD compared to a 29% chance of developing vision loss from advanced AMD for patients taking a placebo pill.
The Cochrane review concluded
The generalisability of these findings to other populations with different nutritional status is not known. Further large, well-conducted randomised controlled trials in other populations are required. Long-term harm from supplementation cannot be ruled out. Beta-carotene has been found to increase the risk of lung cancer in smokers; vitamin E has been associated with an increased risk of heart failure in people with vascular disease or diabetes.
Bausch & Lomb has been selling a product called PreserVision Eye Vitamin AREDS Formula. It contains the same combination of vitamins C, E, beta carotene and zinc that was shown to slow the progression of moderate to advanced macular degeneration in the AREDS trial. The authors of that trial recommended this treatment for patients with extensive intermediate size drusen (deposits seen on ophthalmoscopy that are characteristic of AMD), at least one large druse, noncentral geographic atrophy in one or both eyes, or advanced AMD or vision loss due to AMD in one eye, and without contraindications such as smoking.
Bausch & Lomb has tried to improve their formula to reduce the risk associated with beta carotene. Their PreserVision Eye Vitamin AREDS 2 Formula omits the beta carotene and adds lutein and zeaxanthin, as well as omega-3 fatty acids. Is the new formula better? We don’t know, because the results of the AREDS 2 trial to test it will not be available until 2013. The product has already been recalled for reformulation after some patients reported difficulty swallowing the soft gels or experiencing a choking sensation. The recall affects only the US: the product is still available in Europe and other parts of the world, and we can expect to see it back on our shelves as soon as it is put into an easier-to-swallow form.
Bausch & Lomb has been advertising their AREDS 2 Formula as “the latest scientific advancement in eye vitamin therapy” and has urged ophthalmologists to give it to their patients. A recent article in The Medical Letter criticized them, saying “That seems premature at best.” Much harsher words could be used.
Bausch & Lomb also sells other products (Ocuvite, Ocuvite Lutein, etc.) that contain lower amounts of the vitamins and minerals used in the AREDS trial, sometimes with other ingredients added, like lutein and omega-3. The rationale for products with these dosages is hard to fathom.
Is this Big Pharma or Big Supplement? The products carry the FDA warning “not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease,” yet they are clearly being marketed to treat a disease.
Should everyone with moderately severe AMD be taking antioxidant supplements? I’m not sure. Since there is little else to try, if I had advanced AMD I might be tempted. But I think caution is warranted due to the following red flags: 
    • Evidence boils down to one study funded by manufacturer.
    • Not replicated.
    • Concerns about harmful side effects; no long-term safety data.
    • Modest effect.
    • No clear rationale for the particular combination and dosage of ingredients.
    • Hype by the manufacturer.

   Resveratrol: Of Mice and Men
Harriet Hall
Link
We would all like to live longer. The most promising longevity research indicates that severe calorie restriction might extend life span, but such a diet is difficult to follow. Resveratrol, a phytochemical found in red wine, has been evaluated as a possible way out of the dilemma. When given to obese mice on a high calorie diet, it produced a number of changes associated with improved health, such as increased insulin sensitivity, and it increased survival. Perhaps by taking resveratrol you could eat as much as you want and get fat without suffering the usual consequences. Perhaps you could get the longevity benefits of severe calorie restriction without restricting calories.
In addition to fat mice, resveratrol also extends the life of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Caenorhabditis elegans and Drosophila melanogaster (yeast, nematodes, and fruit flies). But a study in non-obese mice found no increase in survival (although it did find several signs of improved health). Besides the anti-aging claims, there is also some evidence from in vitro and animal studies that it might have cardiovascular effects and anti-cancer effects.
The ads for one product (Vinotrol) say:
• “Life is short… or maybe not.
• Top Harvard researcher says it’s “the Holy Grail of aging research.”
• As seen on CBS “60 Minutes.”
• Harvard Medical School, Johns Hopkins, Salk Institute and UC Davis Medical Research Proves that Powerful Red Wine Extract Holds the Secret to Living a Longer, Healthier and More Vibrant Life
• Has the “French Paradox” finally been explained?
• Trick your body into “aging in slow motion.”
• Can you live years longer and feel years younger?
• “extends the life of every species it’s been given to.”
• Vinotrol, with 50 mg of resveratrol derived from grapes and roots, provides the equivalent of the resveratrol in 278 five ounce glasses of Pinot Noir.
• Promoting circulation, blood flow, [what’s the difference between these two?] immune system [ Mark Crislip has recently explained to us what that means], energy and healthy arteries.
• In tiny print at the bottom, it offers this disclaimer:
These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. This product is not meant to diagnose or treat any disease. Vinotrol is not endorsed, associated or affiliated in any way with Harvard University, Johns Hopkins, Salk Institute or UC Davis Medical.
Dr. Stephen Barrett of Quackwatch has summarized the evidence for resveratrol at “Resveratrol: Don’t Buy the Hype.” It was recently evaluated by the “gold standard” publication The Medical Letter (Vol. 51 Issue 1321, p. 74-5, September 21, 2009). They pointed out “studies in humans are limited” and concluded
Resveratrol appears to produce some of the same effects as calorie-restricted diets that have reduced the incidence of age-related diseases in animals. Whether it has any benefit in humans remains to be established. 
The Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database says
There is insufficient reliable information available about the effectiveness of resveratrol.
Its safety has not been established, and there is speculation that it might potentiate certain cancers. The Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database concluded
There is insufficient reliable information available about the safety of resveratrol when used in supplemental doses in amounts greater than those found in foods.
There are concerns about interactions with other drugs. It has antiplatelet effects and preliminary evidence shows that resveratrol might inhibit the cytochrome P450 enzymes, CYP3A, CYP1A, and CYP2E1.
Resveratrol products have been associated with scams and false advertising. Researcher Dr. David Sinclair is quoted in ads without his permission. He commented
His lab showed that mice fed the chemicals live at least 15% longer than normal mice. But to get such benefits, human beings might have to consume up to 5 grams of resveratrol a day, he says. That’s about 80 pills, at doses found in a typical bottle.
The properties of resveratrol are intriguing, and it may turn out to be a useful drug. But so far the studies on resveratrol are pre-clinical studies. We have no data on its effects in humans. Few people would want to take a proposed prescription drug that had not yet undergone clinical trials: why should resveratrol be any different? In the absence of clinical trials, resveratrol might be recommended for obese mice, but not for men.

   Protandim: Another Kind of Antioxidant
Harriet Hall
Link
Four years ago I received an e-mail inquiry about Protandim. I had never heard of it; but I looked it up and wrote a quick, informal, somewhat snarky answer that got posted on the Internet. It got a lot of attention. Googling for Protandim now brings up my critique right after the Protandim website itself: that can’t be good for sales. Over the years, several e-mails and blog comments have informed me that I was wrong (usually offering testimonials or calling me closed-minded), and recently I’ve been getting inquiries asking if I’ve changed my mind now that a clinical study has been published. I haven’t.
Instead of providing antioxidants directly, Protandim is supposed to stimulate the body to produce its own antioxidants. The website tells us it is “the only supplement clinically proven to reduce oxidative stress by 40%, slowing down the rate of cell aging to the level of a 20 year old.” It provides “thousands of times more antioxidant power than any food or conventional antioxidant supplement.” It signals the body’s genes to produce the enzymes SOD (superoxide dismutase) and CAT (catalase) that act as catalysts to neutralize free radicals and are not “used up” like ingested antioxidants are. It “creates a cascade of your body’s natural catalytic antioxidants that are able to destroy millions of free radicals per second.” It raises the level of glutathione by 300%. Glutathione is good, apparently.
What is Protandim? It’s a combination of Milk thistle, Bacopa extract, Ashwagandha, Green tea extract, and Turmeric extract. I looked these up in the Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database. None of them is known to have any significant clinical benefit from antioxidant effects. Some of them are listed as “not enough information” to know if they are safe. One has estrogenic properties and more than one has known side effects and potential interactions with other drugs. The only one that even sounds remotely like it might have some pertinent data behind it is green tea. Green tea contains antioxidant catechins that are “thought to possibly have a protective effect against atherosclerosis and heart disease” and contains flavonoids that “might reduce lipoprotein oxidation; however benefits have not yet been described in humans.”
A Pubmed search for “Protandim” yielded only 3 studies: One in mice, one in cell cultures and one in humans.
1. The mouse study. Protandim reduced the development of skin cancers in a mouse model.
2. The cell culture study. Cells in cell culture produced more glutathione in the presence of Protandim. There was a synergistic effect of components in the induction of heme oxygenase-1.
3. The human study. The only clinical study so far.
After 30 days of supplementation, TBARS declined by an average of 40% (p = 0.0001) and the age-dependent increase was eliminated. By 120 days, erythrocyte SOD increased by 30% (p < 0.01) and catalase by 54% (p < 0.002). We conclude that modest induction of the catalytic antioxidants SOD and catalase may be a much more effective approach than supplementation with antioxidants (such as vitamins C and E) that can, at best, stoichiometrically scavenge a very small fraction of total oxidant production.
The concept is intriguing, and it may have promise, but the current evidence is not sufficient to make clinical recommendations. There is only one study to date in humans, and it only measured markers in the blood. TBARS (thiobarbituric acid reactive substances) is a measurement that has not demonstrated clinical usefulness. I could only find one study suggesting that TBARS levels might be helpful in predicting outcome in patients who already have cardiovascular disease. This review article critiques TBARS and other measures of antioxidant activity and suggests that measuring isoprostanes might be more meaningful.
It’s all very well to show that a remedy changes blood test results or even a known marker for disease; but what we really need to know is whether it improves health, prevents cancer, prolongs life…We need POEMS: Patient Oriented Evidence that Matters. Avandia improves hemoglobin A1C levels in diabetics but increases mortality. Mortality matters a lot; Hgb A1C levels don’t matter so much. “The operation was a success but the patient died” is not good enough.
I went to Wikipedia not as a reliable source but because it often has links to more information from primary sources. For what it’s worth, the Wiki article on Protandim concurs with my assessment, stating “There is no acceptable evidence that it improves health.” Wiki links to a very useful “Protandim Watch” website that has gathered a lot of information in one place, including information about the company and its multilevel marketing. It is skeptical and recommends caution. Wikipedia also questions Protandim’s claim of life extension, listing several studies on animals suggesting that increasing production of those catalytic enzymes might not increase life span and possibly might shorten it.
From the Protandim Watch website I learned that a second patent was awarded to Protandim in 2008. In the patent application, they claimed that
The compositions of the present invention are useful to prevent or treat the following disorders and diseases: memory loss; Parkinson’s disease; aging; toxin-induced hepatotoxicity, inflammation; liver cirrhosis; chronic hepatitis; and diabetes due to cirrhosis; indigestion; fatigue; stress; cough; infertility; tissue inflammation; cancer; anxiety disorders; panic attacks; rheumatism; pain; manic depression; alcoholic paranoia; schizophrenia; fever; insomnia; infertility; aging; skin inflammations and disorders; alcoholism; anemia; carbuncles; convalescence; emaciation; HIV; AIDS; immune system problems; lumbago; multiple sclerosis; muscle energy loss; paralysis; swollen glands; ulcers; breathing difficulties; inflammation; psoriasis; cancer (e.g.; prostate cancer, lung cancer and breast cancer); pain; cardiovascular disease (e.g.; arteriosclerosis and atherosclerosis); ischemia/reperfusion injury; anxiety; attention deficit disorder; leprosy; arthritis (e.g., psoriatic arthritis; ankylosing spondylitis; and rheumatoid arthritis); hemorrhoids; tuberculosis; high blood pressure; congestive heart failure; venous insufficiency (pooling of blood in the veins; usually in the legs); sore throat; hepatitis; syphilis; stomach ulcers; epilepsy; diarrhea; asthma; burns; piles; sunburn; wrinkles; headache; insect bites; cuts; ulcers; sores; herpes; jaundice; bursitis; canker sores; sore gums; poison ivy; gastritis; high cholesterol; heart disease; bacterial infection; viral infection; acne; aging; immune disorders; dental caries; periodontitis; halitosis; dandruff; cardiovascular disease (e.g., hypertension; thrombosis; arteriosclerosis); migraine headaches; diabetes; elevated blood glucose; diseases of the alimentary canal and respiratory system; age-related physical and mental deterioration (e.g., Alzheimer’s Disease and age-related dementia); cardiovascular disease; cerebral vascular insufficiency and impaired cerebral performance; congestive symptoms of premenstrual syndrome; allergies; age-related vision loss; depression; Raynaud’s disease; peripheral vascular disease; intermittent claudication; vertigo; equilibrium disorder; prevention of altitude sickness; tinnitus (ringing in the ear); liver fibrosis; macular degeneration; asthma; graft rejection; and immune disorders that induce toxic shock; bronchpulmonary disease as cystic fibrosis; chronic bronchitis; gastritis; heart attack; angina pectoris; chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; kidney damage during coronary angiography; Unverricht-Lundborg disease; pseudoporphyria; pneumonia; and paracetamol hepatotoxicity.
Did they leave anything out?
Clearly, these claims can’t be substantiated, and they can’t legally list them on their website. LifeVantage Corporation’s website still states that it
does not market and sell Protandim® for the purposes of preventing, treating, curing, or mitigating any disease, including MS.
I guess we can assume they only market and sell it for the purposes of making money.
The second study listed above really intrigues me. They tested the individual components and apparently established that there was a marked synergism when the ingredients were combined. If this is true, it is unusual and deserves further investigation. In general, mixing natural medicines has produced additive but not synergistic effects, despite the claims of naturopaths that synergistic effects are common and are a basic principle of herbal medicine.
Some 20 studies in humans are said to be in progress. I’ll watch developments with great interest. Meanwhile, I can’t recommend taking Protandim. There has been a lot of hype about antioxidants. Most of the research indicates that eating fruits and vegetables is beneficial, but taking antioxidant supplements is either useless or counterproductive.
If you did want to raise your antioxidant levels, how could you rationally choose from all the products on the market? For instance, how about Seanol? – they say it has some of “the most powerful antioxidants on earth” and is responsible for the longevity of Okinawans.
I’m not buying.

Protandim Update: New Studies and an FDA Warning Letter
Multilevel distributors of the dietary supplement Protandim think that evidence from scientific studies supports their claims for their product. The FDA disagrees.
Harriet Hall on May 9, 2017
Link


On April 17, 2017, the FDA sent a warning letter to the LifeVantage Corporation advising them that their product Protandim NRF2 Synergizer was misbranded and violated regulations.
The claims on the websites www.nrf2science.com, www.lifevantage.com, and www.protandim.com establish that they are selling Protandim as a drug intended to prevent or treat diseases. The claims include prevention and/or treatment of cardiovascular disease, Alzheimer’s disease, high blood pressure, stomach ulcers, osteoarthritis, bacterial and viral infections, and several types of cancer (“shows ability to slow progression of and ‘kill’ cancer cells”). And much more.
The FDA gave them 15 working days to correct these violations. As of this writing, they have not yet done so.
Protandim is a mixture of 5 herbal supplements (milk thistle, bacopa extract, ashwagandha, green tea extract, and turmeric extract) intended to upregulate the body’s own production of antioxidants. It is sold through multilevel marketing. Its patent application said it was useful to treat or prevent an astounding 126 diseases and medical conditions, from tinnitus to aging, from hemorrhoids to cancer. Those claims are not supported by any credible scientific evidence.
Previous articles on Protandim
I first wrote about Protandim in 2005, followed by three articles on the Science-Based Medicine blog. The first, in 2009, was “Protandim: Another Kind of Antioxidant.”
The second, in 2011, was “Pursued by Protandim Proselytizers.” I described how I was getting a steady flow of emails from distributors and customers asking me to reconsider and look at new evidence. I looked at the new evidence, but it was not anything that would lead me to reconsider. I wrote:
We need good human studies showing that people who take Protandim have better clinical outcomes than people who don’t. For instance, fewer heart attacks or fewer cancers…not just higher levels on a TBARS test….I am only asking for the same kind of evidence that the scientific community requires before it accepts any new treatment. Please try to understand what I mean by clinical studies with meaningful outcomes and contact me again when such studies are available… and not before.
They didn’t listen. They kept sending me e-mails every time any new study was announced. In 2012 I wrote a brief update to cover a study that was so bad it made me laugh. Instead of studying any of the conditions Protandim was alleged to benefit, they chose to study alveolar epithelial permeability in alcoholics. The results? It performed significantly worse than placebo!
The new studies are not convincing
They still didn’t listen. I’m still getting emails, most recently this one:
Hi, I’m not even sure how I came across your article against Protandim, last 1 is from 2011. Would you please have a look at the studies now. [sic] I’d love to know if your opinion has changed. Your info is incorrect by stating all the studies are done by the company. Check out the NIA study on life extension or the osteo study by Montreals [sic] Osteoarthritis Research Centre. Surely you must have something to say about these? thank [sic] you for your time.
She didn’t provide details, so I had to do some sleuthing to figure out which studies she was referring to. I found the NIA life extension study. It was in mice, not humans. It found that Protandim significantly increased the median lifespan of male mice at one of the three testing centers but not at the other two; when data from all three sites was pooled, Protandim appeared to increase the median lifespan of male mice by 7%. It did not significantly increase the median survival of female mice. And it did not increase maximum lifespan. Anyway, what happens in mice may not apply to humans.
I located the osteo study. It’s behind a paywall, and the abstract is confusing. Apparently it was a combination of a mouse study and in vitro studies. They used a mouse model where osteoarthritis was surgically induced by destabilizing the medial meniscus. Then they injected Protandim directly into the joint, and the mice’s osteoarthritis scores decreased. Nice for the mice, but it doesn’t tell us anything about humans taking Protandim in pill form! Then they studied human and mouse cells in vitro and measured improvements in Nrf2 and GSTA4-4 expression. Interesting, but not the same as significant clinical improvements in humans with osteoarthritis or any other condition.
I also found this study in human athletes showing that:
Protandim® did not (1) alter 5-km running time, (2) lower TBARS at rest (3) raise antioxidant enzyme concentrations compared to placebo (with exception of SOD in those ≥ 35 years old) or, (4) affect quality of life compared to placebo.
This study is not mentioned on the Protandim website, presumably because of its negative results.
Other critics and concerns
I’m not the only one to critique Protandim. Supplement Geek covered the research thoroughly pointing out that the studies are mostly in rodents and in test tubes; there have only been three studies in humans, two of which were negative. And Consumer Lab was less than enthusiastic. And another review cites “very little evidence.”
And there’s also a Wikipedia page that points out that the in vitro and animal studies have not been replicated in human trials. It also reveals how Protandim was invented: Joe McCord was given a list of 41 potential ingredients and he rapidly penciled out 36 of them. Not very scientific!
For what it’s worth, there was a safety recall in 2012.
And the LifeVantage company is not BBB accredited. The BBB website mentions failure to respond to three complaints and includes a number of customer comments.
There is a Protandim Watch website that lists investigative resources, but it is not up to date.
Conclusion: not backed by scientific evidence
It seems nobody is very impressed with Protandim except for the people who are selling it!
So no, my opinion has not changed. My articles are not “against” Protandim. My opinion is not that it doesn’t work, but that no one knows whether it works; and the only way to find out if it works is through proper scientific testing of the company’s claims.
The good news is that if you don’t want to wait for scientific testing, it is probably safe to try. Over the 88 days of the negative trial on human athletes there were 233 reports of signs and symptoms in the Protandim group compared to 220 in the placebo group. Subjects taking Protandim reported more episodes of stomachache and headache, and less gas, but with only 19 subjects in each group, numbers were too small to draw any conclusions.

The Plant Paradox: Steven Gundry’s War on Lectins
Most of what Steven Gundry says in his book The Plant Paradox is demonstrably wrong. There is no science-based reason to avoid lectins.
Harriet Hall on October 25, 2022
Link

A correspondent asked me to review a book by Steven Gundry, The Plant Paradox: The Hidden Dangers in “Healthy” Foods That Cause Disease and Weight Gain. I intended to reserve judgment and just look into which claims were supported by credible science, but I was put off by the very first sentence:
…everything you thought you knew about your diet, your health, and your weight is wrong.
Isn’t he essentially asking us to reject science? Some of the things we know have been proven by good science, with multiple approaches and multiple systematic reviews of controlled studies that are in agreement. And of course, he is going to cite scientific studies to support his own claims. Who gets to be the arbiter of what is good science and what the rest of the world got wrong? Gundry himself, of course. He says “with all modesty” (Hah!) he has found there is a common cause for most health problems that the rest of the medical establishment doesn’t know. Only he does. He can reverse heart disease and cure whatever is wrong with you through diet alone. (Yeah, sure!)
In the introduction “It’s Not Your Fault” he brags about his expertise as a cardiologist and researcher but he inadvertently reveals how he came to the wrong conclusion about diet. He had been eating what he was told was a healthy diet and was exercising as recommended, but he was overweight, had high blood pressure, migraine headaches, arthritis, high cholesterol, and insulin resistance. All these problems resolved when he changed his diet. He lost 70 pounds. Couldn’t the weight loss, instead of his new diet, account for the improvements?
His program starts with a 3-day cleanse (“cleanse” is a pseudoscience buzzword!) and promises to banish most of your health problems, achieve a healthy weight, reboot your energy level, and elevate your mood. Such a deal! But can we believe it? Let’s look at the science behind the claims.
Plants produce chemicals to defend themselves from predators and you are a predator. The plant paradox, according to Gundry, is that while they offer essential health benefits they are also trying to kill you.
He says lectins cause inflammation, stimulate weight gain, and cause leaky gut syndrome. With the agricultural revolution, grain and beans quickly became the dietary staples of most cultures. These were toxic, but Gundry says when humans were faced with a choice between starvation and surviving with serious health trade-offs, they opted for survival.
Gundry explains that milk from different breeds of cow may contain either casein A-1 (Ayrshire, British Shorthorn, Holstein, and Friesian) or casein A-2 (Charolais, Guernsey, Jersey, and Limousin). (This is not strictly accurate. Actually, the breeds in his A-1 list produce equal amounts of A-1 and A-2.) His diet strictly prohibits milk and dairy products from casein A-1 cows; it only allows casein A-2 milk and alternative dairy products. On his website he calls casein A-1 “incredibly noxious”. He believes it is the primary cause of type 1 diabetes.
What does science say? It says there is some intriguing evidence, but causation of diabetes by A-1 remains unproven. And science says there is a lack of definitive human trials to support the various health claims for the superiority of casein A-2 milk. The first systematic review was published in 2017. It found only three human studies, one study showing delayed intestinal transit for casein A-1 milk and two studies that showed looser stool consistency. So what? The studies didn’t show that these changes harmed people. These were secondary markers; none of those studies looked at clinical outcomes, at so-called POEMS (patient-oriented evidence that matters). The rest of the published evidence was all from animal studies.
He claims lectin avoidance, “as reported in the scientific literature” has been found to cure autoimmune diseases. The reference he gives from the scientific literature is “Curing/remission of multiple autoimmune diseases is possible by manipulation of the human gut microbiome” in the Journal of International Society of Microbiota. He lists himself as the author. I had difficulty locating it and finally discovered it was not a published, peer-reviewed article but an abstract only available to members. An article with the same title was listed as a poster/abstract presentation in the journal Circulation. It was not listed on PubMed. In fact, I could not find a single article by SR Gundry anywhere in PubMed. I was amazed and shocked to find nothing in PubMed for someone who calls himself a researcher.
In the book he describes many case reports of patients who improved on a lectin-limited diet, but he has done no studies with a control group for comparison, so his “evidence” is anecdotal and meaningless. And he has no business extrapolating from inadequate evidence and animal studies to give general advice about what all humans should and shouldn’t eat. He is clearly not a reliable source of medical information and is not to be trusted. He claims, without evidence, that “Everyone who has a disease has a leaky gut”. Leaky gut is not a recognized medical diagnosis; many doctors deny that it exists. And he sells his own line of supplements. And his book is also a cookbook featuring many recipes, some of which sound very unappetizing.
I was appalled that an MD could be so inept at providing references and so clueless about what constitutes evidence and about basic principles of science like the need for a control group.
What are lectins?
Lectins are carbohydrate-binding proteins that are found in most foods. They can be harmful. Kidney beans are toxic but only if eaten raw, which no one does; proper cooking neutralizes the lectins and makes kidney beans safe to eat. Not only safe, but beneficial. Lectins play essential roles in human physiology. Among their many important functions, they regulate cell adhesion and are the first-line defense against invading microorganisms in the innate immune system.
Steven Gundry’s diet
The Plant Paradox diet excludes whole grains, legumes, most fruit, certain nuts and seeds, A-1 dairy products, and the nightshade vegetables (tomatoes, potatoes, eggplant, bell peppers, and chili peppers). A full list of foods to avoid and foods that are OK is available on Gundry’s website. It is extensive. It’s easy to see that following such a restricted diet is likely to reduce total calorie intake and result in weight loss. Substantial weight loss as well as placebo responses may explain why so many of Gundy’s patients believe his no-lectin diet has helped them.
Criticism
A large number of doctors, nutritionists, and scientists have criticized The Plant Paradox. Some of them are listed on the Wikipedia article, including T. Colin Campbell, the author of The China Syndrome, which I reviewed here. I thought the best of all the critical articles was a long, detailed, and well-reasoned article by Michael Matthews. He debunks Gundry’s thesis, giving “7 science-based reasons it’s a scam”:
The Plant Paradox is rife with inaccuracies, misrepresentations, and outright misinformation, and the diet espoused in it is unnecessarily restrictive and blatantly designed to sell people overpriced and ineffective supplements…there’s enough high-quality research to say we know enough about lectins to blow all of Dr. Gundry’s principal hypotheses out of the airlock and thereby dismantle and disarm The Plant Paradox.
Michael Matthews is a personal trainer, not a physician or scientist, and he also is guilty of selling unproven dietary supplements, so I will be criticized for citing him, but of the many critiques of Gundry’s book I found on the Internet, I thought his was by far the best, the most detailed and well-reasoned. It is based on good science and supported by links to published evidence. He reviews the supplements Gundry sells that Gundry says are essential.
The bottom line is Dr. Gundry’s products are a sham, what with the fake science, unproven ingredients, and miniscule dosages.
He doesn’t mince words and his language is not afraid to resort to insults. He calls Gundry “a once-prestigious heart surgeon turned diet quack”. Actually, I think that’s true.
He responds to all the comments following his article and does an excellent job of answering the complaints of true believers with tact and accurate information, and with no insulting language. He tells them he is glad they are feeling better, without reaffirming their belief that lectin avoidance is the cause of their improvement. I was impressed.
His article “Dr. Gundry’s Plant Paradox Debunked: 7 Science-Based Reasons It’s a Scam” can be found on the LegionAthletics website. It repeats what he says in his podcast on Gundry.
Conclusion: Gundry is wrong
The book The Plant Paradox is not science-based medicine. It is…something else. I won’t try to say what it is because I would be tempted to resort to profanity. Lectins are not our enemies, and the foods Gundry prohibits are part of a science-based healthy diet. Avoiding them might lead to inadequate nutrition.

Water

Eight Glasses of Water Myth
The notion that everyone should drink eight glasses of water per day is a persistent myth. Let’s break it down.
Steven NovellaconcJanuary 4, 2023
Link
One of the uncomfortable but empowering lessons of going on a skeptical journey to understand the world we live in a little better is the realization that most bits of conventional wisdom floating around in the public consciousness are wrong. Essentially, if you picked up knowledge from popular culture rather than a reliable source, it is likely not true. In fact, many mostly reliable sources get fooled at times as well. I am constantly running into bits of misinformation clogging my brain that have to be flushed out.
Also, “right and wrong” are not absolute binaries. Sometimes the “wrong” information may be oversimplified or lack appropriate nuance or context. It’s hard to boil down a complex scientific question to a one-line meme that can spread through popular culture, and reality is always way more complex than you think.
Here is one meme that deserves to be flushed out – the notion that people generally should drink eight glasses of water per day. This is not a particularly harmful piece of misinformation (although it is not completely benign), but it is a good object lesson on why we should be generally skeptical of simplistic medical advice.
The origin of the myth is known – in 1945 the U.S. Food and Nutrition Board determined that adults need 84.5 ounces of water per day to remain healthy. However, this advice became distorted. First, the next sentence was the acknowledgment that “most” of this water will come from food. About 20% of water intake comes from actual food. But also, most of the things we drink are mostly water. Even coffee is mostly water, and no, it will not dehydrate you because of the caffeine. The water intake is far greater than the mild diuretic effect.
I supposes to enhance communication, the 84.5 oz. became 64, because that can be translated into the 8×8 rule – eight glasses of eight ounces of water. And that was that – a misinterpreted statement became an enduring myth. But there is another layer also. This myth has been promoted by the bottled water industry. Obviously they have a vested interest in people drinking more of their product, and they didn’t invent the myth, but they have happily promoted it.
The 8×8 myth persists, despite the fact that it is widely debunked online by numerous reasonable sources. It is a favorite myth to debunk for many medical sites. But it also remains widely spread. What is true is, of course, more complex.
First it is worth pointing out that there is zero evidence for the recommendation of eight glasses of water per day. It is based on no scientific information. There is no evidence of health benefits from following this rule, or harm from ignoring it. Also, as you probably have guessed, reality is far more complex than this one generic recommendation. As has been pointed out by numerous sources for years – hydration needs vary tremendously from person to person. They depend on the kind and amount of food consumed, the size of the person, physiological and medical parameters, the environment, and physical activity.
This was all known based upon basic understanding of human physiology. A recent study, however, sought empirical evidence to back this up. They studied what they call “water turnover”, which is essentially how much water people require from all sources. Here is their summary:
Water intake requirements largely reflect water turnover (WT), the water used by the body each day. We investigated the determinants of human WT in 5604 people from the ages of 8 days to 96 years from 23 countries using isotope-tracking (2H) methods. Age, body size, and composition were significantly associated with WT, as were physical activity, athletic status, pregnancy, socioeconomic status, and environmental characteristics (latitude, altitude, air temperature, and humidity). People who lived in countries with a low human development index (HDI) had higher WT than people in high-HDI countries.
So, how can we know how much water we need to drink to stay well-hydrated? Fortunately, evolution has perfected a method over hundreds of millions of years – it’s called thirst. Here is some nuanced advice for most people: Drink when you are thirsty. Make sure that you have access to fluid so that you can drink when you are thirsty. This is especially true if you are going to be in a particularly dry or hot environment, or engage in activity that will make you sweat. In such situations you may want to pre-hydrate a bit because you can get dehydrated very quickly when you are not acclimated to them. You don’t have to drink pure water. Electrolyte drinks are good, and may even be preferred if you will not also be eating to replace electrolytes. Other sources of fluids are fine.
There are also specific medical conditions that may require people to either limit their fluid intake or drink more water than usual. If you have a history of kidney stones, for example, you will want to keep your urine pale. If you have any questions, speak to your doctor.
Is there any potential downside to overhydrating? Yes, although it is difficult to cause direct harm. You can overhydrate to the point that you dilute out your electrolytes, but it takes a lot of water to overwhelm your body’s homeostatic mechanisms. Drinking too much water can disturb your sleep because you may need to get up at night to urinate. This is not a trivial thing – chronically poor sleep has many medical downsides. Using lots of single-use plastic water bottles is also harmful for the environment.
But perhaps the greatest harm that I see in my practice is simply useless misinformation confusing and distracting people who want to live a healthy lifestyle. When a patient tells me they are trying to lead a healthier lifestyle then rattles off a list of things they are doing, most of the list is useless. This list often includes drinking eight glasses of water per day. I would rather they focus on the things that will actually improve their health, rather than being lulled by misinformation into a false sense of being healthy.
This myth also fosters a simplistic, and wrong, understanding of human physiology. It is hard to measure the harm of such things, but it’s not helpful.

Rehydrating with an appeal to nature
Scott Gavura on July 30, 2015
Link


I don’t tend to worry too much about hydration, except when I exercise. I’ve been running regularly for over 15 years, and since I started I’ve usually carried water, or for longer runs, I drink old-school Gatorade. The formulation is basic: sugar, salt, and potassium. There are hundreds of electrolyte products marketed for athletics, but I’ve been faithful to the original: It’s cheap, I don’t mind the taste (even when it’s warm), you can buy it nearly anywhere, and it’s the usual liquid (besides water) offered at races. After exercise, I rehydrate with plain water, preferring to get my electrolytes and carbohydrates from food, rather than a specialty beverage, some of which are “designed” to support rehydration after exercise. The science of sports and hydration is constantly evolving, and so is the marketing. I’m apparently an outlier by still running with Gatorade. New hydration products criticize Gatorade for being artificial and inferior, arguing that natural sources of hydration are better. There’s been an explosion of rehydration beverages, marketed both for everyday hydration and sport purposes. Coconut water was the first natural product to find fairly wide popularity as a sports-oriented beverage. Now you can find maple water, cactus water, watermelon juice and even artichoke water. Is “natural” hydration better that substitutes, including plain old water?
The science of hydration
The science of hydration, particularly during exercise, has come a long way since I started running in the nineties. When I took my first “how to run” clinic, there were a few mantras that reflected the prevailing wisdom: Dehydration is the enemy. Dehydration impairs performance. Dehydration can occur without you even noticing, so don’t trust thirst. Start hydrating before you become thirsty. Drink at every water station during a race.
These seem to still be generally accepted as truths, judging by the ubiquity of water bottles that we now lug everywhere. Hydration is an obsession, and not just when we exercise. We’re advised to drink a specific number of glasses of water per day, to counter hidden dehydration and flush out the toxins. Our hydration options have expanded too. Today you can buy water with added vitamins (and sugar) and popsicles “with added electrolytes”.
The most current science seems to suggest, perhaps unsurprisingly, that we may be taking our obsession with hydration a bit too far. Alex Hutchinson is my go-to source of knowledge on sport science (buy his book; I did) and he writes regularly on hydration and exercise. My own understanding on the current science of hydration in sports has changed, informed in part by scientists like Alex. Like many other fields, the evidence keeps emerging, but the current science-based approach seems to be as follows:
    • “Drink according to your thirst” seems to be the most practical approach to hydration. You don’t need to hydrate if you’re not thirsty. This advice is relevant to both day-to-day activities as well as athletics. There is no need to drink a specific amount of water per day, nor is there a requirement to drink constantly while you exercise.
    • Mild dehydration doesn’t appear to impair performance in endurance athletes.
    • Overhydration in sports, particularly in slower long-distance runners that may ignore the above, is a real risk. Overhydration combined with exercise can lead to hyponatremia (low sodium), which can be a serious medical issue.
    • In general, sugary beverages provide calories but not satiety, so they should be consumed in moderation. In most cases, water is probably the perfect beverage for hydration, exercise or otherwise.
    • For long-duration endurance sports, some carbohydrate (like sugar) may be helpful. While some electrolytes may be helpful, you don’t need your hydration beverage to contain vitamins. You generally don’t need to worry about carbohydrates and electrolytes during a soccer game or similar short sporting events.
When it comes to athletics, there’s a lot of interesting science that continues to challenge what we think we know about hydration. Researchers continue to explore the differences between thirst sensations, dehydration, and performance. Expectations about hydration, and thirst, may influence performance more than ones hydration status itself.
Is there such thing as magic water?
Given the current evidence, is there anything to suggest that any liquid has an advantage over another when used strictly for hydration? One way this has been examined is in treatment of dehydration, particularly diarrhea. In most cases, mild diarrhea is a bother. Severe, sustained diarrhea, however, particularly in children, can become life threatening without treatment. Diarrhea kills millions in the third world each year, mainly children under the age of 5. The treatment is simple, but not always available. The World Health Organization’s Oral Rehydration Solution (ORS), which is 6 level teaspoons of sugar and 1/2 level teaspoon of salt dissolved in 1 litre of water, is considered the optimal ratio of sugar and salt to support rehydration. Why sugar and salt in the water? It’s because plain water is not absorbed as well as a solution of salt and sugar. The concentration of sugar and sodium will impact on how effectively a beverage will hydrate. But does this matter in an athletic context?
You’re using coconuts!
From the grocery store to the yoga studio to the running club, coconut water is everywhere. There’s even a new beer (Sleeman Lift) that is brewed with coconut water and is labeled for the “performance focused”. Coconut water is positioned as a superior product for rehydration. The marketing and packaging rely heavily on the appeal to nature (like the photo above):
     1.  Coconut water naturally contains sugars and electrolytes.
     2.  Natural is better than unnatural.
     3.  Therefore coconut water is a better beverage choice.
Or is it?
Don’t confuse coconut water with coconut milk, which contains a lot of coconut “meat”, the white solid we might refer to simply as coconut. Coconut water is the 2-4 cups of fluid inside a young coconut, which declines as the “meat” grows. Depending on when the water is withdrawn, the electrolyte levels may vary, but have been reported in the following ranges [PDF]:
    • sodium 0.7-0.9 mEq/L
    • potassium 35-82 mEq/L
    • glucose 1.2-2.8 grams/L
    • calcium 5-17 mEq/L
    • magnesium 5-25 mEq/L
There are also small amounts of amino acids, vitamins and minerals present. Compared to a typical sports beverage like Gatorade, there’s more potassium, and less sodium and sugar. It also has no artificial colours or flavours. And unlike Gatorade, coconut water has even been directly injected into veins. Coconut water appears to be inferior for dehydration caused by diarrhea compared to solutions like the ORS. For exercise-induced dehydration, I found three relevant studies:
    • Coconut water was compared to a carbohydrate/electrolyte beverage, and plain water, in subjects who exercised in the heat. After exercise subjects drank 120% of their fluid loss. There was no significant difference in the amount of hydration achieved, electrolyte levels, or fluid balance.
    • Another study compared plain water, sports drink, coconut water, and sodium-enriched coconut water. Again, subjects exercised in the heat and then rehydrated with 120% of their fluid losses. Here, sports drink and both coconut waters rehydrated to a similar extent and all were slightly superior to water. The sodium-enriched coconut water was reported as better tolerated than other beverages.
    • In another study, coconut water was compared with sports drink and plain water, following exercise-induced dehydration. No significant differences were noted between groups.
So what’s best?
In most cases, you don’t need to over-think your hydration. Drink if you’re thirsty. Water is best in most circumstances. There’s no convincing evidence to suggest that coconut water is a superior beverage for hydration. Coconut water has no magical properties which will make you ski faster. Having said that, many love the taste of coconut water. As a low calorie option, it may be preferred by some over carbohydrate-containing sports drinks. Or you can stick with zero-calorie water, and rely on your food for carbohydrates and to replenish electrolytes.


Scaremongering to Sell Water Filters
San Diego Pure Water claims that our drinking water is dangerously contaminated with fluoride, but they’re probably trying to just drum up business selling water filters.
Steven Novella on November 7, 2012
Link

There is an obvious survival advantage to the emotion of disgust – we should fear putting unhealthy, tainted, contaminated, or poisonous substances into our bodies. Emotions, however, are a double-edged sword. They are an effective evolutionary mechanism for motivating creatures to engage in certain behavior, but they also tend to be crude and undiscriminating – inadequate to deal with our complex modern society.
A dispassionate consideration of objective scientific evidence is the optimal strategy for deciding on which foods and substances are safe to consume, but it is far easier to scare people about toxins than to reassure them with data. We see this frequently with the anti-vaccine movement, and also with anti-fluoridation attitudes. It is easy to scare people with the idea that there are “chemicals” in our drinking water.
One company, San Diego Pure Water, seems to have made such scaremongering into a marketing strategy. Their website is full of articles and videos claiming that fluoride is the “the greatest fraud that has ever been perpetrated.”
Let’s take a look at their specific claims.
What are they saying?
They claim:
Fluoride may lower a child’s IQ according to 24 independent studies that have reported an association between fluoride exposure and reduced IQ.
They don’t provide the 24 references, however. The notion that 24 studies support the claim that fluoridation reduces IQ is little more than an urban legend passing around anti-fluoride sites. If you follow the links, when present, they simply refer to other anti-fluoride sites making the same claims.
There are studies looking at the relationship between fluoride and IQ. A recent review and meta-analysis published by Harvard researchers actually reviewed 27 such studies. They concluded that there is a relationship between high fluoride exposure and lower IQ. However – the studies largely compared high levels of exposure that exceed EPA limits, to low levels of exposure that are at the level of fluoride added to some public water supplies and within the safety range set by the EPA.
So, if anything this meta-analysis demonstrated that the levels of fluoride in the US drinking water supply are safe and associated with a higher IQ.
Are they right?
Toxicity is always about dose. There is no evidence that the level of fluoride in US drinking water poses a significant health risk or lowers IQ. The quoted studies refer to higher levels of fluoride that are considered above the safe limit, and therefore their findings are not applicable to drinking water. Still, it may be effective marketing to use such studies to scaremonger about fluoride in order to sell water filters.
Another claim made on the site is that:
Fluoride accumulates in the body according to the National Research Council “it is apparent that fluorides interfere with brain functions,” and it adds to the formation of beta-amyloid deposits which are associated with Alzheimer’s.
They further argue that fluoride increases the uptake of aluminum by the brain, which causes Alzheimer’s dementia. The hypothesis that aluminum causes AD has been around for over 40 years without definitive evidence that it plays a significant role. The bottom line is similar as for fluoride – high levels of aluminum are certainly toxic, but there is no evidence that ordinary levels of everyday exposure pose any risk.
Conclusion: More disingenuous science from antifluoridation activists
We are exposed to countless substances in our food and water. At high concentrations any of them are potential toxins. There are a large number of animal and toxicology studies showing that fluoride, aluminum, mercury, and many other substances are toxic – this is not in dispute. This data, however, is not necessarily applicable to the levels of exposure from the environment, food, vaccines, or other relevant sources.
The amount of fluoride in particular in our drinking water is carefully regulated by the EPA and there is no evidence of any measurable toxic effects at this exposure level. In fact, the evidence often cited by anti-fluoridation activists shows that such low levels are, if anything, safe.

Monochloramines in Tap Water
Steven Novella on October 16, 2013
Link
I recently had a clogged drain requiring the services of a plumber. While discussing the details of the job, he took out brochures and a “fact sheet” prepared by his company explaining that my city tap water was going to kill me. Fortunately, they could provide a solution – a home-wide water filtration system.
The plumber seemed naively sincere, and genuinely fearful of the cancer-causing contaminants found in drinking water. He invited me to read through the material he provided while he unclogged by drain. I did better than that. I took the time to do a quick search for some more objective information on the topic.
Monochloramines
The focus of this particular scaremongering is the additive monochloramine, which is added to city water. According to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA):
Chloramines are disinfectants used to treat drinking water. Chloramines are most commonly formed when ammonia is added to chlorine to treat drinking water. The typical purpose of chloramines is to provide longer-lasting water treatment as the water moves through pipes to consumers. This type of disinfection is known as secondary disinfection. Chloramines have been used by water utilities for almost 90 years, and their use is closely regulated. More than one in five Americans uses drinking water treated with chloramines. Water that contains chloramines and meets EPA regulatory standards is safe to use for drinking, cooking, bathing and other household uses.
Chlorine is still used as a primary disinfectant for drinking water, but most systems switched to or added chloramines as secondary disinfectants because they do not dissipate quickly, and therefore are more effective. Also they produce fewer potentially-harmful byproducts than chlorine, and are therefore useful in meeting the new regulations about the levels of these byproducts.
Ozone, UV light, and chlorine dioxide are also used as primary disinfectants, usually at the water processing plant, not in the distribution system. Disinfectants are necessary to prevent waterborne diseases, like cholera and Legionnaires.
Disinfection byproducts (DBPs)
Of course, everything we do has potential risks and benefit. There is evidence to suggest that some DBPs have potential health risks, such as increasing the risk of cancer, anemia, low birth weight (but not other reproductive outcomes) and neurological symptoms.
As always, however, the dose makes the toxin. With questions of toxicity there are multiple lines of evidence, and we tend to see the same picture emerge over and over.
Toxicology studies look at the effects of the substance of concern on cell cultures. These often demonstrate toxic effects, and DBPs are no exception. Such studies, however, only show the toxic potential of substances, not what actually happens with human exposure. Direct exposure is likely to cause greater toxicity than what occurs in a living animal.
When considering actual toxicity, exposure, bioavailability, and detoxification need to be taken into consideration. While a substance may be toxic in a petri dish, it is not clear if will get to the target cells in a living animal in high enough doses to cause the same toxicity.
The next step is therefore animal studies. The purpose of such studies is not to see if a substance is toxic – everything it toxic in high enough dose – but rather to see the dose-response of toxicity. This information will then be extrapolated to humans (which is admittedly tricky) to develop safety limits on dose.
Human toxicity studies are rare because of ethical considerations. Therefore most human data is epidemiological – looking at exposure and outcomes out in the world (not in a controlled setting). This type of data can be tricky to interpret because of uncontrolled variables, but can provide reassurance that exposures are not associated with adverse outcomes.
The EPA uses all of this data to set safety limits on known DBPs, with a wide margin of safety in order to account for uncertainties in the data. Generally, levels of DBPs in drinking water are very low, and have been lowered over the years because of the use of chloramines and other techniques.
There are many DBPs, however, and it is possible that we have yet to discover all the possible DBPs that are forming in drinking water. Also, DBPs generally form as a reaction with organic contaminants in the water, and therefore the amount and type of such contaminants will alter the amount and type of DBPs that form.
Further, some DBP levels are regulated, while others are not. However, even unregulated DBPs are often still measured, and you can find this information about your local drinking water.
Another concern is that disinfectants can leach lead and copper out of pipes, increasing their levels in drinking water. These, however, are also measured and carefully regulated.
Conclusion
The brochure handed to me by my plumber contained all accurate information, much of it obviously copy-and-pasted from the EPA website. However, it was all cherry-picked with the obvious intent of scaring the average homeowner into thinking they will get cancer unless they buy an expensive filtration system.
The brochure mentioned that DBPs exist, they are potentially carcinogenic, there are some that are unregulated, and we may not have even discovered all the ones that exist. It further mentioned the leaching of lead and copper into the drinking water.
The brochure did not mention that monochloramines have been used for 90 years, that even unregulated DBPs are measured, that epidemiological evidence has not revealed any harm from DBPs, that monochloramines actually decrease their presence, and that the EPA carefully regulates and monitors their levels to keep them well below safety limits, with a wide margin to account for our current uncertainty in the scientific data.
I was also not given information on my local drinking water, information that is readily available online, and which shows that lead, copper, and DBP levels (regulated and unregulated) are well-below established safety limits.
There is also no information indicating that spending thousands of dollars on a home-wide water filtration system has any health or other benefits.
In short, I was given half the story – the scary half, with the clear intent on scaremongering into an expensive purchase. This was further justified using the precautionary principle – “shouldn’t we be safe, just in case?” Admittedly, where one draws the line with the precautionary principle is a bit subjective. Everyone can decide for themselves how much risk they are willing to take, and how much they are willing to spend to decrease potential risk.
Such decisions, however, should be made with full information, and in a proper context. It’s also useful to consider cost-effectiveness. How much money are you willing to spend to achieve what measure of risk reduction? Perhaps that money could be better spent somewhere else, and perhaps there is greater risk in the lost opportunity (for those of us without unlimited funds) from making a major purchase for dubious benefits.

Down the Virtual Rabbit Hole: Kangan water®
Mark Crislip on November 30, 2012
Link
The interwebs are more than a series of tubes, it has the power of endless distraction and tangents, a series of clickable rabbit holes that can drag you deeper and deeper into the alternative universes that are parallel with our own. One moment you can be on Science Based Medicine, grounded on the terra firma of reality, and then with a click of the mouse you can lose your way in the electronic warren.
It started as an advertisement on a skeptical website, perhaps SBM, perhaps not. The entrances to rabbit holes are Hogwartian in nature, never being in the same place twice. It is how I remember it.
Google serves up ads based on what their algorithm perceives as the content of the website. The algorithm lacks a certain, shall we say, nuance, and fails to understand that advertisements suggesting training in homeopathy or the promoting the practice of chiropractic may not have a close relationship to the content of Science Based Medicine. Still the ad did intrigue me, as it mentioned that the practitioner was Oregon’s only MD Acupuncturist. So I clicked.
“If I had a world of my own, everything would be nonsense. Nothing would be what it is, because everything would be what it isn’t. And contrary wise, what is, it wouldn’t be. And what it wouldn’t be, it would. You see?”
Not a particularly interesting site. Nothing special, the usual hodgepodge, and quite a complete hodgepodge, of alternative practices that have no basis in reality as I understand it. If you are a devotee of infection control and sterile technique you will just love the acupuncture photographs.
What I did find on the site were therapies and diseases about which I had never heard: Kangen Water® and Protozoan FL1953. I hate not knowing stuff. It makes my brain itch. So down the rabbit hole I go, a mouse click easier to follow that a tardy lagomorph, and less likely to be a source of tularemia.
Drink Me
Kangan® water is a registered trademark of Enagic and according to the website they make the real stuff, not like the water from the posers in Taiwan and Korea. What is Kangan® water? As best I can tell it is plain old water.
The water has been filtered, but so is the Culligan water at work, not that anyone needs bottled water when your source is the BullRun watershed.
The water has been subjected to electrolysis with the purpose of making the water more alkaline. I am many decades out of chemistry class but I vividly remember the demonstration of electrolysis from high school. The teacher put the electrodes in water and turned on the current and generated H2 on one probe and O2 on the other. He collected the gases in an Erlenmeyer flask and then, for reason that elude me, stuck a flame in one of the flasks. The flask exploded, send glass shooting across the room missing everyone, including my very surprised teacher. Sort of a Pulp Fiction divine intervention moment.
As best I can remember, and confirmed by the interwebs, electrolysis of water should yield a bit of acid at best and very little since at low voltage electrolysis in pure water is very inefficient. If all the electrolysis is done on an aliquot of water the net result should be nothing as any acid generated will be neutralized if shaken or stirred by the equivalent amount of base at the other electrode. I cannot find schematics of the Kangan® machine to see exactly how it would work. At over $3900 for a home machine I am unlikely to buy one so I can take it apart, although I do wonder: will it blend?
“Read the directions and directly you will be directed in the right direction.”
The cartoon schematic is confusing, at least as I remember my chemstiry: The H+, which is the acid, is an antioxidant that goes out the alkaline port while the OH-, which is the base, goes down the drain as an acid. Huh? I do not get it. The purpose of this treatment is to make alkaline water, with optimal pH between 8.5 −9.5 Given that the average pH of tap water in the US is 8.1, they do not have far to go.
“Curiouser and Curiouser”
The basic mechanisms by which alkaline water is beneficial is as follows:
`Twas brillig, and the slithy toves. Did gyre and gimble in the wabe; All mimsy were the borogoves. And the mome raths outgrabe.
Maybe that’s not it. There are evidently nouns and verbs that are placed in an order to suggest a description of reality. Or a reality. Not mine. Although I recently saw a vorpal sword used to kill some wooden soldiers.
Lets try another series of nouns and verbs and see of they make more sense.
Being in a acid state causes diseases, perhaps all diseases. We run towards the acid by eating acids and by the production of acids by pathogens. Drinking alkaline water will correct the acid state and restore health. Kangen water® has small clusters of 5 to 6 water molecules to make it is extra hydrating and it is an anti-oxidant. Alkaline water will raise the blood pH and make the water molecules smaller and get rid of free radicals. Really. A man in a white coat told me so.
“If any one of them can explain it …I’ll give him sixpence. I don’t believe there’s an atom of meaning in it.”
Wabe and outgrabe at least rhyme. One would think that collections of sciencey words would make for science, but it is not the case. As best I can tell from the alkaline water sites their understanding of chemistry and physiology is one frabjous tulgey.
Acid does not cause disease (lysergic excepted). Drinking alkaline water will correct no acidic state beyond neutralizing a bit of the hydrocholic acid in the stomach, water does not cluster. One of the remarkable results of physiology is how tightly some processes are regulated. Core temperature varies very little and blood pH even less. Drinking a couple of glasses of slightly alkaline water a day will do nothing and can do nothing except quench your thirst. And, once absorbed the ionized alkaline will not retain its pH or ionic state. The water becomes, or remains, water.
What can the water be used for? Everything. Flying Crane Acupuncture recommends Kangan water® for
cancer, auto-immune disorders, chemical sensitivities, GERD, allergies, candida, Lyme Disease, Biofilms, protozoan FL1953, fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue syndrome, insomnia, leaky gut syndrome, migraine headaches, multiple sclerosis, osteoporosis, psoriasis, sinusitis, and all people on the standard American diet.
There are innumerable testimonials as to the superiority of alkaline water. And we know how reliable water testimonials are.
Is there any clinical data to suggest the validity of any of the claims of alkaline water? Nope. Clinical trials? Nope. Biologic plausibility? Nope. Anything besides the glowing recommendations of the marketers of the machines and their users touting the benefits? Nope.
Color me unimpressed.
“Well, I never heard it before, but it sounds uncommon nonsense.”
Have you ever read a list and did a double take. I did when I saw the uses of Kangan water®. Good thing I wasn’t drinking the water when I did or my local environment would have become more alkaline. Protozoan FL1953. It is part of my job to know bugs, and while I cannot have seen or heard of every organism out there, I know the most of the ones that cause disease. I never heard of Protozoan FL1953. Off to Pubmed. I find… nothing. Oh. It has another name, Protomyxzoa rheumatica. Pubmed that and…nothing. Same on Google Scholar.
It turns out that only one person has information about this protozoan, Dr. Stephen Fry MD, who has discovered the organism and has the only diagnostic testing. He has yet to publish his findings, but he finds it as a potential cause for CFS, Fibromyalgia, Multiple Sclerosis, ALS, and Rheumatoid Arthritis, Morgellon’s and more (Start at 8:16).
According to Dr Fry he has discovered, using molecular analysis and stains, a protozoan in the blood of people with a large number of chronic inflammatory diseases. As I understand him the protozoan infection leads to immunosuppression and then a fungal super-infection. He has developed a diagnostic PCR, special stains and is working on antibiotic susceptibility testing.
“What is the use of repeating all that stuff, if you don’t explain it as you go on? It’s by far the most confusing thing I ever heard!”
There are few pictures of the protozoan that I can find. I have looked at a lot of microbes in my day. It looks like a red cell to me and nothing more. Other photographs are equally hard to identify as an organism: here and here. It all looks like artifact to me, but with no published information on the special stains, who can say? The beast can be grown in the lab and they have even sequenced the genome, both of which are very impressive accomplishments. I can’t grow Protozoan in our clinical labs. I have to send my Leshmania cultures to the CDC and genomic sequencing is not a trivial. The results of this work suggest it is a:
a slime forming complex protozoan, trying to become a helminth [parasitic worm], trying to become a worm… it’s progenitor with some ameba, or some protozoan in the past. But it is a little more complex than say, malaria or babesiosis genetically. Actually it is sort of in-between, again, a helminth and a malarial type organism.
An amazing discovery, especially given the marked differences between protozoans and helminths. Discovery of a new organism could change the approach to many patients. Just imagine those thousands techs and docs looking at millions of blood smears over the centuries and not seeing this organism, the ultimate gorilla in a basketball game. Unfortunately he can’t get this work published as “Look, this is too political, too new, really a radical concept.”
There are two issues about publishing. There is the description of a new pathogen: photos, cultures, genome. Then there is whether it causes disease: is it the next H. pylori or the next XMRV? The beauty of the Internet is you could benefit thousands of people by publishing on-line. I wait with great anticipation the announcement by Dr. Fry demonstrating the existence and pathogenicity of his new discovered protozoa.
“That’s nothing to what I could say if I chose.”
I suppose it may be best to avoid the path of that attention seeker Barry James Marshall with his publications in peer reviewed journals and grandstanding Nobel prize awarded for the discovery that gastritis and peptic ulcers are due to H. pylori. Who wants that kind of notoriety Which is a shame, since I can obviously neither confirm nor deny the Protozoan as a cause of disease or even as a new organism based on the published literature, or even information on the interwebs.
I have always been torn between the idea that those who discover something new be rewarded for their work and the concept that medical knowledge should be freely available for the benefit of everyone. I mostly favor the free spread of knowledge for the benefit of all, although interviews suggest the information is being kept proprietary pending patents.
But you can only click links for so long, the brain fogs over trying to incorporate all these alternative and new realities. New water, new protozoans.
“I think I should understand that better, if I had it written down: but I can’t quite follow it as you say it.”
So true Alice.

Alkaline Water Surges Despite Lack of Evidence
Alkaline water is pure BS – there is no plausibility to the claims of any health benefits, and what evidence we have is negative. Its popularity grows despite this.
Steven Novella on October 31, 2018
Link

From The Guardian:
According to data from the Beverage Marketing Corporation, a research and consultancy group, the alkaline water market has grown from being a $47m business in 2014 to a $427m business in 2017. It’s projected to be worth $687m by the end of 2018.
Over this same time there has been a slew of popular scientific articles explaining exactly why alkaline water, or an alkaline diet, is pseudoscience (including right here). The basic science is pretty straightforward, and even a grade-school understanding is enough to conclude that alkaline water is snake oil.
From a chemical point of view, an acid is any molecule that can donate a proton or accept an electron pair in a reaction. A base (something that is alkaline) is the opposite – it can accept a proton or donate an electron pair. Acids and bases therefore neutralize each other. The measure of how acidic/basic a substance is is pH, with 7 being neutral, <7 being acidic, and > 7 being basic. This is also a logarithmic scale, so a pH of 5 is ten times more acidic than a pH of 6.
Water (H2O) usually has a neutral pH, but water dissociates into H and OH ions. Hydrogen ions are acidic, and OH ions are basic. The number of such ions in pure water is usually small, partly because they react with each other to form back into H2O. So what is alkaline water? Real alkaline water has something in it to make it basic, such as baking soda. Some products claim to alkalinize water electrically, but again any ions in the water will quickly neutralize themselves – pure water will always tend toward a pH of 7.
Now here is where the real pseudoscience comes in – the notion that you can benefit your health by eating or drinking alkaline food or water. The claim is that the when the body becomes too acidic this causes a host of health problems, and you can fix them by simply balancing the acidity with alkaline water. The problem with this claim is that it is extremely misleading.
The body maintains a very narrow pH (7-7.4), which is the range at which the chemical reactions that keep us alive are optimal. If the pH strays outside this range, you will indeed become acutely ill. For this reason animals have evolved a host of powerful mechanisms to keep the blood and tissues within this very narrow pH. For example, our kidneys will produce urine that is more or less acidic to help balance pH.
Also, since carbon dioxide is acidic, we can maintain a specific pH in the blood just by varying how much we breathe and blow off CO2. In fact, our respiratory rate is determined primarily by the amount of CO2 in the blood – not oxygen. The concentration of CO2 can be adjusted moment to moment, and of course occurs involuntarily without our conscious input.
These mechanisms for maintaining a narrow range of pH (in a healthy person) overwhelm the effect of whatever you eat or drink. The only exception to this are serious acute medical conditions that affect pH, or consuming poisons that affect your pH. Consuming regular food and liquids, regardless of their pH, will simply not affect the pH of your body. Therefore the entire premise of an alkaline diet or alkaline water is pure BS, nothing but pseudoscience.
Despite this utter lack of plausibility, there has been some study of the health effects of an alkaline diet (but not much). A 2016 systematic review of the evidence for an alkaline diet for the prevention or treatment of cancer concluded:
Despite the promotion of the alkaline diet and alkaline water by the media and salespeople, there is almost no actual research to either support or disprove these ideas. This systematic review of the literature revealed a lack of evidence for or against diet acid load and/or alkaline water for the initiation or treatment of cancer. Promotion of alkaline diet and alkaline water to the public for cancer prevention or treatment is not justified.
A 2011 systematic review of alkaline diet for preventing osteoporosis found:
A causal association between dietary acid load and osteoporotic bone disease is not supported by evidence and there is no evidence that an alkaline diet is protective of bone health.
The bone health claim was based on the acid ash hypothesis that the acidity of the diet affects calcium loss from the bones. But this hypothesis is also wrong:
There is no evidence from superior quality balance studies that increasing the diet acid load promotes skeletal bone mineral loss or osteoporosis. Changes of urine calcium do not accurately represent calcium balance. Promotion of the “alkaline diet” to prevent calcium loss is not justified.
I found one exception to the conclusion that there is no plausible benefit from drinking alkaline water, and that is for acid reflux. While a benefit is far from well established, this is the only claim that is at all plausible. Using antacids to acutely treat acid reflux, to buffer the acid in the stomach, does make sense, although the effects should only be very short term. Drinking alkaline water could work just like taking a Mylanta, and there is some evidence to support that.
However – there are no studies of actual efficacy in humans. There is therefore no reason to recommend or use alkaline water for acid reflux over well-established effective treatments.
Therefore – there is no plausibility at all to the claims that alkaline food or water has any general health effect, and in fact there are good reasons from basic biology to conclude that there should be no health effect from adjusting the pH of what you eat (of course, except avoiding strong acids or bases that can burn tissue). Alkaline water is pure snake oil.
Why, then, is the popularity of this snake oil on the rise? As is a common theme here at SBM, there is a triumph of marketing over science and reason. This also represents the power of celebrity over evidence. Celebrities like Tom Brady and Beyonce have been touting the benefits of alkaline water. Add in a little placebo effect, and the public is easy to convince that almost anything works.
There also appears to be something psychologically appealing to magic water. Water has a reputation for being wholesome and healthful, partly because it is essential for life. We are attracted to the notion of pure water, and repulsed by water that is foul or contaminated. These emotions would have an obvious survival advantage in the wild. Pushing these emotions just a little gives us extra-wholesome water with magical healing properties. For this reason there are all sorts of magic water products on the market, and there probably always will be.

Deadly Alkaline Water Case Highlights Problems with Bottled Water Regulations
Bottled water can be convenient, and sometimes necessary, but it is unfortunately not always as safe as it should be. A recent case of toxic alkaline water hospitalizing several people, and killing one woman, shines a spotlight on problems with regulation of the industry.
Clay Jones on September 3, 2021
Link

This will be a brief post compared to my typical efforts, but one that highlights an important issue: the safety of bottled drinking water in the United States. Most of us drink bottled water, with many doing so every day. It is a convenient but expensive choice with the unfortunate environmental downsides of increased plastic waste and a larger carbon footprint, but one which I must admit that I make when I arrive at work most mornings.
I grab a bottle of sparkling water as I pass by the cafe near the entrance to my hospital because of convenience and a preference for bubbles, not because I’m worried about the water coming out of the drinking fountains. There is, however, a false belief held by many in America that tap water is less safe than the bottled variety, particularly among minority households. This is sadly understandable given the events that occurred in Flint a few years ago.
The market for these products is competitive and companies have developed a variety of shady promotional techniques in order to grab our attention. This often comes in the form of appeals to nature, with implications that natural spring water, for example, is somehow better than what comes out of the tap. But many bottled water products, despite pictures on the labels depicting pristine woodland creeks and snow laden mountain ranges, are sourced from municipal water supplies.
Bottled water marketed as “live” or “raw” is perhaps the worst example of this tactic. After all, what’s more natural than unfiltered water straight from the crick? (It has a lovely finish, and am I picking up a hint of bear shit?) But it’s all risk and no benefit with a hefty price tag. But don’t take my word for it.
Bottled water products also frequently contain additives such as vitamins and minerals, and are promoted with claims of health benefits beyond what would be expected from consuming plain water such as “ultimate powerful hydration” and “optimum health“. Smartwater, the popular Coca-Cola Company subsidiary and Golden Windbag award winner, along with many of their competitors, sells bottled water that contains antioxidants using the following marketing copy:
every drop of smartwater antioxidant tastes pure and will leave you feeling refreshed. it’s everything you want from a bottled water—pure, hydrating, and crisp.
it might be thanks to the fact that it’s vapor–distilled through a process inspired by the clouds. or the fact that we’ve added electrolytes for taste and infused each bottle with antioxidant selenium. either way, you can bet on a premium water experience with every bottle.
healthy hydration for healthy living. smartwater antioxidant is a smart way to hydrate.
So many weasel words! It’s brilliantly designed to separate the worried and thirsty from their money using sexy buzzwords like “pure”, “premium”, “healthy”, and…”vapor-distilled”? Kidding aside, the geniuses at smartwater don’t need to make specific health claims which might run them afoul of regulatory agencies. They know that consumers will fill in the details and believe that somehow this product will improve the function of their immune system. It doesn’t, at least not any more so than regular tap water.
Another example of the kind of bogus health claims being used to promote some bottled water products is so-called “oxygen water”. These products claim to improve recovery from exercise or injury and to detoxify the body. But, as our own Scott Gavura explained in his post on this particular form of snake oil, you can’t breath through your stomach. And, kidding aside, even if a bit of extra oxygen were somehow absorbed through the GI tract it wouldn’t matter because it pales in comparison to the amount in a single breath.
Smartwater doesn’t stop with antioxidants, however. Like many other producers of bottled water, they also sell a line of alkaline waters. They avoid making any specific claims regarding health benefits from consuming their water, which is “ionized to 9+pH”, but others aren’t shy about going there despite a complete lack of basic science plausibility and legitimate clinical evidence.
One of these other brands is, or rather was, Real Water. Its Nevada-based manufacturer, Real Water Inc., claimed that their alkaline water could reduce blood glucose levels, lower cholesterol, improve metabolic function, treat acid reflux, increase longevity, improve bone health, and get rid of those pesky free radicals. And naturally, according to the manufacturer, it tasted amazing. But after allegedly killing a 60-year-old woman and some pets, and hospitalizing a bunch of people, including 5 kids, they were forced to shut down by the FDA in June:
The consumption of “Real Water” brand alkaline water was the only known common link between five cases of acute liver failure in children that occurred in November and December 2020 that was reported to the FDA in March. Since then, 11 additional cases of acute non-viral hepatitis in adults, including one death of a woman with underlying medical conditions, have been identified as possibly linked to the consumption of Real Water brand alkaline water.
So what happened? Real Water was Las Vegas municipal tap water that was filtered and processed with lye, potassium bicarbonate, and magnesium chloride. An investigation is underway, so details may change, but it appears that there was very little quality control. One former employee admitted to essentially just adding random amounts of chemicals to the water and the company was cited for “failing to develop a written food safety plan, to clean and sanitize equipment, to sample and test cleaning solutions, and to list all ingredients on bottles”. They were also observed by investigators using potentially toxic detergents and sanitizers to clean reusable containers that were sold to consumers.
Why was this allowed to happen? Sadly, the regulation of bottled water, under the jurisdiction of the FDA, is lacking. They talk a good game, however:
For bottled water production, bottlers must follow the (current good manufacturing practice) regulations put in place and enforced by FDA. Water must be sampled, analyzed, and found to be safe and sanitary. These regulations also require proper plant and equipment design, bottling procedures, and record keeping.
In addition, FDA oversees inspections of bottling plants. The agency inspects bottled water plants under its general food safety program and has states perform some plant inspections under contract. (Some states also require bottled water firms to be licensed annually.)
But here is the problem:
FDA protects consumers of bottled water through the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FD&C Act), which makes manufacturers responsible for producing safe, wholesome, and truthfully labeled food products.
As with the regulation of dietary supplements and herbal remedies, the onus of proving that bottled water is safe is on the manufacturer. The FDA simply does not have the resources to do it themselves. Large companies with well known brands are unlikely to put out a dangerous product but there are many small and niche producers that come and go every year with less incentive to play by the rules. Unfortunately, again as with supplements and herbs, it sometimes takes people being harmed or even killed before the FDA steps in and shuts production down.
        ◦ There are plenty of reasons to reduce bottled water consumption from an environmental perspective. I’m personally going to continue buying my favorite flavored seltzer at work, but I also refill a water bottle from my tap at home to bring to the gym for several weeks, cleaning it every few days, before buying a new one. When it comes to safety, I would recommend sticking to established brands and avoiding water that comes with health related claims other than quenching thirst and hydration, but not ultimate hydration, whatever that even means.

Hydrogen Water Is Not “the New Nutrient;” Health Claims Are Hype, Not Science.
A new fad, drinking hydrogen water, claims to provide all kinds of health benefits. The scientific evidence isn’t there.
Harriet Hall on October 8, 2019
Link

Hydrogen water? Good grief! There are already two atoms of hydrogen in every molecule of water (H2O). They are not talking about that; they mean molecular hydrogen, the gas formed by two atoms of hydrogen (H2). Hydrogen is the most abundant element in the universe, constituting 75% of all baryonic mass. Hydrogen gas is highly combustible: remember the Hindenburg disaster? It is not medicine.
A Fox news story reports that celebrities like Blake Lively, Ryan Reynolds, and Zac Efron have adopted the fad of drinking hydrogen water. It explains that there are many health claims, but “There really isn’t enough scientific evidence to support the claims that hydrogen water has any benefits over plain tap water.” It’s expensive: about $3 a serving. And it deteriorates rapidly: when hydrogen water is exposed to air, the concentration of hydrogen soon returns to the amount in tap water.
Recommended by questionable marketers
Who is recommending it? Dr. Perricone, for one. He is a dermatologist who bills himself as “the original healthy aging expert.” He “believes that the hydrogen molecule marks a revolutionary milestone in total health and well-being.” Dr. Perricone is selling his own hydrogen water at $3 for a single-serving can. He is not a reliable source of scientific information; an article on Quackwatch demolishes his questionable, unverifiable, and erroneous statements and characterizes his advice as creative salesmanship rather than science.
Do-it-yourself
You can buy a machine to make your own hydrogen water at home. Amazon sells the Lourdes Hydrogen Water Generator at a reduced price of $1,150. You can even buy a tablet, Rejuvenation H2, that you can drop in a glass of water to create your own hydrogen water. The tablets cost a dollar each. According to their website, hydrogen water is the most promising anti-aging supplement on the market. It is “the new nutrient.” You should supplement daily with Hydrogen Rich Water. It combats oxidative stress, inflammation, and insulin resistance. It enhances athletic performance and protects the brain from long-term deterioration. It aids in weight loss, enhances moods, and promotes longevity.
Where’s the evidence?
They claim that 1,200+ studies affirm health benefits of molecular hydrogen. Really? I couldn’t find them. Research supposedly started just 12 years ago when a team of Japanese researchers discovered that inhaled hydrogen gas could act as an antioxidant and protect from free radicals. Hydrogen dissolved in water is effective with 1/100th the dose of inhaled hydrogen, and it is effective in some scenarios where inhaled hydrogen had no effect. There have been 65 human clinical trials and benefit has been shown for over 170 disease models.
Where are those “1,200+ studies”? Where are those 65 human clinical trials? I couldn’t find much research at all. I found one small (10 subjects) placebo-controlled pilot study that tested oxidative stress markers in athletes after intense exercise. It found that “Adequate hydration with hydrogen-rich water pre-exercise reduced blood lactate levels and improved exercise-induced decline of muscle function.” It did not find any meaningful clinical benefit for athletes, much less any health benefits for the average person.
A small controlled study found that hydrogen-rich water raised blood pH slightly in healthy volunteers. Do you want your blood pH raised? I don’t. One advocate claims that “a very slight decrease in pH can lead to fatigue and decrease in physical performance.” Not true. This belief ties into the acid/alkaline theory of disease, which is nonsense.
A preliminary study of soft tissue injuries in athletes found that oral hydrogen-rich tablets produced a higher plasma viscosity and faster recovery.
One study found improvements in cholesterol markers for “potential” metabolic syndrome. Another small studysuggested that hydrogen-rich water “may have improved mood and anxiety and reduced activity of the sympathetic nervous system at rest.”
These were all preliminary or pilot studies that have never been replicated and are not supported by better evidence from larger studies. There were several positive studies in test tubes and lab rats, but we have no way of knowing whether this data translates to human benefits.
Conclusion: Hydrogen water is just expensive water with unproven health claims
There are many health claims for hydrogen water, but the scientific evidence hasn’t established that it is any healthier than regular water, and it is ridiculously expensive. I remain skeptical and will continue drinking tap water.

Gold Water, Silver Water, Copper Water
Ayurveda recommends gold water, silver water, and copper water to treat various conditions. There is no evidence that they work or even that they contain gold, silver, or copper.
Harriet Hall on October 16, 2018
Link


From Kangen water to oxygenated water, there are enough pseudoscientific and quacky water offerings to fill an entire website devoted to water-related pseudoscience, fantasy, and quackery. That resource covers ionized water, alkaline water, oxygenated waters, energized water, structured water, magnetized water, and even weirder stuff. Well worth a visit. The crackpottery boggles the mind.
It doesn’t seem to mention gold water. Or silver water. Or copper water. These are far from new, but I just recently became aware of them. It seems they are an old Ayurvedic thing. I didn’t know what Ayurveda was when I graduated from medical school. If I had gone to naturopathy school, I would have known: their major textbook devotes a whole chapter to it. They also teach homeopathy. I’m glad I chose medical school. I’m convinced reality is the best medicine.
The alleged health benefits
An Ayurveda website explains the “health benefits of gold water”:
Gold is not only beautiful but has divine properties that can assist in maintaining balanced health. It is also heating and so should be used in caution in conditions with excess heat. The health benefits of gold water:
    • Strengthens the nervous system
    • Improves memory and intelligence
    • Increases stamina
    • Beneficial in Arthritis
    • Asthma
    • Breathlessness
It goes on to explain the health benefits of silver water:
    • Antiseptic properties
    • Increases strength and stamina
    • Beneficial in emaciation
    • Antibacterial properties
    • Useful in heartburn and fevers
    • Beneficial in Inflammation and Menorrhagia
    • Works as a Disinfectant
And copper water:
    • Obesity
    • Liver and spleen disorders
    • Joint issues
    • Polio
    • Hypertension
    • High cholesterol
    • Stress and mental tension
    • Paralysis
    • Benefits the nervous and circulatory system
    • Aids in bone health
Finally, it explains how to prepare these waters by boiling pure gold, silver, or copper with water and straining. It recommends taking two teaspoons of this water daily for maximum benefits. This couldn’t possibly work: these metals are not soluble in water, only in acid.
Another website explains that “The electronic energy of gold will enter the water during this process.” And it explains that “Milk can be preserved by putting silver coins in it since it kills pathogens.” And:
Copper makes the water ionic which helps to maintain body’s pH (acid-alkaline) balance. Ayurveda advises to keep drinking water in a copper jug in the night and drink it in the morning. This is called tamra jal. This tamra jal will prevent you from all the three doshas: Kapha, Vata, and Pitta.
All that is nonsense, and since those doshas are imaginary, I don’t think I need protecting from them.
The evidence
There is no scientific evidence to support the health claims for gold, silver, or copper water. There are grains of truth behind the myths. Silver ions kill bacteria in vitro but ingesting silver only creates smurfs. Gold was an effective treatment for rheumatoid arthritis, but only if it was injected. Copper is an essential trace element, but it is supplied by the diet; copper deficiency is rare and is treated by copper supplements, not copper water.
Conclusion: Superstition, not science
There is no reason to use gold water, silver water, or copper water. In fact, there is no gold, silver, or copper in them: these metals don’t dissolve in water. The whole idea is a fantasy. The recommendations are from Ayurveda and are based on ancient superstitions, not modern scientific evidence.

“Raw water”: The latest dangerous “natural health” fad
In pseudoscience, appeals to nature are everywhere. It’s not surprising, then, that there is profit to be made selling “raw” (i.e., untreated) water at very high prices for its nonexistent health benefits, those benefits all claimed to be due to the “naturalness” of the water. I can’t help but note that cholera, Giardia, amoebic dysentery, and a wide variety of waterborne illnesses prevented by modern water treatment techniques are all very, very “natural.”
David Gorski on January 1, 2018
Link

As an old year fades into its final days and a new year approaches, I always wonder what new quackery will make an appearance. I know, of course, that all the old quackeries, antivaccine pseudoscience, homeopathy, naturopathy, reflexology, cancer quackery,and the huge number of other variations on self-deception will still be there. I also know that, when it comes to pseudoscience, there is rarely anything truly new under the sun, but I do like to contemplate what previously neglected bit of nonsense will come to prominence in 2018.
Thanks to The New York Times the other day, I might know. It’s variant of many forms of pseudoscience based on the fallacy of an appeal to nature (i.e., that if it’s “natural” it must be better, safer, and healthier, and that many of humanity’s health most intractable health issues are due to the products of modernity, such as industry and pesky public health measures that protect against disease, such as vaccines, pure water, and pasteurization), but it’s also yet another variety of a common form of nonsense that I like to refer to as water woo. Over the years here at SBM, we’ve written about alkaline water, oxygen water, Kangan water, and water cluster quackery. And of course we’ve written extensively about the pseudoscience and conspiracy theories demonizing water fluoridation more times than I care to remember. It’s not for nothing that I like to make frequent Dr. Strangelove references.
Think of this particular form of fashionable nonsense as being the ultimate in water woo. Basically, the idea is that any treatment of water is bad, that you must drink the water untreated and unfiltered from the source, whatever that “natural” source might be:
At Rainbow Grocery, a cooperative in this city’s Mission District, one brand of water is so popular that it’s often out of stock. But one recent evening, there was a glittering rack of it: glass orbs containing 2.5 gallons of what is billed as “raw water” — unfiltered, untreated, unsterilized spring water, $36.99 each and $14.99 per refill, bottled and marketed by a small company called Live Water.
“It has a vaguely mild sweetness, a nice smooth mouth feel, nothing that overwhelms the flavor profile,” said Kevin Freeman, a shift manager at the store. “Bottled water’s controversial. We’ve curtailed our water selection. But this is totally outside that whole realm.”
Here on the West Coast and in other pockets around the country, many people are looking to get off the water grid.
Start-ups like Live Water in Oregon and Tourmaline Spring in Maine have emerged in the last few years to deliver untreated water on demand. An Arizona company, Zero Mass Water, which installs systems allowing people to collect water directly from the atmosphere around their homes, began taking orders in November from across the United States. It has raised $24 million in venture capital.
Reading about this new craze, I couldn’t help but think of two things. My first thought was: Damn, is that water expensive at $14.80 a gallon for the first “orb” and $6.00 a gallon for a refill! Yes, I know that bottled water can be more expensive on a per-gallon basis than a refill of Live Water, depending upon where you buy it (e.g., a sports stadium or concert hall), but this is still some expensive water. My second thought was that this reminded me very much of “raw milk.” As regular readers probably know, the same sorts of arguments are used for raw milk, namely that the usual treatment of milk used to decrease the risk of milk-borne infections to nearly zero (Pasteurization) somehow robs the milk of its taste, nutrition, and “vitality.” Whether raw milk “tastes better” or not, I do not know, never having tried it, but I do know that drinking raw milk increases the risk of potentially serious food-borne illness, as has been extensively documented. Personally, I always wondered if these same people also eat uncooked pork and chicken.
Let’s leave aside the issue of fluoridation and concentrate just on the claims for “raw water” for a moment. Fluoridation is a subset of “contamination” fear that we’ve written about extensively, particularly how fluoridation as practiced today is both safe and effective as a public health means to decrease the risk of dental caries but has been the subject of conspiracy theories at least since the time of Dr. Strangelove over 50 years ago. Let’s see what sort of health claims are made for raw water:
What adherents share is a wariness of tap water, particularly the fluoride added to it and the lead pipes that some of it passes through. They contend that the wrong kind of filtration removes beneficial minerals. Even traditional bottled spring water is treated with ultraviolet light or ozone gas and passed through filters to remove algae. That, they say, kills healthful bacteria — “probiotics” in raw-water parlance.
Yes, when water is improperly treated, the lead pipes still found in some older cities can lead to the leeching of lead into the water. Flint, a city in my own state, made national headlines for that very problem less than two years ago, and the problem still hasn’t been resolved. Of course, what the NYT article lists as health claims for this water are a bit less…extravagant…than what the actual sellers of this water claim. For instance, I wandered over to the Live Water website, and one of the first claims that greeted me was this:
The earth constantly offers the purest substance on the planet as spring water. We celebrate this ancient life source that humanity flourished from, since the beginning of our existance. [sic] We trust it’s perfect just the way it is.
“We trust it’s perfect just the way it is” basically because it’s “natural.” Also notice the distinct tinge of primitive vitalism in the claims made for this water, which is portrayed as an “ancient life source.” That vitalism is made even more explicit in multiple Instagram posts like this one:

We don’t manufacture fresh #livingspringwater ❄️ Our earth provides us this ancient source of #medicine in a complex cycle, far greater than anything we can ever fully comprehend ⛈ We are indeed honored to offer the first ever solution for #livewater conveniently delivered in chilled reusable glass 💎 Now we’re delighted to offer an easy to carry glass for water, smoothies, and tea with our stylish insulated #organiccotton bags 🛸
A post shared by Līve Water (@livespringwater) on Dec 18, 2017 at 11:48am PST
“Our earth provides us this ancient source of #medicine in a complex cycle, far greater than anything we can ever fully comprehend”? This sounds more like magic and mysticism than anything scientific, as does this:

Water is the universal force that connects all life Since our planet and bodies are made up primarily of water this is the medium through which our collective consciousness evolves As we learn once again to honor where we have come from the earth will teach us how to move in harmony with its natural rhythms and cycles As we listen to the great wisdom of our ancestors and of the indigenous tribal cultures we will once again find our correct inner spirits The More we humans align ourselves with nature the more successful we will become as a species Do you honor your body temple with fresh spring water straight from source? #golive #livewater #youarewhatyoudrink
A post shared by Līve Water (@livespringwater) on Dec 26, 2017 at 1:46pm PST
Also, you don’t need to refrigerate it, just to keep it cool and consume it within one lunar cycle:

Common question- Why don’t we offer 5 gallon glass jugs anymore? 🧐 After a handful of customers reported heavy and hard to handle 5 gallon jugs busting in kitchens, switching to 2.5 gallon glass jugs was the only safe solution🚰 Our #custom #leadfree #floweroflife jugs just happen to be easier to maneuver and stackable as well ⏳ Common question- Why do we refrigerate our #livespringwater from the moment it goes into glass till it’s delivered? 🤔 Since our water isn’t sterilized like all other spring water companies, the naturally occurring probiotic microbes in our water, would go green in hot storage conditions🍵 Common question- Does the water need to get refrigerated after delivery? ❄️ Most homes don’t reach the 110 degrees Fahrenheit most trucks and warehouses do in summer. 🔥 Store your #livewater in a cool dark space and enjoy it within one lunar cycle for super freshness ⛈
A post shared by Līve Water (@livespringwater) on Nov 26, 2017 at 6:42pm PST
Then there’s the sorts of things Mukhande Singh, founder of Live Water, says, as in this quote from the NYT article:
Pure water can be obtained by using a reverse osmosis filter, the gold standard of home water treatment, but for Mr. Singh, the goal is not pristine water, per se. “You’re going to get 99 percent of the bad stuff out,” he said. “But now you have dead water.”
He said “real water” should expire after a few months. His does. “It stays most fresh within one lunar cycle of delivery,” he said. “If it sits around too long, it’ll turn green. People don’t even realize that because all their water’s dead, so they never see it turn green.”
See what I mean? To people like Singh, if you treat the water you’re “killing” it. You’re robbing it of its “vital essence.” Of course, I don’t want my water to turn green; that rather suggests to me that there are too many organisms in it.
I will admit that the bottles are quite pretty, although I could do without photos of Singh that look like this:

A post shared by Līve Water (@livespringwater) on Jan 16, 2016 at 9:42pm PST
Note the flowing locks, the levitating nakedness, the concentrated woo. At least he kept most of his clothes on for the photo in the NYT article.
Next up:
Shocking but true– All other filtered and even bottled spring waters are sterilized with UV light, ozone gas, and a sub micron filter. This is similar to how most juice and dairy products are pasteurized for shelf stability. Unfortunately this sterilization destroys beneficial sources of minerals and probiotics.
I can’t help but notice a dig at a potential competitor, as the first link goes to a page on the Mountain Valley Spring Water Company website discussing how its water complies with FDA regulations for filtering and purification. The second link goes to a page on David Williams’ website that claims that chlorinated drinking water is “toxic” to gut bacteria, as are “sterilized” (i.e., pasteurized) foods and a wide variety of other “unnatural” things, including vaccinations. I also note that “Dr.” David Williams is not a physician. He is a chiropractor with “multiple bachelor’s degrees, a Doctor of Chiropractic from Texas Chiropractic College, and research projects at the University of Houston, University of Texas at San Antonio, and Rice University.” There’s not a lot about vaccines on his website, but he does clearly believe that vaccines somehow “damage” the gut bacteria, with detrimental health consequences to infants and children. He also thinks that you should not get the flu shot every year, claiming:
Vaccines deliver either live or dead viruses directly into your body tissue, short-circuiting your body’s normal front-line immune defense system in your respiratory passageways and mucous membrane linings. If your immune system is weak or out of balance when the virus is introduced this way, you could have serious health consequences.
Also, there are controversial additives that have been used for years in seasonal flu shots. The most well known is thimerosal, a mercury-based preservative that has been associated with brain and immune system dysfunction. The majority of flu shots each contain 25 mcg of this toxin.
Yes, Dr. Williams is not only a chiroquack, but he is antivaccine, claiming that “about the only thing flu vaccines are truly good for is lining the pockets of bio-pharmaceutical companies.” Let’s just put it this way. If Live Water thinks Mr. Williams is a good source of medical information about anything, it makes me question its other claims, and there are quite a few.
One example is this:
Microbes outnumber human cells in the body 10 fold. There are more nerve endings in our bellies than in our brains and there’s a constant battle between good and bad bacteria. The micro biome of our gut produces about 95% of the serotonin and 50% of the dopamine in our brains. Anxiety, weight gain, fatigue, and countless other ailments are linked to an imbalance of proper gut bacteria. Living spring water is the key to unlocking a perfect micro-biome balance.
The probiotics listed here are exclusive to our unsterilized water. There could be countless other benificial [sic] microbes present, scientists just haven’t discovered yet. They are imperative for optimal physical and mental health. Without these probiotics we’re not able to fully assimilate all the nutrients in our food. Beneficial bacteria are also proven to have abilities to transform harmful bacteria. Here is a published medical report proving raw spring water has vast healing abilities.
I don’t know about you, but there’s nothing like a link to Pinterest showing all sorts of microbiome memes maintained by the company to persuade me. As for the report, I was struck at one result not reported that is generally considered critical to determining if water is pure: The level of coliform bacteria (E. coli, and other bacteria commonly found in feces, certain strains of which can cause disease). As for the rest, Live Water reports levels of bacteria ranging from 1,310 CFU/mL for Pseudomonas putida to 11,640 CFU/mL for Pseudomonas oleovorans. (CFU=colony forming unit, which is a measure of the number of viable bacteria per volume of water.) This struck me as rather high, and indeed the maximal bacterial level for potable drinking water as regulated by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Drinking Water Safety Act is 50,000 CFU/100 mL or 500 CFU/mL. Granted, these bacteria are generally nonpathogenic, but one has to wonder how careful Live Water is with regards to preventing fecal coliforms to creep in during the bottling process. Also, as the World Health Organization points out, bacterial counts can increase even at 5° C.
As for the purported health benefits of the bacteria found in a spring, Live Water cites a study that is—shall we say?—far more speculative than it is informative. Yes, the authors found a variety of bacteria in a spring near Comano, Italy, but the evidence for the health effects of these bacteria is basically a lot of handwaving. As for the bit about beneficial bacteria “transforming” harmful bacteria, let’s just say that a link to the Wikipedia entry on phage therapy is not a convincing argument. Yes, viruses known as bacteriophages can transform and, in some cases, kill bacteria, but this is not an argument that Live Water has health benefits.
Regarding one of the other water sellers mentioned, I can’t help but note that Zero Mass is a system costing “$4,000 plus tax, delivery and installation” that isolates water by condensing water from the humidity in the air using solar power. Its makers claim it can work in areas of low humidity. There’s nothing wrong with this, as far as I’m concerned, but it’s also silly to lump this system in with purveyors of “natural” water. Given that this system runs the water through a cartridge that adds magnesium, calcium, and other minerals to the water, as well as filtering out pollutants, I fail to see how this water is any more “natural” than standard treated water.
I’ve concentrated mainly on bacteria, of course, because that’s the most obvious problem with the raw water movement, that untreated water can harbor disease. However, they are not the only problems with raw water. I also can’t help but note that one big booster of the “raw water” movement is Doug Evans, who moved rapidly to raw water after his business selling a $400 raw juicer Juicero shut down.
I can’t help but think that those of us living in developed nations are so wrapped up in our little cocoons of technology that we forget that in much of the world potable water is not a given—nowhere near it. Waterborne disease is still very common, with waterborne diarrheal diseases responsible for 2 million deaths each year, with the majority occurring in children under 5. As for those advocates claiming that raw water is more “natural” and “alive,” I like to point out that Giardia, amoebic dysentery, cholera, salmonella and shigella, E. coli, and a whole host of other waterborne diseases that used to regularly cause outbreaks that would kill humans in large numbers before the advent of sewage and water treatment systems (and still do in undeveloped countries) are very much “natural” and “alive” as well.
It would be one thing if there were demonstrable health benefits to “Live Water” and other “raw water” products compared to tap water or even bottled water. In such a case one could discuss the risk of disease versus the documented health benefits. Sadly, however, there are no such health benefits yet demonstrated. Raw water is all high (and expensive) risk for no scientifically demonstrable benefit.

Oxygen water? You can’t breathe through your stomach
Scott Gavura on September 8, 2016
Link


My exercise of choice is running. Despite the heat I’ve been having a great summer, training for the Chicago marathon. I’ve followed the training schedule fanatically since June. But it all came crashing down in one run last week when I moved from the ranks of “marathoner in training” to “injured runner”.
With the sudden onset of very sharp, radiating back pain, I was struggling to walk. My marathon plans seemed to evaporate. And in that moment of weakness, I became prey. Prey to pseudoscience, and prey to anyone offering a quick fix.
I usually know what it takes to resolve back pain. Mainly it’s time. It will resolve. Exercise seems to help me, and the memory of back pain keeps me active almost every day. But despite our best efforts, it can reappear. I’m a terrible patient. I want to do something, anything, that will get me back to normal as quickly as possible.
With the desire to do something other than wait, I found a physiotherapist who could see me the next day. And in doing so, I may have found a setting with more pseudoscience than your local drug store. It’s the sports therapy clinic. In the waiting room there was a display of Kinesio Tape for sale. Brochures invited me to consider acupuncture for my injuries. And I could have booked time with a chiropractor if wanted. I didn’t want any of that. I don’t know what the problem with my back is, but I know it’s not a subluxation, or a problem with Qi. The physiotherapist I met seemed evidence-based, and thankfully didn’t suggest acupuncture. I’ve been doing some of the gentle exercises she recommended, and mobilizing daily. And while I’m not limping anymore, the pain isn’t gone yet, and I’m trying not to get to anxious as I approach two full weeks without running. (If there’s an activity that’s more boring than water running, I haven’t found it.)
Leaving the clinic after my second visit, in slightly less pain, I noted that this athletic therapy clinic also sold bottled water. But it wasn’t just any bottled water. This water was specifically for athletes. The label caught my attention and I snapped a picture (above). I had never heard of water with extra oxygen before, with the exception of when I blogged about hydrogen peroxide. Based on the marketing for this particular product, GP8, some athletes endorse oxygenated water, claiming that they can perform better. There are dozens of water products that claim to deliver more oxygen with each swallow, and they’re sold widely.
I can see why this product would be tantalizing to anyone that wants an athletic edge or faster recovery. When you’re injured, there can be a strong feeling of “what’s the harm” that can overwhelm any cautious consideration of the science and the evidence. It’s the same reason that dietary supplement vendors are sponsoring Olympic athletes, and why many athletes endorse these products despite the lack of evidence that they provide any meaningful benefit. Athletes want any edge they can get, even if it’s pseudoscience. Anything that can help performance (or perhaps recovery from injury) can seem very attractive. What better setting could there be to market these products than a clinic treating injured athletes?
Despite the hype, the claims and the athletic endorsements, there’s no persuasive evidence that oxygenated waters offer any meaningful health or athletic benefits beyond the basic hydration you can get from a tap. Like many pseudoscientific products, oxygenated water in an unsinkable rubber duck.
Who drinks oxygen, anyway?
Why would we drink oxygen at all? We’ve all got unlimited access to air, which at about 21% oxygen keeps our bloodstream almost completely saturated with oxygen. I can only postulate the reasoning behind the development of these products:
    • We need oxygen to live
    • When we exercise, we sometimes get short of breath
    • If some oxygen is good, then more must be better
    • “Hey guys, I’ve got an idea. What if we cram more oxygen in drinking water? Then we can bypass the lungs and put more oxygen in the bloodstream.”
    • ?????
    • Profit (and perhaps get a supportive anecdote)
It’s true that we need oxygen to live, and when we breathe heavily during exercise, it’s to take in more oxygen and eliminate carbon dioxide (CO2). Almost of the oxygen the blood carries is bound to hemoglobin. There’s a small amount of oxygen that’s dissolved in the plasma. When we exercise, the amount of oxygen in the blood decreases only slightly, from nearly 100% saturation to around 90%. Under most circumstances, the air we breathe is providing all the oxygen we need – exceptions being specific medical conditions, or breathing at very high altitudes, where air pressure is lower and the oxygen saturation in the blood is lower, too.
While there’s an oxygen atom in every water molecule, this isn’t “free” oxygen that is available for respiration. There’s a small amount of oxygen (as O2) that’s dissolved in water and available to aquatic life. Putting water under pressure, you can force more oxygen to dissolve into it. But release the pressure, and you’ll see it emerge – it’s the same principle as carbonated water, where CO2 is released when a no longer under pressure.
The manufacturer of the bottled water I spotted in the clinic claims to have solved this issue:
GP8’s Enhanced Solubility Water contains up to 400% as much dissolved oxygen as untreated water. This oxygen occurs in the form of ‘guest’ molecules of O2 which occupy and stabilize the spaces between molecules of H2O. The unique purification process used to create GP8 results in larger spaces between H2O molecules, which in turn allow for two or more molecules of O2 occupying and stabilizing them. The result is increased oxygen content. And unlike ‘oxygenated waters’ which quickly release their dissolved gas after opening, the oxygen in GP8 is not under pressure and remains in the water for several hours, even with agitation. GP8 is believed to improve oxygen delivery through the circulatory system by promoting more efficient oxygen transfer through the plasma. Not only does GP8 maximize oxygen intake, but it is also one of the few alkaline pH waters available – a property which is thought to help counter the effects of lactic acid. Committed to serious athletes, GP8 Oxygen Water is 100% additive-free and contains no chemical by-products resulting from the purification process.
There’s about 5mg/L of dissolved oxygen in typical drinking water, but that can vary based on the source, the temperature and other factors. The proprietary method claimed by GP8 states that it can increase the effective oxygen levels without putting the water under pressure. While there’s an elaborate information sheet posted online, I can’t find any published evidence to show that (1) this phenomena actually exists and that (2) there’s actually more oxygen absorbed through the gastrointestinal tract.
Our need to use oxygen at elevation tells you what happens if we happened to absorb oxygen into our bloodstream. Without putting the body under higher atmospheric pressure, the blood can’t simply dissolve more oxygen in it when it’s already saturated.
The manufacturer of GP8 has a list of several studies that they assert support their claim of effectiveness. I can’t find any that have been published and peer reviewed. And there’s insufficient information presented to even evaluate the data. Here’s one example:
Study ESW 002: Single-Blind, Randomized, Tap Water Controlled, Sub-Maximal Exercise Test at a Predetermined Heart Rate to Ascertain the Effect of Enhanced Solubility Water (ESW) on Cycling Speed Over a Five-Mile Simulated DistanceStudy site: NorCal Bicycle Testing Facility, Santa Rosa, CAThe results showed that after consuming ESW, the cyclists, while maintaining their pulse rates constant, were statistically significantly faster for miles 2-5 and for the full five mile course (P < 0.05), than after ingesting [tap water]. Since Studies ESW 001 and ESW 002 demonstrated markedly positive physiologic effects of ESW, a larger more definitive study was performed.
In order for the claims of oxygenated waters to be considered credible, there needs to be rigorously controlled trials (double-blind) with an appropriate number of test subjects. The entire methodology needs to be well documented, and it needs to be published in peer-reviewed literature. For more credibility, it needs to be duplicated. The fact that there’s no credible, published, peer-reviewed literature showing that oxygenated water delivers any athletic benefits is telling. Probably most importantly, even if there is more oxygen in oxygenated water, and it actually is absorbed, it won’t matter. The amount of oxygen in just one breath is vastly higher than the theoretical oxygen supplied by any oxygenated water.
Conclusion: Snake oil, without the snake or the oil
Like homeopathy, which promises all the benefits of medicine without the actual medicine, or sports supplements that promise “drug free” enhancement of athleticism, oxygenated water promises a sports advantage with zero downside. If I didn’t examine the evidence, I could probably be convinced that oxygenated water might help my back pain recover. Given it is water, what’s the harm? But it is when we are most desperate that we are at our most vulnerable. It’s hard to be objective, to ask for the evidence, and to critically appraise it. But that’s when it’s probably most important. As I am constantly reassuring myself these days, when we see the promise of a magical quick fix, we need to be extra skeptical.

You can’t breathe through your stomach
Some bottle water is claimed to have extra oxygen which is claimed to give a performance benefit. Are these claims valid?
Scott Gavura on August 23, 2018
Link


I’m taking a summer blogging break and recovering from a badly sprained ankle. This week I’m slightly revising an old post. See you in September!
My exercise of choice is running, which I do several times per week. My summer fitness plans came crashing to a halt in July when I badly sprained my ankle (ironically, not running, but walking). I quickly moved from “middle-aged athlete” to “angry, injured ex-athlete”. I was looking for anything that might help me recover more quickly. The physician suggested physiotherapy, so I booked an appointment at my local sports medicine clinic. And with that I entered a world where it’s tricky to tell the difference between science and pseudoscience. 
I’ve never sprained my ankle before, and many people told me horror stories – “It will never be the same again” I was warned. So I went to the local sports medicine clinic, wanting to apply the best science to heal my ankle and recover full function. In the waiting room there was a display of Kinesio Tape for sale. Brochures invited me to consider acupuncture for my injuries. And I could have booked time with a chiropractor if wanted. I didn’t want any of that. I wanted evidence-based advice and treatment. The physiotherapist I’m working with seems evidence-based, and despite his recommendation of acupuncture (and quite possibly the occasional use of ultrasound), the work we’ve been doing seems reasonable and conservative. While I’m not limping anymore, the pain isn’t gone yet, and I’m even allowed to do some gentle “jogging” on flat surfaces again.
Leaving the clinic after my second visit, in slightly less pain, I noted that this clinic also sold bottled water. But it wasn’t just any bottled water. This water was specifically for athletes. The label caught my attention and I snapped a picture (above). I had never heard of water with extra oxygen before, with the exception of when I blogged about hydrogen peroxide. Based on the marketing for this particular product, GP8, some athletes endorse oxygenated water, claiming that they can perform better. There are dozens of water products that claim to deliver more oxygen with each swallow, and they’re sold widely.
“GP8 Oxygen water improves oxygen delivery through the circulatory system by promoting more efficient oxygen transfer through the plasma resulting in advanced hydration.”– Product advertisement
I can see why this product would be tantalizing to anyone that wants an athletic edge or faster recovery. When you’re injured, there can be a strong feeling of “what’s the harm” that can overwhelm any cautious consideration of the science and the evidence. It’s the same reason that dietary supplement vendors are sponsoring Olympic athletes, and why many athletes endorse these products despite the lack of evidence that they provide any meaningful benefit. Athletes want any edge they can get, even if it’s pseudoscience. Anything that can help performance (or perhaps recovery from injury) can seem very attractive. What better setting could there be to market these products than a clinic treating injured athletes?Despite the hype, the claims and the athletic endorsements, there’s no persuasive evidence that oxygenated waters offer any meaningful health or athletic benefits beyond the basic hydration you can get from a tap. Like many pseudoscientific products, oxygenated water in an unsinkable rubber duck.
Who drinks oxygen, anyway?
Why would we drink oxygen at all? We’ve all got unlimited access to air, which at about 21% oxygen keeps our bloodstream almost completely saturated with oxygen. I can only postulate the reasoning behind the development of these products:
    • We need oxygen to live
    • When we exercise, we sometimes get short of breath
    • If some oxygen is good, then more must be better
    • “Hey guys, I’ve got an idea. What if we cram more oxygen in drinking water? Then we can bypass the lungs and put more oxygen in the bloodstream.”
    • ?????
    • Profit (and perhaps get a supportive anecdote)
It’s true that we need oxygen to live, and when we breathe heavily during exercise, it’s to take in more oxygen and eliminate carbon dioxide (CO2). Almost of the oxygen the blood carries is bound to hemoglobin. There’s a small amount of oxygen that’s dissolved in the plasma. When we exercise, the amount of oxygen in the blood decreases only slightly, from nearly 100% saturation to around 90%. Under most circumstances, the air we breathe is providing all the oxygen we need – exceptions being specific medical conditions, or breathing at very high altitudes, where air pressure is lower and the oxygen saturation in the blood is lower, too.
While there’s an oxygen atom in every water molecule, this isn’t “free” oxygen that is available for respiration. There’s a small amount of oxygen (as O2) that’s dissolved in water and available to aquatic life. Putting water under pressure, you can force more oxygen to dissolve into it. But release the pressure, and you’ll see it emerge – it’s the same principle as carbonated water, where CO2 is released when a no longer under pressure.
The manufacturer of the bottled water I spotted in the clinic claims to have solved this issue:
GP8’s Enhanced Solubility Water contains up to 400% as much dissolved oxygen as untreated water. This oxygen occurs in the form of ‘guest’ molecules of O2 which occupy and stabilize the spaces between molecules of H2O. The unique purification process used to create GP8 results in larger spaces between H2O molecules, which in turn allow for two or more molecules of O2 occupying and stabilizing them. The result is increased oxygen content. And unlike ‘oxygenated waters’ which quickly release their dissolved gas after opening, the oxygen in GP8 is not under pressure and remains in the water for several hours, even with agitation. GP8 is believed to improve oxygen delivery through the circulatory system by promoting more efficient oxygen transfer through the plasma. Not only does GP8 maximize oxygen intake, but it is also one of the few alkaline pH waters available – a property which is thought to help counter the effects of lactic acid. Committed to serious athletes, GP8 Oxygen Water is 100% additive-free and contains no chemical by-products resulting from the purification process.
There’s about 5mg/L of dissolved oxygen in typical drinking water, but that can vary based on the source, the temperature and other factors. The proprietary method claimed by GP8 states that it can increase the effective oxygen levels without putting the water under pressure. While there’s an elaborate information sheet posted online, I can’t find any published evidence to show that (1) this phenomena actually exists and that (2) there’s actually more oxygen absorbed through the gastrointestinal tract.
Our need to use oxygen at elevation tells you what happens if we happened to absorb oxygen into our bloodstream. Without putting the body under higher atmospheric pressure, the blood can’t simply dissolve more oxygen in it when it’s already saturated.
The manufacturer of GP8 has a list of several studies that they assert support their claim of effectiveness. I can’t find any that have been published and peer reviewed. And there’s insufficient information presented to even evaluate the data. Here’s one example:
Study ESW 002: Single-Blind, Randomized, Tap Water Controlled, Sub-Maximal Exercise Test at a Predetermined Heart Rate to Ascertain the Effect of Enhanced Solubility Water (ESW) on Cycling Speed Over a Five-Mile Simulated DistanceStudy site: NorCal Bicycle Testing Facility, Santa Rosa, CAThe results showed that after consuming ESW, the cyclists, while maintaining their pulse rates constant, were statistically significantly faster for miles 2-5 and for the full five mile course (P < 0.05), than after ingesting [tap water]. Since Studies ESW 001 and ESW 002 demonstrated markedly positive physiologic effects of ESW, a larger more definitive study was performed.
In order for the claims of oxygenated waters to be considered credible, there needs to be rigorously controlled trials (double-blind) with an appropriate number of test subjects. The entire methodology needs to be well documented, and it needs to be published in peer-reviewed literature. For more credibility, it needs to be duplicated. The fact that there’s no credible, published, peer-reviewed literature showing that oxygenated water delivers any athletic benefits is telling. Probably most importantly, even if there is more oxygen in oxygenated water, and it actually is absorbed, it won’t matter. The amount of oxygen in just one breath is vastly higher than the theoretical oxygen supplied by any oxygenated water.
Conclusion: Snake oil, without the snake or the oil
Like homeopathy, which promises all the benefits of medicine without the actual medicine, or sports supplements that promise “drug free” enhancement of athleticism, oxygenated water promises a sports advantage with zero downside. If I didn’t examine the evidence, I could probably be convinced that oxygenated water might help me be a better athlete. Given it is water, what’s the harm? But it is when we are most desperate that we are at our most vulnerable. It’s hard to be objective, to ask for the evidence, and to critically appraise it. But that’s when it’s probably most important. As I am constantly reassuring myself these days, when we see the promise of a magical quick fix, we need to be extra skeptical.

Living Water
A device called Living Water will convert your tap water into acidic or alkaline water that supposedly is ionized and has antioxidant properties. There is no evidence that it offers any health benefits.
Harriet Hall on May 8, 2018
Link 
I want my water to be dead. If there is anything “living” in it, it would be microbes that are a contaminant and potentially harmful. What do people mean when they talk of “living water”?
If you look up “living water” on the Internet, you will find that it is a Biblical term, mainly used as a metaphor for faith or for the Holy Spirit. The first Google hit is “Living Water – A Foursquare Church.” Under “Next Steps” the Church offers “Meet Jesus” and “Pizza with Pastors.” I’m intrigued. But there’s nothing on their website about actual water.
There’s also Living Water International, an organization that demonstrates the love of God with projects to supply clean drinking water to poor communities in developing countries.
But Living Water came to my attention as a health product offered by Vollara. It is a device that sits on the kitchen counter, plugs into any electrical outlet, and attaches to an existing faucet. You add sea salt to its Salt Port. It filters the water and uses Direct Disk Ionization Technology to provide:
    • Acid-buffering alkaline water for drinking and cooking
    • Acidic water for cleaning without chemicals
    • Water with excellent negative Oxidation Reduction Potential for increased antioxidant properties
The claims
They say this is water the way Nature intended it to be:
Drinking enough water isn’t really enough. You have to drink the right kind of water – water that will help buffer acid, help remove toxins, and is easily absorbed by your body. You need great tasting water with antioxidant properties and proper pH levels.
Allegedly, the right kind of water will help your body hydrate itself, flush out toxins and waste products, and maybe even help you lose weight. The water produced by the Living Water device “empowers you to have optimal health.”
The products
Vollara’s Living Water device produces both alkaline and acidic water, with 8 different pH levels from 4.0 acidic to 10.0 alkaline, plus a SUPER function to achieve extreme pH levels (2.5) when needed. You push a button for the desired pH, which is shown on an LED screen. It has a replaceable filter.
The company also sells air purifiers and nutritional supplements. They say you should take their Essentials for Life supplement if:
    • You experience low energy levels
    • You are under chronic stress
    • You smoke or drink alcoholic beverages regularly
    • You don’t eat five servings of fruits and vegetables per day
    • You drink coffee or tea
    • You have difficulty losing weight
Doesn’t that cover pretty much everyone?
Vollara offers career opportunities for distributors, with a generous Compensation Plan that “rewards you every step of the way, with millions of dollars allocated to reward success.” Enrolling others as your “team” increases your profits. It is essentially a multilevel marketing (MLM) scheme. The Living Water device is only available from the company and its distributors. Distributors buy it at wholesale price and sell it for as much more as they can get away with. When I checked on May 3, there were two of them available through third-party sellers on the Amazon website for $1,200 and $1,899 (plus shipping and tax).
The company offers no evidence as to whether Living Water actually offers any health benefits. PubMed lists no studies on the health benefits of ionized water or alkaline water. Quackwatch has evaluated the acid/alkaline theory and calls it nonsense.
Conclusion: Just more water quackery
There is a superb website about water-related pseudoscience, fantasy and quackery, by a retired chemistry professor. Here are some of the points he makes:
    • The claims for ionized and alkaline water are totally lacking in scientific support.
    • The term “ionized water” is meaningless to chemists.
    • Pure water can never be alkaline or acidic.
    • If you drink alkaline water, the alkalinity is quickly neutralized by stomach acid.
    • The pH of drinking water has zero effect on the pH of blood or the body’s cells.
    • “Ionized” water is not an anti-oxidant, it’s an oxidizing agent.
        ◦ Whatever the hucksters say, there is no evidence that any “special” water is better for your health than plain old water. It’s all just H2O.

It’s Still Not Safe to Go Back in the Water, and Other Tales of Woo
A thoughtful discussion of water-based topics ranging from toddlers pooping in the pool to recommendations on daily alkaline water intake for newborns.
Clay Jones on July 28, 2017
Link

Every month a copy of Infectious Diseases in Children mysteriously appears in my mailbox. I don’t know why it continues to show up, every month, following me wherever I move despite having never subscribed to it. But I can’t say I mind because it’s actually pretty decent as far as “throwaway journals” go.
Backyard pools: harmless Summer fun or above ground cauldrons of death and diarrhea?
Two articles in the July issue were particularly interesting to me, with both involving the risk of exposure to an infectious disease in water as well as questionable parental choices. In the first article, found in the journal’s “Outbreak News” section, we learn that nationally reported cases of infection with Cryptosporidium, a nasty and ubiquitous intestinal parasite that can cause weeks of profuse diarrhea, have increased three fold since 2004. And cases in some states have doubled, even quintupled, in recent years.
Why the increase in reported cases? Improved diagnostic technology may be playing a role rather than an actual increase in the incidence of the infection. Regardless, we now know that it is the leading cause of outbreaks of diarrhea associated with recreational swimming in aquatic facilities. The source of these outbreaks are typically young children whose parents have allowed them to enter the water while ill or too soon after recovery, and the only way to clear the water of these hardy organisms is to literally chlorinate the shit out of it. See what I did there?
Humans are not dolphins, and they probably never will be
I’ve written about the absurd practice of human mothers delivering their babies into water twice, both times laying out the many reasons why this practice is dangerous and without benefit. Adding to the pile is the second article from the July IDC. In it, we learn of two cases of Arizona newborns suffering from Legionnaire’s disease, a diagnosis which is fatal in 10% of cases, caused by exposure to contaminated water during their delivery.
An investigation by the local department of public health revealed that facilities irresponsible enough to allow women to give birth into water are not doing a great job making sure that said water is safe from infectious organisms. Shocking, I know. In one of the cases, heated water sat in the tub for a week prior to the delivery, a perfect breeding ground for the causative organism.
In response to the two cases, which thankfully were not fatal, health officials worked with waterbirthing facilities to put guidelines into place that would reduce the risk of contamination. These guidelines were based on those developed in Texas in 2014, when a baby did die from Legionellosis after a water birth. Not mentioned in the article, or in the response from health officials, is that waterbirthing has no benefit, and the much more common practice of merely laboring in water is of minimal benefit and could still result in infection from contaminated water. In my opinion, medical facilities that claim to provide quality, evidence-based care to women should do away with this ridiculous practice.
Integrative parenting?
Although written in April, I’ve only just stumbled upon Organic Life‘s treatise on the reasons why parents want natural remedies for their children (and 9 cures to try right now!). It’s chock full of the standard fallacies and false claims, and the combination of reasonable health advice with abject quackery that we’ve come to expect from the world of integrative medicine. I’ll pick out a few juicy morsels of malarkey to sink our teeth into.
What do they get right? A few things, actually. Many parents are turning to alternative therapies in addition to conventional recommendations, often basing their choice on anecdotes from friends and family members. And many of these parents are not discussing their alternative choices with their child’s pediatrician or family doctor. It’s also true that herbal remedies aren’t evaluated by the FDA, leaving many unanswered questions regarding safety and efficacy of thousands of products.
But according to the several quoted experts, such as protégé and integrative medical provider Russell Greenfield, there is still plenty of nonsense to recommend based on cherry picked studies, flawed assumptions, and appeals to overly simplistic understanding of human health. Greenfield et al are proponents of fish oil supplements for “boosting the immune system” while somehow also reducing inflammation, in order to prevent colds, ear infections, and acne. No explanation of what part of the immune system is boosted is given, or how this might result in fewer infections without more autoimmune conditions. Also there is no explanation for the contradictory effect of a boosted immune system but somehow less inflammation.
Other questionable “cures” recommended in the article range from the unlikely to those calling into question fundamental laws of reality. These include probiotic supplements for allergic conditions like eczema and asthma, essential oils for a child’s cough, yoga for asthma, acupuncture for headaches, craniosacral therapy for ear infections, and homeopathy for colds. The article has this to say on the most irrational of these recommendations:
“Homeopathy has been found to be effective for some medical conditions in well-designed studies,” says Timothy Culbert, MD, medical director of Integrative Medicine and Cultural Care at Children’s Hospitals and Clinics in Minneapolis and Saint Paul. “But we are not completely certain as to how it works. And that makes doctors nervous.”
Neither Dr. Culbert nor the authors of this article provide a link to one of these well-designed studies. There are many aspects of medicine that I am not completely certain about, but homeopathy ain’t one of them. What truly makes me nervous, however, is that Dr. Culbert has access to ill children.
The quacks who say Kneipp?
Although I had heard of hydrotherapy/hydropathy before, I don’t recall encountering the tale of Sebastian Kneipp. In the late 19th century, after discovering the healing miracle of gently applied water of varying temperatures when his tuberculosis was cured by wading in the Danube, Kneipp developed a large following and is considered a founding father of naturopathy. In addition to promoting treatments such as putting your feet in water and slowly increasing the temperature in order to treat colds and rheumatic conditions, the folks at Kneipp also sell a variety of cheap lotions and bath oils.
Alkaline water for kids!
Alkaline water is nonsense and has been discussed in various SBM articles over the years. I recently discovered this gem on the “industry-wide” recommendations for giving alkaline water to children, and it even breaks down the benefits by age. They claim that drinking comically large quantities of alkaline water, around 8 liters each day for older kids, can improve the immune system as well as mental AND emotional stamina.
They recommend less daily water in younger children, although getting a toddler to drink 2 liters of water would still be a challenge and is completely unnecessary. The claimed benefits are improved toxin elimination and faster recovery from exertion. The most concerning part of this article is when they discuss water consumption in babies down to the newborn period:
Eight to 16 ounces a day is all they should need but it is important that you give you start giving your baby some water – at least filtered water – as early as possible. Babies aren’t particularly picky and this is a good time to help your baby acquire a taste for water.
This is extremely dangerous. Newborns and young infants need exactly zero ounces of extra water on top of their breast milk or formula. That much extra free water could dilute the electrolytes in their blood, particularly sodium, and result in seizures, coma, and even death.
Just a short post this time around. See you in a couple weeks.

Science-based medicine versus the Flint water crisis
David Gorski on January 25, 2016
Link


One aspect of science-based medicine that is not covered frequently on this blog, aside from vaccines and antivaccine pseudoscience, but perhaps should be, is the intersection of SBM and public health. Unfortunately, living as I do in southeast Michigan right now, I’ve been on the receiving end of an inescapable lesson in what happens when the government fails in its mission to enforce science-based public health issues. I’m referring, of course, to what has become known worldwide as the Flint water crisis. The Flint water crisis has become so famous that unfortunately it now has its very own Wikipedia page. That is not an “honor” I like to see for my state, and I’m sure the residents of Flint, which is an hour’s drive north of where I live, would agree. This crisis provides an unfortunate illustration of what can easily happen when multiple layers of government fail in a science-based public health task as basic as providing clean water to the citizens they ostensibly serve.
For those of you who haven’t heard of it yet, the Flint water crisis refers to the ongoing contamination of the tap water in Flint, MI with unacceptably high levels of lead that resulted from change in its water supply nearly two years ago to Flint River water. Because river water is more corrosive than the previous supply that came from Lake Huron (why I’ll explain later) and Flint river water was not properly treated to decrease that corrosiveness, the new water leached lead from old pipes. This resulted in the contamination of the drinking water with dangerous levels of lead in many homes in the city. In addition, there has been a marked increase in the number of cases of Legionnaires’ disease thought to be linked to the new water supply.
I was born and raised in Detroit. My parents didn’t move to the suburbs until I was ten years old, and I stayed in southeast Michigan until I graduated from medical school and ended up in Cleveland for my surgical residency and, ultimately, my PhD work. From there I bounced to Chicago and New Jersey. Then, in 2008, nearly twenty years after I had left my hometown, I ended up back in the Detroit area. The point of this story is that my roots in the Detroit area run deep. Michigan is my state, for better or for worse, which is why I get annoyed when bad things happen here. I particularly become outraged when a preventable tragedy occurs here, one that science told us how to prevent but the government went ahead and did anyway. It’s a horrific tale of how science was basically ignored because of politics, and legitimate scientific concerns about a policy that changed the water source for an entire city were downplayed, derided, and even denied by state officials at every level of government. The story has now gone international. Indeed, our state and the city of Flint are featured on the cover of this week’s TIME Magazine.
Genesis: How Flint was poisoned
Until about a month ago, most people outside of Michigan who’ve even heard of Flint at all probably remember the city because it was featured in Flint native Michael Moore’s movie, Roger & Me, a documentary that explored the effects of GM’s closing several auto plants in Flint back in the 1980s. The title of the film derives from the movie’s organizing conceit, in which Moore portrays himself pursuing then-GM CEO Roger Smith to confront him about what these closings did to his hometown. Basically, if you think Detroit’s been in bad shape over the last 20-30 years, you should realize that Flint has been in worse shape. Now, I realize that there are probably a lot of you who don’t like Michael Moore. I’m not that fond of him myself, but his movie did an excellent job of exploring just how messed up Flint was. Things haven’t gotten much better in the 26 years since Roger & Me.
As a result of its longstanding financial problems that lead to the city’s insolvency, in 2011 Governor Rick Snyder appointed an emergency manager of the city’s finances. Michigan has a law that allows the governor to appoint an Emergency Financial Manager to take control of a local financial unit, such as a city or a school district, after a review finds the unit’s financial situation is deemed precarious enough that a financial emergency exists. Emergency managers have broad, some would say undemocratic, powers to reorganize departments, reduce pay, modify employee contracts, and outsource work.
At the risk of becoming too “political” for an SBM post (forgive me if you find this too “inside baseball,” but it gives some context that I consider important), I can’t help but point out that in November 2012, a referendum was held over the previous emergency manager law. Voters clearly rejected the law. Did the voters’ repeal of the law stop our legislature? Of course not. Now here’s why we in Michigan have come to fear lame duck legislative sessions. A mere month later, the legislature passed another very similar emergency manager law, with some different provisions thought to assuage voters’ concerns. Using a quirk in the Michigan constitution that makes bills with appropriations not subject to voter referendum, our legislature tacked on an appropriation to pay emergency manager salaries before passing this new emergency manager law, which was now referendum-proof. Governor Snyder signed the bill right after Christmas.
Under the old law and the new, Flint went through several emergency managers, although two of them were the same. First it was Michael Brown. Then it was Ed Kurtz. Then it was Michael Brown again. The names, however, aren’t important. What they did is.
This is how it was reported right after the holidays:
Flint’s drinking water became contaminated with lead in 2014 after switching its supply source from Lake Huron to the more polluted and corrosive Flint River. The move — a cost-cutting measure while the city was under the control of a state-appointed emergency manager — resulted in a spike in lead levels in children, which causes permanent brain damage. A recent preliminary report from a task force appointed by Snyder placed most of the blame on the state Department of Environmental Quality and prompted the Dec. 29 resignation of DEQ Director Dan Wyant.
So what had happened? There were higher concentrations of salt in Flint River water, which led to corrosion of the lead pipes that carried water from main pipes to individual houses. Detroit’s less corrosive water had flowed through the same pipes for decades without a problem, but it didn’t take long after the switch was made in April 2014 for elevated lead content to be noticed.
Why was the switch made? Here the story gets complicated. In 2010, the Flint City Council voted to join the new Karegnondi Water Authority, which would supply many communities in the Flint area. Construction of a pipeline from Lake Huron to Flint was begun and is still scheduled to be completed in 2016. In the meantime, Flint continued to get its water from the Detroit system. In April 2014, a decision was made. It’s been argued back and forth whether it was the Flint city council that made the decision or the then-emergency manager, Darnell Earley, who is currently the emergency manager for the Detroit Public Schools—I kid you not—and has been frantically trying to deny that he had anything to do with this decision, painting it as his predecessor Ed Kurtz signing off on a city council decision in 2013, even though the city council had no authority anymore and even though that vote was only to switch to the Karegnondi Water Authority in 2016 when the new pipeline was completed, not to use Flint River water in the meantime.
Another argument defending emergency managers is that Detroit left Flint with no choice but to switch to Flint River water temporarily because it canceled the long term contract with Flint to supply water. This is where an interesting wrinkle is in what happened next:
When Flint notified Detroit in April 2013 that it had opted to switch to the Karegnondi Water Authority, Detroit gave it one year’s notice that it was terminating its contract to supply Flint with Lake Huron drinking water. Detroit’s decision to cut Flint off before the Karegnondi pipeline to Lake Huron would be completed — a decision made one month after Detroit was placed under the control of its own former emergency manager, Kevyn Orr — is what precipitated Flint’s move to the Flint River as a drinking water source pending completion of its own water provider.
Walling [Flint’s mayor in 2013], who takes ownership of the decision to switch to the Karegnondi Water Authority, told the Flint Journal he had no direct involvement in the decision to draw drinking water from the Flint River.
A March 7, 2014, letter from then-Flint emergency manager Darnell Earley to the DWSD, obtained by the ACLU of Michigan, shows Earley declined the DWSD’s offer to continue selling water to Flint after the termination of the contract in April of 2014, saying “the Flint Water Treatment Plant will be fully operational and capable of treating Flint River water prior to the date of termination.”
So at the time, both cities, Detroit and Flint, were under the control of an emergency manager. Both, presumably, were trying to save money when Earley switched from purchasing treated Lake Huron water from Detroit, as it had done for decades, to getting water from the Flint River as a temporary measure until the pipeline was completed. The reason? When Flint joined the Karegnondi Water Authority, the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department terminated its 35-year contract with the city. To continue to purchase Detroit water, Flint would have to renegotiate a short-term contract, at a higher cost, which Detroit was willing to do, justifying the higher cost as helping to pay for improvements it had made in the pipeline supplying Flint with the expectation that it would be used long term. On the other hand, recent evidence has suggested that even the short term deal that Detroit was offering would have been less expensive than using Flint River water. Whether that is true or not is beyond the scope of this post.
The effect of the change in source on Flint’s tap water was rapid. The switch was made with great fanfare in late April 2014, and by June there were stories of residents complaining about the water all over the local press. As can be seen in this excellent time line, report, and overview, residents almost immediately started complaining about the water, saying that it was causing skin problems, including rashes and hair loss. Others complained of a foul odor and cloudiness. By summer, three boiled water advisories were issued because of high levels of coliform bacteria. By October a GM engine plant announced that it would stop using Flint water because it was too corrosive. Last year, it got to the point where avoiding tap water became a way of life in Flint.

The Flint Water Study
Up to this point, it might be possible to view the decision to temporarily use Flint River water as somewhat forgivable, given the fog of politics and the 100% accuracy of the retrospectoscope. That was before officials started denying that there was a problem and in fact actively working to cover up evidence that there was a problem. There’s plenty of guilt to go around, although most of it appears to be the state’s problem. First, though, city officials denied that the water was unsafe, even as a year ago they issued a notice that the levels of trihalomethanes (TTHM), a group of four chemicals formed as a byproduct of water disinfection, were too high.
In January 2015, a public meeting was held during which hundreds of Flint residents attended, many complaining loudly about the “bad water,” its taste, smell, and appearance. They complained about skin problems, particularly in children, as they had been doing for months. Over the next few months, state and city officials, including the Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ), kept insisting that the water was safe and reporting that lead levels were within Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) guidelines. As we will learn, they went beyond that and tried to make sure they were below the guidelines.

Complaints about Flint water eventually lead to a local physician and a water scientist taking matters into their own hands. In September, Virginia Tech University researchers led by engineering professor Marc Edwards, an expert on water safety, tested water samples from 271 Flint homes and found high lead levels in the tap water in homes throughout the city. This recent article in the Washington Post provides what I consider to be the best explanation of what Edwards found. First, it notes what the lead levels were in cities near Flint. For instance, in Troy, which is about a 45 minute drive from Flint, the 90th percentile reading for lead in 2013 was 1.1 part per billion (ppb). For Detroit, it was 2.3 ppb, a bit higher, but still well below the EPA level for concern of 5 ppb.
In comparison, for Flint the 90th percentile was 27 ppb:
At 27 parts per billion, it’s five times as high as the level of concern, and nearly twice as high as the EPA’s already-generous guidelines. According to the researchers who ran these tests, the health effects of lead levels this high “can include high blood pressure and other cardiovascular problems, kidney damage and memory and neurological problems.”
Recall, though, that 10 percent of the homes in the sample had lead levels even higher than this. Here’s the highest lead reading in that sample, from a home in the city’s 8th Ward:
158 ppb
That’s more than 10 times the EPA limit. It’s 30 times higher than the 5 ppb reading that can indicate unsafe lead amounts.
But that 158 ppb reading is far from the worst one that turned up in Flint, unfortunately. In the spring of 2015, city officials tested water in the home of LeeAnne Walters, a stay-at-home mother of four and a Navy wife. They got a reading of 397 ppb, an alarmingly high number.
But it was even worse than that. Virginia Tech’s team went to Walters’ house to verify those numbers later in the year. They were concerned that the city tested water in a way that was almost guaranteed to minimize lead readings: They flushed the water for several minutes before taking a sample, which often washes away a percentage of lead contaminants. They also made residents collect water at a very low flow rate, which they knew also tended to be associated with lower readings.
So the Virginia Tech researchers took 30 different readings at various flow levels. What they found shocked them: The lowest reading they obtained was around 200 ppb, already ridiculously high. But more than half of the readings came in at more than 1,000 ppb. Some came in above 5,000 — the level at which EPA considers the water to be “toxic waste.”
The highest reading registered at 13,000 ppb.
The professor who conducted the sampling, Dr. Marc Edwards, was in “disbelief.”
“We had never seen such sustained high levels of lead in 25 years of work,” he said.
According to Edwards, the team retested the water with extra quality controls and assurance checks, and obtained the exact same results.
Edwards has set up a website with the details of the Flint Water Study that he and his research team had carried out, as well as its complete dataset for anyone who wants to examine it.
To its discredit, the DEQ immediately set about trying to discredit Edwards’ study, first by accusing him of dishonest motives. For instance, MDEQ’s Communications Director Brad Wurfel wrote to The Flint Journal‘s Ronald Fonger:
…the state DEQ is just as perplexed by Edwards’ results as he seems to be by the City’s test results. When I said we were unsure how the Virginia Tech team got its results, that’s not the same as being surprised that they got them. …this group specializes in looking for high lead problems. They pull that rabbit out of that hat everywhere they go. Nobody should be surprised when the rabbit comes out of the hat, even if they can’t figure out how it is done…..while the state appreciates academic participation in this discussion, offering broad, dire public health advice based on some quick testing could be seen as fanning political flames irresponsibly. Residents of Flint concerned about the health of their community don’t need more of that.
This is but a sample of the sort of attacks that were aimed at Edwards and his team in order to try to discredit their work and results. In fairness, Edwards is an activist. However, his finding elevated lead levels should not have resulted in attacks; it should have resulted in the DEQ rechecking its results. But that’s not all. It also appears that the DEQ went beyond attacking Edwards and into manipulating its results to eliminate inconvenient findings:
Lead levels in Flint’s drinking water would have spurred action months sooner if the results of city testing that wrapped up in June had not been revised by the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality to wrongly indicate the water was safe to drink, e-mails show.
The records — obtained by the Michigan ACLU and by Marc Edwards, a Virginia Tech researcher who helped raise concerns about Flint’s water — show how state officials first appear to have encouraged the City of Flint to find water samples with low lead levels and later told Flint officials to disqualify two samples with high readings. The move changed the overall lead level results to acceptable from unacceptable.
That’s right. The DEQ appears to have fudged the report it filed by eliminating the samples with the highest concentration and thereby produce the result that it wanted: The appearance that the water was safe. More specifically, it invalidated two high lead results to keep the 90th percentile below 15 ppb, the level set by the EPA to trigger action. Unlike 5 ppb, which indicates a need for concern, at 15 ppb federal law requires residents be provided information about how to protect themselves and their children from lead in water. That, of course, never happened in Flint.
It’s even worse than that, though. Flint water officials also appear to have misrepresented water samples. When lead levels are suspected to be too high, water systems are required to seek out the highest risk homes to test their water for lead. It turns out that water samples sent to the state labs for testing in the first six months of 2015 were all marked as having come from homes with lead piping serving them. However, nearly all of them came from homes at lower risk, homes with pipes made of copper or galvanized steel, according to documents obtained through the Freedom of Information Act by The Flint Journal-MLive.
Then there were the reactions to a physician who did a study.
Dr. Mona Hanna-Attisha does a study
Last fall, at the same time Edwards was studying lead levels in Flint water, Dr. Mona Hanna-Attisha, a pediatrician at Hurley Medical Center, announced the results of a study that she had done, which was just published in the American Journal of Public Health, accompanied by an editorial by David Rosner entitled “Flint, Michigan: A Century of Environmental Injustice.” Her results could also be found in a slide presentation from when she announced her findings. Basically, Hanna-Attisha and her team found that the incidence of elevated blood levels of lead had increased from 2.4% before the water source change to 4.9% afterwards. In some districts, the incidence had increased by nearly three-fold. Meanwhile, no significant change was seen outside the city (click to embiggen):

So what was the reaction to these findings? You already know that. Wurfel tried to slime Hanna-Attisha, characterizing the water controversy as “near hysteria” and saying:
I wouldn’t call them irresponsible. I would call them unfortunate,” Wurfel said of the doctors’ comments.
“Flint’s drinking water is safe in that it’s meeting state and federal standards,” he said. “The system has an aging portion that needs to be addressed. They haven’t had meaningful maintenance for four decades or more.”
At the same time, Health and Human Services spokeswoman Geralyn Lasher was characterizing Hanna-Attisha’s data as “data” in e-mails to Gov. Snyder and other state officials. (She now denies she was being condescending with the scare quotes.) She was attacked publicly, too:
“We were attacked,” Hanna-Attisha recalls.
She was labeled an “unfortunate researcher” and accused of causing hysteria. Critics said her figures did not line up with the state’s findings. Governor Snyder’s press secretary accused her of “splicing and dicing” her data to get the results she wanted.
Even though General Motors stopped using the city’s water supply because it was corroding engine parts, the official reaction, Hanna-Attisha says, was one of “denial, denial, denial.”
The criticism, she says, took its toll.
“I was physically ill. I think my heart rate went up to 200. You know, you check and you double-check, and you know your research is right. The numbers didn’t lie, but when the state is telling you you’re wrong, it’s hard not to second-guess yourself.”
The state finally had to admit that its data showed the same thing when it analyzed it the same way that Hanna-Attisha did.
By October, Genesee County, which includes Flint, declared a public health emergency, and the City of Flint developed plans to distribute thousands of water filters. Finally, in October, Flint reconnected to Detroit water. Ultimately, several Flint residents filed a class action lawsuit, and in December the new mayor, Karen Weaver, declared a state of emergency, declaring that the elevated lead levels had caused irreversible damage to the health of the children of the city. And, finally, long after he should have done it, earlier this month Governor Rick Snyder declared a state of emergency as well, after DEQ director Dan Wyant and communications director Brad Wurfel resigned.
Finally, last week, Governor Snyder used the State of the State address to apologize to the citizens of Flint, and promised to release his e-mails, even though the state’s Freedom of Information Act exempts lawmakers and the Governor. The EPA issued an emergency order requiring Michigan and the city of Flint to take immediate steps after determining that their response to the crisis had been “inadequate to protect human health,” while Susan Hedman, head of the Midwest region of the EPA, resigned after having played down a memo by an EPA employee that said tests had shown high levels of lead in the city’s water, telling Flint and Michigan administrators it was only a draft report. Meanwhile, Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette, after having resisted doing so for a long time, has launched an investigation, and Governor Snyder might be required to testify before the U.S. House Oversight and Government Reform Committee. President Obama has lit a fire under the FDA and promised aid.
Clean, uncontaminated water: Science-based public health
When I decided to write this, I realized that our readers might question why this would be an appropriate topic for science-based medicine. After all, the effects of lead poisoning are very well known. Lead can result in developmental delay, decreased IQ, decreased hearing, and ADHD. The children of Flint who were affected with this will likely have behavioral problems, and lead exposure has even been linked to violent crime.
Besides outrage, what motivated me to write was a desire to point out how SBM interfaces with public health in ways not involving vaccines. Science-based water treatment is science-based medicine through its effects on public health, and, arguably even more so than vaccination policy, is a product of politics, which can lead to disasters like this. Everybody knows that clean, uncontaminated water is important for the health of the people using it. What’s not so well known is how difficult it is to produce. For instance, before this crisis, I did know that our state had an aging infrastructure. I was not, however, aware of how widespread lead pipes still are in city water supplies. Even though my bachelor’s degree was in chemistry before I went to medical school, I was still also blissfully unaware of the chemistry of water treatment, because that’s a rather specialized field of applied chemistry. I had no idea that there would be a big difference in the ability of water to leach lead from lead pipes depending on its salt concentration and pH, much less what needs to be done to prevent it from doing so.
Water from the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department has a very low corrosivity for lead because of its low chloride, low chloride-to-sulfate mass ratio, and addition of an orthophosphate corrosion inhibitor. In marked contrast, Flint River water is very corrosive to lead because it had high chloride (92 mg/L, compared to 11.4 mg/L in Detroit water), high chloride-to-sulfate mass ratio (1.6, compared to 0.45 in Detroit water), and no corrosion inhibitor. Worse, in response to the finding of high TTHM levels, the city was adding ferric chloride; the problem is that ferric chloride makes water even more corrosive to lead. Add to that a city with an aging infrastructure containing a high proportion of lead pipes that the city can’t even keep track of because data regarding which homes have lead pipes or not are kept on 45,000 index cards, and you have a recipe for disaster. As a result, after the switch to Flint River water, the corrosiveness level as measured by the Larson Iron Corrosion Index rose from 0.54 (low corrosion) to 2.3 (very high corrosion) and the chloride to sulfate mass ratio (CSMR) index for lead corrosion increased from 0.45 (low corrosion) to 1.6 (very high corrosion). The city didn’t add phosphates to reduce the corrosiveness of the water, and as a result the corrosive Flint River water corroded the scale that had built up on the pipes and released lead into the water.
Here’s the even bigger kicker. Even using the Flint River water, the City of Flint could have prevented the corrosion of its copper and lead pipes relatively inexpensively:
Marc Edwards, a professor at Virginia Tech who has been testing Flint water, says treatment could have corrected much of the problem early on — for as little as $100 a day — but officials in the city of 100,000 people didn’t take action.
It’s not clear whether incompetence or saving money was the imperative here. Whatever the reason, the city failed to treat the Flint River water, leaving it corrosive and able to leach lead and copper from the aging pipes used to transport it. As a consequence, an as-yet unknown number of children have been poisoned with lead, which is most damaging to the developing brain. This is all straightforward science. We know what levels of lead are safe and what levels are not. We know what the effects of lead poisoning are in children. We know how to prevent them. Chemists specializing in water purification know that corrosive water placed in old copper and lead pipes will leach lead and copper out of them. They even know how to treat the water to prevent this leaching! Yet that wasn’t done.
Now we will now be forced to use science-based medicine to treat potentially thousands of children for lead poisoning and science to try to fix the problems caused by this colossal failure of science-based public policy. Worse, it’s still going on, as The Guardian just reported on Friday that water authorities across the US are systematically distorting water tests to downplay the amount of lead in samples.
As I think about that, seeing the Governor throwing mid-level bureaucrats under the bus and other politicians saying that the Flint water crisis is a hoax does not give me confidence in how this crisis will ultimately turn out or that the aging infrastructure that allows such a catastrophe to occur will be fixed any time soon.

Deconstructing the Conspiracy of Deliberate Poisoning of US Municipal Water
Craig D Pearcey on July 31, 2016
Link

Heavy metals here, there, everywhere…
One of the key narratives among the supporters and practitioners of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM), particularly those with a conspiratorial world-view, is the claim that vast portions of the US general populous is being deliberately poisoned by certain corporations, special-interest groups, invested individuals, and the US government. Some of these supporters and practitioners go as far as to claim that this conspiracy is global in scope and not restricted solely to the USA. Among the supposed vectors of this poisoning is the claim of elevated and/or toxic levels of heavy-metals in such items as foods, vaccines, as well as municipal drinking water supplies; I will address the latter in this article.
One prolific web-based publication supporting this narrative is Natural News. Many of its writers, including its editor-in-chief Mr. Mike Adams (The Health Ranger), have added outspoken support to these claims of…someone…deliberately poisoning the drinking water. A brief search on Google using the appropriate keywords produces a large number of hits, with many of these hits being found on the Natural News website, and many have heavy-metal “detoxing” as a central theme. Titles of these Natural News articles include:
    • “SHOCK FINDING: Oil and gas industry dumping toxic fracking waste into public water treatment plants incapable of filtering contaminants” [Internet Archive]
    • “Don’t let heavy metals weigh you down; you can detox with some of the world’s greatest superfoods” [Internet Archive]
    • “Health Ranger releases stunning infographic showing how heavy metals end up in the food supply due to industrial pollution” [Internet Archive]
    • “Detox from heavy metals naturally by adding some cilantro to your sandwiches or salads” [Internet Archive]
    • “China arrests thousands for environmental crimes as U.S. continues allowing heavy metals in food supply” [Internet Archive]
    • “How to reduce your toxic heavy metal load simply and cheaply” [Internet Archive]
Of particular interest are three recent articles by Adams himself. In reference to his first article, during announcing the launch of his Natural Science Journal, Adams openly states that none of the existing science establishment (Academia, Corporate and Government) can be trusted [Internet Archive]. This is clearly illustrated in that announcement as follows:
In a world where nearly all so-called “science” is actually little more than corporate fraud and government malfeasance, nearly all mainstream science journals have been taken over by pharmaceutical and biotech interests. As a result, they destroy and suppress human knowledge rather than expanding it.
All the big science journals — Nature, The British Medical Journal, The Lancet and so on — function almost entirely as science prostitutes for corporate interests, spewing out a vomitous cascade of fraudulent, industry ghostwritten “doctored” studies that the industry pretends represent real science. This sad, filthy corruption of science harms the reputation of science itself and detracts from the valuable expansion of knowledge that can be achieved when science is practiced in the interests of humanity rather than corporate profits.
My aim is to rescue science from corporate prostitution and return science to the democratic, decentralized domain of the curious and the informed. (That means you.) This is why today, I have extraordinary news to unveil… a milestone for independent science conducted in the public interest… something that hasn’t happened before in the history of our world.
Today I’m announcing the launch of a new, independent, peer-reviewed science journal called the Natural Science Journal — a science journal that rejects all corporate money, government influence and all the blind, obedient “consensus” science narratives that only end in stupidity.
The actual first article itself, entitled: “ICP-MS analysis of toxic elements (heavy metals) in 100 municipal water samples from across the United States” [Internet Archive], is a simple laboratory report discussing the results obtained. It makes no remarkable claims and is written at the level of a laboratory analyst or technician. However, there is an attempt in the results and conclusion section by the author to make more of the actual observed heavy-metal levels measured than is warranted. The second article, however, is more direct and inflammatory. In it Adams openly claims [Internet Archive] that certain invested individuals and groups are deliberate poisoning the general US public using dangerously elevated levels of various heavy-metals in municipal and state drinking water sources. In this second article [Internet Archive] he referenced to further analytical results of US municipal and state drinking water undertaken by his CWC laboratory. Adams’ accusations are clearly demonstrated in both the title of the article (“Obama’s EPA caught covering up high heavy metals pollution across U.S. cities as federal government wages multi-faceted WAR against its own citizens”) and its content which states:
Our citizen-powered EPA Watch program has now resulted in the open source publishing of heavy metals contamination tests of 230 municipal water samples across America. The results show that two to three per cent of the U.S. water is highly contaminated with toxic heavy metals, poisoning an estimated 10 million Americans with brain-damaging contaminants that surpass EPA limits.
Yet the EPA has not alerted Americans to these toxic heavy metals in their water. Just as in the case of Flint, Michigan, the EPA is systematically covering up irrefutable scientific evidence of heavy metals water contamination across America.
The third article [Internet Archive], the most recent, is just a continuation of Adams’ accusations based on the data referenced in his second:
(NaturalNews) We’ve now published the water testing results for 239 water samples collected by our readers all across America.
As promised, this is part of our effort to conduct real science in the public interest and share the results publicly… even as the corrupt, criminal federal government conspires to hide these data from the public. (The EPA, like every agency of the government regime, has become a corrupt, anti-science front group that deliberately pollutes America’s waterways while covering up its crimes.)
Finally, in the last week Mr Adams has posted two new articles in which he promotes the opening of his CWC laboratory to the public for testing purposes. They reference the earlier articles containing data for the first 100 and, then, extended 239 water samples.
    • “Health Ranger’s science lab announces water and soil testing services for the public: ICP-MS analysis reveals levels of 7 toxic metals, 3 major minerals and 10 trace elements” [Internet archive]
    • “CWC Labs announces heavy metals water and soils testing services to the public; 20 toxic metals, minerals and trace elements analyzed via ICP-MS” [Internet archive]
… Or not
Fortunately, Adams did not only make the aforementioned claims, he also supplied the actual results measured by his Consumer Wellness Center Laboratory. Before diving into the raw data, there is one item that Adams must receive the appropriate due recognition for, namely the ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation recently achieved by his Consumer Wellness Center Laboratory. Having personally spent nearly two decades dealing with ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation for multiple laboratory analytical methods, I am fully aware of the large amount of effort and work required to achieve and maintain such an accreditation.
However, I believe that this accreditation will not provide Adams, his supporters, and those in the CAM arena with the “magic-bullet” they hoped for against the established sciences (academic, corporate and government). In fact, some of them may actually start to view it as a poisoned chalice in the near future.
Tilting at ISO 17025 accredited ICP-MS wind-mills
The ISO/IEC 17025 standard is a lab-based quality system for the accurate, precise, and repeatable measurement of laboratory samples via internationally accepted standards, methodologies, procedures, and techniques to produce results that, when necessary, can be successfully used in any competent legal system. The standard itself is divided into two general sections, an Administrative section and a Technical section. Together they cover all aspects of running an accredited laboratory.
A key criteria underlining the entire ISO/IEC 17025 standard is traceability. Everything must be traceable back to its source/origin and/or to the international standards that the ISO/IEC 17025 standard is based on. This provides an accredited laboratory with a very capable system that is both internationally recognized and which generates reliable and trust-worthy results. Without the traceability, the entire quality system collapses.
The single weakness of the system is around sampling. Many accredited laboratories test samples that are provided by a third party rather than being collected by the accredited laboratory themselves. This is the situation Adams’ Consumer Wellness Center Laboratory finds itself in with regards the Municipal and State water samples.
An Inductive Coupled Plasma/Mass-Spectroscopy (ICP-MS) is the combination of two useful analytical techniques: Inductive Coupled Plasma with a Plasma Sampling Interface and Mass-Spectroscopy. An ICP-MS instrument is actually two analytical instruments linked together by an appropriate sample junction. The initial test sample is fed into the Inductive Coupled Plasma torch which converts the heavy-metals in the sample into ions and delivers these to the MS instrument. The MS instrument then determines the type of molecule each component is, based on its measured molecular mass, as well as its concentration which can be referenced back to original sample and its make-up.
Another aspect of any analytical chemistry technique is the condition of the original sample and any associated preparation required before analysis. It can can be either a solid or liquid or gas, and may require specialized preparation depending on the type of analysis. For water samples, another aspect is whether the samples were supplied as a solution (complete dissolution of components) or a suspension/colloid (fine solid material floating/suspended within the water). For a suspension/colloid, the solid material is usually first separated from the water sample before analysis can commence, but for clear solutions — such as the water samples analyzed by Mr Adams’ Consumer Wellness Center Laboratory — sample preparation tends to be minimal.
And the raw data says …
So Mr Adams did us the favor of providing the analytical data for municipal and state water samples tested by his CWC laboratory. This allows not only a review of his data against his claims, but also a more thorough statistical interrogation of the data. A summary of this statistical interrogation is given in the table following (Table 1).
Table 1: Summary of CWC Laboratory analysis of 239 municipal and state water sources in the USA [Internet Archive]
	Aluminium(Al)ppb (µg/l)	Copper(Cu)ppb (µg/l)	Arsenic(As)ppb (µg/l)	Cadmium(Cd)ppb (µg/l)	Mercury(Hg)ppb (µg/l)	Lead(Pb)ppb (µg/l)	All Metals	As, Cd, Hg, Pb
							No.	(%)	No.	(%)
Variance (Ơ2)	2 730.10	35 369.63	1.34	0.08	0.00	79.56	n/a	n/a	n/a	n/a
Std. Deviation (Ơ)	52.25	188.07	1.16	0.29	0.00	8.92	n/a	n/a	n/a	n/a
No. samples withZ-Scores: >= 3ơ	8	5	5	5	0	3	23	9.6%	11	4.6%
AVE	28.69	101.01	0.80	0.08	0.00	1.49	n/a	n/a	n/a	n/a
EPA permittedmax. (ppb)	500	1300	10	5	2	15	n/a	n/a	n/a	n/a
% of EPA max.	5.74	7.77	7.97	1.67	0.00	9.91	n/a	n/a	n/a	n/a
No. samplesexceedingmax. spec.	0	1	1	0	0	4	6	2.5%	5	2.1%
An initial review of the data provided by Adams indicated that few of the samples tested were outside the specifications stipulated by the EPA. When subjected to a Z-score analysis, a few interesting (but not unexpected) observations were made. For those unfamiliar with Z-Score statistics, it is a statistical method for determining whether each analytical data-point in a sample set is statistical similar or different for the sample set in question. This allows the reviewer of the data to note, with a given level of confidence, if an individual sample is significantly different from the others and, thus, which samples to take note of (ie. whether a particular sample approaches the maximum specifications set for it). Of the 239 samples analyzed, only 23 results were statistically different at a 99% confidence level (i.e. 3 sigma / 3ơ) based on a Z-Score analysis. That is equivalent to only 9.6% of the entire data set of all metals analyzed. If we remove aluminum and copper from the analysis, assuming that these elevated levels are coming from public water infrastructure that is old and/or in disrepair (ie. rusting water lines and pipes — a less scientific, but still reasonable assumption) and focus on the heavy-metals of considerably more concern (arsenic, cadmium, mercury, and lead, which are known for their severely toxic properties), then only 4.6% (i.e. 11 samples) are statistically different and thus are worth further investigation. However, the main finding behind the Z-Score is that the data sets for the water samples tested are mostly uniform, with most of the samples being statistically similar in that they generally have low levels of heavy-metal contamination.
Review of the averages (ie. the mean) across each heavy-metal indicated that all of the averages were below 10% of the maximum limit specified by the EPA, even when including the few elevated “outlier’ readings. That is to say, the average sample was well below the EPA levels of concern. Finally, of all 239 samples tested, only 2.5% (ie. 6 samples) exceeded the maximum limits specified by the EPA, and this drops to 2.1% when aluminum and copper are excluded from the average.
However, in Adams’ third article he states:
EPA limits, by the way, are much higher than what the United Nations requires for third world nations. So even water the EPA declares to be “safe” for Americans to drink may be considered unfit for human consumption in places like Somalia. (How’s that for a little factoid you didn’t expect?)
However Adams claims in this regards are without any merit as given by limits specified for drinking water by both the EU and WHO (Table 2).
Table 2: Heavy metal limits specified by the EPA, WHO and EU
	Aluminium(Al)ppb (µg/l)	Copper(Cu)ppb (µg/l)	Arsenic(As)ppb (µg/l)	Cadmium(Cd)ppb (µg/l)	Mercury(Hg)ppb (µg/l)	Lead(Pb)ppb (µg/l)
EPA (PermittedMaximum)	500	1 300	10	5	2	15
WHO (PermittedMaximum)	200	2 000	10	3	1	10
EU (PermittedMaximum)	200	100* /3 000*	50	5	1	50
* EU Copper / guideline (no limit specified): 100 ppb running water / 3000ppb standing water
In general, the differences between the EPA, WHO and the EU are small. In some cases the EPA is a little less stringent, in other cases its limits are stricter, and for the rest they are essentially identical. In particular, for the four heavy metals of concern (arsenic, cadmium, mercury, and lead) the EPA is on par with both WHO (UN) and the EU. Adams attempted to create the impression that the EPA limits are significant higher than the UN (and dangerously so) but this is clearly not the case from the limits specified. This raises the question as to why Adams made such an accusation. One likely possibility is that Adams is aware that his own data does not strongly support the contention that there is a vast conspiracy to deliberately poison the US public en masse. Thus to create that impression he made the erroneous and deceptive claim about the UN limits for heavy metal contamination of drinking water being significantly lower than those used by the EPA — ie. In other words he was trying to forcibly create a crisis, a “phantom menace” if you will, where there actual was none. If true, this is action is to be condemned with the harshest censure as any individual that claims to be a scientist violates the main precept of science when he or she tries to force the data to fit a pre-existing hypothesis. The data tests the hypothesis, the hypothesis does not dictate the data.
Thus, instead of supporting Adams claims of mass heavy-metal poisoning through drinking water, Adams’ CWC laboratory results actually proven the complete opposite. If Adams, his supporters, and those of likeminded were correct in their speculation, the laboratory data would have shown significantly more samples with heavy-metal contamination above the EPA limits and much higher heavy-metals contents in almost all water samples for all metals tested in general.
If Adams was truly serious …
If Adams and his supporters were truly serious about the possibility of dangerously contaminated drinking water, then they should approach the entire issue much differently. For one, Adams should have designed a much better experiment, as his present design-of-experiment (DOE) is terribly weak. His “one-tap, one-sample, analyzed-once” approach is grossly inadequate. He should be sampling for each zip-code referenced in the data at more than one location and source, and at each source in triplicate. This would reduce any possible variation that typically arises when sampling a large system. Furthermore, this sampling should also be repeated multiple times over an extended time period, for example weekly or bi-weekly at each location and source over a period of about three months to a year. In addition, the overall analysis should not focus solely on single data points, as Adams present approach does, but rather on patterns in the data such as specific water supplies showing elevated heavy-metal repeatedly over long periods of time, with a particular emphasis on the much more dangerous elements of arsenic, cadmium, mercury, and lead. One further aspect of Adams’ DOE that must be addressed is that no attempt was made to account for the spread of population density in reference to the ZIP-codes tested. There is no way of knowing whether the water samples that demonstrated results above the maximum specified by the EPA were from small rural or town communities of a hundred or so people, or cities of millions. In light of this, making the claim that: “…poisoning an estimated 10 million Americans with brain-damaging contaminants …” is not scientifically justified as no attempt was made to account for population density.
In the end, it is easy for individuals or groups to make unfounded and pseudoscientific claims, but when people try to fit actual scientific fact and measurements — particularly using reliable and accurate analytical techniques — to the pseudoscience, then there is bound to be a conflict between the two. In that case, the well-executed science must always win.

Juice Plus+: Good Marketing, Not Good Science
Juice Plus+ is a multilevel marketing company selling fruits and vegetables that they have reduced to a powder and put into capsules. It’s clever marketing using deceptive advertising. There is no scientific evidence that it benefits health.
Harriet Hall on June 11, 2019
Link


Juice Plus+ has been around for a long time. It was introduced in 1993 and has its own Wikipedia page. That page explains that it is sold via multi-level marketing and says,
Studies of Juice Plus’ effects have generated conflicting and controversial results. Although Juice Plus claims its products’ efficacy is backed by research, multiple critics have argued that there is no scientific proof that Juice Plus offers significant health benefits and that deceptive claims are used in the product’s marketing information. Many marketing claims made about Juice Plus products are false or misleading.
What is it?
There are various Juice Plus+ products containing 30 fruits, vegetables, and grains which have been reduced to a powder and put into capsules. Supplemental vitamins and other nutrients are added, which may be responsible for any observed effects.
The rationale
We know that a healthy diet includes a variety of fruits and vegetables. We know that not everyone eats enough fruits and vegetables to guarantee they are getting all the nutrients they need. We worry. We take multivitamins and dietary supplements as insurance. The company is capitalizing on our worries and selling a convenient capsule without any real evidence that it will benefit us. Their advertising clearly says, “Juice Plus+ is not a substitute for eating fruits and vegetables” and “it is the next best thing to eating fruits and vegetables.” Why settle for “the next best thing” when you could have “the best thing?” They claim that it is absorbed by the body, reduces oxidative stress, promotes cardiovascular wellness, supports a healthy immune system, and helps protect DNA. The available published research doesn’t bear that out.
The research
They list more than 20 journals that have published studies on Juice Plus+, but those studies don’t amount to much. They are mainly pilot studies or small studies that show changes in some laboratory value but don’t show clinically meaningful changes in actual health outcomes. They compare Juice Plus+ to inert placebo pills rather than to a more meaningful control like other nutritional supplements or a diet with more fruits and vegetables. The studies were mostly funded and carried out by the manufacturer and distributors.
They cite a Family Health Study Survey that supposedly shows striking health benefits: 60% were missing fewer days of school, 66% were visiting the doctor less, 71% were consuming less fast food and soft drinks, etc. But this is meaningless data collected from self-reports by their customers, with no control group for comparison. Customers are obviously health-conscious, or they wouldn’t be taking the product; there’s no reason to think the product itself makes them any more health-conscious. In an article on MLM Watch, Stephen Barrett explains why the “research” of the Juice Plus Children’s Research Foundation is not valid.
A video on their website describes a study at the University of Newcastle in Australia of 56 overweight adults. It found that subjects who took the product for 8 weeks had a 3.5% reduction in cholesterol levels compared to subjects who took an identical-appearing placebo. They said that was equivalent to a 9-pound weight loss and a 9% reduction in cardiovascular risk, but this was an unwarranted assumption. They had no evidence that those subjects were actually less likely to suffer a cardiovascular event. And they had no evidence that Juice Plus+ was in any way superior to other ways of providing nutrients.
Testimonials from health professionals and O.J. Simpson
On the company website, there is a page of Juice Plus+ reviews with 27 videos of doctors and other health professionals who allegedly recommend Juice Plus+. But do they really recommend that product? From the blurbs accompanying the videos, they seem to be about the general importance of good nutrition for health, from fruits and vegetables in the diet, not from supplements. I would have liked to know more about what they said, but every video I clicked on said “video unavailable”.
O.J. Simpson was a highly paid celebrity endorser of Juice Plus+, claiming that it had cured his arthritis, improved his golf game, and allowed him to stop his anti-arthritis medications. The truth of his testimonials came into question during his notorious trial for murder, where he said he was still taking drugs for arthritis and claimed to have been too incapacitated by arthritis to have murdered anyone.
Criticisms
Many scientists and skeptics have asked questions that have not been satisfactorily answered. Does the product contain enough fruit and vegetable powder to produce clinical benefits? Are the nutrients all bioavailable and well-absorbed? Is the labeling accurate? Chemical analyses have found that the amounts of ingredients differ from what the label says. Complaints have been filed with the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and the FDA for misleading advertising, and Australia’s Therapeutic Goods Association found the advertising to be in breach of their advertising code.
The claims of antioxidant activity are supported by a few small, poor-quality studies that were not placebo-controlled or blinded; better quality studies found no antioxidant activity. Juice Plus+ is marketed to cancer patients, but experts have warned the potential risks of antioxidants outweigh the benefits when taken during cancer treatment. For that matter, antioxidants may not have the health benefits they are claimed to have, and antioxidants can become pro-oxidants in some situations.
The claims for improved cardiovascular health and improved immune function are similarly plagued by poor-quality research and contradictory results.
In “Juice Plus: A Critical Look,” Stephen Barrett says the company would like you to believe everyone should take Juice Plus+, even if their diet contains adequate amounts of the nutrients in the product, and he gives a cogent, well-referenced explanation of why he disagrees.
The fiber in fruits and vegetables has protective effects; the fiber has been removed from Juice Plus+. It is not a complete nutritional supplement; it lacks the vitamin B12 and mineral content that are present in most multivitamin supplements. And the actual amounts of its components are not disclosed. It contains added beta-carotene, which has been associated with increased risk of cancer; The Medical Letter reviewed the evidence and concluded “no one should take beta-carotene supplements”.
The company claims that the “natural food enzymes” in Juice Plus+ provide additional benefit, but they are digested once eaten and don’t act as enzymes in the body.
Dr. Barrett explains:
the Juice Plus+ recipe for success is very simple: Fruits and vegetables are good for us. Capture their goodness in convenient products. Add endorsements, testimonials, a pinch of fear, a scientific veneer, and several dollops of deception. And harness the power of multilevel marketing (MLM) to spread the word.
That’s a recipe for marketing success, but it says nothing about the effectiveness or safety of the product.
The University of California, Berkeley’s Wellness Letter questioned the various claims in detail, concluding “No capsule can substitute for fruits and vegetables“.
Conclusion: reassurance and “insurance” for the worried well; no proven health benefit
Potential purchasers might want to ask:
    • Am I actually deficient in some nutrients? How could I find out? (Blood tests? Evaluation by a dietitian?)
    • Is this product the best way to correct nutrient deficiencies (clearly not!).
    • If nutrients are good, wouldn’t more nutrients be better? (NO. If you already have adequate levels, additional vitamins will be excreted and will provide no benefit; it will only result in expensive pee.)
    • Are any multivitamin or nutritional supplements worthwhile? A lot of people take them, often for bogus reasons like “increased energy” or “soil depletion,” but experts agree that most people don’t benefit from them, and some ingredients can be harmful.
    • Is it worth the money? (In my opinion, it is not.)
    • Is there any evidence that it will make me healthier? (No, only testimonials and marketing propaganda.)
    • If I become a distributor, will I make a lot of money? (Don’t count on it. 99% of MLM distributors lose money.)
Juice Plus+ may reassure scientifically naïve customers so they won’t have to worry about their diet. At a cost of around $500 a year, I don’t think it’s a prudent investment. It makes much more sense to invest that money in improving your diet. We know diet works. We can’t know if Juice Plus+ works unless large, randomized, double-blind, properly controlled studies provide credible evidence. I’m not holding my breath.

   Super Fruit Juices – The New Snake Oil
Steven Novella
Link
The core principle of science-based medicine is that health care decisions should be based upon our best current scientific evidence and understanding. When applied to the regulation of health products this means that health claims should first be required to meet some reasonable threshold of scientific evidence before they are allowed. Admittedly this is not a purely scientific question but the application of scientific knowledge to an essentially political question – the balance of protection vs freedom.
Regardless of where one thinks this balance should be, I think most would agree that is it a problem if the public generally wants more protection than it is getting, or believes it is currently getting more protection than it is. A Harris poll from 2002 indicates that the majority of Americans believe that companies cannot make health claims about supplements unless they have been proven scientifically and approved by the FDA, when in fact this is not the case. The Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994 (DSHEA), largely through the efforts of Senator Orin Hatch from Utah, removed supplements from the control of the FDA and specifically allowed for so-called structure function claims to be made about products without any burden of proof. Most Americans are not aware of this fact.
Since DSHEA there has been an explosion in the supplement industry with products making the exact kind of claims that the law now allows without prior approval. In many ways we have returned to the time of the patent medicine craze, prior to the creation of the FDA, when dubious remedies of all kinds (so-called snake oil) were sold out of the back of traveling carriages. Now the internet is the favorite venue, and snake-oil salesmen have learned how to thrive within the current system – but their claims and marketing ploys are otherwise not very different from the purveyors of patent medicine from last century.
Fad medicines tend to come and go with the fashions of the marketplace. In recent years super juices have been particularly popular. Companies selling exotic fruit juice, usually from a tropical island, for exorbitant prices make a host of health claims for their magic elixir. Over the last decade Tahitian Noni has been popular. More recently XanGo juice has scored billions of dollars in sales.
Here are some of the claims made for XanGo on the company website:
XanGo® Juice boasts a proprietary whole–fruit formula, harnessing a concentrated rush of xanthones—a vigorous family of next–generation phytonutrients. Sounds complex. But here’s the straight scoop. Research shows xanthones possess potent antioxidant properties that may help maintain intestinal health, strengthen the immune system, neutralize free radicals, help support cartilage and joint function, and promote a healthy seasonal respiratory system.*
The asterix links to the following small-print disclaimer:
*These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.
You will notice that the company makes those claims that are specifically allowed for by DSHEA without the need for any evidence – that their product “maintains intestinal health,” “strengthen the immune system,” and “support cartilage and joint function.” The disclaimer is also required by DSHEA, so the company is completely within the law, at least as far as their website goes.
But is the public served by allowing this type of marketing? Despite the disclaimer, most people think these claims have been proven scientifically and approved by the FDA, and the distinction between “structure function” claims and actual health claims is deliberately blurred. Does “maintain intestinal health” mean that this juice will help with irritable bowel syndrome or crohn’s disease? The company is not allowed to make such claims – ones that refer to specific diseases, but they can infer it all they want.
The other component to the marketing strategy is to simply refer to basic science claims (as opposed to clinical claims) – just list some of the ingredients in the juice as if they have been proven to be healthful. Antioxidants are among the most popular recently, but as I have discussed recently there is no evidence that routine supplementation with antioxidants has any measurable health benefit.
Are these claims of superior content (regardless of their health implications) even true? Recently the Associated Press did an independent analysis, just to find out about the antioxidant content of XanGo. This is what they report:
For the lab test, The Associated Press shipped a 750-milliliter bottle of XanGo to Oregon State University’s Linus Pauling Institute at Corvallis. The institute measured its antioxidant strength against store-bought juices that sell for a few dollars a bottle.
On a scale of molecular weight, XanGo’s antioxidants measured 14,884 “micromoles” per liter — slightly higher than cranberry juice, but lower than black cherry and less than half the power of blueberry juice. Apple juice finished last in this test.
“In terms of its antioxidant capacity, XanGo is in the middle of the pack,” said Balz Frei, the institute’s director and chairman.
So XanGo is likely just ordinary fruit juice. It contains calories and nutrients, and is probably reasonably good nutrition, but no more so than many other more common fruit juices. The difference, however, is that XanGo costs $40 per bottle and is sold with a host of pseudo-health claims, while cranberry juice is not.
XanGo maintains, however, that it’s product is “a rich cocktail of other beneficial chemicals barely known to science” If they are barely known to science, then how does this company know about it? There is no evidence that they have conducted any research, published papers, or otherwise established that their product has any special “beneficial chemicals.” I would also point out that “beneficial chemicals” sounds an awful lot like drugs. Yet they are not studied or regulated as such.
It is also interesting to note that both Noni juice and XanGo are sold through multi-level marketing. Critics of MLM companies point out that only the top 1% of distributors actually make any money. The rest are really consumers who are forced to stockpile product they may never sell, and who at best sell enough product to support their own use. In essence, and by their own admission, XanGo has “700,000 unsalaried sales associates in 17 countries.” That is a huge free sales force, that doubles as a customer base, making money for the top 1%. I will also note that both Tahitian Noni and Xango (like much of the supplement industry) are based out of Utah, the home state of Orin Hatch (the man behind DSHEA).
The MLM strategy also allows the company to make one-on-one sales pitches. There is no way to track what individual sales people say to their potential customers – if the claims are not on the company website or in official sales publications. This gives the company of layer of protection from the FDA and FTC. To see this in practice, the AP reports:
XanGo has been warned by the FDA for claiming that mangosteen could ward off disease or cancer. The company insists those claims were printed by a third party on a brochure at a recruitment seminar and it’s not responsible.
The current experience with the “super juice” nutritional supplements highlights many weaknesses of our current system. The public believes that it is getting more protection, and more assurance of honesty and safety, than it is currently getting. Claims are allowed that are virtually designed to be deceptive. Marketing claims go far beyond the evidence. Also, the supplement industry has no incentive to perform meaningful research. Research is a lose-lose proposition: it will cost them money, it may turn out negative, and in any case they already have access to their market without the need to provide scientific evidence.
Unless and until the current regulations change, consumers need to be very aware of DSHEA and exactly what it means. The current system relies heavily on the principle of let the buyer beware – which means consumers need to have sharp criticism toward any supplement claims.

Energy Drinks are Risky, Especially for Kids
Should children drink energy drinks? No, it’s a terrible idea.
Clay Jones on November 21, 2014
Link


Last month I wrote a post on the causes of poor sleep in adolescents, as well as the myriad problems that can result in this high-risk population. Fortunately there is a system-wide public health measure proven to work, and now groups like the American Academy of Pediatrics are fully endorsing it. In that post, I briefly mentioned the increasing popularity of energy drinks and shots as caffeine delivery devices, and their role as both a potential cause of sleep deprivation and a means of temporarily ameliorating the effects.
I have been planning on addressing in greater detail the intentional, and unfortunately often accidental, ingestion of energy drinks in the pediatric population and the various associated risks for quite a while. What finally motivated me to get to work on this topic was the recent spate of media coverage regarding the results of a study presented this week at the American Heart Association’s Scientific Sessions 2014. The research, which involved the analysis of data obtained from the National Poison Data System for October 2010 through September 2013, supports concerns that pediatricians and other pediatric healthcare professionals have had for a very long time. Energy drinks are dangerous, particularly in young children, and a large part of the blame falls on the shoulders of manufacturers as well as the 1994 Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA) so frequently discussed on SBM.
Before I break down the scary numbers from the study, first a little background on energy drinks.
What are energy drinks/shots, who drinks them and what’s actually in those things?
Unless you have recently emerged from a lengthy coma that began sometime prior to the late 1980’s, then you will have been exposed, likely many thousands of times over just the past few years, to the existence of energy drinks and shots, and the lofty claims made by their manufacturers. These are extremely popular beverages, with sales in the United States alone coming in at more than $12.5 billion in 2012. Their popularity is also skyrocketing with a 60% increase in consumption from 2008 to 2012.
Not surprisingly, the typical customer looking for an energy drink is young, with 2/3 being between ages of 13 and 35 years. Also not very shocking is the fact that about 2/3 of overall consumers are male. Just look at the marketing, which is largely tied to sports teams, “extreme” athletics/stunts (skydiving from the stratosphere!) and television shows popular with male teens and young adults. Manufacturers are trying to reach out to other groups however by increasingly marketing energy products as health drinks that are low-calorie or that boost the immune system as well as cognitive performance, in addition to simply granting miraculous increases in energy and stamina “without the crash.” Oh, and don’t forget the antioxidants! These things are often lousy with antioxidants.
Energy drinks and shots contain caffeine of course, often in absurd amounts and for no apparent reason other than to be able to brag about being the most powerful drink on the block. They also contain a number of other ingredients (which Scott Gavura has discussed previously). Some of these other ingredients, particularly guarana, amount to nothing more than additional caffeine. In fact, because of the limits imposed on the FDA (thanks, DSHEA), energy drinks aren’t regulated in regards to the accuracy of their labels. So the amount of caffeine in an individual energy drink may be hidden behind “proprietary blend” on the label, and even when listed can be inaccurate by more than 20%.
Additional ingredients often mixed in with caffeine are sugar, amino acids like taurine, ginseng and the ubiquitous B vitamins. These are often described as the “energy vitamins.” There are many more ingredients incorporated into the hundreds of different energy drink/shot products. I won’t list them all but will add that more than a few can potentially add to the caffeine content, stimulant effect and overall side effect profile. None of these have been studied for safety or efficacy in children or in combination in any age group.
In general, there is a wide range of caffeine amounts found in energy drinks when studied, with some containing very little and relying more on the hype of useless vitamins and herbs to grab the consumer’s interest. With thanks again to DSHEA, however, the consumer can’t trust that what is in the product is accurately represented on the label. Other caffeine containing products are more regulated and the amount of caffeine listed on the label can be trusted. Cokes (and as a Southerner, by coke I mean any carbonated cola-type beverage) and over-the-counter caffeine pills like Vivarin and NoDoz contain what they say they do because they don’t masquerade as a supplement in order to avoid accountability.
As I mentioned earlier, the amount of caffeine in some of these products is shocking. For comparison, a standard 6.5 ounce cup of coffee contains anywhere from 80 to 120 mg of caffeine depending on the brewing method. 12 ounces of cola can’t contain more than 65 mg of caffeine by law, so even Mountain Dew is wimpy compared to most energy drinks. The typical energy drink contains at least as much caffeine as a standard cup of coffee, while some have significantly more per serving. Let’s look at the two most popular brands, Red Bull and Monster, which share well over half of the energy drink market.
A typical Red Bull is made with Alpine spring water (fancy!), taurine, B vitamins, sugar and 80 mg of caffeine in an 8.4 ounce can. Not bad, although many teens and young adults drink more than one serving at a time and mix Red Bull with alcohol, an extremely risky combination which I’ll get to shortly. Monster doesn’t provide a list of ingredients on their website. According to a few online resources, a standard Monster energy drink contains similar ingredients but has a proprietary “energy blend” which has about the same amount of caffeine in it as Red Bull, with 160 mg in their 16 ounce can. But because it also contains guarana, and whatever else is in their stimulant cocktail, who really knows?
Monster sells a number of additional products with names like “Assault” and “Anti-Gravity.” The latter apparently contains nitrous oxide and additional energy blend components like the herb yerba mate that serves as an additional source of caffeine and other potential stimulants. This product contains 160mg of caffeine in a 12 ounce bottle so is a bit more concentrated. It is also important to point out that Monster is in league with Satan.
Okay, now on to the big dogs in the world of energy drinks. While Red Bull and standard Monster energy drinks contain roughly 10 mg caffeine (that we know of) in every ounce of product, another Monster product called M3 starts getting silly. It’s their most potent product, containing much larger doses of stimulant herbs and 160 mg of caffeine in its 5 ounce non-twist off cap covered glass bottle. That is 32 mg of caffeine per ounce if you are keeping score. 5 ounces of sweet syrupy liquid that a young child could easily down in a gulp and end up in the hospital.
The next product I’ll feature shows how scary this stuff can be. Redline energy drink is marketed to body builders and contains, in addition to almost 40 mg of caffeine per ounce in the 8 ounce bottle, and typical herbal stimulants, a number of additional ingredients like guggulsterone and vinpocetine. I honestly don’t even want to know what those are, but I can guarantee you that they haven’t been tested for safety in kids or likely anybody else. This product could kill a toddler or anyone with an underlying heart condition.
Moving on to the energy shot category there are several that contain dangerous amounts of caffeine and other stimulants. The king of energy shots is a product known as DynaPep. It contains no less than “adrenaline inducing phytochemicals”, but more importantly 714 mg of caffeine in one measly little ounce. In case you missed that, it contains 714 mg of caffeine per ounce. It comes in a .14 ounce bottle however, so while a young child who happened upon several containers could easily suffer toxic effects if each was consumed, it is less likely than with ALRI Hypershot for instance. This product contains, among some of the usual additional ingredients, 500 mg of caffeine in a 2 ounce bottle. The much more popular 5-Hour Energy’s extra strength formulation lists 200 mg of caffeine in their 2 ounce bottle but hides behind a proprietary blend so, once again, who really knows? But it’ll be more than enough to cause harm to young children if ingested in full. (5-Hour Energy’s claims and contents have been addressed by our own Harriet Hall previously on SBM.)
How much caffeine is too much?
Caffeine is a central nervous system stimulant and is extremely popular around the world. In the United States, about 90% of adults consume caffeine in some form every day. The reasons for its popularity are straightforward. It can increase mental alertness, especially when sleep deprived, and can provide a mild-to-moderate boost to athletic performance. And long-term ingestion at reasonable levels may have other benefits, such as decreasing the risk of developing Parkinson’s disease. But it is also associated with a number of common side effects, particularly jitteriness, anxiety, insomnia, headaches and heart palpitations. These can occur with even reasonable amounts of caffeine in some individuals secondary to differences in metabolism.
Long term daily use of caffeine can lead to physical dependence and withdrawal, making it a common cause of chronic headaches, and the development of tolerance can lead to a need to ingest increasing amounts over time. Sadly, many regular caffeine users believe that they use it to feel a boost when in reality they crave it just to feel normal. It is not uncommon for neurologists caring for patients with frequent headaches to discuss intake of coffee in pots rather than cups each day. I use caffeine myself, but strategically so by avoiding caffeine intake except when needed for an occasional boost in alertness. And I only take caffeine in the form of regulated caffeine pills. Well, that and chocolate.
The amount of daily caffeine that is widely considered safe in adults is up to 400 mg, although some experts recommend trying to stay between 100 to 200 mg. Of course depending on an individual’s state of health, any amount of caffeine may be unsafe. Patients with underlying cardiac disease who may not tolerate sudden sharp increases in blood pressure and heart rate should probably avoid it altogether. And some people are very sensitive to even small amounts of caffeine. But most people consume caffeine without any major issues.
Caffeine in children is a different issue as they are even more sensitive to potential side effects, especially if they an underlying cardiac abnormality or neurologic disorder. It is not clear what amount should be considered safe in kids, and there are no FDA guidelines on safe consumption in this population. Most pediatricians agree that young children don’t need it and should not ingest it. The same can be said for older kids as well, but it is incredibly difficult to avoid all caffeine intake as children age.
According to the AAP, roughly three out of four non-infant kids get caffeine in some form every day. Mostly caffeine is ingested in the form of cola and candy, but energy drink intake is steadily increasing. Although the AAP doesn’t give specific guidelines other than avoidance, experts in other countries have done so. Health Canada, for example, recommends that 45 mg of daily caffeine be the limit for children aged 4 to 6 years, 62.5 mg for ages 7 to 9 years, and an 85 mg cap for kids 10 to 12 years. A 100 mg limit is widely thrown around when talking about a daily caffeine limit for teenagers.
When it comes to energy drinks, the total consumption in anyone, let alone young children, really should be none. Even forgetting for a moment the fact that what the label says likely does not accurately represent what is actually in the bottle, there are no ingredients found in any energy drink or shot that are required for a healthy diet and lifestyle, even caffeine, that can’t be obtained by eating a variety of fruits and vegetables. And when it comes to kids, it is extremely easy for them to accidentally or intentionally take in harmful amounts.
Mixing energy drinks and alcohol
Teenagers and young adults frequently mix energy drinks with alcohol. In fact, pre-mixed products containing large amounts of both caffeine and alcohol were available in stores until fairly recently. These products were clearly marketed to attract young and often underage consumer. After a number of deaths and a year-long investigation, they were effectively banned by the FDA in November of 2010. This ban has unequivocally saved lives.
Why is it so bad to mix alcohol and energy drinks? Don’t people mix alcohol and caffeine in colas all the time? Sure, but the difference is the amount of caffeine. One of the more popular versions of these now-banned combination products contained 12% alcohol by volume and 260 mg of caffeine in a 24 ounce can, for example, and people often didn’t stop at drinking just one.
The ingestion of such large amounts of caffeine leads to the drinker having an altered perception of just how drunk they really are. They don’t feel as impaired, and may not pass out when they normally would have at a certain blood alcohol level. This increased alertness, and decreased awareness of one’s degree of impairment, can result in the ability to continue drinking and the false belief that they are okay to drive. This has been described as being “wide-awake drunk.”
Now back to the research presented this week at the AHA conference.
What does the poison control data reveal about energy drink dangers?
During the three-year period looked at by the researchers, there were more than 5,000 documented exposures to energy drinks/shots that led to the involvement of a poison control center. It is important to point out that this very likely grossly underestimates the true number of events. This particular study didn’t include visits to emergency rooms for energy drink-related toxicity which did not result in a call to poison control. Also, parents of children with milder side effects may not have even felt the need to call, perhaps because they did not recognize a connection between the ingestion and the symptoms.
Of the roughly 5,000 poison control calls, 40% involved children less than 6 years of age and were considered unintentional ingestions. Moderate and severe outcomes were common overall, occurring in 42% of calls involving a combination of alcohol with an energy drink and 19% when only energy drinks were consumed. Of the serious outcomes, 57% involved dangerous rhythm disturbances in the heart and 55% reported seizures.
The researchers involved in the study, and pediatricians in general, have called for better regulation of these products for years. Why are manufacturers of energy drinks/shots allowed to hide behind misleading labels that cover up how much caffeine is actually in their products? This study further supports our concerns, and not just regarding kids. Many young adults, and in fact people of all ages, are at risk.
Conclusion: Kids shouldn’t drink energy drinks
We need to fix or get rid of DSHEA and hold manufacturers accountable, or at least put warning labels on products that contain such high levels of caffeine. Healthcare professionals also need to be vigilant and ask about energy drink consumption, particularly in children with underlying conditions that would increase their risk of a poor outcome. Education is of course a key component of any response, and increased awareness of the dangers inherent in drinking unregulated drug delivery devices like these is important. Imagine if the energy spent by misinformed anti-GMO crusaders for changing food labels was able to be harnessed for this purpose.

   Energy Drinks
Scott Gavura 
Link
My stimulant of choice is coffee. I started drinking it in first-year university, and never looked back. A tiny four-cup coffee maker became my reliable companion right through graduate school. But since I stopped needing to drink a pot at a time, an entirely new category of products has appeared — the energy drink. Targeting students, athletes, and others seeking a mental or physical boost, energy drinks are now an enormous industry: from the first U.S. product sale in 1997, the market size was $4.8 billion by 2008, and continues to grow. (1)
My precious coffee effectively has a single therapeutic ingredient, caffeine. Its pharmacology is well documented, and the physiologic effects are understood. The safety data isn’t too shabby either: it’s probably not harmful and possibly is even beneficial. (I’m talking about oral consumption — no coffee enemas. Please.) In comparison, energy drinks are a bewildering category of products with an array of ingredients including caffeine, amino acids, vitamins, and other “natural” substances and assorted “nutraceuticals,” usually in a sugar-laden vehicle (though sugar-free versions exist). Given many products contain chemicals with pharmacologic effects, understanding the risks, signs of adverse events, and potential implications on drug therapy, are important.
So are energy drinks just candied caffeine delivery systems? Or are these syrupy supplements skirting drug regulations?
The Message
The ads are seductive. Who doesn’t want more energy? Who doesn’t want their mind and body “vitalized”? And don’t we have time-starved lifestyles? Initially envisioned for athletes, energy drinks are now marketed mainly towards teens and young adults, where uptake has been dramatic. Cross-promotion with extreme sporting events, and creating names like “Full Throttle,” “Rockstar,” and even “Cocaine” burnish the “extreme” image. The market is now segmented further with products targeted at women, vegetarians, diabetics, celiacs, and more. However you identify yourself, there’s probably an energy drink developed with you in mind.
The Ingredients
Evaluating claims of efficacy and safety are complicated by the multiple formulations and versions of the products. Most energy drinks contain these ingredients:
Ginseng is often claimed to have remarkable properties, from preventing colds to acting as an immune “booster”, but there’s actually little evidence to suggest it has any of these effects. Studies looking specifically at performance effects have not been impressive. (2) Furthermore, the doses that have been studied significantly exceed the amounts that are found in energy drinks. At low doses ginseng seems safe, but there’s not a lot of long-term data to reassure us. (3)
Taurine is an amino acid that is is plentiful in our diets, and can also be endogenously manufactured. It’s involved in an array of physiologic functions. What’s not clear is if exogenous taurine supplements have any meaningful effect on subjective or objectively measures of “energy” or performance. There are limited data evaluating taurine in combination with caffeine, but high quality evidence is lacking. Taurine does seem to be reasonably well tolerated, however, with few adverse events reported or expected. (3)
Glucuronolactone is another natural ingredient of food for which there’s no evidence of deficiency, nor any evidence that supplementation improves energy level. Consumption at the levels present in energy drinks is considered safe.
Bitter Orange is the peel or oil from Seville oranges. It became a popular ingredient in supplements after ephedra was pulled from the U.S. market. A natural source of epinephrine-like compounds, it shares the same adverse effect profile, with links to serious events such as syncope, heart attacks, colitis, and stroke. There’s no persuasive evidence demonstrating bitter orange provides any energy boost, particularly at the low levels present in energy drinks. However, given bitter orange is usually combined with other stimulants, the true pharmacologic profile, and consequent adverse effects, may not be clear. (3)
Caffeine and guarana (a natural source of caffeine) are the most relevant ingredients in energy drinks. Caffeine has a variety of physiologic effects, and while it appears to have value improving endurance and reducing fatigue during sustained physical exercise, its role as a cognition booster seems much more tenuous. It also seems to improve the effectiveness of analgesics, and may possibly have its own analgesic properties. In general caffeine has a reasonable safety profile at moderate doses. (3)
While total amount of caffeine in an energy drink may not be listed, as natural sources may not be included in the nutritional information, coffee has more caffeine than many energy drinks. A 16 oz “grande” coffee at Starbucks has 320mg of caffeine; the 20oz “venti” has 400mg. (For Tim Hortons lovers, there’s about half that much caffeine in your double-double). In comparison, a Red Bull has 151mg/16 oz, Monster Khaos has 150mg/16oz, and Rockstar Punched has 160mg/16oz. And a 573mL can of Coca Cola (19oz) has a piddly 62mg. If you accept that caffeine is worth consuming, then energy drinks are clearly not the best source. Even factoring in the caffeine from guarana, coffees still appears to be the caffeine king. (CSPI has a nice compilation of the caffeine content of different beverages.)Besides, there’s always Nodoz.
Vitamins are in many of the energy drinks: especially combinations of the B vitamins, like cyanocobalamin (B12), niacinamide (B3), pantothenic acid (B5) and pyridoxine (B6). Vitamin C is also common. In the absence of a deficiency, there isn’t any persuasive evidence to suggest that supplementation has meaningful effects on “energy”, however defined. (3) Even long term use of the B vitamins doesn’t look promising for cognition.
Sugar is the major sweetener in energy drinks, though sugar-free versions exist. Speaking strictly in terms of chemistry, as a carbohydrate, sugar is the only actual energy in an energy drink. (The “calorie free energy drink” ads make me laugh out loud.) The sugar content of most products seems largely similar to colas and other soft drinks. So if you want to carb-load, there’s no particular advantage to the energy drinks – sugar is sugar, and calories are calories.
Risks
Side effects related to energy drinks appear to be largely due to the caffeine content. Thresholds are difficult to predict, given that tolerances to caffeine can vary. In general, the amounts of taurine, guarana, and other components are felt to be below the level necessary to cause noticeable adverse effects.(2) While there have been serious adverse events reported with energy drinks including seizures and sudden death, clear causation has not been established.
Probably the biggest concern related to energy drinks is their consumptions by youths and adolescents, where caffeine’s effects are less well understood. Sugar and caffeine consumption are probably best minimized in this population, yet it’s clear that this is the target consumer.
The combination of energy drinks with alcohol — they are popular mixers — has been linked to a suppression of the traditional intoxication effects.There’s controversy over the sale of the deliberate combinations of the two ingredients, and some regulators have taken action to stop the sales of some products.
Regulation
Regulation of energy drinks varies by country. From an international perspective, the United States has one of the least regulated marketplaces. (1) Caffeine limits that apply to cola drinks do not apply to energy drinks. In Canada, some energy drinks are federally approved as natural health products. For example, the authorized recommended use for Red Bull is:
Developed for periods of increased mental and physical exertion, helps temporarily restore mental alertness or wakefulness when experiencing fatigue or drowsiness.
The product has a specific caution not to consume more than 500mL (2 cans) per day, and that it is not recommended for children, pregnant, or breastfeeding women.
Given their noveltly in the market, and their growing popularity, expect regulatory approaches to vary around the world. Products like Red Bull have been subject to regulatory restrictions and even bans in some European countries.
Conclusion
Neither innocuous nor toxic, energy drinks seem safe for adults when consumed in moderation. There’s no convincing evidence to back up the cognitive or athletic performance enhancement claims attached to the category, or to specific products. Despite the impressive lists of ingredients and slick marketing, these products are essentially caffeine delivery vehicles, most of which come loaded with sugar. The incremental risk from the other ingredients isn’t well understood, but is probably small when consumed occasionally.
So go ahead and enjoy your Red Bull. But when that liquid candy stops appealing to you, I’ve got some shade-grown, bird-friendly, passive-organic, fair-trade, home-roasted coffee for you to try.
References
     1.  Heckman, M., Sherry, K., & De Mejia, E. (2010). Energy Drinks: An Assessment of Their Market Size, Consumer Demographics, Ingredient Profile, Functionality, and Regulations in the United States Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety, 9 (3), 303-317 DOI: 10.1111/j.1541-4337.2010.00111.x
     2.  Clauson, K., Shields, K., McQueen, C., & Persad, N. (2008). Safety issues associated with commercially available energy drinks Journal of the American Pharmacists Association, 48 (3) DOI: 10.1331/JAPhA.2008.07055
     3.  Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database. Subscription required to view.

The World’s First Productivity Drink
Magic Mind claims to be the world’s first productivity drink. There’s no supporting evidence.
Harriet Hall on April 12, 2022
Link

Magic Mind claims to be the world’s first productivity drink. It seems to me an increase in productivity should be easy to prove. If your widget factory produces 1,000 widgets a day you could do a controlled study comparing workers who used Magic Mind to workers who used a placebo. If the output increased to 1,500 widgets a day for the group using Magic Mind, I would be impressed. But their evidence is merely subjective, on the order of “I felt more productive”.
Each shot contains a magical combination of 12 active ingredients designed to stimulate focus, creativity, energy, and motivation while decreasing stress, oxidation, and decreases post-exercise inflammation in the body.
And they provide links to scientific studies for each ingredient. Wait a minute! Is this supplement mixture based on science or on magic? The label lists 4 types of ingredient: matcha (“ceremonial grade matcha” whatever that means) to give you energy, adaptogens (ashwagandha and turmeric) to help you relax, nootropics (Lion’s Mane Mushrooms, Choline, and Phosphatidylserine) to keep you focused, and honey because it “makes you happy”. For honey, they crow that “They found it in pyramids. PYRAMIDS!” So what?
The claims are inconsistent and incoherent. The references provided don’t support the claims. A reference for matcha and lion’s mane to support the claim that they “extend your morning energy” was not about morning energy, but about mood and cognition. It was about caffeine, L-theanine, and epigallocatechin gallate; it does not mention lion’s mane. For some ingredients they cite positive systematic reviews but neglect to mention other systematic reviews that had negative results. They say “Vitamin C and Echinacea help support the body’s immune system”, a statement that is scientifically meaningless.
This appears to be just another one of those “everything but the kitchen sink” supplement mixtures cobbled together from ingredients that seem to be supported by some cherry-picked studies in order to sell a product with the new claim of “productivity”. That’s innovative and a good marketing ploy, but to my mind it’s more “magic” than science.

   Cranberry Juice
Mark Crislip 
Link
It always somewhat surprises me how some interventions never seem to die. Theophylline seems to have disappeared in the medical pantheon, but what comes around, goes around. I predict a resurgence of theophylline this century. Despite the recent study that shows, yet again, echinacea has no effect on colds, I predict the study will neither decrease the sales of echinacea nor prevent further funds being spent on clinical trials on its efficacy. Hear that JREF? I made predictions. I will await my million dollar check. Make it out to Mark Crislip.
Another therapy that refuses to be put to rest, or even to be clarified, is the use of cranberry juice for urinary tract infections. Pubmed references go back to 1962, and there are over 100 references. Firm conclusions are still lacking.
There is a reasonable, but incomplete, basic science behind the use of the cranberry juice for urinary tract infections.E. coli , the most common cause of urinary tract infections, causes infection in the bladder by binding to the uroepithelial cells. To do this, they make fimbriae, proteinaceous fibers on the bacterial cell wall. Fimbriae are adhesins that attach to specific sugar based receptors on uroepithelial cells. Think Velcro. Being able to stick to cells is an important virulence factor for bacteria, but not a critical one; it is not the sine qua non of bladder infections.
Are all E. coli causing UTI’s fimbriated? No. It is the minority of E. coli that cause UTI that have fimbria, and the presence of fimbriae may be more important for the development of pyelonephritis (kidney infection) than cystitis (bladder infection).
The prevalence of uropathogenic Escherichia coli bearing type 1 and/or p fimbriae was assessed in 179 adult women with urinary tract infections, and the presence of specific fimbriae types was correlated with results of localization studies. E. coli with p fimbriae occurred more frequently in patients with clinically defined pyelonephritis (13 of 23 [57%]) than in women with cystitis (22 of 116 [19%]; P = .0004) or asymptomatic bacteriuria (6 of 40 [15%]; P = .0008), whereas organisms with type 1 fimbriae were equally distributed in these three patient groups. In contrast, the presence of p-fimbriated strains was not correlated with infection localized to the upper urinary tract by either the antibody-coated bacteria technique (among symptomatic women) or ureteral catheterization (among asymptomatic women). Thus although p fimbriation seems to be an important virulence factor associated with development of acute pyelonephritis in adult women, its detection appears not to be a useful localization test per se, and efforts to prevent these infections should not be directed against this factor alone.
and in children
P-fimbriae were present in 91% (33/35) of the urinary strains causing acute pyelonephritis. Among strains causing cystitis and asymptomatic bacteriuria P-fimbriae were found in 19% and 14% of cases, respectively.
So fimbriated E. coli account for a distinct minority of urinary tract infections.
What is the alleged mechanism by which cranberry juice is beneficial in preventing urinary tract infections? Cranberry juice, and some other fruits, contain proanthocyanidins. There is reasonable data that demonstrates that proanthocyanidins block adherence, usually of p fimbriated E. coli , to uroepithelial cells. But not all E. coli:
Interestingly, proanthocyanidin shows a very strong inhibitory activity against mannose-resistant adhesins produced by urinary isolates of E. coli but shows only moderate anti adherent activity against fecal E. coli isolates.
So the theory is that by taking cranberry juice, or cranberry pills, you will block the E. coli sticking to bladder cells and that will decrease the number of UTI’s. The use of cranberry should be more beneficial as a preventative than as a treatment of cystitis and should be effective for a minority of patients.
There have been a variety of clinical trials, in different populations, to see if cranberry products are of benefit in the prevention of UTI’s and there has been variable efficacy.
There are, I am shocked, shocked to find, problems with the studies.
First, no one has ever done basic pharmacokinetics on proanthocyanidins to see if there is, indeed, proanthocyanidins in the urine of patients who take cranberry products.
The closest they have come is that the urine of patients who consume cranberry juice inhibits E coli binding to bladder epithelial cells. Close. But it may be something else in the urine that is leading to the decreased E. coli adherence. I may complain about the pharmaceutical companies and the spin they put on their clinical studies, but at least they are nice (1) and methodical in elucidating the basic pharmacokinetics of their preparations.
Doing clinical trials without determining first if there is sufficient material that CAN be effective, before showing that it IS effective, is the homeopathic, and most SCAM, method of research. No one has been methodical in their evaluation of cranberry juice, so we are left with a hodgepodge of incomplete studies.
Imagine doing an antibiotic study where you neither tested the susceptibility of the organisms to the antibiotic before nor after you treated an infection. It would be stupid. You would have no idea if the therapy should or could have been effective.
Some populations where cranberry prodcuts has been tried, the neurogenic bladder, spinal cord injury and the elderly, have a radically different microbiology and epidemiology and one wonders if the basic principals behind the rationale for cranberry juice are even remotely applicable. Fimbriated E. coli are the least of the reasons why these patients get cystitis. It would have been nice if they had done the groundwork first. It is the usual throw the feces at the wall, uncertain if feces are even the correct projectile, see if anything sticks, and then trying to draw a target around it.
One study found trimethoprim and cranberry juice equivalent in preventing recurrent UTI. There was no placebo wing and at best chronic antibiotics has only modest efficacy in preventing UTI’s, depending on the population studied.
So when the Cochrane review says
Cranberries (usually as cranberry juice) have been used to try and prevent urinary tract infections (UTIs). Cranberries contain a substance that can prevent bacteria from sticking on the walls of the bladder. This may help prevent bladder and other urinary tract infections. This review identified 10 studies (1049 participants) comparing cranberry products with placebo, juice or water. There was some evidence to show that cranberries (juice and capsules) can prevent recurrent infections in women. However, the evidence for elderly men and women was less clear, and there is evidence that is not effective in people who need catheterization. Many people in the trials stopped drinking the juice, suggesting it may not be a popular intervention. In addition it is not clear how long cranberry juice needs to be taken to be effective or what the required dose might be.
I think, well, the studies are so fundamentally flawed who knows what can really be said about the efficacy of cranberry juice.
As noted in the 2004 CID review,
Furthermore, results of the reviewed studies should not be viewed as conclusive because many of the trials suffer from various limitations, including lack of randomization, no or improper blinding, small number of subjects, short trial duration, large number of dropouts, and no reported intent-to-treat analysis. Perhaps the single most consistent limitation of these trials is the lack of uniformity regarding the intervention, including the particular cranberry product evaluated (juice, sweetened cocktail, or capsules/tablets), concentration, dosing regimen, and duration of the intervention, which greatly differed from study to study.
What good is a meta-analysis on crap? If you collect individual cow pies into a larger pile, it does not transmogrify into gold. Can you make any conclusions under those circumstances? GIGO. Garbage in, garbage out, which, I am starting to think, should be the motto for some of the Cochrane reviews.
Which brings us to the most recent cranberry juice study, Cranberry Juice Fails to Prevent Recurrent Urinary Tract Infection: Results From a Randomized Placebo-Controlled Trial, which has all the SBM words: prospective, randomized, double-blind comparison of the therapeutic efficacy of 8 oz of CJC drunk twice daily in preventing recurring UTI.
The cranberry juice “consisted of one 8-oz bottle (240 mL) containing a mean proanthocyanidin concentration of 112 mg per dose (range, 83–136 mg; standard deviation, ±14.1 mg),” but we have no idea there was any product in the urine.
At the end of the 6 month study period, there was no difference in relapsing UTI between those who consumed cranberry juice and placebo.
We report results of a double-blind, randomized, placebo controlled trial of the effects of drinking cranberry juice on risk of recurring UTI among college-aged women. The trial was developed to detect a 2-fold difference in incidence of recurring UTI with alpha of .05 and power of 99%. The power was estimated assuming we would observe a 30% recurrence rate among controls, consistent with that reported in observational studies. Contrary to expectation, we found that drinking an 8-oz dosage of cranberry juice twice per day gave no protection against the risk of recurring UTI among college-aged women.
Does this put the issue to rest? No.
You do not know if the formulation led to active drug in the urine and you do not know if the E. coli that predominated as a cause of the UTI could have been prevented. Were there recurrent infections the same E. coli ? Or a new E. coli . Were any of the E. coli fimbriated? Given that the minority of E. coli should be inhibited by cranberry juice, it would be nice to know if the pre-study bacteria were fimbriated and if the post-therapy infections were also fimbriated.
And to complicated matters, ascorbic acid is found in both products which has been associated with decreased in UTI’s, although the studies have even less rigor than the cranberry juice studies.
But I would predict that the use of cranberry juice will have little effect on either the treatment or prevention of cystitis. When it comes to infection prevention, targeting the bacteria rather that the underlying predisposing cause, is doomed to failure. If you target the bacteria with an antibiotic, the organisms rapidly evolve resistance and you end up with the same infections rates, only with resistant organisms.
People get UTI’s for a reason: catheters, sex (not both at once), and/or genetics. The bacteria take advantage of the underlying pathology to infect people. Even if the use of cranberry juice may decrease the number of UTI’s due to fimbriated E. coli, if the underlying reason for the cystitis is not addressed, then there will only be a substitution in the species of bacteria causing infections, not a decrease in the rates of infection.
In the end, I would conclude that cranberry juice probably does not prevent UTI, and any effects are likely of little clinical value, given the relative rarity of organisms for which it could be effective. It would require a much larger study to prove or disprove efficacy, and not having proper microbiology renders all the studies to date probably worthless for coming up with worthwhile conclusions.
Forty years of evaluation and we are still left wanting. Still, I am sticking with the cranberry juice in my Cosmopolitan, but not for its UTI prevention.
Clarifications
(1) Nice as in The Nice and Accurate Prophecies of Agnes Nutter, Witch.

Cranberries to prevent urinary tract infections: Another alternative medicine zombie that’s impervious to evidence
How much evidence will it take before the idea of cranberries for urinary tract infections is finally dead and buried?
Scott Gavura on December 15, 2016
Link

One way to distinguish science-based medicine from alternative medicine is to observe how each deals with negative or contradictory evidence. Given sufficient evidence, the practice of medicine will change. Yes, the process can take too long. But good science does change medicine, and the practice of medicine is constantly changing as a result. The exact opposite can be observed in alternative, complementary and “integrative” medicine, which are largely impervious to new evidence, and where few therapies are ever discarded as ineffective or harmful. No matter how much evidence exists to show practices like homeopathy, acupuncture or reiki/therapeutic touch are clinically useless, nothing really changes. The willingness to stick with a practice, no matter the evidence, must give practitioners a certain clarity. Perhaps it’s comforting to base your own reality on perceptions, or what “feels” right, rather than scientific fact. Those of us in the reality-based, science-based community welcome new evidence and changing practices. For example, most of the therapeutics I learned in university is now irrelevant or outdated. HIV used to be a death sentence, and my 4th year textbook only mentioned three drugs, all of which were terrible. Today, HIV is managed much like a chronic disease, with drugs that didn’t even exist in 1993. Life expectancy has soared.
Cranberries and urinary tract infections
If there was a folk remedies course offered back in the 1990s, it probably would have mentioned the use of cranberries and cranberry juice to prevent or treat urinary tract infections. While there’s been interest in cranberries (juice or capsules) to treat or prevent urinary tract infection for decades, the science has been suggestively promising, but convincing evidence has been lacking. Now there’s a new, well-conducted trial which should put any questions about cranberry and urinary tract infections to rest. We have convincing evidence that cranberry (as capsules) is ineffective. As a companion editorial states, it is time to move on. Here’s why.
Why cranberry?
Cranberry seems to come up as a post topic every few years. In alternative medicine, it’s commonly used as a supplement (as juice, extract, or capsules) to prevent or treat urinary tract infections (“acute cystitis”). A scientific reason why cranberry might prevent or treat urinary tract infections is still lacking despite over five decades of study. Is it because the berries are so bitter, that they must be medicinal? An early hypothesis may have been the ability of cranberry to lower urinary pH, which was thought to help treat UTI. Later, an ingredient in cranberry, proanthocyanidins, was thought to block some variants of E. coli bacteria from adhering to bladder cells, which might reduce the risk of infection. But these “fimbriated” bacteria are uncommon in species isolated from urinary tract infections. So even if the theoretical mechanism of action is correct (which remains unproven), the real-world effect, based on this assumption, should be minimal. And that’s largely what the evidence shows, when you account for the poor research quality. So after decades of studies, there is still no valid rationale why cranberries might prevent or treat UTIs. But we don’t need to know how it works, if there is convincing evidence it actually does work. Sadly, no such evidence exists. Mark Crislip blogged about a randomized, placebo-controlled trial of cranberry juice back in 2011 and found the evidence was unconvincing. A 2012 Cochrane review concluded that there was no good evidence to suggest cranberries offer any meaningful benefits:
Cranberries (usually as cranberry juice) have been used to prevent urinary tract infections (UTIs). Cranberries contain a substance that can prevent bacteria from sticking on the walls of the bladder. This may help prevent bladder and other UTIs. This review identified 24 studies (4473 participants) comparing cranberry products with control or alternative treatments. There was a small trend towards fewer UTIs in people taking cranberry product compared to placebo or no treatment but this was not a significant finding. Many people in the studies stopped drinking the juice, suggesting it may not be an acceptable intervention. Cranberry juice does not appear to have a significant benefit in preventing UTIs and may be unacceptable to consume in the long term. Cranberry products (such as tablets or capsules) were also ineffective (although had the same effect as taking antibiotics), possibly due to lack of potency of the ‘active ingredient’.
The evidence base of trials that make up the meta-analysis is filled with problems, including:
    • Small numbers of patients
    • Vague inclusion criteria
    • Insufficient duration
    • Patient drop-outs
    • Poor follow-up
    • Unclear diagnostic criteria: Lack of confirmation of an actual infection
    • Inappropriate endpoints
    • Unstandardized products (unclear amounts of active ingredients)
There’s another significant issue with cranberry juice as a preventative of treatment: The calorie load. Unsweetened cranberry juice is unpalatable, so it’s usually sweetened. You’d need to consume about 500mL of cranberry cocktail to obtain the studied amount of the pure juice. Two cups supplies 52 grams of added sugars per day. Over a year, that’s 41 pounds of added sugar you’re putting in your diet in the hope of avoiding a urinary tract infection. So even if this is an effective treatment, the benefits and harms need to be weighed against drug products.
All of this background leads to the basis for what should be (but will probably not be) the last study of cranberry for preventing urinary tract infections.
The definitive trial on cranberries?
The latest trial is from Manisha Juthani-Mehta and colleagues. Published in the Journal of the American Medical Association in October 2016, it’s entitled “Effect of Cranberry Capsules on Bacteriuria Plus Pyuria Among Older Women in Nursing Homes.” The researchers have no conflicts of interest and all appear to be affiliated with the Yale School of Medicine.
This was a well-designed, well-conducted trial. It was a randomized, double-blind, placebo controlled study of 185 women over the age of 65 who were living in nursing homes. Patients were randomized to two oral capsules of cranberry, containing a (standardized) total of 72 mg of proanthocyanidins (equivalent to 20 ounces (or one (Imperial) pint) of cranberry juice. The cranberry capsules and placebos were manufactured by a herbal product manufacturer. The primary endpoint was the presence of bacteria and pus in the urine, measured every two months over a one-year period. Any single positive finding was deemed to satisfy the primary outcome. Secondary outcomes measured included urinary tract infections with symptoms, all cause death, all cause hospitalization, all multi-drug resistant organisms, antibiotics administered, and total administration of antimicrobials.
The mean age of participants was 86.4 years, mainly white, with 31.4% having bacteria and pus in the urine at baseline. 147 completed the study, with an overall adherence to therapy of 80.1%, which is excellent. Over the one year period, there were no significant differences in the presence of bacteria in the urine. Nor was there any difference in the rates of UTIs with symptoms, rates of death, hospitalizations, all multi-drug organisms identified, or antibiotics administered. In short, there were no meaningful differences between the groups. I won’t show you the graphs and charts, because there’s nothing interesting to observe.

It is time to abandon cranberry
This study adds convincing evidence to the scientific case against cranberries. There is no persuasive evidence that cranberries can prevent urinary tract infections. Given the lack of benefit, cranberry capsules should not be promoted to prevent or treat urinary tract infections. In 2013 I concluded my post on cranberries hoping that post was the last word, but fearing a zombie resurgence. I won’t make the same prediction this year. This should be the trial that shifts the focus of preventing urinary tract infections to other strategies. But I don’t think the cranberry myth can be killed. Evidence didn’t lead us to use cranberry to prevent UTI, and evidence probably won’t end its use, either.

   I No Longer Love a Parade
Mark Crislip
Link
Parade magazine is the most widely read periodical in the US, with a circulation of 32 million and a readership of 71 million (1). They get that readership by placing it, free for readers, in over 400 newspapers.
The column in question is “Ease The Aches Of Arthritis” By Dr. Vijay Vad, published 09/28/2008. Dr. Vad is a physiatrist (a rehabilitation doctor) who has published several books on arthritis for the the public.
In the article, Dr. Vad discusses ways to decrease arthritis pain. Like most popular summaries, it is without references, so I used Pubmed and Google for each of his suggestions to look for the evidence to support the advice he offers. I tried to use both narrow and broad search terms in Pubmed, but I do not doubt I missed key articles. I have confidence that the readers of the blog will show me the error of my ways.
There are many types of arthritis: there is inflammatory arthritis, like rheumatoid arthritis, and osteoarthritis, due to wear and tear. There is crystalline arthritis like gout and there is infectious arthritis, due to staphylococcus or other bacteria. Most people have osteoarthritis, or degenerative joint disease. These are different diseases, and studies that evaluate the pathophysiology and treatment of one do not necessarily apply to the others. Dr Vad does not distinguish between the different types of arthritis in his article, broadly suggesting interventions for ‘arthritis’ as if all types of arthritis are equal. It is like suggesting penicillin for ‘infection’, paying no attention to the type of infection and whether the use of penicillin is applicable.
Watch your diet. Eat foods that reduce inflammation, and avoid those that cause it. Red meat, which contains omega-6 fatty acids, and high-fructose corn syrup promote inflammation.
I cannot find a clinical trial where omega-6 fatty acids promote arthritis or increase arthritis pain. I can find no trials that show an association between increased red meat consumption and increased osteoarthritis pain. There is one epidemiologic study (2) that finds an association between high red meat consumption and developing inflammatory arthritis. Note: developing and inflammatory arthritis, not osteoarthritis. It was a mild association. Association is not causation, and as the authors say “A high level of red meat consumption may represent a novel risk factor for inflammatory arthritis or may act as a marker for a group of persons with an increased risk from other lifestyle causes.”
Double blind studies with diet are particularly difficult to perform as people tend to be able to identify what they eat. The one study I could find showed no benefit of a low meat diet and the symptoms of rheumatoid arthritis (3).
Using “high fructose corn syrup” and either arthritis or inflammation yields no clinical trials or basic science articles on a Pubmed search. Nothing. I can find no credible science to support the assertion that high fructose corn syrup promotes inflammation or increases arthritis pain directly. Use of high fructose corn syrup is associated with gout, which is a form of arthritis where uric acid crystals precipitate into the joint and it is the crystals that cause inflammation. But there is no (4) data I can find to suggest that high fructose corn syrup will make your joint pain worse or avoiding it will make your joint pain better.
Instead, to reduce inflammation, consume more foods that are rich in omega-3 fatty acids, such as deep-sea fish, flaxseed, brightly colored fruits, dark-green leafy vegetables, and olive oil.
True, but the data for the benefit of fish oils is valid only for rheumatoid arthritis. If fish oil clinical trials are available for osteoarthritis, I could not find them on Pubmed. Also there are no clinical trials that support the efficacy of flaxseed, green leafy vegetables or olive oil in improving joint pain. In the Adventist Health Study, fruit consumption was weakly associated with increased osteoarthritis, as was the consumption of red meat (9) and a few studies suggesting benefit from avocados, which, I believe, is not a leafy vegetable.
Our prehistoric ancestors, to whom arthritis was virtually unknown…
A quick Google finds reports of ancient human remains with rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis, some dating back 40,000 years ago. I found the information in less than a minute. Why the editors of Parade cannot fact check with similar alacrity I do not know. I thought that’s what editors did: they edit. Prior to modern society, most people didn’t live past their mid twenties to mid thirties, hardly time enough to develop widespread evidence of degenerative arthritis. If you die young, as most people did until the last 100 years, you do not have degenerative diseases that take a long life to develop.
Recent scientific data indicate that the use of ginger, glucosamine, and chondroitin sulfate may be helpful for moderate to severe knee arthritis.
Glucosamine may have some modest effects on joint pain. The results of clinical trials with chondroitin suggests that it is not effective (this is a huge and messy literature fraught with poor studies). I have always thought, since these products are synthesized onsite by the joint, rather than imported whole, that it is a therapy like eating hair for baldness. Which I wish would work.
As to ginger, there are two studies, one shows moderate efficacy for decreasing joint symptoms (5) the other doesn’t (6). Hardly compelling trials, although there are some intriguing in vitro studies to suggest that ginger has some anti inflammatory properties; it is a long way from inhibiting sow cartilage explants (7) in a test tube to recommending routine use of the spice. Unless.
It should be mentioned that Dr. Vad has been responsible as the “leading physician researcher in arthritis” for the development of Gingerflex ™, a supplement with ginger, glucosamine, and chondroitin sulfate. I cannot find his name directly associated with the product and only discovered it from a direct inquiry to the company. The company has not responded to my inquiries as to whether he is still actively involved with Gingerflex, although he recommends the product in his books and his books are sold on the same page as the product on the gingerflex.com website. The editors of Parade do not seem to be interested that the medical advice offered in the periodical may have a conflict of interest.
BTW, Dr Vad has 13 references in low impact journals in Pubmed, a solid resume, and much better than my own resume, but hardly a “leading physician researcher in arthritis.”
Use your body. Some people with arthritis are afraid that exercise can hurt them. But it’s just the opposite.
Given the wide ranging benefits of regualr exercise, I cannot argue with this advice, although the data suggest that the benefits of exercise are short term and minimal for effects on joint symptoms and function. There is surprisingly little data to suggest exercise is of benefit for the narrow indication of relieving joint pain and increasing function in a variety of different types of arthritis, although this literature is huge. As one representative meta analysis said, “For pain assessed using the 0 to 10 visual analog scale, the average effect amounts to a mean of 3.78 for treatment subjects versus 4.33 for control subjects. Control group subjects experienced statistically significant improvements in pain and, to a lesser extent, objectively measured functional ability during study participation. CONCLUSIONS: Physical activity interventions resulted in moderate positive effects on physical activity behavior and small positive effects on pain and physical function outcomes (10)”.
Breathe properly. Proper breathing in a slow, controlled rhythm is the fastest pain reliever I know of, because it shifts the mind’s attention away from the pain.
I agree with this. All my patients who have stopped breathing have done poorly. I have to admit I do not understand this advice. Breathing is for gas exchange; there is no proper way to breath unless you have Ondine’s curse. While focusing on breathing can be distracting, so can many other activities, from TV to a good beer. To be complete, I looked for breathing and changes in arthritis symptoms or pain. I found nothing.
Try massage and acupuncture. Because mainstream medicine has not provided enough arthritis treatments short of drugs and surgery, many arthritis sufferers have turned to alternative treatments such as massage and acupuncture. Specifically, massage therapy has been shown to be beneficial for arthritis of the spine and hip, and acupuncture has yielded promising results for knee arthritis in clinical trials.
One trial I found for massage and osteoarthritis of the knee (8) demonstrated benefit, and I do not doubt that massage makes anyone feel good, although I am at a loss as to how to do a placebo trial for this type of intervention. As to acupuncture, the data for this intervention has been discussed at length in this blog. Compared to sham acupuncture, ‘real’ acupuncture is no better and in one study was worse for arthritis pain. The clinical trials do not support he use of acupuncture for any disease, much less arthritis. Acupuncture is worthless to all but the acupuncturist.
So what can you say about the advice offered in Parade for suffers of arthritis?
Much of what is said does not seem to be supported by the published medical literature or is widely extrapolated from minimal or contradictory data. No effort is made to distinguish the various kinds of arthritis so there can be appropriate application of what minimal data exists. All arthritis is treated the same.
There is a suspicion of conflict of interest in the article. I always find it ironic that while I am the pawn of big pharma, it is the promoters of nutraceuticals who sell the products on their websites and from their offices and reap the profits. I have never made dime one from any drug I have ever prescribed.
As I wrote this I ran the basic ideas by one of our rheumatologists to make sure I wasn’t missing any important information. It led to an interesting discussion of how he applies this kind of information to his patients. The practice of medicine is often messy, especially with rheumatologic illnesses. He told me it is part of the general culture of rheumatology where you discuss these interventions with patients using terms like ‘may help’ and ‘people find it useful’. Not exactly recommending them, but not discouraging them either. Red meat, high fructose corn syrup and fish oils are part of the ‘popular culture’ of the treatment of joint disease, irrespective of the data, and are casually given the same consideration as NSAID’s and prednisone, especially in patients with refractory disease. Shruggies, I suppose, but there is that feeling that we should do something, anything, but not nothing, as long as there is the whiff of a hint of a suggestion of a possibility that maybe possibly it might do something good for someone somewhere sometime. We all want to help, don’t we?
A common complaint in the skeptical literature is the poor job done by mainstream media in covering science. Here is another example. The most widely read magazine in the US apparently lacks the ability for simple fact checking and insuring that the medical advice they offer is free of potential financial conflict. Parade contains a column by Marilyn vos Savant, who holds the record for the worlds highest IQ. Perhaps they should take advantage of this prodigious intellectual power to help edit the medical columns. The editors need help from someone.
References
1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parade_(magazine)
2. Arthritis Rheum. 2004;50:3804-3812
3. Scand J Rheumatol. 2000;29(5):302-7. Diet therapy for rheumatoid arthritis. A controlled double-blind study of two different dietary regimens.
4. as in zip, zilch, nil, nothing, nada, zero
5. Effects of a ginger extract on knee pain in patients with osteoarthritis. Arthritis Rheum. 2001 Nov;44(11):2531-8.
6. Osteoarthritis Cartilage. 2000 Jan;8(1):9-12. A randomized, placebo-controlled, cross-over study of ginger extracts and ibuprofen in osteoarthritis.
7. J Med Food. 2005 Summer;8(2):149-53. Comparative effects of ginger root (Zingiber officinale Rosc.) on the production of inflammatory mediators in normal and osteoarthrotic sow chondrocytes.
8. Arch Intern Med. 2006 Dec 11-25;166(22):2533-8.Massage therapy for osteoarthritis of the knee: a randomized controlled trial.
9. J Nutr Health Aging. 2006 Jan-Feb;10(1):7-14. Associations between meat consumption and the prevalence of degenerative arthritis and soft tissue disorders in the adventist health study, California U.S.A.
10. This is a huge literature, Pubmed arthritis and exercise to review the references. Semin Arthritis Rheum. 2008 Apr;37(5):307-16. Epub 2007 Sep 21 Physical activity interventions among adults with arthritis: meta-analysis of outcomes..

   Probiotics
Mark Crislip
Link
The Wall Street Journal has an assessment of Probiotics in the Jan 13, 2009 issue entitled Bug Crazy: Assessing the Benefits of Probiotics (1). For some reason when I wander around the hospital on rounds people show me articles such as this and ask, so whatcha think about this?
Probiotics are interesting. They are live bacteria given to treat and prevent diseases. It is one of those overlap areas for scientific medicine and so called alternative medicine. There are good clinical trials to suggest areas where these agents are of benefit, but other aspects of their use are blown out of proportion for the real or imagined benefit probiotics may provide. Much of alternative medicine where it overlaps with real medicine is the art of making therapeutic mountains out of clinical molehills.
The Wall Street Journal article is the kind of reporting that drives. me. nuts. It drive me nuts because the reporting acts as if the underlying assumptions of the therapies are true.
Start with the second sentence.
“Many medical experts believe that consuming healthy bacteria, called probiotics, improves the body’s overall balance of good versus bad micro-organisms, boosting general health.”
Many? What is many? A few loudmouths like me? A consensus? Experts in what? What is a healthy bacteria? Are the bacteria healthy? Or does it make you healthy? Then the last part of sentence, “improves the body’s overall balance of good versus bad micro-organisms, boosting general health.” What the does that mean?
Already these is the assumption, unchallenged, that there is an issue in people between good and bad bacteria that is affecting health. And which people? Which bacteria? Under what circumstances? The importance of understanding which patient populations may benefit from an intervention is key.
My mind was boggled when they mentioned that there were 241 probiotics released last year containing probiotics. Someone is getting a good balance of good income vrs bad income, boosting some bank accounts health.
Before we move on to the rest of the Wall Street Journal, lets talk colon and the bacteria that live there.
Your colon is a rich, complicated ecosystem. Each and everyone of you has a metaphorical rainforest in your colon. Your colon is a complex environment containing hundreds of species of bacteria, 99.9% of which are anaerobes (bacteria that are killed by oxygen). Each gram (2) of stool, and a gram is not all that heavy, has 10^11 anaerobes. That is one hundred billion organism per gram of poo. This may surprise you, but your colon is not a particularly hospitable place, and there is not a lot of oxygen there. As a result, organisms that thrive in an oxygen low or deficient place, anaerobes and microaerophilic organisms, predominate in your colon. The predominant anaerobes are bacteroides species. Aerobes, ie oxygen requiring organisms like E. coli, make up only 0.1% of your stool, or 10^5 to 10^7 per gram of stool. Thats 10 thousand to ten million aerobes per gram.
And thats the bacteria we can culture. It is estimated that we cannot grow about 80% of the bacterial species in the feces.
Bowel mucosa is inhabited by Bifidobacteriumand Lactobacillus, the two most common bacteria in probiotics. These bacteria are minor constituents of the bowel flora, but since they live on the mucosa, along with Eubacterium, and Propionibacterium, they may have more beneficial effects. The female genital tract does have a Lactobacilluspredominant flora. The Lactobacillus community varies from person to person. Lactobacillus crispatus and Lactobacillus jensenii are the lactobacilli that predominate in the vagina. The Lactobacillus you eat is not the Lactobacillus that is part of your normal bacterial flora.
The normal gut bacterial flora is important in many ways.
Micro-organisms block out potential pathogens. There are a limited number of niches in which bacteria can live. If the niches are filled with non pathogenic bacteria, then there is no place for pathogens to get a toe hold to grow. Over growth syndromes are a common complication of antibiotics and are frequently mistaken for a weakening of the host immune system. Wipe out the some or all of the normal bacteria, free up some ecological niches, and and bacteria or yeast not killed by the antibiotics will grow like blackberry bushes after a logging. Wipe out normal bacteria with antibiotics and get an overgrowth with yeast or Clostridium difficile, a particularly nasty form of infectious diarrhea. The immune system has not been compromised by the antibiotics, it is a result of the opening up of new living space for micro-organisms that were previously outcompeted for space.
Normal microbiologic flora is important if for no other reason that it fills up a space that could be used by more pathogenic organisms.
Micro-organisms do more than fill up a space. Bacteria, good bad and indifferent are more than animate place holders. They have been co-evolving with us for somewhere between six thousand and 6 million years. Genetic analysis shows that H. Pylori came out of Africa with us 60,000 years ago and head lice have been with us and our ancestors for 1.6 million years. None of us are truly alone, and, after death, will be consumed by the microbiology we have carried with us since the beginning of human existence. Introducing new strains of probiotics is akin to planting corn in a rain forrest. You may get some benefit, but do not think you are reconstituting the normal ecosystem.
During our co-evolution, bacteria have picked up some of the biochemical slack: micro-organisms make Vitamin K help with the digestion and absorption of food. Most importantly, at least from the perspective of my 11 year old, bacteria are responsible for most of the gas of flatulence. Disturbing the normal flora with antibiotics or illness or surgery or probiotics can lead to a variety of biochemical dysfunctions.
I mention all this so there is context as we explore the biologic plausibility and clinical utility of probiotics .
The reason d’etre for probiotics is inherently questionable: Normal bacteria gone, depleted, tuckered out? Take some extra bacteria and replete your ecosystem. Compared to the complexity of the GI micro environment, probiotics contain just a few bacteria, and not even the most common bowel organisms. It is safe to say that the “good’ bacteria so highly touted in probiotics are but a minor constituent of a complex flora.
Some further fine points about the probiotics
- Lactobacillus in yogurt in not necessarily lactobacillus usually found in probiotic pills. Yogurt is usually L. acidophylis or Lactobacillus bulgaricus. The yogurt bacteria turn sugar to lactic acid, making the milk curdle turning it into yogurt. The lactobacillus in probiotics contain one of more Lactobacillus casei, Lactobacillus plantarum, Lactobacillus reuteri , Lactobacillus rhamnosus, or Lactobacillus GG. As mentioned, these are not the Lactobacill found in humans.
-The Bifidobacterium found in probiotics are not necessarily the Bifidobacterium found in and on you. There are many strains of Bifidobacterium, only a fraction of which are included in probiotics.
- Saccharomyces boulardii, found in some probiotics, is not a normal part of your flora.
- Typical of the unregulated supplement industry, what is on the label may not be in the bottle of probiotic pills. In several studies that have compared what is on the label with what is actually grown, not only were the organisms misidentified, sometimes the bacteria were dead were dead. Organisms not mentioned on the label, like enterococcus, were sometimes isolated. But then enterococcus is a real constituent of the gi tract.
- Probiotics, not being part of the normal flora, are cleared and cannot be isolated soon after stopping eating the probiotic. They are not normal flora and will not persist unless you keep consuming them.
If you are worried about your normal gut bacteria, be reassured. We are always consuming fecal flora in the food you eat and the water you drink. The food, your spouse, and the world, is covered in a thin patina of gastrointestinal bacteria, so you are always repleting your bacterial flora orally. Bon appetite. Families tend have similar bacterial strains. My gut flora more closely resemble my parents than my wife’s, suggesting there may be a genetic predisposition for which strains of bacteria make up your gut.
When you give probiotics to normal humans you are introducing, relative to the number and quantity of bacteria that are already there, a small amount of foreign bacteria. Continuing our metaphor, it is like trying to put a putting green in an Amazonian rain forrest. For normal people, it makes no microbiologic sense to take probiotics.
“For maximum benefit, scientists say, try to consume a variety of different bacteria, as each may contribute something slightly different.”Your best bet, with this reasoning, would be to eat a variety of human stool. That way you will get many different bacteria, all contributing something slightly different. “Probiotics are defined as “live micro-organisms which when administered in adequate amounts confer a health benefit,” according to 2002 guidelines developed by the World Health Organization and the United Nations. Exactly how this works isn’t fully understood, but scientists believe that good types of bacteria have long lived in symbiosis with humans and that the positive health effects may have evolved over time.”
Thats right. So why take large amounts of foreign bacteria and yeast that are not a normal part of your gastrointestinal flora?
“In choosing a probiotic, consumers should look for products that list a specific strain of bacteria on their label or on a Web site. Look for three names — in Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG, for example, the final two letters identify the strain. The GG strain has been well tested scientifically and has shown health benefits. A product that simply uses the first two names may include a similar, but not identical, bacterium that doesn’t have the same science behind it.”
Health benefits is so non specific. There is science behind probiotics, but is it good science? My bias: at baseline in normal people, the colon has a enough bacteria and, like supplements, does not need extra bacteria. The alleged health benefits of probiotics are often an example of spin.
Per the WSJ, probiotics are helpful for the following. I will give the WSJ credit where credit is due, they make a point of mentioning that most of the studies that show benefit are funded by the makers of the probiotic, although they do not mention explicitly that studies show the source of funding biases clinical studies in favor of the funder.
1) Gut health. What is gut health? It sound good, doesn’t it?. How can you argue against health? Many supplements promote some kind of health. Gut health, vaginal health, immune health, etc. I have zero idea what this means. Water promotes health. Steak can promote health. Wine promotes health. Everything that is not poison can, under the right circumstances, be said to promote health. It is a content free statement.
2) Increased digestion. This manifests by increased transit time. “…the company says a recent study, presented at a conference of the American College of Gastroenterology, found that a dairy drink with the same active ingredients as a four-ounce container of Yo-Plus reduced transit time to 21 hours from 31 hours.”
This is good because? There is a myth that the colon is filled with toxins that need to be eliminated. Not true to my knowledge. Why might ingesting a large bolus of foreign bacteria lead to increased transit time? Though most of human history, food poisoning was common. Eating tainted food was an unfortunate byproduct of no refrigeration or food preservation combined with starvation level existence. There are three major ways people acquire infections: sex, inhalation and eating. Through most of human history the food supply was not clean, so it is not surprising that a large part of the immune system lines the gut.
According to Dannon, 70% of your immune system is in the gut. True enough. It prevents the normal flora from getting into the bloodstream (a huge problem in people whose immune system is depressed from chemotherapy) and provides the first line of defense against ingested bacteria and toxins. If you inadvertently eat a large amount of bacteria, be it contaminated food or probiotic yogurt, the body gets rid of it with increased transit time. If you really want to increase transit time, take a probiotic laced with Salmonella. That is probably why you get increased transient time with probiotics: the normal inflammatory response attempting to rid the body of a bolus of foreign bacteria. Spin. Take an unimportant and perhaps normal physiologic response to infection and make it a benefit.
3) Irritable Bowel Syndrome. The clinical trials do suggest benefit from various probiotic formulations for the symptoms of IBS. Curiously, there are numerous studies to suggest that IBS is a sequela of infectious diarrhea’s of all etiologies. It is interesting that adding back a bacteria would help symptoms, although what the best probiotic formulation to treat IBS is not known. Since IBS is a post infectious disease, one would wonder if normal people took large quantities of probiotics for a long period of time it would cause IBS. My first prediction for probiotics: long term use in normal people will lead to increased risk of IBS.
4) Colic. Reasonable data to suggest that colic is improved with probiotics. If colic is due to a alterations in bowel flora, then they may be benefit from probiotics. The big benefit from probiotics, as mentioned, is probably by blocking pathogenetic bacteria. Bacteria do not just float free in the colon. The have ecologic niches and often have to bind to specific sites on cells. Probiotics probably have their benefit by blocking the site where the more pathogenic organisms bind, if that is the cause of colic. Most parents with a colicky would do ANYTHING legal to quiet their baby and get just one good night of sleep, so I hope this one study is confirmed.
5) Immune health. More spin. The woo meisters usually phrase it as “boosting the immune system.” First, the immune system in normal people does not need boosting. It is fine at baseline, and millions of years of evolution have given us what is presumably an optimal immunologic set point. When we are infected we respond with inflammation, and inflammation is not always good.
What about boosting or strengthening the immune system.
The data is contradictory. Some probiotic effects, such as on inflammatory bowel disease, are supposed to be due to decreasing immune function by depressing cyokines, while other effects are supposed to be due to increasing immune function in increasing local antibody production and T cells. There are in vitro (test tube), animal, and human studies that show wide ranging effects of probiotics on the immune system. Guess what? That is what is supposed to happen. Any time you take in large quantities of a living organism that is not part of your normal flora, the immune system is going to take notice and react. What they call boosting or increasing immune health, I call inflammation.
I am going to limit discussion to the DanActive product by Dannon with the bacteria Lactobacillus casei. They have trademarked the name of their strain, Lactobacillus casei Immunitas. TM.
Each bottle of DanActive has 10 billion live bacteria, so from a bacterial colony count, it is like eating a gram of stool. So what does that do for your immune system. Not much. They make a big deal about immune strengthening, but the supporting data they provide in their slick but almost substance free scientific summary for providers is as follows (from the Dannon web site).
1) “Consumption of yogurt containing L. casei Immunitas (TM) during 30 days resulted in a significant increase in the percentage of children with a concentration of Lactobacillus greater than 6 log10cfu/g of feces. “
That must have been fun to collect. Children taking DanActive for thirty days increasingly have lactobacillus in their stool. Why is this good? Because they say so. They say it is regulating normal bowel flora. No they are not. Taking a complex ecosystem and trying to replace it with a monoculture of “good” bacteria.
2) L. casei Immunitas (TM) stimulated DNA synthesis and cAMP (cyclic AMP) production in cultured IEC-6 (intestinal epithelial cell line) cells, indicating increased proliferation and cell activity. Again. Why is this good? Any bacteria not part of the normal flora will cause an inflammatory response. Causing an immunologic response is how the immune system is supposed to respond to everything that is not you. Extrapolating from a typical test tube response to improving immune function in people is quite s stretch.
3) “DanActive (TM) may modulate the innate immune cellular response, by reducing the depression of natural killer (NK) cell concentration, induced during intense physical exercise.”
So what. That’s enhancing the immune system? The study to demonstrate this earth shattering immune enhancement?
They looked at 13 parameters in 25 athletes whose NK cells decreased with exercise. First they took milk for a month, then Lactobacillus for an month and found one parameter that decreased less after taking Lactobacillus for a month: NK cells. Milk had a 5 % decrease in NK cells after exercise and lactobacillus had a 3 % decrease. Whoa. No controls (each patient served as their own control) I’m convinced. This is the basis of the immune enhancement of Danactive. The result in one of 13 parameters is probably random noise.
If you do a Pubmed search on L. casei and other lactobacillus you can find a variety of effects on immune function. Various immunomodulatory effects are reported.
Now here is the secret: flood any animal with any organisms and you will get the same response. For example, the literature on Candida, more of a pathogen. If you expose animals or cells in culture to Candida you get immunomodulation. You can activate or turn off the immune system, depending on which part of the immune system you are measuring and what pathogen you are testing.
If the organism, be it Candida or Lactobacillus, induces an inflammatory response, you can protect animals from subsequent infection and from cancer. If you prime the immune system before hand, you get a better host response to subsequent infection. This is a nonspecific response to all foreign bacteria, including probiotics.
More spin. Calling the normal response to pathogens (or to relative non pathogens in the case of Lactobacillus) an immune enhancement rather than inflammation is clever advertising, as is making the result seem like something special rather than the same old inflammatory response the immune system has to all foreign organisms.
There is an interesting literature on the consequences on chronic inflammation and vascular disease: the NEJM had a recent article on how chronic periodontitis leads to endothelial cell activation (the cells that line your arteries) and may account for the long known association between periodontitis and heart attacks. The cardiology literature is filled with epidemiologic studies correlating chronic inflammation and heart attacks.
Acute infections are a prothrombotic states: if you have an acute infection the inflammatory state increases your risk of clot formation and increases your risk for heart attack, stroke, and pulmonary embolism. That risk is increased for up to a year after an infection,
Inflammation, which is what taking 10 billion extra bacteria should cause, may not not be such a good idea.
The other interesting feature of infections is that after inflammation comes anti-inflammation. For every action there is an opposite and sometimes excessive reaction as the body tries to get back to baseline equilibrium. Patients with severe infections, if they survive the acute disease, are at increased risk of acquiring a new infection in the month after the infection is cured as the anti-inflammation phase increases the risk for another infection.
I will make two more predictions about taking chronic probiotics.
a) Population studies will show an increased risk of heart attack, strokes, and pulmonary embolism as a consequence of the mild increase in the inflammatory state induced by chronic probiotics.
b) Infections will increase in the month or two after stopping chronic probiotics.
Any budding epidemiologist out there feel free to run with these ideas.
6) Antibiotic-associated diarrhea. Here is where probiotics have the best data to support their yse. I think the data is clear that they are effective in preventing antibiotic associated diarrhea. So much so that at several of my hospitals we give live yogurt to normal patients who get antibiotics. Probiotics for the treatment of diarrhea? I am not so sure. The data is not as compelling and the treatment is potentially more risky.
Complications from probiotics are rare and may be more common when being used to treat an acute inflammatory diarrhea. If you have a bacillary diarrhea like C. difficile or Shigella or E. coli you can get an impressively inflamed colon. Intact bowel is an important barrier to infection, just like intact skin. Most people would be disinclined to rub large numbers of living bacteria or yeast on a raw, oozing, macerated wound. One would think this is a bad idea and could give the micro-organisms access to the blood stream.
That is what has happens with probiotics. You immune system recognizes most of your bacterial flora, so it is rare to get bloodstream infections from normal flora during infectious colitis. You do not have that innate immunity against the bacteria in probiotics. Almost all the fungemias due to S. boulardii occur when given to treat an inflammatory diarrhea. While it is very rare, if you give people a large oral bolus of live bacteria to which they have no existing immunity and their gut looks like the colonic equivalent of bad road rash, expect the occasional organism in the blood stream. This should come as no surprise to anyone in ID. If you give normal animals a large oral inoculation of some relatively non pathogenic organism it can overwhelm local defenses and lead to a blood stream infection in the absence of colitis.
My career is based on treating weird bugs, so I have a bias against possibly giving a patient an infection they don’t already have. I have seen 2 cases of S. boulardii fungemia in patients receiving this yeast to treat C. difficile. The medical literature does not indicate an increased bacteremia from Lactobacillus due to the use of probiotics. Population studies do not find an increase of Lactobacillus in the blood, but there are a few case reports of people with either severe mechanical or immunologic problems taking probiotics and getting Lactobacillus in the blood stream, for example an AIDS patient with lymphoma. Taking large amounts of a live bacteria in the immuno-incompetent may not be the best idea.
Probiotics are useful for the prevention of antibiotic associated diarrhea. Probiotics may be helpful in preventing other overgrowth syndromes or diseases associated, perhaps, with perturbations of the gut microbial flora such as IBS and colic.
Probiotics are foreign bacteria that are not a normal part of your gi tract, they do not enhance or immune system and, in normal people to note promote the nebulous bowel health.
If you are a normal human, with a normal diet, save your money. Probiotics have nothing to offer but an increased cost.
References
(1)http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123180831081775767.html
(2) For you metrically challanged, one teaspoon is about five grams and I found out that the US dollar bill weighs about a gram. So imagine a dollars sized smear of poo. There are 100 billion bacteria in it.

The Cholesterol Controversy
Why is cholesterol so much more controversial than the other cardiac risk factors? Areview of cholesterol’s troubled and contentious history might help us understand wheremany of the cholesterol controversies originated… and why it’s time to let them pass intohistory.
Christopher Labos on February 15, 2019
Link


A recent article in The Guardian raised an interesting question. Is cholesterol denialism a valid form of skepticism or pseudoscience? Is there valid debate surrounding the benefit of cholesterol medication or is the evidence and the scientific consensus clearly on one side of the issue?
It is true that we argue about cholesterol far more than the other cardiovascular risk factors. It is hard today to find anyone who doubts the harmful effects of smoking, diabetes, hypertension or the lack of exercise. So why is there a cholesterol controversy but unanimity on other risk factors?
First off, we should acknowledge that there in fact has been a controversy on almost all these issues at some point. Ronald A. Fisher was famously resistant to the idea that cigarette smoking was harmful. Also, up until fairly recently, high blood pressure was seen as necessary to push blood through the narrowed arteries of people with atherosclerosis. Some of the more amusing quotes regarding high blood pressure are worth quoting verbatim:
Get it out of your heads, if possible, that high pressure is…the feature to treat.
– William Osler, 1912 address to Glasgow Southern Medical Society
Hypertension may be an important compensatory mechanism which should not be tampered with, even were it certain that we could control it.
– Dr. Paul Dudley White, 1937
The greatest danger to a man with high blood pressure lies in its discovery, because then some fool is certain to try and reduce it.
– JH Hay, British Medical Journal 1931
The fact is that controversies are not new. We simply tend to forget that they happened.
The early history of cholesterol research
The cholesterol controversy is a recent phenomenon because our understanding of cholesterol is relatively new. Diabetes has been described since antiquity and blood pressure measurements first occurred in the 18th century, but our understanding of cholesterol only dates to the beginning of the 20th century.
One of the earliest researchers in cholesterol was Nikolay Anichkov who in 1913 reported that rabbits fed pure cholesterol dissolved in sunflower oil developed atherosclerotic lesions, whereas the control rabbits fed just sunflower oil did not. At the time, this research had little impact and its importance was only recognized in retrospect. As Daniel Steinberg states:
If the full significance of his findings had been appreciated at the time, we might have saved more than 30 years in the long struggle to settle the cholesterol controversy and [Anichkov] might have won a Nobel Prize. Instead, his findings were largely rejected or at least not followed up. Serious research on the role of cholesterol in human atherosclerosis did not really get under way until the 1940s.
Laboratories that tried to reproduce Anichkov’s results using dogs or rats failed to show that a cholesterol rich diet caused atherosclerosis. This likely occurred because dogs and other carnivores handle cholesterol differently from rabbits and other herbivores This led many to dismiss Anichkov’s results on the grounds that rabbits were not a good a good model for human physiology and that his research was likely irrelevant to humans.
The criticism leveled against his research was not entirely unfounded. We have seen countless times how animal research does not translate into humans and to accept the “lipid hypothesis” based purely on Anichkov’s work would have been premature. It should have been an invitation for others to pursue this new line of inquiry. Eventually in the 1950s John Gofman would begin his research in lipoproteins and determine that there were different types of cholesterol. Today of course we acknowledge that low-density particles like LDL are atherogenic whereas high-density particles like HDL are not. Gofman demonstrated this in the 1956 Cooperative Study of Lipoproteins and Atherosclerosis although the distinction of LDL and HDL would only come later.
There was a fair bit of controversy surrounding the study at the time. The study actually had two discussion sections, one penned by Gofman’s group and the other by the other three collaborating laboratories in the study. The schism seems to have occurred over a technical point of cholesterol measurement with the others concluding that Gofman’s Atherogenic Index had “no advantage over the simpler measurement of cholesterol.” They also maintained, “lipoprotein measurements are so complex that it cannot be reasonably expected that they could be done reliably in hospital laboratories.” Fortunately, our technical mastery of cholesterol measurement has improved considerably and people were soon able to conduct large-scale epidemiologic studies to determine if measuring someone’s cholesterol provided insight into their cardiovascular risk.
The epidemiology studies
Despite the controversy that surrounded the Cooperative Study of Lipoproteins and Atherosclerosis, there was evidence that cholesterol (regardless how you measured it) was correlated with coronary disease. The work of Carl Muller studying patients with familial hypercholesterolemia was also largely supportive of this link. The work of Brown and Goldstein and their isolation of the LDL receptor would prove the genetic cause of this disease and win the Nobel Prize, but this work was still decades off. However, it could be argued, with some validity, that individuals with a genetic cause for their high cholesterol were not representative of the general population. Nevertheless, by the mid-1950s there was enough interest in this new potential risk factor that large-scale epidemiologic studies were launched.
The Seven Countries Study has certainly been one of the most notorious studies of the period and its originator, Ancel Keys, has become a popular target for attack. The main thrust of the attack is that he cherry picked the data in order to obfuscate the truth that saturated fats are unrelated to heart disease. The reality is slightly more nuanced and a detailed review of the Seven Countries Study highlighting its strengths and limitations can be found here for anyone who is interested. Suffice it to say, the main argument that can be leveled against the attempt to deny the role of cholesterol in heart disease is to point out that other studies have shown similar results.
Studies like the Ni-Hon-San study and the Honolulu Heart Study examined the rate of heart disease in Japanese men living in Japan, Hawaii and San Francisco. They found that compared to the men living in Japan, Japanese men who had migrated to Hawaii had higher cholesterol levels and higher rates of heart disease. Japanese men who migrated to San Francisco had still higher rates. The not-unreasonable conclusion was that the increase in heart disease was environmentally mediated and that as these Japanese men adopted the diet and lifestyle of their adopted country, their cardiovascular risk rose accordingly.
Finally, we cannot forget the impact of the Framingham Heart Study. Begun in 1948 and still ongoing, this project has provided many insights into the causes of heart diseases. It established that risk factors like cholesterol, hypertension, smoking, lack of exercise, and obesity all affected the risk of cardiovascular diseases. In fact, it coined the term “risk factor”.
Suffice it to say, whatever criticisms one wants to level against the Seven Countries Study, there was plenty of other data suggesting a link between cholesterol and heart diseases. Not unsurprisingly, researchers eventually resolved to try and do something about it.
The era of the diet studies
Although there was fairly good epidemiologic evidence linking cholesterol to heart disease risk, definitive proof would require demonstrating causation, not simply an association from population studies. Given that medications to lower cholesterol were still some years off, the only available tool at this point was a dietary intervention.
Importantly, many of these studies were not studies of a low fat diet. The dietary intervention under study was usually replacing a diet high in saturated fat (i.e. fat from animal sources) with polyunsaturated fats (i.e. fat from plant sources) with the goal of lowering blood cholesterol levels.
The Oslo Diet-Heart Study was one of the first such studies and recruited 412 men for 5 years of follow-up. Those randomized to the intervention group of vegetable oil did in fact see a drop in their cholesterol level as well as a decrease in cardiovascular mortality (79 vs. 94 deaths in the control group). The difference in all-cause mortality (101 vs. 108) was not statistically significant. The Wadsworth Veterans Administration Domiciliary Hospital Study was a similar trial. They had the advantage of a resident population that could be randomized to one dining hall or the other thereby ensuring good compliance with the study allocation. The 846 men in the study were studied for 5 years. Here too there was a reduction in major cardiovascular events (48 vs. 70 events in the control group). Another study in Finland randomized two mental health hospitals, assigning one to serve a diet high in saturated fat and the other to a diet of unsaturated fat. As part of its cross over design, after 6 years the hospital assignments were switched. It significantly included both men and women and demonstrated a reduction in cardiovascular mortality.
Unfortunately, not every study of the time was positive. A study done by the British Medical Research Council found no benefit to soya-bean oil. Serum cholesterol did fall in the intervention group, although the difference between intervention and control groups lessened with time, likely because of waning compliance. The number of cardiovascular events was lower in the intervention group (62 vs. 74) but the difference was not statistically significant. Another study testing corn oil found no significant change in the incidence of cardiovascular events, and one of the few studies to test an actual low fat diet found no benefit to cardiovascular disease.
All in all, the diet studies from this period suggested that lowering serum cholesterol levels could reduce cardiovascular events. However, someone could justifiably say that the evidence to date was inconsistent. In truth, the negative studies tended to be smaller and were probably underpowered. Also, the positive results tended to occur in studies where the change in serum cholesterol was greatest. For example, the low-fat diet study showed no cardiovascular benefit but also had little impact on cholesterol levels, which likely explains why it was negative. Still, the mixed bag of trials from this period instilled in many a doubt about the value of cholesterol lowering. Unfortunately, many failed to appreciate a subtle point. A dietary intervention can fail to produce a benefit (especially if compliance is poor). But the failure of dietary intervention does not mean that serum cholesterol is unrelated to cardiovascular risk.
The era of the early drug trials
By the late 1970’s, there were pronounced criticisms by some regarding dietary interventions for cholesterol lowering, regardless of whether those criticisms were deserved. But research into cholesterol metabolism was providing new medications that might potentially lower cholesterol levels and reduce cardiovascular risk.
The first candidate drug was clofibrate. In one of the first international randomized trials, 15,000 men with no history of heart disease were randomized to clofibrate or placebo. At 5 years there was a decrease in cholesterol and a 25% relative risk reduction in non-fatal infarcts. It was overall a positive study and gave further proof to the idea that lowering cholesterol prevents heart attacks. There were however two problems. There was no difference in cardiovascular mortality and all-cause mortality was slightly worse in the clofibrate group (162 vs. 127 deaths). This increased number of deaths was likely the result of random chance, but the idea that lowering your cholesterol could be dangerous has never really left us since.
The results of the Coronary Primary Prevention Trial were more encouraging. This double blind trial of cholestyramine demonstrated an 8.5% reduction in cholesterol, a 12.6% reduction in LDL and a 19% reduction in cardiovascular endpoints. In absolute terms, the reduction was from 8.6% to 7%. Once again, the trial showed that lowering cholesterol resulted in less cardiovascular events. Cardiovascular mortality was lower with cholestyramine too, but not statistically significant. There was, however, one bizarre finding to the trial. Although all-cause mortality was marginally lower in the cholestyramine group, there were a greater number of violent or accidental deaths (homicides, suicides, and car accidents) in those who got the drug (11 vs. 4 deaths).
These results once again caused some concern that cholesterol lowering was dangerous. Some worried that lowering cholesterol could impair brain function and lead to accidents or suicides (although how exactly it would make you the victim of a murder was never entirely made clear). The idea that cholesterol lowering can impair brain function keeps resurfacing. It is a common claim that statins can cause memory loss, even though the weight of the evidence suggests statins have no strong effect on memory one way or the other.
With two large trials done, in 1984 the NIH convened a Consensus Conference to review the evidence and establish guidelines. Their conclusions were that:
Elevated blood cholesterol level is a major cause of coronary artery disease. It has been established beyond a reasonable doubt that lowering definitely elevated blood cholesterol levels (specifically blood levels of low-density lipoprotein cholesterol) will reduce the risk of heart attacks due to coronary heart disease.
The media was less favorable in their critique. The Atlantic famously run a cover story on “The Cholesterol Myth” claiming, “lowering your cholesterol is next to impossible with diet, and often dangerous with drugs – and it won’t make you live any longer.”
There was of course something to this criticism. If not “impossible” to lower your cholesterol with diet, it is very difficult. In many of the more successful diet trials from the 1960’s, the research subjects were residents in hospitals or other institutions, which made controlling their diet fairly easy. Compliance in the community is of course harder. That it was dangerous to lower your cholesterol with drugs was perhaps overstating the point. That it won’t make you live any longer was technically true in that all-cause mortality was not statistically different. But it did prevent heart attacks and other cardiovascular events. Clearly they would improve quality of life if not quantity of life. Despite these nuances, skepticism about the benefit of lowering cholesterol remained fairly wide spread.
The statin era
When Akiro Endo developed the first statin, I don’t think anyone could have predicted how it would change the debate regarding cholesterol. Mevastatin, or compactin, never made it to market but similar drugs like simvastatin soon would. The Scandinavian Simvastatin Survival Study (4S) would demonstrate how effective statins would be at lowering cholesterol and reducing cardiovascular risk. If you compare the 4S study to the Coronary Primary Prevention Trial with cholestyramine mentioned above:
	CPPT trial 1984	4S trial 1994
Drug used	Cholestyramine	Simvastatin
Population	Only men	Men and women
Total cholesterol	13.4% lower	25% lower
LDL	20% lower	35% lower
Reduced CV events	19% reduction	n/a
CV mortality	24% lower	RR 0.58 (95%CI 0.46-0.73)
All cause mortality	n/a	RR 0.70 (95%CI 0.58-0.85)
The 4S trial demonstrated not only greater cholesterol reductions but also greater reductions in cardiovascular and all-cause mortality. The benefits were also significant in women and patients over age 60.
Twenty-six randomized trials later, we can draw some pretty firm conclusions about the benefits of statins. There are many meta-analyses summarizing the data on statins and some are better than others. Judging the value of a meta-analysis is difficult, although I do not hold with the old joke that the meta-analysis is to analysis, what meta-physics is to physics. There is value to a meta-analysis when done properly. A 2010 meta-analysis summarized the data and had the advantage of using individual patient data, which generally speaking greatly improves the value of the analysis. Also, their findings are largely in agreement with the US Preventive Services Task force. Their summary showed that LDL lowering with statins reduced not just heart attacks and strokes, but also all-cause mortality (RR 0·90, 95% CI 0·87–0·93; p<0·0001) for every 1.0 mmol/L reduction in LDL.

The controversy continues
The preponderance of the data from the statin trials was hard to reconcile if you wanted to maintain that cholesterol had no role in cardiovascular risk prevention. There was of course one possible position you could take. Maybe the benefit seen with statins had nothing to do with their ability to lower LDL cholesterol. Maybe statins had pleiotropic effects that acted independently of their cholesterol effects. For example, maybe statins had anti-inflammatory properties and this was why they prevented heart attacks.
There are two main counter-arguments against statin pleiotropy. The first is that when you re-examine the randomized trial data, the benefits to statin therapy appear quite linear. In other words, statins that lower LDL cholesterol the most have the greatest cardiovascular benefit. Our group found similar results. Using statistical techniques usually used in the field of genetic epidemiology, we were able to re-analyze the data from the statin trials and determine that pleiotropic effects were probably negligible. As I pithily pointed out to a friend of mine once our paper came out, we spent a great deal of time and effort trying to prove that cholesterol medications work by lowering your cholesterol.
The second argument is perhaps more intuitively obvious to understand. After statins were developed two new classes of medications came onto the market. Ezetimibe blocks cholesterol absorption from the intestine and PCSK9 inhibitors act via the LDL receptor. Both medications lower LDL and both prevent cardiovascular events (although the benefit of ezetimibe is relatively small). Importantly though, they act via completely different mechanisms from statins. When statins were the only medications on the market, you could maybe entertain the idea that their benefit had nothing to do with cholesterol. But when you have multiple medications that lower cholesterol via different mechanisms all showing a consistent and proportional cardiovascular benefit, that argument becomes extremely untenable. The figure below demonstrates the point quite clearly. The cardiovascular benefit of different cholesterol lowering interventions is directly proportion to their ability to lower LDL.

The common criticisms
It would be tempting to think that the wealth of data has ended the cholesterol controversy but it continues to this day. Common criticisms leveled against this hypothesis usually follow predictable patterns.
Argument 1: Carbs are the real enemy
The criticism against Ancel Keys, and the low fat diet in general, usually get extrapolated to mean that cholesterol is good for you. It is worth remembering that the diet trials of the 1960s were about substituting saturated animal fats with polyunsaturated vegetable fats. They were not tests of low-calorie vs. low fat diets.
Also, before going down the rabbit hole that is dietary epidemiology and the problems with interpreting the plethora of contradictory research on any subject regarding food, it is worth saying again the real issue is not the cholesterol in your diet but the cholesterol in your blood stream. Lifestyle factors like diet and exercise certainly have a role in cardiovascular risk reduction, but we now have medications that can accomplish degrees of cholesterol reduction substantially greater than what you can achieve with lifestyle changes alone. No one is debating that eating lots of candy is bad for you. What we are talking about here is treating hypercholesterolemia. That should be non-controversial treatment strategy.
Argument 2: Doctors over prescribe statins, lifestyle changes are best
The argument that we overprescribe statins and that people should just eat better is a fairly prevalent one. It is actually in direct opposition to Argument 1 and fails to acknowledge that the dietary trials of the 1960s were only modestly and inconsistently effective at lowering cholesterol and preventing heart attacks. Also, it is worth pointing out that lifestyle changes and medications are not mutually exclusive. You can do both simultaneous and you probably should.
Also, an increasing amount of evidence suggests that we should be pushing cholesterol levels even lower than we currently are. The concern that your cholesterol can be too low has been with us since the CPPT trial, including the concern that lowering your cholesterol could affect brain function. The data though suggests that lowering cholesterol below current targets of 1.8 mmol/L or 70 mg/dl provides a benefit with no trade-off in risk.
Argument 3: Statins have not been shown to be effective in women or the elderly
This is often repeated but not true. Early trials were done exclusively in men, and women have been historically under-represented in clinical trials. But starting with the 4S trial, thousands of women have been enrolled in statin trials and sub-group analyses show their effects to be similar to men. Similar sub-group analyses for people over age 75 also show a benefit.
Argument 4: Statins don’t work for primary prevention
The US Preventive Services Task Force disagrees with this point. There have actually been many studies looking at statins in primary prevention (people who do not have established cardiovascular disease). The benefit in primary prevention is certainly less than in secondary prevention, but the benefit is still there.

As the above graph shows, even in primary prevention, if you lower LDL, you lower cardiovascular risk. The magnitude of that benefit is smaller than in secondary prevention, and you might decide that benefit is too small to justify starting a new medication. As always, higher risk patients benefit most from medications. But the claim that statins have no benefit whatsoever is incorrect.
Argument 5: Statins are too expensive
Statins are generic now, which has largely eliminated the sting from that argument. Whether they are cost effective is a separate, but interesting, question. They certainly become more cost effective as prices drop. There is some debate about whether the benefit justifies the cost, although they are probably cost effective using the general definition of that term. It should be pointed out that cost effectiveness analyses depend quite a bit on the price of medications, and the cost assigned to side effects and outcomes. These can vary quite a bit from study-to-study and region-to-region, and different groups can come to different conclusions. An important point though, is that we are not debating whether cholesterol lowering works; we are debating whether it is worth the money.
Argument 6: Most people who have heart attacks have normal cholesterol
First off, as mentioned above, it is quite possible that “normal” cholesterol is much lower than we think it is. Blood pressures between 150 and 180mmHg, which now cause great stress and anxiety in patients and sometimes bring them to the emergency room, used to be considered as mild hypertension and treating it was of debatable value. Just as blood pressure targets were systematically adjusted downwards over the years, so have cholesterol targets.
Nevertheless there are some people who suggest that when you have a heart attack, having high cholesterol is protective. This observation is usually due to index event bias. Much like obesity can seem to be protective in heart failure, so too cholesterol can seem to be protective in patients after a heart attack. The unfortunate truth though is that neither is good for you. Anybody particularly interested in index event bias can read an editorial about it that we penned in the Canadian Journal of Cardiology.
Finally, if someone argues that most people with heart attacks have normal cholesterol, you can respond that most people with heart attacks are non-smokers, but smoking is still bad for you. The fact that a risk factor is rare doesn’t make it beneficial.
I also doubt the fact that most people with a heart attack have low cholesterol, but after searching I could not find good data one way or the other. Empirically though, my personal experience suggests this is untrue.
Argument 7: Statins have too many side effects
Statins do have side effects, like every other drug. We cannot deny that this is the case but we do not need to guard against hyperbole. People will sometimes claim that the rate of side effects with statins is nearly 20%, but this actually false and usually reflects a mis-quoting of the data. Complaints of myopathy are higher in observational studies than randomized trials and few randomized trials specifically looked at muscle-related outcomes. The one trial that did, STOMP, found statins did not decrease muscle strength or exercise performance but there were more complaints of muscle pain compared to placebo (9.3 vs. 4.6%). So, statins likely do cause some muscle problems although the risk of serious muscle or liver damage is very low. There is also appears to be a nocebo effect at play.
It is important to point out that being intolerant to statins does not imply that cholesterol is unimportant. When statins were the only feasible option the market for cholesterol lowering, the challenge of treating statin-intolerant patients was difficult. But now the problem is easier. A statin-intolerant patient, who cannot tolerate even a low dose or a different statin, can be switched to an alternative medication with a different mechanism of action. Over the years, much cholesterol denialism has been focused on statins specifically but with the advent of new and different drugs, this will become a much harder argument to carry forward. We should be cautious though, because new medications like PCSK9 are substantially more expensive than statins, and overstating the side effects of statins will only push more patients to more expensive medications. Also, there was a worrisome report that suggested that negative news stories about statins were associated with more statin discontinuation and a rise in heart attacks. While other factors likely also played a role, it should remind us that there are real world implications for patients who take these medications. Misstating the evidence has serious negative side effects.
Conclusion: Cholesterol is a risk factor for heart disease
Over the better part of a century, cholesterol has been examined as a possible risk factor for heart disease. There have been many criticisms along the way. Some were justified, some less so. Animal studies in rabbits cannot be applied to humans, diet studies are often ineffective, early drug trials were done exclusive in men, treatment did not translate into a mortality benefit, statins might have had a different mechanism of action, and statins are too expensive.
But all these criticisms belong to a different time. There are studies in humans. We have moved past diet studies for lowering cholesterol. Women are included in studies. There is a mortality benefit. Statins (and other medications) do work by lowering LDL. Statins are now generic. There are alternative to statins if you have side effects. The thing about the cholesterol controversy is that most of it has been settled.
Some issues remain. Maybe it is better to measure to non-HDL cholesterol or ApoB cholesterol instead of LDL cholesterol. But this is a subtle point, and finding a better way to measure something does not negate the underlying truth that high cholesterol increases the risk of heart disease.
There was a time when someone could be skeptical about the role of cholesterol in cardiac risk reduction. That time has now passed.

   Red Yeast Rice to Lower Cholesterol
Harriet Hall
Link
The Medical Letter, a highly respected source of reliable independent evaluations of drugs and therapeutics, has just published an evaluation of red yeast rice (Vol 51, Issue 1320, P 71-2, Sept 7, 2009). It has been widely promoted as a “natural” alternative to prescription medications for lowering blood LDL cholesterol levels. Studies have indeed shown that red yeast rice reduces LDL cholesterol levels and reduces the rate of major coronary events. The Medical Letter consultants concluded that it works, but they don’t recommend it. Why?
It’s Just Another Statin
When rice is fermented with the yeast Monascus purpureus, the resulting product contains numerous monacolins, which are naturally occurring HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors. One of these is identical to the prescription drug Mevacor (lovastatin). So it isn’t an alternative to prescription drugs, it’s just an alternative way of providing the same thing.
It Has Side Effects
Since red yeast rice contains statins, it can cause the same adverse effects as statin drugs, including myopathy. There have been reports of rhabdomyolysis and hepatitis. Red yeast rice contains many other components besides the active ingredients. Those other components are not necessary and may be harmful – it is quite possible that new side effects from those other components would be recognized if large numbers of patients were as carefully monitored as patients on statin drugs have been.
It May Be Contaminated with a Toxin
Some red yeast rice products contain citrinin, a mycotoxin that can cause kidney failure in animals. In one study, measurable amounts of citrinin were found in 7 out of 9 products tested. and in another study citrinin was found in four out of ten products tested, with the highest level found in a supplement sold by a major pharmacy chain.
It’s a Less Reliable Way to Get the Benefit of Statins
Under DSHEA rules, red yeast rice products are not regulated as drugs. They are not standardized and may contain unlabelled ingredients. In one study of 9 brands, the amount of active ingredient in red yeast rice varied from 0% to 0.58% . In another study of 10 products, the content varied 100-fold. The Medical Letter says
The FDA has tried, apparently unsuccessfully, to remove red yeast rice products from the US market as unapproved formulations of an approved drug (lovastatin).
It’s More Expensive
A common argument in favor of natural medicines is that they are less expensive than Big Pharma profit-making drugs. In this case, that’s not true. According to The Medical Letter, the cost of a month’s treatment with red yeast rice is $16-37, and the cost of generic lovastatin is as low as $4 at discount pharmacies.
Why Would Anyone Choose Red Yeast Rice Over a Prescription Statin?
There is no logical reason to do so. Those who choose it are making an irrational decision based on the belief that “natural is better” – a fallacy that Steven Novella demolished here.
Among all the different kinds of complementary and alternative medicine, natural and herbal medicines have the highest prior probability. The history of pharmacology is full of examples where a natural medicine was found to be effective and the active ingredient was isolated, standardized, and became a mainstream treatment. There are few if any examples of a whole natural medicine that was found to be superior (or even equivalent) to a purified pharmaceutical containing the active ingredient. Even in a case like this, where natural red yeast rice was shown to be effective, there are compelling reasons to prefer the regulated pharmaceutical version.

Statins beat supplements
Red yeast rice supplements have poor quality control and there’s no clear evidence they do anything beneficial. So why take it?
Scott Gavura on August 24, 2017
Link

The idea that you might need lifetime drug therapy can be frightening. It’s understandable to ask questions of your prescriber when medication is recommended – why a drug might be necessary, what benefits and harms might be expected, and whether there are non-drug approaches that could eliminate the need for daily medicine. It’s natural (ha) to ask about alternatives. Successful marketing has led to the promotion (and assumption) that dietary supplements and natural health products can be acceptable substitutes for drugs, without the long list of possible side effects. Herbal products are categorized in many countries as a form of dietary supplement when (at best) they are effectively impure, unstandardized drugs. Red yeast rice is a supplement that is promoted as a “natural” cholesterol-lowering remedy as potentially effective as the “statin” group of drugs. And that statement has some truth to it: some brands of red yeast rice have been tested and have indeed been shown to reduce cholesterol, like statin drugs. That’s because one of the active ingredient in red yeast rice is the prescription cholesterol drug, lovastatin. This isn’t necessarily adulteration: Lovastatin is naturally occurring in red yeast rice (a powerful endorsement of pharmacognosy). The main difference between red yeast rice and the prescription drug lovastatin (or Mevacor) is that the drug product has been isolated, purified and standardized to give a reliable dose into the body with each pill.
The belief that “natural” is preferable to anything “synthetic” is actively promoted by the supplement industry, and it’s sometimes referred to as the appeal to nature fallacy: Anything that comes from natural sources (especially if it’s organic) is believed to be good, helpful, and non-toxic, and anything that is synthesized is therefore artificial, unnatural, and dangerous. Nature represents a remarkable drug synthesis lab, and there are many commercially-manufactured drugs that are identical to, or based on, natural sources. But being “natural” has no relationship to whether a particular chemical is safe to humans or effective to treat a specific condition. Many natural products are toxic (e.g., botulism, strychnine, tetanus, poison ivy, and arsenic). When we need reliable and predictable treatments, however, drug products are far more consistent and reliable than any dietary supplements. Not only are drug products standardized and tested to contain and deliver a specific dose of medicine, the same products undergo testing in clinical trials to understanding their benefits (and harms). Dietary supplements undergo little if any pre-market testing and there is little evidence to suggest that dietary supplements consistently meet any reasonable quality manufacturing standard.
A new study has looked at red yeast rice supplements, and the effects of FDA-mandated manufacturing standards that were expected to improve the quality and consistency of supplements. What researchers found was that the strength and composition of red yeast rice products continue to be unpredictable, and there is no assurance for consumers they’re actually getting what they think they’re buying.
Supplement or drug: Why bother lowering cholesterol?
“Statins” are a class of drugs (which include lovastatin) that reduce LDL cholesterol. There’s two general uses for statin therapy: primary prevention (avoiding a first heart attack or stroke), and secondary prevention (using a statin in someone that has already had a heart attack or stroke to reduce the risk of another cardiovascular event). There is good evidence that statins reduce the risk of heart attacks and strokes, when used for both primary and secondary prevention. Much of the debate on the usefulness of statins has focused on the absolute benefit when used in lower-risk groups. This is a fair question, and one that I’ve discussed at length previously. But what is not in question is that statins have been proven to reduce the risk of heart attacks, stroke, and death.
There are no symptoms to high cholesterol. Lowering cholesterol won’t make us feel better today. The only reason to take a drug or supplement that targets cholesterol is because we expect it to lower the risk of heart disease: heart attacks, strokes, and death. Statins drugs lower cholesterol and are proven to reduce the risk of heart attacks and strokes. In theory, red yeast rice should have the same effect, if the active ingredient is the same. But if it’s not present, there’s no reason to expect it will do anything useful or beneficial. If we’re taking it for years, we need the assurance that it is consistent, reliable, and will lower the risk of heart disease. But there is real cause for concern according to a new study by Pieter Cohen and associates, in a paper published in the European Journal of Preventive Cardiology entitled “Variability in strength of red yeast rice supplements purchased from mainstream retailers.” This was a straightforward quality assessment of red yeast rice supplements purchased at Whole Foods, GNC, Walgreens and Walmart. Tablets were analyzed for the active ingredient of monacolin K (i.e., lovastatin) using standardized methods. In testing 28 brands, here’s what they found:
    • no brand actually specified how much monacolin K was present per tablet
    • two brands, when tested, had no monacolin K present at all
    • in the remaining 26 brands, the per-tablet quantity varied from 0.09mg to 5.48mg of monacolin K per 1200mg tablet, a 120-fold difference
    • following the labelled directions, the effective drug dose would range from 0.09mg to 10.94mg per day
    • only two of the 28 brands cautioned against concurrent use with statin drugs
As Harriet Hall noted in a past post, the FDA had previously concluded that red yeast rice products that contained more than 4mg of lovastatin were unapproved drugs. This study found that 21% of the brands studied contained >4mg of lovastatin per daily dose. Unfortunately for consumers, there’s no way to tell. The only red yeast rice products that are legally permitted for sale contain little, if any lovastatin, so they are in effect, ineffective for the intended purpose. Products that do contain significant lovastatin doses are in violation of FDA regulations and are not legally allowed for sale. The consumer has nothing to go on at all, as there is no way to tell the actually quantity of lovastatin in any brand of red yeast rice. Ironically, prescription strength lovastatin is far less expensive than red yeast rice. A three-month prescription will cost you about $10, and you’ll be assured you’re actually getting what you pay for.
Safety concerns
Given red yeast rice may contain prescription-level amounts of lovastatin, it should logically contain the same warnings and cautions as prescription lovastain. The side effects from red yeast rice are consistent with prescription statins. However, none of this information is routinely made available to consumers, who may not even realize that they may be consuming prescription-strength lovastatin that’s labelled as a supplement. And because there’s no way to predict if lovastatin levels are actually consistent in supplements, then there’s no way to determine if the supplement is actually doing anything.
Supplement or drug?
Red rice yeast extract is a natural but crude source of the statin drug lovastatin. If you want to lower your cholesterol and be confident that you’re actually reducing your risk of heart attacks and strokes, take a statin drug. If you want to spend more, prefer products with no obvious quality control, and don’t mind paying more for an active ingredient that may or may not actually be in the bottle, then take red yeast rice. Why red rice yeast extract would be preferred over a drug product is unclear, unless one puts a priority on something “natural” over something that’s standardized, predictable, and demonstrated to be effective. If you need lovastatin, take the drug lovastatin, rather than a supplement that may-or-may-not actually contain lovastatin.

Study – For Lowering Cholesterol, Statins Work, Supplements Don’t
A study comparing a statin drug and six common supplements to placebo shows that only the drug lowers bad cholesterol.
Steven Novella on November 9, 2022
Link

It is now well-established that having high levels of “bad” cholesterol (low density lipoprotein, or LDL) increases the risk of heart disease. Further, lowering LDL is protective, reducing the risk of atherosclerotic vascular disease, with higher risk patients having more of a benefit. This is extremely convenient in terms of cardiac and vascular research because now we can study simply if a treatment effectively lowers LDL. Following a marker in the blood is a lot easier than tracking health outcomes, which have a lot of confounding factors and takes a much longer time.
People looking to improve their cardiac and vascular health by improving their cholesterol numbers (lowering LDL and increasing good cholesterol – HDL) have lots of options. Regular exercise has been shown to improve peoples’ cholesterol profile, and has lots of other health benefits, and so it is a clear recommendation. The relationship between diet and cholesterol is more complex. Dietary cholesterol does not seem to have a significant effect on blood cholesterol for most people (some individuals, however, are genetically predisposed to respond to cholesterol in their diet). Otherwise the basic advice is to have an overall healthy diet, limiting saturated fats and having plenty of fruits and vegetables. Having a lean body mass is also helpful.
Diet, exercise, and maintaining a healthy weight is enough for most people to maintain a healthy cholesterol profile, and should always be part of any strategy to do so. However, not everyone can or does maintain a healthy lifestyle. Also, many people are genetically predisposed to high cholesterol, and no amount of healthy lifestyle will counteract their genetics. For many people, therefore, adding either a drug or a supplement to help improve cholesterol profile is a helpful or even necessary strategy. That is the focus of a recent study published in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology.
The study includes 190 participants, which is modest in size.
It was a single-center, prospective, randomized, single-blind clinical trial among adults with no history of atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease (ASCVD), an LDL-C of 70-189 mg/dL and an increased 10-year risk of ASCVD. Participants were randomized to 5 mg daily of rosuvastatin, placebo, fish oil, cinnamon, garlic, turmeric, plant sterols or red yeast rice.
The primary endpoint was change in LDL-C from baseline at 28 days. The rosuvastatin group confirmed that this medication is effective, with a 35.2% decrease in LDL-C from baseline. That is both clinically significant and statistically significant (<0.001). None of the six supplements showed any significant reduction in LDL-C.
The primary weakness of the study was its modest size. But this is not really a significant issue, in my opinion, because the study was clearly large enough to detect a clinically significant effect. One might argue that the trial was too small to rule out a small beneficial effect from any of the supplements, which is true, but such a small effect is likely not worthwhile in any case. The study was single-blinded, but because the only outcome measure was completely objective, a blood test result, this should not matter. Still, a larger, double-blinded, and multi-center trial would be welcome. I just doubt it would show anything different.
The negative results for all the supplements save fish oil is to be expected. The previous evidence for these supplements was never good. Turmeric, for example, suffers from insignificant bioavailability. Some versions of red yeast rice actually contain a small amount of lovastatin (a proven cholesterol-lowering drug) but not the brands available in the US. Red yeast rice without lovastatin has no effect on cholesterol. Garlic has also been studied, and shown to be ineffective as a cholesterol-lowering agent. The evidence for cinnamon is also negative.
The story of plant sterols is a bit more complicated. The evidence does show a possible modest effect, about a 9% lowering of LDL. This effect may have been missed in the current study. But also, this requires having 2 grams of plant sterols twice a day, which many may find difficult. Further, there are lingering issues of the net clinical effects of these doses, so relying entirely on a marker such as blood LDL may not be the whole story. Margarines with plant sterols may also contain trans fats, which can wipe out the benefits. So this is a tricky option, but may not be entirely useless. Clearly, however, it is no substitute for a statin drug.
Fish oil is also a bit complicated. While the evidence shows it does not lower total cholesterol, and may even increase LDL a bit, its primary benefit may come from increased good HDL cholesterol. This is a situation where we need evidence from net clinical outcomes, but they are very difficult to document with modest interventions because they would requires thousands of subjects, or tens of thousands, over years to get to statistical significance. The bottom line with fish oil is – you can’t just sprinkle it on your steak. It is no substitute for a good diet, or a statin drug. But there may be some benefit in helping to increase HDL.
This one study, because it is modest, is not definitive unto itself, but it does add to a growing body of evidence that is fairly consistently showing the same thing. There are two strategies proven to significantly improve cholesterol profile and cardiovascular health – lifestyle factors, and statin drugs. Supplements are basically drown in the noise of the evidence, and have either been shown to be useless or at best have a modest effect that is difficult to pin down. Supplements are not a substitute for the first two strategies.
This also makes sense because supplements are drugs, they are just drugs that have been poorly purified and generally have poor pharmaceutical attributes (otherwise they would be marketed as drugs). What they have is effective (and misleading) marketing.

The Movie “Cholesterol: The Great Bluff” Is an Exercise in Denialism
The movie “Cholesterol: The Great Bluff” claims that we have been lied to: cholesterol doesn’t cause heart disease and statins are harmful. It is biased and misleading. The people interviewed in the movie are denialists who don’t accept the clear evidence for the role of blood cholesterol levels and the benefits of statins.
Harriet Hall on September 12, 2017
Link

A correspondent alerted me to a new movie, Cholesterol: The Great Bluff, that she had watched on Canadian TV. The premise of the movie is that all those doctors and scientists are wrong: cholesterol is good for you, it has nothing to do with heart disease, and statins are useless and dangerous drugs maliciously promoted by Big Pharma solely to line their pockets. She was skeptical, but couldn’t find any criticism or reviews of it. I couldn’t find any reviews either, so I thought maybe I’d better write one.
The film is in French with English subtitles, and I was not able to watch it, but I was able to read the complete transcript online.
I was appalled. It had snazzy production values, made a very persuasive case, featured interviews with scientists, and might be very impressive to a naïve viewer; but it was a mishmash of propaganda, half-truths, omissions, and misinformation. It is a biased polemic that badly misrepresents the truth about cholesterol, heart disease, and statins.
Misleading appeals to emotion
Its typically irrational, emotional appeals start with the opening scenes. An attractive, fit, muscular man is shown. Captions read “Push-ups 75, Sit-ups 100, Daily laps 50, Total cholesterol 258.” The viewer is meant to jump to the conclusion that his high blood cholesterol doesn’t matter. But of course, we have no basis for that assumption. We don’t know anything about his risk factors. That cholesterol level, in conjunction with his other risk factors, might or might not mean he is at significant risk of a heart attack.
They criticize statin ads for telling us that “An insidious evil can eat away at us, even if we feel healthy.” They present this as if the evil of cholesterol is a myth. Of course, there are many diseases that can eat away at us while we feel healthy, and atherosclerosis is one of them. High cholesterol doesn’t cause any symptoms, but it does increase the risk of a heart attack.
“Cholesterol has been the subject of fierce scientific disputes.” Not so much. There has been an evolving consensus that developed as new evidence became available.
Ancel Keys
Ancel Keys was one of the first to suggest that it was saturated fats that caused heart disease:
Saturated fats would cause your total cholesterol to go up – which was the only thing they could measure in those days. And that would clog your arteries and give you a heart attack. It was called the diet-heart hypothesis.
The movie gives the impression that Keys observed cholesterol-containing xanthomas on the skin and only assumed that there were similar deposits in the arteries that could lead to heart attacks. He didn’t need to assume that. It was demonstrable.
The movie rightfully debunks Ancel Keys’ infamous 7-country study that purported to show a correlation between the amount of fat in the diet and the levels of cholesterol in the blood. The study was fatally flawed [note addendum], and the movie correctly shows how Keys omitted data and manipulated facts to make them look like they validated his hypothesis.
Framingham misrepresented
Doctor Michel de Lorgeril, a French cardiologist and researcher, tells us the landmark Framingham study “absolutely confirmed that tabasco was a cause [No, I don’t think so! And also, note addendum], that high blood pressure and sedentary living were causes. But the researchers were disappointed to find that there was no connection between cholesterol and cardiovascular diseases.” That is demonstrably untrue. The Framingham study identified a number of risk factors for cardiovascular disease, and one of them was elevated blood cholesterol.
A cholesterol skeptic presented as an expert
Dr. Uffe Ravnskov is interviewed. He is one of the worst possible choices of experts to interview; his bias is clear. He is the author of The Cholesterol Myths and a member of THINCS (The International Network of Cholesterol Skeptics), an organization whose mind is irrevocably made up, whose avowed purpose is “to oppose [emphasis added] that animal fat and high cholesterol play a role” (rather than to look at the evidence). Several years ago I wrote an article about THINCS showing how they distort the data and spread misinformation. He claims that in Framingham there were more deaths among people whose cholesterol levels decreased. That’s a distortion: the Framingham study found more deaths among people with a low level of the “good” cholesterol HDL. After Framingham identified high blood cholesterol levels as a risk factor, other studies confirmed that. They went on to determine that lowering cholesterol reduces risk, and the degree of risk reduction can be measured by the degree of cholesterol lowering.
Confusion between dietary cholesterol and blood cholesterol
They spend a great deal of time criticizing the low-fat diet recommendations and the marketing of low-cholesterol and low-fat foods. They are beating a dead horse. Based on the evidence, mainstream medicine has rightfully rejected the idea that dietary cholesterol is an important cause of high blood cholesterol levels. And it has been shown that a low carb diet is healthier than a low fat diet [note addendum].
Homocysteine and other hypotheses, and conspiracy theories
They interview a scientist who hypothesized that elevated homocysteine was causal. He implies that his research was squelched by “the cholesterol people.” In reality, homocysteine has been identified as a risk factor, but is not a significant enough one to use it for risk factor screening. High homocysteine levels can be reduced with B vitamins, but that doesn’t reduce cardiovascular risk.
Another scientist says a secretary(!) at the NIH “called him out in the hall and said, “Doctor Mann, if you continue your opposition to Ancel Keys, it’s going to cost you your research grant.” And, shortly after, it did.
They present other hypotheses. Lack of exercise causes cardiovascular disease. No, sugar is the cause. The sugar industry has suppressed research. Gary Taubes blamed sugar for pretty much everything in his book The Case Against Sugar, which I found less than convincing.
Questionable interpretations of studies
They cite a study where men with high cholesterol levels were fed a low cholesterol diet and treated with the cholesterol-lowering drug cholestyramine. It found only “a very slim reduction in cardiovascular risk.” They emphasize that study rather than the many more studies where cholesterol was lowered much more effectively with statins to achieve a much more significant reduction in risk.
Dr. Michel de Lorgeril did a study where risk was reduced 50-70 percent by a Mediterranean diet. He says people refused to accept his results because the cholesterol levels did not change. They asked, “how can you lower the risk of heart disease without lowering cholesterol levels?” The obvious answer is that cholesterol is not the only risk factor. Scientists have never said it was.
Did Big Pharma deceive us?
When the first studies showed that statins reduced risk, everyone started prescribing them. Dr. de Lorgeril says “I couldn’t intellectually question the clinical trials published in international medical journals. It seems inconceivable to me that investigators could cheat or lie in order to deceive the whole medical community.” They point out that most clinical trials were funded by statin manufacturers, which they assume destroys their credibility. (Industry funding doesn’t mean we should ignore studies; it just means we should exercise caution.) They say no one dared question the results; criticizing statins would be suicidal.
They bring up the example of Vioxx, saying the laboratory had deliberately hidden information about potentially fatal side effects. There are two sides to that story [note addendum]. Anyway, malfeasance in one case would not prove malfeasance by other companies in relation to other drugs. But de Lorgeril says it was a horrendous surprise that pharmaceutical companies could lie. He says “we may have been deceived,” but provides no evidence of deception in the case of statins. He says after this realization in 2005-6, “all clinical trials on statins were proved to be negative, which meant that they were shown to have no beneficial effects.” That is demonstrably untrue. Since 2006, clinical trials have continued to demonstrate the efficacy and safety of statins, as anyone can easily confirm by a PubMed search.
They point out that cholesterol is an essential compound produced by our bodies. True. They imply that lowering it is harmful. Not true. Recent studies indicate that lowering cholesterol to unprecedentedly low levels is associated with improved outcomes.
Statin side effects
They grossly exaggerate the side effects of statins. They offer a scaremongering testimonial claiming that a statin caused a devastating case of Alzheimer’s that was cured by stopping the drug. In reality, people on statins are less likely to develop Alzheimer’s. Anecdotal reports of side effects abound, but in placebo-controlled trials, the incidence of most side effects is no greater with statins than with placebo.
“I don’t want to know.”
The movie ends by asking numerous people DO YOU KNOW YOUR NUMBER? And most of them brag that they don’t know and don’t need to know. One even said he wished his cholesterol level were higher. It reminded me of people bragging that they haven’t immunized their children. They are still healthy…so far…
Denialism
Members of THINCS and the others interviewed in this movie consider themselves cholesterol skeptics. Skeptics are people who ask for evidence. These people go beyond skepticism to denial. The evidence is there, but they refuse to accept it. They people interviewed in this movie are cholesterol denialists and statin denialists.
I recently wrote an article on statin denialism for Skeptical Inquirer, where I addressed most of the same issues covered in the film. I covered the evidence for the efficacy and safety of statins and showed that the reports of side effects were exaggerated. I encourage you to read my article, if only to brighten your day by making you laugh out loud about the claim that table salt is mostly glass and sand.
Conclusion: a denialist rant, not science
The film will probably be impressive to naïve viewers, but it’s one-sided and it certainly doesn’t represent good science. Far from being a “big bluff,” statins are one of the most valuable medicines in the modern armamentarium; I take them myself, for solidly evidence-based reasons. They’re not perfect. They only help a fraction of the patients who take them; but we have no way of identifying who will benefit, so we have to treat a lot of people to benefit the smaller number who will be spared a heart attack or a premature death. I consider them darned good insurance. People who watch this movie will be dissuaded from getting that insurance, and some of them will suffer heart attacks that could have been prevented.
This is just one more example of why people shouldn’t get their scientific information from movies or online videos. Viewers should not accept any claim in a movie without fact-checking it for themselves.
Addendum
Apparently the movie and I were both too harsh in our criticism of Ancel Keys. There is a white paper on his Seven Countries Study that critiques the published critiques of his study and tries to set the record straight. I continue to think that the seven countries were not a properly representative sample, but I don’t think Keys lied or was guilty of any misconduct. My real point was that his epidemiological data did not justify the widespread low-fat dietary recommendations that were based on it.
I linked to the PURE study to support my statement that a low carb diet had been shown to be healthier than a low fat diet. The PURE study did show that, but it was imperfect and its results far from definitive. The point I intended to make was that the dangers of dietary fat have been exaggerated and it is generally accepted today that a healthy diet need not be low-fat.
I said there were two sides to the Vioxx story, and there were. I did not say which side I thought was correct. I do think there are nuances to the story that are often overlooked.
I realize the reference to tabasco in the transcript as a cause of heart disease was a typo for tobacco, but I left it in because it tickled my fancy.

Fake News About Margarine
An alarmist email is circulating with misinformation about margarine. A little fact-checking shows that both margarine and butter can be part of a healthy diet.
Harriet Hall on January 23, 2018
Link


One of those alarmist emails has been circulating with fake news about margarine. A friend sent it to me and asked if there was any truth in it. There is a little bit, but not much! It is horribly misleading, and has even been debunked by Snopes. I’ll go over the email’s claims one by one.
The claims
Margarine was originally manufactured to fatten turkeys
    • When it killed the turkeys, the people who had put all the money into the research wanted a payback so they put their heads together to figure out what to do with this product to get their money back. It was a white substance with no food appeal so they added the yellow coloring and sold it to people to use in place of butter.
Nonsense! It absolutely was not manufactured to fatten turkeys. It was invented in France in 1869 in response to Napoleon III’s offer of a prize to anyone who could produce a viable, low cost substitute for butter, intended for use by the army and the lower classes. Hippolyte Mège Mouriès concocted a mixture of beef fat, salt water, milk, and margaric acid. He called it oleomargarine. The beef fat was eventually replaced by vegetable oils. Butter is made from the butterfat in milk; modern margarine is made from refined vegetable oil and water, and may contain milk.
It was originally marketed without yellow coloring, and people readily bought the white version. I remember an incident from my childhood. I ate dinner at a friend’s house where they served a “white butter.” I was impressed by the novelty, and I thought it tasted better than yellow butter. I went home and asked my Mom to buy it!
At one point, they sold the white version along with a package of food coloring that could be mixed with it to make it look more like butter. Eventually they began doing the mixing themselves prior to marketing.
I can’t imagine where the claim about killing turkeys came from. That appears to be pure fantasy.
Both have the same amount of caloriesYep! 100 calories per tablespoon for both butter and margarine. You can also buy “light butter” and margarine with 50 calories per tablespoon each.
Butter is slightly higher in saturated fats at 8 grams; compared to 5 grams for margarineWrong on both counts. Butter contains 7 grams of saturated fat per tablespoonful. Margarine’s fat content varies by brand: I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter Light contains 1 gram; most other brands contain 1.5 grams. Snopes provides a table comparing various brands.
Eating margarine can increase heart disease in women by 53% over eating the same amount of butterThey say this was according to a “recent Harvard Medical Study.” I couldn’t find any such study. I did find a 1997 epidemiologic study suggesting that trans fats in margarine might slightly increase the risk of heart disease in men. A large prospective 2017 study subsequently found that substituting soft tub margarine for stick margarine or butter may be associated with a lower risk of heart attack.
The dietary advice about fats and heart disease has evolved over time. At first the concern was about cholesterol, which is present in butter but not margarine. (Two brands of margarine (Take Control and Benecol) not only contain no cholesterol but block the absorption of cholesterol.) Then hydrogenated oils in margarine became a cause for concern. Gradually the emphasis changed from cholesterol to total fats, then to saturated fats, and eventually trans fats were identified as the worst offender.
The chart on the Snopes website shows that the total fat in butter is 11 grams per tablespoonful compared to 5-10 grams for various brands of margarine. Butter contains no polyunsaturated fats; margarine contains between 2.5-4.5 grams. Butter contains no monounsaturated fats; margarine contains 1.5-4.5 grams. Current standard dietary advice is to choose a margarine with no trans fats and the least amount of saturated fat.
Eating butter increases the absorption of many other nutrients in other foodsWhere did this claim come from? I found no evidence to support it. Perhaps they were thinking about the fact that some vitamins are fat-soluble, but that would apply to margarine as well as to butter.
Butter has many nutritional benefits where margarine has a few and only because they are added!Butter does have more vitamin content than margarine, but the difference would be negligible for most people eating a varied diet.
Butter tastes much better than margarine and it can enhance the flavors of other foodsMost people think that butter tastes better, but they can’t always tell the difference, especially when it is combined with other food or used in baking.
Butter has been around for centuries where margarine has been around for less than 100 yearsWhat kind of math is that? I count well over a hundred years from 1869 to 2018.
Margarine is very high in trans fatty acidsMany brands contain no trans fats at all, especially the liquid and tub margarines.
Margarine triples risk of coronary heart diseaseThere is no evidence for this claim. As I mentioned above, it may actually decrease the risk.
Margarine increases total and bad cholesterol while lowering good cholesterolMargarine will only increase total and LDL (bad) cholesterol if it is high in saturated fats. And butter is higher in saturated fats than margarine. Anyway, the impact of diet on LDL and HDL (good cholesterol) levels is small.
Margarine increases the risk of cancers up to five timesNo, it doesn’t! There isn’t a shred of evidence for that claim.
Margarine lowers quality of breast milkTrans fats, maybe. Not the margarines that don’t contain trans fats.
Margarine decreases immune response and decreases insulin responseTrans fats may do that. Margarines that don’t contain trans fats don’t do that.
Margarine is but ONE MOLECULE away from being PLASTIC and shares 27 ingredients with PAINTThis is absurd and was obviously made up by someone with no understanding of chemistry. It doesn’t even make sense. Margarine contains several different molecules. Plastics are polymers and completely unrelated to anything in margarine. Paint doesn’t contain any of the ingredients in margarine. I can’t even imagine where this claim came from unless perhaps some ignoramus confused the quality of plasticity with the molecular composition of plastics.
If they were thinking of atoms rather than molecules, that’s even worse. Water (H2O) and hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) only differ by one atom, but drinking water is necessary for life while drinking hydrogen peroxide is a very bad idea. The properties of molecules have little to do with their chemical composition.
Would you melt your Tupperware and spread that on your toast?Good grief, no! What a ridiculous analogy! But I would spread my toast with margarine.
Margarine does not rot or attract flies because it has no nutritional valueYou wanna bet? Margarine has nutritional value. It is food, like butter is food. I can’t believe that flies would reject it. You can do your own experiment.
Conclusion: both butter and margarine are OK
There’s no need to avoid either, although there are reasons to use them in moderation. I use both. I buy a tub margarine that has half the calories of butter, only 1.5 grams of saturated fat per tablespoon, and no trans fats. It is convenient and spreadable, and I can justify using more of it than I would of butter, since it has half the calories. I also buy butter and use it for situations where I think I might be able to taste a difference; I only spread it on my toast when I have remembered to take the butter out of the refrigerator and let it warm up to where it is spreadable.
The lesson to be learned: information in alarmist emails is likely to be fake news, or what Kellyanne Conway might call “alternative facts.” The information must be verified elsewhere. At the very least, do your friends the courtesy of checking Snopes.com before you forward the email to them.
Just for fun, here’s another use of margarine:

Most Patients Get No Benefit from Most Drugs
Some people are reluctant to take statins because they don’t benefit the majority of patients who take them. Actually, most drugs don’t benefit most of the patients who take them. Since we have no way of identifying those who will benefit, we are stuck treating the many to benefit the few.
Harriet Hall on July 18, 2017
Link


I recently wrote an article about statin denialism for Skeptical Inquirer. I showed that there is compelling evidence that statins reduce the incidence of heart attacks when prescribed for patients with existing disease or at high risk. I addressed some of the ridiculous claims from denialists who reject the evidence and demonize statins. They say the evidence was 100% fabricated, and statins are worthless. They claim that nearly half of patients experience devastating side effects (but strangely these don’t show up in controlled studies!). They even resort to nonsense like the claim that table salt is 1/3 glass and 1/3 sand, and the glass particles are cutting the linings of our arteries and making them bleed!
I received an inquiry from a reader who was prescribed statins appropriately, for existing cardiovascular disease, but was one of the few unlucky patients who have to stop the drugs because of intolerable side effects. He sent me an article from New Scientist that made him question the effectiveness of statins and the incidence of side effects. It was not a scientific study, but a “cover story” by Michael Brooks, a journalist with a PhD in quantum physics. The article is built around his personal experience; he stopped taking statins because of muscle pain but is planning to try a different statin. He is not anti-statin. He concludes, “But I certainly won’t see them as the cure-all I once did.” That’s something of a straw man; no one should ever have seen them as a cure-all.
The part that shocked my correspondent was that Brooks’ claim that 96% of patients with existing heart disease and 98% of those without heart disease got no benefit from statins. Why would anyone want to take a drug that is so unlikely to help them? In the first place, those numbers are misleading (see below); and in the second place, most patients get no benefit from most drugs. That’s an important and often-misunderstood fact; I’ll get back to it shortly, but first let’s take a closer look at the New Scientist article.
The “Cholesterol Wars” article
The author says he was “vaguely aware” of a backlash against statins and against the role of cholesterol in heart disease. He set out to do his own investigation. It is difficult for someone with no background in the field to master all the data and the issues involved, and I think he was misled by some of what he found in his research. He cites the 1913 Russian experiment where rabbits were fed a high-cholesterol diet and developed atherosclerosis; but he doesn’t point out that animal research is problematic and doesn’t always translate to human conclusions. In fact, over a century later, no research has found that humans respond to a high cholesterol diet in the same way as those Russian rabbits.
His analysis is fairly well balanced overall. He points out that many factors beyond blood cholesterol determine how healthy your heart is. That’s common knowledge, and the statin treatment guidelines emphasize the importance of lifestyle factors like exercise, smoking cessation, and weight control. These should be tried before resorting to statins and should be continued during statin treatment.
He quotes Uffe Ravnskov, notorious cholesterol skeptic, who calls the cholesterol campaign “the greatest medical scandal in modern times.” Ravnskov claims there is no link between cholesterol and atherosclerosis. He is demonstrably wrong. To be fair, Brooks also quotes an expert who says those who deny a link are talking complete nonsense.
Brooks accurately reports the evidence showing that statins indisputably save lives for patients with existing heart disease, and to a lesser extent, for those without existing disease who are high-risk. Even if they don’t live longer, they are less likely to have non-fatal heart attacks.
He discusses the differing estimates of muscle pain side effects: a systematic review found that less than one percent were affected, but many estimates are much higher. Real-world patients report a higher incidence of muscle side effects than the patients in clinical trials. This bothers me. I suspect the true incidence is higher than one percent, but unsolicited self-reports from patients on statins are meaningless without a control group for comparison. Better-designed large long-term controlled studies will be needed to pin down the true incidence. At any rate, the incidence of side effects is not high, and even the most serious complication, rhabdomyolysis, can usually be reversed by stopping the drug.
He acknowledges that concerns about statins causing diabetes are less solid, and may be an artefact of the way we define diabetes.
He agrees that patients with existing disease should take statins, but he says it’s far from obvious that the rest of us should. Lumping patients without existing disease into “the rest of us” is misleading. No reputable authority is recommending statins for everyone, or for low risk patients; and the benefits of statins vary widely with the individual patient’s risk factors. Some patients at low risk should not take statins; many patients at high risk should, and the greater the risk, the greater the benefit.
His major problem with statins is that most patients will not benefit, and we can’t predict which ones will, so it’s like a lottery. But that’s true of all medicines.
Most patients don’t benefit from most drugs
Yes, you read that right! Most patients don’t benefit from most drugs. This can be expressed as the NNT, the number needed to treat for one person to benefit. I don’t know where Brooks got his “no benefit for 98% and 96%” statistics, but that would translate to NNTs of 50 and 25, respectively. There is a website where you can look up the NNT for various treatments. According to that website, 60 people without heart disease have to be treated with statins for 5 years to prevent one heart attack. For people who already have heart disease, the NNT to prevent one non-fatal heart attack is 39, and the NNT to save one life is 83, even worse than what Brooks said. But looking at the numbers this way is misleading because it is based on averages. If someone has fewer risk factors than average, the NNT will be larger; and if a patient has many risk factors, the NNT will be smaller.
There is a convenient decision aid available online from the Mayo Clinic. In my Skeptical Inquirer article, I showed the following results for a hypothetical patient: a middle-aged man with several risk factors. The left panel shows what can be expected for 100 patients with a similar risk profile: without treatment, 28 will have a heart attack and 72 will not. The right panel shows that with statin treatment, only 17 will have a heart attack, and 11 people will be spared a heart attack because of the treatment. In this case, 100 patients are treated to prevent 11 heart attacks, for an NNT of 9.
Just for kicks, I went back to the decision aid and put in the numbers for a really high-risk hypothetical man, and got an NNT of 4. And I put in the numbers for a hypothetical young woman with no risk factors at all, and it showed that there would be no benefit at all; it would be useless for her to take statins.
Some of these NNTs may seem alarming high to you, but let’s put them into perspective with some other common medical treatments addressed on the NNT website:
    • Blood pressure medications for 5 years:
        ◦ NNT to prevent one death: 125
        ◦ NNT to prevent one stroke: 67
        ◦ NNT to prevent one heart attack: 100
    • Antibiotics for sinusitis: NNT 18
    • Antibiotics to prevent infection with a broken bone that pierces the skin: NNT 16
    • Defibrillation for cardiac arrest: NNT 2.5
    • Warfarin for 1.5 years in patients with atrial fibrillation: NNT 25 to prevent one stroke, NNT 42 to prevent one death from any cause
    • CT lung cancer screening in high-risk smokers: NNT 217 to prevent one death
    • Aspirin daily for one year
        ◦ For healthy people: NNT to prevent one stroke or heart attack: 1,667
        ◦ For people with a prior heart attack: NNT 77 to prevent one heart attack, 200 to prevent one stroke
For many conditions, no benefit was found:
    • Antibiotics for acute ear infection
    • Antibiotics for acute bronchitis
    • Antibiotics for animal bites
    • Antivirals to prevent post-herpetic neuralgia
    • Epidural steroids for sciatica
    • PSA test
    • Screening mammogram
    • Biphosphonates to prevent fracture in post-menopausal women
You may find some of these hard to accept; but for each, the NNT website provides a detailed, nuanced discussion and shows where the numbers come from.
I tried to think of a treatment that consistently benefited everyone.
    • Penicillin for syphilis? Nope; I found a reported treatment failure rate of 22%
    • Insulin for type 1 diabetes? I couldn’t find an NNT. These patients will die without insulin, but some patients die even with treatment.
NNT isn’t everything
There are other considerations:
    • NNT only reflects binary outcomes; not continuous ones (i.e. survival vs. death from high blood pressure rather than how much BP is lowered).
    • Most therapies impact more than one outcome
    • The calculations are time-dependent
    • Benefits will vary with baseline risk
    • The NNH (number needed to harm) must be taken into consideration
    • Patients’ values must be considered when deciding whether to treat
    • Individual patients seen in a doctor’s office may differ from study populations
    • The acceptability of an NNT depends on a lot of factors. “A number needed to treat of 100 may be acceptable for a drug that is cheap, easy to take and has few side effects; however, a number needed to treat of 5 may be too high for an expensive drug that carries substantial potential toxicities.”
Doctors tend not to think about NNT
Most patients do not benefit from most drugs. Doctors know this, but that doesn’t stop them from prescribing. Some patients do benefit from most drugs; after all, pharmaceuticals have to demonstrate benefit before the FDA will approve them for marketing. Doctors tend not to think in terms of NNT. They think in terms of who will benefit, not in terms of who won’t. They have to act without having all the information. There is no way of knowing which patients will benefit, so we are stuck treating the many to benefit the few. Brooks compares it to entering a lottery, but I prefer to compare it to deciding whether to buy insurance. Most of us pay for fire insurance for our homes, but not many houses burn down. We willingly pay premiums that may never benefit us because the cost of an uninsured disaster is so great.
The placebo factor
An argument can be made for de-emphasizing the NNT and letting patients believe the treatment will work for them. Perhaps this is one of the places where doctors could take advantage of the placebo response by giving patients higher expectations. As we have pointed out many times, prescribing inert placebos is unethical; but trying to maximize the contextual effects of the therapeutic encounter for an effective treatment is not.
Conclusion: Not a problem
In short, while the figures presented in Brooks’ article for “no benefit from statins” may sound alarming, they should not be. Most patients do not benefit from most drugs, and the numbers for statins are well within the range of the numbers for many other standard drugs. Perhaps someday genomic analysis or other advances may help us predict which patients will benefit; but until then, we are stuck treating the many to help the few. But that doesn’t mean we should treat indiscriminately or add statins to the drinking water. We know enough to prescribe statins selectively based on risk analyses like the Mayo Clinic decision aids. Still a lottery, but we can improve the odds.

MEAT

Skeptical of the Carnivore Diet
The carnivore diet is the latest fad diet that is particularly pseudoscientific.
Steven Novella on April 19, 2023
Link

Humans are clearly omnivores. There are multiple lines of evidence to support this conclusion. And regardless of what our ancestors ate, we now have decades of research into diet and health that supports a fairly simple conclusion – eat a varied diet, eat plenty of fruits of vegetables, don’t overconsume calories, and everything in moderation. For most healthy people, if you follow this basic guidance you will be most of the way to having a reasonably optimal diet in terms of health. There are tweaks for people with medical conditions, like diabetes. If you want to squeeze out some additional optimization, the evidence generally points to a so-called Mediterranean diet as close to optimal – lots of fruits, vegetables, nuts, legumes, fish, some meat, and heart healthy fats (like olive oil).
There, in one paragraph I just summarized what most people need to know about diet. But there is an entire self-help industry worth an estimated $71 billion around giving fad diet advice and selling dieting products. That is a lot of incentive to sell nonsense.
General common sense advice is also not enough for some. Psychologically there can be a desire to focus obsessively about the details of one’s diet, or the belief that extreme diets are somehow healthier than diverse ones. In the extreme this condition is termed orthorexia nervosa, and is considered an actual disorder. This is likely a largely manufactured condition, meaning it was created by the diet industry, constantly obsessing over “good” foods and “bad” foods. This is embedded in the self-help industry general approach to life which is to find a “hack” or one “crazy trick” to solve complex problems. 
The Carnivore Diet
There are countless diet fads, all worthless, and the latest iteration if perhaps the carnivore diet. As the name implies, this is a typical diet fad in that it takes the good and bad food approach. Meat is good, eat only meat. Plants are poison, avoid them at all costs. Doing this will magically cure all disease (slight exaggeration for effect).
Before we get into the theoretical problems with this diet, we should note that there is no clinical evidence that an all meat diet is not harmful, let alone that it is healthy or has any advantages. Proponents mainly cite anecdote and testimonials. There are not studies on the long term effects. Short term studies that exist are basically worthless, because almost all diet studies show short term weight loss because subjects are on a diet. Long term outcomes are all that matter anyway.
A quick PubMed search did not come up with anything, in humans, anyway. There are a lot of studies in actual carnivores (cats and dogs), but not people, because people are not carnivores.
This is a complex area of research to summarize quickly, but what decades of research has shown overall is that, while meat in the diet is healthy, there are increased health risks to high levels of meat in the diet. Further, there are health benefits to eating plants and fiber.
One good point that critics of the carnivore diet raise is that meat does not contain vitamin C. Humans cannot synthesize vitamin C and have to get it from our diet, and in fact this has been true for millions of years with our direct ancestors. A diet that is missing a critical nutritional element cannot be optimal. Also, if an all-meat diet were optimal evolution would have taken care of the vitamin C issue a long time ago. So this is both evidence that our ancestors consumed plants and that an all-meat diet is unhealthy.
One of the silliest arguments for the all-meat diet is put forward by Carnivore MD, who argues that plants are poisonous, therefore we should not eat plants. He starts with a kernel of a fact, but then completely goes off the rails. Yes, many plants evolved to produce toxic substances to keep from being eaten by animals. But you can’t stop there.
Obviously, the world is also full of herbivores, of animals that survive by eating plants. So animals have clearly evolved to tolerate those toxins, or else the carnivores would have nothing to eat. Also, not all plants use that strategy. Estimates are that about half the plants in the world are edible by humans. That doesn’t mean you would want to eat them, but they are technically edible. We can digest them and deal with any toxins.
Evolution goes both ways. It is better to think of this situation as evolutionary warfare – plants evolve defenses and animals evolve ways around those defenses.
Further still, some plants – fruiting plants – evolved a strategy of producing yummy and nutritious plant flesh to help disperse and germinate their seeds. They bribe animals with good food to provide this service. This breaks the logic that plants don’t want to be eaten. Sometimes they do.
The argument also ignores the fact that humans have cultivates almost all plants that we consume, over thousands of years, specifically to be less toxic. Plant toxins are bitter for a reason, so that we can detect potential harmful substances and avoid them. We cultivated our plants to be less bitter, which translates into them having less plant toxins. This actually makes our crop more vulnerable, because we bred their natural defenses out of them.
The evolutionary argument, therefore, does not even apply to almost all plants that we eat. It doesn’t apply to fruits, and it doesn’t apply to cultivated crops – so basically it doesn’t apply to the human diet.
Conclusion
The carnivore diet is just another diet fad focusing on eliminating allegedly bad food categories and restricting diet to only good food categories. The theoretical justification for this approach is highly flawed, and there is no empirical evidence to support it. Further, there are multiple lines of evidence that restricting one’s diet to only meat and eggs is a bad thing for health.
There is also another layer to the carnivore diet fad. If such a diet were widely adopted it would be entirely unsustainable. The feed conversion ratio for beef, the meat most recommended by proponents, is anywhere from 6x to 25x. So even if we take the most favorable number, the world would have to grow about six times as many calories as it does now in order to convert all those calories to beef for people to eat. This is far beyond the world’s capacity, especially for land and water use.
Inherent, therefore, in the carnivore diet is that this is a diet for select elites. Everyone else can eat plants. This adds an unsavory aspect to what is already a pseudoscientific and harmful fad.

   Meat and Weight Contol
Steven Novella
Link
A new study published in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition is reporting an association with eating meat and weight gain. This is a fairly robust epidemiological study, but at the same time is a good example of how such information is poorly reported in the media, leading to public confusion.
The data is taken from the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition–Physical Activity, Nutrition, Alcohol, Cessation of Smoking, Eating Out of Home and Obesity (EPIC-PANACEA) project. This is a long term epidemiological study involving hundreds of thousands of individuals, and is therefore a great source of data. We are likely to see many publications from from it. This one looked at the association of meat eating – poultry, red meat, and processed meat – with total weight. From the methods:
A total of 103,455 men and 270,348 women aged 25–70 y were recruited between 1992 and 2000 in 10 European countries. Diet was assessed at baseline with the use of country-specific validated questionnaires. A dietary calibration study was conducted in a representative subsample of the cohort. Weight and height were measured at baseline and self-reported at follow-up in most centers. Associations between energy from meat (kcal/d) and annual weight change (g/y) were assessed with the use of linear mixed models, controlled for age, sex, total energy intake, physical activity, dietary patterns, and other potential confounders.
They found that an increase in 240 grams per day of meat in the diet was associated with a 2kg increased weight after 5 years (that’s about 5 pounds, or 1 pound per year). The BBC reported this study as finding:
A European study of almost 400,000 adults found that eating meat was linked with weight gain, even in people taking in the same number of calories.
and
Although it is not clear why meat would lead to weight gain in people eating the same number of calories, one theory is that energy-dense foods like meat alter how the body regulates appetite control.
I find that conclusion problematic in several ways. Let’s look at the study design. One primary weakness is that weight (after the initial weighing) was self reported in most centers. This is a odd study design, and I can only assume this was a matter of practicality. Regardless of reason, self-reported weight is a major weakness. However it pales in comparison to the fact that total caloric intake was estimated, not rigorously controlled. To put this into perspective, 1 pound per year is 3500 Calories, or 67 Calories per week on average. There is no way someone can estimate their caloric intake within 67 Calories per week – that’s less than 10 calories per day.
The notion that appetite control was responsible for the findings also contradicts the assertion that total caloric intake was the same – appetite can only affect weight by increasing caloric intake. The correlation itself is in question because of the self-reported weight. But if we take the correlation as a given, the easiest explanation is that people who consume more meat also tend to consume slightly more calories, which add up over the years. Another possibility is that increased consumption of meat might also correlate with slightly less physical activity.
Assigning a cause and effect is difficult because slight changes that are difficult to measure accurately can result in modest weight differences over years.
Also, the authors concluded:
Our results suggest that a decrease in meat consumption may improve weight management.
“Suggest” and “may” are appropriate in that statement, but were largely lost in the secondary reporting. Again – even if we take the correlation as a given, this kind of data cannot be used to assign cause and effect. It cannot be concluded, in other words, that reducing meat will help reduce weight. Perhaps people who are more hungry for other reasons consume more meat, and if they cut down on their meat consumption they will just replace those calories with other sources. Other studies show that it is the consumption of calorie dense foods that correlate with weight gain, which can either be high fat and protein or high sugar. Calorie density seems to be the common element – which makes sense as increased calorie density can easily lead to overeating total calories, and it only takes a small amount to result in the kind of weight differences typically reported by these studies.
What we don’t have is evidence that decreasing meat intake as an intervention aids in weight control.
Conclusion
This study is interesting, but ultimately does not add much to our knowledge of diet and weight. It is not evidence that diets with the same calories but of different types lead to different weight outcomes, as has been reported. It does add to the literature that suggests that calorie dense foods correlate with weight gain, and this is likely due to increased overall caloric intake. There may be other factors as well, such as total activity, effects on hunger, and even calorie efficiency – how efficiently our bodies extract calories from certain foods.
But I am also struck in such studies, even intervention studies, by how small the difference are among the various diet types. This leads me to the conclusion that varying the ratios of macronutients (protein, carbohydrates, and fats) is of little ultimate utility in weight control. These studies get much attention in the media, but it is often much ado about nothing.
Meanwhile, the more significant factors are basic things like portion control and regular exercise. For health reasons other than weight control eating more vegetables is also a good idea, and this is also a good way to reduce total caloric intake.

   Red Meat: Is It Hazardous to Health?
Harriet Hall
Link
Red meat consumption has been linked to diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and several types of cancer (breast, colorectal, stomach, bladder, prostate, and lymphoma). There are plausible mechanisms: meat is a source of carcinogens, iron that may increase oxidative damage, and saturated fat. But correlation and plausibility are not enough to establish causation. Is red meat really dangerous? If so, how great is the risk? A couple of recent studies have tried to shed light on these questions, but they have raised more questions than they have answered.
A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
A new study in Circulation, “Red and Processed Meat Consumption and Risk of Incident Coronary Heart Disease, Stroke, and Diabetes Mellitus. A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis,” by Micha, Wallace and Mozaffarian, is a systematic review of the literature. It analyzed 17 prospective cohort studies and 3 case-control studies, with a total of 1.2 million subjects. As far as I can judge, it appears to be a well-done systematic review with excellent methodology and multiple precautions. They even looked for things like publication bias (which they did not find).
They found that the consumption of processed meats, but not red meats, is associated with a higher incidence of coronary heart disease and diabetes. (Processed meats include bacon, sausage, ham, hot dogs, salami, luncheon meat and other cured meats.) The increased risk per 50 gram serving of processed meats per day was 42% for heart disease and 19% for diabetes. Unprocessed red meats were not associated with CHD and were associated with a nonsignificant trend towards higher risk of diabetes. They found no association with stroke, but this was based only on 3 studies.
They commented that
“…each of these individual studies has potential limitations, and our findings should be interpreted in that context. On the other hand, this represents the most complete worldwide evidence to date of the potential effects of red and processed meat consumption on incidence of CHD, stroke, and diabetes mellitus.”
A Large Study of Meat and Mortality
A 2009 study in the Archives of Internal Medicine, “Meat intake and mortality: a prospective study of over half a million people,” by Sinha et al., was more comprehensive in that it looked at many different conditions like cancer and cardiovascular disease, and it measured various causes of mortality as well as all-cause mortality.
The half a million subjects were 51-70 years old and were from various geographic locations in the US. They filled out a questionnaire that asked about their usual consumption of foods and drinks and portion sizes over the previous twelve months. Their diets were classified as high, medium or low risk meat diets based on the amount of red meat and white meat adjusted for energy, and they were split into two groups using median consumption as cutpoints. The study was prospective: it assessed diet first and then followed subjects for 10 years and recorded deaths and causes of death.
It concluded that red and processed meat intakes were associated with modest increases in total mortality, cancer mortality and CVD mortality.
In general, those in the highest quintile of red meat intake tended to consume a slightly lower amount of white meat, but a higher amount of processed meat than those in the lowest quintile. Subjects who consumed more red meat tended to be married, more likely to be of non-Hispanic white ethnicity, more likely to be a current smoker, have a higher body mass index, and a higher daily intake of energy, total fat and saturated fat; whereas they tended to have a lower education level, were less physically active and consumed less fruits, vegetables, fiber and vitamin supplements.
They found an increased risk associated with accidental deaths with higher consumption of red meat in men but not in women. It’s hard to know how to interpret that. They found an inverse association for white meat intake: it appeared protective against total mortality, but there was a small increase in risk for CVD mortality in men.
The overall hazard ratios for men ranged from 1.06 to 1.31 for red meat (increasing steadily by quintile of meat intake), .90 to.92 for white meat, and 1.01 to 1.16 for processed meats. The effect of red meat was greater than the effect of processed meats, which was opposite to the findings of the review in Circulation.
They tried to correct for confounders. In the process, they found an increased risk with white meat consumption among never-smokers and commented that the reason was not readily apparent. I suspect that the reason was that if you look at a large enough number of subgroups you can always find an occasional chance correlation that is meaningless.
Their data also showed that increased red meat consumption was correlated to smoking, lack of exercise, higher total calorie intake, higher body weight, higher total fat and saturated fat intake, lower intake of fruits, vegetables and fiber, and lower use of vitamin supplements. Could it be this constellation of factors, rather than red meat itself, that leads to higher mortality?
They estimated that
For overall mortality … 11% of deaths in men and 16% of deaths in women could be prevented if people decreased their red meat consumption to the level of intake in the first quintile.
I don’t think this can be determined from the data. They haven’t reliably ruled out all possible confounding factors and they don’t have any direct evidence that taking people with a high red meat intake and reducing their intake improves their longevity.
What about Vegetarians?
A recent study comparing vegetarians to non-vegetarians found that
…in comparison with regular meat eaters, mortality from ischemic heart disease was 20% lower in occasional meat eaters, 34% lower in people who ate fish but not meat, 34% lower in lactoovovegetarians, and 26% lower in vegans. There were no significant differences between vegetarians and nonvegetarians in mortality from cerebrovascular disease, stomach cancer, colorectal cancer, lung cancer, breast cancer, prostate cancer, or all other causes combined.
Meta-analysis of several prospective studies showed no significant differences in the mortality caused by colorectal, stomach, lung, prostate or breast cancers and stroke between vegetarians and “health-conscious” nonvegetarians.
In vegetarians, a decrease of ischemic heart disease mortality was observed probably due to lower total serum cholesterol levels, lower prevalence of obesity and higher consumption of antioxidants. Very probably, an ample consumption of fruits and vegetables and not the exclusion of meat make vegetarians healthful.
Conclusion
Epidemiologic studies based on self-reporting and recall are not the most reliable form of evidence. What are we to make of all the confusing data? The evidence is far from conclusive, but it suggests that it would be wise to limit our consumption of red meat. The evidence is not strong enough to support recommendations that we give up red meat entirely or become vegetarians.
Aristotle said “Moderation in all things.” Mom said “Eat your vegetables.” They were both right.

Is Meat Poison? Is Fat the Antidote?
Is a diet comprised solely of meat good for you? I think you know the answer.
Harriet Hall on December 13, 2022
Link

I have been watching the National Geographic series of documentaries Life Below Zero, which features individuals who live (often alone) in harsh conditions in the Alaskan wilderness. They are self-sufficient, providing their own water, heat, shelter, and food. They harvest their own food by hunting, fishing, and trapping animals. One of them announced that meat is poison and recommended a diet of 70% fat. I questioned that but learned that he was probably right when it came to his own lifestyle in a sub-zero environment. But it can’t be extrapolated to apply to everyone.
Protein poisoning is a real thing. Also known as rabbit starvation syndrome, mal de caribou, and fat starvation, Wikipedia defines it as an acute form of malnutrition caused by a diet deficient in fat and carbohydrates, where almost all calories consumed come from the protein in lean meat.
Rabbits have very lean meat. Eating only rabbit meat can lead to “rabbit starvation” and death. Groups like the Inuit eat mostly animal products, but they get fats from blubber, bone marrow, organ meats, and the meat of animals that have considerable fat. For the Inuit, seal oil is a dietary staple, used as a dipping sauce. Subsistence hunters in the documentary series are shown eating some of their favorite parts of meat raw at the kill site. Raw meat is a good source of vitamin C, but cooking or drying meat destroys vitamin C.
The carnivore diet
There are many popular fad diets. One is the Carnivore Diet. “It aims for zero carbs per day. You eat only meat, fish, eggs and some animal products; you exclude all other food groups — including vegetables, fruits, grains, legumes, nuts and seeds.” Carnivore diet macronutrients call for 70-80% of calories from animal fat.One advocate says “animal fat is likely the single healthiest and most beneficial nutrient in the human diet.” He describes the results of two large published studies that showed remarkable benefits. Subjects lost an average of 20 pounds, 96% had full resolution or significant improvement in all diseases, 92% of diabetics were able to stop using insulin, 93% had improvement in mental health disorders, and more.
Yes, studies have shown that the carnivore diet can significantly improve and even resolve numerous diseases, reduce medication use, improve gastrointestinal conditions, boost mental health, clear up skin conditions, reduce blood sugar fluctuations, and promote weight loss. But it can also cause harm. It is low in fiber and can cause side effects like constipation, diarrhea, nausea, hunger, sugar cravings, leg cramps, bad breath, and heart palpitations. Meat contains things that we know are bad for our health, like saturated fats and the high sodium levels in processed meats like bacon.
All carbs are not equal. Simple carbs (desserts, cakes, pies, etc.) often contain white sugar, flour, and preservatives They can cause inflammation and weight gain and contribute to diabetes, obesity, and high blood pressure. But complex carbs (fruits, vegetables, and whole grains) contain vitamins and minerals and micronutrients that are essential to health.
High protein diets … advocate excessive levels of protein intake on the order of 200 to 400 g/d … which may exceed the liver’s capacity to convert excess nitrogen to urea. Dangers of excessive protein, defined as when protein constitutes > 35% of total energy intake, include hyperaminoacidemia, hyperammonemia, hyperinsulinemia, nausea, diarrhea, and even death.
Protein intakes above 35% of energy needs have also been shown to decrease testosterone and increase cortisol levels.
Some people argue that humans should not eat meat at all, since they do not share the anatomic characteristics of carnivores.
Are humans herbivores or omnivores?
A related question is whether humans are omnivores or herbivores. I always assumed that it was obvious that we are omnivores. Vegans claim that we are anatomically herbivorous. We have short, soft fingernails rather than sharp claws. We are unable to kill animals with our bare hands and eat them raw. Our “canine” teeth are small. Our jaws move side to side and our back molars are flat, enabling us to grind fibrous plant foods. Our stomach acids are not as strong as those of carnivores. Our intestines are longer than those of carnivores, giving bacteria time to rot the meat, increasing the risk of food poisoning and colon cancer. T. Colin Campbell says “animal protein . . . is one of the most toxic nutrients of all that can be considered.”
On the other hand, “biological anthropologists would point out that the anatomy of our brains, teeth and intestines show that we evolved as highly resourceful and flexible omnivores who can adapt to many varied environments to meet our nutritional needs from both animals and plants.”We may be anatomically more similar to herbivores than to carnivores, but we are functionally omnivores. History shows that humans have thrived on a wide variety of diets.
Conclusion: the carnivore diet is not healthy
A lean-meat-only diet can kill through protein poisoning. Fats and carbs are essential to providing all the nutrients and energy we need. A balance of protein, fats, and carbs is ideal, and that’s exactly what standard diet advice recommends.

Study Correlates Red Meat Consumption and Type II Diabetes
Large study finds association of red meat consumption and type II diabetes – but the data needs to be put into perspective.
Steven Novella on October 25, 2023
Link

A recent study is one of the largest looking at the association of red meat consumption, both processed and unprocessed, and the risk of developing Type II diabetes (T2D). The study used data from the Nurses’ Health Study (NHS), NHS II, and Health Professionals Follow-up Study (HPFS), with over 5 million person-years of follow up, and 22,761 T2D cases. This is a powerful study, and adds to decades of research looking into any association between red meat consumption and negative health outcomes.
They found:
Comparing the highest to the lowest quintiles, hazard ratios (HR) were 1.62 (95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.53, 1.71) for total red meat, 1.51 (95% CI: 1.44, 1.58) for processed red meat, and 1.40 (95% CI: 1.33, 1.47) for unprocessed red meat.
And this is pretty much how this study has been reported in the media – that there is about a 50% increased risk of T2D with too much red meat consumption. But let’s delve a bit deeper into the data to put the risk into perspective. For example, it has been misreported in the media that:
A new study says eating just two servings of red meat weekly increases the risk of developing type 2 diabetes by 62%, reported Fox News Digital.
Incorrect – the 62% is the comparison between the highest and lowest consumers of red meat, eating red meat daily vs not at all. The risk decreased with lower red meat intake, disappearing at 1 serving per week, but at 2 servings per week the risk was small and uncertain. This is consistent with previous data showing that the risks of red meat consumption is only statistically robust when you get to daily consumption. 
A study published in 2022 looked at all the data regarding red meat consumption and disease risk published to date (so it did not include the current study) and found that they methods generally used tended to overestimate the risk. They took a “burden of proof” approach and found a wide range of uncertainty when it comes to the amount of red meat consumption that is healthy (zero measured risk). They found, for example, that the zero risk amount of red meat did include 0 g per day, but the error bars extended to 200 g per day. 
The bigger problem with this data, however, is that it is correlational only. It is not able, by itself, to demonstrate cause and effect. Of course, we are limited to observational data with risk factors such as diet. Large and long term controlled studies of dietary red meat are simply not feasible and we will likely never see them. Observational studies can also still be powerful, but we have to recognize their limitations. With the current study the researchers found:
“Of note, individuals who reported consuming red meat most frequently within each cohort were more likely to eat less fish (or) fruit and (more) calories, weigh more, and engage in less physical activity,” added Lichtenstein, who is also the director of Tuft University’s Cardiovascular Nutrition Laboratory. “This suggests they had poorer overall diet quality and were less likely to engage (in) healthy lifestyle behaviors.”
When controlling for body mass index, they found that explained half of the association with red meat consumption and risk of T2D. That does not mean, however, that red meat explains the other half. We still have the other factors listed above – consuming less fruit and fish and engaging in less physical activity. Perhaps these factors explain the other half.
I am also always very suspicious when I see such associations. If you are someone who eats red meat daily, does not eat much fruits or vegetables, and does not exercise – what other poor lifestyle habits might you have? The rule of thumb for observational studies is that it is very difficulty to identify and control for every possible confounding factor.
This is also why, in order to close the loop on cause and effect with observational studies finding only a correlation, we need evidence of a mechanism. How could red meat consumption cause T2D? What we have now is mostly speculation and preliminary data. The heme in red meat might stress the insulin producing cells of the pancreas. There may be various pro-inflammatory mechanisms of eating red meat. These are currently hypotheses to be explored, not conclusions. A recent systematic review looking at some of the possible mechanisms related to insulin and glycemic control found:
The results of this meta-analysis suggest red meat intake does not impact most glycemic and insulinemic risk factors for T2D.
Where does all of this leave us? Even though I think the data is far from certain, and the confounding factors of other lifestyle factors are likely dominant, it is reasonable to limit red meat, and especially process meat, consumption. This conclusion is based not only on the data but on the general principle that when it comes to diet, everything in moderation is a good approach. Plus, red meat consumption is associated with increased calorie consumption and BMI. Further, it is pretty well established that eating sufficient fruits and vegetables are key to an optimal diet – if you are eating red meat every day, you are probably not getting enough plant-based calories.
Even taking this data (and previous studies) at face value, eating one serving of red meat per week appears to be healthy. Eating red meat and especially processed meat every day probably isn’t. I don’t think this data is robust enough to establish exactly where the line is, however. For most people it is likely good advice to say – limit your red meat consumption to something less than every day, and make sure you eat enough plant calories. If you have a family history or other risk factors for T2D, you may want to limit red meat consumption more. Of course, addressing those other risk factors is also important, and may be more important.
I do think there is a risk to overstating the association between red meat and T2D as it may make some people think that they can do this one thing to mitigate their risk, rather than addressing all of their risk factors. Too much focus on red meat may also cause people to make unhealthy changes to their diet, by substituting in more high glycemic index foods like white carbohydrates. Demonizing individual foods, rather than emphasizing balance and moderation, may ultimately be counterproductive.

Cell-cultured meat: Earth’s savior or just a $600 burger?
Cell-cultured meat raises may issues, including safety, environmental impact, cost, and our current technology’s ability to manufacture it. Most importantly, when it finally hits the supermarket, will consumers buy it?
Jann Bellamy on June 4, 2020
Link

Since the present isn’t looking so peachy, today we distract ourselves with a peek into the future, where cell-cultured meat may help save the planet from environmental destruction and nourish the multitudes with safe, high-quality protein. Or maybe just feed us a $600 burger.
The U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) recently issued a report to Congress detailing the ways the GAO believes the “FDA and USDA Could Strengthen Existing Efforts to Prepare for Oversight of Cell-Cultured Meat“. We’ll leave the bureaucratic details of the GAO’s regulatory recommendations to those who like to study that sort of thing. Instead, we’ll take a look at the facts of, and opinions about, the current state of the cell-cultured meat industry, it’s uncertain potential, and unresolved issues (including safety and nutritional value), reported by the GAO after what appears to be a fairly exhaustive, 2-year information-collecting mission conducted in the service of making its recommendations.
No company is actually selling cell-cultured meat to the public yet, but there are about two dozen firms worldwide, 11 in the U.S., working to bring it to market. There are varying estimates as to when that might actually happen: some suggest as soon as this year, others say 2-4 years. Hence, the Fed’s efforts to try to figure out just how to regulate cell-cultured meat, including whether it should be called “meat” at all. So far, the FDA and USDA have preliminarily agreed that the FDA will oversee the early phases of growing cell-culture meat through the point of harvest (processes we’ll get to in a moment). During harvest, the FDA will transfer regulatory oversight to the USDA, which will assume regulatory control of cell-cultured meat through the food-processing phase (making cell-cultured meat into, say, a sausage or a fish stick), including labeling.
Making “meat”
Whatever the ultimate regulatory decision is on a name, for its purposes the GAO calls the product “cell-cultured meat” (so we will too), defined as
food derived from animal cells grown in an environment outside the animal. . . [C]ell-cultured seafood is a subcategory of cell-cultured meat.
According to the GAO, general information about the process of making cell-cultured meat is available, but specific information about the technology being used, eventual commercial production methods, and the final products are unknown, partly because companies fear competitors getting ahold of their trade secrets and partly because these processes are still in development.
Here’s what we do know, per the GAO. The general process of cell-cultured meat production, which sounds both scientifically fascinating and a bit dystopian, includes five phases:

Biopsy: Collecting rice-sized tissue samples from an animal following “specific laboratory sanitation procedures”, which may involve antibiotics. As best I can tell, the plan is to use slaughtered animals for biopsy, although that is not specifically stated.
Cell-banking: Biopsied cells “with the most desirable traits” are selected from existing cells for use either as is or in genetic engineering, either immediately or frozen for later use. “Desirable traits” can include reduced cholesterol or fat content or other nutritional traits, as well as those resilient to environmental factors like temperature. This phase gives producers an opportunity (according to them) to ensure that source cells are free of pathogens and other contaminants.
Growth: Cells are placed into a bioreactor to divide and differentiate in a growth medium that may include glucose, amino acids, hormones, and other growth factors. It also includes nutrients to “feed” the cells. Cells may require attachment to a structure to grow on, called a “scaffold”. (With no scientific background, “bioreactor” sounds to me like something from Star Trek.)
Harvest: Once a piece of cell-cultured meat reaches the desired size, it is harvested. If the scaffold is edible, the product can be left attached; otherwise it must be separated from the scaffold.
Food processing: The cell-cultured meat is prepared into a product “such as meatballs or chicken nuggets” or perhaps, as the technology becomes more sophisticated, chicken breasts or steak.
As they say, the proof is in the pudding, so I’ll withhold judgment until I’ve actually tasted cell-cultured meat, but at this point: Yuck!
The known unknowns
In an (ironically) chicken-and-egg situation, the FDA and the USDA are somewhat hamstrung by their lack of knowledge about cell-cultured meat manufacturing in deciding how to regulate the industry. On the other hand, the industry says it needs guidance from the agencies on how they intend to regulate in order to adapt their processes accordingly.
According to the GAO, many questions remain unanswered.
Tissue collection: Researchers don’t know enough to accurately estimate how much cell-cultured meat can be produced from a single biopsy of animal tissue. The Feds haven’t told industry what standards the animals will have to meet to be eligible for tissue biopsies. For example, will an animal meeting government standards for conventional processing be sufficient for tissue biopsy, or will there be additional, or altogether different, requirements?
Genetic engineering: The FDA and some industry reps say it’s “likely” that firms will use genetic engineering in production. Other industry reps told the GAO that they are undecided. Part of the problem is the lengthy wait for regulatory approval where genetic engineering is involved; genetically engineered salmon took approximately 20 years. This regulatory uncertainty, in turn, affects the ability to attract and retain investors.
Antibiotics: According to the Feds, use of antibiotics in commercial production and the potential for residues in the final product represents “a significant concern for food safety and public health”, although they felt antibiotics would not be used beyond the cell-banking phase. Industry reps differ on whether they’ll use antibiotics and some have not made a decision.
Growth medium: Although industry reps say they have not finalized the medium they will use in cell production, the ingredients used could affect the end product’s composition and raise safety concerns. The FDA, for example, says that it would likely do a premarket evaluation of some residual growth factors, like hormones.
Scaffold: If the scaffolding is edible, its composition may need to be evaluated for safety. Chemically separating the product from inedible scaffolding during production may also require a safety evaluation.
Production costs: Industry reps told the GAO that the “high production cost of cell-cultured meat is a key industry challenge”, the growth medium being one of the biggest cost drivers. One firm said it cost $600 to make a cell-cultured hamburger patty and some $1,200 to produce a single cell-cultured meatball.
Safety considerations: According to federal officials, “residues and constituents in harvested cell-cultured meat would be expected to be different from those in conventional meat, depending on the details of the production process” although no one yet knows whether any of this will pose hazards not present in conventional meat.
Product composition: Cell-cultured meat products, at least initially, won’t likely be composed entirely of cell-cultured meat. Instead, they will include binding, flavorings, and plant-based materials used in conventional foods. In fact, one firm’s prototype was 90% plant-based, although the aim is to “produce products that contain more cell-cultured meat than other ingredients” and, long term, produce something similar to conventional cuts of meat, like steaks.
Environmental, animal welfare, and health impacts: Some companies and researchers have made as-yet unsubstantiated claims that cell-cultured meat offers environmental, animal welfare, and health advantages over conventional meat. These include using less water and emitting less greenhouse gasses (although that certainly seems logical), eliminating animal slaughter (except those needed for biopsy), and providing fewer opportunities for contamination with foodborne pathogens.
Labeling: Industry is concerned that what you call cell-cultured meat can reflect bias for or against the product which, in turn, affects consumer response. For instance, would you likely buy “clean meat”? How about “lab-grown meat”? “In-vitro meat”? This has put conventional meat producers on the offense. In 2018, the U.S. Cattlemen’s Association petitioned the USDA to limit the terms “beef” to products “born, raised, and harvested in a traditional manner” and “meat” to “tissue or flesh of animals that have been harvested in the traditional manner”. (I suppose they didn’t want to use the terms “killed” or “slaughtered”, hence “harvested in the traditional manner”.) Although it has yet to respond to the petition, which received over 6,000 public comments, the USDA says it’s committed to a public process, likely rulemaking (which can take years), for developing labeling requirements. To confuse matters (as happened with “Right-to-Try” laws), some states are enacting their own requirements, Missouri, for example, prohibits both plant-based and cell-cultured products from being labeled as “meat”.
Consumer acceptance: Finally, according to the GAO, people it interviewed and studies it reviewed “cited consumer acceptance as a challenge for commercializing cell-cultured meat.”
        ◦ For my part, I will not be ordering the $600 hamburger. However, if and when a reasonably-priced cell-cultured meat product comes to market, I will sample it, but only with an appropriately matched wine.

The Red Meat Controversy
A new paper flies in the face of current recommendations and concludes we simply don’t know the health risks of eating red and processed meat.
Steven Novella on October 2, 2019
Link

We deal with a lot of fake controversies here, or “manufactroversies”, ones that are ginned up for political purposes, without a genuine underlying scientific controversy (like the safety of vaccines, for example). However, we also deal with some legitimate scientific controversies. These result when the existing scientific evidence is ambiguous enough that different bottom-line interpretations are reasonably defensible.
So here is another one – based on current evidence, what should our recommendations be regarding the consumption of red and processed meat? The evidence has been building over the last two decades that there is some possible risk from red (meat from a mammal) and processed (smoked, cured, salted) meat with regards to cardiovascular risk, cancer risk, and overall mortality. However, as we have discussed here previously, the evidence has always been weak.
This controversy has been flamed by a new study published in The Annals of Internal Medicine. The study is actually five parallel systematic reviews, four looking at health outcomes of eating red and processed meat, and one looking at people’s values regarding meat consumption. The paper is the result of a consortium put together for this purpose, with careful vetting to minimize conflicts of interests, and with a 14-person panel voting on final recommendations. They write:
These recommendations are, however, primarily based on observational studies that are at high risk for confounding and thus are limited in establishing causal inferences, nor do they report the absolute magnitude of any possible effects. Furthermore, the organizations that produce guidelines did not conduct or access rigorous systematic reviews of the evidence, were limited in addressing conflicts of interest, and did not explicitly address population values and preferences, raising questions regarding adherence to guideline standards for trustworthiness (5–9).A potential solution to the limitations of contemporary nutrition guidelines is for an independent group with clinical and nutritional content expertise and skilled in the methodology of systematic reviews and practice guidelines, methods that include careful management of conflicts of interest, to produce trustworthy recommendations based on the values and preferences of guideline users. We developed the Nutritional Recommendations (NutriRECS) (7) international consortium to produce rigorous evidence-based nutritional recommendations adhering to trustworthiness standards (10–12).
Based on their own reviews, they make the “weak” recommendation based on low to very low quality evidence (with a consensus of 11/14 of the panel) that people not change their current eating habits with respect to red and process meat. This is a different bottom-line interpretation of the same evidence as previous nutritional recommendations, which generally recommend reducing red and processed meat consumption. As a side note, the authors state that these recommendations are based entirely on health data, without consideration of environmental effects or ethical considerations regarding animal welfare.
The authors attribute the difference in recommendation to several factors. In general, they credit the thoroughness of their own review, with explicit consideration of the quality of evidence, conflicts of interest, and effect sizes. But here are the specific factors:
    • They weight randomized controlled trials higher than observational studies.
    • They give great consideration to the limited quality of the evidence overall.
    • They are not impressed with the small absolute effect sizes and the limited statistically significant outcome measures.
    • They err on the side of not recommending any change based on weak evidence, rather than asked people to change their lifestyle given the level of uncertainty.
    • They specifically consider the value system of people regarding eating meat and judge that, if people were fully informed regarding the absolute risk reduction and quality of the evidence, they would not think it is worth changing their eating habits.
For example, regarding unprocessed red meat, here is their summary of the evidence of harm:
Dose–response meta-analysis results from 23 cohort studies with 1.4 million participants provided low- to very low-certainty evidence that decreasing unprocessed red meat intake may result in a very small reduction in the risk for major cardiovascular outcomes (cardiovascular disease, stroke, and myocardial infarction) and type 2 diabetes (range, 1 fewer to 6 fewer events per 1000 persons with a decrease of 3 servings/wk), with no statistically significant differences in 2 additional outcomes (all-cause mortality and cardiovascular mortality) (16). Dose–response meta-analysis results from 17 cohorts with 2.2 million participants provided low-certainty evidence that decreasing unprocessed red meat intake may result in a very small reduction of overall lifetime cancer mortality (7 fewer events per 1000 persons with a decrease of 3 servings/wk), with no statistically significant differences for 8 additional cancer outcomes (prostate cancer mortality and the incidence of overall, breast, colorectal, esophageal, gastric, pancreatic, and prostate cancer) (13).
The risk reduction is very small, without any significant change in all-cause mortality.
It’s also important to note why the evidence is of low to very low quality. Most of the data is observational. A 2009 study nicely summarizes the confounding factors:
Subjects who consumed more red meat tended to be married, more likely to be of non-Hispanic white ethnicity, more likely to be a current smoker, have a higher body mass index, and a higher daily intake of energy, total fat and saturated fat; whereas they tended to have a lower education level, were less physically active and consumed less fruits, vegetables, fiber and vitamin supplements.
Essentially the confounding factors are noise, and the tiny risk reduction is the signal. So what they are essentially saying is that the signal to noise ratio is extremely low, so we can’t be certain of the ultimate effects. So really the conclusion of the authors is not that there is no health risk from red or processed meat. Their conclusion is that we don’t really know. The quality of the evidence is simply too weak to form any confident recommendations. But part of that low confidence is likely the fact that the absolute risk is probably low. If there were a substantial risk, we would be seeing it more confidently in the data (again – signal to noise).
The rest is a matter of interpretation and judgement. Based on weak evidence of a small effect size, do we tell people to change their eating habits? These authors decided no, while other experts erred on the side of caution to recommend limiting red and processed meat.
There are two things that everyone seems to agree on – we need better quality data, and we are unlikely to get it. We simply cannot do the large, long term, randomized controlled trial that would settle the debate. So we must be content with small controlled trials or large uncontrolled observational studies. If the true effect size is on the low side, however, this type of data is unlikely to ever definitely settle the controversy.
My personal bottom line is – look at the data and do what you want (you’re going to do that anyway), based on your own values. I will add one wrinkle to the evaluation – there is good evidence that it is important to health to eat plenty of vegetables. Caloric intake is a zero sum game, so if you eat a lot of meat you are probably not eating enough plants. The better recommendation, therefore, may not be to avoid meat, but to make sure you get enough variety in your diet overall, including plenty of fruits and vegetables.
In fact, I think that a lot of nutritional science can be boiled down to simply eating a varied diet. All the risks and nutritional needs will likely average out. It’s also a very simple and easily understood recommendation (like many science-based health recommendations) – have a varied diet. Done.
There is another layer to this controversy however, the meta-layer of the quality of nutritional science itself. As the NY Times reports:
In a statement, scientists at Harvard warned that the conclusions “harm the credibility of nutrition science and erode public trust in scientific research.”
That may be a defensive interpretation, but I acknowledge this too is complicated. I wrote about this recently (unrelated to the current topic). What we are advocating as scientific skeptics is a nuanced approach to science. Science is complicated, has lots of flaws and biases, and takes a long time to work out. A lot of evidence is weak and flawed, and we need to be humble before jumping to premature conclusions. But we can arrive at confident conclusions eventually, if we follow a careful and rigorous process.
This is neither nihilistic nor naive – but optimistic and realistic. Pointing out the complexity of nutritional research, in my opinion, will only erode a naïve trust in science, not an informed skeptical trust. That naïve trust is inherently fragile, and not worth protecting. I also think this study can foster a healthy and completely appropriate skepticism toward the current state of nutritional science. This is not to denigrate the field, but to point out how difficult it is to do good clinical nutritional science out there in the real world.
Much of our nutritional science is toward the weak end of the spectrum, because of the inherent limits of observational data and the difficulty of controlling experimentally what people eat. We have to acknowledge that and be open about these limitations. Pretending otherwise is a misguided strategy and will backfire. Hopefully this healthy skepticism will foster more mature and informed attitudes among the public, and higher quality research.
In the end this paper can be a great thing for the field, if we take away the proper lessons.

   Raw Meat and Bone Diets for Dogs: It’s Enough to Make You BARF
Brennen McKenzie 
Link
Some of the most rewarding interactions we have with our pets involve food. Most dogs respond with gratifying enthusiasm to being fed, and this activity is an important part of the human-animal bond. Providing food is also part of the parent/child dynamic that in many ways characterizes our relationships with our pets. Giving food is an expression of affection and a symbol of our duty of care to our pets.
Because of these emotional resonances, pet owners are often very concerned about giving their pets the “right” food to maintain health and, if possible, to prevent or treat disease. This has allowed the development of a large, and profitable commercial pet food industry that aggressively markets diets with health-related claims. This industry resembles in some ways the pharmaceutical industry. It is regulated by the FDA, and also by individual states, according to a somewhat Byzantine set of standards established by the FFDCA (the guiding document governing the FDA) and by the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO), a private organization made up primarily of state and federal feed control officials. Thanks to this regulatory structure, imperfect though it is, there is a good deal of solid science and research behind the products and claims the industry produces.
Like all for-profit concerns, the pet food industry also has its share of flaws. Some of these are relatively subtle, such as the probably unavoidable tendency for industry-funded research to come up with findings favorable to the funder’s products. Others are more serious, including rare but devastating instances of malfeasance. One example of the latter is the incident in 2007 in which melamine was substituted for wheat gluten as a protein source in pet food manufacturing, leading to the deaths of hundreds, possibly thousands of pets who ate contaminated commercial foods
And like “Big Pharma,” the pet food industry is often demonized by those who wish to promote unscientific or alternative veterinary medical treatments or theories. Anyone who has ever accepted a dime in research funding or a bagel at a conference (with or without cream cheese) from a pet food company is automatically an industry lackey whose opinion is worthless regardless of their credentials or expertise. This demonization of the pet food manufacturers is often used as a marketing tool for alternative nutritional theories and products.
One of the most popular unscientific notions sold to pet owners these days is that of feeding diets based on raw meat, typified by the BARF diet. According to the a leading proponent of this idea, Dr. Ian Billinghurst, BARF stands for Bones and Raw Foods or Biologically Appropriate Foods (though I confess other interpretations have occurred to me). Raw diets are frequently recommended by veterinarians and other who practice homeopathy, “holistic” veterinary medicine, and other forms of CAM. This is not surprising since, as you will see, the arguments and types of reasoning used to promote the BARF concept are also commonly used to defend other forms of alternative veterinary medicine. Let’s take a look at the arguments some BARF proponents make for this diet.
Dogs are Wolves
Dr. Billingurst refers to the principle behind the BARF diet as “evolutionary nutrition.”
“It is now generally agreed that the ancestor of the modern dog is the wolf…[the] process of domestication where our ancestors removed the ‘wildness’ from the wolf, involved thousands of years of selective breeding…In this process, our ancestors produced hundreds of ‘different looking wolves’…our ancestors made only two basic changes to the wolf. They changed the wolf’s appearance and they changed its mind. What they did not change, was the basic internal workings or physiology of the wolf…As a result, the basic workings or physiology of modern dogs is no different or very little different to their ancestor the wolf…The basic environment which the modern dog requires in terms of food and exercise is exactly the same as it was (and still is) for the wolf.” 
Having established that, despite appearances, dogs are essentially wolves, Dr. Billinghurst goes on to describe the wolf diet.
Raw bones with meat are a major part of their diet… They eat offal such as liver and heart. They eat raw eggs. They eat decaying material…They eat a wide variety of foodstuffs. Insects, bark, soil, birds – complete with their tiny bones and feathers – whatever. Every meal they eat is totally raw. Not one skerrick of it is cooked. Ever. They eat vegetables including herbs, from the gut of their prey. This vegetable material is raw, totally crushed and partly digested. They eat feces. A wolf’s diet contain almost no grains… For a wolf – not one single meal consists of dry dog food. They don’t eat canned dog food either. 
Finally, he makes the connection between this version of canine natural history and the feeding of pet dogs.
How do you feed a dog properly? You feed it the diet that it evolved to eat. It’s [sic] evolutionary diet. A Biologically Appropriate Raw Food diet. A BARF diet…A biologically appropriate diet for a dog is one that consists of raw whole foods similar to those eaten by the dogs’ wild ancestors. The food fed must contain the same balance and type of ingredients as consumed by those wild ancestors…Please note that modern dogs of any breed are not only capable of eating the food of their wild ancestors, but actually require it for maximum health. This is because their basic physiology has changed very little with domestication despite obvious and dramatic changes in their current physical appearance and mindset… 
Certainly a clear, simple, and pretty persuasive argument on the face of it. Taxonomically and phylogenetically, dogs are carnivores and their ancestors ate live prey and carrion, so they must be designed for a diet as close as reasonably possible to that for which they were designed by evolution.
Some raw diet advocates extend this basic argument by claiming that the domestic dog’s gastrointestinal tract is anatomically identical to that of the wolf and so the same dietary needs can be assumed. Others contribute additional arguments in favor of raw foods, such as the well-known homeopathic and holistic veterinarian Dr. Richard Pitcairn:
“All processed pet foods…are missing something that seems to me to be the most important “nutrient” of all. This key ingredient is practically ignored by nutritional scientists, but we can sense it when it’s there. It is a quality found only in freshly grown, uncooked whole foods: Life energy!1 
But while there are variations on the theme, and there are frequent and often bitter arguments over precisely which ingredients are best, and in what form or proportion, the basic “evolutionary nutrition” argument is advanced by all proponents of raw diets.
Processed Commercial Diets are Unhealthy
The other major component to the argument for raw diets is that the commercial diets most of us feed our dogs are inadequate, and possibly outright unhealthy. According to Dr. Billinghurst’s web site,
“as a practicing veterinary surgeon, I constantly see the enormous difference in health between pets raised on commercial pet food compared to those raised on a biologically appropriate raw food diet. I see the enormous change for good in the health of pets switched from cooked to a raw whole food diet…Most degenerative disease processes in pet animals are the direct result of a lifetime being fed cooked and/or processed foods…” 
He goes on to claim that the nutritional deficiency diseases seen in the early 20th century, when most pets were fed table scraps, were simple and easily treated, but thanks to processed foods these have been replaced by “vast array of complex and insidious degenerative diseases which now afflict our pets and fill our textbooks and waiting rooms.” He further claims that,
“Processed pet foods contain barely adequate levels of the known vitamins…Many contain biologically inappropriate antioxidants, enormous levels of refined sugars and masses of salt together with other chemicals used as colorings and flavorings. This chemical cocktail is a lethal brew which is a major factor in producing the epidemic of degenerative disease leading to the early death and suffering we see in pet animals fed such rubbish, including cancer, arthritis and a range of allergies and auto immune diseases…Cooking renders these products biologically inappropriate in a fundamental way…The vast majority of these products are based on cooked grains. This makes them biologically inappropriate. At no time in their evolutionary history (except in the last 50 to 150 years) have cats and dogs been subjected to cooked grain in any amount, and certainly not as the basis of their diet.” 
Commercial foods are also denigrated for a variety of supposedly dangerous ingredients, including (according to Dr. Pitcairn):
        ◦ Toxic products from spoiled foodstuffs
        ◦ Drug residues
        ◦ Hormone levels comparable to amounts that have produced cancer in laboratory animals
        ◦ Artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives, all of which he claims are responsible for an epidemic of cancer and degenerative diseases
        ◦ And even euthanized dogs and cats, which he claims “are routinely rendered by veterinary hospitals or shelters and recycled into pet food.”1 
Cancer, arthritis, allergies, autoimmune disease, and many other conditions are frequently claimed to be the result of eating commercial pet foods. But, of course, proponents of raw diets don’t always limit their critique of commercial foods to claims about nutrition and health which could be empirically examined. Some also paint commercial pet food manufacturers as villains killing pets for profit and veterinarians as their willing, or at least duped, accomplices. A blog entry on Dr. Billinghursts’s website asks,
What is the primary motive of kibble manufactures? Is it profit or nutritional value? … The inferior quality and poor utilization of ingredients is masked by the addition of heat, flavor enhancers, and harmful fat sprays. The kibble manufactures are aware of the potential dangers and potential harm to our dogs but it all boils down to producing an inexpensive product that can sustain and maintain the life of our dogs…for the kibble manufactures it all boils down to profit with a capital P. 
Another proponent of raw diets, Dr. Tom Lonsdale, claims he is
selling plenty of his book Raw Meaty Bones in the US but the Australian media seems to have blacked [sic] him out because the multinational pet food companies don’t want their dodgy doggy tucker exposed [web article 1]…Natural pet food is cheaper, pets live healthier longer lives, vet bills reduce [sic] and the environment gets a better deal. Except for the artificial pet food companies and their veterinary allies it’s a win, win, win situation…junk food is responsible for the majority of pet diseases there are both upstream and downstream implications worth $billions. Upstream those that run the systems – pet-food makers, veterinary profession, veterinary schools, animal welfare bodies, governments, retailers, and consumers — conspire to maintain the racket… The full extent of the junk pet-food fraud may never be fully known. [web article 2] 
Some Inconvenient Truths
Now let’s have a look at the problems with this raw dog food marketing propaganda. To begin with, the concept of “evolutionary nutrition” ignores the simple fact that taxonomy and phylogeny are not destiny, nor do they reliably predict the specific details of a species’ biology, including its nutritional needs. Sure, dogs are in the order Carnivora, but so are giant pandas, which are almost exclusively herbivorous. Functionally, dogs are omnivores or facultative carnivores, not obligate carnivores, and they are well-suited to an omnivorous diet regardless of their taxonomic classification or ancestry.
Domestic dogs did branch off from a wolf ancestor, and current DNA evidence suggests this occurred some 100,000-135,000 years ago.2,3 Though the data are unclear as to what morphologic or ecological changes might have occurred following this initial divergence, and while it is likely that there was much ongoing genetic exchange between dogs and wolves even after they diverged, it is still the case that dogs have not been wolves for a very long time. However, a distinct phenotypic divergence of dogs and wolves followed the development of more sedentary agricultural habits by many human groups some 10-15,000 years ago, which placed new selection pressures on our canines companions.31 Since then numerous anatomic and behavioral changes that have occurred first as a result of living with humans and sharing our food. And even more dramatic changes have been wrought on dogs in the last about 3000 years as a consequence of intensive selective breeding. Domestic dogs exhibit many features of neoteny, the retention of juvenile characteristics into adulthood. They have smaller and less robust skulls and dentition, and numerous features of their skeleton, GI tract, and other anatomic structures are significantly different from wolves. 4-6
Of course, anatomy does not always correlate with function anyway. All humans have essentially the same GI tract from an anatomical perspective, but when someone who is lactose intolerant chugs a glass of milk, he or she may be treated to a visceral demonstration of the fact that anatomy doesn’t necessarily predict function. But in the case of dogs and wolves, the claim that they are anatomically identical with respect to what is an appropriate diet is simply not true. If you try to picture a pack of Chihuahuas bringing down and savaging an elk, the impact of thousands of years of artificial selection is obvious. Other breeds may be more like wolves in appearance, but they are none of them truly wolves. Dogs have lived with humans, eaten our table scraps, and been intensively bred for features we desire, none of which is likely to make them ideally designed for the diet of a wolf.
Of course, even if BARF advocates could demonstrate that dogs were functionally equivalent to wolves in terms of diet, the evolutionary nutrition argument would still fail because at its heart it is nothing but a form of the naturalistic fallacy.
The average life expectancy of wolves in the wild is considerably lower than that of captive wolves, and disease, parasitism, and malnutrition are important factors in the mortality of wild populations.7-9 Captive wolves live longest and are healthiest when fed — guess what? — commercial dog food! This is the recommendation of the leading specialists in captive wolf husbandry and medicine, and it is largely the result of evidence that the previous practice of feeding raw meat based diets to captive wolves led to poorer quality nutrition and health than the current practices. Certainly, raw meat and bones are often used as enrichment items or bait for husbandry purposes, but always with an awareness of the risks they pose, and never as the primary diet. 10-12
BARF proponents persistently confound ingredients with nutrients. They imagine that because wild canids get their nutrients from raw whole carcasses that this must be the only appropriate source of nutrition for all canids, including domestic dogs despite the fact they have been eating our cooked leftovers for tens of thousands of years. This is contradicted, however, by extensive research in canine nutrition and by the generations of dogs who have lived long, healthy lives eating commercial pet foods.
Which leads to the second pillar of the BARF argument, the safety and nutritional adequacy of commercial pet foods. Like all knowledge based on science, our understanding of the nutritional needs of dogs is incomplete and always evolving. However, admitting that we do not know everything is not tantamount to admitting we know nothing. The basic nutrient requirements of our pets are well-established by decades of research, and despite the claims of BARF proponents there is no evidence that nutritional disease are widespread among pets fed balanced commercial diets.
Commercial dog foods are formulated according to AAFCO standards based on extensive nutritional research. These foods are testing through laboratory methods for nutrient content before and after processing, and many are subjected to feeding trials to determine their digestibility and the adequacy of their nutritional content as fed to healthy dogs. These reference standards and limited feeding trials are, like the basic pharmacology and preclinical testing of pharmaceuticals, not perfect, and it is certainly likely that advances in our understanding of dogs’ nutritional needs as well as epidemiologic studies of dogs fed commercial diets will uncover changes that need to be made in the formulations of commercial diets. But the data we do have strongly supports the nutritional appropriateness of these foods. 13,14
By contrast, homemade and commercial raw diets are seldom tested for nutritional adequacy, and when they have been tested they have usually failed to meet known nutrient requirements. 15-18. The knowledge of established nutritional science concerning the adequacy of commercial pet diets, imperfect though it may be, is certainly superior to the near total ignorance of the nutritional adequacy of most homemade of commercial raw diets.
There are many specific criticisms of commercial dog foods made in support of the BARF concept, but there is little evidence to support most of them, and some are clearly false. There are far more than I can deal with in a reasonable space, but I will address a few of the more common of these claims.
     1.  Commercial Dog Food Makes Dogs Sick: There is no evidence to support the claim that degenerative and immune-mediated diseases or cancers are caused by commercial pet foods. These conditions are the usual targets of alternative medicine proponents because the gaps in our knowledge about the etiology of these diseases leave room for them to insert their favorite bogeymen, in this case commercial pet food. The likelihood is that the prevalence of these categories of disease reflects, at least to some extent, the aging of the pet population, which is the result of the reduction in historic causes of mortality such as infectious diseases, trauma, and of course malnutrition.
     2.  Commercial Dog Foods are Toxic: The insinuation that commercial pet foods are full of “toxins” is also unsupported. Common preservatives, such as ethoxyquin, butylated hydroxytoluene, and others with scary-sounding chemical names, have been in use in human and animal foods for decades and studied extensively, and there is no published evidence to support the many claims and anecdotes that indicate these are responsible for disease.19,20 Synthetic preservatives are more effective than “natural” anti-oxidants, and they are an important tool for reducing food-borne illness.
     3.  Anti-vaccine activists have mercury, aluminum, and anti-freeze, and BARF advocates have preservatives and artificial flavoring and coloring agents. What neither have is solid evidence to support their fear-mongering regarding these substances
     4.  Dogs Can’t Digest Grain: It is frequently claimed, based primarily on the fallacious logic of “evolutionary nutrition,” that dogs are incapable of digesting grains or that these make poor nutrient sources in dog foods. Extensive evidence from laboratory research and feeding trials illustrates this is false and that cooked grains are excellent energy sources and can also provide protein and other important nutrients to dogs.21,23 Grains are also often blamed for food allergies, but while some dogs may develop allergies to plant proteins, the evidence suggests that the vast majority of food sensitivities in dogs are to animal proteins.24
     5.  Cooking Destroys Nutrients: BARFers like to claim that cooking destroys nutrients, so processed foods must be nutrient deficient. It is true that some nutrients are destroyed by cooking, but the relationship between temperature and cooking time and the final level of these nutrients in the food is well established, and commercial foods are supplemented to account for this and extensively tested in vitro and in vivo to ensure adequate nutrient levels. Other nutrients, particularly carbohydrates, are made more available by cooking.22,23 And cooking destroys many parasites and bacterial organisms responsible for serious foodborne illness.
     6.  Our ancestors ate raw food for millennia prior to the discovery of fire, and our nearest living relatives, chimpanzees, don’t cook their food. Yet for some reason even most advocates of BARF diets for dogs don’t eat primarily raw plants, insects, and the occasional bit of scavenged or deliberately killed raw meat that “evolutionary nutrition” would suggest they should be eating.
     7.  Commercial Dog Food is Made from Dead Pets: One of the most repulsive accusations made concerning commercial diets is that manufacturers routinely include the rendered carcasses of euthanized pets in their products. Such a practice would be illegal and has been specifically disavowed by dog food manufacturers and the plants that slaughterhouses and rendering plants that provide them with their ingredients. The FDA has investigated this story and has not found evidence to support it.
It is true that miniscule levels of pentobarbital, an anesthetic used to euthanize animals, have been found in some foods. The source of this has not been identified, though no trace of dog or cat DNA was found in the contaminated food. The most likely source of the contaminant is horses who were euthanized with pentobarbital and improperly rendered along with approved sources of meat for pet foods, though this has not been clearly proven. And it is also true that a few rare cases of dog remains being processed by rendering plants that also supplied pet food manufacturers with ingredients have been documented. However, for this to be a common practice, rather than a rare exception, would require a truly enormous and perfect conspiracy of manufacturers, rendering plants, and government, and as of yet no whistle-blower, journalist, or undercover animal rights activist has yet come forward to reveal evidence of any such conspiracy.
The Bottom Line
The argument that dogs are designed by their evolutionary history to eat raw meat based diets is riddled with errors and fallacies and ignores the impact of tens of thousands of years of domestication and cohabitation with humans on the physiology of our canine friends. The accusations that commercial dog foods are nutritionally inadequate or unsafe are not supported by any objective or scientific evidence, only anecdotes, intuition, and conspiracy theories. There is, in contrast, significant evidence that commercial dog foods are nutritious and healthy and that they have contributed to greater longevity and reduced nutritional and infectious disease morbidity of dogs fed these diets.
The benefits promised by advocates of BARF diets for dogs are numerous. Greater health, less disease, better quality of life, and much more. Dr. Billinghurst’s web site even claims, “Eating bones for a dog is a joyous experience. It is so enjoyed by dogs that it actually of itself boosts their immune system.” However, there is absolutely no scientific evidence to support these claims. BARF proponents have no shortage of opinions and anecdotes to demonstrate the benefits of their diets, but they have a severe shortage of data.
The risks of raw meat based diets, however, are well-documented. Homemade diets and commercial BARF diets are often demonstrable unbalanced and have severe nutritional deficiencies or excesses.16-18 Dogs have been shown to acquire and shed parasitic organisms and potentially lethal infectious diseases associated with raw meat, including pathogenic strains of E. coli and Salmonella.25-27 Many other pathogens have been identified in raw diets or raw meat ingredients, and these represent a risk not only to the dogs fed these diets but to their owners, particularly children and people with compromised immune systems.29-30 The bones often included in such diets can cause fractured teeth and gastrointestinal diseases, including obstructed or perforated intestines, and the FDA recently warned pet owners against feeding bones to their canine companions.
So with a dodgy theory behind it, no sound evidence of benefits, and clear risks, there is no justification for recommending raw meat based diets for dogs. As always, I remain open to the possibility that new evidence may emerge to document benefits from such diets that might justify the risks they present, but for now this feeding approach appears to be simply another form of CAM mythology supported only by anecdote and unsound logic.
References
     1.  Pitcairn RH, Pitcairn SH. Dr. Pitcairn’s complete guide to natural health for dogs and cats. 3rd ed. Rodale; 2005.
     2.  Vila C, Maldonado JE, Wayne RK. Phylogenetic relationships, evolution, and genetic diversity of the domestic dog. Journal of Heredity 1999;90(1):71-77.
     3.  Wayne RK. Molecular evolution of the family dog. Trends in Genetics 1993;9(6);218-224.
     4.  Serpell J (editor). The domestic dog: Its evolution, behavior and interactions with people. New York, NY, US: Cambridge University Press; 1995.
     5.  Ziesenis A, Wissdorf H. [The ligaments and menisci of the femorotibial joint of the wolf (Canis lupus L., 1758) — anatomic and functional analysis in comparison with the domestic dog (Canis lupus f. familiaris)]. Gegenbaurs Morphol Jahrb 1990;136(6):759-73.
     6.  Lauer BH, Kuyt E, Baker BE. Wolf milk. I. Arctic wolf (Canis lupus arctos) and husky milk: gross composition and fatty acid constitution. Canadian Journal of Zoology 1969;47(1):99-102.
     7.  Maia OB, Gouveia AM. Birth and mortality of maned wolves Chrysocyon brachyurus in captivity. Brazilian Journal of Biology 2002; 62(1):25-32.
     8.  Smith DW, Stahler DR, Albers E, Metz M, Williamson L, et al. Yellowstone Wolf Project: Annual Report, 2008. 2009. National Park Service, Yellowstone Center for Resources, Yellowstone National Park, Wyoming, YCR-2009-03.
     9.  Max Planck Institute for Demographic Research. Longevity records; Lifespans of mammals, birds, reptiles, amphibians and fish. Accessed 05/07/2010 at http://www.demogr.mpg.de/longevityrecords/0203.htm
     10.  Waddell W. Nutrition. In: Red Wolf Husbandry Manual Guidelines for Captive Management. Red Wolf SSP Management Group American Association of Zoos and Aquariums. 1998.
     11.  Newton K. Nutrition. In: Mexican Wolf Husbandry Manual. Mexican Wolf SSP Management Group. American Association of Zoos and Aquariums. 1995.
     12.  Allen ME. Maned wolf nutritional management. In: Husbandry Manual for the Maned Wolf Chrysocyon brachyurus. N.B. Fletchall, M. Rodden and S. Taylor, Eds. American Association of Zoos and Aquariums. 1995.
     13.  Crane SW, Griffin RW, Messent PR. Introduction to commercial pet foods. In: Hand MS, Thatcher CD, Remillard RL, Roudebush P, editors. Small animal clinical nutrition. 4th ed. Topeka, KS, US: Mark Morris Institute; 2000. p. 111-126.
     14.  Cowell CS, Stout NP, Brinkman MF, Moser EA, Crane SW. Making Commercial Pet Foods. In: Hand MS, Thatcher CD, Remillard RL, Roudebush P, editors. Small animal clinical nutrition. 4th ed. Topeka, KS, US: Mark Morris Institute; 2000. p. 127-146.
     15.  Freeman L, Michel K. Nutritional analysis of 5 types of “Raw Food Diets.” Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association. 2001;218(5):705.
     16.  Lauten SD, Smith TM, Kirk CA, Bartges JW, Adams A, Wynn SG. Computer Analysis of Nutrient Sufficiency of Published Home-Cooked Diets for Dogs and Cats. Proceedings of the American College of Veterinary Internal Medicine Forum 2005.
     17.  Roudebush P, Cowell CS. Results of a hypoallergenic diet survey of veterinarians in North America with a nutritional evaluation of homemade diet prescriptions. Veterinary Dermatology 1992;3:23-28.
     18.  Taylor MB, Geiger DA, Saker KE, Larson MM. Diffuse osteopenia and myelopathy in a puppy fed a diet composed of an organic premix and raw ground beef. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 2009;234(8):1041-8.
     19.  Wortinger A. Nutritional myths. Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association 2005;41:276.
     20.  Dzanis DA. Safety of ethoxyquin in dog foods. Journal of Nutrition 1991;121:S163-S164.
     21.  Walker JA, Harmon DL, Gross KL, Collings GF. Evaluation of nutrient utilization in the canine using ileal cannulation technique. Journal of Nutrition 1994;124(12 Suppl):2672S-2676S.
     22.  Trân ðình Quang. Extrusion processing effects on dry canine diets. 2008 Ph.D. Thesis, Wageningen University and Research Centre, Wageningen, the Netherlands.
     23.  Gross KL, Wedekind KJ, Cowell CS, Schoenherr WD, Jewell DE, et al. Nutrients. In: Hand MS, Thatcher CD, Remillard RL, Roudebush P, editors. Small animal clinical nutrition. 4th ed. Topeka, KS, US: Mark Morris Institute; 2000. p. 21-107.
     24.  Roudebush P, Guilfor WG, Shanley K. Adverse reactions to food. In: Hand MS, Thatcher CD, Remillard RL, Roudebush P, editors. Small animal clinical nutrition. 4th ed. Topeka, KS, US: Mark Morris Institute; 2000. p. 431-453..
     25.  Chengapappa, M., et al. Prevalence of Salmonella in raw meat diets used in racing greyhounds. Journal of Veterinary Diagnostic Investigations 1993;5:372-7.
     26.  Finley, R. et al. The risk of Salmonella shedding by dogs fed Salmonella-contaminated commercial raw food diets. Canadian Veterinary Journal 2007;8:69-75.
     27.  Joffe, D., Schlesinger, D. Preliminary assessment of the risk of Salmonella infection in dogs fed raw chicken diets. Canadian Veterinary Journal 2002;43:441-442.
     28.  Weese, J. et al. Bacteriological evaluation of commercial canine and feline raw diets. Canadian Veterinary Journal 2005;46:513–516.
     29.  Strohmeyer, R.A., et al., Evaluation of bacterial and protozoal contamination of commercially-available raw meat diets for dogs. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 2006;228:537-542.
     30.  LeJeune JT, Hancock DD. Public health concerns associated with feeding raw meat diets to dogs. Journal of the American veterinary Medical Association 2001;219(9);1222-25.
     31.  Vila C, Savolainen P, Maldonado JE, Amorim IR, Rice JE, et al. Multiple and ancient origins of the domestic dog. Science 1997;276:1687-9.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR:
Brennen McKenzie, MA, VMD is a 2001 graduate of the University of Pennsylvania School of Veterinary Medicine, and he works as a small animal veterinarian in private practice in California. He has a special interest in promoting science-based veterinary medicine and is currently chair of the Practitioner Committee for the Evidence-Based Veterinary Medical Association. He has published articles on evidence-based medicine in veterinary science journals, and he also writes about both science-based and “alternative” veterinary medicine as the SkeptVet.
Prior to becoming a veterinarian, Dr. McKenzie completed a Master’s Degree in animal behavior, studying captive chimpanzees and working as a specialist in environmental enrichment for captive primates. He reads too much, with a predilection for science fiction, philosophy, linguistics, and of course skepticism. He travels too much and has climbed Mt. Kilimanjaro and run with the bulls in Pamplona. He also plays the Irish pennywhistle and the mandolin and has been known to wear the kilt on occassion, though he does not claim to do any of these well.

Cannibalism?
Mark Crislip on May 18, 2012
Link
For all the goofiness that is SCAM, I never thought I would have a post with Cannibalism in the title. The ability for humans to find imaginary healing properties in everything from duck liver and heart diluted 1:100 200 times, rhinoceros horns, and waving hands over people to adjust energy fields that do not exist is remarkable. Somehow I never thought Jeffrey Dahmer would be at the forefront of alternative therapies.
Wednesday evening while my wife was reading me the paper (it is how I usually consume the local newspaper, my wife reads stories she finds of interest out loud. Otherwise I do not think I would bother with anything beyond the comics and sports page) she let it be known that Korean officials has confiscated medications containing aborted fetuses and stillborn babies. Instead of the usual distracted, uh huh, that’s interesting, this caught my attention. Say what?
She showed me the article. There it was, in black and white, under the title “Human flesh pills seized.” Korean customs officials confiscated 17,000 health capsules that contain human remains “most likely extracted from aborted fetuses or stillborn babies.” Forensic tests found a 99.7% match with human flesh. Evidently unborn infants and placenta are believed to have medicinal properties in some parts of China and Korea.
Conformation bias kicked in big time. It is the kind of report I would assume to be true since it ties in with my understanding of traditional Chinese medicine, where they will grind up damn near anything to make a medical nostrum. First tigers, now dead babies. Stupid healers.
And there are parallels. In parts of Africa, albino’s are dismembered and sometimes killed for body parts that are used by witch doctors to make potions that make the user healthy and wealthy (but not, evidently, wise). As best I can tell, the potions and charms are used in rituals but not consumed, but the interwebs are not specific on the use of the albino parts. It is difficult to tell what is fact and fiction, although there is no doubt that albinos are being murdered for magical purposes.
The Wikipedia entry on the persecution of albinos has the following note at the top :
An editor has expressed a concern that this article lends undue weight to certain ideas, incidents, controversies or matters relative to the article subject as a whole. Please help to create a more balanced presentation. Discuss and resolve this issue before removing this message.
I guess there is an opportunity for the pro murder and processing of albino’s into potions to weigh in with their side. Sigh. The eternal quest for being neutral and telling both sides of the story.
I though the topic would be a nice addition to prior entries on Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). Then I thought wait a minute. There are two topics about which I have expertise: Infectious Diseases and SCAMs. The Oregonian always gets it wrong when they have articles on these topics. So why should it be correct this time?
As I thought about it, I have spent significant time in the byways and backwaters of TCM, looking for the odd and unusual therapies, and I have never heard of this form of medication. Something that weird and repugnant would have been noticed long ago. Given the lack of veracity of the ingredients on the average bottle of TCM, even if it included ‘dead babies’ and ‘embryos’ on the label, I would be skeptical of the contents.
The article is only five paragraphs long, but rereading with a skeptical eye instead of confirmation bias suggests it doesn’t hold together.
There is this weirdly specific Auschwitz-like description in the article:
The pills were composed on “ground stillborn fetus or babies that had been cut into small pieces and dried in gas ranges for two days, and then made into powders and encapsulated.
Although the Huffington Post suggested
dead babies whose bodies were chopped into small pieces and dried on stoves before being turned into powder.
And the Mail suggested more modern techniques
Overnight she dried it out on absorbent paper before slowly microwaving it on a low heat
My microwave doesn’t have low heat; maybe they mean low power.
So how do they know it is specifically babies and not placenta or other human tissues. I am not certain as I cannot find a copy of the report in English.
The video report is in Korean and the only organs on screen look like placenta. I could see nothing that looked like fetus
They comment a 99.7 % match with human tissue. Human tissue does not a fetus make. I am of course limited by my lack of Korean and Google translation (which summarizes the entry with “saw culture terrible wrong against humanity is an act of singing.” I agree) but I can’t find the forensic report on line, just references to it. The video has some lab coated science done on screen, but I have no clue what they are really doing. There are graphs and pipetting, so it must be valid.
There is something peculiar in the missing 0.3% that to my mind suggests someone wants to imply that the source not quite 100% human, a goal if the message is not truth, but demonizing someone or something. Those Chinese, eating dead babies. They are not even completely human dead baby pills.
Is there any data to suggest the pills contain babies? Nope. Could it be placenta? Almost certainly. Placentas are popular the world over. It is the one meat OK with vegans:
While some argue placentophagy is basically an act of cannibalism, many vegans think it’s okay to eat one’s own placenta, or a friend’s placenta, because no animal suffered for the meat.
Although half the human race, and certainly my wife, whose graphic description of pushing a bowling ball through a paper towel tube doesn’t sound like fun, might argue with the last 6 words of that sentence. Not unsurpizingly the author is male.
How did they know such gruesome specifics about the manufacturing processes. The video is not revealing and the written reports appear to be rewrites of the same article; the interwebs echo chamber can make research tedious.
All the comments on the beneficial effects of dead babies are in over the top sites about cannibalism in China. Wouldn’t baby oil be cheaper? I can find no other independent references to traditional healers who think dead baby pills are of benefit. I am sure there are a few Elizabeth Báthory wannabe’s , who think that consumption of human blood and body parts are of benefit. Any alleged mystical/alternative health benefits from cannibalism are not mentioned on the interwebs outside of population control.
So I went a googling, an found all the reports started around 2000 and every instance I could find were on anti-abortion sites. Ah. No wonder the grisly description of the manufacturing process. And the reports get really sensationalist with respect to China:
Usually, I washed the foetuses clean, and added ginger, orange peel and pork to make soup. After taking it for a while, I felt a lot better and my asthma disappeared. I used to take placenta, but it was not so helpful.”
and
The next day the reporter returned at lunch time. The doctor eventually emerged from the operating theatre holding a fist size glass bottle stuffed with thumbsized foetuses.
She said: ‘There are 10 foetuses here, all aborted this morning. You can take them. We are a state hospital and don’t charge anything.
‘Normally, we doctors take them home to eat – all free. Since you don’t look well, you can take them.
Most of the sites are in the same sensationalist mode. When I was a medical student at the VA we would eat the dinner trays of patient who had been discharged or could otherwise not have their meals. That is where I draw the line.
As best I can tell, the entire dead baby pill story is nonsense. Whether started by Koreans or Pro-life proponents to aggravate their enemies and give succor to the faithful, I do not know. Everything I can find suggests sensational, unverified reporting by people with an ax to grind. It is another version of the blood libel, a common manifestation of bigotry, ignorance, and xenophobia. Accusations of cannibalism has a long history as a form of propaganda used against the ’other’.
Glen Beck takes the opportunity to draw a parallel between dead baby pills and Obama’s stand on some aspects of health care. That pretty much sums up the probable reason this story exists.
And by the way, it is the Koreans who seem to be the market for dead baby pills, the Chinese are the re-processors. It is the Koreans who have some ‘splanin to do.
While I am convinced the multiplicity of logical fallacies and its resultant fundamental irrationality of humans, I also am convinced of the basic decency and goodness of most humans*. The whole concept of eating dead babies goes against fundamental human nature, even if I do agree with the idea that for humans there is nothing unnatural, just untried. Dead baby pill are almost certainly not about alternative medicine, but demonizing your enemy, be it Chinese or the abortionist. Hmm. Maybe I have to rethink the whole decency and goodness thing. The idea of dead baby pills fails at the human level. It has about the same probability of being true as the The Protocols of the Elders of Zion.
This is by no means a definitive review of the topic, but none the less I call urban legend. I await the Mythbusters to prove me right. Watching the hosts consume stillborn fetuses would make great television.

* I have always found the need of SCAM and anti-vaccine proponents to demonize their opposition to be the saddest part of their argument. I try, not always with success, to remember it is the idea, not the person, that is the problem. But then you have Gary Kevin Trudeau, Dr. Oz, and Robert Young, and it is the person after all. Damned if you do, damned if you do.

   Eating Placentas: Cannibalism, Recycling, or Health Food?
Harriet Hall 
Link
After giving birth, most mammals eat the afterbirth, the placenta. Most humans don’t. Several hypotheses have been suggested as to why placentophagy might have had evolutionary survival value, but are there any actual benefits for modern women? Placentophagy has been recommended for various reasons, from nutritional benefit to preventing postpartum depression to “honoring the placenta.” In other cultures, various rituals surround the placenta including burial and treating it as sacred or as another child with its own spirit. Eating the placenta is promoted by some modern New Age, holistic, and “natural-is-good” cultural beliefs.
Some women eat it raw, but many women have a yuck-factor objection to eating raw bloody tissue. It can be cooked: recipes are available for preparing it in various ways. For those who don’t like the idea of eating the tissue, placenta encapsulation services are available, putting placenta into a capsule that is more esthetically acceptable and that can even be frozen and saved for later use in menopause.
Does placentophagia benefit health? Does it constitute cannibalism? It it just a way to recycle nutrients? How can science inform our thinking about this practice?
Is It Cannibalism?
As I researched this, I found the assertion that the placenta is part of the woman’s body. Actually, this is inaccurate. While there is a maternal component, placental tissue is mainly derived from the fertilized egg and carries the fetus’s genome. So technically, wouldn’t eating the placenta fit the definition of cannibalism: eating the flesh of another individual of your own species? Some people have categorical philosophical or ethical objections to cannibalism, but there is no evidence (and no reason to think) that eating “long pig” would be harmful to health as long as the tissue is healthy and unable to transmit diseases (such as the infamous kuru).
My mind wandered into other hypothetical scenarios. What about swallowing semen: would that fit the definition of cannibalism? If eating human tissue is sometimes acceptable as in placentophagia, when does it become not acceptable and why? Would it be acceptable to eat surgical specimens of healthy tissue? For instance, a healthy uterus that had been removed only because of prolapse, or breast tissue from breast reduction surgery? Circumcised foreskins? Unused tissue from a phallus removed during sex-change surgery? Not that anyone has suggested eating those things, but it’s interesting to think about where reasoning might lead us once we have accepted a principle. Socrates was famous for that: he would get his interlocutors to agree to a statement and then would make them explore the logical consequences that would necessarily ensue.
Some vegetarians make an exception for placentas. One writer on Yahoo! Answers justified placentophagia by rationalizing that she eats eggs and placenta is basically human egg white!
My personal preference? I didn’t eat my placentas because I saw no reason to do so, but I don’t object on principle. Even if placentophagia qualifies as cannibalism, I don’t see any rational objection to cannibalism per se, as long as it doesn’t involve unethical practices like murder. I have an aversion to raw meat, but I wouldn’t have any objection to eating placenta if it were cooked and seasoned. With the high blood content, I imagine it would taste somewhat similar to the fried (bovine) blood I enjoyed eating when I lived in Spain. Fried blood tastes something like liver and is delicious when prepared with garlic and olive oil.
Forgive the digression and the weird speculations.
Is It Recycling?
The placenta contains a lot of nutrients and could help replace the nutrients depleted during pregnancy, especially iron. This might be important for some animals; but for humans who have adequate access to food, these nutrients are easily replaced through more conventionally accepted means. It seems a shame for good nutrients to be thrown away. On the other hand, recycling placental nutrients would have only a very small impact. Most of us don’t feel an obligation to recycle everything. We throw away other nutrients by discarding the outer leaves of cabbages and the fat trimmings from cuts of meat. A fanatical recycler might accept recycling as a compelling reason for placentophagia, but I suspect that most people wouldn’t be persuaded by that argument alone.
What Health Benefits Are Claimed?
According to Placentabenefits.info, health claims include:
    • Increase general energy
    • Allow a quicker return to health after birth
    • Increase production of breast milk
    • Decrease likelihood of baby blues and post natal depression
    • Decrease likelihood of insomnia or sleep disorders
    • Other benefits are also likely but too numerous to mention.
    • “Definitely worth considering as part of a holistic postpartum recovery for every expectant woman.” 
Dried human placenta is also used in traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) to treat wasting diseases, infertility, impotence, and other conditions.
Is there scientific support for those claims?
The Placentabenefits website offers the following scientific research to support those claims:
     1.  A 1954 article from Czechoslovakia showed that taking a supplement derived from placenta increased milk production, but after 57 years this study has still not been replicated. This same study is mentioned by the authors of the second reference only to question it, characterizing it as “a somewhat unrigorous study”
     2.  “Placentophagia: A Biobehavioral Enigma” discusses animals and human cultures that practice placentophagia and ponders why. It provides no data directly relevant to the claims for human health.
     3.  A study of opioid levels in rats after placenta ingestion, showing that placenta enhances y- and n-opioid antinociception, but suppresses A-opioid antinociception — in rats. No apparent relevance to their claims for human benefits.
     4.  A 1980 study showing that placentophagy alters hormone levels in rats. It didn’t even look at what clinical effects might result from those altered levels.
     5.  They cite an article without giving sufficient clues for me to be able to locate it. By their description, the article apparently cites research by Chrousos suggesting that lower levels of human corticotrophin releasing hormone (CRH) after delivery might be a possible etiology for postpartum depression; but it says nothing about treatment or the effects of eating the placenta.
     6.  An article showing that iron deficiency anemia affects postpartum emotions and cognition, with no discussion or evaluation of whether eating placenta elevates serum iron levels significantly or improves emotions or cognition.
     7.  An article about predicting postpartum depression by assessing postpartum fatigue. Nothing about eating placenta.
     8.  Unexplained fatigue may benefit from iron supplementation. Nothing about eating placenta.
     9.  A discussion of why postpartum iron deficiency should not be overlooked. No mention of placentas.
My own search of PubMed didn’t uncover any relevant studies on humans. If these 9 articles are their best effort, they’re grasping at straws. All they’ve got is rats and speculation. The best they can do is to mention the need for adequate iron and speculate that placenta-eating might be a useful source of iron. To counter that, we know enough about iron metabolism to make us think it is highly implausible that a one-time ingestion of placenta would contribute very much to effectively replenishing the body’s iron stores.
Conclusion
Science does not offer sufficient evidence to either support or reject placentophagia as a health practice. Nonscientific considerations will continue to determine women’s choices in this matter.

Placentophagy and the Risk of Invasive Neonatal GBS Disease
A young infant has suffered an invasive and potentially deadly bacterial infection…twice! Now the CDC is warning that maternal placentophagy may have played a role.
Clay Jones on July 14, 2017
Link

On June 30th, the CDC published a case report of a neonate who suffered a recurrent invasive infection involving group B Streptococcus, commonly known as GBS. Although recurrence is uncommon, occurring in about 1% of cases, that’s not what made this report newsworthy. Revealed in the CDC publication, and focused on in numerous, news, reports over the past several days, is the fact that the patient’s mother had been consuming her placenta, a practice known as placentophagy (which we have discussed here before).
The media didn’t do a bad job (this time) covering the issue. For the most part they simply repeated the facts of the case per the CDC discussion, and echoed their call for caution. Where many, if not most, failed was in leaving out the nuance of the CDC recommendation and assuming a causal relationship between placentophagy and the child’s illness. I’ll explain shortly.
But first…
Wait…what? She ate her placenta?
The mother of the ill newborn did consume some of her own placenta. If you have never heard of this practice before, take a minute to pick your jaw up off of the floor. Harriet Hall actually wrote about placentophagy back in 2011, and the supporting evidence of benefit in humans remains in the “we asked a bunch of women if they enjoyed it and would recommend it to a friend” stage.
Placentophagy is the norm in mammals, exceptions being marine mammals, camels, and humans. There was some use of the placenta in traditional Chinese medicine, although no known examples of a new mother consuming her own. And there have also been rare reports in the medical literature going back to early last century, again with none involving consumption by a mother soon after delivery.
The current trend of maternal placentophagy can be traced to proponents of “natural birth” in 1970s California. But it wasn’t until the past decade, as the practice was reported among celebrities such as Kim Kardashian and Alicia Silverstone, that it started to go a bit more mainstream. Another driving factor in its increased popularity is that, rather than eating the placenta raw, in smoothie form, or as part of one of many available recipes involving cooked afterbirth, people are increasingly having it dehydrated and encapsulated. Taking placenta via a pill is considerably more palatable than slapping it on the grill or making it into jerky.
But…placenta…why?
Many reasons have been offered up by placentophagy proponents over the years to support the practice, none of which hold up to critical evaluation. And the evidence is virtually non-existent. I’ll quickly run through the most common proposed justifications.
     1.  Animals do it. Nobody knows why, but it must be for a good reason that also applies to us.
     2.  Hormones are good. Hormones in the placenta prevent postpartum depression and improve breastfeeding success.
     3.  The placenta is full of great nutrition, particularly iron. And iron deficiency is common in pregnant women. Women who eat their placenta will have more energy.
Dr. Hall goes into more detail in her 2011 post, but none of the above reasons really makes any sense for humans. There are numerous behaviors seen in the animal kingdom that are not observed in humanity and would not be beneficial, such as the coprophagia that is common in dogs and rabbits. And again, not all mammals even eat their placenta. And honestly, dolphins are really smart and I would trust a camel over a weasel any day of the week.
It is a fallacy to assume that all widespread behaviors must have an evolutionary benefit. Animals may consume the placenta for nutrition or to reduce the risk of predation at a vulnerable time. Maybe they do eat their placenta to replace hormones, but ultimately claims made by proponents are arguments from ignorance. We just don’t know why they do it.
There is no evidence that the consumption of the placenta raises levels of beneficial hormones in any animal, including humans. There is no evidence that any hormones in the placenta are present in clinically meaningful amounts after cooking or encapsulating. There is no evidence of benefit regarding postpartum depression or breastfeeding other than testimonials and survey data, which are essentially just a collection of selected anecdotes.
I have little doubt that the placenta is nutritious, particularly when food is a scarce resource. And to be completely honest, I would eat any placenta that I could get my hands on before starving to death. If the argument is that Kim Kardashian and Alicia Silverstone were facing starvation, then I feel compelled to disagree.
Is placentophagy risky?
Eating your own placenta, especially if thoroughly cooked, is probably less risky than driving without a seat belt or bullfighting drunk, but it still isn’t a good idea considering the absence of any proven benefit. There has been chatter over the possibility of various heavy metals and other toxins being absorbed by placental tissue, but there is as much a lack of evidence regarding this risk as there is for any benefit.
The exception, however, is the potential risk of contamination with pathogenic viruses and bacteria either during pregnancy, such as with HIV infection, or during delivery when the placenta is exposed to vaginal and intestinal flora. We used to think that the placenta is typically sterile prenatally, but that is proving to be a myth as studies are now showing that oral bacteria are colonizing the placenta during pregnancy. The placenta may also be contaminated after delivery if not handled properly.
That being said, I’m much less worried about the risk to the mother than I am to the baby. Which is where the new CDC report comes into play. They are raising the concern that the infant’s recurrence of GBS disease was potentially a result of maternal placentophagy. This is extremely plausible, as I’ll explain shortly, but first a quick primer on GBS.
What is GBS and how does it hurt babies and make me very, very angry?
Though first isolated in the 1930s by Rebecca Lancefield, GBS wasn’t fully recognized as the etiologic agent in the majority of neonatal sepsis cases worldwide for another few decades. In many people, however, it asymptomatically colonizes the lower intestines and, in females, the vagina. And although it can cause disease in patients of all ages, particularly if immune compromised in some way, it truly does love babies.
There are many risk factors for invasive GBS disease in neonates, but the most important by far is maternal colonization of the lower GI tract and/or the vagina. This is why routine prenatal care since the mid-1990’s has involved some type of risk assessment. Since 2002, this risk assessment has universally involved culturing maternal rectovaginal swabs for GBS that are obtained at 35 to 37 weeks of gestation.
Mothers who are “GBS+”, or “GBS unknown” with certain other risk factors, will typically receive intrapartum antibiotic prophylaxis (IAP) ideally at least 4 hours prior to delivery. An exception is when a baby is being born via a scheduled C-section without labor or rupture of membranes prior to delivery. IAP has been shown to significantly reduce the likelihood that a newborn will be colonized and subsequently develop an invasive infection in the first week of life, so-called early-onset GBS disease, which had historically affected 1.5 out of every 1,000 babies born.
Unfortunately, IAP does not decrease the likelihood of late-onset GBS disease that occurs after the first week of life, likely because it doesn’t decolonize the mother and the baby may also be exposed to other colonized caregivers over time. The early-onset variety used to be much more common, but because of IAP recommendations it is now a smidge less likely to occur than the late-onset variety. The overall risk for either is now roughly 0.2-.3 per 1,000 births, but there are serious disparities in populations less likely to receive routine prenatal care.
It’s important to point out that our current approach to GBS screening and the use of IAP is not perfect. There are false negative culture results and women can become colonized during the time between screening and delivery. In fact, currently most cases of invasive early-onset GBS disease now occur in babies born to “GBS-” mothers.
GBS disease tends to involve sepsis, and death occurs in around 5% of early-onset cases and as many as 7% of late-onset overall. But when looking specifically at certain populations, mortality is much higher in premature infants and when the central nervous system is involved. With meningitis, which occurs in 7% of the early-onset cases and 27% of late-onset, there is an increased risk of death and almost half of these babies will have long term neurologic impairment of some kind.
Just the CDC facts
The case presented by the CDC involved a term newborn born to a mother without pregnancy or delivery complications. Her prenatal screening for GBS was even negative, although as I explained earlier this doesn’t count as a protective factor. We still pay close attention to early signs and symptoms of disease in all newborns, even if low risk. As with this baby, early-onset GBS disease almost always presents in the first 12, if not 24 hours, just one of many reasons why I’m not a fan of home deliveries.
The infant was transferred to the NICU and found to have GBS growing in his blood, but thankfully not his spinal fluid, and he was discharged home after eleven days of IV antibiotics. Five days after discharge he was again admitted to the hospital for treatment of GBS infection involving only the bloodstream. It was during this hospitalization that the treating team discovered that the mother had been ingesting her encapsulated placenta beginning three days after delivery.
Testing of the mother’s breast milk, a known potential source of GBS recurrence, was negative. However, culture of a sample taken from the encapsulated placenta revealed a GBS isolate genetically identical to the GBS found in both blood cultures. A rectovaginal culture was not obtained on the patient’s mother, but the very plausible assumption was made that she was colonized and that the ingested placenta increased the burden of her colonization, thus likely increasing the risk of recurrence.
The company that encapsulated the mother’s placenta was not identified, however it was revealed that they could not guarantee that the dehydration process would reach a temperature sufficient for sterilization. The authors were clear that they could not rule out another caregiver as the potential source of GBS with any certainty. They then specifically warned against the ingestion of encapsulated placenta without commenting on raw or cooked consumption, although one could perhaps argue that it is implied.
What does it all mean?
I don’t know if the mother’s ingestion of placenta resulted in her child developing a recurrence of invasive GBS disease. I can confidently say that it had nothing to do with the initial infection, however. The mother clearly had a false negative GBS screen or became colonized in the interim between screening and delivery.
We know that recurrence happens in a small percentage of patients without maternal placentophagy, somewhere around 1 out of every 100 cases. It is very possible that another family member with close contact to the mother and the baby was also colonized with the same strain of GBS. We know that family members can spread GBS around either during intimate sexual contact or through the fecal-oral route.
But the claim that placentophagy increased the burden of GBS in the mother’s GI tract is extremely plausible. And taking into account the utter lack of proven benefit from the practice, I think it is reasonable to recommend that new mothers not eat their placenta. But we didn’t really need this new report to say that now did we?
A response from the Association of Placenta Preparation Arts
Soon after publication, proponents of placentophagy responded. The APPA response is interesting and I’ll focus on it in this post, but there are plenty of additional examples if any readers feel the desire to ride that snake. The APPA tells parents that encapsulated placenta is probably safe, which doesn’t seem all that reassuring, and they throw the encapsulation company under the bus:
A well-trained placenta arts specialist will make sure that your placenta is prepared safely for consumption, unfortunately, it seems that this specialist may not have done so.
They claim that dehydration alone is not sufficient to kill pathogenic bacteria such as GBS, and that their method, which incorporates steam heat followed by dehydration, is effective. Also, according to the APPA guidelines, one of their certified practitioners would have rejected the placenta because of the initial case of GBS disease. But considering that plans for encapsulation are typically made prior to delivery, the person picking up the placenta would have to ask about the development of maternal infection at the time of delivery or early-onset infection in the baby. The family may be a bit too distracted to think about notifying them on their own, and the company would not have access to medical records, so having this contraindication is likely not a foolproof measure of protection.
As a rebuttal to the CDC concerns regarding the safety of the placenta encapsulation process, the APPA twice cites research out of Jena University in Germany performed by Dr. Sophia Johnson. They claim that this research demonstrated “that in properly prepared placenta capsules, there were no unsafe organisms found.” They add that the study also found levels of potential toxins such as heavy metals to be safe.
I looked into this research and found it to be extremely unimpressive. The experiment, was funded through public donations in a manner similar to GoFundMe. This doesn’t invalidate it, I merely point this out because I wasn’t aware of this concept.
The research, which hasn’t been published or even presented anywhere, is very preliminary. Furthermore, it only involved collection of 6 placentas, each of which was divided into half, with one half being frozen and the other dehydrated. But their preliminary report mentioned comparing raw placenta to placenta that was dehydrated alone or exposed to steam followed by dehydration. So I’m not sure exactly how they divided up the samples, and ultimately they still only had 6.
According to the preliminary results, dehydration reduced bacteria counts but not as effectively as steam followed by dehydration. This makes sense, but still it’s only 6 samples and this can’t necessarily be generalized to all placenta encapsulation facilities. Of note, they found that there were significant reductions in all hormones in the steamed samples, a little nugget conveniently not included in the APPA response.
Final thoughts
Don’t eat your placenta. It’s ridiculous. There is absolutely no proven benefit, and very little plausibility to any of the theoretical benefits. And it may increase your child’s risk of developing a serious bacterial infection. But if you insist on practicing placentophagy, at least make sure it’s well done.
.

Eggs and Atherosclerosis
Steven Novella on August 15, 2012
Link
The headline of a recent Los Angeles Times article is, “No yolk: eating the whole egg as dangerous as smoking?” The question mark is meant to convey uncertainty or surprise, or perhaps both. The article represents much of what is wrong with science and health reporting by mainstream media.
The news report is based upon an article published in Atherosclerosis – Egg yolk consumption and carotid plaque. The study is highly problematic in ways not explored at all in the LA Times article. The researchers surveyed 1,262 patients seen in a vascular prevention clinic, asking them about their egg consumption, smoking history, and other lifestyle factors. They created a measure known as “egg yolk years” – the number of egg yolks consumed on average per week times the number of years of consumption. They compared this to pack years of smoking – packs per day times number of years, a routine method of reporting smoking history.
Their conclusion:
“Our findings suggest that regular consumption of egg yolk should be avoided by persons at risk of cardiovascular disease. This hypothesis should be tested in a prospective study with more detailed information about diet, and other possible confounders such as exercise and waist circumference.”
The LA times times used this as their money quote:
“We believe our study makes it imperative to reassess the role of egg yolks, and dietary cholesterol in general, as a risk factor for coronary heart disease,” the study authors write.
The authors feel the role of dietary cholesterol needs to be reassessed because current evidence does not support a significant role for dietary cholesterol in heart disease, but more on that below.
The weaknesses of this study include the fact that it is retrospective and based on survey data, which is notoriously inaccurate. Further, it is an observational study and therefore there are many confounding factors that are not controlled for. Perhaps people who eat more egg yolks also eat more bacon, or have a generally poorer diet, or don’t exercise as much. The authors acknowledge this in their last line about needed a prospective study that controls for possible confounding factors.
But the data in the study is even more problematic, in my opinion. The article itself is behind a paywall, but here is table two containing the key data.
A	B	C	D	E	
Egg yolk years	<50	50-110	110-150	150-200	>200
Age at first visit	55.70	57.97	56.82	64.55	69.77
Eggs per week	0.41	1.37	2.30	2.76	4.68
Total cholesterol	4.93	4.94	5.00	4.90	4.81
Triglycerides	1.88	1.84	1.96	1.94	1.85
HDL	1.34	1.33	1.33	1.29	1.35
LDL	2.76	2.75	2.81	2.73	2.67
BMI	27.62	27.42	28.71	27.00	26.31
Smoking (pack years)	14.14	14.37	16.57	13.88	17.00
Female	48.60%	51.70%	44.80%	45.00%	46.70%
Diabetic	11.80%	14.50%	11.80%	13.40%	14.60%
Plaque area (mm2)	101.45	110.35	113.58	135.76	175.77
The table does indeed show a significant increase in carotid plague, the build up of cholesterol on the inner lining of the main arteries that feed the brain, with increase in egg yolk years. There are significant confounders and contradictions in the data as well, however. The most glaring to me is that total cholesterol, triglycerides, HDL and LDL do not vary significantly across the egg yolk years columns. Apparently what the authors have shown (which is consistent with previous data) is that eating lots of eggs does not increase total cholesterol or bad cholesterol (LDL) nor does it decrease good cholesterol (HDL). In my mind this leaves the authors completely without a mechanism to explain a causal relationship between egg consumption and carotid plaque. This strongly suggests the association is not causal but is incidental or spurious – unless an alternate mechanism can be proposed and supported by evidence.
Further, egg yolk consumption was associated with increased age at first presentation (a known significant risk factor) and pack years of smoking (although inconsistently). The authors say that the association between egg yolks and carotid plaques remained significant even after adjusting for risk factors and for age. However, these associations suggest the probable existence of other factors not controlled for.
Overall the data are not very compelling. The lack of correlation with cholesterol is most damning, in my opinion.
The story of eggs, cholesterol, and vascular disease is actually a bit complex. Recent studies are all over the place in terms of correlations. This recent study, for example, shows that eating eggs increases HDL and improves the cholesterol profile. A recent review also concludes:
Egg intake has been shown to promote the formation of large LDL and HDL subclasses in addition to shifting individuals from the LDL pattern B to pattern A, which is less atherogenic. For these reasons, dietary recommendations aimed at restricting egg consumption should be taken with caution and not include all individuals. We need to acknowledge that diverse healthy populations experience no risk in developing coronary heart disease by increasing their intake of cholesterol but in contrast, they may have multiple beneficial effects by the inclusion of eggs in their regular diet.
Another study found no association between egg consumption and cholesterol or mortality in men but did find an increase for women. And yet another study finds an increased risk for vascular disease from high cholesterol and lipid diets in the older population, especially diabetics.
A 2001 BMJ systematic review of fat and cardiovascular disease concluded:
There is a small but potentially important reduction in cardiovascular risk with reduction or modification of dietary fat intake, seen particularly in trials of longer duration.
A 2012 review concluded:
The findings are suggestive of a small but potentially important reduction in cardiovascular risk on modification of dietary fat, but not reduction of total fat, in longer trials. Lifestyle advice to all those at risk of cardiovascular disease and to lower risk population groups, should continue to include permanent reduction of dietary saturated fat and partial replacement by unsaturates. The ideal type of unsaturated fat is unclear.
My conclusion is that the topic is very complicated and the current data is a bit unclear. There does seem to be a consistent signal in the research data that high LDL and triglycerides and low HDL are risk factors for vascular disease, especially when combined with other risk factors. Improving the lipid profile through diet, exercise, and medication is beneficial to vascular risk.
The dietary recommendations are a bit complex, though. Reducing total fat 1980s style is probably not a good idea, as the reduction in good cholesterol probably more than outweighs the reduction in bad cholesterol. Further, the dietary contribution to lipid profile for most people is probable mild (unless you have an extreme diet). Avoiding trans fats and minimizing saturated fats seems to be supported by the evidence.
Overall, if you have a balanced diet and avoid extremes and exercise regularly you are probably OK. Further tweaking your diet is unlikely to produce large health benefits. If you are in a high risk group, such as diabetics, you need to be more specific about your eating habits, and should consult with your physician.
With respect to eggs specifically, it seems that moderate consumption of eggs are not a health risk and may even be beneficial. It is reasonable, based on the data, to avoid extreme high egg consumption – but you can probably say that about most things.
When it comes to diet the rule of thumb, everything in moderation, seems to be a good first approximation of the scientific data.

The Skinny on Saturated Fat
The bottom line is that there are trade-offs and complexities when it comes to biology. A high carbohydrate diet is a risk factor for many diseases, and this is highly genetically variable. Types of sugar matter, weight matters, exercise matters, and genetics matter. The same is true of fat.
Steven Novella on June 28, 2017
Link

Last week I wrote about the latest American Heart Association (AHA) guidelines and their warning that a recent “health food” fad, coconut oil, is actually not good for your health. There has been a lot of reaction to this report, however, reigniting the public controversy over the true health risks of fat vs sugar.
The traditional camp, the one represented by the AHA, is that diets high in fat, particularly saturated fat, contribute to atherosclerosis and heart disease. The alternate view, perhaps epitomized by journalist Gary Taubes, is that fat in food is fine; it is sugar that is the real health risk. I think the public controversy is out of proportion to the real underlying scientific debate, but there is room for debate here because there is evidence on both sides and that evidence is ambiguous.
What we do know
I often like to begin discussions of disagreement with what we can consider common ground. In this case there isn’t much common ground, because even the most basic pillars of understanding cardiovascular disease (CVD) are challenged in some circles. But there is a strong consensus that vascular disease is largely caused by high cholesterol in the blood which leads to build up of fat in the inner lining of blood vessels (atherosclerosis). This fat buildup can restrict the flow of blood through vessels. Also, the resulting plaques can rupture, forming a crater that then becomes a location where platelets can build up, forming a blood clot that acutely blocks the artery (causing a stroke or heart attack, depending on which artery is affected).
This, of course, is not the entire picture. High blood pressure is also a risk factor for CVD and stroke, as is diabetes (correlating with high blood sugar and high insulin levels). Inflammation is also playing a role. Further, not everyone is the same. Genetics plays a huge role in vascular risk and the response to other risk factors.
I also think there is broad agreement that maintaining a lean body mass and regular exercise reduce the risk of vascular disease. 
The role of diet
Once we start getting into diet, however, the controversy begins. Over the years the AHA recommendations have shifted, as new evidence came in. The classic view was that high fat and high cholesterol diets contributed to high serum cholesterol and therefore vascular risk. In the 1980s, if you are old enough to remember, there was a low-cholesterol craze. However, later research showed the dietary cholesterol was not really an independent risk factor for vascular disease. While it did increase total cholesterol somewhat, it increases both LDL (bad fat) and HDL (good fat) in the blood without changing the ratio, which appears to be the main factor in terms of risk.
There isn’t as much discussion about cholesterol anymore. The debate now focuses on fat in the diet. It’s clear that the old recommendation of an overall low-fat diet were too simplistic. There are different kinds of fat, as I mentioned above. LDL transports fat from the liver to the blood vessel walls, while HDL transports fat from the blood vessels to the liver. Therefore, LDL bad, and HDL good.
So the question became – which kinds of dietary fats increase LDL and/or lower HDL? The current consensus, represented by the AHA, is that saturated fats, trans-fats, and hydrogenated fats all increase LDL. Polyunsaturated fats increase HDL. Monounsaturated fats may increase HDL a bit, but not as much as polyunsaturated, and perhaps not enough to have a health impact.
There is ongoing debate about the relative impact of LDL vs HDL and their ratio. Coconut oil, for example, is high in saturated fat, and increases both LDL and HDL. The AHA recommendation to avoid coconut oil comes from evidence that raising LDL has more of an impact of vascular risk than raising HDL.
There is not that much controversy over the relationship between saturated and polyunsaturated fats and LDL/HDL profiles. The real controversy is over the impact this has on vascular risk, and that was the focus of much of the backlash against the AHA report. Critics argue that the evidence for a net health benefit (longer survival, for example) from lowering dietary saturated fat is slim.
Here is a 2015 systematic review. The authors concluded:
The findings of this updated review are suggestive of a small but potentially important reduction in cardiovascular risk on reduction of saturated fat intake. Replacing the energy from saturated fat with polyunsaturated fat appears to be a useful strategy, and replacement with carbohydrate appears less useful, but effects of replacement with monounsaturated fat were unclear due to inclusion of only one small trial.
They further reported in the results:
Subgrouping and meta-regression suggested that the degree of reduction in cardiovascular events was related to the degree of reduction of serum total cholesterol, and there were suggestions of greater protection with greater saturated fat reduction or greater increase in polyunsaturated and monounsaturated fats. There was no evidence of harmful effects of reducing saturated fat intakes on cancer mortality, cancer diagnoses or blood pressure, while there was some evidence of improvements in weight and BMI.
These conclusions match the more recent AHA review of the evidence. However, those in the camp that believe sugar is the culprit and fat is not a real risk factor point to this part of the review:
The included long-term trials suggested that reducing dietary saturated fat reduced the risk of cardiovascular events by 17% (risk ratio (RR) 0.83; 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.72 to 0.96, 13 comparisons, 53,300 participants of whom 8% had a cardiovascular event, I² 65%, GRADE moderate quality of evidence), but effects on all-cause mortality (RR 0.97; 95% CI 0.90 to 1.05; 12 trials, 55,858 participants) and cardiovascular mortality (RR 0.95; 95% CI 0.80 to 1.12, 12 trials, 53,421 participants) were less clear (both GRADE moderate quality of evidence).
They characterize this evidence as slim. This, of course, is a subjective judgement. That is the whole point of having panels of experts review the evidence – we want their subjective judgment. I can also give you mine, from an SBM perspective. In the case of saturated fat, there is a highly plausible mechanism, and there is a clear and consistent signal in the evidence that saturated fat raises LDL, and increases the risk for heart disease. Further, there is often uncertainty with these kinds of studies because we are trying to track uncommon events. This requires very large studies over long periods of time, often just to obtain barely statistical results. There also seems to be a dose-response effect in the evidence, which further supports a true causal connection.
So I would say that the conclusion that saturated fat is a significant risk factor for cardiovascular disease is plausible and probable. Further, there seems to be little risk in exchanging saturated fat for polyunsaturated fat. Therefore, a risk-benefit analysis favors a diet that replaces saturated fat with polyunsaturated fat to a significant degree.
The anti-sugar crowd, however, differs from this consensus opinion. They focus on the uncertainty in this data. They blame the AHA’s conclusions on their historic bias against fat, but that judgement does not seem justified. There are numerous reviews by independent experts all coming to the same conclusion. Part of the reason they want to exonerate saturated fat is because they advocate a very low carbohydrate diet, which means you need to have more calories from fat and protein. It would be simpler to advocate for such a diet if dietary fat were not a real risk factor.
There is some mainstream dissent from the AHA, however. Here is a 2016 review of the relative role of sugar and fat in the diet:
This paper reviews the evidence linking saturated fats and sugars to CHD, and concludes that the latter is more of a problem than the former. Dietary guidelines should shift focus away from reducing saturated fat, and from replacing saturated fat with carbohydrates, specifically when these carbohydrates are refined.
This seems to be a bit of a strawman, however, since the reviews and guidelines show that replacing saturated fat with sugar has no health advantage. They recommend replacing saturated fat with polyunsaturated fat. Limiting refined and simple sugars in the diet is also part of the standard guidelines.
In both cases, fat and sugar, the guidelines have moved away from worrying about the total amount of fat vs sugar in the diet to focusing on the type of fat and type of sugar. There is further nuance, as the 2016 review does state, in that different sources of saturated fat have different effects on LDL and HDL and affect people differently based on their genetics. We are drilling down pretty far into the details. You also have to consider the effect of dietary changes on body mass index (BMI) and the secondary effects from that.
The bottom line is that there are trade-offs and complexities when it comes to biology. A high carbohydrate diet is a risk factor for many diseases, and this is highly genetically variable. Types of sugar matter, weight matters, exercise matters, and genetics matter. The same is true of fat.
All of this can be overwhelming and leave the average consumer confused and without clear direction on how best to optimize their diet for health. This often leads to latching onto a simplistic narrative (such as fat bad, or sugar bad) that can be counterproductive. So while understanding the nuance is important and affects our recommendations, we also have to be careful about how we translate this nuance into lifestyle advice. Giving people too much complexity can lead to bad decision-making.
Most people will be best served from the basic advice to eat a varied diet, eat plenty of fruits and vegetables, exercise regularly, and maintain a healthy weight. As long as you avoid extreme diets, that basic advice will get you most of the way to an optimal diet. I also think the overall evidence supports avoiding too many saturated fats, and using oils that are higher in polyunsaturated fats. And avoid too many refined and simple sugars. Part of the problem is that some people will start using coconut oil, thinking it is a superfood, instead of making the more basic adjustments to their diet and lifestyle. There are no superfoods. As one of my med school lecturers put it – you can’t sprinkle fish oil on your steak and think it’s healthy. Take care of the basics first.
I do not think the evidence supports any extreme diet, such as a low carbohydrate or low fat diet. Balanced macronutrients from a varied diet is likely best.

Of Mice and Men…and Coconut Oil
Grant Ritchey on December 18, 2015
Link

Editor’s note: This post is a collaborative effort between Grant Ritchey, a Science-Based Medicine semi-regular, and Stephanie Tornberg-Belanger, a co-author of the research paper discussed below and who brought the study to Grant’s attention. We are pleased to welcome Stephanie as a guest contributor to SBM.


In his last SBM post, Grant reported on a systematic review of the literature that undermined just about everything dentists had been taught in dental school and have been preaching to patients since The Olden Times: flossing, as it turns out, is not the be-all, end-all that we’ve been led to believe with regard to cavity and gum disease prevention. While the message itself was interesting and relevant, the meta-message in that piece is that we all must be willing to slay our own sacred cows when the evidence demands it, even if it requires shedding long-held, cherished beliefs. This is difficult for any human being to do, and skeptics who are presumably open minded are no different (and can sometimes be worse, because we are often overconfidently convinced of our “rightness”).
So with that in mind, gather ’round children, because we have another meta-message for you. This one deals with coconut oil.
(Pause for gasps.)
If you just had a visceral negative reaction at the mention of coconut oil within the venerable halls of SBM headquarters as we did, then we hope you’ll stick around for the entire blog post. Coconut oil is pervasive in the alt-med world, a virtual panacea, ostensibly showing benefits against heart disease, helping with weight loss, “boosting” the immune system (see figure above), and in dentistry, pulling out dreaded toxins, among many, many other maladies – the CAM counterpoint to the cause of all disease. It even raises your body temperature! (Isn’t that called a “fever?”) So naturally (pun intended) many of us tend to summarily reject any health claims involving coconut oil, because after all, they have to be ineffective treatments if they are recommended by the likes of woomeisters such as Oz and Mercola, right?
Well, not so fast there.
A recently published research paper of which Stephanie is among the co-authors demonstrates the effectiveness of coconut oil in the treatment gastrointestinal candidiasis (a fungal or “yeast” infection) in mice. Whether this will eventually translate into a safe and effective treatment for humans remains to be seen, but the research – even if it does contain the words “coconut oil” – is worth considering and not dismissing it out of hand. And the lessons we learn from it can serve us well into the future.
A fungus among us
Candida albicans is a microscopic fungus which is part of normal human flora. However, given the opportunity (such as in premature infants, uncontrolled diabetics, long term antibiotic use, immunocompromised persons, etc.), C. albicans infection is capable of causing pathologies ranging from mild oral thrush to systematic disseminated candidiasis, which is why it is labeled an “opportunistic pathogen.” Fungal infections are difficult to treat, and because C. albicans can be fatal, there has been interest in reducing the fungus through dietary means rather than resorting to pharmaceutical antifungals as a first line of treatment. (It’s also a favorite fake disease among CAM purveyors and supplement salespeople.)
A recent publication from a collaborative research effort (including Stephanie) at Tufts University, investigated the effect of coconut oil on gastrointestinal candidiasis in a mouse model. The research team found a significant reduction in the gut colonization of C. albicans in mice fed a diet high in coconut oil versus diets high in soybean oil or beef fat. To look into this effect further, they fed mice diets high in beef tallow then changed to the high coconut oil diet after two weeks, and a reduction in C. albicans was still observed. Even when feeding mice a diet with an equal combination of coconut oil and beef tallow there was a reduction of gastrointestinal candidiasis in the mice. This demonstrated that something in the coconut oil had an anti-fungal effect; it wasn’t a function of the other dietary components and could still be effective in the presence of other dietary components.
Looking into the molecular biology of the coconut oil’s mechanism of action, there is good explanatory plausibility for the results they obtained that has nothing to do with some magic natural essence of coconut oil. The expression of genes used to break down fatty acids in C. albicans exposed to coconut oil versus those exposed to beef tallow was lower, which supports the findings seen from the gut colonization in the mice. C. albicans is able to utilize fatty acids as a carbon source for fuel; decreased ability to metabolize fatty acids not only reduces its ability to obtain nourishment to grow and reproduce, it can also reduce its virulence. In addition, medium chain fatty acids such as lauric acid and decanoic acid, which are present in relatively high concentrations in coconut oil, have previously been shown to have fungicidal effects in vitro. All of these results put together show an exciting potential for using coconut oil as a dietary intervention to inhibit C. albicans. It should be emphasized that these effects must be replicated in humans; just because Minnie and Mickey’s candidiasis can be managed with coconut oil doesn’t necessarily mean Grandma and Grandpa’s can. This point cannot be emphasized enough. To take the next step in this line of inquiry, two of the authors have joined with a neonatologist in proposing a clinical trial looking at the reproducibility of reducing gastrointestinal candidiasis in premature newborns, a population at increased risk of severe fungal infections. In addition to the limitations presented using animal models or in vitro studies, the diets the authors fed the mice accounted for more calories from fat than recommended by the USDA. Though populations at high risk for C. albicans infections may not run a risk of long term heart disease problems when using coconut oil as a short term prophylactic intervention, there may be a cardiovascular risk to people who choose to consume a lifetime diet high in fat to prevent conditions which they may not be at risk for. Therefore, should this research pan out for humans, the active ingredients (possibly the aforementioned lauric acid and/or decanoic acid, but that remains to be confirmed) theoretically could be isolated and developed into a medicinal form for use in patients.
When worlds collide
This blog post is a bit different than most found in SBM, because the story really isn’t the story. I hope we’ve made it abundantly clear that this is preliminary research that, while interesting and promising, may or may not apply to humans. A lot more research has to take place before that can even be considered. But that’s beside the point. Our goal was not to tout the potential benefits of coconut oil. Rather, our take home message here is two-fold:
    • Primary research is just that – primary. Its aim is to show proof of concept, generate new questions and hypotheses, and to lay the fundamental groundwork for later studies. Scientific medicine knows this and acts accordingly; alternative practitioners often tout primary research as definitive, often basing treatment recommendations upon it. They stretch the data well beyond what it’s qualified to show, inferring what shouldn’t be inferred. Mice aren’t people; sometimes murine models translate to humans, sometimes they don’t.
    • Next, just because you are a science-based individual, do not automatically and summarily reject research just because it has alt med “trigger words” such as coconut oil, herb, or plectum as the object of study. Of course, biological plausibility must be taken into consideration first; don’t waste your time seeing if something will work until you know if it can work. Do your due diligence to see if the research was well done and if the data support the conclusions the authors make instead of the authors trying to use the data to support an agenda or worldview. The best way to arm yourself in this area is to learn how to read and understand a scientific paper if you don’t already know how to do so. Accept legitimate findings tentatively, contingent upon further confirmatory and expansionary research.
“Be skeptical. But when you get proof, accept proof.” ~Michael Specter
And lest we are misinterpreted, misquoted, or in any other way misrepresented, we also want to go on record as to what we don’t mean to say or imply:
    • We are not saying to give every woo therapy “equal time” in the marketplace of ideas. Most ineffective alt-med therapies have been marginalized for good reason.
“The weight of evidence for an extraordinary claim must be proportioned to its strangeness.” ~ LaPlace
However, one must be intellectually nimble enough to give oneself cognitive wiggle room to entertain plausible possibilities and if the evidence warrants, one must accept the finding, no matter how unpalatable it might seem.
    • We are not saying that coconut oil can treat candidiasis in humans. The research Stephanie was part of shows plausibility and justifies future study into the matter, possibly leading to research and clinical trials in humans. If those trials pass rigorous standards, there could even be a product developed for use in people, one that has gone through the proper channels to demonstrate safety and efficacy. And we can be relatively certain that should said product come to marketplace, it will not be just a matter of slamming down a few shots of coconut oil. Just as we take aspirin instead of chewing on willow bark and we take penicillin tablets instead of slurping down a petri dish full of mold, the active ingredient(s) in the coconut oil could be identified, purified, and standardized for maximum efficacy, safety, and quality control in manufacturing. But we’re getting way ahead of ourselves and we’ll cross that bridge if and when we get to it. In the meantime, if you read a report that claims that it is effective in humans, you can be assured that you are being quack’D.
With great power…
Sadly, but not surprisingly, the alt-medders have already seized this paper and are using it to tout it as a “natural” cure for “Candida overgrowth,” an alt-med term for the cause of almost all human ailments (including cancer). When they cite “a Tufts University study,” it adds unearned and undeserved legitimacy to their claims, which can deceive the non-SBM layperson. They are likely also using it to help sell their products on their woobsites. Unfortunately for Stephanie and her co-authors, their names will forever be cited in the alt-mediverse. Do not hold this against them.
Sometimes worlds do collide. There can be quite a bit of overlap between the “natural” medicine world and the “conventional” medicine one. However, all of it has to be vetted the same way and if it works, it’s medicine; if it doesn’t, it isn’t. It’s that simple. The easy thing for a person to do is to prejudge and to decide what is woo and what isn’t based upon preconceived notions, not evidence. We need to avoid that fallacy.

Coconut Oil
Is coconut oil a miracle food, or a health hazard? Likely neither.
Harriet Hall on May 28, 2013
Link
In a former life, when I was an Air Force doctor, one of my duties was to give “Healthy Heart” briefings with a script furnished by Air Force experts. It covered the scientific consensus of the time (the early 80s) about diet. It recommended a low fat diet, restricted cholesterol and saturated fat, and demonized tropical oils like palm oil and coconut oil. (Trans fats weren’t yet on the agenda.)
Times have changed. Today we are more lenient about cholesterol in the diet, less concerned about total fat and saturated fat, and more concerned about trans fats. While many major health organizations still discourage its use, coconut oil has not only been rehabilitated in the public mind, but all kinds of health benefits are being claimed for it.
The fats in coconut oil
Coconut oil is high in saturated fats; it contains more saturated fatty acids than any other non-hydrogenated oil. It is stable and has a long shelf life. It is used in movie theaters to pop popcorn and in South Asian cuisine for dishes like curries. A hydrogenated version of coconut oil is an ingredient in non-dairy creamers. Much of the research done on coconut oil studied hydrogenated or partially hydrogenated forms. According to an article in The New York Times:
Partial hydrogenation creates dreaded trans fats. It also destroys many of the good essential fatty acids, antioxidants and other positive components present in virgin coconut oil. And while it’s true that most of the fats in virgin coconut oil are saturated, opinions are changing on whether saturated fats are the arterial villains they were made out to be. “I think we in the nutrition field are beginning to say that saturated fats are not so bad, and the evidence that said they were is not so strong,” Dr. Brenna said.
Coconut oil contains lauric acid, which raises both HDL and LDL cholesterol levels. This may improve the cholesterol profile, although there are concerns that it may promote atherosclerosis by other means. Virgin coconut oil contains medium-chain triglycerides, which are not as risky as some other saturated fats.
Health claims
Any number of health claims have been made for lauric acid. According to proponents, it’s a wonder substance with possible antibacterial, antimicrobial, antiviral properties that could also, in theory, combat HIV, clear up acne and speed up your metabolism. Researchers are skeptical:
“There are a lot of claims that coconut oil may have health benefits, but there is no concrete scientific data yet to support this,” said Dr. Daniel Hwang, a research molecular biologist specializing in lauric acid at the Western Human Nutrition Research Center at the University of California, Davis.
The hype comes from unreliable sources. Joe Mercola says it is the smartest choice for cooking, is good for your heart, contains the kind of fat found in mothers’ milk, enhances immunity, and helps with weight loss by stimulating metabolism. And of course he sells it. Dr. Oz says it is a heart healthy food that helps resist viruses, bacteria, yeast, fungi, and candida; boosts thyroid function; improves blood sugar control and reduces the need for insulin; increases energy and endurance; increases digestion and improves absorption of vitamins; lowers cholesterol; helps control weight; has anti-aging effects; is good for skin and hair; and is quite safe to take in reasonable amounts. The Wellness Mama website lists 101 uses for coconut oil, including treating sunburns, athlete’s foot, Alzheimer’s disease, nasal allergies, arthritis, insomnia, autism, heartburn, hemorrhoids, depression, acne, cellulite, mosquito bites, and lice.
Alzheimer’s disease
The Wellness Mama website provides a link to a reference for Alzheimer’s disease but it is only a case study showing that the writer’s husband improved and was able to draw a more accurate picture of a clock after adding coconut oil to his diet. Natural News says coconut oil can prevent and reverse Alzheimer’s. Naturopath Bruce Fife has several books touting the benefits of coconut oil and coconut water. One title claims you can “Stop Alzheimer’s Now!”
A clinical query search for “Alzheimer’s coconut oil” on PubMed yielded no results. Snopes has evaluated the claims for coconut oil and agrees that “there are no peer-reviewed articles addressing research on coconut oil as a treatment for Alzheimer’s disease.” Even the Alzheimer’s Association says: “A few people have reported that coconut oil helped the person with Alzheimer’s, but there’s never been any clinical testing of coconut oil for Alzheimer’s, and there’s no scientific evidence that it helps.”
Coconut water
The liquid inside a coconut is being promoted as a sports drink and as a miracle food. They claim it is so compatible with the human body that it can be infused directly into the bloodstream (indeed, it is likely sterile and there are reports of its use as an intravenous fluid substitute in emergencies when medical saline was unavailable). As with coconut oil, there are a few suggestive studies in animals and test tubes, but no credible evidence for clinical benefits in humans.
Conclusion: Neither demon nor angel
Coconut oil is probably not as bad as once thought, but it’s no “miracle” food either. It is probably safe to use it in reasonable amounts to replace other oils in the diet, and doing so may have a favorable effect on lipid profiles; but it’s not clear whether that will actually reduce the risk of cardiovascular events. There is no justification for adding it to the diet on top of the usual consumption of other fats. There is no credible evidence to support any of the many health benefits claimed for using it as a supplement.

Coconut Oil Warning
Coconut oil is promoted as a health food, but a recent warning from the American Heart Association warns that coconut oil is very high in saturated fats and increases your risk for heart disease.
Steven Novella on June 21, 2017
Link

Coconut oil is currently enjoying its 15 minutes of fame as the popular natural cure of the day. As is typical, this is based entirely on marketing, and not on science. As a result the public is largely misinformed about the net health effects of consuming coconut oil.
The American Heart Association recently put out a presidential advisory in which they discuss all aspects of fat consumption and heart risk. While it is only one small part of the advisory, the section on coconut oil is getting the most attention because of the disconnect between the science and public opinion. In fact they report that 72% of the public, when surveyed, expressed the belief that coconut oil was a “healthy food.” This compared to 37% of nutritionists (which, unfortunately, means that a third of nutritionists don’t seem to know what they are talking about).
This disconnect is clearly due to the marketing of coconut oil as a natural health food. There is a deeper cause, however, rooted in differences in interpreting the scientific literature. Health gurus (which I will distinguish from science-based nutritionists) tend to interpret the literature is a very superficial way. They take basic science studies and then extrapolate the findings simplistically to clinical effects. We have a vast scientific experience, however, that clearly indicates this is not a valid approach. Such simplistic extrapolations are almost certainly going to be wrong. Science-based professionals take a different approach – they systematically review at the evidence and think carefully about what it actually shows, what we can and cannot conclude. They give special weight to clinical studies that directly compare interventions and specific clinical outcomes.
There is also a cynical aspect to the marketing of “natural” cures and products. There is a lot of money to be made from marketing snake oil, which is a marketer’s dream. You can make up compelling health claims based on flimsy evidence and implausible or simplistic chains of reasoning, and then market cheap products with hefty price tags. Sometimes this is done explicitly, meaning that first a snake oil peddler will secure a supply of some exotic berry or nut, or even some waste or low quality food product – something they can buy cheap and in bulk, with little market value. They then manufacture bogus health claims for their product and promote them through health gurus and a willing media happy for the click-bait headlines that result.
Often the bad science and the cynical marketing work synergistically.
Meanwhile the actual scientific research may take years to catch up. It takes time to do the kinds of studies that will actually answer the question of health effects. But by then the public has already been marketed into true believers. Antioxidant hype is still going strong, despite the fact that the scientific evidence has failed to show any health benefit for antioxidant products. If enthusiasm for a product wanes because evidence shows it is worthless, that’s OK too. Snake oil peddlers can just move on to the next scam.
Coconut oil and health
The claims made for coconut oil, not surprisingly, essentially portray it as a cure-all. The first hit I get when I Google “Coconut Oil” is from the Wellness Mama, who claims that coconut oil is a:
Great Source of Healthy Fats– Over 50% of the fat in coconut oil is lauric acid. In fact, coconut oil is the richest source of lauric acid after breastmilk.
This is the opposite of the truth. She also claims that coconut oil is good for digestion, supports the immune system and hormones, and boosts mental function. Other gullible sites repeat these same claims. Let’s address the “healthy fats” claim first.
This claim is based on the fact that lauric acid will increase HDL (high density lipoprotein) levels in the blood. HDL is considered “healthy” cholesterol as it does not increase the risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD). However, the most recent data shows (summarized in the AHA report) that increasing HDL alone has little health benefit. Rather, we should focus more on LDL (low density lipoprotein) which carries significant risk for CVD. Lauric acid is a saturated fat, and saturated fats increase LDL. Lauric acid specifically increases both HDL and LDL, but this has a net negative health effect – it increases the risk of CVD.
A quick biochemistry aside for those who are interested: Triglycerides have a backbone of glycerol and three fatty acid “tails.” Fatty acids contain a carboxylic acid end and a long hydrocarbon chain, which is a chain of carbon atoms with hydrogen filling all the open bonds. A saturated fatty acid is saturated with hydrogen, meaning that all the carbon bonds in the hydrocarbon chain are single bonds, and there is the maximal amount of hydrogen. Unsaturated fatty acids have one or more double bonds between carbon atoms in the chain, and therefore less hydrogen. Monounsaturated means one double bond, and polyunsaturated means more than one double bond.
In general saturated fats increase LDL and contribute to CVD, while mono and polyunsaturated fats do not.
Back to coconut oil – coconut oil is 82% saturated fat, and is therefore one of the worst possible oils you can consume. Palm oil is also 82% and is therefore also an unhealthy oil to consume. By comparison butter is 63%, pork lard is 39%, and beef fat is 50%. That’s right – coconut oil is worse than lard. On the other hand, olive oil is only 14% saturated fat, and safflower oil is the lowest at 6%.
The AHA did not stop there; they reviewed seven clinical trials that looked directly at the effects on lipid profiles of consuming coconut oil. Of the seven trials all seven showed an increase in LDL, six of them to statistical significance. Further, the increase in LDL was comparable to consuming other saturated fats, such as animal fat. That conclude that because of this, and the fact that there are no proven benefits to consuming coconut oil, they recommend people avoid coconut oil as unhealthy.
This is the opposite recommendation as that from the health gurus, because they do not understand the scientific literature and draw the wrong conclusions from partial information.
What about the anti-microbial effects of coconut oil? This is also a common health guru claim because lots of things will kill bacteria in a petri dish. That does not mean it has clinically beneficial effects. I already discussed the practice of “oil pulling”, which is swishing and rinsing the mouth with coconut oil. There is no proven benefit for this practice, although it does seem to reduce bacteria in the mouth, but no more than rinsing with standard mouth wash.
The Health Mama and other gurus claim that eating coconut oil will have an antibiotic effect. This is possible but unproven. Coconut oil may disrupt the lipid coating on some bacteria. But why would you think this is beneficial? If true, then the primary effect would be to reduce normal GI flora. This would likely be a bad thing.
It’s interesting that the health gurus generally rail against the evils of overusing antibiotics, but then recommend a “natural” antibiotic for regular use and claim that it will magically be beneficial. They can easily flip their logic when convenient.
Like all products that claim to boost the immune system, or increase antioxidant effect, or kill bacteria – either they don’t work or you don’t want them to. If they actually have the claimed effect, it is probably bad for your health. You don’t want to mess with the normal homeostasis of your immune system, nor do you want to indiscriminately kill off your normal bacterial flora. Again this reveals the difference between sloppy and simplistic thinking on the part of gurus and careful, systematic, logical and evidence-based thinking on the part of scientists.
Coconut oil is not a health food
The bottom line is that coconut oil is not a health food. It is very high in saturated fat and you should avoid consuming it in any significant quantities. If you want to use it for its cooking properties or because you like the taste, that’s fine, just consume it in moderation (like all sweet and fatty treats). But do not be confused by the misleading marketing – coconut oil is not good for your health.
The other health claims made for coconut oil are all unsupported by scientific studies and make little scientific sense. With such claims, many people err on the side of being hopeful. This is not a rational position, however. We have a century of scientific experience to tell us that when it comes to preliminary or speculative health claims, do not be hopeful, be realistic. Casino owners want their customers to be hopeful rather than realistic too. It’s good for business, but it’s not good for your health. The vast majority of such claims will not turn out to be true, and you are far more likely to harm yourself than to help yourself by basing health decisions on such evidence.

What the Health: A Movie with an Agenda
The documentary “What the Health” espouses the fairy tale that all major diseases (heart disease, diabetes, cancer, and many others) can be prevented and cured by eliminating meat and dairy from the diet. It is a blatant polemic for veganism, biased and misleading, and is not a reliable source of scientific information.
Harriet Hall on July 11, 2017
Link

Several people have asked me to review the documentary film What the Health, and it was available via my Netflix subscription, so I watched it and took notes. Its thesis is that meat and dairy are killing us and that all the major diseases can be prevented and cured by adopting a plants-only diet (claims we have seen before: here, here, and here). It features emotional testimonials and selected scientific studies; and it suggests that major health organizations and government agencies have been “bought” by Big Food and Big Pharma and are conspiring to hide the truth from the public.
It starts with Hippocrates’ aphorism “Let food be your medicine and medicine your food.” Hippocrates died in 370 B.C., before there was much in the way of effective medicine and before science had learned much about food (like the existence of vitamins). So Hippocrates is hardly a credible authority; and even if he were, the appeal to authority is a logical fallacy. The film tries to convince viewers that food is medicine, and indeed is all the medicine we need to prevent and cure obesity, diabetes, heart disease, cancer, and a host of other chronic diseases. It failed to convince me.
The filmmaker, Kip Andersen, describes himself as a former hypochondriac who once assumed that he was destined by his genetics to develop heart disease, cancer, and diabetes like others in his family. At some point in his life, he was exposed to the belief that healthy eating could prevent and cure those diseases. This was a complete revelation, and he felt betrayed. He says, “it felt like this information had been practically withheld.” He proceeded to interview doctors and others who subscribed to that belief, and to find supporting information on Google. Confirmation bias worked well, as it always does. He failed to obey my SkepDoc’s Rule: before you accept a claim, try to find out who disagrees with it and why. Most of us don’t believe all those diseases can be prevented and cured by diet, because the evidence just isn’t there.
Processed meat
He cites a summary of epidemiologic studies showing that eating a single serving of processed meat a day increases colon cancer risk by 18%. In the first place, epidemiologic studies can only show correlation, not causation. In the second place, that 18% increase is in relative risk, not absolute risk. In the third place, it doesn’t take the baseline rate of colon cancer into account. By one estimate, your risk of developing colon cancer by age 65 is 2.9% if you eat no processed meat, and 3.4% if you eat one serving a day. So out of 100 people who avoid processed meat, 2.9 will develop colon cancer, and out of 100 people who eat one serving a day, 3.4 will develop colon cancer: the difference in absolute risk is one more case of cancer out of every 200 people, which sounds much less alarming than the 18% figure. And there could be many confounding factors that would influence a person’s actual risk like genetics, salt consumption (processed meats like bacon have a high salt content), smoking, other lifestyle factors that might happen to be more common in people who eat a lot of processed meats, etc.
He makes a big deal of the IARC classification of processed meat as a Group 1 carcinogen, the same group as cigarettes, asbestos, and plutonium. The film interprets this to mean that hot dogs and bacon could be as dangerous as cigarettes, but that is simply not true. Cigarettes raise the risk of lung cancer by 1,900%! The WHO information page clearly states that classification in Group 1 is based on the strength of evidence that it causes cancer, not on the level of risk. It does NOT mean that everything in that group is equally dangerous. They concluded that processed meats cause cancer, and that there was inconclusive evidence of an association with stomach cancer.
But they did NOT recommend people stop eating meat. They explain, “Eating meat has known health benefits. Many national health recommendations advise people to limit intake of processed meat and red meat, which are linked to increased risks of death from heart disease, diabetes, and other illnesses.”
Red meat
The IARC classified red meat as a Group 2 carcinogen, but that only means that there is limited evidence for an association with colorectal cancer and possibly pancreatic and prostate cancers. They explain:
Limited evidence means that a positive association has been observed between exposure to the agent and cancer but that other explanations for the observations (technically termed chance, bias, or confounding) could not be ruled out.
Reality check: the movie presents an alarmist version of information that has been widely accepted for decades and is incorporated into nutritional guidelines. The consensus is that processed meats should be limited; but the data on unprocessed red meat is unclear. Only vegans recommend total elimination of meat.
Preventable deaths
It claims that food is the cause of most diseases, and 70% of deaths are preventable with lifestyle changes. They call obesity a “death sentence” that will certainly lead to diabetes and frequently to cancer. A recent study looked at the association between dietary factors and mortality from cardiovascular disease and diabetes. As a whole, ten dietary factors accounted for 45.4% of deaths. Only 0.4% of these deaths were associated with a high intake of unprocessed red meats, and 8.2% with a high intake of processed meats. Low intake of fruits and vegetables were associated with 7.5% and 7.6% of deaths respectively. According to the CDC, somewhere between 20% and 40% of the top five causes of death could be prevented by lifestyle changes, but not just dietary changes. Tobacco is the leading preventable cause of death, not improper diet; other important lifestyle factors are alcohol use, lack of exercise, sun exposure, and failure to use seatbelts and motorcycle helmets. The 70% estimate is an exaggeration; the true proportion of lifestyle-preventable deaths is probably less than 50%. And diet has a relatively small impact when compared to other lifestyle factors. The movie tells us dietary factors trump smoking, but that is demonstrably not true. It tells us plant-based diets will stop and reverse heart disease, and breast cancer can be prevented by diet; I wish!
Diabetes
We are in the midst of a (type II/adult-onset) diabetes epidemic. The movie tells us diabetes is not caused by sugar: meat and fat cause diabetes. It says carbs can’t make you fat; only fat can. It says the body can’t turn carbs into fat (yes, it can!). They cite a Harvard study showing that one serving of processed meats a day raises the risk of diabetes by 51%, but this 2017 systematic review says it raises the risk by 19%. And remember, this is relative risk, not absolute risk.
They say the risk of Type 1 diabetes is increased by exposure to dairy at a young age, but this study says just the opposite. Early exposure is not a risk factor, and it may actually decrease the risk. These are just two of many examples of how the movie cherry-picks studies that support its beliefs and ignores contradictory information.
Chicken
Is chicken better than meat? They say, “It’s a question of whether you’d rather be shot or hung.” They say chicken is the number one source of cholesterol in the American diet and it’s the leading source of sodium because chicken is injected with salt water. They tell us the risk of prostate cancer is four times greater with chicken. (Not true: this meta-analysis found no association.) A comedian walked out of an ADA event where they served chicken, saying it was like serving alcohol at an AA function. They say chicken is carcinogenic and fast food restaurants should be required to post that warning. But guess what? Fruits and vegetables contain carcinogens too! And they don’t recommend warning vegans about the carcinogens they are getting from plants. An obvious double standard.
Eggs
They tell us egg yolks are pure fat and cholesterol (not true; they contain half the egg’s protein along with vitamins, essential fatty acids, and other nutrients). One “expert” tells us egg yolk coats our red blood cells (!?), makes our blood thicker, and alters hormone levels. They claim that eating one egg decreases longevity as much as smoking 5 cigarettes. I doubt that.
Cheese
They tell us cheese is one of the worst foods; they describe it as “coagulated cow pus.” It is addictive, metabolizing to a compound that attaches to heroin receptors in the brain. It may cause SIDS and autism. 450 drugs are given to animals, and companies hide information about what is in their products.
Fish
They claim that diet guidelines are wrong to suggest replacing meat with fish. Fish is full of mercury, PCBs, cholesterol, pesticides, herbicides, and hormone disruptors. Farmed fish contains antibiotics and antifungals.
Milk
They claim that cow’s milk is “terrifying.” It’s full of bad things like saturated fat, cholesterol, and pus. A pediatrician tells us it gives children eczema, acne, constipation, acid reflux, and iron deficiency anemia. He calls it the most allergenic food. Dairy is linked to many types of cancer, as well as asthma, MS, type I diabetes, mucous, and autoimmune and rheumatologic diseases. Milk doesn’t build strong bones: people who drink milk have more fractures and don’t live as long. We are not supposed to drink milk: lactose intolerance is the norm for adults. African Americans have a high prevalence of lactose intolerance. The government encourages them to drink milk knowing it will make them sick; this amounts to “institutionalized racism.” They also mention racism in conjunction with runoff and spraying on pig farms, claiming the pollution is greater where there are African American communities.
Miscellaneous other questionable claims
Eating “dead meat bacteria toxins” causes an immediate burst of inflammation, causing immediate damage within minutes, stiffening our arteries and reducing their ability to relax by half (?!). Meat eating causes brain damage that is misdiagnosed as Alzheimer’s. Mad cow disease is killing people and the government won’t admit it. Many studies are funded by the dairy, egg, and meat industries in order to deliberately create doubt as the tobacco industry did when it said “doubt is our product.” Government diet recommendations come from a panel stacked with industry representatives. The government imprisons people who go against them, and even criminalizes people for simply taking a picture or recording what goes on in the animal industry. Whistleblowers are silenced by “ag-gag” laws. Apparently, the government is in collusion with Big Pharma, Big Food, and organizations like the ADA and the ACA; they’re all motivated by making money, not by keeping people healthy. We are anatomically frugivores (fruit eaters), not omnivores: you can tell because we don’t have the kind of teeth required for a carnivore to rip, tear, and bite its prey to death. (They forget that we have brains and tools that equip us to hunt, kill, and cook meat without any need for fangs or claws.) Further proof that we are frugivores is that we find fruit smoothies more palatable than blenderized meat!
Doctor-bashing
They are very critical of conventional medicine. They bring up the same lame doctor-bashing tropes we have debunked so many times. Doctors aren’t interested in prevention (nonsense! They invented prevention). Doctors don’t consider the underlying causes of disease (they always do, whenever there is evidence for an underlying cause). Doctors condemn patients to lifelong medication; if you take their advice, you’ll never get well (if you take their advice, you may not be cured from an incurable disease, but you’ll live longer). People who take statins still get heart attacks (true, but they get fewer of them). Doctors don’t learn about nutrition (nonsense, they understand the principles but they leave individual diet advice to the dietitians). Big Pharma and doctors have a vested interest in keeping people sick (but even if they didn’t care about their patients, surely they would have a vested interest in staying healthy themselves and keeping their loved ones healthy).
Phoning the American Cancer Society and others
In the first of several phone call vignettes, the filmmaker, Kip Andersen, calls the American Cancer Society to ask why they don’t warn about the dangers of meat on their home page. He is put on hold, but is eventually granted an interview. The interview is cancelled and the ACA stops responding when they realize he only wants to argue with them about diet and cancer. I’m not surprised. Their recommendations are based on expert evaluation of all the published evidence and they are not likely to change their minds because a single nonscientist with an agenda walks in off the street to argue with them.
The phone call gimmick is repeated for the American Diabetes Association. He wants to know why they don’t clearly state on their home page that meat causes diabetes, and how dare they include a recipe for bacon-wrapped shrimp! He eventually is able to interview an ADA spokesman who very reasonably tells him there is insufficient evidence that diet can cure diabetes, and says “We recommend a healthy diet.” He acknowledges that there are studies, but points out that many of them have never been replicated or are wrong; that’s why we do peer review. Andersen keeps bringing up individual studies until the spokesman loses patience and stops the interview, saying he doesn’t want to get into an argument. Andersen interprets this to mean that the ADA is not interested in prevention or cure.
Then he calls the American Heart Association to ask why they include beef and egg recipes. He gets a similar response. He interprets these failed phone call inquiries as stonewalling and an organized effort to conceal the truth. He discovers that the ACA, ADA, AHA and other mainstream organizations are funded in part by food manufacturers like Dannon, Kraft, Tyson, and fast food restaurant chains like KFC. He says we can’t trust them because they’re taking money from the companies that are causing the very diseases they are trying to prevent.
As an analogy, I couldn’t help wondering how the American Academy of Pediatrics would respond to a random phone call demanding that their home page warn that vaccines may cause autism and complaining that doctors can’t be trusted because they are paid by the Big Pharma companies that sell vaccines. I wouldn’t blame them for hanging up.
Benefits of a vegan diet
The American Dietetic Association issued a statement on vegetarian/vegan diets, listing a number of health benefits, but pointing out the variability of dietary practices and the need to individually assess nutritional adequacy.
The movie claims that patients crippled with rheumatoid arthritis can go off their meds, but this systematic review concluded that the effects of dietary interventions for RA were uncertain
Many of the arguments for veganism are not health-related but moral. Animals suffer from being confined, conditions are unsanitary, they produce greenhouse gases and are bad for the environment.
Testimonials
They interview people who have gone vegan and whose testimonials I find simply unbelievable. An obese woman saw her doctor for asthma; after a CRP test (not indicated!) her doctor supposedly told her she was “on the verge of a heart attack in 30 days.” I find it hard to believe any doctor would make that prediction. She allegedly experienced complete relief of her asthma and chronic pain after only two weeks on a plant-based diet; she was able to go off all her meds for asthma, pain, heart disease, and depression.
Elite athletes who go vegan report improved healing of injuries and “100% better” performance. A patient claims a plant-based diet cured her thyroid cancer in a year. A patient scheduled for bilateral hip replacement says she was able to walk pain-free and stop all her meds after just two weeks. I am skeptical.
The filmmaker provides his own testimonial that “within a few days I could feel my blood running though my veins with a new vitality.” (I can’t feel the blood running through my veins; can you?) He refuses to eat even a little animal food, not for health reasons but because he “can’t support an industry that is causing so much suffering to communities, families, and all life on the planet.” He rejects the “everything in moderation” argument because the evidence doesn’t show that eating small amounts of animal-based foods is healthy (but the evidence doesn’t show that it’s unhealthy either!).
Conclusion: Spectacle, not science
There are undisputed health advantages to a plant-based diet, but the evidence is insufficient to recommend that everyone adopt a vegan diet. The What the Health movie is not a balanced documentary, but an alarmist, biased polemic. It cherry-picks scientific studies, exaggerates, makes claims that are untrue, relies on testimonials and interviews with questionable “experts,” and fails to put the evidence into perspective. It presents no evidence to support the claim that a vegan diet can prevent and cure all the major diseases. It is simply not a reliable source of health information.
The consensus of scientists, doctors, and dietitians is that a vegan diet can be a healthy diet but is not the only healthy diet. We as a society should eat more plant foods, but we needn’t entirely reject all animal foods. A healthy diet can include eggs, milk, cheese, fish, shellfish, some red meat, and even a small amount of processed meats. There’s certainly no clear-cut evidence that would persuade us that everyone should completely forgo animal-based foods. We needn’t give up eggs, or bacon, or an occasional steak. There are risks to almost everything we do (even carcinogens in a vegan diet!), and many of us would rather accept a small hypothetical risk than give up the foods we love. Pending better evidence, I think “moderation in all things” is a very reasonable approach.

   The China Study Revisited: New Analysis of Raw Data Doesn’t Support Vegetarian Ideology
Harriet Hall
Link
Over a year ago I wrote about The China Study, a book by T. Colin Campbell and his son based on a huge epidemiologic study of diet and health done in China. The book’s major thesis is that we could prevent or cure most disease (heart disease, cancer, diabetes, autoimmune diseases, bone, kidney, eye and other diseases) by eating a whole foods plant-based diet, drastically reducing our protein intake, and avoiding meat and dairy products entirely.
I noticed a number of things in the book that bothered me. I found evidence of sloppy citations, cherry-picked references, omission of data that contradicted the thesis, and recommendations that went beyond the data. I concluded:
He marshals a lot of evidence, but is it sufficient to support his recommendation that everyone give up animal protein entirely, including dairy products? I don’t think so.
The China Study involved 367 variables and 8000 correlations. I said I would leave it to others to comment on the study design and the statistical analysis, and now someone has done just that. Denise Minger devoted a month and a half to examining the raw data to see how closely Campbell’s claims aligned with the data he drew from; she found many weaknesses and errors.
Campbell says
Plasma cholesterol… is positively associated with most cancer mortality rates. Plasma cholesterol is positively associated with animal protein intake and inversely associated with plant protein intake.
The data do show that cholesterol is positively associated with various cancers, that cholesterol is positively associated with animal protein, and that cholesterol is negatively associated with plant protein. So by indirect deduction they assume that animal protein is associated with cancers and that reducing intake is protective. But if you compare animal protein intake directly with cancer, there are as many negative correlations as positive, and not one of those correlations reaches a level of statistical significance. Comparing dietary plant protein to various types of cancer, there are many more positive correlations and one of them does show strong statistical significance. The variable “death from all cancers” is four times as strongly associated with plant protein as with animal protein. And Campbell fails to mention an important confounder: cholesterol is higher in geographic areas with a higher incidence of schistosomiasis and hepatitis B infection, both risk factors for cancer.
Campbell says breast cancer is associated with dietary fat (which is associated with animal protein intake). The data show a non-significant association with dietary fat, but stronger (still non-significant) associations with several other factors and a significant association with wine, alcohol, and blood glucose level. The (non-significant) association of breast cancer with legume intake is virtually identical to the (non-significant) association with dietary fat. Animal protein itself shows a weaker correlation with breast cancer than light-colored vegetables, legume intake, fruit, and a number of other purportedly healthy plant foods.)
He indicts animal protein as being correlated with cardiovascular disease, but fails to mention that plant protein is more strongly correlated and wheat protein is far, far more strongly correlated. The China Study data show the opposite of what Campbell claims: animal protein doesn’t correspond with more disease, even in the highest animal food-eating counties.
These are just a couple of examples. Minger found many more, which she describes in her long article, complete with impressive graphs. Her exposé is well worth reading in its entirety, if only as a demonstration of how to think about epidemiologic data.
Minger goes on to reveal gaping logical holes in Campbell’s own research on casein, a milk protein that he believes causes cancer. He showed that casein was associated with cancer when given in isolation to lab animals, but he projects those results onto humans and onto all sources of animal protein. Other animal proteins have been shown to have anti-cancer effects, and the results of a normal diet containing multiple protein sources are likely to be very different from his casein-only studies.
Minger concludes
I believe Campbell was influenced by his own expectations about animal protein and disease, leading him to seek out specific correlations in the China Study data (and elsewhere) to confirm his predictions.
She is being polite.
This is a cautionary tale. It shows how complex issues can be over-simplified into meaninglessness, how epidemiologic data can be misinterpreted and mislead us, and how a researcher can approach a problem with preconceptions that allow him to see only what he wants to see. The China Study was embraced by vegetarians because it seemed to support their beliefs with strong evidence. Minger has shown that that evidence is largely illusory. The issues raised are important and deserve further study by unbiased scientists. At any rate, one thing is clear: the China Study is not sufficient reason to recommend drastic reductions in protein intake, let alone total avoidance of meat and dairy foods.

H.O.P.E.: A Movie Promoting Veganism
H.O.P.E., a movie promoting veganism, is short on science and long on appeals to emotion.
Harriet Hall on June 19, 2018
Link

H.O.P.E. stands for Healing Of Planet Earth. The movie H.O.P.E. – What You Eat Matters is a slick propaganda film produced by Nina Messenger. It argues that all humans should stop eating meat, dairy, and eggs, because animal-based foods contribute to starvation, global warming, environmental degradation, cancer, diabetes, and heart disease. But its biggest objection seems to be that animal-based foods involve cruelty to animals. It didn’t achieve its goal of converting me to veganism. In my opinion, instead of being titled H.O.P.E. it might better have been titled H.Y.P.E. for Hyperbole Yoked to Persuasion through Emotion.
It features several talking heads:
Jane Goodall, famous for her chimpanzee research, who says how we treat animals is as important as how we treat each other.
Caldwell Esselstyn, MD, who claims heart disease is caused by food and can be cured and prevented by his version of a vegan diet. I have written about how his claims are misleading and based on skimpy evidence.
Colin Campbell, PhD, co-author of The China Study. The movie presents that study as conclusive evidence for a diet devoid of animal protein. It is not; Robert Carroll’s article in the Skeptic’s Dictionary explains why.
Vandana Shiva, PhD (in philosophy), is an activist who is vehemently opposed to GMOs and globalization. Her controversial views were criticized by Michael Spector in a New Yorker article.
There isn’t even a token attempt at balance. There are no interviews with anyone who disagrees with their overall premise or their specific scientific claims; they don’t even acknowledge that anyone might possibly have reasons to disagree with them about any of their claims. The movie relies on biased proclamations by people with an agenda, on anecdotes, and on emotional appeals.
Milk
I’ll just provide one out of many possible examples of how the movie’s information is unreliable: they demonize milk. Campbell claims his research shows that casein (a protein in milk) is one of the strongest promoters of cancer. He says he could turn cancer on and off in the lab by varying the amount of casein in the diet. But this research was in mice, not humans. And milk is a complex mixture, not just casein. There’s little evidence that his research applies to milk consumption by humans. In fact, a 2016 meta-analysis showed that “higher total dairy, milk, yogurt, butter and skim/low-fat milk intake was not associated with increased cancer mortality risk.” They did find an association with the highest intake of whole milk and prostate cancer.
They repeat the myth that milk causes osteoporosis, based on population studies that failed to look at vitamin D intake. Most experts agree that milk is a good source of calcium and can help prevent osteoporosis, but it must be accompanied by adequate vitamin D, which is why most milk is now fortified with vitamin D. The National Osteoporosis Society says there is no good evidence that dairy is bad for bones. And this review, while it is from a commercial site, is a reliable report of the evidence from scientific studies that “debunk the milk and osteoporosis myth.”
Studies have generally agreed that a high protein diet is associated with cancer. But they are talking about totalprotein; they don’t single out milk protein. Milk is a nutritious food that provides “complete protein” with a full mix of amino acids and is an excellent and convenient source of many other essential nutrients. Eliminating it might very well result in poorer nutrition for some people.
Anecdotal evidence
The movie’s patient testimonials are not convincing.
A patient with major coronary artery blockages turned down surgery and used food as her medicine. After 4 weeks, her pain went away, and eventually she was able to run a marathon. Was it the diet, or the fact that she lost weight, exercised, and developed collateral circulation?
A patient had recurrent coronary artery blockages after multiple stent procedures. After 30 days of Esselstyn’s diet, his angina and facial numbness(?) were gone. In 5 months, his diabetes was gone. His eyesight improved so that he only needed glasses for reading. Was it the diet? Was it the considerable amount of weight he lost? Had nutritional deficiencies on his old diet been impairing his visual acuity?
A cancer patient in Germany had advanced lung cancer. He had surgery to excise cancer and metastases; he refused chemo. After 12 years on a diet of “pesticide-free plants that haven’t been heated,” he says he is cancer-free. Is he really cancer-free? If so, isn’t it possible it was the surgery that cured him?
Campbell’s wife had melanoma, refused chemo and surgery. Got strict about her diet. 9 years later, no problem. No details are given. What did the biopsy show? Was a biopsy even done? What did her doctors have to say about this? Even if the story is accurate, there are many reports of spontaneous regression of melanoma. Was it the diet? No way to know.
One of the speakers “knows a lot of people” who get migraines, and “when you stop dairy they go away.”
Will Tuttle says he and his vegetarian friends feel great and have lots of energy.
Without proper documentation and comparison to control groups, anecdotes like these are meaningless.
Environmental arguments
They say meat consumption accelerates global climate change and species extinction. It damages soil, water, and air. It spurs global starvation. They quote Gandhi, “Earth provides enough to satisfy every man’s need but not every man’s greed.” They say animal foods won’t be able to support our increasing population. A former meat producer says that in 20 years there won’t be enough food. Animals are being fed while humans are starving. Only 10% of U.S. corn production goes to food; most goes to “tortured animals.” And corn “doesn’t suit their digestive system.” Europe has to import animal feed from South America, where the rain forest is being destroyed to produce grain and raise livestock.
Producing a kilogram of beef uses up 15,500 liters of water; 1 kg of eggs uses 3300 liters of water; plants require much less, around 700 liters of water for a kilogram of apples. Animals produce methane, which is much worse than CO2. Excrement pollutes the soil: it releases ammonia which causes long-term damage to soil and threatens our drinking water. “Forcing meat on people is a crime for the environment and for our bodies.”
Emotional appealThis movie is a perfect example of the fallacy of emotional appeal: a type of argument that attempts to arouse the emotions of its audience in order to gain acceptance of its conclusion. It pulls at the heartstrings. It shows emaciated African toddlers covered with flies. It shows squealing piglets having their tails docked and their testicles “ripped off” without painkillers. It shows horrifying scenes of animal abuse in factory farms and slaughterhouses. A former slaughterhouse worker says, “I was a contract killer,” a mercenary for all the people who want to eat meat. It shows animals screaming in pain. It contrasts the misery of animals confined in narrow cages to pigs happily playing outdoors and rolling in mud. “There is more suffering in a glass of milk than in just about anything;” we are paying people to impregnate cows, kill their babies, and steal their milk. It shows tears falling from a cow’s eye. It says chickens are empathetic and feel the pain of other chickens; a claim that is questionable, to say the least (chickens are more likely to peck a sick chicken to death and eat it than to feel sorry for it). It asks us to individualize animals and say, “Who are we having for dinner,” not “What are we having.”
It shows appealing scenes of people cuddling with adorable farm animals. It shows happy families cooking together and enjoying colorful vegan meals adorned with edible flowers. It even shows cute kittens.
Big farm and big pharma
They emphasize the profit motive that drives sellers of meat, dairy, and eggs. They say that, in contrast, no one is financially motivated to keep people healthy. Medical and pharmaceutical industries make money by treating sick people. Big farm and big pharma have infiltrated the academic community and the government.
Other ways of thinking
The movie presents an extremist, absolutist point of view; it brooks no dissension. There are more moderate views. A vegan diet can be a healthy diet, but so can various other diets, especially those that emphasize plant-based foods. Humans can thrive on a wide variety of diets. I agree that we should eat less meat and more plant-based foods. I agree that the typical American diet is not healthy. But the poison is in the dose. I have seen no evidence that including modest amounts of animal products as part of a varied diet causes any measurable harm to human health.
I abhor animal cruelty as much as anyone; but rather than ban meat, why not find ways of raising livestock humanely? Temple Grandin has done outstanding research in reducing stress for food animals and in monitoring animal welfare at slaughter plants.
We mustn’t forget the Law of Unintended Consequences. A kneejerk prohibition on all animal foods might actually be worse for the environment. Some common vegetables use more resources per calorie than meats. Lettuce produces three times as much greenhouse gas emissions as bacon. Many foods are imported and transported long distances; their transportation has environmental consequences that could be lessened by eating locally grown foods.
Conclusion: Moderation makes more sense than elimination
Humans evolved as omnivores. We like the taste of animal products. The movie wants everyone to subsist only on plants. I don’t see that as either necessary or as practically achievable. I don’t see any reason we can’t enjoy meat in moderation while also minimizing harm to the environment and treating animals humanely.
H.O.P.E. is one of those pseudo-documentary movies that tell a one-sided story and promote their agenda by manipulating the viewer with appeals to emotion. Our decisions should be made on the basis of rational thought and a balanced assessment of all the scientific evidence, not on the basis of emotion.

   Simply Raw: Making overcooked claims about raw food diets
David Gorski
Link
This week, I plan on taking on something that’s been sitting near the bottom of my “to do list” for several weeks now. Indeed, readers have been sending me links since November or so to what will be the topic of this week’s post, but something somehow has always managed to push it aside each weekend when the time came to sit down and start writing my weekly post for this blog. I was also motivated by noting that, even though we are now entering the fourth year of this blog’s existence (yes, as hard as it is to believe, we started way back in January 2008), no one has done a post specifically about this particular topic, although I have mentioned it in the past, in particular in my discussion of a movie about the Gerson protocol for pancreatic cancer over a year ago.
This time around, I will be discussing a movie as well. Unlike The Beautiful Truth, which was about the Gerson protocol and didn’t feature any big names, this movie, Simply Raw: Reversing Diabetes in 30 Days, features at least a couple of big names. These include Morgan Spurlock, who directed and starred in the 2004 documentary Super Size Me, which featured Spurlock eating nothing but McDonald’s food for 30 days and documented the effects that diet had on him, and actor and “raw food activist” Woody Harrelson. Both were interviewed for the movie, and a longer interview with Spurlock is featured as part of a promotional film series on the web that goes along with Simply Raw.
Here are two trailers for the movie. First, trailer #1:
Then, trailer #2:
And here is the introduction to the Raw for Life DVD, a companion “A-Z encyclopedia” of “live food” veganism that is being sold as a companion piece to Simply Raw:
As you can see, Simply Raw follows the story of six people, four of whom have type II diabetes, one of whom has type I diabetes, and one of whom is presented as having initially been diagnosed with type II diabetes but then diagnosed with type I diabetes. These six show up at The Tree of Life Rejuvenation Center in Arizona to try to reverse their diabetes “naturally” with a “raw food” diet, having answered an advertisement for subjects in a “raw food challenge” to reverse diabetes. The center is described thusly on its website:
The Tree of Life is the world’s leading spiritual, vegan raw and live food retreat center. It was founded in 1993 to promote spiritual awakening and to support an inspiring, healthy and “alive” lifestyle through education and first-hand experience. The Tree of Life serves as an oasis for the realization of whole-person, whole-planet healing. It is a place where people of all ages, nationalities, and religious and spiritual paths come to experience physical, mental, emotional and spiritual renewal and well being.
The “healing modalities” offered at The Tree of Life are listed thusly:
    • Fasting, Juice Fasting & Detoxification Retreats
    • Natural Cure for Diabetes Program
    • Conscious Eating Program
    • Living Modern Essene Way Workshops
    • Modern Essene Minister & Priesthood Training
    • Psycho-spiritual healing with our 4-Day Zero Point Program
    • Mental Wellness program for Healing Brain and Nervous System
Dr. Cousens, the founder of The Tree of Life, describes himself thusly on the website:
Dr. Sir Gabriel Cousens, M.D., M.D.(H), D.D. (Doctor of Divinity), Diplomate of American Board of Integrative Holistic Medicine, Diplomate Ayurveda, a physician of the soul, teaches and lives the sevenfold peace.
To the process of awakening and healing, Gabriel Cousens, M.D., M.D.(H), weaves a background as a holistic physician, medical researcher, world-recognized live-food nutritionist, psychiatrist, family therapist, homeopath, Rabbi, acupuncturist, Ayurvedic practitioner, expert on green juice spiritual fasting and detoxification fasting, ecological leader, Reiki master, internationally celebrated spiritual teacher, author, lecturer, culture-bridger, world peaceworker, to give a unique holistic approach to nurturing the hungry soul.
A homeopath and a reiki master? Is there any woo that Dr. Cousens isn’t into? It sure doesn’t look that way.
Leaving that aside, I’m more interested in what the claims made in this movie are and whether there is any science behind them. However, it is not irrelevant to look briefly at the person promoting these claims, as I have above, because it is clear that his methodology at The Tree of Life is a hodge-podge sampling from a veritable cornucopia of woo. I should also point out that, before I move on, contrary to the claims in the trailer, science-based medicine (SBM) does not dismiss the contention that diet can have a profound effect on health. From the trailer, it appears that the movie argues the typical false dichotomy that irritates the crap out of me, specifically that SBM denies that food matters, that proper eating and a healthy lifestyle can greatly improve health and even reverse some health problems. What SBM demands is the evidence and science supporting claims, and this trailer already has some dubious ones right from the start.
“Raw food” versus vegan and vegetarian diets
Most people know what a vegetarian diet is and what the difference between a vegetarian diet and a vegan diet is. Basically, a vegetarian diet usually means a diet consisting of fruits, vegetables, grains, nuts, and seeds without meat or fish. There are different flavors of vegetarianism, ranging from considering it acceptable to eat animal products that are not actually the flesh of dead animals, such as milk and the cheese that is made from it or eggs, to veganism, which eschews any animal product and may even exclude any product tested on animals. Some examples include:
    • Ovo-vegetarianism: Allows eggs but no dairy products.
    • Lacto-vegetarianism: Allows dairy products but not eggs.
    • Ovo-lacto-vegetarianism (or lacto-ovo vegetarianism): Allows animal/dairy products such as eggs, milk, and honey.
    • Veganism: Excludes all animal flesh and animal products.
    • Raw veganism: Permits only fresh and uncooked fruit, nuts, seeds, and vegetables.
It gets more complicated from there, as there are vegetarians who will eat certain meats and fishes from time to time, for instance limiting themselves only to occasional seafood or poultry products. Be that as it may, Simply Raw is obviously concerning itself with a raw vegan diet. The reasoning behind such extreme vegan diets is often more a matter of philosophy than science. In many (but not all) cases, the rationale is vitalistic-sounding. Note, for instance, the language used to describe The Tree of Life vegan diet. The words “live” and “living” are used frequently. That’s because there really is often a strong element of primitive vitalism at the heart of an embrace of raw food vegan diets. In essence, if you peruse raw food websites, it won’t be long before you find references to cooking as “killing” the food or “removing the life” from the food or to fresh, uncooked food as being “alive.” Perhaps the most hilarious example of this comes from a video I referenced back in 2009 when reviewing a movie (it’s not in Simply Raw, but should be):
The claim in the clip above comes from The Beautiful Truth and argues that the uncooked baby carrot is “alive,” with a photo of a seeming aura of “energy” surrounding it, while the cooked carrot is dead. The conclusion? Cooking and pasteurization “kill” food, and raw food is “living.” Given that Dr. Cousens traces the parentage of his diet all the way back to Max Gerson himself, it wouldn’t surprise me if he saw nothing wrong with the video clip above. Be that as it may, various explanations are postulated for the supposed benefits of “living food,” in particular that cooking destroys enzymes in the “living food,” which is inarguable, but it is also inarguable that stomach acid and the digestive enzymes in the proximal small intestine rapidly reduce proteins, and thus enzymes, into their component amino acids. The sorts of claims that the more woo-ful raw food vegans tend to be along the lines of these excerpts from a FAQ from Living and Raw Foods, which bills itself as the “largest community on the Internet dedicated to educating the world about the power of living and raw foods”:
What are Living and Raw Foods?
Raw and Living Foods are foods that contain enzymes. In general, the act of heating food over 116 degrees F destroys enzymes in food. (Enzymes start to degrade in as little as 106 degrees F). All cooked food is devoid of enzymes, furthermore cooking food changes the molecular structure of the food and renders it toxic. Living and raw foods also have enormously higher nutrient values than the foods that have been cooked.
What are Enzymes?
Enzymes assist in the digestion of foods. They are known to be the “Life-Force” and or “energy” of food.
Another example:
Is there a difference between living foods and raw foods?
Living and Raw foods both contain enzymes. In living foods, the enzyme content is much higher. Raw, unsprouted nuts contain enzymes in a “dormant” state. To activate the enzymes contained in almonds, for example, soak them in water for as just 24 hours. Once the almonds begin to sprout, the enzymes become “active” and are then considered living.
This is, of course, a load of hooey, to use a scientific and skeptical term. Using this rationale, the most “living” food of all would be a test tube containing purified enzymes, similar to what I used to work with back in the 1980s during a laboratory job I had one summer as an undergraduate. Of course, enzymes aren’t all. The other claim, such as this one by one of the “experts” who appear on Simply Raw (Dr. Joel Fuhrman), is that cooking somehow destroys living antioxidants, phytochemicals, and a variety of other compounds, without which the body can’t be healthy and “must break down. He describes processed food as “foods whose life has been taken out of them” and makes the claim that, without these micronutrients, cells accumulate “toxins” that need to be “detoxified,” while touting broccoli and various vegetables as having “incredible medicinal power.”
Far be it from me to denigrate diet as a therapeutic tool for chronic disease, such as type II diabetes, hypertension, and heart disease. There is plenty of evidence in SBM that losing weight and exercising can have a profound positive effect on blood pressure, type II diabetes, and cardiovascular disease. Indeed, the very first thing that physicians do when they diagnose someone with hypertension or type II diabetes is to try to get them to lose weight and eat a healthier diet, knowing that significant weight loss can lower blood pressure and even often reverse partially or completely the elevated blood sugar of type II diabetes. Unfortunately, diet is a very, very hard thing to change, and it’s very hard to change one’s lifestyle. The problem with “complementary and alternative medicine” approaches to diet, such as raw food veganism, is that they often claim far more than they can deliver, while justifying dietary choices using by appealing to vitalism and mystical properties. Simply Raw follows this template.
Simply Raw: Reversing Diabetes in 30 Days
Using my super blogger contacts, I scored a borrowed copy of Simply Raw to watch and review. The movie starts out as one might expect, introducing the six cast members who responded to a Craig’s List add to take a “raw food challenge” and “reverse their diabetes in 30 days.” This cast includes a perfect reality show-ready group of people with disparate backgrounds, including a construction worker, a retired chiropractor, a casino worker, a graduate student, a receptionist, and a postal worker. Following a typical reality show format, each cast member is introduced individually and portrayed making the long journey to Arizona. After everyone has arrived at The Tree of Life Rejuvenation Center, introductions are made, and the drama begins.
What’s particularly irritating is that at the beginning of the 30 days, Dr. Couzens sits down with the six and tells them that “healing diabetes is easy.” He makes claims, such as that adding that cooking food decreases the protein content by 50% (which is utter nonsense; it’s more like 6%), 70-80% of the vitamins (it actually depends on the vitamin), and close to 100% of the phytonutrients (it also depends on the specific phytonutrient). There is even a scene of Dr. Cousens doing what appears to be live cell analysis on a blood sample of one of the six, pointing out what’s wrong with his blood. Live cell analysis, is, as regular readers here should know, rank quackery. Meanwhile, Morgan Spurlock opines that using diet to treat disease is viewed with contempt by modern medicine, a massive exaggeration. He even claims it’s viewed by “conventional” medical practitioners as being “like a witch doctor.” Hearing that, I couldn’t help but think that Spurlock might have a point, just not in the way he thinks. After all, the “live” food movement, with its blend of vitalism tarted up with science-y-sounding terminology, is actually not too far from a witch doctor telling his tribe about a magical spirits, a “life essence,” in food.
Simply Raw is basically a single-arm, uncontrolled clinical trial consisting of six patients. Actually, it’s not even that. It’s basically six anecdotes from six different people of vastly differing ages, races, and backgrounds. As a result, it’s hard to generalize from the results shown in the movie. Five of the six appear to respond very rapidly to Dr. Cousen’s diet, within days, but one woman named Michelle does not. Once she is taken off of her insulin, her blood sugar readings remain, at least initially, between 350 and 400 mg/dl, way too high. As a result, she seriously thinks about leaving, leading the other five to try to persuade her not to go. Not surprisingly, this is a bit of false alarm, although useful drama for the movie, and Michelle–surprise! surprise!–ultimately decides to stay. At the end of the 30 days, she actually does have a good response to the diet.
Another member of the six, Henry, a casino worker and direct descendant of the hereditary chiefs of the Pima tribe, is portrayed having a particularly difficult time with the diet. In fact, he just can’t stick to it, finding it just too hard. He is portrayed suffering from stomach pain, extreme hunger,, fatigue, lethargy, and depression. When Henry finally leaves, it is stated that he had lost 30 lbs, which strikes me as a rather dangerous amount of weight to have lost in two and a half weeks. (Henry went home on day 17.)
Another thing that disturbs me about this movie is the claim that type I diabetes can be cured with diet. Given that type I diabetes results from a failure of the cells in the pancreas responsible for making insulin to produce an adequate amount of insulin to regulate blood sugar, holding out the promise of getting a type I diabetic off of his insulin entirely is dangerous. Even so, the type I diabetic in the group (Austin) does succeed in reducing his daily insulin requirement quite dramatically. This is not anything amazing or spectacular. It’s well known that diet can reduce insulin requirements in type I diabetics, sometimes dramatically, but they still need insulin. In rare–very rare–cases, it might–might–be possible to get a type I diabetic off insulin, but only if his pancreas still makes a little insulin.
In one telling scene in the movie, a staff member named Keith asks Austin what he thinks his chances are of getting off of insulin completely. Austin replies, quite reasonably, “Probably a zero percent chance,” to which Keith replies, “I don’t buy that.” Elsewhere in the movie Dr. Cousens cites without description three cases of type I diabetes that he’s “cured.” (Remember, he claims to have treated many thousands of diabetics; so even if this claim can be taken at face value it’s not particularly impressive.) Not surprisingly, it turns out that Austin isn’t the fourth. For a while, in fact, Dr. Cousen’s diet regimen led Austin’s blood glucose to be even harder to regulate because it would drop so low that he needs to drink orange juice or something with sugar in it to bring it back up again. Ultimately, Austin decides to leave for a day trip to Mexico, where he buys two bottles of tequila, drinks a lot, and gorges on tacos and enchiladas before returning and settling down again. One of the more dramatic scenes occurs when Austin is confronted after Keith finds his plastic bottle hiding his tequila mixed with a soft drink. In any case, I can’t help but notice that Simply Raw, even taken at face value, belies Dr. Cousens’ claim that it’s “easy” to cure diabetes. Three of the six subjects had major problems adhering to the diet, so much so that one left halfway through the program and one “fell off the wagon,” so to speak, while one almost gave up during the first week. One wonders whether, in the long term, the remaining five subjects can maintain such a radical diet.
The end of the movie also belies the claims made in the promotional material and in the movie about how resistant “conventional doctors” supposedly are to treating diabetes with diet. Three days after the 30 day program, Pam (the postal worker) goes to see her primary care doctor, who is very happy with her 25 lb. weight loss, her lower blood pressure, and her controlled blood sugar. He immediately discontinues her insulin, hugs her, and congratulates her heartily for having learned that type II diabetes is best treated by “what you put in your mouth.” Later, this same doctor is filmed asking, “How do we ship all of my patients to Arizona?” That hardly sounds hostile to he concept of diet as a treatment for diabetes to me. Of course, the doctor probably doesn’t realize that Dr. Cousens’ regimen is basically boot camp. People stay at his compound, isolated from their family and friends and interacting only with fellow residents and the center’s staff, eat only the meals Dr. Cousen’s staff makes for them or teaches them how to make, and are subject to serious peer pressure from the other residents there not to give up. Even so, even in this self-selected group, even under a situation of isolation from one’s familiar surroundings, one out of six bolted; one out of six had a relapse, and at least one more almost left.
The Trojan Horse of raw food veganism
When I first sat down to watch Simply Raw, I was expecting a lot more woo. And, yes, there was woo there, but not as much as I expected. Most of it came in the beginning and near the end, when there was a lot of talk of “living” food full of enzymes and the importance of giving up the “dead food” and interviews in which it was claimed that 50% of diseases would “go by the wayside” if everyone started on a raw food diet. There was also one brief scene of Dr. Cousens doing live blood analysis, something that the vast majority of viewers would not have noticed. Surprisingly, the movie actually showed very little of what, exactly, Dr. Cousens’ regimen consists of. There were a few scenes of cooks showing the residents how to make various “live” meals, but the vast majority of the movie focused on the interpersonal relationships between the subjects and the difficulties they had following the raw vegan diet. I think this was intentional. I think this was the typical use of a Trojan horse to sell an alternative medicine world view.
Why do I say this?
The reason I label this film a “bait and switch” is because it takes knowledge that SBM has already developed, namely that it is possible to reverse type II diabetes with weight loss and exercise (indeed, these are almost always the first interventions suggested when a diagnosis of type II diabetes is made), which require a much healthier diet to achieve, and then makes the implication that reversal of type II diabetes can best be accomplished by Dr. Cousens’ raw food vegan diet. The Trojan horse is the co-opting by alt-med practitioners of the idea that diet can have a significant impact on controlling type II diabetes. Within the Trojan horse of diet lies the woo of raw “live” foodism, complete with the idea that cooked food is somehow “dead,” that “living food” is living because it contains enzymes that are destroyed by cooking, and various other mystical and pseudoscientific concepts about raw food, such as that it somehow contains a mystical “life energy” that is destroyed by cooking. True, in the movie, although Dr. Cousens does talk some about the concept of “living food” and their belief that cooking somehow kills food, neither he nor the other “experts” interviewed dwells on this concept, which is surprising, given that Dr. Cousens directed the movie. Instead, the documentary focuses on interpersonal relationships and, in particular, three of the original six who had such difficulty sticking to the plan.
Instead, much of the woo is in the associated promotional materials on the Simply Raw website. For instance, there is the Raw for Life Encyclopedia, which includes “experts” not used in the movie, and there are full length interviews with the “experts” interviewed in Simply Raw, including Morgan Spurlock, and some whose interviews were not featured. These “experts” include Gary Null (yes, that Gary Null!), Mike Adams of NaturalNews.com, and Dr. Julian Whitaker. Gary Null, as you may recall, is well known in “alt-med” circles for being one of the co-authors of an article entitled Death by Medicine, which basically blames “conventional medicine” for causing in essence as many deaths as lives saved. He’s a promoter of all manner of quackery, HIV/AIDS denialist, and anti-vaccinationist who, ironically, nearly killed himself with his own supplements. Mike Adams is even more out there than Gary Null. For instance, he is a raw food faddist who once attacked Dr. Mehmet Oz for not being sufficiently radical in his dietary recommendations. More recently, he has been blaming psychiatric drugs and the food industry for Jared Lee Loughner’s rampage a week ago during which he shot U.S. Representative Gabrielle Giffords in the head, killed six people, and wounded 20, even going so far as to brand Loughner a “Manchurian candidate” programmed by the government to kill Giffords in order to allow the government to stomp on civil liberties. I kid you not. Finally, Julian Whitaker is Suzanne Somers’ doctor. If you want to get a flavor of what Dr. Whitaker is about, check out this video:
This is the classic example of taking something that’s true (namely that type II diabetes can often be kept under control through diet, exercise, and weight loss) and going right off the rails through exaggeration and distortion. Dr. Whitaker does this by saying that oral hypoglycemic drugs like metformin don’t work (they do) and that IV antibiotics don’t work (they do, but not always) and then taking a bunch of anecdotes to argue that “conventional medicine doesn’t work.” He even advocates acupuncture and chelation therapy for diabetes.
Come to think of it, given that Dr. Cousens is a homeopath and acupuncturist who apparently hasn’t seen a bit of woo that he doesn’t like, one wonders whether he uses pseudoscience like what Dr. Whitaker uses. Indeed, Dr. Cousens has his very own tag on NaturalNews.com. In particular, there are interviews with Dr. Cousens advocating “detox fasts,” where he appears to believe in “cell memory“:
Gabriel: And you may have a genetic tendency to diabetes. Okay, that’s cool. But the phenotype is your actual expression. If you live a live-food lifestyle, you will not express diabetes. You will keep a genotype — a phenotype that’s really healthy. And so what we do with the live-food diet is the foundation of basically turning on the healthy phenotype and turning off the diabetes phenotype, genetic expression. Now that’s the key to the program. That’s why it works.
Kevin: And once it’s turned on, let’s say, someone comes to you and the phenotype is turned on and then you turn it off using live foods and then someone goes back to the culture of death as you were talking about. Is it more readily turned on again?
Gabriel: Yes because the body has some familiarity.
Kevin: Yes. And when people make the switch, transitioning is an interesting experience — went from cooked foods to live foods and emotions come out and things surface. What’s your explanation to that?
Gabriel: Umm…
Kevin: I’m sure you see a lot of it?
Gabriel: Yes, and this is often why we recommend people to just go 80% first because usually with the dead food you’re putting dead food in the dead places.
Kevin: Okay.
Gabriel: You’re suppressing. The more you eat, it’s like a made ego for suppressing your consciousness. You go to live foods and suddenly, you’re putting live food in that place because you’re activating all the suppressed stuff that comes up. So, we like people to get up to 80%.
Okay. And just hold there until they kind of emotionally detox and physically detox because the live food is just forcing out every level of toxin. That’s how we look at it. So, maybe you need it to be refreshed after three months or six months. When people do spiritual fasting and the zero point which follows up which is part of our program here; you know we have right here then that process is greatly excoriated and really fasting on green, this is just probably the fastest way to make a transition because you lose your cell memory for the cooked food but you also detox very quickly.
Kevin: Is that cell memory?
Gabriel: Cell memory for the cooked food, yes.
No wonder Dr. Cousens buried all the real woo behind is raw food regimen in his accompanying encyclopedia. At least he didn’t include his Zeolite detox nonsense.
But there’s more. I’ve been on the Simply Raw e-mail list for over a month now, and I see what sort of dubious medical products the movie’s executive producer Alex Ortner is promoting through his mailing list about his movie. For instance, he seems to be quite enamored of “super immunity,” which is longevity and “detoxification” pseudoscience featuring Joe Mercola and David Wolfe; the tapping solution, which is billed as a form of “meridian tapping” or a variety of emotional freedom technique (EFT), a variety of “thought field therapy,” both of which are utter quackery claiming that finger tapping along meridians “releases the body’s energy flow”: Dr. Joe Vitale’s “blood pressure miracle,” which claims to be able to reverse hypertension “naturally” without drugs; the “seven day back pain cure,” which promises to cure your back pain without drugs, surgery, or much of anything else; and, just yesterday, in my e-mail I found an ad from Ortner hawking a plan from a “holistic” doctor and homeopath named Mark Stenger, who is promoting a method to “balance your hormones” — naturally, of course. (Is there any other way?) In other words, although the movie Simply Raw itself doesn’t delve too deeply into woo, it does make overblown claims for just what diet can do for type II diabetes, and its ancillary materials, such as the DVD encyclopedia and most of the other products Ortner is hyping in addition to his movie, are dubious in the extreme. The movie appears to be “gateway” pseudoscience, designed to suck people in with reasonable-sounding claims about diet and then sell them on a prescientific, vitalistic view of the world wrapped up in the naturalistic fallacy.
Trojan horse, indeed.
The only things live about live food is the living woo
“Live food” faddism resonates with a great many people, because, when stripped of its mystical underpinnings, the concept that eating fresh, unprocessed food makes sense to most people. Also, the naturalistic fallacy, which implies that raw “live food” is somehow more “natural” than processed food, remains very appealing to many people who distrust modern society and science. Moreover, physicians know that one of the most effective methods of treating type II diabetes is through dietary manipulations and weight loss. Certainly, that is the first move that is usually tried. Unfortunately, Simply Raw implies that the only (or, at least, the best) strategy for type II diabetics to achieve the goal of glucose control and getting off their medications is a radical diet that consists of raw vegan food. Implicit in that idea is the belief that cooked and processed food is somehow poisoning us. Of course, countering that is the recently developed concept that cooking might have been a major factor in the increase in human brain size during evolution, the reason being that raw “live” food of the type featured in Simply Raw is far less energy rich than meat and takes more energy to digest. In any case, the entire premise of Simply Raw is an exaggeration. There’s no reason why a raw food vegan diet alone should be necessary to have a major positive impact on type II diabetes, much less should it be necessary to adopt the dubious concept that you need to eat “living food.”
Of course, that is not the message conveyed by Simply Raw. It’s quite clear that the message of the movie is that the best way to reverse diabetes is through a raw vegan diet of “living” food. Worse, although it features what Peter Lipson likes to call the “quack Miranda warning,” the movie also suggests strongly that diet can reverse type I diabetes. Representing what is in essence a set of anecdotes from six, self-selected diabetics, all with no science, it’s also highly effective propaganda. No one, least of all me, argues that diet isn’t incredibly important as a therapeutic modality for type II diabetes, but the entire Simply Raw package goes far beyond that, promoting vitalism and other dubious concepts as part and parcel of what is necessary to reverse type II diabetes.

MILK

Evaluating milk and its substitutes
Scott Gavura on March 12, 2015
Link


I knew milk alternatives were becoming mainstream when a new bakery/café appeared in my neighborhood. I ordered a latte and learned that they didn’t use milk. At all. Not only were the baked goods vegan, organic, “natural” and some were gluten-free, they were completely dairy-free for their coffee beverages. While everything looked and smelled great, I was shocked that they had no milk on the premises. The milk alternative made with soy didn’t taste bad, but it didn’t taste like milk. I left with my coffee, wondering how long the place would survive. I was wrong. It’s been a few years and the shop is still here, suggesting there’s a sizable appetite (at least in my laid-back, coffee-shop-saturated neighborhood) for milk-free, wheat-free vegan food and drinks. I shouldn’t be surprised. The number of people on restricted diets seems to be growing, and so have the food choices to meet their dietary demands. There have always been people that avoided milk, but the reason was traditionally lactose intolerance or dairy allergies. Now more are simply choosing to avoid it. I’m often asked about the merits of milk and the multiple milk alternatives, as the assessments of dairy seems to take one of two positions: Either milk is the dietary equivalent of unicorn tears, a nearly perfect food, or it is poison that’s almost certainly killing us. What’s clear is that we have more choice than ever for milk-like beverages. My local grocery is pictured above, where cow’s milk is just one small section. Who knew you could milk cashews?
I can understand and appreciate why people might not drink milk, for cultural reasons alone. I grew up drinking milk and eating dairy products regularly, but married into a family that didn’t drink or eat any at all. When my kids were young, we went through a lot of milk each week. Now that they’re older, our consumption’s dropped, as they almost always opt for eggs instead of cereal each morning. Given juice is tightly restricted in my home, milk’s now mainly for coffee, cooking, and helping the kids meet their vitamin D requirements. Whether it’s society’s declining devotion to breakfast cereal, concerns about animal welfare, or recognition that consuming milk simply isn’t essential, habits have changed. In North America consumption is dropping steadily over time, something the dairy industry seems unable to reverse. With the decline of milk, there has been a rise in the number and types of milk-like beverages, raising the question of the relative merits.
Whether milk is “good” or “bad” and how it compares to the alternative “milks” depends on the question being asked. Good for what? Chemically, milk is emulsified fat in water that’s a good source of protein and several nutrients. If studying the effects of medication is difficult, that’s nothing compared to studying dietary interventions, where it’s exceptionally challenging to tease out cause and effect from studies which lack randomization and blinding. Correlation is not causation, and addressing all of the potential confounders seems nearly impossible. The result is trials with often equivocal results that are used to support nearly any position. Milk may be a good source of calcium, but consumption doesn’t seem related to fewer hip fractures as we age. It’s cited as an important part of the DASH diet, but DASH didn’t look at dairy in isolation. Cancer is often attributed to milk, but there’s a lack of convincing data. Even autism has been blamed on milk, a claim that’s never been substantiated. On balance, from a strictly nutritional perspective, milk is probably neither good nor evil, especially when you consider it’s just one component of a diet. When consumed in moderation, there are almost certainly other factors, many controllable, that can have more significant effects on overall health (e.g., regular exercise, not smoking, and maintaining a healthy weight).
The alternatives to regular milk seem to have grown in popularity for different reasons. Organic milk caters to dietary preferences, but there’s no convincing evidence organic food is healthier. Lactose-free milk makes milk tolerable to those that lack the ability to digest the sugar lactose. Raw milk (where it’s legally sold) seems to exist for those that prioritize taste over the risk of a food-borne illness. Others are concerned about what else might be in milk. Just yesterday there was a report that milk may not always be free of antibiotic residues. Nobody wants (or should accept) ciprofloxacin in their milk, especially when any detectable amount is forbidden.

There are more and more “milks” on the market. The most common ones are soy and almond, but you can also find rice, oat, coconut, potato, and even hemp milks for sale. Each has its own nutritional profile. Many are fortified (to mimic milk’s content) and often contain added sugars and flavors, so the nutritional profiles vary widely. (This CSPI table is among the more comprehensive). It’s important to note that plant-based milks lack the nutritional and caloric density of real milk, and are not a safe substitute in young children (<2 year). While there are nutritional differences between the products, eating an otherwise-balanced diet with plenty of variety is probably the best approach to minimize the risk of dietary gaps. Total calories is one area where these products can vary significantly, and given liquid calories don’t seem to satiate like food, it is reasonable to conclude that consuming in moderation is best.
Almond milk is one of more popular “milks” now. It’s made by soaking ground-up almonds in water and then removing the solid matter. Almond milk leverages the health halo that almonds currently enjoy, offering “good fats” and vitamins. Nutritionally, almond milk has a fraction of the protein of milk. One cup of almond milk contains the protein equivalent of just four almonds. Almonds, not almond milk, are a much more convenient and nutritionally-dense source of energy. The rest is expensive water, often fortified with vitamins and sometimes added sugar.
Soy milk was one of the earliest milk substitutes. Soy comes closest to real milk from a nutritional perspective, and some are fortified with vitamins to closely mimic real milk. Soy contains alpha-linolenic acid (ALA), an omega-3 fatty acid too, but if you’re not a vegan, you’d be better off eating other omega-3 sources. The relationship between soy and cancer is unclear.
Coconut milk is a mix of coconut water and the thick coconut cream. Like other coconut products, there’s a fair amount of saturated fat. They’re low in protein, and usually fortified with vitamins.
Rice milk is low in protein but usually has levels of calcium that approach real milk. There are some concerns about arsenic levels, but the overall health impact isn’t clear. Compared to the other milks, rice tends to come up short from a nutritional perspective.
Conclusion
If you enjoy drinking milk, there’s no convincing evidence to suggest you’re doing your body badly. If you’re consuming milk strictly for the perceived health benefits, then it’s fine to omit it from your diet. Milk isn’t magical and it isn’t poison. The same applies to the milk substitutes. If you want a milk-like beverage to drink, then there are lots of choices, and you can probably find one that you find palatable and is also fortified to deliver many of the nutritional benefits of regular milk.

Milk and Health: The Evidence
A useful review of all the current evidence about milk and health provides a lot of surprises. It shows that current recommendations are flawed and that much of what we have believed is wrong.
Harriet Hall on February 25, 2020
Tweet

Milk has been praised and vilified. Vegans eschew it. Babies thrive on it. Adults who are lactose-intolerant learn to avoid it. Maasai men thrive on a diet of mainly milk, meat, and blood. The recommended intake of milk, cheese, yogurt, and other dairy products in the US is 3 servings, to meet calcium requirements and reduce the risk of bone fractures; but the average adult only gets 1.6 servings. In the China Study, T. Colin Campbell recommended avoiding all meat and dairy products. He claims that the casein in milk is harmful, extrapolating from animal studies to demonstrate that casein causes cancer. The evidence is clearly mixed enough that different people have reached different conclusions. What does the science actually show?
I usually try to review the pertinent scientific evidence and draw my own conclusions, but this time I didn’t have to. In an excellent review article in The New England Journal of Medicine, two medical doctors/scientists from Harvard (Walter Willett MD, DPH and David Ludwig MD, PhD) have done all the heavy lifting for me. There were some surprises.
They point out the health implications of the way milk is processed. Cows have been bred to produce more insulin-like growth factor, and there are increased levels of hormones in their milk. Products are usually pasteurized and may be fermented, fractionated, and supplemented with vitamins A and D.
They provide a handy table of the nutrient composition of human and cow’s milk and cheese.
Did you think babies need milk? They don’t. They can get adequate nutrition for growth and development without it, as long as there is careful attention to diet and vitamin intake. We do know that milk consumption increases their attained height, and tall stature is associated with lower risk of cardiovascular disease; but it is also associated with many cancers, hip fractures, and pulmonary emboli.
Calcium and risk of bone fracture
I was surprised to learn that the US recommendations for milk consumption were based on small, flawed studies of calcium balance. Other countries recommend lower levels of calcium intake. The US recommends 1000-1200 mg for adults, the UK 700 mg, and the World Health Organization, 500 mg. Counterintuitively, countries with high milk and calcium intake actually have the highest rates of hip fracture. Clinical trials of calcium for fracture prevention are complicated, because of confounding factors like vitamin D, phosphorous, and adult height. High calcium intake during childhood and adolescence was thought to serve as a way to “bank” calcium, but studies have not supported that hypothesis. In fact, men’s risk of hip fracture increased by 9% for every additional glass of milk consumed during adolescence.
Body weight and obesity
After numerous randomized trials, no correlation has been found between milk consumption and body weight. Yogurt consumption was associated with less weight gain, but that finding could be confounded by the healthier lifestyle of those who eat yogurt. One surprise: drinking low-fat milk was associated with higher weight gain than drinking full-fat or 2% milk.
Cardiovascular effects
Randomized trials of low-fat milk have shown inconsistent results with regard to blood pressure. Neither low-fat nor whole milk has been clearly associated with the risk of coronary heart disease or strokes. The risk depends on the comparison foods. The risk is lower than with red meats but higher than with fish. Dairy fat increased cardiovascular risk more than polyunsaturated or vegetable fat.
Diabetes
Could cow’s milk cause Type 1 diabetes? Studies of antibody production have not confirmed that hypothesis. Some studies have shown a modestly lower risk of Type 2 diabetes with consumption of dairy products. In one analysis, “the risk of diabetes was lower with milk consumption than with consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages or fruit juices but higher with milk consumption than with coffee consumption.” The relationship of milk to risk of diabetes remains uncertain.
Cancer
Milk consumption may increase the risk of some cancers (prostate but not breast) but appears to reduce the risk of colorectal cancers. Studies are difficult to interpret because they are usually done in adults, whereas many cancer risk factors operate earlier in life. In one study, milk intake by adolescents had no effect on future risk of cancer. Campbell’s simplistic assertion that milk causes cancer was almost certainly wrong.
Allergies and intolerance
4% of infants are allergic to cow’s milk, and scattered reports suggest milk consumption may predispose to allergic disease and eczema. In adults, milk may exacerbate asthma. And lactose intolerance limits milk consumption worldwide.
Total mortality
In a recent meta-analysis of 29 cohort studies, milk was not associated with higher total mortality. But when protein sources were compared, dairy foods were associated with lower mortality than processed red meat and eggs, but with higher mortality than plant-based sources of protein.
Organic and grass-fed production
Because of grass feeding, organic milk may have slightly higher levels of beta carotene and n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids, but “No long-term studies have compared milk from cows treated with somatotropin and untreated cows with respect to health outcomes in humans.”
Environmental effects
The authors point out that there is more to consider than just the health effects. Limiting milk production could conceivably reduce greenhouse gases and climate change, improve water use and reduce pollution, and reduce the risk of antibiotic resistance.
Conclusion: No simple answers
As with so many things in medicine, the health effects of milk are not simple. Much depends on what else the person is eating. And much of what we have believed about milk turns out to be wrong. Milk doesn’t “build strong bones” but may actually increase the risk of fracture. There’s no evidence that reduced-fat milk has any health advantages over whole milk. This excellent review article, bolstered by 121 references, helps set the record straight. Science can’t dictate what we should eat; but it can dispel myths, correct misinformation, and give us the evidence we need to make informed choices.

Should We Avoid Dairy Out of Fear of Cancer?
A doctor is adamant about avoiding dairy because IGF-1 allows cancer cells to multiply. I think he’s relying on speculation and an over-abundance of caution.
Harriet Hall on June 9, 2020
Link

A neighbor told me, “one of my doctors was very adamant about not consuming dairy because the growth factor creates the right environment for cancer cells to multiply.” My reaction was “Whaaaat!??” From what I’ve been reading, dairy products decrease the risk of bowel cancer, may increase the risk of prostate cancer, and there is no strong evidence linking dairy to any other cancers. My neighbor is a woman, so prostate cancer is not an issue. I checked out various health, cancer, and vegan websites, and they pretty much confirmed what I thought. Did I miss something? Is there some new evidence that I haven’t heard about yet? Or did her doctor over-react? I decided to look again.
IGF-1 is insulin-like growth factor-1. Cows have been bred to produce more IGF-1, plus they are treated with hormones. Cow’s milk contains IGF-1, and blood levels may be higher in milk drinkers. PubMed lists numerous studies suggesting an association of higher blood levels of IGF-1 with various cancers, but the evidence doesn’t show that milk drinkers are actually more likely to develop those cancers. IGF-1 is produced in the human liver in considerably larger amounts than anyone is likely to get from dairy foods.
An article on Healthline says, “IGF-1 has been linked with an increased risk of prostate cancer. However, this may be a consequence of cancer rather than a cause… Keep in mind that most of the available evidence is based on observational studies, which provide suggestive evidence but not definite proof.” References are provided from what they consider to be trustworthy sources. Remember the difference between correlation and causation.
A new study published in February 2020 in the International Journal of Epidemiology found an association between high dairy intake and breast cancer. It found that women who drank the most cow’s milk per day had 50% increased risk for breast cancer compared with women who drank the least.
Medscape reported it in an article titled “New Study Suggests Milk Could Increase Breast Cancer Risk.” Note the careful language “suggests” and “could”. The new study was based on data from a long-running study of Seventh Day Adventists, whose other health practices might act as confounders and skew the data. An independent cancer scientist characterized the study as “provocative, but not enough to warrant a change in guidelines”. He pointed out that it was an observational study that can’t prove that cow’s milk causes breast cancer, and noted that the results were significant only for postmenopausal women and not for premenopausal women, and we know the incidence of breast cancer rises with age. Also, the associations were significant only for hormone receptor-positive cancers. He said the data must not be overinflated, and called for the study to be replicated. The Medscape article added that “Dairy has even been tied to decreased risk for breast cancer, according to the World Cancer Research Fund.”
The Medscape article referred to a review in The New England Journal of Medicine by Willett and Ludwig that I covered in my recent SBM post about the evidence on milk and health. That review essentially said the guidelines on milk consumption are not based on good evidence. Medscape interviewed Willett and quotes extensively from him and other scientists who agree with him. He does not say everyone should abstain from dairy because IGF causes cancer.
Conclusion: I’m not convinced
The observational studies looking for a correlation between cancer and consumption of dairy foods are far from definitive, and their conclusions are often conflicting. While there is legitimate concern about IGF-1, the evidence has not shown that fear of cancer is a good reason to avoid consuming dairy products. I think my neighbor’s doctor went way beyond the actual evidence and relied on speculation and an over-abundance of caution. The precautionary principle may sound like the safest approach, but often it isn’t: it can lead to unanticipated harms.
        ◦ Disclaimer: I don’t drink milk because I don’t enjoy the taste, but I love cheese and yogurt and butter, and I don’t intend to reduce my consumption any time soon. If my doctor told me what my neighbor’s doctor told her, I would change doctors.

   Raw Milk in Modern Times
Mark Crislip 
Link
It is hard to get infected. The immune system is robust and has a multitude of interlinking defenses that are extremely efficient in beating off most pathogens. Most of the time.
Fortunately, it is a minority of microbes that have evolved to be virulent in humans. Bacteremia is common with our own microbiome. When you brush or floss, bacteria leak into the blood stream:
We identified oral bacterial species in blood cultures following single-tooth extraction and tooth brushing. Sequence analysis of 16S rRNA genes identified 98 different bacterial species recovered from 151 bacteremic subjects. Of interest, 48 of the isolates represented 19 novel species of Prevotella, Fusobacterium, Streptococcus, Actinomyces, Capnocytophaga, Selenomonas, and Veillonella.
but with a good immune system, low virulence bacteria and no place to go, unfortunately the bacteria rarely cause infections.
Even heroin users rarely get infection. Heroin is a rich melange of with bacteria and, on occasion, yeasts (I hate to say contaminated, since avoiding microbes is hardly a worry of heroin manufacturers), and the water used for injection is rarely sterile, yet infections are relatively rare despite the filth in which many heroin users exist.
I used to be somewhat fatalistic about hospital acquired infections. However, as the institutions in which I have worked have proven, almost all infections in the hospital are preventable if the institutions aggressively pursue high standards of care.
There are many systems in place in society to prevent infections: flush toilets, good nutrition, public health, vaccines, antibiotics, good hygiene, and an understanding of disease epidemiology, and I suspect people forget there are bugs out there that are pathogenic, just waiting to sicken and kill us. At least a couple of times a year I see patients come into the hospital, previously healthy, who rapidly die of acute infections. But for most people, most of the time, it takes a lot of effort to get an infection.
From my perspective we are Charlie Chaplain on skates , mostly unaware of the infections that awaits us if we do something silly, or even when we act with the best intentions to avoid illness. The odds are small we will get a life threatening or serious infection in the US, just as the odds are small we will drown or be killed in a car accident. The germs are there, waiting, and in the end, no matter what we do, we will be consumed by the microbial world.
It is that perspective that leads to a lack of understanding as to why some people seem to love tipping the odds in favor of the bacteria. Avoiding vaccines is perhaps the most popular method for getting infections that could otherwise be avoided, but dietary habits are an curious way to acquire preventable infections.
Humans and cows have a long history of sharing infectious diseases. Measles is either a variant of rinderpest, a cattle illness, or they share a common ancestor. On the beneficial side of the relationship was cowpox, which lead to the small pox vaccination.
While I am a bit of a foodie (for example, while I do not remember by first kiss, I remember the epiphany of my first gourmet restaurant meal), I cannot grok (see how old I am) people who either think a specific food is to be avoided at all costs or is the panacea for preventing illness. Like cows milk.
There is school of thought that cows milk should be never be consumed: it is filled with pus, blood, hormones, foreign protein and antibiotics. And not only does milk not build strong bones, it leads to cancer. And if you can’t trust a kinesologist, who can you trust?
It’s not natural for humans to drink cow’s milk. Humans milk is for humans. Cow’s milk is for calves.
Sounds like a metaphorical argument for cannibalism to me.
And, as the anti-cows milk proponents note, milk has infectious diseases swimming in the white murk. A cesspool of bovine feces and bacteria that should be avoided, although how you can eat a homemade chocolate chip cookie without it, I cannot imagine.
So milk is one of the bad foods and should be avoided. Except when you shouldn’t. Newtons Law states that for every SCAM, there is an equal and opposite SCAM. Milk is dangerous, except when it is a panacea, when the milk should be raw milk, fresh from the organic, happy, contented cow.
Why raw milk? Pasteurization and homogenization rids the milk of the beneficial components: white cells, proteins, lactoferrin, immunoglobulins, fats, cholesterol and bacteria, curiously all the substances that the anti-milk faction says are the root of milky evil. I suppose that, for a raw milk aficionado, there would be no greater dietary sin than a warm glass of milk at bed time or a cup of hot chocolate after skiing.
The truth? I do not doubt that flash heating (usually to 165 degrees for 15 seconds) is going to have some nutritional effects on the milk and, if my diet consisted entirely of milk, it would be a concern. However, what small decrements in nutritional value occur would, and should, be made up with a varied diet. Milk is not, unless turned into Baskin Robbins Chocolate Chip ice cream, a miracle food. I also have no reason to doubt that there is a subset of people who have allergic issues with cows milk. Not everyone can drink bovine proteins with impunity.
Taste, of course, is a personal matter, and I cannot gainsay those who say raw milk tastes better. In my family everyone is picky about their milk; it cannot come in plastic and has to be a specific brand, Dairygold. My wife insists Oregon milk is inferior in flavor to Minnesota milk. French milk tasted weird, and I though everything else tasted better in France. Pasteurization has mild effects on the nutritional components of milk, and perhaps the taste.
But what raw milk is, above all, a source for infection. There have been outbreaks with Campylobacter, Salmonella, E. coli associated with raw milk and other organisms can be found in raw milk, some not common in the US, including Brucella, Listeria, Mycobacterium bovis (a cause of tuberculosis), Salmonella, Shigella, Yersinia, Giardia, and norovirus. Some are found in cows milk, and some, such as Brucella, more common from goat’s milk. These outbreaks have lead to hospitalizations and a few deaths.
Warm liquid filled with protein, fat and sugars. A good growth media for a bacteria, if they can gain access to the milk. Impossible. Proponents of raw milk point to the clean cows and clean environments that produce raw milk, but you cannot deny both microbiology and gravity. The colons of cows are frequently colonized with the aforementioned potential pathogens and the udder sits below, waiting to be splashed with cow pie. MMMMmmmmmm. Milk and pie. Seriously. Would you lick any cow udder, no matter how clean?
Still, people want their raw milk for the taste and health benefits. Some obtain raw milk illegally at milk speakeasies where I bet the password is Swordfish. You can time share a cow and get the milk straight from the source, although you have to see a presentation on time sharing cows to get the free weekend on the farm. This is good news for me. Since we have instituted aggressive infection control at my hospitals nosocomial infections have plummeted. Once upon a time milk was associated with 25% of infection outbreaks; in part due to pasteurization those rates fell to 1%. Thanks to the raw milk advocates, infections are looking up. The sad thing is parents will feed their children milk supplemented with cow poo. Adults have the right to be stupid; it is what makes America great. But it is a shame that children should suffer as a result of their parents goofy idée fixe.
There is a tendency for humans to have the oddest dietary obsessions, both for and against.
God told Moses certain animals were “clean” to eat — those with cloven hoofs which chewed the cud such as cattle, goats, sheep, deer, and so forth. All fish with fins and scales, and insects of the locust family were also “clean.” The pig and the camel, however, were “unclean” and were not to be eaten. All carnivorous birds, sea creatures without fins and scales, most insects, rodents, reptiles, and so forth were “unclean.
Milk is not on the list. Milk can be an enjoyable part of a diverse diet for most people, but like most foods it should not be filled with live organisms. Pasteurization is a good thing. Except for Hefeweizen. Give me my raw beer.

Spring Update on Prior Posts
Mark Crislip on April 20, 2012
Link
Although I write the definitive entries on topics in this blog, new information trickles in after publication. The new studies are often not worth an entire entry, recapitulating prior essays, but the new information is still worth a mention. What follows are updates on topics covered in prior SBM posts.
Raw Milk
In Oregon we are having a small outbreak of infections from consumption of raw milk. Not a surprise, since milk is a wonderful culture media and the udder is just down the gravity well from the cows anus. Raw milk violates the classic dictum “Don’t shit where you eat” although I understand the saying concerned dating in its original conception.
Although the sale of raw milk is illegal in muchof the US, the law can be bypassed by owning the cow rather than buying the milk, a reverse of dating advice. Such is the case in Oregon, where 48 people are time sharing the cows responsible for the current outbreak. There has been the spread of pathogenic E. coli to at least 5 people, mostly children, and has lead to the hospitalization of at least 3 children.
Of course, it is hard to get infected. Humans have lived in Filth and Squalor (like Minneapolis and St. Paul or Buda and Pest) for centuries, drinking and eating contaminated food and enough survived perpetuate the species. Most infections in the past would have been from consuming contaminated food and drink. I have wondered if the reason fevers are often associated with diarrhea and/or vomiting is that it an evolved response for removing infected material as soon as possible.
The CDC has reported multiple outbreaks of infection traced to consuming raw milk, not that anyone is paying any attention. The results were recently summarized:
The study included 121 dairy–related disease outbreaks, which caused 4,413 illnesses, 239 hospitalizations and three deaths. In 60 percent of the outbreaks (73 outbreaks) state health officials determined raw milk products were the cause. Nearly all of the hospitalizations (200 of 239) were in those sickened in the raw milk outbreaks. These dairy-related outbreaks occurred in 30 states, and 75 percent (55 outbreaks) of the raw milk outbreaks occurred in the 21 states where it was legal to sell raw milk products at the time. The study also reported that seven states changed their laws during the study period.
Consumers can’t tell if raw milk is safe to drink by looking at, smelling, or tasting it. Even under ideal conditions of cleanliness, collecting milk introduces some bacteria. Unless the milk is pasteurized, these bacteria can multiply and grow in the milk and cause illness. Pasteurization involves heating milk to kill disease-causing bacteria.
It is rare to get infections from milk: it is estimated that 1% of milk is consumed raw, about 27 billion pounds. Lets see. A pint is a pound the world a round, so that’s 54,000,000,000 cups drunk drank drunken consumed for 4400 illnesses. Not a huge risk, although children were disproportionately affected (60%) and E. coli 0157 mediated hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS), with kidney failure and occasional deaths are reported.
Not that it makes any difference to those who believe in the unproven benefits of raw milk over safe food:
…people who drink raw milk tend to be fierce advocates. One person, who posted anonymously on Oregonlive.com, said that he or she would not stop drinking milk from Foundation Farm even though it had sickened the commentator and the commentator’s 2-year-old child.
The inability to admit error boggles the mind.
“ Two simple words. Two simple words in the English language: “I forgot!” How many times do we let ourselves get into terrible situations because we don’t say “I forgot”? Let’s say you’re on trial for giving your kid HUS from raw milk. You say to the judge, “I forgot raw milk is contaminated with dangerous bacteria. Let’s suppose he says back to you, “You have committed a foul crime. You killed your child by deliberately giving them milk contaminated with cow manure, and you say, ‘I forgot’?” Two simple words: Excuuuuuse me!!”
Rhinos and Tigers and Bears. Oh my.
“I would personally kill every chimpanzee on the planet with my bare hands if it meant saving one homeless crack-addict with AIDS.”~ Penn Jillette
I don’t know. I have met some pretty nice chimps and some remarkably evil crack-addicts. I suspect he would be more protective of our evolutionary cousins if the choice were between chimps and some of his colleagues on The Apprentice, but perhaps I read body language incorrectly. But I would not kill a single animal for any Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) nostrum.
Several years ago I summarized the adverse effects of Traditional Chinese Medicine on the environment and other species. It is not uncommon to grind up endangered animals and plants such as rhino horn, tigers and antelope for medicinal purposes. Their efficacy is less than plausible; rhino horn is basically hair and will not even cure baldness. But use of TCM is increasing, consuming plants and animals with a Galactus-ian hunger. There is big money to made in puree of endangered species.
The issue with many of the supplements from India, China, and the US is quality control. What is on the label may or may not be what is in the tablet. But how can you tell if your TCM nostrum is filled with toxins or a melange of mammals? Modern technology has the answer. Or magic.
Targeting both the p-loop region of the plastid trnL gene and the mitochondrial 16S ribosomal RNA gene, over 49,000 amplicon sequence reads were generated from 15 TCM samples presented in the form of powders, tablets, capsules, bile flakes, and herbal teas. Here we show that second-generation, high-throughput sequencing (HTS) of DNA represents an effective means to genetically audit organic ingredients within complex TCMs. Comparison of DNA sequence data to reference databases revealed the presence of 68 different plant families and included genera, such as Ephedra and Asarum, that are potentially toxic. Similarly, animal families were identified that include genera that are classified as vulnerable, endangered, or critically endangered, including Asiatic black bear (Ursus thibetanus) and Saiga antelope (Saiga tatarica). Bovidae, Cervidae, and Bufonidae DNA were also detected in many of the TCM samples and were rarely declared on the product packaging.
They also found toad, goat, sheep, buffalo, and cow DNA in some of the concoctions. Listed ingredients, when they bothered to list them, included toad cake, testis et penis callorhini, and cow and monkey bezoar. Almost makes raw milk appear palatable by comparison.
Consumers of TCMs need to be wary of honesty of food labelling , as in 78% of samples, animal DNA was identified that had not been clearly labelled on the packaging (in either English or Chinese). This adulteration of medicine occurred in the Saiga Antelope Horn powder which claimed to be 100% pure, yet was found to also contain significant quantities of goat (Caprine) and sheep (Ovine) DNA. In some TCMs, undeclared ingredients are used to reduce the cost of manufacture of the medicine by increasing the bulk of the powder, but it is impossible to determine why Caprine and Ovine appeared in this product. Water buffalo (Bubalus bubalis), domestic cow (Bos taurus) and deer species were also not listed on the packaging of samples in which they were genetically identified. The inadvertent consumption of undeclared animal products found in 78% of the medicines, such as bovid, risk violating certain religious and/or cultural strictures.
What? I am using adulterated quackery instead of pure quackery? Consumers of TCM have more to worry about than honesty in food labeling, as if somehow lying about nonsense is worse than honest nonsense.
The take home is when you use TCM products, you are likely contributing to the extinction of species even when the label on the nostrum appears safe. You are not even saving a homeless crack-addicted AIDS patient, much less helping yourself.
Like Cure Like
Not.
It has been a while since I pursued the Pubmeds on homeopathy. Regular readers of the blog know the fantasy based premises of homeopathy. Substances that cause symptoms, when diluted beyond any residual presence, will cure the disease.
Most of the time trying to test this fantasy is messy. There are a lot of diseases, but fewer symptoms. There are a lot of potential variations in fevers or headaches or sinusitis that result in choosing a homeopathic remedy being “individualized.” Despite being fantasy based, the enormous variation makes it hard to test one homeopathic cure for one illness or symptom. The wiggle room is enormous.
Testing ‘like curing like’ would be more straightforward if it were poisoning. Lead or arsenic poisoning would seem a straightforward condition to test homeopathic validity. You would know exactly which like would cure which like. Lead toxicity should be cured with homeopathic lead. And, incredibly, such studies have been done.
And, at least for lead, like does not cure like:
INTRODUCTION:Poisoning due to lead and its compounds has short and long-term effects primarily on the nervous, hematopoietic, gastrointestinal, cardiovascular, musculoskeletal, renal and reproductive systems. It can manifest in acute or chronic symptoms. Measuring serum concentration is the primary method for diagnosing and monitoring exposed workers. Presently, elevated lead levels are treated by drugs whose effectiveness is contested on various fronts. Experimental studies suggest that homeopathic preparations may be in controlling blood lead levels in laboratory animals, creating the need for controlled studies to evaluate the effectiveness and safety of these preparations in humans.OBJECTIVE:To evaluate the effectiveness of the homeopathic preparation Plumbum metallicum in reducing the blood lead level of workers exposed to this metal.DESIGN:Double-blind randomized trial.SETTING:Workers’ clinic in the Ajax battery plant, which employs 900 workers with varying degrees of lead exposure in Bauru, São Paulo State, Brazil.SUBJECTS:131 workers exposed to lead.INTERVENTION:Plumbum metallicum 15 cH or placebo, orally for 35 days.RESULTS:The percentage of workers who demonstrated a reduction in lead counts by a percentage greater than or equal to 25% following treatment was the same for both groups: 20.3% in the homeopathic groups versus 21% in the control group [Relative Risk (RR) = 0.95, confidential interval (CI) 95%: 0.47-1.92)]. Analysis by intention-to-treat also did not show any difference between the groups: 18.2% in the treated group versus 20% in the placebo group (RR = 0.91, CI 95%: 0.45-1.84).CONCLUSION:The homeopathic preparation Plumbum metallicum had no effect, in this study, in terms of reducing serum lead in workers exposed to lead.”
What a surprise, although one wonders what they were thinking in the Institutional Review Board at the Federal University of São Carlos for allowing such a study to be done.
A similar study, this time with arsenic, was done in China. And you have to love the description of how ‘informed’ consent was obtained
Most arsenic victims were weak and anemic and therefore concerned about giving blood at regular intervals. They were in general frustrated and almost resigned to their fate. They signed informed consent on the basis of the agreement that they would provide samples of their urine and blood only twice; once on the day before they started taking the “verum” or “placebo”, and then 2 months after administration of the “verum” or “placebo”.
Half of the 28 subjects dropped out, resulting in nine people in the treatment group and 5 in the placebo.Any conclusion would be 200C. The researchers seem to be unaware that multiple measurements in small numbers of subjects with multiple statistical analysis will find something ‘significant’ but are are as meaningless as the underlying premise of the study.
From the results of this pilot study, it becomes obvious that the verum-fed group showed positive ameliorating effects, like that of the other potencies of centesimal dilutions, Ars Alb 30C and Ars Alb 200C reported earlier. Since Ars Alb LM 0/3 potency can be used for a long time and since this remedy also has protective abilities in subjects living in a village where arsenic-free drinking water facility was unavailable, this could be used as an interim measure, particularly in remote villages without having any other kind of medical facility. As a higher potency may actually be required for sustaining the ameliorative effects, it is recommended that the remedy be used under supervision of a practicing homeopath, who may suggest when the next higher potency ought to be used. Furthermore, change in symptoms may call for some intermittent remedy (may be a constitutional remedy) as based on severity of condition and totality of symptoms…How the tiny globules soaked in the ultrahighly diluted remedy could bring about changes in so many parameters of study while the same could not be achieved by the Ars Alb LM 0/3 unsoaked globules (placebo) remain largely unknown. However, one working hypothesis advocated by Khuda-Bukhsh et al［17-19］ is that potentized homeopathic remedies may act as a “molecular switch” to trigger specific genes that may in turn activate/deactivate a cascade of other relevant genes may be one way of explaining such inexplicable phenomenon at the state of our present understanding.”
One would think in a town with arsenic in the water, that taking homeopathic water in large quantities would be of benefit, although they were limited to 10 drops twice a day. It is a town that actually needs a massive continual overdose of homeopathy: potable water. Finally a real use for homeopathy. Oddly they used an Indian homeopathic preparation and given the propensity of other Indian SCAM products to be adulterated with arsenic, I would be fatalistic as well if asked to be in the study.
CAM is placebo. Placebo is nothing. Therefore CAM is nothing.
Several studies out this year emphasized the concept that it is the therapeutic interaction and the patients belief that is important for the subjective (but not objective, for there are none) responses to SCAM’s, not the specific SCAM modality. Two nonsensical SCAM interventions had the same result.
First was homeopathy where
Homeopathic consultations but not homeopathic remedies are associated with clinically relevant benefits for patients with active but relatively stable RA.
The other was acupuncture. It has been know that acupuncture efficacy depends in part on how strongly the patient believes it will work. This was confirmed in a study in Pain where patients with osteoarthritis were treated with acupuncture, Streitberger placebo acupuncture, and mock electrical stimulation, each with empathic or nonempathic consultations. The results supported the understanding that the only thing that matters for reported outcomes with acupuncture is the patients belief in its efficacy, although one practitioner had better results than the others:
Empathic consultations did not affect pain (3.0mm, -2.2 to 8.2; P=.26) but practitioner 3 achieved greater analgesia than practitioner 2 (10.9, 3.9 to 18.0; P=.002)… The 2 placebos were equally as effective and credible as acupuncture. Needle and nonneedle placebos are equivalent. An unknown characteristic of the treating practitioner predicts outcome, as does the patient’s belief (independently).
Why do I envision a Rasputin like practitioner getting better results? SCAM’s, like placebo effects, are self deception by the patient and practitioner. N-Rays all the way down.
And if it were ethical, and it is not ethical since acupuncture is nonsense, you would be able to help the undiagnosed and perhaps undiagnoseable patient with a round of supportive acupuncture:
BACKGROUND:Medically unexplained physical symptoms (MUPS) are common and difficult to treat.AIM:To investigate the effectiveness of adding five-element acupuncture to usual care in ‘frequent attenders’ with MUPS. DESIGN AND SETTING:Randomised controlled trial in four London general practices.METHOD:Participants were 80 adults with MUPS, consulting GPs ≥8 times/year. The intervention was individualised five-element acupuncture, ≥12 sessions, immediately (acupuncture group) and after 26 weeks (control group). The primary outcome was 26-week Measure Yourself Medical Outcome Profile (MYMOP); secondary outcomes were wellbeing (W-BQ12), EQ-5D, and GP consultation rate. Intention-to-treat analysis was used, adjusting for baseline outcomes. RESULTS:Participants (80% female, mean age 50 years, mixed ethnicity) had high health-resource use. Problems were 59% musculoskeletal; 65% >1 year duration. The 26-week questionnaire response rate was 89%. Compared to baseline, the mean 26-week MYMOP improved by 1.0 (95% confidence interval [CI] = 0.4 to 1.5) in the acupuncture group and 0.6 (95% CI = 0.3 to 0.9) in the control group (adjusted mean difference: acupuncture versus control -0.6 [95% CI = -1.1 to 0] P = 0.05). Other between-group adjusted mean differences were: W-BQ12 4.4 (95% CI = 1.6 to 7.2) P = 0.002; EQ-5D index 0.03 (95% CI = -0.11 to 0.16) P = 0.70; consultation rate ratio 0.90 (95% CI = 0.70 to 1.15) P = 0.4; and number of medications 0.56 (95% CI = 0.47 to 1.6) P = 0.28. All differences favoured the acupuncture group. Imputation for missing values reduced the MYMOP adjusted mean difference to -0.4 (95% CI = -0.9 to 0.1) P = 0.12. Improvements in MYMOP and W-BQ12 were maintained at 52 weeks.CONCLUSION:The addition of 12 sessions of five-element acupuncture to usual care resulted in improved health status and wellbeing that was sustained for 12 months.”
Positive interactions with other humans is always of benefit can improve the quality of life. As I have said before, grooming each other has salubrious effects on apes. The benefits of SCAMs are the medical equivalent of nit picking, without the ick factor of eating the louse.
And finally, are there Florence and the Machine fans who can tell me what this study is all about? Clinical comparative study on the influence of acupoint sticking therapy in dog days and in non-dog days to the quality of life of allergic rhinitis patients. I thought the dog days were so over.

   Raw deal: Got diarrhea?
John Snyder
Link
I recently saw a 14 year old girl in my office with a 2 day history of severe abdominal cramps, bloody diarrhea, and fever. Her mother had similar symptoms as did several other members of her household and some family friends. After considerable discomfort, everyone recovered within a few days. The child’s stool culture grew a bacterium called Campylobacter.
Campylobacter is a nasty little pathogen which causes illness like that seen in my patient, but can also cause more severe disease. It is found commonly in both wild and domestic animals. But where did all these friends and family members get their campylobacter infections? Why, from their friendly farmer, of course!
My patient’s family and friends had taken a weekend pilgrimage to a family-run farm in Buck’s County, Pennsylvania. They saw farm animals and a working farm. And they all drank raw milk. Why raw milk? Because, as they were told and led to believe, raw milk is better. Better tasting and better for you.
In 1862, the french chemist Louis Pasteur discovered that heating wine to just below its boiling point could prevent spoilage. Now this process (known as pasteurization) is used to reduce the number of dangerous infectious organisms in many products, prolonging shelf life and preventing serious illness and death. But a growing trend toward more natural foods and eating habits has led to an interest in unpasteurized foods such as milk and cheese. In addition to superior taste, many claim that raw milk products provide health benefits not found in the adulterated versions. Claims made about the “good bacteria” (like Lactobacillus) conquering the “bad” bacteria (like Campylobacter, Salmonella, and E. coli) in raw milk are pure fantasy. Some even claim that the drinking of mass-produced, pasteurized milk has resulted in an increase in allergies, heart disease, cancer, and a variety of other diseases. Again, this lacks any scientific crediblity.
With this growing interest in unpasteurized dairy products has come an increase in the rate of food-born infections. The federal government developed the Grade ‘A’ Pasteurized Milk Ordinance in 1924, providing a set of guidelines for the safe processing and handling of milk products. Although all 50 states have voluntarily adopted these guidelines, the FDA has no oversight jurisdiction. It is up to individual states to determine their own safety protocols and enforcement strategies. While selling raw milk is currently illegal in 26 states, those with a will have found a way to skirt the law to get their fix of the real deal.
My patient was a victim of a recent outbreak in Pennsylvania, but similar outbreaks of infectious disease due to unpasteurized milk products are a recurring headache for public health officials. Between 1973 and 1993 there was an average of 2.3 milk born disease outbreaks per year. That number increased to 5.2 per year between 1993 and 2006. Whatever the numbers are, there is no question that the increasing consumption of raw milk is a genuine threat to public health.
The health claims made for raw milk, and against its pasteurized cousin, are being heavily pushed by a small but passionate contingent one might refer to as “food guardians.” These are people who espouse a return to the good old agrarian days of wholesome, farm-raised foods, free from man-made chemicals and mass-market processing. Some of these ideals are highly respectable and healthful responses to the ways in which society has dealt with the need to push products to a mass market at profit. For example, the use of pesticides, animal hormones and antibiotics, and farm run-off can have deleterious environmental and human health consequences. However, many of the health claims that are made about products like raw milk are not supported by scientific evidence, and lack scientific plausibility. Despite this lack of evidence, however, the allure of raw milk products is clearly on the rise.
Beyond the obvious public health consequences of this trend lies the problem of an increasing public credulousness when it comes to pseudoscientific claims. This is similar to the trend we are seeing regarding concerns about the dangers of vaccines and excessive fears concerning certain potential environmental hazards.
Unscientific and outright fraudulent claims about the health benefits (as well as the hidden dangers) of a variety of foods is on the rise. And bogus or unsupported nutrition claims are big business. From the immune boosting and weight loss powers of the acai berry, to the cancer protective effects of vitamins, nutrition pseudoscience is all the rage. While raw milk will never have quite the celebrity cache of these “super foods”, it is promoted with the same lofty yet empty claims, and provides the added bonus of infectious diarrhea.
On a recent visit to a local high-end wine shop, I came face-to-face with the ease with which people fall prey to the marketing of food pseudoscience. A woman was examining a bottle of wine when the store keeper approached to offer help. She told her a little about the wine and then said, “And all of their wines are biodynamic.” To this, the shopper exclaimed “Oh wow, that’s great.” She bought the wine, likely without having a clue what the term “biodynamic” even means. Biodynamic farming is a mixture of Gaia-like principles (the earth is a living organism) and organic practices, with a smattering of mysticism, alchemy, and astrology. In essence, a smorgasbord of pseudoscientific farming practices perfect for the current culture of armchair environmentalism and the new found heal-thy-self mantra of the well-to-do. While the motivating factors and socioeconomic status may differ between those drinking biodynamic wine and those drinking raw milk, both are relying on false beliefs and unsupported claims in making their choices to consume these products.
As a lover of cheese, I appreciate that there are those whose refined palates favor the delicacy of unpasteurized, aged cheeses so prevalent in other countries. But to stretch this taste preference to include health benefits unsupported by science and even common sense is not just misguided, it can be dangerous. Dangerous because it increases the risk of infectious disease, but also because it perpetuates a credulous perspective that adds to the ongoing erosion of our appreciation and acceptance of science.

More Evidence Raw Milk is Bad
More evidence that raw milk has no health benefit, but does carry higher health risks.
Steven Novella on July 8, 2020
Link

One of the common themes of SBM is that our public health decisions, and individual health decisions, should be based on the best evidence currently available evaluated as much as possible within a thorough scientific context. Unfortunately, many segments of society do not operate under this paradigm. Rather, they operate under one or more other approaches: what emotionally feels right, what is ideologically convenient, conspiracy thinking, or the demands of marketing. Often these threads weave together.
For example, industry often tries, and succeeds, to create a health halo around their product, so that people feel they are being smart and healthy when they use it, regardless of the science. They may also exploit an existing health halo, such as the notion that a product is “natural”. Conspiracy theories can always be invoked to fend off science-based criticism or refutation of their claims.
In essence alternate narratives to the scientific evidence can be manufactured, or can emerge spontaneously, and then take on a life of their own. Social media makes this process faster and easier, and can create virtual “rabbit holes” that curious people can fall into if they use social media to satisfy their interest in the topic.
One such rabbit hole is the “raw” food narrative. This is the notion, completely divorced from reality, that raw food is healthier than cooked or heated food. There was even a movement to sell “raw water”, which was essentially contaminated water. The “raw” health halo is especially pernicious, however, when applied to milk.
Most milk consumed in the US and industrialized nations is pasteurized and homogenized. Pasteurization is the process of flash heating raw milk in order to kill bacteria, making the milk safer and extending its shelf life. The process involves heating milk in stainless steel containers to 161° F for 15 seconds then rapidly cooling down to 39°F. This creates milk with a refrigerated shelf life of 10-21 days. There is also ultra-pasteurized milk, which involves heating to 280-300°F for 2-3 seconds and storing in a more sterile condition, which results in milk that still needs to be refrigerated, but can last 30-90 days.
Then there is UHT – ultra-high temperature pasteurization, which uses the same high temperature process as ultra-pasteurized, but then the milk is stored in sterile and hermetically sealed conditions. This produces shelf-stable milk that can last for 6 months without refrigeration.
Of course, regardless of the process, as soon as the container is opened there is the potential for contamination, and therefore it is recommended that the milk be consumed within 7-10 days.
Pasteurization undeniably works as advertised. As Mark Crislip summarized previously, the widespread use of pasteurization has reduced milk as a source of human bacterial infection outbreaks from 25% to 1%. Many studies have shown that consuming raw milk is a risk factor for bacterial infection. So why would raw milk proponents claim it is better? They believe that raw milk is more nutritious and tastes better, and contains healthy probiotics.
I am skeptical of the taste claim, because of the mountain of scientific evidence that taste is extremely subjective and amenable to other sensory clues and expectations. Therefore I only trust blinded taste tests. Having participated in these myself, it is often shocking how much expectation plays a role in perceived taste. To be generous, though, I will grant this point to anyone who has a personal preference, but I will just caution everyone that you really don’t know until you have done a blind test. Heating does chemically change the milk and therefore the flavor, but whether or not the result is “better” is personal choice.
The questions that have more scientific evidence behind them regard safety and benefits. Is raw milk better? The nutrition question has been answered. Here is one study that compares raw milk to standard “Holder” pasteurization and shelf-stable (retort processing or SS) milk:
Macronutrient content is relatively unaffected by processing; Holder pasteurization and retort processing maintain similar fat, lactose, and total protein levels. Lysine and thiamine were significantly decreased by retort processing, but not by Holder pasteurization. Thiamine losses are clinically significant, and fortification may be necessary if SS donor milk is a long-term feeding choice.
For regular pasteurized milk, therefore, there is no significant nutritional difference. Any minor differences are clinically irrelevant. Ultra-pasteurized or shelf stable milk has reduced thiamine, which is only an issue if milk is your primary source of thiamine, which is likely not true for most people. Milk doesn’t even crack the top ten in terms of sources of thiamine, which you can get from a variety of meats, vegetables, and legumes.
So the nutrition claim is bogus. What about the claim that raw milk contains beneficial probiotics? That is partially the topic of a recent study. They examined raw and pasteurized milk for bacterial content at baseline and over time if left at room temperature vs refrigeration at 4 C. They found:
Despite advertised “probiotic” effects, our results indicate that raw milk microbiota has minimal lactic acid bacteria.
The claim to health benefits from routine use of probiotics is problematic at best in any case. The best conclusion we can make from existing data is that there is no benefit for healthy people routinely consuming probiotics. There is some open question when it comes to those suffering from irritable bowel syndrome or similar conditions, and also with the use of high culture count probiotics in the early treatment of diarrhea produced by antibiotic use. Even there the data is thin, but a benefit is plausible. But there is clearly no benefit from routine use.
This is a double-whammy for the raw milk claim – routine consumption of probiotics is probably not beneficial, and raw milk doesn’t contain them anyway.
What raw milk does contain in abundance is pathogenic bacteria, those capable of causing infection. Further, raw milk is loaded with antibiotic resistant genes (residing in those bacteria). Consuming raw milk not only risks infection, it is potentially seeding the bacteria already in your body with antibiotic resistant genes. This study does not establish a specific health risk to consuming the resistant genes, but they are a potential hazard.
Unsurprisingly, leaving raw milk at room temperature quickly and dramatically increases the number of bacteria and resistant genes. People do this when they are making a culture for certain products. The authors recommend that a starter culture be used instead of starting with raw milk. Incidentally, at refrigeration temperatures the bacterial counts were stable (but still higher in raw milk).
        ◦ The bottom line is that there is no health benefit to drinking raw milk vs pasteurized milk, but there is a clear increased risk from pathogenic bacteria and now possibly from increased spread of antibiotic resistant genes.

More On Raw Milk
HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. has been pushing the narrative that raw unpasteurized milk is both safe and better for your health than pasteurized milk. As usual, he is objectively wrong.
Steven Novella on April 8, 2026
Link

Our current HHS secretary has been pushing the narrative that raw unpasteurized milk is good for your health, and the FDA is wrong to overregulate it they way it does (what he calls “aggressive suppression”). He is objectively wrong, but this has resurfaced the public misinformation fight over raw milk.
I last wrote about the topic six years ago, focusing on the question of risk of bacterial infection from raw vs pasteurized milk. The quick version is, pasteurization (which is simply heating milk to kill bacteria) works, it reduces the risk of infection from milk, it is an effective public health measure, and it does not significantly degrade the nutritional value of milk.
A 2017 study concluded: “Unpasteurized dairy products thus cause 840 (95% CrI 611–1,158) times more illnesses and 45 (95% CrI 34–59) times more hospitalizations than pasteurized products. As consumption of unpasteurized dairy products grows, illnesses will increase steadily; a doubling in the consumption of unpasteurized milk or cheese could increase outbreak-related illnesses by 96%.”
This data has not changed. The CDC reports: “During 2009–2021, a total of 143 enteric disease outbreaks that were confirmed or suspected to be associated with consumption of raw milk were reported to CDC.”
Since this is based on reporting this is likely an underestimate. In 2017 it was estimated that 3.2% of the US population consumes raw milk. This has increased to 4.4% more recently. Proponents cite the overall low numbers of outbreaks, but this of course misses the point – if regulations decrease and raw milk consumption increases, outbreak numbers would increase as well. Also, having greater numbers of pathogens passing through cows to humans increases the probability of a zoonotic spillover event from this source.
It’s a lot of risk with no benefit. Previously I have focused on the risk part of this equation, while noting the lack of nutritional benefits. But proponents also claim another benefit claim that I have not previously discussed, that it reduces lactose intolerance. Two putative mechanisms are cited, that raw milk contains bacteria that produce enzymes that help digest lactose, or that the raw milk is itself easier to digest. Neither of these claims, however, is true.
There is no evidence that drinking raw milk is less likely to cause symptoms of lactose intolerance than drinking pasteurized milk. There appears to be only one actual study of the question, which found no difference. Raw milk also contains the same amount of lactose as pasteurized milk.
Raw milk does contain one thing in much larger amounts that pasteurize milk – bacteria. Some of those bacteria are lactobacilli, which can produce beta-galactosidase which does digest lactose. But they do so in insignificant amounts which have no effect on milk digestion. Raw milk, therefore, is not a probiotic.
Even the evidence for the effects of probiotics on symptoms of lactose intolerance is fairly weak, but on the whole there is likely an effect. However, this effect is strongly dose dependent, and you need a high colony count to see it. Again this supports the conclusion that the extremely low counts (of lactobacilli – most bacteria in raw milk are not probiotic but are environmental or pathogenic) in raw milk are unlikely to have any effect on lactose intolerance.
Another claim of benefit touted by raw milk proponents is that it reduces the risk of asthma, allergies in general, or milk allergies specifically. None of these claims are established either. There is no significant protein difference between raw and pasteurized milk and no observed difference in the likelihood of having an allergic reaction.
There is a 2007 study showing an association with the consumption of farm milk and reduced asthma and allergy risk. However, this was not a study of raw milk, it was a study of farm milk, which is often boiled (a form of pasteurization). There is already an established link between living on a farm and lower risk of asthma and allergies, which does likely result from exposure to allergens at a young age. However this has never been established for raw milk.
In the end we have ample evidence for significant risk of harm from consuming raw milk or dairy products, and no significant evidence for any benefit. The FDA is therefore correct to regulate raw milk products in order to reduce the risk of food-borne infections and zoonotic spillover.


PETA Embraces Autism Pseudoscience
Steven Novella on May 28, 2014
Link
PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) has a history of (as the old saying goes) using science as a drunk uses a lamppost – for support rather than illumination. In that way they are typical of ideological groups. They have an agenda, they are very open about their beliefs, and they marshal whatever arguments they can in order to promote their point of view.
Favoring information that supports our current beliefs is a cognitive bias common to Homo sapiens, but ideology tends to take this simple bias to a new level. It can lead to the systematic distortion or denial of science, and render belief systems immune to logic and evidence.
PETA provides us with a nice example of how having an ideological agenda can motivate an individual or a group to embrace dubious science. In an article currently on their website, and making the rounds in social media (this is repeating a claim from at least 2008, but the current article is undated), the group warns: Got Autism? Learn About the Link Between Dairy Products and the Disease. They claim:
The reason why dairy foods may worsen or even cause autism is being debated. Some suspect that casein harms the brain, while others suggest that the gastrointestinal problems so often caused by dairy products cause distress and thus worsen behavior in autistic children.
Saying that “how” dairy harms the brain is being debated implies “that” dairy harms the brain is accepted and not being debated. This is misleading. It is not accepted that dairy harms the brain or is in any way linked to autism, and the evidence is largely against it.
Gluten-free and casein-free diets for autism have been around for decades. They are based largely on the anecdotal observation that children with autism can experience a worsening in behavior when they consume gluten (a protein in wheat and other grains) or casein (a protein in milk and other dairy products). Parents will sometimes try to place their children on a gluten-free or casein-free diet, and some report improvement in behavior.
Such observations are a reasonable basis for a hypothesis, but not a conclusion. Behavior in children, especially those with the challenge of autism, can be unpredictable. Unpredictable and variable symptoms lend themselves to confirmation bias, with a strong tendency to lead to the anecdotal experience that whatever is being looked for is real. For example, many parents believe that sugar makes their children hyperactive, when this is simply not true.
Such uncontrolled observations need to be confirmed by blinded observations. These studies have been done for both gluten-free and casein-free diets. A 2008 Cochrane review of these studies concluded:
Current evidence for efficacy of these diets is poor. Large scale, good quality randomised controlled trials are needed.
A more recent review from April 2014 came to a similar conclusion:
We observed that the evidence on this topic is currently limited and weak.
The pattern of evidence reveals that the methodologically poor studies, ones that are liable to confirmation bias, show some effect, but the properly blinded studies tend to show no effect. For example, a 2010 study (although small) observed children with autism on a gluten-free and casein-free diet, and then challenged them with either gluten, casein, or placebo in a blinded manner. There was no difference in behavior observed. A recent 2014 study also showed no association between dairy and behavior in autism.
As an aside, when such studies are pointed out, the emotional argument is sometimes made that we are “attacking mothers” or “criticizing parents.” This is a diversion, however. Our only point is that parents are humans and are subject to the same cognitive biases that we are all subject to. Being a parent does not magically render someone immune to bias. We need controlled and blinded observations so that we can differentiate between a real effect and self-deception. When an effect disappears under proper blinding, the most likely conclusion is that the phenomenon is not real but is an artifact of observational bias.
Given current evidence, that is the best conclusion we can come to regarding the effects of gluten and casein on autism. The evidence for any effect on behavior is weak and likely not real. There is also no credible evidence to suggest that casein plays a causal role in autism. The evidence is overwhelming that autism is a genetic disorder. Clinical signs are evident at least by 6 months of age, if not sooner, and there is evidence that the developmental processes leading to autism begin in the womb. Despite this, the PETA article concludes:
It isn’t surprising that dairy products may worsen this disease, considering that milk has already been strongly linked to cancer, Crohn’s disease, and other serious health problems. Anyone who wants to alleviate or avoid the devastating effects of autism should give cow’s milk the boot and switch to healthy vegan alternatives instead.
PETA claims that “milk has already been strongly linked to cancer.” That is their summary of the evidence. Now let’s read the conclusion of a 2011 systematic review of the published evidence:
For most cancers, associations between cancer risk and intake of milk and dairy products have been examined only in a small number of cohort studies, and data are inconsistent or lacking. Meta-analyses of cohort data available to date support an inverse association between milk intake and risk of colorectal and bladder cancer and a positive association between diets high in calcium and risk of prostate cancer.
(This May 2014 systematic review comes to the same conclusion.) So milk, if anything, has a protective effect for colon and bladder cancer, while high calcium diets (not necessarily from dairy, but milk is high in calcium) increase the risk of prostate cancer. For all other cancers the jury is still out. Milk therefore might reduce cancer risk in women, and probably also in men, as long as you limit your total calcium intake.
There is also not a “strong” association with Crohn’s. There is preliminary evidence at best. One study of the incidence of Crohn’s in Japan found an increase in incidence after the introduction of a more Western diet, including meat and dairy, and reduction in rice consumption. There are too many variables here to make any conclusions about dairy specifically. There is also preliminary evidence that a bacterium found in cow’s milk may be linked to Crohn’s. Crohn’s is still a poorly understood disease and there is no clear evidence that dairy is playing a causative role.
It’s not even clear if people with Crohn’s need to limit their dairy intake. There are no blanket recommendations for patients with Crohn’s. A recent study found no association between dairy intake and symptoms, suggesting that there is no need to restrict dairy. Some patients with Crohn’s may also have lactose intolerance, and this can be difficult to diagnose because of the overlap in symptoms, so a lactose-free trial period is often recommended. However, eliminating dairy can cause nutritional deficiencies, such as low calcium, and so this needs to be done with care.
Conclusion
There is no evidence that dairy products cause autism, and the current evidence (while weak) does not support the conclusion that dairy has an adverse effect on behavior in children with autism. Further, dairy has a complex relationship with cancer risk, and is as much a benefit as a potential risk factor. There is also not a strong link between dairy and Crohn’s, although some preliminary evidence warrants follow up.
PETA, however, has launched a campaign warning the public about the association between milk and autism, throwing in claims that it is “strongly” linked to cancer, Crohn’s, and other unnamed diseases.
This is clearly, in my opinion, a campaign of fear mongering based upon a gross distortion of the scientific evidence. The purpose is to advocate for a vegan diet, which fits their ideological agenda. They are likely aware that it is easier to spread fears than to reassure with a careful analysis of the scientific evidence.

   One Hump or Two? Camel’s Milk as a New Alternative Medicine
Harriet Hall
Link
I wasn’t really surprised to learn that camel milk is being promoted as a medicine. I long ago realized that the human power of belief is inexhaustible. The news did make me laugh, probably because camels are rather funny-looking animals, because I am easily amused, because it reminded me of some of my favorite camel jokes, and because it wouldn’t do any good to cry.
Camel milk has been claimed to cure or benefit patients with diabetes, tuberculosis, stomach ulcers, gastroenteritis, cancer, allergies, infections, parasites, autism, even AIDS. This isn’t really quite as silly as it might sound. PubMed does list several studies showing health benefits from camel milk. A handful of studies have suggested that camel milk improves control of blood sugar in diabetes, but they are preliminary studies that typically compare standard treatment to standard treatment plus camel milk rather than using a blinded control. There are also a few small, poor quality studies suggesting a possible benefit in allergies, in peptic ulcers, in infections such as hepatitis, and in schistosomiasis. All in all, the research doesn’t amount to much. Camel milk can only be classed as experimental treatment. The existing studies justify doing more (and better quality) research, but they don’t justify prescribing it to treat patients.
Among other properties, camel’s milk is high in vitamin C, low in vitamin A, and low in fat compared to cow’s milk, and it is tolerated by those who are lactose intolerant. It is different from cow’s milk in many other ways that I won’t attempt to list, but the clinical significance of those differences is not clear.
A couple of studies suggested reasons for caution. A study in Saudi Arabia, where brucellosis is endemic, showed that the main source of brucellosis infection was unpasteurized camel milk and there is a report of anaphylaxis to camel’s milk in a child with atopy.
The founder of the American Camel Coalition, Millie Hinkle, ND, says
The high levels of insulin in camel’s milk and the antibodies, which are much simpler in structure than human milk antibodies, enable it to penetrate deeper into the human tissue and cells [whaat?], which means that the milk has the potential to serve as a major weapon against many human illnesses.
She thinks that studies done in other countries on autism, diabetes, cancer, heart disease, Crohn’s, Parkinson’s, food allergies and a variety of other illnesses have been “impressive.” I couldn’t locate the studies she cites for some of these claims, and I didn’t think the ones I did find were “impressive.” The one she cites for autism is not original research but just a speculative rumination that includes brief, unconvincing reports of three patient observations and talks about highly controversial and disproven hypotheses as if they were proven facts. She wants to repeat previous studies using pasteurized camel milk; obviously pasteurization is a wise move, but rather than repeating previous studies, why not do better designed, controlled studies?
I didn’t know what to make of one study I found on PubMed. Its abstract said
Camels’ milk, women’s milk and cows’ milk were kept at 30 degrees C and refrigerated at 4 degrees C. This explains the necessity to immediately freeze milk if it needs to be kept even for a few days. Cows’ milk remained good for days if stirred and then turned sour, enabling the making of cheeses and butter. Camels’ milk did not sour at 4 degrees C for up to 3 months. This means that camels’ milk is mainly good only for drinking, as was promised to this animal by the Prophet.
Isn’t it inappropriate to make religious comments in scientific articles? Is religious support pertinent? In Sunni Islam, the Sahih Bukhari, one of the six major Hadith collections, does include several verses where the prophet Muhammad is said to have advocated drinking camel’s milk and urine as medicine. For instance,
The climate of Medina did not suit some people, so the Prophet ordered them to follow his shepherd, i.e. his camels, and drink their milk and urine (as a medicine). So they followed the shepherd that is the camels and drank their milk and urine till their bodies became healthy. Then they killed the shepherd and drove away the camels.
The Sahih Bukhari’s medical advice is not reliable or even consistent. It also says
Healing is in three things: A gulp of honey, cupping, and branding with fire (cauterizing). But I forbid my followers to use (cauterization) branding with fire.
Does that mean Muslims shouldn’t bother with any medical treatment but honey and cupping?
I’m not just picking on Muslims. Other religious texts also give questionable medical advice. In the Essene Gospel of Peace, Jesus gave detailed instructions for colon cleansing using river water and a long-necked gourd:
Seek, therefore, a large trailing gourd, having a stalk the length of a man; take out its inwards and fill it with water from the river which the sun has warmed. Hang it upon the branch of a tree, and kneel upon the ground before the angel of water, and suffer the end of the stalk of the trailing gourd to enter your hinder parts, that the water may flow through your bowels.
I’d rather drink camel milk than do that.
There is even a book Love Thine Enemas and Heal Thyself. One of the customer reviews on Amazon.com says “This book helps people understand the love of God, in a very intimate area.” You can find the darnedest things on the Internet! But I digress…
There is a website, Camel Milk for Health that recounts one (only one!?) story about a young man who had an undiagnosed condition that allegedly made him “allergic to all foods…unable to eat or digest any foods, unable to absorb any food nutrients” so that he was “subsisting on a tablespoon of rice and a tablespoon of rice milk per day.” Do you believe that? His parents claim he was cured by drinking camel milk, and they tell how they had to battle the authorities to get special permits to import the milk into Canada. The website announces a symposium to be held in Vancouver BC on February 9th with 3 panelists entitled “Camel Milk: A New Alternative Medicine.” The main speaker is a retired professor of veterinary medicine from Israel who has done some of the research. The symposium is sponsored by an orthodox Jewish congregation, the oldest and largest synagogue in Vancouver. I am puzzled, because camels and camel milk are trayf (not kosher) and are forbidden to orthodox Jews.
While looking for evidence of possible health benefits, I came across some intriguing camel trivia in the Wikipedia article:
    • Camel milk can’t be made into butter by conventional churning methods.
    • The Abu Dhabi Officer’s Club serves camelburgers. Bubonic plague has been transmitted by eating camel liver.
    • The ancient Roman emperor Heliogabalus enjoyed eating camel’s heel.
    • Camel blood is consumed in Northern Kenya.
    • Camel lasagna is available in Alice Springs, Australia.
It’s nice to know these things. Forgive the digression.
If you want to try camel milk, you can’t. Selling it is illegal in the US. According to a CBS news report in July 2010,
The FDA allows people to drink camel milk, but it can’t be imported or sold in the U.S. until a test for drug residues is validated, said FDA spokesman Michael Herndon.
Could this be a conspiracy by Big Dairy to prevent competition?
The Camel Milk for Health website links to the Oasis Camel Dairy website, which is interesting and has some cool pictures. The OCD is producing camel milk but is not legally allowed to sell it. What they can and do sell is camel milk soap for $5.00 in varieties like “gold frankincense and myrrh” and “rosemary mint.” They also sell camel milk chocolate bars.
All of the research seems to be on one-hump camels. It’s not clear whether Bactrian camel milk is equally efficacious. The “one hump or two” question remains to be answered; but there’s no rush, since we can’t get either kind of milk. Jabalicious and other brands have recently come on the market in the UK, but those of us who live in the US will have to either wait for FDA approval or buy our own camel and milk it ourselves.

   Oil of Oregano
Scott Gavura
Link
Paradoxically, the less evidence that exists to support the use of of a treatment, the more passionate its supporters seem to be. I learned this early in my career as a pharmacist. One pharmacy I worked at did a steady business in essential oils. And king of the oils was oil of oregano. Not only were there several different brands of the basic oil, they were different forms, including capsules, creams and even nasal sprays. Not aware of any therapeutic benefits, I would ask customers what they were using it for. I rarely heard the same condition described: skin infections, athlete’s foot, head lice, colds, sore throats, “parasites”, “yeasts”, diabetes, allergies and ringworm were apparently no match against the judicious use of oregano oil. Intrigued, I took a closer look.
Long before our scientific understanding of bacteria and antimicrobials, infected wounds were packed with different products in an attempt to minimize the odour, and hopefully speed healing. It’s likely that someone happened upon a fragrant herb and discovered that it seemed to help treat wounds (or at least, cover some of the smell). Given there have been some amazing drugs with powerful effects that have emerged from natural products, it’s certainly plausible that oil of oregano could have biological and therapeutic effects. Oregano (Origanum vulgare) leaves contain a wide variety of chemical compounds, including leanolic acids, ursolic acids, and phenolic glycosides. Phenolic compounds make up to 71% of the oil. Carvacrol, thymol, cymene, and terpinine and are found in oregano leaves and do appear to have biological effects. It’s these chemicals that are proposed to be the parts with beneficial effects.
The claims made by one manufacturer are unambiguous:
Oreganol P73 is the most powerful germ killer with scientifically proven results against almost every virus, bacteria, parasite, and fungi. The complexity of the phytochemical matrix in Oreganol P73 possesses a broad spectrum of antimicrobial properties that are safe for prolonged use. The oil can be used topically and internally. Oreganol P73 is the medicine chest in a bottle, especially since it is proven never to harm the internal organs, even when used daily for health maintenance.
So if we accept the manufacturer’s claims at face value, there should be evidence demonstrating oregano oil is both safe and effective when used internally and externally. There is apparently also adequate long-term safety data to demonstrate that it can be safely used on a daily basis.
Effectiveness
When we contemplate administering a chemical to deliver a medicinal effect, we need to ask the following:
    • Is it absorbed into the body at all?
    • Does enough reach the right part of the body to have an effect?
    • Does it actually work for the condition?
    • Does it have any hazardous, unwanted effects?
    • Can it be safely eliminated from the body?
These questions are usually answered through a series of investigations, starting with preclinical (test-tube) studies, and moving into to animal trials, and then to human clinical trials that start with validating safety, and then progress to investigating efficacy and safety.
The short answer is that there’s little beyond animal studies to demonstrate that the ingredients in oregano oil have any effects. One of the best reviews seems to come from the McCormick Science Institute (yes, the spice company). They commissioned a paper on oregano by Keith Singletary that appeared in the journal Nutrition Today in 2010. Happily, though the journal is paywalled, McCormick is hosting the paper on its own website.
1. Is oil of oregano absorbed? Some parts of the oregano do appear to be absorbed but the bioavailability of its different chemical constituents has not been verified. So we can’t be certain which components are reaching the circulation.
2. Does enough reach the right part of the body to have any beneficial effect? It’s not clear where the chemicals in oil of oregano act in the body, as no research has been done to show that it is adequately absorbed. However, there is some evidence to suggest that oregano may be implicated in inducing abortions in mice, so some parts of the herb must be absorbed, if this a causal effect. When applied to body surfaces or skin for topical effect, oil of oregano is more likely to reach high concentrations, at least locally, and then possibly deliver a medicinal effect. This makes topical effects seem much more plausible than ones that require ingestion.
3. Does it actually work for the condition? There is no published evidence to demonstrate that that oil of oregano is effective for any medical condition or illness. The McCormick review notes that that data for every condition evaluated is “preliminary, inconclusive.” There is some very limited evidence to suggest that it might be useful for parasite infections — but given the evidence consists of only one study with 14 patients, and no placebo comparison, we really have no idea if the oregano oil itself was effective.
Let’s consider how oil of oregano might treat an infection. Bacteria are killed by antimicrobials based on a specific dose-response relationship. The minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) must be reached at the site of an infection. Then there’s a concentration range where the bacteria (or viruses, or fungi, or parasites, depending on what you’re treating) are killed, typically in rough proportion to the dose. Keep increasing the dose, and the effect plateaus. If you can hit the MIC without causing side effects or toxicity, congratulations: you have a potential therapeutic agent.
There’s some evidence out there demonstrating that oil of oregano will kill different species of bacteria, etc in the test tube or Petri dish ( in vitro). If I pour a pile of salt, lime juice, Cointreau, or tequila on a Petri dish, it will likely kill most bacteria too — but that doesn’t mean margaritas can treat pneumonia. It’s not difficult to kill bacteria if you change the conditions enough that it cannot live. So while it’s easy to get high concentrations of oregano in a test tube and subsequent positive effects, these effects are meaningless in the human body unless we can achieve similar concentrations, without any toxicity. And this has not been demonstrated with oil of oregano, or its individual chemical ingredients.
4. Does oil of oregano have any hazardous, unwanted effects? Natural does not mean safe. There are some reports of gastrointestinal upset with oil of oregano. There are also reports of allergic reactions. There is no evidence to suggest that oil of oregano, used at high (medicinal) amounts, may be used safely in pregnant or breast feeding women. However, when used in cooking, and as part of a regular diet, there is also no evidence that causes harm in pregnancy or breastfeeding. Animal studies show that if you give enough carvacrol, it will kill, though.
5. Can oil of oregano be safely eliminated from the body? So little published research exists on oil of oregano there is no way to determine if oregano oil is non-toxic. Certainly, at low doses, when used as a food, there is no reason to have any concerns. But at higher doses, and particularly with regular use, there is no data to sugges it’s safe to consume all that carvacrol, thymol, cymene, and terpinine. As we have no idea if and how oregano oil works, we have no information to estimate what a proper dose might be. Doses published by manufacturers are not based on any published evidence.
Conclusion
Oil of oregano, and the claims attached to it, is a great example of how interesting laboratory findings can be wildly exaggerated to imply meaningful effects in humans. A few small studies have been conducted, mainly in the lab, and advocates argue this is evidence of effectiveness. The rest is all anecdotes.
Despite the hype, there is no persuasive evidence to demonstrate that oil of oregano does anything useful in or on our bodies. And while it is popular, there is no science to support the use of oil of oregano for any medical condition. Suggesting that this herb is can effectively treat serious medical conditions like diabetes, asthma, and cancer is foolish and dangerous. If you’re ill, stick to the proven science, and save your oregano for cooking.

Turmeric for osteoarthritis: Promising but modest effects
A new trial of turmeric (curcumin) for osteoarthritis suggest it may have medicinal effects.
Scott Gavura on September 17, 2020
Link

Osteoarthritis (OA) is a chronic joint condition that can include pain, stiffness, and limitations on a joint’s range of motion. It commonly affects the knees but can also be found in other joints in the body. The traditional view of osteoarthritis was that it was a consequence of wear and tear on the joint, leading to cartilage thinning and ultimately, bone-on-bone friction. The reality of OA is more complex: What appears in investigations (like X-rays) does not reliably correlate with pain and other symptoms. Osteoarthritis is increasingly considered a whole body or systemic condition with a variety of contributing factors, which can ultimately manifest as joint pain. It is the old, narrow view of OA that led to the traditional perception that joints were “worn out” and that rest and drugs were preferred over more active therapies. This was misguided and wrong.
Physical activity and active management are now the preferred primary treatments for OA. However there continues to be a heavy reliance on medications to treat OA. These treatments range from simple analgesics (like acetaminophen (e.g., Tylenol)), anti-inflammatory drugs (e.g., ibuprofen or naproxen), topical treatments (as I have written about before), and less commonly, opioids, injections, and supplements like glucosamine and chondroitin. For the treatment of OA, there is good evidence that most of these treatments provide minor/modest benefits compared to placebos. Moreover, many of these products have substantial side effect profiles that make them undesirable for use for a chronic condition, like OA.
A preferred new treatment for OA would provide substantial pain relief compared to a placebo, with an acceptable side effect profile. It would ideally target some of the underlying pain signalling pathways that have been observed. Turmeric (Curcuma longa) has a long history of use as a traditional medicine and as a food ingredient. The main ingredient, curcumin, has a number of interesting biological properties, and it has been studied as a treatment for OA before. A 2017 systematic review compiled all the evidence and concluded that curcumin was an effective therapy, albeit less effective than ibuprofen. Even that conclusion was weak, given the diversity and overal poor quality of the original studies, all of which had been done in Asia. This brings us to a new randomized controlled trial that examined the effectiveness of curcumin on OA in adults in Tasmania.

Reeling In Misrepresentation: Fish Oil Supplements Found Lacking
An analysis of label claims for fish oil supplements finds a lot of tall tales
Scott Gavura on September 14, 2023
Link

The dietary supplement market in the United States is a multi-billion-dollar industry, enjoying steady growth year over year, and is currently valued at over $40 billion. The industry encompasses a wide range of products, including vitamins, minerals, herbal remedies, sports nutrition supplements, and more. Fish oil supplement sales are big business, and the category is one of the more popular in the market. Annual sales of fish-derived supplements amount to more than a $1-billion market in the United States, driven more by hype than good evidence. Many formulations are sold over-the-counter, while others require a prescription or are available for purchase from a health care provider. The enthusiasm for fish oil has been influenced in part by observational studies of diets, noting a relationship between fatty fish consumption and cardiovascular disease. But in trials with fish oil capsules, those benefits haven’t been demonstrated.
The absence of good product quality and labelling standards is a substantial barrier to the science-based use of supplements. With drugs, standards are rigorous and largely consistent across countries: Clinical trials are conducted to determine if a drug has meaningful effects. These clinical trials are scrutinized by regulators. Products approved are considered safe and effective based on that evaluation. Marketing claims related to drugs are permitted only as they are consistent with the evidence that supported their approval.
The same quality assurance standards are not in place for supplements. Even if there is promising data from clinical trials, we can’t make the same inference about the expected effects, because there is not guarantee that a supplement for sale is identical to (or even closely similar to) another product.
A new paper by Joanna N. Assadourian and colleagues looks at health claims and doses of fish oil supplements in the US. Published in JAMA Cardiology in August 2023, it reinforces existing concerns about the labelling of supplements, and gives further evidence that consumers are not well served by the status quo.
Fishy claims
The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is responsible for overseeing the regulation of health-related statements found on supplement labels, as mandated by the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994. For fish oil supplements, two categories of health claims are permitted: qualified health claims (QHCs) and structure/function claims (SFCs).
QHCs are statements that pertain to the potential of a supplement or food product to treat or prevent diseases. QHCs are vetted by the FDA against the evidence. (It’s worth noting that all QHCs include qualifying language that acknowledges the absence of a universally established scientific consensus or the presence of uncertainty.) In the case of fish oil, there are two FDA-approved QHCs, one addressing coronary heart disease (CHD) and the other focusing on blood pressure (BP), both in 2004. However, since that time, RCTs have failed to show that fish oil has cardiovascular benefits. The FDA does continue to allow these claims, despite the accumulated evidence since 2004.
SFCs claims describe the role of a nutrient or dietary component in influencing the structure or function of the human body. Importantly ,these claims cannot state that the supplement can prevent, treat, or cure any disease. Examples of structure/function claims include statements like “calcium contributes to strong bone health” or “fiber supports regular bowel function.” If you see phrases such as “maintains,” “supports,” or “promotes” on a supplement label, that is an SFC.
Perhaps given there is no obvious or proven benefit to fish oil supplements, products are sold in a variety of formats and doses. When administered at higher levels, eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), the active constituents found in fish oil, are plausibly beneficial. In an RCT, a daily intake of 4 grams of purified EPA led to a reduction in cardiovascular events. However, a subsequent trial involving high-dose combined EPA and DHA did not demonstrate any cardiovascular benefits. When consumed at doses of 2 grams or more per day, EPA and DHA can lower triglyceride levels in individuals with hypertriglyceridemia, albeit at an elevated risk of atrial fibrillation.
The authors in this study sought to evaluate the claims made on labels of fish oil supplements and to examine the doses of marketed supplements. It used labels from fish oils taken from the National Institutes of Health Office of Dietary Supplement’s Label Database. This database is compiled of product labels voluntarily submitted by manufacturers. Manual data extraction was used to determine the total daily dose of EPA, DHA, and total EPA+DHA from each supplement. Screening of each label was performed to to find and categorize QHCs and SFCs.
Starting with an initial list of of 20,000 supplements in the database, the final data set included 2819 fish oil supplements, of which 2082 (73.9%) contained at least one health-related label claim. The overwhelming majority of claims where SFCs (80.8%), 18.9% made a QHC for coronary heart disease and 0.14% used a QHC for blood pressure. The majority of labels suggest advantages for cardiovascular health, such as statements like “supports heart health.” Many fish oil supplements also assert benefits for various other bodily systems, such as brain/mental health, joint health, and eye health, despite a lack evidence to substantiate these claims. Claims were distributed as follows:
Some of the SFAs on labels included:
    • Heart: “promotes heart health”; “supports heard, mind and mood”
    • Brain: “DHA is one of the good fats that helps keep our brains running optimally as we age”; “helps prevent against normal cognitive decline as we age”
    • Joint: “promotes joint comfort & mobility”; “omega-3 fatty acids are necessary for many vital functions in the body and support heart health and healthy skin and joint function”
    • Eye: “maintains eye health and normal vision”; “promotes brain, vision, joint and heart health”
    • Antioxidant: “powerful antioxidant support for healthy aging and vitality”; “broad spectrum cellular health formula”
    • Immune/inflammation: “immune system support”; “advanced cellular support & immune activation”
    • Lipid lowering/cholesterol lowering: “Omega 3 FA, especially when combined with exercise, can help to support the maintenance of healthy blood lipids”
    • Triglycerides: “clinically proven to maintain healthy triglyceride levels”
Looking at dosing in a subset of products, 255 labels were examined. Most (91.2%) contained EPA and DHA, with a minority containing one or the other. The median dose was 240mg of EPA and 270mg of DHA, and a total of 600mg/day of combined DHA and EPA. Few (9.4%) had doses of 2000mg or more of EPA+DHA which was the higher dose necessary to lower triglycerides.
Navigating the supplement oil: Buyer beware
There were several limitations to this study. Importantly, it was based on labels that were voluntarily submitted to the National Institutes of Health Dietary Supplement Label Database. There could be other products where the manufacturer didn’t bother submitting a label – and those were not captured. For dosages measurements, only supplements from the 16 largest potential brands were evaluated.
The primary and most important finding of this audit of fish oil product labels was that they showed a diversity of structure/function claims, which are not supported by robust evidence. While it’s not known if unfounded claims are driving demand for this category of supplements, consumers are likely not well-served by products with a variety of unsubstantiated claims. This study also showed a array of product formulations and doses. Unfortunately there was no actual audit of capsule content, so it’s not known how accurate labels actually are. While the authors point to this variety of product formulations (and doses) as a problem, I personally feel that as long as products are accurately labelled, then a diversity of formulations is reasonable. However, it needs to accompanied by good information for consumers so they know what an “appropriate dose” is. Given there is a lack of convincing evidence demonstrating that that fish oil capsules are beneficial for health, perhaps this is an unrealistic expectation.

Is Olive Oil Good Medicine?
A study found that olive oil increased longevity and reduced the risk of cardiovascular disease, cancer, and other chronic diseases, but it only showed correlation, not causation.
Harriet Hall on August 23, 2022
Link

I enjoy the taste of olive oil and use it for cooking. It has been recommended as part of the Mediterranean diet for heart health and as a healthy monounsaturated replacement for other fats in the diet. But should we take it as medicine to promote longevity and reduce the risk of death from other diseases? A news item in Reader’s Digest says we should, that it is beneficial either used in cooking or taken straight from the bottle. It reports a Harvard study that makes olive oil sound like a miracle drug, almost a panacea. But that study only showed correlation, not causation.
The study was published in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology in Jan 2022. It was an observational study based on the self-reported eating habits of over 92,000 participants in the Nurses Health Study and the Health Professionals Follow-up Study. Participants filled out questionnaires every 4 years over a 28-year period, answering questions about their use of olive oil for salad dressing, baking, frying, sauteing, and spreading on bread, and about their use of other vegetable oils, margarine, butter, and dairy fat. The researchers tried to calculate the average amount consumed and looked at the causes of death for those in the highest quartile of olive oil consumption compared to those who rarely or never used olive oil.
The results
36,856 people died during the period studied. Those in the highest quartile of olive oil consumption were 19% less likely to die from all causes. They were 19% less likely to die of cardiovascular disease, 17% less likely to die of cancer, 29% less likely to die of neurodegenerative diseases, and 18% less likely to die of respiratory diseases.
Correlation does not always mean causation. Sometimes it does. For instance, when you are weighing apples, the number registered on the scale is correlated with the number of apples added, which is the direct cause. But it’s easy for correlation to be mistaken for causation when there is no causal link. Children learn as they get older, and they also grow in body size. The size of a child’s vocabulary would be expected to correlate well with their shoe size. A simplistic interpretation might imply that wearing bigger shoes would result in a bigger vocabulary. But that doesn’t mean putting on Daddy’s big shoes would somehow magically enable children to understand the meaning of big words like “Gigantopithecus” or “Pneumonoultramicroscopicsilicovolcanoconiosis.” The real causal relationship involves age and education, not shoe size.
Criticism of the study
Joel Dahms reviewed the study for the Institute for Functional Medicine. He was skeptical of the results for several reasons, including the inaccuracy of self-reporting, the impossibility of controlling for all possible confounders (participants may have had other healthy habits), the likelihood that participants were not representative of the entire population, and the low intake of olive oil compared to other studies. The average intake in this study was 4 grams, less than one teaspoonful, compared to 20-22 grams in the Spanish PREDIMED study. He wondered if another vegetable oil might have shown similar results and wondered whether some component of olive oil like oleic acid or polyphenols might be responsible. Basically, all he can recommend is the standard advice to replace animal fats in the diet with healthier fats.
He did find reason to be hopeful:
Perhaps more surprising was the comparison between the second quartile of the olive oil intake and the lowest quartile (rare/no olive oil intake), which showed a 12% reduction in mortality risk from all causes at the intake level of just 0.5 teaspoon or about 1.5 g/day of olive oil. If this finding is borne out in further studies, that’s an amazing benefit from an astonishingly low level of olive oil consumption. Another promising finding was a 27% reduction in risk of dementia-related mortality for those in the highest versus lowest category of olive oil consumption, which, considering the lack of proven preventatives for Alzheimer’s disease and dementia, could be of great importance from a public health perspective.
Conclusion: food, not medicine
Olive oil is a healthy fat that has a proven place in the kitchen. This new study is intriguing, but the evidence is insufficient to justify re-classifying olive oil as a medicine or taking it every day in order to avoid chronic disease and live longer.

Seed Oils Are Not Bad For You
Steven Novella on June 4, 2025
Link
So-called “health influencers” – self-appointed health gurus spreading their unvetted opinions about health through social media, have apparently decided that seed oils are bad for you. Our chief health guru, RFK Jr, even blames seed oils for the obesity epidemic (based on the flimsiest of evidence and logic, which is his MO). I’m not exactly sure where this demonizing of seed oils originated, but health gurus love to demonize “bad” food while promoting their own brand du jour of “superfoods”, so they all quickly jumped on the anti-seed oil bandwagon.
However, if we look at the totality of the evidence we find that seed oils are – food. That’s right, they are a source of nutrition and calories, and as long as you follow the golden rule of everything in moderation, this is not something you need to worry about or expend resources trying to deal with.
In fact seed oils, if anything, are at the healthier end of the spectrum when it comes to food in general and oils in particular. This is why nutrition scientists were puzzled over this particular fad because now they are picking on an overall healthy food. This should not have been surprising, however, because this is how health influencers operate – misinterpret preliminary or partial information and leap to ridiculous conclusions, as long as this gives you something to scare people about or something to sell. It’s good for engagement – learn the one food you must avoid to stay healthy. It’s clickbait health advice.
The TLDR version of this post is – seed oils are just fine, in fact it’s good that your diet contains some seed oils, don’t worry about it, go on with your life. For those who want some more details, read on.
First, whenever we talk about eating fats or oils we need to consider their effect on cholesterol and therefore heart and other vascular disease. Here, seed oils appear to have a beneficial effect on our cholesterol. They contain omega 6 (a polyunsaturated essential fat) such as linoleic acid, which reduces LDL, the bad cholesterol. That’s a good thing.
A recent systematic review found that increased levels of linoleic acid reduces the risk of fatal coronary heart disease. This aligns with other research finding a reduced risk of heart disease with lower LDL, which omega 6 does.
We also can consider the ratio of consumed omega 3 (the other good fat) and omega 6. Pre-industrial societies had a ration of 6:3 around 4:1. Industrialized diets, which do contain more seed oils, can be closer to 20:1. The claim is that this increases both inflammation and clotting. This is one chain of logic that leads some to argue for reduced omega 6 intake, but there are numerous problems with this logic.
First, this is basic science information, which is always difficult to apply to whole organisms. This is where many health gurus fail – they extrapolate from the petri dish to human health, but this is not a straight line. We need to look at clinical evidence, and whole organism evidence, to see what is actually happening. We find, for example, that omega 6 is associated with decreased inflammatory markers, if anything, although we do need more research.
The same is true of blood clotting. There are plenty of pro and anti-clotting factors in the body, maintaining an optimal balance (in healthy individuals). Pushing this system away from clotting reduces the risk of strokes and heart attacks, but increases the risk of bleeding (and vice versa). There is no one without the other. So saying that any clotting factor is necessarily a bad thing misses the point about this balance. What we need to know is – what is the net clinical effect.
In the end, there is no evidence that having a higher 6:3 ratio is a health risk for inflammatory or vascular disease. What is very likely true is that the body, which is a dynamic homeostatic system, just deals with it without any significant effect. Further, if you want to make your 6:3 ratio closer to pre-industrial societies, the best way to do this is to increase your omega-3 intake, not decrease your omega-6 intake, since both oils are overall heart healthy.
The anti-seed oils warriors also claim that cooking or heating seed oils can result in the formation of toxic chemicals (such as aldehydes). There may be an issue with repeatedly heating seed oils to high temperatures, such as in a restaurant deep fryer, but not with home use. Again, there is no proven risk here, just something requiring further study. There is also a simple way to avoid any potential risk – swap out the oil in deep fryers a bit more frequently.
Some point to chemical processes in the industrial formation of seed oils (rather than cold pressing, which is more costly), but anything added in this process is later removed to insignificant levels, and so again there is no evidence of risk or harm.
Finally, seed oils have been caught up in the anti-ultra processed food trend. This is an issue unto itself, but the quick version is that – processing food is not in itself harmful or a health risk. The only thing that matters is the final product. It is true that many processed foods are high in salt, sugar, and calories, and that’s the real issue. Focusing on the processing is missing the real issue, as is demonizing seed oils by association.
Based upon all the evidence, what are some bottom line actionable conclusions?
    • First, feel free to consume and use seed oils at home. Plant-based oils are generally healthy, and again if you follow the rule of – everything in moderation – that is a simple and effective approach to most nutritional questions.
    • If you are concerned about your 6:3 ratio in your diet, then increase you omega-3 intake, which most people could benefit from anyway. Do not avoid omega-6. Doing so is far more likely to be harmful than helpful to your health.
    • We may need further research and perhaps regulation in terms of how restaurants use deep fryer oil. However, again, if this is a concern you probably should eat less fried foods.
    • Do not listen to anything RFK Jr. has to say. He is a dangerous health crank and conspiracy theorist who does not know how to interpret scientific evidence.
    • An extension of the RFK rule is – do not get your health advice from “influencers” on social media. There are plenty of reliable academic and professional sources of information online.


A review of Benecol, a plant-stanol margarine
Most nutraceuticals don’t really work as advertised. For the most part, Benecol pretty much does. But is it worth it?
Katherine Pett on December 27, 2016
Link

Ed. Note: Harriet Hall was injured in a fall in Australia earlier this month. While she recovers, we are running guest posts in her regular Tuesday slot for as long as our supply of guest posts lasts. (Hint: If you ever thought of submitting a guest post and want a shot at your guest post being published on a Tuesday, now’s the time.) We wish Harriet well and hope she recovers sufficiently to resume blogging soon.

The definition of “functional food,” (also called a “nutraceutical”) is “a food containing health-giving additives and having medicinal benefit.”
But aside from providing calories and maybe some added fiber or protein, there are very few nutraceuticals that have been proven to do anything. Ok, maybe there’s that yogurt that helps Jamie Lee Curtis poop (still not proven). Vitamins are good if you’ve got a bona fide deficiency, but aside from that, you’re better off just eating healthy foods, some foods you enjoy (hopefully those categories overlap a bit), and ignoring the hype.
In fact, nutraceuticals aren’t allowed to say they do anything besides vague structure-function claims. Things like: “Supports Strong Bones,” or “May Help Boost Your Immune System,” or “My Sister Swears By This Thing,” and so on. They sound good, and can be convincing to the uninformed consumer, but are essentially meaningless.
So, while attending the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics’ annual Food & Nutrition Conference & Expo (better known as FNCE, or #FNCE), I was surprised to see a food product in the expo hall making a claim to this effect: “Benecol can reduce your cholesterol in two weeks.”
This is a very specific claim.
Benecol is sold in numerous forms, but can be found in grocery stores as a brand of margarine. It represents a specific group of functional foods known as plant sterols and stanols, which are unique in the supplement world because they actually do what they say they do.
In trials, when added to the diet, two grams of plant sterols or stanols per day lower LDL cholesterol an average of 8-10%. There are some caveats to this:
Stanols/sterols seem to work best as part of a food with fat.
Better results have been seen when intake is spread throughout the day rather than all at once.
So why, you might wonder, aren’t they in more common use? This is what I pointedly asked the Benecol representative at the Expo hall. She shook her head, wide-eyed. It seemed to be a mystery, even to the Benecol people.
But I think I’ve figured it out.
First: Do plant sterols & stanols lower cholesterol? How?
As it turns out, it is well established that plant sterols (and stanols – plant sterols that are saturated at the 5 α- ring position) interfere with the absorption of cholesterol in the small intestine, effectively lowering plasma cholesterol. And there seems to be a proportional response: In those with higher LDL cholesterol, plant sterols have a stronger effect.


On the left side of the diagram you can see that the alcohol group (-OH) has been replaced by an ester (O-C=O). This is how plant stanols (and sterols) are incorporated into Benecol.
These molecules resemble cholesterol, but all the extra carbons at the end (all the branches in the diagram) make the sterols and stanols much more difficult for the body to absorb.

Are they beneficial?
While scientists have understood the effects of plant sterols since the 1950s, it is less clear whether they would have an impact on clinical endpoints (ie development of cardiometabolic disease). This is because the resources it would take to do a definitive RCT on the effects of the sterols are prohibitive. In a review in Mayo Clinic Proceedings, Katan, et. al noted that:
… with a 6% reduction in total cholesterol (corresponding to a 9% reduction in LDl cholesterol), close to 50,000 postmenopausal women might need to be randomized and followed up for 9 years to show the expected reduction of 14% in CHD at a power of 86%.
However, many experts agree that the use of sterols is indicated based on the beneficial effects of sterols on surrogate markers, i.e. LDL cholesterol. Dr. Alice Lichtenstein, Director of the Cardiovascular Nutrition Laboratory at the Jean Mayer Human Nutrition Center on Aging, had this to say:
My assessment of the evidence is that if a food/drug/lifestyle behavior lowers LDL cholesterol there will likely be a benefit on health outcomes. Sterols and stanols clearly lower LDL cholesterol, hence, one would predict a benefit.
This is in line with a review by AbuMueis and Jones in Current Atherosclerosis Reports:
It is estimated that a 10% reduction in serum cholesterol level produces a reduction in CHD of 50% at age 40 years, 40% at age 50 years, 30% at age 60 years, and 20% at age 70 years. Therefore, the degree of placebo-adjusted reduction in LDL-C levels caused by plant sterols is of clinical importance.
And a more recent consensus document, published in Atherosclerosis in 2014, the European Atherosclerosis Society Consensus Panel on Phytosterols came to the following conclusions:
Based on LDL-C lowering and the absence of adverse signals, this EAS Consensus Panel concludes that functional foods with plant sterols/stanols may be considered
in individuals with high cholesterol levels at intermediate or low global cardiovascular risk who do not qualify for pharmacotherapy,
as an adjunct to pharmacologic therapy in high and very high risk patients who fail to achieve LDL-C targets on statins or are statin- intolerant,
and in adults and children (>6 years) with familial hypercholesterolemia, in line with current guidance.
But in an unscientific survey conducted by moi (aka I asked one person who is on a statin), I learned that this person had never heard of plant sterols, let alone considered adding them to his diet. Add that to the “who knows” mystery face of the Benecol rep at the FNCE expo floor and I have an anecdata set of two people suggesting that the benefits of plant sterols are not widely used or widely known in the US.
Why would this be?
The downsides
There has been concern that higher plasma levels of plant sterols and stanols would increase cardiovascular disease risk and offset the benefits obtained from lower cholesterol. There seems to be a consensus among experts that this is largely a hypothetical risk and that even among patients heterozygous for phytosterolemia (a genetic disease where a person absorbs an unusually high percentage of plant sterols and develops atherosclerosis at an early age), plasma levels of plant sterols remain orders of magnitude lower than those homozygous for phytosterolemia even when supplementing.
There has been some concern that high sterol intake could inhibit absorption of fat-soluble vitamins – but this remains largely theoretical as well.
So why aren’t health professionals – doctors and RDs alike – more inclined to recommend plant sterol intake?
Here are my ideas:
Plant sterols cannot replace a statin for cholesterol lowering – Phytosterols work to lower cholesterol levels up to about 10% but then plateau.For someone with hypercholesterolemia this would not cut it as a stand-alone intervention. And if a statin returns cholesterol levels to normal, it may not be necessary to recommend a plant sterol product in addition.However, they do have an additive effect when used with statins, and do not lose their effectiveness – in some patients adding plant sterols to statin therapy can have the same effect as doubling the statin dose.But, there have not been a lot of studies done on plant sterols in combination with ezetimibe, a drug that lowers plasma cholesterol by preventing absorption, similar to the action of plant sterols and stanols.
Convenience: According to the bulk of the literature on plant sterols, the dose is most effective in a food form (fat spreads like margarine are the most studied) taken at least twice per day. If someone is eating a margarine, they need to remember to eat enough of the margarine and eat it twice per day – it sounds simple, but it would be all too easy to forget.
Cost: Food and supplements are not reimbursed by insurance companies, so while the cost of a statin may be mostly covered by a patient’s insurance, the cost of a Benecol margarine is fully on the consumer.
A major PR problem: Arguably, the most effective way to lower one’s cholesterol with plant sterols is by eating margarine – probably one of the most hated “fake” food products of our time.Since even the diets highest in plant sterols only hit several hundred milligrams, it is impossible to get therapeutic doses through vegetables alone. The only way to get them is in “processed food,” another term that gets a lot of unfair hate these days.
I ate it
So I did what any self-respecting nutritionist would do, I ate some. As far as taste, there is nothing to report – it tastes like a soft, buttery spread and doesn’t have a weird aftertaste. Since I am usually a butter eater, the soft texture of the stuff right out of the fridge threw me off, but once it was on my English muffin, it tasted totally normal.
But after my snack, I noticed some features that would make Benecol (or any plant sterol/stanol margarine) a less practical intervention.
In a single serving of one tablespoon, there is only half a gram of plant stanols. In order to get a full dose of two grams of plant stanols a day, I would need to eat four tablespoons of margarine. That seems like a lot, since I would need to find ways to incorporate it into every meal, or eat a double dose at lunch and dinner.
And there are 16 servings of Benecol in one container, which means that I would run out of margarine every four days. Benecol is not cheap – running between $5-6 a tub. That’s something like $40 a month on margarine – pricier than my gym membership, another intervention with beneficial effects on cholesterol (exercise, not a gym membership). Since plant sterols/stanols work by preventing cholesterol absorption when you eat them, continuous use is required to maintain cholesterol-lowering effects.
Finally, the nutrition facts panel notes that each serving of Benecol contains half a gram of trans fats, meaning that with my two grams of plant stanols, I’m also getting two grams of trans fats, a food additive we have long considered “no bueno.” Trans fats are believed to increase heart disease by raising LDL cholesterol, so it is unclear whether the net cholesterol-lowering effect of a plant stanol/sterol nutraceutical would cancel out the risk. But really, why include them? I reached out to Benecol customer service asking why they haven’t reformulated or if they were considering it, but have not heard back.
Interestingly, trans fats may have been mislabeled on earlier containers of Benecol leading to a class action suit, which was settled out of court. I reached out to Benecol to inquire about trans fat content and have not yet heard back.
The verdict?
Clinicians should feel free to recommend plant stanol/sterol products to supplement healthy lifestyle changes in preventing heart disease – there are little indications for negative effects. Consider whether you think it would be practical: If you have a patient or client with a ton of money who eats bread with butter 3+ times a day, you have an ideal candidate.
Other well-studied plant sterol-enhanced foods are yogurts and other dairy products. Overall, the efficacy of plant sterols incorporated into “fat spreads, mayonnaise and salad dressing or milk and yoghurt” reduces LDL more than sterols in other products. It should be noted that plant stanols/sterols can be taken in capsule form and also have cholesterol lowering effects. However, they still must be taken two or three times per day with meals.
Which brings us to the real problem with plant stanols; it requires daily adherence, a change in dietary habits, and consistency.
In other words, it requires the most effective and elusive of interventions: a lifestyle change.

Pass the Salt (But Not That Pink Himalayan Stuff)
Harriet Hall on August 19, 2014
Link

Humans, like many other animals, crave the taste of salt. Animals frequent salt licks, humans have traded salt for equal weights of gold, and the word “salary” comes from the Roman soldier’s allowance for purchasing salt. Salt appears in our language in idioms like “worth its salt” and “salt of the earth.” Shakespeare’s play King Lear is a variant of a folktale where a daughter tells her father she loves him as much as meat loves salt. In a murder mystery I read years ago, a character listed the four food groups as sweet, salty, sticky, and chocolate.
It’s no fair: everything that tastes good turns out to be bad for us. We love the taste of salt, but dietary guidelines tell us we should all limit our sodium intake to less than 2.3 grams (2300 mg) a day to avoid high blood pressure and death from cardiovascular disease. And those who are fifty-one, African American, or who have high blood pressure, chronic kidney disease or diabetes should limit their intake even further, to 1500 mg a day or less.
(Note: the salt molecule consists of an atom of sodium and an atom of chloride; 40% of the weight is sodium, so 1500 mg of sodium equals 3750 mg of salt, roughly ¾ of a teaspoon. Over 75% of our salt is already in the food, not added from the salt shaker.)
In 2010, the American Heart Association lowered its recommendations to 1500 mg a day for everyone. We thought that was good advice, but new evidence has muddied the waters.
In the latest issue of The New England Journal of Medicine, three new studies about the role of salt in cardiovascular disease were published. Instead of providing clear answers, they raise more questions. In a cute NEJM QuickTake cartoon video they summarize the findings of the studies. If you’d rather spend three minutes watching cartoons than reading my explanation, feel free.
Salt and health: the background
High blood pressure is a known risk factor for heart attacks and strokes. Numerous studies have shown a correlation between salt intake and blood pressure, but the correlation between salt intake and cardiovascular outcomes like stroke and death has not been so clearly established. The large INTERSALT study found a modest association between higher levels of sodium intake and higher blood pressure. Some systematic reviews of the literature have confirmed that association, others have not. A 2013 review in the British Medical Journal found that lower sodium intake was correlated not only with a lower risk of hypertension but also with a lower risk of stroke and fatal coronary heart disease. Prospective cohort studies have shown inconsistent associations between sodium intake and cardiac risk.
Larger studies were needed to settle the issue.
First study: Association of Urinary Sodium and Potassium Excretion with Blood Pressure, by Mente et al.
Subjects: 102,216 adults from 18 countries. Method: single fasting urine levels of sodium and potassium were used to estimate 24-hour excretion, providing an indirect estimate of dietary intake. Findings: the association of sodium with BP was greatest in hypertensives, the elderly, and those who had the highest intakes of salt. It was greatest in those ingesting over 6 grams of sodium a day, modest in those ingesting 3-5 grams, and not significant in those ingesting less than 3 grams a day. They found an inverse relationship for potassium: higher levels of potassium were associated with lower blood pressures.
Second study: Urinary Sodium and Potassium Excretion, Mortality, and Cardiovascular Events, by O-Donnell et al.
Subjects: 101,945 adults from 17 countries. Method: as in the first study, single fasting urine tests were used to estimate 24-hour urinary sodium and potassium excretion; those estimates were compared to a composite outcome of death and major cardiovascular events. Findings: mean sodium excretion was 4.93 g. Compared to a reference range of 4.00-5.99 g a day, the odds ratio for death and cardiovascular events was 1.15 for high sodium excretion (over 7 g a day) but was even greater at 1.27 for a low sodium excretion (below 3 g). Higher potassium excretion was associated with decreased risk.
Third study: Global Sodium Consumption and Death from Cardiovascular Causes, by Mozaffarian et al.
The authors reviewed 205 studies on sodium consumption from 66 countries. Estimated mean global consumption was 3.95 grams a day, with regional means varying from 2.18 to 5.51. Daily sodium intake >6 grams a day was associated with increased risk of mortality and cardiovascular events. Surprisingly, so was intake of <3 grams. The lowest risk was in the 3-6 gram range. They used a computer model to estimate that 1.65 million deaths a year could be attributed to a sodium intake of greater than 2 grams a day. That’s about 10% of all cardiovascular deaths. The rate ranged from 4 deaths per million adults per year in Kenya to 1,967 per million in Georgia.
Discussion of the results
We knew too much sodium was risky, but these studies raise concerns that too little sodium might be even worse. As the accompanying editorial points out,
They call into question the feasibility and usefulness of reducing dietary sodium as a population-based strategy for reducing blood pressure…the alternative approach of recommending high-quality diets rich in potassium might achieve greater health benefits, including blood-pressure reduction, than aggressive sodium reduction.
It may not be the potassium itself; diets rich in potassium are also rich in a lot of other healthy nutrients from fruits and vegetables.
These studies were large and well designed. They gathered an immense amount of data, looked at a variety of associations, and did their best to rule out possible confounding factors. But epidemiologic studies like these are imperfect by nature. The authors themselves pointed out several limitations of their studies, including the indirect way they measured sodium and potassium excretion.
So what did we learn?
None of this really sheds any light on what we should do as individuals. Should we continue asking “pass the salt?” Should we abstain from adding salt at the table? Should we read labels and monitor the total amount of salt in our diet? Should we aim for 3–5 g a day?
These studies found associations, but they couldn’t determine causes, and they did not even attempt to measure what would happen if people changed the amount of sodium and potassium in their diets. If anything, they suggest that existing guidelines for salt restriction for the general population may be too extreme.
They also suggest that “moderation in all things” and “eat your vegetables” are still good advice.
Bonus question: What kind of salt should we use?
A related question is whether some kinds of salt are healthier than others. Sea salt, table salt, kosher salt, flavored salt, fleur de sel, Hiwa Kai, Black Hawaiian Sea Salt, Kala Namak, “organic salt,” and Pink Himalayan Sea Salt are all basically the same chemical, sodium chloride. Only the trace amounts of other substances vary. Table salt is fortified with iodine and is a highly effective way to prevent iodine deficiency and goiter. Gourmet cooks swear by the taste differences of different salt varieties.
(Don’t eat Epsom salt. You’d regret it: it’s has a significant laxative effect when taken internally.)
Pink Himalayan sea salt was introduced to me by an e-mail correspondent who questioned the claim that it contained “84 trace minerals that promote health and well being.” I questioned it too, so I did a little research.
Mike Adams, the infamous Health Ranger, explains that Himalayan Pink Crystal Salt contains the full complement of minerals and trace elements “just like Mother Earth intended.” It is an unrefined, unprocessed raw salt mined by hand from salt caves that formed 250 million years ago as ocean salt settled into geologic pockets. It is stone-ground, which apparently doesn’t count as “processing.” Table salt is bad stuff, you see, since it was processed to remove all the good stuff and then they had to replace the iodine because people who ate it started to get goiters. Oh, and incidentally he sells the good stuff on his website and even offers a discount.
I found a website that reports the results of a spectral analysis of Himalayan salt. I think this is where the claim comes from. Even if this analysis is accurate, it is meaningless for health and if anything is worrisome. The amount of minerals in it is too minuscule to make any difference, and we already get plenty of the same trace minerals from other foods. They claim that two double-blind studies were done, but no such studies are listed in PubMed. There is no evidence published in peer-reviewed journals that replacing white salt with pink salt makes a shred of difference or leads to any improvement in health.
If you read down the list of minerals, you will notice that it includes a number of radioactive substances like radium, uranium, and polonium. It also includes substances that act as poisons, like thallium. I wouldn’t be worried, since the amounts are so small; but if anyone believes the trace amounts of “good” minerals in Himalayan sea salt are good for you, why not believe the trace amounts of poisons and radioactive elements are bad for you?
The claim that pink Himalayan salt contains 84 trace minerals may be true, but the claim that it “promotes health and wellness” is false until proven otherwise by legitimate clinical studies. While waiting for evidence, I’d just as soon my salt didn’t contain uranium.

SWEETNERS

Sugar Industry Research
Steven Novella on September 14, 2016
Link

A recent New York Times article about how the sugar industry manipulated research starting in 1965 is getting some attention. The article is largely based on a recent JAMA Internal Medicine article that reviews historical documents revealing how the Sugar Research Foundation (SRF) (based largely on revealed internal documents) put their thumb on the scale of diet research starting in 1965 in an attempt to shift the blame for heart disease from sugar onto fat.
The diet wars
I think this latest round of information can only be understood in the context of the longstanding diet wars. Heart disease has become the number one cause of death, as life expectancy has increased and we have reduced many other causes of mortality.
Overweight and obesity are also diseases of modern civilization which is characterized by abundance and an increasingly sedentary lifestyle. Further, the food industry is driven by market forces which favor tasty foods, which often means being high in fat and/or sugar.
The public, understandably, simply wants to know what diet is optimal for reducing cardiovascular risk and maintaining a healthy weight. Ironically, we already have the answer, in my opinion, at least the “90% answer.”
I also think that most people know the answer – engage in regular exercise and eat a moderate, varied diet with plenty of vegetables. If you do that you are most of the way to an optimal diet, and all the controversy is essentially over that last few percentage points of minimizing risk by optimizing diet.
Self-help and food industries
The people who seem to have the highest stake in those last few percent are the self-help industry and the various food industries. The self-help industry want to sell you the optimal diet, and so they have a vested interest in coming up with some diet schtick and selling it – the Atkins diet, the Zone diet, the South Beach diet, etc.
The one diet that seems to have the most science behind it is the Mediterranean diet. That is probably because it is a moderate diet, nothing extreme. Even then, a recent systematic review gave it a soft recommendation:
The limited evidence to date suggests some favourable effects on cardiovascular risk factors. More comprehensive interventions describing themselves as the Mediterranean diet may produce more beneficial effects on lipid levels than those interventions with fewer dietary components. More trials are needed to examine the impact of heterogeneity of both participants and the intervention on outcomes.
The research on diet has been controversial, allowing for ongoing multiple opinions, I think because they are playing with those last few percentage points. There simply isn’t enough of a difference to show up as a strong signal. Other differences in the participants, such as amount of exercise, weight, stress, and sleep, likely overshadow the dietary changes being studied.
A recent study comparing high fat, high sugar, and a “prudent” diet (essentially a moderate diet) also reveals this basic pattern of not seeing much difference. They looked at all-cause mortality, heart deaths and heart events. The high fat diet was associated with increased overall mortality, but not heart deaths or events. The high sugar diet was associated with a borderline but not significant trend toward higher heart deaths and events but not overall deaths. The prudent diet had no increased risk.
There are also various food industries that would love for the research to show that the food they produce is the healthiest – for example, the sugar industry, the dairy industry, and the meat industry. All these industries fund research hoping to show that their product is healthful.
Sugar industry tampering
The recent NYT article and the JAMA article on which it is based detail how the SRF engaged in a clever campaign, not so much to exonerate refined sugar, but to shift the focus onto fat. They funded research, provided papers for review, and participated in reviews that emphasized saturated fat and cholesterol as primary cardiovascular risk factors.
There is nothing necessarily wrong with industry funding research. This is pretty much a necessity as the amount of research that can be funded with public dollars is limited. Over the years, however, standards have emerged to mitigate the problem of bias in industry-funded research.
These standards include total transparency. Researchers have to reveal the source of their funding and any potential conflicts of interest, including ties to industry. Journals also have to reveal industry ties. Human trials also have to be registered, so industry cannot later hide them if they don’t like the results. Further, reviewers are encouraged to weigh independent research more heavily than industry funded research.
This is a bit of an ongoing game of cat and mouse, where industry tries to find ways to put their thumb on the scale, and the scientific community tries to stop them. Vigilance is required, and exposés like the JAMA article are all part of the picture.
However, I think the NYT article failed to put this episode into the full context of the diet wars over the last 50 years. Scott Alexander wrote an article making the same point.
The dairy industry and meat industry also funded research over this time. It is actually not clear what the net effect of industry research was. Further, the research is complex. Researchers are looking for what I think is a small signal and there are many ways to conduct research and look at the data.
In the end I think it’s clear that eating too much sugar and eating too much fat are both risk factors for obesity and heart disease. Again – moderation is the answer.
Bottom line for the consumer
Despite all the complexity in the research, the many factions pushing their special diet, and those trying to exonerate the food they produce or point the finger at a competitor, we are back to a simple recommendation – eat a varied moderate diet with plenty of vegetables and exercise regularly.
I always have to add the caveat that for those with medical conditions, like diabetes, they may need to eat a modified diet with another layer of complexity. Some people may also have specific nutrient deficits. But for most people, the above advice is really all they need to know.
Further, there is no magic optimal food, or bad food to avoid, or “zone” of balance of macronutrients, or superfood, or special diet that will have a significant positive impact on your health. In fact, such diets can be a net negative when they deviate from a moderate diet with extreme recommendations. Special diet tricks and supplements also will not compensate for an overall bad diet or lifestyle.
People sometimes lose the 90% benefit of a moderate diet while pursuing an apparent few percentage points of advantage from a special diet.
What this episode also reveals, and is something that I think most people already know, is that you should not believe marketing hype. Foods plastered with labels that they are “all natural,” “low fat,” “low sugar,” “organic,” “clean,” “free of something,” or whatever will not benefit your health. These are nothing but marketing ploys.
(Oh, and whatever you do, don’t listen to celebrities or take advice from People magazine.)

Does the Movie Fed Up Make Sense?
Harriet Hall on October 14, 2014
Link

The 2014 film Fed Up is an advocacy documentary. Its message:
    • There is a worldwide epidemic of obesity.
    • It is endangering our children.
    • Increased sugar consumption is responsible.
    • The food industry is responsible for our increased sugar consumption because it puts hidden sugar in processed foods, bombards us with advertising, favors profits over health, and lobbies against regulation.
    • The government is responsible because it has failed to control the food industry.
The film has received mostly positive reviews and has been called the Inconvenient Truth of the health movement. It was written and directed by Stephanie Soechtig, whose earlier films attacked GMO foods and the bottled water industry, and narrated by Katie Couric, who “gave anti-vaccine ideas a shot” on her talk show in late 2013.
The film shows families struggling with childhood obesity and “experts” expressing their opinions. Their selection of “experts” is heavy on politicians and journalists and light on nutrition scientists.
Is sugar really the cause of the obesity epidemic?
Between 1971 and 2000, the prevalence of obesity in the United States doubled. During that time, fat consumption decreased, carbohydrate consumption rose, and average calorie intake rose (from 2450 to 2618 for men, and from 1542 to 1877 for women); the film blames sugar, but one could argue that total calorie intake was to blame.
Correlation is not causation, even when there is a strong correlation like the one between the rise in autism diagnoses and the rise in the sales of organic food. There is no such strong correlation between sugar consumption and obesity, much less any convincing evidence of causation.
Sugar consumption has actually decreased around the world even as the rate of obesity has continued to climb. Between 1999 and 2008, American consumption of added sugars decreased from 100 g/d to 76 g/d, mainly due to a reduction in soda consumption.
This webpage lists per capita sugar consumption by country, and it clearly does not correlate with rates of obesity in those countries. Countries with higher per capita sugar consumption than the US include Argentina, Australia, Austria, Belarus, Belgium, Brazil, Chile, Denmark, Estonia, France, Georgia, Germany, Iceland, Malaysia, Malta, Mexico, Morocco, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, Slovakia, Sweden, Switzerland, Ukraine, UK, and Venezuela. According to this source there are 17 countries with higher rates of obesity than the US. Not a single one of those countries has a higher per capita sugar consumption than the US.
There are other sources with different numbers, and these statistics don’t tell us much, because there are so many possible confounders such as lifestyle, total calorie intake, fiber, the type of sugar, hidden sugar in prepared foods, consumption of an otherwise nutritious diet, etc. The point is that it’s premature to make the kind of definitive pronouncements that the film makes about the role of sugar.
Gary Taubes makes a strong case for low-carb diets both for weight loss and health, but he admits that his hypothesis has not yet been properly tested. Chris Voight did an informal test of its exact opposite, a carbs-only diet: he ate nothing but potatoes for 60 days. According to Taubes’ low-carb theories he should have gained weight and raised his blood sugar, but instead he lost 21 pounds and lowered his blood sugar. His cholesterol and triglyceride levels dropped; he felt well and had plenty of energy.
The sugar/obesity hypothesis has not been properly tested either. There are plenty of examples of people who eat a lot of sugar and processed foods and don’t gain weight. In fact, one obese boy in the film complains that his brother eats the same way he does but doesn’t gain weight. There are plenty of examples of people who have lost weight and kept it off by reducing calorie intake and increasing exercise. We know some of the factors involved in successful weight loss, and eliminating sugar is not on the list.
Restaurants contribute to obesity by providing high-calorie food choices, large servings, and super-sized drinks. Fast food restaurants get a lot of blame, but John Cisna lost 56 pounds in 6 months while eating all his meals at McDonald’s. He counted calories and stuck to a 2000 calorie a day limit.
We don’t know that eliminating sugar from the diet is an effective strategy by itself. A family in the film eliminated sugar from their diet (they said they were “detoxing”!) and lost weight, but that could have been because they ate fewer total calories, and we don’t know that they would have lost any less weight if those fewer calories had included some calories from sugar. And the teenage boy lost weight but then gained it right back. What went wrong?
Colin Campbell of the Center for Nutritional Studies points out that the evidence showing sugar to be a major factor in obesity is relatively weak and is confounded by total calorie intake and other factors. He says:
I know of no evidence that were we to eliminate all sugar from our diets, presumably leaving the rest of the diet the same, we could rid ourselves of disease and restore our health.
The film gets a lot of things wrong
I was going to do some further fact checking, but Google saved me the trouble. I discovered that two writers at Food Insight had already analyzed the claims in Fed Up and shown that the filmmakers got many of their facts wrong. They give these examples:
    • “This year for the first time in the history of the world, more people will die from the effects of obesity than from starvation.” Not true: three times as many die of starvation.
    • “For the first time in 200 years, the current generation of children are expected to live shorter lives than their parents.” Expected by whom? According to the CDC and the Census Bureau, life expectancies are on an uninterrupted upward trajectory that is expected to continue rising until at least 2020.
    • While fitness club memberships more than doubled, the obesity rate also doubled. A meaningless comparison that is intended to suggest that we are helpless to do anything about our weight.
    • It rejects the concept of energy balance, but the scientific evidence clearly shows that it is possible to lose weight by decreasing calorie intake and increasing calorie expenditure.
    • Dr. Robert Lustig gets a lot of screen time. He says that there is “really good data” that “a calorie is not a calorie,” in that the “toxicity” of sugars is an inherent and unique contributor to obesogenicity. “When your liver gets that big sugar rush… it has no choice but to turn it into fat immediately.” His language is inflammatory, demonizing sugar as toxic and addictive. Lustig’s views are inconsistent with mainstream scientific opinions based on all the available evidence. Dr. David Katz of the Yale Prevention Research Center characterizes Lustig’s theories as “humbug” and explains why.
    • “Between 1977 and 2000, Americans have doubled their daily intake of sugar.” Not true: Americans are eating more total calories but have not doubled the calories from sugar.
    • “Over 95 percent of all Americans will be overweight or obese in two decades.” No, obesity prevalence has leveled off since 2003 and the forecasted trend-line is virtually flat.
    • It claims that consuming a single soda per day increases one’s risk of diabetes by 22 percent. Sugar doesn’t cause diabetes; the film presents a simplistic caricature of the relationship between sugar and diabetes.
    • The film says the pledge of food companies to remove 1.5 trillion calories from the marketplace amounts to “nothing,” a mere 14 calories a day per person. Actually, they have already removed 6.4 trillion calories, ahead of schedule and more than 400 percent of the original goal. The resulting reduction of 78 calories a day per person is probably more than enough to meet the Healthy People 2020 target for obesity reduction.
This review concludes by saying the central claims of the film are shadings of the truth, sins of omission, and outright fabrication. It says the film’s “obsessive focus on a single nutrient actually could cause more harm than good, in that overconsumption of any macronutrient can lead to overweight and obesity.” It offers credible evidence and provides links to additional resources.
At Reason.com, Baylen Linnekin points out that the film overwhelmingly features supporters of increased food regulation, and non-supporters are treated unfairly. David Allison is asked for his opinion on the contribution of sugar-sweetened beverages to obesity, and when he asks for a moment to collect his thoughts, the editing cuts him off and makes him look foolish.
In the film, Senator Tom Harkin asks how the food industry executives can sleep at night. I find that ironic. He supported farm bills that pay billions of dollars in subsidies to farmers in his home state Iowa, which leads the nation in high fructose corn syrup production. Harkin is a major advocate of alternative medicine who has been instrumental in legislation such as creating the NCCAM, a travesty and a waste of taxpayer dollars. He is so ignorant of how science works that he complained that the NCCAM has been disproving things rather than doing its intended job of “seeking out and approving.” He has been characterized on this blog as “waging a war on science.” I wonder how Harkin can sleep at night.
What can be done to improve the American diet?
I think we can all agree that the typical American diet is not healthy. It provides too much processed food, convenience food, sodas, red meat, salt, sugars, and calories; and it is deficient in fruits, vegetables, and fiber. Sugar is only one part of the obesity problem, a part that may be due to its contribution to total calorie intake rather than anything inherently bad about sugar. No one would argue that we shouldn’t try to reduce sugar consumption; the question is how to accomplish that.
The film’s comparison to tobacco is interesting. For a long time, the tobacco industry misled the public about the dangers of smoking. Tobacco advertising dropped when equal time was required for anti-smoking information. Societal attitudes changed rapidly for tobacco thanks to public information campaigns. Legislation has contributed to a decrease in smoking, but I would argue that legislation would not have been possible without a change in public perceptions.
I think the general public is well aware of the need to control weight, and instead of trying to control their eating habits by passing laws to control the food industry, we might do better to educate them about how to eat a healthier diet. There is so much they don’t understand. The film shows tearful families unable to lose weight and trying so hard — but their efforts include things like switching from regular Hot Pockets to a low-fat version. There are many flavors of Lean Pockets, but the very first one I looked up contained the equivalent of 3-4 tsp of sugar and a whopping 655 calories. Obese teenagers are shown lamenting their inability to lose weight while gorging on cereal, finishing large bags of potato chips to “savor the flavor,” and choosing hamburgers and fries for lunch at school. One is shown making what he thinks is a “healthy lunch” to take to school: a peanut butter and jelly sandwich! These people desperately want to adopt healthier eating habits, but they have no idea how to go about it. How can we best help them?
People complain that they weren’t able to lose weight by reducing calories, but some of them don’t realize that they never actually reduced calories enough to get results. I once had an overweight 13-year-old boy as a patient. I asked what he usually ate for lunch, and we calculated that his daily cheeseburger, fries, and milkshake added up to over 1000 calories. I asked if he would consider bringing a lower calorie sack lunch from home, and he enthusiastically agreed. He had never even thought of that option. I had an adult patient who couldn’t understand why she hadn’t lost weight when she was eating mostly yogurt. She thought yogurt was “diet food” so she could eat as much of it as she wanted. When I asked her to read the label, she was astounded to learn that each container of yogurt had 240 calories.
Efforts are already underway to improve school lunches and remove junk food vending machines from schools. That’s a step in the right direction. Agatha Raisin, a character in a delicious series of mystery novels by M. C. Beaton, brags that she loves to cook, but her idea of cooking is sticking a TV dinner in the microwave. A lot of our young people grow up with similar ideas about what it means to cook. Why not require Home Ec. classes in our schools? They could teach nutrition, menu planning, and meal preparation from scratch with fresh ingredients. Students might learn to think of healthier options when it comes to planning what to do for dinner.
To my mind, it’s not just a matter of educating children, but of educating the parents who buy and serve the food their children eat at home, educating the parents who think you can lose weight by switching from Hot Pockets to Lean Pockets. Just as information campaigns educated the public about smoking, they could educate the public about healthy food choices, hidden sugars, and calorie content of various foods. Even without legislation, a public outcry and grass roots movements would be enough to change food manufacturing. The food industry exists to please its customers and has provided us with easy, timesaving, attractive options that are hard to resist. What if the general public learned to buy less processed food, to read labels, to avoid hidden sugars, to be aware of how many calories they are ingesting, and to enjoy cooking at home? If they did that, market forces would make the food industry adapt. If companies wanted to keep profits up, they would have to be creative about providing healthier products. Just think how quickly they responded to public enthusiasms like gluten-free and low-carb.
People naturally tend to eat the way their parents ate, the way their culture eats. It can be hard for them to even imagine other ways of eating. My parents grew up on farms and ate the way their own parents and grandparents had always eaten. I grew up thinking the ideal meal was meat, potatoes, a green vegetable, a yellow vegetable, bread and butter, a sugary dessert, and milk for a beverage. Last night I cooked dinner from scratch, using several ingredients that never crossed the threshold of my mother’s kitchen, including red quinoa, chickpeas, collard greens, olive oil, yogurt, and limes. I used to see items like those in the grocery store and pass them by; it never would have occurred to me to cook with them because I had no experience with them and wouldn’t have known what to do with them. We can’t expect people to think outside the box of the traditional American family dinner table and the fast food restaurant without some help. My horizons have been hugely expanded by subscribing to the Blue Apron program, which has me cooking from scratch with a variety of ingredients like heirloom vegetables and exotic foods from other cultures (many of which I had never even heard of) and trying out new cooking techniques. Blue Apron is expensive and is not something that could be recommended for everyone, but I can see how school programs and media campaigns might be able to accomplish something similar.
I favor education over regulation. I’m not against regulating the food industry, but I would like to see proposals tested before they are widely implemented. Providing nutrition information on menus seemed like a great idea, but it has had minimal impact on food choices in real-world settings. Many thousands of young people were put through abstinence-only sex education programs before we realized they were ineffective and might even be doing more harm than good. We can’t just assume that any proposed remedy for the obesity epidemic will work. No matter how slam-dunk it sounds, it must be tested using scientific methods.
Conclusion
The film’s thesis, that sugar has caused the obesity epidemic, is not well supported by evidence. It is a partial truth that the filmmakers have dogmatically represented as the whole truth, with nary a hint of nuance. And it’s not fair to demonize the food industry. It has done a lot of good by providing a greater variety of safer food to more people for lower prices. We must share the responsibility for their shortcomings, because their less healthy offerings were created in response to public demand, and large numbers of people have chosen to buy those products because they don’t know any better.
The film will undoubtedly do some good by helping raise public awareness of childhood obesity and of hidden sugars in processed foods. I only wish it could have done so without misrepresenting the facts and without the bias and hype in support of the filmmakers’ political agenda of increasing food regulation. I try to eat a healthy diet, but I enjoy an occasional sugary treat and fast food meal, and I appreciate the convenience of packaged, processed foods when I don’t have a lot of time to shop and cook. I see no compelling reason to think it is impossible for people to lose weight on a diet that is overall nutritious and calorie controlled but that allows small amounts of even the “worst” foods.

Gary Taubes and the Cause of Obesity
Harriet Hall on May 13, 2014
Link
Gary Taubes has written two books explaining why people get fat and why a low-carb diet is the solution to preventing and treating obesity. He didn’t like what I had to say about his books on this blog back in 2011. I was not the only one to criticize. Another reviewer accused him of “abandon[ing] journalistic and scientific integrity in place of observational data, straw men and logical fallacy.” He says he agrees with Taubes’ premises but that his “arguments made me cringe,” and he goes into considerable detail to explain why. His analysis is worth reading.

Rather than engaging in the Comments section, Taubes complained to me in a somewhat offensive personal e-mail, saying I had failed to understand what he wrote. Recently he e-mailed me again, condescendingly suggesting that I might understand his arguments better if I read an article he wrote last year for the British Medical Journal. I read it, and confirmed that I had understood perfectly well the first time around and that it was Gary Taubes who didn’t understand my criticisms. I pointed out some omissions and inconsistencies, but my major criticisms boiled down to two:
     1.  The clinical evidence isn’t yet sufficient to convincingly prove his thesis. (He himself admitted this.)
     2.  He strongly recommended that everyone adopt a low-carb diet, essentially insisting that we act on insufficient evidence. And this was after he had devoted whole chapters of his books to demonizing the low-fat diet advocates for doing exactly that: acting on insufficient evidence.
His basic thesis is that conventional wisdom is wrong when it says we get fat because we overeat, and that counseling patients on the basis of the energy balance hypothesis has been remarkably ineffective. He thinks we get fat not because we eat too much but because of carbohydrates.
He says:
What is wrong with the mechanism that normally adjusts appetite to caloric output? What part of this mechanism is primarily disturbed? Any regulatory defect that drove people to gain weight…would induce them to take in more calories than they expend. Positive caloric balance would be, then, a result rather than a cause of the condition.
I agree completely. I think we are talking at cross-purposes and getting hung up on semantics. It is obvious to me that “something” (likely more than one “something”) causes us to take in more calories than we expend. And then that positive energy balance is what causes us to gain weight.
Taubes says the real question is not why we eat too much, but why we store too much fat. The endocrinological hypothesis attempts to explain the root cause of obesity on the basis of insulin and/or the concept of lipophilia. Insulin is fattening, and since serum insulin levels are driven by the carbohydrate content of the diet, it seems only logical that a low carb diet would tend to reduce weight. Lipophilia (“love of fat”) explains that fat deposition is not uniform throughout the body and that must have a basis in biology; and that people who are constitutionally predisposed to fatten must have adipose tissue that is more lipophilic than that of lean individuals. The lipophilic tissue gloms onto calories even in the presence of under-nutrition and deposits them as fat, which deprives other organs and cells of energy and leads to hunger or lethargy. Withdrawing fat from the circulation after meals results in a delayed sense of satiety and a yearning for carbohydrates. This is supported by the conventional wisdom that carbohydrates are fattening.
But Taubes said in his book that simply restricting carbohydrates
…leads to weight loss and particularly fat loss, independent of the calories we consume from dietary fat and protein. We know that the laws of physics have nothing to do with it.
That is simply wrong. The only grain of truth is that a low-carb diet may result in decreased hunger pangs so that total calorie intake drops. The laws of physics tell us that if you ate 7000 calories of protein and fat during a period of time when you only expended 3500 calories, you would gain a pound, even if you ate no carbohydrates at all. There is no getting around the physics. If you expend more calories than you ingest, you will lose weight. No diet has ever been shown to produce weight loss without a reduction in calories. The problem is that reducing calorie intake is fiendishly hard to accomplish for many reasons, both physiological and psychological. No one has ever denied that.
Low carb diets came into fashion in the 1970s; and Taubes says they worked “remarkably well” but were criticized because they were rich in saturated fats, which the medical community believed caused heart disease. Sure, lots of people lost weight by controlling the quantity and quality of carbohydrates in their diet, but the evidence does not support the claim that these diets worked “remarkably well.” In comparative studies, people achieved sustained weight loss just as well on diets with different macronutrient compositions. Taubes concludes that there is little long-term compliance with any diet, which seems to me to undermine his recommendations.
He stresses that knowing the underlying cause of obesity is a different question from advising someone to follow a Mediterranean, low-fat, or low-carb diet. Yes it is! Which is exactly my point. There is no evidence that any diet works unless it results in lower total calorie intake. Does it really matter how that lowered calorie intake is achieved? Some people prefer one diet to another; if they are able to lose weight on a diet that includes carbs, why insist that they change their habits?
Taubes agrees with me that diet studies are inherently problematic (poor compliance, poor self-reporting of intake, etc.) and that rigorous studies are required to test hypotheses. He has cofounded a not-for-profit organization called the Nutrition Science Initiative to fund and facilitate rigorous well-controlled experimental trials carried out by independent, skeptical researchers. He says we must “refuse to accept substandard science as sufficient to establish reliable knowledge, let alone for public health guidelines.” I couldn’t agree more, and my criticism of Taubes is based on his track record of accepting substandard science and basing recommendations for public health on that rather than on rigorous science. Where we part company is that I am content to withhold judgment until the hypothesis is properly tested, while Taubes is so convinced that his hypothesis is right that he has urged everyone to change their eating habits before the test results are in. In his books, he says that obesity is such a serious problem that it is urgent that we institute his diet recommendations now, without waiting for the evidence. Which is exactly what he criticized the low-fat diet campaign for doing.
We need to understand why some people gain weight easily and others don’t. Taubes doesn’t have an answer for that: his “cause” of obesity is more of a “mechanism” that doesn’t really get at the underlying genetic, environmental, and behavioral causes. While we are waiting to understand that, we still have the practical problem that overweight people need to lose weight now. It is undeniable that if you can find a way to reduce total calorie intake sufficiently, you will lose weight. I maintain that there is more than one way to accomplish that, and that we don’t know enough yet to dictate one method. Most people find it difficult to reduce total calorie intake without restricting carbohydrate intake, particularly simple carbohydrates. But that doesn’t mean everyone must follow a strict low carb diet.
A 2003 systematic review found insufficient evidence to make a recommendation for or against low-carb diets, and found that weight loss on a low-carb diet was principally associated with decreased caloric intake.
The Swedish Council on Health Technology Assessment recently reviewed the dietary treatment of obesity. They said a low-carb, high-fat diet is the most effective for weight loss in the first 6 months and it improves health markers like HDL cholesterol. But they also said long term studies show no statistically significant differences among different diets, probably because compliance decreases over time. And they didn’t deny that other diets can also be effective for weight loss and can also improve health markers. And contrary to popular wisdom, they found that the benefit of adding exercise to diet is marginal or non-existent. Another 2014 meta-analysis found that the short-term benefits of higher protein, lower carb weight loss diets appear to persist to a small degree over a longer period.
My prescription for weight loss is this:
     1.  Start keeping a food diary. Write down everything that goes in your mouth and track how many calories you are eating to maintain your present weight.
     2.  Whatever number you come up with, cut it down by 500 calories a day; this should result in loss of a pound a week.
     3.  If you are not losing a pound a week, cut down by increments until you are.
     4.  Exercise will allow you to eat more calories but is not absolutely essential; those who abhor exercise or who are unable to exercise due to physical limitations can still lose weight.
     5.  It doesn’t matter if your calorie estimates are inaccurate; reducing calories on the basis of inaccurate estimates will still result in weight loss.
     6.  It is the average calorie intake that matters. If you are aiming for 1200 calories a day, you could splurge on a 2400 calorie Thanksgiving dinner or binge on 2400 calories of birthday cake and ice cream and make up for it by cutting down by 100 calories on each of 12 other days.
     7.  There is no need to deny yourself anything you crave as long as you control total calories.
     8.  Try to include a variety of foods to insure adequate nutrient intake. If you are concerned that you may have cut calories so much that good nutrition is suffering, it’s better to consult a dietitian than to rely on self-prescribed vitamins and supplements.
     9.  Try to pick foods that are filling but low in calories (low calorie density foods). Use the diet diary to study your eating habits, identify situations or foods that particularly tempt you to overeat, and look for ways to outwit the temptations. You might want to try tricks like using smaller plates, eating more slowly and consciously savoring every bite, eating in the dining room instead of in front of the TV, etc. One of my patients would walk the dog whenever she felt hungry; when she got back home, the cravings had passed and she and the dog had benefited from the exercise.
I’m not claiming that everyone can do this successfully, but then Taubes admits that there is poor long-term compliance with a low-carb diet, too. He even admits that the diet can cause side effects, which he attributes to (1) eating too much protein and too little fat, (2) attempting strenuous exercise without taking the time to adapt to the diet, and (3) most importantly, to the body’s failure to compensate for the lower insulin levels. He admits that carbohydrate cravings can be difficult to overcome, and that high protein diets can be toxic.
Conclusion
Taubes’ hypothesis about the underlying cause of obesity may be right, and a low-carb diet may be best not only for weight loss but for disease prevention. I look forward to the results of rigorous studies. Meanwhile, I favor moderation: going easy on the carbs, especially simple carbs with low nutrient content, but not following a low-carb diet per se. The recommendations in Taubes’ books go beyond the currently available evidence. In his understandable enthusiasm for his attractive and plausible hypothesis, he has jumped the gun and committed the very sin he criticized in others. Perhaps he has reconsidered: the BMJ article is more about finding the underlying cause of obesity than about pushing a specific diet. Until the evidence is in, I see no compelling reason to prefer Taubes’ low-carb recommendations to the sensible advice of Michael Pollan to “Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants.”

Gary Taubes and the Case Against Sugar
Gary Taubes writes that sugar is the cause of obesity and most chronic diseases. He makes a good case for the prosecution, but he doesn’t convict.
Harriet Hall on April 25, 2017
Link

Gary Taubes is a journalist on a crusade. In two earlier books, Good Calories, Bad Calories and Why We Get Fat: And What to Do About It, he marshaled masses of evidence to support his thesis that the calories in/calories out model is wrong, that carbohydrates are the cause of obesity and most of the “diseases of civilization,” and that simply restricting carbohydrates will result in weight loss regardless of the total number of calories ingested. In his new book The Case Against Sugar he narrows his focus to sugar. He says it is an addictive drug and is the cause of the obesity epidemic and of many chronic diseases.
He makes a cohesive argument backed by evidence, but his Author’s Note inadvertently exposes what is wrong with the book. He says,
If this were a criminal case, The Case Against Sugar would be the argument for the prosecution.
In science as in the courts, fairness requires that we hear the argument for the defense before we convict. Taubes’ book is a polemic, not a balanced scientific review. To his credit, he admits that his thesis is based partly on circumstantial evidence and has not been proven beyond all reasonable doubt – and yet he wants us to act on it. He thinks it justifies removing added sugars and processed foods from our diet. In my opinion, he goes too far. He commits the same sin he accused the low-fat diet advocates of: going beyond the evidence and recommending society-wide changes based on inadequate data.
Background
I reviewed his earlier book Why We Get Fat and explained my objections:
     1.  Low carb diets work, but if Taubes’ thesis is correct, they should overwhelmingly outperform other diets, and they don’t. And people who lose weight on low-carb diets reduce their calorie intake.
     2.  The clinical evidence isn’t yet sufficient to convincingly prove his thesis. (He himself admitted this.)
     3.  He strongly recommended that everyone adopt a low-carb diet, essentially insisting that we act on insufficient evidence. And this was after he had devoted whole chapters of his books to demonizing the low-fat diet advocates for doing exactly that: acting on insufficient evidence.
Taubes objected to my review in a rather offensive and condescending e-mail, saying I had failed to understand what he wrote. I thought I understood very well, and I thought he had failed to understand my arguments.
Calories in/calories out
We exchanged some words, but we were talking at cross purposes based on our different understandings of the meaning of the calories in/calories out (CI/CO) model. Taubes wrote:
[restricting carbohydrates]…leads to weight loss and particularly fat loss, independent of the calories we consume from dietary fat and protein. We know that the laws of physics have nothing to do with it.
He sees CI/CO as a false explanation of why people get fat, essentially an attempt to blame the victim for sloth and gluttony. I see it simply as an incontrovertible fact of physics that weight increases when calorie intake exceeds expenditure; it doesn’t even attempt to explain why people get fat, why their calorie intake exceeds expenditure. Whatever the underlying cause, whatever the individual’s metabolism, even if Taubes is right, and sugar is the cause of obesity, the laws of physics ensure that any obese person will lose weight if calorie intake is reduced sufficiently (not that that’s easy to accomplish!).
Of course, what we really want to know is what causes some people to take in more calories than they expend. Once they do that, the laws of physics take over: the laws of physics have everything to do with why the weight goes up. Gary Taubes thinks he has found the one true cause of weight gain: sugar. I suspect it’s not quite so simple.
The obesity epidemic
There is plenty of epidemiologic evidence for a correlation between the rising consumption of sugar and the rising prevalence of obesity and diabetes. But correlation doesn’t establish causation. I can’t help but wonder if increasing prosperity and the increased availability and affordability of food have allowed more people to eat more of everything and to change their lifestyle in other ways. Some experts discourage sugar consumption simply because it consists of “empty calories” that replace other, more nutritious elements of our diet and add to the total calorie intake. Taubes thinks the “empty calories” arguments are misguided. He thinks sugar has unique physiological, metabolic, and endocrinological effects that directly trigger obesity, diabetes, and many other chronic diseases. He thinks sugars are long-term toxins that act over decades and affect future generations through epigenetic effects. Sugars cause insulin resistance, which causes metabolic syndrome and probably triggers a host of diseases including diabetes, heart disease, cancer, liver disease, Alzheimer’s, rheumatoid arthritis, asthma, inflammatory bowel disease, gout, polycystic ovary syndrome, and even varicose veins! He says Occam’s razor favors the idea that a single cause underlies all of these. In his previous books, he recommended limiting carbs, but now he thinks people can be healthy on a carbohydrate-rich diet, even a grain-rich diet, if they consume relatively little sugar. He suggests that sugars may have killed more people prematurely than cigarettes or all wars combined.
Big Sugar and bad science
He devotes many pages to the history of sugar, the economics and lobbying efforts of the sugar industry, and the misguided science that led to misguided official recommendations for a low-fat diet. He explains that experts were fixated on energy balance and were slow to consider the effects of genetics and hormones and to realize that all calories are not equal. History may help us understand how we got to our current level of sugar consumption and how doctors got things wrong, but that doesn’t mean Taubes got things right. We can’t be sure his low-sugar diet won’t be discredited by future evidence just as the low-fat diet was.
The evidence against sugar
Taubes presents a lot of evidence. For instance:
    • In animal models of obesity, as animals grew fatter they were hungrier and ate more; some would remain fat even if they were prevented from eating more. This suggests some kind of dysregulation of fat storage that is likely influenced by genetic factors.
    • Diabetes is not just a matter of too little insulin. Some type 2 diabetics have too much insulin. Diabetes is a disease of insulin resistance.
    • The evidence that a high fat diet was unhealthy was confounded by the fact that people who ate a lot of fat tended to also eat a lot of sugar.
    • Eating sugar seemed to shorten the life span of some strains of rats (but not others).
    • Feeding animals large amounts of fructose results in fatty liver, insulin resistance, and metabolic syndrome (but animals are not humans, humans eat a mixture of sugars, not fructose alone, and they don’t eat as much sugar as the animals got).
    • The Pima tribe had practically no diabetes until they started following a Western-type diet and lifestyle. Their sugar intake skyrocketed, and so did the incidence of obesity and diabetes.
    • There is evidence for “metabolic imprinting”: diabetic mothers have babies who are fatter and more likely to develop diabetes.
    • Medical missionaries in Africa have documented a paucity of obesity, diabetes, and other “diseases of civilization” in their patients followed by a surge in those conditions after their patients underwent Westernization.
But Taubes admits that “research…couldn’t establish whether or not sugar was truly the cause of these chronic diseases, or whether people (and the laboratory animals used in the experiments) simply ate too much of the stuff, and so got fat first and sick second.”
One cause or many?
Can the host of chronic diseases that cluster together and are associated with Western diets and lifestyles be explained by a single dietary trigger, or are there multiple triggers? Does Occam’s razor apply here, or Mencken, who said “For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong”? Taubes’ answer is clear and simple, but it could be wrong. He admits:
Because the kind of observational evidence researchers deal with is incapable of establishing beyond reasonable doubt that sugar…is the factor in Western diets and lifestyles that triggers the aforementioned cluster of chronic diseases, the best we can do is ask whether this is a likely possibility, and if so, whether it is, indeed, the most likely.
Taubes thinks the recent revelations about metabolic syndrome and insulin resistance make sugar the most likely candidate. Maybe. Maybe it’s sugar but not just sugar alone. Maybe genetics, psychology, cultural traditions, food cost, availability, lifestyle, and other factors are involved.
The if/then problem
He devotes two whole chapters to what he calls the if/then problem. If sugar causes insulin resistance and makes us fat, then it very likely causes hypertension, at least indirectly. And it very likely causes all the so-called diseases of civilization, including cancer and Alzheimer’s. He presents evidence and reasoning to implicate it in:
    • Gout: the incidence of gout paralleled the availability of sugar, and fructose increases serum levels of uric acid.
    • Hypertension: high blood pressure increases with age and weight in Western populations, but in indigenous populations it remains low throughout life.
    • Salt sensitivity
    • Kidney disease
    • Cancer: He considers cancer to be a metabolic disease. He cites the Warburg effect, the observation that cancer cells preferentially metabolize large amounts of sugar. Warburg thought the metabolic changes were the cause of the cancer; but they are just as likely to be a result, as Dr. Gorski explained here.
    • Alzheimer’s and other types of dementia: he admits the evidence is weaker here.
    • Complications of diabetes such as kidney disease, retinopathy, neuropathy, arteriosclerosis, and premature aging of skin and other tissues.
    • Changes in gut bacteria: still not known whether these result from insulin resistance or contribute to its development.
Is sugar addictive?
Sugar is pleasurable; some call it intoxicating. Taubes calls it “pleasure with a price.” Sugar craving seems hardwired in our brains; it stimulates the reward center. Once introduced to a population, consumption rises meteorically. Is it addictive, or do some people and populations only act as if it is? In times of economic hardship, the British poor would cut back on other foods before they would cut back on sugar. Rats addicted to cocaine will choose sugar water over cocaine.
Many animals respond positively to sugar, but not all. Cats don’t. Neither do chickens, whales, sea lions, or some fish. Why do humans? Taubes speculates about how a human sweet tooth might have evolved by offering a survival advantage.
To my mind, sugar doesn’t act like addictive drugs. I would call it habit-forming, and habits can be broken. People can lose their sweet tooth as they get older. I seldom eat desserts any more, and I don’t crave them. I used to drink my coffee with so much sugar my father used to tease me, asking if I would like some coffee in my sugar. I eliminated it when I started watching my calorie intake, and now I prefer to drink my coffee with no sugar at all. Now if I happen to drink a cup of coffee with sugar, I do not relapse; I don’t want the next cup to have sugar too. Would that happen with an addictive drug like alcohol, nicotine, or heroin? Taubes asks how much sugar is too much. Do we ask how much heroin is too much? How many cigarettes are too much? Can you smoke just one? For many recovering alcoholics, taking just one drink is enough to cause a relapse. I think calling sugar addictive is misguided; it trivializes true addictions.
Conclusion: Compelling, but inconclusive
Taubes makes a compelling case against sugar, but as he acknowledges, the evidence is insufficient to definitively convict. Wouldn’t it be wonderful if we could eliminate obesity, diabetes, cancer, and most chronic diseases by simply removing one component of our diet? When something sounds too good to be true, it usually is.
As so often in medicine, we have to make decisions on the basis of incomplete information. I’m biased. I want to believe we can safely eat a modest amount of sugar as part of a healthy, calorie-controlled diet; but I readily admit I can’t cite any good evidence to support that belief. While we are waiting for more evidence, I will continue to limit my sugar consumption but I won’t deny myself the occasional sugary treat.

   High Fructose Corn Syrup: Tasty Toxin or Slandered Sweetener?
Jim Laidler 
Link
The perils of fructose:
High fructose corn syrup (HFCS) has, over the past few decades, gradually displaced cane and beet sugar as the sweetener of choice for soft drinks, candy and prepared foods. In recent years, there have been a growing number claims that HFCS is a significant health risk to consumers, responsible for obesity, diabetes, heart disease and a wide variety of other illnesses. 
In fact, there are large amounts of experimental data supporting the claims that high levels of fructose in the diet can cause hyperlipidemia (high levels of fats — triglycerides primarily — in the blood), obesity and insulin resistance and may lead to cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes (for a good recent review, see [1]). A high-fructose diet is thought to cause hyperlipidemia (and probably visceral obesity) because fructose is preferentially “sent” to fatty acid synthesis and it also reduces the activity of lipoprotein lipase (for a good review, see [2]). The mechanisms by which fructose causes insulin resistance and cardiovascular disease are less clear (see, for example [3], [4] and [5]), but there is no shortage of hypotheses. Despite the fact that some of the underlying mechanisms are not clear, the evidence seems pretty solid that there are real risks to high fructose consumption.
However, the question remains — is HFCS more of a health risk than other sweeteners? Many of the sources that demonize HFCS list alternative sweeteners — cane sugar, honey, agave syrup, etc. — that they claim are healthier than HFCS, but those claims usually rest primarily on the fact that these alternatives to HFCS are “natural” rather than any actual data showing that they are safer than HFCS. 
Sugar 101:
Before we can properly analyze these claims, we need to understand a bit about sugar. To begin with, what is sugar? To most people, sugar is the white granulated solid that they find in the sugar bowl. In reality, sugar is a much broader term. There are two general classes of sugars — aldose and ketose — and over twenty individual sugars (monosaccharides), if you limit yourself to only those found in nature. Of these, only a few play any significant role in human nutrition, primarily glucose, fructose and galactose (ribose, a sugar that forms the backbone of DNA and RNA, also plays a minor nutritional role). 
Further complicating the issue, there are also sugars — disaccharides — that are compounds made of two monosaccharides covalently bound together. The most common of these is sucrose, a compound made by joining one molecule of glucose to one molecule of fructose. Sucrose is the sugar in the average sugar bowl. It is also the sugar in brown sugar, molasses, cane sugar, beet sugar and is the major component of maple syrup (and maple sugar). Another common disaccharide is lactose (milk sugar), which is a combination of glucose and galactose. Less commonly encountered is maltose, a combination of two molecules of glucose. 
Starches, such as corn starch, are also sugar. They are made up of long interlinked chains (polymers, also known as polysaccharides) of individual sugars (usually glucose). Cellulose, the major component of paper and wood, is also a polymer of glucose (with different bond geometries). Insect and crustacean shells are made of a sugar polymer known as chitin (also a major component of fungal cell walls). We literally live in a world of sugar. 
One final note about sugars — humans only absorb monosaccharides; no matter what form the sugar enters the digestive tract, it is only absorbed after it is broken down to its component monosaccharides (there are, as usual in biology, a few minor exceptions to this rule). There are a variety of enzymes — amylases, disaccharidases, etc. — that perform this function. Any disaccharide or polysaccharide that isn’t broken down (such as the raffinose and stachyose in beans and many other gas-causing foods) remains inside the gut, providing food for our gut bacteria.
“Natural” Sweeteners:
Now, let’s take a look at some of the sugar-based sweeteners in common use today. Honey was probably the first sweetener — at least in the part of the world where honey bees are native. Honey is about 82% sugar, with almost all the remainder being water. The sugar in honey is 43% glucose, 50% fructose, 4% galactose, 2% maltose, 1% sucrose and trace amounts of other sugars [6]. As mentioned earlier, it is considered by many to be a natural sweetener that is a healthy alternative to HFCS. 
Another sweetener used in ancient times — especially in regions where honey bees were not native — is tree sap. The most famous of these is the sap of sugar maple trees, used to make maple syrup and, when crystallized, maple sugar. Natural maple syrup is 60% sugar, with that sugar being 95% sucrose, 4% glucose and 1% fructose [6]. 
Fruit juices also have an ancient history of use as sweetening agents and — not surprisingly — are often cited as natural and healthy alternatives to HFCS. The sugar content of fruits varies with the type of fruit and even with the variety. Apples, for instance, are a bit over 10% sugar by weight, with that sugar being 57% fructose, 23% glucose and 20% sucrose. Peaches, in contrast, are 8.4% sugar by weight with that sugar being 57% sucrose, 23% glucose and 18% fructose. Pears – the most common fruit juice used in sweetening - are 9.8% sugar, with that sugar being 64% fructose, 28% glucose and 8% sucrose. Table grapes are about 15% sugar, with the sugars being 53% fructose and 47% glucose [6]. 
Sucrose, the disaccharide in common table sugar, was originally obtained in ralatively pure form from sugar cane, which can only grow in the tropics. The high cost of cane suger led to a search for alternative sources. As early as the 1700’s, sucrose was being extracted from sugar beets, but it took both selective breeding of sugar beets to increase their sucrose content and improvements in the extraction process to make beet sugar economically viable. By the late 1800’s and early 1900’s, sucrose from sugar beets had outstripped cane sugar in Europe and the U.S. Sugar beets have the advantage of growing throughout the temperate zone, closer to the demand. Just to be clear, beet sugar and case sugar are indistinguishable — they are exactly the same chemical compound (sucrose).
The rise of HFCS:
So, with all of these sugar-based sweeteners available, what prompted the development of HFCS?
Corn syrup is a relatively recent arrival as a sweetener; it had to wait until food processors discovered how to take corn starch (which, like most starches, is a polymer composed of long interlinked chains of glucose molecules) and break it down into isolated glucose molecules using the enzymes amylase and maltase. Commercial amounts of corn syrup were available by the middle of the 20th century [7]. Corn syrup was so much cheaper than sucrose that it saw extensive use as a sucrose substitute for thickening foods and to help retain moisture. It wasn’t much used solely as a sweetener because it isn’t as sweet as sucrose.
The fact is that not all sugars are equally sweet. If we assign sucrose (table sugar) a sweetness of 100%, glucose has a sweetness of 60 – 75% (on a gram-per-gram basis) and fructose has a sweetness of 140 – 170% [8][9][10]. (Note: the sweetness of fructose varies with its conformation, and so will differ under different circumstances [11]) Candy and soft drink manufacturers exploited the greater sweetness of fructose even before HFCS was available by using what is called “invert sugar”. Invert sugar is sucrose that has been treated with a weak acid solution and then recrystallized (to get rid of the acid). This treatment causes a portion of the sucrose to break apart into fructose and glucose. Although the glucose part is less sweet than sucrose, the fructose is so much sweeter that the overall effect is to get more sweetness with less sugar. This allowed the manufacturers to use less sugar and thereby save money, even though invert sugar was more expensive than plain sucrose.
In 1957, a process was developed to convert some of the glucose in corn syrup to fructose, yielding a product that was 42% fructose and 58% glucose [12]. This dramatically increased its sweetness, making a product that was a commercially viable competitor to sucrose as a sweetener. This was HFCS 42, which has a sweetness — gram-per-gram — slightly greater than sucrose (110%).
The primary advantage of HFCS 42 to food manufacturers was its low cost — much lower than the cost of sucrose. Secondary advantages were that it retained moisture better than sucrose (twice as many molecules), was slightly sweeter than sucrose (so less was needed), was in a liquid form and didn’t caramelize as readily as sucrose (this last one could be an advantage or a disadvantage, depending on the use).
Later, HFCS manufacturers began putting some of their HFCS 42 through separation columns to produce syrup that was 90% fructose (HFCS 90) [5]. Today, the bulk of the HFCS 90 production is used to make corn syrup with 55% fructose, known as HFCS 55, although a very small amount is used in some reduced-calorie confections (HFCS 90 is about 60% sweeter per gram than sucrose, which allows a 35% reduction in the amount of sugar used). 
With the introduction of HFCS 55, which is 25% sweeter than sucrose, food manufacturers found that the slightly increased price (which was still less than sucrose) was more than offset by the fact that they needed less of it to get the same level of sweetness. 
That’s right, HFCS allowed food manufacturers to use less sugar — and thus fewer sugar calories — in their products without compromising sweetness. Using sucrose — cane or beet sugar — would require 20% more sugar (and 20% more sugar calories) than using HFCS 55. 
How safe are other sweeteners compared to HFCS?:
Still, none of this alters the fact that a diet high in fructose has been shown to cause — or at least contribute to — hyperlipidemia, obesity, insulin resistance and cardiac disease. However, those who have been paying attention will have noticed that HFCS is not the ONLY sweetener that contains significant amounts of fructose.
In fact, sucrose — even “natural” cane sugar — is 50% fructose once it is digested and absorbed. While this is 20% less than the fructose content of HFCS 55, food manufacturers need to use less (about 20% less) HFCS 55 to get the same sweetness, so it’s a wash as far as fructose content.
Honey, long touted as a “healthy” and “natural” alternative to evil HFCS, is also 50% fructose. Agave syrup (also called agave nectar), often promoted as a healthy alternative to HFCS (especially in diabetics), is very high in fructose, although there is some disagreement over how much fructose it contains. According to the USDA, the sugar in cooked agave is 87% fructose (due to breakdown of fructans — a starch-like polymer of fructose — in the plant when it is cooked) [6]. A wholesale supplier of agave syrup, however, lists the fructose as 70 — 75% of the total sugar in their syrup [13]. Either way, agave syrup is higher in fructose than any other natural sweetener (and any form of HFCS except HFCS 90). 
Even fruit juices (and what could be more natural and healthy than fruit juice?) are 40 — 70% fructose, if you count the fructose in sucrose. And for those who argue that ingesting sucrose delays the absorption of fructose, Monsivais et al (2007) showed that sucrose breaks down spontaneously in carbonated beverages (and, presumably, all acid solutions), with 50% of the sucrose being hydrolyzed to fructose and glucose within the first 30 days after bottling [14].
Finally, a study that directly compared the short-term effects of fructose, HFCS and sucrose showed that they are indistinguishable [15]. 
What does all this mean?:
So, what are the take-home messages from all of this? 
    • HFCS 42 and HFCS 55 have essentially the same amount of fructose, as a fraction of their total sugar, as honey, sucrose (cane or beet sugar) or maple syrup/sugar (to be agonizingly precise, HFCS has slightly less, and HCFS 55 has slightly more).
    • HFCS 42 and HFCS 55 have an equal or smaller amount of fructose, as a fraction of their total sugar, as many commonly consumed fruits.
    • Agave syrup has higher fructose content than any type of HFCS except HFCS 90. 
For people who are worried about their health or their children’s health — and who isn’t, these days — the data suggest that the best choice is to reduce intake of all sweeteners containing fructose. That includes not only the evil HFCS, but also natural cane sugar, molasses (which is just impure cane sugar), brown sugar (ditto) and honey. Even “unsweetened” (no added sugar) fruit juices need to be considered when limiting your family’s fructose intake. 
Finally, the best nutritional advice is to eat everything in moderation — and that includes sweets. While a diet high in fructose may increase your risk of obesity, diabetes and heart disease — maybe — a fructose-free diet is not guaranteed to prevent those diseases. Eat a variety of foods, including a small amount of sweets, get enough exercise, watch your (and your children’s) weight and see your doctor for regular health check-ups. 
And stop worrying that HFCS is poisoning you and your children. 
Until later,
Jim Laidler
Jim Laidler, MD graduated from USC School of Medicine and went on to do an internship in Pediatrics before spending four years as a flight surgeon in the US Army. After his military service, he completed a residency in Anesthesiology and a fellowship in Pain Medicine at the University of Illinois. He practiced for several years in Alaska and Oregon before deciding to take up a new career in research. He is currently finishing his PhD thesis in Molecular Biology in Portland, Oregon.
DISCLAIMER: The opinions expressed by Dr. Laidler are his own and not those of any organization or institution he is affiliated with. His writings are not meant to diagnose or treat any diseases or disorders except ignorance and misinformation.

The Sweetener Wars – HFCS Strikes Back
Steven Novella on September 19, 2012
Link
The health conscious and trendy public are a bit obsessed with the food they consume. This can be a good thing, to the extent that it results in a more healthful diet, but unfortunately those interested in improving their diet must wade through a great deal of misinformation before getting to accurate and helpful information.
For example, I recently gave a lecture (ironically on health information) at Google (you can view the entire talk here). Google is a progressive company that tries to help their employees stay healthy. They provide many snack stations and helpfully divide snacks into red, yellow, and green shelves. Employees can freely choose whatever snacks they want, but they are gently encouraged to choose from the more healthful green shelf and avoid the unhealthy red shelf. I noticed that beverages sweetened with sugar cane were placed on the green shelf, while those sweetened with artificial sweeteners like aspartame or Splenda were slumming on the red shelf. It was ironic to see such a high-tech company falling for the naturalistic fallacy.
Sugar cane sweetened sodas are becoming fashionable, mainly to avoid high fructose corn syrup (HFCS), which many claim is associated with obesity and increased cardiovascular risk. Jim Laidler did an excellent job reviewing this controversy two years ago on SBM. To me this represents a general tendency to try to understand a complex question by oversimplifying, specifically by avoiding perceived “villains.” It may seem overwhelming to grapple with all the complex information involved in basic dietary health choices, like which beverages are best. Following simple rules, such as avoiding single ingredients that are perceived to be “bad,” therefore has an appeal. I also think this is part of the appeal of the naturalistic fallacy, a simple litmus test to what is good vs bad.
While there are some simple rules that are helpful and mostly accurate (calorie control, varied diet, eat enough plants), there are many more which are misleading and counterproductive. The naturalistic fallacy and fear of HFCS may lead many a Google employee, for example, to consume sugar cane sweetened soda with the false security that the calories won’t contribute to obesity.
A recent commentary in the International Journal of Obesity seeks to set the record straight with respect to HFCS. The authors point out that, in reality, there is very little difference between sucrose and HFCS. Sucrose is 50% fructose and 50% glucose. There are two main forms of HFCS in drinks and processed food: HFCS-42 and HFCS-55, indicating the percentage of fructose they contain. So one form has slightly less and the other slightly more fructose than sucrose. Available evidence indicates that this is not metabolically significant. In fact HFCS-55 is slightly sweeter than sucrose and so products with this sweetener may use less sweetener, and therefore contain fewer calories.
The authors write:
HFCS existed as a benign and essentially non-controversial product for over 35 years until 2004 when Bray, Nielsen and Popkin published a commentary suggesting a potential link between HFCS consumption and obesity.1 These authors buttressed their argument by charting the consumption of high fructose corn syrup along with the prevalence of obesity in the United States between 1970-2000,
And…
Bray et al.1 used the temporal association as their primary evidence even though this is an example of an ecologic fallacy in which group data are extrapolated to individuals.
Later research showed that HFCS is not a unique cause of obesity (beyond the calories they contain), and there is no significant difference between the effect of different carbohydrate sweeteners on metabolism and weight gain. They also point out that there has been a lot of misleading research involving feeding animals a high carbohydrate diet consisting entirely of fructose, which cannot be extrapolated to HFCS consumption.
The scientific controversy is largely over. The Bray hypothesis, which was always weak, has not survived later research. But the meme that HFCS is harmful is out there, taking on a life of its own on the internet, and so the public controversy continues.
The disconnect between the scientific consensus and public perception remains a problem in many areas, not just with HFCS. We clearly need to do a better job overall of communicating scientific findings to the public – starting with scientists but also including journalists and the blogging community.
There doesn’t seem to be any way to stop misinformation from spreading on the internet, however. All we can do is get the accurate information out there.

Artificial Sweeteners – A Free Lunch, or an Obesogenic Carcinogen? What 80+ Studies Say (part 1 of 2).
In this two part series, I explore the impact of artificial sweeteners on obesity, diabetes, the gut microbiome, and cancer. Part one of two!
John Solokas on May 21, 2021
Link

Many awesome experiences come tethered to inevitable baggage. Take binge drinking, for instance, or eating a dozen chocolate donuts in one sitting. An overflow of dopamine and hedonistic bliss in the moment, but a fiercely unpleasant stomach ache or hangover, along with a strong feeling of self disgust, awaits the next day. But in the case of artificial sweeteners, sugar substitutes that tickle our taste buds without the massive caloric load that is inherent of “real” sugar, we can have our stevia-sweetened cake and eat it too. Or can we?
On the surface, artificial sweeteners seem too good to be true. Let’s consider the most popular artificially sweetened product – diet soda. Though diet soda has an eerily similar taste to regular soda, the full sugar version contains with an extra 140 calories and 40 grams of sugar per 12oz serving, packing a serious, metabolically damaging punch. Artificial sweeteners deliver a sweet taste sans the calories and sugar but have been very much demonized in the media as a cause of all maladies, from obesity and metabolic syndrome to cancer. As we know, there is no such thing as a free lunch in biology; so, what’s the catch? Are artificial sweeteners the exception to the rule, or are they secretly making us sick and overweight? Let’s find out.
The story of artificial sweeteners begins in 1878 after German researcher Constantin Fahlberg “accidentally” stumbled upon the sweet taste after licking his finger while working in his lab. He went on to break the first rule in every science class and decided to lick every beaker and vial in his lab in a radical yet effective attempt to discover the source. After this severe compromise of hygiene and lab safety, he identified the sweet substance chemicals and would later produce the first commercially available artificial sweetener, saccharin (1).
Today, the artificial sweetener industry has BOOMED and calorie free sweeteners can be found in nearly every food product imaginable. Sugar-free versions of any sweet fare you can imagine, including barbecue sauce, syrup, and even powdered sugar itself, are readily available on the local supermarket shelf.
As Fahlberg discovered and others would go on to study, artificial sweeteners have a taste practically indistinguishable from sugar because, on a chemical level, the two share a similar molecule shape. The most common artificial sweeteners fall into three categories:
     1.  Non-nutritive natural sweeteners, such as stevia or monk fruit.
     2.  Non-nutritive artificial sweeteners, such as saccharin, aspartame, ace K, sucralose, etc.
     3.  Sugar alcohols, such as erythritol, xylitol, etc. (anything that ends in “-ol”).
Despite their molecular similarities, they are processed completely differently than sugar in the body – while most artificial sweeteners are calorie-free and pass through the digestive tract without providing energy, the calories in “real” sugar are converted to fuel or stored for later use as body fat, or as glycogen in muscles and the liver.
Until recently, most accepted that it was just this simple; artificial sweeteners offer the same sweet taste as sugar without any of the consequences. That was, of course, until studies began to show otherwise. The primary headline about artificial sweeteners was not “Magic substance that will help you lose fat and stave off disease – more scientists need to start licking their lab equipment“, but more along the lines of “Artificial sweeteners cause cancer” and “Artificial sweeteners make you eat more and gain weight“. The 4 most common and alarming accusations against artificial sweeteners include:
     1.  Artificial sweeteners cause weight gain
     2.  Artificial sweeteners cause diabetes
     3.  Artificial sweeteners disrupt gut bacteria
     4.  Artificial sweeteners cause cancer
These potential side effects sound terrifying, and, if the accusations are true, no self-respecting health nut would be caught dead consuming such a substance. If you have already tossed all of your Splenda in the trash, I wouldn’t blame you. But before you take the can out to the curb and fully swear off on artificial sweeteners, let’s assess each accusation and see if it holds up under the scrutiny of the available body of research.
Artificial sweeteners cause weight gain
If you were to google “artificial sweeteners and obesity”, you would find a ton of websites, news articles, and even research studies that claim artificial sweeteners cause weight gain. As we know, Dr. Google is not a reliable source. This myth has only spread so far and wide because of two factors; misinterpretation of the research and sensationalism in the media. It is a slippery slope:
     1.  A researcher finds reports an observational link between obesity and artificial sweeteners.
     2.  Then, a journalist misinterprets that claim to believe that artificial sweeteners cause obesity.
     3.  Finally, to make matters even more confusing, the mainstream media not only misinterprets but sensationalizes the aforementioned studies, with headlines such as “Artificial Sweeteners Linked to Weight Gain and Type 2 Diabetes” and “Your Artificial Sweetener May Be Giving You a Gut” (2, 3).
As you will see, just because headlines on your 5 o’clock news turn a lot of heads does not mean that they are well-substantiated.
The body of research on artificial sweeteners is a mixed bag. Many observational studies, including the first ones to pop up after a quick Google search, link artificial sweeteners to weight gain and unfavorable health outcomes (4, 5, 6, 7, 8). While mis-interpretation of observational studies casts artificial sweeteners in an unfavorable light, to date, there are ZERO well controlled, experimental studies that show a causal link between artificial sweeteners and weight gain. These studies may have some eye popping, clickbait titles, but NOT ONE shows causation in either direction.
Extrapolating from observational studies that “artificial sweeteners cause weight gain” is likened to claiming that ice cream consumption causes murder – just because both ice cream sales and murders increase in the summer does not mean downing a pint of moose tracks will make you kill your neighbor.
The majority of studies, on the other hand, link artificial sweeteners to no change in weight (9, 10, 11, 12) or to weight loss (13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22). In many cases, the consumption of artificial sweeteners reduces overall sugar and calorie intakes, making it easier to lose or maintain weight. This calorie-reducing effect of artificial sweeteners holds up in well designed studies and it appears that artificial sweetener intake is an effective weight loss strategy for many people. For instance, this 2006 meta-analysis that only considered randomized controlled trials that assessed energy intake for at least 24 hours found that artificial sweetener consumption (specifically aspartame) resulted in a daily average calorie intake reduction of 10% (23). And this 2012 experimental study found that when replacing regular soda in the diet, diet soda had the same weight-loss inducing effects as water (24).
Furthermore, the researchers behind this study had overweight and obese people consume either a quarter gallon of water, milk, regular soda, or diet soda every day for 6 months. By the end of the study, those in the diet soda group weighed 17–21% less, had 24–31% less belly fat, 32% lower cholesterol levels, and 10–15% lower blood pressure, compared with those in the regular soda group (25).
As you can see, the observational links between artificial sweetener intake and weight gain that the media loves to promote can largely be explained by mistaking correlation for causation and the failure to recognize reverse causality. In other words, people who are gaining weight or already heavy may be consuming artificial sweeteners in an effort to reduce calorie consumption. Now that we have explained the faulty link between artificial sweeteners and weight gain or loss, let’s dive a little deeper into the actual mechanisms that may cause artificial sweeteners to impact weight.
To simplify matters, let’s break down the accusation that “artificial sweeteners cause weight gain” into 2 sub-sections:
Artificial sweeteners inherently cause weight gain on a physiological level.
In accordance with the laws of thermodynamics, a food that has zero calories cannot possibly cause weight gain. If a person consumed only artificial sweeteners and water, he/she would eventually starve to death. Unless they are a substance created by black magic or witchcraft and are able bypass the laws that govern the universe, artificial sweeteners don’t directly cause weight gain in any capacity.
Artificial sweeteners cause weight gain through downstream effects, such as by increasing appetite or by decreasing our sensitivity to sweetness and making us crave sugary foods.
This argument is much more interesting and requires that we delve into the research. Because artificial sweeteners taste sweet but do not contain calories, it has been postulated that they “trick” the brain into seeking out high-sugar, calorically dense foods in order to compensate for the lack of energy provided by the sweeteners (26).
It has been demonstrated in multiple studies – some in humans, some in rats – that consumption of artificial sweeteners can increase feeling of hunger (27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32). For instance, this study showed that after exercise, those that drank either a sugar sweetened beverage or an artificially sweetened beverage consumed more calories at their next meal than those that drank water (33). And this study in rats showed that those that were given artificially sweetened beverages ate more calories compared to a group given sugar sweetened beverages. The authors explain that a possible mechanism may be that consumption of noncaloric sweet beverages either increases food intake or decreases energy expenditure (34).
It makes sense – if you ever want to get hungry quickly (i.e. before a Thanksgiving dinner or going out for ice cream), just consume a sweet such as candy or soda. The hyper-palatability of these foods tend to have an appetite inducing effect, and I suspect that this is the cause for the subsequent increased caloric consumption observed after artificial sweetener intake.
However, multiple studies support that consumption of artificial sweeteners either decrease or have no effect on subsequent energy intake or feelings of hunger (35). This study showed that artificial sweetener consumption did not impact subsequent energy intake or feelings of hunger and this review found that aspartame consumption is not associated with increased food intake (36, 37). Additionally, this 2020 study suggests that consumption of a stevia sweetened beverage, compared to water, before a meal may reduce appetite and energy intake, without affecting blood sugar or other metabolic markers (38).
One of the best explanations of artificial sweetener’s effect on food intake is the following excerpt from researcher Qing Yang:
Lastly, artificial sweeteners, precisely because they are sweet, encourage sugar craving and sugar dependence. Repeated exposure trains flavor preference. A strong correlation exists between a person’s customary intake of a flavor and his preferred intensity for that flavor. Systematic reduction of dietary salt or fat without any flavorful substitution over the course of several weeks led to a preference for lower levels of those nutrients in the research subjects. In light of these findings, a similar approach might be used to reduce sugar intake. Unsweetening the world’s diet may be the key to reversing the obesity epidemic (39).
Because repeated exposure does train flavor preference, it certainly follows that consumption of artificial sweeteners could lead to increased sugar consumption (40). This may result in increased consumption of calorically dense foods and lead to excess energy intake.
In short, the effect of artificial sweeteners on appetite and food preference is complicated. Though artificial sweetener consumption may decrease sensitivity to sweetness and increase sugar cravings for some, it appears that the exact opposite is true for others. At this point, it is unlikely that artificial sweetener intake directly increases appetite or energy intake in healthy humans and one’s behavioral response (i.e. higher or lower appetite, more or less cravings, etc.) seems to be dependent on the context and the individual.
To be continued…
I had intended to cover artificial sweeteners in one post, but my research efforts quickly turned into a meta-analysis-esque project. For an analysis of the next 3 accusations against artificial sweetener intake (cause diabetes, disrupt gut bacteria, cause cancer), plus my overall recommendation and a breakdown of my personal consumption, tune in in two weeks for Artificial Sweeteners – A Free Lunch, or an Obesogenic Carcinogen? What 80+ Studies Say (part 2). In the meantime, (and SPOILER ALERT) – I don’t think you have much to worry about, enjoy your diet soda and stevia packets in peace.

Sources
     1.  https://www.sciencehistory.org/distillations/the-pursuit-of-sweet
     2.  https://www.newsweek.com/artificial-sweeteners-weight-gain-type-2-diabetes-1478137
     3.  https://www.menshealth.com/weight-loss/a19544903/artificial-sweetener-and-weight-gain/
     4.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18535548/
     5.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29159583/
     6.  https://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/32/4/688
     7.  https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/jgs.13376
     8.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24741154/
     9.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3714671/
     10.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19056571/
     11.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12324283/
     12.  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2650084/
     13.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20429009/
     14.  https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1467-3010.2006.00564.x
     15.  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4786736/
     16.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24862170/
     17.  https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article-abstract/51/6/963/4695307
     18.  https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/76/4/721/4677434
     19.  https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/65/2/409/4655348
     20.  https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1467-3010.2006.00564.x
     21.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2008866/
     22.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22998340/
     23.  https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1467-3010.2006.00564.x
     24.  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3632875/
     25.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22205311/
     26.  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2892765/
     27.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9023599/
     28.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2359769/
     29.  https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/07/160712130107.htm
     30.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17712114/
     31.  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5896338/#B28
     32.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20060008/
     33.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10336168/
     34.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18298259/
     35.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21255472/
     36.  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2900484/
     37.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2008866/
     38.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32125421/
     39.  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2892765/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15581664/

Artificial Sweeteners – A Free Lunch, or an Obesogenic Carcinogen? What 80+ Studies Say (part 2 of 2)
In the second and final chapter of this two part series, I conclude my exploration of the impact of artificial sweeteners on obesity, diabetes, the gut microbiome, and cancer.
John Solokas on June 4, 2021
Link

Two weeks ago in part 1, we explored the history of artificial sweeteners (AS) and debunked the claim that they have been proven to cause weight gain, the most infamous accusation against synthetic sweeteners. This week, we take a look at the next three allegations, that AS:
    • Cause diabetes,
    • Disrupt gut bacteria, and
    • Cause cancer.
If we search PubMed, we’ll find studies that support these claims. We’ll also find studies that contradict them. This makes our job more fun, although significantly more difficult – instead of simply reading titles and abstracts, we have to assess the strength of the evidence to develop an informed opinion. Lucky for you, I’m going to take care of all of it. Additionally, we’ll discuss the acceptable daily intake (ADI) of the most common AS. Sit back, relax, and let’s dive in.
Artificial sweeteners cause diabetes
Now that we know that AS have not been shown to cause fat gain, it’s time to answer another question about its metabolic effects; do AS cause diabetes? Similar to the relationship between AS and obesity, researchers have found an observational link between AS intake and diabetes (1, 2, 3, 4).
Once again, these are observational studies and not well-controlled experimental trials – yet another example of correlation vs. causation and reverse causality leading to a misinterpretation of research. This being the case, the research only conveys that people with metabolic syndrome and diabetes are more likely to consume AS (possibly in an effort to decrease sugar intake) and not that AS cause these diseases. In contrast, high quality studies have found that diet beverage consumption has no effect on metabolic disease risk (5, 6, 7).
To better understand the directionality of the link between AS intake and metabolic disease risk, let’s take a look at the studies on the impact of AS on hormones and blood sugar response. A few studies have found that AS negatively impact satiety hormones and increase blood sugar levels. This study in mice supports that AS consumption may increase energy intake by suppressing GLP-1, a hormone that makes us feel full after a meal and plays an important role in glucose homeostasis (8). And this small study of seventeen obese women found that those who drank an artificially sweetened beverage before consuming a sugary drink had 14% higher blood sugar levels and 20% higher insulin levels, compared with those that drank water before the sugary drink (9). With this study in particular, as these women had not previously consumed artificially sweetened beverages, it is important to note that AS may have different physiological effects depending on one’s age, genes, and history.
If I was trying to demonize AS – as many nutrition “experts” will do – I would end this section here and you would probably be convinced that your weight loss plateau is being caused by the Splenda in your coffee. But, in the interest of painting a comprehensive picture, we must consider the opposing argument. In fact, the majority of human studies have found that AS intake does not increase blood sugar, insulin levels, or other satiety hormones (10-21).
For instance, this randomized controlled trial of 50 people found that an intake of 2 diet sodas/day for twelve weeks had no effect on insulin response, as well as no effect on bodyweight or food intake (23). And in contrast to the previously mentioned rat study on GLP-1, this study of healthy human subjects found that AS had no effect on GLP-1 release (24).
In conclusion: There is no doubt that consumption of artificially sweetened beverages are better for acute glycemic response and short-term metabolic health than fully sugar-sweetened beverages, and there is no human evidence that shows AS consumption increases one’s risk of developing metabolic syndrome or diabetes.
Artificial sweeteners disrupt gut bacteria
The study of the gut microbiota is a relatively new science with far-reaching implications. It appears likely that the types and number of bacteria that reside in the gut affect many facets of health, from body composition to mood to heart and brain health.
While it is becoming increasingly apparent that the condition of our gut plays an integral part in the maintenance of our health and wellbeing, the impact of AS intake on gut bacteria is not as clear-cut. First, we know that the food we consume does have an impact on the number, structure, and activity of the bacteria in our gut (25, 26). It follows, then, that AS intake would have some effect on the gut microbiota. The question at hand is whether that effect is positive, negative, or inconsequential. Holding strong to the common theme with AS, it’s complicated.
In mouse studies, the effect of AS intake on the gut microbiota looks grim. In general, mice that are given AS experience negative changes to their microbiome, resulting in more fat gain and an impaired metabolic response to glucose, compared to their counterparts given water or sugar sweetened beverages. In some studies, it is suspected that the metabolically damaging effects are due to increased hunger and caloric intake, while in others it is speculated that the negative effects are caused directly by altered gut microbiota resulting in decreased glucose tolerance and insulin sensitivity (27-32).
Fascinatingly enough, some studies even found that AS resulted in adverse metabolic effects despite positive changes in body composition. For instance, a 2014 study found that mice fed artificial sweeteners had increased fasting glucose levels and more insulin resistance than the mice fed sugar, despite having a lower bodyweight and improved body composition (33). For people that consider their physique a reliable indicator of health, this finding is especially concerning – this particular study indicates that artificial sweeteners may have an insignificant effect on our physical appearance but, nevertheless, may cause metabolic damage. As we know from “metabolically obese, normal weight people“, it is certainly possible to look “good” on the outside but be in poor physical health (34).
However, (shocking!) not all of the research is consistent. Another study found that AS intake actually improved glucose tolerance in insulin-resistant mice and yet another study found that Stevia intake had no impact on bodyweight or glucose tolerance (35, 36).
Once again, let’s break down the two sides of the evidence. As we now know, there is a mountain of evidence showing that high intakes of AS in mice wreaks havoc on gut bacteria and results in serious adverse metabolic consequences. On the other hand, humans are not mice and most people do not consume even close to the amount of AS used in these studies. For instance, another rodent study found harmful effects on the gut microbiome, except it was with doses of AS equivalent to humans eating 165 packets of Splenda or 36 cans of diet coke per day, for 6 months! (37).
If you know anyone that consumes 6,500 cans of diet soda over the course of 6 months, he/she may have cause for concern. Otherwise, I am skeptical that AS intake in moderation, i.e. not 36 cans of diet soda a day, as a component of an otherwise well-balanced, primarily whole foods diet, will have significant harmful effects on the gut microbiota (38).
In conclusion: The gut microbiota is a complex realm of human physiology. For this reason, it is the effect of AS on gut bacteria that gives me greatest pause with my personal AS consumption. Most of the information regarding the effect of AS consumption on the gut microbiota is speculation derived from observational research and studies performed on rodents or petri dishes. There is a significant need for more well-designed studies in humans to assess this topic and, until that time, it is advised to proceed with caution. Consume AS in moderation or not at all if you have concerns about the health of your gut microbiota (39).
Artificial sweeteners cause cancer
Do AS really cause cancer? Despite all of the evidence that supports the contrary, the scary myth that diet soda is a carcinogen can still be heard today at water coolers around the world. After a study was published in 70s that showed saccharin caused increased rates of bladder cancer in rats, it was claimed that AS caused cancer (40). As a result, in the 80s the FDA required that artificial sweeteners come with a warning label and saccharin was even banned in the U.S. until 2000. In Canada, it was banned until just a few years ago! (41, 42)
Not so fast, Canada. The bad news – a lot of innocent rats were killed in that study. The good news – the dosage of AS given to the rats was outrageously high, rats are not humans (in case there’s still confusion), and the carcinogenic effects, as it turns out, do not translate to humans (43). A subsequent study found no association between saccharin intake and bladder cancer in humans (44). Future studies on sucralose and stevia have concluded that they are also not carcinogenic to humans (45, 46).
In conclusion: You can rest assured that artificial sweetener intake has NOT been shown to cause cancer. If I haven’t yet convinced you, here are some more resources that explain the history of the relationship between artificial sweeteners and cancer.
    • Information Sheet: Intense sweeteners and cancer risk (Cancer Council Australia) (47).
    • Does Aspartame Cause Cancer (American Cancer Society) (48).
    • Artificial Sweeteners and Cancer (National Institutes of Health/National Cancer Institute) (49).
Artificial sweetener acceptable daily intake
Acceptable daily intake (ADI) is the maximum amount of a compound that can be consumed daily over a lifetime that is deemed to not cause appreciable adverse health effects (50). The ADI for the most common artificial sweeteners is very high. This is important to note because many of the studies I cited, especially those that showed harmful health effects, used doses of artificial sweeteners that were near or at the ADI.
Sweetener ADI
    • Aspartame 50 mg/kg/d (21 cans of diet soda)
    • Sucralose. 5 mg/kg/d (31 Splenda packets)
    • ACE-K 15 mg/kg/d (30 cans of diet soda)
    • Saccharin 5 mg/kg/d (10 Sweet n Low packets)
    • Stevia 40 mg/kg/d (40 Stevia packets)
From Additional Information about High-Intensity Sweeteners Permitted for Use in Food in the United States (United States Food and Drug Administration webpage) (51).
Although I’m sure they exist in some dark corner of the universe, nobody I have ever met consumes 20+ cans of diet soda per day. It is not a stretch to believe that while occasional AS intake may be more or less harmless, 20 cans of diet soda daily may have some negative health effects.
Conclusion: I’ve made my decision, you have to make yours
Human nutrition is complex. Every food decision is influenced by, just to name a few, biological, psychological, physical, societal, and economic cues. The specific choice to consume artificial sweeteners is made even more complicated by mixed research, conflicting expert opinions, headline-grabbing fear mongering, and logical fallacies. It’s not a black and white concept, and there is no correct answer that applies to everyone. That being said, it becomes our responsibility to consider the strength of the available evidence and our individual circumstance to make the best possible decision for our health and wellbeing. After performing a thorough cost benefit analysis, I have made my decision.
For me, the pros of artificial sweeteners:
    • increased adherence to my macronutrient/calorie goals
    • increased enjoyment of my food
    • increased diet satisfaction while limiting my intake of hyper palatable “junk foods” such as donuts, cookies, and ice cream,
outweigh the potential cons:
    • increased appetite
    • decreased sensitivity to sweetness
    • negative effects of very high doses on the gut microbiome resulting in decreased glucose tolerance
Sure, a diet without AS may technically be “healthier”, but if their intake facilitates better overall health through lower caloric intake and decreased stress and feelings of restriction, it may very well be more optimal to include them your diet. Although at this point it does not appear that artificial sweeteners are a 100% risk-free biological free lunch, they are a useful tool that, when used in a reasonable way, can help us achieve our health and body composition goals.

Sources
     1.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23364017/
     2.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24932880/
     3.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19151203/
     4.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19151203/
     5.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18212291/
     6.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24190652/
     7.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22205311/
     8.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22561130/
     9.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23633524/
     10.  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3402256/
     11.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16280432/
     12.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19221011/
     13.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20420761/
     14.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21245879/
     15.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2923074/
     16.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3046854/
     17.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7652029/
     18.  https://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/36/12/e202
     19.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7652029/
     20.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9062523/
     21.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19808921/
     22.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22777177/
     23.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29982723/
     24.  https://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/36/12/e202
     25.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26376027/
     26.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24336217/
     27.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20060008/
     28.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27090230/
     29.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25231862/
     30.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28594855/
     31.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25231862/
     32.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18800291/
     33.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25313461/
     34.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27552473/
     35.  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1564347/
     36.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32356872/
     37.  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5522834/
     38.  http://www.sugar-and-sweetener-guide.com/acceptable-daily-intake.html
     39.  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6363527/
     40.  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1637197/
     41.  https://publications.iarc.fr/40
     42.  https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/food-nutrition/food-safety/food-additives/sugar-substitutes/saccharin-artificial-sweeteners.html
     43.  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK402050/
     44.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6103207/
     45.  https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23845273/
     46.  http://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/efsajournal/pub/1537
     47.  https://wiki.cancer.org.au/policy/Intense_sweeteners_and_cancer
     48.  https://www.cancer.org/cancer/cancer-causes/aspartame.html
     49.  https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/diet/artificial-sweeteners-fact-sheet
     50.  https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/pharmacology-toxicology-and-pharmaceutical-science/acceptable-daily-intake
https://www.fda.gov/food/food-additives-petitions/additional-information-about-high-intensity-sweeteners-permitted-use-food-united-states

Update on Low Calorie Sweeteners
An updated review of the science finds that artificial sweeteners are still a safe and effective option for weight management.
Steven Novella on November 7, 2018
Link

One of the primary goals of SBM is to provide information to consumers regarding health decisions they make for themselves and their families. We make such decisions every day, and unfortunately the public sphere is flooded with misinformation about common health choices. Most non-experts I discuss these issues with, whether personally or professionally, are either uninformed or misinformed about common health topics. Frequently those who think of themselves as being highly informed are burdened with the most misinformation.
This is extremely unfortunate, because I find that people who are making the greatest effort to have healthy lifestyles are actively looking for information to help them do so, and are finding mostly slick narratives full of falsehoods. This often leads them to make changes to their habits that are useless or even counterproductive, while missing the real changes that have been shown to have a positive impact.
One of the most common questions I get about personal habits is the consumption of low calorie sweeteners (LCS, also called low energy sweeteners or LES in the literature), such as sucralose and aspartame. Just search on either of these terms and you will find a flood of fearmongering, conspiracy theories, and alternative nonsense. You will also find serious discussions of the research that are complex and confusing – hardly a remedy to the simple scary narratives sold by self-appointed gurus.
I reviewed the evidence in 2015, concluding:
In this case, despite confusing results from many types of studies, the best evidence consistently indicates that consuming LES results in reduced energy intake and reduced weight compared to either consuming sugar-sweetened beverages or even water. There does appear to be room for further rigorous studies, but this is the best conclusion we can currently make based upon all the evidence, and it is fairly consistent and robust.
It’s been a few years, and the conversation really hasn’t changed much, but I wanted to see if there was any new relevant evidence. To quickly review, the main reason for confusion is that observational studies consistent show that consuming LCS is correlated with an increased body mass index, BMI. However, this data is correlational only, and it is more likely that being overweight motivates people to consume LCS, rather than the other way around. Animal studies also suggest a correlation between weight gain and LCS consumption, but in these studies the results are mixed, and the data is very difficult to extrapolate to humans. Rats and mice simply appear to have different metabolisms than humans, and in most of these studies the diets fed to the experimental animals were unrealistic, adding further confounders.
As with many questions in medicine, animal, basic science, and observational studies are useful – but they are trumped by well-designed controlled clinical experiments. In such experiments variables can be controlled for, and we can make cause-and-effect conclusions. These studies consistently show that substituting LCS for sugar helps in weight loss. It may even help to substitute LCS for water. There also does not appear to be any negative effect from consuming LCS.
What new evidence is there on the question of LCS and weight control? A 2018 review, the most recent published I could find, concluded:
Low-calorie sweeteners provide a means to reduce energy density while largely preserving food or beverage reward value. Consistent with this, consumption of low-calorie sweeteners compared with consumption of sugars has been found to reduce energy intake and body weight.
This review focuses on an interesting point – the strategy of reducing the ratio of calorie intake to the physical and mental reward of eating. Energy intake and expenditure are not perfectly matched (which is why we have the problem of obesity in the first place). We evolved a host of reward sensations that influence how much we eat, by estimating the calorie density of food. LCS essentially trick the body into thinking the food we are eating is more energy dense than it is, and that can help reduce caloric intake. This works best as part of an overall strategy of eating foods that are rewarding compared to their energy density.
A 2016 review focusing on energy balance found:
Randomized controlled trials are consistent in showing a benefit of LCS which suggests that simple behavioral engagement by individuals attempting to control their weight is a sufficiently strong signal to overcome any potential mechanism that might act to promote energy intake and weight gain. Based on existing evidence, LCS can be a useful tool for people actively engaged in managing their body weight for weight loss and maintenance.
All the reviews I found came to the same conclusion – that controlled experiments in humans shows a weight loss benefit. However, some reviews decried the lack of studies looking at other metabolic outcomes. Personally I don’t think this is concerning, because weight control seems to be the dominant factor for most people in determining related metabolic factors, like glycemic control. Looking at them separately would be useful, but I consider it unlikely that we will be surprised. Still, it is always better to be sure.
To that end, there are recent studies (perhaps too recent for the reviews to have taken into consideration) that do look at metabolic outcomes. A 2018 study looked at the glycemic impact of consuming LCS (which they call non-nutritive sweeteners, or NNS):
In comparison with the baseline, NNS consumption was not found to increase blood glucose level, and its concentration gradually declined over the course of observation following NNS consumption.
So LCS did not have an adverse effect on insulin effectiveness (which some of the animals research suggested) and in fact had a positive impact on blood sugar over time. This is yet another example of why you cannot directly extrapolate from basic science to net clinical outcomes in humans – you have to study them directly.
There are still some sub-questions, such as the impact of LCS on young children. Perhaps it affects their reward system or metabolism adversely and has later negative consequences. A 2016 and 2018 review both concluded that there is no evidence for an adverse effect, but more research is needed to be sure.
The safety of the various LCS, long established, has also been recently reaffirmed by reviews of the published research.
However, for those dedicated to fearmongering about artificial sweeteners, there is always something new to worry about. It is, of course, legitimate to ask new questions as our medical knowledge advances, and we may find previously missed risks. But it is reassuring that we have years and even decades of clinical research looking at overall health outcomes, so if there were any real health risk, even from a completely unknown mechanism, we should have seen it.
Despite reassuring safety data, you can stoke fears anew by simply doing another basic science study and showing some new potential effect to worry about – in this case the new concern is over the gut microbiota. Studies in mice show changes to the bacterial flora of the gut, which can be used to speculate wildly about the possible health impacts. The gut microbiota is the new oxidative stress; it can be blamed on anything about which you want to stoke fears. We won’t know for decades what all of this preliminary evidence about our microbial friends really means, but it will serve as a fresh source of pseudoscience, fearmongering, and speculation for that time and beyond. At this point there is no clear evidence that LCS have an adverse effect on our gut microbiota leading to any adverse health outcome. Anyone quoting the basic science to suggest that there might be should be referred to the utter lack of correlation between the basic science and clinical outcomes on all the other false fears about LCS.
So in 2018 we are basically in the same place we were in 2015 – artificial sweeteners are safe, they do not cause obesity or any known metabolic or other health problems, and they can be very useful as part of a weight control strategy. People should not avoid them because of unwarranted fears.
Further, we should reject the offer of “all natural cane sugar” and other sugar gimmicks. Unlike the speculative an unknown risks of LCS, there are well-documented and clear health risks from consuming too much simple and refined sugars. I know many people who choose to consume cane sugar rather than sucralose or aspartame because they believe it is better for them. They are wrong, the victims of deliberate misinformation campaigns, fearmongering, and misguided narratives. But they are also poorly served by popular communication regarding a complex scientific literature. They are exchanging a small speculative risk for a large known risk, and patting themselves on the back for it.
.

New Review of Artificial Sweeteners
A new review of research finds a modest but inconsistent benefit from consuming artificial sweeteners over sugar. Their conclusion of a possible backfire effect, however, does not seem to be supported by the studies they review.
Steven Novella on July 19, 2017
Link

A new systematic review of artificial sweeteners published in the Canadian Medical Association Journal concludes:
Evidence from RCTs does not clearly support the intended benefits of nonnutritive sweeteners for weight management, and observational data suggest that routine intake of nonnutritive sweeteners may be associated with increased BMI and cardiometabolic risk.
Unsurprisingly, this is how the results are being widely reported in the media – that artificial sweeteners “may” increase body weight. I had to take a close look at this review, since a 2015 review of the same question came to a different conclusion. I discussed the 2015 review at the time. Had there been new research that essentially flipped the conclusion?
A brief overview of artificial sweetener research
I gave a summary of the research in my 2015 discussion, which you can read if you are interested in the details. Briefly, there are several types of research looking at the effects of consuming low energy sweeteners (LES), also called non-nutritive sweeteners (NNS). The first is animal research. These studies show some interesting possibilities, that consuming LES may lead to greater calorie consumption overall in some settings. However, these studies tend to be contrived in terms of what the rats eat and the applicability to humans is uncertain.
Human trials are largely divided into cohort studies, in which people are followed over long periods of time, and randomized trials, in which subjects are randomized to consuming water, LES, or sugary drinks. The cohort studies tend to show a small correlation between consuming LES and greater BMI or other measures of obesity. However, these studies show correlation only and are not able to determine causation. It is highly probable that people consume diet drinks because they are overweight, and not the other way around.
The best data is probably randomized controlled trials. These studies vary from short term (as little as one meal) to long term (six months) and have the advantage of randomizing subjects, and therefore we are better able to draw conclusions about causation. In the 2015 review they found a consistent but small benefit to consuming LES over drinks containing sugar, and even over consuming water. While this data is far from definitive, it does suggest a role for consuming LES beverages in weight management.
It is also probably true that effects depend on individual variables, as is true of weight management in general. There are many variables, including psychological ones, that are difficult to pin down. For example, there is a possible unintended consequence that when people do one thing for their health that takes will power, they then feel empowered to indulge in something they know is not good for them. So if they put Splenda in their coffee, they can have that piece of cake.
Further, most attempts at weight loss fail. It is therefore not surprising that attempts at weight loss with LES also have modest benefits. If the research shows any benefit of substituting LES for sugar, it is likely useful.
The new Canadian review
The new review from the CMAJ looked at two different kinds of studies, cohort studies and randomized controlled trials (they did not review animal studies like the 2015 review). In line with the 2015 review, they found that the nonrandomized cohort studies showed a modest correlation with consuming LES and being overweight. They also included several secondary health outcomes, like blood pressure, heart disease, and diabetes. These do not add much to the analysis, in my opinion, because they are all consequences of being overweight, and are therefore just measuring the same thing. There is no reason to conclude or even suspect that LES directly causes any of these secondary outcomes.
So this much of their conclusions is nothing new, and contains the same limitations. We can show correlation only, not causation, and there is a good reason to suspect that the causation is from being overweight to consuming LES. Yet reporting (starting with the study itself) focuses on the less plausible hypothesis that consuming LES causes weight gain.
Further, I think that the results of the randomized trials essentially completely trump the results of the cohort studies, because they are randomized. Here is where the conclusions differ from the 2015 review. The 2015 review concluded:
Overall, the balance of evidence indicates that use of LES in place of sugar, in children and adults, leads to reduced EI (energy intake) and BW (body weight), and possibly also when compared with water.
The 2017 Canadian review concluded:
Evidence from RCTs does not clearly support the intended benefits of nonnutritive sweeteners for weight management…
The first thing I thought was – were there new studies since the 2015 review that warrants a different conclusion? The CMAJ review reports that there were new studies since the previous review and lists them. I looked through the new studies and found only one that is a relevant randomized controlled trial, this one published in 2016 that concluded:
NNS beverages were superior for weight loss and weight maintenance in a population consisting of regular users of NNS beverages who either maintained or discontinued consumption of these beverages and consumed water during a structured weight loss program. These results suggest that NNS beverages can be an effective tool for weight loss and maintenance within the context of a weight management program.
There was also a late 2015 study comparing LES to water, and found:
Replacement of DBs with water after the main meal may lead to greater weight reduction during a weight-loss program.
The other new studies were either cohort studies or looked at secondary outcomes. Neither of these two studies seem to warrant a reversal of the conclusion that consuming LES has a moderate benefit for weight loss. The first study actually supports a benefit for LES, and the second study is about replacing LES with water, and is not a comparison with sugary drinks.
Where does that leave us?
In the end the conclusions of this review are not dramatically different than the 2015 review – there is only a difference in emphasis which I think reflects the biases of the authors of each review. This is unavoidable because the data is complex, there is no perfect type of data, and the results are mixed and modest. There is therefore a lot of room for interpretation.
The Canadian reviewers acknowledge that the long term randomized trials did show a benefit for consuming LES, but they pointed out that these studies tended to have industry sponsorship. That is a legitimate point, as prior research shows a correlation between industry sponsorship and favorable outcomes, but in itself does not nullify the research findings.
I think the bottom line is that weight loss is difficult and complex. The effects of all interventions are modest and inconsistent. There are many variables, and no study will ever be able to control for all of them. The net effect of consuming LES vs sugary drinks or water is likely dependent on the individual and the situation.
But I do think we can draw a couple of conclusions from all the available research. The first question is this – is there a health or weight disadvantage to consuming sugar? I think the answer here is a clear yes. Sugary drinks contain many calories that add to total calorie consumption and are counterproductive if your goal is calorie control for weight management. Replacing high calorie sugary drinks with low calorie drinks is therefore advantageous.
The second question is this – is there an unintended backfire effect to consuming LES, because it tricks the brain into being more hungry or some other hormonal or metabolic effect? Here I think the answer is probably no, and the new Canadian review does not change this conclusion. Randomized controlled trials in humans supersede cohort studies and animal studies in addressing this question. Those studies find, if anything, a modest benefit to consuming LES. It is obviously possible to disagree about whether or not this benefit is real, given that there are inconsistencies in the data. The randomized trials clearly do not show any disadvantage – no backfire effect.
What I think this means is that, if you are trying to lose weight replacing sugary drinks with low calorie drinks can be a helpful part of your overall strategy. It will not be a panacea, or make weight loss easy. The research shows the most effective strategies involve making permanent changes to your lifestyle regarding food consumption and exercise. Avoiding sugary drinks can be part of those lifestyle changes, and you should not fear drinking LES because of an alleged backfire effect. The research, including this recent review, does not show such an effect in humans.

Low Energy Sweeteners and Weight Control
Steven Novella on November 11, 2015
Link

A new systematic review published in the International Journal of Obesity looks at the totality of evidence investigating whether consuming low energy sweeteners (LES), such as aspartame, sucralose, or stevia, is a net benefit or detriment for weight control. In addition to providing some clarity on the answer, the review also provides some insight into how different kinds of evidence address such questions.
LES vs sugar or water
The question may at first seem obvious – if you consume a beverage sweetened with an LES instead of sugar you will be avoiding up to several hundred calories. Those calories add up quickly. Twelve ounces of cola with sugar has 138 calories, for example. These are foods that people generally consume on a daily basis, and so avoiding these unnecessary calories should reduce total energy intake and help reduce or maintain weight.
The human body, however, is a complex system, as is human psychology, and so we have to consider the law of unintended consequences. It is possible, for example, that when people drink a diet beverage they feel they have earned the right to consume more calories elsewhere. This phenomenon is called compensation, and there is evidence for this effect.
It is also possible that consuming a food or beverage that tastes sweet but contains no or few calories will trick or confuse the brain, separating the sensation of sweetness with the ingestion of calories. This may lead to a craving for more calories. There are also studies showing the existence of sweet receptors in the GI tract, and activating these receptors may stimulate appetite.
Types of evidence
There are basically three types of research that address the question of whether or not consuming LES results in a net increase or decrease in total caloric intake. The first is animal studies, mostly in rats. Rats can be fed water sweetened with sugar or an LES and then given access to as much food as they want to eat (ad libitum).
The advantage of rat studies is that the experimenters have total control over the animals. They can record everything they consume, control everything they do, and record the results. The disadvantage of rat studies is that rats are not people.
There are two types of studies of LES in humans, cohort studies and controlled experiments. In cohort studies groups of people who consume or don’t consume LES are followed with their caloric intake and weight tracked. The advantage of such studies is that they are plausible to do for a long period with many subjects, and they are a real-world observation. The big disadvantage, however, is that it is difficult to make any conclusions about cause and effect. Specifically, if people who are overweight consume more LES, do they consume LES because they are trying to lose weight, or are they overweight because they consume LES?
The best type of data are controlled experiments in which people are randomized and blinded to either LES, sugar, or unsweetened water. The advantage to this type of data is that you can make confident conclusions about cause and effect. The disadvantage is that they are more difficult to conduct, and therefore may be small or short term.
The systematic review
The authors of the current review looked at all three types of studies. It was their intent to do the first systematic review looking at the totality of evidence addressing this question. Here is what they found:
Rat studies generally show no advantage to LES in terms of calorie intake, and some even show a disadvantage:
In 62 of 90 animal studies exposure to LES did not affect or decreased BW. Of 28 reporting increased BW, 19 compared LES with glucose exposure using a specific ‘learning’ paradigm.
For the animal studies the bottom line is that most showed no effect on body weight or energy intake. Some of the studies did show a decrease in weight and caloric intake, but these studies tended to use doses of LES 10-100 times what a human would typically consume.
The “learning” paradigm is an interesting subset of studies, some of which do show increased weight in rats fed LES vs sugar with a moderately sweetened feed. The authors conclude that there does appear to be an effect here, but the problem is its applicability to humans. The experimental setup is contrived, exposing rats to a food source they are not used to. One hypothesis is that the LES sweetened water may make the food more palatable to the rats, so they consume more.
Incidentally, most often when I see a headline declaring the LES cause weight gain, it is this type of animal study. Let’s get to the human studies to see if these rat studies are likely to be applicable.
Twelve prospective cohort studies in humans reported inconsistent associations between LES use and body mass index.
In total there were six comparisons in adults and five in children. The random effects model showed no change in BMI with LES consumption. However, there was a high level of heterogeneity among the studies.
The bottom line with these types of studies, it seems, is that they are a wash. Results are all over the place, consistent with either random noise or various confounding factors that differ from study to study.
Human experiments were divided into short and long term studies. The short term studies looked at LES consumption on the caloric intake of a single meal. There is some variability in these studies depending on specific methods used, but the authors give this bottom line:
In sum the results of these short-term studies comprise a large body of evidence showing that consumption of LES in place of sugar reduces overall EI [energy intake] acutely, with no indication that LES increase appetite.
So short term there is an advantage to consuming LES vs sugar, but this leaves open concern for long term compensation effects. The authors point out that these short term studies do show compensation, meaning that consuming LES was associated with consuming more calories in the following meal, but those calories were less than the calories avoided by not consuming sugar.
The long term studies were mostly in overweight or obese subjects, followed subjects from between 10 days and three years, were mostly in adults, and some were in the context of a weight loss diet. The authors found:
In all cases, the use of LES led to a relative reduction in EI, and greater loss (or reduced gain) of BW. Notably, there was no example of a sustained exposure intervention trial where LES use led to a relative increase in mean EI or BW. This was supported quantitatively by the results of the meta-analyses of BW change, indicating lower relative BWs in LES intervention arms. Furthermore, outcomes were similar in studies with children and adults, and followed a similar pattern whether participants were blinded or not blinded to the intervention. Consumption of LES-sweetened beverages also reduced BW relative to consumption of water.
The results are fairly consistent, differing only in the magnitude of the effect – consuming LES vs sugar or water was associated with a reduction in energy intake and body weight. I was a bit surprised about the advantage vs water, as water is also zero calorie. This implies that drinking a sweet beverage vs an unsweetened beverage allows for lower overall calorie consumption.
Conclusion: Low energy sweeteners probably help with weight control
The results of this systematic review and meta-analysis are quite compelling. In my opinion, human experimental studies trump observational studies, studies in animals, or basic science studies looking at possible mechanisms.
In this case, despite confusing results from many types of studies, the best evidence consistently indicates that consuming LES results in reduced energy intake and reduced weight compared to either consuming sugar-sweetened beverages or even water. There does appear to be room for further rigorous studies, but this is the best conclusion we can currently make based upon all the evidence, and it is fairly consistent and robust.
The story of research into the question of low energy sweeteners is also a massive cautionary tale for the average consumer. The media, self-help books, and nutrition and alternative gurus have been handing out conflicting recommendations to the public, largely based on extrapolation from possible mechanisms, animal studies, and observational studies.
In retrospect, and not only with the question of LES but with many health questions, these types of studies should be considered with a heavy dose of skepticism. There is a reason why skeptics and proponents of SBM don’t find such studies definitive, because history has shown they are often misleading.
What is compelling is controlled blinded experiments looking at the relevant net health effects of an intervention. Until we see consistent results from rigorous studies of this type, it is best to reserve judgement. I don’t find extrapolations from basic science or animal studies to be compelling – history has shown they are simply not reliable. However, such studies do serve a useful purpose in designing clinical trials and informing our choices about which interventions are worth studying.
Unfortunately, wild extrapolation from basic science is common in nutrition self-help books. Diets are justified based upon studies showing the effects of insulin, or the presence of receptors. The human body, however, is simply too complex to be able to draw a straight line from these starting points to a net clinical effect. There are simply too many compensatory mechanisms and feedback loops in biology.
We always need clinical studies looking at net health outcomes, and they need to be rigorous and repeatable.
In the case of LES and weight control, the clinical studies are giving us a consistent answer. Initial common sense actually holds up in this case – not consuming extra calories in the form of sugar-sweetened beverages or food is a good way to reduce calorie intake and manage weight.

   Aspartame – Truth vs Fiction
Steven Novella
Link
If you believe everything you read on the internet, then is seems that a chemical found in thousands of products is causing an epidemic of severe neurological and systemic diseases, like multiple sclerosis and lupus. The FDA, the companies that make the product, and the “medical industrial complex” all know about the dangers of this chemical but are hiding the truth from the public in order to protect corporate profits and avoid the pesky paper work that would accompany the truth being revealed. The only glimmer of hope is a dedicated band of bloggers and anonymous e-mail chain letter authors who aren’t afraid to speak the truth. Armed with the latest anecdotal evidence, unverified speculation, and scientifically implausible claims, they have been tirelessly ranting about the evils of this chemical for years. Undeterred by the countless published studies manufactured by the food cartel that show this chemical is safe, they continue to protect the public by spreading baseless fear and hysteria.
Hopefully, you don’t believe everything you read on the internet, and you don’t get your science news from e-mail SPAM, where the above scenario is a common theme. While there are many manifestations of this type of urban legend, I am speaking specifically about aspartame – an artificial sweetener used since the early 1980s. The notion that aspartame is unsafe has been circulating almost since it first appeared, and like rumors and misinformation have a tendency to do, fears surrounding aspartame have taken on a life of their own.
I am frequently asked my opinion about the safety of aspartame. Nutritionists often council to avoid the sweetener, citing unverified claims that it is unsafe. I was recently sent a chain letter warning that aspartame causes MS (which of course can be cured by simply avoiding aspartame), and Snopes informs me that this particular letter first appeared in 1998.
There are also hundreds of websites dedicated to smearing this much abused food additive. One site, run by Dr. Janet Starr Hull (she has a doctorate in Nutrition), responds to the latest report of aspartame’s safety by writing:
I will never accept the news of aspartame safety. I think it is a “business” decision to discredit/discount the research results that aspartame DOES cause cancer, major nerve disorders, birth defects, and brain imbalances. Think about it – can you imagine the chaos that will occur when the truth of aspartame dangers is accredited. The FDA has known about the dangers, the corporations have known about the dangers, and the medical community (if it is really worth anything) has known about the dangers.
The statement that “nothing will ever convince me” is a huge red flag that someone is defending an ideological position, one immune to evidence or reason. Admittedly, in context it could be a clumsy statement that something is very unlikely. It would be very difficult to convince me that the earth is flat – I’m really saying that the existence evidence is overwhelming that the earth is not flat. But that is not what Dr. Hull is saying. She is specifically saying that she will dismiss any evidence that is contrary to her belief that aspartame is not safe on the a-priori basis that such disconfirming evidence is part of a vast conspiracy.
Of course, Dr. Hull also sells an aspartame detox kit, which might lead a cynical person to conclude that she cares more about selling alternative health products and stoking her sales with some unreasonable fear than about scientific evidence.
What evidence does she have for such a conspiracy? The argument from final consequences logical fallacy – big industry wouldn’t want it. It’s also not very plausible. Products get pulled from the market all the time when new evidence suggests they are not safe. Also, the final safety net for the consumer is legal liability. Class action law suits have bankrupted companies, even when the underlying claims were false. Imagine if they were true. Look how much the tobacco industry has had to fork over.
Now I am not arguing that corporations are all good corporate citizens or wouldn’t dream of sweeping some inconvenient evidence under the carpet. But I am saying that a decades long conspiracy among industry, federal regulatory agencies, the medical community, and multiple research institutions and individual researchers – all under the nose of the press and lawyers looking for big class-action suits – is implausible in the extreme. I am also arguing that we should fairly assess all the evidence, not just cherry pick the evidence we like and dismiss the rest out of hand.
What does the evidence say about aspartame? A recent published review of all available evidence, including hundreds of studies, concluded:
The studies provide no evidence to support an association between aspartame and cancer in any tissue. The weight of existing evidence is that aspartame is safe at current levels of consumption as a nonnutritive sweetener.
Multiple reviews, going back to 1985, conclude the same thing. Since this latest review there have been more studies, in various countries (how big is this conspiracy?), showing no link between aspartame and brain cancer, and a lack of correlation between artificial sweeteners and gastric, pancreatic, and endometrial cancers.
Like all such research, there is noise in the data (but no apparent signal). There is no pattern of evidence to suggest that aspartame causes cancer, autoimmune disease, neurological disease, diabetes, or anything else its critics claim. What legitimate scientific controversy there is comes from the animal data, mostly in rats. Here the evidence for a carcinogenic or genotoxic (causing changes in the DNA) effect of aspartame is mixed and requires careful review. Some effects, such as a dose-dependent effect on renal tumors, are specific to rats and do not translate to humans. Other studies are plagued by significant flaws, such as properly calculating doses (a big issue when trying to extrapolate doses from rats to humans). And still others show flat effects without a dose response curve, suggesting that a confounding factor, and not aspartame, is responsible for any observed increase in tumors.
For example, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) recently reviewed a 2005 study by the European Ramazzini Foundation of aspartame in rats showing increases in various neoplasms. They found multiple significant flaws, as described above, and concluded:
The data on total malignant tumours do not provide evidence of a carcinogenic potential of aspartame.
As I have noted before – you have to interpret a literature, not a single study. The results of one lab or one study can be erroneous. When decades have produced hundreds of studies on a question, the cherry pickers will always have a lot to choose from. That is why systematic reviews are necessary, and it is also necessary to understand the strengths and weaknesses of each type of research. In this case studies in humans have found no cancer risk from aspartame. Animals studies are problematic and have produced mixed results, but no clear evidence of a neoplastic risk.
A separate question is whether or not aspartame causes headaches in some people. While there is not a lot of specific data on this, there are case reports of aspartame triggering migraines in susceptible people. Migraineurs frequently have multiple food triggers, and there is a long list of foods known to be potential migraine triggers. This is not evidence for toxicity. So while evidence is lacking to demonstrate aspartame is a headache trigger, this is not implausible and not particularly worrisome. What I recommend to patients with frequent headaches is to keep a headache diary, rather than trusting to memory (and confirmation bias) to detect real associations. If there is a clear pattern between a potential trigger and headaches, then avoid that trigger.
Yet another distinct question about artificial sweeteners (not just aspartame) is whether or not they contribute to obesity by interfering with brain’s association between sweetness and calories. The theory is that using zero-calorie sweeteners dissociates the sensation of sweetness from caloric intake, so that sweetness will cause less satiety, leading to increases in overall sugar and calorie consumption.
The question of aspartame and weight control is a complex one, and can be approached from many research angles. Here is a recent review of research. At present the question is very much unsettled. It seems that there is no significant metabolic and no demonstrated neuronal effect from artificial sweeteners. However, people who knowingly consume diet drinks do tend to overcompensate by consuming greater calories overall. While studies of substituting aspartame for sugar in a blinded fashion show that calories are reduced, contributing to weight loss.
By my reading, the current summary of available research is that consuming calories in drinks contributes to weight gain and obesity, substituting calorie-free drinks (whether water or diet drinks containing artificial sweeteners) does help reduce caloric intake and aid in weight control, but there is a tendency to overcompensate by increasing other caloric intake. Therefore it seems reasonable to use artificial sweeteners to reduce caloric intake from drinks, but to be careful to control overall caloric intake (so no, putting aspartame in your coffee does not mean you can eat the cheesecake).
Conclusion
Aspartame is a highly studied food additive with decades of research showing that it is safe for human consumption. As expected, the research is complex making it possible to cherry pick and misinterpret individual studies in order to fear monger. But the totality of research, reviewed by many independent agencies and expert panels, supports the safety of aspartame.
A conspiracy to hide the risks of aspartame, however, remains a popular internet urban legend that will likely not disappear anytime soon.

Aspartame and Cancer
Despite the leaked new classification as a “possible” carcinogen, the evidence still shows aspartame is safe.
Steven Novella on July 5, 2023
Link

It was recently leaked that the World Health Organization (WHO) is about to change their classification of the artificial sweetener, aspartame, to category 2b – possibly carcinogenic to humans. This has caused some confusion, and has fed existing conspiracy theories about the sweetener. For some reason, even before the web, there was a viral campaign to spread fear and misinformation about aspartame. This took on a life of its own, and could not be quelled by something as pedestrian as evidence.
There must be something about the narrative that resonates – aspartame seems too good to be true. It is 200 times sweeter than sugar, and so can give the foods we love a sweet taste without the calories. Something in our “Simpsons” programmed sensibilities and baseline cynical nature says – it must be unhealthy. Also, the appeal-to-nature crowd that demonizes anything they arbitrarily deem not natural found a convenient target to sow fear and mistrust in mainstream institutions.
Meanwhile, there have literally been thousands of studies, and over 60 scientific and regulatory bodies around the world have reviewed the evidence and found aspartame to be safe for human consumption. There are also many reviews of the evidence in the published literature, generally finding no clear evidence of any link between aspartame consumption and any disease. It always needs to be noted that the one exception is people with phenylketonuria, who should not consume aspartame.
But researching risk is complex and the evidence is often misunderstood and misrepresented. One type of such research is pre-clinical, basic toxicology research. This focuses on whether the chemical in question does stuff to cells or biochemistry. How is it metabolized, what are the breakdown products, does it increase or decrease inflammation or oxidative stress, is it a potential mutagen, and many other assays. This kind of research just tells us if a substance is a potential hazard, but not whether it will confer a health risk.
The difference between hazard and risk is important to understand in terms of this research. A good analogy I often go to is – a shark in a tank is a hazard, meaning that it can potentially cause harm in the right circumstance. But as long as you don’t swim in the tank with the shark, the risk is zero. Something happening chemically may be a hazard, but we need to know how the substance is metabolized, will it get to the target tissue and in what dose, and what compensatory mechanisms are there? A potential hazard can be of zero risk depending on exposure.
Then we get to animal research, which more directly assesses risk. But in animal research the goal is often to “Mythbuster” the question – stress the system until it breaks, meaning increasing the exposure to a potential hazard to see where it starts to become a risk. Sometimes this is explicitly done in what is called the LD50 test – what is the dose that kills half of test animals? Toxicity is all about dose, and so this research is used to know where the threshold dose of toxicity is. Typically, regulations then build in 1-2 orders of magnitude of a safety buffer.
Finally there is clinical and ecological research – is there any actual increase in a negative outcome (such as disease incidence) from controlled or real-world use? This is the definitive evidence about risk. It doesn’t matter if a substance changes a chemical in a petri dish, or kills rats when given in massive doses. What matters is if there is any net health risk when used by humans in the usual dose.
With aspartame, as with anything that gets studied enough, there is a lot of noise in terms of things that happen at a petri dish level, or in animal research, but there is no apparent risk of any disease when consumed by humans in normal amounts. Actual risk may come into play with levels of consumption that are inhuman – on the order of 60 liters of aspartame-sweetened drinks per day every day.
With this as context, how do we make sense of the new WHO classification? We need a bit of further context. The WHO classification system is based on hazard, not risk. They are not determining that something actually causes cancer, only whether or not it is a carcinogen. Further, the classification system is based upon the strength of the evidence, not the magnitude of the effect. Classification 1 is for substances known to be carcinogenic to humans. This means the evidence is clear, but it says nothing about the effect size – we could be really confident in a tiny effect size. Classification 2A is probable, and 2B (the apparent new classification for aspartame) is possible. Category 3 is unclassifiable as a carcinogen, and class 4 is probably not carcinogenic.
A lot of things that we consume every day are in category 2B. Drinking hot beverages is in category 2A, above that of aspartame. Here is a full list of 2B.
But even the categorization of 2B is likely to be controversial. Here is the latest review of the question in the published literature, from 2022, which concludes:
Taken together, available evidence supports that aspartame consumption is not carcinogenic in humans and that the inconsistent findings of the RI studies may be explained by flaws in study design and conduct (despite additional analyses to address study limitations), as acknowledged by authoritative bodies.
Even if we can quibble about the evidence and whether or not there is the possibility of a carcinogenic effect from aspartame, it is not controversial that exposure levels would have to be much higher than what most people consume to confer any risk. At the end of the day the evidence still supports the conclusion that aspartame is safe at human levels of consumption.

Pepsi Removing Aspartame
Steven Novella on April 29, 2015
Link

Pepsi has announced that it will remove aspartame from its formulation of diet Pepsi products in the US this year. Apparently this is a reaction to a 5% drop in the sales of Pepsi. Seth Kaufman, vice-president of Pepsi, said “Aspartame is the number one reason consumers are dropping diet soda.”
This move comes in the same week that Chipotle announced it is removing GMO food from its food chain. Unlike Pepsi, who cited only public opinion, Chipotle went one step further and directly cited pseudoscientific fears of GMOs as their justification. (But that’s another story.)
Like GMOs, aspartame has been widely studied and found to be safe, but remains the target of fear-mongering and conspiracy theories. It is not clear why this one food additive has continued to be the target of a fake controversy, other than that fears and conspiracies can take on a life of their own. The best example of anti-aspartame conspiracy theories comes from Janet Starr Hull, who wrote:
I will never accept the news of aspartame safety. I think it is a “business” decision to discredit/discount the research results that aspartame DOES cause cancer, major nerve disorders, birth defects, and brain imbalances. Think about it – can you imagine the chaos that will occur when the truth of aspartame dangers is accredited. The FDA has known about the dangers, the corporations have known about the dangers, and the medical community (if it is really worth anything) has known about the dangers.
That is a common claim of conspiracy theorists – the truth is being suppressed out of fears that it will bring chaos if revealed. I think our society will survive Pepsi moving over to a different sweetener.
There have been hundreds of studies showing aspartame is safe in the amounts consumed in food (unless you have a disease known as phenylketonuria). The first systematic review of this evidence was published in JAMA in 1985, and concluded:
Available evidence suggests that consumption of aspartame by normal humans is safe and is not associated with serious adverse health effects.
A 2002 review found:
The safety testing of aspartame has gone well beyond that required to evaluate the safety of a food additive. When all the research on aspartame, including evaluations in both the premarketing and postmarketing periods, is examined as a whole, it is clear that aspartame is safe, and there are no unresolved questions regarding its safety under conditions of intended use.
A more recent 2007 systematic review found:
The studies provide no evidence to support an association between aspartame and cancer in any tissue. The weight of existing evidence is that aspartame is safe at current levels of consumption as a nonnutritive sweetener.
They specifically found no association with any cancer. A 2012 updated review found:
In the Nurses’ Health study and the Health Professionals Followup study some excess risk of Hodgkin lymphoma and multiple myeloma was found in men but not in women; no association was found with leukemia. In the NIH-AARP Diet and Health Study, there was no association between aspartame and haematopoietic neoplasms. US case-control studies of brain and haematopoietic neoplasms also showed no association. The NIH-AARP Diet and Health Study and case-control studies from California showed no association with pancreatic cancer, and a case-control study from Denmark found no relation with breast cancer risk. Italian case-control studies conducted in 1991-2008 reported no consistent association for cancers of the upper aerodigestive tract, digestive tract, breast, endometrium, ovary, prostate, and kidney. Low calorie sweeteners were not consistently related to vascular events and preterm deliveries.
The slight increased risk for men in the Nurse’s Health study was not replicated in the other studies and likely just represents noise in the data. You always have to look at the totality of evidence and the statistical spread of results. There are always going to be outliers in any large data set.
Of course this provides the opportunity for those with a dedicated agenda or ideology to cherry pick the inevitable positive studies. In any case, the scientific data with regard to the safety of aspartame is very clear. It is one of the most studied food additives, with multiple independent studies and reviews, with a comfortable margin of safety.
Not only the FDA, but the European Food Safety Authority has reviewed the data and concluded that aspartame is safe.
Health Canada has a helpful page in which they review many of the internet fear-mongering memes relating to aspartame, linking the additive to many diseases, and showing that none of them are supported by evidence. The World Health Organization has assigned an acceptable daily intake level for aspartame of 40mg/kg/day. (The FDA uses 50mg/kg/day). Even if we take a 50kg person (that’s 110 pounds), 2,000 mg per day would be an acceptable intake of aspartame. The highest amount of aspartame found in an 8oz diet drink is 125 mg, which comes out to 16 cans, or almost 4 liters (over a gallon!), a day. This is well below actual consumption:
Consumption estimations for aspartame from one such method, the food intake survey, have been done in the United States, Canada, Germany, and Finland. APM consumption in all age groups and selected subpopulations, even at the 90th percentile, is approximately 2-10 mg/kg/day and is thus well below the ADI.
Conclusion
Aspartame is one of the most studied food additives in the world. It has been a common food additive for over 30 years, and there is a strong consensus among scientists and regulatory agencies that it is completely safe.
The fear and conspiracy genie, however, is difficult to put back into the bottle. In an ideal world corporations would stand strong in defense of science vs pseudoscience, but it is understandable that they would cave to popular opinion even when it conflicts with reality. They are in a no-win situation.
I would argue, however, that in the long run capitulating to public fear based on pseudoscience and rumor is a losing strategy. It just makes corporations more vulnerable to the Food Babes of the world, who can use the internet to push buttons of fear, disgust, and conspiracy to demonize any product.

Are dietary sugar alcohol sweeteners safe?
Should we be concerned about new research linking sugar alcohols like xylitol and erythritol?
Scott Gavura on August 15, 2024
Link

Xylitol is a “sugar alcohol” made from xylose, a plant-based sugar. Its sweet taste and lower glycemic index have led to its use as an artificial sweetener. A recent paper from authors at the Cleveland Clinic has linked the ingredient to an increased risk of heart attack, stroke or cardiovascular-related deaths, reigniting debate about the overall safety of artificial sweeteners.
What are sugar alcohols?
Sugar alcohols can occur naturally in food but are more likely to be consumed from synthetic sources added to processed food. Despite the name, there is no ethanol in sugar alcohols. The class includes products like erythritol, maltitol, mannitol, sorbitol and xylitol. Because they’re lower in calories (0-2 calories per gram, vs 4 calories/gram with sugar) and do not cause cavities, they are used in “sugar-free” products, especially gum and mouthwashes, but also food products. These products are not absorbed by the body well (hence their lower calorie count), so side effects can include gas and diarrhea. See these reviews of sugar-free Haribo Gummy Bears to get some idea of the side effects of eating an immoderate amount of sugar alcohols.
Moderate amounts of sugar alcohols in the diet appear safe, and xylitol and erythritol are approved food additives in the United States. There have been some concerns that processed foods that contain sugar alcohols in large amounts may have health hazards.
Safety signals with consumption
In research published in Nature Medicine in February 2023, Marco Witkowski and colleagues examined the artificial sweetener erythritol and thrombotic heart disease risk, building on other studies that have tried to understand if a causal relationship exists. This study looked at patients undergoing cardiac risk assessments (i.e., this was not a healthy population). They found that high circulating levels of multiple sweeteners, especially erythritol, were associated an elevated risk for major adverse cardiovascular events (MACE; includes death or nonfatal myocardial infarction or stroke), even after controlling for multiple risk factors, over three years. Those with the highest erythritol levels (top 25%) were approximately 2x as likely to have cardiovascular events over three years of follow-up as those with the lowest (bottom 25%) levels. Subsequent analyses in other populations confirmed this association.
Finally the authors did a prospective pilot evaluation of erythritol in eight volunteers and found that ingestion of a large single dose (30g) led to plasma levels (for at least two days) that were associated with (in vitro and in vivo) studies showing effects on platelet reactivity and thrombosis. The authors concluded that erythritol is increasing cardiovascular risk and recommended further safety studies.
It’s important to note that dietary intake was not captured in this study – this was simply a measurement of levels. As erythritol is produced by the body, we do not know if the elevated levels were attributable to diet, or to natural (endogenous) levels. Causation attributable to diet is not clear, as the authors note that most participants were enrolled before erythritol became popular as a dietary ingredient in food products. Given fasting blood levels were being drawn, there is the possibility that the higher levels were endogenous (i.e., produced by the body) and not due to dietary consumption.
Like many other products, the dose makes the poison, and correlation is not causation. Because this was not an otherwise healthy population, and the pilot with dosing was only in 8 people, the findings have been criticized – is it possible that plasma erythritol is raised because of a different cause (e.g., chronic disease) and only correlates with cardiovascular disease? Yes.
In research published in July 2024 in the European Heart Journal, the same group of researchers studied xylitol levels and platelet function in a manner similar to their 2023 analysis. Blood samples from 10 healthy people before and after drinking a xylitol-sweetened beverage were examined (a dose that would be comparable to a serving of xylitol-sweetened ice cream). Not surprisingly, xylitol levels shot up in the blood and decreased over 4-6 hours. Blood xylitol levels increased 1,000-fold within 30 minutes of drinking and returned to baseline after 4 to 6 hours. Platelets were more sensitive to clotting signals when xylitol levels were high. Again, no direct causation of harm was shown.
Overall this research suggests that blood levels of erythritol and xylitol may correlate with cardiovascular disease. I personally am not one to panic based on observational data that could be confounded (and I don’t consume sugar-free foods except Coke Zero) but I would like to see more research exploring this relationship, and if there is causality. Until then, the advice to use sugar alcohol sweeteners in moderation and minimize consumption of all processed foods (sweetened with sugar alcohols or not) remains reasonable.

Sweetened Drinks and Risk of A-Fib
Steven Novella on March 27, 2024
Link

Yet again the public is being subjected to warnings about the potential health risks of consuming a common food item based upon insufficient evidence. Last month it was oat products, and now it’s sweetened drinks.
The study is a prospective cohort study, which means it is observational. The researchers looked at over 200 thousand participants in the UK biobank. At the start of the study they did not have a condition known as atrial fibrillation (A-fib), and by the end of the study there were 9,362 cases. They found that the risk of developing A-fib was 20% higher among those who drank 2 liters or more of artificially sweetened drinks, and 10% higher among those who drank a similar amount of sugar sweetened drinks. They also found that risk was 8% lower among those who drank unsweetened pure fruit juice, like orange juice.
One author states:
“Our study’s findings cannot definitively conclude that one beverage poses more health risk than another due to the complexity of our diets and because some people may drink more than one type of beverage,” said lead study author Ningjian Wang, M.D., Ph.D., a researcher at the Shanghai Ninth People’s Hospital and Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine in Shanghai, China. “However, based on these findings, we recommend that people reduce or even avoid artificially sweetened and sugar-sweetened beverages whenever possible. Do not take it for granted that drinking low-sugar and low-calorie artificially sweetened beverages is healthy, it may pose potential health risks.”
And this is where I have to strenuously disagree. I don’t think this one study is sufficient to make sweeping recommendations about diet. The quote above misses a major reason why we cannot make conclusions about actual risks from this data – it is not controlled. This is observational data, so we cannot make conclusions about cause and effect (something the authors do acknowledge, although then go on to make sweeping diet recommendations).
All the caveats of uncontrolled, self-reported, observational data apply. There are many social and health factors that influence our diets. People in the different groups were not comparable, and it was not really possible to adjust for all the potential confounding factors. They did adjust for genetic risk, but that’s it. They noted, for example, that those who drank more sweetened drinks tended to be more overweight, have other cardiac risk factors, and be of lower socioeconomic status.
That is all the generic limitations of large observational studies – you cannot control for all confounding factors. As the authors note, the confounding factors with something like diet are massive.
But I also had some specific questions and concerns about this study. First, it strikes me as odd that there would be similar risks, as least in the same direction and similar magnitude, for both artificially sweetened low calorie drinks and sugar sweetened drinks. Other than the fact that they are sweet, what would be the similar mechanism here? Sugar and low-calorie sweeteners are very different things. This suggests to me that, if there is an actual risk factor for A-fib here, it’s not the sweetener. It’s something else in the beverage, something not present in fruit juice.
The first thing that occurred to me is so obvious I thought – they must have controlled for this. Then I got to the line, “It is also unknown if the sugar- and artificially sweetened drinks contained caffeine.” To me that makes these study results difficult to interpret, to say the least.
The question of the relationship between caffeine intake and A-fib risk is a complex and interesting one. There is no simple answer at this time. Most of the research involves coffee intake, and coffee contains about 1000 compounds some of which are potentially cardioprotective. Low levels of coffee intake may even have a protective effect on A-fib risk, while higher coffee intake is neutral or may increase risk, depending on the methodology of the study. In the aggregate it’s a wash, without any apparent risk.
However, again, these are mostly from observational studies with lots of confounding variables. What I could not find are any studies looking specifically at caffeine intake from soft drinks. A-fib has more clearly been linked to energy drinks, which generally have higher caffeine and sugar content than soft drinks.
This study could have been an opportunity to look specifically at caffeine intake from soft drinks and A-fib risk, but it did not.
There is also another huge potential confounding factor. Whenever studying diet and trying to link a health risk to the consumption of a specific food, it must be considered that food intake is mostly a zero-sum game. We can only eat and drink so much, and every time we choose to consume one thing we are also choosing to some extent not to consume another. Therefore we need to ask – for those who were consuming large amounts of sweetened drinks, what were they not drinking? Fruit juice appears to be protective in this study, so is it, perhaps, that people who are drinking lots of soft drinks are just missing some of the nutritional benefits of consuming fruit juice?
In the end, this study, which is still useful data, at best can be used to generate hypotheses. But this kind of data – observational with massive potential for confounding factors – cannot be used as the basis for making any conclusions about cause and effect, and therefore should be viewed with caution. I do not think it should be used to make bottom-line public health advice.
Ultimately I find the results difficult to interpret and apply to daily life. But this can be used to design some follow up studies that are better controlled.
There is also the potential here for significant unintended consequences. Making big diet recommendations based on observational or preliminary data causes “alarm fatigue” in the public. If every week they are hearing about another thing they are supposed to avoid it all becomes impossible to manage. As I have written before, just about every food and ingredient has been linked to some health risk or benefit.
The public also loses faith in the medical establishment when such recommendations are constantly shifting or appear to be conflicting. This means they are more likely to ignore solid health advise when it is available.
The obvious solution here is to significantly raise the threshold for what constitutes sufficient evidence to put out a press release reporting health studies, and not to trumpet preliminary or ambiguous health evidence. Also, researchers and journalists need to be careful about how they frame such reports. You should not blare warnings in the headlines and opening paragraph, then bury the caveats deep in the article, where almost no one will read.
The signal to noise ratio is really low in mainstream health reporting. We need to significantly reduce the noise, so that the important signals can get through.

Soft Drinks and Death Risk
New study linking soft drinks to increased mortality is correlational only, and should be interpreted with caution.
Steven Novella on September 11, 2019
Link
A new study on the association between the consumption of soft drinks (sweetened or diet) and risk of death is making some headlines. But caution is necessary in interpreting these results. The study itself, “Association Between Soft Drink Consumption and Mortality in 10 European Countries“, is fine in terms of its methodology. This is what they found:
Of this total, 451 743 (86.7%) were included in the study, with a mean (SD) age of 50.8 (9.8) years and with 321 081 women (71.1%). During a mean (range) follow-up of 16.4 (11.1 in Greece to 19.2 in France) years, 41 693 deaths occurred. Higher all-cause mortality was found among participants who consumed 2 or more glasses per day (vs consumers of <1 glass per month) of total soft drinks (hazard ratio [HR], 1.17; 95% CI, 1.11-1.22; P < .001), sugar-sweetened soft drinks (HR, 1.08; 95% CI, 1.01-1.16; P = .004), and artificially sweetened soft drinks (HR, 1.26; 95% CI, 1.16-1.35; P < .001). Positive associations were also observed between artificially sweetened soft drinks and deaths from circulatory diseases (≥2 glasses per day vs <1 glass per month; HR, 1.52; 95% CI, 1.30-1.78; P < .001) and between sugar-sweetened soft drinks and deaths from digestive diseases (≥1 glass per day vs <1 glass per month; HR, 1.59; 95% CI, 1.24-2.05; P < .001).
This is a cohort study, which means they evaluated subjects on entry into the study and sorted them into various groups, then followed those groups over the duration of the study to assess for death from all causes. They then calculated the risk of death over the period of the study. This is a large study, so obtaining very low P-values is not difficult. For sugared drinks they found a relative risk of dying of 1.08%, with a 95% confidence range from 1.01-1.16. This is a small effect size, that almost overlaps with 1.0, which would be no change in risk. But when dealing with death as the outcome, even a small increase in risk can be meaningful.
The effect size for artificially-sweetened drinks was higher, 1.26 with a range of 1.16-1.35. This is a fairly large increase in the risk of death, and should certainly be taken seriously. There is a huge caveat in interpreting these results, however – this is an observational study. That means it can find correlations only, and not, by itself, determine cause and effect. It would require other types of data to establish a specific cause for this increased risk of death.
The obvious confounding factor here is that people who are at higher risk of vascular disease are more likely to drink diet soft drinks, not the other way around. If you are overweight or obese and trying to lose weight, you may avoid sugary drinks (which is actually a good thing). This is a classic sick-user effect.
This is similar to research showing that taking a daily multivitamin is associated with increased risk of mortality. The prevailing interpretation, supported by some evidence, is that people who are sicker at baseline are more likely to take a multivitamin because they think they need to for their health.
In both cases there may also be another phenomenon at work, a behavioral backfire effect. Whether taking a multivitamin or drinking a zero-calorie drink, people may feel as if this gives them permission to engage in other unhealthy activity. I can eat that cheeseburger because I am pairing it with a diet drink. Or I can have a bad diet or not exercise because I take a daily vitamin.
In both cases, it is probably much more likely the correlation we are seeing is due to a sick user or backfire effect rather than direct harm from either multivitamins or zero-calorie sweeteners. The way to resolve these questions is with further research. The best type of evidence would be a randomized clinical trial, because then confounding variables could be controlled for (it would eliminate the sick user or backfire effect).
For both vitamins and low calorie sweeteners (LCS) we do have some experimental data. I recently reviewed all the data for LCS, which finds that consumption of LCS is associated with decreased calorie intake and therefore weight loss, and improved metabolic parameters. Therefore if we look at the totality of the evidence there seems to be a health advantage to drinking beverages with LCS over sugar-sweetened, and people should not be scared off because of this correlational data.
For multivitamins and other vitamins the data is a bit more complex. I reviewed this data recently as well. For multivitamins there is probably no risk or benefit to all-cause mortality. However, there does appear to be an increased risk of death from taking antioxidants. There are plausible mechanisms to explain this as well.
Both of these cases illustrate that you need to look at various kinds of scientific data before making any specific recommendations based on correlational data alone. Health behavior itself is particularly susceptible to confounding factors. The authors of the current study conclude:
the results are supportive of public health campaigns aimed at limiting the consumption of soft drinks.
I disagree. I would change that to “sugary drinks” not all soft drinks. In fact, the totality of research supports the use of soft drinks with LCS as an effective method of improving health. To their credit they also say,
For artificially-sweetened soft drinks, we now need a better understanding of the mechanisms that may underlie this association and research such as ours will hopefully stimulate these efforts.
At least they gave the “more research is needed” caveat. They also acknowledge it’s not just the mechanism, it’s the arrow of causation itself that is in doubt. There may be no mechanism to LCS increasing mortality, because they don’t. At this point we still need to focus on the proper cause of this association, which other research suggests is probably primarily a sick-user effect.
This nuance is important, because we have to carefully craft the ultimate message we send to the public. Scaring people off of beverages with LCS may have a net negative effect on public health. I am confident that the authors of this study do not want that outcome. When dealing with public health, it is extremely common to have unintended consequences. Human behavior is complex, and it is often difficult to anticipate the net effect on behavior of our messaging. People often do the opposite of what we intend. Public health messaging is also competing with a host of product marketing, which has a very different goal. There is also a lot of “wellness” pseudoscience that is largely based on fearmongering, and we don’t want to inadvertently feed that.
In the end I don’t think this study changes the bottom line recommendations based on existing research. People in general should avoid drinking lots of sugar. Low calorie sweeteners are a safe and effective way to help achieve this goal. Sure, drinking water is also healthful and a great option. But many people prefer to have a little flavor, and in fact this may help them moderate their calorie intake.

Coca-Cola Science
Steven Novella on August 19, 2015
Link

Science functions best when it is free from any bias or conflict of interest. All those engaged in the process should value what is actually true more than anything else. Unfortunately, there are many sources of bias in science.
Researchers may want their pet theory to be supported. Journal editors want to publish research that will have a high impact. And of course, corporations would prefer that the results of scientific research favor their products and services. A recent round of editorials accuses the Coca-Cola company of trying to put its thumb on the scale of science in order to deflect attention away from sugary drinks as a source of obesity and overweight. What are they doing and what does the science actually say?
Promoting uncertainty
According to The New York Times:
The beverage giant has teamed up with influential scientists who are advancing this message in medical journals, at conferences and through social media. To help the scientists get the word out, Coke has provided financial and logistical support to a new nonprofit organization called the Global Energy Balance Network, which promotes the argument that weight-conscious Americans are overly fixated on how much they eat and drink while not paying enough attention to exercise.
This is one subtle way for corporations to influence science. They find legitimate scientists who already support a position that is favorable to their company and they fund them. This is often not difficult to do, there is often a range of opinions on scientific topics, or at least a minority opinion. You could probably find a scientist to support almost any position.
Give that scientist money to further their research, or to communicate their position to the world, and you may help them promote that position. At the very least you can give the public a distorted view of what the consensus of scientific opinion is, by amplifying a minority voice.
In this way the company can be completely hands off the research and the message. They can honestly say that the opinions are those of the scientist, without their influence. All they are doing is cherry picking the opinions they like. This sort of funding bias is also difficult to regulate. What we can do, and what is being done, is to require absolute transparency when it comes to funding sources.
Diet vs exercise
At the heart of this particular debate is the relative role of diet vs exercise in maintaining a healthy weight. There is some legitimate controversy over this question – are Americans, for example, increasing in weight because we are consuming more or moving less? Should we blame computers and multi-media, or supersized fast food?
As with many such debates (but not all), the answer is somewhere between the two extremes. There is no serious debate about the importance of calorie control in managing weight. There is also a strong consensus that exercise has many benefits to health, and does contribute to maintaining muscle and reducing adipose tissue (fat). The old advice to eat right and exercise regularly still holds.
The real question is the relative importance of each of these factors. If your goal is to reduce excess weight, exercise is helpful but exercise alone (without calorie control) is not very effective. A 2010 study randomized obese women to two groups, one with added exercise the other without, and both groups instructed not to change their diet. They found:
Women in the exercise group exercised a mean of 3.6 days (s.d.=1.3) per week and 178.5 min (s.d.=76.1) per week. Changes in all measures of adiposity favored exercisers relative to controls (P<0.001). The mean difference between groups was: −1.8 kg for body weight; −2.0 kg for total body fat; −14.9 cm2 for intra-abdominal fat area; and −24.1 cm2for subcutaneous abdominal fat area. A linear trend of greater body fat loss with increasing volume of exercise was also observed.
While exercise did result in weight loss, you will notice that 178.5 minutes of exercise per week over a year led to a loss of 2 kg of body fat. That is a lot of work for a small benefit.
What about diets for weight loss? A recent meta-analysis showed that for all diet types, over a year, average weight loss of study subjects was 7.25 kg. That is still modest, especially for someone who is obese, but it is more than the exercise-alone group. There is evidence that more exercise will produce higher weight loss, but there are practical limits to what most people can do.
Some researchers also emphasize that weight is not necessarily the most important measure of health. Metabolic health may be more important. Exercise improves metabolic health, and therefore there are health benefits to regular exercise even if it does not result in significant weight loss.
Also, another issue is not just weight loss but maintaining a healthy weight. Most people who lose weight will gain it back, and then some. Dieting alone is a frustratingly ineffective method for maintaining a healthy weight. A survey of those who were successful show:
National Weight Control Registry members have lost an average of 33 kg and maintained the loss for more than 5 y. To maintain their weight loss, members report engaging in high levels of physical activity (≈1 h/d), eating a low-calorie, low-fat diet, eating breakfast regularly, self-monitoring weight, and maintaining a consistent eating pattern across weekdays and weekends.
So again we are back to a combination of diet and exercise. What about the role of sugar-sweetened beverages (SSB)? A 2006 review concluded:
The weight of epidemiologic and experimental evidence indicates that a greater consumption of SSBs is associated with weight gain and obesity. Although more research is needed, sufficient evidence exists for public health strategies to discourage consumption of sugary drinks as part of a healthy lifestyle.
A 2013 review concluded:
Taken together, the evidence that decreasing SSBs will decrease the risk of obesity and related diseases such as T2D is compelling.
Conclusion: Diet and exercise
There certainly remains some scientific controversy over the exact role of diet vs exercise in maintaining a healthy weight, and the exact role of sugary drinks. This is partly due to the fact that the science is complex, the variables are many and they are difficult to control. It is difficult to do research on the behaviors of people over long periods of time.
Given these challenges, there appear to be several strong signals in the data. Both diet and exercise are important to health in general and specifically to maintaining a healthy weight, metabolic profile, and body composition. When it comes to weight, caloric intake appears to be a stronger factor in the short term, but exercise may be critical to maintaining weight control in the long term. Sugar-sweetened drinks contain significant calories that, if consumed regularly, contribute to overall caloric intake and obesity and overweight.
There is certainly no justification for downplaying the role of calories in general or sugar-sweetened drinks specifically in weight and overall health.

Do you need to drink electrolytes?
Electrolyte drinks are very popular – but are they necessary?
Scott Gavura on February 13, 2025
Link
I’ve been long-distance running on and off for the past 25 years. Every few years I enter a race just to see if I’m any closer to qualifying for the Boston Marathon, hoping the increasingly generous cutoff times for older athletes might offset my declining speed. Friends, the trend is not in my favour.
Running and then triathlons led me to start drinking sports beverages. My usual hydration of choice while exercising has always been Gatorade. When I started running, it was the market leader. It was also cheap, and was universally used in races. Train with what you race with, I figured. Gatorade provides some sugar and a bit of salt, it never upset my stomach and I found it more palatable than water – whether it was almost frozen or warm as soup. So it’s all I’ve used.
The market for sports beverages and particularly electrolytes has exploded. These products are widely marketed for hydration – not just for athletes – but for everyday living. If you listen to any podcast, you probably hear ads for companies like LMNT, which argues we should be consuming 4-6 grams of sodium per day, ideally with their sodium-rich packets you add to water. We’re constantly hearing the claim that water is not enough, and only electrolytes plus water can deliver optimal hydration and well-being. But are electrolyte powders really necessary for everyday living?
In this post I want to look at the necessity and benefits of electrolyte powders and beverages for adults, outside of athletics. Optimizing fluid consumption and nutrition during exercise is a topic unto itself. Instead, I want to focus on electrolytes that are consumed outside of exercise situations, because that’s what the current marketing is pushing.
Essential electrolytes in the body include sodium, potassium, magnesium, phosphorus, and chloride. These minerals have critical roles in multiple physiologic functions, so, our bodies have mechanisms (mainly the kidneys) to keep levels tightly controlled in the bloodstream. The amount one needs to consume on a daily basis will vary based on age, physical activity, health status, and certain medical conditions, including pregnancy and lactation. But in most cases, micromanagement or even specific consumption of electrolytes isn’t needed. We get what our need from the food we eat, and we discard what we don’t need in our urine.
Dehydration can cause electrolyte imbalances. When you lose fluids, be it by sweating, urination, or even vomiting, you are losing electrolytes. Strenuous, prolonged exercise can lead to significant fluid loss – but also sodium (and some potassium) loss.
Endurance athletes aren’t the only ones that need to focus on staying hydrated and potentially replacing electrolytes. If you’re ill (especially if you’re vomiting, and not eating or drinking), it’s easy to become dehydrated and create an electrolyte imbalance. The same can be said for spending a lot of time in a hot environment. While water is essential, it may not be enough. Compensating for huge volumes of sweat by drinking water without replacing sodium can cause hyponatremia, which can be a serious medical issue. Now and then you’ll hear about cases of hyponatremia in endurance races, so the message to athletes to address significanct fluid loss with water AND electrolytes continues to be emphasized.

What are electrolyte powders and drinks?
Electrolyte powders are mineral powders that may be flavoured and can be added to water. They may include flavors, caffeine, vitamins, antioxidants, and sometimes carbohydrates. They vary widely in their ingredients and particularly, calorie count. Carbohydrate-containing beverages may be more appropriate for prolonged exercise, as they provide a source of energy, in addition to mineral replacement.
Do you need electrolyte drinks and powders as part of your daily diet?
For eons, humans have survived on earth without electrolyte powders, and that’s because we obtained electrolytes the natural way – through our food. The overwhelming majority of the time, you do not need to consume electrolytes. Exceptions include:
    • If you’re engaged in vigorous exercise over 60-75 minutes, or if it is extremely hot when you exercise
    • If you’re ill and have serious or prolonged vomiting or diarrhea
    • If you’re sweating heavily for a long period
Athletes or anyone with high sweat rates over prolonged periods may prefer electrolyte-containing beverage instead of water. Ideally, we would measure how much one is sweating and the salt concentration of your sweat, but this isn’t practical for obvious reasons. Stepping on the scale can help – if you’re losing a few pounds when you exercise – that’s water (plus electrolytes) lost and you may benefit from some minerals while you work out.
Electrolytes yes, electrolyte powders, probably not
The marketing for electrolyte beverages is impressive, making you feel like plain water just isn’t enough. And electrolytes added to water could potentially be absorbed more quickly. But in most cases, water is perfectly fine for to meet your hydration needs. Athlete or not, you need to ensure your diet and fluid intake contain enough sodium to compensate for losses through sweat and urine. For most people, that’s done without any intervention or any electrolyte supplements – no additional elements required.


Implausible Apple Cider Vinegar Weight Loss Study Retracted
When a trial has results that defy basic biology, it’s reasonable to be skeptical.
Scott Gavura on February 26, 2026
Link

Interest in vinegar as a health remedy is perennial. Apple cider vinegar (ACV) is simply vinegar made from fermented apple cider. Chemically, it is mostly dilute acetic acid, the same ingredient found in ordinary white vinegar. In 2024, a study published in BMJ Nutrition, Prevention & Health reported that a small daily dose of apple cider vinegar produced dramatic weight loss 6–8 kilograms (13-17 pounds) over 12 weeks. The paper was withdrawn more than a year later after substantial criticism. But even before concerns about methodology and reporting were raised, the magnitude of the results should have prompted skepticism: The numbers reported did not align with basic physiology.
The Study and its findings
The trial, entitled Apple cider vinegar for weight management in Lebanese adolescents and young adults with overweight and obesity: a randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled study was published in January 2024. The study population included 120 participants aged 12-25 years (with a body mass index (BMI) of 27-34.5 kg/m²). Participants were divided into three groups who took 5mL, 10mL, or 15mL daily ACV diluted in 250mL water, versus a placebo control, over 12 weeks. Participants were instructed to maintain their usual diets (and track in a diary) without additional interventions. Measurements of weight, BMI, waist/hip ratios, and blood markers like fasting glucose, triglycerides, and cholesterol were taken at baseline and weeks 4, 8, and 12.
The authors reported that all ACV groups showed significant reductions in weight (up to 6-8kg in the 15mL group by week 12), BMI (decrease by an average of 2.7 to 3.0), body fat ratio, and metabolic parameters compared to baseline and placebo. The authors concluded that ACV consumption improved anthropometric and metabolic outcomes, potentially supporting its use as a dietary intervention for obesity management.
The Energy Math
Even a cursory read of the study will likely prompt questions, but let’s take the findings at face value based on what was reported. The group with the largest reported weight loss consumed 1 tablespoon (15mL) apple cider vinegar (5%) daily. That’s 0.75mL of acetic acid. That’s about 15 drops of liquid.
Now look at the reported results:
    • 1 kg of fat stores approximately 7000-7,700 kcal
    • 6-8 kg represents 45,000 – 60,000 kcal
Over 12 weeks, this implies a sustained calorie deficit of 500-700 kcal per day.
A 500 kcal daily deficit is the result of a major change in lifestyle. It means eating substantially less, every day. Or you could burn it by running 30-45 minutes at 10km/hour. Walking briskly, it would take 60-90+ minutes to burn this many calories.
There is no known mechanism by which a small amount of a common food product can increase one’s metabolic rate by 500–700 kcal per day, sustained for three months. We would expect obvious increases in heat production, heart rate, and other systemic effects. People would feel it. Clinicians would identify it. It would not be difficult to distinguish the treatment group from the placebo.
So if the scale is moving by 6–8 kg over 12 weeks, but there is no corresponding change in physiology or behavior, the claim lacks face validity. Either intake was reduced in ways not accounted for, weight was mismeasured, or the study design failed. What it cannot plausibly represent is a dramatic metabolic effect of a widely consumed kitchen ingredient.
But that’s not all
The implausibility of the effect size naturally led readers to examine the study more closely. And once scrutiny began, substantial problems were identified.
Without even looking at the trial, critics noted it had not been registered in advance. The reporting itself didn’t follow expected standards for randomized controlled trials – standards that were supposed to be a journal standard.
Critics noted improbabilities in the reported data, including discrepancies in baseline characteristics and outcome reporting. Questions were raised about the randomization process, the adequacy of blinding, and whether dietary intake and physical activity were sufficiently controlled or monitored. Given that weight loss of this magnitude would almost certainly require reduced energy intake, the absence of any analysis of dietary intake, despite participants keeping diaries, was surprising.
There were also concerns about statistical reporting and the internal coherence of the results. When effect sizes are large but the surrounding methodological details are limited, questions are to be expected. While the authors stated “All data relevant to the study are included in the article or uploaded as supplementary information,” none was available.
One critic noted that the results suggested that ACV was far more effective than semaglutide (Ozempic) which results in a 6% weight loss at 12 weeks – less than up to 9% found with ACV. That critic noted,
An unpatentable, freely available, absolutely harmless dietary intervention that is 50% more effective at short/medium term weight loss than GLP-1 agonists for ~1/1000th of the price feels improbable.
Ultimately, the journal withdrew the paper. Retractions are part of science’s self-correcting process. But in this case, the warning signs should have been visible during the peer review process: the results did not make physiological sense.
Spotting bad data
Retractions reflect the self-correcting nature of science. But the key point I wanted to make by blogging about a retraction is not that the process works. It is about how the reader needs to consider these types of studies.
When evaluating claims about weight loss, especially those involving common foods or supplements, start with the size of the reported effect. Large, sustained weight changes require large, sustained shifts in energy balance. Those shifts must come from either reduced intake, increased expenditure, or pharmacologic effects that meaningfully alter appetite or metabolism. These are the only ways you can change energy balance.
If a study reports dramatic weight loss from a simple intervention, ask these questions:
     1.  What daily calorie deficit would this result require?
     2.  What mechanism could plausibly produce that deficit?
     3.  Would that mechanism produce noticeable physiological effects?
If the answers are unclear, implausible, or absent, it’s reasonable to be skeptical of the findings. And where the findings are an outlier, or are called “unprecedented”? Even more skepticism is warranted.
The appeal of simple solutions is understandable. A tablespoon of vinegar is inexpensive, accessible, and harmless in small amounts. But physiology has no regard for these factors. Energy balance is not suspended because an intervention is “natural.” This shouldn’t have passed peer review – and until all the discrepancies are actually addressed, it’s reasonable to keep thinking of ACV as a food and not a miracle weight loss cure.

The Health Benefits of Moderate Drinking
Harriet Hall on December 30, 2014
Link

A Book of Verses underneath the Bough,A Jug of Wine, a Loaf of Bread–and ThouBeside me singing in the Wilderness–Oh, Wilderness were Paradise enow!”
– The Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam

Alcoholic beverages have always inspired strong opinions pro and con. Omar Khayyam included wine in his vision of Paradise; Carrie Nation took a hatchet to saloons. Humans have been drinking alcoholic beverages for at least 12,000 years. In earlier eras beer and wine were dietary staples that provided essential calories and were safer to drink than water. Early cultures worshipped wine deities; today, some religions ban all forms of alcohol while others embrace red wine as an essential part of a holy sacrament. Alcoholic beverages are widely used as an accompaniment to meals and as a social lubricant (as Ogden Nash put it, “Candy is dandy, but liquor is quicker”). Prohibition didn’t work.
It’s always good when opinions can be backed up by scientific evidence. Those who drink, especially wine lovers, can bolster their personal preference with the evidence from recent studies showing that moderate alcohol consumption prolongs life and improves health in various ways. Those who prefer not to drink are being told they can get the same benefits from resveratrol, a component of red wine. Just how good is the evidence, and what does it really tell us?
Benefits of alcohol
According to this website, there is evidence that drinking wine provides the following health benefits:
     1.  Promotes longevity
     2.  Reduces heart attack risk
     3.  Reduces risk of heart disease
     4.  Reduces risk of Type 2 diabetes
     5.  Lowers risk of stroke
     6.  Cuts risk of cataracts
     7.  Cuts risk of colon cancer
     8.  Slows brain decline
This sounds very encouraging. Are they reasons to rush out and buy stock in a vineyard or build a wine cellar? To make you start drinking if you don’t already? To make you buy resveratrol supplements to get the benefits of wine without the intoxication?
Risks of alcohol
Maybe you shouldn’t jump on the bandwagon just yet. According to another website, there is evidence for an even longer list of health problems caused by alcohol:
     1.  Anemia
     2.  Cancer
     3.  Cardiovascular disease
     4.  Cirrhosis of the liver
     5.  Dementia
     6.  Depression
     7.  Seizures
     8.  Gout
     9.  High blood pressure
     10.  Infectious disease
     11.  Nerve damage
     12.  Pancreatitis
That list is incomplete, leaving out things like fetal alcohol syndrome. And what about the social costs of drunkenness, alcohol-fueled violence, addiction, and accidents?
The research
Wine and other alcoholic beverages have been used for medicinal purposes throughout history, but modern science-based interest began with the discovery of the French paradox. Researchers studying risk factors for coronary disease discovered that after controlling for known risk factors, heart disease was less common in France than in the US; it was proposed that the much larger consumption of red wine in France might explain the difference. The average annual consumption of red wine was 60-70 liters in France compared to 5-10 liters in the US.
Just how credible is the research supporting the claims of health benefits? Does it extend to drinking beer and other forms of alcohol, or just red wine? If moderate intake is beneficial, how much is enough to get the benefits? Let’s take a closer look.
Some people decry the use of Wikipedia as a source, but in this case the Wikipedia article on the long-term effects of alcohol consumption is an excellent place to start. It provides an exhaustive overview of the research on alcohol with plenty of citations. I’ll try to summarize what we know.
There is considerable high-quality evidence that moderate drinkers live longer than either abstainers or heavy drinkers, but there are some caveats. The subject does not lend itself to randomized, placebo-controlled studies, so we have to rely on other, less certain kinds of evidence. That’s not a problem per se. We had the same problem in studying the health effects of smoking, but in that case we had a mountain of corroboratory evidence from various kinds of studies and basic science that led to a firm conclusion. The evidence on alcohol has not yet reached a comparable consistency or critical mass. It relies mainly on epidemiologic studies, a type of research that has a lot of drawbacks. Correlation doesn’t necessarily mean causation. We can never be sure all possible confounders have been eliminated; for instance, people who drink red wine might belong to a higher social status and have a healthier diet and lifestyle than the average nondrinker. And there are studies from non-Western cultures that found the opposite: no benefit and even possible harm from alcohol consumption. Most importantly, there is no evidence that people who don’t drink would improve their longevity if they started drinking. Or that people who do drink would decrease their longevity if they stopped drinking.
Many of the studies looked at total alcohol consumption without breaking it down into wine, beer, and other spirits. When red wine was singled out, multiple studies found it was more beneficial than other alcoholic drinks, even white wine. It was suggested that this might be due to the high polyphenol content of red wine. Antioxidant polyphenols are concentrated in the skin and seeds of the grape, which are omitted from white wine. Alcohol is a pro-oxidant, but the polyphenol content makes red wine an overall antioxidant. Older wine has a lower antioxidant capacity than younger wine. Red grape juice also contains polyphenols and shows some of the same antioxidant benefits as red wine. Polyphenols in red wine inhibit platelet aggregation; this effect is only seen when the skins and seeds are both used, so there may be a synergistic effect between different components. Polyphenols relax arteries and reduce blood pressure; this effect occurs with alcohol-free red wine but the opposite effect occurs with alcohol. The evidence for the superiority of red wine is inconsistent: some studies have indicated that other alcoholic beverages are equally beneficial.
Might it make a difference whether alcohol is a regular accompaniment to meals in a culture consuming a Mediterranean diet versus drinking in non-meal settings or with other kinds of food? That hasn’t been tested. We simply don’t know. And we’re not likely to find out, since randomized controlled trials can’t be done. We are left with guesswork based on epidemiologic studies and basic science.
The benefits and risks for cancer are not clear. Overconsumption of alcohol has been correlated with several types of cancer, and moderate consumption is correlated with a higher risk of breast cancer. One study found that red wine reduced DNA damage but alcohol alone did not. The list above of benefits includes “cuts risk of colon cancer,” citing a 2005 study showing that moderate drinkers of red wine were 45% less likely to develop colon cancer. But that is belied by a 2011 meta-analysis that found strong evidence for an association between alcohol and an increased risk of colon cancer.Sirtuin is an enzyme associated with increased lifespan in mice but not yet verified for humans. The resveratrol in red wine is thought to increase sirtuin levels. I have written about resveratrol before. The longevity benefits of massive doses of resveratrol for obese mice are impressive, but there is little evidence that resveratrol supplements benefit humans. This 2013 review of clinical trials concluded:
The relevance of the huge output of in vitro and animal studies looking at the health benefits of RES is unclear. Scientific literature is filled with plenty of studies where unrealistic assay conditions have led to many effects and mechanisms that are far from being confirmed in humans.
As for the evidence that wine slows cognitive decline, this 2012 review shows that alcohol has both a neurotoxic and neuroprotective effect, and warns that study findings should be interpreted with caution.
Conclusion
Can (should?) alcoholic beverages be part of a healthy diet? As usual, science doesn’t give us the kind of clear-cut answers we would like.
There are known risks to heavy use of alcohol. Moderate use of alcohol has been associated with improved health and longevity; but the evidence is not entirely consistent or conclusive, and the benefits may be from components of red wine rather than from alcohol per se. Claims that the benefits of red wine can be achieved with resveratrol supplements are premature. The optimum dose of wine or alcohol has not been established.
There are plenty of reasons not to drink to excess; but there is no firm evidence-based consensus about how much is too much. In my opinion, if you don’t drink, the prospect of health benefits is not reason enough to start. If you do drink responsibly and in moderation, you can reassure yourself that the health benefits may outweigh the risks, especially if you drink red wine.

   Failed Flaxseed and Bad News Brownies
David J Kroll
Link
Well, it’s been a tough month for herbs since my last monthly soiree here at SBM.
Just last week at the American Society for Clinical Oncology (ASCO) meeting, a group out of the Mayo Clinic presented data from a study showing that a well-characterized flaxseed extract was ineffective against hot flashes in postmenopausal women. But as Steve Novella noted here earlier this week, negative clinical trials data on supplements rarely influence the behavior of those who continue to advocate for their herbal use.
Flaxseed, known to contain phytoestrogen compounds such as secoisolariciresinol diglucoside (SDG) and enterolactone, has been purported to relieve hot flashes.
But I think the hypothesis was flawed in the first place: while these compounds bind the estrogen receptor, they have largely been shown to be estrogen receptor modulators that act in a negative manner. Work from the group of Dr. Lillian Thompson at the University of Toronto has repeatedly shown in an estrogen-dependent animal model of human breast cancer that flaxseed components act in a predominantly anti-estrogenic manner. One might suspect that hot flashes would be made worse by flaxseed, although this was not the case in the study presented as ASCO.
However, flaxseed is definitely a great source of fiber and may have preventive effects in prostate cancer, but not through an estrogenic mechanism. Instead, another flaxseed component, the omega-3 fatty acid alpha-linoleic acid (ALA), reduces the conversion of testosterone to its more active form, dihydrotestosterone. This work comes from a former colleague at Duke University, Wendy Demark-Wahnefried, now at the University of Texas-M.D. Anderson Cancer Center.
Bottom line: A good understanding of the basic science of herbal medicines is absolutely essential to good clinical trial design.
Don’t Bogart My Brownies
A story that’s more likely to have been seen by SBM readers is Lazy Cakes, a dietary supplement-laden brownie intended as a sleep-aid (here’s an example from NPR). The implied undercurrent of this product, of course, is the longstanding tradition of baking marijuana into brownies to – uh – get baked. The packaging itself evokes memories of the Grateful Dead, Phish, and Widespread Panic – musical groups closely associated with marijuana use who the reader will identify with depending on their age. Their tagline, “Relaxation Baked In,” isn’t even a veiled association with this traditional herbal practice.
Lazy Cakes have created an uproar in part because they contain a dietary supplement with potential of central nervous system activity, melatonin. This naturally-occurring hormone is synthesized in the pineal gland and appears to regulate our circadian rhythms. The reader may best recognize melatonin for prevention of jet lag. It is, in simple terms, a sedative and appears to be more potent in younger people. National poison control centers report several thousand calls regarding melatonin each year, with the majority of reports of sedation in children who’ve gotten hold of a parents supplement. Here’s one example from the Texas Department of State Health Services.
Lazy Cakes might also be riding on the well-known Philadelphia-area delicacy, Tastykake. The fact that I have included Tastykake in a post about Lazy Cakes is most certainly not pleasing to this East Coast institution but I have yet to find anything in the Philadelphia press about this issue. (By the way, these wonders of the food world fueled my childhood development as well as my scientific training at the school known previously as the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy and Science.)
The concern with Lazy Cakes seems to be that each brownie contains 7.8 mg of melatonin, well above the generally recommended sleeptime dose of 1 to 3 mg. While there have been no controlled trials of Lazy Cakes, anecdotal reports suggest that the brownies do indeed have physiological action. From the NPR story:
“There is an effect with Lazy Cakes, but I wouldn’t say it’s comparable to marijuana at all,” says Niki D’Andrea, who bought one while at a shop that sells drug paraphernalia.
D’Andrea’s not shy about having tried both; it’s part of her job writing about subculture for the Phoenix New Times. She didn’t get high from the Lazy Cake, but she was shocked at how sleepy it made her.
“I really did go to bed for about, I think 10 to 12 hours after I ate that first Lazy Cake, so well, maybe I should have started with half,” D’Andrea says.
Actually, half is the recommended serving size. As if anyone ever just eats half a brownie.
Less attention has been given to the other herbal components: valerian and passionflower extracts.
Valerian (Valeriana officinalis L.) has been investigated for sleep-inducing and anti-anxiety effects. In fact, some of the same researchers who presented the ASCO work above on flaxseed conducted a Phase III trial of valerian extract in cancer patients. Published earlier this year in the Journal of Supportive Oncology, the study revealed that this valerian root extract had no effect on overall measures of sleep efficacy, although some beneficial effects were observed on secondary measures such as fatigue.
However, we have no idea what valerian might do together with this rather high dose of melatonin. Come to think of it, I have no idea how the manufacturer made a valerian-containing brownie even remotely palatable. I have a 16-year-old bottle of valerian root that I use for classroom demonstrations and it still smells of rancid gym socks. But, then again, baking valerian extract is likely to release some of these volatiles.
Less is known about passionflower (Passiflora incarnata). Even a Cochrane review of passionflower for anxiety was unable to come to a solid conclusion due to the low number of studies.
Another issue not addressed in most MSM reports is that the actual content of components can vary wildly from amounts listed on dietary supplement labels. In most cases, the products contain less but this inconsistency is concerning with a product that contains a human hormone well-known to induce sleep.
The bottom line: don’t mess with Lazy Cakes. As with any sedative drug – whether a supplement, prescription or over-the-counter – there’s always a concern for additive or synergistic effects with alcohol.
But rest assured that the uproar over Lazy Cakes will further fuel sales. And given dietary supplement regulations in the United States, I really don’t see this product being banned – although the manufacturer has added additional warnings about sedation and intended use by adults.
That’s right – a product featuring a sleepy brownie that resembles Spongebob Squarepants is intended solely for adults.

Swedish Blueberries Are Bluer, But Are They Better?
Swedish blueberries are bluer, are they better?
Harriet Hall on June 7, 2022
Link

New Nordic Supplements has been selling “Blue Berry™ – The essence of eye health” since 1997. According to their website:
The secret of wild low bush blueberries began with the most traditionally used berry in Sweden. Years of research and cooperation with world renowned ophthalmologists resulted in the world’s first lutein enriched blue berry eye care tablet. Since its creation in 1997, the factory in Sweden has increased its output of Blue Berry tablets every year, and with loyal consumers in 30 countries from China in East to the US in west, the demand is still growing. It is one of the fundamental products of New Nordic, and is definitely here to stay.
They say Blue Berry has been the number one eye supplement in Scandinavia for two decades. It is based on blueberries and lutein. They have plenty of testimonials, but nothing in the way of scientific evidence of efficacy.
They also sell products to increase hair volume and to activate collagen in the skin, as well as a variety of products for detox, weight loss, immune support, beauty, and vitality. They sell ashwagandha vegan gummies, apple cider vinegar, a “clear brain” memory supplement, a “strong legs” supplement, and other questionable products. They don’t offer any scientific evidence of efficacy for any of them.
I have written about this before. No treatment will reverse the changes of macular degeneration. The AREDS2 formula has been shown to slow the rate of progression of moderate to severe AMD (age-related macular degeneration) but there is no evidence that it is effective for milder disease or for prevention.
I did learn something about blueberries from their website. Swedish blueberries, more properly known as bilberries, have flesh that is blue throughout. Swedish blueberries are bluer than American blueberries, whose flesh is a lighter, greenish, almost white color. Does bluer mean better? Maybe, maybe not. The company hopes we will assume their berries must be better, but it is dangerous to assume. It can make an ASS out of U and ME. Science could test Swedish vs American blueberries to find out if the bluer berry is more effective for macular degeneration.

Garlic, the fragrant panacea
Garlic supplements are claimed to treat and cure nearly every disease. What does the evidence say?
Scott Gavura on June 9, 2022
Link

There’s a high-end grocery/health food store near me. It’s one of those stores where almost everything is organic (even the tissues), there’s an in-house juice bar, and a large “wellness” section with loads of tinctures, essential oils, and other products. Think Whole Foods, but tiny, and with a dispensary for homeopathy. I get their flyer to my door periodically and while I don’t shop there, I keep an eye on the alternative medicine trends in the products they profile. Last week I spotted a product I hadn’t heard of, and some claims that looked…impressive:
I decided to take a closer look at this product. Alternative medicine approaches to allergies is a subject I’ve covered before, and I keep coming back to it because the consequences can potentially be harmful if products don’t work as directed, or if they are used in place of treatments that actually do work. 
Garlic and allicin
Allimax is an allicin product, derived from garlic. Garlic (Allium sativum) needs no introduction given its culinary use, but it has a long history of medicinal uses as well. The medicinal effects are attributed to the bulb, where the cloves reside. The cloves themselves contain multiple chemical compounds, with the one of greatest interest being alliin, which is converted to allicin when the bulb is cut or crushed. It is the allicin which gives garlic its characteristic aroma. Depending on the method of preparation, supplements may have alliin, allicin, or different proportions of both.
Fresh garlic has been studied extensively and found to have numerous possible medicinal properties – in the laboratory. It may be antibacterial, but whether or not these effects can appear when garlic is ingested is a different question. It’s also been shown to have potential effects on parasites, fungi, viruses, blood lipids and more. Plus there are possible antioxidant effects. But from a practical perspective, like other supplements, we really need to look for clinical trials with the product in question.
Consuming is garlic is generally considered safe when consumed in amounts that would be expected in foods. In human studies, the most promising area of research has been in the study of garlic supplements to slow the progression of atherosclerosis where some brands of garlic powder supplement have shown positive effects on markers of heart disease. Whether this extends life or reduces the rate of cardiovascular events is not known. Heart associations don’t encourage garlic consumption, but neither do they discourage it.
The other area where garlic has the most promising research is in type 2 diabetes. A “natural” treatment for diabetes that could be incorporated into regular dietary habits would be tremendous. Overall, research suggests that different forms of garlic extract (powder, oil, aged extract), when taken regularly for several weeks, may reduce fasting blood sugar levels slightly. However I couldn’t find any major treatment guidelines that recommend garlic (or garlic supplements).
There is also preliminary but encouraging evidence for garlic supplements to have small (but beneficial) effects on cholesterol levels and on blood pressure.
Given the unique manufacturing process and the lack of standardization of garlic products, I looked specifically for clinical trials with allicin, and preferably the Allimax product.
Allimax, the product in the advertisement, is marketed as “stabilized allicin”. There is not much described in the manufacturing process, and no evidence is cited that there is any testing (independent or otherwise) to show how they came up with the 180mg capsule calculation. There is a dosing chart available, which provides Allimax doses for conditions ranging from acne to asthma to blood pressure to fungal infections to herpes to peptic ulcer to ringworm to “wounds”. Where these doses are derived from is not clear.
There is little on the Allimax websites with respect to evidence. (It recommends the reader consult Wikipedia, among other resources.) The articles page is” under construction”“. There is a 2007 announcement on the completion of a clinical trial in Lyme disease, but I could not find that it was published. (The manufacturer claims it is effective on their website.) There was a very rudimentary clinical trial with what may be Allimax when used for the prevention of the common cold, published in 2001. The Cochrane Review examined this study and commented in 2014 that there was insufficient evidence to suggest that garlic may prevent occurrences of the common cold. Allimax states that “No other garlic supplements contain ANY allicin” which if correct means that little if any of the garlic research I noted above is relevant to Allimax at all.
When I looked specifically for evidence for Allimax for the treatment of hay fever or for the prevention of insect bites, I could find no information that it had been studied. Moreover, there is no published evidence showing that garlic (in any form) is effective for these purposes.
It should be noted that the FDA wrote to the manufacturer of Allimax in 2021 and asked it to remove statements suggesting Allimax could prevent or treat COVID-19.
Supplements aren’t tasty like real garlic, and your mileage may vary
In general, I have found that a supplement’s effectiveness is often inversely proportional to the number of conditions a product it is claimed to treat. Garlic is an interesting herb from a culinary and medicinal perspective. Some forms of garlic supplements do have pharmacological effects which may provide meaningful (if modest) health benefits. But like any other supplement, in the absence of any standardization, it is a leap to assume evidence from one product is relevant to another (particularly since there is no guarantee the bottle actually contains anything listed on the label). What does seem fair to conclude is that there is no persuasive evidence that garlic or garlic supplements can prevent hay fever attacks or protect against insect bites. Moreover, there is no clear evidence that regularly consuming garlic or garlic supplements provides any meaningful anti-bacterial, anti-viral, or anti-fungal effects. I will continue to use garlic liberally in my cooking, and will await more published evidence for garlic supplements before recommending them.av

Pesticide in Oat Products – Should You Worry?
You know the rule about headlines – if there is a question in a headline the answer is almost always “no”. This article is no exception.
Steven Novella on February 21, 2024
Link

You know the rule about headlines – if there is a question in a headline the answer is almost always “no”. This article is no exception.
But the lay media seems to want you to worry (presumably because it’s better for clicks), such as this headline from CBS news, “Pesticide linked to reproductive issues found in Cheerios, Quaker Oats and other oat-based foods.” To be fair, headlines don’t always reflect the full content of an article, but if you read the piece all the way through you just get dueling quotes, no real scientific context.
The pesticide in question is chlormequat, a plant growth inhibitor that limits the height of crop stems, making them easier to harvest and reducing the risk that they will bend over or break. In the US the chemical is allowed for use on ornamental plants but not food crops. However, it is allowed for use on food crops in the European Union, and in 2018 the EPA altered their rules to allow the import of European grains grown using the chemical, such as oats.
The study which is getting all the media attention is by the Environmental Working Group, a group that I think is better describes as an advocacy group rather than an objective scientific group. I have long had a problem with how they present data, and this latest study fits right in with their history. The study is described in the title as a “pilot” study and is rather small, involving only 96 subjects. They found:
Here we report, the presence of chlormequat in urine samples collected from people in the U.S., with detection frequencies of 69%, 74%, and 90% for samples collected in 2017, 2018–2022, and 2023, respectively.
Even though it is a small pilot study, let’s assume their results are accurate. As far at they go, they are not surprising since the US started importing grains grown with the use of chlormequat in 2018. They also tested oat-based products and found:
Food samples purchased in the U.S. from 2022 and 2023 show detectable levels of chlormequat in all but two of 25 conventional oat-based products, with concentrations ranging from non-detectable to 291 µg/kg, indicating a high prevalence of chlormequat in oats. Median levels were similar between samples collected in 2022 and 2023, at 90 and 114 µg/kg respectively. Only one sample out of eight organic oat-based products at detectable chlormequat at 17 µg/kg.
Again, not surprising. The real story here is the way in which this study is being reported to the public, which, in my opinion, reveals the true purpose of the study – to create another round of fearmongering about toxins in our food and shill for the organic food industry.
What’s missing from almost all of the reporting is a couple of important pieces of information. From the study itself, what I consider to be the money quote:
Current chlormequat concentrations in urine from this study and others suggest that individual sample donors were exposed to chlormequat at levels several orders of magnitude below the reference dose (RfD) published by the U.S. EPA (0.05 mg/kg bw/day) and the acceptable daily intake (ADI) value published by the European Food Safety Authority (0.04 mg/kg bw/day).
Several orders of magnitude below accepted safety limits – you notice the safety limits are in the mg (milligrams) and the chlormequat levels are in µg (micrograms). For a 70 kg person, they would need to consume (using the US numbers) 3.5 mg per day of chlormequat. Using the highest concentration above and rounding up to 300 µg/kg, you would need to consume 12 kg of oats every day to reach the lower limit of the safety range.
The authors point out that chlormequat is rapidly removed in the urine, which means that measuring it in urine samples likely means ongoing exposure. But it also means that chlormequat is rapidly removed from the body, so you would have to consume those 12 kg of oats every day. Keep in mind, safety limit are already typically set 1-2 orders of magnitude lower than evidence shows correlates with any negative health outcome.
And yet much of the reporting, as in the CBS article, simply states:
Some studies have shown chlormequat can damage the reproductive system and disrupt fetal growth in animals, a cause for concern as to “whether it could also harm humans,” EWG stated.
These studies are in animals. There is no evidence for a similar effect in humans. As they frequently do in my experience, the EWG is confusing hazard and risk. Toxicology and animal studies tell us about a potential hazard from a substance – it is biologically capable of causing some disruption or harm. But this kind of data does not tell us about risk – does this harm actually happen in humans, and at what exposure level? The EWG cannot point to any data regarding risk, so they fall back once again on a hazard-based argument and an overapplication of the precautionary principle – arguing we need to further study potential harm.
Further research is always welcome, but should we be fearmongering in the meantime? It almost makes it seem like this pilot study, with highly predictable results, was done so that the EWG could raise fears about our food and argue that, in order to be safe, just buy organic. The lay media fell for it. The EWG also opposes legislation in the US to allow use of chlormequat, so this study becomes fodder for that lobbying as well.
In reality, this is all a giant nothing burger. The EWG study actually demonstrated that even with allowing into the US, EU grains grown with the use of chlormequat, exposure levels are still several orders of magnitude below safety levels. This nicely demonstrates there is nothing to worry about, but they have successfully spun the story into the exact opposite.
Note: The math above was corrected from the original.

A good journal breaks bad: AAP spreads misinformation about glyphosate
The latest report from the American Academy of Pediatrics is filled with misinformation and missing key articles that support the well-researched conclusion that there is no legitimate evidence of negative health effects of glyphosate.
Nicole Keller on January 14, 2024
Link

On Dec 11, 2023, a clinical report titled, “Use of Genetically Modified Organism (GMO) – Containing Food Products in Children” was released from the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP). This was accompanied by an educational article meant for parents titled, “Are GMO Foods Safe for My Child? AAP Policy Explained” on the AAP’s healthychildren.org website.
As a pediatrician with an interest in this subject, I was excited to read these papers. I thought it would be great to see the AAP lay to rest concerns about food containing ingredients derived from genetic engineering (GE). Instead, what I found was a piece filled with misinformation and missing key articles that support the well-researched conclusion that there is no legitimate evidence of negative health effects after more than three decades of intense study and surveillance.
After I picked my jaw up off the ground and took some deep breaths to calm my fury, I dove into the concerns presented, trying to be open minded that maybe I had something to learn. After thorough review, though, I’m not convinced by the concerns presented in this report. In fact, I’m majorly concerned that this piece is going to spread like wildfire and spark unnecessary fear amongst healthcare workers and then onto patients. I can’t let this be. So, I’m going to use this article to help dispel inaccurate information and unfounded worries brought up by this report. Here goes!
Glyphosate/pesticide residue concerns
I initially assumed the concerns about “GMOs” would be regarding risks associated with genetic modification. Rather, the authors make clear statements that they are chiefly concerned with increased and persistent use of herbicides on GE crops and that this pesticide exposure is harmful to health. Regarding herbicide exposure they write, “These toxic and carcinogenic risks substantially overshadow any theoretical risks to children’s health that may be associated with the introduction of novel genes into corn, soybeans, and other food crops.” In other words, their primary issue with genetic engineering is not the product itself, rather the dietary exposure to herbicide residues. They go on to detail their pesticide concern, targeting the herbicide glyphosate.
Let’s take apart their concerns:
Farmers use glyphosate because it is a nonselective herbicide that kills all plants, except for those that are genetically engineered to tolerate it. Farmers plant seeds, allow weeds and crop to grow together, then apply a light concentration of the herbicide (more on this later) which kills the weeds and leaves the crop to dominate the field. While highly toxic to plants, its acute and chronic toxicity to non-target organisms is exceedingly low (more info can be found here, and here).
As the AAP report points out, glyphosate use has indeed gone up in the decades since it was first introduced in the mid 1970’s. But the authors of this piece would have you believe that this increase is due to unchecked agricultural abuses. Rather, farmers choose to use glyphosate to control weeds instead of using other herbicides (like atrazine) or repetitive tilling, which disturbs soil and promotes erosion. Glyphosate is chosen as an effective and safe option that helps protect our food supply with limited unwanted effects. The other omitted fact is at the same time as glyphosate use has increased, use of other harsher chemicals have been majorly decreasing (great visual of these volume shifts here). Even more, the volume of overall pesticide use (and use of more toxic pesticides) over time has actually decreased.
Beyond glyphosate
This report also briefly mentions fears about the toxicity of two other herbicides – 2,4 D as well as Dicamba. I won’t spend too much time on these but thought I could briefly address their worries. Both 2,4 D and Dicamba are commonly used on lawns, gardens, and golf courses. They are also used in agriculture on crops like corn and soybeans. When assessing 2,4 D toxicity, you’d have to be massively exposed repeatedly to see harm over time or have a large dose exposure at one time to have physical symptoms. Typical everyday exposure should cause no issues. Oh, and this report mentioned that 2,4 D is part of Agent Orange, too – scare tactic by chance?? I mean the AAP must know just because one chemical combined with another may be toxic, it doesn’t mean that chemical by itself has the same toxicity. They must realize that, right?? Dicamba has its issues and has been in the news because of volatilization and off-target movement, harming other crops. But like 2,4 D, when used appropriately dicamba also may be applied without special risk. Like all agricultural chemicals, dicamba undergoes routine reassessment review as part of the EPA’s ongoing monitoring and reassessment of new research over time. Both these chemicals are commonly used around personal homes and recreational areas as well as in agriculture.
Regardless, it is of utmost importance that parents, landscapers and farmers use any chemical judiciously and per the instructions on the label to limit undue risk. When used appropriately, the chemicals the report references don’t have any worrisome toxicity that should make us sound the alarms. Interesting to think of it that way actually – just like a doctor might think about appropriate use of prescription medications. What a parallel!
Worries about too much
Next, after worries are laid out about specific chemicals, the clinical report moves on to state unease over heavy or repeated application of herbicides to GE crops. Let me tell you a secret before we go deeper into this worry: Glyphosate (or any chemical) comes with a cost to farmers. Pesticides cost money, they cost time, application puts wear and tear on equipment, and improper application could affect future crops – do you think farmers want to overuse these chemicals after considering all these costs? If you do think farmers are just spraying pesticides at will, then please read on as chemical use turns out, is done with lots of caution, planning, and expert consultation.
How is glyphosate (or any other pesticide) applied then, you ask? I am not an expert in this area, so I consulted with a plant scientist along with several farmers to learn more. Turns out farmers routinely consult the chemical label instructions to ensure safe and effective applications. They also have agronomists and agricultural extension agents who know the soil and the crops to help come up with an appropriate plan. Furthermore, many farmers hire professional pesticide applicators to do the job most efficiently. This professional applicator will consider environmental conditions, timing of applications and appropriate dosing to get the job done right. The timing of when a pesticide is used may also allow a farmer to only spray one application to a field to get the full benefit – really! Additionally, glyphosate is sprayed on crops as the plant is starting its growth. For corn and soybeans, it is sprayed when the crop is young, before any ears of corn or soybean pods are even present on the plant.
Agricultural chemicals are used in very calculated amounts and applied precisely to crops – modern spraying equipment is incredibly accurate and allows farmers to spray a chemical to within inches of their target. The volume of glyphosate typically used is what would fill about two cans of pop (or beer if you’d rather) and is mixed with a large volume of water (hundreds of gallons) and finely spread over an area the size of a football field. Let’s say that again – two cans of pop spread over an area of a football field. And glyphosate is what is called a foliar herbicide. It only works if it is applied to leaves, so anything hitting the soil is wasted. Farmers apply a small amount, a fine mist, to a canopy of unwanted plants – not exactly a heavy soaking. We often hear about farmers “dousing” fields with chemicals – does this sound like “dousing?” Just like doctors use prescription medication with caution, farmers use pest control with caution and only when needed, for their own safety and the safety of their families, their land, and their crops.
Resistance
The clinical report then tries to double down on our chemical fears by telling us about heavier applications of herbicide used to combat resistance. Let’s clarify this: If you have a resistant weed problem, you might be able to overcome it with a heavier volume of use. But this is not often done. Instead, farmers again consult with their local agricultural extension agent or agronomist to determine the next best option for effectiveness and safety. Farmers don’t want to have to use unsafe levels of chemicals used for their own land’s safety and their own personal and family safety. Let alone wasting money on a treatment that won’t work anyway.
To give credit where credit is due, the authors were correct in pointing out the emergence of glyphosate tolerant weeds, which has become a problem. Like the overuse of antibiotics can lead to problems in health care, the reliance on a single strategy for weed control also forces selection of weeds that grow through the herbicide unabated. This is a concern most scientists and crop specialists predicted and are working on, and unfortunately is a residue of a cheap and effective weed control strategy.
Glyphosate: How it works
Let’s get to the good part, how glyphosate works. Glyphosate is what’s called a competitive inhibitor of the enzyme 5-enolpyruvalshikimate 3-phosphate synthase, or EPSPS for short. The enzyme is not found in animals, which is the basis of its limited toxicity. Inhibition of this enzyme prevents plants from making some amino acids, and without amino acids to use, the plant slowly dies. Genetically engineered plants are equipped with a special version of the same enzyme that does not bind glyphosate, so they continue to manufacture aromatic amino acids in the presence of the herbicide and continue to live. What happens post-mortem once the weed has died, you ask? Well, glyphosate breaks down in the soil into ammonia, inorganic phosphate, and carbon dioxide – these byproducts are also not dangerous.
But wait – here is the kicker!! EPSPS synthase is only found in plants and some microorganisms. EPSP synthase is NOT found in animals or humans. This therefore means glyphosate has no known mechanism of action in humans or animals. It is almost all excreted from our bodies when it is ingested. The pharmacological fate of this molecule, coupled to the low residue exposures, means there is virtually no risk from occupational or dietary exposures. But I know you can’t wait to hear more, so, let’s continue (just to be thorough).
But what about residues???
Next, there’s lots of hullabaloo about glyphosate (and other pesticide) residues. The paper talks about how when people eat organically grown foods (which reject the science and benefits of genetic engineering), detectable glyphosate residue levels in our urine go down. What?! Not eating residues of a certain chemical means you’ll find less of it in my urine?? I know. Shocking.
Here’s the breakdown of this revelation: when glyphosate residues are found in our food or urine, they’re found in minuscule amounts. Amounts hundreds of thousands of times below the level of concern. The parts per billion (and sometimes parts per trillion) they find are akin to talking about seconds of time in thousands of years. And honestly, finding glyphosate in my pee tells me my body is doing a great job of auto-detoxing by peeing out this chemical my body can’t use! What is interesting, is that the authors dwell on the fact that the compound can be detected, but they never discuss the relative risk of levels detected. They continue to raise concerns about levels that have never been causally connected to any risk, in laboratory animals or epidemiological study of populations.
By the way, if you’re wondering how much residue you’d need to ingest to cause harm, this nifty “Pesticide Residue Calculator” calculates (based on most recent Pesticide Data Program data) how many servings you’d need of a particular food to ingest dangerous pesticide levels for kids and adults. Spoiler: the results show that you’d need to eat volumes of food that would burst your stomach before you’d have any effects from pesticides. 2300 bowls of cereal anyone?
Additionally, the EPA conducts yearly monitoring of pesticide residues via this Pesticide Data Program. It consistently finds that 95-99% of samples have no residues or residues far below levels of concern. Of note, they test for conventional pesticides, but organic pesticides are given a pass and are not routinely monitored. So, no one really knows how much organic approved pesticide residues are on our food. Pesticide residues (organic or conventional) can also be rinsed off (rinse with water, no soap, don’t scrub and damage the outer produce layer!) prior to eating which makes an even lower level of exposure for the consumer. To their credit the AAP does mention this rinsing trick, but it is hidden between all the other fearmongering.
The dose makes the poison
Pesticide residues (glyphosate or otherwise) on our food are consistently monitored and found to be well below levels that would cause health effects – let alone that some pesticides such as glyphosate don’t even have any known action in the human body. The studies the authors present showing urinary exposure have two flaws: the first being that exposure doesn’t equate to toxicity (as they even mention) and that the volume detected reflect exposures hundreds of thousands of times below the acceptable daily intake level for glyphosate. These tolerance levels are set with a wide margin of safety – anywhere between 10-100x below the level at which an effect is observed (more info can be found here and here). As that AAP is a group of health care providers, I’d like to remind them that we calculate appropriate medication doses for our patients to avoid toxicity all the time – this is the same concept!
Glyphosate and cancer… or not
Beyond residue detection, the clinical report’s next biggest concern is the carcinogenicity of glyphosate. The AAP totally missed the memo on this one. The IARC designation for glyphosate as a probable carcinogen has been consistently criticized by the scientific community since it came out in 2015. The IARC designation is hazard based, and they reached their conclusion based on non-statistically significant trends and omission of data not supporting the narrative. At the time of its determination, the IARC left out a significant study (the 2018 Agricultural Health Study “Glyphosate Use and Cancer Incidence in the Agricultural Health Study”) that would not have supported this carcinogenic label. In fact, the head of the IARC review group was found to have knowingly left out this data that would have changed the group’s carcinogenic designation. This means even though the IARC came up with this label, it was not a thorough appraisal of all the information that this AAP report makes it sound.
The designation of glyphosate as carcinogenic was an outlier, as Dr. Steven Novella writes. And while emotional court cases are raking in massive paydays for law firms using the IARC designation, no other organizations have supported labeling glyphosate as carcinogenic. Organizations like the American Medical Association (AMA), the World Health Organization and the United Nations Food and Agricultural Organisation (FAO), the European Food Safety Authority, the National Toxicology Program, the US’s Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and even Health Canada state there is not enough evidence to support the notion of glyphosate carcinogenicity. To continue to show the authors’ bias and agenda in this pediatric clinical report, they fail to cite Andriotti et al. (2018) – the largest and oldest cohort analysis of applicators – as a report conflicting with their claim of carcinogenic associations. This work has followed 54,000 applicators over more than two decades and shows no association between glyphosate and non-Hodgkin lymphoma.
The selective omission of this study that does not support their narrative is deeply concerning. The AAP report authors instead cite studies such as Zhang et al (2019) to try to prove their points. This meta-analysis jams together data from previous papers that are not directly comparable. The paper suggests a 41% increase in risk of non-Hodgkin lymphoma (20 cases per 100k to 28 cases per 100k). However, the work has been highly criticized because associations were only seen when comparing highest exposures and time points and were generated only when data were inappropriately combined.
As you can see, the science does not support this carcinogenic label whatsoever. The 3 articles cited by the AAP only show associations without confirmed causation. Numerous additional research studies have not confirmed this worry. All this shows us this report not only spreads misinformation, but this gross misrepresentation and omission of the body of research on the topic is concerning for intentional covering up of the facts. The authors of the AAP report cite only papers that support their fear-based message and leave out conflicting studies and peer-reviewed criticism by cancer epidemiologists. Selection omission is poor scholarship.
Fearful recommendations about food hurt our patients
The downstream effects of this clinical report in a respected journal will not only result in confusion amongst healthcare providers and parents, but even worse it will make the public fear perfectly healthy food options. We have research showing that when consumers fear conventionally grown produce, but they can’t afford (or don’t have access to) organic options, they SKIP buying that produce all together.
The AAP article suggests buying organic food, which is automatically “non-GMO”, to avoid all these concerns about pesticide exposure. In the same vein, they admit that organic food is consistently more expensive than its conventional counterparts and may not be realistic for some families. Beyond being overpriced, organic food also isn’t accessible to many consumers. Worse, a significant number of rural and deep urban consumers do not even have access to even conventional produce, and now the authors have convinced them it is poison. The added monetary cost plus lack of accessibility plus fear equates to deterring families from eating fruits and veggies all together. This is massively more detrimental to public health than the ingestion of exceedingly low levels of pesticide residues on our foods.
The organic myth
Beyond the harmful side effects of this messaging, organic growing practices can (and do) use pesticides – why, then, aren’t we worried about these organic pesticides? What’s more risk, a synthetic poison or a natural poison? Should we not be calling for more research on organic pesticides as they are less closely monitored? Let’s remember, a chemical being natural versus synthetic tells you absolutely nothing about its toxicity. And in case you’re thinking the recommendation to try buy organic food is based in its superb safety or nutrition compared to conventionally grown products, we have yet to see consistent research that has shown any real health benefits of organic options.
Beyond these facts, the environmental impact of growing foods for the masses with organic methods uses more land and resources to get the same yield as conventional methods. You can see more evidence of the concerning environmental impact of organic food here, here, here and here. All this is to say, the organic label’s health halo isn’t as shiny as it might first appear. It is a classic example of an appeal to nature. The recommendation for people to seek it out is just plain elitist. A costly virtue signal. No thanks AAP, I’ll save my clinical recommendations for things that really matter.
Fearmongering about ultra-processed food and high-fructose corn syrup
After they finish telling us how risky pesticide residues are, the authors shift to fearmongering about ultra-processed food (UPF) and high-fructose corn syrup (HFCS). The AAP here wants us to tell families they should limit UPFs in exchange for minimally processed (and organic) produce. They also hope this will limit ingestion of HFCS – the poor sugar with the bad rap. Come on, AAP, HFCS is just a version of sugar that our bodies process the same way as other sugar versions. Just because HFCS is present in processed foods doesn’t make it bad. And UPFs aren’t what they make them sound like either – they keep using this term, but I do not think they know what it means – read more here and here.
The food standards being set in this AAP report are not helpful. We all know that we need more fruits and veggies in our diets. But instead of lecturing us on what to avoid, it would have been better if the AAP authors gave us tips and ideas on how to help us incorporate produce options into our daily lives in a realistic manner. Enough food shaming already! For some families, UPFs are foods a child with disabilities requires – you going to tell me our g-tube formulated nutrition (which is ultra-processed!) is bad because of that processing and presence of HFCS? Or that the autistic child who has food aversions should instead go hungry? Processed food may be all a family can make work for them. This reflects so powerfully on the stark reality of some people’s food insecurity. How dare we make people fear food that may worsen meeting this basic human need. It would have been refreshing for the AAP to instead offer a plan to help families work with that they have.
To be fair, the authors of the clinical report do state the importance of talking with families and taking into account unique and realistic food options for each family and guiding them with this in mind. But while they do make these appropriate points, when given in the context of a clinical report that is otherwise making people fear food unnecessarily, it creates a massive disconnect in their message. They say in their introduction that pediatricians can, “minimize fear-based messaging” but then proceed to scare people for the rest of the piece. Basically, they’d like me to tell families there are “risks” to eating GE and non-organic and ultra-processed food but then say, “but it’s OK if those options are all you can do.” How is a family supposed to take that?? Instead, how about we just counsel on the wealth of good food options in all forms that can help make up a balanced diet for people of all ages, abilities, and economic statuses.
Pot, meet Kettle
While I have tried to address the concerns in the clinical report, I need to say a quick word about the additional “parent education” piece on the topic. As if things weren’t bad enough already, this accompanying article touts the same fears and inaccurate information. But what I found funny in this parenting article was how they tell parents to be wary of misinformation. They state, “Social media posts and news stories may shrug off the dangers of GMOs…” To this I’d like to say to the authors, take your own advice! You omitted research that didn’t agree with your conclusions so you could keep with your fear-based message. You used sources that have been wrong for decades about genetically engineered crops. You are the ones that need to read the evidence. YOU need to do better.
What’s to be done?
As an AAP member and physician, I have an obligation to stay current on the state of the science and help families understand risk. When the internet and mommy groups are rife with false information and conjecture, pediatricians (and all physicians) have a key role in connecting families to the realities of empirical data and the best peer-reviewed research. It is eerily similar to anti-vaccine rhetoric when a leading organization manufactures a highly publicized, visible, and shared article that misinterprets risk, promotes false claims, and shows horrendous scholarship. Pediatrics might as well be promoting that the childhood vaccine schedule causes autism. Our credibility as a reliable source of healthcare information is at stake. Yes, the disinformation, selective citation, omission, and bias are that bad.
Pediatrics should commission and publish a critical review of the review or retract the work altogether. The bell of fear has now been rung – and that is hard to undo. This makes our jobs as pediatricians and our role as science communicators even more challenging. But if the AAP can help work to right their wrongs, it will support us all in continuing to fight misinformation and unfounded fears.
In ending, I’d like to offer thanks to several members of the science community who offered me confidence and additional education as I wrote this piece. They helped me present this topic in adequate breadth and with scientific accuracy. For that, I am truly grateful.
Want additional supporting articles showing flaws in the IARC designation?
Epidemiologic studies of glyphosate and cancer: a review, Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology Journal, June 2012
Exposure to glyphosate and risk of non-Hodgkin lymphoma and multiple myeloma: an updated meta-analysis, La Medicina del Lavoror Journal Italy, Feb 2020
Systematic review and meta-analysis of glyphosate exposure and risk of lymphohematopoietic cancers Journal of Environmental Science and Health, Mar 2016
Evaluation of carcinogenic potential of the herbicide glyphosate, drawing on tumor incidence data from fourteen chronic/carcinogenicity rodent studies” Critical Reviews in Toxicology, Mar 2015
Glyphosate epidemiology expert panel review: a weight of evidence systematic review of the relationship between glyphosate exposure and non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma or multiple myeloma, Critical Reviews in Toxicology, Sep 2016
European Chemicals Agency stating classifying glyphosate as a carcinogen is not justified, May 2022.

Panera Markets Food Fear
Panera Bread goes full Food Babe in their latest ad campaign, which fearmongers about a safe food preservative.
Steven Novella on August 30, 2017
Link

Panera Bread has gone full Food Babe in their latest ad campaign. They state:
Sodium Benzoate is an artificial preservative found in sauces, jellies, and pickled foods. It’s also an active ingredient in fireworks. So to celebrate the removal of all artificial preservatives from Panera food, we brought Independence Day fireworks to Johnston City, IL, for the first time in 10 years.
The accompanying video opens with people in hazard suits handling sodium benzoate, which they state can be found in many foods as a preservative. They then ask, “But what if instead of doing harm sodium benzoate could be used to do good?” What harm are they referring to? That’s a good question.
This is, unfortunately, a clear example of fearmongering as a marketing campaign. Imply that some feature or ingredient is dangerous, and then proudly state that your product doesn’t have it. This leads the consumer to believe that other products do have it, and just to be safe they better avoid all competitors. In this case the deception is that sodium benzoate and other artificial preservatives “do harm.”
The new wrinkle in this marketing approach is the Food Babe tactic of implying that an ingredient is harmful because it is found in non-food items. She famously attacked Subway for using azodicarbonamide as a bleaching agent in their breads. This is a perfectly safe substance as used, but it also has a variety of industrial uses as a blowing agent. It is included in some plastics and rubbers, leading the Food Babe to call it the “Yoga mat chemical.” She therefore likened eating food made with azodicarbonamide with eating yoga mats.
This logic is nothing more than blatant chemistry illiteracy. First, when chemicals react with other chemicals their properties change. The properties of chlorine gas say exactly nothing about the properties of sodium chloride (table salt). Also, substances which are perfectly safe to consume may have a variety of industrial uses. Just look at a quick list of some of the uses of sodium chloride:
The chemical industry uses large amounts of sodium chloride salt to produce other chemicals. Chlorine and sodium hydroxide are electrolically produced from brine. Chlorine products are used in metal cleaners, paper bleach, plastics and water treatment. The chemical soda ash, which contains sodium, is used to manufacture glass, soaps, paper, and water softeners. Chemicals produced as a result of sodium chloride reactions are used in ceramic glazes, metallurgy, curing of hides, and photography.
Sodium benzoate
The fact that sodium benzoate can also be used in explosives is completely irrelevant to its safety as a food additive, and Panera should frankly be ashamed that they have based a marketing campaign on such anti-scientific fearmongering. What does the scientific evidence say about its safety?
Sodium benzoate is produced by a reaction of benzoic acid with sodium hydroxide, and is used as a food preservative and also in cosmetics. In an acidic environment it converts back to benzoic acid, which can inhibit the growth of bacteria, mold, and yeast. This significantly extends the shelf life of food and increases their safety.
Reviews of safety have concluded that in the amounts found in food, sodium benzoate has no adverse health effect. The FDA limits sodium benzoate in food products to 0.1% by weight. Most products contain much lower amounts.
Here is the World Health Organization’s summary:
In humans, the acute toxicity of benzoic acid and sodium benzoate is low. However, both substances are known to cause non-immunological contact reactions (pseudoallergy). This effect is scarce in healthy subjects; in patients with frequent urticaria or asthma, symptoms or exacerbation of symptoms was observed. A provisional tolerable intake of 5 mg/kg body weight per day can be derived, although benzoates at lower doses can cause non-immunological contact reactions (pseudoallergy) in sensitive persons. As there are no adequate studies available on inhalation exposure, a tolerable concentration for exposure by inhalation cannot be calculated.
The further note that sodium benzoate, because it is not fat soluble, does not accumulate in the body and is rapidly eliminated. So, like all substances, the dose makes the poison. At doses used as a preservative in food sodium benzoate is perfectly safe, is well below toxicity limits, and does not bioaccumulate. There are separate limits for skin exposure, because of its use in cosmetics, and in too high a concentration can cause a skin rash.
Sodium benzoate is also a fine powder. Like many fine powders, it can present a risk when dealing with it in an industrial context. Fine powders tend to disperse in the air and are dangerous if breathed in. They are also an explosion risk simply because of their relatively high surface area. But just about anything you eat, if purified and handled in massive quantities, is risky and says nothing about its safety as encountered in food.
As always, we also have to consider risks vs benefit. Sodium benzoate is added to food for a reason – it delays spoilage by inhibiting microbial growth. Food spoilage has two large adverse effects, increasing food waste and increasing the risk of foodborne disease. This is therefore a good example of fear over something which is not actually a risk leading to bad decisions which increase a real risk.
In my research I also found it interesting that some dubious sources are claiming that sodium benzoate is actually a natural health product. Selfhacked, for example, writes:
Sodium benzoate (NaB) actually is a derivative (or metabolite) of cinnamon. While not as promising, studies also show that potassium sorbate (sorbic acid) and sodium sulfite can suppress Th1-type immune responses, which has an anti-inflammatory effect.
Interestingly, sodium benzoate decreases cholesterol, too, in the same manner, that statins do – by inhibiting an enzyme called HMG-CoA reductase. It’s in this manner that it has an anti-inflammatory effect.
It’s amazing how you can weave either type of narrative with the exact same substance. Selfhacked emphasizes the fact that sodium benzoate is derived from cinnamon, and has anti-inflammatory and cholesterol lowering effects. Meanwhile, other sources are claiming that it is a horrible artificial toxin that should be completely avoided. Both extremes are overinterpreting the scientific evidence and ignoring the role of dose. Sodium benzoate, as used, is a benign preservative. It is neither a health hazard nor a panacea.
What is perhaps most disappointing about the Panera Bread campaign is the degree to which they have embraced fearmongering and meme-based advertising. The video is blatantly manipulative, which is not surprising in itself as it is advertising. However, when such manipulation promotes the fear of innocent and useful food ingredients this adds to the collective harm that internet “clean eating” fear warriors are doing.
Not properly preserving food causes real harm and waste that we cannot afford. We need to use the best science available as our guide, not internet guru memes.

Phthalates and BPA: Of Mice and Men
Harriet HallonDecember 13, 2011
Link
Is your soup poisoning you? In a recent study subjects who ate canned vegetable soup had markedly increased levels of BPA in their urine compared to those who ate freshly prepared soup. We are constantly bombarded with alarmist warnings about the dangerous chemicals in the products we use. Especially BPA (Bisphenol A) and phthalates. Beware plastic bottles! Beware rubber ducks! And now, beware canned soup! BPA and phthalates are classified as endocrine disruptors. They have been discussed before on SBM here and here. BPA has been accused of causing everything from obesity to prostate cancer. Phthalates have been accused of causing everything from breast cancer to reduced anogenital distance in baby boys (the significance of this is unknown: there is not even any standard for what the normal distance is).
In the book Slow Death by Rubber Duck
Using a variety of test methods, the authors determined individual “body burdens,” or the toxic chemical load we carry. The innocuous rubber duck, for example, offers a poison soup of phthalates that “permeate the environment and humans.” From other products and food we also have a collection of chemicals shorthanded as PFCs, PFOAs, PSOSs, and PCBs. None of them are good, and they are everywhere…
Is this science or irresponsible fear-mongering? What does the best evidence tell us? Should we be afraid of our canned soup and rubber ducks?
Phthalates and BPA are ubiquitous and unavoidable. They are widely used in the manufacture of plastics, medical devices, and many consumer products. How dangerous are these and other common chemicals in our environment? Does it mean anything to have a high level of a chemical in our urine if the chemical is rapidly eliminated from the body and didn’t cause any harm while it was there? When does intelligent concern become irrational fear?
The canned soup study was reported in a “Research Letter” rather than as a typical peer-reviewed journal article. It was single-blind and its sole purpose was to measure “total BPA and conjugated species” in the urine. It did not even attempt to investigate whether there was any effect on the subjects’ health. The researchers themselves noted that the elevation of urinary BPA was transient and that further research is needed. They found the highest levels ever reported outside of occupational exposure, which raises questions. If levels this high are confirmed in other studies, that still doesn’t tell us whether such transient levels have any clinical significance.
I won’t attempt to cover the vast body of research on endocrine disruptors; but for those who are interested, Wikipedia provides useful compilations of studies on the health effects of phthalates and BPA. To summarize: research by chemical companies has generally shown no risk; studies elsewhere have raised many concerns, but results are inconsistent and inconclusive and often based on animal experiments with no confirmation in humans. The World Health Organization (WHO) and government agencies in various countries have concluded that current use is not risky, but a few groups have disagreed. Canada banned BPA in baby bottles as a precautionary measure.
What Do the Measurements Mean?
Measurement of these chemicals in urine is problematic. Nearly all the BPA found in the urine is in the form of metabolites. Trace levels of BPA found in some samples may be due to degradation of metabolites back to BPA after collection. It makes a difference which metabolite is chosen. One-time measurement is not likely to reflect overall exposure. Excretion varies by time of day and other confounding factors. These compounds are rapidly excreted from the body and may not stay around long enough to cause any problems. BPA is rapidly and completely metabolized into glucuronide, which is not estrogenic and is rapidly excreted in the urine. Even premature infants can metabolize it at the low levels involved. Rodents have a different metabolism. They excrete BPA through bile into the gut where it can be reabsorbed and has a longer half-life. Studies using IV administration are inapplicable to oral consumption.
Reassuring Reviews
Kamrin reviewed and analyzed all the available data in his 2009 article “Phthalate Risks, Phthalate Regulation, and Public Health: A Review.” He concluded that “the risks are low, even lower than originally thought, and that there is no convincing evidence of adverse effects on humans… [so] phthalate regulations that have been enacted are unlikely to lead to any marked improvement in public health.”
He says, “Early high-dose studies in animals suggested that phthalates might induce liver cancer in humans, but careful consideration of the mechanism of action, peroxisome proliferation, led to the conclusion that animal studies are not relevant for humans.” Animal studies can alert us to possible problems in humans, but they can also create false alarms. For instance, aspirin causes congenital defects in mice, but it has no such effects in humans.
Do combined exposures to multiple phthalates increase risk? He argues that they probably don’t, because individual exposures are so small that the total doesn’t approach effect levels, there is no evidence of additive effects in humans, and not all phthalates affect the body in the same way.
Epidemiological evidence is inconsistent and not persuasive. Adults and neonates who have been exposed to high levels of the phthalate DEHP from medical procedures do not exhibit the adverse effects seen in animals.The lowest levels at which adverse effects occur in sensitive animals are much higher than the doses to which humans are exposed.
There is further reassurance in a 2010 article by Witorsch and Thomas. They reviewed endocrine disruptors in personal care products and concluded “although select constituents exhibit interactions with the endocrine system in the laboratory, the evidence linking personal care products to endocrine disruptive effects in humans is for the most part lacking.”
Should We Be Worried?
We were once blissfully unaware of the trace amounts of all these things in our bodies. Our improving technology enables us to measure them and worry about them. My interpretation of the evidence on endocrine disruptors like phthalates and BPA is that the risks are still theoretical and unproven, that drastic measures are not warranted without more evidence, and that we need to keep an open mind and evaluate any new evidence as it comes along. As we do that, we need to keep a couple of things in mind:
    • We are not mice. Concerns from animal experiments can’t be automatically extrapolated to humans. Human studies are required.
    • We can’t protect ourselves from every conceivable risk. Trying to eliminate one risk often results in other, unforeseen ones. Banning BPA and phthalates would result in substituting other compounds that are more costly, may not work as well, and have not been as well tested for safety. BPA-free products are marketed for what they are not, not for what they are.
Conclusion
In my opinion, current evidence might be sufficient to justify banning phthalates and BPA for mice, but not for men. I’m not going stop eating canned food, and I’m not about to throw my rubber ducky away. I’m with Ernie.

Killer Tomatoes and Poisonous Potatoes?
Harriet Hall on February 14, 2012
Link
Remember the movie “Attack of the Killer Tomatoes”? That was fiction, but some alarmists would have us believe that the tomatoes and potatoes on our plates are really out to get us.
I recently got an e-mail inquiry from an MD who said he had read that solanine in tomatoes, potatoes, and eggplants could be responsible for essential hypertension and a number of GI complaints, as well as symptoms of rheumatoid arthritis, apparently through their inhibition of acetylcholinesterase. He had looked for supporting scientific studies and hadn’t found any. He wondered if I had seen any such studies. I looked too. I couldn’t find any either.
History
Tomatoes originated in the New World. They suffered from guilt by association because they were related to the deadly nightshade. Early on, they were used for witchcraft and as an aphrodisiac (“love apples”). They were slow to gain acceptance in Europe and the US, not coming into common use until the early 1800s. Thank goodness they finally did: without them, Italian food just wouldn’t be the same. Potatoes, another import from the New World, were also suspect: they were even accused of causing leprosy. Tomatoes are technically a fruit, although they are generally classified as a vegetable. Remember the attempt to count ketchup as a serving of vegetables in school lunches?
Solanine Poisoning Is Real
Solanine is indeed a poison in large doses, causing everything from gastrointestinal symptoms to hallucinations, paralysis and death. Large amounts are toxic, but the amounts usually found in food are innocuous. It is poorly absorbed and rapidly excreted. It is estimated that it would take 2–5mg per kilogram of body weight to produce toxic symptoms. A large potato weighs about 300g and has a solanine content of less than 0.2mg/gm That works out to around 0.03mg per kilogram for an adult, a hundredth of the toxic dose; I figure a murderous wife would have to feed something like 67 large potatoes to her husband in a single meal to poison him. Unless he’s a phenomenally big eater, arsenic would be a better bet. Potatoes that are diseased with blight or that have sprouted have a larger than usual amount of solanine. They will have a bitter taste and often a green discoloration; such potatoes should be avoided. Even integrative health guru Andrew Weil is not afraid of solanine, pointing out that there hasn’t been a single case of solanine poisoning in the US from eating potatoes in the last 50 years.
Solanine Toxicity Syndrome Isn’t
I found information about “Solanine Toxicity Syndrome” on the website of a chiropractor who uses bogus muscle testing (AK) to diagnose it. He finds that almost all arthritic patients test positive. He claims that in sensitive patients, solanine can:
    • act as an endocrine disruptor especially to the thyroid
    • cause chronic joint pain, arthritis (all forms), joint inflammation- this is due to solanines ability to remove calcium from the bones and deposit it in any weak or genetically predisposed area of the body
    • for the same reason it can be a major contributor to osteoporosis (since it removes calcium from the bones) and arteriosclerosis (it can deposit the calcium in the blood vessels)
    • “leaky gut” as well as IBS
    • appendicitis
    • birth defects including spina bifida
    • depression (correcting it in one patient stopped their strong suicidal tendencies)
    • migraines
    • greatly interfere with calcium and vitamin D absorption, despite supplementation
Scientific Evidence
This will be a very short section. He doesn’t provide references. I looked for credible published evidence to support these claims. I couldn’t find a thing.
Testimonial “Evidence”
He describes his moment of epiphany. While he was treating one of his chiropractic patients, he happened to mention that he had been having pain, stiffness, and swelling in his hands, especially in the mornings (symptoms suggestive of rheumatoid arthritis). The patient asked him if he had eaten eggplant parmesan last night. He had! There you go! That must mean that dietary solanine is hazardous to your health, right? For someone who believes in AK, that was easy enough to believe. Practice makes perfect: the White Queen in Through the Looking Glass practiced believing as many as six impossible things before breakfast. Believers don’t need no stinkin’ science.
There are a number of testimonials in various places on the Internet from individuals who claim to be unusually “sensitive” to solanine, but no controlled studies to support such claims.
Should We Avoid All These Foods?
Solanine-containing foods from the nightshade family include:
    • potatoes
    • tomatoes
    • paprika
    • eggplant
    • peppers
Foods that are not part of the nightshade family but that also contain solanine include:
    • Blueberries
    • Apples
    • Cherries
    • Sugar beets
    • Huckleberries
    • Okra
    • Artichokes
All these foods can be part of a healthy diet. Their solanine content is not a concern. It’s hard enough to get people to eat their vegetables without this kind of irresponsible fear-mongering.
Bottom line: Avoid green potatoes; otherwise, no worries!

IgG Food Intolerance Tests: What does the science say?
Scott Gavura on February 2, 2012
Link
I spend a lot of time as a pharmacist discussing side effects and allergies to drugs. For your own safety, I won’t recommend or dispense a drug until I know your allergy status. I don’t limit the history to drugs—I want to know anything you’re allergic to, be it environmental, food, insects, or anything else. Allergies can create true therapeutic challenges: We can’t dismiss any allergy claim, but as I’ve blogged before, there’s a big gap between what many perceive as an allergy and what is clinically considered a true allergy. My concern is not only avoiding the harm of an allergic reaction, but also avoiding the potential consequences from selecting a suboptimal therapy that may in fact be appropriate. You may need a specific drug someday, so I encourage patients to discuss vague drug allergies with their physician, and request allergist testing as required.
Food allergies can be as real as drug allergies, and are arguably much harder to prevent. We can usually control when we get penicillin. But what about peanuts, eggs, or milk, all of which can also cause life-threatening anaphylaxis? Food allergies seems to be growing: not only anaphylaxis, but more people believe they have some sort of allergy to food. Allergy is sometimes confused with the term “intolerance”, which seems more common, possibly as the availability of “food intolerance testing” grows. Food intolerance testing and screening is particularly popular among alternative practitioners. Testing can take different forms, but generally the consumer is screened against hundreds of food products and food additives. They are then provided with a list of foods they are “intolerant” to. I’ve spoken with consumers who are struggling to overhaul their diet, having been advised that they are actually intolerant to many of their favourite foods. These reports are taken seriously by patients who believe that they’ll feel better if they eliminate these products. In the pharmacy, I’ve been asked to verify the absence of trace amounts of different fillers in medications because of a perceived intolerance. Children may be tested, too, and parents may be given a long list of foods they are told their child is intolerant of. I’ve seen the effects in the community, too. Think going “peanut free” is tough? A public school in my area sent home a list of forbidden food products: dairy, eggs, bananas, tree nuts, peanuts, soy, sesame, flax seed, kiwi, chicken, and bacon. Were these all true allergies? It’s not disclosed. Anaphylactic or not, the parents had informed the school, and the school had banned the food product.
But can a simple blood test actually identify and eliminate food intolerance? That’s the question I wanted to answer.
When it comes to food intolerance testing, blood tests are just the start. Other methods used include vega testing, the K-Test, hair testing,and applied kinesiology. But the blood tests are enjoying new popularity—and even pharmacies are now actively promoting these tests:
You might love food, but some food might not love you
The HEMOCODE Food Intolerance System can unlock your hidden food sensitivities
Speak with your Rexall Pharmacist today to learn about a painless blood test that can identify over 250 common foods that may be causing you unpleasant symptoms such as chronic fatigue, migraines, back pain, fibromyalgia, psoriasis, acne, diarrhea and constipation.
There’s a short video (above) that is very illustrative. Narrated by a pharmacist, it describes that a simple fingertip blood test is used to screen blood against 250 items. Test results are then reviewed by “naturopathic medical professionals” who will describe the foods and other products that you are intolerant to, and your degree of intolerance. You’re also advised:
Your personalized results also include recommended vitamins and supplements that are uniquely suited to the customer, based on the foods that are suggested to be eliminated from your diet, which are themselves, uniquely personal.
So the $450 blood test, includes dietary change recommendations as well as vitamin and supplement recommendation. The vendor explains it as follows:
By adding personalized vitamin and supplement recommendations, the Hemocode System will help consumers move towards optimal nutrition as they work to eliminate offending foods from their diets. No other food intolerance program offers this type of seamlessly delivered, highly customized solution. In addition to delivering a meaningful wellness benefit to their customers, the inclusion of dietary supplement recommendations as part of Hemocode creates an opportunity for retailers to recognize: accretive revenue from Hemocode System sales; incremental growth in their core vitamin program and an enhancement of their market differentiation.
This testing is also positioned as a weight loss plan:
Would I be able to lose weight with HEMOCODE?Your chances of permanent success are excellent: HEMOCODE(TM) works differently than other conventional diets and rules out the yoyo-effect.
Is HEMOCODE a miracle diet?It is not a miracle diet, but a scientifically based diet modification. Unlocking your HEMOCODE(TM) gets to the root of your problem. Food intolerances can be the cause of a weight problem and inhibit the success of losing weight with conventional diets. The HEMOCODE(TM) test looks at foods on a one-by-one basis for individual intolerances.
Hemocode is just one of several blood tests that’s marketed. There’s also the YorkTest in the United Kingdom and also Canada:
Food intolerance is all about how your bodys immune system the bodys natural defence against foreign substances, such as poisons and harmful bacteria reacts to specific foods. [sic]
Food intolerances are believed to arise when certain, incompletely digested food particles enter your bloodstream and are treated as foreign substances. This results in your immune system producing tailor-made antibodies (IgG), which attack the food in question. Some researchers believe this inflammatory response in the body can increase certain symptoms. Food intolerance has been associated with Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS), bloating, tiredness, constipation, diarrhea, cramping, eczema, headaches and migraines.
So just what is the evidence supporting the use of food intolerance tests?
Testing Principles
Diagnostic tests can be as pseudoscientific as treatments. To evaluate, we ask the following:
    • Analytic validity: How reliable is the testing? This includes within-laboratory and between-laboratory precision.
    • Clinical validity: How consistently and accurately does the test detect an objectively-measured clinical status? The test should be both sensitive (few false negatives) and specific (few false positives). Patients in the same circumstances should consistently have the same test results.
    • Clinical utility: What is the natural history of the disorder? Will the use of the test make any difference in the outcome? Interventions taken should be evaluated and compared against no testing.
    • Ethical, legal, or social implications : What are the potential patient consequences of the use of the test, and its results? What if the results are erroneous?
It all boils down to a single question that must be satisfactorily answered before we proceed with testing: How has this test been validated?
What’s a Food Intolerance Blood Test Actually Testing?
Hemocode is an IgG blood test, according to the manufacturer (text now removed; cached version here):
The Hemocode System is a finger prick test that identifies specific immune system-based food intolerances.
Everything we eat can elicit a positive or negative reaction in the body. If you are intolerant to a certain food and you continue to eat it, your body will mount an inflammatory reaction which may manifest in a variety of lifestyle-affecting conditions such as headaches, chronic pain, digestive disorders and many other issues
The Hemocode food intolerance test is a statistically proven, doctor and pharmacist recommended IgG-related test that determines which foods are causing negative reactions.
The YorkTest is also an IgG test. There is no published information in the literature that describes either the Hemocode or the Yorktest, or their analytic validity for any of the products tested for.
Understanding IgE, allergies, and what IgG means
Food allergies are reaction to food proteins. They may be categorized as immunoglobulin E (IgE)–mediated (immediate) reactions, non–IgE-mediated (delayed) hypersensitivity reactions, and mixed reactions. IgE-mediated reactions are the ones we worry about when we hear about a “food allergy”: flushing, itchy skin, wheezing, vomiting, throat swelling, and even anaphylaxis. These reactions can occur immediately following exposure, and are the consequence of the interaction of allergens with IgE located on mast cells. The interaction causes the release of inflammatory chemicals like histamine and leucotriene, triggering the the allergic response which is typically skin related (itchiness, swelling and rash) but may be anaphylactic as well.
Not all reactions follow this cascade. Non-IgE-mediated allergic reactions can cause localized (e.g., contact dermatitis) or generalized reactions, which are usually gastrointestinal or dermatological in nature. Celiac disease is a non-IgE related allergic reaction. Finally, some allergic disorders are both IgE and non-IgE mediated, such as atopic dermatitis (eczema).
Beyond the IgE mediated reactions, there are a number of possible reactions to food, which may be termed “food intolerances”. Not immune-system based, they’re more common than allergies. They include conditions like lactose intolerance, gastroesophageal reflux (GERD), enzyme deficiencies, metabolic conditions, infections and other processes. It’s a catch-all term by definition.
So where does immunoglobulin G (IgG) come in? IgG molecules mediate interactions of cells with different cellular and humoral mechanisms. IgG antibodies signify exposure to products—not allergy. IgG may actually be a marker for food tolerance, not intolerance, some research suggests:
    • Children with eczema and egg or milk allergies with higher levels of IgG to milk/egg were more likely to be tolerant of these foods at a later age.
    • Resolution of cow’s milk allergy is associated with increasing IgG
    • A study found increasing IgG in patients who underwent oral immunotherapy for milk or peanut allergy
That research is continuing. But given the lack of correlation between the presence of IgG and physical manifestations of illness, IgG testing is considered unproven as a diagnostic agent as the results lack clinical utility as a tool for dietary modification or food elimination.
The Evidence Check
I sought to understand the literature supporting IgG blood tests. There are no citations on the Hemocode website, and the term Hemocode does not appear in Pubmed. The Yorktest website cites a placebo-controlled study which it claims demonstrates its IgG test reduced symptoms in patients already diagnosed with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS). This finding has been criticized for multiple shortcomings, suggesting the effectiveness of the test in this population remains to be established.
In light of the lack of published clinical trials that validate Hemocode or Yorktest, I looked for consensus opinions and statements on IgG testing from allergy and immunology experts. Here’s what I found, emphasis added:
From the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology & American College of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology: Allergy diagnostic testing: an updated practice parameter:
IgG and IgG subclass antibody tests for food allergy do not have clinical relevance, are not validated, lack sufficient quality control, and should not be performed.
And from the the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology (AAAAI) Practice Paper, Current approach to the diagnosis and management of adverse reactions to foods [PDF]:
Some tests are considered unproven in regard to the diagnosis of specific food allergies. Those for which there is no evidence of validity include provocation-neutralization, cytotoxic tests, muscle response testing (applied kinesiology), electrodermal testing, the “reaginic” pulse test, and chemical analysis of body tissues. Measurement of specific IgG antibodies to foods is also unproven as a diagnostic tool.
From the European Academy of Allergy and Clinical Immunology [PDF]:
Testing for blood IgG4 against different foods is performed with large-scale screening for hundreds of food items by enzyme—linked immunosorbent assay-type and radioallergosorbent-type assays in young children, adolescents and adults. However, many serum samples show positive IgG4 results without corresponding clinical symptoms. These findings, combined with the lack of convincing evidence for histamine-releasing properties of IgG4 in humans, and lack of any controlled studies on the diagnostic value of IgG4 testing in food allergy, do not provide any basis for the hypothesis that food-specific IgG4 should be attributed with an effector role in food hypersensitivity.
In contrast to the disputed beliefs, IgG4 against foods indicates that the organism has been repeatedly exposed to food components, recognized as foreign proteins by the immune system. Its presence should not be considered as a factor which induces hypersensitivity, but rather as an indicator for immunological tolerance, linked to the activity of regulatory T cells. In conclusion, food-specific IgG4 does not indicate (imminent) food allergy or intolerance, but rather a physiological response of the immune system after exposition to food components. Therefore, testing of IgG4 to foods is considered as irrelevant for the laboratory work-up of food allergy or intolerance and should not be performed in case of food-related complaints.
From the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases Guidelines for the Diagnosis and Management of Food Allergy in the United States [PDF]:
4.2.2.9. Nonstandardized and Unproven Procedures; Guideline 12:
The (Expert Panel) recommends not using any of the following nonstandardized tests for the routine evaluation of IgE-mediated (food allergy):
    • Basophil histamine release/activation
    • Lymphocyte stimulation
    • Facial thermography
    • Gastric juice analysis
    • Endoscopic allergen provocation
    • Hair analysis
    • Applied kinesiology
    • Provocation neutralization
    • Allergen-specific IgG4
    • Cytotoxicity assays
    • Electrodermal test (Vega)
    • Mediator release assay (LEAP diet)
From the Australasian Society of Clinical Immunology and Allergy (ASCIA):
Inappropriate use of Conventional Testing: Food specific IgG, IgG4; Use: Diagnosis of food sensitivity / allergy.
Method: Antibodies to food are measured using standard laboratory techniques.
Evidence: Level II
Comment: IgG antibodies to food are commonly detectable in healthy adult patients and children, independent of the presence of absence of food-related symptoms. There is no credible evidence that measuring IgG antibodies is useful for diagnosing food allergy or intolerance, nor that IgG antibodies cause symptoms. In fact, IgG antibodies reflect exposure to allergen but not the presence of disease. The exception is that gliadin IgG antibodies are sometimes useful in monitoring adherence to a gluten-free diet patients with histologically confirmed coeliac disease. Otherwise, inappropriate use of food allergy testing (or misinterpretation of results) in patients with inhalant allergy, for example, may lead to inappropriate and unnecessary dietary restrictions, with particular nutritional implications in children. Despite studies showing the uselessness of this technique, it continues to be promoted in the community, even for diagnosing disorders for which no evidence of immune system involvement exists.
From the Allergy Society of South Africa, Position Statement: ALCAT and IgG Allergy & Intolerance Tests [PDF]:
We are constantly consulted by colleagues, health funders and practitioners about the reliability and appropriateness of the ALCAT and IgG food allergy tests for patients with suspected allergies and other disorders. We would like to provide the following information to the readership of the journal and to the public.The manufacturers and suppliers of ALCAT and the IgG test claim that the tests have diagnostic value in identifying substances responsible for allergic and intolerance reactions. These tests are being marketed directly to the public and health professionals, claiming to be more effective than traditional skin prick tests or serum specific IgE tests, particularly for delayed allergic reactions. The manufacturers of the ALCAT test argue that orthodox allergy practice does not recognize delayed allergic reactions, when in fact these reactions are universally acknowledged to play a role in up to 30% of the spectrum of allergic reactions!To date neither ALCAT nor IgG has been shown to have any predictive value in the diagnosis of allergy or intolerances.
and
The second test marketed with insufficient documentation is the IgG test for food allergies. Specific IgE determination and its diagnostic value have been documented for over three decades in being specific for allergic disorders. Although IgG does play a role in the allergic response, there is no evidence to suggest that it has a diagnostic value in predicting food allergens or other substances that may be affecting individuals. The IgG test is also marketed as effective in predicting foods implicated in Attention Deficit Disorder and obesity. There is no published evidence for these claims.
I also found review papers from immunologists and allergy experts:
From the Department of Pediatric Pneumology and Immunology, University Children’s Hospital Charité, Berlin: Unproven diagnostic procedures in IgE-mediated allergic diseases [PDF]:
The determination of specific IgG-antibodies in serum does not correspond with oral food challenges (5). In cow’s milk intolerance proved by oral challenge, no increased IgG-antibodies could be found (6). IgG milkspecific antibody levels are similar in children with early and late-type clinical reactions (7). Furthermore, there is no evidence that IgG subclasses (8) or the IgE/IgG4 antibody ratio (9) are reliable diagnostic tools. A study of 27 children with hen’s egg allergy found that children with a positive challenge tended to have a higher IgE/IgG 4 ratio and a higher IgG1/IgG4 ratio than those with anegative challenge test, but concluded that oral provocations are still necessary to confirm diagnosis of food allergy (10). A large study in 601 newborns, infants, children and adults showed that the determination of IgA and IgM antibodies did not contribute to the diagnosis of food allergy (11). Since IgG-antibodies to common dietary antigens can be detected in health and disease (12), the determination of food-specific IgG is of no clinical relevance (13) and should not be part of the diagnostic work-up of food allergy.
From the Department of Paediatrics, National University Hospital , Singapore, Diagnostic tests for food allergy [PDF]:
INAPPROPRIATE TESTS :Food-specific IgG testsTests for food-specific IgG are marketed as IgG radioallergosorbent tests and vary in offering measurements of total IgG toward a food, or IgG4 with or without food immune complex assay. The measurement of such specific IgG antibodies and their subclasses, primarily IgG4, is based on the fact that the titre falls after a period of withdrawal of the specific food antigen.Thus, some physicians opt to use such a modality to diagnose food allergies. Unfortunately, the determination of specific IgG antibodies in serum does not correspond with oral food challenges.(43) Burks et al conducted a study of antibody responses to milk proteins in patients with milk-protein intolerance proved by oral challenge, and found that no increase in IgG antibodies was noted.(44) In another study, Shek et al concluded that foodspecific IgG or IgG4 does not add any information to the diagnostic workup of food allergy.(45) Furthermore, most people develop IgG antibodies to foods that they eat, and this is a normal immune response indicating exposure but not allergic sensitisation.(20) Recent studies have shown that the IgG response may even be protective, and thus prevents or protects against the development of IgE food allergy. Hence, there is no convincing evidence to suggest that this test has any diagnostic value for allergy.
Other reviews and commentary identified included the following:
From the UK House of Lords Science and Technology—Sixth Report on Allergy:
We are concerned both that the results of allergy self testing kits available to the public are being interpreted without the advice of appropriately trained healthcare personnel, and that the IgG food antibody test is being used to diagnose food intolerance in the absence of stringent scientific evidence. We recommend further research into the relevance of IgG antibodies in food intolerance, and with the establishment of more allergy centres, the necessary controlled clinical trials should be conducted. We urge general practitioners, pharmacists and charities not to endorse the use of these products until conclusive proof of their efficacy has been established.
From the Food Allergy Initiative:
IgG Testing: This test checks your blood for the presence of food-specific immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibodies. Unlike IgE antibodies, which occur in abnormally large quantities in people with allergies, IgG antibodies are found in both allergic and non-allergic people. Experts believe that the production of IgG antibodies is a normal response to eating food and that this test is not helpful in diagnosing a food allergy.
Interestingly, IgG tests are also rejected as unproven by at least one insurer, Aetna:
IgG RAST/ELISA Testing: There is no evidence that IgG antibodies are responsible for delayed allergic symptoms or intolerance to foods.
A consumer advocacy group investigated different allergy tests, including IgG, and noted the following:
Researchers from the consumer group trialled alternative tests that claim to diagnose food intolerances through analysis of blood samples or strands of hair, changes in electric current, or resistance to pressure applied to their legs or arms. They found that:
    • The tests diagnosed 183 intolerances – although the researchers actually had just one medically confirmed allergy and one food intolerance between them
    • Identical blood and hair samples sent under different names to the same company produced different test results
    • There was little or no overlap between test results from different companies
    • The testers felt the practitioners applied more pressure when measuring resistance for certain foods – which they were then told to avoid
    • The tests recommended excluding up to 39 foods – which could make it difficult to eat a balanced diet and lead to nutritional problems.
The tests cost between £45 and £275 each, but an expert panel of medical specialists and a dietitian that assessed the results felt that none had diagnostic value for genuine allergies or intolerances.
The UK’s Advertising Standards Authority has evaluated the marketing of the YorkTest and the claim the test is clinically validated, and noted the following:
YorkTest provided three papers to support their claims for the FoodSCAN intolerance tests and believed those showed that the presence of IgG antibodies in the blood was indicative of food intolerances. however, we were concerned that the studies were conducted on people suffering from chronic medical conditions such as IBS and migraine and considered that those findings did not support a general claim for diagnosis of food intolerance. We noted one of the studies was published in an academic peer-reviewed journal, but also noted that although the study concluded that IgG tests may have a role in the treatment of irritable bowel syndrome symptoms, it did not refer to food intolerance among the general population and also stated that futher clinical research was required. We acknowledged that the independent charity Allergy UK endorsed YorkTest’s FoodSCAN range with one of their Consumer Awards but also noted this was based on anecdotal evidence (self-reporting) that individuals felt they were benefiting from using the tests. We concluded that the evidence submitted was not sufficiently robust to prove the efficacy of the tests for diagnosing food allergy or intolerance.
On this point, the ads breached CAP Code clauses 3.1 (Substantiation) 7.1 (Truthfulness) 50.1 (Health Beauty and Therapies)
Conclusion
At present, there are no reliable and validated clinical tests for the diagnosis of food intolerance. While intolerances are non-immune by definition, IgG testing is actively promoted for diagnosis, and to guide management. These tests lack both a sound scientific rationale and evidence of effectiveness. The lack of correlation between results and actual symptoms, and the risks resulting from unnecessary food avoidance, escalate the potential for harm from this test. Further, there is no published clinical evidence to support the use of IgG tests to determine the need for vitamins or supplements. In light of the lack of clinical relevance, and the potential for harm resulting from their use, allergy and immunology organizations worldwide advise against the use of IgG testing for food intolerance.

IgG food intolerance tests continue to mislead consumers into unnecessary dietary restrictions
IgG food intolerance testing is ineffective, yet it continues to be promoted to consumers. CBC Marketplace recently investigated two Canadian companies that sell these tests.
Scott Gavura on November 15, 2018
Link


Several years ago I wrote about what was then an emerging and concerning service offered by pharmacies and endorsed by naturopaths: “Food Intolerance” testing with claims that a simple blood test could identify foods that you were intolerant to. There was never any credible science to substantiate these tests, and over time I was relieved to see most pharmacies (in Canada, at least) drop them, while one of the major purveyors seems to have closed up shop in Canada completely. Whether that was due to growing recognition that this direct-to-consumer testing was effectively useless, or some other reason, I am not sure but I was just relieved to see it disappear. Or so I thought. Like any other form of alternative medicine, there will always be the true believers – or at least those prepared to sell you a test, whether it’s validated, or not.
Recently the CBC television show Marketplace did an excellent deconstruction of IgG testing. It’s worth watching in its entirety, but I’ll use the episode to illustrate just how IgG testing is clinically useless and arguably harmful.
Allergies and intolerances – What’s the difference?
Food allergies are reaction to food proteins. They may be categorized as immunoglobulin E (IgE)–mediated (immediate) reactions, non–IgE-mediated (delayed) hypersensitivity reactions, and mixed reactions. IgE-mediated reactions are the ones we worry about when we hear about a “food allergy”: flushing, itchy skin, wheezing, vomiting, throat swelling, and even anaphylaxis. These reactions can occur immediately following exposure, and are the consequence of the interaction of allergens with IgE. The reaction leads to the rapid release of inflammatory chemicals that trigger the reaction which is typically skin related (itching, swelling, rash) but can be severe- to life-threatening anaphylaxis.
Not all reactions follow this cascade. Non-IgE-mediated allergic reactions can cause localized (e.g., contact dermatitis) or generalized reactions, which are usually gastrointestinal or dermatological in nature. Celiac disease is a non-IgE related allergic reaction. Finally, some allergic disorders are both IgE and non-IgE mediated, such as atopic dermatitis (eczema).
Beyond the IgE mediated reactions, there are a number of possible reactions to food, some of which may be called a “food intolerance”. They include conditions like lactose intolerance, gastroesophageal reflux (GERD), and anything else attributed to food. “Intolerance” is a catch-all term.
When you see advertising promoting “Food Intolerance” testing, it’s a test for immunoglobulin G (IgG). IgG antibodies signify exposure to products—not allergy. IgG antibody testing will identify what you ate recently – there is no correlation between an IgG test result and your ability to eat that food without distress. In fact, some research suggests IgG may actually be a marker for food tolerance, not intolerance. Given the lack of correlation between the presence of IgG and physical manifestations of illness, IgG testing is considered unproven as a diagnostic agent as the results lack clinical utility as a tool for dietary modification or food elimination. As the Australasian Society of Clinical Immunology and Allergy notes, IgG testing is a useful as iridology or kinesiology – in other words, it’s not useful at all:
Vega testing, kinesiology, allergy elimination techniques, iridology, pulse testing, Alcat testing, Rinkel’s intradermal skin testing, reflexology, hair analysis and IgG food antibody testing have all been proposed as being useful for diagnosing allergic conditions or food intolerances. Not only do these tests lack any scientific rationale, but have been shown to be inaccurate and poorly reproducible when subjected to careful study. Treatment based on inaccurate results is not only misleading, but can result in ineffective and sometimes harmful treatments, and delay more effective therapy.
The Marketplace sting
CBC Marketplace took a very straightforward approach to evaluating the claims made by IgG testing advocates – they compared them to reality:
To test the accuracy of these food sensitivity tests, Marketplace ran several different kinds on host Charlsie Agro, including drawing blood for the IgG tests offered by Dynacare and Rocky Mountain Analytical, which is owned by LifeLabs. Both tests require a requisition from a naturopathic doctor or licensed physician. LifeLabs’ test is typically offered through naturopaths or other health outlets, however, while Dynacare’s food intolerance test is advertised and promoted directly to the consumer in its clinics. The results from the Rocky Mountain Analytical test reported intolerances to 52 foods, while Dynacare reported 30 intolerances.
Before taking the tests, Agro had tracked what she was eating. Yet both tests reported intolerances to foods she regularly consumed, with absolutely no adverse reactions. For example, Agro had a smoothie, which included flax seeds, for breakfast daily. Yet both tests suggested Agro is intolerant to flax. She also ate vegetable soup — containing barley, kidney beans and corn — without problem. Both IgG tests again claimed Agro is intolerant to these foods. Both sets of lab results also showed Agro is “intolerant” of egg whites, all milks, wheat and gluten — all foods she eats regularly without issue.
The IgG test, as expected, identified food that Agro had consumed recently – not foods that she had any difficulty tolerating. It’s easy to see how this type of testing could lead to disordered eating, potentially causing someone to totally transform their diet in the belief that they are “intolerant” to their regular diet. These tests are not harmless, as allergists noted:
Dr. Douglas Mack, a pediatric allergy, asthma and immunology specialist, argues the results of an IgG test are an indication that you had exposure to the foods — not an intolerance of them. IgG tests measure levels of an antibody known as Immunoglobulin G — or IgG, for short. “It should be used to track whether a patient actually is developing tolerance, not intolerance,” he said.
Interpreting the test otherwise is not only incorrect, but potentially hazardous to your health, Mack argues. By unnecessarily eliminating foods, he says he sees “kids that are coming in with nutritional deficiencies, with failure to grow very well.” Removing foods from your diet could also lead to development of a food allergy, especially in children, says Mack. One young patient of his developed a milk allergy after eliminating it from his diet when a food sensitivity test suggested he had a milk intolerance. “If these tests result in the harm of a child, we really gotta think twice about whether or not these labs should be offering these,” he said.
In response, both LifeLabs and Dynacare provided citations in support of their claims about IgG testing. I’d review them for you, but the CBC already did that.
Social media hype
Instagram seems to be THE place to promote your product these days, and food intolerance advertising masquerading as unbiased testimonials are widespread. It’s reported that companies like Pinnertest buy social medial followers and pay “influencers” thousands of dollars to promote its $490 IgG blood testing:
“If this test has any value, we will see literature that would be published to prove this test really could be useful,” Alessio Fasano, a pediatric gastroenterologist at Harvard Medical School, told BuzzFeed News. “But honestly, I haven’t seen anything like this so far. In the literature, in practice, I don’t see it.”
STATnews called the IgG test widely marketed by Everlywell “medically dubious” quoting multiple experts who are critical of the testing:
Patients who ask Dr. Robert Wood, an allergist at Johns Hopkins Children’s Center, whether they have a food sensitivity would never undergo an immunoglobulin G test. Immunoglobulin G tests “are completely useless and do dramatic harm” because they may compel patients to unnecessarily avoid broad swaths of a healthy diet, Wood said. “In all my years of practice, I have never sent an immunoglobulin G test because they have no ability to predict food sensitivity,” he said.
And:
Dr. Martha Hartz, an allergist at Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn., says she frequently evaluates patients who’ve already forked over the cash for the testing. “Anytime I see a patient who’s had these kinds of tests, we get them to toss it aside,” Hartz said. “It has no relevance to anything. It is just not a test that should done.”
Believe the evidence, not the vendors
While food intolerances are non-immune by definition, IgG testing continues to be widely promoted as a diagnostic tool, and to guide dietary choices. There is no credible evidence to support IgG testing by consumer laboratories to identify food intolerances. The CBC Marketplace episode highlighted how IgG testing has the potential to harm, not help consumers. It’s not surprising, then, that major allergy and immunology organizations worldwide advise against IgG testing.

IgG Food Sensitivity Tests Not Valid
IgG testing for food sensitivity has not been validated by scientific evidence – that does not stop CAM practitioners.
Steven Novella on October 18, 2023
Link

An increasingly common alternative medicine intervention is to diagnose patients with a food sensitivity and then prescribe eliminating that food from the diet. This all sounds very “integrative” and scientific. After all, food allergies are a real thing. The diagnosis often comes from taking a thorough history, and is then “confirmed” with a blood test, showing antibodies to the offending food. Eliminating the food will then often seem to help whatever subjective symptoms are of concern through nothing more than placebo effects. In this way an entire modality of medical intervention can seem quite legitimate, even if it is based on nothing. That is the essence of integrative or alternative medicine – they never bother to do (or they simply ignore) the kinds of research that would determine whether or not a reasonable sounding idea is actually true. If an intervention is proven in this way then it’s just medicine, and does not have to be “integrated”.
While food allergies are real and demonstrable, food “sensitivities” are controversial and not supported by sufficient scientific evidence. An allergic reaction is a specific immune hypersensitivity that involves a specific type of antibody known as IgE, and activates cells that release chemicals that cause the allergic reaction. Reactions are often unequivocal, causing a visible rash, runny eyes, swelling, and even difficulty breathing. Severe allergic reactions can be life threatening.
There is also a category of reactions to food known as food intolerance, but these have nothing to do with the immune system. A food intolerance typically results from digestive problems. The most common type is lactose intolerance, which results from a paucity of the enzyme lactase, which is necessary to digest the lactose sugar in dairy products.
A food sensitivity is neither an allergy nor an intolerance, but is alleged to be a more subtle immune response that causes – well, whatever ails you. That leaves a lot of wiggle room to impose the diagnosis on patients, because it does not require objective clinical findings and can be matched to a host of possible symptoms. One CAM site gives a typical description:
But what many people don’t know is that food sensitivities can affect our health and our moods. What’s more, food sensitivities are largely undiagnosed. While they may be less scary than a food allergy, these mysterious and highly individualistic food sensitivities can still make us experience unpleasant and unwanted symptoms.
Mysterious and individualistic – very CAM. A positive review of the concept of food sensitivity in migraine headaches noted:
“While food sensitivities and intolerances are recognized within the clinical medicine community, diagnosing these sensitivities and intolerances can be challenging because symptoms are usually delayed hours to days and may not occur after every exposure to the allergen.”
This is a pattern we are very familiar with at SBM – a variable delay between exposure and symptoms, and an inconsistent relationship. This does not prove by itself that the correlation is spurious, but it is highly suspicious. Such an inconsistent pattern is ripe for confirmation bias. It’s also hard to disprove – you can’t just do a challenge test, because the reaction does not always occur.
This is also where the IgG testing comes in, because it gives the appearance of legitimacy and objectivity to an otherwise nebulous syndrome. What is more scientific in medicine than a blood test? However, as the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics summarizes:
IgG antibodies have not been shown to reliably identify either food allergies or sensitivities. Most people produce IgG antibodies after eating food. They are not specific to a person’s sensitivity, although past or frequent exposure to a food may cause these levels to be higher.
Studies have not validated IgG antibody testing as a clinical test. But the full story is a bit more complex, so let’s look at what’s published. It does seem that IgG antibody titers can increase after ingestion of certain foods. The question is – are these antibodies causing any symptoms or clinical syndrome. There is also evidence that some of these IgG antibodies may increase gut permeability. However, critically:
Notably, neither IgG titers to wheat, eggs, and dairy, nor permeability biomarkers, were increased in symptomatic participants compared to those without symptoms.
So the research has not closed the loop – whatever is happening does not appear to correlate with actual symptoms. This is also a pattern we commonly see – biology is complex, and often if you look at a basic science level you will see that stuff is happening. But we cannot simply extrapolate from the fact that biomarkers are changing to any specific clinical outcome. Biomarkers are a notoriously poor predictor of net clinical outcomes, unless clinical research specifically shows a connection. Here we are explicitly seeing no connection between IgG food titers and symptoms.
In fact the research shows that increases in IgG titers after ingesting food is a normal immune response, without any clinical implications. If anything, a specific subtype – IgG4 – may be associated with tolerance of food, because these antibodies block the allergy causing IgE antibodies.
Several companies provide panels of IgG testing for food sensitivity. But they have never validated their tests. They have not demonstrate that repeated testing, for example, gives the same results. Perhaps whatever antibodies are detected are determined entirely by what the subject recently ate, and would be different every time. They have not demonstrated that IgG titers predict a positive response to removing the target foods from the diet. This is why, as the AAAAI states:
Due to the lack of evidence to support its use, many organizations, including the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma & Immunology and the Canadian Society of Allergy and Clinical Immunology have recommended against using IgG testing to diagnose food allergies or food intolerances / sensitivities.
IgG antibody testing for food sensitivity is a classic example of the difference between CAM and science-based medicine. The only real functional difference is that the latter relies upon scientific evidence and the former does not.

The Obesity Paradox
Harriet Hall on September 25, 2012
Link
Being fat is bad except when it’s good. It’s called “the obesity paradox.” (No, that isn’t a mis-spelling for “two physicians who treat fat people.”) The adverse health effects of obesity are well established, but there are exceptions. Obesity appears to confer an advantage in certain subgroups with conditions like heart disease and diabetes.
In the News
Casual consumers of some recent media reports might interpret them as an excuse to stop trying to lose excess weight, especially if they are diabetic. Others might think we have been lied to about the dangers of the obesity epidemic. The reality is more complicated.
An article in the NY Times asks:
Obesity is the primary risk factor for Type 2 diabetes, yet sizable numbers of normal-weight people also develop the disease. Why?
The question is a bit misguided and the answer is simple. Obesity is the primary risk factor but that doesn’t mean it is the only risk factor or the cause of the disease, and non-obese patients who develop diabetes obviously have other risk factors. We know Type 2 diabetes is a multifactorial disease involving interactions between genetic, environmental, and lifestyle factors.
The article highlights recent research showing that:
Diabetes patients of normal weight are twice as likely to die as those who are overweight or obese.
And not just in diabetes:
In study after study, overweight and moderately obese patients with certain chronic diseases often live longer and fare better than normal-weight patients with the same ailments.
That’s true. Overweight and obese patients undergoing dialysis have better outcomes. Overweight people have better outcomes from heart failure and peripheral artery disease. After cardiac revascularization surgery, obese patients have similar or lower mortality rates compared to non-obese patients.
A simple interpretation of these findings might be that obesity must not really cause diabetes, that being obese is healthier than being non-obese, and that the concern about an “obesity epidemic” is misplaced. As usual, simple is wrong; reality is more complex.
Obesity and Diabetes
If you are overweight, the most effective thing you can do to prevent diabetes is to lose weight. The Diabetes Prevention Program study of patients with prediabetes showed that weight loss was the primary predictor of risk for developing the disease. Weight loss and exercise lowered the risk by 58%. Losing 5-10% of body weight significantly reduces blood sugars and allows many type 2 diabetic patients to get off their insulin and medications. The ADA recommends weight loss both to improve diabetic control and to reduce the risk of complications.
If you already have diabetes, there is evidence that losing weight is beneficial. In the Cancer Prevention study, patients with diabetes who lost weight had a 25% reduction in total mortality and a 28% reduction in cardiovascular plus diabetes mortality. And the benefit persisted even if they regained weight. But patients who lost more than 70 pounds had small increases in mortality.
In the National Health Interview Survey, patients who were trying to lose weight had a 23% lower mortality rate than those who were not trying to lose weight, even if they didn’t lose weight! Actual weight loss was associated with increased mortality only if the weight loss was unintentional.
A JAMA study suggested that people who are normal weight at the time of diabetes diagnosis may not be comparable to overweight diabetics. They may be at a disadvantage due to other factors like their ratio of muscle to fat (“thin outside, fat inside,” or TOFI). It may be a matter of fitness, not fatness.
Obesity and Cardiovascular Risk
A systematic review of 40 studies in The Lancet looked at the relative risk of total and cardiovascular mortality compared to a baseline of 1.0 for people with a “normal” BMI of 20-25. Their data show that the death rate is lower for people who are mildly to moderately overweight, but it is greater for those who are underweight or very overweight.
BMI	RR for Total Mortality	RR for CV Mortality
<20	1.37	1.45
25-29.9	0.87	0.88
30-35	0.93	0.97
>35	1.1	1.8
Several hypotheses have been proposed to explain these findings. For instance, one study suggested that obese patients have an advantage because they are treated more aggressively. The increased risk in the underweight category is not surprising: some of those underweight people are malnourished, cachectic from cancer, or are in poor health for other reasons.
Morbidity: Death Isn’t the Only Consideration
If obesity doesn’t kill you it could still hurt you in lots of other ways and make your life less pleasant. In addition to the obvious practical, social, and aesthetic disadvantages, there are a number of serious health consequences short of death. The Wikipedia article on obesity-associated morbidity provides a handy list of all the health problems associated with obesity. It’s a long list, divided into 10 categories from cardiology to urology. It includes gallstones, infertility, congenital defects, gastroesophageal reflux disease, stroke, carpal tunnel syndrome, multiple sclerosis, obstructive sleep apnea, erectile dysfunction, and many others.
Summary
There really is no obesity “paradox” — there is just a complicated situation. Obesity predisposes to developing a number of health problems. Once those problems have developed, in some cases patients who are overweight have a survival advantage over patients who are not. That advantage diminishes as weight increases and eventually turns into a disadvantage when the weight gets high enough. Being underweight is also a health risk. Fitness may be as important as fatness. We don’t yet understand what all this means: we have hypotheses, but so far they are not supported by credible studies.
The Bottom Line
Obesity is a health hazard but it should not be over-simplified or categorically demonized. It is a complex issue with exceptions to the general rule. Science supports trying to control weight in general but it doesn’t support forcing every individual into the same mold of an ideal BMI range of 20-25.

BMI and the Obesity Epidemic
Obesity is a serious and growing health problem worldwide. Ditching BMI as a measure of obesity is not the solution.
Steven Novella on June 14, 2017
Link

The incidence of overweight and obesity continues to climb in the US, and throughout the world. The most recent statistics from the CDC indicate that, from 2000-2014, obesity in the US increased from 30 to 37% in adults, and 13 to 17% in children.
A recent NEJM study of obesity worldwide found:
In 2015, a total of 107.7 million children and 603.7 million adults were obese. Since 1980, the prevalence of obesity has doubled in more than 70 countries and has continuously increased in most other countries. Although the prevalence of obesity among children has been lower than that among adults, the rate of increase in childhood obesity in many countries has been greater than the rate of increase in adult obesity. High BMI accounted for 4.0 million deaths globally, nearly 40% of which occurred in persons who were not obese.
Obesity is no longer a problem only of rich industrialized nations, and is increasing in poor nations as well.
Body mass index revisited
Most of the studies use body mass index (BMI) as the measure of overweight and obesity. Like many measures in medicine, BMI is useful but it has its limitations. A recent article in Popular Science repeats the common criticisms of using BMI but doesn’t put those criticisms into context. BMI is a measure of weight in kilograms divided by height in meters squared. It is a rough estimate of adiposity, and is extensively used in epidemiological studies because of convenience. We tend to have height and weight data for large numbers of people.
When applied to large groups, BMI works just fine. When applied to individuals it is more problematic, but still not as bad as its critics would have you believe. For example, in one study researchers compared BMI to a more direct measure of body fat percentage using skin-fold thickness. They found that when subjects met the criterion for obesity based upon BMI, they were truly obese by skin-fold thickness 50-80% of the time (depending on gender and ethnicity). When they were not obese by BMI they were not obese by skin-fold 85-99% of the time.
Accuracy of BMI breaks down at the extremes of height and muscularity. Body builders will have a high BMI because of their extra muscle weight. Meanwhile, a person with an exceptionally thin frame but excess truncal fat might have a normal BMI. The PopSci article points this out as if this would not be obvious to a medical practitioner. In clinical practice BMI supplements an actual physical exam, in which things like girth and muscularity will be obvious. When confronted with an individual patient with an atypical body frame then additional measures like waist circumference and skin fold measures can be used as supplemental data.
All of this is also in addition to metabolic data about an individual patient, like cholesterol, glucose control, and blood pressure. A medical practitioner should put all of this data together in a thoughtful and evidence-based manner to address their patient’s real risks.
In the sports world the situation is a little different. There are indications that coaches and trainers overutilize BMI, which is likely to be less accurate for athletes. This is likely to be coupled with unsafe weight loss practices.
In short, there is no problem specifically with BMI – it is a reasonable and convenient measure that applies well to large populations and can supplement other information about individual patients. There may be a problem with how BMI is used in certain cases, but this too is similar to many measures in science and technology. There is an oversimplification bias in which we substitute a simple question for a more complex question, or a simple measure for a more detailed one. BMI should not be used as the one measure of health or even ideal weight. It needs to be use properly and in the context of other relevant information.
As an analogy, there is nothing specifically wrong with using the p-value to evaluate scientific data in an experiment. The problem comes from simplistically substituting this one number for a more thorough analysis of the data and its implications.
Tackling the epidemic
There is no question at this point that there is an obesity epidemic, the problem is worsening over time, and it is spreading throughout the world. This seems to be an inherent problem with modern civilization. There is an ongoing debate about the relative contributions of a sedentary lifestyle and food abundance, but clearly both play a role.
There is also no question that obesity is an independent health risk factor. According to the NEJM article:
In 2015, high BMI contributed to 4.0 million deaths (95% uncertainty interval, 2.7 to 5.3), which represented 7.1% (95% uncertainty interval, 4.9 to 9.6) of the deaths from any cause; it also contributed to 120 million disability-adjusted life-years (95% uncertainty interval, 84 to 158), which represented 4.9% (95% uncertainty interval, 3.5 to 6.4) of disability-adjusted life-years from any cause among adults globally. A total of 39% of the deaths and 37% of the disability-adjusted life-years that were related to high BMI occurred in persons with a BMI of less than 30.
Excess health risk comes mainly from cardiovascular disease and increased risk of diabetes. Increased risk from obesity may exceed that from smoking. For individuals, extreme obesity (BMI > 45) has a higher mortality than having a healthy BMI and smoking.
Unfortunately, there is no simple solution to this problem. It seems that cultural changes will need to be made, and that is never easy.

Update on the Obesity Epidemic
The obesity epidemic continues, and even accelerates, among continued debate about its causes and solutions.
Steven Novella on September 4, 2019
Link


The obesity epidemic continues relentlessly across the globe, despite the increasing attention being paid to it. The latest CDC statistics (as of 2016) show that 39.6% of adult Americans are obese, with every state having a rate >20%. This is an increase from 2011 – 34.9%. In fact, the trend has accelerated. The same is true world-wide. As of 2016 there were 650 million obese adults worldwide. This is no longer a problem of just industrialized nations, and obesity can occur alongside malnutrition. The figures have tripled since 1975.
Despite these alarming numbers, there remains a fringe of “obesity denial”, which I first discussed in 2011. There are two main elements to this denial. The first is the notion that people are not really getting fatter, that it is just a trick of statistics. This is clearly not true, as the trends over the last 8 years further demonstrate. Second, there is the notion that overweight and obesity may exist, but are not in and of themselves unhealthy. This is also not true, but takes a bit more data to unpack.
The counter claim is that obesity correlates with other things that are unhealthy, such as a poor diet, lower socioeconomic status, and less access to health care, but is not an independent risk factor for disease. This is the “fat but fit” hypothesis. This has always been a minority opinion among experts, but a plausible interpretation of the data, resulting in some controversy. This is because the data, by necessity, is observational. You cannot make people get fat to see if they are more likely to die from disease. Correlational data leaves the door open for multiple interpretations of cause and effect.
However – this does not mean we cannot arrive at confident conclusions based on observational data alone. The trick is to control for as many plausible confounding factors as possible, and to triangulate to the most likely cause and effect. The “fat but fit” outliers served a useful purpose in this regard – making sure the broader scientific community did not settle prematurely on the simplest interpretation of the data. The stakes are pretty high here as well. We want to focus our public health and individual efforts on addressing the real health risks, and not be distracted by something that may be ultimately cosmetic.
At this point, however, I think we can say that the data is in. The “fat but fit” hypothesis is all but dead. Multiple large studies have reasonably isolated obesity as an independent risk factor. A 2018 study in the European Heart Journal looked at almost 300,000 people prospectively. They first evaluated them for their metabolic health – diabetes, blood pressure, cholesterol – and then tracked their health over four years. They found that waist size was an independent risk factor for heart disease and strokes. Further, there was a “dose response” effect – the bigger your waist, the higher your risk.
Further, being overweight is an independent risk factor for other things which themselves carry further risk – such as sleep apnea, diabetes, certain cancers, and arthritis.
A recent study also shows this risk extends to younger age groups. Specifically, tracking of cancer rates over the last decade show a shift in obesity-related cancers to younger age groups.
In this cross-sectional study of 2,665,574 incident obesity-associated cancer cases and 3,448,126 incident non–obesity-associated cancer cases from 2000 to 2016, the percentage of individuals diagnosed with incident obesity-associated cancers increased in younger age groups, with some of the greatest increases observed for liver and thyroid cancers (all sex- and race/ethnicity-specific strata), gallbladder and other biliary cancers (non-Hispanic black men and women and Hispanic men), and uterine cancer (in Hispanic women in the 50- to 64-year age group).
As with the global warming controversy, it seems the data is past the point where we should be debating whether or not it is happening, and whether or not it is a bad thing, and instead focus on what to do about it. Here genuine controversy remains. What we do know is that obesity is a problem worldwide, but there are regional differences. In the US, there are significant differences by state, which suggests an environmental or cultural factor.
One demographic hypothesis is that obesity is linked to urbanization, which may in turn increase access to fast foods and reduce physical activity. However, a 2019 study published in Nature found that increases in BMI in rural areas is primarily driving the obesity epidemic:
We show that, contrary to the dominant paradigm, more than 55% of the global rise in mean BMI from 1985 to 2017—and more than 80% in some low- and middle-income regions—was due to increases in BMI in rural areas.
The one thing about which there is general agreement is that the epidemic cannot be understood simply through the lens of individual behavior. This is a public health issue, relating to societal factors. A lot of blame focuses on the fast food industry. Over the last 30 years the average calorie content of a fast food meal has increased (along with salt and fat content). There is also focus on “food deserts” – locations that lack sufficient access to fresh fruits and vegetables. There is some debate about the role of sedentary life style, although it seems the evidence supports the conclusion that obesity is largely due to excessive caloric intake.
Overweight and obesity is a complex behavior problem without a known consistently effective solution. The primary problem may be that we evolved in an environment that was calorie restricted and now we have access to calorie abundance. The food industry competes with increasingly tasty products, and that means more calories. Health and dieting fads have apparently not been helping.
What is likely necessary is a significant change in the culture of food, but that is not something that is easily changed, or really in the power of any one organization or institution to change. That is why we debate endlessly about the causes and solutions to the obesity epidemic, while the numbers continue to worsen and even accelerate.

RFK Jr On Obesity
Steven Novella on December 18, 2024
Link

We have been giving a lot of attention to RFK Jr recently, with good reason. He is poised to be put in charge of the federal institutions that regulate health and medicine. This is beyond problematic, as he has a long list of antiscience opinions. Part of the problem is that he lacks topic expertise (he is not a health care professional or scientist of any kind) but he does not seem to realize it. He is an activist with just enough information to feel confident about his pseudoscience and conspiracy theories.
It is also frustrating to watch many in the media try to sanewash his opinions, and don’t seem to appreciate the underlying problem. Such reports often takes the form of – well, he may be nutty, but he has a point regarding this issue. But actually he doesn’t have a point – being sort-of right from a certain angle but for an entirely wrong reason is simply not good enough when it comes to the health of our country. Process matters. If a researcher carried out a horrible study with flawed methodology throughout, but happened to come up with an answer somewhat in line with reality, the outcome would not matter. Science is about process.
RFK Jr has a flawed process, and all of his conclusions are tainted by these flaws. He does not seem to understand how science works, the nature of risk-vs-benefit in medicine, nor the difference between hazard and risk. He also tends to look at all health issues through the same ideological lens – it’s always about toxins in the environment, toxins in our food, and toxins in our medicines. Because actual experts don’t agree with his nonsense, he then concludes that they are the problem (not him) and therefore they are part of a dark conspiracy.
As an example, let’s take his evidence-free response to a complex question – what is driving the obesity epidemic in the US. There is no one answer, but we do have a lot of pieces to the puzzle. It’s pretty clear that the primary issue is that Americans (and increasingly other developed nations) consume too many calories. This is more about increased caloric intake and less about sedentary lifestyle.
The deeper question then is – why are we consuming more calories? Again, human behavior is complex and multifactorial, and it is always hard to pin it down to one factor. But it is true that fast food contains more and more calories than it did in the past. When we order a meal and consume it we are putting far more calories into our bodies than in the past. This is true generally of the food we eat – they are more calorie-dense and proportions have increased. The marketing feedback loop in the food industry is driving more and more tasty food, and what tastes good is fat, salt, and sweet – i.e.,. calories. Decreased physical activity may be playing a minor role but is not the main driver.
There is a lot more nuance to this topic, but that is the quick answer. When RFK Jr was asked this question during an interview, he gave a very different answer. He said the obesity epidemic is cause by “poisoned food” (because it’s always about toxins and poison, right?). He then goes further to say that GMOs are the problem – GMOs are “nutrient barren” while non-GMO produce used to be nutrient rich.
This is simply not true. If you make the wrong diagnosis it’s very unlikely that you will prescribe the correct treatment. GMO crops are not less nutritious than non-GMO crops. They are not “nutrient barren”. But RFK Jr likes his boogeymen. This is a question that has been studied and answered – GMO varieties are not less nutritious than their non-GMO counterparts. Genetic modification is a set of processes, it is not one outcome. Generally in order to get on the market you have to prove that a GMO variety is substantially equivalent to the non-GMO variety. In fact, the only time there would be a substantial nutritional difference is if the genetic modification enhanced the nutritional content of the crop (as with golden rice).
RFK Jr also warns about pesticides from GMOs – but GMOs do not increase pesticide use overall. Some GMOs reduce it. But again, it is incoherent to say that “GMOs” do anything – it depends on the specific modification and the specific crop. He then goes on, without any evidence, to blame glyphosate use on wheat for the rise in celiac disease, which itself is a complex diagnostic question.
RFK Jr’s process is fatally flawed, and his conclusions are nonsensical and incoherent. Sure, if you squint you may see bits and pieces that are related to the actual answer, but even then he gets the diagnosis wrong. The problem is not with processed food (or ultraprocessed food, whatever that is) – it’s partly with the caloric density of these foods. But he wants to boil down these complex public health problems to identifiable villains – toxins and poisons that can be banned.
Banning GMOs would be an absolute disaster for agriculture and for the environment. And that will do absolutely nothing to improve the health of Americans. Banning glyphosate will also hurt agriculture and if anything would cause a shift to worse pesticides.
    • What should we do – that is a complex question. Reversing some of the dietary trends would be a good idea, but it is really hard to change public behavior. We tried listing calories and ingredients, but that has a minimal effect. Banning individual ingredients will likely not help, and the industry can simply shift to other ingredients with the same effect. The goal is to reduce the overall caloric content of processed food, and that would require some thoughtful and evidence-based regulation – but these are things we are unlikely to get from RFK Jr,

Fat Shaming Is Counterproductive
Fat shaming not only doesn’t work, it is counterproductive. So what might help fight obesity?
Steven Novella on September 25, 2019
Link

I recently wrote about current trends world wide in obesity. The quick summary – it is not only increasing, it’s accelerating, and it’s world-wide, not limited to industrialized nations. Obesity is an independent risk factor for various disease, such as type II diabetes, which itself is a risk factor for complications like heart disease and stroke. Obesity is now the number one preventable cause of life-years lost (recently overtaking tobacco use). So it is reasonable to consider overweight and obesity a serious health problem.
Understanding the causes of obesity is therefore critical. It’s difficult to fix a problem when you don’t know the cause. A recent psychological review outlines what prior research has shown. First, there is no evidence that obesity correlates with independent measures of will power. Rather, obesity correlates with certain biological, lifestyle, and environmental factors.
The biological factors include genetics, brain chemistry, and even our gut microbiome. Genetics alone, however, is clearly not the full answer, because it would be unable to explain the clear rise in obesity rates in the last half century.
Lifestyle factor involve things like one’s job. If your job is sedentary and does not afford much opportunity for physical activity, that is a major risk factor for obesity. Environment plays into this as well. Living location, which also may not afford much opportunity for exercise, is a factor. Access to healthful food is also important.
Psychologically, the main factors that seems to correlate with obesity is life stress. The review notes:
Psychological experiences also play a big role, the report says, with up to half of adults attending specialist obesity services having experienced difficulties in childhood.
Perhaps one of the most significant conclusions of the review is that fat shaming is counterproductive. It does not motivate people to lose weight, and lack of motivation is likely not a contributing factor to obesity in the first place. Rather, fat shaming simply adds to their psychological stress and low self-esteem, which exacerbates obesity.
For example, a 2013 longitudinal study found:
Participants who experienced weight discrimination were approximately 2.5 times more likely to become obese by follow-up (OR = 2.54, 95% CI = 1.58–4.08) and participants who were obese at baseline were three times more likely to remain obese at follow up (OR = 3.20, 95% CI = 2.06–4.97) than those who had not experienced such discrimination.
What this means is that we need to remove the stigma of obesity from our public health messaging. This can be tricky, because we want to communicate that obesity is a health problem that needs to be addressed. But we don’t want to add to the stigma attached to obesity, or imply blame or shaming. To show how tricky this can be, a recent public information campaign by Cancer UK tried to inform the public about the increased risk of cancer from obesity. In order to make this point more impactful, they showed a pack of cigarettes with the brand name replaced by “obesity”, to bring home the fact that obesity can be just as much a risk factor for some cancers as smoking.
In response the ad campaign was accused of fat shaming. There has been pushback against the pushback, however, with some commentators claiming we are abandoning personal responsibility.
This is one of those situations where both sides have a point, and there is a nuanced position in the middle. We do need to communicate basic scientific facts to the public. Obesity is a health risk factor, including for certain cancers. But – the ultimate goal of public service announcements is to have a positive impact on behavior. What matters most in the ends it – does the messaging work?
This is a case where, to some extent, perception is reality. When people perceive they are being fat shamed or discriminated against because of weight, that adds stress which leads to more overeating, exacerbating obesity. There is also the fact that simply knowing about a health risk does not alter behavior.
So in this case I do think the critics of the Cancer UK ad campaign are mostly right. Giving the public information about the risks of obesity is not effective, and to whatever extent there was a perception of fat shaming the campaign was counterproductive. But we don’t want to go too far and make it impossible to discuss scientific facts in public. We just need to be careful about our messaging.
So what, then, would work to turn this obesity ship around? I think the short answer is, we don’t really know (because we haven’t been able to do it yet). But our best guess is that we need to make systemic changes to the environmental contributors to obesity. This means organizing the institutions of life, such as work, so that people have the opportunity to get physical activity and that it is built into the day more routinely. Further, we need to address food insecurity and access to healthful food. We also need to address the “supersized” culture. It is extremely difficult, for example, to eat out without consuming far more calories that you intend or should. We are simply living in a culture with access to massive amounts of stealth calories.
Calorie labeling at the point of purchase has had mixed results when studied scientifically, but reviews conclude that overall, at the population level, there is no apparent benefit. It may still be useful for many individuals, however, if they incorporate that into their weight management strategy. But as a public health measure, it is not enough.
A tax on sugary drinks may be effective. One study found a 52% drop in consumption over three years following the start of the tax. This approach needs further experience and study, however.
I also think we need to directly confront pseudoscience in the wellness/weight loss industry. This industry is mostly peddling misinformation about weight loss, fad diets, and demonizing foods that are not the problem.
Overall it seems that we need a culture change to significantly tackle the obesity problem. It is likely a culture change that is causing the epidemic in the first place, and we need a further change to permanently change people’s habits. Going on a diet does not seem to work. The vast majority fail long term. Permanent lifestyle changes are necessary, and these require institutional and society change. And one thing is for certain at this point – fat shaming not only doesn’t work, it is counterproductive.

Okinawan Flat Belly Tonic
Okinawa Flat Belly Tonic is yet another scam weight loss product made up of a random grab-bag of vitamins, minerals, and powders.
Harriet Hall on May 25, 2021
Link

A message appeared in my email in-box with the subject line “bulging belly”. It turned out to be an advertisement for another way to supposedly lose weight without diet or exercise, the Okinawa Flat Belly Tonic. It provided three links to click on, one titled “Red Soda burns 3 lbs every 5 days,” another titled “Discover the ‘Done for You’ Japanese Tonic to Melt 3 pounds every 3.5 days,” (so which is it, 5 days or 3.5 days?) and “Just have a quick cup before 10am to dissolve 3 pounds.” In addition, there is an embedded video you can click on to play. All of these lead to the same video presentation, which is a long, disgusting tour de force of marketing tricks, deception, hype, testimonials, incredible claims, and the typical offers of deep discounts with warnings that the price will soon go up. I won’t go into detail because I have repeatedly covered similar marketing ploys for other bogus products. There’s nothing new here.
The presenter is a firefighter, Mike Banner. He starts off with a story about his sister Susan, a dramatic, emotional appeal designed to tug at the heartstrings. He then claims she lost 54 pounds in seven weeks, despite being unable to exercise due to osteoarthritis in her knees, by simply drinking a tasty Japanese tonic before 10 AM. He claims doing this will melt twice as much fat as 1 hour on a “joint-destroying” treadmill. The entire presentation is an insult to the viewer’s intelligence.
He describes how he imports the ingredients for the tonic and says they cost him over $300, yet he is selling the tonic for much less. Does that make sense? How could he do that? He claims to have developed the tonic after he had been given the secret by a maverick Japanese doctor. The tonic is said to be sold exclusively on the Okinawa Flat Belly Tonic website, but guess what? Amazon.com sells it on their website. Some of the Amazon customer reviews report an objectionable taste, a lack of effect, labeling that doesn’t match the commercials, and poor business practices.
This discussion on Yahoo! reviews the claims and raises some questions.
What’s in it?
It allegedly targets the root cause of weight gain: elevated levels of inflammatory molecules known as C-reactive protein (CRP). When CRP goes up, the fat-burning hormone adiponectin is blocked. The product is claimed to expel CRP and to have many benefits besides weight loss: fewer food cravings, lower stress levels, lower bad cholesterol levels, improved mental clarity, increased energy and vitality levels, improved self-esteem, hormonal equilibrium, and even increased libido.
The published list of ingredients includes:
    • EGCG – Found in green and white tea, this plant extract burns body fat instantaneously and induces thermogenesis.
    • Piperine – Extracted from black pepper, this antioxidant is what makes the spice the best ingredient for effective digestion. This is what it does as an ingredient of the Flat Belly Tonic. Piperine aids in blocking the formation of fat cells too.
    • Inulin – Extracted from the chicory plant root, this fiber works by tackling visceral fats and eliminating increased food cravings. Additionally, inulin is a probiotic that promotes healthier digestion.
    • Hibiscus sabdariffa – This delicate red flower is endemic to the Okinawa region and aids in the acceleration of fat loss.
    • Antioxidant fruits – These fruits actively promote overall health. They facilitate quick fat burning, energy boosting, better immunity, and increased digestion.
    • Aronia berry – As a powerful antioxidant, Aronia berry promotes immune system health and energy. Furthermore, it helps to regulate glucose levels.
    • Acai berry – This berry regulates cholesterol levels whilst supporting brain health. Additionally, the Acai berry eliminates fat absorption.
    • Mulberry – Similar to Acai berry and Aronia berry, Mulberry helps to regulate cholesterol and blood sugar, respectively. Rutin, found in Mulberry, enhances fat burning rates too.
    • Momordica charantia – Whilst controlling blood sugar levels, Momordica charantia (also known as “bitter melon”) decreases fats in the waistline too.
But wait! There’s more! It also contains a vitamin and mineral blend (with over 80 minerals), a metabolic boosting blend with Shilajit extract (an Ayurvedic substance found in Himalayan rocks), a polyphenol blend with 25 potent antioxidants and plant extracts, and a digestive support blend with probiotics and prebiotics. If all these ingredients can fit into a small scoop taken daily, do you think any of them are present in amounts sufficient to have an effect?
The science
They claim to have scientific studies to support their claims, but it consists of sparse pickings for some of the individual ingredients. The product itself has never been scientifically tested. The rationale for taking the tonic before 10 AM is never explained.
Conclusion: just another dietary supplement with extravagant claims and clever marketing
In my opinion, this is a scam. I don’t think the marketers believe in their product: they can’t even agree on how long it takes to lose 3 pounds! I don’t believe for a minute that this product could enable users to lose weight without diet or exercise. The marketers use every trick in the book to persuade naïve customers. Not being as naïve as their intended victims, I found their spiel not just unconvincing but downright insulting. I used the “unsubscribe” link and with any luck, my email inbox will no longer be contaminated with their spam.

Garcinia Probably Works But Is Far From a Weight Loss Miracle
Harriet Hall on December 24, 2013
Link
Women make up a majority of Dr. Oz’s audience. The majority of women would like to lose weight. That is a match made in heaven, a marketer’s dream. And Oz has never hesitated to exploit that fact to increase audience share, playing fast and loose with sensationalized evidence instead of giving his viewers science-based advice.

Dr. Oz has promoted a series of weight loss supplements on his show. Raspberry ketones were presented as a fat-busting miracle, then green coffee bean extract was touted as “magic,” “staggering,” and “unprecedented.” And now both of those miracles have apparently been superseded by an even greater miracle: Garcinia cambogia extract.
Dr. Oz calls it “The newest, fastest fat buster.” A way to lose weight without “spending every waking moment exercising and dieting.” “Triples your weight loss.” “The most exciting breakthrough in natural weight loss to date.” “The Holy Grail.” Oz claims that “Revolutionary new research says it could be the magic ingredient that lets you lose weight without diet or exercise.”
All that sounds too good to be true, and it is. Garcinia probably does work to some extent to improve weight loss, but the evidence doesn’t begin to justify such grandiose claims.
Garcinia basics
Garcinia cambogia extract (GCE) comes from a tropical fruit grown in India and Southeast Asia. The active ingredient has been identified: hydroxycitric acid (HCA). It is said to block fat and suppress the appetite. It inhibits a key enzyme, citrate lyase, that the body needs to make fat from carbohydrates. It suppresses appetite by increasing serotonin levels; low serotonin levels are associated with depression and emotional or reactive eating.
It allegedly decreases belly fat, suppresses appetite, controls emotional eating, and changes body composition by increasing lean muscle mass. It doesn’t just produce weight loss, but it improves overall health. It is said to decrease cholesterol, LDL, and triglycerides by 10-30% and to raise levels of the “good cholesterol” HDL.
Quality concerns
An independent analysis found that some brands contain far less active ingredient than claimed. Consumers are advised to look for at least 50% GCE with potassium but with no fillers, binders, or artificial ingredients.
It should be taken on empty stomach 30-60 minutes before a meal. Results increase with dosage, but doses over 3 000 mg a day should be cleared with your doctor.
Oz’s advice
Dr. Oz recommends a dose of 500-1000 mg of Garcinia cambogia potassium before each meal. (Some experts believe the potassium salt is more effective than other formulations.) He says not to take it if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, or if you have Alzheimer’s disease or other forms of dementia, because it can worsen dementia. If you have diabetes, it can cause hypoglycemia, and if you are on a statin, it can increase the risk of harmful side effects like rhabdomyolysis or muscle degradation.
Oz contradicts himself: he suggests that it can produce weight loss without diet or exercise, yet he clearly recommends it be used along with exercise and properly portioned meals.
The garcinia evidence
With Dr. Oz’s track record, I was not willing to simply accept his word for the wonders of Garcinia. I went to PubMed, where a search for hydroxycitric acid brought up 64 articles. Some were irrelevant, and the relevant ones included a lot of animal studies and a smaller number of human studies with inconsistent results.
Guinea pigs on a high cholesterol diet who were given a different Garcinia species (atriviridis) had a tendency to decrease lipid composition levels and fat deposition in the aorta. HCA caused congenital defects in rats. Another rat study found that it decreased body weight gain and visceral fat accumulation by reducing food intake but had no lasting beneficial effects on hypertriglyceridemia and hyperinsulinemia. Yet another rat study showed that it suppressed body fat accumulation but was toxic to the testes.
To try to make sense of the inconsistent results, Onakpoya et al. did a systematic review of the published randomized controlled trials (RCTs) as of 2011. Their analysis found a small, statistically significant difference in weight loss (1.75 kg vs 0.88 kg, less than 2 pounds). They commented that the studies all had methodological weaknesses, so these results could be due to GIGO (garbage in/garbage out). The two studies with the best methodology found no statistically significant difference from placebo. Adverse events were twice as common with Garcinia (headache, nausea, upper respiratory and gastrointestinal symptoms). The authors concluded:
The evidence from RCTs suggests that Garcinia extracts/HCA generate weight loss on the short term. However, the magnitude of this effect is small, is no longer statistically significant when only rigorous RCTs are considered, and its clinical relevance seems questionable.
Oz featured a patient testimonial on the show from a woman who had lost 10 pounds in 4 months. She started noticing results after a week; she reported that her sugar cravings were decreased, she had more energy, and she went down a dress size from 10 to 8. She had no side effects. Says she was at a plateau and wanted a jump-start.
Garcinia verdict
At this point, I don’t think we can reliably say whether Garcinia has a clinically relevant advantage over simple calorie reduction and exercise. It appears to be safe, and it may have a role in helping patients lose weight by assisting motivation and enlisting placebo effects.
Dr. Oz’s popularity is enduring, but diet fads aren’t. I confidently expect another “miracle” to supplant Garcinia in the Land of Oz in the not-too-distant future.

Forskolin: Here We Go Again
Harriet Hall on June 3, 2014
Link


My BMI is 21, but my e-mail and Facebook accounts must think I’m fat. I am constantly bombarded with messages about miracle weight loss solutions, and most of them are diet supplements featured on the Dr. Oz show. Back in December I wrote an article about Garcinia cambogia, Dr. Oz’s “newest, fastest fat buster.” I made this prediction: “I confidently expect another “miracle” to supplant Garcinia in the Land of Oz in the not-too-distant future.” I was right. The e-mails about Garcinia have recently been outnumbered by e-mails about a new Dr. Oz miracle weight loss supplement, forskolin. Actually, I think he discovered forskolin before he discovered Garcinia, but the forskolin propaganda seems to have reached a critical mass in the last few weeks.
The Land of Oz
A Dr. Oz episode on the “Rapid Belly Melt” aired a month ago, on May 5. He set fire to a paper representation of a fat belly to show how forskolin “works like a furnace inside your body.” The paper ignited, went up in flames, and revealed a non-flammable model of muscle tissue inside to show how forskolin burns fat, not muscle, and to illustrate how quickly it works.
In an earlier episode, in January, he called forskolin “lightning in a bottle,” and a “miracle flower to fight fat.” His guest, a weight loss expert, claimed it had doubled the weight loss of her clients. She said “if your metabolism is sleeping, forskolin is gonna wake it up.” She doesn’t claim that it will work miracles all by itself, but recommends it as an addition to gentle exercise and “cleaning up the diet”.
Dr. Oz says he pulled up all the research and was impressed by the evidence that it “ignites your metabolism.” He illustrates this metaphorically by throwing a white powder into a pot of simmering water, causing it to instantly start boiling vigorously.
The Land of Evidence
Dr. Oz is easy to impress. He cites a randomized placebo-controlled double blind trial of forskolin. It was a small preliminary study of obese or overweight men; there were only 15 men in each group, and the study lasted for 12 weeks. The subjects on forskolin showed favorable changes in body composition: a significant decrease in body fat percentage and fat mass, with a trend (non-significant) toward increased bone mass and lean body mass. Serum free testosterone levels were also significantly increased.
The details of the study are not important. What’s important is that the subjects taking forskolin did not lose weight. Even without weight loss, the changes in body composition are likely beneficial, but the increase in testosterone could be dangerous. Whatever the unresolved questions about benefits and risks, it is obviously misleading to cite this study as evidence that forskolin has been proven to melt belly fat or improve weight loss.
Another double blind study of 23 mildly overweight women, showed that forskolin had no significant effects on body composition and concluded that it “does not appear to promote weight loss but may help mitigate weight gain in overweight females with apparently no clinical significant side effects.”
Those are the only two studies in humans. Supplement Geek has written an analysis of some of the flaws in those studies that I won’t get into here. The only other pertinent research I could find was a study in rats suggesting that it may be effective in preventing diet-induced obesity. In rats.
What is it?
Forskolin is an herbal extract from Coleus forskohlii, a plant belonging to the mint family. Its mechanism of action? It increases the production of cyclic AMP, which increases the contractility of heart muscle. Evidence for other actions is preliminary and inconclusive: there is speculation that it may have effects in other cells of the body such as platelet and thyroid cells, it may prevent platelet aggregation and adhesions, and it might even prevent tumor cell growth and cancer metastasis. So far, there is no evidence that it is clinically useful or safe for those purposes.
The Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database rates forskolin as “possibly effective” as an inhaled powder for asthma, and as an intravenous medication for idiopathic congestive cardiomyopathy. It also mentions that it may decrease intraocular pressure but has not been tested in patients with glaucoma. It doesn’t even mention the possibility of using it for weight loss. The safety rating is “possibly safe,” and it lists potential interactions with prescription drugs and with other herbs and supplements. They say it may increase the risk of bleeding and should be discontinued at least 2 weeks before surgery.
The bottom line
So what do we know?
     1.  There is a more-or-less plausible mechanism of action, as speculated by the study authors (see the study for details).
     2.  It improved body composition in one study but not in another.
     3.  It has not been demonstrated to cause weight loss, except possibly in rodents.
     4.  Its clinical efficacy and safety have not been established.
     5.  It raises blood levels of testosterone, probably not a good thing.
I am not saying it doesn’t work for weight loss or belly melting; we don’t have good enough evidence to know whether it does or not. I’m not saying people shouldn’t take it, although they shouldn’t assume it’s perfectly safe. I’m only saying there is inadequate evidence for anyone to make the claims Dr. Oz and other proponents have made for it. If we had such limited evidence for a proposed new prescription drug, I doubt if Dr. Oz would want the FDA to approve it for marketing. The double standard is obvious.
Déjà vu all over again
I’m getting really tired of these weight-loss products, ever since I wrote about Akavar 20/50 “Eat all you want and still lose weight!” back in January 2008. I get a strong stink of déjà vu, because they all fit the same pattern: a small grain of plausibility, inadequate research, exaggerated claims, and commercial exploitation. There are always testimonials from people who lost weight, probably because their will to believe in the product encouraged them to try harder to eat less and exercise. But enthusiasms and fads don’t last. A year later, the same people are likely to be on a new bandwagon for a different product. Dr. Oz will never lack for new ideas to bolster his ratings. Enthusiasm for easy solutions and for the next new hope will never flag as long as humans remain human. I guess I’ll just have to keep doing the Sisyphus thing and hope that I can at least help a few people learn to be more skeptical and to question what the evidence really shows.

Weight Loss Customers Are Being Hoodia-Winked
Harriet Hall on November 8, 2011
Link
I first wrote about Hoodia in my “SkepDoc” column in Skeptic magazine (Vol. 13, No. 1, 2007).  The following is adapted from that column with an update from new research revealing that it doesn’t work and that it causes worrisome side effects.
I first heard of Hoodia in 2006, when a radio ad informed me that it was the new miracle weight loss pill. Shortly after that, I started seeing ads for Hoodia everywhere. Anna Nicole Smith took it. It was featured on Oprah.  Lesley Stahl went to Africa to taste the plant on 60 Minutes. There are nearly 40 competing brands of pills, a patch version, and even a Hoodia lollipop. It seems to have taken the world by storm; but it’s not new.
Hoodia gordonii is a cactus that grows in the deserts of southern Africa, and the San people have traditionally used it as an appetite suppressant, thirst quencher and to treat severe abdominal cramps, hemorrhoids, tuberculosis, indigestion, hypertension and diabetes. The claim is that it banishes hunger and thirst. What is the evidence? At this point it’s strictly anecdotal. Skinny Bushmen report it relieves hunger pangs in starvation conditions on long hunts; we don’t know what happens if it’s used by lazy fat people with access to food. Before the new study, there hadn’t been a single published study in humans.
The African Council for Scientific and Industrial Research isolated the active ingredient, P57, in 1977. They granted a license to Phytopharm, who collaborated on research with the pharmaceutical company Pfizer.
Pfizer eventually gave up on Hoodia due to the difficulty of synthesizing P57, and released their rights to it.  Jasjit Bindra, Pfizer research scientist, said there were other components in Hoodia that damaged the liver and could not be easily removed from the supplement. He advised:
Until safer formulations are developed, dieters should be wary of using it.
In 2008, Unilever dropped its plans to market a Hoodia product after spending over 4 million pounds on research.  Phytopharm continued to investigate it. Meanwhile, Hoodia is readily available as a diet supplement.
As well as being scientifically unsupported, Hoodia is politically incorrect. For one thing, it has been “stolen” from its original owners, the San people. Legally, it can only be exported under license, to guarantee patent rights and return a portion of the profits to the San people.  Some of the trade in Hoodia is clearly illegal: at least one poacher has already been arrested. For another thing, Hoodia is a protected species. It grows wild, only in a small area, and takes several years to mature. It has not yet been successfully cultivated. Uncontrolled harvesting could wipe it out.  There’s not enough available to supply all the products said to contain it. Products that have been tested have contained between 0.1 and 0.01 percent of the active ingredient claimed.  One testing company estimated that half of the Hoodia products they test contain no Hoodia at all.
The FTC had received over a hundred complaints as of 2007. ConsumerLab concluded that Hoodia had not been proven safe or effective, and the quality of products is uncertain. Consumer Reports on Health recommends against taking products containing Hoodia. Even herb-friendly Andrew Weil recommends caution on his website.
I concluded my 2007 article with:
You have no way of knowing whether you’re getting the real thing; and if you are, you may be ripping off the San people or endangering a species. You have no way of knowing if the real thing works or if it’s safe. Other than that, it’s probably a great product!
A 2011 review found that:
Publications based on scientific studies of key aspects such as in vivo biopharmaceutics, the biological activity of all chemical constituents, clinical efficacy, and especially safety are insufficient or completely absent causing great concern as H. gordonii is one of the most widely consumed anti-obesity products of natural origin.
Finally, A Human Study
Now a new study published in October 2011 in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition by Blom et al. has revealed that it doesn’t work and that it causes side effects. It was a randomized placebo-controlled double blind clinical study of 49 healthy overweight women. They were carefully monitored as inpatients, given either an H. gordonii extract or a placebo for 15 days after a 4 day run-in period, and were allowed to eat as much as they wanted. The researchers took a lot of precautions such as not letting subjects watch each other eat and standardizing the food so they could accurately measure calorie intake. I was impressed that the study was well-designed, carefully executed, and fully described even down to the brand and model of the machine used to do EKGs. The authors were employees of Unilever and Phytopharm, which holds the worldwide license for the application of H. gordonii extract in weight management products. The study results are a let-down for Big Pharma and are just the opposite of what might have been expected from researcher bias.
They found no significant difference in calorie intake or weight loss. They found significant and sustained increases in blood pressure, pulse, heart rate, bilirubin, and alkaline phosphatase. And they found a significantly higher incidence of side effects including nausea, vomiting, and disturbances of skin sensation.  No serious reactions occurred, and a number of other tests (other liver function tests, hematocrit, cholesterol, EKGs, etc.) showed no significant change. Although subjects were not told to reduce their food intake, both groups ate less and lost an average of 1.2 kg, showing that just being enrolled in a study had an effect on behavior.
Conclusion
At this point I think it is reasonable to give up on H. gordonii.  It doesn’t produce weight loss, and it causes a number of adverse effects. There is no miracle product that will magically decrease your hunger and melt the pounds off. Don’t be Hoodia-winked.

It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo dream
David Gorski on March 18, 2013
Link
There are many fallacies that undergird alternative medicine, which evolved into “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), and for which the preferred term among its advocates is now “integrative medicine,” meant to imply the “best of both worlds.” If I had to pick one fallacy that rules above all among proponents of CAM/IM, it would have to be either the naturalistic fallacy (i.e., that if it’s natural—whatever that means—it must be better) or the fallacy of antiquity (i.e., that if it’s really old, it must be better). Of course, the two fallacies are not unrelated. In the minds of CAM proponents, old is more likely to have been based on nature, and the naturalistic fallacy often correlates with the fallacy of antiquity. Basically, it’s a rejection of modernity, and from it flow the interest in herbalism, various religious practices rebranded as treatments (thousands of years ago, medicine was religion and religion was medicine—the two were more or less one and physicians were often priests as well), and the all-consuming fear of “toxins,” in which it is thought that the products of modernity are poisoning us.
Yes, there is a definite belief underlying much of CAM that technology and pharmaceuticals are automatically bad and that “natural” must be better. Flowing from that belief is the belief that people were happier and much healthier in the preindustrial, preagricultural past, that cardiovascular disease was rare or nonexistent, and that cancer was seldom heard of. Of course, it’s hard not to note that cancer and heart disease are primarily diseases of aging, and life expectancy was so much lower back in the day that a much smaller percentage of the population lived to advanced ages than is the case today. Even so, an implicit assumption among many CAM advocates is that cardiovascular disease is largely a disease of modern lifestyle and diet and that, if modern humans could somehow mimic preindustrial or, according to some, even preagricultural, lifestyles, that cardiovascular disease could be avoided. Not infrequently, evolutionary and genomic arguments are invoked, claiming that the estimated 10,000 years since the dawn of human agriculture is not a sufficiently long period of time for us to have evolved to handle diets rich in grains and meats and that we are “genetically wired” to exist on a diet like those of our paleolithic hunter-gatherer ancestors. For instance, in 2004, James H. O’Keefe Jr, MD and Loren Cordain, PhD wrote an article in the Mayo Proceedings entitled Cardiovascular Disease Resulting From a Diet and Lifestyle at Odds With Our Paleolithic Genome: How to Become a 21st-Century Hunter-Gatherer that asserted in essence, just that. Over the last decade, Cordain has become the most prominent promoter of the so-called “Paleo diet,” having written The Paleo Diet: Lose Weight and Get Healthy by Eating the Foods You Were Designed to Eat and multiple other books advocating a paleolithic-mimetic diet as the cure for what ails modern humans. Meanwhile, diets thought to reflect what our hunter-gatherer ancestors ate, such as the Paleo Diet consisting largely of animal and fish that can be hunted and fruits and vegetables that can be foraged for in the wild, have been promoted as a near-panacea for the chronic diseases of aging, such as cardiovascular disease and cancer.
But how does one determine what the prevalence of cardiovascular disease was in the ancient past? Time and the decomposition it brings are brutal on the flimsy meat of which we are made, and it is uncommon to have access to anything other than bones, much less bodies intact enough to be examined for signs of atherosclerotic disease. Even so, however, there have been indications that the idea that ancient humans didn’t suffer from atherosclerosis is a comforting myth, the most recent of which is a study published a week ago online in The Lancet by Prof. Randall C. Thompson of Saint Luke’s Mid America Heart Institute and an international team of investigators entitled Atherosclerosis across 4000 years of human history: the Horus study of four ancient populations. Basically, it was a study of 137 different mummies from four different geographic locations spanning 4,000 years. The areas spanned included ancient Egypt, ancient Peru, the Ancestral Puebloans of southwest America, and the Unangan of the Aleutian Islands.
The reason for the study is described in the introduction:
Human cultures residing in environments that are either very dry, hot, or cold have independently discovered how to mummify their dead. Thus, preindustrial or preagricultural cultures created the opportunity for a natural experiment—to study these ancient human beings with modern CT scanning to assess the extent of vascular calcifications in diverse environments and cultures. A common component of a mature atherosclerotic plaque, vascular calcification in modern day human beings is pathognomonic for atherosclerosis.4 Calcification consistent with atherosclerosis has been identified by CT scanning in the naturally mummified Iceman from present day Italy who lived around 3000 BCE (before common era).5 More than a century ago, Johann Nepomuk Czermak6 and Sir Marc Armand Ruffer7 gave serious evidence for atherosclerosis in several autopsies of Egyptian mummies from around 1000 BCE. Our recent studies confirmed these findings of atherosclerosis in 20 of 44 Egyptian mummies who lived during several dynasties between 1981 BCE and 364 CE (common era).8 and 9 However, ancient Egyptian culture and lifestyles might have had unique attributes relative to atherogenesis. Moreover, mummification in Egypt during the bulk of this time was primarily performed on elite Egyptians of high socioeconomic status.
So, although there was a fair amount of evidence from studies of Egyptian mummies that atherosclerosis was not uncommon, in Egypt it was mainly the wealthy and powerful who were mummified after their deaths. Conceivably, they could have lived a very different lifestyle and consumed a very different diet than the average Egyptian living around that time.
So the authors obtained whole-body CT scans of the 137 mummies, either pre-existing scans or scans prospectively done, and analyzed them for calcifications. The mummies to be included in the study were chosen primarily based on two factors, being in a good state of preservation with identifiable vascular tissue, and being adults. The authors obtained identifying information from an extensive search of museum and other databases by a team of archeologists and experts in mummy restoration, and sex was determined by either analysis of the genitals and reproductive organs when present and by pelvic morphology when they were not present. Age was estimated by standard analysis of architectural changes in the clavicle, femur, and humerus. Finally, multiple anthropological and archeological sources were used in an attempt to estimate likely risk factors for the mummies. Obviously, this last part involved a fair amount of inference and speculation, but that is to be expected in archeological studies.
Here are the findings:
Probable or definite atherosclerosis was noted in 47 (34%) of 137 mummies and in all four geographical populations: 29 (38%) of 76 ancient Egyptians, 13 (25%) of 51 ancient Peruvians, two (40%) of five Ancestral Puebloans, and three (60%) of five Unangan hunter gatherers (p=NS). Atherosclerosis was present in the aorta in 28 (20%) mummies, iliac or femoral arteries in 25 (18%), popliteal or tibial arteries in 25 (18%), carotid arteries in 17 (12%), and coronary arteries in six (4%). Of the five vascular beds examined, atherosclerosis was present in one to two beds in 34 (25%) mummies, in three to four beds in 11 (8%), and in all five vascular beds in two (1%). Age at time of death was positively correlated with atherosclerosis (mean age at death was 43 [SD 10] years for mummies with atherosclerosis vs 32 [15] years for those without; p<0·0001) and with the number of arterial beds involved (mean age was 32 [SD 15] years for mummies with no atherosclerosis, 42 [10] years for those with atherosclerosis in one or two beds, and 44 [8] years for those with atherosclerosis in three to five beds; p<0·0001).
Figure 2 summarizes the findings nicely:
There’s also this video featured in a Nature report on the study showing the reconstructed scan of one of the mummies with atherosclerotic plaques in the coronary arteries.
As expected, more atherosclerosis correlates with advanced age, and the amount of atherosclerosis in the young and middle-aged (although the times in which the people who became these mummies after death lived age 50 was old) was less. Although the sample number was far too small to draw definitive conclusions (as is often the case in archeological research), the prevalence of atherosclerotic disease in these mummies did not appear to correlate with the cultures in which the mummies lived. As is noted in Thompson’s article, ancient Egyptians and Peruvians were agricultural cultures with farms and domesticated animals, Ancestral Puebloans were forager-farmers, and the Unangans were hunter-gatherers without agriculture. Indeed, the Peruvians and Ancestral Puebloans predated the written word and were thus prehistoric cultures. At least, there were not large differences to suggest that studying more mummies might yield a statistically significant difference. Certainly,this doesn’t rule out the possibility that there was a difference, but also certainly atherosclerosis was common even among hunter-gatherers.
One notes that no one, including the authors of this study, is saying that lifestyle and diet are not important factors for the development of atherosclerotic heart disease. What they are saying is that atherosclerosis appears to be associated with aging and that the claims that mimicking paleolithic diets (which, one notes, were definitely not vegan) are overblown. In other words, there is a certain inherent risk of atherosclerosis that is related to aging that is likely not possible to lower further, with the study concluding:
In conclusion, atherosclerosis was common in four preindustrial populations, including a preagricultural hunter-gatherer population, and across a wide span of human history. It remains prevalent in contemporary human beings. The presence of atherosclerosis in premodern human beings suggests that the disease is an inherent component of human ageing and not characteristic of any specific diet or lifestyle.
I actually think that the authors probably went too far with that last statement in that, while they might be correct that atherosclerosis is an inherent component of human aging, it is quite well established that this inherent component of aging can at least be worsened by sedentary lifestyle and probably certain diets. Professor Thompson provided a bit more nuance in a quote in an article for TIME Magazine:
We found that heart disease is a serial killer that has been stalking mankind for thousands of years. In the last century, atherosclerotic vascular disease has replaced infectious disease as the leading cause of death across the developed world. A common assumption is that the rise in levels of atherosclerosis is predominantly lifestyle-related, and that if modern humans could emulate pre-industrial or even pre-agricultural lifestyles, that atherosclerosis, or at least its clinical manifestations, would be avoided. Our findings seem to cast doubt on that assumption, and at the very least, we think they suggest that our understanding of the causes of atherosclerosis is incomplete, and that it might be somehow inherent to the process of human aging.
One notes that, although the Paleo Diet is not, strictly speaking, always sold as CAM/IM, the ideas behind it are popular among CAM advocates, and the diet is frequently included as part of “integrative medicine,” for example, here at the University of Connecticut website, where it’s under integrative nutrition. Indeed, take a look at this video:
One wonders how some of the cavewomen in this video managed to have big hair and lipstick. several thousand years ago.
A related site is called CaveMenMeds. Although it features rather strong support for the theory of evolution, unfortunately, it also misuses evolution in much the same way that Cordain has done (as discussed in this very post) and in parallel make the same sorts of fallacious arguments about placebo effects that we’ve discussed many times before here on SBM. Basically, it couples myths about how paleolithic humans lived with a typical “integrating” of ideas that range from the sensible to the pseudoscientific to discuss disease. This is just the most direct link between CAM and paleofantasies that I came across in my web wanderings. There are many more less direct links to be found.
In particular, the appeal to ancient wisdom and ancient civilizations as yet untouched by the evil of modernity is the same sort of arguments that are made in favor of various CAM modalities ranging from herbalism to vegan diets rebranded as being somehow CAM to the appeal to “natural” cures. Indeed, the fetish for the “natural” in CAM is such that even a treatment like Stanislaw Burzynski’s antineoplaston therapy is represented as “natural” when in fact, if it were ever shown to work against cancer, it would be chemotherapy and has toxicities greater than that of some of our current chemotherapy drugs.
All of this brings us to another article from about a week ago about a book that I think I need to read that talks about “paleofantasy” and “Stone Age delusions.” The book is by Marlene Zuk and entitled Paleofantasy: What Evolution Really Tells Us About Sex, Diet, and How We Live. Zuk is an evolutionary biologist, and in particular she points out how the evolutionary arguments favored by advocates of the Paleo diet don’t stand up to scrutiny.
The interview begins with Zuk confronting Cordain at a conference on evolution and diseases of modern environments. At his lecture, Cordain pronounced several foods to be the cause of fatal conditions in people carrying certain genes. These foods included, predictably, cultivated foods such as bread (made from grain), rice, and potatoes. Zuk couldn’t resist asking a question, namely why the inability to digest so many common foods would persist in the population, observing, “Surely it would have been selected out of the population.” Cordain’s response? That humans had not had time to adapt to these foods, to which Zuk retorted, “Plenty of time.” Apparently, in her book, Zuk produces numerous examples of evolution in humans occurring in a time frame of less than 10,000 years, including:
    • Blue eyes arose 6,000 to 10,000 years ago
    • Rapid selection for the CCR5-D gene variant that makes some people immune to HIV
    • Lactase persistence (production past the age of weening of the lactase enzyme that digests lactose in milk) probably dates back only around 7,500 to 10,000 years, around the time that cattle were domesticated
Zuk also points out, as Thompson did in the Lancet study of atherosclerosis in mummies, that there is no one diet or climate that predominated among our Paleolithic ancestors:
Zuk detects an unspoken, barely formed assumption that humanity essentially stopped evolving in the Stone Age and that our bodies are “stuck” in a state that was perfectly adapted to survive in the paleolithic environment. Sometimes you hear that the intervention of “culture” has halted the process of natural selection. This, “Paleofantasy” points out, flies in the face of facts. Living things are always and continuously in the process of adapting to the changing conditions of their environment, and the emergence of lactase persistence indicates that culture (in this case, the practice of keeping livestock for meat and hides) simply becomes another one of those conditions.
For this reason, generalizations about the typical hunter-gatherer lifestyle are spurious; it doesn’t exist. With respect to what people ate (especially how much meat), the only safe assumption was “whatever they could get,” something that to this day varies greatly depending on where they live. Recently, researchers discovered evidence that people in Europe were grinding and cooking grain (a paleo-diet bugaboo) as far back as 30,000 years ago, even if they weren’t actually cultivating it. “A strong body of evidence,” Zuk writes, “points to many changes in our genome since humans spread across the planet and developed agriculture, making it difficult at best to point to a single way of eating to which we were, and remain, best suited.”
Some advocates of “paleo” will claim that they are not at all advocating that humans should eat what their paleolithic ancestors ate but that we should use what they ate as a template to figure out what to eat today. That’s a distinction without a real difference because the assumptions upon which the Paleo Diet are based (e.g., that atherosclerosis didn’t exist in hunter-gatherers and that hunter-gatherers were “almost always healthy, lean, fit, disease-free, strong people” and that 10,000 years is too short a time period for humans to have evolved to accommodate a grain-based diet) are more the product of wishful thinking and the “noble savage” myth than anything else. At the very least, Thompson’s study suggests that this assumption is overblown and that there has long been a certain “baseline” level of atherosclerotic disease among humans that is an inevitable part of aging. Whether or not a “Paleo”-like diet can modulate that baseline risk factor downward or at least decrease the risk of people living in modern technological societies from what our current mosaic of genetics, lifestyle, diet, and environment produce is an open question, but we’re not off to a good start when the underlying premise is so questionable.
Oh, and, as Zuk tells us, paleolithic people got cancer, too.
Ever since the rise of science and industry, there has long been a significant proportion of the population who distrust, fear, and sometimes even loathe modernity. Science changes too fast; it is thought to endanger “spiritual matters”; it tramples on “traditional values.” People fantasize about and long for a (nonexistent) time long past, when humans supposedly lived in harmony with their environment, and view science, specifically for the purposes of this discussion modern biomedicine, has having participating in destroying that “ancient wisdom.” We see strains of this tendency not just in medicine and “integrative medicine” but in literature and many other areas as well. Films such as Avatar and Dances With Wolves, among many others, portray scientists and “Western” man as rapacious and ready to destroy a race of hunter-gatherers and early agrarian people who are portrayed as living in complete harmony with nature. CAM and the Paleo diet share this fear of modernity as an underlying assumption even as their advocates use and misuse evolution to “prove” their worth. This is nothing new, and the rationale behind the Paleo diet is nothing more than, as Zuk has put it, the evolutionary search for our perfect past. Unfortunately, fantasy is not reality, and we humans have long been known to abuse and despoil our environment, even back in those “paleo” days. Indeed, when I took a prehistoric archeology course, which was largely dedicated to the period of time of the hunter-gatherers, one thing I remember my professor pointing out, and that was that what he did was largely the study of prehistoric garbage and that humans have always produced a lot of it.
We still haven’t stopped, unfortunately.

Keto Diet for Neurological Disorders
Does the ketogenic diet work for epilepsy or other neurological disorders? While the consensus is that it probably does, the evidence is surprisingly thin.
Steven Novella on February 20, 2019
Link
In the 1992 film, Lorenzo’s Oil, we see the story of Augusto and Michaela Odone, who defied the medical opinions of the time and sought out a treatment for their son Lorenzo’s adrenoleukodystrophy. The notion that a diet could affect a severe neurological disorder was met with skepticism, but the loving parents persisted and finally found what they were looking for.
It is a compelling story, but the reality is more complex. After a few decades of research, we are still left with uncertainty. The diet does prevent the build up of very long chain fatty acids (VLCFA) in the blood, but not in the brain. The evidence does suggest that if the diet is started in asymptomatic individuals with X-linked ALD (but not other disorders) it may delay progression to symptoms. However, once symptoms have started it does not alter the progression of the disease.
We are still at the stage where reviews conclude:
In conclusion, although additional controlled, large, and long-lasting studies are needed to confirm it, Lorenzo’s oil could be effective in preventing neurological manifestations in asymptomatic patients with X-ALD.
Ironically, Lorenzo had significant clinical progression prior to having the special oil (a combination of a 4:1 mix of oleic acid and erucic acid) added to his diet. So while the evidence shows the oil might work in asymptomatic patients, it also shows that it does not work in patients like Lorenzo.
Keto diet for seizures and migraines
Another dietary intervention claimed to be effective for neurological disorders is the ketogenic diet, and again the story is complicated and the evidence short of definitive.
Prior to modern medical treatment, all sorts of interventions were used for patients with epilepsy. Dietary restrictions go back to 500 BCE. The ketogenic diet specifically became popular in the 1920s, but then was largely replaced by modern antiepileptic drugs. In the last 20 years, however, it has seen a resurgence in popularity. So with almost a century of use, where does the evidence stand?
A ketogenic diet is essentially one that is low enough in carbohydrates that the brain becomes starved of glucose. This triggers the production of ketones, which is an alternate fuel source. This results in a host of metabolic changes. It is therefore plausible that there is a real physiological effect from such an extreme diet. But this cuts both ways – there is also the potential for negative effects.
At this point we are still not sure what the potential mechanism is. The production of ketones has been shown to affect the activity of neurotransmitters, which is a plausible mechanism. It also alters antioxidant activity and inflammation in the brain. There are countless studies showing effects on various physiological markers, but nothing tying a specific mechanism to any apparent clinical effect.
The clinical evidence, after almost a century of use, is surprisingly unclear. A 2018 Cochrane review of the ketogenic diet for refractory epilepsy concludes:
The RCTs discussed in this review show promising results for the use of KDs in epilepsy. However, the limited number of studies, small sample sizes and the limited studies in adults, resulted in a low to very low overall quality of evidence.
Most reviews are still concluding that more and better studies are needed. Why is this? Part of the problem is that these studies are hard to do. Subjects need to be placed on an extreme diet, something which is hard to blind and has overall poor compliance. Studies also need to be long term, at least a year if not longer. This is because the effect may take time to occur, may not last, and side effects may start to appear over time.
Studies are plagued by a high drop-out rate, often for lack of benefit. This hugely biases the outcome of studies. But in addition, the high drop-out occurs in clinical practice as well. When a doctor places their own patients on the diet, those who see an apparent benefit are more likely to stick with it. This is a setup for confirmation bias, which might explain why many clinicians are more confident in the treatment than the clinical studies warrant.
I should also point out that the evidence supports effectiveness in children with refractory epilepsy, but not in adults. The reason for this difference is unknown, but it is plausibly due to the different causes of epilepsy between childhood and adult onset.
The side effects of a ketogenic diet are also non-trivial, including gastrointestinal symptoms, increased cholesterol, and long term cardiovascular effects. However, there haven’t been enough long-term studies to really know what the risks are.
So if we do a risk-benefit analysis for the ketogenic diet in childhood refractory epilepsy the result is complex and plagued by unknowns. The diet itself it difficult to adhere to and can have a significant negative impact on quality of life, with significant side effects and some unknown long term risks. There seems to be a benefit in terms of reduction in seizure frequency for some patients, but we still need better quality studies to confirm this.
Because, however, refractory epilepsy is a severe problem that can have a devastating effect on quality of life, many clinicians think it is worth a trial in appropriate patients (the risk is high, but the potential benefit is also high). But clearly the time is ripe for a definitive high quality clinical trial to reduce the uncertainty about this century-old treatment.
What about the ketogenic diet for migraines? Everything I said above about plausibility and side effects applies. The clinical evidence for efficacy is even more preliminary. It consists mainly of case reports and open-label case series. There are no high quality double-blind studies.
The risk-benefit for migraines, in my opinion, is not worth it. What this means is that I would not recommend this intervention outside of an approved clinical trial. I also have concerns about the long-term effects of a ketogenic diet, which have not been adequately studied. Migraines, like seizures, are a chronic condition. We may need to treat patients for decades. That is a major life commitment for an intervention like the ketogenic diet.
There is evidence that milder diets, like the modified Atkin’s diet (MAD) has similar efficacy to the keto diet with fewer side effects and better compliance. This is good, but equivalency to a questionable intervention does not resolve the question of efficacy, and arguably shows a lack of a dose-response effect which could reduce confidence in the treatment.
Further, there are newer migraine interventions coming online, like the recent CGRP antagonists, which are showing great efficacy. I would not recommend the diet until after seeing a headache specialist and exploring all of the established treatments.
The story of dietary interventions for neurological disorders is an instructive one. First, we cannot be dismissive of interventions that seem implausible at first. Similarly, the pop-culture aspect of an intervention, like the keto diet, is not an argument in its favor, but should not cause serious scientists to dismiss it either.
Even more importantly, the controversy over the keto diet shows how important rigorous clinical trials are. We can debate endlessly about the potential risks and benefits of the keto diet, with patients stuck in the middle trying to decide if they should turn their life upside down with an extreme diet, but one that might dramatically improve their lives. The stakes are pretty high for patients.
Unfortunately, the “just try it” approach does not work. It may seem counterintuitive, but the vagaries of chance and the systematic deception of cognitive biases means that unblinded trials are not likely to produce a definitive answer, even for an individual. That last thing you want is for a patient to be convinced that an expensive, difficult, or risky intervention works because of placebo effects, when in fact it is not really helping them. Then they are trapped with a very costly placebo.
We need to know with a higher degree of confidence what the risks and benefits of this intervention are. That requires high quality clinical trials.

Diet Cults vs. Science-Based Healthy Eating
Harriet Hall on August 26, 2014
Link
This will be shorter than my usual book reviews and is something of an afterthought. I just finished writing a long article on “Food Myths” that Michael Shermer had asked me to write as a cover article for an upcoming issue of Skeptic magazine, and while researching the subject I read a book that someone had suggested to me (I’ve forgotten who you are, but thank you!). It occurred to me that since not everyone who reads SBM subscribes to Skeptic, it would be good to tell this audience about the book too.
(Note: if you subscribed, you could not only read my upcoming “Food Myths” article but also my regular SkepDoc column and my long article “On Miracles” in the next issue. And there’s lots of other great stuff in the magazine, including the Junior Skeptic section for your kids and grandkids. A digital subscription is available for only $14.99 and you can even get a trial issue for free, so you have no excuse not to check it out. End of commercial.)
The book is Diet Cults: The Surprising Fallacy at the Core of Nutrition Fads and a Guide to Healthy Eating for the Rest of Us, by Matt Fitzgerald, an endurance sport and nutrition writer. Not a doctor, but he understands science better than a lot of doctors who have written about diet and nutrition. His reasoning is persuasive and is supported by the scientific evidence.
One of his theses is that humans have a natural propensity to make moral judgments about others’ food choices. This probably developed because it was a practical way to encode trial and error knowledge about safe and unsafe foods, then it became hardwired into human behavior because of the survival advantage for group cohesion. Taboo foods and religious dietary laws like kosher and halal define “our tribe” and emphasize our difference from “others.” We can see a similar group solidarity, peer pressure, moral stance, and semi-religious zeal among today’s environmentalists and animal rights activists.
He argues that most people initially choose diets because of emotional and social factors, and then cherry pick the published evidence (if there is any!), using confirmation bias and rationalization to find post hoc reasons for their unreasoned choices.
Fitzgerald handily debunks the arguments for the Paleo Diet. There was no one paleolithic diet: our Stone Age ancestors ate a variety of diets determined by whatever they could get. Anyway, we couldn’t possibly eat like they did because their food sources are long gone. Today’s plants and animals have been drastically altered by selective breeding. The corn we eat is a far cry from the “natural” teosinte gathered by early humans. Arguments that we should eat what we evolved to eat are undercut by three facts: humans have continued to evolve since the Paleolithic (adult lactose tolerance is one of many examples), and humans evolved to be adaptable and to thrive on a wide variety of dietary intakes; and we evolved to have the survival advantage of intelligence and inventiveness to develop technology to improve our access to food (for instance, cooking). In other words, technology is “natural” for humans, and eating in a variety of ways is natural for humans too. If our ancestors had been less adaptable and if there was a single healthy diet, humans could not have spread to new continents or survived the climate changes of the Ice Age.
He says:
Science has not identified the healthiest way to eat. In fact, it has come as close as possible (because you can’t prove a negative) to confirming that there is no such thing as the healthiest diet. To the contrary, science has established quite definitively that humans are able to thrive equally well on a variety of diets. Adaptability is the hallmark of man as eater. For us, many diets are good while none is perfect.
I think he’s right. If science had identified one optimum diet for human health, all the fads and arguments could have stopped by now. Despite the uncertainty, the existing scientific evidence does seem to be converging towards certain principles that most experts can agree on. There is good evidence that a diet high in fruits and vegetables is healthier than the typical American diet high in calories, red meat, and processed foods.
Fitzgerald provides a 10-item hierarchy of foods from more healthy to less healthy:
    • Vegetables
    • Fruits
    • Nuts, seeds and healthy oils
    • High quality meat and seafood
    • Whole grains
    • Dairy
    • Refined grains
    • Low quality meat and seafood
    • Sweets
    • Fried foods
He recommends that we eat more of the categories higher on the list, and less as we go down the list. No foods need be prohibited.
One could certainly argue with his list, and it hasn’t been tested to see if his plan will actually keep people healthier or make them live longer, but it seems to me that it is at least as reasonable as anyone else’s diet advice. Why not follow this plan while we are waiting for more conclusive scientific evidence? It is flexible, accommodates individual preferences, avoids extremes, and is consistent with the best evidence that we do have.
We don’t just eat for health, we also eat for enjoyment. Why deny ourselves some of the greatest pleasures of life on the basis of diet fads and recommendations that are based on uncertain evidence?
Fitzgerald covers a wide variety of topics such as superfoods, low-carb, protein supplements for weightlifters, sugar, grains, dairy foods, vegetarian diets, dehydration, weight loss, severe calorie restriction for longevity, and many more. The book is well-written, accessible, and a treasure trove of scientific study results and interesting trivia about diet. I enjoyed it, and I think you would too.

What Can We Learn from the Kitavans?
Harriet Hall on September 10, 2013
Link
A Swedish researcher, Staffan Lindeberg, has been studying the inhabitants of Kitava, one of the Trobriand Islands of Papua New Guinea. He claims that sudden cardiac death, stroke, and exertion-related chest pain never occur in Kitava; and he attributes this to their eating a Paleolithic diet.
2,250 people live on Kitava. They are traditional farmers. Their dietary staples are tubers (yam, sweet potato and taro), fruit, fish, and coconut. They don’t use dairy products, alcohol, coffee, or tea. Their intake of oils, margarine, cereals, and sugar is negligible. Western foods constitute less than 1% of their diet. Their activity level is only slightly higher than in Western populations. 80% of them smoke daily and an unspecified number of them chew betel. The macronutrient composition of the Kitavan diet was estimated as 21% of total calories from fat, 17% from saturated fat, 10% from protein, and 69% from carbohydrates.
Lindeberg’s Kitava study examined a sample of 220 Kitavans aged 14-87 and compared them to healthy Swedish populations. They found substantially lower diastolic blood pressure, body mass index, and triceps skinfold thickness in the Kitavans. Systolic blood pressure was lower in Kitava than in Sweden for men over 20 and women over 60. Total cholesterol, LDL cholesterol, and apolipoprotein B were lower in men over 40 and in women over 60. Triglycerides were higher in Kitavans aged 20-39 than in Swedes of the same age. HDL was not significantly different.
Another study examined how the Kitavans’ risk factors changed with age.
I am always suspicious of initial reports of unusually healthy or long-lived groups in remote areas, because I have so often seen such reports disconfirmed by subsequent investigations. Lindeberg’s studies were done in the early 90’s and have not been confirmed by other studies in the ensuing two decades. In the Kitava study, the ages of subjects were not objectively verifiable, but were estimated from whether or not they remembered significant historical events. The absence of heart disease and stroke was deduced by asking islanders if they had never known anyone who had the symptoms of either condition. This was reinforced by anecdotal reports from doctors who said that they didn’t see those diseases in islanders. EKGs were done on the Kitavans, but a normal EKG does not rule out atherosclerosis or cardiovascular disease. I’m not convinced that we have enough solid data to rule out the presence of cardiovascular disease or other so-called “diseases of civilization” in that population.
But even supposing those diseases don’t exist in Kitava, what could we deduce from that? Lindeberg thinks it constitutes evidence to support the Paleolithic diet of meat, fish, vegetables, fruit and nuts that our ancestors ate 2,000,000 to 10,000 years BP. We aren’t really sure what our Paleolithic ancestors ate, but we can be reasonably sure they didn’t typically eat what Kitavans eat. The Paleolithic diet included meat and was probably much higher in protein than the Kitavan diet. Most of our Paleolithic ancestors probably did not have access to coconuts or taro or to an abundance of fish. Our ancestors were hunter-gatherers, while the Kitavans are farmers; agriculture did not develop until around 10,000 BP.
I don’t see how we could assume the absence of those diseases was due to the Kitavan diet. Other causes would have to be ruled out, including heredity and environmental factors. Even if it was due to the diet, how could we possibly know whether it was due to the diet as a whole or to some specific aspect or component of the diet?
What can we conclude?
The Kitava study serves as a disconfirming example to discredit the claims made for low-carb diets. Kitavans eat a very high-carb diet, with lots of saturated fat and little protein, and they appear to thrive on it without becoming obese or developing a high incidence of metabolic syndrome as the low-carb theorists would predict.
It is evidence against the hypothesis that low-fat diet recommendations caused the obesity “epidemic” simply because people replaced fat with carbohydrates. It shows that a diet high in carbohydrates does not necessarily lead to obesity, especially if they are complex carbohydrates and the total calorie intake is not excessive.
It supports the general consensus of most diet experts that a predominately plant-based diet is healthy. It supports Mom’s admonishments to eat our vegetables.
It suggests that saturated fat need not be avoided, especially if it is of vegetable rather than animal origin.
It tends to confirm the health benefits of weight control and the principle that weight can be controlled simply by limiting calories. The Kitavans are not overweight, and their intake of calories is lower than the conventional Western diet.
It tends to support advice to avoid processed foods and refined carbohydrates.
It reinforces the concept that humans can thrive on a wide variety of diets.
Bottom line
The Kitava Study provides food for thought; it doesn’t provide enough justification to recommend either a Kitavan diet or a standard “Paleolithic diet” over other healthy diets.

Does Intermittent Fasting Work?
New research, same old narrative.
Steven Novella on June 28, 2023
Tweet

The short answer to any question about – does diet X work – is always going to be, yes and no. Intermittent fasting is no different. Diets statistically work in the short term because any time you pay attention to your calorie consumption and exercise you are likely to consume fewer calories, which can result in weight loss. But diets notoriously don’t work in the long term for about 95% of people. But every new diet is presented as if it finally represents the behavioral “hack” everyone has been looking for.
Recent studies looking at intermittent fasting demonstrate the basic reality of the situation and the challenges of doing research in this area. One study recently published in the Annals of Internal Medicine compared time-restricted eating (8 hours per day without explicit calorie counting) to unrestricted eating but with calorie counting, to a control group with no intervention. They found:
Compared with the control group, the time-restricted eating group reduced on average 425 more kilocalories per day and lost 4.61 kg more weight at 12 months. Similarly, the calorie restriction group reduced an average of 405 more kilocalories per day and lost 5.42 kg more weight than the control group. There were no significant differences between the time-restricted eating and calorie restriction groups in terms of reduced calorie intake and weight loss achieved.
Of note, all participants had access to a dietician once per week. It’s hard to know what this study is actually showing us. Studies of diet and weight loss are all challenged by background effects that are likely to obscure the effect being studied. There is an effect just from paying attention to how much you are eating and exercising. There is an effect from being weighed on a regular basis, which gives you concrete feedback about your calorie balance. There is an effect from having a support structure, such as the infrastructure of any clinical trial. There is an effect from having regular diet counseling.
From this point of view, this study tells us that if you regularly meet with a dietician, weigh yourself, and pay attention to your eating (let’s call these general effects), you are likely to lose weight. It also showed that the details of your diet strategy (specific effects), in this case intermittent fasting vs calorie counting, don’t really matter.
If we look at the dieting and weight loss research in total over decades, there is a common and persistent theme. The general effects I listed above are dominant, and the specific effects of dietary details either don’t matter at all or have only a small effect. Often strategies are proclaimed to be superior based upon tiny and short term effects.
About 95% of weight loss, in terms of behavioral strategy, is about paying attention to how much you are eating, weighing yourself regularly, maintaining or increasing your physical activity, and having some psychological support or encouragement. Yet there is a vast literature focusing on the 5% – the kind of calories (macronutrients) and the timing of eating. Research consistently shows that these factors either don’t matter, or there is a small effect, and/or the effect is short lived and sometimes comes with a long-term deficit.
The research also shows that sustained weight loss is really hard. Most people lose only a small amount of weight and don’t keep it off long term. Three to six month studies are presented as “proof of concept” studies, but may be ultimately useless if the goal is long term weight loss and maintenance. Intermittent fasting is just the latest attempt to come up with the one trick that will finally work, but the research is finding essentially the same thing. Yet studies and headlines obsess over small effects from, say, the duration of fasting, or the timing of fasting. Is it better to eat in the morning or later in the day?
It seems as if we just don’t want to admit to the big picture – none of this really matters. Weight maintenance for many people is simply really hard. Distracting ourselves with these small details won’t change that.
So what will work? On an individual level, we really still don’t know, beyond the general effects I listed. The evidence also suggests that obesity is not an individual failure but a societal problem. Developed nations generally have readily available calorie-dense food in large proportions. We are simply not evolved to deal with this abundance of food engineered to maximally stimulate our senses. Brute force of willpower is simply not up to the task of living in this world without overconsuming calories (for most people most of the time).
There are medical options. Various forms of gastric bypass are effective. But surgical intervention is generally reserved for the severely obese with medical complications. There are medications available, such as Ozempic. These are primarily for diabetes, but are shifting to treatments for obesity itself. However, these medications are expensive and have to be taken indefinitely, with a risk of rebound if they are stopped. Medical interventions therefore have a role to play, but they are not for everyone.
The bottom line is that we still haven’t cracked this problem. We are nibbling around the edges, debating about the 5%, looking for the next hack. Meanwhile, we actually know what the solution is, but there doesn’t seem to be the collective will to do anything about it. The environment needs to change. The food industry needs to change. Until that happens it feels like we are rearranging deck furniture on the Titanic.

Shred360: The Weight Loss Product with the Stupidest Hype Ever
Harriet Hall on March 17, 2015
Link

There was a half-page ad in my local paper, thinly disguised as a “Special Report” by a Health and Fitness Editor, for a new fat-melting pill that “could put diet industry out of business by 2016.” I have seen a lot of ridiculous ads for weight loss products, but this one takes the cake. It’s arguably even worse than the one that proclaimed “we couldn’t say it in print if it wasn’t true” and then proceeded to say things in print that weren’t true.
It’s called Shred360. Here are some of the claims:
    • It shook up the fitness industry because it DOUBLES your fat-burning potential.
    • It allows anyone to LOSE INTENSE AMOUNTS OF FAT without grueling workouts or tasteless diet foods.
    • It breaks your fat cells apart and disintegrates them, even while you sleep.
    • Speeds your metabolism by 43%.
    • It vaporizes fat without effort.
    • Its proprietary blend of 16 potent ingredients is scientifically proven.
    • Burns stored fat through thermogenesis and lipolysis.
    • Increases energy and mental clarity almost immediately – guaranteed.
    • Fools your body into feeling full: the ultimate appetite suppressant.
    • Unconditionally guaranteed to make every surplus bit of your unwanted fat disappear effortlessly.
    • Analysts think it will put Jenny Craig and Weight Watchers out of business by 2018 (which doesn’t even make sense if it has already put the entire diet industry out of business by 2016).
    • You can eat like a normal person, skip the gym, and lose the fat you want while you sleep.
    • Produced under highly controlled environmental conditions in small batches, so supplies are very limited.
    • Free samples available for 100 customers – don’t wait to call.

They include a series of pictures that supposedly show fat cells disintegrating. Mechanical loads may be able to disintegrate fat cells, but there’s no way a diet supplement could do that. When people lose weight, it’s not because their fat cells disintegrate; the number of fat cells remains constant throughout life, even after drastic weight loss.
If ads like these sell products, it only means “there’s one born every minute.” It’s particularly galling, since a few years ago the FTC asked the media to help their underfunded and understaffed agency rein in false diet supplement advertising. They provided simple guidelines so the media could spot red flags, exercise their own judgment, and reject deceptive ads like this one. I’ve tried complaining to my local newspaper to no avail: they don’t want to be bothered, and the income from ads takes precedence over providing accurate information to readers.
Synergism not proven
They claim Shred360 works by a synergistic combination of ingredients. Adding ingredients together may or may not produce a synergistic effect, and this particular combination has never been tested to determine whether it does. They brag that their ingredients are supported by a “landmark scientific trial” in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. I think they must be referring to this one, which showed that green tea extract alone, in doses comparable to 3.5 cups of tea, increased fat oxidation during moderate-intensity exercise and improved insulin sensitivity and glucose tolerance in young men. But another study of green tea extract in obese women showed no difference in weight reduction between the tea and placebo groups after 12 weeks of treatment. And a 2014 systematic review concluded that it had no statistically significant effect on weight loss in overweight adults.
Oh, and by the way, it may cause liver failure.
Ingredients
So the green tea extract in Shred360 probably doesn’t do much of anything and might even be dangerous. What else is in the product?
Nutrients:
    • Vitamin B6 (1500% DV)
    • Vitamin B12 (2500% DV)
    • Chromium (167% DV)
Lipomax 1010 mg comprised of:
    • Green tea extract
    • Green coffee (bean?) extract (chlorogenic acid)
    • Raspberry ketones
    • Cayenne extract
    • Evodia extract (a tropical fruit)
    • Naringin (a grapefruit extract)
    • Synephrine (related to ephedra, increases metabolic rate)
    • Black pepper extract (used as an absorption agent)
Hyperfocus 410.03 mg comprised of:
    • Caffeine (120 mg)
    • Yerba mate extract (a South American tea containing caffeine)
    • N-acetyl-L-tyrosine (a non-essential amino acid)
    • DMAE
    • Huperzine A
They say it produces none of the side effects that people get from caffeine and ephedra, like jitteriness and overstimulation. So we can deduce that the amounts of each ingredient are not large enough to have any significant effect on metabolic rate. For comparison purposes, a cup of brewed coffee contains 95-200 mg of caffeine.
Does it work?
I don’t know, and they don’t know either, since the mixture of ingredients has never been tested. But I am far more skeptical than the vendors are. For some of the individual ingredients there is indeed preliminary evidence that they may have a small but probably not clinically significant effect on weight loss. I would be delighted to learn that Shred360 had been rigorously tested and shown to be an effective and safe way to lose weight. But I would be very surprised.
Does it disintegrate fat cells? No! (Who knows what those pictures are really of?)
Is it going to put the diet industry out of business? No way!
Conclusion
This is just another in a long line of money-making weight loss products that make extravagant claims based on the flimsiest preliminary evidence and trade on the perennial desire for a miracle that will take pounds off effortlessly. The extravagant hype in these ads is beyond anything I’ve ever seen: it ought to win some kind of award for the greatest silliness in advertising.
I’m wondering why Dr. Oz has not featured this new weight loss miracle on his show; he’s already featured some of the ingredients as miracles, and combining them ought to compound the miracle, right? Or are these claims too silly even for the credulous Dr. Oz?

The HCG Diet: Yet another ineffective quick fix diet plan and supplement
Scott Gavura on July 19, 2012
Link
I contribute biweekly to Science-Based Medicine and could easily devote every post to writing about weight loss supplements, and never run out of topics. As soon as one quick fix falls out of favour, another inevitably replaces it. Some wax and wane in popularity. And pharmacies don’t help the situation. I cringe every time I walk down the aisle where weight loss products and kits are located. Detox? Hoodia? The “fat blaster”? Here are pharmacists, well educated and perfectly positioned to provide good advice to consumers, but standing behind a wall of boxes with ridiculous weight loss promises. Yet pharmacists tell me that these products are not only sought out by customers, but they actually sell well. It’s a lost opportunity to provide good advice, and consumers pay the price.
Perhaps because consumers associate these products with pharmacies, I get regular questions about weight loss programs. I end up developing some degree of familiarity with many of them, if only to be able to credibly redirect away from some of the more harmful plans and approaches. It’s that philosophy that I used recently when I was asked about how to best to manage a “plateau” on the HCG diet. I’d never dispensed human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG) before, but knew of its use for the treatment of infertility, where it promotes egg release. But weight loss? I couldn’t think of a mechanism for how HCG could promote weight loss. So I did some digging, and found a long, rich vein of pseudoscience that dates back decades.
HCG is a hormone secreted by the placenta during pregnancy. Its use as a weight loss adjunct has roots that date back to the 1950s, when Italian physican ATW Simeons announced [PDF] case studies of weight loss in patients given HCG injection and placed on very low calorie diets — about 500 kcal/day. Simeons’ data failed to be replicated in later studies, and interest seemed to deservedly fade. The diet leapt back into consciousness when telemarketer and convicted felon Kevin Trudeau started promoting the diet again in 2007, claiming the TRUTH had been suppressed by the American Medical Association and the FDA. Since then, HCG (also called the Simeons method) has been on a bit of tear, and it’s currently enjoying a resurgence of popularity.
The Evidence
With HCG, we’re not facing a situation of unproven efficacy. Rather, there’s good evidence to demonstrate that it does not have any meaningful effect. Multiple studies and meta-analyses have evaluated the HCG diet and found no evidence that HCG injections offer any incremental benefit. The studies date go way back to the 1970s [PDF], and their conclusions are consistent and persuasive: The weight loss effect on the HCG diet is due to the dramatic calorie reduction, and the HCG has no measurable effect on weight loss. Not surprisingly, there are no medical associations that I could find that endorse the use of HCG for weight loss. The American Society of Bariatric Physicians warns,
Numerous clinical trials have shown HCG to be ineffectual in producing weight loss. HCG injections can induce a slight increase in muscle mass in androgen-deficient males. The diet used in the Simeons method provides a lower protein intake than is advisable in view of current knowledge and practice. There are few medical literature reports favorable to the Simeons method; the overwhelming majority of medical reports are critical of it. Physicians employing either the HCG or the diet recommended by Simeons may expose themselves to criticism from other physicians, from insurers, or from government bodies.
So does the HCG Diet Work?
Any weight loss from the HCG diet is actually due to the dramatic calorie restriction required as part of the diet plans — in some cases, as low as 500 calories per day. This near-starvation diet is dramatically below appropriate levels for weight loss or maintenance, and escalates the risk of malnutrition if prolonged. Even if it wasn’t immediately harmful, a 500kcal diet is simply unsustainable. Weight maintenance is the real challenge with obesity.
HCG injections are not innocuous. It may be teratogenic (cause birth defects) in pregnant women. Reported side effects include headache, fatigue, irritability, restlessness, ovarian overstimulation, ascites, and edema.
Regulatory status
The FDA has long maintained that HCG is ineffective for weight loss and in the 1970’s mandated this warning with all HCG diet advertisements:
HCG has not been demonstrated to be effective adjunctive therapy in the treatment of obesity. There is no substantial evidence that it increases weight loss beyond that resulting from caloric restriction, that it causes a more attractive or “normal” distribution of fat, or that it decreases the hunger and discomfort associated with calorie-restricted diets.
What’s appeared over the past several years have been non-prescription (i.e., over-the-counter) HCG products, including “homeopathic” HCG which if you follow the absurd principles of homeopathy, should cause weight gain, not loss. Moreover, HCG is a protein that would be digested if consumed orally. But scientific cogency isn’t a necessary component of a good sales pitch, and you’ll see homeopathic versions sold widely. The FDA noted this and took action this past December, when it began to pull all unapproved HCG products completely off the market. This has put the supplement industry into the positon of creating “HCG-free” versions of their products become infused with “radionics” where the HCG “energy” is transferred to vitamins or amino acids. The FDA emphasizes in its warnings that all non-prescription versions of HCG are fraudulent and ineffective, as non-prescription HCG does not exist. Even “homeopathic” HCG is prohibited:
“Deceptive advertising about weight loss products is one of the most prevalent types of fraud,” said David Vladeck, director of the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection. “Any advertiser who makes health claims about a product is required by federal law to back them up with competent and reliable scientific evidence, so consumers have the accurate information they need to make good decisions.”
The FDA even notes that the infamous Quack Miranda warning is insufficient warning to consumers, when it comes to HCG:
We recognize that a number of pages on your website contain a disclaimer stating that the products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. However, notwithstanding this disclaimer, the claims made on your website for “HCG Fusion 30” and “HCG Fusion 43” clearly demonstrate that these products are drugs as defined by section 201(g)(1) of the Act [21 U.S.C. § 321(g)(1)], because they are intended to affect the structure or any function of the body.
The Alternative Universe
The lack of evidence for HCG, and the explicit FDA warnings haven’t stopped a thriving business model among those that promote alternatives to science-based medicine. In the United States, for example, a naturopath has formed the “HCG Diet Council” and is collecting anecdotes from providers and users as part of their “standardized research program” of both HCG and homeopathic HCG. “Does the FDA Want to Keep America Fat?” the council asks. In Canada, naturopaths at the Northern Centre for Integrative Medicine thumb their nose at the evidence, and Health Canada’s warning:
HCG (Human Chorionic Gonadotrophin) is authorized in Canada only for treatment of women with infertility, and only in an injectable form. There is no scientific evidence that the use of HCG either by mouth (as drops under the tongue, as advertised on the Internet) or as a self-administered injection, could promote weight loss.
NCIM honors the intent of Health Canada’s statement, which is protective in nature. Health Canada’s statement does not address the more substantive issue, which is the significant risk of not taking action to reduce your weight and risking future illness. The NCIM HCG Rx+ weight loss intervention cannot make any guarantees, it nevertheless provides a time-tested approach to weight loss that is physician supervised and individually monitored for safety and effectiveness.
And NCIM doesn’t honour the intent of the statement at all. It notes that the prescription it provides for HCG injections may be covered by private drug insurance.
And a post on HCG can’t neglect it’s biggest television promoter after Kevin Trudeau: Dr. Oz, who having recommended against the HCG diet, turned around and subsequently promoted it on his show, prompting obesity specialist Dr. Yoni Freedhoff to ask “Dr. Oz — so corrupted by fame he even sells himself out?”
Conclusion
There’s no persuasive evidence that HCG injections has any meaningful effects on weight loss. And “homeopathic” HCG is quite literally, nothing. If the HCG diet shows one thing at all, it’s the tenacity of an idea once it’s been planted. Despite warnings by researchers, health professionals, and regulators since at least 1976 about the lack of evidence for HCG as a weight loss adjunct, it continues to attract attention and new users, now promoted by naturopaths and television personalities that are indifferent to the evidence. It’s gratifying to see a regulator (the FDA in this case) take off the gloves with supplement vendors and other purveyors of HCG pseudoscience. When it comes to weight loss there are no quick fixes.

GOLO for Weight Loss
There are lots of testimonials from people who say they lost weight with GOLO, but its effectiveness is not supported by any scientific evidence.
Harriet Hall on November 29, 2022
Link

Advertisements for GOLO seem to be everywhere. They feature people who were unable to lose weight until they tried GOLO. The testimonials are enthusiastic and feature before-and-after pictures of people who lost weight, sometimes over 100 or even 200 pounds, and kept it off.
The ads claim to tell “the truth about weight loss”. They say insulin resistance is the root of the problem. But obesity is not just a result of insulin resistance. It is thought to be one of the major causes of insulin resistance.
The name GOLO means GO LOse weight, GO LOok great, GO LOve life. They say with GOLO you can eat your favorite foods, lose weight, and will never have to diet again. It is a two-part program: their GOLO for Life advice on how to eat and the dietary supplement GOLO Relief.
The GOLO for Life Plan is a 2-1-2-1 approach: 2 protein, 1 carbohydrate, 2 vegetable, 1 fat. There are no prohibited foods, no menus, just education on how to change your approach to choosing foods in order to decrease insulin resistance, lose weight, and prevent diabetes and other diseases.
GOLO Release is a tablet taken with every meal. A month’s supply costs $59.99, and many users can reduce the dose and even stop taking it after a few months. They say:
Release is a patented formulation containing 7 natural plant-based ingredients and 3 minerals. The key ingredients are organically bound, chelated minerals Zinc Bisglycinate, Chromium Nicotinate Glycinate, Banaba Leaf Extract and Rholiola Rosea. The complementary ingredients are Magnesium (chelated dimagnesium malate), Berberine , Salacia Reticulata Extract, Gardenia Jasminoides Fruit Extract, Apple Polyphenol Fruit Extract and Myo-Inositol. The ingredients in Release are proven to be safe and enhance weight loss results. There are over 200 published independent experimental studies supporting the safety and efficacy of the ingredients in Release.
Yes, there are some published studies showing that the individual ingredients have benefits like lowering blood sugar, but many of the studies are in animals, and these ingredients are not part of the standard evidence-based treatment of diabetes. It might seem logical that combining these ingredients should result in a larger effect, but it’s also possible that some ingredients might reduce the effects of others. We can’t assume anything about these mixtures; they must be tested.
They claim to have over 2 million happy customers and a 98% customer satisfaction rating. But testimonials are not reliable evidence. What we need are human studies with an appropriate control group. GOLO claims to have done such a study:
In a 2018 13-week randomized double-blind placebo-controlled study on overweight subjects, those taking Release lost significantly more weight, inches around their waists and lowered their health risk markers more than subjects taking a placebo.
Elsewhere they say, “In a 2019 study participants taking the GOLO Release supplement lost 79.9% more weight and 208 inches from their waists than those taking a placebo”. Was it 2018 or 2019? No such study was published in a peer-reviewed journal, and the mention on the GOLO website was the only thing I could find.
They make other unsupported claims for hormone balance, hunger control, immune health, faster metabolism, more energy, improved stamina, protection against damage from free radicals, support of mental focus, improved sleep, and much more.
Dietitians are not fans of the GOLO diet. One of them is concerned about the recommended calorie intake of 1200 to 1500 calories a day, which “is really low for most people over 130 pounds”. Another says “There is no conclusive scientific evidence to support the claims of this diet”. And another points out that “the studies were paid for by GOLO and cannot be found on peer-reviewed databases”.
Jennifer Brooks, the president and co-founder of GOLO, is listed as “Board-Certified in Holistic Nutrition, Certified Dietary Supplement Professional, and Degree in Culinary Arts”. That doesn’t inspire confidence. She has no legitimate scientific or medical credentials.
Conclusion: based on testimonials, not science
Any diet that gets people to lose weight and that people can stick to is great! But if you’re looking for scientific evidence that GOLO is effective, there’s nothing to be found. Will it work for you? There’s no way to know, and if it does work, it could be because it triggers a placebo response. While there’s no evidence that it is effective, there’s no evidence that it is harmful. If you can spare the money, there is no compelling reason not to give it a try.

Plenity – A New Weight Loss Pill
Plenity is a new weight loss pill designed to create a sense of fullness. It is backed by a single study where users had an average weight loss of 22 pounds. Not an effective way to achieve ideal weight, but may help some people when combined with diet and exercise.
Harriet Hall on May 10, 2022
Link
I’ve been seeing TV commercials for Plenity, and I have found them confusing. They say it is made from naturally derived building blocks found in fruits, vegetables, cellulose, and citric acid. It contains no drugs, and yet it requires a prescription. Prescription-only meds are usually drugs. What’s going on here?
Plenity is not FDA approved as a drug. It is “FDA cleared” as a class II medical device that works by mechanical means. The website says it is:
…indicated to aid weight management in adults with excess weight or obesity, a Body Mass Index (BMI) of 25-40 kg per meter squared when used in conjunction with diet or exercise…when Plenity is combined with water, small hydrogel particles are formed. These hydrated hydrogel particles do not clump together, rather they mix with food and promote a sense of fullness.
Three capsules are taken with 16 ounces of water 20 minutes before lunch and dinner. A four-week supply costs $98.
Plenity is not for everyone. You can answer a series of questions on their website and a medical professional will tell you if you are eligible, and if you are, a US-licensed physician will write you a prescription. I answered the questions honestly and was correctly told I was not eligible.
A strange requirement
Warning: Plenity prescriptions can only be filled at a single online pharmacy, GoGoMeds. This bizarre requirement makes me suspicious and I don’t know of any other prescription products with similar limitations. They don’t offer any explanation. GoGoMeds generally has good reviews but was characterized as “a possible fraud” and “a complete scam” by some online reviewers.
The study
The GLOW study, a randomized, placebo-controlled trial of Gelesis 100, which apparently is the same thing as Plenity, was published in Obesity in 2019. A summary states:
Findings: Mean weight loss was 6.4% in the treatment group compared with 4.4% in the placebo group (P = 0.0007). Significantly more patients in the treatment group achieved ≥5% weight loss compared with those in the placebo group (59 vs. 42%), and 27% of patients in the treatment group lost ≥10% of their body weight compared with 15% in the placebo group.
According to the Plenity website, average weight loss over 6 months was about 22 pounds. I wondered how it would compare to just drinking 16 ounces of water 20 minutes before meals. I’m guessing that wouldn’t be as effective, but it might be somewhat effective and would be less expensive.
Conclusion: No miracle drug, but modestly helpful
So far, effectiveness has been shown in only one placebo-controlled trial. Diet and exercise must be continued. It doesn’t work well for everyone: 6 out of 10 users lost at least 5% of their body weight; the other 4 didn’t. It appears to have fewer side effects than other weight loss products. Not a way to achieve ideal weight, but probably worth trying for patients who understand that it is only an aid and not a final solution. I hope they will be encouraged enough by a 22-pound weight loss to continue losing weight with or without Plenity.

Big Success for Anti-obesity Drug
Will an expensive, new, injectable, untested medication help people lose weight?
Maybe! But right now, we don’t know if it’s safety and efficacy profiles make it worth the price.
Harriet Hall on May 24, 2022
Link

When I saw this headline on an article in The Week magazine, I was impressed. Diet and exercise, when combined with existing obesity drugs, typically result in only a 10% weight loss; this new drug produced a 22.5% weight loss, or about 52 pounds. That sounds fantastic, but my enthusiasm quickly abated as I learned more.
In the first place, it was not intended to be an anti-obesity drug. Eli Lilly’s tirzepatide, brand name Mounjaro, was recently approved by the FDA to treat type-2 diabetes. It is given once weekly by subcutaneous injection. It is the first and only combined GIP and GLP-1 receptor agonist. Another injectable drug, Wegovy (semaglutide) was previously approved to help manage weight loss in combination with reduced-calorie diet and exercise in patients with obesity or overweight who have at least one weight-related condition such as high blood pressure, type 2 diabetes, or high cholesterol. It targets only GLP-1. I wrote about semaglutide here. GIP has been shown to decrease food intake and increase energy expenditure.
Mounjaro is not indicated for type 1 diabetes and has not been studied in patients who have had pancreatitis. It can cause thyroid cancer and there is a long list of side effects, some serious, including gall bladder and kidney problems and changes in vision. Its use for weight loss is based on what might be considered a side effect. That’s not necessarily a problem. Minoxidil was originally a blood pressure drug and was approved for treatment of hair loss after many reports of unexpected hair growth.
The retail price has been set at $12,666 a year.
The company intends to ask the FDA to approve Mounjaro for weight loss, but the study has not yet been published and the data has not been submitted for peer review.
Conclusion: Stay tuned
Tirzepatide sounds very promising as a drug to help obese and overweight people lose a substantial amount of weight (in conjunction with reduced calorie diet and exercise), but it will be expensive and is not without risk. I am cautiously optimistic but must withhold judgment for now. More research is needed, and FDA approval has not yet been granted.

Eat To Save Your Life: Another Half-True Diet Book
Val Jones on November 9, 2012
Link
I am hesitant to review diet books because they are so often a tangled mess of fact and fiction. Teasing out their truth from falsehood is about as exhausting as delousing a long-haired elementary school student. However, after being approached by the authors’ PR agency with the promise of a book that contains science-based nutrition information I decided to agree to the review. This is how the book was described to me in an email:
In their provocative new book, Eat to Save Your Life, best-selling authors Dr. Jerre Paquette and Gloria Askew, RRN, sort through the piles of information and misinformation about nutrition to reveal the true connection between food and health. Fed up with the advertising hype and conflicting nutritional advice, the duo provides common sense explanations for consumers everywhere who are looking to make smart nutritional choices.
Unfortunately, I was sold (quite predictably) a bill of goods. And rather than ignore the book and simply not do a review, I figured that maybe a negative review would reduce the number of incoming PR requests for future tomes of pseudoscience. In the end, I’ll probably just become the focus of personal attacks by dedicated proponents of various snake oils. 
That being said, I thought it might be somewhat instructive to remind SBM readers of certain basic “warning signs of pseudoscience” that I accidentally overlooked in agreeing to review the book. For a more complete review of similar “signs” I highly recommend Dr. David Gorski’s 2007 classic, humorous take on predictable arguments and behaviors of alternative medicine proponents (written in the style of comedian Jeff Foxworthy). As for me, I tend to think of much of the world of integrative medicine as a militant group of bakers eager to add odd, inert and occasionally toxic substances to cake recipes.
And so, without further ado, here is a small sample of what authors Askew and Paquette have added to their half-true diet book recipe:
    • The “one true cause” fallacy: The book opens with an interesting review of vitamin C deficiency, noting that it (apparently) took the British Royal Navy 40 years before they accepted that the treatment for scurvy was citrus extract (rather than flogging). Citing this incident as an example of nutritional deficiency leading to life-threatening illness, it’s a short ride to the “one true cause” fallacy whereby the authors postulate that there are untold numbers of modern diseases caused by unrecognized nutritional deficiency syndromes. Nutritional deficiency may be the one true cause of most diseases, you see.
    • The appeal to research without references. Countless appeals are made to “mounting evidence” of this and that (arthritis being caused primarily by food-related inflammation for example), either without reference footnotes, or with mentions of sources of dubious credibility (such as the Canadian Association of Naturopathic Doctors).
    • The appeal to supplements in lieu of vaccines. No diet advice would be complete without a gratuitous attack on vaccines, right? The authors suggest that flu vaccines (for example) only provide immunity for 2 months “and only for certain individuals.” Meanwhile, they assert that a combination of Echinacea, garlic, and vitamin C support the immune system to successfully fight of viruses. These claims are simply unproven and multiple studies have already found no benefit (over placebo) of these supplements at preventing and treating the common cold.
    • Over-diagnosis. If you think that the world of medicine is predisposed to seeing disease where there is none, try the alternative medicine world. The authors assert that everything from zits, to rashes, to “brain fog” are potential signs of grave underlying immune compromise – caused by, you guessed it, dietary deficiencies.
    • Over-supplementation. The authors argue that “supplementation is a necessity in our nutrient-robbed world.” However, new evidence doesn’t support supplementation for the general population, though it had been traditionally felt that multi-vitamins might be valuable. In addition, new studies are finding that food sources are preferable to supplements for daily nutritional requirements (such as calcium) and that anti-oxidants such as vitamin E may do more harm than good.
    • The “organic is more nutritious” argument. Although a recent systematic review of the scientific literature found no support for the notion that organic foods contain more nutrients than those grown with traditional methods, the authors attribute Americans’ supposed vitamin deficiencies to poor soil quality caused by non-organic farming methods.
    • Nutrigenomics and DNA hype. The authors do not take a sufficiently skeptical view of the emerging field of nutrigenomics (whereby certain foods and supplements are recommended to individuals based on their genetic profiles). They even suggest that nutrigenomic testing is so much fun, it’s “almost like being part of a CSI television show.” Who cares if it’s no more accurate than fortune telling?
So what’s the half true part? Well, obesity is certainly a driver of many modern illnesses, and obesity is caused by (in no small part) nutritional choices. The authors cite statistics on the ravages of heart disease, high blood pressure, and diabetes on the U.S. population which are all quite true. (How this supports the “deficiency” argument is somewhat lost on me – because it would seem more logical that a possible excess of nutrients could be the “one true cause” of a lot of these diseases, but I digress).
There are real nutritional deficiencies that cause medical problems, such as iron-deficiency anemia, neural tube defects related to folic acid deficiency, vitamin D deficiency and rickets, and osteoporosis contributed to by low calcium levels. These conditions underscore the importance of healthy eating habits, but do not support the idea that the entire population is deficient in these nutrients. In fact, a large population study analyzed by the CDC, suggests that most Americans are not deficient in any major nutrient even with their current sub-optimal and obesogenic eating habits.
In general, fair-minded individuals will find Eat To Save Your Life to be yet another example of a half-true, hysteria-peddling, micro-nutrient-obsessed diet advice book. Ironically, the book’s title itself states the opposite of what we really need to be doing to reduce obesity-related diseases: stop eating (so much) to save our lives. 
This book may be purchased (against my medical advice) at Amazon.com.

The Shred Diet: A Minimally Kooky Way To Lose Weight
Val Jones on January 11, 2013
Link

With New Years’ weight loss resolutions freshly made, let’s take a science-based look at another of the latest diet books being promoted by various public relations agencies. In my last post we explored the claims made by the hysterical Eat To Save Your Life authors in their book featuring a demonic cheeseburger on its cover jacket. Today I will review, Shred: The Revolutionary Diet ‚ 6 Weeks, 4 Inches, 2 Sizes, by Ian K. Smith, M.D.
I’m not sure what images the word “shred” conjures up for you, but if they have anything to do with muscle-bound, uber-lean bodybuilders on steroids you will be pleased to note that this book has nothing to do with them. In fact, what you’ll find in this book is a rather practical and healthy eating and exercise prescription with recipes and careful calorie counting. You’ll also find one fairly harmless chapter of liver detox pseudoscience, and an odd command to stare at yourself in the mirror at the beginning of week six.
Quietly stand in front of the mirror, and look deeply into your eyes as if you’re trying to see all the way into the depths of your soul… [p. 167]
The purpose of this visual exercise is never explained.
Since our purpose here at Science Based Medicine is (in large part) to evaluate medical claims, I will spend the remaining paragraphs focusing on the “cleanse” phase of the diet since that is the major area of scientific controversy. Shred’s week five is devoted to “eating particular foods and drinking certain beverages that naturally activate enzymes in the liver to enhance the detoxification process.” As detox regimens go, I was pleased to find nothing of harm here (I had braced myself for an exploration of coffee enemas, high dose vitamins, and extreme laxatives). Dr. Smith’s detox plan includes one daily cup of each: lemon water with flaxseed oil, cranberry juice, and hibiscus tea.
The claims? Doing this will “cause your gastrointestinal tract to move better, your energy levels will increase, and your skin will even appear healthier (some have said that it takes on a certain glow).”p. 126. So what we have here is an exceedingly mild “detox” regimen with very soft clinical endpoints that are difficult to measure objectively. 
But just for fun, let’s take a look at the potential liver enzyme influence that these 4 detox ingredients might have: hibiscus flower, lemon juice, cranberry juice, and flaxseed oil.
1.Hibiscus sabdariffa
The hibiscus plant (hibiscus sabdariffa is used to make tea) contains over 88 different chemicals, according to Dr. Duke’s Phytochemical and Ethnobotanical Databases. There is nothing particularly noteworthy about the plant’s chemical makeup, other than that it contains a significant amount of vitamin C. A review of the PubMed database revealed a smattering of small, animal and in vitro studies linking hibiscus to inducement of rat testicular atrophy and decreased hematocrit when exposed to very large doses. Hibiscus extract was found to be somewhat bacteriostatic in vitro, possibly because of its acidity. One human study of the effects of drinking hibiscus tea was presented at a medical conference. The study, sponsored by a tea company, found that hibiscus tea consumption could reduce systolic blood pressure by an average of 8mmHg in mildly hypertensive adults. The study included 65 participants in a 6 week placebo controlled trial. 
So as far as hibiscus tea is concerned, there is almost no evidence to date of its usefulness as a liver enzyme stimulator. In large doses it has some possible toxicity in rats, and in humans it may have a blood pressure lowering effect – which is interesting, but unrelated to Dr. Smith’s claims.
2.Lemon juice
In terms of the potential therapeutic effects of lemon juice, kidney stone prevention is probably the most well studied. Lemon juice is an excellent source of vitamin C, which is important for general nutritional needs.
Grapefruit is known to be an inhibitor of certain liver and intestinal enzymes that help to break down medications. Luckily, this is not a citrus “class effect” but is related to a compound unique to grapefruit. As for lemons, they seem to have no major effect on the liver.
3.Cranberry juice
Although there was some initial enthusiasm years ago about the potential for cranberry juice to reduce urinary tract infections in women, follow up studies have not found cranberry juice to be more effective than placebo. At least one small study suggests that overweight women experience an improvement in lipid oxidation (a risk factor for heart disease) with consumption of two cups of cranberry juice per day. Cranberries, like lemons and hibiscus, contain vitamin C and therefore have anti-oxidant and pro-collagen synthesis properties. As far as direct liver enzyme influence is concerned, I found nothing in the medical literature to support that claim.
4.Flaxseed oil
In theory, flaxseed oil could have anti-inflammatory effects in vivo. A recent study found no change in inflammatory markers or clotting pathways with 8 weeks of regular intake of low dose flaxseed oil. Some studies have noted a decrease in serum LDL cholesterol levels with daily consumption of flaxseed oil. Most experts agree that the desirable anti-inflammatory properties of omega-3 fatty acids are experienced in vivo via consumption of marine sources of omega-3’s only. This is because the chemical properties of fish oil and flax seeds are not biologically equivalent. While flaxseed oil may reduce LDL cholesterol, fish oil is a much more potent source of healthy omega-3 fatty acids. As far as liver “detoxification” is concerned, that does not seem to be a primary benefit of flaxseed oil.
As for the claims of “improved gastrointestinal movement” – small amounts of vitamin C, water, and plant oil are probably not going to make a noticeable difference – at least, not taken by mouth as prescribed by Shred. A “healthier, glowing skin” might be a real benefit of increased vitamin C intake in dieters with true deficiency (think scurvy) – but for those of us who are currently meeting our vitamin C needs, the excess will be excreted (as are all water-soluble vitamins) in our urine. As for the “increased energy levels” I can’t see any reason why citrus or flaxseed would provoke that response, unless you count the increased effort it will take to make a few extra bathroom breaks to relieve oneself of all the tea and juice.
And so, without further belaboring the point, I think we can safely say that Dr. Smith’s liver detox week is little more than hand waving and some increased fluid intake. 
That being said, the recipes, diet plan, and exercise prescriptions in Shred are quite sensible. Eating is organized into four, calorie-controlled meals and three snacks at regularly scheduled intervals throughout the day. Alcohol and soda are limited. The diet is rich in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, lean proteins, and healthy fats. Sugar and refined carbohydrates are avoided. Cardiovascular exercise is recommended for at least forty-five minutes per day, five days a week. The plan is presented in such detail that one can follow instructions for each meal, snack, and exercise every day for six weeks. You simply repeat the six week “course” (perhaps skipping the detox section and the part about staring into your eyes in a mirror) as many times as you like to achieve your total weight loss goal.
In my view, the Shred diet, is a reiteration of sound nutritional and exercise principles in an easy-to-follow menu format that requires little thought processing. If it didn’t wander off into the liver detox fantasy world in chapter five, it would be a sensible book indeed. 
Shred: The Revolutionary Diet – 6 Weeks, 4 Inches, 2 Sizes is now in hardcover and Kindle editions from Amazon.com.

Eat Fat, Get Thin?
Harriet Hall on December 6, 2011
Link
I recently received an e-mail from a high school science department head who is teaching a unit on nutritional science. He asked for my opinion of a YouTube video of a lecture advocating a high saturated fat diet. The speaker is Donald W. Miller, Jr., M.D., a cardiothoracic surgeon at my alma mater, the University of Washington. My correspondent commented, “I have a feeling that there is room for some skepticism.” I agree: there’s a whole lot of room for skepticism.
An article based on that video lecture is available on Dr. Miller’s website. It’s entitled “Enjoy Saturated Fats, They’re Good for You!” If you want to judge for yourselves, I recommend the article over the video, as he is a poor public speaker.
Dr. Miller’s website contains a lot of disturbing material. He appears to be a contrarian who disagrees with the consensus of scientific experts on a wide variety of topics, for instance:
    • Health Benefits of a Low-Carbohydrate, High-Saturated Fat Diet
    • Fighting Fluoride [fluoride is poison!]
    • Cardiac Surgeon Dr. Donald Miller Tells Dr. Dean Ornish to Take a Hike
    • Avoid Flu Shot, Take Vitamin D [flu is a Vitamin D deficiency disease?]
    • Questioning HIV/AIDS, Human-Caused Global Warming, and other Orthodoxies in the Biomedical Sciences
    • A User-Friendly Vaccination Schedule [no vaccinations before age 2, no live vaccines, etc.]
He refers to questionable sources of information like the Weston Price Foundation and the notorious AIDS denialist Peter Duesberg.
Based on the company it keeps, it would be tempting to write off his diet advice as crankery. But I tried to ignore who was saying it and give a fair hearing to what he was saying. He begins by attacking the lipid hypothesis: the idea that fat in the diet causes elevated blood cholesterol which causes cardiovascular disease. This no longer needs attacking: mainstream recommendations have followed the evidence and have evolved from a low cholesterol diet to a low fat diet to a low saturated fat diet to avoidance of trans-fats and of excess calories from fat. He echoes Gary Taubes’ low-carb arguments and his contention that government recommendations to avoid fat led to higher carbohydrate intake and thereby caused the obesity epidemic. That may be true, but it doesn’t justify his conclusion that the solution to the obesity epidemic is to replace carbohydrates in the diet with saturated fat.
He relies on epidemiologic data and evolutionary arguments to show that dietary fat is good: he says that breast-fed babies get high-fat milk, Eskimos and the Maasai eat a high-fat diet and don’t develop CVD (cardiovascular disease), the paleolithic diet was high in fat, and our genome has evolutionarily adapted to a high fat diet. In fact, the groups he cites do develop CVD, although they have a low incidence. He conveniently fails to consider any other possible explanations for why people like the Maasai might have less CVD: they are thin, get a lot of strenuous exercise, have different genes, and have a low life expectancy, often dying of infectious disease and trauma before they are old enough to have developed signs of heart disease.
He says protein is bad for you in excess: it causes nausea, diarrhea, etc. He repeats Gary Taubes’ arguments to demonize carbohydrates. He prefers fat, particularly saturated fat, and recommends it constitute 70% of our diet.
His epiphany came from reading an article in Nexus in 1999 that led him to question Dean Ornish’s low fat advice. He was further influenced by the book Eat Fat, Lose Fat by Mary Enig and Sally Fallon (co-founders of the Weston A. Price Foundation, which has been criticized by medical experts as purveying misleading information) and by the writings of notorious cholesterol denialist Uffe Ravnskov.
He cites data from the Framingham study showing that over age 50, there is no effect of either high or low cholesterol levels on mortality except for those whose cholesterol level is falling: for every 1% drop in cholesterol levels, there is an 11% increase in all-cause mortality. He doesn’t mention that the same study showed a robust correlation of cholesterol levels with mortality below age 50, and that the authors said the data for those over 50 is confounded by people whose cholesterol levels are not stable, but falling — perhaps due to diseases predisposing to death. He cites an article by Castelli allegedly showing that increased saturated fat, cholesterol and calories in the diet are associated with decreased blood cholesterol and that people who ate more cholesterol, saturated fat and calories had lower weight and increased activity levels. This was not an original study but a commentary accompanying an article about The Seventh Day Adventist Health Study showing that, in vegetarians who ate nuts and whole wheat bread, greater nut consumption was correlated with lower CVD mortality. In fact, Seventh Day Adventists have lower blood cholesterol levels, lower fat consumption, and lower mortality rates than the general population.
His is not a fair assessment of the literature, but an exercise in cherry-picking and confirmation bias. The consensus of experts who have reviewed all the published evidence is that high blood LDL cholesterol is a major risk factor for CVD and that lowering it reduces risk, with a greater effect on those with multiple risk factors.
He says, “A hundred years ago less than one in one hundred Americans were obese and coronary heart disease was unknown.” It was hardly unknown, although it was admittedly less prevalent and may not have been diagnosed with that name. He is correct that obesity has become a serious problem and is a risk factor for diabetes, heart disease, and a number of other illnesses; but he goes too far when he claims
    • that it has been “proven” that CVD, diabetes, and cancer are nutrition diseases;
    • that a low fat/high carb diet is a human-made disaster comparable to wars and economic meltdowns and to natural disasters like hurricanes, the Ice Age and asteroid impacts;
    • that soda pop trucks are Weapons of Mass Destruction.
He plays the conspiracy card. He says that scientists who question state-sanctioned paradigms like low fat diets, mutations as a cause of cancer, and HIV as a cause of AIDS are denied grants and silenced. In fact, some of them are very loud for people who have been “silenced,” and they may have been denied grants simply because their research was not as worthy as competing grant proposals.
Taubes says as long as you avoid carbs you can eat all the protein and fat you want and not gain weight. Miller goes even further, claiming that a high fat diet will make you lose weight. I think any influence on weight loss is due to a decrease in calorie intake; admittedly, the satiety from fat might reduce total calorie consumption, but this has not been proven to have any practical effect on dieters.
Miller says
The ideal caloric ratio between carbohydrates, fats, and protein is carbohydrates, 10-15 percent; proteins, 15-25 percent; and fats, 60-70 percent of calories, with the majority of them being saturated fats. Among the different kinds of fats, saturated fats and monounsaturated fats are good; except for omega-3 and a small amount of omega-6 essential fatty acids, polyunsaturated fats are bad in the high quantities that they are eaten in a Western diet, particularly industrially processed vegetable oils; and trans fats are terrible. Saturated animal fat is best obtained from grass-fed beef and pastured chickens, along with nitrate-free, additive-free bacon and sausage; and seafood from wild, not farm-raised, fish.
Some of this sounds like ideology based on the natural fallacy. He starts each day with two tablespoons of coconut oil. He claims that eggs from pastured poultry are much richer in nutrients, that organic isn’t good enough, and that the “Sacred Cow” transforms green grass and sunlight into vitamins A, D, and K and that this process is enhanced when cows are contented, grass fed, and not confined. He cites no peer-reviewed studies as evidence for these claims, but cites his own articles and podcasts and unreliable books by Enig and Ravnskov, and he shows a video of Julia Child talking about how much she liked the French fries from McDonald’s when they were deep-fried in lard. In passing, he mentions that aspartame is neurotoxic and causes obesity; I think he’s wrong about that. He also links Alzheimer’s to a deficiency of saturated fat and asthma to a lack of the dietary fat needed to make lung surfactant.
He says:
Saturated fats work best for losing weight. In a randomized, double-blind trial comparing the effects of coconut oil and polyunsaturated vegetable (soybean) oil in women with abdominal obesity, women who consumed coconut oil had a significant reduction in waist circumference (with no change in cholesterol levels). Women taking vegetable oil had no change in their waist size and had a statistically significant increase in LDL cholesterol and reduction in HDL cholesterol (Lipids 2009;44:596–601).
This is cherry-picking and misrepresentation. The study doesn’t support his claim: it was a small trial and in fact it showed no difference in weight, but only a change in waist circumference.
Miller manages to ignore the mountain of data that resulted in the current recommendations for the prevention and treatment of heart disease. It is probable that the dangers of saturated fat have been exaggerated, but no reputable cardiologist would claim that saturated fat is good for you or that fat should make up 70% of the diet. Cardiologists have become more liberal about allowing some cholesterol and fat in the diet, but they still consider fat intake as part of the complex equation of risk factors. Fat contains 9 calories per gram compared to 4 calories per gram for protein and carbohydrates, and the calories can add up fast to contribute to weight gain.
Serendipitously, I have on my desk an uncorrected proof of a book by two cardiologists that is scheduled for publication in January. They mention that recent studies have questioned the saturated fat/CVD link but they suggest that those studies only compared one unhealthy diet to another. Reducing saturated fat in the diet is not good for the heart if you replace the fat with refined carbohydrates and more calories. The heart-healthy diet that is supported by the best evidence is the Mediterranean diet, although even there the evidence isn’t perfect, because no good controlled prospective studies have been done to show that switching to that diet actually reduces mortality. They recommend avoiding trans fats and limiting eggs, fatty meat, saturated fat, and salt, consistent with the guidelines of the American Heart Association and every other credible source of diet advice.
I see Dr. Miller as an example of an oft-repeated pattern. A conventional doctor becomes frustrated with his inability to help some of his patients, and he becomes seduced by an overly simplistic answer based on anecdote and speculation; then confirmation bias does the rest. He convinces himself that his new treatment plan is working. He cherry-picks the literature, writes books and articles, proselytizes to the world, imagines conspiracies against the Truth he has found, and generally becomes far more enthusiastic than the evidence warrants. He is sure he is right, and considers his experience proof enough; whereas a true scientist entertains other possible explanations, engages in meaningful debate with peers who disagree, and even tries to prove himself wrong. Listening to Miller gave me déjà vu all over again, and made me feel rather sad.

The Diet Fix
Scott Gavura on February 27, 2014
Link
Diets fail. Not just often, but almost always—90% of the time. If diets worked we wouldn’t have a worldwide obesity problem. And obesity is a problem that needs to be solved. The prevalence of obesity has doubled since 1980. As a public health issue, there are few determinants of illness that are more destructive, as obesity contributes to the growing rates of diabetes, heart disease, and even cancer. There’s no “one true cause” of all illness, but obesity comes pretty close. When people ask me for the single most important thing they can do for their health, my advice (after quitting smoking) is to (1) ensure you keep your weight under control and (2) exercise in any way possible.
Despite its tremendous impact on health, I’ve only blogged about obesity in an indirect way—by pointing out what doesn’t work. Dr. Oz is my perpetual source of bad health information with his regular promotion of bogus “weight loss” supplements like the green coffee bean “miracle”. I’ve also criticized eating programs like the fads of “Eating Clean”, gluten “intolerance”, or harmful diet delusions like “detox”. It’s the typical skeptical science blogger approach—spot pseudoscience, debunk it, and hope you did something good. But none of my posts have focused on what one should do—just what you shouldn’t. Weekly SBM contributor Dr. Mark Crislip recently commented that what we (SBM) support manifests in what we oppose. He’s right, because that’s the easy approach. Using the principles of science-based medicine, there’s an awful lot to oppose in the current writing and popular opinion on how to treat obesity. And my professional advice in the role of a pharmacist has been limited to steering people away from supplements, and then giving some basic advice about dietary planning. Anecdotes and platitudes. I admit that I’ve told patients to “eat less and exercise more”.
I surmised several years ago that if I could be a more effective advocate and coach on obesity, I could deliver some meaningful health benefits to my patients—likely far greater than any medication. I started following obesity and nutrition experts who blog and tweet, and began to read the literature they cited. What I learned left me a bit chastened. My basic advice about eating less and exercising wasn’t wrong—but it was simplistic, incomplete, and almost certainly ineffective. I didn’t recognize the drivers of obesity in the population—and how people can identify and change them. Sure, “Eat food, not too much, mostly plants” has a kernel of truth. But alone, that type of recommendation isn’t helpful for weight loss. It isn’t a lack of willpower that has almost tripled childhood and adolescent obesity rates since 1980, and made one third of adults obese. Exercise as the sole strategy for weight loss is actually a terrible strategy. And while I knew most of the popular diet plans rarely succeed in the long run, I didn’t know what the evidence actually said about effective interventions. Other than recommending blogs and articles, I didn’t have any resource I could recommend without reservation, especially for those that prefer books over blogs. Until I read The Diet Fix [Amazon]—the first “diet” book I’ve read that is science-based and pseudoscience-free.
I’ve been a fan of Dr. Yoni Freedhoff’s blog Weighty Matters for years—it’s deservedly one of the most popular blogs about obesity. Freedhoff is a fierce critic of obesity pseudoscience and also an outspoken critic of the products and policies that contribute to today’s obesogenic environment. As a family physician with his own obesity practice, Freedhoff brings to the blog a knowledge of the medical literature, combined with extensive experience working directly with obese patients.
The healthiest life you can enjoy
This is an unconventional diet book because it doesn’t recommend what many will think of as a “diet” at all. If you’re looking for a strict meal plan with foods that are either celebrated or demonized, you’ll be disappointed. There are no traumatic sacrifices required. No starvation, no cleanses, and no miracle supplements.
Freedhoff opens the book describing “Dieting’s Seven Deadly Sins”, which are commonly held, but dangerous, beliefs about dieting. Hunger is the first myth to go. Freedhoff argues that any diet plan that leaves you hungry won’t be sustainable. Sacrifice is next—perpetual sacrifice of anything you enjoy will make any diet fail. Willpower is important, but permanent resistance is almost certainly futile. Blind food restrictions are the next to go, and Freedhoff is adamant we need to manage, but not banish, certain food groups. Sweating is the next myth, with The Biggest Loser epitomizing the belief that exercise can contribute to significant weight loss. You can’t outrun your fork—not in the long run. Anticipating perfection is also a myth, so real diets must be flexible enough to accommodate setbacks. Denial is the last myth. “The diet was great—I just couldn’t stick with it” is a common refrain. As weight loss progresses, any suffering gets harder to sustain, and harder to deny.
Given almost all typical “diets” don’t deliver long-term results, few who read The Diet Fix will be dieting newbies. Negative emotions and expectations from dieting are to be expected and Freedhoff reviews the most common traumas, and how to address them. These include guilt, shame, failure, depression, despair, binge eating, and weight cycling/metabolic slowdown.
The core of the book is focused on what Freedhoff calls the “Ten Day Reset” that is designed to “reset” behaviors and recalibrate expectation about what a “diet” really should be. Each day describes how to develop a new set of skills to support permanent behavior change. One of the points that Freedhoff repeatedly emphasizes is in order to make permanent changes in your weight, you must be prepared to make permanent changes in your life. And the more weight you want to lose, the more of your life you must be prepared to permanently change. Any intervention that is too difficult to sustain will eventually be abandoned, so Freedhoff emphasizes that one’s target weight must be based on a “best weight”. The “best weight” is the point at which you’ve found a balance between your weight and your own satisfaction and willingness to stick to a plan. There are no promises of magical (and unsustainable) weight loss. This is an approach for a lifetime.
The ten days of the reset are as follows:
     1.  Gearing up: Scales, for you and for your kitchen, to measure and weigh food (and yourself) accurately. A journal (for a food diary) is essential. And buy food. Freedhoff emphasizes healthier choices and thoughtful selections, and recommends minimizing refined carbs (including juice) while promoting whole foods. He doesn’t demonize any food group, except (justifiably) artificially-created trans fats.
     2.  The food diary: All food has a metabolic cost, and it’s measured in calories. It’s promoted as a tool to guide eating, and make eating more conscientious. Freedhoff not only encourages logging what was eaten, but also the calories, when it was eaten, and any hunger cravings. There are a number of online sites and phone apps that make logging take only minutes per day.
     3.  Banishing hunger: Keep hunger pains at bay by eating regularly: Don’t skip breakfast, eat every 2-3 hours (set reminders if necessary), and include adequate protein (for satiety) every time you eat. Your daily calorie “budget” needs to be allocated across your meals.
     4.  Cook: Regularly eating purchased and prepared meals make it more difficult to control portions and calories. Cook real foods focusing on healthy ingredients. Minimize using refined and processed foods as much as possible, but not so much that you’ll give up.
     5.  Think: Describe your best weight—one in which you’re living the healthiest life you can honestly enjoy.
     6.  Exercise: You can’t out-exercise a bad diet, but regular exercise helps keep weight off, and changes your attitude for the better. And exercise has enormous health benefits beyond any impact on weight. What exercise? Something. Anything. “Some is good, more is better, everything counts” Freedhoff suggests.
     7.  Indulge: There are no forbidden foods. Real life includes indulgences, and permanently denying yourself pleasurable foods (whatever they may be) makes any diet plan unsustainable. So one must learn to manage indulges in a calorically-responsible way. Freedhoff suggests asking yourself two questions: “Is it worth the calories?” and “How much of it do I need to be happy?”
     8.  Eat out: Cooking is crucial, but eating out is part of life for many—so navigating a restaurant successfully is an essential weight management skill. Freedhoff suggests knowing your calories, pre-eating, moderating alcohol, and making thoughtful choices between calories and food you’ll actually enjoy.
     9.  Goal setting: Behavior change is accelerated when goals are achieved. The two most important goals are (1) to eat the smallest number of calories possible (while still liking your life) and (2) to exercise as much as you can enjoy.
     10.  Troubleshoot: Making permanent change can inevitably lead to roadblocks, and Freedhoff looks at the commonly encountered roadblocks to sustainability.
Freedhoff is adamant that there is no one perfect “diet” for everyone, so The Diet Fix doesn’t prescribe one beyond his general guidelines. The behaviors and skills are relevant to any approach to weight loss—as long as you’re enjoying the approach and see it as sustainable for the long-term, then it will work. Freedhoff repeatedly emphasizes that healthy living is a lifelong approach—not something you can repair with a “quick fix” diet or detox.
In this book we obey the laws of thermodynamics
Freedhoff tackles a number of diet and obesity issues throughout the book, blowing up cherished myths throughout:
    • Calories do matter (Yes, Taubes is still wrong). Calories are the fundamental unit of energy and counting calories is the intervention that Freedhoff ranks more important than anything else in the book.
    • Low carb/Low fat/Paleo/Vegan are all acceptable—if you can sustain it, and as long as you watch caloric balance. Freedhoff argues against demonizing any food (even chocolate has its place, he says) and cautions that your diet must be sustainable.
    • The enemy isn’t carbs/fat/glucose/gluten. Cutting out food groups can sometimes deliver short term results (like low-carb) but they’re difficult to maintain over the long term.
    • Dietary fats are not the enemy. Saturated fat is not the health risk it was once believed to be. Unsaturated fats may offer health benefits, so ensuring these are part of your diet is probably a good idea.
    • There are no magical supplements. There is no persuasive evidence to support the long-term effectiveness of any supplement.
    • Artificial sweeteners are safe, and can be beneficial as part of a weight loss strategy. The same cannot be said for sugar.
Conclusion
The Diet Fix is an oddity among the diet books you’ll find in bookstores. There are no outlandish promises, no strict dietary rules, no excessive exercise, and no recommendations for supplements and potions. I doubt we’ll see Dr. Freedhoff’s book profiled on Dr. Oz. And that’s a shame because this book deserves a wide audience, especially to those that have struggled and failed on the types of weight loss strategies that Dr. Oz loves to tout. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend The Diet Fix as a science-based guide for anyone that seeking credible and sustainable advice on permanent weight loss.
Full disclosure: I received a free copy of The Diet Fix from the publisher, but I was not asked (nor did I offer) to write a review of the book.

Blue Zones Diet: Speculation Based on Misinformation
The Blue Zones where people live longer may be a myth. The Blue Zone Diet is based on speculation, not solid science.
Harriet Hall on October 12, 2021
Link

The so-called Blue Zones are geographical locations where people are said to live longer than elsewhere. These include Sardinia, Okinawa, Loma Linda (California), the Nicoya Peninsula in Costa Rica, and Icaria, Greece. They have been studied looking for common factors that might promote longevity. Some of the common factors: these are people who live in tight knit communities, they eat well, following a Mediterranean or plant-based diet, they don’t over-exercise but they have a busy domestic life with energetic chores. The Blue Zone Diet assumes that common dietary factors have been identified and that following the diet will make us live longer. That appears to be a false assumption based on speculation, misinformation, and wishful thinking, not on science.
Blue Zones may be a myth
The claims of longevity in those locations may be based on fraud and error. Record-keeping has been deficient in many of those areas; systematic verification of age has been practiced only recently and only in some parts of the world. People may be confused with parents and grandparents who had the same name. People can misremember. People can lie. The longest verified life span was that of Jeanne Calment of France, who died at age 122.
Loma Linda has a longer-than-average life span. This has been attributed to the large population of Seventh Day Adventists with a healthy lifestyle, but it might just be due to the fact that people who are richer tend to live longer. Similar longevity might be found in other well-to-do locations. There have been no good studies to rule out possible confounders.
The Okinawa claim is now disputed. Overall Japan has the highest life expectancy of any country, but recent data shows that men in Okinawa don’t live as long as men in other Japanese prefectures. A recent commentary in the journal Gerontology pointed out that “Current demographic and nutritional data suggest that the remarkable Okinawan longevity is now a phenomenon of the past”.
Even if they did live longer, it might have nothing to do with their diet
It is simplistic to assume that diet is the reason. There could be any number of confounding factors such as heredity and lifestyle differences. Science has been studying dietary factors that might improve longevity, but it hasn’t come up with any definitive answers. Calorie restriction prolongs life in many animals but the data for primates is mixed, and the concept has not been proven in humans. The positive studies in other animals have involved very severe calorie restriction. Most people would not find such a diet palatable or feasible, and it might be difficult to ensure adequate nutrition. Nevertheless, some optimistic people are already following a very low-calorie diet. The Calorie Restriction website claims that death can be postponed for many years. Time will tell whether their optimism is warranted.
How could there be one Blue Zones diet?
Obviously, the diet of an Okinawan in Japan is markedly different from the diet of a Seventh Day Adventist in Loma Linda, California. The idea of a Blue Zone diet doesn’t make sense, but they thought they could identify enough common factors to devise a diet and lifestyle that would reveal the secret of longevity.
Apparently, the secret to longevity is that there is no secret
The Blue Zone Diet essentially repeats much of the conventional advice for a healthy diet:
A diet similar to the Mediterranean diet, with whole grains, fruits, vegetables, nuts, legumes, seeds, and spices, with meat consumed sporadically, mainly fish and lean meat. Olive oil is preferable to butter. Meat limited to 2 oz. servings twice a week from free-range animals. Avoid processed foods. Up to 3 oz. of fish daily; avoid farmed fish, overfished species, and fish with high levels of mercury, PCBs, or other chemicals. Minimize dairy. No more than 3 eggs per week. At least half a cup of beans daily. Slash sugar (no more than seven added teaspoons a day. Snack on nuts (two handfuls a day). Replace common bread with sourdough or 100% whole wheat bread. Eat whole foods that are recognizable for what they are. Avoid foods wrapped in plastic and foods with more than five ingredients. Try to eat at least three “super blue” foods a day: these include beans, greens, sweet potatoes, nuts, olive oil, oats, barley, fruits, green or herbal teas, and turmeric. To drink: coffee and tea OK; red wine in moderation; avoid soda pop.
To make it easier to remember, there are four “always” foods: 100% whole wheat bread, nuts, beans, fruit. And there are four foods to avoid: sugar-sweetened beverages, salty snacks, packaged sweets, and processed meats.
Some of these guidelines are based on good science; others have been questioned, for instance the idea of “super foods”.
Lifestyle
In Dan Buettner’s book The Blue Zones, he provides these nine lessons that characterize the lifestyles of people who live in the Blue Zones:
     1.  Moderate, regular physical activity
     2.  Life purpose
     3.  Stress reduction
     4.  Moderate caloric intake
     5.  Plant-based diet
     6.  Moderate alcohol intake, especially wine
     7.  Engagement in spirituality or religion
     8.  Engagement in family life
     9.  Engagement in social life
Conclusion: Myth and speculation, not solid science
        ◦ If you follow these Blue Zone guidelines, will you live longer? Maybe. We simply don’t know yet. Good controlled studies are lacking, and time will tell. Humans live a long time, so the effect of this diet won’t be measurable until many years have passed. In the absence of good data, I’d rather follow the advice of Craig Good’s book which I reviewed last week: relax and enjoy your food.

Intermittent Fasting
Harriet Hall on December 15, 2015
Link
Fasting can mean anything from total abstinence from food and beverages to restricting specific foods or the hours of food intake. Many religions have traditions of fasting, with various restrictions. There is a good summary of those traditions on Wikipedia. The reason for religious fasting is not to improve health, but for other reasons like improving discipline and demonstrating devotion.
There are many health claims for different fasting regimens. Daily calorie restriction has been demonstrated to prolong lifespans in several organisms, from yeast and worms to mice and monkeys, although the evidence for monkeys is equivocal and there is no evidence for humans. There is some evidence that intermittent fasting can forestall and even reverse cancer, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and neurodegenerative disorders in mice. In humans, there is some evidence that it might help reduce obesity, hypertension, asthma, and rheumatoid arthritis. How good is the evidence?
Two good reviews of the evidence for fasting
There is a good summary of the relevant research on intermittent fasting here. That article also covers the physiologic and metabolic responses to fasting and argues that they ought to lead to improvement in health. I won’t go into the details here. You can read the article if you want to know more. It’s complicated. Basically, intermittent fasting has potential benefits for anti-aging, cancer, cognitive function, inflammation, hypertension, and the metabolic syndrome; but the evidence so far is insufficient to justify making clinical recommendations.
Another recent review article examines the physiologic reactions to the following regimens in animals and humans:
     1.  Calorie restriction (CR) of 20-40% with 3 meals a day
     2.  Intermittent energy restriction (IER), e.g., reduce to 500 calories a day on 2 days a week
     3.  Alternate day fasting (ADF – food only every other day)
     4.  Time-restricted feeding (TRF) (intake limited to a 4-6 hour window)
They point out evolutionary arguments that support fasting: eating patterns of mammals typically involve intermittent energy intake, not three meals a day. Evolution did not prepare us for the modern lifestyle of widely availability high calorie foods and sedentary habits; this lifestyle makes us susceptible to obesity and various diseases. We might do better to eat intermittently like our ancestors did.
They also cover circadian rhythms, which are disrupted by artificial lighting and shift work. There is evidence that this contributes to ill health. There is a circadian rhythm to hunger, with a trough in the morning and a peak in the evening. So maybe eating breakfast isn’t “natural” and isn’t as essential as we have been led to believe.
So far, human studies of fasting in overweight and normal weight subjects have produced mixed results, with generally more favorable results for the obese. Genetic factors may predict which individuals will benefit. The authors conclude:
Further studies are required… As findings from basic research studies and controlled interventional trials accrue, consensus recommendations for healthy patterns of meal frequency and diurnal timing may eventually emerge. If sufficient evidence does emerge to support public health and clinical recommendations to alter meal patterning, there will be numerous forces at play in the acceptance or resistance to such recommendations.
Other considerations regarding fasting
Various fasting regimens have been recommended to aid weight loss, and it seems logical that not eating during some periods would tend to decrease total calorie intake. But a 2003 mouse study found that every-other-day fasting had benefits that were not related to total calorie intake. The mice’s overall food intake did not decrease, and their body weight did not change, but their glucose and insulin levels were reduced and their neurons became more resistant to excitotoxic stress.
A 2014 study in mice found that prolonged fasting (48 hours) promoted stem-cell-based regeneration of the hematopoietic system after damage from chemotherapy by downregulating IGF-1 and PKA activity. The authors speculated that their findings might have significance for human aging and disease. More studies will be needed before it can be recommended to humans. They cautioned that fasting might not be safe for patients who were underweight or had risk factors like diabetes. And fasting can result in headaches and drops in blood pressure that might make driving dangerous.
A 2007 review of studies of alternate day fasting (ADF) found discrepancies between human and animal studies, and could only conclude that:
ADF may effectively modulate metabolic and functional risk factors, thereby preventing or delaying the future occurrence of common chronic diseases, at least in animal models. The effect of ADF on chronic disease risk in normal-weight human subjects remains unclear, however, as do the mechanisms of action. Much work remains to be done to understand this dietary strategy fully.
Joe Mercola recommends fasting, which is worrisome. His website is on the “top 10 worst anti-science websites” list.
Concerns about fasting
Concerns have been raised about various possible adverse effects. It might lower glucose tolerance in women. It might increase blood pressure and cholesterol levels. Some people have gained weight on ADF. It might contribute to eating disorders and create an unhealthy obsession with food. It increases stress and elevates cortisol levels. People on the diet are not fun to be around. Since coffee is allowed, it could lead to overindulgence in caffeine, insomnia, etc. It might increase food intolerances and inflammation. These are largely just speculations not yet supported by any evidence.
Conclusions: Fasting might help, maybe
     1.  People who can tolerate periods of hunger might find intermittent fasting helpful for weight loss; it is simpler to not eat than to try to decide what to eat.
     2.  Although some of the evidence for intermittent fasting sounds promising, we don’t yet know whether it will prolong life or improve health.
     3.  It may be OK to skip breakfast.
     4.  We don’t yet know what the optimum meal frequency and timing are in health or in disease.
     5.  More research is needed, particularly well-designed human trials comparing various fasting regimens to the traditional three meals a day.

The McDougall Diet
Dr. McDougall is a maverick who disagrees with most experts. He recommends a high starch, low fat diet with no dairy or animal foods and other prohibitions. Its severe restrictions make it nutritionally questionable and it has never been properly tested in a controlled study.
Harriet Hall on October 20, 2020
Link

It is commonly believed that people who want to lose weight should avoid starchy foods like potatoes and pasta, and low-carb diets are often recommended. I was surprised to hear that a medical doctor, John A. McDougall, was recommending a starch-based diet for weight control. He claimed patients on his diet lost 6-15 pounds a month while eating as much as they wanted of approved foods. He was even claiming that a high-starch diet could be used to treat chronic diseases such as arthritis, cancer, diabetes, osteoporosis, and heart disease.
I found that hard to believe; but since McDougall is an MD board certified in internal medicine, I couldn’t just dismiss him as an uneducated quack. I assumed he must have found convincing evidence to support his claims. I read his book The McDougall Program: 12 Days to Dynamic Health hoping to find that evidence. I was disappointed. The book was full of anecdotes, testimonials, lists of foods that are permitted or prohibited, shopping lists, menus, and high starch recipes. Many claims were made without supporting evidence. Evidence appeared only twice:
     1.  In Chapter 3, he says “Scientific support for the material in this chapter” can be found in another of his books, The McDougall Plan, published in 1984.
     2.  Part 3 covers dietary and lifestyle treatment of medical conditions and is followed by a section of references applying to the material in Part 3.
The section on Treatment of Medical Conditions included a lot of questionable statements. He says lactose cannot be digested by most adults; that’s simply wrong. Under Diabetes, he claims that patients with childhood-onset diabetes will usually drop their insulin needs by 30 percent and their blood sugar levels will be more stable (less brittle). None of the listed references support that claim. He says insulin dose adjustments should be made “as usual, with the aid of urine sugar and blood sugar tests”. Does anyone still monitor diabetics with urine tests? The references are outdated, all from the 1970s and 1980s. He recommends never taking oral hypoglycemic drugs because they increase your chances of dying sooner. (Wrong! More recent studies have demonstrated that they actually reduce mortality.) And he says he usually stops the pills of adult-onset diabetics the very day they start his Program. That could be dangerous!
He blames diet for hair loss because he read a book review of a Japanese book with the title Can Hair Grow Again? He says treating high blood pressure with medications doesn’t work. Wrong! It demonstrably does. I was particularly intrigued by the discussion of Multiple Sclerosis. He says that for most of his patients with MS, the progress of MS symptoms has been halted. He cites a study by Dr. Roy Swank, saying he treated more than 3,000 MS patients with a low fat diet; he says Swank’s results are unchallenged by other studies and are unmatched in effectiveness. Swank’s study began in 1949 and his results for 144 patients were published in The Lancet in 1990. There was no control group. And his results certainly have been challenged, repeatedly. A recent study reported decreased subjective self-reports of fatigue but “no significant improvement on brain MRI, relapse rate or disability”.
The references listed were far from convincing. For example, there were five references for acne. The most recent one was from 1981; the others dated back to 1964, 1966, 1969, and 1977. More recent articles and systematic reviews with different findings were not listed, such as a 2016 Cochrane review that said “only a small proportion of studies met sufficiently high scientific standards that would enable therapeutic recommendations to be made in practice”.
Criticism
I scrupulously resisted reading the criticisms of other people until I had given the book a chance. After it failed to convince me, I found that there were plenty of others who were equally unconvinced. My SkepDoc’s Rule is “Before you accept a claim, try to find out who disagrees with it and why.” In this case, pretty much all health care providers and nutrition experts disagree, and they have a very good reason: they follow the published evidence. How likely is it that they are all wrong and this one individual is the only one to get it right? Not very.
McDougall claims there is “overwhelming evidence” to support his diet. An article on SkepticBlog has fun with his claim that dairy food causes all disease:
And the science is overwhelming! Well, if this guy says so, it must be true. But I wonder how he has come to this conclusion, since McDougall has not managed to convince any meaningful percentage of the medical community that outrageous claims are anything other than quackery. This total failure constitutes “overwhelming science”?
That article goes on to point out that the preponderance of published research supports exactly the opposite of what McDougall claims. Nutritionist Kurt Butler agrees, saying that while McDougall backs up his claims with published medical studies, his interpretations of those studies are often at odds with the studies’ authors.
The Wikipedia article on McDougall concludes, “There is no scientific evidence that McDougall’s diet is effective”.
A book review by Stare and Whelan says McDougall has “peculiar ideas about food” and “eccentric ideas about the relationship between food and disease”. It concludes that:
The concepts in this book are extreme and out of keeping with nutrition reality. The diet is nutritionally precarious and, we hope, too austere for anyone to think about trying to follow.
What exactly is the McDougall Program?
     1.  Follow a diet centered around starches with the addition of fresh or frozen fruits and vegetables.
     2.  Give up meats, fish, poultry, dairy products, eggs, oils, refined foods, alcohol, and caffeine (except for rare special occasions). Limit fat, sugar, and salt.
     3.  Exercise every day.
McDougall has long offered an inpatient program in Santa Rosa, California, but now the same program is available to people who stay at home, for a reduced cost of $2,495. Whether inpatient or online, dramatic results are promised: improved appearance, rapid weight loss, lower blood pressure and blood sugar, improved biomarkers for cardiac risk, and an end to annoying discomforts like headaches, bowel irregularity, and chronic fatigue.
Other possible explanations
Patients who experience those improvements will attribute them to the Program, but are all those restrictions really necessary? I suspect not. They might see similar improvements if they reduced total calorie intake by other means and exercised regularly. Suggestion and psychological factors surely play a part. It would be nice to have a controlled study comparing the McDougall diet to a less restrictive, nutritionally balanced, calorie-limited diet. But we don’t; and I doubt if we will in the foreseeable future. Meanwhile, I’d rather accept the preponderance of evidence than the questionable assertions of a maverick. Some of McDougall’s recommendations are in line with mainstream advice, but there is reason to fear that strict adherence to his whole Program might result in nutritional deficits that could do more harm than good.

GAPS Diet
Harriet Hall on May 7, 2013
Link
A correspondent asked me to look into the GAPS diet. I did. I was sorry: it was a painful experience. What a mishmash of half-truths, pseudoscience, imagination, and untested claims!
GAPS stands for Gut and Psychology Syndrome. It is the invention of Dr. Natasha Campbell-McBride. According to her, a wide variety of health problems can be traced to a single cause: an imbalance of gut microbes. She cites ancient wisdom: Hippocrates said all diseases begin in the gut. She says science confirmed that wisdom when it discovered that 90% of all cells and all genetic material in the human body belongs to the gut flora. She says the modern world poses many dangers for the gut flora, and once it is damaged, the health of the whole body enters a downward slide towards disease. She claims that autism and ADD, OCD, schizophrenia, epilepsy, depression, and numerous other ailments are all digestive disorders.
According to her, the gut flora is “highly organized” (?) and is dominated by beneficial species. When the balance is out of whack, children don’t digest and absorb food properly, and they develop all kinds of symptoms in the digestive tract and elsewhere. The microbes convert the undigested food into hundreds of toxic substances, which clog the body with toxicity. The brain becomes so clogged with toxins that it can’t process sensory information, so children are unable to learn and develop skills. When the toxicity levels are low, they may show single signs like hyperactivity or dyslexia. With higher levels, autism develops. 80% of these clogged children have a mixture of symptoms that don’t fit into any diagnostic category, but it is important for them to be identified as suffering from GAPS early in life to prevent permanent damage.
Explaining the Autism EpidemicShe explains why we are seeing more autism. It’s not so much an autism epidemic as an epidemic of abnormal gut flora. She says autistic children were born perfectly normal (not true), but after birth they developed abnormal gut flora which created toxicity. Babies get their gut microbes from Mom as they pass through the birth canal, microbes that originated in the bowels of both parents. They get pathogenic microbes because the parents’ good microbes were wiped out when they took antibiotics earlier in life. The disruption of gut flora leads not only to autism but to many other diseases.
Another factor is that breastfeeding went out of fashion. Bottle fed babies develop abnormal gut flora. Breastfed babies don’t because the mother has developed an immune response to her own abnormal gut pathogens and immune factors are transmitted in breast milk. Another factor: oral contraceptives have “a devastating effect on gut flora”. (Really? Where’s the evidence?) Processed foods allow pathogens to proliferate in the gut. High fructose corn syrup contributes to the problem.
And vaccines are also to blame. She subscribes to the “Too many too soon” philosophy. She says babies with abnormal gut flora are not fit to be vaccinated like healthy people. Their immune systems can’t respond well to the vaccine. And vaccines themselves are harmful. She says they were developed to make profits for Big Pharma rather than to benefit children. She says genetically modified organisms that may not be safe are used in vaccines because natural ones can’t be patented. Antibiotics directly damage immune cells. Vaccines may cause type 1 diabetes, celiac disease, etc. Siblings of children with ADD, etc. should not be vaccinated until their gut flora has been normalized. (This kind of misinformation and vaccine rejection threatens herd immunity and public health.)
Is There a Test for GAPS?She says there are ways to diagnose it, follow its progress, and determine when normal gut flora has been restored. First you get a health history from the parents, then you get a urine test for microbial metabolites, and a stool analysis for gut flora. (As far as I could tell, these are questionable tests offered by questionable labs like Genova, and interpretations of the results are not based on any credible scientific evidence.)
The DietIt is a healing diet that is intended to last only for a couple of years. It excludes sugars and starches, prohibiting potatoes, rice, pasta, bread, wheat, flour, dairy products, and sugar in any form other than fruit. It allows certain vegetables and fruits, meats, fats, nuts, and broths. You can purchase an Apple app that lists all the foods allowed and not allowed. Die-off phases are to be expected, where the dead “bad” bacteria release toxins and the symptoms get worse.
It starts with a GAPS Introduction Diet and proceeds in seven stages.
The body is starved, so you must start with easily digested foods. The first stage allows only room temperature water, probiotics and a very limited diet. When other foods are gradually introduced, if the patient gets black diarrhea, pain or any other digestive symptoms, wait a week and try again. (Dangerous advice, because black diarrhea could mean gastrointestinal bleeding and a medical emergency.)
As foods are introduced, you can do this (bogus) sensitivity test: put a drop of food on the wrist at bedtime. If there is an angry red reaction in the morning, avoid that food for a few weeks, then try introducing it again starting with a small amount.
In stage two, raw organic egg yolks are added, (a great way to get Salmonella) along with homemade yogurt and kefir, fermented fish, homemade ghee, and certain kinds of stews and casseroles.
Stage 3 adds avocado and special pancakes made with only butter, egg, and squash. Other foods are gradually added. And so it goes, up to Stage 7 which is the full GAPS diet. Eventually patients are allowed some kinds of starches, but sugar and refined starches are permanently banned. Ground-up nuts replace flour for baking, and fruits replace other sweeteners. The whole family should go on the protocol and change their lifestyle.
After the period of the diet, she says many of her patients choose to continue with the diet permanently since it is very healthy and allegedly prevents all kinds of diseases and obesity.
DetoxificationShe strongly advocates detoxification. She realizes the liver detoxifies for us, but she thinks it gets clogged up and needs help. She knows this because mercury, lead, arsenic, and formaldehyde can be found on analysis (sure they can, with bogus tests like the “urine toxic metals test” and and the Heavy Metal Screen Test). Juicing provides effective, gentle detox. Baths with Epsom salts, seaweed powder, bicarb, and cider vinegar provide gentle but “incredibly effective” detox. Fermented foods supply probiotic bacteria that take out harmful chemicals and hold them until detox can remove them. But you must be careful. Too much fermented food can cause a die-off that releases toxins, so you temporarily get worse. (Isn’t it curious how many alternative treatments make things worse before they get better? It’s a convenient “out” when the patient fails to improve.) You should make fermented foods at home and make homemade yogurt from raw milk (never mind the risk of infection).
She says fasting is another way to detoxify: when you stop eating, your body re-directs its energy to other jobs such as removing toxins and parasites and healing. She says it has an excellent record of curing all sorts of incurable conditions from rheumatoid arthritis to cancer. (I don’t think so!)
Who Is This Woman?Natasha Campbell-McBride earned an MD in Russia, where she practiced as a neurologist and neurosurgeon. After moving to the UK she got a degree in Human Nutrition and now practices as a nutritional consultant in a clinic in Cambridge, England. Her website provides a long list of diseases and conditions she may be able to help with: GAP syndrome, tummy pain, aggressive behavior, cystitis, epilepsy, PMS, ADD, autism, heart problems, migraine, psychosis, poor memory, and 74 other health problems. I noticed that arthritis is not on the list; I wonder why?
She had never encountered an autistic child until her own child was diagnosed with autism at age 3. This threw her into a fast learning curve as she researched ways to help her child that the medical establishment didn’t offer. She came up with her own hypothesis, invented a new disease (GAPS) and an effective treatment all by herself, and her son recovered completely.
She Sells ThingsHer online store offers probiotics, books, DVDs, essential fatty acids, fermented cod liver oil, high vitamin butter, coconut oil, immune support supplements, essential oils, Cinderella’s organic multipurpose cleaner, hand sanitizers, a garden hose filter so your children can engage in “clean water fun”, and Urban Moonshine Organic Bitters, because bitter flavors are essential to good health because they stimulate the digestive system. You can be trained to become a GAPS practitioner in a two-day course for $1175. Training includes a business starter package.
Scientific EvidenceAs the Wikipedia article succinctly and politely puts it, “Science is not known as yet to support…GAPS theories, or claims of psychological benefits.” It seems science hasn’t yet bothered to test it: I couldn’t find any published studies on GAPS or the GAPS diet. Campbell-McBride is not a researcher and has not published anything. She might at least have written up a formal case report on her own son and his apparent cure so we could try to understand what actually happened. Instead, all she has given us is testimonials from grateful patients.
Other Questionable ClaimsShe says a lot of other things that are odd, questionable, or even demonstrably wrong. Some examples:
    • If you listen to your desires for food, you will be able to digest that food and it will only do you good because you ate it at the right time, when your body asked for it.
    • Avoid perfumes and scented products because they destroy your sense of smell.
    • Processed foods alter your sense of taste.
    • Brush your teeth with olive oil instead of toothpaste: this Ayurvedic procedure detoxifies the mouth. (No fluoride?)
    • Avoid processed salt and use natural unprocessed salt such as Himalayan or Celtic salt that contains more than 90 minerals. (How much of each? Surely not enough to matter.)
    • The autonomic nervous system shifts back and forth from sympathetic to parasympathetic dominance, which require different foods. One likes meat and fat, the other needs more plant foods. Your body will tell you which you need more of.
    • There are daily and seasonal cleansing cycles and building cycles, each requiring different nutrients: animal foods build, plant foods cleanse.
    • Our needs depend on our heredity. If your ancestors were Vikings or Eskimos, you will need to eat lots of fish.
    • Avoid vegetable and cooking oils. Polyunsaturated fats are bad because they are chemically mutilated. 50% of the fat in our diet should be saturated.
    • Don’t test your blood cholesterol. Testing is pointless and potentially harmful. Old people with high cholesterol are healthier and live longer.
    • Eating cholesterol-rich foods is essential to produce enough vitamin D.
    • Vitamin D deficiency causes cancer, diabetes, heart disease, mental illness, autoimmune illness, obesity, bone and muscle disease, high blood pressure, chronic pain, poor immunity and susceptibility to infections.
    • Instead of cholesterol, test CRP and insulin levels.
    • Our soils are worn out. We would have to eat 2 kilos of apples today to provide the nutrition one apple used to give us.
    • Using volcanic rock dust in organic gardening improves nutrition, and if used on a global scale, it would enable the soil to absorb enough excess atmospheric carbon to stabilize global climate change.
    • The alarming growth of degenerative disease in our modern populations to a large degree is due to relentlessly decreasing levels of minerals in our food.
    • Black elderberry is one of the most powerful anti-viral remedies known to man.
    • Meat, fish, nuts, oily seeds are easier to digest than other foods.
Red FlagsThere are plenty of red flags here: the “lone genius,” the “one cause” of most disease, the die-off and “wait a while and try again” explanations to keep patients on the diet when it is making them worse, the unvalidated sensitivity and diagnostic tests, the detoxification language, the bold but unsubstantiated claim of total reversal of autism, the dangerous recommendations for raw eggs, raw milk, and saturated fat and against vaccines and cholesterol testing, and more. Birds of a feather: she is associated with the Weston Price Foundation and was featured on Mercola’s website (both notorious sources of misinformation).
ConclusionThe GAPS diet reflects serious gaps in Dr. Campbell-McBride’s reasoning and in her understanding of science. There is no published evidence to support it. The early introductory stages may not provide adequate nutrition; the full diet is probably healthy but is onerous. It seems very unlikely that it could accomplish all that is claimed. Without testing, there is no way to know whether it benefits or harms patients.

The Hallelujah Diet
The Hallelujah Diet is said to be supported by both the Bible and by science. Neither is true.
Harriet Hall on August 18, 2020
Tweet


Many people look to religion for dietary guidance. Sometimes organized religion offers official guidance in the form of dietary prohibitions (no pork) or prescriptions (halal, kosher, etc.). Sometimes individuals attempt their own interpretations, with inconsistent and sometimes amusing results.
One website lists the “Top 10 Christian Weight Loss Programs.” These are:
     1.  The Daniel Plan
     2.  The Daniel Fast
     3.  The Maker’s Diet
     4.  Take Back Your Temple
     5.  First Place 4 Health
     6.  Victory Steps for Women
     7.  The Eden Diet
     8.  The Hallelujah Diet
     9.  Bod4God
     10.  Weight Loss, God’s Way
Some of these emphasize prayer and partnering with the Holy Spirit, others claim to offer specific health benefits. The Daniel Plan allows any kind of food that is not man-made or processed. The Daniel Fast is a 21-day vegan detox diet. The Maker’s Diet calls for organic foods, fasting one day a week, “avoiding toxins, such as water and toothpaste with fluoride, and limiting exposure to devices with electromagnetic fields such as cell phones, microwaves, and X-rays”. And so on. Since these diets rely on faith rather than on science, there are no scientific studies to evaluate their safety or efficacy or to determine whether one of them is superior to the others.
The Hallelujah Diet
The Hallelujah Diet focuses on a biblical, vegan plant-based diet where 85% of the food you eat should be eaten in its raw natural state. This program recommends the use of supplements because the foods we consume today are less nutritious than they once were because of pollution, toxins, and pesticides. This diet is used to revive the natural self-healing power of the body by consuming enzyme-rich raw foods that are beneficial to the body at the cellular level.
No meat, dairy, eggs, or alcohol are allowed.
It claims to be “Scientifically validated. Biblically based. Over 170 diseases reversed through the Hallelujah Diet and whole-food supplements.” The diet is “designed to guide you in eating the way God intended.” But apparently God did not intend healthy eating to be sufficient, since Hallelujah diet supplements are needed to “give you the added nutrition you need to get back to your best health.”
They offer thousands of success stories (“I lost 50 pounds!” “tumors on the lungs are still regressing”) but no scientific studies. Their “research” page is laughable, citing studies like “What the Glycemic Index Really Says About Carrot Juice and Blood Glucose”. They offer a quiz “to discover the best supplements for you”. The quiz asks things like whether you suffer from constipation (defined as less than 2 soft bowel movements a day!), if you ever have colds, if you often feel sad, if you wake up during the night, if you ever have body odor, if your eyesight has gotten weaker over the last year, if you are currently taking Barley Max, etc. I tried taking the quiz twice, once answering honestly and once answering no to every question. The website promised instant results, but both times I got only a persistent “working” symbol that just kept going round and round. They offer a 60-day money back guarantee and there is a disclaimer in small print at the bottom of the page, saying individual results may vary.
Their mission is based on Genesis 1:29:
And God said, Behold, I have given you every herb bearing seed, which is upon the face of all the earth, and every tree, in the which is the fruit of a tree yielding seed; to you it shall be for meat.
It is not entirely clear how they got from this Bible verse to Barley Green and all the other supplements they sell.
The Hallelujah Diet originated with Rev. George Malkmus. Quackwatch featured him in a 2003 article. It does not inspire confidence. Malkmus claims the diet cured his colon cancer, but that diagnosis is questionable; no biopsy was done, and the diagnosis was made by nutritionists and chiropractors. He claims not to have experienced any health problems since starting the diet, but admits he had a stroke. He refused medical treatment and treated himself with extra Barley Green and carrot juice. He reluctantly took drugs to control his high blood pressure but then tried to wean himself off medication. He is anti-vaccine and sells videotapes by a doctor who claims medical care is against God’s will.
The Quackwatch article by Stephen Barrett reports that “In 1988, the FDA ordered AIM (American Image Marketing, the multilevel marketing company that Malkmus was once a distributor for) to stop claiming that Barley Green would make people more energetic and was effective against cancer, arthritis, high blood pressure, obesity, depression, and many other health problems. The FDA also told the company to stop making false statements about the quality of the American food supply. In 1989, the FDA seized quantities of several AIM products because their labeling or promotional material exaggerated the dietary value of the products. The case was settled by a consent decree ordering the destruction of one product and the offending labeling for the others. However, some distributors continued to make false claims, including claims that Barley Green is effective against cancer.”
Quackwatch’s (and my) conclusion
Although low-fat, high-fiber diets can be healthful, the Hallelujah Diet is unbalanced and can lead to serious deficiencies. The overall program is expensive because the recommended supplements cost over $2,000 a year. Reverend Malkmus’ sales pitch includes beliefs that are historically and nutritionally senseless, as well as health claims for which he lacks appropriate substantiation. Using his diet instead of appropriate medical care is very foolish.
I have no objection to people following religious dietary beliefs. I would not object if people chose to follow arbitrary rules like not eating foods whose name starts with a vowel. But I have to agree with Stephen Barrett that following the Hallelujah Diet makes no sense and is very foolish.

The Rosedale Diet: Here We Go Again
Harriet Hall on June 2, 2015
Link

Ron Rosedale, MD has devised a “powerful program based on the new science of leptin.” “Finally — the ultimate diet for fast, safe weight loss, lifelong health, and longer life…” He suggests it will prevent or improve high blood pressure, diabetes, heart disease, osteoporosis, arthritis, and a host of other ills. He repeats the CAM canard that “doctors only treat symptoms” and claims that his diet corrects the underlying cause of obesity, premature aging, and many diseases. That underlying cause is hormone (leptin) dysfunction. His is essentially just another low carb diet, only with more fat and less protein than other versions. His recommendations are ridiculously elaborate and are not supported by good evidence. His diet extrapolates from basic science, is based on speculative hypotheses, and has never been tested to see whether it works and is safe, much less whether it is superior to other diets.
If this sounds vaguely familiar, it should. He is doing what so many proponents of fad diets have done in the past, and he does it poorly. His book is a puerile effort compared to Gary Taubes‘ Good Calories, Bad Calories; Taubes at least marshaled an impressive mass of scientific data, presented a cogent argument, and ultimately acknowledged that more studies would be needed to test his recommendations.
What is leptin?
Leptin, discovered in 1994, is the “satiety hormone” that controls hunger. When we eat, leptin levels rise and let us know when it is time to stop eating. There were early hopes that leptin supplements would help people lose weight; that didn’t pan out. Unfortunately, in obesity, leptin levels are already high and resistance to leptin has developed. When anyone loses weight on any diet, leptin levels drop. Rosedale’s approach is to reduce leptin levels by changing metabolism and reducing leptin resistance, thereby causing weight loss.
Are you leptin resistant? Take this quiz.
He says you are likely to be leptin resistant if you answer yes to any of the questions on his quiz. Do you have trouble losing fat, trouble keeping weight off after dieting, are you constantly hungry, do you crave sweets, do you wake up hungry at night, have a “spare tire” or are apple shaped, feel stressed out, have high triglyceride levels, have high blood pressure, or have osteoporosis? Has this quiz been tested or validated? No. Is this a useful way to learn if you are leptin resistant? No. But it helps sell books.
What is the Rosedale Diet?
It involves two stages. The first stage is designed to teach the metabolism to burn fat, not sugar; for 3 weeks, practically no carbohydrates are allowed. In stage two, more carbohydrates are allowed, but only the healthiest kind with the highest fiber content.
Foods not allowed: dairy, white potatoes, breakfast cereal, rice, bread, peanuts and peanut butters, beans, corn, honey and sugar, all cakes, cookies, ice cream, candies, flavored jellos, and most fruits (pineapple, orange, apple, watermelon, banana, all dried fruit, cantaloupe, honeydew, grapes). Fried foods, all commercially processed oils, all fruit juices, many condiments (mayonnaise, ketchup, etc.), most artificial sweeteners, all soda pop.
Foods allowed in limited quantities (one serving a day or less): carrots, parsnips, peas, fresh or frozen blueberries, raspberries, strawberries, blackberries, lemons, limes, tomatoes. Canola oil only once or twice a week.
Foods allowed daily:
    • Protein sources: nuts, seeds, fish, eggs, tofu, poultry, wild meats, protein powder, seafood, veggie burgers, curd/cottage cheese, some cheeses, full fat cream
    • Fat sources: Avocados, olives, nuts, butter, unheated cod liver oil, flax oil, fish oil; if you must cook with oil, use olive oil, coconut oil, or ghee
    • Carbohydrate sources: lettuce, greens, broccoli, cucumbers, mushrooms, onions, peppers, squash, sprouts, seaweeds, asparagus, some of the smaller beans, black soy beans, Wasa fiber rye crackers (2-3 per day)
    • Drinks: teas, coffee substitutes; one cup of real coffee if you can’t give it up entirely
    • Alcohol: OK in small amounts
    • Condiments: turmeric, cayenne pepper, cumin, basil, oregano, fennel, Masala, ginger, garlic, vinegar, mustard, miso salt, lemon, lime, tamari
    • Sweeteners: most are terrible for you, but stevia, xylitol and erythritol are permissible in moderation
Other recommendation:
    • Feel good about yourself
    • Eat when you are hungry
    • Eat slowly
    • Drink lots of water
    • Don’t eat for 3 hours before bedtime
    • Exercise after the last meal of the day
    • Eat the right amount of protein for you (one gram per kilo of ideal body weight minus 10%)
He doesn’t provide any evidence from controlled scientific studies to support any of these recommendations.
He recommends avoiding coffee because it raises blood sugar. Maybe it does, but not enough to worry about: the ADA recommends coffee for diabetics because it is zero-calorie.
He prohibits peanuts and peanut butters because they “contain an element called ‘aflatoxin’, which is a potentially deadly carcinogen.” That’s nonsense. There is no aflatoxin in peanuts unless they are moldy. Aflatoxins are produced by a fungus, Aspergillus, that can sometimes contaminate grains, milk, and peanuts. Peanut products are monitored for aflatoxin in the US. Toxicity is a concern in developing countries, but peanuts sold in the US are not considered a problem.
Supplements
He claims that targeted nutritional supplements can dramatically enhance the effectiveness of the diet.
His basic supplement plan includes L-arginine, L-carnitine, chromium, CoQ10, lipoic acid, magnesium, potassium, aspartate, a multivitamin without iron, vitamins C and E, and L-glutamine powder. The Rosedale Diet Supplement Plan Plus adds biotin, gymnema sylvestre extract, phosphatidyl serine, and pregnenolone. If you have cardiovascular disease, you should take extra CoQ10 and arginine, plus vinpocetine, vitamin B12, trimethylglycine, and folic acid. If you have diabetes, you should add vanadyl sulfate, extra thiamine, and extra alpha lipoic acid. If you have osteoporosis, you should add vitamin K. If you have arthritis, you should add glucosamine and cetyl myristoleate. He offers some hypothetical rationales based on preliminary cherry-picked studies but provides no evidence from clinical studies that any of these supplements actually improve the health of people on his diet or with those diseases.
Medical tests that can save your life
He recommends that 16 tests be done at your annual physical, with follow-ups at 3, 6, and 12 months to monitor your progress. He says many of these tests can be done as part of the routine CBC that should be done at your annual physical. He explains that CBC stands for complete blood chemistry. It doesn’t; it stands for complete blood count (red cells, white cells, etc.) and is NOT recommended as part of a routine physical. In fact, the routine annual physical itself is no longer recommended.
The tests he recommends, in order of what he considers to be their importance:
    • Leptin
    • Insulin
    • HbgA1c
    • Glucose
    • Thyroid function
    • Basal body temperature
    • IGF-1
    • Norepinephrine
    • C-reactive protein
    • Triglycerides
    • Homocysteine
    • BUN
    • Creatinine
    • Uric acid
    • Liver enzymes
    • Cholesterol
None of these tests are recommended on an annual basis by any reputable organization like the USPSTF, and most of them are not recommended at all as routine screening tests in healthy people. He offers no evidence that monitoring these lab values improves clinical outcomes. The only thing that most doctors would check periodically (not annually, and not for certain age groups or low risk groups) is cholesterol, and he considers that the least important thing on the list. In my opinion, ordering these tests is a waste of money, is likely to produce false positives and unnecessary concern, and is likely to do more harm than good.
He warns patients that if you’re on medication for heart disease or diabetes, you should monitor it carefully, because the need for meds will diminish and likely disappear. Maybe. Maybe you would see the same improvement on a different diet. Maybe you will be persuaded to give up medications you really needed.
The evidence
The science of leptin is new, and we are just beginning to understand its effects. It’s becoming clear that it plays an important role in obesity and many other physiologic processes. But the possible practical clinical applications of this new knowledge are far from clear. Rosedale has convinced himself that he has figured out how to control leptin with diet, but he is relying on hypothesis and speculation, not on evidence from clinical trials. He has seen improvement in his patients; but without a control group, his unsystematic observations are meaningless. He mentions a lot of studies on everything from insulin sensitivity to the effect of protein on aging in fruit flies, but he doesn’t manage to weave them into a coherent evidence-based narrative that would support his claims.
It’s hard to follow Rosedale’s arguments in his book, because he doesn’t cite references for specific claims but only provides an appendix with short lists of references grouped by topic. He repeatedly says things like “I believe” and “I have come to believe,” “I lecture on that topic,” “one day it dawned on me,” “I decided to try,” and “I offer the only alternative diet that works, and works fabulously well.” In his section on supplements, he recommends a total of 24 supplements, but the list of supplement references in the appendix consists of only 5 references that refer to only 5 supplements. And one of those references is a Chinese study of the effects of chromium and fish oil in obese developing rats! It appears that he’s not making a serious effort to provide evidence; it’s as if he expects us to just take his word for most of what he says.
Is anyone really recommending high-carb diets?
Rosedale says all the popular diets today are either high-carb/low-fat or high-protein/low-carb. I think that’s a gross mischaracterization. It may be true that low fat diet recommendations led a lot of people to inadvertently overdo the carbs and contributed to the prevalence of obesity, but current recommendations are for a diet low in calories, not high in carbs. And low carb diets are not necessarily high protein diets. He says a high-carb diet is being prescribed for diabetics. That’s not true: diabetic diets are designed to limit carbohydrate intake. Rosedale puts no limits on calories or fats as long as they are not “killer fats” but good fats that lower leptin levels. The only thing he asks patients to keep track of is their protein intake. I agree that overdoing the protein could lead to harm, but he hasn’t provided the evidence to convince me that he knows how much protein is ideal.
Statins
He questions the use of statin drugs. He says they are “not without significant side effects, that they deplete the body of CoQ10 and cause muscle damage”. He goes on to claim that:
Since the heart is a muscle, it is probably getting damaged also, impairing its ability to pump blood and increasing the risk of congestive heart failure. In other words, over time, these drugs can weaken the heart and impair its major function. Sure, in the short run, they may lower cholesterol, but in the long run, they can kill you.
In my opinion, this is irresponsible fear-mongering. Statins have been proven to reduce the rates of cardiovascular mortality and all-cause mortality. They save lives. And he has no evidence that his diet can do any better.
Testimonials and recipes
As with so many fad diet books, this one includes testimonials, recipes, and a month’s worth of suggested menus. That’s all very nice, but it isn’t evidence.
Other opinions about overcoming leptin resistance
Dr. Oz claims that protein and fiber are the keys. He offers a different prescription for overcoming leptin resistance:
    • Start your day with peanut butter and oatmeal.
    • Take an Irvingia supplement.
    • Do not eat for 12 hours between dinner and breakfast the next day.
There are other leptin diets, for instance here.
Conclusion
Rosedale is supremely confident that he knows how to overcome leptin resistance, prolong life, and improve health. He could be right, but I am skeptical. He makes a big deal about showing how leptin levels decrease in his patients, but he has no control group, and we know that leptin levels drop when weight is lost by any means. Leptin doesn’t exist in a vacuum: it interacts with insulin, ghrelin, and a lot of other things. When you change one thing, you may be inadvertently changing a lot of other things that you might not want to change. It’s complicated, and simple one-size-fits-all solutions are seldom the answer to a medical problem. Like any other claim, this one will have to be tested in controlled studies before mainstream medicine can accept it. Even if there is a layer of truth in Rosedale’s hypothesis, the truth is buried under a laundry list of specific recommendations that don’t make sense and are not based on any credible evidence.
Without controlled testing, we don’t have any credible evidence that this diet works as claimed or is safe, but we don’t have any evidence that it doesn’t work or isn’t safe either, so if anyone wanted to try it, I wouldn’t object.
Dr. Joseph Mercola says, “The Rosedale Diet is a must-read for anyone interested in health.” I say neither Mercola nor Rosedale can be recommended to anyone who is interested in science-based medicine.

Vegan Betrayal: The Myths vs. the Realities of a Plants-Only Diet
Harriet Hall on July 5, 2016
Link


NOTE: The original version of this book review was criticized for not making it clear when I was simply reporting the book’s content and when I was expressing support for one of its arguments. I have revised it to make it more clear. The additions are marked by brackets.
Vegetarians come in several flavors. Ovo-vegetarians eat eggs, lacto-vegetarians eat dairy products but not eggs, ovo-lacto-vegetarians eat both eggs and dairy products. Pescatarians eat fish but no other animals. Vegans eat nothing derived from animals. Vegans have claimed that a plants-only diet offers a multitude of health benefits, is better for the environment, and is the only ethical choice. While some of them respect the dietary choices of others, some of them proselytize with religious-like fervor and are working to get their diet adopted by all of humanity. In her new book, Vegan Betrayal: Love, Lies, And Hunger In A Plants-Only World, Mara Kahn questions those beliefs, pointing out that no human population has ever endured on a plants-only diet; that while some studies have shown short-term health benefits, long-term follow-up is missing; that long-term vegans frequently experience “failure to thrive,” go off their diet, and feel better when they return to eating meat; and that veganism might actually harm the environment and might not even save animal lives overall.
The book is really three books interleaved into one:
    • The story of her own experiences as a vegan.
    • An evidence-supported analysis of veganism and vegetarianism
    • Some rather woo-woo ideas about finding a unique diet for each individual
I can highly recommend the first two, but I deplore the third.
Her personal story
At age 19, she went to Europe alone, backpacking, hitchhiking, and falling under the spell of a new acquaintance who persuaded her to become a vegan. She returned home and shocked her very conventional family by refusing to shave her hairy armpits, wear a bra, or eat any food derived from an animal. She is a great storyteller; her vivid recollections are described in colorful language and are often hilariously funny. I very much enjoyed the anecdotes of her life in various parts of the world first as a vegan, then as a vegetarian. Eventually she realized that her health was suffering and in slow steps she gradually incorporated more and more animal foods into her diet.
She says, “I never missed the taste of meat, not once. What I did miss was the after-meal sensation of being energized and well nourished.” She experienced “overwhelming protein/fat hunger,” and tried to satisfy it with yogurt and coffee.
Health claims
Much of the [published nutritional] research is faulty[, according to Kahn]: in some studies, vegetarians are lumped with vegans and occasional meat-eaters. Not one respected study has ever shown a long-term vegan diet to be healthier than any other, and most research uncovers troubling deficiencies. They claim meat-free diets are healthier, but healthier than what? Than the typical unhealthy American diet [?]
Control for lifestyle habits, as every useful nutrition study must, and then compare a vegetarian or vegan diet to one of whole plants and judicious amounts of wild-caught fish or pastured meat—like the seafood-loving Mediterranean diet or the animal-adoring French diet—and the health advantages either disappear or are greatly surpassed.
[Kahn says] research has shown vegan deficits in many key nutrients including iodine, iron, zinc, taurine, vitamins A, D and B12, selenium, protein, calcium and omega-3 fatty acids. Yes, it is possible to get adequate nutrition from a vegan diet; but in practice, many vegans don’t. She observes vegans eating huge amounts of carbs and vegan junk foods and skimping on their protein and vitamin needs. This is particularly a concern for teenage girls who are still growing; teenage girls are a big part of the vegetarian demographic.
[She says] a famous Seventh-day Adventist study found that “vegetarians live longer than meat-eaters,” but fish eaters were lumped with vegetarians and they live even longer. And there are plenty of other groups that eat meat and live longer than Seventh-day Adventists, including Okinawans and Sardinians. No studies show that veganism is the healthiest of diets and some suggest that it is not.
Vegans often cite Campbell’s controversial book The China Study (see also here), but the subjects in his study were not vegans and most of them weren’t even vegetarians.
[Kahn reports that] more and more disillusioned ex-vegans are offering testimonials like Angelina Jolie’s claim that an all-plants diet “nearly killed me.” [She hypothesizes that] vegans may feel better at first simply because they are eating fewer calories and have replaced processed and junk foods with healthier fruits, vegetables, and grains. But the feeling doesn’t last.
[She points out that] the standard nutritional recommendations to eat more veggies and fruits are about adding more plants to the diet, not about eating only plants.
Bottom line: Research shows that a mainly plant-based diet is healthy, but the findings can’t be used to justify a plants-only diet. [I agree with this conclusion.]
Vegans are often malnourished
[Kahn reports that] there is a high dropout rate. “Once you pull out all animal-sourced food, a whole lot of nutrients have suddenly gone missing or exist in deficient amounts.”
While it is possible to get adequate nutrition from plants alone, it requires a lot of knowledge and discipline, and in practice many vegetarians begin to suffer from insidious borderline malnutrition.
Kahn argues that dietary recommendations tend to underestimate the amount of protein needed for health. When vegans get hungry they tend to gorge on carbs when what they need is protein.
“Too-thin vegans are eating animal flesh after all: their own.” Protein starvation leads to self-cannibalization.
Vegans often rely on soy for protein, but soy can [sometimes] be harmful to health in various ways [although it does also have proven health benefits]. One of the prominent side effects of all-plant diets is flatulence, which can range from a mild inconvenience to a serious problem.
It may be possible for individuals with naturally lower protein needs who can tolerate large amounts of legumes, lead low-stress lives (a low-stress life, what’s that?) and keep a vigilant eye on daily quantity, quality, and amino acid completeness. Easy? No, it is not.
Arguments from evolution
[Kahn finds vegan arguments from evolution unconvincing. I agree. What follows reflects my own thoughts on the subject:] You may have heard vegans, fruitarians, or other food faddists claim that humans were not designed to eat meat. They cite our lack of fangs and claws for bringing down prey. Admittedly, humans are not carnivores, although they can thrive on a diet of raw meat alone. Humans aren’t herbivores either: they lack the rumens and multiple stomachs of animals like cows. Cows are equipped to eat a 100% plant-based diet; humans are not. Raw food faddists argue that humans didn’t evolve to eat cooked food, ignoring the fact that cooking makes some nutrients more available and food more digestible. Demonizers of wheat argue that our ancestors were hunters/gatherers, not farmers.
Some argue that we can’t digest meat; that’s simply not true. We can and do digest it. Plant protein is actually less digestible than meat protein.
Arguments from evolution tend to miss the point: humans are not carnivores or herbivores, but omnivores. Evolution equipped us to thrive on a wide variety of diets. Our ability to eat whatever foods were available allowed us to survive in very diverse environments.
History and purity
Kahn delves into the history of vegetarianism and veganism. Much of it is bound up with ideals of purity. Fasts and dietary prohibitions, food-related rituals, and purification rites have been prominent in most religions. Pythagoras’ followers could eat meat, but not bone marrow, because they believed it concealed messages from the gods. For them, it was beans that were absolutely prohibited. Go figure!
In some cultures, specific animals and foods were endowed with special meanings. Group cohesiveness was promoted when hunters distributed meat to others in their tribe. Shared meals have an important social function in today’s world, from family dinners to wedding celebrations and Thanksgiving feasts. Our dietary choices and customs are more emotion-driven than fact-driven.
Food ethics
As human history progressed, the circle of compassion enlarged to include animals. I think it’s fair to say that the majority of vegans and vegetarians chose their path mainly because they are repelled by the idea of killing animals. But [Kahn suggests that] perhaps they should examine their conscience more closely.
Don’t they realize they are eating animals in many plant foods? The FDA allows 60 insect fragments per 100 gram candy bar; 225 insect parts and 4.5 rodent hairs or excreta per 100 g pasta; 10 whole insects and 35 fly eggs per 8 ounces of raisins.
To be consistent maybe vegans should be more reluctant to kill plants. [As Kahn reports,] new research indicates that plants have a degree of awareness, change their behavior in response to environmental conditions, communicate with other plants by chemical signals, and [some researchers have even suggested they] may perceive pain. [These are intriguing findings, but I don’t see any reason to believe plants can suffer.]
Kahn says:
Our food choices involve ethics, no doubt about that, but trying to impose a single moral code of eating on all people is profoundly unethical. In following a well-planned vegan diet, an unknown percentage of us will suffer, our health and quality of life. Surely the compassion that lies at the heart of ethical veganism extends to human animals.
Environmental concerns
It is generally accepted that plants-only diets are better for the environment. [Kahn suggests that] that may not be true.
Even if you repudiate the eating of animals, you are killing animals by proxy at every meal. Consider the field mice, pheasants, snakes and tender young rabbits—all of the innocent wild beings diced and sliced by the tiller that prepares the soil for your favorite grains.
If we gradually moved to the larger foraging mammals only, … and raised them on their natural diet of 100% grass using a no-till, pasture-forage model, this might mean fewer total animals killed (domestic and wild) than in the all-vegan model. Let’s give this intriguing idea a closer look.” [she goes on to present a plausible argument] [Note: I have not researched this and won’t venture a personal opinion.]
She argues for ethical hunters, sustainable agriculture, abolishing factory farms, and being kind to the animals we are going to eat.
Woo intrudes
On the subject of veganism, Kahn’s information is evidence-based and reliable and her reasoning plausible; but unfortunately when she turns to other subjects she goes off the rails. Her concerns about GMOs, glyphosate, sugar, fructose, wheat, “inflammatory” foods, and bottle-feeding are alarmist and not based on rigorous science. She quotes unreliable sources like an Ayurvedic doctor and Weston Price. She consults a TCM practitioner. Her criticism of statin drugs is misguided. She believes in superfoods and bioidentical hormones. She talks of adrenal exhaustion and yeast overgrowth.
She consults a naturopath for nutritional advice and is given homeopathic remedies. She thinks there are proven benefits of guided imagery; there aren’t. She cites a study where guided imagery and therapeutic touch (!) were used to treat PTSD in soldiers. She consults medical intuitives. They intuit that she should increase her intake of fat and protein, but she refuses to follow that advice until it is echoed by an MD she believes is knowledgeable about nutrition, Dr. Diane Schwarzbein. She believes acupuncture was effective in restoring her daughter’s absent menses. She believes in metabolic typing tests and diets based on metabolic type. She stresses bioindividuality (i.e., you are so unique that studies don’t apply to you). She thinks all the cells of the body are conscious, and you can rely on the wisdom of the body to tell you what foods your body uniquely requires.
The real problem
What I really could not bear at such a tender young age was the biological truth of our earthly existence. Every creature is food for others, including me, including you… the vegan argument is, in fact, is a profound denial of nature. We are animals. And our living and dying and nourishing are utterly entangled with other animals.
She now accepts her participation in this natural cycle with a conscious and reverent approach.
Conclusion
Ideology can be persuasive, but harsh reality often ruins an appealing idea. People can die from fanatical diet beliefs.
What did my own journey teach a comically naïve if earnest youth who thirsted for carnal knowledge and hungered to abolish all animal suffering? Its hard truth was this: the very real dangers of a rigid ideology, born of the mind and the emotions, which does not line up with the biological realities of the body. For as much as I longed to honor and respect my animal brethren by not eating them, the earthly reality is that I need to do exactly that.
I wish I could recommend this book for its funny, engaging human story and its trenchant analysis of plants-only diets, but the later chapters are contaminated with beliefs not based on scientific evidence. Too bad! [She is an excellent writer, and it might have been an excellent book if she had asked science-based reviewers to critique the more wooish subjects during the editing process.] I agree with the author that the evidence for health and environmental benefits and the ethical and evolutionary arguments are insufficient to justify a plants-only diet [for the whole population. Those who choose a plants-only diet for whatever reasons can thrive on it, but only if they are careful to ensure good nutrition.

Betraying the Science on Vegan Nutrition
After the prolonged comment thread in Harriet Hall’s review of this book in July, given the controversy, we were willing to consider a guest post offering another perspective. In this case, the perspective, from a dietician, is similar to Harriet’s, the main difference being primarily in emphasis.
Ginny Messina on December 3, 2016
Tweet

Ed. Note: After the prolonged comment thread in Harriet Hall’s review of this book in July, given the controversy, we were willing to consider a guest post offering another perspective. In this case, the perspective is very similar to Harriet’s, the main difference being primarily in emphasis.
As a dietitian working in the area of vegan nutrition, I see no shortage of outrageous claims about vegan diets. They come from both sides of the debate. Advocates for veganism sometimes ascribe unsubstantiated benefits to vegan diets while downplaying concerns about meeting nutrient needs.
On the other side of the debate are bloggers and authors who insist that a vegan diet is a dangerous choice and that it can’t support health over the long term. Prominent voices for this perspective include those whose health failed on a vegan diet and who eventually returned to eating meat, dairy and eggs. They are now on a mission to prove that humans require animal foods.
Mara J. Kahn is the latest author to try to capitalize on that story. Her book Vegan Betrayal has already been reviewed on Science Based Medicine and the nutrition information was deemed evidence-based. I came away with a different impression when I read the book.
I don’t feel any particular need to prove that a vegan diet is the only healthful way to eat; that’s not the point of veganism. The term was coined in 1944 by the founders of England’s Vegan Society and was defined as:
a philosophy and way of living which seeks to exclude — as far as is possible and practical — all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing or any other purpose.
So, a vegan diet doesn’t have to be the best; it just has to be as good as any other healthful way of eating. There are only two relevant questions: Can vegans meet needs for all nutrients? And do vegans suffer from nutrient deficiencies more often than omnivores?
And in fact, while she meanders off into a whole lot of tangential issues, Ms. Kahn says that answering these questions is the primary purpose of her book.
Vegans need good nutrition advice, just like everyone else
First things first. Being vegan can place you at risk for certain nutrient deficiencies. So can being a meat-eater. Kahn correctly notes that research has found deficiencies of iodine, iron, zinc, vitamins D and B12, selenium, calcium, and omega-3 fats in some vegans. According to NHANES data, Americans (most of whom are meat-eaters) are at risk for getting too little vitamin A, vitamin D, vitamin E, folate, vitamin C, calcium, potassium, magnesium and iron.
No matter what dietary pattern you follow, you need to pay attention to food choices to ensure adequate nutrient intake. The fact that some vegans and some meat eaters don’t meet all nutrient needs doesn’t say anything about the general safety of either eating pattern.
In fact, a whole lot of what Kahn addresses in her book has nothing to do with the safety of vegan diets. She says that a lot of vegans are eating in ways that undermine health because of bad advice on the internet. I agree. Most of my own work is devoted to countering harmful information aimed at vegans. But Kahn fails the logic test here. It doesn’t follow that vegan diets are risky, only that you should be careful about where you get your nutrition information.
And the irony of all this is that she doesn’t do a whole lot better with her own set of experts. They include a doctor who “knows nutrition inside and out” and who doesn’t consider beans, dairy or soy to be “authentic members of the top-quality protein category.” This is the same doctor who prescribes a homeopathic remedy for Kahn’s nerves. From here she gravitates to a medical intuitive and then finally to a couple of books published in 1952 and 1972 which have her convinced that some people can’t be vegan because of their “metabolic typing.” I’d say that Kahn’s round up of nutrition experts suggests that anyone, eating any kind of diet, can find bad nutrition advice.
Research versus headlines
There is a bit of a challenge in reviewing this book. While the author provides a long list of citations at the end of the book, she doesn’t always match them up with what she says in the text. Sometimes she’ll reference a study, sometimes she couldn’t be bothered. So, for example, unless you’re an expert on the role of termites in diets of African children (I’m not) you’ll just have to take her word for the fact that kids who eat termites have more beneficial gut flora and more “vigor” than European children who don’t eat bugs.
Except that once I got into this book, and saw how misleading most of her conclusions were, I didn’t want to take her word for anything. I wanted to know whether her larger point—that dietary variety is important and therefore vegans are at risk—was actually supported by this study. So I tracked down the research (1). It did indeed find a healthier gut environment among children in rural Burkina Faso compared to kids in Italy. But this was linked to a diet that the researchers said “consists mainly of cereals (millet grain, sorghum), legumes (black-eyed peas, called Niébé), and vegetables, so the content of carbohydrate, fiber and non-animal protein is very high.” The children in Italy were eating a “typical western diet high in animal protein, sugar, starch, and fat and low in fiber.”
Yes, the African children had more beneficial gut microflora but it was because their diet was mostly vegetarian, not because they ate an occasional termite. The study doesn’t support Kahn’s point; it counters it.
It’s just one of the ways in which she misuses data to bolster her position. But I doubt this was intentional. As I started poking around the book’s resources, I realized that Kahn most likely never looked at any research. She looked only at what reporters and bloggers were saying about the research. So I am guessing that her experience with this particular study (it doesn’t appear in her list of citations) was through an article in US News and World Report, which – it’s the media after all – played up the whole termite issue.
She doesn’t seem to be familiar with the research on any of the topics she addresses and it trips her up over and over again. Here’s another example. She suggests that soy isoflavones have not been shown to reduce menopausal hot flashes. Well, yes and no.
Placebo-controlled hot flash studies use one of two types of isoflavone supplements. When they utilize supplements that are derived from the whole soybean and that mimic the isoflavone profile of soybeans (that is, they are high in the isoflavone genistein) they are effective in reducing hot flashes (2). Supplements that are lower in genistein, and therefore very different from actual soyfoods, are far less effective. It’s a fine point, but a critical one in determining whether soyfoods affect hot flashes or not. A superficial glance at the research might suggest that they don’t. A more informed analysis tells a completely different story.
Anecdotes, observations and a little cherry picking
Kahn thinks most vegans are eating diets that are packed with carbs and too low in fat and protein. How does she know this? She’s seen it with her own eyes while having lunch at a Whole Foods café in Boulder, Colorado. By observing two “leggy” teens eating blue corn chips and coleslaw (which incidently, is not vegan) and a bored child “playing ring toss with her macaroni and cheese” (also not vegan) she concludes that vegans eat too many carbs. And while it’s possible that they balance their carb-heavy lunches with a protein-rich breakfast, Kahn says it’s unlikely because “breakfast for every veggie I’ve ever known is cereal or granola with a splash of soy or almond milk, often just a bagel with coffee or juice.”
I’ve never been to Whole Foods in Boulder, but I’ve looked at more than a few studies of vegan diets. Average fat intake among vegans is not particularly low; it’s about 30% of calories and average protein intake is moderate at 10 to 12% of calories (3-5).
Yes, vegans eat more carbohydrates than the average American. But the evidence suggests that this does not put them at risk for the insulin resistance that Kahn warns about (5, 6). In fact, among Seventh-day Adventists, vegans are far less likely to develop type-2 diabetes compared to meat eaters and lacto-ovo vegetarians (7).
Likewise, when Kahn cites studies on the triglyceride-elevating effects of high-carb, low-fat diets she completely ignores the more than a dozen studies showing that vegans typically have lower triglyceride levels compared with both meat eaters and lacto-ovo vegetarians (5, 8-10).
Sneaky paraphrasing
Lysine is the limiting amino acid in vegan diets, but Kahn uses some duplicitous misquoting to make it seem like a bigger problem than it is. She says: “Jack Norris, RD, himself a vegan, admits that it’s ‘very hard’ for vegans who don’t work out every day to meet daily lysine needs because they’re not consuming the calories needed to get enough from plants alone.”
Since I co-authored a book on vegan nutrition with Jack, I’m pretty familiar with his perspective on lysine. I know for a fact that he doesn’t believe it’s difficult to meet needs. Here is what he actually says about lysine [emphasis added]:
It is very hard to design a vegan diet that meets lysine requirements for a person who does not exercise daily without including legumes, seitan, quinoa, amaranth, pistachios, or pumpkin seeds…
That is, it’s only difficult if you happen to eliminate a huge category of plant foods from your diet. Jack recommends (as do I) at least three servings per day of lysine-rich plant foods. Menu choices might include veggie burgers, hummus, bean burritos, quinoa, pumpkin seeds sprinkled into a salad, scrambled tofu, split pea soup, falafel, cereal with soymilk, or a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. There is nothing odd or onerous here. It is not particularly difficult to meet lysine needs on a vegan diet.
She read it on the internet
Like every other book aimed at discrediting veganism, Kahn has a chapter on soy. And, like every other soy detractor she claims that Asians eat very little of this food and that what they do eat is usually fermented. This comes straight from the internet. It couldn’t possibly come from the research, because it’s not at all what the research shows.
Studies published over the past 25 years have comprehensively quantified soy intake throughout Asia. The research shows that non-fermented foods like tofu and soymilk actually play a bigger role in Asian diets than fermented soy products. In fact, ethnic Chinese in China, Singapore and Hong Kong consume almost no fermented soy with the exception of soy sauce. Even in Japan where the fermented foods natto and miso are widely consumed, tofu accounts for about half of all soy intake. And depending upon the country and region in question, average soy intake ranges from one-half serving per day to about two servings per day (11).
Nor has soy intake been associated with lower testosterone levels in men as Kahn warns. That’s the internet again. Yes, a few case reports showed that men consuming excessive amounts of soy – 12 or more servings per day – experienced a reduction in testosterone levels. But the extensive clinical trial data, which includes more than 30 studies, show that soy doesn’t lower testosterone levels even when men consume the equivalent of six servings per day (12).
Soy is not the only dangerous plant food according to this book. There are pages of fearmongering about wheat which Kahn alleges is an opiate due to genetic modification of its protein gliadin. Never mind that there is no genetically modified wheat on the market. Or that the digestive product gliadorphin, which has been found to have opiate-like effects in lab animals, probably can’t even be absorbed by humans. Or that there is no evidence of addiction to or withdrawal from wheat.
“Carninutrients” and more
And then finally, there is this: “Science continues to discover essential micronutrients found solely in animal sourced food.”
If you’re familiar with the Weston A. Price Foundation, you know where she’s going with this. For those who don’t know, Dr. Price was a dentist who, in the 1930s, traveled the world and determined that not only “fine teeth,” but also “fine character” were related to nutrition. He wrote a book called Nutrition and Physical Degeneration in 1939, and it somehow gave rise to a movement that focuses on the benefits of butter, raw milk, and cod liver oil, and the harmfulness of vaccines, baking powder, and tofu.
Dr. Price suggested that there was an Activator X that improved mineral absorption, bone development, prevented tooth decay and protected against inflammation and cancer. His followers believe that this was vitamin K2 or menaquinone. According to Kahn, vitamin K2 deficiency is widespread in the American population. According to the Institute of Medicine we have no actual dietary requirement for vitamin K2 as long as we consume adequate vitamin K1. Nor are there any established requirements for the other compounds that Kahn believes are essential nutrients like carnosine, taurine, and conjugated linoleic acid.
When a vegan diet fails
The bottom line is that Mara Kahn was unable to maintain good health as a vegan. I can’t speculate as to why that is. I only know that her book fails to make the case against a vegan diet. She cobbles together misinformation from the internet and blends it with her own faulty interpretations of nutrition research. And then for good measure tosses in a whole lot of completely irrelevant observations about nutrition. It makes for a compelling read. But by no means does it prove anything about vegan diets.
References
     1.  De Filippo C, Cavalieri D, Di Paola M, Ramazzotti M, Poullet JB, Massart S, Collini S, Pieraccini G, Lionetti P. Impact of diet in shaping gut microbiota revealed by a comparative study in children from Europe and rural Africa. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2010;107:14691-6.
     2.  Taku K, Melby MK, Kronenberg F, Kurzer MS, Messina M. Extracted or synthesized soybean isoflavones reduce menopausal hot flash frequency and severity: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Menopause. 2012;19:776-90.
     3.  Spencer EA, Appleby PN, Davey GK, Key TJ. Diet and body mass index in 38000 EPIC-Oxford meat-eaters, fish-eaters, vegetarians and vegans. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord 2003;27:728-34.
     4.  Waldmann A, Koschizke JW, Leitzmann C, Hahn A. Dietary intakes and lifestyle factors of a vegan population in Germany: results from the German Vegan Study. Eur J Clin Nutr 2003;57:947-55.
     5.  Goff LM, Bell JD, So PW, Dornhorst A, Frost GS. Veganism and its relationship with insulin resistance and intramyocellular lipid. Eur J Clin Nutr 2005;59:291-8.
     6.  Waldmann A, Strohle A, Koschizke JW, Leitzmann C, Hahn A. Overall glycemic index and glycemic load of vegan diets in relation to plasma lipoproteins and triacylglycerols. Ann Nutr Metab 2007;51:335-44.
     7.  Tonstad S, Stewart K, Oda K, Batech M, Herring RP, Fraser GE. Vegetarian diets and incidence of diabetes in the Adventist Health Study-2. Nutr Metab Cardiovasc Dis 2013;23:292-9.
     8.  Bissoli L, Di Francesco V, Ballarin A, Mandragona R, Trespidi R, Brocco G, Caruso B, Bosello O, Zamboni M. Effect of vegetarian diet on homocysteine levels. Ann Nutr Metab 2002;46:73-9.
     9.  De Biase SG, Fernandes SF, Gianini RJ, Duarte JL. Vegetarian diet and cholesterol and triglycerides levels. Arq Bras Cardiol 2007;88:35-9.
     10.  Li D, Sinclair A, Mann N, Turner A, Ball M, Kelly F, Abedin L, Wilson A. The association of diet and thrombotic risk factors in healthy male vegetarians and meat-eaters. Eur J Clin Nutr 1999;53:612-9.
     11.  Messina M, Nagata C, Wu AH. Estimated Asian adult soy protein and isoflavone intakes. Nutr Cancer 2006;55:1-12.
     12.  Hamilton-Reeves JM, Vazquez G, Duval SJ, Phipps WR, Kurzer MS, Messina MJ. Clinical studies show no effects of soy protein or isoflavones on reproductive hormones in men: results of a meta analysis. Fertil Steril 2010; 94(3), 997-1007.

Mosconi’s Brain Food Diet
Mosconi offers a plan to prevent and treat Alzheimer’s and maximize cognitive function in everyone. She claims brain health requires a unique diet, but she fails to make her case. Some of what she says is good standard health advice, but the rest is speculative, not based on good scientific evidence, and sometimes demonstrably wrong.
Harriet Hall on May 29, 2018
Link


Lisa Mosconi has a web and media presence and a book Brain Food: The Surprising Science of Eating for Cognitive Power. She claims, “There is increasing evidence that implementing the lifestyle changes described in this book has the potential to prevent Alzheimer’s from developing and also to help slow down or even halt progression of the disease.” What’s more, “eating for your brain…actually helps you achieve peak performance in every part of your life.”
She says, “The human brain has its own unique diet, different from the rest of the body.” The evidence presented in her book does not support that claim. In fact, the diet she recommends for brain health is also a diet for bodily health.
Others have speculated…
In my SkepDoc column in Skeptic magazine (text available online) I reviewed the video series “Awakening from Alzheimer’s,” in which a journalist interviews numerous “experts” and claims that Alzheimer’s is for the most part preventable and can be reversed in 9 out of 10 patients! The recommendations of those “experts” are all over the map. There is nothing even remotely approaching a scientific consensus. They claim the main cause of Alzheimer’s is everything from gluten to obesity to lack of sleep to chronic Lyme disease to toxins spewed by “leaky gut” syndrome. They claim to have reversed Alzheimer’s with a wide variety of treatments: everything from coconut oil to a ketogenic diet to probiotics to strenuous exercise to various long lists of dietary supplements to psychological interventions that are considered successful if they make patients cry. There is no satisfactory evidence to support any of their claims.
What science says
There are several known modifiable risk factors for Alzheimer’s, according to a Lancet review:
    • low levels of education
    • midlife hearing loss
    • physical inactivity
    • high blood pressure (hypertension)
    • type 2 diabetes
    • obesity
    • smoking
    • depression
    • social isolation
Notice that poor diet is not on the list. They recommend active treatment of hypertension, more childhood education, exercise, maintaining social engagement, reducing smoking, and management of hearing loss, depression, diabetes, and obesity. They do not recommend specific dietary interventions or supplements. They estimate that lifestyle interventions “might have the potential to delay or prevent a third of dementia cases.”
But about 65% of the risk is still due to factors you can’t control, such as ageing and family history.
According to the Mayo Clinic:
there’s strong evidence that several factors associated with leading a healthy lifestyle may play a role in reducing your risk of Alzheimer’s disease and other types of dementia. However, more research is needed before any of these factors can be considered a proven strategy to prevent Alzheimer’s disease.
Mosconi is not waiting for more research.
Mosconi says, “The human brain has evolved over millions of years to absorb specific nutrients and to function on a relatively specific diet.” I don’t think that’s true; I think we have evolved to thrive on a wide variety of diets. Our ancestors ate whatever food they could get.
She repeats many of the standard memes of alternative medicine: doctors only treat symptoms, nutrition is not taught in medical schools, our soil is depleted, our food is less nutritious…pesticides, toxins, etc.
She says the brain is the one most easily damaged by a poor diet. Maybe, but she provides no evidence that the brain is damaged when people follow the nutritious, well-balanced, varied diet that is recommended by most mainstream scientists and doctors.
She shows two MRI images to contrast the effects of the Mediterranean diet and the Western diet on brain anatomy. As if two individual scans could prove anything.
Water
She repeats the oft-refuted advice to drink at least 8 glasses of water a day. She claims that drinking water improves cognitive performance. Her citation for that claim is a small study in which participants were instructed to fast overnight and not eat or drink anything after 9 pm, so they were presumably somewhat dehydrated. There is no evidence that people who are not dehydrated benefit from increasing water intake.
She says purified water is bad because essential minerals are missing. She makes the ludicrous claim that purified water is “entirely incapable of hydrating you”! As sources of water she recommends coconut water and aloe vera juice, but she doesn’t provide any evidence that they have significantly beneficial effects compared to plain old tap water. She says energy drinks are not good for you because they are “chockful of manufactured minerals and salts.” Again, no references.
She concludes:
…simply drinking more water and eating water-rich foods could be one of the healthiest changes you make to bring about better health as well as greater cognitive power in your life.
I suppose it “could” be, but I seriously doubt it.
She covers all the major nutrient groups, and her thinking falls into this simplistic sillygism:
    • The brain uses nutrient X
    • Foods A, B, and C are high in nutrient X
    • Therefore you need to eat those foods to be healthy.
This is the same fallacious argument made for superfoods. The same levels of dietary nutrients can be supplied by eating more of other foods. Caviar contains more omega-3s than salmon, but the typical serving of caviar is much smaller than the typical serving of salmon. And it’s possible to get plenty of omega-3s in a varied diet without eating either one.
Standard advice coupled with questionable ideas
Much of what she says is standard health advice. Avoid trans fats. Eat fresh vegetables and fruit. Avoid processed foods. Limit red meat consumption. It’s better to get your nutrients from food than from supplement pills. Exercise, get adequate sleep, and avoid stress. Since the brain runs on glucose, she wouldn’t agree with the low-carb diet folks; she says we need adequate sources of glucose in our diet, and recommends complex carbs, paying attention to the glycemic index.
She provides many examples of observational studies where lower intakes of a certain nutrient were correlated with cognitive impairment. Obviously, if someone is deficient in a vitamin or other nutrient, the deficiency should be corrected. But she doesn’t have any evidence from prospective interventional studies showing that, in practice, altering diet significantly improves cognition for people who are deficient, much less in people who are not deficient.
Often her language is not that of a scientist. She uses buzzwords like detoxification and boosting the immune system. She avoids GMOs and things that she thinks are unnatural like “manufactured” minerals and salts. She says she takes royal jelly daily for its natural antibiotic effects; she says these effects are “known, but perhaps not scientifically confirmed.” If not scientifically confirmed, how are the effects “known”? She says plants produce phytonutrients to increase their life span, and then she leaps to the conclusion that humans will derive the same benefits from eating the plants.
She says by committing to drinking 8 glasses of water a day, you can increase your focus and reaction time by as much as 30%. There is no evidence to support that claim.
At the end of the book, she provides an 80-question test you can take to see how well you’re following a brain-healthy diet. The test has not been validated, so it’s hard to say what a high or low score really means. Then she provides meal plans and recipes.
The ingredients in her recipes are representative of her thinking. Local raw honey. Organic everything. Free-range eggs. Organic, grass-fed whole milk (I assume she means feeding grass to the cows, not feeding it to the milk). Filtered water. Goji berries. Açai berry powder. Ginseng extract with royal jelly and bee pollen. Organic spirulina powder. Even Himalayan pink sea salt, for heaven’s sake! Good grief!!
Where did she go wrong?
Mosconi holds a dual PhD in neuroscience and nuclear medicine. She is the associate director of the Alzheimer’s Prevention Clinic at Weill Cornell Medical College/New York-Presbyterian Hospital, and the founder of the Nutrition and Brain Fitness Lab at New York University School of Medicine. With her training and experience, she ought to understand and practice rigorous science. She makes all the right noises about scientific literacy and recognizing pseudoscience, but she seems unable to look in the mirror and see her own errors.
She reveals where she went astray. In a lecture she gave, she lamented the failure of science to offer a cure for Alzheimer’s or even an effective treatment. Someone in the audience asked, “How about olive oil?” She realized she didn’t know anything about the effects of nutrition on Alzheimer’s. She seems to have assumed that diet must be crucially important, and for some reason instead of studying conventional nutrition science, she got a degree in Holistic Nutrition. She bills herself as a certified Integrative Nutritionist and holistic healthcare practitioner. I couldn’t find where she studied, but Stephen Barrett has criticized the Institute for Integrative Nutrition on Quackwatch. Its training is not based on scientific nutrition. It seems most programs in Integrative Nutrition are 6- to 8-month correspondence courses with no prerequisites. I wonder what she was taught.
Conclusion: Healthy diet yes, brain diet maybe (who knows?)
        ◦ Mosconi does not make a persuasive argument that the brain requires anything unique, anything more than the same good nutrition that benefits the entire body. Her Brain Food plan provides much good advice about healthy lifestyle and diet, but the good advice is mixed with unsupported claims, speculations, extrapolations that go far beyond the evidence, and some very questionable ideas. (Himalayan pink sea salt? Water that doesn’t hydrate?) Her plan might reduce the risk of Alzheimer’s; it might not. Is it any better than any of the many other plans recommended in the “Awakening from Alzheimer’s” videos? The only way to tell would be to do controlled studies, which have not been done or even contemplated, as far as I could see. It might not be any better than the general health advice provided by science-based conventional medical practitioners. There may be no difference between eating for your brain and eating for your entire organism.

Eat for Life: Joel Fuhrman’s Nutritarian Diet
Joel Fuhrman thinks his Nutritarian diet will increase longevity and prevent or treat most chronic diseases. He claims it is based on science, but his evidence is far from convincing.
Harriet Hall on January 4, 2022
Link

Joel Fuhrman, MD is a celebrity doctor, entrepreneur, and best-selling author whose latest book, Eat for Life, advocates his “Nutritarian” or micronutrient-rich diet. He calls the diet “the breakthrough nutrient-rich program for longevity, disease reversal, and sustained weight loss”. He says it is possible to never have a heart attack or stroke, to avoid dementia, to radically reduce your chance of getting cancer, avoid and heal digestive problems, resolve high blood pressure, heal auto-immune diseases, prevent and reverse diabetes and high cholesterol. He says it “amounts to a miracle in our modern world”.
If the diet could really do all that, it would be a miracle indeed! I wish it were true, but the book failed to convince me. He claims it is science-based, and he provides over 40 pages of references. In his mind the evidence is overwhelming and the science is settled, but it isn’t. He tends to assume the “associations” shown in many of his references are clear evidence of causation, but they aren’t. And the diet itself has not been evaluated in controlled scientific studies.
He is one of many who are convinced that the one true cause of disease is poor diet. He claims that if you eat right (i.e., follow his Nutritarian diet), you will be able to attain and maintain perfect health. You will never develop chronic diseases and if you already have those diseases the diet will reverse them.
The cause of aging
His view of what science has accomplished is mostly overly optimistic. Occasionally, one of his statements is more circumspect:
Scientific research suggests that biological aging is a treatable condition.
That’s more accurate, but he operates under the assumption that science has conclusively determined the cause of aging. The science of aging has suggested a large number of possible factors but has not conclusively determined which factors are actual causes and which are concomitants, results, or just correlations. The anti-aging researcher Jay Olshansky once said the secret to aging is that there is no secret.
He thinks science has determined that the four processes that drive aging are:
    • chronic inflammation
    • damage to DNA and proteins (including oxidative damage)
    • cellular senescence (cumulative DNA damage leading to dysfunction and loss of ability to divide)
    • reduced capacity for tissue repair (due to stem cell dysfunction)
He thinks science has established that these same processes (especially inflammation and oxidative damage) are also responsible for cancer, diabetes, obesity, dementia, and most other chronic diseases. He claims they are caused by eating excess calories and low-nutrient foods. He claims they can be effectively controlled by phytochemicals, caloric restriction, and exercise. The book doesn’t address exercise, and it assumes that calories will be restricted automatically when the emphasis is on micronutrients. It claims:
Caloric restriction with adequate micronutrient intake is the most consistent intervention that slows or hinders these hallmarks of aging therefore extending lifespan.
Is this true? A lawyer would object “assumes facts not in evidence”.
Telomeres?
He says telomere shortening is one indicator of biological aging, in fact “telomere shortening is essentially cellular aging”. Maybe, but that’s still controversial. Correlation is not causation. Telomere shortening might accompany aging but not be the cause of aging. It is far from universal: in some animals, telomeres lengthen with age. And there is a species of bat whose telomeres don’t change with age; they live far longer than other bat species and are more resistant to disease.
Insufficient intake of vitamins and minerals?
He cites a study showing that Americans don’t get sufficient vitamins and minerals. It claims that over 60% of Americans have insufficient intakes of vitamins C, K, A, and calcium. That may not be accurate, since the study was based on self-reported estimates and estimated average requirements. Even if accurate, it did not show that insufficient intake had any significant impact on health. We don’t really know the optimum levels of micronutrients.
He fails to mention that the same study showed that a significant number of Americans exceeded the tolerable upper limits for some micronutrients.
He praises the vegan diet and the diets consumed in the so-called Blue Zones but acknowledges that vegans require supplements for adequate nutrition. His Nutritarian diet is essentially a new and improved vegan diet.
Foods to eat and foods to avoid
The Nutritarian diet requires eating these every day:
     1.  A large salad
     2.  At least a half-cup serving of beans/legumes
     3.  At least three fresh fruits
     4.  At least an ounce of raw nuts and seeds
     5.  At least one large serving of green vegetables, steamed or as an ingredient in a soup or entrée
It prohibits these foods:
     1.  Barbecued meats, processed meats, or red meat
     2.  Fried foods
     3.  Dairy (cheese, ice cream, butter, milk)
     4.  Soft drinks, sugar, other sweetening agents, and artificial sweeteners
     5.  White flour products
     6.  Oil
He claims that once you get used to the Nutritarian diet your tastes and food preferences will change. You will find it delicious and won’t miss the foods you used to eat. Maybe.
Testimonials, recipes, menus, etc.
The book is larded with enthusiastic testimonials from his patients. He claims no one who followed his diet ever had a heart attack. He offers help in the form of recipes and menus. And of course, he has developed products that he sells in his online store, including foods, supplements, multivitamins, salad dressings, superfood powders, nutrition bars, kale chips, and much more. They aren’t cheap, but he offers a discount for members.
G-bombs
Fuhrman invented the term “G-Bombs” as a mnemonic for the 6 best cancer-fighting foods: greens, beans, onions, mushrooms, berries, and seeds. If you eat these every day, will you avoid cancer? Maybe. But there’s no clear evidence. There’s no “breakthrough” here; these foods are included in most conventional diet advice.
Nutrient IQ scores
I was particularly annoyed by his table of Nutrient IQ Scores based on typical serving sizes. Cooked kale scores 112, tomatoes 60, an orange 19, salmon 5, eggs 4, skim milk 5, coffee 2, meats 0, and so on. This looks very sciencey and precise but that’s deceptive. He compiled these scores himself and they have not been validated. He says they are more reliable than the older ANDI scores that Whole Foods Markets have been using. ANDI stands for Aggregate Nutrient Density Index; it rated 34 nutrients by the amount per calorie. Guess who invented the ANDI scale? Joel Fuhrman himself!
Many foods with lower scores are known to be good for health. Coffee, which gets a score of 2, is known to be the number 1 source of antioxidants in the American diet, and his “G-bombs” score far lower than leafy greens. Giving meats a score of zero merely shows his vegan bias; meats are known to have many micronutrients.
He says the Nutrient IQ scores are for men; women should multiply the scores by 1.2, and children younger than 12 should multiply them by 1.75. How does he know this? In fact, how does he know any of this? There are more than 34 micronutrients, and they have not all been identified or quantified. We don’t know which ones are in which foods, and we certainly don’t know the optimum amounts of each or how they affect health.
At one point, Fuhrman himself admits that it is not enough to just track these scores; a healthy diet should include some items not high on the list or not on the list at all.
Conclusion: Insufficient evidence
Fuhrman makes extraordinary claims for the Nutritarian diet, but extraordinary claims must be supported by extraordinary evidence, and the evidence he presents is far from compelling. When I reviewed Craig Good’s book Relax and Enjoy Your Food I found his advice far more reasonable. After all, food is not just for nutrition. It is one of the great pleasures of life and its social and cultural connotations are important too.
Is Fuhrman’s diet healthier than the standard vegan diet or the Mediterranean diet? We simply don’t know yet. Where are the controlled studies comparing their objective results?
A Nutritarian diet requires a lot of time invested in shopping and chopping and it’s very restrictive. I don’t think most people would find it palatable or would be able follow it long term. I eat kale but don’t particularly enjoy it; I found his recipes and menus unappetizing, and I’m not convinced that it’s in my best interest to give up meat and dairy entirely.
        ◦ Betty White, who was in pretty good health until her death at age 99, would have disagreed with Fuhrman. When asked about her secret to longevity, she said “I try to avoid anything green”.

Lose Weight without Diet or Exercise? Where’s the Proof?
Can an obese person lose 52 pounds in 28 days without diet or exercise, by simply taking this pill? Yeah, sure! Pull the other one!
Harriet Hall on April 13, 2021
Link 

I’ve been getting emails with “Confirmation numbers” in the Subject Line, numbers like 711, 526, 95311. One even says “Your order is pending”. The numbers don’t confirm anything; they are just click-bait to get you to read an ad for a dietary supplement. They are clumsy attempts to market products that promise incredible weight loss in a short time with no diet or exercise, by just taking a pill.
Perhaps the most ridiculous was from “keto=happiness.” It features a picture of Mark Cuban from Shark Tank and asks, “Why did Mark Cuban and the other sharks invest millions in this product?” Cuban is quoted as saying on ABC News, “It may not be a ‘miracle cure’ – but the science says it’s the closest I’ve ever seen”. When I clicked on “Having Trouble Sticking to a diet?” it took me to this web page.
The headline says “LIFE-CHANGING: Harvard Medical Student Discovers 1 Secret Mineral That Helps You Lose 52 lbs in 28 Days.” And “Big Pharma Doesn’t Want You To Know About This”. It raised a lot of questions. It starts with “before and after” pictures of Emily Senstrom that look suspicious to me. Is that really her? Are they legitimate pictures, or might they have been photo-shopped?
They describe Emily Senstrom as “a top medical student at Harvard”. Is she really a medical student at Harvard? What does “top medical student” mean? They say her medical specialty is nutrition. Medical students don’t have specialties, and nutrition is not a medical specialty. They say “in her experiments for her senior thesis, she stumbled upon a new fat blocking code no one has heard of before”. She is said to have defended her thesis on stage, but the picture is strange. It shows her from behind at a podium facing an almost empty auditorium with only two people in the audience. She claimed to have discovered a secret mineral that would enable anyone to lose 52 lbs in 28 days without dieting or exercise. It “seemed fake” to the Harvard professors (all two of them?), so she set out to prove them wrong. She apparently thinks she did that; I don’t.
So what was it, a fat blocking code or a secret mineral? If it was secret, how did she learn about it? According to the story, she was looking for a book in the library, and found a book that was not the one she was looking for, but that had a chapter called “The Fat Blocking Code”. When she looked up, she found that she was in a restricted section. She took notes and photocopied “all the juicy pages of info”. She used the Harvard nutrition lab to put together the perfect combination of ingredients. She had gained over 50 pounds in her first year of med school, and it melted off: 52 pounds in 28 days! The fat-blocking code allegedly works by overcoming “leptin resistance”. It tells the brain you are full and it triggers signals to speed up your metabolism.
Was she really in a restricted section of the library? What does “restricted” mean if anyone can just walk in unknowingly like Emily did? What was the title of the book? It allegedly reported early experiments in the 1980s; were those experiments published? They are not identified or even described. How can information be “secret” if it has been published in a book? If the code was in the book, why did she need to develop the perfect combination of ingredients?
There is a picture of men sitting around a table. It is said to show that the wealthy Harvard alumni who fund Harvard’s research are key players in Big Pharma, but no one is identified. The inference is that Big Pharma influenced Harvard’s professors to reject Emily’s findings.
There are a series of impressive bar graphs comparing the weight loss of traditional dieters to secret mineral testers, the superiority of fresh batches to older batches (!!! – does the secret mineral lose potency as it ages?), increased weight loss in April compared to other months, and the superiority of her formula to the keto diet.
After many teasers and many before-and-after pictures of many people (which look to me like they depict more weight loss than is stated), they finally reveal the secret: the K3 Spark Mineral. It is described as a “well-researched, natural mineral with no side effects whatsoever”. It is sold as “Safeline Ketosis”. Of course, she is not doing this for the money. It mentions a 70% off limited time offer, but wouldn’t divulge the actual price without my giving them my personal information. It warns that supplies are limited, and features a countdown clock. Typical marketing ploys.
Misinformation about Shark Tank
I was unable to verify the information about Shark Tank. I couldn’t verify that Mark Cuban had ever said what he was quoted as saying. I couldn’t verify that Shark Tank had ever evaluated the product, much less invested millions in it. Snopes has called this a scam. Mark Cuban and celebrities have protested the misuse of their names, denying that they ever endorsed keto products.
What is K3?
Potassium is a mineral; vitamin K is a vitamin. They are sometimes confused because they use the same symbol, K. Do Emily or these marketers know the difference? The information they provide online is not sufficient for me to tell. I’m confused, and I suspect they are too. K3 is an isotope of potassium. Vitamin K3, also known as menadione, is not natural. It is a synthetic version of vitamin K that isn’t legally sold for human consumption due to safety concerns. Studies in the 1980s and 1990s linked it to liver damage and red blood cell destruction.
Conclusion: I don’t believe any of this
Is it really possible to lose weight without diet or exercise? No one has ever demonstrated that simply taking a pill could be a substitute for lifestyle changes. They make claims that are simply not credible. They don’t even explain what the K3 Spark Mineral is; and they don’t explain the difference between the mineral isotope and the vitamin. I don’t believe the claims, I don’t believe the weight loss stories or the pictures, I don’t believe Shark Tank has invested millions, and I don’t believe the story of Emily’s discovery in the restricted section of the library. I don’t believe Harvard’s library has a restricted section that people can just stumble into by mistake. I’d like to see some actual evidence, not just before and after pictures with no identification and bar graphs with no clarifying details. How about some data? How about some controlled studies? In short, I’d like to see some scientific evidence. They don’t have any. Effortless weight loss remains a pipe dream.

#Oatzempic – The viral oat-based alternative to Ozempic?
Can the Oatzempic diet deliver Ozempic-like weight loss?
Scott Gavura on November 7, 2024
Link
Many consumers feel positively about dietary supplements. Most Americans take them. There is a large appeal to nature baked into the marketing – a natural remedy may be felt to be safer than anything “unnatural”, like pharmaceuticals. But natural doesn’t necessarily mean safe or effective. And when there’s a real medical need, “Big Pharma” can deliver the goods, usually better than anything “natural”. If you have have acute trauma, you’re not going to use a dietary supplement for your pain. If you have cancer, you’d be wise not to treat it with alternatives-to-medicine. And with weight loss, there is no dietary supplement that comes close to the impact of the newest weight loss loss drugs, like semaglutide, or Ozempic.
Recently a “natural” remedy has been trending on social media, billed as an alternative to Ozempic. It’s called Oatzempic, it’s popular on TikTok, and influencers are touting massive weight loss results.

Oatzempic is a new diet trend with a clever name. The relationship to Ozempic stops at the name. Oatzempic isn’t a drug but a meal replacement, with claims that the “Oatzempic diet” can lead to 40 lbs of weight loss in two months.
The recipe for Oatzempic is simple: Mix 1 cup of water, ½ cup of uncooked rolled oats and the juice of half of a lime in a blender. Maybe add some cinnamon if you’re feeling frisky. Blend until smooth, and then drink. Why lime? No one seems to know. Advocates claim the mixture has an an effect similar to semaglutide.
The ingredients in this concoction are not unhealthy. 1/2 cup of oats with some lime juice is about 150 calories, and rolled oats are mainly carbohydrate with a small amount of protein. Oats have micronutrients like iron, magnesium and zinc as well. They’re also a good source of soluble fibre, which can promote regularity and even lower cholesterol. Oats can also have positive effects on blood sugars.
The challenge come when you look closer at the usual directions for use. You’re apparently supposed to drink this once a day, in the morning, and then fast until noon. So this effectively becomes a calorie-reduction diet, combined with an intermittent fasting plan. For some, 150 calories until noon may be an insufficient number of calories. While oatmeal can provide satiety, whether or not you end up in net calorie loss depends on your diet over the rest of the day.
So can Oatzempic actually help you lose weight? If it causes sufficient satiety, and leads to a reduction in total calories consumed daily, then yes – it could lead to weight loss. If your current breakfast is relatively higher in calories, and you hold the rest of your diet steady – then an overall calorie decrease could support weight loss. It’s important to note that intermittent fasting isn’t for everyone – but it can support weight loss goals for some people. The Oatzempic diet may not be sustainable – and sustainability is essential for “permanent” weight loss. The Oatzempic diet hasn’t been formally evaluated, so we have no hard data on which to evaluate its overall success rate.
The effectiveness of semaglutide is based on its effect on the GLP-1 receptor, which stimulates insulin secretion and reduces blood sugar. It decreases appetite and suppresses hunger, ultimately reducing energy intake and can cause weight loss of 15-20%. Naturally occuring GLP-1 does not last long in the body. Semaglutide, however, was designed to lasts longer in the body and consequently will have much more profound effects on diet. In doing so, it lowers the risk of heart disease, and can improve blood pressure and blood lipid levels. Semaglutide can do this to an extent simply not possible with food products like oats.
Bottom line? Oatzempic isn’t the worst dietary trend to emerge from TikTok. But trendy meal replacements and fasting may not support long-term weight loss goals. Oats are a healthy food that can be incorporated into a nutritious diet. But you don’t need to blend them with lime juice into a slurry to reap the benefits. Porridge is delicious. Combine that with some fibre-rich fruit, and maybe some protein, and you’ve got a much more appetizing (and potentially sustainable) breakfast habit.


GLP-1 Patch Scams: The Science Doesn’t Support the Hype
GLP-1 drugs work; GLP-1 patches don’t
Scott Gavura on August 14, 2025
Link
Drugs like semaglutide (Ozempic/Wegovy) and tirzepatide (Mounjaro/Zepbound) have transformed the management of obesity. Originally developed for type 2 diabetes, these medications have shown remarkable efficacy in promoting substantial weight loss and even cardiovascular benefits, leading to widespread use. But with their success (and cost) has come a flood of imitation from those looking to capitalize on their popularity. So-called “GLP-1 weight loss patches” are promoted by influencers as a cheaper, non-prescription alternative to GLP-1 injections. Is there evidence to support these claims?
The biggest new drugs in a generation
GLP-1 receptor agonists like semaglutide and the dual GIP/GLP-1 agonist tirzepatide mimic naturally occurring hormones that regulate blood sugar, appetite, and digestion. GLP-1 (glucagon-like peptide-1) slows stomach emptying, promotes feelings of fullness, and stimulates insulin release when blood sugar is high. GIP (glucose-dependent insulinotropic polypeptide) works in a complementary way, further enhancing insulin secretion and further boosting the effectiveness of GLP-1 drugs. There are now numerous GLP-1 drugs available, as different pharmaceutical companies have raced to get a share of this huge new market.
Importantly, GLP-1 and GIP drugs are large peptide molecules, meaning they are not absorbed through intact skin, or well absorbed when swallowed in their original form. The skin’s outermost layer, the stratum corneum, effectively blocks most molecules from being absorbed. And in the stomach, acid and digestive enzymes rapidly break down peptides like semaglutide unless they are specially formulated with absorption enhancers, as in the approved oral form of semaglutide. So the primary form of delivery of these drugs is by injection.
The problem with patches
Despite the scientific (and patent) barriers, “GLP-1 weight loss patches” are widely marketed online and even sold in some retail stores, typically with claims that they deliver GLP-1 or “boost” GLP-1. None of these products are approved by the FDA, Health Canada, or any major national drug regulator. In most cases, the ingredient lists are vague or missing entirely.
When ingredients are provided, it may list components like B-vitamins, berberine, cinnamon extract, and L-glutamine. While some of these products may have therapeutic effects, none have been shown to meaningfully contribute to weight loss, particularly when administered via a transdermal patch. There is no evidence to demonstrate that supplements have effects similar to these drug products.
Delivering large molecules through skin is inherently difficult. If these products truly contained semaglutide or tirzepatide, they would be considered prescription drugs, subject to strict manufacturing standards. And before licensing, manufacturers would have to prove that the drug was not only absorbed reliably and consistently via patch, and that these products worked as well as the (proven) injectable versions.
Risks beyond the wallet
When consumers buy GLP-1 “patches,” they are putting themselves at the mercy of a largely unregulated industry. As I’ve blogged many times before, non-drug supplements are not held to the same manufacturing standards as prescription medicines. There is no assurance that what’s on the label matches what’s inside, or that the product contains any active drug at all. As a health care professional, I rely on regulators to ensure products are made to high quality standards so I can confidently apply clinical evidence to the patient in front of me. With unregulated products like these patches, all bets are off. It’s buyer beware: you don’t know if it works, and neither do your pharmacist or doctor. At best, it’s a placebo and only your wallet suffers. At worst, it may cause skin irritation, and could even contain contaminated or undisclosed ingredients. In either case, you’ve delayed getting an effective treatment.
The bottom line
GLP-1 and GIP/GLP-1 drugs like semaglutide and tirzepatide have transformed the treatment of obesity and type 2 diabetes – but there are no over-the-counter shortcuts. A patch claiming the same benefits without a prescription is not only scientifically implausible, it’s a red flag for an unregulated product that hasn’t been tested or proven safe. If you’re interested in these medications, speak with your primary care provider or pharmacist. Don’t rely on social media influencers. Health care professionals can help you understand the real benefits and risks, determine if these drugs are appropriate for you, and ensure you get a product that’s been evaluated for safety, quality, and effectiveness. There may even be ways to reduce the cost through insurance coverage or manufacturer assistance programs. With your health and money on the line, there’s no substitute for evidence-based medicine.


Generic GLP-1s are coming, but Americans don’t want to wait
Compounding pharmacies are illegally selling GLP-1 drugs, and the FDA is determined to shut that pathway down.
Scott Gavura on March 12, 2026
Link

GLP-1 drugs like semaglutide (sold as Ozempic and Wegovy) are so successful that they have redefined what the pharmaceutical industry calls a “blockbuster”. Few prescription drugs have moved from regulatory approval to mass adoption so quickly. First approved for the treatment of diabetes, they were soon recognized and sought out for their weight loss effects. Surveys suggest about 12.4%, or one in eight Americans report using a GLP-1 drug for weight loss, up from 5.8% in just two years. Globally, spending on GLP-1s is expected to triple from $50-60 billion today to more that $135 billion within the next decade, with most of those sales expected in North America.
In the United States, lower-cost generic equivalents are still several years away. Canada, however, may see generic semaglutide as early as 2026 following what looks like an unintentional patent lapse. Meanwhile, many Americans have turned to compounding pharmacies to obtain cheaper GLP-1s, a pathway the Food and Drug Administration is now moving to shut down.
The Impact of GLP-1s
Widespread GLP‑1 use is having more than individual effects. With this scale of use, they’re measurably changing consumer behaviour, business strategies, and even economic forecasts. Goldman Sachs estimated US GDP could be boosted by 0.4% through productivity gains and healthcare savings. People that use GLP‑1 drugs are reducing grocery spending by around 5% and buying fewer processed snacks and desserts. Smaller portions and more products with protein and fibre are coming. It may be that GLP-1 drugs may promote reduced alcohol intake as well. We may only now be starting to see the bigger impacts of these popular, effective drugs.
Generic semaglutide is coming to Canada
I consider Derek Lowe’s blog a must read and his post on semaglutide last June was jaw-dropping. He describes an apparent decision by Ozempic/Wegovy’s manufacturer, Novo Nordisk to stop paying their annual patent fee in Canada, which led to the patent lapsing:
I posted this on my BlueSky account and a follower there (Prof. Michael Hoffman from Toronto) put me on to the Canadian Patent Database, where you can find that Novo did file a patent there for semaglutide. . .but the last time they paid the annual maintenance fee on it was 2018! You can even find a letter where their lawyers send a refund request for the 2017 maintenance fee ($250) because Novo apparently wanted some more time to see if they wanted to pay it. On the same date in 2019, the office sent a letter saying that “The fee payable to maintain the rights accorded by the above patent was not received by the prescribed due date. . .” By that time it was $450 with the late fee added, but that was apparently too much for Novo. They had a one year grace period to make it up, and apparently never did, so their patent lapsed in Canada. And as the Canadian authorities remind them, “Once a patent has lapsed it cannot be revived”.
The Canadian patent lapsed on January 4, 2026. Multiple manufacturer plan to bring generic versions forward in Canada, and they’re expected later this year. Given the popularity and cost, the arrival of lower-priced generics is expected to be welcomed by Canadians.
No generics for Americans – anytime soon
There are no FDA‑approved generic versions of semaglutide or of any other GLP-1 drug. These drugs can cost up to $1000/month, making them difficult to afford for all but the very wealthy. While there are expectations and hopes that list prices will drop in 2026, this has not stopped an explosion of unapproved GLP-1 sales, offered by compounding pharmacies. Currently anything being offered as a generic is either a compounded drug, or it could come from an unapproved source (e.g., imported).
While a shortage of semaglutide and tirzepatide enabled compounding pharmacies to legally manufacture these products, the restoration of full supply has closed the door on legal compounding. However, some compounding pharmacies are continuing to produce products.
Compounding is the process by which a pharmacy can create a customized drug product that addresses unique patient needs, such as allergy, or dosage form requirements. But importantly, compounded drugs are not subject to FDA approval, and finished products are not reviewed for safety, efficacy, or quality. Risks of harms are consequently higher with compounded products, so they should be avoided when an FDA-approved product is available. Compounding was never intended to be for mass production, or as a way of circumventing intellectual property laws.
For price-sensitive Americans eager to get access to low cost GLP-1s, these advertisements are likely tempting: If you can’t afford Ozempic, why not buy what’s advertised as “generic semaglutide” from a telehealth company that ships it to your door? The FDA has repeatedly warned that some compounders are using different salt forms of semaglutide, unverified active ingredients, or multi‑dose vials and concentrations that have already led to serious dosing errors and hospitalizations.
In its March 2026 enforcement action against 30 telehealth companies, the FDA emphasized thats that compounded GLP‑1s are unapproved and are not generics. One letter notes,
Compounded drug products are not FDA-approved. Your claims imply that your products have been FDA-approved or otherwise evaluated for safety and effectiveness when they have not. As a result, these claims are false or misleading and your products are therefore misbranded under sections 502(a) and 502(bb) of the FDCA [21 U.S.C. §§ 352(a) and (bb)].
The introduction or delivery for introduction into interstate commerce of these misbranded products is a prohibited act under section 301(a) of the FDCA [21 U.S.C. § 331(a)]. The representations and claims identified in this letter put you on notice of our concerns but do not represent an exhaustive list of violations.
For the reasons discussed above, your compounded semaglutide and tirzepatide products are misbranded drugs under sections 502(a) and 502(bb) of the FDCA [21 U.S.C. §§ 352(a) and 352(bb)], introduced or delivered for introduction into interstate commerce in violation of section 301(a) of the FDCA [21 U.S.C. § 331(a)]. Please be advised, the receipt in interstate commerce of misbranded drugs, and the delivery or proffered delivery thereof, is also a violation of section 301(c) of the FDCA [21 U.S.C. § 331(c)].
Conclusion: Generics for some
GLP‑1 drugs are highly effective therapies addressing a genuine health need. They are generally well tolerated and are having meaningful, population-level effects on obesity. Unfortunately, that demand has run up against high prices, and an illicit grey market has appeared as a result. While US prices are expected to drop somewhat in 2026, the Canadian market may give a preview of what Americans can expect in several years: Regulator-approved, low-cost generic equivalents that make GLP-1 drugs accessible and affordable.

A British Teenager is Blind, But Not Because of Junk Food or “Fussy Eating”
A recent case report about a British teenager blinded by severe nutritional deficiencies resulted in widespread media coverage, much of which missed the point. He wasn’t blinded by junk food and he wasn’t just a fussy eater.
Clay Jones on September 6, 2019
Link


A tragic story out of England involving a teenager rendered permanently blind because of a severe nutritional deficiency is making the rounds this week. People, even children, go blind all the time unfortunately, so it may seem odd that there would be such coordinated coverage of this particular case by all the major news outlets. But there are some unique aspects to the child’s history that had these journalists salivating.
According to the authors of the Annals of Internal Medicine case report, the 17-year-old boy had an extremely limited diet:
He had a daily portion of fries from the local fish and chip shop and snacked on Pringles (Kellogg), white bread, processed ham slices, and sausage.
Many of the news reports have referred to the 17-year-old as “picky” or “fussy” about what foods he would eat, with one article even claiming that he was “blinded by junk food”. To be fair, that was essentially the title of the case report that these articles are based on. And everyone knows that “junk food” is bad for you, right? Most of the articles even feature pictures of French fries or potato chips to help focus the readers attention on the dastardly and muttly culprits.
As a pediatrician, I work with many families who become overly concerned about their child’s health because of something that they have hear or read in the news. While unintentional I’m sure, some articles discussing this case may result in undue anxiety. One example of this is the opening paragraph of the coverage in Ars Technica, which involves a joke in poor taste about using the fear of blindness to deal with “picky eaters”:
In the past, parents may have tried to coax their picky eaters to dinner with misguided reminders of starving children—or perhaps letting them imitate farm animals. But, the parents of today now have a scarier prompt.
Parents, like all humans, aren’t always rational. Yes, this is a joke. A very bad joke. But it is at the beginning of an article discussing the terrible outcome of what is largely being described as picky or fussy eating. Normal picky eating behaviors in childhood have no place even being mentioned in this context. Maybe it’s a bit of a stretch, but I worry that this may be confusing to some readers. And while the article goes on to provide good information, it isn’t until the final paragraph.
As is often the case, a lot of the media coverage lacked nuance, and an opportunity to educate the public about a severe and recently recognized eating disorder was largely wasted. What the patient suffered from was far more than simply being a fussy eater. He likely experienced extreme anxiety, potentially even the fear of death, at the mere thought of eating most foods.
Blinded by junk food?
The child in question first presented with symptoms of fatigue related to nutritional deficiency at the age of 14. He was found to have anemia caused by a vitamin B12 deficiency, which was ultimately blamed on “fussy eating” after a limited work-up for causes of poor intestinal absorption was performed. He was prescribed B12 injections and given advice on proper diet. This was a missed opportunity to recognize and properly manage his eating disorder.
By age 15, he had developed hearing difficulty and unspecified “visual problems”, and was evaluated by both an ENT surgeon and an ophthalmologist but no underlying cause was found. Another missed opportunity, particularly given the history of known issues with his diet and the fact that he had not been adherent to the B12 injections for undisclosed reasons. After 2 years of progressive vision loss, he was seen by a neuro-ophthalmologist and diagnosed with permanent optic neuropathy.
Optic neuropathy, which is the term for essentially any injury to the optic nerve, has a long list of potential etiologies but is very rare in the pediatric population. A thorough work-up involving laboratory and genetic testing, neuroimaging, and intestinal biopsies was completed, and the cause was narrowed down to multiple severe nutritional deficiencies. In particular, vitamin B12 deficiency was again found and believed to be the primary cause of the patient’s visual loss. It was at this point that his extremely restricted food intake came to light.
Avoidant Restrictive Food Intake Disorder
This unfortunate child was not blinded by junk food. He suffered from a recently recognized eating disorder known as Avoidant Restrictive Food Intake Disorder, or ARFID. The concept of a pathologically restrictive diet isn’t new, of course. It’s more fair to say that the ARFID is a new label for the older “Selective Eating Disorder”, complete with a better description of the presentation, that was incorporated into the most recent edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders in 2013.
Patients with ARFID are not just picky eaters. They avoid or restrict themselves from certain foods because of severe anxiety related to eating them, or because of extreme emotional discomfort related to certain food textures. Many of these patients become physically unable to eat many foods because of gagging and vomiting that occurs when attempting to do so. Some experience an intense fear of choking to death when even thinking about eating certain foods.
This degree of avoidance and restriction of foods, by definition, results in physiological harm in addition to the adverse effects on psychosocial functioning. Failure to maintain appropriate weight isn’t as common as it is with the more well known anorexia nervosa, but it can occur. As in the case discussed above, nutritional deficiencies are also a major concern. Also by definition, ARFID does not involve a disturbance in how the patient experiences their body. They don’t have concerns about being overweight.
Here is a description of a typical case of ARFID. I have admitted several extremely ill patients with this condition to the hospital and each one has been hard to witness and challenging to treat. It takes involvement from medical doctors, particularly experts in adolescent medicine and psychiatry, as well as dietitians and social workers. It is not unusual for patients to require anxiety medications with each meal in the early stages of treatment, just to help correct nutritional deficiencies and stabilize organ function, before long-term cognitive behavioral therapy can be initiated.
Missed opportunities
The authors, the lead being an ophthalmologist, appeared to be more into the discussion of optic neuropathy than the patient’s ARFID, but at least they do mention it in passing at the very end. Like much of the news coverage, however, they focused on the fact that his diet consisted of mostly “junk food”, a nebulous label that often serves to demonize food and the people consuming it rather than to educate them on healthy dietary choices. This was evident in the press release:
The researchers concluded that the patient’s ‘junk food’ diet and limited intake of nutritional vitamins and minerals resulted in the onset of nutritional optic neuropathy. They suggest the condition could become more prevalent in future, given the widespread consumption of ‘junk food’ at the expense of more nutritious options, and the rising popularity of veganism if the vegan diet is not supplemented appropriately to prevent vitamin B12 deficiency.
That seemed like an unnecessary cheap shot at veganism given the context of this case.
The news article I just linked to has a giant picture of French fries, but while French fries are a convenient scapegoat that makes this whole thing cognitively easier to digest, demonizing specific foods is not what we should be focusing on. The focus should be on mental health as it relates to eating, and how systemic factors can lead to a child like this going so long without appropriate help. We should be talking about how this was a preventable tragedy, not about junk food and veganism.
Popular media have highlighted the risks for poor cardiovascular health, obesity, and cancer associated with junk food, but poor nutrition can also permanently damage the nervous system, particularly vision.
This wasn’t simply a case of “poor nutrition”. The child was avoiding a wide variety of foods necessary for complete nutrition because he was suffering from untreated severe anxiety. This could have happened even if the foods he could eat weren’t classic junk foods.
I highly doubt that there are many people out there who would not recognize his diet as extremely high risk. So this case report raises many more questions than it answers. How did this kid slip the cracks so egregiously? Why was he not admitted to a hospital for inpatient management when he presented with blatant ARFID and associated hearing and vision loss two years prior to the involvement of the case report authors?
Ironically, approaching a case like this as a consequence of the “junk food” rather than the ARFID induced avoidance of foods necessary for vital organ function might actually play a role in causing an eating disorder in some people. What people define as a bad food is often subjective and often not based on science. Gluten, for example, is now frequently seen as something to avoid even if celiac disease isn’t a concern.
When we demonize particular foods rather than encourage healthy diets it fosters an environment where excessive fear of unhealthy foods can result in disordered eating. I’ve seen many patients who have, over time, added more and more “unhealthy” foods to their list of things to avoid until they are left with a very limited diet. This has come to be known as orthorexia, and is widely accepted even if it hasn’t yet been officially recognized as an eating disorder.
Conclusion: A missed opportunity to discuss disordered eating
This was a preventable case of blindness in a pediatric patient. Somehow this child didn’t get the medical care he should have. His dietary restrictions, caused by a severe eating disorder and not “fussy eating”, should have been recognized and managed prior to his loss of vision. Rather than demonizing the foods he ate, however, we should be focusing on preventing children like this from slipping through the cracks.
One important step in that process is awareness of ARFID as an entity. The overwhelming majority of picky eaters do not have ARFID and will never develop it. But if the behaviors seem extreme or persistent, talk to your child’s pediatrician or family doctor about it. The National Eating Disorder Association is a great resource as well.

Natural Medicine, Starvation, and Murder: The Story of Linda Hazzard
History is replete with doctors who practiced quackery. Here is the story of one such quack whose fasting therapy resulted in many deaths, a story that is so bizarre and horrific that it’s hard to believe it really happened, but it did.
Harriet Hall on December 13, 2016
Link


Editor’s note: Harriet is still in Australia recovering from her injuries. She is expected to return to the US with her husband later this week. In the meantime, we have one more post by her, which was written before her injuries. We don’t know when she’ll have recovered sufficiently to resume her weekly blogging here, but we have a guest post for next week. After that, we’ll play it by ear. Finally, this post has been reposted under a new URL because of another WordPress issue; you might see duplicates in RSS feeds, and the old comments are gone. Sorry about that.
I recently learned of a real-life horror story that is all the more frightening because the horror is not supernatural fantasy but a matter of real humans torturing and killing fellow humans under the guise of medical care.
Linda Burfield Hazzard was an American quack doctor who put her patients on such stringent fasts that some of them died of starvation. She is thought to have been responsible for at least 14 deaths over one four-year period. She was convicted of manslaughter but was out of prison in two years and went right back to her old practices. She was one of a kind and is long gone, but there are lessons to be learned for today.
Who was she?
Linda Burfield was born in Minnesota in 1867. She had no medical training but was granted a license to practice medicine in Washington State under a grandfather clause. She was a follower of Edward Hooker Dewey, MD, who believed in the healing power of nature and had his patients abstain from food. Linda believed that excessive eating was the cause of most illnesses, and that fasting would remove toxins from the body, correct imbalances, and allow the body to heal itself. After practicing in Minnesota and later in Seattle, she opened a sanitarium, Wilderness Heights, in Olalla, Washington, on the shores of Puget Sound. Her patients were allowed to eat nothing but small amounts of dilute tomato and asparagus juices. They lost weight rapidly. An example of one of her diets can be found on Wikipedia in the form of excerpts from the diary of a patient who died of starvation under her care. In addition to fasting, patients were subjected to painful osteopathic manipulations, prolonged enemas, and other indignities. 40 patients died while under her care. She performed autopsies in her bathtub and alleged that they had died of unrecognized illnesses like cirrhosis rather than of starvation. The house she lived in still exists, and the original bathtub is still there. I wonder if the new owners think of her when they bathe.
The people who lived in Olalla were aware that patients were dying at her establishment; children were afraid to go near it, and when they saw the weakened patients out and about they laughed at them because they were unable to walk without falling down.
Her husband, Samuel Hazzard, was a con man and a drunk who had spent time in prison for bigamy. Together, they conspired to steal patients’ jewelry and clothing, they forged documents, they had patients falsely declared mentally ill and incompetent, and they got powers of attorney so they could take over their patients’ estates and enrich themselves. They even extracted the gold fillings from the patients’ corpses and sold them to a dentist.
The death of Claire Williamson
The shit hit the fan with the death of Claire Williamson. Claire and Dorothea (Dora) Williamson were wealthy British sisters who could probably be best characterized as the “worried well.” They had some minor complaints, but were vigorous and well enough to travel the world. They had always been interested in natural healing and had eagerly followed every new fad. They sought out Linda Hazzard in Seattle and later were patients in her sanitarium. The story of their decline and Claire’s death is told in the book Starvation Heights by Gregg Olsen. He spares no details. The description of how the sisters slowly wasted away is one of the most painful things I have ever read. They became fatigued, had difficulty walking, were in pain, and eventually became too weak to get out of bed. They were essentially kept prisoners and even denied access to their mail. The only reason their plight came to light was that Dora was able to smuggle out a message to a friend in Australia. By the time the friend arrived and got the authorities involved, Claire had died. She weighed less than 50 pounds at her death. Hazzard did an autopsy and said she had died of cirrhosis. Dorothea was shown the body but didn’t recognize it as her sister’s and believed another corpse that weighed more had been substituted. The funeral home was apparently in cahoots with the Hazzards.

After Claire’s death, the Hazzards tried to brainwash Dora into believing that she was insane and unable to care for herself; they tried to get guardianship so they could control the Williamson estate. With the help of the British consul, Dora was forcibly removed from the sanitarium just in the nick of time before she, too, starved to death. She looked like those pictures of walking skeletons from when the Nazi death camps were liberated.
It proved very difficult to get the local prosecutor to act, due to lack of motivation and lack of funds. When the case finally went to court, it was a circus. Hazzard’s defense was that the witnesses were all lying and the medical establishment had conspired against her out of jealousy, since she cured patients they couldn’t help. Her former patients were not allowed to testify. She tried to influence witnesses, grandstanded for the newspapers, and was proved to have forged Claire’s will as well as the last entry in Claire’s diary. She was convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to two to twenty years of hard labor, but was released after two years and was granted a full pardon by the governor.
Prison didn’t stop Hazzard
After her release, she went to New Zealand and practiced as an osteopath and dietitian for five years. Eventually she was found guilty of practicing medicine without a license and was fined £5 plus court costs. The next year she was right back in Olalla building a bigger sanitarium. Her Washington license had been revoked, but she got around the law by calling her sanitarium a school of health. She continued to supervise fasts there for 15 years until the building burned down. Three years after that, in 1938, she died while trying to cure herself by fasting. Poetic justice?
Why didn’t the sisters realize what was happening to them?
To me, the most appalling thing was that the sisters continued to believe in Hazzard’s starvation treatment until the bitter end. Couldn’t they see that they were dying? When they first consulted Hazzard they were walking around and travelling the world; soon they were too weak to walk. Surely they could see that their flesh had melted away and that 50 pounds was an unhealthy weight for an adult. They were completely under the thrall of Hazzard’s strong personality and they truly believed the starvation treatment was working and they were getting better.
Lessons to be learned
Thank goodness there are no Linda Hazzards today (that we know of), but there is much we can learn from her saga. We still have to deal with many of the same issues today.
Living without food. There are Breatharians who think they can survive by prana (the Hindu vitalistic force) alone, and there is an 83-year-old man named Prasad Jani in India who claims to have lived without food for 7 decades. Three years ago a Seattle woman named Naveena Shine embarked on an experiment to see if she could live on water, sunlight, and tea. She lost 20% of her body weight, developed worrying symptoms, and resumed eating after 44 days. In a previous article I described Ray Jardine’s 40-day water-only fast. Intermittent fasting is being seriously studied by scientists for weight loss and improved health. A recent historical novel, The Wonder, by Emma Donoghue, was inspired by a number of cases in Ireland of girls who stopped eating, usually because of warped religious beliefs and superstitions. (It’s a great read, by the way, about a nurse who was sent to investigate an Irish peasant girl’s claim that she hadn’t eaten for four months.)
Lack of prosecution. The laws are still not being enforced adequately. Quacks are getting away with practicing medicine without a license and licensed doctors are practicing quackery with impunity. The lack of effective action is epitomized by the Burzynski case. Despite lawsuits and medical board investigations, he is still garnering big bucks for his untested cancer treatments.
Defenses of quackery. Any quack can produce reams of patient testimonials. Satisfied patients idolize them as gifted healers, assuming that the quack treatment was the cause of their improvement, committing the logical fallacy of post hoc ergo propter hoc. When confronted, quacks insist that mainstream medicine is persecuting them and just trying to protect their own turf for purely financial reasons.
Women’s issues. Hazzard stood up for her gender and challenged the male-dominated medical establishment of her day. Serial killers are usually male, and she stands out as an exception to the rule. Her treatments were every bit as lethal as bullets, and arguably worse because of a slower death and more suffering.
Belief in implausible treatments. Public gullibility is alive and well. We have quackademia and there are homeopathic remedies in every drug store. The general public and many elected officials have a very poor understanding of science and hold pseudoscientific and anti-scientific beliefs.
Human psychology. How can we understand the mentality that led the Williamson sisters to continue to believe in a treatment that was obviously rushing them into an early grave? Because they believed so strongly, they were unable to see what ought to have been glaringly obvious to any observer. We see the same thing today in cancer patients who insist they are on the right course despite clear evidence that they are getting worse with quack cancer treatments.
Conclusion: We can learn from this
I live a scant 34 miles from Olalla, Washington, where all this happened. How had I never heard about it until now?
This is a story that deserves to be told. As Santayana said, those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it. This is the story of a unique person’s crimes of murder, theft, and torture, but it is more than that. Many people let the Williamson sisters down: the quack doctor, her husband, the public prosecutors, the community of Olalla, the nurses who assisted with patient care, the state licensing board, the prison system, the governor who granted a pardon, the funeral home that aided in the deceptions, the coroner who failed to investigate the suspicious deaths, and the postal system that let the doctor intercept the sisters’ letters. And the patients themselves bear a large part of the responsibility for what happened. No man is an island; we all share responsibility for others. The Hazzard story can be useful as a wake-up call; as a community, surely we can do more than we are currently doing to protect our more vulnerable members.

Let Food Mislabeling: Let Food Be Thy Dogma
Should you feed your dog organic, biodynamic, grain-fed, non-GMO, high-protein, low-carb, unpasteurized, cruelty-free, free-range, soy-lacto-egg-free caribou Num-Nums? Particularly when their last meal was cat vomit?
Greg Bishop on August 30, 2019
Link

Zealotry about pet food is every bit as self-satisfied as a Food Babe mantra. Since food is the new religion, and pets are the new kids, the new angels and demons must be different ingredients in pet foods. Ask a chihuahua owner in the pet store why they’re reaching for a $40 bag of kibble with a painting of a wolf eating a caribou, and they’ll usually say, “Because it’s biologically appropriate“. As the joke goes, I’ve never seen a pack of chihuahuas hunting caribou (the closest I’ve seen is a Chihuahua wearing a reindeer outfit). But let’s just say for sake of argument that Paleo for poodles were better for dogs (it’s not). If that were true (and again, it’s not), can you wriggle your self-righteous nose knowing that you’ve given Mrs. Fluffybutt the finest tundra ungulate* meat available?
Well no, and not just because your premise is wrong.
The problem is a little-talked-about issue in pet food known as mislabeling. Mislabeling means the contents of the food are different from what is stated on the label. It can be either added ingredients that aren’t listed, or listed ingredients that aren’t added. It’s rampant in pet food, and despite being pervasive, it’s a largely ignored issue in the greater fanaticism about what our pets eat. Mislabeling is just one problem in pet food, which is about as full of myths as the Greek pantheon. We’ll get to mislabeling in a bit…
But first, let’s all freak out about pet food
If you want to test the limits of your sanity, walk into a boutique pet store and ask the kind-hearted attendant what you should feed your Norwegian puffinhund. There is a great deal of public confusion about what pets should be eating. We’ve seen a completely unnecessary “grain free” movement that now may be responsible for making hundreds of pets sick. And thousands if not millions of pet owners feed their pets raw meat in a misguided belief that they are doing them a favor. Many if not most of these people are well-intentioned but misinformed, but then of course there are all sorts of scams taking advantage of these fears, including a cringe-worthy Netflix “documentary”, and bogus food allergy kits marketed to pet owners.
This is all exhaustingly familiar to skeptical eaters of food, who know that most fear-mongering about most foods is ignorant bunk at best, and profit-motivated deception at worst. There are strong incentives in the pet food industry to hype their food, with annual sales of pet food in the US at about $30 billion, and over 600 brands (not types or formulas but brands) of pet food all competing with each other for your dollar. At the same time, the size of a bag of pet food is getting smaller, so we’re spending more money on smaller, more customized pet foods. People are paying a premium to get what they believe are superior ingredients. Even if they don’t need it (and again, they don’t), at least what’s on the label should be what’s in the bag, right?
The (actual) truth about what’s in pet food
Now let’s get back to mislabeling. You might be surprised to find out that the ingredient list on a bag of pet food is not a sacrosanct document verifying the precise contents of that particular bag. However, there are a number of studies looking at the discrepancy between food labeling and actual contents (reviewed nicely here). Of the nearly 800 foods investigated in this review, about 45% tested positive for unlabeled ingredients, with some studies showing rates as high as 83%. Most of these cases were of unlabeled added ingredients, but a significant number of them couldn’t find a labeled ingredient in the food! What’s more, most of these tests used PCR, which only works when you know exactly what you’re looking for,** so it’s probable that the actual percentage of mislabeled foods is much higher.
That is a decent sample of commercial pet foods and a shockingly high amount of mislabeling. Even with “limited ingredient” products, which are marketed to owners of pets who may have a sensitivity or allergy to certain foods, a recent study found that all the diets included had DNA from a source not listed on the ingredient list (and one diet didn’t even test positive for the listed ingredient!). And even in the diet that is considered the gold standard for dogs with dietary allergies (a hydrolysed protein diet) unlabeled proteins that could be allergens were detected.
It seems there’s a lot of “other” stuff in pet foods, although the amounts detected could have been trace and contaminants from using the same equipment to process different types of foods. In case you are smugly scoffing at the pet food manufacturers for being incompetent yokels, be aware that your own food supply is hardly better. Food mislabeling in human products is rampant as several high profile scandals (tah–dah!) made clear.
Does any of this actually matter?
We don’t actually know how much of a problem this is. PCR is extremely sensitive, so the amount of mislabeled ingredients in pet food might not even cause clinical problems. But obviously there are issues of consumer protection and outright food fraud to contend with. I, for one, would be a bit miffed if I walked into a movie theater to watch Toy Story 4 and was instead shown Fifty Shades Freed, even if they’re equally as entertaining.
For some individuals though, mislabeled food can be a serious problem. Consider the warnings on food packages that state whether or not a product was processed on equipment that also processes nuts. The FDA regulates both human and pet food, and issues dozens of allergen-related food recalls each year. Fortunately, dogs and cats don’t often get severely ill from dietary allergens, but there are lots of pets that don’t tolerate some ingredients. For those of us and our pets without dietary allergies, it’s pretty unlikely that any of these ingredients are making us sick in any way.
Conclusion: Don’t quibble about kibble
Most pet food labeling is simply not very helpful. The front of the package labeling is often woefully misguiding, and most pet owners aren’t aware of what they should be looking for. There’s little guarantee that the ingredients listed are an accurate representation of the food in the bag, even though mislabeling pet food is a federal crime. Pet owners, like most people, think food is a lot more important to health than it is. But dogs are evolved from dumpster diving mongrels, and wolves in captivity do great on commercial dog food, so can we all agree that most pets are going to be fine on most foods (in fact they’ll eat almost anything), as long as they’re not overfed? No? We can’t agree? Okay, well then I guess I’ll just keep working on suppressing my sense of irony as English bulldog owners proudly tell me they would never give their dog a food that contains GMO’s. Sigh.

*Can we please, please call caribou tundrgulates?
**For example, nobody was looking for tree DNA, which may be making its way into pet food soon.

   The Top Ten Pet Supplements: Do They Work?
Brennen McKenzie
Link
An Embarrassment of Riches?
Much has been written here about the dietary supplement business, a multibillion dollar industry with powerful political connections, and about the woeful inadequacy of regulation which allows widespread marketing of supplements without a solid basis in science or scientific evidence. 
The veterinary supplement market is a pittance compared to the human market, but still a billion-dollar pittance that is growing rapidly. Unfortunately, the resources available for good quality research in veterinary healthcare are also a pittance, and it is not at all unusual for our pets to suffer, or even be euthanized, as a result of treatable diseases for want of money to pay for needed care. So $1 billion a year spent on nutritional supplements may not be such a good deal if these products don’t effectively prevent or treat disease. 
The variety of supplements available is staggering. Many proprietary concoctions of vitamins, minerals, herbs, and other ingredients are marketed for health maintenance, “boosting the immune system,” retarding aging, or treating specific diseases. A comprehensive review of this multitude of moving targets is impossible. But the lion’s share of the pet supplement market goes to a few specific compounds, so I will focus on these. Most of these ingredients are also among the most popular supplements for humans, so there will be substantial overlap with previous discussions of the plausibility and evidence for many of these substances. 
1. Glucosamine
The biggest name in the veterinary supplement world by a large margin is glucosamine. It is sold alone or in combination with chondroitin, MSM, green-lipped mussle extract, and a zillion other ingredients. It is sold over-the-counter and through veterinarians and as an additive in commercial pet foods, and it is ubiquitous. It is also widely believed by pet owners and veterinarians to be an effective treatment for osteoarthritis. 
Glucosamine for arthritis in humans has been discussed at length here before. There is some reasonable plausibility to the underlying theory, but decades of clinical trials have failed to find any consistent benefit, and the balance of the evidence strongly suggests it is no better than a placebo in treating arthritis in humans. Given the subjective nature of pain and the multitude of ways biologically inert interventions can influence people’s perceptions of their own discomfort, this placebo effect might be of marginal value in humans, but the same kind of psychology does not apply to dogs and cats, though it certainly does apply to their owners.
There is very little clinical research on glucosamine as a treatment for arthritis in dogs and cats. In preparing a recent brief literature review, I found only two clinical trials in dogs. One found no benefit for glucosamine and the other, which had a weaker design, showed little benefit. Both showed far greater and more predictable benefit to non-steroidal anti-inflammatory (NSAID) therapy, which is a consistent feature of clinical research on glucosamine.
Because cats are poorly tolerant of NSAIDs, there is particularly great interest in glucosamine and other nutraceutical therapies for osteoarthritis in this species. Nevertheless, I have found no published clinical trials studying this supplement in arthritis cats. The closest is a study of a diet containing glucosamine, chondroitin, and a number of other supplements purported to have benefits in managing arthritis. I have addressed this study in detail elsewhere, but in brief there were not consistent differences between the experimental diet and the control diet even on subjective measures of comfort and no differences at all on objective measures of activity. And, of course, the role of glucosamine, if any, in any effect that might have been seen would not be demonstrable in a study of a diet with many other ingredients.
Glucosamine is also marketed for treatment of feline interstitial cystitis, an uncomfortable and potentially very serious chronic inflammatory disease of the urinary bladder. However, the only clinical trial to investigate this use did not find any evidence of benefit.
2. Fish Oil
After glucosamine, one of the most popular supplements for pets is fish oil. In humans, the most common use of this supplement is for lowering blood lipid levels and prevention of cardiovascular disease. There is some controversy about exactly how much of which components is useful for which specific conditions, and whether eating fish is better than taking fish oil supplements, but in general there is good evidence for some benefit in cardiovascular disease prevention.
Cats and dogs don’t have the problems humans do with atherosclerosis and cardiovascular disease, so this is not a reason for use of fish oils. Instead, this supplement is most commonly used in the treatment of skin allergies. A 2010 narrative review of the evidence for various approaches to treating canine skin allergies concluded that there was some evidence that fish oil supplements can improve coat quality and reduce the dosage of steroid medications needed to control itching, but that these effects are small and not great enough to substitute for other therapies. There is also not evidence to support the use of any particular source, dosage, or formulation of fish oil over any other. 
The other common use of fish oils in pets is for treatment of arthritis. There is weak evidence in humans for the use of fish oil supplements as an adjunctive treatment in patients with rheumatoid arthritis, but in general this is not a well-supported intervention for degenerative osteoarthritis in people. There have been several studies of fish oil as a therapy for osteoarthritis in dogs, which I have reviewed in detail (here and here). These are pretty well-designed studies, all by the same group of investigators, and as is common for studies of dietary supplements, they report mostly negative results but then focus on the few statistically significant findings, generally with subjective measures, to conclude the studies are proof of a benefit. The idea that fish oil supplements might have some small benefit for arthritis in dogs and cats is not out of the question, but so far the evidence is not encouraging.
3. Probiotics
Mark Crislip has eloquently addressed the theory and science of probiotics for humans, and the bottom line for pets appears to be much the same. We understand very little about the important and complex ecology of the gastrointestinal tract, about what bugs are there and what they do for or to us. So while the idea of influencing this flora to restore or maintain health makes some sense, adding a few Lactobacillus to the mix and expecting it to have a major effect seems a bit like tossing a few grass seeds into the Amazon rain forest and expecting a golf course to grow there (thanks Mark!). 
Clinical studies in humans support some benefits for some conditions, particularly antibiotic-associated diarrhea, but many of the claims made for probiotic products, especially for health maintenance or “boosting the immune system” are unsupported. There is less research on probiotics for dogs and cats, but there are some encouraging studies which show a likely benefit of some products for acute idiopathic diarrhea in dogs (e.g. here and here, analyzed in detail here). There are also serious problems with the quality control of largely unregulated veterinary probiotics. A recent study found the majority of products tested had inaccurate labels, with many not containing the amount or species of organisms claimed on the label. There are also many products marketed with ridiculous and completely unsupported claims. 
So overall, the idea of probiotics as a therapy for gastrointestinal disease seems promising, and there are some early suggestions that some products may be useful for some conditions. But this optimism must be tempered by the very limited, preliminary understanding we have of gut ecology and how to manipulate it, the minimal reliable clinical trial evidence to support probiotic use, and the concerns about poor quality control and exaggerated, unscientific claims for probiotic products.
4. Multivitamins
Multivitamins are widely touted as a preventative health measure or as “insurance” for a nutritionally imperfect diet. As Harriet Hall has discussed previously, taking a multivitamin is more a form of self-administered psychotherapy than a preventative health practice. A 2006 review of the available evidence, as well as more recent studies, do not support claims of health benefits in humans from vitamin supplementation in the absence of confirmed deficiencies. And there are circumstances in which vitamin supplementation can be harmful (for example raising cancer risk, interfering with cancer therapy, or even increasing mortality). 
As usual, there is virtually no research on the subject in dogs and cats. Commercial pet diets are nutritionally balanced in a way that the rather haphazard eating habits of most humans is not, so there is even less reason to think a multivitamin would be necessary in dogs and cats eating such a diet. In fact, such supplementation could very well lead to excessive, even toxic levels of fat soluble vitamins or some minerals. Homemade and raw food pet diets, however, are more likely to be nutritionally inadequate, so multivitamin supplementation might be more appropriate when feeding such diets. However, the bottom line is there is no good quality epidemiological or experimental research to suggest that dietary deficiencies are common or that non-targeted vitamin supplementation of apparently healthy pets eating a balanced diet has any value. And there is some evidence that supplementation under certain circumstances can be harmful (for example, calcium in growing large-breed dogs). 
The lack of evidence may preclude a definitive statement that such supplements are unnecessary or harmful, but it also makes the confident, sweeping claims of supplement marketers entirely unjustified. 
5. Lysine
Lysine is an amino acid which is hypothesized to be useful in the prevention and treatment of Feline Herpesvirus (FHV-1) infections. This virus is extremely common, and many cats will be exposed and become infected as kittens. Clinical symptoms include sneezing, nasal congestion, and conjunctivitis, and they range from mild and self-limiting to very severe. Most cats will get over the initial infection, but many remain chronically infected. With suppression of immune function from stress, medication, or disease, the virus can re-emerge and cause symptoms again. A small subset of cats may develop chronic, ongoing symptoms associated with this infection. Vaccination reduces the severity of symptoms but does not prevent infection. 
Lysine is proposed to interfere with the replication of FHV-1 by blocking the uptake of another amino acid, arginine. There are theoretical concerns that lysine supplementation could make cats arginine deficient, but experimental studies suggest this is unlikely in practice. So it appears to be safe, but does it work?
Well, maybe. For once, numerous studies have been done, but there is no clear, consistent pattern of results. Some show that oral supplementation is ineffective and might even make infection worse (Drazenovich, 2009; Rees, 2008; Maggs, 2007). Others do seem to demonstrate some benefit (Maggs, 2003; Stiles, 2002). So while lysine supplementation appears to be safe and there is a plausible rationale for its use, no definitive conclusion about its efficacy is justified.
6. Milk Thistle
Milk thistle is an herbal product that is widely recommended and used. Like glucosamine, it is a supplement which has leapt over the gap between alternative and conventional medicine. The active ingredient is a cluster of compounds called silymarin. There has been extensive in vitro research on silymarin, and it has a wide range of potentially useful effects. It appears to interfere with pro-inflammatory chemicals, functions as an anti-oxidant, and may interfere with the metabolism of some chemicals into toxic compounds in the liver. It also has some activity which could be potentially harmful, including interfering with the metabolism of a number of drugs and stimulating the effects of hormones like estrogen.
The primary uses of silymarin in humans are to protect or treat liver damage from toxins and infectious diseases, to improve the condition of diabetics, and to protect the kidneys from toxins. In dogs and cats the primary use of for non-specific “support” of the liver regardless of the specific disease. 
In humans, clinical trial evidence is mixed. A couple of studies have suggested it reduces insulin resistance in diabetic and may lower blood lipid levels. A Cochrane review of 13 studies including 915 people “could not demonstrate significant effects of milk thistle on mortality or complications of liver disease in patients with alcoholic and/or hepatitis B or C liver disease.” High quality trials were negative, and low quality trials suggested a benefit. 
Very little research exists in dogs and cats. A small study of 20 cats given acetaminophen, a known liver toxin, found that those given a single oral dose of silymarin did not show the elevation of liver enzyme levels seen in those not given the compound. A similar study in dogs found some differences in elevations of kidney values between those that got silymarin and those that didn’t following exposure to a kidney toxin, though there was not a completely consistent pattern.
A study done in 1978 showed that dogs given a toxic mushroom compound orally and then given silymarin intravenously did not show the increase in liver enzymes that was seen in control dogs. Another in 1984 found that 30% of the control dogs died whereas none of the dogs given IV silymarin along with the mushroom toxin died, and the livers from the treated dogs did not appear damaged by the toxin. What relevance this has for the value of oral supplementation isn’t clear.
As far as risks, there appear to be few. Nausea, diarrhea, and other gastrointestinal effects are sometimes seen in humans and animals, and allergic reactions have been reported in humans.
So overall, the in vitro and laboratory animal evidence indicates it is plausible that milk thistle extract might have beneficial effects, though harmful effects in some situations could be possible as well. In humans, the clinical trials show weak evidence for benefit in some conditions and no evidence of benefit in others. Very little experimental, and apparently no high quality or controlled clinical research exists in dogs and cats. So once again, harm seems unlikely and a benefit is possible for some dose and some form of silymarin in some conditions, but we lack the information to use the compound rationally or to know for certain if it is even useful in most cases.
7. S-adenosyl methionine (SAM-e)
SAM-e is a chemical which occurs throughout the body and has a fascinating array of in vivo functions and in vitro effects. In humans, it is marketed for use in depression and arthritis, and a variety of other conditions. The clinical trial evidence is mixed and not generally high quality (for example, Cochrane Reviews for arthritis and alcoholic liver disease, Mayo Clinic summary for various conditions). 
In pets it is primarily promoted as protecting the liver from damage due to disease of toxins, often in combination with Milk Thistle, though its use for arthritis and other conditions is also sometimes recommended. While the theoretical arguments for these uses, especially in the case of liver disease, are plausible, there is virtually no clinical research that the compound actually benefits patients when given as an oral supplement. There is one study which found no significant benefit in preventing liver changes associated with steroid use, one case report claiming some possible benefit in a dog with acetaminophen toxicosis, and one clinical study that suggest some possible value in treating age-related cognitive dysfunction in dogs. And despite how widely used this supplement is, and how sweeping the claims made for it often are, that’s about it.
8. Digestive Enzymes
The claims made for digestive enzyme supplements are often sweeping and dramatic, and they can make you wonder how anyone ever digests their food without them. The usual arguments are that these enzymes exist in raw foods but are destroyed in the production of commercial pet foods, so if you are so foolish as to feed a nutritionally balanced commercial diet, you’d better give your pet these supplements, or else! These exaggerated, unsupported, sometimes outright mythical claims for raw food diets in humans and dogs have been discussed here before. They are based on fundamental misconceptions about digestive physiology and nutrition, and they hold no water.
Healthy humans and dogs have all the enzymes they need to effectively digest foods. The organs that produce such enzymes do not become stressed or fatigued by doing what is, after all, their normal function. Commercial diets and their constituent ingredients are extensively tested for digestibility, and there is no evidence that any deficiency of enzymes in these foods creates nutritional deficiencies or any specific health problem. 
In addition to use in healthy individuals, enzymes are also recommended for cancer treatment, anti-inflammatory effects, and treatment of many other disease conditions. Though the occasional study is published to support these recommendations, often in “integrative medicine” journals, there is no consistent, high-quality clinical evidence in humans that digestive enzymes are effective therapy for any condition other than true pancreatic enzyme deficiency. And there is evidence that this approach may be ineffective or even harmful. 
There is, surprise surprise, no clinical research at all on the subject in cats and dogs. Apart from pancreatic insufficiency, in which enzyme supplementation is often effective, the claims made for the use of enzyme supplements are based solely on anecdote, theory, or extrapolation from in vitro research. 
9. Coenzyme Q10
Like most dietary supplements, coenzyme Q10, also known as ubiquinone, is recommended for a wide range of apparently unrelated conditions. It is recommended in humans for cardiovascular disease, Alzheimer’s disease, migraines, diabetes, and many others, as well as a general tonic and, of course, the inevitable “boosting” of the immune system. In dogs and cats it has primarily been recommended for treatment or prevention of heart disease and age-related cognitive dysfunction. 
There is controversy about many of the recommended uses in humans, with mixed and generally low-quality clinical trial evidence for most uses. And, as you will no doubt have anticipated by now, there is virtually no reliable research on its use in pets. One small experimental study failed to find evidence of decreased Coenzyme Q10 levels in dogs with congestive heart failure. There appear to be no clinical trials for any specific indication, and the recommendations for this supplement are again based entirely on theory, anecdote, and pre-clinical research or clinical research conducted in humans.
10. Azodyl
Azodyl is a proprietary mixture of probiotic organisms and prebiotics (substances intended to promote the growth of supposedly beneficial gastrointestinal bacteria) that is marketed for the treatment of kidney failure in dogs and cats. The theoretical argument advanced to support its use is “enteric dialysis,” the idea that populating the gastrointestinal tract with bacteria that breakdown some of the nitrogenous wastes the kidneys normally remove from the body can lower the levels of these substances and improve clinical symptoms of renal failure. While this idea is not inherently unreasonable, it does suffer from the weakness of other probiotic therapies in that it requires relatively small additional to the gastrointestinal flora to have significant systemic physiologic effects, which may or may not actually be possible. In any case, it is not a concept that has been validated in practice.
A single pilot clinical trial of the product in humans, sponsored by the manufacturer, has been published. This identified statistically significant changes in one out of three laboratory measures and in a subjective assessment of clinical symptoms. An unblinded, uncontrolled case series in 7 cats reported small changes in laboratory values in 6 of the subjects. And similar small studies in vitro and in rats and miniature pigs, again all supported by the manufacturer, have reported some positive changes in some measures of kidney disease.
Overall, the theory is possible but of uncertain plausibility in the real world, and the clinical evidence is limited and highly vulnerable to bias in terms of methods and funding source.
Bottom Line
So to answer the original question, do these popular supplements work? Well, glucosamine almost certainly does not, and the case for multivitamins and digestive enzymes are extremely weak. Fish oil likely does have small benefit for allergies, and no definitive conclusion can be made concerning arthritis, though the early veterinary trials haven’t been promising. Probiotics are a promising avenue for research, and there is reasonable evidence for some benefit in acute idiopathic diarrhea, but overall they are really not ready for prime time. Lysine, SAM-e, Milk Thistle, and Coenzyme Q10 all have reasonable theoretical foundations based on preclinical research, and none have adequate clinical evidence to draw any firm conclusions.
So should veterinarians and pet owners use these products? The decision whether or not to employ a particular medical intervention is always a matter of balancing the urgency of acting with the risks and benefits of the therapy, and always in the context of the limitations on the available information. In cases where the therapy is very unlikely to provide a benefit, such as glucosamine, there is really no rational argument for its use even if it is harmless, and the resources wasted on such treatments could better be spent on more plausible therapies or research to find better treatments.
In cases where there is a plausible theoretical rationale but inadequate clinical evidence to make a firm conclusion, I am personally reluctant to recommend using such supplements because in the face of such uncertainty we are as likely to do harm as good. For example, Milk Thistle and the combination SAM-e and Milk Thistle products seem to induce loss of appetite in cats and dogs fairly frequently in my experience, and they are usually given to patients who are pretty sick and already taking many other medications. So in the absence of stronger evidence of benefit it seems imprudent to use them routinely. However, in urgent cases where there is no validated therapy and the clinical circumstances are dire, I can’t fault anyone for grasping at straws, and I have certainly done so myself. 
And, of course, if there is a sound theoretical rational and some reasonable clinical evidence, as in the case of fish oils for allergies and probiotics for acute uncomplicated diarrhea, use of such supplements seems perfectly reasonable. We must be careful not to let the perfect become the enemy of the good, and in veterinary medicine where the quantity and quality of the research evidence will always be less than optimal, we are justified in trying out things that are reasonable but unproven if the clinical circumstances warrant it. 
Of course, the marketing used to promote these supplements goes well beyond anything justified by real scientific evidence and is almost universally untrustworthy. Likewise, the testimonials and anecdotes about their effects, whether from patients, pet owners, veterinarians, or Nobel Laureates, are all just stories with almost no probative value. And since most good ideas in medicine ultimately fail to become real, effective clinical therapies, it is likely that many even of the more plausible of these products will turn out not to be useful or to have unknown risks. Without adequate supporting evidence and without effective quality control, regulation, and post-market surveillance, we can never be sure we are helping and not harming our patients by using them. 
However, it is also possible that some of these products will survive the rigors of real scientific investigation, if they are ever subjected to them, and will turn out to be truly useful therapies. And in the meantime, it may be reasonable to use some of them if the existing evidence and clinical need of the particular case are sufficient to justify doing so.

Science-Based Satire: Portland Compounding Pharmacy Introduces Line of Bespoke Artisinal Parenteral Nutrition
Are compounding pharmacies working with naturopathic integrative functional medicine doctors to make bespoke artisanal IV nutrition that looks like soup in a mason jar? No. Stop it. You know this isn’t true. It’s satire.
Clay Jones on February 19, 2021
Link
Portland, OR – Peach & Barrow, a Portland based compounding pharmacy that opened in 2015, has recently begun marketing a line of small-batch artisanal intravenous nutrition products for use by high-end clinics catering to clients looking for a more natural experience.

Whether prescribed to help support a healthy diet or even as a complete replacement for oral intake, nutrition administered to a patient through a vein rather than their own mouth hole has been used to improve patient health for decades. Dr. Mort Fishman, a naturopathic functional medicine physician and certified integrative nutritionist at Nature’s Miracle Family Clinic in Portland who often prescribes Peach & Barrow compounded IV nutrition for his patients, has been prescribing IV meal replacements for as long as he can remember. “Some patients can’t use their mouths, or their guts don’t work right for some reason. I’ve literally read about lives being saved by this stuff.”
For years, the healthcare consumer has been forced to rely on parenteral nutrition made in an assembly line fashion without any respect for the process,” Peach & Barrow owner Jasper Online Name Generator Wilson explained. “We locally source all of the constituents of our handcrafted products, from the trace elements to the lipids and amino acids. And all of our batches of bespoke parenteral nutrition contain honey-based dextrose obtained from bees that worked with us voluntarily.”
At Peach & Barrow, no two parenteral nutrition solutions are the same, with each recipe being tailored to the individual patient with guidance from their doctor. But there is also an art to the process, and it is more about intuition and respect for nature than the use of any pharmacy textbook. Recipes largely depend on the season and also what is currently popular. According to Wilson, each morning his pharmacy technicians scout out the local farmers’ markets and scour social media sites like Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook for pictures of what people are eating and inspirational David “Avocado” Wolfe quotes. “And each of our IV nutrition blends comes in a mason jar that was hand blown from rare sea glass.”
Total parenteral nonsense?
Parenteral nutrition, whether used along with enteral (the gut) nutrition or as the only source, is an extremely valuable tool that has saved the lives of countless patients. I have prescribed it countless times for hospitalized children over the years, particularly for premature babies who sometimes require weeks of growth and development before they can tolerate a full diet using their gut. There are also a lot of people of all ages at home who require IV nutrition, which is where compounding pharmacies come into play.
Essentially, if you can’t eat or can’t digest for more than a few days you would likely benefit from IV nutrition. But IV nutrition is tricky. Our bodies just were not designed to thrive on the stuff. And though in many cases the benefits outweigh the risks, there are some pretty serious potential complications associated with long-term use.
There are also serious risks associated with short-term use. It has taken decades to determine the best way to make and administer parenteral nutrition and it is extremely important for it to be done right in order to avoid electrolyte disturbances, liver injury, infections, etc. In the hospital, when a patient is stared on IV nutrition we check labs daily and carefully adjust the “recipe” until stability is achieved. I’m simplifying this process a lot but that’s okay because TPN isn’t really what I was worried about when writing this bit of satire, it was compounding pharmacies and their sometimes unholy alliance with practitioners of irregular medicine (and sometimes political administrations).
In 2018, Harriet Hall wrote about the elephant in the room when it comes to compounding pharmacies:
The elephant in the room is the fact that compounding pharmacies are often used injudiciously by naturopaths, “integrative medicine” doctors, “functional medicine” doctors, and other providers who prescribe treatments that are not supported by credible evidence and that often involve risky IV administration. The elephant is that many of those using compounding pharmacies are guided by speculation and belief rather than by acceptable scientific evidence. They are endangering their patients because they fail to understand that science is the only reliable guide to safe and effective treatments.
We need compounding pharmacies. They do things such as making parenteral nutrition for home use. They help me out sometimes by turning a medicine that only comes in pill form into a suspension so that a child can take it. Sometimes we have to accept some increased risk in order to gain the more significant benefits. But as Dr. Hall explained, there are many instances where there are no potential benefits, such as when people were killed by compounded IV turmeric in 2017.
In 2012, a number of people were killed by contaminated steroid medication mass produced by a Massachusetts compounding pharmacy. This resulted in some increased protections at the federal level, mostly geared towards the safety of medications compounded in bulk. But the Drug Quality and Security Act of 2013 clearly does not do enough to protect patients.

Science-Based Satire: A New Fad Diet Has Farmers and Doctors Baffled
Are people crawling around farms eating directly from the plants or using their mouths to dig up root vegetables in order to better absorb the life sustaining essence of their food? No, and frankly I’m surprised at you for even considering the possibility. This is satire. But there are a lot of people out there partaking in some rather silly diet fads.
Clay Jones on January 6, 2023
Link

Sacramento, CA – When Central Valley farmer Jim Jabernathy walks through his fields every morning, he expects to find the occasional mouse or even a corn possum or two. But these days he is more likely to find something that he considers to be an even greater pest: people. Calling themselves “connected eaters”, these proponents of the latest fad diet are growing in number and leaving farmers like Jabernathy no choice but to take drastic measures.

“I thought I’d seen it all from folks around here,” Jabernathy explained. “I’ve seen a lot of fad diets in my time, from paleo to those people who don’t eat anything made with chemical bonds. Heck, my daughter even started strafing last year. But this beats all. Just yesterday I done ran off about thirty of ’em from my best kale patch. They were like locusts!”
What is connected eating? And why are farmers installing razor wire fences and training perimeter defense badgers? Proponents are quick to point out that eating connected food has numerous health benefits, but are they worth the risk? Proponents think so. But why? And how? What?
Connected eating involves the consumption of unharvested food that is still attached to the so-called “mother plant”. Believers say that simply eating unprocessed or even raw whole foods isn’t enough. They want to experience the severing of the food’s connection to it’s life source, and to absorb its essence as well as its nutritional content. Some proponents liken the experience to Earthing, the science of connecting to the Earth’s natural energy in order to achieve vibrant and long lasting true health.
Dietary folklorist Allen Levitzky, author of Food Tribes: How What We Eat Defines Who We Are and What the Future Will Be, is an expert in fad diets and irrational appeals to nature as a guide for human behavior. He sees connected eating as an example of evolution in mankind’s dietary journey, but cautions that many branches in the evolutionary development of social behaviors, just as with physical changes in an animal species over long periods of time, end up being dead ends. “The belief that nature holds the key to health and longevity has been around since the first caveman looked at the world around him, not with fear but with curiosity…and hunger. Oooh, I like that. Use that one.”
Farmers aren’t the only ones that are concerned about the connected eating trend. Medical experts, like Sacramento interventional culinologist Mort Fishman, warns that the risk of foodborne illness may be increased and that failing to at least rinse connected food prior to eating it could result in exposure to toxic pesticides. “I tell my patients who are determined to eat connected food to limit meals to right after a hard rain.”

Despite the risks, connected eating has continued to increase in popularity, especially after a recent viral TikTok video showing Jenna Ortega pulling radishes from the ground with her bare teeth while in her costume from The Wednesday Chronicles. Farmer Jabernathy, who prefers his food good and dead, doesn’t mince words when it comes to the new trend. “I drive through a lot of farmland, and every week I see more of them crawling around on their hands and knees, covered in dirt and partially chewed spinach like animals. Just like a herd of mindless animals.”
A mouthful of reality?
Obviously this is nonsense, but there really are some wacky diet fads out there based on magical thinking rather than established science. There are a lot of absurd beliefs regarding energies and essences as well, and “connected eating” combines all of that into something that probably could/will be a thing at some point in the future. It’s not all that different from the “magnetic diet” for example:
The magnetic diet consists of such food substitutes as rays and oxygen, which can be easily assimilated and converted into energy by the latent life forces in the body. Magnetic foods give energy more quickly than solids and liquids, which are less easily converted into life force
Connected eaters would likely boast about how effective it is as a way to lose weight. Of course, this would boil down to difficulty consuming a lot of calories eating this way plus the increased caloric burn that comes from all that bobbing for beets in the Sacramento soil. All diets, even this one, are more about math than magic when it comes to weight loss.
Now that I think about it, if someone ate enough connected food to maintain a healthy weight, it would essentially just be a nice way to experience nature and eat mostly plants. I don’t want to think about how one would incorporate animal products into this diet, however. Regardless, I think I need to talk to a good lawyer and get this intellectual property locked down before Mark Hyman gets a hold of it.
Happy New Year everybody!

Science-Based Satire: Experts are Warning Parents About a New and Highly Potent Synthetic Sugar
Is there an epidemic of extremely potent synthetic sugar sweeping the nation and putting our children, and first responders, at risk of hyperactivity and ruined dinners? No, there isn’t. At least not yet. This is satire. Some people are getting pretty ridiculous when it comes to fentanyl though.
Clay Jones on October 14, 2022
Link

Atlanta, GA – Experts from the Centers for Disease Control in Atlanta are warning parents about a new and highly potent form of synthetic sugar that is flooding playgrounds and birthday parties, and even finding its way into home pantries across the United States.

“Fentanose is many thousands of times more potent than simple sugars like glucose, galactose, and even fructose,” CDC director Rochelle Walensky explained. “Unsuspecting children are being exposed when parents decide to save money by buying cheap but unregulated generic candy from Mexico or China that has been laced with the powerful substance. And some children may come into contact with fentanose when purchasing homemade candy from neighborhood dealers.”
The CDC isn’t alone in recognizing the dangers of fentanose. Pediatric pharmacokinesiologist Mort Fishman has been researching the effects of the synthetic sugar for years. “Very small amounts of candy or baked goods containing fentanose, only the size of a standard Sour Patch Kid, two to three Skittles, or just a small slice of Scooter pie, can cause extreme behavioral changes such as hyperactivity, euphoria, and even stage 3 giddiness.”
Representatives from law enforcement agencies across the country are joining the CDC in an attempt to educate parents, caregivers, and teachers on the dangers of incidental exposure to fentanose. As part of a public service announcement, San Diego County Sheriff Bill Gore recently released bodycam video of a deputy suffering a fentanose overdose after responding to a disturbance at an area above ground pool birthday party. “In this case, the officer did not consume any of the tainted cupcakes, though he was offered one which was very nice of Mrs. Johnson. All it takes, however, is contact to the skin or being in the same general area as the substance. This stuff is terrifying and we feel threatened by it.”

In the video, the officer can be seen politely turning down an offered cupcake and then complimenting Mrs. Johnson on her home. Just as he is beginning to inform her of a neighbor’s noise complaint, he becomes visibly excited, hopping up and down as he focuses his attention on the Johnson’s backyard trampoline and then runs towards it while laughing and wildly flailing his arms. After five full minutes on the trampoline, the officer can be seen refusing to let Timmy C. have a turn, after which he has to be carried away by two dads. In the final moments of the edited footage, the officer is seen crying after Mrs. Johnson says it’s time to open presents and takes the XBOX controller away from him.
As Halloween looms ominously around the corner, politicians and pediatric safety experts are raising concerns that fentanose dealers might take advantage of the holiday to give out free samples. The Commission on Safety for Kids (CSK), a Republican effort to ensure that children aren’t exposed to anything dangerous until after the midterms, is asking for parents to be wary of any loose candy or baked goods handed out in homemade bags. According to CSK spokesperson Cassie Frumph, it only takes exposure to one unsafe or thought provoking “trick or treat” for a child to die or to ask their parents uncomfortable questions. “Halloween is about having fun and fatal car accidents, not exposure to deadly poisons or new ideas.”
The CSK has released a list of items for parents to watch for on October 31st, particularly when inspecting their child’s Halloween haul:
1. Loose candy
2. Homemade baked goods
3. Rainbow fentanyl
4. Woke
5. Puberty blockers
6. Drag queens reading books
7. Gay dads
8. Wind turbines
9. Critical race theory
10. Black people voting
The sweet truth
Obviously this is based on the ongoing absurdity involving people overdosing on fentanyl by just touching it, or even just being in the same room as it, as well as the more recent nonsense about rainbow fentanyl. These myths aren’t based on good science, a firm grasp of history, or even basic common sense. Rather these claims are often political in nature and are potentially harmful distractions.
The recent uproar over fentanyl on our playgrounds and in our children’s plastic Halloween pumpkins is meant to scare people into voting a certain way by promoting fears of “open borders” and incompetent government officials, or to justify calls for more funding. Colored fentanyl pills aren’t new, and they aren’t designed to target young children. They will not be handed out at Halloween to unsuspecting children by dealers who want a customer for life or deranged monsters looking to harm strangers.
Children are much more likely to be killed by a car on Halloween, which is the issue that politicians and pediatric health experts should be focused on. If statistics hold, as they have for many years, there will be around 100 fatal Halloween car accidents in America this year. So parents do not need to inspect their child’s candy for drugs, needles, or anything else. They do need to take some effort to reduce the risk of their child getting hit by a car.
Like cops who think they touched fentanyl, the reaction that children have when exposed to sugar comes down to environmental and psychological factors rather than pharmacological. I mean, who wouldn’t get excited at Timmy J.’s above ground pool party? But I do recommend keeping tabs on how much a child eat at one time in order to avoid any sick tummies. Oh, and don’t forget about brushing those little teeth. You too, you candy-loving fiends.

   Law and Regulation

Can Medical Schools Really Teach 71 Nutrition ‘Competencies’?  Should They?
Henry Miller on May 12, 2026
Link

In recent years, nutrition has become the focus of renewed attention in medical education. Advocates argue that physicians receive too little formal training about diet and that more comprehensive nutrition education is needed to address chronic diseases such as obesity, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and certain cancers. A greater focus on the “root causes of chronic diseases” is a mantra of the Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) movement.
That concern has now culminated in a proposal from the Department of Health and Human Services for “Comprehensive Nutrition Education Reforms.” Providing details for that proposal, the department issued the Medical Education Nutrition Competency Framework, which suggests 10 domains and 71 competencies intended to provide guidance for a curriculum for undergraduate medical school nutrition education that meets a 40-hour equivalent minimum and for “identifying gaps in covered topics.”
In announcing the framework at a press conference, HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. said that chronic disease “is overwhelming the country and it is accelerating. …Today, we spend $4.5 trillion a year on healthcare, and 90% of it goes to managing chronic disease, and poor nutrition is often at its core.” He did not present any evidence for those claims.
Easier Said Than Done
The goal — better equipping physicians to advise patients about diet — sounds reasonable, but it raises an important question: Is it realistic for medical schools to incorporate even a fraction of these competencies into already crowded curricula?
Medical education is famously dense. In four short years, students must absorb enormous bodies of knowledge ranging from molecular biology and pharmacology to pathology, clinical diagnosis, and the complexities of patient care. As I did in medical school, some students also spend some rotations doing research in the labs of faculty members. Every discipline, understandably and predictably, believes its subject deserves more time.
The nutrition competency framework illustrates the tension between worthwhile aspirations and practical realities.
The Proposed Framework
The framework organizes nutrition training into 10 domains, encompassing basic science, clinical care, counseling skills, public health, and health-system practice: Within those domains, advocates have proposed 71 specific “competencies” that medical students should be able to demonstrate:
     1.  Foundational Nutrition Knowledge (21 competencies, 48 hours)
     2.  Nutrition Assessment and Diagnosis (8 competencies, 27.5 hours)
     3.  Food and Nutrition-Related Communication Skills (9 competencies, 29.5 hours)
     4.  Collaborative, Interprofessional Referral and Patient Management (5 Competencies, 12.0 hours)
     5.  Public Health Nutrition (6 Competencies, 15.5 hours)
     6.  Experiential Hands-on Learning (Culinary Medicine) (5 Competencies,16.0 hours)
     7.  Medical Interventions in Combination with Lifestyle Practices (6 Competencies, 17.5 hours)
     8.  Personal Food & Lifestyle Behaviors for Health Care Professionals (4 Competencies, 6.0 hours
     9.  Food Systems and Environmental Impacts (6 Competencies, 16.5 hours)
     10.  Billing, Coding, and Reimbursement for Food and Nutrition Services (1 Competency, 3.0 hours)
Domain #9 – “Food Systems and Environmental Impacts” is totally irrelevant to medical students, dealing with such things as “understand[ing] relationship between soil microbiota diversity and mineral/nutrient content of foods” and “participat[ing] in on-site learning at farms including soil sampling, composting, crop rotation”.
Some of the competencies are ridiculously arcane, such as #17: “Epigenetic modulation through nutrition: comprehend how methyl donors, phytochemicals, and feeding rhythms influence gene expression.” Or irrelevant to medical students, such as #71: “Billing for nutrition services, culinary medicine consultations with RDNs.”
A Worthy Goal—But an Already-Overloaded Curriculum
On paper, most of these competencies seem entirely sensible. None of them is unreasonable in isolation (except, perhaps, domain #9 and competency #71, described in the previous section). Physicians should understand the role of nutrition in disease and should be able to counsel patients about diet. But the scale of the proposal is imposing. It reads more like the requirements for certification as a dietician than a minor aspect of training for an MD degree.
Seventy-one competencies — spread across subjects ranging from biochemistry to sustainability policy — represent a significant educational burden. Even if each competency required only modest instruction, the cumulative time required could be substantial. Consider that devoting only an hour of class time to each of the competencies would require 71 hours – about two weeks.
And consider that medical schools already face severe curricular constraints.
Over the past several decades, the volume of biomedical knowledge has expanded dramatically. Students must master genetics, molecular biology, immunology, advanced imaging technologies, complex pharmacology, and increasingly sophisticated diagnostic tools. New topics—from artificial intelligence in medicine to genomic medicine and health-system science—are continually being added.
Every new innovation and requirement competes with existing content. Medical educators often describe the curriculum as “a suitcase that is already overpacked.” Adding something new almost always requires removing or truncating something else.
Are the “Suggestions” Really “Suggestions”?
But the biggest flaw in the HHS prescription is the focus on “functional medicine” competencies for physicians under the guise of nutrition, which, as Kevin Klatt, PhD, RD, has observed, not only risks integrating pseudoscience into medicine but also distracts from real nutrition competencies. It has the distinctive stench of the influence of HHS Secretary RFK, Jr. and the Means grifter twins – Calley, a senior adviser to Kennedy who focuses on food, nutrition policy, and the “Make America Healthy Again” (MAHA) agenda; and Casey, President Trump’s famously unqualified nominee to be U.S. Surgeon General, whose nomination was just abandoned.
It is true that it might not be mandatory for every competency to be included in the curriculum. The federal directive to medical schools states:
After conducting an assessment of your current nutrition curriculum and identifying gaps in covered topics, we recommend schools choose from the competencies” to “design a curriculum for undergraduate medical school nutrition education that meets a 40-hour equivalent minimum.
However, “suggestions” or “proposals” from the federal government about university curricula raise concerns, given the recent history of the Trump administration using federal funding mechanisms as leverage against universities perceived to be politically or culturally oppositional. In several high-profile disputes, universities lost research grants or other federal support after conflicts over issues such as campus speech, diversity policies, or compliance with federal directives. Such punitive measures could be applied to medical schools, which receive more than $30 billion in federal research funding annually, if they did not conform sufficiently to the nutritional domains and competencies.
The Independent, May 1, 2026
Nutrition Is Already Embedded in Medical Education
Another problem with the framework is the implicit assumption that nutrition education is inadequate in current medical training. In reality, nutrition already permeates many aspects of medical education, although it may not appear as a separate course labeled “nutrition.”
Medical students encounter nutrition repeatedly during both their classroom and clinical training.
For example:
    • Biochemistry courses teach the metabolic pathways that govern carbohydrate, fat, and protein metabolism.
    • Physiology courses explain energy balance, hormonal regulation of appetite, and nutrient absorption.
    • Pathology and internal medicine address diseases in which diet plays a critical role—diabetes, cardiovascular disease, kidney disease, liver disease, and many others.
    • Clinical rotations frequently involve dietary management as part of care of patients with cardiac, endocrinological, genetic, and other diseases.
In hospitals, students also observe and interact with dietitians participating in patient rounds, especially for patients with complex metabolic or nutritional problems. These professionals often provide detailed dietary assessments and recommendations. I found them to be especially valuable, both as a medical student and as an intern and resident.
For patients with specific medical conditions, dietary management is often central to treatment. Examples include:
    • sodium restriction in heart failure
    • carbohydrate management in diabetes
    • low-protein diets in certain kidney diseases
    • gluten-free diets for celiac disease
    • food allergies
    • specialized feeding regimens for premature infants
In such contexts, medical students see firsthand how nutrition becomes integrated into clinical decision-making. An additional educational experience for me occurred during my rotations at a VA hospital: Meals were delivered to the wards even when patients weren’t able to eat them because of an impending procedure, such as a colonoscopy or surgery, so I’d consume the food. (I found “clear liquid,” “full liquid,” “pureed,” “no added salt,” and “kidney disease” diets to be pretty unpalatable, while “high protein” and “high calorie” were pretty good!)
Learning Through Clinical Context
Medical education has long recognized that students learn most effectively when knowledge is connected to real clinical problems. Nutrition is particularly well-suited to this approach.
Consider a student caring for a patient with newly diagnosed diabetes. The management plan naturally includes dietary counseling, glucose monitoring, and lifestyle changes. A dietitian may join the clinical team to explain carbohydrate counting and meal planning.
In this setting, the student learns nutrition in the context of a disease that requires it—an approach that favors retention more than memorizing isolated competencies.
Similarly, during a gastroenterology rotation, a student might encounter patients with inflammatory bowel disease, malabsorption syndromes, or short-bowel syndrome. Each condition involves distinctive nutritional considerations.
These experiences already teach many of the competencies listed in the framework.
The Risk of Competency Inflation
The nutrition competency proposal reflects a broader trend in modern education: the proliferation of competency frameworks.
Competency-based education can be valuable when it emphasizes essential skills. But frameworks can also expand endlessly as advocates add more goals and sub-goals.
In some cases, the result is a long checklist of aspirations rather than a realistic curriculum. Seventy-one “core nutrition” competencies risk becoming exactly that.
Moreover, some competencies in the framework extend well beyond clinical nutrition into areas such as food systems, sustainability, and public policy. These topics may be intellectually interesting (to some), but their relevance to day-to-day medical practice varies.
Medical students must above all become competent clinicians. Time spent on peripheral topics inevitably displaces training in core medical knowledge.
The Importance of Collaboration
Another reason the framework may be overly ambitious is that physicians do not practice nutrition care in isolation. Modern medicine relies heavily on multidisciplinary teams. Dieticians, nurses, and other specialists possess extensive training and experience in nutritional science and counseling. In many cases, they are better equipped than physicians to provide detailed dietary guidance, and AI has become an increasingly useful adjunct.
The physician’s role is often to identify when nutrition is relevant and involve the appropriate specialists.
Several competencies in the framework acknowledge this reality by emphasizing collaboration with dietitians. But if collaboration is central to effective care, then expecting physicians to master an exhaustive list of nutrition competencies is, arguably, unnecessary.
A More Practical Approach
None of this means that nutrition education should be neglected. Physicians should certainly understand basic nutritional principles and should be able to recognize when diet plays a role in disease and its treatment. But rather than attempting to teach dozens of discrete competencies, medical education might focus on a smaller number of core concepts, reinforced through clinical experience.
For example:
    • understanding the basic physiology of metabolism
    • recognizing the role of diet in major chronic diseases
    • querying AI for information and suggestions about patients’ diseases
    • knowing when to refer patients for specialized nutritional counseling
    • communicating clearly with patients about diet and lifestyle
These goals can be achieved through existing courses and clinical rotations without dramatically expanding the curriculum.
The Real Challenge: A Sensible Balance
The nutrition competency framework highlights an important issue: The role of diet in health is substantial, and physicians should not ignore it. But the proposed list of 71 competencies illustrates the risk of trying to solve every supposed educational shortcoming by piling on more requirements.
As discussed above, medical students already encounter nutrition in numerous contexts—from biochemistry lectures to hospital rounds with dietitians—and, as in my case, by consuming the various kinds of customized meals prepared for hospitalized patients. These experiences provide a practical understanding of how diet influences health.
The challenge is not necessarily a lack of nutrition course content but rather ensuring that students appreciate its clinical relevance. Achieving that goal does not require an encyclopedic checklist of competencies. Instead, it must integrate nutrition thoughtfully into the broader fabric of medical education.
In the end, the most effective nutrition training may come not from endlessly expanding the curriculum, but from teaching students how to recognize when nutrition matters—and how to work with experts who specialize in it.

Why Did the FDA Ban Red Dye #3
Steven Novella on January 22, 2025
Link

The FDA recently removed FD&C Red No. 3 from the list of approved food additives. This was not based on any new data or interpretation of the data, but rather was a response to a petition from food safety and environmental groups. Their argument was in turn based on the Delaney Clause, a 1960 law saying that the FDA must ban any food dyes that have been shown to cause cancer in humans or animals.
While removing a food coloring from the food supply is hardly a hill worth dying on, the underlying principles here are extremely important. Food and drug regulations are extremely complicated, and there is no one obvious optimal way to determine if a food additive is safe for humans and in what dose. Some decisions are easy, because a potential additive has clear toxicity at one end of the spectrum or no signs of toxicity at the other. But many foods and additives are somewhere in between these extremes, with conflicting and complex scientific data. Let’s take a look at the evidence for Red No. 3 to illustrate.
The petition reviewed much of the published evidence on Red No. 3 but focused on two studies in rats that showed an increased incidence of cancer. This is because the petition was specifically asking the FDA to determine if these studies trigger the Delaney Clause.
There is a deeper political issue here as well that I will not get into, but just point out. The recent Supreme Court decision ending Chevron Deference may have played a role here. The question is – who interprets federal regulations? The Chevron Deference standard says that the experts working in the relevant agency would be given deference when interpreting the law. For example, the FDA could determine how to apply the Delaney Clause based upon an expert level understanding of the complexities of toxicity research. The SC ended such deference, meaning that regulations can be interpreted by the courts without deference to experts. One has to wonder if this otherwise odd decision by the FDA was a response to this.
Let’s get back to those rat studies. These came from the “Certified Color Manufacturers’ Association (CCMA) initiated studies on FD&C Red No.3 including chronic toxicity and carcinogenicity studies in rats and mice.” In these studies the rats were fed “4% FD&C Red No.3 in the diet (2464 mg/kg/day) during life-time (30 months) following in utero exposure.” To put this exposure level in context, the Acceptable Daily Intake (ADI) for Red No. 3 based on studies in humans was set at 0.1 mg/kg/day. So the rats were fed 24,640 times as much Red No. 3 as the ADI in humans, throughout their entire lives, following in utero exposure.
Further, the hormonal mechanism by which there was an increase in thyroid cancer in these rats does not exist in humans. The evidence shows there is no mutagenicity in humans. This is why the FDA approved Red No. 3 in the first place, as have many other countries.
This is where, I think, the Chevron Deference issue comes into play. The Delaney Clause says that the FDA should bad food dyes shown to cause cancer in animals – but as experts they can interpret this to mean that the animal data is relevant to humans. But now they are facing a petition based upon a simplistic interpretation of the law without the Chevron Deference to back them up, so they caved.
The FDA announcement is dripping, in my perception, with passive aggressiveness in response to this situation. They state:
“The petition requested the agency review whether the Delaney Clause applied and cited, among other data and information, two studies that showed cancer in laboratory male rats exposed to high levels of FD&C Red No. 3 due to a rat specific hormonal mechanism. The way that FD&C Red No. 3 causes cancer in male rats does not occur in humans. Relevant exposure levels to FD&C Red No. 3 for humans are typically much lower than those that cause the effects shown in male rats. Studies in other animals and in humans did not show these effects; claims that the use of FD&C Red No. 3 in food and in ingested drugs puts people at risk are not supported by the available scientific information. “
They are basically saying, we are banning Red No. 3 despite the fact that the science says it is safe at the approved level of exposure. They point out later that Red No. 3 is not widely used in food so higher levels of exposure are unlikely.
This is a horrible precedent.
There are many technical issues here that I have discussed previously in SBM. There is a difference, for example, between hazard and risk. Hazard means there is a potential mechanism of harm, while risk is the chance of actual harm occurring at exposure levels. The FDA generally uses a risk assessment when determining approval.
Further, much toxicity research is designed to probe for possible hazard, and not determine risk. Rats are given ridiculous doses of substances to see if there is any potential mechanism of harm. This is more useful when the studies are negative – we can say that even at extremely high exposures there is no apparent negative effect. But when there is a negative effect, that does not determine that there is a risk for humans (that kind of research was never meant to determine that), but rather scientists now have a potential mechanism to further research. This further research can include whether or not the mechanism is relevant in humans.
This decision on Red No. 3 turns the relationship between toxicity research and regulations on its head. If Red No. 3 can be banned based upon exposure levels 24 thousand times greater than the highest allowed human exposure, and a mechanism that is relevant in rats but not in humans, then you can get almost anything banned.
Further, many of the groups in the petition are known to have a history of chemophobia and questionable use of science in the name of advocacy. We have handed a flame thrower to cranks and charlatans who can now burn down the regulatory order.
Food regulations are critically important for the safety of Americans, and we need an agency with the authority and expertise to apply the best and most up-to-date science to ensure the safety of our food supply. In this endeavor science should dominate over politics and ideology, but that is clearly not the world we are currently living in.

Food fights in the courtroom
Jann Bellamy on July 24, 2014
Link
What’s in a name? Will sugar by any other name taste as sweet? Well, yes, but calling sugar “evaporated cane juice” in an ingredient list may get food manufacturers into trouble. Consumers in several class action suits allege that companies are trying to disguise the amount of sugar in their products by calling it something else.
Robin Reese filed a class action suit against Odwalla, a subsidiary of Coca-Cola, saying use of the term “evaporated cane juice” instead of sugar fooled her into thinking she was getting a healthier product when she purchased Odwalla juice. Odwalla told the judge the suit should be dismissed because it’s up to the FDA to decide the issue. The FDA issued draft guidelines, in 2009, taking the position that the term “evaporated cane juice” should not be used because it’s not a “juice” as defined in the Federal Regulations. For unknown reasons, no final guidelines were issued and food companies seem to be honoring the draft guidance more in the breach. The FDA reopened the draft guidelines for comment in March of this year, for 3 months, but still hasn’t decided. Meanwhile, similar class actions against other companies were dismissed or stayed pending the FDA’s making up its mind.
So what’s the difference, if any, between the two? Sugar company Florida Crystals told NPR the two are not the same and that evaporated cane juice is a “natural sweetener with ‘dark golden hues’ and a ‘sweet sugarcane flavor.’” Competitor U.S. Sugar begged to differ. Its rep said they are basically the same thing: “white sugar is stripped of all traces of molasses, while evaporated cane juice still has some little flecks of molasses that give it a darker caramel color.” According to this rep, from a health standpoint, there’s no real difference.
While Odwalla and other food companies may be trying to run from the word “sugar,” makers of high fructose corn syrup should be so lucky. The Corn Refiners Association asked the FDA to allow use of the term “corn sugar” instead of “high fructose corn syrup,” which, in some circles, is the equivalent of saying “poison” on the label. The FDA said no.
It’s only natural. Or not.
“Evaporated cane juice” is small potatoes compared to the food fights over “natural” ingredients. The biggest problem here is that no one really knows what” natural” means, even though it is ubiquitous in food product labeling and advertising.
The whole issue aggravates synthetic biologist Terry Johnson:
“Natural” is a word that has been used in so many contexts with so many different meanings that it’s become almost impossible to parse. Its most basic usage, to distinguish phenomena that exist only because of humankind from phenomena that don’t, presumes that humans are somehow separate from nature, and our works are un- or non-natural when compared to, say, beavers or honeybees.
When speaking of food, “natural” is even slipperier. It has different meanings in different countries, and in the US, the FDA has given up on a meaningful definition of natural food (largely in favor of “organic”, another nebulous term). In Canada, I could market corn as “natural” if I avoid adding or subtracting various things before selling it, but the corn itself is the result of thousands of years of selection by humans, from a plant that wouldn’t exist without human intervention.
Johnson’s comment is part of a terrific list titled “Ten Scientific Ideas that Scientists Wish You Would Stop Misusing” (including “quantum” and “gene”) which, in my opinion, which should be required reading for everyone.
In the last few years, dozens of class action lawsuits have been filed alleging food and other consumer products are labeled “natural” when, according to the plaintiffs, they contain synthetic ingredients. Many consumers believe that “natural” equates with “healthier” so they seek out and purchase products alleged to be made partly or wholly from natural ingredients. Mintel, a market research firm, did a consumer survey reported in a publication called Natural Foods Merchandiser. 60% of consumers read nutrition labels regularly and 51% look for “all natural” on the product label. One suit (over tortilla chips) cited a survey by Consumers Union which found that 86% of consumers understand the term “natural” to mean that the product doesn’t have any artificial ingredients in it.
My source for information on these lawsuits (including the “evaporated cane juice” cases) is a website called “Top Class Actions.” Motto:
Connecting Consumers to Settlements, Lawsuits and Attorneys
For example, here’s a “top class action” from July 11th, titled “Flushmate Toilet Class Action Settlement.”
The manufacturer of the Flushmate toilet flushing system has agreed to pay $18 million to resolve multiple class action lawsuits accusing the company selling a defective product that causes toilets to explode. If you own or owned a toilet equipped with a Series 503 Flushmate III Pressure-Assist Flushing System, you may be eligible to claim money from the class action settlement.
Of course, this suit has absolutely nothing to do with natural products, except in the broadest sense, but I couldn’t resist. To get to the suits we’re discussing in this post enter “natural” in the Top Class Actions search box.
WARNING: This website is not for use by drug and device manufacturers, consumer products manufacturers, financial institutions, publicly traded companies, large employers, or any other persons likely to have issues with the plaintiffs’ bar. Viewing this website may cause a dangerous spike in blood pressure, insomnia, depression, gastrointestinal upset, apoplexy and other symptoms of extreme aggravation.
The “natural” American meal: pizza, soda and cupcakes
My sympathies don’t lie with either side in this fight. One the one hand, it is simplistic to believe that “natural” and “healthier” are synonymous. On the other hand, companies shouldn’t be allowed to get away with false advertising. But is it false? After all, what does “natural” even mean? That’s a question we’ll return to in a minute.
And I have to wonder whether some of the consumers who file these suits are all that concerned about healthier eating. Take a look at the type of products they allege are mislabeled:
    • Waffles
    • Shakes
    • Cookies
    • Crackers
    • Snack bars
    • Enchiladas
    • Pizzas
    • Sodas
    • Ice cream
    • Cinnamon rolls
    • Buttermilk biscuits
    • Cheese
    • Pretzels
    • Chips
    • Bean dip
    • Baking mix
    • Pie
    • Cupcakes
Other consumer products have also been sued in class actions over the “natural” claim as well, including toothpaste, baby wash, sunscreen, shampoo, conditioner, shaving gel, diapers and deodorant.
Products containing GMOs are the subject of several lawsuits, including one against Heinz, alleging its distilled white vinegar is made from GMO corn, which is not really natural. Other suits allege that products containing Vitamin B12, Vitamin D2, niacin, iron, riboflavin, folic acid and ascorbic acid should not be labeled “natural.” Go figure.
The financial reward in these suits is not great, at least not for the members of the plaintiff class. While the total amount of the settlement can range from several hundred thousand to several million dollars, costs and attorneys’ fees must come out of that amount. To recover, individual consumers must file a claim with the court and generally receive only a few cents to a couple of dollars per product purchase, with a limit on the total reward, depending on whether the claimant has a proof of purchase or not. (Who saves grocery receipts in anticipation of a possible consumer lawsuit?) To add insult to injury, a claim will sometimes be rewarded with a voucher for more of the defendant’s products. If the settlement fund is not sufficient to pay all claims, each claim can be reduced pro rata.
For example, in a class action over claims of “natural” ingredients involving several dozen Kashi products, class members will get $0.50 per product, but those without proof of purchase will be capped at $25 total. The total settlement fund is $5 million. (As in all such settlements, Kashi denies plaintiffs’ claims.)
Attorney’s fees can sometimes eat up a substantial chunk of the settlement fund. In a recent class action against the maker of Nutella, plaintiffs claimed the product was misleadingly advertised as a “healthy breakfast food.” The case was settled with an agreement to alter Nutella’s label and advertising as well as a settlement fund of $1.5 million. About two thirds of that went to the attorneys. Three class members challenged the fee amount, arguing that such awards were generally limited to 25%, but a federal appeals court refused to overturn the lower court’s approval of the settlement.
Common sense
Not all plaintiffs have been successful.
An Alabama federal district judge tossed out a class action suit against Citrus World, Inc., makers of Florida Natural orange juice. The plaintiff’s complaint alleged that the juice was mislabeled as pure and natural when, in fact, it is “heavily processed, stored and flavored” before it is put on store shelves. In effect, the judge told the plaintiff to use a little common sense in the grocery store.
The plaintiff makes much ado about believing the packaged containers of orange juice contained ‘fresh squeezed’ orange juice. As a matter of common sense, whatever is in a container on a store shelf with an expiration date some weeks hence cannot contain ‘fresh’ anything. . . The fact that the plaintiff may have believed defendant hired individuals to hand squeeze fresh oranges one by one into juice cartons, then boxed up and delivered the same all over the country does not translate into a concrete injury to plaintiff upon his learning that beliefs about commercially grown and produced orange juice were incorrect.
Class action lawsuits have also been filed alleging orange juice made by Coca-Cola, under the name “Simply Orange,” and Tropicana, is not actually 100% juice nor is it natural. Plaintiffs claim that these companies use “flavor packs” to add back flavor and fragrance that is lost in processing.
So, what is “natural” anyway? That’s a question the plaintiff in a lawsuit against Nestle USA, Inc., couldn’t answer.
The complaint alleged the plaintiff bought Buitoni’s Three Cheese Tortellini and Spinach Cheese Tortellini believing that “all natural” meant they didn’t contain any unnatural, artificial or synthetic ingredients, when, in fact, they contain certain ingredients that aren’t “natural:” xanthan gum, soy lecithin, sodium citrate, maltodextrin, sodium phosphate, disodium phosphates, and ferrous sulfate. She would not have bought them had she known this, according to the complaint. The judge didn’t buy it.
The question before the court (on a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim) was whether a reasonable consumer would likely to be deceived by the “all natural” claim. The plaintiff’s problem was that she could not provide an objective definition of just what “all natural” means. Basically, if you don’t know how to define it, you can’t say you were deceived by thinking a product failed to live up to the definition of “all natural.” This failure was not for lack of trying.
First, she tried the dictionary definition of “natural:” “produced or existing in nature” and “not artificial or manufactured.” The judge rejected this attempt, saying that consumers are obviously aware that Buitoni pastas aren’t “springing fully-formed from Ravioli tress and Tortellini bushes.”
So she tried again. This time, she argued that none of the ingredients in “natural” products can be “artificial” as that term is defined by the FDA. But the FDA’s definition applies only to flavor additives, not any of the ingredients plaintiff alleged were “unnatural.”
Finally, the plaintiff argued that none of the ingredients in a “natural” product are “synthetic” as defined by the National Organic Program (NOP). Two problems with that argument. First, the pastas weren’t labeled organic, so the NOP didn’t apply. Second, the ingredients plaintiff claimed were “synthetic” are actually permitted in products labelled “organic.”
The judge found, as a matter of law, that the description “all natural” was not deceptive because the actual ingredients were clearly disclosed on the label, quoting from another case where the plaintiff claimed “all natural” was misleading:
Because the labels clearly disclosed the presence of the [allegedly unnatural ingredients] it is not plausible that Plaintiffs believed, based on Defendant’s ‘[o]nly natural ingredients’ or ‘all natural’ representations, that the [product] did not contain [the challenged ingredients]
In other words, read the ingredients list on the label. That’s what it’s there for.

Nigeria Court Ruling on Benzene in Soft Drinks
A Nigerian court condemned the current level of benzene found in local soft drinks. Was this decision reasonable given the evidence? Is there something else going on here?
Steven Novella on April 5, 2017
Link
A recent ruling by a Nigerian high court judge has sparked a round of online discussion about the safety of certain soft drinks. The ruling actually only affects the Nigerian Bottling Company (NBC) and their manufacturing of certain Coca-Cola products, Fanta and Sprite. Before I get to the court case, here is the background science.
Benzene in soft drinks
Benzene is a known carcinogen. Long term exposure increases the risk of certain cancers, such as leukemia and myeloma. It is therefore the goal of regulatory and health agencies to minimize human exposure to benzene to levels that carry an insignificant risk.
The World Health Organization reports:
Because of the unequivocal evidence of the carcinogenicity of benzene in humans and laboratory animals and its documented chromosomal effects, quantitative risk extrapolation was used to estimate lifetime cancer risks. Based on a risk estimate using data on leukaemia from epidemiological studies involving inhalation exposure, it was calculated that a drinking water concentration of 1 µg/litre was associated with an excess lifetime cancer risk of 10-6 (10 µg/litre is associated with an excess lifetime risk of 10-5 and 100 µg/litre with an excess lifetime risk of 10-4) (15).
A “µg/litre” is a microgram per liter, which is equal to one part per billion (ppb). So regular exposure to benzene in 1 ppb had an increased lifetime risk of cancer of 10-6, which is one addition case per million people.
We are exposed to benzene in gasoline fumes, tobacco smoke, fumes from other products that contain benzene, and a small amount gets into our food and water. Smokers have 3-6 times the exposure to benzene than non-smokers. The WHO also reports that the amount from drinking water is a small overall contribution:
Exposure to benzene may vary considerably. For nonsmokers, the estimated average daily intake is 200–450 µg/day. The estimated contribution from food is 180 µg/day but, as information on benzene levels in food is very scanty, this background level should be considered only as an approximate reference point. For smokers, the intake levels are increased by a factor of 2–3 (urban areas) or 2–6 (rural areas). The levels commonly found in drinking-water are minimal compared with the intake from food and air (3).
Benzene is not directly added to soft drinks, although there may be a tiny amount from the water used to manufacture the drinks. However, benzene can form from a combination of benzoic acid, which is added as a preservative, and ascorbic acid (vitamin C). This reaction is increased by heat and light and inhibited by sugar and EDTA.So, how much benzene gets into soft drinks and how much is allowed? The various regulatory agencies around the world limit benzene from 1 to 10 ppb. At one ppb, if you drank one liter of the soft drink you would consume 1 microgram of benzene. In one review of 28 soft drink products the mean benzene levels detected were 0.45 ppb. In that survey two citrus fruit-based drinks (so they contained benzoic acid and ascorbic acid) exceeded 1ppb.Another survey of 199 soft drinks found:
The vast majority of beverages sampled contained either no detectable benzene or levels below the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s drinking water limit of 5 ng/g. Beverages found to contain 5 ng/g benzene or more were reformulated by the manufacturers. The amount of benzene found in the reformulated beverages ranged from none detected to 1.1 ng/g. [1 ng/g is also equal to 1 ppb – SN]
Soft drinks therefore have a very low level of benzene, with the vast majority being lower than the legal limit, but a few having just above the more stringent limits. Now, let’s put this level of exposure into context. Again, 1 ppb would give you one microgram from a liter of soft drink. Let’s use a high estimate of 5 micrograms per day from soft drinks, assuming someone drinks 5 liters a day of a soft drink at the limit of 1ppb.
The WHO, as stated above, estimates that the average person is exposed to 250-400 micrograms of benzene per day. You will inhale 32 micrograms when you fill up your car, and 40 micrograms from driving for one hour. Smokers inhale 2-7 thousand micrograms a day, and passive exposure to smoke contributes an estimated 50 micrograms per day.
Total contribution from food and water is estimated at between 1 and 3 micrograms per day, which is a small contribution to overall exposure.
The Nigerian case
The recent court case decision (the case itself was filed 10 years ago and took this long to get a decision) dealt with a lawsuit from an exporter. They attempted to export Fanta and Sprite bottled in Nigeria by the NBC to the UK. The product was tested on import into the UK and found to exceed their limit on benzoic acid (note – this refers to benzoic acid, not benzene):
The UK standards limit benzoic acid in soft drinks to a maximum of 150 mg/kg. Both Fanta and Sprite have benzoic levels of 200 mg/kg which is lower than the Nigerian regulatory limit of 250 mg/kg when combined with ascorbic acid and 300 mg/kg without ascorbic acid and also lower than the 600 mg/kg international limit set by Codex.
So the product was compliant with Nigerian and international limits, but over the stricter limit for the UK. The case focused on whether or not the NBC and the Nigerian regulatory agency (National Agency For Food and Drug Administration and Control – NAFDAC) was negligent in allowing these higher limits. NBC claimed that they bottle soft drinks for local distribution and comply with local regulations, and their product is not intended to export. The judge, apparently, did not buy this argument:
In her judgment, Justice Oyebanji said: “It is imperative to state that the knowledge of the Nigeria Bottling Company that the products were to be exported is immaterial to its being fit for human consumption. The court is in absolute agreement with the learned counsel for the claimants that soft drinks manufactured by Nigeria bottling company ought to be fit for human consumption irrespective of color or creed.
“It is manifest that NAFDAC has been grossly irresponsible in its regulatory duties to the consumers of Fanta and Sprite manufactured by Nigeria Bottling Company. In my respective view, NAFDAC has failed the citizens of this great nation by its certification as satisfactory for human consumption products, which in the United Kingdom failed sample test for human consumption, and which become poisonous in the presence of Ascorbic Acid ordinarily known as Vitamin C, which can be freely taken by the unsuspecting public with the company’s Fanta or Sprite.”
I’m no legal scholar, but that seems like a massive overreaction to me. It sounds like the judge had a political point to make. They are claiming that these products are poisonous and not fit for human consumption because they contain 200 mg/kg of benzoic acid, when the international limit is 600 mg/kg, but the UK’s limit is 150. Further, all the evidence suggests that even at the higher limit the amount of resulting benzene would be well below safety limits and an insignificant contribution to overall benzene exposure.
As always, the dose makes the poison. And, when considering overall exposure, individual sources should be put into the proper context of how much they contribute. Benzoic acid and resulting benzene from soft drinks is a non-issue. Overall the levels are extremely low, and are a minor contributor to overall benzene exposure. The Nigerian court decision has more to do with political maneuvering than the actual science.
